This is a conversation from 2019 when I was privately uncomfortable with the Peak Oil narrative I'd been articulating for several years but hadn't turned against it publically. In this conversation with Bob Brown, I let the curtain drop. KMO returns to the long-neglected C-Realm topic of Peak Oil in this conversation with Bob Brown of the Investing with Nature blog. Much of the conversation turns on comments made by Chris Martensen and Dmitry Orlov in a YouTube video called Electric Cars and Happy Motoring.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Sea Realm Vault Podcast, episode number 323. Friday, January 4th, 2019. The light of consciousness shines on everyone, but not everyone gains access to the vault. Hey, Serum Vault subscribers. Happy
New Year. I've got to keep this super short. I'm having technical difficulties and my computer is really not up to the big files that I need it to be able to tackle in order to make podcasts. So I just have to be very brief in my statements here. What you have in this episode of the podcast is a recording that I made on the first of the year. with a blogger who listens to the Sea Realm podcast or who had years ago. He'll explain his connection to the realm. His name is Bob Brown.
He contacted me and basically he convinced me that he would be somebody who would be worth getting on Zoom to have a chat with, particularly since he represents a set of concerns which I know are still very important to a large percentage of the Sea Realm audience and which are just... Really old news to me. So I'm going to play a couple segments from a YouTube video. This is from a couple years back. Basically, I read out a question about solar, the returns on solar, and also the rapid advances in electric car technology.
This comes from Eric Boyd, who is probably the single most technophilic and optimistic repeat guest on the Sea Realm podcast. And basically his whole point of view was handed back to him, absolutely rejected by all the folks at the table. But the answers to the question that I got from Chris Martinson and Dmitry Orlov are the ones that are still most interesting to me now in hindsight a couple of years later. So I sent that video to Bob, this week's guest, and he watched it and we are going to comment on it.
So I'm not going to play that whole video in this episode, but I am going to play the answers from Dmitry Orlov and Chris Martinson. And actually, in the video, they come in the reverse order that you'll hear them here on this podcast. All right, so first up, you'll hear from Chris Martinson, and then my conversation with Bob Brown. And then in the middle, I will also cut in Dmitry Orlov's answer to the question of, yo, how can you guys still be such peak oil conversions when solar electricity and electric cars are coming
along so quickly? And fantasies often don't come with numbers. So here's some numbers. Okay. Let's hear it for the number man. I'm the number guy. You're the number guy. Hit it. So if Elon Musk manages to sell 500 ,000 cars a year, which is up from about 80 ,000 this year, that number of electric cars, as they're currently configured, will consume 100 % of the world's mining source of lithium. So I'm going to imagine China has something to say about that, and Japan is going
to, and Germany and other countries will say, but even if you did 500 ,000 cars growing exponentially, don't forget that, 500 ,000 at a current run rate of about 17 .5 million cars sold is about 3%. So for the United States to supplant just 3 % of the current sales volume will require 100 % of current lithium. And that's just one bottleneck. That's just one. I got more, right? Yeah. You're good. You're good. So fantasies, as you're talking about, they don't comport with
reality. They don't stack up to the numbers. And I wish these people would just get a crayon and a napkin out and just go run through the basic numbers. Because they just don't. All righty. Well, it is New Year's Day. 2019, and I'm here with tech and investment blogger. Is that a fair way to say it? Yeah, a modest blogger, but a high -tech person. I'm kind of an enabler behind a lot of the things you see in the internet.
Like what? One of thousands of people. Well, when you say you are an enabler, what do you mean? Okay. But at my work, what we do is actually make cooling systems for routers and servers that form the backbone of the Internet. So they use a lot of power, they generate a lot of heat, and they need very advanced cooling systems to keep the temperatures down and lower the temperature
on electronics, the better the reliability. We make systems for that. So when you talk on your cell phone, you use a computer over the Internet and so forth, there's a good chance it's going through a router or a server that I had some little piece of. So you are definitely not a – well, I can't say definitely. I don't know you that well. Tell me about your attitude toward technology. You're certainly knowledgeable about it. What's your level of optimism, say, for the
ability of the human species to use its technical know -how to get out of its current predicament? I think there is some hope of using technology to do it, but I think we have to drastically scale down our energy usage in the future. Technology can help do that, but I think we're tending not to go in that direction. We're exploiting technology to use more energy, and we just keep exponentially
increasing our energy usage rather than using it to reduce it. So I think a lot of things are going in the wrong direction, and people throw out technology as a hope for the future, but the way we use technology kind of has to be redirected. Do you like to make the distinction between system -dependent technology and useful standalone technologies
that a lot of appropriate technology people like to make? I think there's a lot to the appropriate technology scene. Simple, standalone technologies, they're resilient, they're not dependent upon a very complex web of interrelated technologies that take a fair amount of complexity and energy to use. So there's something to be said for that.
I think... We could more selectively in the future use some of the very high -tech stuff that takes a lot of complexity, but it would have to be really looked at for and preserved. So it'd take a little bit of a special effort that I don't see us doing right now. When you first contacted me via email, it seemed like the point of contact thematically would be electric cars. Electric cars. Let me say just a, I mean, long -time listeners
will know this, but the Sea Realm audience is kind of a strange mix in that, you know, this was one of the early podcasts. I started it in 2006, and most of the audience came in via one of two vectors. There was a permanent link on the homepage for the Psychedelic Salon podcast, which played a lot of old Terrence McKenna. recordings and things. And that podcast has a large audience. So just a fraction of that audience clicking on the permalink to the C -realm from the front page of matrixmasters .com brought in a lot of
people who were interested in psychedelics. And then some of the early guests that I had on the program, like Jim Kunstler and Dmitry Orlov, and then a couple of years later, John Michael Greer, that brought in the peak oil crowd. And it's kind of a strange mix of people who have, you know, on to the sea realm and stayed with it for years. So I'm guessing that you're more of the peak oil crowd than the psychedelic salon crowd. Yes, definitely. I kind of followed John
Michael Greer and James Howard Kunstler for a bit. I came across your podcast actually in an odd way. I think you appeared with the guy, Two Beers with Steve podcast. Oh, yes. Years ago, and I actually came across your podcast through that. You were a guest on there, and then you interviewed him. And I think his podcast is long gone, but I started listening to you. Lost track a little while ago, and then caught up with a
very old high school friend, actually. I hadn't seen in 35 years. I was on a different podcast, and he happened to listen to that. And then we talked for a while, and he brought up your name again. I got back listening about it a few years ago. It's a small but very select audience that listens to the Sea Realm podcast. Small by, you know, podcast standards. If it was a church, it would be a big church. It would be a big congregation. Well, you definitely have a good, steady following.
Well, let's talk about electric cars for a minute. I directed you to a video that I shot. I went to an event where John Michael Greer, Dmitry Orlov, James Howard Kunstler, Chris Martinson, and somebody else who wasn't really a peak oil person, but they were all gathered together in one room in the makeshift green room waiting to go up on stage at an event. And I read out a letter. From somebody that I talk to from time to time, maybe you'll recognize the name. His name is Eric Boyd. He is Canadian. He was one
of the founders of a tech site, I think it's StumbleUpon, which he then sold and made a nice chunk of change. As I say, he's Canadian. Something happened with his visa and he had to leave the U .S., so he's no longer admitted within our borders. Dangerous type that he is. The answers that the people gave at that table, John Michael Greer gave the standard religion of progress answer, which, while worth knowing, wasn't really
specific to the question. So I kind of tuned that out. Jim Kunstler's response also seemed pretty familiar and boilerplate to me. But what I wasn't expecting was Chris Martens' response. And basically, he said in a rather sort of derogatory way that the person asking the question didn't understand the hard resource constraint imposed by lithium supplies. And lithium, as far as I know, is not a particularly rare. rare earth. You know, it's not, as you've pointed out, neodymium
or some of the other more exotic things that come from just a few places in the world. You know, some of these places are conflict ridden and China controls the supply of certain rare earth minerals, but lithium is definitely not one of them. So his answer is the one that is stuck in my mind as being both seemingly just, you know, simply wrong, but also needlessly combative, you know, in the way that He criticized people who like electric cars for not even being able to take a crayon to a napkin and do simple math.
I thought, you know, whenever I hear statements like that, my spider sense tingles. That alerts me to a weak argument if somebody is pouring on an extra helping of derision to go with their answer. So I sent that video to you, and you responded that you were fairly in agreement with all of the responses given. I'd like to ask you to expand on that. Okay, I mean, I generally agree with John Michael Greer, and for the most part, James Howard Kunstler's arguments. James
Howard Kunstler, I mean, some of his stuff about suburban beauty and suburban sprawl, I don't quite buy. I think I'm more into functional than, you know, my house is kind of a rectangle. but it functions and it's fairly energy efficient. You know, I'm semi -rural suburban, but I think that's probably a somewhat livable arrangement, at least for the quite near future. And I think
there is something to the religion of progress story too. Now, Chris Martinson, I mean, he does look at these things very thoroughly. And let's... To be clear, when we talk about a rare earth element, it is actually something, I don't know if you remember your high school chemistry. I didn't take any high school chemistry. I was a high school chemistry teacher at one point. And if you look at a typical periodic table, there's all these squares with the different
elements represented. Down the bottom, there is a bunch of elements that way back when I was in school, we had no clue. what they could be used for, if they had any use. Those are the rare earth elements. They're very, very heavy atomically. You know, a lot of protons, a lot of neutrons in them, a lot of electrons, you know, in the hundreds. Those are called, they just call them the rare earths. That's the name they're given. They're not super, super rare. They have to be mined. Mining, of course, is
energy intensive and actually ends up, you know, the fuel that's used, of course, in mining is diesel. So, you know, when you analyze any technology, it seems you always get back to oil via diesel fuel. But, yeah, rare earths are controlled mostly in China and so forth right now. There's been a few attempts to get mines going outside of China, but every time that happens, what happens
is you get a demand drop, a little fluctuation in economics, and the mine goes out of business, as long as China can provide supply. Lithium has nothing to do with rare earth elements. It's semi -rare. A quick Google search told me it's the 25th most common element in the earth's crust. A couple of different ways of mining. Again, mining is an energy -intensive, expensive business.
It usually takes a while to get going, so it's difficult to ramp up supplies. So Chris Martinson is probably right, at least in the very near term, that you can't quickly increase the supplies of lithium. I'm not sure if he is right in the mid to long term. Five, ten years out, could you make an effort to increase the supplies dramatically? Maybe. And lithium isn't the only critical element
in the batteries. They're known as lithium batteries, but I believe nickel is also the other element. So you're also in mining constraints there. So it is something that has to be... kept in mind. And I think Chris's point, which maybe he overstates it kind of derisively as you put it, but a lot of people think of these elements as appearing
the way a lot of people think of their food is something you get from the supermarket. It's on a shelf. And they don't understand the whole process behind getting that. So when you get strawberries in January, they don't realize, okay, those were grown in South America. They were flown on a plane. They were delivered to the store. They don't understand that whole process behind it. There's a lot involved in doing that. Mining, very, very intensive industry. They typically, whatever they're mining, the element they're
trying to get out, they're usually digging up tons to get. of earth to get grams of that element. So an intensive digging process, isolating that element, that's an intensive process. And then the transportation process, the refining of the raw material. So a lot goes into that and it can't be quickly scaled up or ramped up easily, even if it is available. And then with the markets the way they are, you've got a lot of fluctuation
on it. So you bring a new mine on board, all of a sudden you increase the supply. If the demand doesn't match, you sometimes crash the price and cause mines to go out of business or shut in. So it's not as simple as people think that, okay, if we want this stuff, we just go get it. It's got to be planned years out, I think at least five years in advance for most types of
mining that I'm aware of. So you can't just simply have half percent of the cars be electric one year and then ramp that up to 10 % easily the next year. A lot of things have to be planned for that to happen, and they all have to go well. Well, I don't know the current state of... operations there, but soon after I had posted that video with all the gentlemen that I just mentioned, Tesla Motors announced a contract that they had
signed to basically source all of the lithium for their batteries from the state of Nevada, which is where their manufacturing facility is. So I don't know what the timeline was for getting that up and running, but I didn't hear, and I looked around for it, you know, any voices in the industry saying this is unrealistic. And, you know, there are people who who go over everything, like his every utterance and every tweet, it's gone over with a fine -tooth comb. And if Elon Musk says something that is obviously stupid, there's going to be a lot of people who are going to jump on that. And I just didn't see anybody
jumping on the idea that there is lithium to be had in Nevada. It seems like an odd place to... you know, to zero in and say, here is the problem, you know, the constraint, the supply constraint on lithium. In the industry itself, I just, you know, I've looked for it and I haven't found that criticism anywhere. I only hear it in these sort of esoteric peak oil circles. Yeah, I had seen a little bit about the Nevada site and certainly at this level of production, I
would imagine they could ramp things up. I mean, they're not producing at this point a lot of electric cars. The other thing, though, I mean, in terms of electric cars being viable for the future, you have to consider, you know, people point at Tesla. And if you really look at Tesla, what is that? It's a rich man's fifth car. You know, one of these people have, you know, five garages at their house, and that's his fifth car. It's not a practical car for people like you and me. No, but the major manufacturers,
the GMs and their peers of the world are also ramping up electric car production, not at the rich man's toy level, but at the level of actual commuter devices that people will use, regular people with regular lives. In fact, Tesla's – as you say, the level of production at Tesla is so low as to really be – rather irrelevant in terms of how it impacts the automotive industry and how it impacts people's lives and how it impacts traffic patterns and energy usage and things like that. But they are creating the prototypes
for the production cars of the future that the big manufacturers will be producing in significant quantities if things go the way the industry says they're going. Yeah, potentially. I still see you have other supply constraints, though, and one of them is the electric grid itself. You know, a typical home has, you know, maybe 100 amp service. And, you know, usually people
don't use near that much. But if you think how, you know, our scale of cars, it has gone up so much in terms of the horsepower on the car and so forth. people typically driving SUVs. I haven't blogged much on my blog, but one post I did put up was about my first car, which was a 65 VW Beetle. So that thing had 35 horsepower on it. And I was trying to convey the scale of what
that was in terms of solar panels. If you go look around and you see a solar panel on somebody's roof. The typical solar panel you see is a 200 -watt solar panel. A horsepower is 745 watts. So that means in full sun, four of those solar panels generate one horsepower worth of energy. Okay, so for my underpowered VW Beetle with the 35 -horsepower engine, you're talking four of
those panels times 35. That's a lot of solar surface area dedicated to the power that's required for a car. Now, you charge the car, if you figure, okay, eventually we're going to have all solar panels powering these electric cars, you have an awful lot of area that has to be dedicated to those cars. And our typical SUV is not 35 horsepower, but it's 350 horsepower. So you multiply
that amount again by 10, and you're seeing, I mean, my yard is about three -quarters of an acre. You're probably filling that with solar panels. If they get full sun for an hour and you use that to charge the battery on my electric SUV, that allows my SUV to run that engine for an hour. Of course, there's losses along the way, but you can kind of think of it, the losses are maybe in the 10 % area. So you can kind of think of it as equivalent. Feeds the other, feeds
the other. But you don't get out more than you put in. So we don't have an electric grid that's set for that. And the other thing you have to think of is that each time you charge your car, you're charging it from an electric grid. Ultimately, that electric grid is probably being powered by coal. Or nuclear. Or nuclear. Okay. both of which have, there's a lot of things to object about that. And the electric grid is not that
efficient. You lose about 50 % typically of the power that's generated as it travels through the grid. Just resistive losses, you know, electricity traveling over the wire, it heats up the wire over long distances. So you're actually, if it's... Being powered by coal, you're using twice the amount of coal energy that you would be of oil energy in a car. And I mentioned this other podcast
I was on about being in Switzerland in 2010 and driving a natural gas -powered car. And that, you know, the car ran well. It was a combination. dual -fuel car. It had gasoline and natural gas. It started up using the gasoline because gasoline oil is the most energy -concentrated fuel you have, so that's better for starting. And then it would switch over to natural gas if you had any. And yeah, the car ran perfectly fine, and
in Switzerland, they already had natural gas gas stations. And the host mentioned, he said, well, I think what we'll have is electric cars and we'll produce our electricity by natural gas. But the more indirectly you use any source of energy, the more the losses are in between. So when you're driving the car directly on natural gas, you're getting the full efficiency of that natural gas in the engine. If you create electricity using natural gas, then transfer it over the
grid, you have a... a lot of losses, and then you charge it into the battery. The battery heats up as you charge it. That's some losses. It heats up as you discharge it. There's some losses there. So you actually use more energy to drive an electric car than you do using the fossil fuel directly. I think what we're discussing is a handful of specific instances of the more general point that fossil fuel energy is incredibly energy dense. So much so that it's not friendly to the
human intuition, the difference in energy density between the different sources of energy we imagine we'll be using in the future. There really is nothing that packs the energy into a confined space like fossil fuels. Oh, that's definitely true. And that's, I think the scale, I mean, this is something Chris Martinson. harps on constantly and maybe he overdoes it uh to the point where
you you shrug it off and ignore it but yes the scale of certain things people just don't comprehend and you know i certainly find that i'm an environmentalist and a lot of environmentalists they're they're lovely people but they don't have you know the mathematical type brain that i have where i kind of see these scale relationships more naturally it just comes easier to me and so i'll see flaws
in the arguments that other people might not seem obvious to them so yes oil oil is just tremendously dense and until you you start thinking about like powering my VW Beetle in terms of solar panels and so forth, that you just can't always, you can't comprehend the scale of the difference. I think electric vehicles do make sense, but probably on a much more limited scale. I mean,
we've gotten spoiled with driving, you know, overpowered SUVs around this country. You know, you look around the rest of the world, you go into Europe and you see a lot more smaller, lighter cars powered by all different kinds of fuel. I know in Switzerland, they had in 2010, we had the natural gas car. There were cars powered by propane in addition to regular gasoline and a lot of diesel. But in general, I mean, the
cars are smaller, lighter, much more energy efficient. And, you know, Europeans use a lot less. energy than Americans do, with actually, I think, as good or, in the case of Switzerland, probably a better standard of living. Yeah, and the standard of living in the United States is much, there's a whole industry, I think, you know, information industry devoted to obscuring the fact, but our standard of living is definitely falling, particularly,
you know, the middle class seems to be revealing itself to have been a temporary phenomenon. Yes, people people are definitely sliding down and they're going from, you know, an upper middle class sliding into middle class to lower middle class gradually. And I don't know if they're not acknowledging it. They're borrowing more money to cover the difference is certainly one thing that's happening. But we are definitely
sliding. Bit by bit, person by person, you know, it's not a sudden collapse all at once, but at the fringes it just keeps trickling down and everything, higher taxes, are just nibbling at it, the standard of living, and dragging it down a little bit year by year. Do you know Kathy McMahon, the peak shrink? No, I don't. I don't know that she's really in the peak oil scene anymore, largely because there really isn't much
of a peak oil scene anymore. But she used to be one of the better known names. And she was a I assume she still is a psychologist. But she started she encountered peak oil, I think, from one of her patients and people who were who had anxiety about. Civilizational fragility from a peak oil angle would often get pathologized by mental health professionals who had no idea about the realities of the energy situation. And they would put labels on people and describe
their anxiety as some sort of pathology. And Kathy McMahon was the person who was the peak oil aware psychologist. So come to her and get a more knowledgeable sort of response as you articulate your concerns. And I think this is her phrase, but I associate it with her. She differentiates between a fast collapse and what she calls the sucky collapse. And the sucky collapse is sucky because it proceeds so slowly that we can ignore it and deny it. Whereas if there were
to be a sudden collapse, like people were describing in the peak oil scene back in 2006, 2007, when I first encountered this material, well, that's something that would require an immediate and decisive response. And the sucky collapse that proceeds slowly so that, you know, people, individuals, as they collapse at different rates, they get blamed for their own problems. You know, they bear the responsibility for their own personal collapse. Well, that doesn't marshal the same sort of immediate and concentrated and coordinated
response that a fast collapse would. Oh, yes, that that makes a lot of sense. I've never heard of her, but but it it certainly is making sense. what is happening around the country. And yes, the political attitude seems to be to blame people for the problems of the collapse that hit them. Now, and to be fair, I think people should get
a fair amount of blame for some of their problems. There should be a sense of personal responsibility To an extent, but not everything is under people's control. And there are things that are out of people's control that are giving them problems, too. So, yeah, I think that's that is a very good way to put it. The sucky collapse. We were just kind of it's hitting a person here and there,
you know, one in 10 or something like that. Their standard of living will suddenly drop. So the other nine. don't have it hasn't impacted them uh you know we'll have some climate disaster it will hit one part of the country that part will be devastated but hey the rest of us we don't really notice anything different so so you you it's not hitting everybody all at once and and i think that's you know it that's a uh
kind of long emergency that's long descent type thing that a lot of people are talking about, the peak oil scene. You know, it's strange to even hear myself uttering the phrase the peak oil scene. It was such a thing. Like back in 2011, I remember I went to the ASPO conference in Washington, D .C., and it really seemed like peak oil was about to break out into mainstream consciousness. And then I guess, you know, hydro fracturing and cheap oil and cheap gas basically
just Wash that away. It's really that whole scene. I'll get the occasional email from the Post Carbon Institute, and every now and again, once in a blue moon, some indication that ASPO as an organization still exists, but really that scene failed to launch. Yes. I think we're very reactive, and the thing that hits people the most is the economics. Now, I'm a few years older than you. I'm 63. I'm a mid -baby boomer. So I remember the 70s
very well. Just got my driver's license. Gasoline was, in 1973, gasoline was 39 cents a gallon. Okay. A year later, it had doubled. And there were gasoline lines and so forth. People talking, you know, waiting for an hour to get the gas tank filled up and so forth. And then... We went along, it kind of stabilized at double the price
for a while, and then the same thing happened again late in the 70s. At that point, we got religion as far as resource limitations as a country. Everybody was very conscious. People who were driving Cadillacs were driving Nissans that got 40 miles per gallon. Very different attitude amongst people. OK, as soon as the 80s
hit and, you know, we the North Sea oil drilling, the Alaska oil drilling. The conservation measures that have been taking people driving less resource intensive cars and, you know, maybe insulating their house a little better, turning down the thermostat, all those things worked. OK, that crashed the oil price. And the next thing you know, all those things were forgotten and SUVs became the common thing. All those little 40 mile a gallon cars disappeared and were replaced
by, you know, big trucks. I think the same thing happened again the last time. OK, the oil price went up. It panicked people. They reacted to it. All of a sudden they took these people, peak oil. people seriously. Then once the price got crashed, I think it got crashed both by demand. The markets are so dynamic that if the demand is slightly less than the supply at any given moment, the price just crashes. If the demand is slightly more than the supply at a moment,
the price rockets. And everybody, of course, speculates, jumps on that and exaggerates it the way our investing economy is trying to everybody get in the middle, make a few pennies off of each swing and so forth. So we exaggerate that. And I think when oil price hit $140 per barrel, people got religion again about peak oil and resource limitations. Once that crashed and the price of gas went down, price of oil went down,
it got forgotten again. The other day in our permaculture group, a woman commented about, oh, yeah, the transition town movement. But I haven't heard anything about that. And, of course, transition towns was a response to peak oil. You know, it just seemed to lose all those things, lost all the momentum at that point and immediately was discredited. And yet you have people claiming peak oil is dead. You know, so we tend to economics tends to dominate our actions in this country. And, you know, what people. When it's hurt in
their pocketbook, people notice. When it's not, they stop noticing. All right. Cars really don't have anything to do with technology per se. They have a lot to do with petroleum chemistry. If you take a barrel of crude oil and you crack it, about 50 % of it ends up as gasoline, and a small fraction, maybe 10%, something like that, ends up as asphalt. So you have to figure out how to sell the gasoline and the asphalt. And
if you don't manage to do that, then the really valuable parts of the oil barrel, which is jet fuel, kerosene, diesel, the useful stuff, suddenly the price goes up and the entire economic model stops making any sort of sense at all. So cars are not really about transportation. They're about forcing people to buy gasoline. Electric cars cut into that, and if electric cars become popular enough, they will destroy enough of the
petroleum infrastructure that runs on diesel and jet fuel that that part of the economy will fail. And then the electric cars will not be delivered because it requires diesel. And roads won't get paved because that requires road tar. And then what you'll have is solar cars driving on dirt roads. Now, is that a viable future? I don't think so. Those things are not really all -terrain. I'm yet to see an all -terrain vehicle that is solar. So what fraction of the
barrel of oil goes to make regular gasoline? About 50%. 50%. Yeah. I'd like to go back to that video that I've mentioned a couple times now. And talk about Dmitry Orlov's response, because of the various responses I got to that question, for me, his was the most interesting. His point was basically that when you take crude oil and you refine it, you get different products. So, you know, you get kerosene, you get jet fuel,
you get bunker fuel, you get diesel, as you've mentioned, which is so necessary for so much of our industrial processes and mining and manufacturing and things like that. But then the largest fraction of that is gasoline. And gasoline isn't really... good for much other than, you know, moving cars around. And for the economics of a fossil fuel powered system to work, you know, your job and my job and the job of everybody listening to this is really just to burn gasoline. You know, just to make it work economically, because we absolutely need that jet fuel and that bunker
fuel and that kerosene and most especially that diesel fuel. We don't really need the gasoline so much, but unless we have a public, you know, constantly in need of the gasoline, the economics of fossil fuel sort of fall apart. Yeah, I find that that interesting. I mean, what would happen in that case is power plants would end up using gasoline, I would think. Is gasoline a viable fuel for generating electricity? I mean, are there plants in existence that could, say, switch over from natural gas to gasoline? I would think
that could be done. Certainly, as I said, I drove a car that you switch back and forth between natural gas and gasoline just as easily. It's basically an engine. I would imagine that you could make convertible multi -fuel. engines that could power a generator. So we've switched from coal to more natural gas and power plant generations when the price of natural gas went down. And we'll switch back and forth. It takes some time.
But new generation is going to use whatever the cheapest fuel is available. I just don't see that happening. I see us continuing to use gasoline as long as it is available. I don't see the... I don't see the long -term environmental advantages of electric cars anyway. I think you end up using just as much fuel as you do with gasoline. It may just be a different mix that you get to select from, but power has to be generated from something.
And the electric car, it doesn't generate its own power. So, ultimately, it's going to be some fossil fuel base and, you know, it might be gasoline used in a different manner. Yeah, as a topic, electric cars by themselves are not all that interesting to me. Self -navigating cars or, you know, hybrid systems where sometimes the human is in control and sometimes the AI is behind, you know, is the power behind the wheel. That, to me, is more interesting. Largely, you know, for the safety issues. We just sort of shrug
our shoulders and write off 30 ,000 deaths in auto accidents every year. It's just the price of doing business. So that's an area that is much more interesting to me, is the whole self -driving car topic. I mean, it doesn't do anything, obviously, for the environment. If you're sitting in a car and moving it around, you're using just as much energy. The self -driving aspect would add very little weight, and so it would make very, very little difference. It certainly is
doable. Now, as a software engineer and somebody who deals with software problems, self -driving cars do make me pretty nervous. A software bug could wipe out a lot of people, and occasionally you hear reports of that with any of these problems with a Prius, which is all software behind it. problems with different electric cars. Of course, they're all software -driven underneath. We don't
necessarily recognize that, but it's the type of software that I write. I write embedded computer software, and all these cars and self -driving vehicles, they would be all controlled by embedded computers, and most of even a standard gasoline -powered car. It's a lot of embedded computers within that car controlling everything. And they do a wonderful job, but as you scale it up and increase the complexity, the ability of the human mind to anticipate every possible thing that
could happen is pretty tough. And that's got to be programmed into those programs. It scares me a little bit, occasionally dealing with buggy software and so forth. I think even a lot of what you see lately with some of these products like you get from Microsoft, Excel, I think the latest versions have gotten worse and worse in just subtle ways than versions from 10 years
ago. More complexity gets built into them, but things act a little bit more flaky in a lot of cases. So I don't know if you've seen that too in software you use. I've definitely seen that. Well, the software I use is the same software I've been using for a very long time. But I do get irritated every time Adobe feels the need to make Photoshop much more complicated. The things that I needed to do are the exact same things I needed it to do 10 years ago. But for
me, you say... cars controlled by software and microprocessors makes you nervous, but cars controlled by hominids with cell phones should make you really, really nervous. It definitely does. It's not a matter of comparing self -driving cars to cars driven by angels. It's a matter of comparing self -driving cars to cars driven by people who are under a lot of stress and professionally distracted. I remember... When I lived in New York City, you know, I drove a pickup truck,
which sat up higher than most of the cars around me, and I'd be sitting in traffic, and everybody, every single driver in view had one hand on the wheel and the other hand on a phone, and their eyes were on their phone. You know, it seems like, to me, the fact that... auto fatalities haven't jumped by like a factor of five in the past decade is really a testament to how sophisticated our brains are and how much we can multitask. But the science of multitasking is very clear.
We don't do it nearly as well as we think we do. And I think that the current situation with drivers so distracted and so invested in the abstractions and the social. abstractions that are just in the palm of their hand that I'm amazed anybody can drive at all. Yeah, that is scary. I guess, you know, for me, I'm not one who spent a lot of time on my cell phone. So, you know, I drive, I drive. And to me, to give up control
to software, to me, that's a little bit scary software that somebody else wrote, because I know the pitfalls and so forth. But Yes, I guess I'd rather have a self -driving car coming down my street than an 18 -year -old staring at their cell phone. Or a 48 -year -old. You know, I live in an apartment building which has a big parking lot. And I'm walking across this parking lot all the time because the other building is where my gym is and it's where it's the TV station where I do some work is. So I'm always walking across this parking lot. And it is just a survival
skill that I have to look at every person who's sitting behind the wheel of a car, whether it's in motion or whether it's stationary, and see where they're looking. Because so many people, they come out of this hospital, which is the other building in this complex. They get into their car and... as they're putting the key in the ignition, with the other hand, they're looking at their phone, and they frequently, I mean regularly, start the car, and they're in motion before they look up at their surroundings. And I could easily be, if I'm not watching to see where they're
going, I could get run over rather easily. And it's always to do with the phone. And this brings me around to a lament that I have about... the direction of the Sea Realm Podcast in general. You know, when it started, I was not interested in peak oil. And it was interviewing, you know, early interviews with Dmitry Orlov and Jim Consler and Albert Bates that got me interested in that topic. And then the Sea Realm Podcast largely became the podcast completely devoted to energy issues and the fragility of, you know, our energy
infrastructure and our way of life. And the same year that I started this podcast, the iPhone. premiered. And I think over the 13 years that I've been podcasting, the iPhone, social media, mobile computing in general has had a much larger impact on daily life and on politics and on the experience that people have, you know, of their world than has energy constraints. You know, energy constraints, you can certainly say, are definitely important from a big picture perspective.
And, you know, long term, they are a bigger issue probably than social media and mobile computing. But over the last decade and change, I think social media and mobile computing have had a much bigger impact. And I wish that I had paid more attention to that back at the start of this podcast. Yeah. Definitely. There are times I feel a little bit guilty about the work I do because I do have a piece in supporting it. And the impact of cell phones and that technology,
I don't know that it's done our society a lot of good. I see a lot of negative aspects, what you're talking about with people driving and deaths from cell phones and just constantly being distracted by them. You know, my kids are still fairly young. I'm an older dad, so they're 18 and 22. You know, you see the impact on their lives where they're not used to talking to people
face to face. They don't know how to do that. It's like they'd rather sit next to somebody and send them a text, which, you know, they're more comfortable doing that. Nearly as into it as a lot of people. But, you know, just those basic communication skills. And, you know, you see so many people walking around, you know, they're hunched over their phone, staring at
it. And, you know, they'd walk into a wall before they'd pull away from their phone. They're not seeing the world around them. To be honest, a lot of it. Is it adding value to people's lives? I don't think so. You know, if you think of technology leaps forward, you know, originally like the TV, which amazes me that people came up with this back when they did, were able to broadcast video signals over airwaves and you could watch from a distance or initial early radio. To me,
I am so impressed with the people who invented those things. Being able to stream stuff over your cell phone or watch your TV show over your cell phone is not such a big advance when you compare it to that. And certainly when you compare a lot of this stuff to indoor plumbing in terms of quality of life, they're not that big of an advance. So, yeah, I don't know if it's not had a positive thing and certain politically how
it's gotten people, they're able to tune out voices and just tune into things that reinforce what they think. I think it's created a divide between people where they can't really talk to anybody with any different ideas. When you are online, you feel a disconnect from the person you're talking to. It's not the same as talking to somebody face -to -face. And I think people just treat people much more rude. They wouldn't
talk to a person face -to -face the way they would post comments online and so forth. So I think it's become polarizing very much socially and politically. So I think there's been a lot of downsides to the to this whole Internet revolution. Yeah, I don't know about you. I had this thought the other day. I was thinking about, you know, my youth and, you know, you know, if I there were things that I could bring back to my youth that my kids have now, what would I do? And,
you know, I watch my son. My son ran track in the spring and they had a girls track team and a boys track team. And when it came time for the prom, there were a lot of couples of boys and girls who ran track together. I said, you know, the best thing I could bring back from if I had to live my life over again would be girls track. I wish I had that when I was in high school, because back then they didn't have those girls sports. But did I feel like I missed out because I didn't have cell phones or things
like that? Not really. But some of the social changes that I think have been positive, you know, my youth was early enough that had women's liberation. You know, racial problems were a lot worse. Those things have definitely progressed. But the technology, I don't know if it's made us better. Well, I am the father of two teenage boys, and my childhood was so much richer than theirs because I was out in the world, you know, the real physical world, usually on my bicycle
with friends. Roaming far from home and getting into trouble and exploring and having some spectacular wipeouts on my bike and sustaining serious injury. I've been, as a kid, I went to the hospital, the emergency room, fairly regularly with injuries. And my kids never have. They are inside, on their devices. Both of my kids have cell phones, although only one of them has cell phone service, because a smartphone is just a handy little pocket computer,
and there's Wi -Fi at school, so even without a cell phone contract, it's a handy device. And I know that the... The children of the rich and powerful, even the Silicon Valley folks who made their fortunes from this technology, they send their kids to private schools with no screens, with no information technology, learning from books and from lectures and things. And my kids, who are sort of the very low end of middle class, if that, really they're sort of the children
of former middle class people who are now struggling working class people. They have their phones with them all the time at school, and the phones and laptops and tablets are all allowed in the public school. And that just seems strange to me. I mean, if you could bring these things back to when I was in school, you know, in high school in the 80s, they certainly, you couldn't have them, you know, in your hand in class. You would have to, you know, if they were allowed at all, they'd have to be in your locker. And it seems like the schools, you know, the public schools for the massive kids have just given up on that.
Like the screens are everywhere. The processors are everywhere. But for the children of the elite, you know, it seems the elite recognize how harmful these technologies are, and they make sure that their kids have a learning environment which is free of these things. Yeah, that's definitely true. You see all these posts about, you know, the people who are the real high -level enablers of all this technology. don't want their kids constantly exposed to it uh and i think they have very very valid reasons i just think the
schools feel they're over they're overwhelmed and you know face it most of the teachers are probably uh on their cell phones all the time anyway so you know they don't they don't necessarily recognize it so uh yeah i think they've just kind of thrown up the flag and and given up any hope of that but yeah there's a definitely a benefit to not having uh your cell phone on you all the time. Yes, indeed. So, yeah, I think there's no contest. My life, my childhood was so much better than that of my kids. And it is
the technology that makes the difference. And the social expectations that go along with it, I think we're much more fearful now than we were when I was a kid, like, you know, in the 70s and the 80s. I would be gone. You know, I would be out of my mother's sight all day, all day. She wouldn't know where I was. She couldn't call me. I wasn't near a phone. You know, I was off on my bike with friends. And then as long as I made it back, you know, at dinnertime, it was all good. And these days, you know, if your kids are not immediately within sight, then you start
to wonder, you know, what dangers are they exposed to? What do I need to be protecting them from? And that has seeped into the expectations of our culture in general so that parents who, you know, raise their kids the way I was raised are considered negligent. Yes, yes. You hear the stories of the police coming because the kid's playing on his front lawn by himself, and they don't see a parent in sight and so forth. The pendulum swung way too far that way. I had a
story. My dad one time, and I realized afterwards, after a while, it was the best thing anybody ever did for me. I was got in a rut of sitting and watching TV every day after I'd come home from school. And he got home from school about the same time I did. One day he came over and said, Bob, after the show, you're getting outside. And I said, oh, no, I want to watch whatever the next show was. I forget what it was. But I mentioned a stream of shows that were coming up. He said, no, Bob, you're going outside. And
he didn't say any more. When that show ended, he came in. I hadn't shut the TV off. He went over, shut the TV off. I protested. came over, picked me up, carried me out the door, put me outside, locked the door, and said, you're going to spend time outside. Fortunately, my parents were very good. They both stuck with what they said, and they backed each other up. So I knew I was never going to win that battle and watch TV. So I made the best of it outside and ended up having a good time and kind of got out of
my TV rut. But I realized that was one of the best things he'd ever did for me. even though I was screaming mad at the time. You know, there are advantages to the way we grew up, being able to, you know, golf on your bicycle, running around and so forth. I mean, people were healthier. Definitely, you know, trimmer. You know, there's something to be said for keeping an eye on kids and so forth, but the pendulum swung way too
far. You can't cocoon everybody and keep them safe in front of the electronics things. It's just different dangers that they're being exposed to now through the electronics. You know, everything we've said over the past 10, 15 minutes basically has gone back to my point of the technologies that have created all of these problems and also which allow us to do things we couldn't have done before. They really have had a much bigger impact on... the character of life in the early
21st century then has constraints, supply constraints of fossil fuels. And so, you know, this is why I say I would much rather that, you know, if I could go back in time and do it over again, I would focus more on information technology and particularly social media and mobile computing. You know, people our age, 2011 doesn't seem like very long ago, but I remember Back in 2011, you know, that was the start of the Arab Spring and then later that year, Occupy Wall Street. And in the Arab Spring, the tech executives were
all crowing, saying, you know, this is what giving everybody access to the Internet brings. It is it's democracy. You know, democracy just springs up unbidden. when you give people these tools. And that's not how it's played out. You know, and I think those comments are, they're sort of an embarrassment now to that sector of industry and that set of people that these tools do not create democracy and that China, you know, the remaining, or I would say even rising communist
superpower, communist possibly in name only, but they're certainly authoritarian. Google, with their do no evil motto, is more than happy to work with China to make sure that China can be our partner in creating the tools that we use and implementing them in an authoritarian friendly way. And I think these are all very important topics that have enormous impact on our lives. And I wish that I had been tuned into it earlier. Yeah, I don't think it's too late
to talk more about that. I hear so many people talk about, you know, the Internet technology and, you know, a lot of them, you know, they're big on Bitcoin, for instance, and saying, you know, this is freeing people. We can have virtual nations and so forth. What they seem to leave out is that the Internet, basically people have two or three ways of connecting to the Internet, which can be easily controlled. So it provides
a central mass point of control that governments can use, businesses can use to their advantage. But independently, most of us don't have a way to get on the Internet on our own. We're through some ISP, maybe a cable provider, telephone provider, cell phone provider. That's about it. Any of those things can filter what. Any way they want. They're businesses. There's nothing stopping
them from doing that. And any of them could shut down your access, as you've recently found with Facebook. I mean, they're a central controlling power now. And, you know, it's not giving individuals necessarily more power. Yes, we can talk about things that might be somewhat subversive in small quantities. you can be controlled. Yeah, I mean, that seems to be really the primary use of the
technology these days is to control perception. And, you know, that's not new, and it's certainly not unique to social media. I mean, that's largely been the role of television. And so it goes. Well, we have just passed the one hour mark on the recording, and I like to keep these files not much longer than that. So let me just... open it up to you to say what message would you like to end on or what topic? Okay. I mean, I
think long -term, we still have to consider energy constraints, scaling down. I'd like to see when we talk about things like electric vehicles, that we actually talk about, okay, more practical electric vehicles, electrifying bicycles, electrified scooters. small scale cars on electric cars on the power of my old VW Beetle. If we scale down, electrification of certain things becomes much
more possible. And I just think some old technologies, really, people would laugh at those technologies, but... putting more insulation in people's houses. I mean, I've done that, and it makes such a huge difference. The house is quieter inside, and my bills are a lot lower for heat. No longer need air conditioning in here in northwest Connecticut for most. Once there's a few days, I could use
it, but most of the time, it keeps the house much cooler in the summer. So working things like that, I think, long term have a lot more potential than people harping on electric cars and so forth. I'd love to see people pick up those type things more. And, of course, I'm very into permaculture, learning about that, which is totally out of my normal skill set. Learning
about that has a lot of benefits. Growing your own quality food and so forth long term I think is a good skill for people to develop. I'd love to see people go more in that direction. Put your cell phones down a little bit and experience the world. What's the name of your blog? I have a blog, investingwithnature .com. Pretty wimpy blog. I don't blog much. I'm more hoping in a
few years when I retire that I'll blog a little more often. And even if I make an occasional blog between now and then, that it will have built up a little bit of work. Do you have any New Year's resolutions? Well, one was, and the original reason I contacted you was to support... People like yourself who are doing good work. Make sure I do that in some manner. You know, support James Howard Kunstler, John Michael Greer,
some of these people who I've listened to and followed their work, read their books. And, you know, I think they are saying some useful things and they're certainly much better writers than I am. So I enjoy their reading and just, you know, support these. these people. That's been my big New Year's resolution. All right. That's a good one. All right. Bob, it has been a lot of fun talking to you. Oh, a lot of fun here, KMO. Thank you very much. Thank you. Take care.
Take care. Bye. That was Bob Brown. Check out his blog. You can burn through it pretty quickly. He's not kidding when he says he doesn't blog often. I say this with no disrespect meant to Chris Martinson, but I was riding with somebody in a car a few months back, and they had on a podcast from Peak Prosperity, which is Chris Martinson's outfit. And really, it could have come from 2008 or 2009. I mean, there was just
nothing there that struck me as particularly interesting. If the conversation about peak oil hasn't advanced any further than that in the last, what, eight years? It's just not a conversation that's worth keeping up with as far as I'm concerned. And when I say to people who are interested in peak oil that, look, mobile computing, social media, and just ubiquitous connectivity has had a much bigger impact on human consciousness and
social organization than has resource constraints over the past decade and a half. They seem to take me to be saying that this is a good thing, that this is an uncomplicated boon to humanity. And I'm not saying that at all. That's not what makes it interesting. What makes it interesting is all of these social knock -on effects, all of these psychological, you know, all the psychological collateral damage that takes place in the wake of the implementation of these technologies on a massive scale. Those were unanticipated even just a few years ago, and now we are having enormous
difficulties navigating this new world that we have created for ourselves. That is a very interesting conversation to me. And poo -pooing the most optimistic projections from technophiles, I guess it still needs to be done, but I'm just not the person to do it. It's just not anything that can hold my attention. But, you know, there are people for whom that is their bread and butter, and they do not deviate from that formula. So if it's what you want, there is no shortage of supply of peak oil doom, even though the peak
oil scene generally is a ghost of its former self. All right, well, I'm going to try to put all this podcast into one file and get it uploaded for you. And then I have some more commentary that is specific to notes that I took on the conversation while editing it down to the... the length that you heard, but I don't have time for it in this episode of the podcast. So I always say this, but you know, it's always true. I'll talk to you again soon.
Originally released March 24, 2020, C-Realm Podcast episode 554 features a conversation with James Howard Kunstler, recorded just as the COVID-19 pandemic was overturning ordinary life in the United States. The...
C-Realm Podcast 120: The Long Descent - John Michael Greer Originally released September 17, 2008, this C-Realm conversation between KMO and John Michael Greer is being reposted nearly eighteen years later because a...
Date: April 20, 2026 Host: KMO Guest: Kenneth E. Harrell Episode Summary A 20-year-old throws a Molotov cocktail at the home of Sam Altman, then heads to OpenAI headquarters and escalates. He’s arrested within the hour....
KMO revisits a sampler created during the original assembly of Conversations on Collapse and uses it to open a new project: Getting Over Collapse. Featuring excerpts from: Dmitri Orlov Albert K. Bates Thomas Homer-Dixon...
C-Realm Vault Episode 89 - originally released April 20, 2014 This episode, recorded on KMO's 46th birthday two weeks after the suicide of Michael C. Ruppert, is one of the clearest early documents of KMO's departure...