In the latest episode of The Line Podcast, Matt Gurney returns from a leave to care for his wife and wonders if he’s missed anything over the last two weeks. Turns out he has. It’s his first chance to sit down with Jen Gerson and talk about the Alberta referendum, and Jen - finally having gotten some sleep - offers her concluding thoughts on … all that. Matt gives his reactions and asks Jen a fairly basic question: what, exactly, was the point of the whole exercise? They agree that Danielle Smith doesn’t come out of it looking particularly good. They also agree she might just skate anyway, especially since the separatists lost so badly that a lot of them might just move on to the next grift. This episode is brought to you by BioCanRx. We’ve been partnering with federally-funded Canadian not-for-profit BioCanRx to learn how made-in-Canada immunotherapies offer new ways to beat cancer. This month we’re addressing common questions, like: is Canada behind on immunotherapy? Canadian researchers continue to be global leaders at discovery research. Where Canada lags behind is in bringing these discoveries from the lab to the patient. While many immunotherapies come to Canada for clinical trial or market authorization, few are based on Canadian research or developed in Canada, meaning we access them when their international sponsors choose, at whatever prices they want to charge -- provided Health Canada approves and the provinces decide to pay. Developing more Canadian discoveries into approved therapies in Canada would help reduce Canada’s dependence on other countries, enable our health systems to learn what it takes to deliver these novel therapies while collecting data to assess their value via early stage clinical trials, and provide patients with much-needed access to advanced therapies. A win-win-win scenario. BioCanRx continues to work with researchers and policymakers to deliver on this mission. Thanks to them for continuing to partner with The Line to share this information and visit BioCanRx.com to learn more. Next, your hosts turn to the catastrophe at CFB Wainwright, where some of the worst instincts of Canadian governance were on full display. The safety of the troops and care for the families of the fallen obviously come first. But the disaster also became a textbook example of how Canadian institutions respond to emergencies by smothering transparency. Matt and Jen go through what was known, what was revealed and, yes, read aloud what may be the worst official communication ever produced by a Canadian government comms person. Matt also responds to criticism that the military probably didn’t yet know the answers to the questions The Line wanted answered. There’s just one problem with that defence: someone leaked The Line the memo. They knew. So .... This episode is also brought to you by Cameco. Building Canada’s energy future means creating jobs for Canadian workers. That’s why the AP1000 reactor is the right choice for Canada: it is already operating and ready to deliver the power we need. Choosing the AP1000 means a reactor built by Canadians, creating skilled jobs in construction, fabrication and the trades while keeping more investment and economic benefits here at home. If we are serious about creating Canadian jobs and strengthening our economy, the choice is clear. To learn more, visit ap1000.cameco.com. Finally, Matt offers a personal update on the family medical emergency that took him away from the podcast. He’s still figuring out how much he can and should say publicly, but he has some broader thoughts about Canada’s health-care system. It turns out all the clichés are true: it can be astonishingly good and absolutely awful at the same time. Matt also has some very sharp and specific criticisms of one group of hospital professionals. He thinks the problems there are serious enough that they could end up collapsing the system, literally. Canadians will die because of this; Canadians are already dying of it, and Matt got to watch one of those deaths with his own eyes. The harder question is what anyone can do about it. All that and more in the latest episode of The Line Podcast. YouTube: Video goes live at 6 p.m Eastern/4 Mountain. Spotify: Apple: And plenty more options here. Please sign up at those options not just for this episode, or future episodes of The Line Podcast, but so that you can also receive our other podcast series, On the Line, which releases new episodes every Tuesday morning. In case you missed it, here is last Tuesday’s episode, where Jen Gerson speaks with Patrick Lennox, author of On Treason, a new book examining the moral and political consequences of betraying one’s own country. That’s all for now! Talk to you guys soon. The Line is entirely reader and advertiser funded. No federal subsidies, no bailouts. If you value our work, please consider supporting us by subscribing or making a donation. Donations are not subscriptions and do not unlock paywalled content, but they help keep The Line independent To contact The Line with a general inquiry or comment, please email info@readtheline.ca. For other ways to connect with us or to follow us on social media, please see our LinkTree. Get full access to The Line at www.readtheline.ca/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Well, I take two weeks off and look what happens. It's The Line podcast as I try to get caught up on what the hell just happened in Alberta. Jen's going to explain that to me. And then also what the hell just happened in Alberta. We're going to talk the tragedy at CFB Wainwright. And then I'm going to talk a little bit about the health care system. I'm going to start to tell a little bit of the story I've been living for the last year. Stick around. It's The Line podcast. [music]
SPEAKER_01This message is brought to you by BioCanRx. We've been partnering with federally funded Canadian not-for-profit BioCanRx to learn how made-in-Canada immunotherapies offer new ways to beat cancer. This month, we're addressing common questions like, is Canada behind on immunotherapy? Canadian researchers continue to be global leaders at discovery research. Where Canada lags behind is bringing these discoveries from the lab to the patient. While many immunotherapies come to Canada for clinical trial
SPEAKER_01or market authorization, few are based on Canadian research or developed in Canada, meaning we access them when their international sponsors choose at whatever prices they want to charge, provided Health Canada approves and the provinces decide to pay. Developing more Canadian discoveries into approved therapies in Canada would help reduce Canada's dependence on other countries, enable our health systems to learn what it takes to deliver these novel therapies while collecting data to assess their value via early stage clinical trials,
SPEAKER_01and provide patients with much needed access to advanced therapies. A win-win-win scenario. BioCanRx continues to work with researchers and policy makers to deliver on this mission. Thanks to them for continuing to partner with The Line to share this information. And go to biocanrx.com to learn more. Well, did I miss anything? Yeah. Remember when you and I used to joke that every time we would do the dispatch or
SPEAKER_01the podcast early, something would happen?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is why the thing has started to eat our Sunday nights. By the way... That's got to stop. We can't keep making dispatches on Sunday night, man. I can't do it.
SPEAKER_01No, we need to. I think we need to start writing them Friday and publishing them Saturday, but we can have that conversation. Or we can like Monday.
SPEAKER_00Let's make them Monday or Friday, whatever. Anyway, that's fine. We'll figure it out.
SPEAKER_01So in the third segment, I'm going to talk a little bit about my family's healthcare journey. And I'm not going to get into any big personal details yet, but I am going to make a structural observation. But I lead with that, Jen, just to say for the last two weeks, I've been off because my wife's cancer treatment has been ongoing. And she had a major surgery in recent weeks, and I've just been taking care of her. And no one is more excited than her for me to be doing this podcast because it's the first time I haven't been hovering over her in about 14 days.
SPEAKER_00Wives love it when you do that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. So yeah, she's really excited for this podcast. But I bring this up because I haven't really been paying that much attention over the last two weeks because I've been tied down to other things. Yeah. This is a joke I've told with you before, Jen, and some of our audience will have heard me tell it before. Every time something takes me out of action for an extended period, My phone explodes with news alerts that would be historic, but I just don't have time to care
SPEAKER_00about it. I actually blame the total collapse of the Western world order on you. On me. It's all on you. I don't know why God hath chosen you to be the single pillar upon which the Western order shall stand or fall. I don't know the
SPEAKER_01fairy tale, but the Dutch kid with the finger in the dike, that's me taking a vacation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's all on you.
SPEAKER_01It's all on you. One of the things, even we're joking, but Jen, just a couple of minutes ago before we hit record, Trump announced he's ending some Canadian tariffs because they're killing Republicans in the midterms, right? So I kind of looked at that and I'm like, well, this is something I don't have time to care about today.
SPEAKER_00So I guess we won the trade war.
SPEAKER_01I guess.
SPEAKER_00I guess we won.
SPEAKER_01I plan to come back to work next week. Probably on halftime hours for next week and then hopefully back full time after that. And I bring that up because that probably means the chaos will be ending. Because when I'm at work, the shit doesn't happen. But okay, so I missed the entire Alberta referendum. And I was like looking at it on my phone. Can I... You have spent all week reacting to it.
SPEAKER_01You've written about it for us. You've been all over the media. You've done TVO because friends of mine here in Toronto have been like, hey, I saw your partner, Jen. So you've definitely been doing the media rounds. Apparently, you became memeable because you said something on CBC.
SPEAKER_00The kids on TikTok were all over one of my CBC interviews where I made poor David Common. He lost the power of speech for a minute and basically was like, I ended my little clip and he was like, go on. Just let Jen Gerson cook.
SPEAKER_01David has a pretty good sense of humor, so I'm sure he wasn't actually speechless. I suspect he was suppressing his laughter.
SPEAKER_00Maybe, maybe.
SPEAKER_01Is there anything you think you want to say before I start asking you questions? You've been talking about this Okay.
SPEAKER_0066%, although you can double check this when all is said and done. Actually, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_01There are still a few polling stations that haven't reported yet.
SPEAKER_00There are still a few polling stations that haven't reported yet. My big fear, as many people with The Line podcast will know, was that voter suppression or long lines would effectively keep the voter turnout super, super low, which would give the potential for an indecisive or potentially even in a long shot, a leave vote. Which wasn't going to be reflective of what Albertans really wanted, but was going to be reflective of the desire of Albertans who wanted to use this kind of gambit either to send a message to Ottawa,
SPEAKER_00gain more leverage in interprovincial negotiations, or at the extreme end to create a democratic pretext for forcing American involvement. That was always my fear here. And because this was a really complicated, stupid ballot with 10 long questions, and I can talk about the logistics of voting in a ballot like that, and because this was a referendum that wasn't attached to any other actual election, like municipal election or provincial election, there was a really high risk from my perspective at that time was that we were going to have like a 30 to 40% voter turnout.
SPEAKER_00And if we had a 30 to 40% voter turnout, the most committed wins. And the separatists were radically more motivated to vote than the federalists were. Because Federalists were normal. And the separatists were, you know, highly engaged. And that didn't turn out. Like, you know, I will give massive props to the Forever Canadian crowd. And I'm going to give some props to Mark Carney, who did multiple rallies in the run-up to the election. I'm going to give massive props to just general ordinary Albertans who recognized that this was not the moment to be complacent.
SPEAKER_00And we turned up. And we turned up and we voted very strongly for staying in Canada. It was like a 75-25 split in favor of staying with a high voter turnout. So we can be confident that that reflects the will of Albertans. Not only was I happy to see that they voted to stay in Canada and recognize the risks of playing games like this at a moment where the geopolitics of the world are shifting and where Playing with separatism in a moment when America's going through whatever America is going through is
SPEAKER_00a really dangerous game for us to do. So we just, we just, we really came together and rejected that. And that was wonderful. And I'm just, I'm really proud of Albertans for, for seeing through the bullshit, seeing the risk and deciding that, no, no, we're playing games like this is not actually in our collective best interests. So there's that. I would also say that the emotional, say,
SPEAKER_00the morning after emotional backlash to this referendum has been very, very interesting. I know of people who actually voted to leave in the election, and even they are pissed off that this referendum was even held, which was very interesting. There's an overwhelming sense that we spent $140 million on... Frankly, almost a political hoax, right? A political hoax that was designed to give one premier and one party internal cover
SPEAKER_00and internal cohesion. And it has clearly failed to do that.
SPEAKER_01Even like,
SPEAKER_00you know, as the referendum results were announced, you know, Daniel Smith announces that, oh, yeah, we're a federalist party again. And anybody who supports separatism is. Excuse me. Anybody who supports separatism has no place in our party. A well-known separatist MLA quit or said he wasn't going to run again. The separatists are imploding internally, like they've become internally fractious. And like if you're willing to come out the day after the referendum and say we're a Federalist party and if you're a separatist, go elsewhere.
SPEAKER_00If you had just done that six months ago, there never would have been a need for the referendum in the first place. So I think what's messy about all of this is like the referendum didn't even buy the internal party piece that Danielle Smith would have wanted it to buy because she could have just done that six months ago and spared us the last six months of drama, the money, all of that. And I think also what people aren't taking into consideration here is like these kinds of highly divisive internal votes have real emotional costs on people. I'm tired.
SPEAKER_00Everyone I know on the Federalist team is upset and tired and demoralized. And families fought over this. I know people who had internal squabbles inside their families where they weren't talking for a little while over this stupid vote. And to have a vote turn out that lopsided and to think of the emotional costs that went into it for a vote that Albertans really didn't want... The idea that there's not going to be some kind of consequence for that is
SPEAKER_00a real hard pill to swallow.
SPEAKER_01This will sound ruder than I intend. Are you done? Because I want to say things, but I don't want to cut you off. Oh, no.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no. I'm done. Go for it.
SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah. And yeah, sorry.
SPEAKER_00No, no, it's good. Are you done yet? That's completely reasonable. Shut the fuck up, Gerson. Shut up.
SPEAKER_01No, okay. So I wanted to give you a chance to kind of have that five days later opportunity. Because I did see, even when I was off in hospital land, I did see you on the CBC. And it was muted where I was, but I saw David's non-response to whatever you said. I didn't see it until I saw it later. And I still think he was trying not to laugh. That's his mind. You hadn't slept before.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01You've now had some days to sleep, and I wanted to give you the chance to. Can I make my observations now and just kind of tell me what you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01One of the things, first of all, I want to brag. When the voting was happening in one of our line group chats, we talked about what our predictions were. Who came closest?
SPEAKER_00Didn't I think it was going to be 70-30?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I said mid-20s.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, fair enough. Good for you. I was not, but I was rooting that that was all based on voter turnout. It's all based on voter turnout. That was the question.
SPEAKER_01Who showed up? The funny thing is, and this is, we're going to talk about the catastrophe at CFB Wainwright, and my tone is a little lighthearted here for something that is very serious, but I want to make a very serious comment, and I hope the audience will not think I'm making light of anything. Without CFB Wainwright, I think it might have been 70-30.
SPEAKER_00Maybe. Yeah, maybe.
SPEAKER_01I think there were people... On Monday, who couldn't vote against Canada when our boys wearing the maple leaf were fighting for their lives.
SPEAKER_00Maybe. But the other thing I would just observe here that would maybe present a counterweight to that point is that if you look at the breakdown of voting by advance ballot versus voting day, there's a pretty considerable stark.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. No, I noticed that. But I also think that was always going to be the case. I think the separatists were raring to go. They wanted to show up, right?
SPEAKER_00But the advance ballot was overwhelmingly to stay. Like it was an 85, 50, 15 split to stay. And I think that that is reflected in the fact that a lot of federalists were like, don't get caught in lines. Don't do that. Advance vote, advance vote, advance vote. Whereas the E-Day ballots were like, again, these are early numbers. So let's not, don't put this as final, but I think it was closer to 60, 40. So to me, that tells me that, you know, don't, The voter turnout really, really mattered.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It really mattered.
SPEAKER_01A couple other comments I would make. This is obviously an outside view looking in, and you'll probably want to respond to one of these in particular. I concluded for myself that the separatists were going to lose two or three weeks ago. And I just don't mean lose on ballot 10, the choice to leave Canada. I was always confident they were not going to win. But I began to realize they were going to lose,
SPEAKER_01even in their own eyes, because the way they were talking was what I recognized from a career watching politics was loser pre-positioning. Yep, absolutely. And they were mustering out and forming up their circular firing squads. And I knew what that was. And I Look, I would have been happier if it was 95 to 5, but I think for our purposes, a 3 to 1 drubbing is sufficient.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and 3 to 1 drubbing, sorry, I don't mean to talk over you. It's sometimes difficult with the, we're doing this remotely, so we sometimes accidentally talk over each other. That's got to be it. But I would also remind people that even of the 25% of people who voted, if you look at sort of additional polling, you start to realize that most of those people don't actually want to leave Canada. Only really about a third of the people who voted to leave actually want to leave. The other two thirds were like on some version of send Ottawa a message to this is going to give us more leverage.
SPEAKER_01The absolute best case scenario for the separatists is that they lost three to one.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01In the most favorable possible scenario for them, they lost three to one. And that to me as a Federalist is good news. Yeah. I'm going to leave aside the issue of the separatists imploding because I do want to talk with you about that after. But rapid fire, a few more observations from me. In terms of all of the other ballot questions, Daniel Smith, with maybe one exception, I actually think has created a ton of problems for herself.
SPEAKER_01Because the idea of a referendum is to go out and to determine the will of the people. And basically the Alberta population is split on almost everything. She has wins on some of these, right? Some of these are like, oh, yes, Scott, 52 or 53. You know what? I actually have the numbers. I have the live numbers.
SPEAKER_00Those aren't dramatic wins though.
SPEAKER_01No, that's it, right? Like if you go to the people, like should I do a thing? And you get – 52% in favor and 48% opposed. I don't think that does you any favors.
SPEAKER_00You don't have a strong mandate. And a lot of those questions too, I'll be honest with you, as someone who voted in this election, nobody was reading through those 10 ballot questions and carefully – No, yes, no, yes. The ballot questions aren't non-clearly worded. They were actually pretty slanted. They're poorly written. And because they were stacked one on top of the other, they weren't quick or easy. And nobody's standing there at a ballot box laying out these 10 ballots and be like,
SPEAKER_00hmm, what should I do about that? So I don't think she has a strong mandate on any of these questions. And on all of the constitutional questions, no one- No one.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I have to – The five immigration ones. Here are the raw numbers. These are live as of an hour ago, the last update. I'm not even going to tell you what the questions are. I'm just going to tell you the numbers. 55 to 45. 52 to 48. 53 to 47.
SPEAKER_0052 to 48. Well –
SPEAKER_01And the one that actually did, I think, have a pretty clear win, the only one I will tell you is proof of citizenship before voting, 58 to 42. And the funny thing is, too, of all these questions, the only one that I think actually probably should have won a clear yes was that one. I think that's the least objectionable one. And Albertan voters, in their wisdom, gave that one the most support. All the other ones that I think were kind of shitbag questions ended up being... And effectively coin tosses.
SPEAKER_00That's right.
SPEAKER_01And losing Canada was a three to one defeat. If you're Danielle Smith and you're trying to figure out what the fuck to do with that, I don't know what you do.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a mess. That's a messy, messy response. The other one I would just point out as well is like voter turnout collapsed after the main question. So a lot of people voted for question 10. They voted for the separation question. And then they were like, fuck the rest of this. I'm not even engaging with the rest of this. Right. Because the questions were so poor and loaded. Right. I don't think she even even on the stuff where she, quote unquote, won, the splits were really close and the voter turnout collapsed on. So, like, how do you take that and say I have a strong Democratic mandate to do anything?
SPEAKER_00Like, honestly, if anything, I think she she has less leverage to negotiate for things like immigration control now than she did prior to the referendum.
SPEAKER_01Everything she would want to negotiate on other than voter ID, roughly half of the people oppose her.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And the actual will isn't really there. So I actually think she undermined her leverage on almost all of those questions. And when it comes to the constitutional stuff, they voted no. She lost. One of the great successes of this referendum, the thing that I think is most hilarious, is that the majority of Albertans really don't have any interest in messing with the Senate. They don't care. You have a funny tweet
SPEAKER_01about that, that Senate reform for right-wingers is what proportional vote is for left-wingers, an issue they're passionate about that no one else gives a shit about.
SPEAKER_00It is a complete niche elite political interest. Nobody else gives a shit about this. So to me, I'm really thrilled. And also at the same time, the appetite for constitutional reform in this godforsaken year of 2026 is zero. Nobody's reopening the constitution right now. That's not going, like, nobody wants to do that right now. Nobody, except for like 40 people at the Calgary School. Like, you know what I mean? Like, this is not, even your fellow Albertans don't want to reopen the Constitution.
SPEAKER_00We're not that interested. Move the hell on. Anyway.
SPEAKER_01You know what's funny, Jen? And I have two specific questions for you. What's very funny about that is One of the things you were worried about, and you've spoken about this in public, so I hope you'll forgive me. I'm going to reveal a little bit of what you and I talked about behind the scenes, but it's nothing you haven't talked about in public. You were worried about an option one win that was very narrow. That was something you really were worried about, that Albertans would say, we want to stay in Canada, but it was going to be like 52-48. Or 60-40 even would have been a bad decision.
SPEAKER_01You were worried about that as kind of a maximum chaos scenario where the issue isn't really settled. Your opponents are animated. You know who ended up getting that? Smith. Her issues failed or barely won.
SPEAKER_00So now the question is, what do we do? Because we've got a couple of possibilities here. My possibility tree is now a tangled web. In my head, because one, there's going to be an AGM in the end of November. The question is, do the separatists take over the AGM and either put a motion to the floor to turn the UCP into a separatist party or do something wild like that? Do the separatists, are they organized enough to sort of push a leadership review? Right now, I think probably no, because the separatists are right now they're infighting.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know, like there's hilarious stuff coming out of the Alberta Prosperity Project where like They're claiming that the leaders of the Alberta Prosperity Project are now, like, they were fired from their positions as leaders weeks ago, but this was kept under wraps until after the referendum. And now, like, Jeff Rath and the leaders are now saying, no, no, no, I wasn't fired. You weren't legitimate members of the- It's just a mess. These guys are now going to engage in protracted infighting, which I think has a pretty good chance of sapping any momentum that they have
SPEAKER_00toward taking over the party, turning these peas into anything. So it's possible, possible, possible. That Danielle Smith kind of glides through this AGM without any kind of consequences. On the flip side, I've heard that essentially 7,000 people have signed up to attend this AGM and they are not the same 7,000 people. And that the people existing within the party are trying to force normies to show up for Smith and force normies to show up for the party. And the normies are like, you just dragged us through hell and back, F you, and a bag of chips with it.
SPEAKER_00We're not showing up to save your ass now. You solve your own separatist crisis. It's the one of your own making. So I don't know what happens at this AGM. No one can predict to you what's going to happen at this AGM. I don't rule out the possibility of a snap election being called before the AGM in order to avoid an AGM. That could totally happen in the next six weeks. I don't know, but why not at this point? It's Berta. I don't know whether or not Danielle Smith manages to glide between the goalposts
SPEAKER_00because the Federalists will look at her and be like, okay, but what if she's worse? And the Separatists in her party will look at her and be like, we can't do better. I don't know if that happens. I don't know if the Separatists get their act together to basically mount some kind of a coup. I don't know whether or not if the UCP passes some kind of Separatist motion, whether or not the party splits or divides upon itself. It would not be the first time that Alberta's Conservatives... Decided that civil war was the way to go, we? So look, any potential option is on the table right now and I don't know how this is going
SPEAKER_00to go. I find it harder and harder to listen to Danielle Smith make excuses and make comments and retroactively justify her actions against those comments. One of the things that really pissed me off yesterday was the fact that she was blaming Thomas Lukasik and the Forever 21 people for saying the referendum on her. And look, even the separatists in my feed are like, yeah, that's a lie. That's not true. She didn't use the Forever Canadian question.
SPEAKER_00She didn't use the Stay Free Alberta question. She invented her own question in order to placate her own separatist party. Yeah. Meanwhile, the Stay Free Alberta question is still a live matter before the courts. Considering the fact that what success for staying in Canada, I think a lot of it is actually owed to people like Thomas Lukasik, who showed up, did the work for months on hand, campaigned like a mofo, was visible and aggressive in getting people to vote for Canada,
SPEAKER_00and who I think probably had the only real GOTV For Danielle Smith, who has claimed to be a Federalist but has done bluntly fuck all for the Federalist cause to go around and then preemptively or post hoc sort of blame Thomas Lukasik for forcing a referendum that he explicitly didn't want and advocated against in committee. I just find that so bad faith and that's so dishonest that it actually makes me kind of physically ill.
SPEAKER_00And I think that if Danielle Smith is expecting Ordinary Federalists to show up to her aid in the AGM, that's a real bad strategy. I don't think most Normie Albertans are showing up for that. How about an apology? How about that?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I was thinking about that. I'm not expecting one, but I would say you've always noted that Daniel Smith, and I agree with you, Has an almost unparalleled ability in politics to read a room and give them what they want. 75% of Alberta voters just told her what they want. And it's now up to her to decide how to deal with it. And I think in the last week, something that occurred to me was an old joke that the best day the French resistance ever had for recruitment was the day before the war ended.
SPEAKER_01Everybody was in a hurry to be in the resistance on that day. So I wouldn't be shocked to see a version of it in Alberta right now where a lot of people are going to be, well, I was always a Federalist or I always thought this was stupid, right? There's a lot of rewriting of history afterward. I said I had two questions for you and you already answered one of them because I was about to ask what's going to happen with the UCP now. I think my other question, Jen, the second one, and then I have really nothing more for you.
SPEAKER_01Well, pardon me on this. I have so much for you. Separatists. I said about 20 minutes ago that they were already forming their circular firing squads, right? And I know what that is. I oppose Alberta separatism. I oppose Quebec separatism. I think Canada functions best united. I think Canada can and should function better. I'm not blind to that, and I want it to. But to me, in my mind, it was not that hard to distinguish between fairly thoughtful,
SPEAKER_01incredible separatists who I disagreed with but could admire, respect, even in some cases be friends with.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I think they're wrong, but I like them, and I respect them. Their thought process. One of the things that happened over the last few years, and they know this, is they got overwhelmed by the shit nutters. And is this going to be a situation where the adults in the separatist room, as much as I disagree with them, impose some order and go, well, we're going to learn from this and we're going to do this again.
SPEAKER_01Or is Alberta separatism going to get relegated over to vaccine cranks and ostrich resistors and Who's going to run the movement now? I honestly don't know. Because it can go either way, right? There could be a renaissance in Alberta separatism where the adults in the room go, well, that was a fucking disaster. We've got to professionalize. We've got to get serious. Do what you've been saying, which is form a party, elect candidates, have a platform. The other thing that can happen is that the serious, thoughtful people in the room can decide they did not like getting
SPEAKER_01the shit kicked out of them three to one with a stacked deck in their favor. And walk away and decide they have better things to do with their lives. And the entire movement is inherited by the shit nutters. What do you think?
SPEAKER_00I mean, my hope for the separatist movement is that, look, and I've said this from the beginning, I have no moral or intellectual objections to a separatist movement that follows in the path of the Parti Québécois and decides even if you're just doing it for the leverage, fine. Start a party. Create a platform that is adult and sensible. Organize, get elected. Because I think that that process forces normalization on the process. That process doesn't tend to reward the shit nutters.
SPEAKER_00It requires people who show up, people who understand procedure, people who understand how the system works, people who understand rules. It forces all of that passionate energy to be contained into something that is democratically productive. And great, if you do that, I respect that. I disagree with the outcomes that you're trying to pursue against, but you're operating within a normal democratic context. Cool. The problem with this, the way that they did this is that they didn't do it the right way, the right procedural way.
SPEAKER_00They did it by trying to essentially take over a mainstream, explicitly federalist party with people who were not credible and And who were overwhelmingly animated by conspiracy theories and the kind of manic energy that comes with that. The problem is that I'm not sure separatism maintains any real serious momentum without those people. So I said, like anything's on the table. I also think that Paul Will's rules of Canadian politics apply and like the most boring outcome is probably the correct one.
SPEAKER_00That the same manic energy that drives separatism is the energy that will essentially drive it apart. And that Danielle's going to skate. I think it's very possible she's just going to skate. That would be the most boring outcome.
SPEAKER_01Not only that, I mean, I agree, but I would also say, Jen, from my view, a couple of time zones away, I would call that the base case right now. I think that's pretty much what's going to happen. I think the energy that has animated Alberta separatism in the last couple of years is going to bifurcate. And some of it's going to end up being very thoughtful and forlorn policy papers churned out by the Freedom Institute of Liberty or some bullshit, right? Yep. Most of the energy in six months will be 100% dedicated to live streaming rioting in Paris.
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly right. They're going to find a new cause and they're going to move on. It's like these guys are the omni-causers of the right, right? There's always another passionate thing. The other thing that I would just observe in all of this, and I made this comment in my last column about the futility of trying to argue with conspiracy theorists, right? And not all separatists are conspiracy theorists. I said there's some credible ones out there, but- The second argument that I would just make in all of this is that it's easy to mistake passionate intensity for credibility.
SPEAKER_00You can get overwhelmed in the moment by bots, passion, people whose profile was built up in the last 18 months and they catch a wave. They just catch this wave of a moment and they generate an audience and they generate a following. But Matt, you and I have been doing this for 20 years. And we've seen this wave come in and out and come in and out and come in and out. And we've seen personalities come and go and come and go and come and go. And then people like us stick around like a craggy little island in the sea.
SPEAKER_00And we can get overwhelmed for a moment, but then the wave always comes out again. And this to me was another example of that. Like, The people who gained personalities and profiles on a lot of this stuff manage, like they burn hot, but they burn fast and then they burn out. And then us assholes are still here, still back, maybe not as flashy, maybe not as like, not as big, maybe not as famous, but we sustain ourselves over time.
SPEAKER_00And I think that that's worth noting because I think it matters too.
SPEAKER_01I remember the day Joe Biden was sworn in, our friend Justin Ling was hanging out on some of the QAnon web boards and he was live tweeting or posting somewhere. I don't know if he was on Twitter, but he was basically narrating the pivot from absolute conviction. To confusion and then despair and disillusionment these people went through when the black helicopters didn't descend and Trump and the loyal army did not rise up
SPEAKER_01and arrest the imposter Biden. Because the online conspiracy theory collided in real time with reality and the conspiracy theory did not hold. I haven't paid a ton of attention for reasons I've already explained, but there were some separatist accounts I began following quietly over the last year or two. Because I marked them as either influence bots or people who are crazy. And it's often hard to tell the difference.
SPEAKER_01And all through election day, I was looking at huge turnout of the polls. Exit polls show that we're winning. We're going to win this. Followed by, okay, the numbers don't look great, but don't worry. Followed by, huh. And in quite a few cases, the accounts have just gone silent. And I don't know if that's bots being deactivated before they get repurposed with a fresh profile photo. And again, they're all about rioting in France using French and, you know, getting their accounts VPN through Marseille or something.
SPEAKER_01Or if there are real Albertans sitting in the home right now today, not understanding how they lost because everyone they know is a separatist. How could this have happened? I'm in a Facebook group with 10,000 fellow Albertans and all of us agreed that we were going to win. What the fuck?
SPEAKER_00How could this have happened? There's a lot of that. There's a lot of that. And good people, they're not in the same information space as the majority of the province. There's a lot of... Look, I think after COVID, we lost 20% of the population and I don't think we're going to get them back. I think we just have to plan around that.
SPEAKER_01One of them said to me a couple of days ago, respectfully, he said, Matt, everyone I know is a separatist. I said, yeah, I know, but all my friends are Leaf fans.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, that's the problem.
SPEAKER_01And therefore, the entire NHL fan base, as far as I'm concerned, must be Leaf fans.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. The other one I would just say is like, look, if you look at studies, there's been a couple of years ago I did this. I read a book about a fascinating look at what happens to cults when the doomsday cults, when the doomsday doesn't
SPEAKER_01follow through. Yeah. When the UFO doesn't land.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. When the UFO doesn't land, what happens? And actually the phenomenon is fascinating because maybe the majority of the cults then dissipates, but the people who are left double down. Mm-hmm. An astonishing number of people will double down after the prophecy fails to come true. And they'll find excuses, reasons why it didn't happen, or they double down on the leadership's judgment.
SPEAKER_00In some ways, it actually becomes a forced loyalty test, and the most loyal will twist themselves into intellectual pretzels in order to continue... Aligning with the belief system that's given them value and purpose. So like 75% of people may dissipate and like, oh, well, this is an embarrassing thing we'll never talk about again. But the remaining 25% We'll go even further down the rabbit hole, which is why a lot of these conspiracy theorists take conspiracy movements take on an omni cause kind of energy, right?
SPEAKER_00Because people need to double down and double down and double down and double down and double down. They can never admit that they were just deceived. They can never admit that their information bubbles were limited. They can never admit that they were wrong. So rather than that, then deal with the emotional consequences of just saying, look, I was off. They go further and further and further and further and further. And it's why these types of omni-causes never really let up. They just change their name and they just change masks. They just change purposes. So anyway, that's just something I'm watching for. I think we've gone on long enough, 36 minutes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I got nothing left to say about that. And you know what? Can I actually know I'm going to immediately prove myself a liar? I have one more thing to say. Oh, gosh. I don't want to talk about this anymore.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01I'm like, Alberta separatism to me is something I really hope we don't have to talk about for a long time.
SPEAKER_00Nope, I think we're done. I mean, Alberta politics is going to get fun.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but that's the right thing to be talking about. Talk about fixing the roads, talking about building the hospitals, talking about building the transit, talking about the pipelines, the energy, the healthcare.
SPEAKER_00Like, please. I would like a leadership class that it's really boring and made up of accountants. Can we do that? I want our leaders to be boring accountants named Dave who understand that governance is really about managing the books and filling the potholes. I would like to go back to that, please.
SPEAKER_01Me too. Yeah. We're going to come back in a minute. We are, no pun intended, mean this very sincerely. We're going to talk about another catastrophe in Alberta. The tragedy at CFB Wainwright is something Jen and I have both been watching. We'll talk about that in a moment. Stick around. This is The Line Podcast. Like and subscribe.
SPEAKER_00This episode is also brought to you
SPEAKER_01by Cameco. Building Canada's energy future means creating jobs for Canadian workers. That's why the AP1000 reactor is the right choice for Canada. It is already operating and ready to deliver the power we need. Choosing the AP1000 means a reactor built by Canadians, creating skilled jobs in construction, fabrication, and the trades, while keeping more investment in economic benefits here at home. If we are serious about creating Canadian jobs and strengthening our economy,
SPEAKER_01the choice is clear. To learn more, visit ap1000.cameco.com. We have to do this on the pod sometimes, Jen. It's hard to do this, and we want to just acknowledge that. It's hard to make a hard tonal shift because you and I can get a little lighthearted and spirited about some topics, but we're talking about the catastrophe at CFB Wainwright on the weekend. And well, there's no non-awkward way to make a pivot from what we were just talking about
SPEAKER_01to this. So we have four Canadian soldiers who have been killed. We have, as of last update, 13 that remain in critical condition. My understanding is those are burn injuries and Uh, I've been praying for those troops, but the reality of it is 13 critical burn injuries. I would be surprised if all 13 survive.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We're expecting casualties to go up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. We, I think we expect the death toll to go up. Um, the good news such as it is, is that the number of, uh, wounded being treated is going down with every update. So some of the less severely wounded are, um, Have been discharged and are either recovering. And in many cases, Jen, and this is something people who don't understand the military don't understand this, but I did. The rest of the unit got right back to work because in war, this stuff happens. And when it happens in a training exercise, it's just something else to be trained around.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_01So you get these guys, shit happens. You will have days like this in battle, everybody back to work. And that's one of the ways the military is different from most elements of society. I saw the General's press conference on the weekend where he tried to explain that, and I know some people were confused by that, but I wasn't. I have two points I want to make, and one of them is very depressing, and one of them is going to annoy people. So I'll do the depressing one first.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01I don't want to sound callous or heartless, but we are planning a dramatic expansion in the size of the Canadian Armed Forces. Okay. A larger, busier military will have more accidents. And I just wanted to say that, and I'm not going anywhere there with a big point. But if we are going to have a larger, more capable Canadian Armed Forces, I've already made this point before, Jen, but that is going to have a larger footprint in civil society. And some of it's going to be tragic.
SPEAKER_01And I think the Canadian public needs to know that. And I don't say this to chastise them, but I'm saying this is a great opportunity to show your support for the military. And I just don't mean with bumper stickers and pins and showing up on Remembrance Day. I also mean demand political accountability. These wounded troops are going to soon discover that the Canadian Armed Forces don't have much of a health care system. These guys are going to be discharged into the civilian systems of whatever, either where they're sent back to, or in the case of troops who will never be able to return to active duty,
SPEAKER_01they're going to go home. And the care they're going to get is going to depend on the level of primary care available and wherever home is for these boys. I think they're all males or troops. So we as a public, we need to make sure they get everything because they have paid their debt in blood and now the debt is on us. The thing that I do think we need to talk about, and you and I were both making this point.
SPEAKER_00As gently and responsibly as we possibly could.
SPEAKER_01The communications were awful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And can I also just say, if we're going to start trading these as training exercises, we need to be able to candidly acknowledge that the communications were awful. And if this were an attack, that would not be an acceptable way to respond to the public.
SPEAKER_01I want to read verbatim. The Line, theline.
SPEAKER_00I will say, as someone who was in Alberta that day, the winds were biblical. They were crazy, crazy high. So that's legit.
SPEAKER_01So Ashley Stewart, again, of Global News, sent a proper request to Environment Canada asking about What weather alerts, if any, had been issued that day? And I might not describe this totally accurately, so Ashley, forgive me if I mangle this, but as I understood her explanation of it, Environment Canada website will show warnings and watches for weather, but that when a watch ends, it just vanishes off the website. It isn't like, click here to see watches over the last seven days.
SPEAKER_01That information exists, but it's not possible. So she had sent Environment Canada a request wanting to know what watches and warnings, if any, had been posted leading up to the fire. And she also asked for basically like a spreadsheet that kind of showed the detail of this is a watch that was issued. This is when it was rescinded. All of this is information that Environment Canada would have. Like this is literally what it does. I would like to read for you what Environment Canada sent back to her, which she tweeted.
SPEAKER_01Hello, Ashley. Apologies for the delay in responding. And remember, Jen, I'm going to just jump in here. Ashley said, may I please have the data about what watches were issued? The government of Canada are deeply saddened by the tragic incident that occurred this past weekend at Canadian Forces Base Wainwright in Alberta. We wish to extend our sincere condolences to the families, friends, and loved ones of those who lost their lives. Environment and Climate Change Canada is providing its full collaboration to the Department of National Defense and the Canadian Armed Forces.
SPEAKER_01Due to the ongoing investigation into the incident, the Department will not comment further at this time. Our thoughts are with those who sustained injuries and their families and with all members of Canada's Armed Forces. That, I think, Jen, is a Hall of Fame entry into non-responses by the Canadian government to request for information.
SPEAKER_00Can I just be blunt here? Because we've got a problem as journalists where we have to draw The Line between not being conspiracy theorists and still being critical and skeptical of authority because that's our job. And Matt, can I be blunt that I don't buy whatever version of events has been presented to the public? It doesn't make sense. Like, I'm sorry, I pulled up the satellite images of all the grass fires and all the wildfires within Alberta at the time that this was happening.
SPEAKER_00And CFB Rainwright's sort of live fire exercise was the only place within 200 clicks that had anything resembling a wildfire happening. Like it would be a different matter if like there were like a, I understand the winds were high that day, absolutely. And winds contribute to grass fires, no question. But if this were a perfectly naturally occurring wildfire that had nothing to do with the live fire exercises that were happening on the base,
SPEAKER_00then I would expect there to be a couple of grass fires in that region and there's none. That doesn't make sense to me. The answer here that makes sense to me Given the information that I have, is that the live fire exercise probably caused a grass fire. The live fire exercise probably shouldn't have been happening at a moment of high winds. And then the grass fire got out of control. That's the answer that actually makes sense to me. And it sounds to me like all of the communications coming out of CAF and
SPEAKER_00the government of Canada is coordinated to cover up that fact. It's a cover your ass exercise. That's what this feels like to me as a journalist. Now, I could be wrong about that. I don't have the data to make that conclusion decisively. But there has been an extraordinary lack of openness and an extraordinary use of passive voice in all of the communications coming out of the Canadian Armed Forces. And I don't find that to be... And also, there's been a lot of canards.
SPEAKER_00Like, you don't get the information before the families of the dead get the information. And I reject those canards. One, nobody was demanding the names of the dead before next of kin notification. No one was demanding that at all. And secondly, actually, as members of the public, we do get the information, the basic information about what's going on immediately and urgently and before the dead, the families of the dead are notified. CAF is not a private entity. It is a public entity. And if there is a mass casualty event at a Canadian Air Force base, that is a public emergency, not a private one.
SPEAKER_00So those answers are unacceptable. Even a week later, we don't have clear clarity on what the fuck happened here. That's unacceptable. That's not normal in a democracy. I'm sorry, it isn't. Even in America, which is going through its own little moment, that wouldn't be acceptable to the American public and nor should it. It follows on a culture of lack of transparency at every level of government. I think the culture of transparency is rooted in a society that has a high trust
SPEAKER_00for government, that is sometimes abused and misused, and I don't find it acceptable.
SPEAKER_01The response Ashley got from Environment Canada is almost verbatim. I gave off-the-record remarks recently to a private group, so obviously I can't tell you who the group was, but one of the things I can say is that when I was giving off the record remarks to a private organization, I was asked kind of a question that was kind of along the lines of what are the challenges the media in this country faces today? And I mean, God, that's how much time do you have? But one of them that I identified for the group was
SPEAKER_01that we actually do not usually have the power to compel cooperation. This has always worked on some combination of the honor system Mutual self-interest, right? Because the government and government agencies have typically understood that satisfying public curiosity, cooperating with the media in the long term was in their own self-interest. Something has broken in Canada where that has stopped being true. And if someone just decides to not give me information,
SPEAKER_01even if legally and morally and ethically, I probably should have it. Beyond appealing to their sense of shame or trying to exert public pressure, I cannot change that. In theory, we have the access to information system, but it's broken. Yeah. And it's like everybody knows it's broken. We'll never get the answers.
SPEAKER_00We'll never get the answers from our access to information system. That will never happen.
SPEAKER_01And I don't think the public understands that.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01And I think one of the other things the public doesn't understand is that The Line, theline. Is juggling multiple stories at a time and if a government agency takes a week to get back to them with an answer, they have been assigned 10 new stories in between now and then.
SPEAKER_01Is it worth then going and writing about something that was already a week old news? The government has gotten very good at waiting us out and there is nothing you or I or Ashley or anyone else can do about it. Except on those occasions where we either get a whistleblower or a document gets leaked in some way or on the rare occasions where there is something like an accessed information request that succeeds. And as I wrote often at the time, and you and I talked about this a ton, the reason I was so excited to get the Public Order Emergency Commission and
SPEAKER_01the Foreign Interference Commission was because that's one of the only opportunities we had in this country to have a scenario where someone had the authority to compel disclosure. A justice can do things that Jen and I cannot.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01And we learned so much. So much. But we were learning things we probably should have known already. And to your point, Jen, about being conspiratorial, here's the problem I have. I assess that the government of Canada's normal way of communicating is Is so indistinguishable for how it would communicate if it was attempting to cover something up. Yep. But I can't tell the fucking difference.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So if the government of Canada is trying to cover something up, it would behave in a way that to me cannot be easily separated from how it behaves almost all the time. During the pandemic, I don't have this anymore. This would have been at my old National Post email. But I had gotten an email that was virtually indistinguishable from what Ashley got, which was basically the government had announced that it was like doing a crash production of a vaccine production facility.
SPEAKER_01Like, we're going to have this thing ready. We're going to break ground. We're going to have it operating. We'll be ready to make vaccine. And it gave a fairly specific timeline. And I remember sending them an email just kind of going, hey. Thankfully, hey, just referring back to this announcement with these specific deadlines, what is the status on the first two? Because according to the previous timeline, we would already have done these two things. Have we? Like that was literally it. Have we done these things? And the response I got back was basically, hello, Matt, thank you so much for your curiosity.
SPEAKER_01The government of Canada remains committed to keeping Canadians safe during the COVID-19 pandemic. Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Thank you. And then none of the questions that I had asked were answered. But what I got was the approved political talking points. That is what the communication staff exists to do. They do not exist to answer the questions of the citizenry or the press. They exist to issue political talking points to voters.
SPEAKER_00And also, we've learned that the only way to get information about what's happening in the government is to go around those people.
SPEAKER_01Well, obviously, I'm not going to reveal sources. Ah, hmm. But I had to really bite my tongue a couple of days ago because some people who I like and respect who are passionate but less experienced than me in media stuff were being pissy with me and going, Matt, the military probably doesn't even know what you're asking about yet. You have to give them grace. You have to give them time. They probably don't even know yet.
SPEAKER_00Well, then they're allowed to say we don't know, by the way. That is an acceptable communications answer. Second of all, I already had the internal
SPEAKER_01fucking memo. Yeah. I knew exactly what the military knew because I had read their internal memo. Yeah. And thanks again for the person who sent it to me. And I didn't say anything in public at the time.
SPEAKER_00Wait, you have the internal memo and you haven't shared what's in the internal memo, Matt?
SPEAKER_01I did.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00All right.
SPEAKER_01Can I just say, look, You and the rest of our team already knew. Okay.
SPEAKER_00But it was like just how frustrated I was. I didn't find that internal memo to be compelling either, by the way. There was a lot of passive voice in that internal memo.
SPEAKER_01No, but basically there was information in there that people were yelling at me the military couldn't possibly have. And of course they fucking had it. Of course they had it.
SPEAKER_00And also, nobody was demanding perfection either. Nobody was demanding a point-by-point. We've done this before, guys. We understand that information is fluid in the first few days after a tragedy. We're not dumbasses. We've been doing this for a long time. We know that casualties are fluid. We know that death counts are fluid. We know that you don't have a technical point-by-point readout or a TikTok just yet.
SPEAKER_01And we don't want to know the names of the dead.
SPEAKER_00I'm not looking for the names of the dead at that point. But hey, was this a Russian attack? That's a reasonable thing for the public to know. And if you knew that it wasn't, you need to come out with that really quickly. Not having McGinty come out a couple hours later and be like, this is a delicate and ongoing situation. Like, you know, like the non-answers were compounding. So, look, this is the thing that I just want to say. This is why this matters. One, we are in an era in which bad actors internally and externally are trying
SPEAKER_00to undermine our democracies by undermining trust in institutions. Okay? Trust in institutions is fundamental. Absolutely rooted in your ability to act in ways that are trustworthy and credible and your ability to communicate those actions to the public in ways that they understand. So if your communications culture is about covering your ass as opposed to transparency, if your communications culture doesn't know how to communicate with people, the trust in the fundamental institution is going to corrode and corrode quickly.
SPEAKER_00Secondly, and I'm gonna say this again, I am not an insano conspiracy theorist. I've got a pretty good track record of being level-headed and grounded. I don't believe CAF's version of events as presented as of today. I don't believe them. They are not credible, clear, honest, or forthright enough given where we are in the timeline of the moment, like given how many days have passed since we know this. If I don't believe your version of events, that is a mainstream position.
SPEAKER_00And that means that your credibility is being corroded by the fucking hour. Yeah. Okay. I think you're covering it up. I think you're covering up what really happened here. And I think you're actively and knowingly covering up what really happened here. And that is the conclusion that I'm making based on the information that you've released and the plain facts that are available to me. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm wrong. Okay. But I'm telling you honestly, I'm telling you honestly, I don't believe you.
SPEAKER_00That's a problem for you. Because if something bad were to happen, it means I don't believe you more next time.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to be sarcastic here and I hope the audience will indulge me because I'm not making light of the tragedy that killed these boys. But I was talking with a colleague inside who's pretty embarrassed about all this. There are a lot of people in the government who do not disagree with what Jen and I are saying. This is a policy issue and a procedure issue. But I was saying to him, if you guys were responsible for announcing major international historical events, it would sound something like this.
SPEAKER_01Church services at Pearl Harbor disrupted. Some Titanic passengers to arrive two days later aboard Carpathia. Further updates to come. President Kennedy luncheon canceled due to route change. Several flights delayed after diverting to New York City. Road closures in effect in southern Manhattan.
SPEAKER_01This is how the government of Canada communicates stuff. And someone, I think in good faith, sent me a pretty pissy email, but I actually do think asked a good faith question of what kind of answer would have satisfied me when the Emergency what had just happened. And I've actually thought about that. And I think something that goes, and I'm just winging this, but something basically like, because what we actually got was there has been a fire and there are casualties. This is a delicate situation. We will provide updates in coming days.
SPEAKER_01That's pretty much verbatim what the initial statement was. I think I would have been satisfied with something like, I think it was 3rd Battalion, if I'm remembering correctly, but 3rd Battalion Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry was participating in an exercise today in The Line, theline.
SPEAKER_01To hospitals. This includes local hospitals and some critical cases will be transported further away. We ask the public's cooperation in staying off the roads and keeping communication channels clear while we evacuate the wounded. At this time, we are sad to report there are fatalities. We need time to locate and notify the families of these fatalities, and we request the media's and the public's patience while we do this. We will convene a full briefing at 0900 local time tomorrow morning
SPEAKER_01where we will provide more information. Yep.
SPEAKER_00That should have been like the first five hours.
SPEAKER_01If that had been the statement, I wouldn't have said boo when this was happening because I would have been satisfied. And again, because some of us happened to see some of the internal communications, all of that information was available when the government announced there's been a fire and there's some casualties. The reflex in the Canadian communications apparatus is to say as little as possible
SPEAKER_01and to allow other people to fill the void. Nothing, Jen, I said in that statement would have violated the privacy of any family.
SPEAKER_00Nothing at all.
SPEAKER_01It would not have complicated in the slightest any of the efforts to notify anyone who needed to be told anything about their loved ones.
SPEAKER_00Just one more point, and then I think we should wrap this up here. This happened the day before a referendum on separation. And what was happening on social media literally within hours, like that statement I think would have quelled a lot of this. But what was happening within hours is that the total lack of clear communication created a vacuum that the separatists very quickly were eager to fill. They were claiming this was a false flag exercise. They were claiming all kinds, like this was done on purpose. Like they were claiming all kinds of crazy ass shit.
SPEAKER_00And they were able to gain some traction within their own social media circles on this Because of the lack of trust in the institution that is being developed, and also because of the lack of clarity of timely communications. Also, I would just point out finally, several days after this event, we should have a clear answer as to whether or not the live fire exercise caused the grass fire. We should know that by now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I want to, yeah, Jen, I'm with you. I don't really have anything else to say except I do want to take one moment to speak directly to some of my friends in the Canadian Armed Forces and the Department of National Defense. First of all, I'm really sorry.
SPEAKER_00Of course. God. We're not inhuman. We're not assholes most of the time. We don't mean you harm.
SPEAKER_01No, it's worse than that. We mean them well.
SPEAKER_00Really well.
SPEAKER_01We're trying to help. You know that meme of the woman going, I'm saving you. I'm saving you. And then she falls into the pool. A lot of my friends in uniform have bad experiences with the media where, for instance, some dead troopers family gets a knock on the door and some reporter shoves a microphone on their faces. How does it feel that you just lost your son?
SPEAKER_00I've done that job and it sucks on both sides, let me tell you.
SPEAKER_01I didn't have to do a lot of that, but I had to do a little bit of it and ugh. It's awful. But what I need my friends in uniform to understand is that families must be notified is turning into a all-purpose excuse that the military uses in the same way gutless politicians use the matters before the courts. Yep. And the military is not thought of often by the public,
SPEAKER_01but it is thought of well when the public thinks about it. And I would prefer that not to be destroyed by the military starting to communicate the same way the heritage ministry or the finance ministry or any other generic Canadian government ministry communicates. And this is not a federal only problem. It's a fucking nightmare to get the Provincials to talk. Large municipalities are nightmares. Small municipalities, often weirdly good because those people aren't comms trained. You call the person on their listed phone number.
SPEAKER_01It's a landline. They actually answer it and they'll answer your question.
SPEAKER_00Comms training is going to destroy liberal democracy. There's my thesis.
SPEAKER_01No, I agree with it.
SPEAKER_00Comms training is destroying liberal democracy because none of you talk like people anymore.
SPEAKER_01It took the government 12 hours to tell us that it wasn't an attack or sabotage.
SPEAKER_00It's fucking insane, guys. It's insane.
SPEAKER_01At a moment of international tension when Canadians have been told repeatedly that our country is under existential threat.
SPEAKER_00The day before a separation referendum in which we've been warned about foreign interference.
SPEAKER_01When our allies in Europe are seeing hybrid warfare attacks targeting their military facilities, we had a mass casualty event. On a Canadian Armed Forces base, and the government didn't want to talk about it.
SPEAKER_00You've got one final thing. Like and subscribe.
SPEAKER_01You know, I am not a man without a sense of irony, Jen. You and I are just speaking in the last segment a lot about transparency, and here I'm going to be non-transparent for a little bit, but I did want to offer just this quick update. As I mentioned at the beginning of the podcast, I've been off for the last two weeks because my wife had surgery because my wife has cancer. I'm still figuring out, Jen, and this is something I'll talk with you about when the time is right, how much of this I ever want to disclose in public fully because we're still
SPEAKER_01a family with privacy rights. As you said in the last segment, a catastrophe on a military base is a public problem. The catastrophe in this household over the last 12 months is a family one. So I need to kind of figure out what I want to say in public. But I will say this much. My wife has recently had a surgery that, to our knowledge, cleared the last of the cancer she had. And we're going to have to be very, very vigilant because her kind of cancer has a bad habit of coming back. But to be at a point in less than a year of this nightmare where she is now,
SPEAKER_01as far as we know, free of cancer is astonishing because she presented in such a bad condition. I never thought we'd get here. And so many line readers and podcast audience members have been so incredibly gracious. And I I'm still figuring out what to say in public, but I did want to say thank you and That's the update. As far as we know right now, we've beaten it. Whether it stays that way, only time will tell. And that's a miracle. So for those who prayed for us, thank you. And keep it up because we're not done yet. Whether or not we've beaten this forever,
SPEAKER_01Jen, is something that will only be revealed in the fullness of time. So I'm glad I'm bald already because if I wasn't, I'd be ripping my hair out. But that's as personal as I want to get today. Yeah. What I'm going to have to figure out now is what I want to say about the healthcare system. And I said to Jen before we started recording, I am a writer first. Podcasting is fun, but I'm a writer. I hate cliches.
SPEAKER_01As a writer, I try to avoid them. As an editor, I get them out. Like, don't tell me in writing you're going to cross that bridge when you get to it. Like, ew, don't do that to me. And I'm so self-conscious about this, Jen, because everything I would want to say about the healthcare system to date is a cliche. It is, my experience with the healthcare system has been almost verbatim what every talking point about the Canadian healthcare system is. We almost lost my wife because her illness was not caught early when it should have been.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And also gender effects absolutely played a role in that stereotypical gender effects. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Once it was caught, the system was phenomenal. Like the care she ended up getting was fantastic. But if we'd caught it two years earlier, the healthcare workers, here's another cliche, Canadian healthcare for you. The healthcare workers have been spectacular with like one or two exceptions. Like there was one doctor I think should be fired into a black hole and And there's one nurse who needs an attitude transplant. But after 11 months grinding this thing out, if that's the extent of my problems, we're doing okay.
SPEAKER_01The healthcare workers are heroes, and I want to build statues for them all. And even though I'm still trying to figure out what I'm going to say fully, there are certain individuals I am going to name publicly with my thanks when the time is right. Okay. The other cliche is that the system itself is a fucking catastrophe. What these people are accomplishing in the system is miraculous largely because of how hard the system makes them work to do it.
SPEAKER_01Canada is very, very good at oncology, but we are years behind state of the art. If you have a fairly routine cancer, you're going to get the best standard care in the world. We're really good at that bulk assembly line kind of treatments. But if you need something cutting edge, you'd better hope you're American with good insurance or even European. They're ahead of us. We're behind. And that's something I'm going to be talking about a lot in the next little while. But the big picture I want to talk about today, Jen, I want to give you credit.
SPEAKER_01You had this wonderful term. You called it the octopus economy. Did you invent that? Was that yours?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think octopus economy was mine. But there's a bunch of ways of saying that effectively you have an overly centralized economy that has a lot of rent seeking. Yeah. With people who have access to social and political capital.
SPEAKER_01I've been thinking about that so often during my parade through the healthcare system of these last, oh God, almost a year, almost, it's a year almost to the week. And one of the things we're going to have to figure out as a country is the administration. Of our healthcare system. Because I think one day I'm going to write a column
SPEAKER_01that basically describes our worst day in the system. Well, one of the things that happened, Jen, on that worst day in the system is that I watched someone die. And actually, because of some weird life experiences I've had, it wasn't even the first time, But what happened was that in a major hospital in the largest city of a very rich country, a very old man was wheeled in and there was no room to take him and he had no one
SPEAKER_01who was with him. And he lay there on a stretcher alone and he died. And it took a while for anyone to realize he was dead. And when someone finally came and checked on him, And the reason I was watching this is I was sitting in a goddamn waiting room chair. And this guy, because he had no bed to be in, was about 20 feet in front of me. And I saw a nurse kind of stop and look at him and check vitals. And I knew he was dead, Jen,
SPEAKER_01not because the nurse freaked out, but because their face had that neutral look. Just the game face came on. And the nurse very quietly stepped up and whispered to someone else. And the other person's game face came on and that person went and checked out this individual, this old man who just had a sheet over him. And they whispered some more and they wheeled that guy into a room, pulled the sheet and three or four more healthcare professionals went into the sheet
SPEAKER_01and I heard more whispering. And then all of them left and the sheet stayed closed. And I just kept watching because I had nowhere else to be. And after about an hour, a couple of guys in suits wheeled another stretcher into a room. And 10 or 15 minutes later, they left with the man's body zipped up in a nice body bag. Kind of somebody had like a nice zipper and like a velour cover. And they were very somber and they wheeled this guy away.
SPEAKER_01And as I was watching that, I was thinking to myself, eventually I'm going to tell this story in more detail. And when I do, the hospital is going to respond through its media relations apparatus because it's going to be bad publicity for them. And there are going to be people at the hospital who are going to view this thing entirely through the lens of, is this going to hurt my next board appointment? The people who run these hospitals, and I'm sure many of them are doctors and are medical professionals
SPEAKER_01and they're patient focused, but there is an entire element of our healthcare system that is exactly like what Jen and I were just talking about in our last segment. The job is not to communicate information to the people. It's to protect the institutions.
SPEAKER_00And to protect the institutions from the very critique that could actually help the institutions maintain trust in the public and get better.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And I don't know yet emotionally what I'm going to do with my feelings of incredible gratitude to the institutions that employ the people who saved my wife. But also to the people who, when I talk about the old man who died alone in a hallway while I watched it happen. And he died in his sleep. There was no struggle or anything. He just closed his eyes and he died.
SPEAKER_00And that might have been unavoidable.
SPEAKER_01Oh, no, I think it probably was, but he died alone in a hallway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And there is absolutely no one in this country who thinks that's acceptable. But there are very well-paid people who will view that not as a human tragedy, but as a media relations problem. And the people who are in charge ultimately, their personal incentives and priorities are are not to prevent the next person from dying alone in a hallway. Their personal incentives and priorities are to protect the institution because if they do a bad job at that,
SPEAKER_01they won't get an even better board appointment in two years. I don't know how to fix this problem, Jen.
SPEAKER_00I think you need to write a book. And I think you need to just embrace the fact that some of it's going to be cliched, but it's going to be a personal story, you know, with consent. And we'll give people some insight into what the reality of the system is and the parts that are successful and the parts that aren't in a way that's nuanced and personal and real. I think that's actually the answer here. Because, I mean, you and I both are aware that like one of the major problems that Canada has is that our national identity has attenuated to such an extent that we mistake,
SPEAKER_00you know, Public services for a nation. Canada's national identity is what you can get from a Service Canada kiosk. And one of those services is healthcare, right? So we're trapped into an increasingly dysfunctional healthcare system because our sense of self is too rooted in that at the expense of any other concept of national identity. And that means that the system can have compounding failures within it. And when you point out that there are compounding failures happening,
SPEAKER_00the answer you get from people is, well, you just want American style healthcare, fuck you, elbows up. And that is not constructive. That is not constructive opposition. That doesn't fix any problems. And unless we can have an honest sort of look at what's happening and what's going wrong, we can't have an honest reform of the failures. So I think that's probably your destiny here. And I think that's probably her destiny with her consent and her enthusiastic consent, I would say.
SPEAKER_00And I hope that you guys get to that point. But until then, I think that that's probably where you should be leaning your energy.
SPEAKER_01It's hard to fix a thing when the thing is focused on avoiding admitting the problems.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, basically all of Canada right now is a dysfunctional narcissistic family that is doing its damnedest to pretend that everything's great.
SPEAKER_01I think you had it kind of in the last segment, right? I think one of the largest obstacles to fixing Canadian healthcare right now is the Canadian healthcare system. It's collective because there's all these different agencies in it, right? But using the term collectively, what is preventing us from fixing Canadian healthcare is Canadian healthcare's various communication professionals.
SPEAKER_00I think that – Anyway, like I said, communications as an industry is a cancer on liberal democracy right now, especially in places like Canada where the culture around non-transparency is so entrenched. People are terrified. People in this country are fucking terrified to speak openly about anything. Why do you think my CBC hit went viral? It's not because I'm some raging genius. Yeah. I just speak openly about what's happening.
SPEAKER_00That's the bar, guys. It's the only bar and everyone's terrified to do it. I don't understand.
SPEAKER_01Something that has been interesting for the last almost year, it was our friend Andrew Coyne once described journalists kind of at our level as C-list celebrities, which I think is perfect.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I wouldn't want to be any higher.
SPEAKER_01Most people will not recognize Jen or I if they run into us in a food court at a mall. But some people will. It's a small subset of the population will know exactly who we are and the majority will have no idea who we are. And as I've been sort of marching through the healthcare system, I have had that situation where for most of the nurses, I'm just another worried husband. A couple of them go, holy shit, I know exactly who you are. I kind of hated that because I just wanted to be a husband when I was there.
SPEAKER_01I didn't want to be doing like media relations of my own. Well, thank you for supporting The Line. Like, I didn't want to be doing that. It's like, fix my wife. Like, give her pain heads. But some people recognize me. The things the nurses and doctors have told me about the healthcare system. Like, as soon as they know who I was, I was their chance in a 45-second outpouring of grief to tell me what they really think is going on.
SPEAKER_00Don't we get that all the time, though? But we're getting that from D&D. We get that from every level of government where people are like, they'll talk to us candidly about what's going on, but they're too afraid to come forward themselves or they can't come forward themselves because they can't avoid the communications cancer at the heart of our society. So we're the ones who have to come up and be like, yeah, guys, the thing is fucked. But because we don't have the credibility of being inside the system, We can say the thing, but it doesn't necessarily get acted on.
SPEAKER_00And that's the breakdown in accountability and communications that we're talking about. And it's broken. It's broke.
SPEAKER_01We're going to need the people who are running the hospitals to start thinking more about the old man dying in the hallway and less about what their next board appointment is going to be.
SPEAKER_00And until and unless that
SPEAKER_01happens, it's going to get worse.
SPEAKER_00It is. And it's also but it's like it's everyone from the nurses to the hospital CEO. Is afraid to say what's actually happening. Everyone's afraid to speak openly now. It's just, I don't know what happened to us culturally. And I think, like I said, part of it is I think we have a culture of high trust. And because we have a culture of high trust, it's really, really hard to be the oppositional force within that culture. I also think that we have institutions that aren't used to having to earn trust. I think that's part of the problem.
SPEAKER_00They don't see it as their role to have to earn trust from the public. It's the public's job to sit down, shut up and take what they're told. And that lasts until it breaks. And then when it breaks, it breaks so hard. And I just, I don't know how to fix that because I think it goes beyond just incentive problems.
SPEAKER_01I think it's a deep cultural problem. Yeah, I think that's correct. I think what happened is that a million individual micro decisions that were made Entirely to maximize short-term incentives.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Agglomerated into a culture.
SPEAKER_00That's right.
SPEAKER_01And I don't know how to fix it. I'm not convinced it can be fixed. And it's going to get worse.
SPEAKER_00Things will have to break catastrophically before people are willing to start breaking out of their conditioning because I do think it's a social conditioning problem.
SPEAKER_01I think so too. I'm sorry. The funny thing is too, this segment actually started relatively optimistically. I've spent most of the last year thinking my wife was going to die. Now I think a lot would have to go wrong for her to die. So this should have been an uplifting segment. But as we move out of the immediate catastrophe of the medical situation, I'm going to have time to reflect on the whole experience and
SPEAKER_01And I'm still struggling to balance the awe and gratitude with the fear and contempt.
SPEAKER_00And I think that balance is going to be a beautiful aspect of your book because I think you can get into this in a nuanced way. Chapter one, awe.
SPEAKER_01Chapter two, contempt.
SPEAKER_00Well, maybe you just go emotion by emotion. But on that note, Matt, we have gone on way too long. We really have to wrap this the fuck up.
SPEAKER_01Www.readtheline.ca Like and subscribe. Talk to you soon. [music]
In the latest episode of The Line Podcast, recorded on November 20th, 2026, Matt Gurney hosts a special edition of the show with three guests and three very different conversations. This episode is brought to you by...
In this episode of On The Line, host Matt Gurney is joined by two guests to discuss hockey, inflation, politics, and whether Canada can finally get serious about building major infrastructure. This episode is brought to...
In the latest episode of The Line Podcast, recorded on November 13th, 2026, Matt Gurney is joined from Montreal by Andrew Potter, filling in for Jen Gerson. This episode is brought to you by Cameco. Building Canada’s...
In this episode of On The Line, host Matt Gurney is joined by two guests to discuss what the federal budget tells us about Canada’s plans for national defence, immigration, housing and the economy. This episode is...
In the latest episode of The Line Podcast, recorded between November 5th and 6th, 2026, Matt Gurney and Jen Gerson are joined by special guest Stephanie Levitz of The Globe and Mail. This episode is also brought to you...