Jose, Yan, Duncan and Ceteris discuss the recent approval of the Bitcoin ETF and its impact on the cryptocurrency market. The conversation then shifts to the evaluation of different blockchain ecosystems, including Solana and Ethereum, and the importance of applications in driving adoption. We also discuss the fragmentation of attention in Ethereum's roll-up ecosystem and the need for new innovations in the DeFi space. The conversation covers topics such as Solana Sanctum and Liquidity Staking Tokens (LSTs), desired innovations in DeFi, copy trading and social features in DeFi, and the future of crypto gaming. Disclosures: Nothing said on The Hivemind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. The podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Jose, Yan, Duncan, Ceteris, and our guests may advise or hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed. Delphi's transparency page can be viewed here. Get a 20% discount on a premium Delphi PRO or PRO+ for listening to this episode! Follow the links below or use the codes on checkout: 20% off Delphi PRO annual Code: PODCASTPRO Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastpro 20% off Delphi PRO+ annual Code: PODCASTTEAMS Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastteams Follow Delphi Digital Website: https://members.delphidigital.io/home Twitter: https://twitter.com/Delphi_Digital YouTube: https://youtube.com/@Delphi_Digital
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Nothing said on the hive mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions, not financial advice. Hey everybody, uh my name is Jose Masedu, and welcome to the Hive Mind Podcast. The goal of the podcast is to provide an inside look into what we like to call Delphi Hive Mind, bringing together some of our brightest minds from each of the divisions to share insights, alpha, and ship posts.
SPEAKER_03Today with us as always, we have Cederis Parabus from Research, who focuses on infra and DeFi. We have Jan, who's the managing partner at Delphi Ventures, and Ventures Associate Duncan, also known as Flood Capital. I lead Delphi Labs, our protocol RD arm focused on incubating and accelerating new web 3 primitives. We're coming to you on ETF Day. So to start off with, just like round the go round the table and some reactions to ETF Day.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean we've already gone what over 2 billion volume. Um we hit over 49k, we're back at like 48 now. But I mean Bitcoin went from 26k was where the Cointelegraph intern started the run, right? And we went from 26k to 45 in like three months, and that even still looks like it wasn't enough for what it's doing today. So there's been nothing people, there's been nothing bearish about this whole thing.
SPEAKER_04Um it's basically been pretty straightforward. Like now advisors can buy Bitcoin for their clients, they might allocate like one, two percent. Um I just have never really seen the bear angle for it. So yeah, now everyone, I guess, is gonna we'll see how these these flows do first few days, and then everyone I'm assuming is just gonna start talking about the ETH one now. But I mean at the same time, it'd be nice. I do feel kind of fatigued by all the ETF talk because at the end of the day, like okay, this is good, it legitimizes the industry more, especially in the US.
SPEAKER_04Um, de-risks it from like some Orwellian complete ban or something. But um, I kind of want to get back to like talking about DA value accrual and like you know, execution layers and all that kind of stuff. So yeah, hopefully we're not just talking about the ETT the ETF for the next like five months.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Pretty pretty epic just uh in terms of how crypto markets work for the ETH BTC bottom to come in basically on the approval, um, which was telegraphed to some extent in the sense that I think it was uh a more and more consensus take, especially as you see people on on kind of CT and and just others in chats, but um it's hard to kind of extrapolate you know a few loud people uh as the as the exposure of of everyone else.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, it'll be interesting to see how much of a variety there is, but it definitely seems like there's just uh a natural kind of catch up trade internally. I don't I don't think you'll see too much. I don't think it's gonna be too much external capital necessarily flowing into ETH, but I think you'll see it's it's more of a an in within crypto rotation.
SPEAKER_01Um that that I feel like that one was a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy. Like everyone was saying as soon as the BDCTF goes, like, then you just buy ETH, and then like people are like, oh, that's right, they're right, like the market's putting in the bottom here, and then just everyone just piles in.
SPEAKER_03But it was also like peak ETH VUD, right? Like on the at least on my timeline, it was just like ETH has no narrative, it's you know, it's it's it's stuck between yeah, I don't know. I feel I feel like it was pretty telegraphed in in a bunch of ways.
SPEAKER_02It was also in another person sold their ETH, right? I think I think you had some people that moved into Sol, but everyone was still sitting in ETH just kind of quietly. I I don't think you had like ETH capitulation by any means.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, not at all. Everybody, everybody owns ETH. Um I own ETH or ETH. Yeah, because you're anything over yeah, you just you're in the weeds. Um what was I gonna say? Um well the other thing too is like it was also another fake, not a fake approval, but like a jump of the gun approval that caused the ETH rotation, so it's exactly what happened.
SPEAKER_01So what the coin was that happened?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Jeez. Yeah, but it also threw the Coin Telegraph uh situation replayed. Yeah, yeah. Pretty funny.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I don't know if you guys read the opinions, but it was also like three out of five of the of the chairman passed it, and like two of them dissented and wrote some pretty scathing things. Um, like we're definitely not merit-based, like we don't think about the merits of of any of the of this stuff, but this is only used for crime, money laundering, child trafficking, you know, like all this stuff. And like linking to like their references were like these articles that have been disproved like a million times. I don't know. Pretty wild to see like the industry had to be forced by the courts into doing this, and it was pretty clear by the the opinions they wrote that they're not happy about it.
SPEAKER_03And I think ETH's gonna have gonna have a hard time for that reason.
SPEAKER_04I mean, when did when the grayscale thing happened in the summer? Like, people were not taking that seriously enough. Like, everyone was kind of saying, Oh, this doesn't mean an ETF is approved, all this, they can still go back, they can re-challenge them accord, all this stuff. It's like that was like a massive pivot. Like, if that didn't happen, who knows? Like, honestly, we're there's no way we we probably don't have an ETF right now.
SPEAKER_01Um I think it's in the Yeah, but what would have happened?
SPEAKER_02Like, Gensler was the tie-breaking vote. He he was the least dissenting of the of like the two no's were heavily dissenting. He threw in his jab at the end, where it's like mostly speculative and a little bit for the other reasons you listed. Yeah, and so like what would have happened had he voted no?
SPEAKER_04Well, yeah, they're like for for yesterday, yeah. There's I don't think he could have voted no.
SPEAKER_01Um I have no idea.
SPEAKER_04I think, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes, but we're not happy about it.
SPEAKER_04It's funny how it's like a three of five multisig that ends up getting it through, though.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01I feel like we probably put in uh like a top on BDC soon-ish. Not on alt, but like on B like in the next like week or so. I feel like everyone's way too excited. The market, like this was so telegraphed to the market and anticipated. Unless you really do just have like this massive wall of money that was refusing to allocate before there was an ETF. Like, I'm I feel like you probably put in some sort of thing.
SPEAKER_04Okay, but it was like it was uh it was literally illegal for RAs to like buy their clients BTC.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but like I I feel like everyone else is running that. And it's gonna take a while for those flows to come in. I don't think it's just gonna be immediate.
SPEAKER_03The the bear case is that, right? That it's priced in, people have been front running it, and the bull case is just like there isn't enough capital in crypto to front run like the the actual like long-term flows this thing will get.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but even stuff like CME, like oh long term for sure, it's bullish. I'm just saying like I think we might have gotten ahead of ourselves like for the next, let's say, yeah, tops in like you know, in the next week or so.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think you know the the the uh the comparisons that are drawn now, you see the chart of of kind of gold pre and post-ETF, but I think I I think that will take place, but not for the reason of the ETF per se, right? Like I I think BTC uh was much more accessible pre-ETF than than gold was uh back then, especially to especially with how retail dominant markets are relative to what they were back then.
SPEAKER_02Uh, but I do think the market share for BTC or the the the the TAM will continue growing as you kind of get um you know just currency dis uh destabilization and and and just the rotation uh of kind of wealth transfer into you know people who are the younger generation who's more open to the idea of of crypto and and BTC as a substitute for gold. So I think it will kind of fill that that timeline, but not because of the ETF, but more so just for the other reasons.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03I think the biggest thing is now there's all these Tradfly boomers that can make money off this and hopefully they'll just stop flooding. You know, like Jamie Diamond, just just stop. Like stop fudding. I saw there was one comment he made that was bullish once, and now he's back to he's back to flooding and he's an authorized participant. I don't know. I think you should learn.
SPEAKER_02He doesn't care. He like the pride thing in being right is is more important. So I don't see his two necessarily changing. I think it might soften a little bit, but I don't think diamond.
SPEAKER_03I'm just saying TradFi generally like uh has been yeah.
SPEAKER_04What's kind of interesting with these ETFs is that none of them are gonna make money. Um I saw like all the ETF guys, like Belchunis and um talking about this. Uh it's been like such a crazy fee race already that you need like hundreds of billions to make these actually worthwhile. And I mean, we're not gonna expect that much in these like anytime soon. That's like a tenth of Bitcoin's actual market cap. Uh so they're basically just lost leaders. And so what's the angle here for the ETF issuers, right?
SPEAKER_01Is it you want to get the altcoins down there through it?
SPEAKER_04Well, is it well? I mean, is it the altcoins, or is it also or is it also like you have this relationship with the advisors now, and then they're gonna buy the rest of like BlackRock's ETFs or whatever, right? But either way, it's it's yeah, the and the other angle too is how this is actually gonna be competitive for like the crypto exchanges, because you know, you buy a Bitcoin ETF, you pay 20 bips for a year, versus you take a one trade on like Coinbase and you pay that, right? And so crypto exchanges have always been like very high margin.
SPEAKER_04And like if you're a retail person who's just using Coinbase, you don't care about most of the properties of the stuff, anyways, you just care about price.
SPEAKER_03And so there are no US customers on on crypto exchanges. Coinbase? I mean, other than Coinbase, yeah. But Coinbase is a lot of us anyway.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, wait, so do you know how much Coinbase we can charge for the custody and of the ETFs? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04No, I have no idea.
SPEAKER_02It's gotta be below the fee. So it can't be too much.
SPEAKER_04Like the ones they have more opportunity to make money on are they are like ETH if they do staking. Um because like there's the one in Canada that got converted a few months ago. Um and it's taking 25% of the staking yield, and then there's still like a decent hefty fee on it. But as you're if you hold the ETF, you can either all hold like a vanilla ETH ETF or you can do one that does staking, and you even though they're taking 25% of the staking rewards, you're still net increasing your exposure over time, right?
SPEAKER_04And I mean, you'll probably see like fee competition on there too, but Coinbase, Coinbase's staking fee is what, like 25%, 20%. So I can see those ones being like a like an ETH-staking ETF being pretty good ones for the issue.
SPEAKER_02You have these leaderboards that are constantly refreshed with flows, and and and so it's just like uh a measuring contest almost.
SPEAKER_03Cool. Um so moving on to the rest of the non-bitcoin, non-ETF stuff. How are you guys seeing like maybe we can go through sector by sector? Obviously, uh you guys on the research side spent a bunch of time putting together the these year-end reports, which were awesome. If you haven't read it, if you're not a subscriber, go subscribe and read them. They're the best research reports you can you you can read. Um maybe we want to like spend some time going through DeFi, infra, and and gaming. Uh and I guess NFTs, although I don't think any of us here have particularly strong takes on NFTs, maybe I maybe I'm wrong.
SPEAKER_03But uh yeah, maybe we could start with with uh with DeFi and go around the table. Like, what are you guys seeing for DeFi in 2024?
SPEAKER_04I mean, we can start with infra because I can talk a little bit about it. Let's talk about it right now. I mean, I think this is the most confusing time ever. Uh, you have, you know, we had ETH, it used to be pretty simple, like you had ETH, and then they were moving to this roll-up-centric roadmap, and you know, people use some of these like UVM copy pasta chains for a while, but that's the direction everyone was heading in, and like you're just gonna have these ETH roll-ups and all that. Now you had you know the resurgence of Solana taking a lot of retail traders, like there's been a ton of trading activity there.
SPEAKER_04You have Celestia that's launched now, um, which has you know all the they already have a couple roll-ups already, they got Eclipse coming soon. Um, I think you're gonna start to see a lot of new roll-ups use this construction, and something we talked about in the report with this, like have the bridge to ETH, and then use Celestia DA or like Eigen DA. And so that has a lot of implications because now, you know, all those DA costs for roll-ups, they can cut their DA cost by like 90 plus percent, switching from Ethereum to Celestia, and so that's now gonna put like competitive fee pressure on um like Ethereum, I guess.
SPEAKER_04Uh, and then you still have like all these app chains. Um, Cosmos has seen like their own resurgence even outside of Celestia. Uh, and then you know you got stuff like Dimension 2. So there's just so many, it seems like there's so many like different ecosystems and like paralyzing like EVM is like another thing, right? Like high throughput EVM chain. Um, so there's just so many different like areas and sectors now, and we still mostly just trade assets, right?
SPEAKER_04And we have like so many options for that now. So that's like I don't have any super like super strong convictions. Like, I still think Solana that ecosystem will keep growing. Um I'm not like I'm not sure how the Celestia thing shakes out. Like, I'm not I'm not sure how many roll-ups they get, how many they get with like good usage, is like Eclipse the the one that most people use, is there something else? Like, yeah, and then there's 484 coming for Ethereum too in like a month or two.
SPEAKER_04That it's like this new fee market that is only for roll-ups. Um, and so you'll see a lot of roll-ups start to deploy there as well, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think infra has been like the the infinite money glitch with crypto, right? You can just like whatever infra launches, it just gets priced at multiples of applications or or or DeFi, right? Because there are just no fundamentals to ground it by. The market, you know, for it is seems massive, it can be said to be massive. Um, and these things like alt L1s, I think we've seen some pretty crazy valuations on on all L1s, and there was this theory that you know, like okay, Aptos launched, but once once Suey launches, it'll dilute and you know that that that sort of narrative and and valuations will split, and then once they know, and that just didn't happen.
SPEAKER_03Like they all just they all just keep doing well. Um and when you look at like the market cap of the applications on these chains, whether you look at it, you know, public market caps or even like private amounts raised, it just doesn't match up at all. Like some of these chains have have like eight to ten billion dollar valuations, and the second biggest project on them is like sub hundred mil. You know, it's it's it's pretty wild. Like the ecosystems just do not get there, there's no beta play, uh, other than like NFTs, really, and those don't don't don't get that many flows either.
SPEAKER_04It's definitely like a problem.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I guess if you think about the path that we got there, right? Initially it was kind of on-chain summer, and there wasn't a lot of new money flowing into the space, so you had to play lower liquidity games, and that's why you know you saw a lot of those assets um doing well, and then as soon as money started flowing in, it was more about these larger caps because you could punt perps on them and you can get them in size, and and you couldn't pin a valuation to them. Whereas apps, I think you you it's it's a bit the value is a bit more tangible.
SPEAKER_02Here it's kind of ethereal, and and you know, you just uh you you you don't ping into anything really fundamental. You have like the moneyness element, which is is part of that infinite money glitch where the the L1 token turns into into money, but you know, we're certainly far from that on almost all of these except for you know a handful, and so um it seems like it's more a product of just new money flowing into the space and having nowhere to park itself since you can't really do on-chain in size.
SPEAKER_02And then um so like uh on one hand, you know, it could continue somewhat uh just using you know the reasons as to why it got here in the first place. But I do imagine there's gonna be somewhat of a rotation into apps, but I think yeah, it's it's apps I think are are more uh tangibly valued, and so they they typically end up having higher ceilings or rather lower ceilings.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but but also like the massive FDVs, like a lot of the like Celestia, like SUSE appdos, like they all have like yeah, they're uh like Celestia is at like 14 billion or something, but then it's circulating as like two. And that seems that's like the case for for all of those that you listed off. Right now they're all supporting insanely high valuations, but unless there's like a significant amount of money that comes into this space, like even Arbitrum at like$2.20 is$22 billion, with like you know, four billion dollars circulating, something like that.
SPEAKER_01Even like that, I think unlocks are starting in March. I don't know if like all of these like Arbitrum Optimism and all the plays that you just listed supporting these like pretty massive FTVs are gonna continue to outperform or shine like they have. Like it's it's tied up, it's timed up really well, in my opinion, because Seoul ran first, and then people are like looking for these other infra plays, and they all had you know low floats, relatively speaking, and you could get size on them and and fund them on perps.
SPEAKER_01And like there's a lot of investors who want to generate like liquidity to exit. So I think things um line up really well for those plays, but I don't know if that's going to continue in the future, especially as new ones are launched and then they just instantly get priced at like you know, five billion FDV, one billion circuit's like how long can that continue to happen for before the market like kind of stops supporting that? And I think likely when these unlocks actually start start happening.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, which I'll do. I mean, this is this is why people like meme coins. This is why people like meme coins, because it's like they're this is why a dog with a hat goes to like you know 100 mil of nowhere, because it's just all of retail is basically competing against each other. Yeah, yeah. Um and you don't have like a box.
SPEAKER_02So the the next big one, I guess if if you because there's also been uh a stimulative effect from these airdrops, so you're gonna have the next one in in eigen layer, which is gonna be a big one, right? That's I think they're doing 10%.
SPEAKER_01So what's we talk about that more? Like, what do you think that actually is? Because if there's no new money coming in, then it's just kind of paper. Like you're just giving someone paper, like if there's new dollars flowing in, then you're just like handing someone this and like saying it's worth that much. Um, and it's kind of weird because when Arbitrum did it more in like a bear market, like you know, I mean, like you and I saw uh we're a fan of GMX, and like we thought the GMX was gonna benefit like massively from this Arbitrum airdrop, but really it was the reverse. Like people sold Arb Eco uh to buy Arbitrum, and we were like, damn, because it's no new it's actually no new net money.
SPEAKER_01So I think like when stuff's like ripping, like when Seoul is ripping, and then you have like the um the Jito airdrop, there's like an element of just like people feeling richer that can go on where it's like no one's selling, they just all mark that to their net worth and then just like buying more stuff, taking on more risk. But I think at a certain point you actually need new money coming in to kind of support these flows beyond this kind of psychological benefit of like the wealth effect on the ecosystem because everyone on paper is worth a bit more.
SPEAKER_02Which is where the ETF comes in, right? And and funds allocated. Because also if you're if you're a larger fund, you know, it's it's harder to allocate further on the risk curve when there's no centralized exchange liquidity for these assets.
SPEAKER_03I mean, or just new use cases, right? Better products that bring in like actual users. Um which I think is what's missing from a lot of these all L1s. But you from crypto, yeah. But I mean, it's interesting, like in the background, there are some cool stuff happening. Like we had this experience with a protocol reincubating with Mars where uh L1s do realize that they need good apps right and there's like a dearth of good app developers and like good app teams and so there are like some pretty vicious fights going on in the in the in the in the sort of background with L1s kind of fighting for for apps um and it used to be like the Grant Wars you know that that sort of Polygon was was was was famous for and they've done a really good job this cycle too of attracting applications um and that's a really interesting thing right because it's like the market might not price L1 might not price applications correctly but the L1s kind of know that it is like as you say Duncan like paper unless you get an ecosystem a thriving ecosystem of applications on on on top of it right and ideally native applications like that's really that what everyone wants um because I think importing applications like Avalanche style doesn't work too well like having Ave and Uniswap there.
SPEAKER_03It's kind of like an emerging economy right you want to you want to be have like some protectionist policies initially to develop your own industry rather than like importing in um importing in like other applications. And I think that'll be interesting to see like I think Solana is is really the one with with uh and cosmos are the ones with the strongest ecosystems outside of outside of Ethereum like measured by applications and like money raised. Yeah like even if the I guess the point is like even if the market doesn't value these apps like L1s do and like some of the grant wars going out in the background going on in the background kind of like show that and basically I think they have to kind of try and convert their market cap into applications right and I think the ones that deploy their ecosystem funds and their grant programs the best are really gonna have like huge benefits here and then have like a good vision, good strategy.
SPEAKER_03Obviously the tech has to be good and actually enable new use cases it's compelling um and I also think there's some advantage to not being EVM in this because you really like burn your you know like kind of with Solana right if Solana was EVM when the FTX thing happened it probably would have been a lot worse right it would have been a lot easier for these teams to to leave and go elsewhere and be seduced by grads because the opportunity cost is way smaller whereas if you have your own stack some differentiated value prop you you you have your own like community I think that's really like the only way to win long term.
SPEAKER_04It's also enticing for app developers too like are you going to come in and be a Solidity dev and compete against all these people that have been writing in Solidity for years or you're gonna take on some new like esoteric language that not a lot of people are experts in and you can kind of like rise to the top right I know that's like a pitch that the Starkware guys um were giving people a lot with uh Cairo and yeah like I don't it's being early right you always just want to be early everybody always wants to be early and and it's like our I mean have we seen most of the experimentation with like EVM apps or is there like new stuff there I'm not totally sure.
SPEAKER_01When I I bridge over to Solana and used it like recently like maybe a few months ago well I bought a couple things on it a while ago but like actually properly tried using it and it is honestly way better than Ethereum like Jupyter like the DCA thing like built right in like the low fees like actually swapping and not getting like paying a lot of money is just like nice instant um there's like a there's a lot of nice features and like really good UI that I kind of didn't even know existed before.
SPEAKER_04I mean I think like not having token approvals makes like a 10x difference alone.
SPEAKER_01Yeah like don't even think about anything else just the fact that there's no messages for all these protocols and like I don't even know what I'm signing. It's like it's nice. Like on on on Ethereum.
SPEAKER_04Wait on that note setters how long until Fire Dancer gets like so there they're there so the networking component is which like doesn't include consensus or the runtime like SVM it's just like sending passing stuff between validators that's on testnet right now and I think that is supposed to be they're aiming first half of this year to get that on mainnet. So basically um validators can run so you'd have the fire dancer networking component and then you'd have the labs runtime and consensus and then they're targeting like next year for the full thing but it's impossible to say one of the challenging things for them is that Solana keeps changing so rapidly all the time that it's hard to like keep up so this is one thing that this is just like contrasting both ecosystems is like Ethereum moves a lot slower these days um because like it would take a lot of effort to like change and have all these different client teams and everything um keep up and you know Ethereum is a pretty successful ecosystem right now so you don't need to be like taking these like move fast and break thing type risks.
SPEAKER_04I think Solana is starting to transition um into a bit of a slower pace because like the ecosystem's gone pretty big now there are a lot of like applications in different sectors that are relying on a lot um I think their fee markets are still not complete like there's gonna be a lot of work there um and so they kind of need to I think slow down on some of the core stuff for a bit and like see how much juice they can get out of the current network right I'm I'm obviously like bullish Solana very bullish Solana I I don't really see why the UX will be better at scale than than fully deployed rollups.
SPEAKER_04I think there's other criticisms you can make of rollups but I think the you should be able to get like Jupyter like UX on yeah yeah for sure you can get it from like a user perspective you can make it better on a rollup because you can just have a single sequencer that gives you a soft confirmation and like users don't get users don't care about like actual finality and all that stuff.
SPEAKER_03There's a lot of yeah I mean that's a that's a whole topic in on it on its own.
SPEAKER_02Yeah go ahead how much do you think uh so you know not to go back to the ETF topic but you know part of what if you assume in the long run the experience is is relatively comparable um then it kind of depends on on mind share and and and capital flows and I think you know ETH the probability of an ETH ETF relative to the the probability of a Solana ETF is is is you know miles apart.
SPEAKER_01And so um how much of that do you think plays into the level of mainstream adoption that'll happen as a result you had this good point because I asked the same thing about the role because like if roll-ups are the same execution as or like the same user experience as Solana like you know that obviously sounds like ETH has a big advantage but then I think you were talking about the like the shared liquidity layer of Solana just ignore Jan's question.
SPEAKER_03Should we just should we just no that's that's what it that is the question. No it's like but I think this question was ETF related.
SPEAKER_01Yeah yeah but no he's saying like anyway he was he's going into one of the assumptions in it he's basically saying that if the if ETH has his ETF and Solana doesn't and they have the same UX then ETH should do better because it gets more or how does ETH do better because it gets more capital? And then we're going back to the UX point.
SPEAKER_04Yeah I mean Solana is just going to they're always going to have or aim to have like the most throughput uh the most applications on one chain than anything else. And so while like these individual roll ups yeah you can make them feel a lot faster and everything. Yeah. Sorry go ahead. The other thing too is like it's also just the developers and the applications at the end of the day. Like I agree that yeah ETH is going to get a lot of institutional capital. Where are the actual retail users going? Like retail users it doesn't matter if institutions are like allocating to ETH they're still going to go wherever gives them like the best experience.
SPEAKER_04And I also don't think that like in just because ETH is getting an ETF and Soul won't I don't think that's like bearish for Soul in any way.
SPEAKER_03Soul still like the way you guys framed it in the in the report in one of the reports where it was like uh Seoul has more narrative shots on goal something like this where you you talked about like they have a bunch of payments apps they have like the Solana phone they have fired answer they have a bunch of things going on that give it more narrative shots on goal and I also think there's like more of an intangible point which is just like fragmentation of of attention right like with with ETH it feels like every new roll up that launches people just get like pissed off right it's like off on another roll up it's just like it's it it fragments attention it fragments users it's like more bridges uh you know bridges of multi-sig or whatever people are pissed off about that whereas with Solana everything that that launches is like aligned and and bullish bullish soul right everyone is is is is like aligned there I think that makes a big difference and it's kind of one of the things that Cosmos suffered from that I think it's it's improving a lot recently which is there was no central token to ape right this is like an obvious point like Adam never really fulfilled that role but I think what you're seeing now with Cosmos is new launches are very bullish Cosmos because of IBC because composability kind of um was was was like a design consideration that came first every new token launch that's successful effectively like increases the market cap of the interchain right like osmosis when tia launches they do a bunch of volume they get a bunch of TVL when Enoma launches they're gonna do a bunch of volume get a bunch of TVL DYDX like all these new cosmos chains like grow the market cap and the and like the the the volume of stuff happening on on Cosmos Rails and I feel like Cosmos and Solana kind of share that now but ETH is more fragmented um because it's bigger and it also makes it like people what people saying about ETH right a less clear narrative to to apen and stuff and I don't really know how to how to solve that how that gets solved rather yeah I mean I think so on the Cosmos thing so that was one of like our big thesis at the end of the previous year so like 2023 year ahead and uh it really took until the end of last year until Cosmos started getting this like positive momentum and like this composability with all these new chains launching and so yeah there was definitely a point there near the end of last year that I did start to think like does IBC just like go away?
SPEAKER_04Like are people going to be using this stuff anymore? Um but I don't really think that anymore. And then on the Ethereum thing yeah I I so like Ethereum is always in my opinion will always have usage and we'll always have roll-ups using it like no matter what because if people just like stop using Ethereum for for DA and everything and it becomes cheap there's like this Jevons paradox where it's like well we might as well just use like Ethereum it's the most secure longest oldest chain all this um but I do agree that it's hard to kind of coalesce around things because in Cosmos to your point when all these new chains launch they normally aren't doing exactly the same thing and they're doing something like a bit different and then there's like this camaraderie camaraderie in a sense and like everybody gets these airdrops and all this stuff and it's like everyone is kind of together in it versus in like Ethereum now there is like pretty strong competition between each roll up ecosystem.
SPEAKER_04And this is something we talked about in the yearhead report too where they're all launching their own you know they all have their own bridge to Ethereum and then the roll ups of that ecosystem like share liquidity on that bridge. So you're kind of creating new silos um in like these roll-up ecosystems and so that's what I think I think the social aspect like the social scaling for Ethereum is like the most challenging thing there um and like I I don't think all these roll up ecosystems are gonna last because there's just there's kind of like too many.
SPEAKER_02And so are the ones that are losing the Ethereum race are they just going to like pivot and just become like do Celestia for everything now and like not even have an ETH bridge of all that or yeah could you uh argue that that can be I think you can also make the argument that it's bullish right you have new incentives for new builders to come in and try and and and and dominate in their like sub-ecosystem within ETH which helps bring in new investment capital and and versus you know something that's already pretty established and it's harder to break in to to rebuild primitives that are potentially slightly better.
SPEAKER_03And and it's just a function of how big it is right like if anything gets to the size of ETH it will also have fragmented narratives I think I mean like Solana has Eclipse right as an as an L2 uh if if if that gets traction there will be others like I don't know I think um it's kind of like and for me I don't it sounds uh kind of lame but I do think ETH is money like uh everyone wants to have an ETH bridge or like settle to ETH because you have that uh and it's kind of like the argument that BTC Maxis made about ETH right if ETH might be useful but uh Bitcoin is money and so Bitcoin will be the prime like collateral and and like store value on ETH and that that didn't really play out but I feel like with ETH with it it is actually playing out and like with it being net deflationary which I feel like people have just forgotten about like I I just think that's like a huge achievement I don't know if that matters fundamentally it's it's it's negligible but uh narrative wise sure especially when yields come down.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I mean no ETH is definitely money listen all these assets are money to an extent like you know if people denominated in it it is like money coins are money but we need to oh yeah go on one quite one quick thing just like on the narrative front of like what's actual today is just I think like Solana just has a way better experience for trading and that's like the main use case of crypto right now is trading other cryptos and like Solana's like use case um or like I guess like Solana's functionality for trading is just like way better than ETH or any of the L2s right now and supposedly gonna get better with like if they have a proper like if like a dual IDX platform comes online with like some proper liquidity on Solana like that's gonna be no but that won't I don't think perps make sense on Solana because you don't like perps make sense app chain app chain perps because you only need one collateral asset.
SPEAKER_04Like on Solana you need like spot order books like Phoenix because you have like millions of assets and so you need that like composability on that one layer and you don't want to move spot assets like off different chains and everything. But if you're talking just like pure trading experience like even DYDX they looked at Solana right when they were considering moving and it was like well we'd have to take up the majority of Solana's throughput for our application.
SPEAKER_03That's the thing I don't think it offers a better trading experience than like maybe spot is obviously really good. But for for perps like Vertex um DYDX and hyperliquid I think are are crushing for action yeah yeah I think app chains actually have product market fit for for perps like it's pretty cool two out of three I think of the I mean for me the the top perp platforms um maybe that moves us on to DeFi do you guys have anything to to say on on DeFi anything you're excited about?
SPEAKER_04Feels like there hasn't been much innovation in a while it's hard it's hard to put materially innovate so I think I think I think uh this uh Sanctum is pretty cool. This is a Solana sorry Sanctum. So they are we wrote about this in both the DeFi and info report um they're not live yet but Sanctum is essentially a liquidator DAO for LSTs on Solana. So the biggest problem with like LSTs is that you need a bunch of liquidity for them in order for DeFi protocols especially like money markets to underrate them.
SPEAKER_04What Sanctum does is that they'll buy any LST and deal with like the two to three day unbonding because um unstaking the uh like an on Solana unstaking it's it's like one epoch epoch um so it's like relatively quick so it's like a couple days um so basically you can now start accepting collateral and and Solana is also launching these single single stake pool like LSTs so you can have an LST that's only one validator. So if you just want to you want like to have an LST but you don't want to you know use like Cheetos or Marinade or whatever and you just want like one specific validator you can do that too right and so Sanctum solves a real problem here where like you're not going to have DeFi protocols underwriting millions of or hundreds of like individual LST tokens right but Sanctum now sits on like this back end where it'll liquidate for these protocols any LST that they have.
SPEAKER_04And so that what why I think this is cool is because it also kind of reduces the chance of having one dominant LST that takes up so much of the liquidity and then becomes kind of like this excess that existential threat on like the DeFi ecosystem if there's ever an exploit or anything right because like this is like not fixable on Ethereum at this point the Lido is never going to lose that spot and if anything ever happens to Lido like I mean that's that really going to generate a lot of fees though I feel like it's it's a very useful product but it's not really gonna be yeah we'll have to see why do you say it that way just like your contrarian thing Lido says it that way.
SPEAKER_03Sounds cool though how do you say how do you say Delphi the way you said it go on Duncan uh I was just asking Setters if he liked any other Solana you might protocol you're trying to get your things to ape Duncan's open up well I think the one two of the things that I've wanted that I think we've all wanted to see for for a while that's just never taken off that I'm hoping will take off in 2024 well three maybe first one is like copy trading or like Socifi.
SPEAKER_03Like I feel like someone's gonna nail this at some point I just feel like it's like perfect product for crypto and for for uh for for like crypto twitter and then DeFi culture. There's obviously a lot of like implementation issues with it uh with with front running and things like this but I think someone's gonna nail it either with private rounds like an angel list syndicate type thing or with with with public rounds like I think telegram butts are are pretty interesting approach there. The other one is like interest rate swaps like I'm surprised they still I mean pendul did okay but I'm surprised they still haven't got any traction right it feels like uh everyone was predicting this last year with stake death right there was going to be like a uh a yield curve and there's gonna be people gonna be leverage trading this stuff that hasn't hasn't really happened yet and then the third one is is just like better ICO slash launchpad primitives which you know we're we're we're helping build but I do feel like that's an important one and maybe maybe the last one just like UX improvements to DeFi I feel like telegram butts this year were a huge uh breakthrough uh even though they look like toys right now like the fact that they can charge these fees and stuff and and I do think the chat interface is an interesting one to play with uh for for just like crypto generally right like chat interface plus ai of just being able to type like bridge my asset you know like the intent space I also I also think it suits an intense based world very well right where you just say I want to buy X uh you know uh whatever Sanctum once it launches on Solana get me the best the best route and then it just it just kind of does it and I I feel like seeing seeing a a meaningful UX innovation to MetaMask would be really cool too.
SPEAKER_04So I guess those four are like things that I would love to see take off yeah I do I do think intense will be I know it's like I meme and people will get triggered when you say intense but I do think uh most most is going to move towards that it also kind of one like underrated thing is that it helps with like blind signing. Because no more most of the time when you're like blind signing stuff there's just like this long like hash string and it's like not human readable and anything and everything. And intents kind of fix that um where you actually know like exactly what you're signing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah any of that yeah but yeah like on even like perps I feel like which has been the most successful product of DeFi it's like it's kind of hard to innovate beyond like there's there like there can't really be a breakthrough there. Like I guess all the stock exchanges in the world have decided like this is the best way to do trading. So it's like I'm not sure if we're gonna get a massive breakthrough on that if that's kind of already consensus and tested for for a long time. Like it could come at some point and obviously like there's some interesting takes on it like GMX but that's not really like any of the Oracle models but I think it's gonna be pretty difficult to uh to make a breakthrough there.
SPEAKER_02I also think there's on the copy trading side I mean I'm sure there could be improvements but the market's kind of spoken uh in terms of the demand for right you had the asset management protocols those never really took off you had like even you have the copy trading on like Bybit and others and and it hasn't really taken off There are all things are a big one running.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, it just kind of seems like everyone thinks they can generate their own alpha.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. I think I think I think I disagree with that because I think there's a massive cohort of people that just like trade based on Twitter. Like today every everyone gets bullish, like Hasaka tweets and then they open along. And you know, like uh Ansim shows a token, they open along. So it's like I think when you whenever you see a behavior that's already happening in kind of like an inefficient way, I feel like that's a sign that there's there's a potential product there. Um and I see the same thing with like Telegram bots. Uh I just feel like a lot of these things are happening, but we haven't found the right like product unlock.
SPEAKER_03And I do think the right copy trading feature will be like very blended in with a social app where you know like a lot of crypto Twitter, uh or not a lot, but but a good part of Crypto Twitter is already like flexing like trades and and and P ⁇ L either overtly or covertly, right? Taking victory laps and having that in like a verified way where people can actually have like um and and then I think building copy trading features on top of that, I think is super interesting. I think there's different ways to get there, like the syndicate approach is another one, but I do think it'll happen eventually, honestly.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So maybe last one, uh, I don't think anyone anyone here maybe has strong takes on gaming other than you, Jan. Uh do you want to give a quick I feel like we've predicted like four of the last zero gaming bull markets, you know, have been saying every year, like the year of gaming. Uh I'm still very bullish on that thesis. Uh, but uh I'm curious, like, what do you what do you think?
SPEAKER_02Uh I mean zero would be incorrect. Uh true.
SPEAKER_03But four or four yeah, yeah. Four four one gaming bull market.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think so. The last game bull market was was um obviously 2021 and and early 22. Uh, but that was on the back of just uh you know insane speculation within crypto itself. And so you know that reflexively kind of fueled the the the um the crypto game.
SPEAKER_03I didn't really mean bull market, I meant more like just like adoption of games, like crypto games game players, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well so it so games take a while to build. So you know there's a lot of like you had the the deployment of capital into into Axie in like 2019-2020 that then uh or like 2019 that then you know created what happened in 2021. Uh I I think you know that then fueled another wave of of investing, and and that's starting to kind of come to play now. And so you know the the bigger learnings are basically obfuscating the the crypto element in the sense that you don't require any interaction with crypto to play.
SPEAKER_02And so it's it's you know, we we don't necessarily need to go into all the the benefits we think crypto offers gaming because that's already been you know rehashed a bunch, but it's more about introducing that as a carrot rather than making it a requirement to play. And so I think you're seeing a lot of new games adopt that approach where you know you you kind of open the top of the funnel as wide as possible, and then um the earn element or you know, claiming your your your NFTs or your resources or whatever it is that you won, that's when you kind of introduce the crypto element.
SPEAKER_02So I think a lot of games are taking that approach, plus it just takes a while to spin these up. And so um, and then the yeah, there's a few exciting like ones we're excited about that's not going now, but um uh yeah, I I think this is certainly gonna be uh an exciting time as you're starting to see a lot of interesting games launch and and allow people to play them as easily as possible. It also just can you show something that you're excited about? Uh yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uhtopia, cypher.
SPEAKER_03Um all of these are portfolio companies, by the way. So maybe maybe just show like maybe or maybe just talk about like two or three that you're excited about, or just one that you're excited about, and like why. Uh maybe the what's the Clash of Clans one that's like a good one. By the way, Jan is like uh Jan is an extreme gamer, for the for those who don't know. He was like uh whatever the hell is gym master of Grand Central Station in Pokemon Go is is one of the top spenders on on Robit, is playing every every game in the moon, Clash of Clans.
SPEAKER_03So he's uh yeah, he knows his stuff when it comes to this.
SPEAKER_01Well yeah, and have you played Clash Royale? Do you play that one? I played it for a little while, yeah. We should get on.
SPEAKER_02I'm down. Um, it's uh yeah, so uh I guess yeah, we can Topia's got the the it's a round we led recently and and has the I think one of the ones that has launches coming up, basically a uh an improved version of Minecraft, which you know Minecraft right now exists because creators are creating these worlds and game types that that the hundred million monthly active users really enjoy, right? And that's what keeps the game evergreen.
SPEAKER_02There hasn't really been development from the original creators, it's more uh it's more community-based creation. And so what this game is doing is allowing for those creators to better monetize what they're doing. And so, you know, the what you want to target is you you you create a world where the creators themselves make more money than they do in Minecraft, and and that would help bring over some of the players that are only there for those people in the first place. And so the idea is this is a game where you don't need to reintroduce the world to this game or introduce the world to this game and teach them about it.
SPEAKER_02It's a it's a you know one of the most popular games in the world, and so capturing even one percent of that audience uh can is is really material in terms of bringing users on board, and the idea is it it looks exactly like Minecraft with improvements to UI, but it it's and UX, but it but it's effectively a very similar game, and and so everyone who's already playing can easily move in, it's backwards compatible, and then at the same time, the creators are the ones that the people are here for, and they're financially incentivized to basically do what they're doing, but but make more money doing it.
SPEAKER_01The one liner for Minecraft plus Roblox with crypto economics, like crypto marketplace, frictionless payment, and game monetization, like items for player zone. I'm also very excited about it.
SPEAKER_03Nice. Cool. All right, guys. I think with that we can wrap up. Really enjoyed this episode. Thought it was one of the better ones we've we've recorded. Um, we'll try and keep the cadence on these more regular in 2024. Do them do them every two weeks. Uh, hope you enjoyed and happy ETF day to all of you out there.
Anthropic goes public with no six-month lockup and an unlock schedule José calls more aggressive than any low float, high FDV token. Is the selling about to drain the market? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris after...
US equities just lost $2 trillion. Is the worst behind us? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris split on it. Yan says the bull market is intact and the setup for a short squeeze is there; Jason's macro models say wait....
Two years of gridlock just started, and the crew thinks that's good for crypto. Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris are joined by Omnia, co-founder of Kinetiq, the day after the midterms. Yan explains why chop into the...
What happens when a cyber attack costs a thousandth of what it used to? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris are joined by Jake Sylvestre, founder of Hypercall, the options protocol from Synapse built on Hyperliquid....
Is the bottom in for crypto? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris break down a market that just shook off weeks of selling, from the 10:30 AM seller who finally ran out of coins to the year-end unlocks and what the...