Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The KMO Show

The KMO Show artwork

032 - Librarian of Celaeno

May 27, 202555 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

KMO and the Librarian of Celaeno discuss various topics including the challenges of building an audience on Substack, the impact of AI on education and writing, the decline of reading among young people, cultural shifts in literature, the role of religion in society,and the intersection of race and ideology. They explore the complexities of racism in America and the enduring nature of cultural patterns, concluding with thoughts on the role of technology in shaping society.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

KMO Show, episode number 32, prepared for release on Tuesday, May 27th, 2025. You are listening to the KMO Show. I am your host, KMO, and I am speaking with the librarian of... Kalino, who's handled pronunciation I just now learned, so

I hope I got it right. Yes, very much so. Thank you. Thank you for having me. Ah, my pleasure. I know you, well, don't really know you, but we're speaking because of Substack. I've been on it, I guess, a couple of years, but for the first nine months or so, I was not posting regularly. I was writing a novel instead, and I find it's a lot easier to write a novel when you're not also a blogger. But you have, I think, been quite a success on Substack. So did you bring an audience

or did you build an audience on Substack? I built an audience. I started off from ground zero. I was told the story a couple other times. I was a commenter, basically, on John Carter, postcards from Barsoom, his Substack, which is a great Substack. Everybody should subscribe to it. I was a commenter there. And then some people responded kind of positively to some of my comments. And so I thought, oh, maybe I can give this a try. I like writing. And then I went from there and got my first subscriber. And everything I have

came from Substack. Right on. I brought an audience to Substack, but it was a small one because I've discovered that audiences are not particularly portable. Like if you start a new podcast with a new RSS feed. Good luck. Yeah, it's something some of the people I sort of know on Substack, we talk about the Cringe Stack authors that bring over 100 ,000 people with them, instant purple checkmark. And there's a way you can do it, I

guess, if you're media savvy and have people. But for the most part, yeah, you're pretty much on your own to build your own organic audience if you're not already famous. Yeah, but you can come in and write a post about how to build an audience on Substack and get a whole bunch of... I guess one -time readers that way. Yeah, five tips to grow your stack. Five tips to get more paid subscribers. How I got 30 ,000 paid subscribers in a month. Okay. That was like half my feed for a while. When you are not the librarian on

Substack, you are an educator. Yes, I'm a high school teacher. I'm actually transitioning jobs right now. Lost one job, got another one. So I'm starting a new career at a different school. But I teach high school. I also teach college classes here and there. And obviously I write. So that's pretty much my spectrum of careers. And you also teach some online courses, is that right? Yes, online college classes. Yeah. So with AI, large language models, writing papers

for students, like... I was a grad student in the 90s and I taught undergraduate courses and I had to grade a lot of papers. And I remember, you know, end of semester, I had my own papers to write. You know, I had my own classwork that I had to really, you know, buckle down on. But also, you know, all the student papers are coming in. And if I read like two paragraphs of a paper and the first paragraph is like a proper opening saying this is the subject matter I will cover. This is the position I will defend. And, you know, it's all punctuated correctly. A, put an

A at the top of that paper, circle it and move on to the next one. And it's the C minus papers that I'm struggling with trying to figure out what the student is trying to say. You know, and I always felt like I was doing a disservice to those A students not reading their papers. But, you know, if I'm going to pass most people, you know, and justify those C minuses, well, the A papers were just, you know, if there was a grade higher than A plus, that's what they would get. Yeah. But AI changes all that. Now,

anybody who wants to can write perfectly without, you know, knowing how to use a semicolon or an em dash. It's actually become kind of a, I would say, a personal challenge where I would say I've become better as a reader just from seeing so much of this AI stuff to where I can spot the subtle nuances. between something AI generated and something human generated. And I can say

with no small amount of pride, I think I'm actually kind of a pretty good detector. There's just a way that AI prose appears that is just distinct. It's this flat aspect, like someone with a thought processing disorder trying to explain something. It's just not right. It's not everything. The words are all there, but the meaning is just so... formulaic and devoid of human emotion or input or anything. It's just obviously something

machine generated. The worry becomes, I think that, I mean, and when I see something obviously AI generated, that creates a moral problem because now I have to ask myself, all right, well, do I slap an F on it like the school says to? But because I can't prove it, if a student actually were to say, no, I totally wrote that. I'd be without recourse and I'd have to give them an A anyway. So what I've kind of started doing is if I see something that I'm pretty sure is AI, I swear in court is AI, but it's not, but

I can't prove it, you know. I'll usually slap a grade on there of like, you know, B plus, you know, and I'll call out any, like if they ask why, I'll say, well, you know, this sentence wasn't very good or you could have expressed this better or something like that. I'll grade those papers much more harshly. And then the kids who authentically are writing things, I give them the A plus because they actually put in the work. How are how's their writing? Because when I was grading papers, you know, university student papers back in the 90s, kids couldn't

write then. And I don't imagine it's gotten better. As a whole. Well, so one thing I'll say, the pool of people I draw from, I mostly handle dual enrollment. So these tend to be the smartest kids in the high school. And in that group, I do tend to get, you know, 25 % of them are pretty competent writers. They can express themselves. Another 50%, they can get their point across,

but it's not done very artfully. And then another 25%, even though they're smart, they just struggle with expressing themselves. It's hard. And if you work with them, they can get passable as writers. But the ones that are the worst off are the ones that have the most recourse to AI. Because they're not confident, they go straight to chat GPT, tell them to bang out an essay. Sometimes it's laziness, but a lot of times it's just fear. They don't want to be judged because... They're in dual enrollment. They think all their

other peers can write, and they're just scared to do it themselves. I try to get across to them. I'm not there to judge them. Now, the population as a whole, like when I teach high school and I'm just getting a general cross -section of the population, no, they cannot write. It's bad. I had one kid. He turned in some paragraphs he was supposed to write to answer questions, and I actually— No joke. I went to the dean and I said, I think this kid is still suffering from concussion symptoms. And I showed him the paper

and he agreed. And it was that bad. The words were just disjointed. It looked like something like a serial killer who'd been up for three weeks would scrawl in his insane journal. This is a senior about to graduate high school. It's unfortunate. AI is happy to, I say AI, I should say large language models, but they are happy to crank out whatever piece of writing you ask them to. And compared to most of the population,

they're brilliant at it. I mean, compared to professional writers, yeah, they're certainly flawed and limited, but compared to most people, they are superhuman. And it's unfortunate that they can write at that level, but they're not very good at editing. Because I think if a lot of people would just, you know, take the plunge and just put something down, like, you know, crank out 1500 words and then ask a patient's skillful editor, hey, how can we make this into something that I would want to show to somebody?

Then AI would be beneficial. But, you know, just saying, hey, I don't feel like doing this. You do it. Yeah, that's the worst. The papers that are the most that I would say get past my mental detector the most. are the ones where the kid clearly put in some effort. They've got the core of something there, and then they had AI come in and, like, modify it in some way. I've dinged people for AI where they've come back and said, no, I wrote it. I just used Grammarly to come

in and, you know, change up a ton of stuff. And it's like, well, you can't do that either. You know, it's got to be your work. But those papers tend to look better than the ones where the kid literally just typed in a prompt. You know, I need five paragraphs about, you know, Abraham Lincoln. Yes. But given the students that you're dealing with, you don't see that all that much, I'm guessing. So, yeah, the online dual enrollment kids tend to be a little bit brighter and more assertive and able to express themselves better. The regular high school kids lack either the

ability or the will or both. And it all stems from the same cause. People who can't write can't write because they don't read. And they don't read because they can't read, because they lack the discipline, because they haven't, at a young age, put themselves through that necessary process of being able to sit still, tune everything out, and focus on a written word. History, which is my main discipline, it's a text -based discipline. It's all about going in, looking at a text, analyzing

it, drawing meaning from it. Being able to draw meaning from a text is the essential skill. And as a history teacher, I have to say, not many people have that skill. I do a lot of reading these days, but it's all on screen. If I take in a novel, it's most likely going to be an audio book. But it was Robert E. Howard's Conan stories that turned me into a reader. And, you know, as a teenager in the 80s or maybe even a preteen, I think I was like 14, 15 when I started reading this. There was material in there that was not

age appropriate. Yeah, I've read those stories. Right. But because, you know, because it's just words on a page and nobody's going to read what I'm reading, you know, that was a place where I could go to get stuff that wasn't available to me above board. like I would go to the bookstores at the mall and the science fiction sections, which we know were science fiction and fantasy then as well. Yeah. You know, the, the covers by Frazetta and Vallejo, I mean, they were just soft core porn and it was just, it was. You're

telling me that chain mail bikini isn't battle ready. I think it's, I think it's, it makes tactical sense. Exactly. Distraction, distract the enemy. But, you know, so the thing that kills me is I'm. I work in a library. I hesitate to call myself a librarian because I'm at the bottom of the library hierarchy totem pole. But men my age, I mean, I'm at the very, I'm 57 and I'm at the very youngest layer of readers, you know,

male readers in the library. Yeah. Millennial, Gen Z men, they do not read. period they simply do not go back into the stacks they have no interest they come in every day you know and they go right to the computers but they don't read women read girls read and so science fiction my my genre that i just love has become fantasy book porn for girls yeah and the more that the the publishers cater to that audience you know the more they

drive away what few uh male Readers and I think probably a lot of other people who would be writing science fiction, they're just driven to computer games. Yeah. And, you know, there's there's this really what I consider horrible feedback loop on the other end of that. So I worked I used to work in an all boys male military school or all boys male. Yeah. But an all male. military

boarding school so it's none of the boys and um the dean was really into this like uh boys brains are different guru type guy and he would come in and he would say like yeah boys you know boys can't focus on texts boys are very physically oriented so you can't can't have them read for more than 20 minutes and you got to have them up and active and doing stuff boy girls will sit and read but boys have to be moving all the time and And I'm thinking to myself, as this guy's going on like this, who wrote all these

texts? Everything we read is written by a guy. So a man can sit there and type a 30 ,000 -word book, but no male can be bothered to sit and read it? That doesn't make any sense. People used to read these things. All of these things used to have a male audience. So if your argument is that boys are biologically disinclined to read, you really have a – you've kind of begged the question there of why that genetic predisposition

did not manifest itself before the 1990s. And it's a dodge. It's a way of rationalizing our – I'll say our as in me – our failure as educators. to get these boys the discipline they need to be able to use their imaginations and focus on these texts and draw meaning from them, not just the factual meaning, but aesthetic meaning, emotional meaning, to make a connection with these words. It's a tragedy what's happening to them. I have

boys in my class, or I had in my school years over, but I had boys in my class who would read. And I kept my own library in my classroom. And the boys would come in, and I'd let them borrow books, and some of them would borrow and read very serious books and ask for more. And I can't help but think that if they had gone to another teacher, that guy would have said, well, shouldn't you be running around in a circle or something? What are you supposed to do? A lot of it, too, is the education profession is heavily, heavily

female, especially in the public schools. My school, a little bit different. It's a military boarding school, so a lot more male teachers. But your typical school, elementary schools will be 80 % women. High schools will be 60 % women, some of them. And the male teachers tend to be not English. If they're in history, they're coaches. So you end up with a whole system that does just sort of take it for granted. Oh, boys don't read. Girls read. Boys don't read. And that mindset,

that background set of assumptions, I think is really poisoning boys. ability to access these bugs. Yeah. And just the fact that there's not naked women on the covers anymore. That's a real blow. Oh, yeah. The 80s movie posters, too. Roger Corman movies. Oh, yeah. Galaxy of Terror. I was thinking Deathstalker. Oh, that's got a Vallejo

poster, as I recall. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yes. Boy, I was probably in my late 20s before I learned how to pronounce Vallejo. Yeah. Not a lot of Spanish speakers when I was growing up in Kansas City. Yeah, I learned how to pronounce Nietzsche. I don't know. I was probably 30. I'm still not confident that I've got it right. Well, Nietzsche is an interesting point to change direction.

Was raised in the Southern Baptist faith, but some of my earliest prayers that I can remember were me bargaining with God saying, OK, if I if I stop believing, my salvation is still locked in. Right. Because a lot of this I'm just I'm having trouble with. And so I've, you know, I've been a. What I would now call a Christian atheist for most of my life for a brief period. You know, when I was young, I was an obnoxious sort of evangelical atheist, but put that behind me fairly

quickly. But these days, Sam Harris years. Yeah. Well, Sam Harris is not that much older than me. So, yeah, I had never heard of Sam Harris at the time that I was. And I think he was probably just, you know, either a high school student or a college student when when I was going through the evangelical atheist phase. But these days, you know, I look around and I look at people who go to church and I look at people who are

not necessarily philosophically atheists. They're just sort of, you know, a religious because the culture is a religious and they're just sort of, you know, temperamentally. Yeah, well, they're living the default life. They're not really put much into it. This is really manifest for me at the library because our library is right across the street from the county courthouse. And on days when court is in session, you know, the white criminal underclass comes into the library to use the photocopier to send faxes or whatnot. So that's that's a group that I see regularly,

you know, up close, talk to them. You know, the ones with the neck and facial tattoos and who look way older than they are in most cases. And then another group that also comes in regularly are Mennonites. And, you know, these young Mennonite men and women, they're just they look so healthy and so fit. And, you know, they come in and, you know, the girls check out Amish romance books and the boys get online and they go to YouTube and they watch, you know, horse training videos or something. Oh, yeah. Yeah. But they just seem

so much better off. Just look at life outcomes. The people with, you know, Christian religion seem to be killing it. And the people without are struggling. And so I'm I'm actually like part of me says you should go to church, young man. But well. The part of me that says young man is being facetious, but I'm not going to my mother's church. I live in the same house with my mother. She's about to turn 86 and she goes to a Southern Baptist church, but I can't

stand the Southern Baptist services. I get plenty of her religion on TV because she's got it going all day on Sunday. But my father was Roman Catholic. And there was a time when they were still trying to make me go to church and they gave me a choice of the Southern Baptist service or the Catholic service. And I opted for the Catholic service a lot of the times because it was shorter. But my father was not a regular enough attender of his, you know, his mass for me to really go full time there. And also, you know, as soon as he

was out of the house and his authority was gone, I just stopped going to church. There's a Catholic church here in my small Arkansas town, and I've thought about going, but another part of me says, you know what, that's kind of abusive because you're not really one of them. It would be sort of an esoteric project for you, and that's not fair to this community. But then another part of me says, no, outreach is their job. If I go and sit in the church, even if I don't believe,

I'm doing half their job for them. You probably know how all that spun out from just the mention of Nietzsche. So I'll stop talking and then let you pick up. So, yeah, I think there's a lot to unpack there. So the Mennonites, by the way, my people, my ancestors were Mennonites. My last name in real life is a very unusual one. And you only find it in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Back when they had phone books, my last name was like, there's like a million of them in the

phone book and it's the only place where there ever was. So every one of my ancestors comes from that community. And I've learned about that community on and off throughout my life. I'm not a member of it myself, but I know, you know, I kind of know about them. It's their religious faith and it's also their sense of community. You know, they have this shared sense of identity and belonging. They feel like they're a part of something bigger than themselves. So there's psychological factors involved, apart from the faith factor, which is obviously the most important. In terms of, you know, should you go to a Roman

Catholic? Should anybody go to a Roman Catholic church? Should they go to church locally? Is it wrong to do that if your commitment is half -hearted? I think if there's 1 % of you saying, I should go to church, you should go to church. You know, everybody there, everybody in that room, I can guarantee you, including the priest and the priest, I'm sure would tell you this. Everybody there is there like as a percentage

of how much they want to be there. You know, the one guy 70 % wants to be there. 30 % want to stay home that day. You know, another guy's there, 95 % there, but 5 % he's struggling with a little bit. And then there's one person there who's. there because somebody made him come. He's 5 % wanting to be there and 95 % wanting to be someone else. Everybody, nobody's there a hundred percent. We can't be because we're not perfect. You know, the only person who's a hundred percent there is Christ. And that's why you go there to meet him. You know, the,

the, the gaps are what he fills in when you ask him to, you know, that, that, you know, I'm Lord, 1 % of me wants to be in this place. Would you please provide me the other 99? And I truly believe if you ask for it, it will come if you want it. Now, of course, and I hesitate to talk about religion because I don't want to put myself out there like I'm this extremely religious guy that

I regularly go to church all the time and I always do what I'm supposed to do. I don't. I'm a sinner. I'll put that out there. I'm the worst sinner out there as far as I'm concerned in my own mind. But at the same time, I know that when I will myself to do it, when I ask for God's help, it happens. And if you have that 1 % commitment and you ask God to give you the other 99%, there has to be space for that. You have to clear out

everything else that's in there to allow that 99 % to come in. And to the degree you clear out those other factors that are keeping you out is the degree that other things will show up and make it more – give you that sense of fulfillment, I think, that you're looking for. Because the things that keep you out of church are – we all have this. I'm not singling you out. Our judgments. The people that go to this place are all fake. I don't like how long the service is. I don't like how short it is. I don't

like the language it's in. I don't like what they wear. I don't like – the smile. There's all these things that come from pride, where the correct attitude is always to humble yourself and approach these mysteries as they are, as mysteries, and take it on faith that what they have to offer, you might not always understand it. You might not like the people around you. There might be things about the politics going on that you don't like, but you're here ultimately for an encounter with God. Now, Nietzsche, and

I'm going to monopolize here, but Nietzsche, to my mind, could never get past that. He could never get past those superficialities. He looked at the Christianity of his age and he judged it. You know, these are the last men. These are bourgeois people. This is convention. And the problem with Nietzsche is that he was right. You know, there was a lot lacking in that faith. There was a lot lacking in that faith in AD 33.

There's going to be a lot lacking in that faith in 10 ,000 years, if God wills. Nietzsche was correct in his critique, but he was not able to humble himself to look past it. I use Nietzsche as the segue to this topic because on Substack, I think there are a lot of people who are kind of like me who look at Christianity and see it as a positive force in terms of its social effects, but they just can't bring themselves to believe. the cosmology behind it. And so they try to substitute.

And what a lot of people go for is a sort of Nietzschean vitalism. And they try to use that in place of God. And people on the right tend to be better than people on the left in terms of not forming a circular firing squad. And so there's some infighting there, but there's also a lot of accommodation of different people's viewpoints. I know that you must deal with or hear from a lot more people from that, you know, both aspects, both cells in that community than I do. So what's. He's having an affair with one

of his friends and then was hooking up with Sigmund Freud and this other guy and could not manage a family life, could not mean, I mean, just nothing like this. Just there's nothing about this guy's life that I would look at it and say, well, I want to be like that, you know. And granted, I guess he lived the way he wanted to, but I just can't imagine wanting to live like that. But at the same time, you know, do his ideas have value? Sure. Sure. I mean, there's a lot of things he said that were very interesting and profound. I would say the same thing about

Karl Marx. I have no interest in living like Karl Marx or being a Marxist, but certainly there's play aspects of Karl Marx's social critique that I think are very valid and interesting. On the right, you know. There isn't this necessarily need for ideological purity. What makes someone right wing? I mean, there's obviously a core around this idea of tradition and hierarchy and transcendent value that kind of make you the right. But beyond that, I think people are pretty

tolerant. Certainly, you know, my own following includes people who are Christians and missions and atheists. All kinds of others. I've got people who are avowed leftists who read and subscribe to my work, which I find interesting and I'm grateful for. You know, I'm not I don't look at people in terms of, well, you believe this, so I hate you. I'm interested in dialoguing with anyone. I'm interested in anybody's critique of my work. And I think that attitude you see

more on the right than the left. And that's why the right, I think, is becoming an ever more attractive place for ideas. People are comfortable expressing themselves on the right. I mean, compare right wing subset to, you know, blue sky, blue sky. I mean, it's horrible. It's just nothing but like all the maniac tendencies of the left cranked up to 11. They're always attacking each other. You know, this one doesn't respect this one's neo pronouns. This one supported Biden

when he shouldn't have. And this is ridiculous. I mean, I get people who will argue with me sometimes. They tend to be the base pagans that I poke fun at sometimes. They'll argue with me and stuff, but I mean, that's a small group for the most part. Pretty much everybody, I mean, the range of people I get along with on Substack is probably better than the range I get along with in real life. Unfortunately, all of my social contact other than talking to my mother and brother comes from my job working at the library. Yeah. Where

I meet a lot of people and I interact with a lot of people and I, you know, I have informal conversations with a lot of people. But when it comes to political topics or, you know, anything that's potentially divisive, you know, my my professionalism requires me to just shut up and just smile and nod and not really get into any anything in any depth that could be, you know, that could attract other ears in the library. Yeah. So that's. On that level, it's sort of pallid, but it does give me a nice vantage point

from which to make observations. Hopefully, none of my co -workers are reading my substack. I do my best not to ever mention the name of the library, but it would not be hard for anybody who was looking to nail me to the wall to figure out which library I'm talking about. For my part, in those doxing terms, I obviously write under a pen name, but I mean, I give enough details about my life that if someone really wanted to, some hope not hate nutcase came or, you know,

what do you call it? SPLC guy came after me or something. They could probably figure out who I was, but it doesn't bother me that much because, I mean, there's not really anything I say on Substack that I wouldn't say in real life to somebody. So, you know, I don't, I'm not one of these people. You get people who just want to run their mouths online and say offensive stuff and hurtful stuff and be nasty. And then they're worried about getting called out. But I mean, I don't, my, the librarian and who I am in real life, it's the same person. I just, I don't want people like calling up the school

where I work and bugging people just because they've got some beef about what I said, you know, it causes problems for other people. Right. Well, I'm not sure what you just said, but it popped into my head that it was an anchor point for the topic of. race and the discussions of race that on right wing Substack. Actually, before we get into that, you know, you mentioned Blue Sky. Every now and again, I will somehow end up looking at the main Substack page when I'm

not logged in. And it's Blue Sky. Oh, yeah. Substack, for whatever reason, just promotes these people. And it's, you know, I talked about earlier, Cringestack, you know, this just sludge. coming out that's just nothing but this you know i hate donald trump it's all they write about every single week they have nothing else to say and they say the same thing and they have subscribers there are people who pay to hear this they cannot get

enough of it these people that subscribe paid subscribers to 10 15 20 sub stacks and it's the same thing they just they pay to have this like ridiculous echo chamber. Any day now, Trump's going to jail. Any, oh, the economy just crashed. Oh, well, it didn't. Oh, it's just so dumb. And you almost have, this is a running joke I have with people in my circles where we all say we're going to come up with like a, you know, cringe

stack publications making fun of Donald Trump all the time, where we just use chat GPT to just write these sludge articles one after another. and just get these people to pay us and then use that money for our actual work, you know? Now, there's a use for, you know, using an LLM to write for you that I could totally get behind. I actually did one time. I didn't post it, but I asked Grok. I said, Grok, write me an article in the style of Steve Schmidt about why Donald Trump is bad. And what it came up with was indistinguishable

from what he actually wrote. You would think if I just created a parody account and posted it, people would think it was him. So one last thing on Substack and the mainstream left, if that's what you want to call them. Whenever I do end up looking at the main page when I'm not logged in and I'm seeing all these Orange Man bad posts, I always see one of my posts in there as well. Which just says to me, OK, look, you

know, it's me because I know you're not promoting my work to anybody else. They have like IT checkers or something, I'm sure. I don't know how that stuff works, the algorithms, but they know. Yeah. So, you know, why why go to the pretense then of, you know, showing me things that, you know, I'm not interested in, but whatever. So, John Carter. You say you got your start basically as a commenter on his posts. And John Carter, who writes postcards from Barsoom. I mean, anybody

who's a fan of classic science fiction recognizes that that's, you know, not William S. Burroughs, but Edgar. So, you know, he's a very, like I would say, upwing, forward looking. you know, tech positive sort of person, but he also has conservative views and he is, I guess you'd say what a race realist. Well, that, that word, I mean, there's a spectrum, you know, that kind

of, that, that term implies there's people who, I mean, there's a sense in which I'm a race realist where I would say, you know, race is a thing. It is a real thing to just sort of say that all people are. indistinguishable blank slates, I think is wrong. And then there's like another end of the race realist spectrum where it's, you know, races are biologically, you know, immutable. And, you know, these people have low IQs and we need eugenics. And, you know, I think that you can make positive claims, like empirical

claims about something and not necessarily draw the moral conclusions and political conclusions that some of those more extreme people draw. John Carter has, I'm not going to speak for him, he's his own guy, but he's Canadian. And the situation in Canada, they have a lot of immigration. I'm not sure the exact ratios, but I would say in terms of their population, they have right now more immigrants in their country per capita than we have in America. And a lot of them are

coming from the Indian subcontinent. And a lot of people who have lived in Canada for generations, they call them heritage Canadians. you know, don't like that. They don't like the changes that their country is undergoing. And I think rightly so. I think there's very much a place for that critique. You know, can it veer into hatefulness? Sure. But I think that that, in a lot of ways, is just sort of downstream from the fact that the government of Canada does not take these critiques seriously. people vote over

and over again. They say, we want less immigration. We want these people to assimilate. We want to keep Canada the way it was. And kind of like in America, before Trump took over, nobody cared. They just sort of kept going with what they wanted to do. That's that managerial system I write about a lot. So I think that there's definitely a place for that sort of critique, yeah. So you're talking to me and I read his, I read John Carter's posts, but for somebody who doesn't, You've basically gestured at things without naming them. So what

critique are you talking about? So John Carter and a lot of other people, too, and Substack is actually kind of dense with Canadians a little bit. The critique of sort of the idea of the multicultural society, which is the sort of ideal of the managerial system, that human beings are these fungible economic units. You can import massive numbers of people from any part of the world to any other part of the world, although this tends to just be importing from the third world to the Western world. You can import people and there'll be no friction. There's no problems.

Everybody is basically the same and everybody will basically get along. And if they're not getting along, it's because of racism on the part of white people. And so the managerial class, the globalists that run all this stuff, tend to interpret critiques of immigration as that kind of racist friction that's keeping everything from working the way it should. And people like John Carter, and again, I don't want to speak for him, he's got his own views and everything, but people like John Carter, people like Fortisax, and there's a lot of other, Kryptos a little

bit, look at this and they say, you know, no, the point where, this is absurd, it's just a violation of basic common sense. You can't take people from one part of the world who've lived a certain way for millennia and put them in a different society and just expect everything to work out harmoniously. It's just not. It doesn't make sense. It's never worked before in history. Why would it work now? But there's this sort of neoliberal mindset, the ideology of the managerial elite, this neoliberal ideology of, well, with the proper social inputs and the proper organization

and the proper education and everything like that, we can just will it into being. You know, we human beings are blank slates and we're the ones that write on them. And that's what I mean by critique. People are critiquing that neoliberal managerial. ideology of all human beings are basically fungible economic widgets. So you mentioned that John Carter is Canadian. I, from the year 2006 through, I don't know, a couple of years ago, I was doing something called the C Realm

Podcast, which is the letter C and then a dash and then R -E -A -L -M. And C stood for consciousness most, you know, most prominently, but also a lot of other things. And jokingly, I would say it also stood for Canadian. because a disproportionate portion of my audience were Canadians. And when I would travel internationally, I would often be mistaken for a Canadian, which I took as a compliment at the time, because when I was traveling internationally, I was still of the mindset that one distinguished oneself as an intellectual

by being hypercritical of the United States. Yeah. Yeah. I've gone probably too far in the other direction since then, but I used to be on that page. But I have a friend, somebody I've known since the mid 90s, who's Canadian. And he worked in tech in San Francisco in the late 90s and early 2000s and did pretty well for himself before basically being kicked out of the United States for some, I don't, I can't even reproduce

what it was. It was some trivial, trivial, you know, visa irregularity. And now he's, you know, he's banished. But I sent him a post by John Carter. And, you know, it had something to do with science fiction and tech. And my friend is, you know, he's into tech and he's in the makerspace. And, you know, I thought he'd be interested. And he basically just wrote back and said, that's racist. End of discussion. I'm like, okay, this is probably the wrong John Carter.

article to start you with here let me send you a different one and i sent him one called the whims of mars and which you know john carter's mostly talking about the the prospect of um you know a robust population establishing themselves on mars yeah and yeah you know he's actually an astronomer by trade oh no i didn't did not know that oh that's that's great so anyway i sent this follow -up to my canadian friend who said, this is racist too. Whims, it's right there in the title. And I'm like, okay, so that's just

the thought stopper. I mean, if there's anything that can be considered racist, then nothing the person has to say is worth discussing. And I'm not singling my friend out for particular intolerance or having a particular blind spot. It's just that's the culture in which he lives. You will not... He lives in Toronto. You will not be branded a racist in Toronto, particularly in the, you know, the progressive tech scene. If you are, you're done. You know, it reminds me of the book

Dune, D -U -N -E for the readers of Dune, Frank Herbert, where the Bene Gesserit sisterhood could use these hypnotic techniques. You called it Prana Bindu binding. Binding, I think was what they called it, where, or hypnoligation, where they could put a. word subconsciously into someone's head that if another person said it, it would cause the guy to have some kind of psychosomatic reaction. And they had the knife fight at the end where Paul Atreides is fighting Faye Rautha.

Faye Rautha had one of those words in his head where if Paul had said it, it would have caused his whole body to shut down. And Paul didn't want to win that way. And I think part of what our neoliberal managerial class does... is create these kind of hypnoligations in our heads, especially Canadian heads, but a lot of Americans do, where they hear certain things, whim, ooh, shut down racist, shut down, ooh, and the whole system crashes, and they're blue all to death, they can't handle it. It's like, you know, it really

does. It's like this learned, like, disgust reflex or something, where it literally makes these people sick to hear certain ideas. even if they make sense, even if they're logical, even if you spell it out in a way where, okay, I proved point A, I proved point B, so point C must be true. Their minds just cannot go there. The programming is too deep. They have become, in the truest sense, NPCs. You know, I've tried to look up the definition of whim while you were talking, and I'm just getting the proper definition, you

know, of the noun. It means like a wish or something, like you want something to happen, a desire. Right. It's a WIM. But when it's in all caps, it's white, what is it, hierarchical, what does it stand for? All right. WIMS stands for White Hierarchical Individualistic Male. Yeah. So the white hierarchical individualist males will go to Mars and create a robust society where they're

They are allowed to form and bask in asabiyah. Yes, community building. Yes. I think asabiyah is more of a community spirit. It's a vitalism that lends itself not necessarily to community building, but just group formation and group identity. And everybody's allowed to have it except white people these days. Yeah. And that's kind of the point he was making. You know, and that's again, so somebody that's racist. OK,

well, let's let's look at this. Right. So is it is it good that people from India are allowed to be Indians? Yeah, of course. Why would it be wrong? All right. So and they're allowed to be Indians wherever they are. Right. They're in India. They're in Canada. Yeah, absolutely. Multicultural society. Anybody can be who they are. So with that logic, then should white people be allowed to live like they are? That's racist. Like it just shuts down. You know, it's just there's no there's no getting past that. It's not a logical thing. It's like something placed

deep in that lizard brain part, you know, where you just vomit up a dead insect, you know, like in the most primitive form of life. Yeah, my last name is O 'Connor, so I can be Irish, you know, and being Irish by, not necessarily anymore, but for most of my life, being Irish by definition meant you were white. Yeah. Do you remember when Google image search, if you asked for a white couple, it would definitely show you a whole page full of interracial couples. Oh, yeah. Yeah.

George Washington thing they had that called the Gemini, I think it was. Well, that was a different incident, actually. Yeah. You're thinking of generative AI, you know, if you ask for an image to be created, like, you know, founding fathers, it would show them as black or Chinese or something. Yeah. But a few years before that. Just with the image search, you know, if you search for white couple, it would show you a full page of mixed race couples or black couples or whatever. Basically, it would it would scold

you for searching for the wrong things. So if you wanted a picture of a white couple, you would type in Irish couple, you know, or Polish couple. Well, even that would kind of screw you up. The thing about all that stuff is like you can construct a white identity. as something negative. You're allowed to say whiteness exists if it's being excoriated. But the problem for these people comes where you can't talk about whiteness and

not make people think about it. You know, if you beat into somebody's head, you're white, you're white, you're white, you're white, even if you're constructing as something negative, people will see it as inherently part of themselves. So the whole project of creating a colorblind society like neoliberalism wants to do falters on the premise of, you know, everybody gets to be who they are, but white people have to be something that white people hate. Whiteness is only an attitude of contempt. But at the same

time, it's immutable and inescapable. You know, you can't get rid of your whiteness. You can critique it. You can denounce it. But you can never, ever free yourself from it. And because I, as a white guy, can never free myself from my whiteness, that forces me to think of my race as an immutable characteristic. And thus, logically, everybody else's race as an immutable characteristic with its own particular features. So I have a

Substack friend. who probably wouldn't mind his name being mentioned, but I won't anyway. But he's into science fiction like I am, but he's also a Gen Xer like me, but he's a black man. But he reads and restacks posts by John Carter. And, you know, I've said to him, hey, I need to get you on the line and have you discuss that on a podcast. And I thought he would be reticent to do so. He said, no, sure, I'll come on. There are no bigger race realists, I would say on Earth,

but definitely in America, than black Americans. Like, they will give you a frank assessment of the characteristics of every race, including their own, without hesitation. There's a whole section of Black YouTube, I don't know if you've ever heard of a guy, Tommy Sotomayor, who just goes in and just lambasts in characteristics of Black society. He goes after other people too, and he's a Black man. Just lambasting characteristics of Black culture he sees as negative in terms

that if a white man were to use it, would just be completely socially out of bounds. I'm not surprised he agreed to talk about it. My high school where I went to was a very highly majority black school. And you would just hear them casually, you know, like even among themselves, you know, the degrees of coloration matter quite a bit. The ones with lighter skin would make fun of the ones with darker skin and vice versa. They would have these beefs over that. So again, if you want race realism, that's a good place to

start. Yeah. So I've, you know, for years I've been thinking, as the left and, you know, the cultural left, the economic left, as they've been denouncing white people and, you know, shaming people for being white, shaming people for, you know, something they can't change and justifying, you know, mistreatment of them on the basis of historical, the writing of historical wrongs. I've just been thinking, you know, you guys, you realize that the pendulum's going to swing the other way, right? And the worse you are when

you're in power, the more vociferous, you know, the reaction will be. So you think you're going to be in power forever? I mean, has the pendulum stopped swinging? There was a, there was a real telling, I wish I could remember the exact circumstance. I think Ramsey Paul had a YouTube show about it one time where he talked about it. It was in Wisconsin and they were trying to teach the kids at this like all white school about their white privilege. And so to do it, they gave them those little like rubber wristbands, you know,

that people wear, like they say, what would Jesus do and stuff? Well, they gave out these little rubber wristbands that were just white. And you were supposed to wear this white wristband to remind you of your white privilege. But they stopped doing it because the kids were wearing it like ironically, like to demonstrate how white they were. Like kids would get like five or six of them and wear them. And it was like this whole thing where they were just, you know, there was a. I think it was in Colorado. Somebody was protesting the Native American names for, you know, football

teams and stuff. And he came up with a shirt called the Fighting Whiteys. And he thought this was going to be like a dunk, you know, like, oh, burn, white guy on a shirt. And it's like he had like an Etsy store or something for it. It sold out like immediately. People were buying these shirts and wanting to wear them because they thought it was awesome. So anytime, again, you know, they think they're being clever. By just constantly throwing in white people's faces, you're white, you're white, you're white, you're white. But I mean, you can't really control where the imagination leads you from that. Yeah. I'm

not sure that this is necessarily thematically connected to what we've been talking about, but I have a dog and I walk my dog every day and there's a dog park within an easy walk of where I live. So we go there every day. Sometimes some of the people who are there are not locals. They're traveling cross country, but they've stopped at this place and they're, you know, letting their dogs play in the dog park. And there was this one couple I was talking to, and the man, like, within a couple of sentences, you know, after hello, was, you're not a Trump supporter, are you? And one, you know, dude, this is Northwest

Arkansas you're traveling through. You're going to run into a few. I didn't say that to him, but, you know, I was not looking to escalate, but he was giving, you know, somebody who would. take those as fighting words, ample opportunity to take offense. But I will say those folks are much preferable to the ones who won't go into the dog park unless it's empty. Sometimes I'll be in the dog park and I can see that somebody

has pulled up and they've got dogs in the car and they're just waiting for me to leave before they will go into the dog park. I'm like, I think you're missing the whole purpose of the dog park. It's not the prison yard, you know, where you let the inmates out to walk in solitude for an hour. It's a place to socialize for humans and dogs. You know, I'm actually kind of surprised nobody's come up with the concept, like the drug companies, no one's come up with the concept of dog autism. You know, like to medicate the

dogs, like your dog won't socialize with the other dogs and you won't do whatever the, oh, dog's got autism, here's a pill. And then you can imagine somebody doing that, like, oh, I can't let my dog play with other dogs. You've got dog autism. But people will. So right now I'm in Florida with my dad, helping him out with stuff. And the area where he lives, Florida's pretty much a solid red state at this point. But a lot of the snowbirds come down, and they come from Massachusetts or Connecticut or all

these other places. New York City. Yeah, New York. They'll just be, you know. I can't believe that Donald Trump got elected. These people are such rednecks. And they're so used to everybody just agreeing with them. It's beyond them that people could think differently. And it's why, you know, these white people, I'm a white nationalist. I'm not a white nationalist. I have nothing in common with these people. I don't know what they're about. I don't want to live in a society where they're in charge. I know they want to live in my society because they keep coming down here

where I live in the South. I don't want to live with them. And it really is like just a different, a different nationality, a different country. Like they just have, they have totally different conceptions about how the world should operate. All right. That was the librarian of Kalino. There's like another 20 minutes left, but today is Tuesday. And that is the day that I both write and post my Gen X. science fiction and futurism

post for the week. And I haven't even started yet. And it's a little after 4 p .m. So I got to put this podcast to bed and get to writing. I will share the final 20 minutes, which I will tell you up front is pretty unfocused and is me jumping around from topic to topic. You've heard the best part of the podcast, but I will put that in Sea Realm Vault episode number 475. But that will probably be a few days before I post it. The Sea Realm Vault podcast is available on Patreon, and I also post it to Substack, so

it is accessible to those people who have paid subscriptions to my Substack. Most everything I put on the Substack is free, so the paid subscribers are really, they're not doing it for the extra content. They are doing it to support my work, and they have my sincere gratitude for that. All right, I must go. Talk to you soon. Stay well.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. C-Realm Podcast 554 - History is a Prankster with James Howard Kunstler

    Sep 15, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    Originally released March 24, 2020, C-Realm Podcast episode 554 features a conversation with James Howard Kunstler, recorded just as the COVID-19 pandemic was overturning ordinary life in the United States. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. C-Realm Podcast #120: The Long Descent with John Michael Greer

    Sep 13, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    C-Realm Podcast 120: The Long Descent - John Michael Greer Originally released September 17, 2008, this C-Realm conversation between KMO and John Michael Greer is being reposted nearly eighteen years later because a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 035 - Anti-AI Backlash with Kenneth Harrell

    Apr 20, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Date: April 20, 2026 Host: KMO Guest: Kenneth E. Harrell Episode Summary A 20-year-old throws a Molotov cocktail at the home of Sam Altman, then heads to OpenAI headquarters and escalates. He’s arrested within the hour....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Conversations On Collapse Retrospective

    Mar 24, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    KMO revisits a sampler created during the original assembly of Conversations on Collapse and uses it to open a new project: Getting Over Collapse. Featuring excerpts from: Dmitri Orlov Albert K. Bates Thomas Homer-Dixon...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Public Projections of Private Despair - C-Realm Vault #89

    Mar 16, 202658 minAudio

    C-Realm Vault Episode 89 - originally released April 20, 2014 This episode, recorded on KMO's 46th birthday two weeks after the suicide of Michael C. Ruppert, is one of the clearest early documents of KMO's departure...

    Credit the people on this episode