Can we PLEASE stop using bingo behavior charts in kindergarten? I know there are some adorable options out there, but why are we leaving classroom behavior rewards up to chance? When kindergarteners consistently meet expectations but still don't earn a reward because their number wasn't called, it doesn't take long for them to figure out that the system isn't exactly fair. In this episode, we're talking about why bingo behavior charts and random PBIS reward drawings aren't always the best choice for kindergarten classroom management. You'll learn how these systems can unintentionally overlook students who consistently make positive behavior choices, why delayed and unpredictable rewards don't make much sense to five-year-olds, and how all of this can affect student motivation and buy-in. We'll also talk about what kindergarteners actually need from a positive behavior support system. When you're trying to encourage positive behavior in kindergarten, your students need clear expectations, consistent feedback, and rewards they can actually count on. This episode will help you rethink the behavior incentives you're using and find simpler ways to recognize positive choices so ALL of your students have opportunities to feel successful. Resources Mentioned in This Episode: 🔗 Kindergarten Management Toolbox 🔗 Build-a-Reward Charts 🔗 Glow and Grow Behavior Notes 🔗 Show notes: https://kindergartentoolbox.com/bingo-behavior-charts-kindergarten/ 🎧 Follow The Kindergarten Toolbox Podcast so you don't miss future episodes with simple, practical kindergarten teaching and classroom management strategies.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Can we please stop using these bingo behavior systems, especially in kindergarten? I know that's probably not a popular opinion, especially when there's so many really adorable options out there floating around. In fact, I just saw one the other day on Instagram. And here's my problem with them. Why are we leaving classroom behavior rewards up to chance? Bingo is a great game with random winners, and that's what makes it fun. But when we're trying to motivate positive behavior in kindergarten, I don't think that luck should determine whether or not kids get rewarded for making positive behavior choices.
SPEAKER_00And I've seen firsthand, both as a teacher and a parent, how these systems can fail our kids who consistently do what they're supposed to do. And today we're talking about why I think bingo behavior charts are a bad idea and what we can try instead. Let's dive into your shortcut to calmer days and more confident writers.
SPEAKER_00But I have a problem with behavior systems that leave the actual reward up to chance. I've seen a couple different versions of these bingo charts in action. One version is a whole class chart where students earn spaces on a bingo board for making positive choices. And on the surface, that looks great. But because spaces are chosen randomly, your class might get bingo pretty quickly, or they might have to keep earning spaces without completing a row for quite a while. And then there's those school-wide, usually tied to PBIS systems where students earn tickets and write their name in a square on a bingo board and wait for a certain square or row to be called.
SPEAKER_00And that's the kind I experience firsthand teaching and now as a parent on the other side of this. And honestly, I'm just baffled at how we think this is an effective way to encourage positive behavior. We're asking our students to make positive behavior choices, follow directions, and work towards earning a reward. But then we're telling them that whether they actually get the reward depends on luck. Why? We want our kindergartners to be successful. We want them to understand that their choices matter, so why are we putting a random drawing between behavior and the reward?
SPEAKER_00I think we sometimes forget that our kindergartners are little, but they're not clueless. And I promise you, the students who are meeting your expectations notice these systems aren't fair. Think about how tickets get handed out in a school-wide positive behavior program. You might remember to give out a few tickets throughout the day. You're busy teaching, helping students, managing the classroom, doing all the other things, so handing out tickets isn't necessarily at the top of your mind every minute. At least it wasn't for me. And then when you do remember to pass them out, it can turn into a bribe pretty quickly.
SPEAKER_00Like the first one to follow directions earns a ticket. Sound familiar? And maybe the music teacher is giving out one every class, and maybe in the cafeteria they're handing them out left and right. Maybe the reading specialist gives a ticket to every student she works with who meets her expectations. And if the math coach is doing the same thing, they're getting it there too. So now you've got students who are seeing several different adults throughout the day, and they're getting multiple opportunities to earn tickets. Meanwhile, there's a few children sitting in your classroom doing their work, following directions, consistently meeting your expectations all day long.
SPEAKER_00And what are they getting? Maybe a ticket here and there when you happen to remember. And it's not because they're not doing what they're supposed to do. It's because they're always doing what they're supposed to do, and you've come to expect it. Do you see the problem? We're not necessarily rewarding the students who are consistently demonstrating the behaviors we want to see. Instead, we're rewarding the students who happen to be in situations where somebody remembers to handout a ticket. And then we're giving the students who collect more tickets more chances to win a prize. And that doesn't seem like a great system to me.
SPEAKER_00Here's an example of what I'm talking about in action. Students can earn tickets and write their names in squares on the bingo boards. Then on Friday, the principal calls two squares over the announcement. If your name is in one of those squares, then you get called down for a prize. So let's say Susie earns 20 tickets throughout the week and she's got 20 different chances to win. And Joey has consistently met expectations all week but has only earned five tickets. He only has five chances to win. Those numbers don't tell us anything about how well either student behaved. It's just how many tickets they collected.
SPEAKER_00They might tell us more about how many adults remembered to give them tickets than their behavior. And if we take it a step further, maybe there's another student. We'll call him Sam. And he's been having a really tough time with behavior. But one day he makes a great choice, and somebody recognizes that, so he earns a ticket. As well he should. It's wonderful. He absolutely deserves to be recognized for that choice. And I'm not suggesting otherwise. But let's say that's only one ticket he earns all week. Friday comes, his square gets called, and he earns a prize.
SPEAKER_00Meanwhile, Susie and Joey don't win anything. And I know there's someone out there thinking, well, yeah, that's how drawings work. Exactly. That is how drawings work. But why are we using a drawing or bingo or randomized system to decide who gets rewarded for positive behavior? And Sam, who only earned one ticket, absolutely deserves the recognition and praise he gets for the positive choice he made. And the student who's been meeting expectations all week, Susie and Joey, they need them too. Those are not mutually exclusive thoughts.
SPEAKER_00But when the reward comes down to who square gets called, we're not really recognizing consistent positive behavior. We're recognizing whoever gets lucky. And I think our kids notice that pretty quickly. One of the more important parts of a classroom management system is getting your students to buy into it. They need to understand what you're asking them to do, why it matters, and what happens when they meet the goal you set. But what happens when a child keeps meeting expectations and doesn't get recognized because they're just unlucky? How long do you think they're going to be excited to earn tickets and never get called?
SPEAKER_00Maybe they're excited for the first week and maybe even through the second week, but eventually they're going to figure out that they can do everything they're supposed to do and still walk away with nothing, while the kid who rarely does what he's supposed to do walks away with the prize. And that's not going to motivate them to keep working toward a reward. Now I know we want our students to make positive behavior choices because they're the right choices, not just because they might get a prize. Of course we do. But if we're choosing the reward system to encourage those behaviors, shouldn't it actually encourage them?
SPEAKER_00Shouldn't kids who are consistently meeting expectations feel like their efforts matter? Because I think so. And I think that we need to be especially careful about not overlooking those students, because they're the ones who can be such wonderful role models in our classrooms. They're showing their classmates what it looks like to follow directions, to get started on their work, to use kind words and do all the things we're desperately trying to teach in kindergarten. We should be noticing that, we should be pointing that out. We should be helping other students to see those positive choices and what they look like.
SPEAKER_00Not just assuming kids will keep doing what they're supposed to do, whether we recognize them or not. And my biggest pet peeve about these bingo systems, especially in kindergarten, is they're too abstract. Think about it. A student makes a positive choice and earns a ticket on Tuesday. They write their name on the bingo board, they forget about that. Friday rolls around, the principal calls their square, and they win a prize. That's a lot of steps between the behavior and the reward. And by Friday, does that student even remember why they earned that ticket back on Tuesday?
SPEAKER_00Likely not. They can't even remember what they did in school by the time they get home that same day. They probably will love going down to the office and picking out a prize, and that's awesome. But will they understand why they earned that prize? And the whole point is to motivate them to repeat the behavior that they did to earn the ticket in the first place. But if they can't remember what that is, then the system is failing everybody. So is that chance of winning a prize on Friday actually encouraging them to make the same positive choice over and over again? I'm less than convinced. And the one thing I know about kindergartners is they need things to be concrete, to make sense.
SPEAKER_00They need to see what they're working toward. They need consistent feedback so that they know when they're meeting expectations. And they need the connection between their choices and the outcome to make sense. A ticket that might turn into a prize several days later isn't nearly as clear as a teacher saying, I noticed you raised your hand and waited your turn. That's exactly what we're working on. And then letting that student see the progress they've made toward their goal. That's something a kindergartner can understand. So what should we do instead of these bingo charts? I think we need to start by making our behavior expectations really super clear, and not just telling students to make good choices or be respectful.
SPEAKER_00What does that actually look like? Are we working on raising our hand before speaking, walking quietly in the hall, following directions the first time, or getting started without a reminder? We need to pick something specific that our students can understand and practice and then give them consistent feedback when they're doing it. And please make sure you're looking for opportunities to recognize the students who are already meeting those expectations. I know it's easy to get caught up in helping kids who are struggling. Somebody needs a reminder, somebody needs help calming down, somebody else needs you to repeat the directions for the fifth time.
SPEAKER_00And before you know it, your attention has gone to the same handful of students all morning. I totally get it. I've been in those classrooms too. But the children who are sitting quietly doing their work deserve to know that you notice them too. And sometimes that recognition can be as simple as, I love how you get started right away. You knew exactly what to do. And when you use rewards, make sure your students know how to earn them, not earn a chance to get them, how to actually earn them in a concrete way that makes sense for five-year-olds.
SPEAKER_00This is one of the reasons I love using a whole class system like our builder reward charts, because we're making progress something kids can see. They know exactly what behavior they're working on. They can see their progress as they earn pieces to build the character or fill the chart. And when the character is finished, they've earned their reward. There's no random drawing, it's not left up to chance. No waiting around to see if somebody calls the right square. They're working together toward a common goal, and everybody gets to participate when they reach it. And that doesn't mean we are expecting every single child to be perfect all day long.
SPEAKER_00They're kindergartners, they're still learning. You'll hear me say that over and over again. But the class can see the progress they're making, they know what they need to keep working on, and they can see the goal. And that's so much more meaningful than earning a ticket and hoping and praying that it turns into something later. I also love using our glow and grow behavior notes for individual recognition. When a student makes a positive choice, you can recognize it right away. Give them a glow note to take home and celebrate their success. And they get to take the glow note home right away.
SPEAKER_00They don't have to wait and enter a drawing and hope their name gets picked. They earn the recognition and they get to keep it. And as the teacher, you can be intentional about looking for opportunities to recognize all different students. You can make sure that you're noticing the child who's working hard to improve behavior and the child who's consistently meeting your expectations. And isn't that what a positive behavior support system should feel like? Like students understand what they're doing well, what they need to work on, and feel successful. And you want them to trust that when they earn something, they actually get it.
SPEAKER_00It's not left up to chance. And listen, I love an adorable classroom resource just as much as the next kindergarten teacher. And all of the resources we have inside kindergarten management toolbox are eye-catching and adorable. And I love bingo. It's a super fun game, but it doesn't belong in the middle of a behavior reward system. Because when we leave rewards up to chance, we're also taking the chance that our students stop buying into the system and trusting it altogether. And that's a pretty big risk to take when we're trying to build a positive classroom community. Our kindergartners need clear expectations, consistent feedback, and rewards that make sense to them.
SPEAKER_00They need to know that their positive choices matter, and students who consistently meet our expectations need to know we see them too. So let's keep bingo for class parties and use classroom management tools that actually help our kids experience success. And if you're looking for more ways to encourage positive behavior without leaving rewards up to chance, you'll find tons of adorable options inside Classroom Management Toolbox. It's filled with individual and whole class behavior tools as well as all the visuals you need to support positive choices, motivate your students, and create a classroom where kids know what they're working toward.
SPEAKER_00There's a link to kindergarten management toolbox down in the show notes if you'd like to check it out. Because managing kindergarten behavior is hard enough without making rewards a guessing game. Thanks for listening to the Kindergarten Toolbox. I'm Amy Murray and I'm so glad you're here. Be sure to check the show notes for all the links and resources from today's episode. For even more tips, tools, and support, head to teachingexceptionalkinders.com or connect with me on Instagram at Teaching Exceptional Kinders. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow along and subscribe to the show and take a minute to leave a review.
SPEAKER_00It helps other kindergarten teachers to find us too. Teaching kindergarten is tough, but you're not alone. Here's to calmer days and more competent writers. You've got this.
Don't spend so much time correcting behavior that you barely have a chance to recognize the positive choices your kindergarteners are making. It's easy to get caught up in reminders and redirections, but those little...
Are you trying to keep up with table points, sticker charts, ClassDojo, and a whole-class reward system? With so many cute kindergarten classroom management ideas out there, it's tempting to try all the things. But more...
Stop reminding your kindergarteners about the same classroom expectations over and over again! A whole-class behavior reward system can help you encourage positive choices, build classroom community, and get your...
Are you spending more time correcting challenging behaviors than noticing the kids who are following directions? It's easy to get caught up in putting out little behavior fires all day long, especially when the same...
Have a kindergarten parent-teacher conference coming up where you need to talk about a child's behavior? It's one thing to share assessment scores and work samples, but explaining challenging behaviors to parents can...