Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Imperfects

The Imperfects artwork

Dr Emily - Tough Love vs Shame

Aug 16, 20261 hr 19 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Is tough love to blame for our shame? 💌Join 9,200+ people getting a Dr Emily values worksheet and takeaways from this week’s episode in our newsletter - http://bit.ly/45NyQDy We all know that parent or coach on the sideline who takes under 10’s basketball a liiitttllleee too seriously. And occasionally, tough love might seem to work in the moment, long term, the shame train isn’t going anywhere good. Dr Emily, our resident psychologist, is here to name the shame to tame it, and teach us how we can be shame strippers too (get your head out of the gutter. Shame on you). We go into the difference between shame, humiliation, guilt and embarrassment, bow down to the queen Brene Brown, and introduce ourselves to our own Healthy Adult. Shamelessly, this is one of our best episodes to date. 0:00 - Ever heard of a shame stripper? 6:27 - Bow down to Brene Brown 12:25 - The other self-conscious emotions (they’re shy) 20:51 - Humour and humiliation 29:21 - Shame is a full body experience 36:16 - Beware of who you share (with) 40:43 - Manosphere + behaviour change 46:59 - Tough love + kids sport 57:07 - Working with shame 1:06:10 - Bring on the compassion! 1:10:07 - Introducing the Healthy Adult If you’d like to watch the full episode on YouTube, follow this link - 🫖 Imperfects episodes mentioned on this episode Ryan Shelton - Shame, Jealousy & Purpose - https://bit.ly/4qgEqrO Dr Emily - Compassion of The Self - https://bit.ly/4hqWa1k How do you know you’re in a thinking trap? - Maria Ruberto - https://bit.ly/4ze4eJh 🎧 Things to listen to Between Two Beers with Steven Adams - https://bit.ly/4g3wipS 📚Things to read Daring Greatly, by Brene Brown - https://bit.ly/45VT2Dx The Compassionate Mind, by Paul Gilbert - https://bit.ly/3UewPOq Movember study of the Manosphere - https://bit.ly/4wZxtOs Proneness to shame vs proneness to guilt research by Tangney et al. - https://bit.ly/4g4lQyl 📖Things to do The Mindful Self-Compassion Workbook, by Kristin Neff and Christopher Germer - https://bit.ly/4zg353K Othership (breath work app) - https://bit.ly/4g7Q03E 🩷To host your own Vulnerabilitea House, purchase here - theimperfects.com.au/shop 🩵To purchase our journal (or your novel) My Imperfect Life, click here - theimperfects.com.au/shop 🩵To join our subscriber community, A Little More Imperfects, follow this link - patreon.com/theimperfects 🩷 AND you can subscribe to A Little More Imperfects through Apple Podcasts http://apple.co/theimperfects The Imperfects is not a licensed mental health service and is not a substitute for professional mental health advice, treatment or assessment. The advice given in this episode is general in nature, but if you’re struggling, please see a healthcare professional, or call lifeline on 13 11 14.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Guilt says I've done something bad. Shame says I am bad. And embarrassment says… Yeah, when I wet my pants at show and tell. Oh, what a shame. And shame is exactly what Dr. Emily is here to talk about. I saw a coach, an opposition coach under 10s, their dad slash coach subbed them off and like yelled, what is wrong with you, switch on. So instantly with that comment, what's wrong with you? We get shame. From that place, how do we perform well?

Yeah, you can't. So what do we say instead? Shame cannot survive in the face of empathy and compassion. To me, it felt like immediate humiliation transitioned into shame straight away. And it wasn't until I told it on the podcast that it got a very different reaction from you guys of empathy. And that was the beginning of me actually starting to write music again. This is the key aspect here of shame, is that it tells you to hide. Do not share that with anyone.

Imagine that. Everyone feels shame at some point, even Dr. Emily. It felt like a soccer punch. I punch right in the gut. Soccer punch? Is that the right word? Soccer. Soccer maybe. Soccer punch. Is it? All this time I thought it was soccer. It's a less used phrase, but it's still correct. Sorry, I didn't mean the soccer punch was soccer punch. Quick, is anyone here a doctor? Yes, her name is Dr. Emily and she's a psychologist.

Please welcome to The Imperfects, our very own... Psychologist! Dr M is back. Speaking of backs, Hugh, how's your back? Because I know it's been a bit troublesome. Something's happened to your back. This is the most middle-aged man thing to maybe ever happen. Yeah. I wish it was like a cool story like I was doing weights or I was wrestling Ryan. I don't know. That would be so cool.

Yeah. Bad example, but I was quite stressed. I had a few stressful meetings at the end of the day yesterday, and I got in the car, and I was going home to kids who are going through a bit of a rough patch. I knew it would be stressful at home, and I thought, I'm going to do some deep breathing in the car. And I went, I'm going to do box breathing as I'm driving. And I took one breath in and just went, ah! And then I did my back doing that. Breathing. Breathing. Must have been a big breath. It was just a, yeah, it was a big breath. It was my first box breathing. Oh. I did my back breathing, trying to relax. That's how middle-aged I am.

It's ridiculous. But you've breathed before. I have so many times for a long time. For 45 years I've been doing it and I did one big one. And my back has been spasming non-stop. And I am in so much discomfort. Have you tried not breathing? I've tried lots of things just wanting to make it better and nothing is fixing it. There you go. Well, good luck. Thank you. Good luck for the future. Are you okay now sitting down? It's going to get a bit sore sitting down for a long time? Yeah, but that's okay. Okay. That's okay. I wouldn't miss Dr. Emma, especially with what she's talking about today because it is...

Breath work. No, you're not talking about breathwork, eh? I am not, no. It would have been really helpful for someone. Exactly. You're talking about shame today, which is such a, oh my God, it's a topic of a great discussion. It comes up in almost every episode we do with someone. It's like everything comes back to and we hear a lot of talk about shame. Yeah, exactly. And I was thinking about how the imperfects arrived. Really, in some ways, it was born out of the response to shame.

And that is in this practice of vulnerability. Yeah. Yeah. And definitely like one of the first episodes, which is an episode where I told a story of mine, like a thing I was going through, which kind of was the story that I told Hugh before the podcast. A lot of that was around shame. And it was the reason that we started the podcast in the first place. And we can link back to that. But it's, but yeah, it's, it is, it's present. It's been present throughout the last eight or nine years of this podcast. Yeah. And that's because it's present in all of our lives. So in that sense, I didn't really want to bring in a previous episode because it is part of everyone's experience as a human.

And I also am aware that I don't want to be... It's a funny thing, shame, and I've kind of bought into it here a little bit, but I didn't want to shame anyone by bringing in their episode. Yeah, fair enough. And I will be honest that... I have steered clear of shame because, and I bow down to her now because Brene Brown is, you know, for so many of us... The most shameful woman in the world. You know, the preeminent voice on this topic.

And I haven't wanted to pretend that, you know, I would have more expertise than her, for example. But I will certainly be referencing her work here, but also bringing in the therapeutic lens, how it might be... exhibited or how it's shown in the therapy room, but also how it's felt and experienced day to day. So at the top of the episode, I'm absolutely giving an immense nod to the incredible work of Brené Brown and how that has, I think for all of us, particularly in this podcasting world too, so profoundly influenced how we share and how we talk about our experiences that might feel shameful.

It must be so much of really what you and good psychologists do is like your shame removers or shame strippers, but that sounds a bit different. And not like stripping people, like you help strip people of their shame. You help strip people of their shame. And that's kind of like what you tell me. That's what you would do so often is like remove the shame for people. And that's like, I guess when someone sits down with you and you meet them for the first time, there must be a part of your brain going, well, I need to find out where the shame is and I need to help them. Yeah, well, the shame walks into the room. You know, the shame often is here because you're here in some ways.

So shame is an inherent aspect of healing, the healing work. It requires a turning towards, which is what we don't want to do when we experience shame. So I'll explain, I'll explain all of that. Love that. So it's really important that we can understand what it is because the more we know about the experience, the more we can identify it and therefore the more we can work with it. Okay. So I will reference back to Brene Brown's operationalised definition of shame and she says that it's the intensely painful feeling or experience of believing that we are flawed and therefore unworthy of love and belonging.

Okay. It is the fear that something we have experienced, done or failed to do makes us unconnectable. Whoa, yeah. So shame is inherently the fear of disconnection. And disconnection, isolation, loneliness, rejection, abandonment are core fears that we hold being a human. Mm-hmm. it kind of brings up that the fear that I've definitely had and I know a lot of people have, which is that the shame that you have, which is that you're not good enough at the thing that you value.

And as a result, you'll be rejected by society. To be more specific, it's like people will think that I'm not funny. You know, people think I'm not funny or I'm not the funniest or I'm not special in any way. that I believe that if that's what people think, then they'll reject me. They won't want to be friends with me. They won't want to hang out with me. And as a result, I'll feel disconnected from them. Exactly. Yeah. So there are, in some ways, when you explain that, there are two feelings or two experiences here.

The first is I get exposed to this sense that I'm unworthy, that I'm not good enough, that I'm inherently flawed. That's the first experience. Yeah. And then if I am that, there's a threat here of rejection and exclusion. Because what if people discover this part of me? If people knew this about me, they would leave me. So that's those two parts here is the first experience of the very profound, heavy, full contact experience of feeling flawed, not good enough.

And then if that's the case, then there is the threat here that people will leave me. Hi, it's Ryan from The Imperfects, and I'm reaching out to you now because we need your help, gosh darn it. Why do we need... Sorry, no, I'm just making a plea to the listeners and viewers to ask them to subscribe to the show in whichever way they see fit because it really helps. The more subscribers, the better we can make this show, am I right? Yeah, but I don't think we need to... I think we could just ask them politely.

Yeah, but if I use the emotional music... I think the music's a bit much. Is it? Who's playing that music? Doesn't matter who's playing the music. The important thing is we're pulling at the heartstrings and asking them to do us a solid. Could we not just ask them straight? It'd really help us if you guys subscribed because we would be able to make more of the show and make the show better. Oh, and not use emotional manipulation. Yeah. Yeah, I reckon. We can give it a go, but I doubt it'll work. I'm trying to work out when the best time to bring this up is, but I think I have really good examples that have come up for me recently because I've been doing, as you guys know, breath work.

I didn't work for me in the car yesterday, but I do do it. I'm doing it like two or three times a day at the moment. And there's one I'm doing on the app that I use, Othership, which is I think it's called Inner Child, and it's like 30 minutes. And during quite extensive breath holds, it says go back to a time in your life when you needed support and to feel loved and like – imagine yourself giving that version of you a hug and telling you that things will be okay and you're okay. And I realised as you're saying that, that was the exact feeling I was having. So the one that keeps coming up for me when I was in year eight on the tram going home

I remember I noticed there were two girls who were sitting like opposite me, but sort of off diagonally. And I realised they were trying to like impersonate what my face looked like. Like they were like pretending to look like me and piercing themselves laughing. And I was so shattered. Like it was the most pain, it was the most hurtful. Like they were genuinely teasing me for what I looked like and weren't trying to hide it too much. And I remember getting off the tram and that walk home was just, I was just devastated. And so in my, like, that was the feeling I had of like absolutely flawed, not worthy, like actually a joke.

And it was so horrific, but I keep in the breath work. That's one of the times I go back to where I literally pitched myself being like waiting for myself getting off the tram, like an adult version. Yeah. And like, I just say, mate, you're fine. Like, trust me, you're fine. Like, it's okay. This is awful, but it kind of, you're going to be fine. I promise. I think that's, that's such a powerful reflection and such an incredible example of, of that, like the sheer desperation.

and collapse that we fall into when shame is here. There is a self-loathing and sometimes for some people are disgust and a sense of hating who I am. Yeah, that was a very strong thing. Yeah. And so I'm kind of curious, do you remember if you told anyone? No. Yeah. No, definitely not. Yes. And this is the key aspect here of shame is that it tells you to hide. Do not share that with anyone. Imagine. And yet when, and this has been so clearly articulated in the research and in practice too, is that when we speak shame, it loses its power.

We'll come back to that. Which is, it's so hard because it feels like the scariest thing to do. Yeah. The reason I want to, I'll come back to that because I want to come back to how we work with it. And you're already really on the right track there. You know, this is like, how do we, how do we offer what we needed at the time to ourselves now? But I think it's really important that we differentiate shame from the other self-conscious emotions. So the other self-conscious emotions are things like embarrassment, humiliation and guilt. So just starting off with guilt because they're often used interchangeably, but incorrectly.

So guilt says, I've done something bad. Shame says, I am bad. Well, I reckon the example would be potentially the girls when they go off the tram, one of them might be like, I feel guilty. That was, I did something quite bad there. Yes. And I had the opposite experience of like, I'm bad. Yes, and if we go one step further with those girls, perhaps one of those girls says, oh, look, that was really poor form. That's, you know, that's kind of not the kind of person I want to act, you know, like, because that moment there is a violation of potentially her values.

And that's where guilt emerges, is that I have acted inconsistently with what I value. It's a nudge usually to make amends guilt. It's very adaptive. So guilt would be, I've done something that has violated my values. I've done something bad here. But perhaps another girl after that goes, that was so bad, I am such a bad person. I'm such a bad person for saying that out loud.

And you can see how that girl's experience would have moved her into a spiral of negative evaluation, of criticism and self-loathing. Yeah. And so the two pathways are very different Can they lead into each other though? Yes. Like guilt can, because I think about my life, I think guilt often leads to shame. Yes. Yeah. And I think that's really important to know. And that is that whilst they are separate emotions, they can absolutely be co-occurring or lead to one another. Usually it's guilt leads to shame.

Yeah. So I'll give you an example, and this is really very obvious in trauma work, but it might be something like, let's just say someone was involved in a car accident. And perhaps that person took a different route home that day. And that person says, I should have known better. I shouldn't have taken that pathway. I never go that way home. I should have known better. That's guilt, should. So we can tune into guilt usually with shoulds, woulds, coulds.

Okay. Okay. I should have known better, then I'm such a terrible person. So we can see the interlinking there, that guilt is the pathway to shame. I shouldn't have gone that way. This is all your fault. You're an awful human being. Yeah. For me the guilt is like opening the crack to revealing the true person that I am underneath.

Yes, exactly. And it's like the bad part of me coming out. Yeah. And I feel guilt about something that I've done, but it's actually an example of the unlikable, flawed person person at the core of me. Yeah, exactly. I think that feels like a really beautiful reflection there. It's like opening the door to this deeply held sense of almost like a defectiveness. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.

Yeah. They can absolutely also not occur together. I really want to be clear about that. So that's guilt and shame. If we look at embarrassment, do you guys have a sense of how embarrassment would be different? Yeah, when I wet my pants at show and tell in grade two. Uh-huh. Highly embarrassing. Yeah, I'm curious as to why that wouldn't be shameful. Like, how do you distinguish that from something that would be shameful? I just remember I went very red. Yeah. I went very red and ran to the toilet.

Yeah. And then mum kind of picked me up and mum was a genius with emotions and she just, we talked about how I felt all the way home. Yeah. And we talked, yeah, we talked about the feelings. Yeah. Extensively. That's amazing. Yeah. So I was very lucky. Aha. So it's a really interesting example in contrast to that previous one where you didn't go home and tell anybody. That's shame. Yeah. Whereas, you know, what's interesting about embarrassment is that usually embarrassment is a swiftly experienced emotion. And it's usually a mistake that we've made publicly that all humans can do, like wetting your pants when you're a kid.

We know that this is something that kids can do. What age are you not a kid, do you reckon? What's the cutoff in your clinical opinion? Yeah. Well, that's the interesting thing too is that at some point your brain is going to go, this is no longer just an embarrassing thing. This is a really shameful thing. Yeah. Right? And there's a lot of stuff in there around bodily functions. I won't go down that track today. Yeah. Because there's a part of that, and I'm just thinking about a time that... Oh, I want to say it.

There's a time where... I know what you're about to say, I think. Yeah, well, there's a time where I pooed my pants. Pardon? I said, don't make me say it again. Wait. It was a time when I was working at, fine, may as well say it, Channel 7, and I was in the building. The building has now been destroyed, so that's okay. I was in the building. Has it actually been destroyed? Yeah, not because of me.

But it was just like obviously an accident. Yeah. Didn't see it coming. Yeah. And I had thin pants on and so it affected the chair as well. So I had to secretly remove it from that level at least. I'm just curious how old you were. I would have been early 20s. Yeah. Gosh. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and so that, you know, even as you're saying that, I can hear the shame. I know that you're laughing and all that stuff and you can talk about it now in that kind of sense.

I use humour as a shield. But, you know, you can hear the shame because there's a part that says this is not meant to happen, that humans, adult humans are not meant to do this. So there's like this kind of part that feels defective. But yet when we zoom out and have a look at an experience like that, It's like, how do we bring on board a compassion that, gosh, you're just a normal human being and this is a normal thing that can happen? Yeah. Because then if we're moving into a compassion about like, oh, this thing happened and it's like, I don't feel great about it, but I'm also a normal human being.

How much of a difference does that make in comparison to holding like this sense of like, oh, yeah. I'm so ashamed that that happened. Does that make sense? Yeah. Yeah. And I guess it's like, I mean, it was in the moment it was stressful because I didn't want to be found out. Yes. Yeah. I'm not, I'm, I'm, to be honest, I'm not sure if it was, if I, if it entered a shame place, it might not be appropriate for this conversation. Cause I, cause I think I was like, I knew it was like embarrassing.

It's like obviously really embarrassing, but it actually probably didn't enter a place of like, I'm a, I'm, I'm a shit person. I remember. But it was probably more embarrassing in all honesty. Did you tell Pip? Well, I told Tim, Bartley, I'm pretty sure, because I had to go home and change. Um, but I, but I, to be honest, where I was, what I was really nervous about was cause I was working with Hamish and Andy as well at the time and they had a radio show at the time.

And in, in that era of being friends with them, you cannot show any vulnerability because they will turn it into a six week story arc. Yeah. So I had to be really careful, actually, of them not finding out. Yeah. So I was then, like, embarrassed on a national stage. Can I ask about humour? Because I know you said sort of tongue-in-cheek that you use it as a shield. And I can see how in the case of it being turned into a story arc, there is how shame could develop for you. Possibly.

But also I feel like humour when you've done something embarrassing or if you've had an embarrassing moment can be really kind of therapeutic and for me can be the thing that like gives it the relevant size of stress or something. Like it takes up the right amount of space in my brain and can actually reframe it as I'm kind of glad that happened because I got to laugh about it so much. Yeah. So that's usually the differentiating piece with embarrassment is that with time it's usually funny. Yeah. So yes, and that's how we can distinguish it often from shame because shame doesn't feel funny.

And, you know, we'll talk about kind of different coping modes that show up when in response to the experience of shame. But when we think about embarrassment, usually it's short-lived experiences that we recognize would be embarrassing for anyone. Yeah. And that with time they become funny. Yeah. Okay. Good distinction. Yep. Okay. So that's embarrassment. The last one I want to mention is humiliation because shame and humiliation are often also used interchangeably. And the thing that I find really fascinating about humiliation and how it's different from shame is that it's usually based upon a sense of deservingness.

So let's just say you are told off in class as a kid, and the teacher says something really punitive and shaming. So says like, Billy, you're such an idiot, you should have known better about that. And if that child's internal response is, how dare she? If there's an anger response, a defensive, I don't deserve this treatment, that's not shame, that's humiliation.

So it's how we're internalising. That's how you respond to it. Yeah. And what the internal dialogue and what the internal feeling and sensations are. So if someone is treating me in a way that I think is undeserving, that will be more likely that I have felt humiliated. That's interesting because, you know, say I made like a TV show and it got a one-star review and the difference between shame and humiliation is me going like, I don't deserve that one star.

This is humiliating because everyone thinks it's a bad show, but I don't deserve that. I know it's at least a two. Whereas like... If I responded in a way of like, they're right. Yeah. It is one star. Yes. That's absolutely spot on. Yeah. So shame is, I deserve that. Yeah. Now, I think the research initially was suggesting that shame is a more dangerous experience than humiliation. Yeah. But recent research, and Brene Brown has spoken about this not long ago, is that recent research is suggesting that humiliation and shame can both be extremely destructive.

And if you were to look at the research around, like, for example, mass shootings and perpetrators of mass violence, that there has often been a history of bullying and humiliation in their past. They're angry, yeah. And so we can see the power that these emotions can have to be immensely destructive both to other people but also to ourselves. There's very clear and an immense amount of research about the role that shame plays in almost all psychological conditions and also in terms of perpetration of violence, aggression and hostility.

So it's really so important that we can have a language around shame, that we can understand it and also learn how to respond to it when it shows up. Sounds like, yeah, the how to respond to it is so key. That and working out what it is. Like what am I feeling here? Yes. I can imagine the same incident as we've just sort of displayed, that the same incident can bring out shame or humiliation. And I think in my life I've felt a lot of shame. I'm not sure I've actually felt that much humiliation, maybe a little bit but not a huge amount.

But I feel like that says something more to the core of who I am and it feels like can something be extrapolated about that person, whether how they interpret a certain incident. Yeah, absolutely. The story that you've told before about when the guy pulled the book out of your jacket is sort of a good example. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so years ago I told this story, but a long time ago I was at a party with people I didn't know. I had a book in my jacket pocket and a guy pulled it out and started reading it out aloud and taking the piss out of me.

And they were lyrics to I was trying to write songs and they passed it around at the party and everyone had a go at reading songs. them. And then from that moment, I kind of don't think I ever really tried to write lyrics again. I sort of stopped until doing the show and talking about it on the show. But for a very, very long time, I barely wrote anything. And to me, it felt like immediate humiliation transitioned into shame straight away. Yeah. And a confirmation of that you're not good enough sort of thing.

Yeah. There's some really important things I want to acknowledge in what you've just said there. The first is that, yes, we all will have different shame triggers So that's a really important process in developing shame resilience, is getting really clear on what you're going to get triggered by. So what are your points of vulnerability? And one of the entryways into understanding that is actually an exercise that Brene Brown has developed, and it's to do with the notion of what's called unwanted identities.

So when they were ridiculing the lyrics, what identity or what part of you was it attacking? Uh, the, I guess me as a creative person. Yeah. Yeah. So if I said to you the identity that I want to be perceived as would be what? Certainly back then, definitely want to be perceived as kind of creatively brilliant.

Yeah. Okay. So I want to be perceived as creatively brilliant. I do not want to be perceived as. I don't, could I, maybe this is breaking the exercise, but I don't want to be revealed as creatively incompetent. Yes, yes, exactly. So that we can say there is an unwanted identity as being not brilliant, as being not creative. Maybe there's another word in there. Maybe it's being boring or something akin to that. Or a failure.

Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So I don't want to be perceived as a creative failure. Well, there's something else in there that I feel like it's like you're trying to be creative. Like you've been found out for trying. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, yeah. That was also being laughed at, the effort that you went to, I feel like, maybe in that moment or – Yeah, I think potentially I held on for way too long this idea that truly brilliant, creative people, it just kind of pours out and it doesn't need effort. It's like it's a revealing of how great this is and it's not...

You're a genius or you're not. Yeah. And it's not about a sort of step ladder of trying and trying and getting better and failing, which I understand now. But I think I didn't understand that at the time. Exactly. Yeah. It's like all or nothing in some ways. Yes. So the identity, like I want to be perceived as being creative. I do not. I deeply do not. And perhaps even fear being perceived as not creative enough. Yeah, that's true because in my belief it's either one or the other. And so if I'm perceived as not creative, then I'm in the bucket of not creative people who will never do anything.

Yeah, exactly. And then there's probably a cascading of a whole host of negative beliefs or negative thoughts that follow that. So that is a shame trigger. Yeah. So, you know, potentially for you, Josh, situations or experiences that expose you to the feared identity, the unwanted identity will trigger a shame response. Yeah. And that shame response can look like a number of things. So usually it will look like very reminiscent of the fight, flight, freeze response.

So when we get exposed to shame, We can go inward, which means that we withdraw. So that's kind of what happened to you. It sounds like you went quiet. Yeah. You also then subsequently avoided approaching, looking at, talking about anything creative. Yeah. Certainly that specific area. Yeah. So there's withdrawal. So that's kind of representing here this response that is threat driven. So there is a physiological response that is getting activated when we feel shame.

Okay. This is what's so important to understand about shame is that it's not just a feeling. There's a whole vast array of research which suggests that it's what's called a multidimensional construct. So that basically means that it's not just one thing. It's not just a feeling. It's an experience that's happening physiologically. neurologically, it's happening in the socio-cultural environment, and it's also happening across institutions. So it's really multidimensional.

It's not just one feeling. But if we come back to that moment when you get hit with shame, so we have these potential responses that are being driven by this sympathetic nervous system whose primary goal is to keep you safe. Okay. So we've gone out of our kind of rational, regulated, balanced nervous system functioning into this threat response. And, yes, one of those threat responses is get me out of here as soon as possible, withdraw, shut down, freeze.

Very, very common and very normal response to feeling threatened. Okay. Or we can have a reactive response response. And this is the fight response. So when someone triggers a shame for me or is shaming me, I become explosive. I react or become defensive. I might kind of act out in some way. So this also is a really normal response and an understandable response to this attack on the self.

So if you had in that instance, Josh said, you know, he grabbed the book from you and you're like, started swearing at him. Like, what the F are you doing? Like, what's wrong with you? We can see that it's coming from the same initial activation of a shame experience, but it's manifest very differently. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. But just knowing Josh's personality in that moment, he's gone, I will make everyone have a good time here and I will facilitate, I will be part of everyone having fun and it doesn't matter, it's my expense, I can still turn this into a fun thing when no one knows it's about me.

Yeah, yeah, sort of hide. And then I participated in reading the lyrics and taking the piss out of myself because I told the important detail is that I told everyone at the story that it's not my book and that it wasn't mine. Yes, absolutely. And so therefore they, that's why they did it. They weren't like saying you're, they didn't know that it was my attempt. Yeah. Yeah. And that's actually a really, um, another really interesting example of what's called the fawning response, which is really kind of people pleasing response. So I'm, I'm smoothing the waters.

I'm participating in almost in the ridicule. Mm. And this is, again, it has a really adaptive function from an evolutionary point of view. If I am fawning, if I'm being submissive, if I'm pleasing, if I'm not attacking, then that ultimately is ensuring that I don't get attacked again or that I'm as safe as possible. So, again, it has this immensely adaptive function of attempting to either keep us safe or reduce the likelihood of being attacked again.

Interestingly, I have told that story. I told that story to many people many times before telling it on the podcast. And I would tell it as an amusing anecdote, something really funny and embarrassing that happened. And for years I told it and got a good reaction. So it was like one of the stories you've got in your sort of armory of stories to tell. And it wasn't until I told it on the podcast that it got a very different reaction from you guys of sort of sympathy and empathy.

And that was the beginning of me actually starting to write music again, that response from you guys on that time. Yeah. So it sort of speaks to that thing I brought up before about humour, how humour in that case was probably a really negative way of, or not negative or unhelpful way of processing that story and that shameful moment for a very long time, for like 15 years almost or 10 years. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's such a great catch.

I think that that will speak to a lot of people's experience that, um, the humour, yes, it might allow it to be spoken, but it's not allowing us to touch the feeling. So when you shared it with the boys and they responded with care, nurture and empathy, it almost allowed you to feel and to be held in that shameful experience. Yeah, yeah. Which meant that you were turning towards this part of you that you had not wanted to actively face.

Absolutely. Yeah. Is there a chance, Em, that like Josh is maybe even unconsciously telling like over his life, telling people that story, kind of like throwing the line in, like, you know, just to see if you get the response that you need but... protecting yourself with humour, knowing that like you probably won't and that's fine because you're protected and treating it as a funny story. But you just keep throwing the line in, sharing the story with people until you do get the response that you need.

That's interesting. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's quite possible that that's what's happening. I think... It's really interesting when we talk about speaking shame and I think even Brené Brown attests to the way in which information can be misunderstood or misheard. about working with shame and that is that the obvious kind of brand came out that we need to be vulnerable.

We need to be vulnerable to deal with this shame. But the piece that was missing in there is that we need to be really discerning about who has earned the right to hear our story. because that expression of vulnerability needs to be held so carefully and held obviously in an empathic and nurturing way. And we don't always know who that person could be. So the fact that you shared it with your brother

would tell me that you already inherently knew, and with Ryan as well, that they were safe and that they had earned the right to hear that piece of vulnerability. Yeah, and I'm also thinking about times where I'd shared it and I actually can feel it feels awful now because I remember thinking like with people, you're laughing a bit too much. Like this is not nice. Like you're almost re-litigating or re-putting me through it again because you're laughing just a bit too much about this. And this is, I think, confirming to me that you think I'm ridiculous as well and you think I'm not worthy.

Yeah. There's like an appropriate level of laughter. Yeah, the appropriate response, even if you're saying it funnily in a funny way, the appropriate response for anyone is to like look behind that laughter and go, that would be so painful. And just, yeah, it feels like a strange misread from someone to that. To laugh heaps. Yeah, yeah. And almost retell it with excitement to other people. Yeah. Yeah. That's a whole other thing. Okay. Yeah, I could do a whole episode on that, on like gossiping.

We should do gossip. Would it be judgment as well? Yes. Just recall episode fuckwits. Like we'd do that and like document episode about fuckwits. We'd do that. So today's topic. But yeah, but can we, yeah, can we like gossip judgment? Yes. My God. Yeah. And what sits on the other side of that is trust, right? So... It's and shame and trust are going to sit alongside each other here in some kind of way. that you had had enough evidence with these two boys here to know that they're trusting.

And so that is the platform from which you can go, I'm willing to show this part of myself here and know that you won't ridicule me. So this is the thing is that there's a step into I'm exposing the part of me that I deeply believe is flawed. And I'm willing to take a risk here that you're not going to leave me or abandon me because of it. And so we have a platform already that says these boys are not going to leave me or I'm pretty certain they're not going to. Yeah.

There's at least like it's likely. Yeah. I've built up enough evidence to say that they're trustworthy enough. Yeah. Yeah. So I think I just wanted to really emphasise that when it comes to how we're experiencing and then sharing shame is that we have to be really discerning around who we are willing to trust with these parts of ourselves that we may have held back for so long. It was like a fun activity or like a revealing activity to write down the names of people in your life that you would feel you could trust with, something like that.

It'd be such a revealing thing of like, these are the people that are very important in my life. Yeah, like my people. Yeah. And they are the people that will affirm that you are worthy of love and belonging. Yeah. Even if they don't have the language on it, they may not say, I just want to affirm, but like their response will be one that makes you feel that. Like you will feel like, oh, they're not going anywhere. They get it. They don't judge me. Yeah. And they feel probably like a sense of like, I feel really special. You shared that with me.

Yeah, exactly. And we can talk then about the upward spiral of connection that occurs when we do share. But I wonder, I just want to kind of bring in some other things before we then move on to how we do work with it. Is that okay? So I mentioned earlier that there are these kind of this notion of unwanted identities. And I want to mention a few really common ones because I think it's really important to name what they can be. So things like being a good mother, Um, anything for in like, in terms of masculinity, being strong enough, not being weak, being good looking enough, anything around body image, um, around sex, around money, around, um, career.

So these are kind of these core domains where we can have a vulnerability towards feeling shame. Body image is a very, very big one. And I would say that it goes particularly now with Instagram, social media, that has been amped up immensely. Add to that for men, we talk about a lot of the hair, after we were talking about it when you came in today, like hair. I was literally talking about how I'm half jokingly thinking about getting a hair transplant. But that's a big thing from a young age for men who like that's a... Yes, exactly.

That's absolutely right. And this is not my area of expertise, and I'm going to point here to the incredible research from the Movember Institute, but there is very clear information about the role of shame in the manosphere. Totally. Yeah. Of course. And that shame is being weaponised. to create a sense of belonging. And so I really, you know, really encourage people to go and have a look at the research that is out there, but also just to have an awareness that shame is not just an experience that we have individually.

It's also it sits in the zeitgeist. So it sits as a socio-cultural experience. So we are constantly being fed messages about what we should feel not good enough about, what we should feel shameful about. Yeah. If we bring this back to the repercussions of shame, the research... I say the research a lot. It's probably an important part. I know. I'm always banging on about research. How annoying.

I'm like I need another word for it. My hunch. Yes, my suspicion is that on the surface, we have been taught through centuries perhaps, of messaging that if I shame someone enough, it will change their behaviour, right? Yeah, I have an example in my mind at the moment just because I'm literally catching up with a friend from primary school who I haven't seen in 32 years, catching up with her tomorrow. So I've been thinking a lot about primary school and we're reflecting on how our teacher in prep who was kicked out of the teaching profession, but she used to put kids in the bin.

Like she would literally pick them up and put them in a bin if she was unhappy or something, and she would say, that's where you belong. It was horrific. I remember as a five-year-old just being like that. Yeah. What the hell's going on? But there was a boy that she, he thought he ate too much and she just kept, she wouldn't let him have lunch. And so you can sit in the bin while everyone has their lunch. So there's two parts there that are shaming. Sure. But it was, yeah, it was like double shaming and it was horrific. Mum actually got her teaching.

Yeah, what a mum. She's got that for mum today. But that was like her approach. Like clearly like this is horrific shaming that will change this person's behaviour. When I think about it, it would have made them go to that behaviour more to soothe themselves from the absolute pain of that shame. It's immensely misguided because actually what we know is that shame and shaming behaviours create more dysfunction, more maladaptive behaviours and much, much poorer outcomes.

So there was this incredible longitudinal study conducted by... I'm not going to pronounce her name properly, Tangnae, and I'll get the date for you on that one. And they followed 380 children across adolescence and looked at the concept of what's called shame proneness. And so that's a tendency to feel shameful across a whole host of situations and experiences. So not just in one area. And so there's a real vulnerability here to feeling shame often.

Okay. And then they also looked at kids who experienced guilt proneness. So the sense that I'm going to feel guilty about my behaviour, right? And in this study, what they found was that the kids that had experienced greater shame proneness experienced far poorer outcomes in terms of delinquency, increased use of drugs, much riskier behaviour, much younger sexual behaviour and unprotected sex, risky sex behaviours.

In contrast to the guilt proneness group. that actually experienced the opposite. They had much better outcomes. They were less likely to engage in risky behaviours. But the kids that were experiencing shame really profoundly were much more likely to experience those negative outcomes. But are you saying that like instead of shaming someone, we're better off guilting them? I mean, no.

I mean, I know you don't mean that. So it's like how can you, are you just saying just like generally speaking, it's interesting to note that you're better off guilting Yeah, it's not really a better off. It was more just a contrast. Yeah, okay. That shame is in some ways more profoundly and pervasively impactful than someone that might be prone to feeling excessive guilt. Now, as we know, anything that is experienced excessively, frequently and profoundly will, of course, have really detrimental outcomes.

and a detrimental impact on your sense of wellbeing. So I'm not saying let's all go down the guilt pathway, but more recognising that that shame proneness in particular is really, really painful and results in a lot of suffering unless we're intervening in particular ways. Would you the idea of tough love? Is that kind of in the ballpark of shaming? Yes, it depends and it depends what it looks like. OK, so

When we look at the origins of shame proneness and the people that are more likely to experience shame and have a lot of difficulty with it, that of course our early experiences with our primary caregivers and also experiences with teachers, coaches and mentors during that kind of childhood period are going to influence how we experience a sense of worthiness and belonging.

Okay. So what the research suggests is that experiences like abandonment, abuse and neglect will most likely or is highly associated with a tendency to feel more shame. Mm-hmm. Interestingly, neglect has been shown to be a very strong predictor of shame. And if we look at that, you think about a little kid that is being neglected by their parents or their primary caregivers.

What's the core message that shows up with that? You're not worthy of attention, love. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And you're not one of us. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. How's this sitting so far? Well, I'm just thinking about, I'm, I'm a, we now do kids sport, our kids are now doing kids sport and we've got basketball on the weekends. I mean, if ever, I'm sure it's the same with all kids sport, but if ever one of the great social, I mean, it should be, I'm surprised there's not hundreds of researchers and psychologists sitting around with notepads, writing down stuff and taking notes, but yeah.

There's all types of appalling behaviour, but I saw a coach the other day, the opposition team whose child went the wrong way, like ran the wrong way, didn't the court pass in the ball, and then their dad slash coach subbed them off and yelled, what is wrong with you, switch on. And I remember saying that and I was like, that is, and the kid just looked shattered. But I remember I was looking at this dad and I was thinking, I have no doubt those words were said, those exact words were said to you. Like I have no, you are, you know, what it shouldn't be.

It's kids basketball, but a stressful situation. And so you're, I mean, it should be the least stressful thing in the world. Under sevens, under eights basketball, whatever it is. Yeah. But he's in that stressful situation. He's like, I'm going to say what I've heard, what it was said to me, because that was good for me. Look at me now. And it was awful. But you see it all the time. And that like you see shaming happening in kids sport. And it's a kids sport. I cannot believe the summer stuff I'm saying. I think this topic needs so much attention. It actually gives me a very strong visceral reaction when we talk about how we're taking, how we're caring for our kids in these situations.

Like in sports situations particularly? Yeah. Particularly, I think it's very prevalent and there are so many reasons as to why shaming comments and behaviours are occurring. That's a topic for probably another time. But it's a great example of why we think that kind of comment is going to produce better performance. So if we kind of come back for a second, if you imagine that a parent is yelling at their child about their performance, you've got to do better.

It could be a coach. That's not uncommon either. It could be any kind of mentoring, teaching role that they've got. You can do so much better than that. What's wrong with you? Why did you miss that pass? You should be over there. In that tone with that almost like a threat piece, you're going to be able to do that. When you think about, okay, so this child is hearing this and in that moment it's activating the stress response. So instantly with that comment, what's wrong with you?

we get shame. Shame is here. Activation of the fight flight response from that place. How do we perform well? Yeah, you can't. Yeah. It's impossible. Yeah. So in that, in that second, that kid is going to feel immense pressure to perform because they don't want to have this experience again of feeling unworthy of their parents' love. In some instances, they're not. for that game potentially or maybe some future games that kid might perform really well.

It's like the whip kind of motivating them. They're motivated by this fear of punishment. So yes, maybe in the short term it looks like it works. It looks like this kid is now performing because I've given them the tough love, I've given them the hard word and they can do better and look, they're doing better. What are the long-term consequences or even mid-term consequences? There's a cost. There is such a big cost to that kind of behaviour. Yes. So you can look at, if we look at, there are some very well-known elite athletes who have spoken about, like Andre Agassi is one of them, who's spoken about the role of a punitive parent.

Tiger Woods, Alana Docky. Yeah, it's endless. Yeah, it's so sad. Not to mention the millions of people who... Don't actually, because I feel like I agree with you, those are classic examples, but you could look at those people and say, well, look at all the success they've had too. But I think of the millions of people and I can think of specific sports people I played junior sport with who are so talented and so brilliant who just stop playing enjoying it and gave up and missed out on so much fun at like 14 or 15.

Or I mean, if you want to extrapolate that for the ones who are successful, they might be good at their sport, but they're deeply troubled human beings. Deeply, who have come, all of them come and done at some point. I mean, it's probably a topic for another thing, but kids sport is, it's a mess the way it's done at the moment. I feel like there should be two people that could coach. a kid side, they should do a survey and ask all the parents involved, out of 100, how much do you care? And the person who does the least, who cares the least, they're the ones who are qualified to coach because they are so compromised if you care too much about an under 10's game of football.

And the other one is teachers. Teachers should make teachers don't want to spend their Saturdays coaching kids sport. I thought you were going to say the people who care the least should also be the teachers. But it should be someone who's, if you are emotionally invested to the point where, I mean, I should, I just want to say this and I don't know where we'll put it in, but we hit the jackpot with our, with our child's basketball team. We have an incredible, wonderful man who is, he is like the absolute prototype of what a good kids sports coach could be. But yes. Yeah. Yeah, but I think that that's what, so it really highlights the potential for either great healing, nurturing and encouragement or great harm.

So those like, for example, you may be able to remember really important teachers, really important coaches, that there will be memories that you might hold of there being this one person, maybe outside of your family, for example, that deeply impacted your sense of worthiness, your sense of potential, your sense of belonging. So these roles have the capacity to be either incredibly helpful and nurturing or incredibly harmful.

Because is it right in thinking, I'm thinking that like the parent who gets really angry at their kid and shames them, like what's wrong with you, you can do better. Are they just sort of doing the best they can at exercising their own shame? And sort of like the shame that they have about loss and like, you know, like the coach that you're talking about, like maybe his great fear or shame is that he's not good enough and he can't. And this kid, my kid, is going to ruin it for me.

Absolutely. Or do repeat my mistake. Yeah, that's what I see. Yeah. Yeah. There's so much attached to why we want our kids to do well, so much attached to that. Yeah. And this great challenge that we have as parents is to actually let our kids be who they are. And so there is this really, for me, as a mum, and as a psychologist that comes intertwined often, like how do we cultivate a space of feeling free to learn, free to make mistakes and free to grow?

Like that's that for me is the biggest, most important piece. And is that it would, I mean, it's hard for me to make, I'm not a parent, obviously, but like, like the coach, there's maybe no interest in trying to understand what the kid is, what the kid cares about. Like the kind of the Andre Agassi example. It's like, like I've read his book and it's like got to a certain point where he hated tennis as a kid, hated it. But because his dad wanted it so much for him, he felt like he couldn't quit. Yes.

Yeah, exactly. And interestingly, when you listen to Andre Agassi's story, he admittedly kind of goes off the rails at one point in time during almost the height of his career. And then he goes down the ranks and he essentially has this kind of come-to-Jesus moment where he connects to the meaning of him playing tennis and that that meaning was actually around the possibility of doing a greater service to actually to the philanthropic work he now does. Yeah.

And so it was the moment there that he connected to, you know, something bigger than myself, rather than being driven by the threat of failure, so being rather than being driven by the whip We're now being driven by values aligned behaviours. Does that make sense? Yeah. Yeah. No one chooses their parents or their sporting coaches as a kid. And I feel like there's be a lot of adults who are stuck with this shame and don't know what to do with it.

So what can you do as an adult? for yourself and also will only benefit any children that you happen to fall into your care at any point. So what can you do once you're in this position? I think that there are some really well-discovered and well-named resources and intervention strategies that we can use. But the first, and it will sound so boring, and I feel like a bit of a broken record when I say this, the first is we have to know it's here.

So it's about being able to identify when I'm getting, when I'm being almost like attacked with a shame. Name it, tame it. Yes, but even before we use language, actually it's often the body. So because shame is such a full, I think Brene Brown calls it like a full body contact emotion or a full contact emotion, it's often felt very profoundly, very obviously in the body, sometimes more so than other sorts of emotions.

So if you imagine like the moments that you felt shame, where do you think that shows up in the body or what's the feeling in the body? Yeah, gut. Yeah. I have hands and arms everywhere. Yeah. Often I feel like tingling in the hands or something as well. Yeah. Yeah. So I will share with you that the other day I had a shame moment when someone questioned how much travelling I was doing and whether this was taking away from time with my children.

And when I heard the comment, it felt like a soccer punch, like a punch right in the gut. And I actually audibly went, oh, it was involuntary and I didn't have any other responses other than in that moment feeling again, like my unwanted identity is bad mom. And that's where I went. I went traveling time away from kids, bad mom. And immediately soccer punch in the gut. Soccer punch? Is that the right word?

Soccer, maybe. Soccer punch. Soccer is... Is it? All this time I thought it was soccer. Oh, yeah. It's a soccer punch. It's a soccer punch. Really? We call it soccer. I knew what you meant. We all knew what you meant. I don't know what soccer is. A soccer ball in the gut. I was thinking like a literal soccer ball into my gut. In that case, it's right. Yeah. In that case, that's what you're thinking. It's a less used phrase, but it's a little correct. I'm open to learning. I'm not going to feel shameful. That can be a trigger for me. That's so funny. Also, unwanted identity, dumb. Definitely.

Yes. Yes, definitely. I didn't mean to soccer punch a soccer punch. Yeah. This is so good. So now I'm talking about it, I'm not going to feel shameful about it. But yeah, in that moment, felt a very literal sense of like literally feeling punched in the gut and an audible sigh comes out of my mouth. And yes, in that micro moment there, it totally identified this shame trigger. And I didn't really respond in the moment with anger or actually even assertiveness.

I just kind of went a bit quiet mostly. Preach, sister. Yeah. But then I will say that what I did do afterwards was I said to my husband, I said, you know, I have to tell you, I just felt really hurt. It wasn't him that made the comment, by the way. I felt really hurt. by that comment and he gave me a hug and I was like, that, that to me helped me move with that shame. He's a shame stripper too.

Yeah, exactly. We heard you the first time. Yeah. So that moment there was me speaking the shame with someone that I trusted. Okay. And so it didn't take away the feeling. And this is the really important piece is that shame, like any emotion can act as information. We need to be wise about how we listen to it and how we respond to it. Okay. So the first is, um,

really being able to tune into knowing it's here in the moment. And that's going to be most often the first thing is your physical sensations, like the sucker punch. The feeling of heat often is a big one. The sense of shrinking or the sense of puffing up even. An urging, like it can bring with it an urge for, you know, physical reactions, for example. Yeah. So we really want to in some ways map our response to this feeling that's arising.

That's the first thing. Do I have a language to know or do I have an almost like an interior language to know that shame is here? That's the first thing. I'm going to do it in real time because I'm feeling that now because what I just said to Hugh before, which was like you've said it before. You've already said that once, whatever I just said to you before when you said the shame stripper. And then I felt immediately guilty that I was like, oh, that's not a nice thing to say. He's like, you know, it's a joke. It's whatever. And then I just like said that and then I felt guilty and then I started thinking I'm mean to Hugh.

I'm a mean person. Oh. Like that's what I start. I have that worry all the time whenever we have our, you know, banter. And I like, you know, you say something silly and then I'll, you know, whatever. But then just to name it, like I was, as you were describing those feelings and emotions and hate, I was feeling those exact same things as you were saying it. So just to say. Okay. Well, this is amazing. I'm not sorry though. Okay. This is an amazing example to work through because I was thinking the exact same thing after you said that but in the opposite way.

I was noticing that I don't get in the slightest bit hurt or upset with that because I don't have an unwanted identity about the fact that I'm not intelligent or not like what I say is like I'm quite confident that I'm – I wasn't as a kid but I'm quite confident that I'm an intelligent person, not in a book smart academic way but I know that I'm – so that doesn't – making jokes about that wouldn't. Yeah. Yeah. No, just smart, smart. Yeah, smart, smart. So that's what you said. That doesn't it didn't trigger any hit or I didn't feel anything.

And I noticed I was like, I was like, I wonder why. Just very quickly, as you're thinking, I was like, wonder why that me being like my joke show on this podcast never affects me in the slightest. It's because I've been humiliated. I don't ever I'm so confident in that I don't have an unwanted what is it again Unwanted identity I don't have an unwanted identity around that I'm so confident that's not me there would be other things that I'd have unwanted identity What is your unwanted identity now that we're on the subject just so I know to not go there just to not go there

Well, you could start off with your wanted identities, first of all. So like that, like some, when we're exploring this, because this is part of shame resilience is being able to name what your triggers are and naming what your wanted or unwanted identities are. So they might be, sometimes they can be linked to your values. So if you think about, you know, your maybe core values, let's just say it's being caring and maybe being creative, all that sort of stuff. When you're in violation of that, that might be an unwanted identity.

So this is the opposite of what you want. So being perceived as uncaring, that for me would be a shame moment. Yeah. Can you think of one? I've done so much work with Anita on this. Like I don't, I feel pretty good. Your psychologist, yeah. Yes, my psychologist. I feel like I'm sure there are some. but I don't know what they are to say right now. Yeah. Well, I think what's important to note in there to really emphasise is that we're not trying to get rid of shame. Shame is very instructive and has the capacity to be really helpful.

In working with any unpleasant, painful emotion, we can never stop them from happening or stop them from arising. They're part of being human. So the way we work with it is actually how we first of all notice and name that it's here. explore it. So we can bring a critical lens to this, like, what's my mind saying here about this? Or what does this feel reminiscent of? And often in shame, it will be reminiscent of a younger you.

So when you're being triggered, it can be a reminder of a little part of you that felt unworthy, that felt ostracized, that felt excluded or felt not good enough. And then, and this is the, well, there are two parts that are really hard, but they're the most important, and that is sharing and speaking the pain or the shame and bringing on board compassion and empathy.

So technically speaking, we could say that compassion and empathy are the antidotes to shame and that shame cannot survive in the face of empathy and compassion. But they're very tricky to do. Very, very tricky. Yeah. Did you mean compassion, empathy for yourself? Well, yes, and also when someone is sharing something with you too. Yeah. Okay, yeah. Because we can absolutely, and we know that when we share our shame with a trusted person, that that is a very helpful pathway to working with this and to moving with it and to developing a resilience around this emotion.

But oftentimes you will be by yourself or oftentimes it's not just going to end after you've shared it, it's still getting activated. Mm-hmm. And so how is it that we bring on board a compassionate response to this pain that's here? And I will tell you that in the work that I do as a therapist, I can, I mean, shame is so, it is felt so viscerally when you're in the presence of it. And in my early career, I used to kind of naively believe that if I offered someone enough advice,

nurturing or care or compassion, that that would take their shame away. And what I know now is that's not how it works. I can absolutely provide a sense of safety, of nurturing, of compassion and kindness, but it's not the only ingredient that's needed to help someone shift, particularly long-term-held deeply ingrained shame experiences. We need to go to another level there where at some point in time through a number of different pathways, that individual is able also to take on their own self-compassion.

Me giving them is not always going to be enough. Yeah. Yeah. It's genuinely in my experience, particularly with childhood sexual abuse, complex PTSD, me offering a warm, nurturing, safe place is simply not enough. But I guess even in saying this, I really want to emphasise that working with shame, particularly in the place of trauma, there's no quick, simple fix here. And also just like that, for a lot of people listening who've lived with shame for a long time, that's probably a really hard thing to hear.

Yeah, I think it is really hard. And I think... It makes me emotional because for so many of the clients that I have worked with in the past and you see the shame, you see the shame and all you want to do is just take it away from them, but you can't do that. You can't do that. And yes, this is a long process. It's absolutely doable, but there is no quick fix.

There's no quick pathway. from a place of not feeling worthy, from a place of not feeling good enough to feeling suddenly good enough. It is an absolutely doable process, but it certainly takes time and it's complex. It's complex work. So I just want to give a really big, important, empathic nod to those that are struggling there with this desire you know, deeply held what we might call a defectiveness schema.

So the belief that I am somehow defective and therefore unworthy of love, this is a really hard pathway to tread. Yeah. Yeah. can i can i um because i always feel the need especially like any episode we do always want people to have something they can go away and just try like because i feel like people who resonate with this are going yep this is something that i want to work on and i want to start now i just heard this um there's an nba basketballer who talks up in this interview talks about this exercise he does every day and i feel like it would be so powerful i first thought was gosh this is really good to deal with shame can i play it to you and we might not put this in the final episode just

And then you can talk about if you think it's a good activity. Yeah. So for context, this is an NBA basketball. He's actually a Maori, New Zealander called Stephen Adams. And I just heard him do this. He's an incredible man. He's a wonderful man. To get a sense of him, there's all this footage. You can look at videos of him making sure people don't hurt themselves during a game of basketball. Like when someone's about to fall over, opposition, he'll catch them. He's such a big man. He's one of the biggest men in the world. I would love to have him here. Like if anyone listening knows how we could get Stephen Adams on the podcast, please come forward now.

We would happily redo our door so we could fit in. We were so happy to do that. But, yeah, this is him talking about an activity that he came across. It's on a New Zealand podcast, a brilliant podcast with two guys. Their podcast is called Between Two Beers. And they sat down and spoke to Stephen Adams and he said this, which I think was just so beautiful. I know, so that's a trance video. That's chicane. That is chicane. Hang on. Hang on.

It's like technique. I don't even know where I got it from, bro, but I just started doing it randomly. All I did was I write down exactly how I feel, and it's just raw emotions. And like whatever it is, the word, bro, I'm just writing it down. Even if it's like not even a fully made sentence, it doesn't even have to make sense. But I put that all down, and then what I do is just like I'll stop, then I'll reread it, and then I'll respond in a different font, like a different colour, sorry, different colour. The one that I read, the raw emotion, I imagine that as like a technique.

an adult Stephen. So then I'll do more of like okay this one's like going crazy. Again that's more like the self hate like oh you suck and blah blah blah. The response is more I'm actually really proud that you acknowledge this this and that. Understand it's a stressful moment. You're doing a good job. It's like I'm giving advice to an actual kid. Because it's something that you actually do. Because a lot of us, we probably would, like if your mate comes to you and asks you for advice, you'll be very, very nice to that person. Same scenario for yourself, you probably won't. You know, because it's just how, I don't know, just how the brain works, I guess.

Yeah, it's kind of like that. I just like remove myself and like I'm talking to a younger Stephen. Right or wrong? Dr Emily decides. Oh, look, I think that's such a, I mean, it's so beautiful to hear that. It feels, it's very moving. But I think, you know, he's absolutely talking about this notion that we have the potential and the capacity to bring on board what's called this healthy adult, the healthy adult that is able to...

regulate emotion, that is able to see things clearly, that is able to be flexible and compassionate, and that that healthy adult can come on board to soothe the younger part of you that is feeling so shameful. I think that, and it's also actually really nice the way that he puts it when, if someone else came to you for advice, because even if, even if now as an adult, you don't feel, you still feel in, in the mud and you still feel like you're not that much, you know, you're not through all the stuff you were dealing with as a child.

You're still able to give, to, to rise to the occasion for someone else. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I will say that, and I've spoken about compassion before, and so I probably encourage anyone who's interested to go and have a listen to that episode because it talks about this much more specifically. But what tends to happen with compassion, when you've not experienced much of it as a child and then someone gives it to you, it is not met with the same response that someone who has had a very compassionately held life has.

So what it will do is often reveal pain and actually there will be a painful response to the compassion. Okay. Because it's revealing what I've not had ever. And so in some ways it can give over to a grief to what I've never experienced or never had. It's called technically the term is backdraft and it's akin to the firefighting principles. I'm sure I've mentioned this before. So if there's a fire in a house and you open the door, the oxygen flames the fire.

So it's like when you open the door with compassion, it flames the pain that's already here. Now that's not necessarily wrong or bad. It's actually just revealing the pain. but it's not going to feel necessarily good. It's going to feel like you're not going to like it or want it and you might want to push it away. So it might sound like, Emily, you're having a really hard time. The internal dialogue might be something like, what are you talking about? Yeah. Like you're not having really time, like other people have got it worse than you.

So it kind of can activate that critic that is going to not allow you to take on the full feeling of loving kindness, for example. Does that make sense? Yeah. So that's why it's just not as simple to say, be kind to yourself. It's much more complicated, but there are some incredible resources that are available to help with developing like a compassionate mind and a compassionate lens to help that healthy adult come on board to soothe the part that's feeling so deeply defective or abandoned or shameful.

And I want to give a big nod here to. Paul Gilbert, who is the founder and developer of Compassion-Focused Therapy, and also to Kristin Neff and Christopher Germer, who are the founders and researchers around mindful self-compassion. They have great online programs, incredible research that they've conducted, and that at the bottom of everything, what we know is that compassion doesn't lead to laziness and indulgence and inaction.

Compassion actually leads to productivity, to creativity, to much, much better outcomes rather than that whip that we've got that is, you know, tending to attempt to drive us forward. We'll link to all of that stuff in the show notes. I also want to give a shout out to myself here. Hey, Josh. And our subscriber show because we recently, Bridge and I have started a new show called A Little More Questions.

And we talk within, this is within A Little More Imperfects on Patreon or Apple Podcasts. You can subscribe. Yeah. And in the first ever episode, we spoke to Maria Roberto and, And we went into compassion-focused therapy a little bit and talked about its benefits and how incredible it is and exactly what you're just saying. So there's more there on that if you want to hear it. Yeah, wonderful. I will also note that shame is such a huge, huge topic and there's so much that I haven't spoken about today and so maybe I might carry that over into another chat.

We'll do shame the sequel, shame resurfaced. Coming soon. Thank you, Em. Yeah, well done. I feel like, as you just said, it's a huge topic and I think you've done such a great job of trying to condense as much as you can helpful stuff into what is really a short space of time considering the topic. So thanks, Em. Yeah, my pleasure. Thanks, Em. Thank you for having me. Great to see you. Let's catch up again soon. Indeed. If you love this episode with Dr. Em, then there's a little bit more of it on our subscriber show, A Little More Imperfects.

Experiencing shame is not always a function of someone shaming us. Shame, particularly in adulthood, is often more likely an echo from the past. Which you can find at patreon.com slash theimperfects or in the Apple podcast app. And if you'd like to join our newsletter, you can do so at theimperfects.com.au. And while you're there, you'll be able to see the names and faces of all the incredible people who helped make this show. A show made on the lands of the Wurundjeri, Woiwurrung people. And we pay our respects to elders past and present. The Imperfects is not a licensed mental health service and is not a substitute for professional mental health advice, treatment or assessment.

The advice given in this episode is general in nature, but if you're struggling, please see a healthcare professional or call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Usman Khawaja - What Belonging Feels Like

    Nov 15, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    Who is Usman Khawaja outside of cricket? With a Paul Kelly song written about him and 88 Test cricket matches under his belt, Usman Khawaja is an Australian icon. But he hasn’t always felt like he belonged. 💌 To join...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Missy Higgins & Dr Emily - Burnt Out But Still Parenting

    Nov 8, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Do you feel the type of exhaustion that just doesn’t go away, even after a few good nights of sleep? Do you feel yourself becoming emotionally distant from your kids to protect yourself from huge emotions? Have you...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Beginning For Beginners with Hamish Blake & James van Cuylenburg

    Nov 1, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Have we ruined the art of being a beginner? 💌 To join our journaling club, with 9,900+ others, subscribe to my imperfect email - https://www.theimperfects.com.au/sign-up-to-our-newsletter/ With guest host Hamish Blake,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How To Audit Your Mental Load with Prof. Leah Ruppanner

    Oct 25, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    It’s time we talked about the mental load. Again. 💌 To join our journaling club, with 9,900+ others, subscribe to my imperfect email - https://www.theimperfects.com.au/sign-up-to-our-newsletter/ Consider this a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. “MND Took Everything” Matt Nable on Grief, Depression & What Really Matters

    Oct 18, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    In the end, Matt Nable wished his brother would give in. Motor neurone disease had taken everything, except his brother’s will to live. 💌 To join our journaling club, with 9,000+ others, subscribe to my imperfect email...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode