#59: Andy Farrell's Four Fly Halfs - Ireland Summer Series Preview
25 minAudio
Episode 59, and the club season is done - back-to-back URC champions, Leo Cullen's departure announced, and now the focus shifts to Andy Farrell's Ireland squad heading south for the inaugural Nations Championship. Jack Crowley is ruled out, which leaves four fly-halves in the squad: Sam Prendergast, Harry Byrne, Ciarán Frawley, and Nathan Doak - the Ulster scrum-half who can also play 10. Here is what I'm hitting on this week's episode: 🎙️ Discussion Point; Andy Farrell's Four Fly Halfs - Crowley ruled out, Prendergast's Grand Final form, Byrne's Champions Cup credentials, Frawley's South Africa tour experience, Doak's versatility at 9 and 10, and who starts in Sydney, Newcastle, and Auckland. 🏉 Next game; Ireland's Nations Championship Southern Series - Australia (4 July, Sydney), Japan (11 July, Newcastle), and New Zealand (18 July, Eden Park).
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome back to The The Leinster Listen. I'm your host Mick Linnane and it's episode 59. And it's a special one I suppose because normally I would start this by saying the preview or review of whatever match was on. But we don't have any more matches because we're back -to -back winners of the URC. No, this is actually a special episode and it's probably going to be one large discussion point with the focus on the summer series that is coming up. Well, I suppose you want to call it the Nations Championship. And yeah. let's get into it all right so folks the nation's championship
is coming up the summer series is a summer campaign and i suppose i i wanted to make this episode since it's a little bit of an interim one in between uh what's coming and what's happened but uh we're going to go through the squad a little bit and we'll focus on the fly half position now Let's start this off by going through a little bit of the squad picture as it is now. So, as you would have known, on the 17th of June, Andy Andy Farrell named his 36 -man Ireland squad for, well, the summer series, I suppose, is what we're
talking about. And within that, I do have to note that there technically is four out -halves mentioned there. And one of them is not who you think I'm going to say, but they are Sam Pendergast, Harry Harry Byrne, Ciarán Ciarán Frawley and Nathan Nathan Doak. Now, you would have said Jack Crowley would have been here, but look, he's injured, he's not travelling, and that's just it. And the reason I say Nathan Nathan Doak there, and I know he normally plays scrum half, but he is a good kicker, and he does occasionally play 10 position for Ulster. I'm going to dive
a little bit deeper into that. And, you know, it's a strange one. You might be thinking, all right, he's pulling at straws here, but I might convince you otherwise, coming down. the line here but look let's go back a little bit obviously Jack Jack Crowley ruled out there he got a blood vessel injury in his leg he can't play and hasn't played since mid -April Munster boss Clayton McMillan obviously confirmed that diagnosis there and that's just it he's out fair enough I don't think Andy Andy Farrell kind of expected him before he put out that squad anyway so it is what it is on
top of that though unfortunately Andrew Porter is also out which is a significant blow to the pack and then they also have Caelan Doris and Tommy O 'Brien who've also been tipped away from that Tommy Bryan obviously getting that groin complaint and Dara's obviously going off very early there within six minutes of that URC final with a foot injury so well first and foremost there Dan Dan Sheehan obviously taking over as captaincy so that's fantastic for him huge step up there but more notably the ones the players that were called up you know in the stead of Tommy Bryan and Caelan
Dorris is two fantastic players. And they're coming from Ulster. And two fantastic players, mind you. And you definitely know them by now. And that is Bryn Ward and Zach Ward. Bryn Ward is a 21 -year -old. He's obviously brother to Zach Ward. Bryn is the back row in for Dorris. And Zach Ward is the back end for Tommy O 'Brien. Now... Both of them are, if you know them, sons of Andy Ward, who had 28 Ireland caps and played in the 1999 World Cup. But look, they are Ulster's representation to the squad, and they actually
achieve a double -figure squad number now because they've been added into it. There's also three uncapped players in Connacht, and they are Billy Bohan, Sam Illo, and Sean Jansen. And that actually makes five uncapped players in a total now. So that's, you know... I think I would have said it in another episode before, but it's fantastic to see uncapped players being brought in for these kind of, oh, I was going to say Mickey Mouse championships, but they're not Mickey Mouse championships. They obviously are going to have weighting to the world rankings, but they're
not ones that you would probably want, you know, a lot of effort put into, especially coming up to the likes of the World Cup and another six nations. But look, it's fantastic. The Leinster lads flew out there on Monday. You know, they're in Australia now. it's gonna be crazy it's gonna be fantastic games it's great for those five uncapped players as well really hope they they shine through and this is you know this is the time to experiment with the team you don't want to obviously experiment you know right before the world cup so hopefully that's this does actually change the dynamic but realistically what i want
to talk about here is that fly half position. Now, as I said before, Jack Jack Crowley has been ruled out. I do think if he wasn't injured, he might have been pipped for the starting position for most of these. Just considering how Sam had performed at the international level there in Six Nations, just really didn't shine properly for Andy Andy Farrell. Now, as we all know, he played a fantastic last three games and really stepped up when he needed to in the URC. So he probably has my full backing at this moment. But, you know. I do want to talk a little bit more about
what is actually happening in that squad. And I gave a little hint there saying that there is potentially four fly halves being sent out, which I think is actually crazy. You know, we definitely have enough depth there to just send out two. Now, as I said, Nathan Nathan Doak obviously plays scrum half, but we've all seen him play that 10 position. We've all seen him slot balls over those posts very easily. But let's just start off with Sam Priner -Gaster. You know, he's 15 Ireland caps there. He started his first Six Nations game. The first two Six Nations games, actually, this year. So, you know, had been given
literally the reins and unfortunately just didn't capitalize on it. But, you know, he is Leinster's man for the big nights now. He's done such a fantastic job in those last three games. Played an absolute blinder there in the grand final. So, look, he's our preferred start, obviously. Harry Harry Byrne. Again, he is a very good player, but really wasn't given the reins there in the URC. Now, he was obviously given it in the European Championship, but the form book says at the moment that San Sam Prendergast should be started in Sydney,
and that is what's happening. Okay, the team sheet hasn't been announced for that first game, but I have every faith that San Sam Prendergast is going to start on that. But, you know, questions remain there about the game management, and it's a bit strange, right? Because looking at that team sheet, the untrained eye. I'm not saying I'm a trained eye, but the untrained eye might say, oh yeah, look, sure, you have Sam Sam Prendergast, you have Harry Harry Byrne, and you have Ciarán Ciarán Frawley, right? But no, I think, I honestly think Nathan Nathan Doak has been put in there as an absolute backup
to the 10. And the reason I say that is because you have Craig Casey, who is a fantastic scrum half, has been put on that team, and obviously Jameson Gibson -Park. I don't really think you need more than two scrum halves, right? It's... Okay, well, fair enough. Nathan Doe can play that. So you have three, right? But I do think that he has been put there specifically for that 10. And I think it's going to be an experiment. Do I think he's going to start at 10? Probably not. But let's just kind of go through each of them and see what kind of comes up here. So Harry Harry Byrne, obviously, you know, fantastic that he's
been named in this squad first off because he only has four Ireland caps. Like, even when I saw that, I was like, no, I have to double check that. That doesn't seem right. He only has four. four stars well not even stars I'm assuming he probably came on for those but four caps for Ireland is just crazy and it really does show that he really came to the the Leinster squad at a very bad time you know he was obviously Sexton's you know like little apprentice coming on there he's Harry Harry Byrne's little brother so
he had all these people kind of putting him into their shadow putting him into his corner into his little box and you can stay there now and you can come out now when we go off to Six Nations and you can pop out every now and again and take the reins and that's it's unfortunate really when he you know he's come to then in this season when Sam Sam Prendergast really wasn't shown and he stepped up to the mark and he's done a fantastic job at it but it's just I even just still even though I've double checked it the fact he has four caps is just crazy moving on there to Ciarán
Ciarán Frawley you know he has 12 Ireland caps which is alright okay fair enough but he's a versatile option he actually you know starred at fly half on the 2024 summer tour to South Africa he actually started both tests there in Johannesburg and Cape Town and he did actually show an awful lot of composure and a calm head in in hostile environments and also you'll remember years and years ago when he came on to try to get that that drop goal against I think it was La Rochelle or maybe it was Toulouse actually but you know he can play 10 he can play 12 or he can play 15 but really he you know he's moving to Connacht because
he wants to play 10 I think Andy Andy Farrell knows that He's definitely been vocal about it. And, you know, he wasn't getting it under Leo Cullen. So he is a dark horse here. And, you know, at New Zealand, at Eden Park, I think that might even be the game for him. I think they might give him the option of starting at 10 there. But, you know, the one I want to focus on here is actually Nathan Nathan Doak. Now, Nathan Nathan Doak only has one Ireland cap. Again, something I had to double check. I was just like, this can't be right. But he made his senior debut there against Wales and Six Nations in March 2026. So literally
just this year. Obviously, he's the Ulster scrum half by trade. I'm not saying he shouldn't be playing scrum half. He is a very good scrum half. But he's played fly half throughout his career as well. He started at 10 for Ulster when he was needed. He's a very handy goal kicker. And, you know, he's another string to Andy Farrell's bow there. He is a very good one. And Andy Farrell picked him as a 4 -10 option, in my opinion, because Craig Hayes, he's the other scrum half, and Jameson McBark is the other scrum half. And that's an awful lot. So why is he being put in there? Is
he really thinking that one or both of those scrum halves are going to get injured and he needs a backup scrum half? No, I don't think so. Look, am I saying he's going to start against Australia or New Zealand? No. But, now, here. Stay with me here now. Stay with me, right? I do think he might be started in the Japan game. I just, I think he will be. And look, I might be saying, because look, I have a tinfoil hat on right now, if you can't see it because I'm
only talking, right? But I do think he's going to start against Japan because he might just be that experiment that we need. And look, Nathan Doak at 10 with Jamison Jamison Gibson-Park or Casey at 9 would be an absolute weapon. He'd be an absolute weapon. He's so good. So look. He's the outside of the four there, but he's in the squad for a reason. He's 22 years old. It's his first proper Ireland tour. And I think he is there because Andy Andy Farrell wants him as a potential 10 for the Ireland gig. And, you know, as I said before, this is the
experimental time. You have the five uncapped players. Why not? just throw another hat in the ring there you know Andy Andy Farrell has the perfect opportunity to to blow the discussion around the 10 in the Ireland gig out of the water here he's going to make the media fraught at the mouth if he puts Nathan Nathan Doak at 10 right and it won't even take Sam Sam Prendergast being injured or it won't even take Kieran Fowley being injured if he just starts him a 10 or even puts him as the backup 10 I think that is going to start a huge
conversation there and I'm look I don't know anything about Nathan Duck I don't know if his aspirations there are to be a 10 to be honest every time I've seen him play you know he's opting for the kicks he's opting for the kick goals obviously Ulster have a fantastic 10 already but I think he has been you know put in the same position as Ciarán Ciarán Frawley has in Ulster in the sense that he probably wants to start at 10 but newer 10s are coming along and are just a little bit better than him and he's he's been pushed to the side and look as I said he's fantastic from half but you have to wonder what Andy Andy Farrell
is thinking putting four lads there who can play a fly half into that squad now I do think, though, right, if Nathan Nathan Doak starts as 10 in any of those games, Ciarán Folley is going to blow his top. Like, imagine moving to Connacht, right, and thinking, right, this is my time to prove myself as a 10, get onto the international gig, be put in that fly half. shirt and then Nathan Doe comes along a natural scrum half and gets that 10 position I'd feel for Ciarán Frawley now to be honest he's a fantastic player and I as I
said before I'm raging he's leaving Leinster but obviously himself and Leo just had literally the end of their conversations but yeah I don't know like what do you think is it is it potentially what Andy Andy Farrell trying to do you know coming into like the last year before the World Cup comes around is he thinking right I need to I need to sort out this 10 position so why not put a little bit more pressure on the two boys that are obviously pipped for the you know the starting position they're obviously being Sam Sam Prendergast and Jack Jack Crowley now Harry Harry Byrne
honestly I do think he needs his time I think they should put him in as the 10 in one of those games start him I think start him right he obviously played a fantastic series in the European Champions Cup fair enough the last game the actual final wasn't fantastic Sam Sam Prendergast obviously came on for him but I do think he's actually shown potential there I think he needs to be given the opportunity to show himself in the international level and look as I said before I'm probably battling both sides at table here because I've
often said that we need to have less players from Leinster fielding the Irish team I suppose this time you probably are seeing them because as I said Ulster after hitting a double figures now for their team fronting the ireland team as well so but again an awful lot of those players you're looking at are lenzer players and the fact that the two warbirds come up is mainly because two lenzer players are injured but look maybe i am being a little bit out on a whim here maybe it is too far fetched maybe it is tinfoil hat uh time for this but i was just looking through
that sheet again and i just i couldn't help but notice that sound rounder guest harry burn kieran frawley and Nathan Nathan Doak are all very good fly halves when they need to be. So look, I suppose in a sentence, I guess, do I think he's going to start? No. Do I think he'll be an option? Absolutely. And to be honest, I can't really see a time when Nathan Nathan Doak is going to be put on that scrum half position first. Maybe Japan,
but first before Craig Casey and Jefferson Gibson Park. Those lads are just, they're so good. Obviously, Jameson is probably going to get the position first, and he'll have Craig Casey on the bench. But, like, if you're really bringing Nathan Nathan Doak as a backup for an injury, that is, well, as it is, an insult, really. So that's why I'm thinking, I'm thinking, I'm putting this little tinfoil hat on, I'm just pondering around, I'm trying to stir the pot here. But look, I also think that he probably should be given a shot. He's
a very good player. He's a very good track record with actually putting him over the posts at hard angles as well. And the fact that he only ever has one Ireland cap is also something that should be considered there as well. He obviously hasn't been tried and tested in that 10 position. Obviously hasn't been tried and tested in the scrum half position, naturally enough, since he only has one cap. but yeah I don't know look who starts where maybe okay let's go through it right so we have Australia on the 4th of July Sam Prendergast 100 % he's going to start there I'd say we're all in agreement here you go with what you know
that's it no experimentation round one you don't want to do that against Schmitz Wallabies and obviously I'd say Harry Byrne is going to be on the bench and Ciarán Frawley within the bench they're covering 10 and 15 respectively yeah fair enough now Japan right japan i think is the rotation game right i think you're going to see an awful lot of those uncapped players being brought on to that game now that's not putting anything against japan japan are a very good team they have gotten the experience through all those kiwis going over to make bank so they've been they've been looking at all those plays they do a very good job and
they've obviously had those huge upsets where they beat us in the world cup and they've beaten south africa in the world cup you know huge upsets there they're a team to be reckoned with now in the nation series we don't really care and we're not so we don't really care well we don't really care right but we'll say that kind of hushed we'll say that the the the quiet part out loud we don't really care right the world cup obviously is the main the main event and the six nations obviously is another big event that we want to actually perform well in but that japan game right 11th of july it's in newcastle
obviously down south not the newcastle ripe sales i think we're gonna see a huge and heavily rotated team right i think farrell's gonna say right this is my time to do a bit of an experimentation even if we lose this no one's really gonna care if we put a brand new team out right and mark my words now i'm not a betting man but mark my words doke at 10 against japan that'll tell you a lot about farrell's thinking now farrell if you're listening to this fair play to you you finally found a podcast where to listen where
to listen and do however don't take me As someone who should be trusted with these decisions. But why not? Why not just throw a dog at that? He might be an absolute star. He might be a star. He might come out there and miss absolutely nothing. So, why not? Why not? Now, New Zealand, 18 July. don't fucking do that right that's the that's the acid test you cannot especially at Eden Park you cannot play anything that we are not absolutely sure about uh go hell for leather with that one
and put the entire uh team that you've always put out against that team because we cannot lose against the I want to say I want of all those games I just want us to be the all blacks Jesus Christ please please please um so with that obviously go with Sam Sam Prendergast and then it'll be frawley uh sorry might know it'll be harry burn probably as a backup there or but you know what probably frawley's there as well as as you know it'll be no yeah it'd probably be a four maybe a four or two ah you don't know you look i don't know
but what i'm saying here is i probably sound a bit crazy now i'm taking the tinfoil hat off sorry look i i think with that one you have to probably just play what you know we need that one that's the that's That's the game changer one. You need to have that, especially going into the World Cup. You need to have that game solid. But look, three games, four fly halves. I think someone's going to miss out entirely. But that's part of the story. And I do think that the media will go absolutely bonkers. if Nathan Nathan Doak starts 10 in one of those games so why not it'll actually probably revitalize an
awful lot of this discussion around the 10 around you know the Ireland team are we ready for the World Cup are we going to dominate are we going to get to the semi -final I think we do it just do it why not it like it couldn't hurt us really could it and but look anyway the bigger picture here kind of a closing comment in that sense and and probably take you back into something less crazy but the bigger picture here obviously is Jack Crowley will be back for the the Northern series in November so it's the very late one that's against Argentina, Fiji, South Africa and that's at the Aviva so That's going to be
an absolute cracker series of games. Can't wait for that. I'm hoping I can get tickets to the Fiji game. I didn't get tickets to either of the other ones yet. But the Fiji game is probably the most likely to have more tickets available. So I'm going to try to get to that. But I would love to see the Pumas play. Don't know. Mightn't be able to. But look, the summer is all about finding what we have as first choice. I think we're not there yet. I think we're building upon that. And the war is obviously going to make a very tough discussion around that time coming into the World Cup in 2027. But look, three of
the four there, even at the 10, are Leinster. Nathan Doak is obviously the ulcer outlier there, but Andy Farrell clearly sees the rest of them as a 10 option. Jamison Jamison Gibson-Parker, nine. Garry Ringrose and Aki in the midfield. An absolute spine there. Fantastic. That is chef's kiss. But look, Andy Farrell's challenger is still a 10 pick. So Sam Rangas really is going to want to shine. Obviously, really had a huge setback in the Six Nations. We can all agree with that. Just really did not get into sixth gear. Very poor. But look, the Nations Championship
is new, obviously. There's no legacy and there's no fear. It's just three tests just to set the tone. Grant, lovely. None of this double games, triple games. Just get in for those three games and get out. And that's why I'm saying the experimentation is exactly what we need. But look, that is the bigger picture there. Whoever wins this summer series, you know, fair play to them. But I do think Ireland's going to probably win two out of three of those games. And the one I think we probably will lose, and again, I'm not a betting man, so don't put the money on it, lads. But if you do, obviously give me some, because I'm
telling you now. But I'm not a betting man, but I do think the one we'll lose is the one we're least expecting to lose, which will be the Japan game. Mainly because we're going to heavily rotate the team for that, right? It's going to be Australia first, beat them, happy out. Japan game comes along, heavily rotate the team, might. lose marginally right and then bring all those boys back for the new zealand game and beat the all blacks eden park please please please please please please uh if there is a god oh my god uh but yeah look that is it obviously in order again
the next games if you don't know them round one is australia versus ireland it's on saturday 4th of july it's at 11 10 a .m irish time So, fantastic. It's 8 .10pm local time. No one really listens in Sydney. Except Conor. Fair play to you. And the venue there is the Allianz Stadium in Sydney. Referees are also picked for that one. I think it's Ben O 'Keefe. I'll have to double -check that. But if I'm wrong, you just double -check it. Now, here's the other thing. I don't know if they're coming on domestic channels.
I'm really hoping RT have bought the rights for these because they would just be devastating if they didn't. But it could very well be Virgin Media. one of them probably will have it. If not, TGK, All Reliable. You won't be able to understand it, but you'll be able to watch it. That's actually very poor. I don't know Irish, unfortunately. Round two is Japan versus Ireland. That's the 11th of July, and that is also at 11 .10am Irish time, so very early starts there, but it's a Saturday. And that is in the McDonnell Jones Stadium in Newcastle. And then, last but
not least, you have the All Blacks, New Zealand versus Ireland. Saturday, 18th of July. 8 10 a .m irish time unfortunately you have to get up very early for that don't go into pines on friday and that is in eden park in auckland and uh yeah neither of those last against i know the referee for i don't think they've been decided for yet but yes that is it folks i mean look at it it's going to be it's going to be an absolute cracker of a series and i'll be covering all of them obviously preview and review for all them again 36 man squad sheehan captain and after
doors ruled out crowley's out Porter's out Caelan Doris is out and Tommy Reiner out obviously they're the headline absentees there we also have the uncapped players Billy Bowen Samuel Shawney Anson who's unconnected Bryn and Zach Ward and that is going to be a fantastic set of players to come up there for their uncapped debuts Brilliant. But the Leinster contingent there, and I'll name them out one by one, since we should know them all at this stage. And that is Tadhg Furlong, Conan, Ryan, Dan Sheehan, Kelleher, Jamison Jamison Gibson-Park, Garry Ringrose, Henshaw, Hugo Keenan, Osborne, Sam Prendergast, Harry Byrne,
Ciarán Frawley, and Jimmy O 'Brien. You'd lose your breath naming all them Leinster players in that team, huh? Sorry, lads. But yeah, look, the squad flew out to Australia there, Monday 23rd of June. And yeah, look, it's going to be electric. I can't wait for her. I can't wait for her. I know you can't wait for her too. All right, folks, that is her. If you haven't already, please do follow us on social media. Also, if you've noticed, I did a little guest podcast there with TQL Rugby.
Thanks again to Chris for having me on. It was a fantastic little episode to have. If you haven't seen that, it's on YouTube. You can check the socials there or just go on to TQL Rugby to find that. But yeah, folks, look, even though it's a while away, Please do remember that we are back to the Lear Arena next year and I've actually just seen a couple more emails coming through and a couple more social media posts saying that there is some season tickets left on the north and south stand of the Leinster Rugby home of that. So if you do have a few extra bob flying around, why not buy a season ticket? You'll be
there beside me, you know. that's that's that's where you want to be that's you're not even going for the game you're going actually to listen to me talk the whole way through the matches right beside you in your ear saying oh i think i think annie farrell is gonna go what for fly house but um no no i won't be saying that uh not at all uh but yeah anyway folks as always thanks for listening
Episode 89, and with no Leinster game this week The Leinster Listen stays on Ireland - Andy Farrell makes seven changes for the Flying Fijians at the Aviva on Saturday night, kick-off 8:10pm, after we squeeze in a quick...
Episode 88, and The Leinster Listen flips the script, Chris Collyer from TQL Rugby joins me for a collab catch-up. We rewind my earlier stint on TQL, then dig into how Chris went from Six Nations fan to club rugby, the...
Episode 87, and with no Leinster game this week The Leinster Listen turns to Ireland - Andy Farrell's side open the Nations Championship Northern Hemisphere Series at the Aviva on Friday night against Argentina,...
Episode 86, and Leinster turn a wet Aviva interpro on its head from 13-0 down to a bonus-point 24-18 win over Munster in URC Round 4. Jamison Gibson-Park marks his return with three try assists and URC Player of the...
Episode 85, and the interpro is back at the Aviva - Leinster host Munster on Saturday evening in a one-off BKT United Rugby Championship Round 4 return to Lansdowne Road, with Leo Cullen naming Dan Sheehan at number...