As a young teenager, Randy Schekman cycled to his local police station and told the duty officer he was running away from home. His mother kept borrowing the money he was saving for a microscope. Half a century later, that same microscope sits in the Nobel Museum in Stockholm. Randy Schekman won the 2013 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discovering how cells package and ship their molecules. That work now underpins how a third of the world’s insulin is made. He is a professor of molecular and cell biology at UC Berkeley, a former editor-in-chief of PNAS and the founding editor-in-chief of eLife. He has mentored two students who went on to win Nobel Prizes of their own. In this conversation with Méline Liu, he explains: ◼ The 1:20am phone call from Stockholm, and what his wife said before he’d even woken up ◼ Why he believes nature matters more than nurture in making a scientist ◼ The weekend he told his famously tough mentor, Arthur Kornberg, that he was going skiing ◼ How a discovery in yeast became a global supply of human insulin ◼ Why the popular idea of how exosomes work is wrong ◼ How stem cells could replace the brain cells lost in Parkinson’s disease ◼ Why we probably won’t live to 150, whatever billionaires spend ◼ The one trait that separates great scientists from merely smart ones 00:00 Intro 01:11 The night he won the Nobel Prize 04:43 “This is not a hoax” 07:30 Is the Nobel an artificial distinction? 08:37 Luck, mentors and being in the right place 09:33 How a science fair sparked a lifelong passion 13:03 Running away from home for a microscope 14:21 From the closet to the Nobel Museum 15:48 Nature vs nurture in curiosity 17:15 Learning from Arthur Kornberg 20:09 Why he never chased crowded fields 22:29 Do cells have a brain? 27:31 How yeast makes a third of the world’s insulin 28:42 Why understanding beats usefulness 30:03 The truth about exosomes 34:28 What stem cells really do 38:15 Stem cell treatments for Parkinson’s 39:01 How the brain works at a molecular level 41:01 Why Parkinson’s kills brain cells 43:14 Can we live to 150? 44:40 Where creativity in science comes from 46:37 Why most scientists aren’t creative 48:07 The trait all great students share 49:53 His advice for achieving at a high level 52:28 Outro More info on Randy here: https://vcresearch.berkeley.edu/faculty/randy-schekman
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_001.20 in the morning, the phone rings. I didn't even hear it, but my wife did. I heard her yell out, this is it. I raced the phone. My hand was trembling when I picked up the receiver. At that point, I think I said, oh my god, we have to be willing to take risks. We can do something different if you need that high level. Most people are unwilling to take risks. I didn't really care whether I was doing something different. I only cared about understanding that I took my bicycle and I rode directly to a local police station. And I told the duty officer that I was running away from home because my mother was stealing my money and I couldn't get the microscope.
SPEAKER_00Out of that, I got my hundred dollars, we drove to a local secondhand store where it was auctioned microscope, and that became my treasure. Aging is not a single thing that goes bad. It's a system of things that goes bad. Many billionaires want to live longer, so they're spending lots of money on research. But what we've discovered is that Hi Randy, welcome to the Humanware Project.
SPEAKER_01And it's such an honor to sit with you here today in UC Berkeley. On the day you know that you are winning a Nobel Prize, how do you feel? Can you bring us back to that day?
SPEAKER_00It was a complex day and and and uh time preceding that. I I won, you know, other significant prizes, some of which are, you know, many people who get the prize eventually go get the Nobel. One of them is called the Lasker Prize, which is the highest prize in biomedicine in the U.S. And Rothman and I shared that prize in uh 2002. And uh when you win that prize, if you win that prize, then people every October that comes around.
SPEAKER_00So you keep saying, well, it could be this year, uh, you know, years go by, well, why hasn't this happened already? You know, and so for Rothman, Rothman, it was uh 11 years before we won the Nobel. Um but you know, there are a lot of people who win the last group who never win the Nobel. So you know you know, it's j uh you just never know. But I I knew that I'd been nominated for the Nobel. Rothman and I've been nominated many times. Um and so uh you tend to you tend to know exactly when that moment could come, you you know, because they every year it's a particular time that they call you.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_00On a particular day, depending upon which category. So um I had just come back from a meeting in Germany where I won a you know the highest prize, the German Biochemical Society. And the people the the on a Friday night before the Monda before the Magic Monday, the guy who introduced me in front of this audience said, Well, so many of the people who won this German prize who go on to win the Nobel, and he looks at me, I'm s ready to get up and talk. He says, Well, let's see what happens on Monday.
SPEAKER_00So I I I I yelled out, No pressure, no pressure. So I came home. My wife at that point was uh deeply into dementia because she was suffering from Parkinson's disease. And so she was with a caregiver. She'd been with a caregiver for at that point a couple of years. And when I got home, it was late, and I I said, Well, okay, I'm I'm gonna go to bed, but I have to tell you there was this article online by a reporter in Stockholm entitled uh Five Discoveries That Have Not Yet won the Nobel.
SPEAKER_00So I I said, you know, this reporter hasn't, you know, it's it's not based on anything, it's just speculation. But Rossman and I were on this list, as was uh one of the ones who won the physics prize prize the next day. But I knew the next morning some you know some people were gonna be called. You know, I managed to get to sleep. And uh uh at 1.20 in the morning, the phone rings. And uh I didn't even hear it. I was I was so dead to the world. But my wife did, and in spite of her dementia, I heard her yell out, this is it.
SPEAKER_00Oh now when someone calls in the middle of the night, it's usually bad news. But you know, when I heard her yell out and then I heard the phone ring again, I I didn't think it was bad news. So I I raced the phone, and I'm sure my hand was trembling when I picked up the receiver. And then on the other line, there I heard a this wonderful Swedish accent. So um I at that point I think I said, Oh my god. My wife came to me and uh this guy announced that I'd won the prize and with whom I'd shared it, and congratulated me.
SPEAKER_00And then he said, uh, now you can be assured this is not a hoax. You can just imagine someone doing something like that too as a practical joke. But I knew it wasn't because I recognized this guy's voice because I'd worked on a committee with this guy before, so I knew who it was. So he says, Okay, now in an hour there'll be a press conference in Stockholm, and so you can't tell anybody now, until then. I said, But I can't call my parents. He said, Well, you can tell your family, but they have to be quiet for the next hour.
SPEAKER_00So I hugged my wife, we did a little dance, I sat down at the phone and I called my uh my dad. My mom had died years earlier of a brain tumor, but my dad had remarried. And so it was, you know, 1.30 in the morning. And his wife picks up the phone thinking, oh God, it's gonna be bad news. And so I said I'd won the prize. She sh screamed out, woke my father up. My father had for years in October, in early October, said, you know, when is this gonna happen?
SPEAKER_00I'm not gonna live forever. His expectation it was, you know, it was a done deal, it's just a question of when. So he was beside himself. I called my children, I I called uh my fellow laureate, Jim Rothman, uh, I called the press officer here on the Berkeley campus because he'd told me years before, if you get that call, I you have to call me before the press conference because I'm gonna mobilize the press here. So I called him up and he said, Well, I can't quite call the chancellor yet, it's still too early, but I'll get the press there.
SPEAKER_00And so within an hour, I had cars driving up on the street, you know, press officers from the news and from the campus to you know coordinate. And then uh and then the press conference happens, and then all hell breaks loose. The phone is ringing off the hook. There's a picture of me with a cell phone in one ear and the land life in the other. And uh so it was great. There was a great day. They took me on a, you know, the day they drove me to campus, they put me on a little jitney, and uh there's another video of me and the jitney going over to a press conference where I'm on there with my wife, and um I was looking at my cell phone.
SPEAKER_00My cell phone was buzzing off of my off uh, you know, constantly buzzing. There was a then there was an email from my high school biology teacher who uh was still alive and had kept up with me and even visited me here Berkeley some years ago, and he wrote that he was thrilled to live to see this day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I feel the system of Novell have been here for a while, and I'm so glad that they have such a curation for the award, um, because then as an audience we are able to learn deeply into um you know the the highlight of the year, which is a remarkable change.
SPEAKER_00I mean you have to know that there's so much really great stuff out there that is just as good that you just don't you just don't know about it. And uh there, I you know, I know people who are have made enormous, enormous important discoveries. And for whatever reason it's not selected. It's easy, uh it's kind of an artificial distinction. So, you know, if this had not happened to me, would I be bitter? I hope not. I don't think so.
SPEAKER_01Because I've enjoyed you have so much passion come out of your eyes when you talk about science.
SPEAKER_00You know, I've I I still enjoy the stuff, you know, irrespective of the Nobel.
SPEAKER_01But there has good time and bad times throughout your career. What do you think is your cornerstone to get you through all the good time and bad times?
SPEAKER_00Well, I've been yeah I've been really fortunate. I mean, unbelievably fortunate, blessed with um being at the here at the right time. I mean, I've had uh the benefit of great colleagues and you know unbelievably talented students. You know, um the first m the first year of my uh being an assistant professor here, I had a student who joined me that first year who was irreplaceable. Uh, you know, if I I you know I probably could have done it with some other people, but not nearly as well or as quickly with this one student.
SPEAKER_00Um just dumb luck. And I, you know, and I, you know, the the the biggest gift was being born and you know, in this country at that time and being educated in California when public education was advancing. I mean, uh these you know, one can't plan these things.
SPEAKER_01Bringing us back to your childhood. Do you ever want to become a scientist? And how does that all start?
SPEAKER_00So, first of all, I I grew up in a middle class family with uh high aspirations for the children. There were five children in my family, and uh, you know, the expectation was that we would all go to college and that we would go out and be in the workforce somehow. There were no scientists or physicians or educators in my family. My father was uh an engineer. Um but uh for some reason, and I don't know what happened, when I was about 11 years old, I suddenly found an interest in science.
SPEAKER_00That it started in two ways. One was when I was in what the it was called seventh grade in the U.S., uh about 11 years old, I went to a science fair project at my middle school and saw the kids in front of displays showing things that they had done of their own design, usually very primitive, uh, for the families and teachers to on display. And that kind of turned me on because I was never going to be an athlete or I was never gonna be a musician uh or or even a scholar.
SPEAKER_00But this seemed like it was something that I could do and that I could uh you know develop. So um around that time I had a I got a toy microscope, probably for a birthday, maybe 11 or 12. And um I must have seen something in a science class, uh video or whatever they used to show on maybe on television. And I uh went down to, I took a jar from my mother's collection from the kitchen, and I went down to a kind of an almost dry riverbed near my home in Southern California, and I picked up uh, I skimmed it off the top and picked up a jar of just scum on the top of the water.
SPEAKER_00And I, because I knew there'd be stuff in there that would be worth looking at in the microscope. So I took it home and I put a drop on a glass slide, and I just couldn't believe what I was seeing. Things that you can't see with your naked eye. Creatures crawling around and bumping into each other and twisting and turning, and you could see movement on the surface of one of them that allowed it to swim. And I mean, I just how does this happen? How does it work? You know, this of course happens in our body by the billions, by the trillions, but individual cells with their own life, how does this happen?
SPEAKER_00So I was um captivated as I spent hours looking at these things in this microscope. One evening to dinner, I um expressed uh my fascination. My my father thought I was imagining things. This couldn't possibly be. So I remember being a little put off by that comment of his, and I decided maybe the problem was this was a toy microscope. I needed a real, a real microscope. So I I decided I was gonna save my earnings. I used to babysit, mow lawns, babysit, uh, deliver newspapers, you know.
SPEAKER_00Uh so I collected some money, and I would c keep all the money in an envelope in the closet in my bedroom, uh, with the goal of building up to$100, which in 1962 was a lot of money. And uh, but my mother kept borrowing the money from this envelope, and I I could never quite get to the$100 that I wanted. So um I don't remember arguing with her about this, but I do remember one Saturday morning I was mowing a neighbor's lawn as part of my chore one of my chores, and I was worked myself up into a frenzy.
SPEAKER_00I was so upset that I took my bicycle and I rode directly to a local police station. Oh, okay. And I told the duty officer that I was running away from home because my mother was stealing my money and I couldn't get my microscope. So they they called my father in to the police station and he went into the captain's office and they closed the door, and I'm sure they had a good laugh over this. And out he came. He was, of course, very upset with me. But um, out of that, I got my$100. We drove to a local second-hand store, a pawn shop, and I remember seeing in the front window there was a Boschenlaum student professional microscope, and that was it,$100.
SPEAKER_00So I took it home, and that became my treasure for the next five, six years. Every year, I would uh use the microscope to look at microorganisms or blood cells, uh, whatever I could see, and did an annual science fair project and got lots of rewards and you know, and recognition, and you know, that became my thing. I was uh I was the what what would be called in the US the science nerd in my in my high school class.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you still have it.
SPEAKER_00Well, what happened was, you know, many decades later, um when I had my own family here near Berkeley, uh my my dad shipped the microscope back up to me. And um regrettably, neither of my children ever showed an interest in science. They played around with the microscope and but they didn't destroy it. And then it sat in a closet collecting dust until um I learned that it won the Nobel Prize. And uh about a month after that, every year they send out a note from the Nobel Museum in Stockholm asking each laureate to have some piece of equipment or some reflection of their discovery.
SPEAKER_00And what I had in my laboratory didn't seem all that interesting, but that microscope was sitting collecting dust. So I dusted it off and I sent it to Stockholm, and it's now still on display, together with a little caption in English and in Swedish about how I had to run away from home to begin my career in science, and I'm told it's one of the most popular exhibits there in the Nobel Museum.
SPEAKER_01Because it's quite fascinating that you have no family members that are used to be scientists. So, what do you think is triggers that kind of, you know, core character into inside of yourself and have that curiosity?
SPEAKER_00You know, I've I've wondered that for my entire life. You know, having raised two children who are in the same family with the same values, who turned out completely differently, I think it's some it's nature, it's much less than nurture. There was something intrinsic in me from my genes, some combination of genes from my mother and father that came together in this unpredictable way that gave me this passion. And I, you know, I can't I can't I I can't explain it any other way.
SPEAKER_00People come to me and they show me pictures of their childhood microscope. But they, you know, most of them who had my interest when they got to university, they decided the best outlet for this was to become a physician. That was my interest too when I started university. I thought, you know, in the U.S., first you go to university for four years, and then if you want, you go into a professional school such as a medical school. And when I started in my first year in university, it was absolutely with the intention of going, eventually going to medical school.
SPEAKER_00And I think most kids who had that interest, that kind of science-y interest, most of them probably choose a profession like that, where, you know, probably they're more confident that they would actually have some comfort in their life and where their parents feel that they will, you know, be successful in their eyes. And uh, you know, when I told my parents before university that I wanted to do in medical school, they were, of course, very proud. First son of a Jewish family, you know, what what could be better?
SPEAKER_00And then when I came home after my first year in university and said, no, I want to be a scientist, they uh they were a little taken aback, but they got over it.
SPEAKER_01Throughout your career, what triggers you like to study East and can you bring us to the original story?
SPEAKER_00I attribute a lot of the way that I've gone forward to the uh influence of the mentors that I had at every step in my career. I was very fortunate, even in high school. I had a great science teacher. And uh when I got to university, um I got to work in a research lab, you know, in my first year, and that's really what changed my life. And then I had a mentor there at UCLA who was a beginning uh faculty member himself, and he took me under wing and showed me how to do things. And and uh then I went to I had the I did well enough that I got admitted to the Stanford Biochemistry Department for my PhD, where I was had focused on continuing to study what I had learned in university.
SPEAKER_00And I picked very specifically the best biochemist in the world studying this problem. His name is Arthur Kornberg. He had won the Nobel Prize himself, actually, at a quite a young age. And he was a master uh tactician. He he had a vision of how to solve a complicated problem. He was a very specific, focused image of how to solve a complicated problem using the tools of biochemistry. And so I learned from a master not only how to do things, but how to think about doing things.
SPEAKER_00And uh he was relentless, absolutely relentless, and he could be really tough. He was very demanding, the highest standards possible. It was impossible to satisfy him because nothing was ever good enough. And um I rem- I mean I worked hard. I worked hard. And uh I remember one uh one Friday afternoon, I'd done an experiment, I don't remember which one it was, but it was it was a really terrific result. And uh I was standing in the door to his office and with a friend of mine who was a postdoc.
SPEAKER_00And uh the three of us were looking at the piece of data, it was on a graph paper, this was a long time ago. And uh the excitement was now, what's the next experiment? You know, what will you do next to take this next to the next step? And it was Friday, remember it was Friday afternoon, and and Kornberg said, Well, when are we gonna know the results of the next experiment? Now, in his mind, that would be you know tonight or tomorrow. And I said, Well, maybe next Tuesday. Tuesday. What's wrong with tomorrow?
SPEAKER_00And I said, Well, Bill, my friend, and our wives and I uh and I are going skiing this weekend. And he looked at me with an ever so slight smile. He said, What am I running around here? Some kind of a country club?
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_00So it was he was like that all the time. Uh usually he was just more brutal than that. I mean, because there was never, there was less often a smile. Aside from that sort of humor, he was deadly serious. Deadly serious. But um, near the end of my PhD, uh, as things work very well, um uh I had the prospect of continuing in that broad area of nucleic acids, which was growing with excitement. It was just the advent of the recombinant DNA revolution where it became possible to isolate individual genes.
SPEAKER_00So there was enormous growth potential in that field. But I never enjoyed doing something that I knew other people were doing. I always wanted to do my own thing. And I didn't enjoy the idea of competing with someone else in another laboratory who was gonna, you know, beat me by a few weeks to a publication. I just didn't, I just seemed like an enormous waste of energy. So I did I decided at that point that I had to move into a new area, an area in by in in cell biology that um uh uh had a good foundation, but did not yet have a molecular understanding.
SPEAKER_00So I went to San Diego after my PhD to postdoc. And just by pure coincidence, uh George Pilates, this famous biologist, won the Nobel Prize just as I arrived. Um, but he was in New York. Uh but he that a meeting of the American Society for Cell Biology was convened in San Diego just months after I started. And I went to this meeting, and Pilates had come almost right from Stockholm to give a version of his Nobel lecture at this meeting.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, it was a beautiful lecture to an extraordinarily appreciative audience of classical cell biologists. But in looking and at what he had done and thinking about it over the course of the next few years, it became clear that here was an area about which nothing at a molecular level was really understood. No genes, no. Proteins, no specific lipids, were known to be involved. And so I thought, okay, here's an opportunity. And you know, and an opportunity where I knew I had the right skills to take it to the next step.
SPEAKER_00And that's what I started when I came here now, almost precisely 50 years ago.
SPEAKER_01And uh when we think about, you know, how our cells function inside of our our body, I I find it's quite incredible to think cells have no brain.
SPEAKER_00Um but how they have a brain, it's just not the same as ours. They have a va a fabulous blueprint called the genome, where all the genes are there and they get turned on and off by signals that are built into the structure of the genome. Um now you there's an experiment, a really cool experiment, where you can take a cell and pluck out the the nucleus so there's no more genome. And the cell will continue to operate for a while. Uh making things and building things for a while, not not for very long, but because it's everything's been set in motion by the blueprint in the genome.
SPEAKER_01And uh how can we keep our cells functioning in such an order and don't, you know, break or have interruptions? Is there anything you can do to help?
SPEAKER_00Well, there are there are all kinds of repair mechanisms that operate in the cell and operate in the body. That again is a process of evolution. Um this all started three and a half billion years ago on Earth with bacteria or bacteria prokaryotes, single-celled organisms, that somehow the molecules came together to make a self-perpetuating structure, which that is still a mystery. It is still a very one of the most difficult problems in biology is to do experiments of some sort or devise theories that to explain the origin of life.
SPEAKER_00That's really tough. There are some scientists who are struggling with that over many years. But once life started, once it started, then the rule of evolution, which, you know, I think if there's life elsewhere in the universe, that will fundamentally obey the same idea of evolution. I mean, the the the consequence of that evolution elsewhere in the universe will be very different than what it is on Earth. But the same rules will apply. Once an organism is established, if if it can live, it has to do that by dividing.
SPEAKER_00And and there will be pressure, evolutionary pressure in the niche in which an organism arises that uh fosters that or brings it to an end. And if it's fostered and develops, then it will continue to evolve in unpredictable ways, based on forces of the environment that uh ensure that evolution selects those organisms fittest for survival. So what Darwin described, you know, I mean I'll I'll assert this without any evidence, what Darwin described, I believe, will play out elsewhere in the universe.
SPEAKER_00And so two billion years ago, life evolved to a point where we have cells now where the chromosomes are housed in a nucleus inside the cell. So that's a fundamental change between a single-celled organism that has a chromosome to having a cell with chromosomes that are inside of a nucleus. So that's a transition between prokaryotes or bacteria and eukaryotes, like yeast. And yeast, although it's a microorganism, is very similar to us.
SPEAKER_00And so when we discovered the genes that in yeast cells that operate this process, um I was pretty sure that it would be similar to human, the human process, because if you look at the yeast cell, it uses the same kind of steps along the way. And sure enough, when we obtained the genes, these genes that we had discovered, that at first they didn't look like anything when we sequenced the genes, didn't look like anything because the databases were very small. But within a few years the human genome was sequenced, and there they were, the same, virtually the same genes in the human genome.
SPEAKER_00And so uh at the time, which was still fairly early in my career here, the biotechnology industry was emerging in the Bay Area, and I helped to, uh I consulted for a local company that wanted to use yeast as a platform to manufacture uh clinically important proteins like insulin. And so um I didn't do this for them, but I uh helped them take the gene for human insulin, which others had cloned, and which was being used by another company called Genentech to make insulin in bacteria.
SPEAKER_00But bacteria operate very differently than eukaryotes. And so the company that I consulted for took the gene for human insulin, put it in the yeast cells, and they were able to basically trick the yeast cells into manufacturing and exporting, by this process of secretion, human insulin into the growth medium. And so now one-third of the world's supply of human recombinant insulin is made in giant fermentation vats where yeast cells are bubbling away, secreting insulin into the growth medium, which can be isolated and used to treat diabetics.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's a very incredible study that it starts from you finding these um pathways for the cells to how they work, and then to today, we actually have a lot of supplies of insulin for the people who have diabetes. So could you help us to understand for all the award being given to the Nobel Lloyd Hunt why that is matters for our life today? Because it seems like it's a very deep science and it's away from our everyday life. But what are the links?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, this is a this is always a um uh a source for me of of inspiration and interest in in educating people. Because it's not obvious. I mean, most people, you know, when I tell them, even my parents, you know, they didn't they didn't know what the hell I was doing, you know, what what what good was it? And it was only when I started consulting for a biotech company that my father said, Oh, I see now you're doing something useful. You know, uh to be honest with you, I didn't really care at first that I whether I was doing something useful, in the sense that it would be useful in medicine.
SPEAKER_00That that did not particularly interest me. Maybe it should have, but it didn't. Um I only cared about understanding how a cell works. Because I knew that if you understand how a cell works, people will build on that and uh make additional discoveries that will inevitably be a benefit. And and uh the application in my case was actually very quick. I mean, within a few years it was practical, practically useful. But you look at what Einstein did or what the early nuclear physicists did in in the early 20th century, you know, when did that become useful?
SPEAKER_00Not for almost, you know, a hundred years. The idea of quantum physics. Who who thought that would be of you of use anyway? But absolutely it's essential to our modern life.
SPEAKER_01And uh, how did you see like those original studies and turn into a commercial use, right? Right now we hear about the words exosome and uh insulin is such an important thing people use nowadays, either in longevity drugs or in um cosmetic. So could you tell us what are those?
SPEAKER_00Are those a buzzword or those are something that actually so my work now has changed, and and in the recent dozen or so years I started to work on uh a subject called extracellular vesicles, of which some of them are are actual are called exosomes? And uh some subset of them, they all carry protein molecules, but some of them also carry small pieces of RNA. And this became very interesting to me uh a little over a dozen years ago with a new graduate student who joined the group.
SPEAKER_00How do they get these RNA molecules? What could these RNA molecules be doing? Are these things delivering their cargo to other cells to inform processes in other cells? So this has captivated me, and I've been working on it again from a purely basic point of view. But there is a lot of talk about the application of these things, and it's easy to think about how you could apply them. But what we've discovered is that what most people think about how these exosomes may communicate with other cells is wrong.
SPEAKER_00Most people think that these things carry molecules into other cells, and what's inside the vesicle is dumped into the interior of a target cell. That would be cargo transfer from one cell to the next. And we find that happens very, very inefficiently. Okay, so here's the problem. Viruses like HIV or SARS, many viruses, are little vesicles with a membrane that has an infectious nucleic acid.
SPEAKER_00And the way those things deliver the viral nucleic acid for infection requires that the virus has in its shell a protein that allows membranes to fuse, to merge with one another, a fusion protein. And so some of these fusion proteins are essential for the viral infection. And drugs against SARS and antibodies against SARS actually inactivate the protein that allows this pro to this membrane to fuse.
SPEAKER_00And when it fuses, when a virus fuses, let's say, at the cell surface, the membrane that surrounds the virus merges with the surface membrane of the cell, and what's inside the virus is then dumped on the other side of the membrane into the cell. That's how it delivers things. But it turns out that these exosomes do not have such a fusogen. And many experiments, not only ours, have shown that they just don't deliver anything.
SPEAKER_01Then what they do.
SPEAKER_00Well, okay. There are two things. One that we've proposed is that they are a means of maintaining cellular homeostasis, that is, keeping the cells stable and healthy. And so conditions we found, conditions that damage the surface membrane, causing holes in it or uh small ruptures or pores, uh, are accompanied by the massive secretion of these vesicles.
SPEAKER_00And they are being secreted as part of a repair mechanism to repair the damage. And and in general, cells that are full of junk too get rid of them by dumping stuff outside the cell, where there are professional cells that go and scavenge. So we we think that these vesicles are largely an effort of the cell to maintain its equilibrium. Okay, now it's also possible, and I believe likely, that some of these vesicles can interact with other cells not by fusion, but by binding on the on the outside of a cell and triggering some event, like a hormone does, only this is a now a more complicated hormone.
SPEAKER_00It's a it's a particle. And so I'm sure that's true. So there so these things do influence communication, and we're looking to study examples of this in my lab now. But they don't deliver cargo. So I'm I have to say I'm rather unpopular in this field when I give talks now because I I sort of uh but that that's fine. At this point in my life, I can get away with that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What about stem cell, right? What does stem cell doing in our body?
SPEAKER_00There are broadly two categories of stem cells. There are cells in our body that are called adult stem cells. Most tissues have a reservoir of adult stem cells which can be called on for replenishment of cells that have died. In parts of the brain, there's some replenishment of that sort, but many of the cells in our brain, you know, have are not replaceable. They, you know, they if they die like they do in in a subset of of these cells in the brains of Parkinson patients, if they die, you know, they're dead and they're not replaced.
SPEAKER_00But other parts of the brain and other parts of the body have adult stem cells that can be a reservoir for replenishment. Uh but those cells are already fairly selective. That is, they only replenish that tissue. They can't do so universally for other tissues. That's a limitation of adult stem cells. But those that can be very useful in medicine. Now then there's a very special reservoir of what are referred to as pluripotent stem cells, embryonic stem cells.
SPEAKER_00When an embryo is created by fertilization, in the pre-implantation stage, that is, before the, it's called a blastocyst, before it implants on the uterine wall, it has a series of cells on the surface that will eventually give rise to the placenta. And then inside, inside this hollow sphere, there's a cluster of cells called the inner cell mass. And among those cells are pluripotent stem cells, which now it's been possible to isolate.
SPEAKER_00And human pluripotent stem cells from early embryos were only, you know, first cultured in the laboratory, maybe now 25, 30 years ago. Um but these cells, if you can grow them in the laboratory, you can f by different tricks, you can get them to go in many different directions. They can become muscle cells, they can become nerve cells, they can become fat cells, the any of the hundreds of different cell types, by nourishing them with different hormone regimens, you can you can encourage them to to grow and then mature, differentiate into a fixed determined state.
SPEAKER_00So it's possible to take embryonic stem cells and nurture them in the laboratory so that they turn into nerve cells that produce and secrete this um chemical neurotransmitter called dopamine, which is um there are many different tissues in the body that produce dopamine. Dopamine does many different functions in nerve cell communication. But in a region of the midbrain called the substantia nigra, a population of some tens of thousands of these dopaminergic neurons are there to help organize uh and control movement and executive function.
SPEAKER_00And these cells are what are vulnerable in patients who have Parkinson's disease. And as they die more rapidly than they do in a normal person, these patients lose their ability to control movement and many other things go bad. And it's now possible to take embryonic stem cells in the laboratory and to nurture them in cell culture to make human dopamergic neurons and then to implant them back into that region of human brains.
SPEAKER_00And there's some promise that these things will form the right connections, replace the dead cells, and this will become a treatment for Parkinson's disease.
SPEAKER_01How far are we to ask early days?
SPEAKER_00There are about a half a dozen companies around the world that are doing this. One company that I know is called Blue Rock in New York, and they uh enrolled about 12 patients who were willing to be subjected to this treatment. And the results were encouraging. And they've been, that was in what is called clinically a phase one trial, which is just it's not really to prove that it works, it's just to prove that it's safe. It was not only safe, but there was some evidence of efficacy, some of you know, restoration of function.
SPEAKER_00So this company was authorized to move right into phase three, which is a big jump.
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_00Where they now are going to try to enroll a few hundred patients. You know, fingers crossed, we'll see.
SPEAKER_01When we think about how our cells function in our body, and then also how our brain, how our thoughts, how is our mind and body aligned?
SPEAKER_00Well, the nervous system, of course, that's the great frontier now. And if I were starting over again, I would, that was, I don't know what exactly I do, but I choose to study how, at some level, how the brain works. And each nerve cell touches or nearly touches up to a million other nerve cells, the cells that are responsible for Parkinson's disease, these dopamergic neurons. And what's amazing about these dopamergic neurons is they have a forest of nerve terminals, up to a million, making contact with a million other cells.
SPEAKER_00So if you look at the brain at that level of complexity, it's, I mean, it's hard to fathom. Trillions, trillions of different nerve connections operating in unique pathways and patterns that give rise to everything about us. You know, I you know I argue with my brother, who's uh who was a high school principal. I, you know, to me, everything in life will ultimately be explained by chemistry and physics. And and our the way our brain functions controls everything about us, and that can all eventually be understood by molecular interactions.
SPEAKER_00By the pattern by it in the pattern by which a nerve terminal communicates with another cell, which involves this process that that Rothman and I helped elaborate, the mechanism. It's a little vesicle that carries a chemical neurotransmitter that goes up to the nerve terminal, and by this process of membrane fusion, the neurotransmitter is excreted outside the cell and it touches other cells and turns on other cells. Everything about us, talking as we are now, acting, looking, whatever, is dictated by a pattern of that very tightly controlled membrane fusion event that pulses little bits of neurotransmitter between cells.
SPEAKER_01Well, what happened when people have Parkinson disease for like what those cells are doing?
SPEAKER_00Well, they die. Um the the dopamergic neurons die more rapidly than normal, although those cells in us are vulnerable. I mean, they're they're they're turned on all in a million different connections. The lights are always on for a dopinergic neuron. So they're vulnerable. Any little perturbation can send them down a death spiral. And and in Parkinson's disease, for many different reasons, those cells are somewhat more vulnerable than they are in a normal patient.
SPEAKER_00And there are many different reasons for that vulnerability. There are genetic reasons, about 10 to 15 percent of patients with PD have mutations that are responsible for their progressive death. But most Parkinson patients are not of genetic origin. It's some what it's called sporadic or idiopathic unknown origin, which almost certainly is exposure to some environmental toxin. Well, there are certain toxins that are used in the in the food industry or in the chemical industry that are known.
SPEAKER_00Uh, toxins that people who work with these things in industry have a much higher rate of Parkinson's disease. And there may be, through exposure even at a lower level over a lifetime, there may be those influences that cause Parkinson's to be initiated and to progress because of this, you know, tox toxic influence.
SPEAKER_01So in you know, a person's life, what will be able to help, in your opinion, like for them to better preserve their brain cells?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's the same, it's it's the same thing as just keep you know, keeping your cell, your body and mind uh healthy and safe. You know, uh good eating habits, good exercise, good sleep, these things all contribute to that. But what what it is that you know makes some people more talented or passionate or intelligent or or you know strong, you know, those are the differences that make life interesting.
SPEAKER_01According to you, what is aging? Like, will we be able to leave, let's say, 150 years old?
SPEAKER_00No, that's I don't think so. Um aging is not a single thing that goes bad. It's a systems thing that goes bad. Many different systems function and uh may decay at a certain point as we grow older. You know, the the natural limit appears to be something like 120 years. There are very few people who've lived beyond that. You know, you know, in 50 years will there be more people who live beyond that? I'm not so sure. You know, there are a lot of people, particularly these billionaires, who want to live longer.
SPEAKER_00And they're so they're spending lots of money on research on aging. Uh but you know, there's not going to be one thing. I think we are uh each of us somewhat genetically programmed for longevity. Um, my father lived in 93, but my mother died in Age 69 of a brain tumor. So, you know, it's a mixed uh mixed bag for me. I think as we were talking earlier, I you know, uh to me, the most important thing is to live a natural, naturally long life as healthy as possible and to not suffer for years.
SPEAKER_00Uh to me, that's the worst thing is I wouldn't want to live to be 100 if the last 10 years of my life was just misery. You know, what good is that?
SPEAKER_01Where does your creativity come from? Like do you read? Is that coming from colleagues or come from mentors?
SPEAKER_00Come from it comes in anywhere. You know, I can be sitting in the in the middle of someone giving a talk on something else and just be bored and just start daydreaming. Yeah. You know, so I like to picture in my my mind's eye what you know what something looks like. You know, I have a visual impression of something in a cell and how how it could work. And I'm always turning it over in my mind to think how one could test an idea that I have. Or I, you know, if we have weekly presentations of members of my group, I'm always thinking when they're doing, when they're describing experiments, what could they do better?
SPEAKER_00What could they do different? If they're having a problem, you know, how to improve. And it never ends. So I'm likely to retire in a few years because I'm now 77. And my my partner, who's also a colleague here, um, she's younger, but we'll probably synchronize our retirement. We're both worried about what we'll do when we don't have a laboratory to keep us mentally engaged. Well, we'll we'll we'll find other things. But um I love that process.
SPEAKER_00And I, you know, I love looking at data, thinking about it, and seeing what's wrong. We have also a weekly journal club where a member of my team will pick a paper out of the literature. We love picking it apart. There usually something wrong with it. Something, very often there's something fatally wrong with it. We love to pick it apart. That's that's how science works. It's not by proving something, it's by disproving something. That's usually the way it works. And uh it's not to be cruel, it's to be uh constructive and uh you know think clearly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think the more understanding about science, about how many breakthroughs has been made, it's actually one of the most creative jobs out there. Could you give us an example why scientists have to be creative?
SPEAKER_00Well, they don't have to be. Most are not.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00If people are just turning the crank, I tell my my students and postdocs when they leave the lab to strike off in a new direction and don't just continue. Even if they've done well, they should do something different. They should go from my lab to a postdoc and learn something different. And then when they go to their own lab, they should use their imagination. And I've had several students who've done spectacularly well. Uh I have had two former PhD students who won the Nobel Prize on their own work. Most recently, my my you know, one of my best students is a guy named David Baker.
SPEAKER_00He won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry now two years ago for um doing things that he didn't do in my lab at all. Completely different. Completely different. He is enormously ambitious and creative. He did he do he was involved in designing computer algorithms that could predict how proteins fold. And he shared the Nobel Prize for his his development of tools to design proteins that have never existed on Earth before, designed to pr to do unique functions.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, incredibly challenging. And but, you know, the guy was he's a genius. And uh he, you know, he would you you could you you know he would he would hate doing something that someone else is doing.
SPEAKER_01Working around a lot of great mind and being a great mind yourself, where did you see a pattern or personality trait?
SPEAKER_00I don't have the ability to see in advance whether someone's gonna turn out to be great. I mean, i in in the in the life sciences in the US, now generally around the world, when new PhD students come in, they usually spend uh some time in in several different laboratories to see if they're a good fit for that laboratory. And you know, it's an opportunity to see some of the how they interact, but uh, you know, I don't necessarily know how they're gonna be until they get into the lab and I see how they think. And then there's one thing that I found among the best students that I've had, and that is uh they have an instinct to know what to do next without my telling them.
SPEAKER_00That's because they're thinking about their problem, thinking constructively or you know, critically, and they think creatively, and they come up with an idea, and then they just go and do it. And they will, when it works, they'll come and tell me, and I'm really excited. Sometimes they have this great idea and then they come and they tell me first, and I say, you know, go for it. Uh, but they have the idea first. That's the important thing. Now, most of my students aren't that way.
SPEAKER_00Most of them need to come to me for the ideas or to, you know, for them to and to for me to put them through a process of thinking about the idea. And these are people who may be very smart, and they may end up being effective, but they will not be the best.
SPEAKER_01So critical thinking.
SPEAKER_00Yes, critical and creative thinking. And I've had, you know, a a small number of people who are that good.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01And if you could give our audience one other voice in general in pursue their truth, what that other voice will be.
SPEAKER_00And so it's a combination of being good at something and having passion for that. I mean, passion isn't enough. And being good isn't enough. You have to have a drive and skill and intelligence. And so, you know, if you're fortunate to have a confluence of those gifts, then it's important to really push yourself forward and to be focused and and quite deliberate in pursuing a goal.
SPEAKER_00So uh you know, in in experimental science and probably another aspect, you know, all aspects of creative endeavor, um you have to be willing to take risks if you're gonna make something, if you're gonna do something different, achieve at a high level. And most people are too conservative. Most people are unwilling to take risks. So I have here at Berkeley, we have lots of really bright kids who are, you know, good test takers and can memorize lots of things.
SPEAKER_00Many of them want to go into medicine, uh, which is great, um, because they can it's really complicated the human body's really complicated, so if they can learn lots of things, but but they won't enjoy experimental science because most of the time things don't work. And uh you so you have to be able to put up with a lot of uh disappointment. And uh the way to do that in my mind is to uh when you start have a have a picture in mind of exactly what you want to achieve.
SPEAKER_00Not what you want to discover, but what how what you want to achieve in terms of an understanding. And then how you know, and then you have to think, how am I going to do this? What are the tools that I need to do this? And then once once that comes together, then you just do it. And and um don't allow yourself to be distracted. You know, smart people, unfortunately, also also have lots of different ideas, and they can be distracted by that. I've seen great scientists who just dissipate their energy doing lots of different things.
SPEAKER_00And so they the the the the depth of understanding that they can achieve is diminished. So focus. This is something that I learned from this guy, Kornberg, with whom I studied for my PhD. Focus.
SPEAKER_01Focus.
SPEAKER_00Terribly important.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Randy, for our time today.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for watching this new episode of Humanware Project. So that we can bring out more amazing content like this one to you. Please like and subscribe. Your support means the world to us.
At 28, Richard Branson bought an island he couldn’t afford. Decades later, it is still his home, and the place where he lives by the principles that built the Virgin Group. In this episode, Méline returns to Necker...
Most microscopes have a limit to what they can show us. Eric Betzig helped to break that limit, and won a Nobel Prize in the process. In this episode, Méline goes behind the scenes at Eric’s lab at UC Berkeley. Eric is...
Eric Betzig once walked away from science altogether. Years later, he and his best friend put $25,000 each of their own money into building a microscope on a living room floor, and it won him the Nobel Prize. In this...
What if some of the best health and longevity secrets are not found in laboratories or supplements, but growing on trees right in front of us? In this episode, Méline travels to Hainan, China’s tropical island, with her...
At Golden Door, one of America’s best-known health retreats, guests are served a light tomato broth in the middle of the day, after a morning of hard work and before lunch at one o’clock. It looks simple, but there is a...