Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Infinite Inning

The Infinite Inning artwork

Infinite Inning 398: Hey! Babe Ruth's in the Wrong Dugout!

Oct 24, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Tampa Bay Rays’ return to the World Series inspires a look at the best players to come out of Florida, and - surprise - we discover that the most prominent Hall of Famers may not be the ones who have the most to teach us. Then we visit with Babe Ruth’s two daughters, one delighted, the other disappointed, and track down a story that broadcaster Mel Allen told about the Bambino concerning an improbable Yankees comeback that took place even as the best player in baseball left to hang out with Ty Cobb. The Infinite Inning is a journey to the past to understand the present using baseball as our time machine. America's brighter mirror, baseball reflects, anticipates, and even mocks the stories we tell ourselves about our world today. Baseball Prospectus's Steven Goldman shares his obsessions: history from inside and outside of the game, politics, stats, and Casey Stengel quotations. Along the way, we'll try to solve the puzzle that is the Infinite Inning: How do you find the joy in life when you can’t get anybody out?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1With the Tampa Bay Rays in the World Series, and by the time you have heard this episode, no doubt the first game will have been played. Even wearing their old Devil Rays duds from time to time. I would mention the name of their owner from back then, but if his name was said two more times, he might appear. Still, this gives us an occasion to talk about Florida and the game. In a way, it's rather surprising that baseball didn't expand into Florida until the 1990s. Florida has been a state since 1845, and it's in the east, so

Speaker 1it fits the game's original geographic footprint, which was dictated in part by transportation requirements, and of course, broadly speaking at least, the weather was more than suitable, except for when it wasn't, in which sense Florida is like everywhere else, but worse, or better, depending again on well, what time of day it is quite often. You might think that baseball had reserved Florida for spring training, but baseball, once it discovered spring training in an organized way, held it

Speaker 1all over the place in its early days and actually well into the 20th century, from Cuba in the east to Catalina Island in the west. I don't recall if we've talked about this on the show or not, but one of the all-time great baseball headlines resulted from the early 1920s Yankees Being so foolish as to cite spring training in the wide-open city of New Orleans, escapades resulted, giving us the headline, Yankees Training on Scotch. Really, that

Speaker 1was the principal part. They were training on other people, too. Of the female persuasion, I mean the hireable female persuasion, but maybe that's never changed in one sense or another. So Florida might have been a possibility if someone had been willing to go there. An owner, I mean, not just the Ringling brothers and Addison Meisner and Marjorie Merriweather Post, who built herself a little cottage that today is known as Mar-a-Lago. I just listened back, and I don't know if it seemed this way to you, but it sounded

Speaker 1to me like I said Ringling brothers, as if there were some brothers who were improperly pressed when they sent themselves out to the laundry. No, I'm referring to John Ringling, and his brothers, who founded the famous circus, Ringling Brothers Barnum and Bailey. I do believe the lot's defunct now, aren't they? They needed a place to hide a circus during the winter, and Florida was perfect for that. Baseball, however, did not find the will or the incentive or the money bags to move a team or expand for more

Speaker 1than half a century, and then only under pressure from a potential third league. I'm talking about expansion. and the Continental League. A moment in time which, for better or worse, brought us the Mets and the Astros. If we indeed live in an infinite universe or multiverse where everything that we've imagined actually could have happened or has happened, there exists a version of baseball in which some owner got suckered in during the Florida land bubble of the 1920s

Speaker 1and moved, say, the Browns to Jacksonville. only for a couple of hurricanes to sweep in and take the ballpark and everybody else along with it. I know we've talked about John McGraw's involvement with the Pennant Park real estate development at that time and how its failure left him and other investors in a bad spot. Well, at least he and Charles Stoneham, a guy with an eye for making a quick buck under most circumstances, didn't move the Giants. So Florida came late to making memories at the team level,

Speaker 1but it's provided them in other ways. For one thing, it's given us some great ballplayers. For me, of the ones I actually saw play, my favorite would have to be Dwight Gooden of Tampa. If you weren't around at the time, and I suppose around the New York City area in particular, You haven't experienced this level of excitement and legitimate hype. Hype implies that this person is being blown up, inflated in an artificial way. But it was completely real with Doc Gooden. And to this day... I

Speaker 1don't think we've seen it again in the same way. The Yankees have never had a young pitcher who was that dominant and caught the popular imagination in the same way. Jabba Chamberlain, maybe? They made such a hash of that. Well, I'll put it a different way. The Yankees in 1984 tried to emulate or steal some of the glory that was accruing to Dwight Gooden by bringing the 19-year-old Jose Rijo to the majors. Jose Rijo obviously became a great pitcher later. when health permitted. It wasn't time yet, though,

Speaker 1and no teenager has pitched for the Yankees in the 40-plus years since. So if being a literal kid is a prerequisite for Dwight Gooden-style excitement, they just haven't had the opportunity. Maybe something similar went on, the same electricity, when Christy Mathewson or Tom Seaver came to town, but they predate my own experience, so I can't really say. I mean, Christy Matthewson nearly predates electricity. Certainly no one ever painted them on the side of a building, so

Speaker 1they hovered crane-like over midtown Manhattan. And of course, mass media did not exist in the same way. No radio, no television when Christy was pitching for the Giants. It was just those few years for Dwight and then For a lot of reasons, the shine came off, some of it due to his off-the-field issues, which no doubt you are well aware of, some due to the fact that he'd thrown about 1,200 innings in the majors by the time he was 23. Can we put that in context?

Speaker 1Chris Sale might go to the Hall of Fame, right? Pretty likely. If not, he's going to be the subject of debate for years. He's 37 years old. and has thrown a total of 2,246 and two-thirds innings. That is, in five years, Dwight Gooden had thrown over half of the career innings that Sale has thrown in 16 years. Justin Verlander's career is now in the books. In five years, Gooden threw one-third of the innings that Verlander threw in

Speaker 120 years. He was pushed very hard. And yeah, cocaine didn't help. I'm sure it didn't. But it didn't put mileage directly on his arm in the way that, well, his own excellence and Davy Johnson did. For the aforementioned reasons, Gooden is not in the Hall of Fame. But if you've been around a bit, you probably saw one or more of the recent Hall of Famers born in the state. Steve Carlton from Miami. Andre Dawson, also of Miami. Chipper Jones from DeLand, Fred McGriff of Tampa, and Tim Raines

Speaker 1of Samford. I said recent so I could save the best of them all. I like to think of John Henry Pop Lloyd as a New Jersey guy because he spent so much of his life after playing, well, while playing as well, in Atlantic City and died here in my state. But he was born in Palatka, Florida in 1884. Palatka is a town about halfway between St. Augustine and Gainesville. It's got about 73,000 people nowadays, which is bigger than the town in which I live, and this place feels

Speaker 1crowded as hell. He was raised in Jacksonville. As I mentioned the last time we discussed Lloyd, which was earlier this year, right at the beginning, his dad died when he was young, and he had to drop out of grade school to support his family. He was actually raised by his grandmother, Maria, who was born a slave. Lloyd's biographer says, Wes Singletary, and I think his is the only attempt at a full-length book on this great, great player, says that there was no birth certificate for Lloyd because

Speaker 1at that time in Florida, no one cared if black births were documented or not. He writes of the Jacksonville of Pop Lloyd's youth, By 1900, Jacksonville's black population, comprising nearly 60% of an urban populace that was Florida's largest, lived mostly in poverty on the edge of downtown, with a large concentration in Hanson Town and other smaller settlements in Oakland, La Villa, and Brooklyn. Their mortality rate was almost twice that of whites. Pools of stagnant water, piles

Speaker 1of garbage, and overflowing privies contributed to 75% of all typhoid fever cases coming in Hanson Town alone. Most adults did menial jobs with little opportunity for advancement. Jim Crow segregation ruled, and an onerous poll tax limited political activity. Black children attended seven segregated elementary schools. There were no public high schools open to them. Such secondary schooling was afforded by the private academies, Edward Waters College, Cookman Institute,

Speaker 1Florida Baptist Academy, and Boylan Industrial School. This is something that we in the North, in particular, don't appreciate very much at all, I think, Throughout the Jim Crow era, there just wasn't public schooling available for black Americans in the South, not past about age 13 or eighth grade. When Brown versus the Board of Education came, meaning that the Supreme Court, the federal government, forced desegregation in schools, some parts of the South just stopped having public school

Speaker 1rather than give in. Simultaneously, white parents opened up, quote, academies, private schools for their children to go to, abandoning the public schools that were now open to black kids. And that's why we have to talk about another Hall of Famer from Florida, John Jacob Buck O'Neill, who Veterans Committee voters kept out of Cooperstown until after he was dead. A final cut, a last insult to a pioneering player, Coach O'Neill. and ambassador for the game. As a player,

Speaker 1he was a first base glove man, although he had more pop than your Doug Mankiewicz types, without hitting as well as Keith Hernandez did either. At least I don't think so. It's hard to tell much from fragmentary stats, except that he was a patient hitter, that in his years starting for the Kansas City Monarchs, the team was very successful, and that in four Negro Leagues postseason series, he hit. 342, with a. 366 on base percentage and a. 519 slugging percentage. He wasn't necessarily that guy in the regular season, but he didn't turn into Quique Hernandez in

Speaker 1the regular season either. I'm guessing you know the rest of his CV, but in short, he was also a manager, and then when integration happened, he became a scout. who signed Ernie Banks and Lou Brock, among others, and a major league coach, the first black American coach when he went to the majors in 1962. And then Ken Burns found him. He had a comic book origin story. His father did not rocket him from the dying planet Krypton. His father rocketed him from Florida. Or perhaps it's more

Speaker 1accurate to say that he took the initiative and rocketed himself and his father confirmed him in the correctness of that desire. O'Neill, born in 1911, was also the grandson of slaves. He was from Carrabelle, Florida, which is on the panhandle on the Gulf Coast. He started playing semi-pro ball at 12, in part because his family was in Sarasota by then, and as we've said, there was no high school for black kids. It also sounds like physically

Speaker 1he matured early in so he was a large fella for his age. If your future is in sharecropping or bussing tables or converting seats to beds in Pullman cars, and that's all we're going to allow you to do, why should a kid know math, history, and science? And so, it was off to the ballpark, to the good, and into the celery fields with his father, to the bad. And I want to pause here and say something that's directly applicable to our times, whether you are white, black

Speaker 1or to borrow from Leo de Rocher, striped like a bleeping zebra. And it's simply this. When some demagogue attacks our schools, whether primary or secondary, public or private, it doesn't matter. and asks, why are you teaching them that stuff anyway? They don't need to know that stuff. And it could be anything. It could be literally anything. My teachers used to make fun of kids going off for their basket weaving elective, which was, I think, a hangover from the 60s when they said that. Like the kids

Speaker 1were all little hippies instead of just doing whatever they thought they could do or their parents thought they could do or the school thought they could do to round out their mind. When they start taking away our kids' choices, they start limiting their futures, especially when they say, well, that's not a practical thing to know. It's just knowledge for knowledge's sake. Well, what do you think develops a brain? There are multiple ways to do it, and hammering something with a hammer is not the only one. And yes,

Speaker 1being able to hammer things is a valuable skill. I'm not terribly good at that part. I grew up in apartments. If something broke, you called the super. But when they want to limit you to that, not only are they trying to hammer all the square pegs into round holes... They're trying to limit us to a servile future. And I know that sounds paranoid, but if you don't have the inputs as a kid, you're not going to have the ability as an adult. And oh, by the way, when now they say, you don't need to know that.

Speaker 1Let the AI do it for you. Same deal. In O'Neill's memoir, I was right on time. The title is a rejoinder to catcher Quincy Troop's book, 20 Years Too Soon. Troop was a catcher and a contemporary of O'Neill's. Buck says that Sarasota was better than most towns in Florida for black folks. Jim Crow was still very much alive, and my father couldn't even vote, though he had to pay taxes. We could only sit in the balcony at the movie theater, but that was just an inconvenience. Sometimes,

Speaker 1if the roads needed maintenance, the county would round up as many young black men as they needed, charge them with vagrancy, and put them on chain gangs for a few months. He also notes that there weren't lynchings in Sarasota, but they were happening pretty close by. Florida at the time, and up through the 1930s, I think, had the highest rate of lynchings, which is to say extrajudicial racialist murder in the country. When Buck was a teenager and working in the celery fields with his father, man, I hate

Speaker 1celery so much. I didn't think it was grown so much as created in the lab, but it was hard labor. O'Neill said out loud, damn, there has got to be something better than this. Later, his father came to him and said he'd overheard, and Buck thought that his father was going to get on him for swearing. But his father instead said, You're right. There is something better than this. But you can't find it here. You're going to have to go out and get it. That is, he had to get out of Florida, as many people of color

Speaker 1were getting out of the South at the time in what was known as the Great Migration. To know that your education stopped when you were 14, O'Neill wrote, and all that was out there was celery, or the blade of a sawmill, or the shoes of a white man. Well, it didn't seem right, and I didn't think it was enough. There was a long article in The Nation today about the way the venerable magazine Scientific American was assassinated by its ownership due to fear of an administration in the

Speaker 1United States that hates science generally and and science that implies it might be wrong in its views specifically, say, promoting vaccines. The editor-in-chief at the time, Laura Helmuth, argued that the magazine had to get into politics to be relevant, and I quote, she argued that science cannot be disentangled from its social context. That's what I've said to the stick-to-sports folks for my entire career, and it's a reason why this show exists. Our government is currently trying to

Speaker 1suppress our knowledge of stories like Buck O'Neill's because they know, as he knew, that knowledge is the key that unlocks the door out of the infinite inning. Thank you. Well,

Speaker 1hello there, and welcome back to the show, Infinite Inning. This is episode number 398 in an ongoing series, and I, for the 398th time, plus a couple of extras, remain your convivial host, Stephen Goldman, Steve America, whatever you want to call me, really, for this trip to the past. on a mission to better understand the present, the time machine, the vehicle, being the game of baseball, the national pastime,

Speaker 1which is to say, a vessel for the national memory. As I indicated at the top of the show, I am coming to you before Game 1 of the World Series, so chances are you know more about it than I do. The outcome, I mean. I'm looking forward to this one. I know there's been some muttering, as was inevitable, no matter what the matchup turned out to be once the Dodgers were eliminated from things, that this is not interesting to that many people. I think these are two really

Speaker 1fascinating teams. They are not all one thing. They have a lot of good pitching. The Brewers may have the hardest thrower, at least on a consistent basis in the history of the game. and neither one is one-dimensional. The Brewers hit the second-fewest home runs in the game this year, leading the last-placed Toronto Blue Jays by two, while the Rays, despite having 42-homer kid Junior Caminero on the roster, hit

Speaker 1only 169. which is in the bottom third. Conversely, the Rays stole the second most or tied for the second most steals in the majors with the Padres. The Nationals were about 14 ahead of them. They stole 164 bases, while the Brewers were in fourth place with 162. So these teams are not going to just stand around and wait for the ball to leave the park. They are clubs that need to make things happen. As the Rays

Speaker 1showed in the previous round by batting Chandler Simpson, who hit zero home runs, but puts it in play a heck of a lot, batting him third. So if you're a baseball purist, if you're there to watch some interesting, well-played games, and you're not just showing up for a particular set of uniforms or big names like Shohei Otani, well, you should be in for a fun time. Of course, there's no knowing, and maybe by the time you're hearing this, One side or the other blew the game out 20

Speaker 1to nothing, and it looks like it'll be addressed you never do know till they play the games that's part of the fun too but right now i'm expecting this to be at least an entertaining and interesting series along the lines of the last time the brewers were in it back in 1982, as we discussed last time. I don't know that I need a lot of added tension in my life, but some suspenseful one-run games, that would suit me just fine. As I said earlier in the show, I live in the New York area, and although I'm

Speaker 1not a fan really of any specific team, just because I'm here, I absorb more of the Yankees and Mets. I see more of the Yankees and Mets, and then as a close third, the Phillies, than I do most other teams. There's just a familiarity to it because I'm marinating in this environment. So I usually start off my evening baseball consumption with the locals. But you know, most of the suspense I endured in those games was either, will Howie Rose on his farewell tour tell another good Beatles anecdote today? Or will Jose Caballero tap his helmet

Speaker 1on this pitch? Yeah, he will because he taps it on all of them. That's not very exciting after a while. So I'm ready. I am ready to say, Goodbye to baseball for the winter with a great World Series and then immediately segue into mourning because as soon as that trophy is awarded, the owners are going to lock out the players and threaten to take baseball away from all of us for half the season, for the whole season, for a thousand years. I don't know. As if that were their right. And I realize they own the business. They can do whatever they want, but they don't own

Speaker 1the stories of Major League Baseball, the story of it. and to mishandle something that's only transiently theirs, that's a real crime against, again, a vessel for our common experience, a thing that knits so many of us together. Even if you're not a baseball fan and you don't wholly realize it, it's been traveling alongside you all the time and vice versa. Say it with me now, folks. Baseball is everything. And everything is baseball. Even the history of

Speaker 1the state of Florida... even if baseball didn't show up with a major league team until 1993. Brett Barbary forever. I don't know where that came from. I don't know why. There must be a more emblematic first-year Marlin than Brett Barbary. Jeff Conine, obviously. But it was Brett Barbary who popped out of my head. I don't know why. Very briefly, I did write my usual column for Baseball Perspectives this week. It's there on the front page. It is called, Does Aaron Boone Deserve Tenure? You've probably read that both he

Speaker 1and Brian Cashman will be back next year. I didn't go into Cashman. We're planning on doing that at a later date. But I was intrigued by Boone just in the sense that only 14 managers over the last 126 years have gotten 10 or more consecutive years with the same team. That kind of length in office, despite not winning a championship, anywhere in those 10 years. You win a championship in 10 years, that earns you a number of additional tries, usually. Unless you're Bob Brenly or someone

Speaker 1like that. And I'm not saying that Aaron Boone shouldn't be one of those guys who gets to stick around regardless of postseason performance or lack thereof, in part because... What we ask of managers nowadays is very different from what we asked of them back before front offices just slew that dragon. It was a long war. It lasted pretty much the entirety of that 126 years. But the front offices are in ascendancy now. And maybe Aaron Boone is good enough at the limited things that he's expected

Speaker 1to do. But read the piece. See what I say. And as ever, I welcome your comments and I often respond to them if there's something for me to say. On that note, we are overdue for a break and the second segment of the show, I guess the third technically, note there was no trigger warning this week. Nothing bad for me to tell. Well, so here's the thing. There's no trigger warning necessary, I don't think. We're going to spend the second act of the show with a benevolent personage. maybe the most benevolent personage in all of baseball history,

Speaker 1by which I mean George Herman Ruth, the Babe. But we do start with some dark stuff from Babe's life, from his family life, from his after-baseball career, but I promise you we end with a really fun story from the heart of his career, when he was his best, most potent, most mischievous self. And I think you'll enjoy it. So jump in the time machine and join me on the other side, won't you? I was working on something

Speaker 1and wanted to have a throwaway line about Babe Ruth being a strict parent, so I spent some time this week confirming that memory by reading competing books by Babe Ruth's daughters. Ruth had two. One was his natural daughter, Dorothy, by, well, we don't really know, but a woman named Juanita Jennings, or so Juanita Jennings said. Ruth was married to when his daughter Dorothy was conceived, not to Juanita, but to the former Helen Woodford. And well, either he had something

Speaker 1to do with that conception or he didn't. And either Juanita Jennings had something to do with that conception or she didn't. The short version is that Ruth and Helen adopted a little girl, a very young little girl. Ruth would never tell her anything about her real parentage, except in moments of extreme stress to her confirmed that, yes, he was her biological father. Helen and the babe later separated and lived apart for about five years without divorcing,

Speaker 1apparently due to their Catholicism. Sadly, Helen then died in a fire started by some badly installed wiring. And when Ruth wed for a second time to Claire Merritt Hodgson, a divorcee herself, she came with a daughter of her own, Julia. When Dorothy and Julia's parents got married, Julia was 13, and Dorothy was 8, and each adopted the other's kid. In Julia's telling, this worked out spectacularly for her because Babe Ruth was the father she had always wanted, a

Speaker 1loving dad, a fun dad, and for Dorothy, it worked out terribly because Claire turned out to be the stepmother you read about in all the fairy tales. Meanwhile, Juanita stuck around as a friend of the family, a friend of Claire's, oddly enough. She and Dorothy... became very close. She was kind of Aunt Juanita. And Dorothy ended up taking care of her in Juanita's old age, long after everyone we've discussed, well, except for Julia, had gone on

Speaker 1to the next stage of their existence or non-existence, depending on your beliefs. Juanita telling Dorothy that, Luke, I am your father, or more appropriate words to that effect, was a sort of deathbed confession. According to her, when Ruth found out she was pregnant, he said, all right, cool, I'm with you. He obviously did not leave his wife, but he set her up so that she had access to doctors, a place to live, and kind of kept her around. But down the road, he, in really unforgivable fashion,

Speaker 1if true, leveraged her to give up custody of Dorothy so that the babe and Helen could raise her instead. And Juanita just did what she had to do to ingratiate herself with the family so she could still be around her daughter. Now, all this information is pretty old. Both of Babe Ruth's daughters have now passed. I don't know if there has been genetic testing or anything done by the family, if that's even possible, to confirm what Juanita said. And maybe they don't want to, because as

Speaker 1long as that story remains a black box, they're biologically related to Babe Ruth. And if it's disproven by testing, well, they're just people like everybody else. And as I say that to you, I find myself wondering, no disrespect to my own parents, certainly no disrespect to yours, who I'm sure you love and honor, at least when they're not being really annoying. If you could pick someone to be your secret relative, who would you choose? I sort of imagine myself if I thought, that Babe Ruth was actually

Speaker 1my first cousin or great uncle or grandfather, how long I would have been able to keep that to myself as an elementary school kid. Well, you're dumb. Well, Babe Ruth is my uncle. It's a non sequitur, but if it doesn't win the argument, at least it changes the subject and someone's going to be envious of your status in life. I don't think I would pick Babe Ruth, though. And I don't think the rules of this game permit you to pick, say, Shakespeare, because it should be someone... whose existence in time is relatively close to your own.

Speaker 1Because 500 years on, given the way that people propagate and spread out, William Shakespeare could be everybody's ancestor, or at least a lot of people's. So that doesn't seem very intimate and very legitimate in terms of making a claim. You know who popped into my mind when I just opened it up and cast a wide net? Jack Kirby, born Jacob Kurtzberg in New York in 1917. was about the right age in the right place. and the right ethnicity to have been, say, my grandfather or great uncle.

Speaker 1You thought I was going to say Casey Stengel, right? The other person I thought of was Leonard Nimoy purely because I actually was on the other side of that discussion. I mentioned this before on the show, but he had relatives in my hometown and would show up from time to time. Not that I ever ran into him. And it was probably more dignified for both of us that I didn't, because I don't think I would have been able to keep from weeping, particularly prior to my teenage years. Dorothy collaborated on just one book about her father, and Julia did, I think, three. Neither woman was a writer,

Speaker 1so they had ghosts or collaborators, however you want to put it. Emanuensi, is that the plural of Emanuensis? Julia's are more excuses to show off pictures from the family scrapbook and other sources. She repeated that exercise about three times, with the text in each version largely duplicating that of the others, which at least shows she was consistent in the way that she remembered what had happened. Dorothy's book has a little of the scrapbook aspect too, but it's

Speaker 1more of a real book than an exploitation. And as I suggested earlier, she had an axe to grind, not just the intention of celebrating her dad. It's sort of the mommy beerist of baseball books. Julia doesn't really argue with it, except to mention in one of hers that she disagrees with Dorothy's story of Ruth's estrangement from Lou Gehrig, in what she characterizes as a bitter book. Now, they were not pals either, the two sisters, which is sad.

Speaker 1And Dorothy's book sure is bitter, but the question is whether it's true or not. And at least in terms of the Garrig-Ruth story, everyone kind of agrees on the basics. As you might remember, the Garrigs and Garrig's mom used to watch little Dorothy. And one day, Dorothy went over there in some hand-me-down play clothes. And the question is whether Dorothy dressed herself or Claire didn't give her anything better to wear because she was Cinderella. And Ma Garig

Speaker 1made a comment. The comment got relayed to Claire Ruth. Claire Ruth said, screw those people forever. The babe said something to Lou. Lou said, never talk to me again. And the two pals broke up over that, not even dimly patching things up until Lou Gehrig Day in 1939, where, and I've remarked on this before, if you look at the pictures, the babe is hugging Lou and Lou ain't hugging him back. The two women did agree that the babe was a great father to both of them, which

Speaker 1is a relief, though I found myself wondering if they would have allowed themselves to say anything negative about him if there was something negative to say, given how beloved Ruth was and is. Both tell stories about Ruth being a traditional father, which is ironic given what a womanizer he was in his youth and right through his marriages. Now, the accepted conventional biography of Ruth, at least I think so, is that during his marriage to Helen, when he was still in his early 20s, he essentially slept with the

Speaker 1known female population of the world, vows be damned. However, once he married Claire... He settled down. Dorothy kind of disagrees with that. Do as I say, not as I do. I guess when it came to Babe in Parentis, both women told stories of their receiving early and untimely marriage proposals and the babe intervening forcefully to say, uh-uh, no way. Dorothy's came from a guy who was 20 when she

Speaker 1was 15. But that's the way things often were back then. Maybe not common. but certainly not unheard of and situationally scandalous, but not necessarily as scandalous or blatantly illegal as it would be today. Even that you have to slam an asterisk in there because there are still states where parents can kind of arrange for their underage daughters to get married to adults. And in Let's say extremely cult-like situations,

Speaker 1they go ahead and do that. As Casey would say, you could look it up, but I don't think you'll find many good situations coming out of that. Julia's version of the same story concerns a proposal that came when she was closer to 20 herself, but the babe said no woman is mature enough to get married until she was 25. It turned out he was being a little hyperbolic. When she wanted to get married at 23, he gave his assent. And yes, it's misogynistic or chauvinistic or insulting

Speaker 1to Julia personally, if not women generally. But insulting women generally was kind of a thing that guys like to do back then and have picked up on again now. Not that it was OK then and not that it's right today. Repeat after me for the benefit of whoever is sitting next to you on the bus as you listen to this show on headphones. Do not generalize about groups. Treat every individual as an individual. I am a member of a group, but I am also an individual. As I would not have others dismiss me as a drone,

Speaker 1I shall not dismiss others as a drone. That is lazy thinking. Ready? Let's say it together. Do not generalize about groups. Treat every individual as an individual. I am a member of a group, but I am also an individual. As I would not have others dismiss me as a drone, I will not dismiss others as a drone. That is lazy thinking. Thank you. Some of you were pretty shy about pitching in. You never know who might be listening

Speaker 1these days. Validating Dorothy's story is that she got out of the house supposedly to get the hell away from Claire as soon as she turned 18, whereas Julia stuck around. Everyone involved is, of course, long gone, and there's no way of knowing what really happened. In the same way that some of Joan Crawford's other kids and friends said that Christina Crawford's book was exaggerated or dishonest, the same thing happened with Bing Crosby's kid and Betty Davis's daughter. I mean, with Bing Crosby, the son whose book cast

Speaker 1him as an insane disciplinarian, he was also really troubled. And chicken? Egg? You can't wholly know. I mean, Mackenzie Phillips, what she said about her father, John, woof. And I hope it's not true, but we have to accept that it is. And at least in this case, the more benign case of Dorothy, Ruth, Well, there were a lot of other people who didn't like Claire either. As for Babe Ruth, put Dorothy and Julia's books together, leave out the Claire stuff, and you get a portrait of a man who was better to both his daughters, biological and not,

Speaker 1than his wife was to him or she was to them. That's how I'm taking it anyway, and it makes me happy to know it. What's perhaps troubling, assuming Dorothy's story is accurate, or this is the flaw, and you see this in a lot of couples, is that he was so deferential to his wife that he didn't help Dorothy out more often. He was also gone a lot, sometimes working, often hunting, golfing, fishing. Dorothy would say it was in order to get away from Claire. And again, based on corroborating evidence, that seems plausible. So who is Claire going

Speaker 1to take out her hostility on? I mean, about being ditched by her husband if George Herman wasn't available. And that was his whole point in leaving, right? In comparison, Julia's books are simply tomes of praise about daddy. She didn't know her birth father and really went all in on the babe as a parent. Her books don't tell you anything that's more secret or revelatory than that. He called her butch and fried her toad-in-the-hole sandwiches. I think that's what they're called. They were a piece of bread

Speaker 1with a hole in it, some egg dumped in the middle, and he liked to throw bologna on top instead of bacon. That was his personal twist on the dish. She doesn't say anything critical of her mom, not that I would have expected her to. I have Claire Ruth's memoir, too, also with a collaborator. I haven't forced myself to pull it off the shelf for a reread, in part because to do so right now feels like a betrayal of Dorothy. I do feel bad for her, but I feel bad for the babe, too, at least in her version. The

Speaker 1marriage lasted almost 20 years, from 1929 until his death in 1948. And I'm sure not all of it was miserable. But it also seems pretty clear that in retirement, he drank too much and she drank too much. And even when they were together, they were basically apart, even at home in separate rooms. Dorothy tells of the babe, perhaps in great pain from the cancer that was soon to consume him, or maybe just drunk and depressed, threatening to

Speaker 1jump from the 14th floor window of their apartment. She doesn't say who restrained him, She implies that she talked him down. She also says that Claire wasn't trying to talk him down or anything, but was in the next room reading a book or a magazine. The suggestion was that she just didn't care. That's horrible. But so is the thought of someone like the babe being that lost. That's not how we like to think of him. We like to think of him as a life force, as someone who had a zest for living. And at the

Speaker 1same time, It's a reminder that he was a human being, not a cartoon. And not every minute, even for him, was a rollicking good time. And perhaps he was a person of fairly simple needs. Food, drink, sex. cigars, and something with a competitive or athletic aspect that kept him occupied. Could be baseball, could be golf, could be hunting quail. But just because his needs were basic doesn't mean that his emotions were or that he experienced them in a simplistic way. He was bigger than life, but not bigger

Speaker 1than himself, and was capable of experiencing pain just like everyone else. Edwin Arlington Robinson's famous poem Richard Corey doesn't quite fit, in part because the physique of his protagonist is the anti-babe. Whenever Richard Corey went downtown, the people on the pavement looked at him. He was a gentleman from soul to crown, clean-favored and imperially slim. Well, the babe was many things in his life, but imperially slim was generally not one of them. His bill just didn't

Speaker 1run that way. And yet the theme of internal pain amidst public plenty certainly fits. It's kind of like the Pagliacci gag, right? To the extent that that even is a gag. A man goes to a doctor and says, doctor, I can't help feeling depressed. And the doctor says, I know. Go to Yankee Stadium. The Yankees are there today. Babe Ruth is hitting third. He'll hit three home runs and cheer you up. You'll never feel bad again. But doctor, I am Babe Ruth. Now, having given you that as

Speaker 1a kind of preamble, I want to give you the antidote. Because Julia and Dorothy's books didn't just make me aware of Babe Ruth's pain. They also reminded me of how much fun he could be, not just as a dad taking his daughters out to the golf course, one at a time, it seems. Again, they weren't close. But also, well before they came along, when he ruled baseball and was subverting its proprieties in every way that he could.

Speaker 1And I will tell you that story right after this brief intermission. Here's a happier story I came across in

Speaker 1one of Julia's trio of books. It seemed like the thinnest one, too, but you don't know until you check. And I always check. That's part of my job here. I didn't believe the story at first, but I found the game in question. At least I think I did. And now I do believe it. There's a passage from Yankees broadcaster Mel Allen. You know, the this week in baseball. How about that guy? who spoke of seeing this game that we're about to discuss in Detroit. He wasn't from Detroit,

Speaker 1but his mom would bring him there. He saw it as a kid. He said, I don't remember much about the game because my eyes were fixed on the Bambino. And this is a true story. He was the last man to bat in the top of the eighth inning and made the final out. The Yankees were way behind. The Tigers were retired in the last of the eighth. So now the Yankees come to bat in the top of the ninth inning and the game is surely going to be over. The Yankees are behind by five runs. They had a common runway to the clubhouses in those days,

Speaker 1and so he had to go right by the Tiger bench and down the stairs to get to the clubhouse. But instead, having made the last out of the eighth inning, he didn't expect to come to bat in the ninth. So he sits down on the Tigers bench, and he's having one heck of a time, even though his team is behind. But that was part of Babe Ruth. And lo and behold, the Yankees put on a rally and dadgum, the ninth batter is due up and Babe, he bursts out laughing, gets off the Tiger bench, walks around back of home plate, goes to the Yankee bench where the

Speaker 1bats are, and picks up his bat. There are a couple of men on base with the Yankees still behind by two runs. And typical of Babe Ruth's life in so many of those instances, he belts the ball over the center field fence for a home run to cap a six-run rally. If this happened, and I'm pretty sure it did, it would have been on September 11th, 1926, when Mel Allen was 13 years old. The Yankees were eight games up with about two weeks to play. The

Speaker 1Tigers were in fifth place and fighting for a taste of that sweet first division money. Spoilers, they did not get it, in part because of games like this one. It was a matchup of Yankees control lefty Herb Penick and Tigers righty Ulysses Simpson Grant Stoner, whose name was McGill, but he called himself Lil and everyone knew him as Nancy. Well, that's not true. Actually, Buck O'Neill was known as Nancy due to Satchel Paige hanging that nickname on him during a marital emergency. Stoner, though, was known as Lil. Somehow

Speaker 1that's supposed to be a shortening of Ulysses, I don't see it, but your guess is as good as mine. Penick, as I said, an extreme control pitcher, who was having a decent year overall, not one of his best, was just very hittable on this occasion, and a Mark Koenig error at short, his 48th of the season, didn't help him much. The Tigers were up 3-2, going to the top of the fourth. Ruth opened that frame by drawing a walk, Then Lou Gehrig hit a ball far out to the opposite field for a two-run homer. So the

Speaker 1Yankees were up 4-3, but that didn't last long as the Yankees plated five runs in the bottom of the inning. Stoner himself had an RBI double. Future Hall of Famer Heini Manush drove in two runs on a single, stole second, and scored on a single by Bob, that's Father Gill. It was 8-4 Tigers. The Yankees' bats went silent at that point. Stoner was still in there in the top of the eighth. Ruth did not make the last out of the inning. He made the second out. Bob Musil

Speaker 1made an out that seems to have gone unrecorded, but he went out. Ruth struck out. Gehrig doubled on a check swing. Sometimes you just get lucky. But Tony Lazeri stranded him, also going out on a play that no one seems to have written down. That meant that the Yankees at bat in the top of the ninth would begin to with the number seven hitter jumping Joe Dugan, and Ruth would be the unlikely seventh man to bat in the frame. Ty Cobb was the manager. Yeah, he was on his way out due to the game-fixing issues

Speaker 1raised by disgruntled pitcher Dutch Leonard, but he probably should have been out anyway just given his indolence in this contest. So we go to the top of the ninth. Again, six batters have to go before it's Ruth's turn. Catcher Benny Bengo doubled with one out. Yankees manager Miller Huggins pinch hit outfielder Ben Pascal for the pitcher, and he singled, scoring Bengo. Koenig made an out, two down. If Ruth were indeed sitting on the Tigers bench, he must have

Speaker 1felt safe getting comfortable. Who was he hanging out with? Cobb, basically. The rest of the big stars like Harry Heilman were on the field. The Peach only played about half the time that season as he was pushing 40. He actually played a lot more for Connie Mack in 1927, when he was 40 and was still a better hitter than most of his contemporaries. And then, two outs. Earl Coombs singled, chasing Pascal to third. Musil doubled, Fothergill just missing snagging it before it hit the ground. That scored Pascal, and

Speaker 1would you believe it, Ruth was up with runners on second and third. Cobb did go out to the mound. Stoner was still in there. Why didn't he lift Stoner? Why didn't he order Ruth intentionally walked? We'll never know. Like Gehrig, Ruth hit, I quote, a line drive, which sailed at terrific speed over the wall in deep left center. Three-run homer. The Yankees were up 10-8. Urban Shocker pitched a perfect ninth to save the game. Usual caveat, save was just a figure of speech then. The headline in

Speaker 1the next day's Detroit Free Press article And pretty much all the papers was, Little Stoner collapses under heavy barrage, which seems terribly unfair. That was, by the way, home run number 13 for Lou out of an eventual 16 that year, number 42 for the Babe out of an eventual league-leading 47. It was a nice comeback after he had been so ill the year before and hit only 25 in 98 games, although that was still good for second in the league to teammate Musil's 33. Now that

Speaker 1is how I like to think of Babe Ruth, making a joke of decorum, sitting in the wrong dugout and winning anyway. That appeals to me. There's a poem by the eccentric British writer Gerald Manley Hopkins, 1844 to 1889, called Pied Beauty. It's a sort of sonnet. It goes, Glory be to God for dappled things, For skies of couple color as a brindled cow, For rose moles all in stipple upon trout that swim, fresh fire coal, chestnut falls,

Speaker 1finches wings, landscape plotted and pieced, fold, fallow and plow, and all trades their gear and tackle and trim. All things counter, original, spare, strange, whatever is fickle, freckled, who knows how. With swift, slow, sweet, sour, a dazzle, dim, he fathers forth whose beauty is past change. Praise him. See, All things counter, original, spare, strange. That was Babe Ruth.

Speaker 1Praise him indeed. Glory be to God and the Babe. Hallelujah! Oh yeah, we've got that old... old time religion, that old time time travel religion. And should you wish to travel over to social media, you can follow me at stephengoldman.bsky.com You can also write us, by which I mean me, at InfiniteInning at gmail.com, and there remains a Facebook group.

Speaker 1Simply go to Facebook, search on Infinite Inning, bang, you are there. Should you wish to support the show, and I very much hope you do, please journey over to patreon.com slash theinfiniteinning. I thank you very much. Gear of a rudimentary kind, available at the-infinite-inning.creator-spring.com. Original soundtrack available gratis at casualobservermusic.bandcamp.com. Finally, should you find yourself with the proverbial moment to spare. please go to the podcatcher of your choice, rate or

Speaker 1review or subscribe, or all three at once. It tickles the algorithm in its happy place. And wouldn't you know it, the algorithm does not subscribe to Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics. Our theme song, which you are hearing now and have been listening to throughout the episode, was a co-composition of myself and Dr. Rick Mooring, who asks, now wait a minute, treat individuals as individuals? Is that supposed to be deep or something? Do you think you're profound? Well, I'm not

Speaker 1trying to be profound. I'm just trying to do my best with what I have. A few ideas, a whole lot of history, and this shiny time machine. I figure trying to do good, however inept, beats trying to do harm. And if I can just get that time machine out of the shop, I'll be back next week with more tales from inside the Infinite Inn.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Infinite Inning 402: The Ted Williams You Meet in Heaven

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    We speculate on what happens when we move on to the next stage of existence and want to meet our heroes. What form will they take? It’s a more complicated question than it first appears. Then we go south for a battle...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Infinite Inning 401: He Ran All the Way to the Cardinals Game

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    A young man shows his love for baseball by running all the way to the Cardinals game - and likes it so much he buys the team! But this is the Infinite Inning, so he only gets to hold it for a very brief time. Then we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Infinite Inning 400: A River Runs Through the Outfield

    Nov 6, 202657 minAudio

    Thank you for supporting the show through (more than) 400 episodes! In addition to the usual celebrations and ruminations about what it all means, we have the usual two stories. We take a trip back to the great Cubs...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Infinite Inning 399: Isn’t it Time the Brewers Move On?

    Oct 31, 202650 minAudio

    Our first post-World Series episode asks if the Brewers’ inflexible budget will help or hinder them in the defense of their championship. Examples from the past provide a surprising answer! First, though, we remind...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Infinite Inning 397: Living with the American Terror

    Oct 17, 202656 minAudio

    Meet the Milwaukee Brewers of yesterday and today - 1944, 1982, and 2026 - as well as that time Casey Stengel managed them to a pennant and had to leave anyway. Then we go back to the world of 1982, take a high-level...

    Credit the people on this episode