Jose, Yan, Duncan and Ceteris, joined by Matt at @0xdef1 discuss the past, present and future of AMMs and on-chain liquidity as well as giving their thoughts on the market going forward. Disclosures: Nothing said on The Hivemind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. The podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Jose, Yan, Duncan, Ceteris, and our guests may advise or hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed. Delphi's transparency page can be viewed here. Get a 20% discount on a premium Delphi PRO or PRO+ for listening to this episode! Follow the links below or use the codes on checkout: 20% off Delphi PRO annual Code: PODCASTPRO Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastpro 20% off Delphi PRO+ annual Code: PODCASTTEAMS Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastteams Follow Delphi Digital Website: https://members.delphidigital.io/home Twitter: https://twitter.com/Delphi_Digital YouTube: https://youtube.com/@Delphi_Digital
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hey everyone, my name is Jose Maseru, and welcome to episode three of the Hive Mind Podcast. We all should have much better mics today. We got a lot of complaints about sound quality, so that should be that should be fixed. And as always, the goal of the podcast is to provide an inside look into what we like to call the Delphi Hive Mind, bringing together some of our brightest minds from each of the divisions to share insights, alpha, and shitposts. Today with us, we have Cederis from our institutional research arm, who focuses on blockchain infra and DeFi.
SPEAKER_02We have Jan Lieberman, who's the managing partner at Delphi Ventures, and we have Ventures Associate Duncan, also known as Flood Capital, prodigious shitcoin scavenger and investor. I lead Delphi Labs, our protocol RD arm, focused on incubating and accelerating new Web3 primitives. And we also have Matt, also known as OXDFi, who uh heads up research at Labs and is a general uh gigabrain on AMMs, which is gonna be a lot of the topic of today's today's chat. Uh it's a bit of a stale, it's been a bit of a stale news week in in crypto, maybe news month.
SPEAKER_02So we're gonna be talking about uh the future of on-chain liquidity, um, which is we of our research recently published a report on it. Check it out if you're a subscriber. But uh basically this conversation is gonna be around whether there is a future for on-chain liquidity or whether everything is just gonna move to to off-chain. And so to start with, we just want to go over like a brief history of of on-chain liquidity starting back in the in the ether delta days. Uh Cetteris, yeah, take it away.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so basically the first on-chain liquidity was like using this uh ether delta. And this is a fully this is a fully on-chain order book. And so you would actually have to uh this was like 2017, like do a transaction. Like yeah, 2017, right? Um I would guess like 99% of stuff that was traded on there is like effectively zero now. But you'd have to do like a transaction to deposit into the exchange, and then you do uh you know another on-chain transaction to like place and cancel orders.
SPEAKER_00And this was on Ethereum with like 12 second block times, and so it was very expensive and very inefficient system. And before DeFi uh summer kind of came around, as it was it was kind of workable still because gas fees were so cheap because no one was really using like Ethereum L1 or anything. Um, but as soon as people started using it, it became clear that like, okay, this fully on-chain order book um is way too expensive, like it's not practical, okay? And that's when AMMs started coming out with stuff like curve and uniswap.
SPEAKER_00Well, it was uniswap first, right?
SPEAKER_02Like Vitalik like put put up this this xy equals k, then Hayden built it as like a grant, I'm pretty sure, from the from the EF. And then yeah, it started kind of.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I'm I'm not sure which one was first, but like the what it would the big the big thing that AMMs solved is that they were workable in a gas constrained environment, right? Because um, you don't need to as a liquidity provider, you don't need to keep doing uh placing and like canceling orders. Uh when someone takes like one side of the pool, you automatically kind of like flip to now offering the other side, right? So this is like why AMMs took off, is that you're in such a gas-constrained environment, and this kind of got around those gas hurdles.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and then second of all, it was kind of just like all the rewards and all the farming that people were doing, right? I think synthetics was probably one of the bigger reasons why people started LPing, right? Because they started doing all this SUSD stuff, uh, and then they were big on curve. Like some of those early, some of those early LPs, LP and SUSD on curve, like massive, massive airdrops, right? Like millions of dollars airdrops.
SPEAKER_01And ETH. Synthetic ETH and regular ETH.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's like a very simple pool, right? Like you're it's just ETH against ETH, and this is synthetics doesn't go insolvent, like you have no impermanent loss or anything. And yeah, so so that's kind of like how these AMMs took off. Um, and then of course came the whole DeFi summer, curve did their airdrop. Uh, then sushi forked Uniswap and they started pumping out the token rewards, right? And so the when it's like a bull market and no one knows how to value these these farm tokens that you're getting, right?
SPEAKER_00Like how defensible is this income that LPs are getting and all this, that kind of led to the mayhem of like on-chain AMM farming, that whole craze, Uniswap did the airdrop. Um, and so that's kind of like how the whole on-chain liquidity started.
SPEAKER_02And it looked for a while as if that's where it would stay, right? Like most projects would launch with like LP incentives, like yield farming was was was all the rage, uh, I guess kicked off by synthetics. Yeah, and and then things took a dark turn.
SPEAKER_03The other thing that I'll add to this is um it it was um in a gas-constrained environment, so yes, like the the AMMs got around those constraints, but also being fully on-chain made it decentralized, and people started to realize that um if there was a significant mass of liquidity in these pools, they could really launch tokens in a decentralized way without having to negotiate with exchanges or hire market makers or or trust third parties. Um and so as people were uh creating these new ecosystems and wanted to um create a token to incentivize certain behaviors, having on-chain liquidity and being able to bootstrap that on-chain liquidity by get by giving rewards.
SPEAKER_03You know, Wi-Fi, um, their launch was one of the first people that did this, um, really started this um, you know, the DeFi summer revolution of uh if we take some of our token, some of our token supply, and uh pay people to LP, it's a valuable service to us and it's it's gonna get us more distribution, more users in a fully decentralized way. I think that was pretty novel.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Yeah, maybe Centers, you want to go through like when when things started to change? I guess like one inch and tents.
SPEAKER_00I get I guess I mean, well, so that's kind of how it started, and then yeah, then he had all these aggregators pop up, and those were good for traders because now instead of you know, if you go through Uniswap, it would row through Uniswap pools, but maybe not all these other AMMs that popped up, and so that was good for traders, but over the past, I guess, year or two, um, people have started to realize how much money LPs lose to basically just toxic flow and arbitrage.
SPEAKER_00Um because since an LP is passive and doesn't update its prices, every time the price, I mean, so like price discovery happens for all the liquid assets on centralized exchanges, right? So anytime the price changes on a centralized exchange, you now have these stale pools on-chain, and so a big part of on-chain volume has just been people ARBing the pools um from like centralized exchanges, right?
SPEAKER_00And so this whole like loss versus rebalancing thing that people have been talking about a lot over the past year uh is kind of this phenomenon, right? Where if ETH is trading at like thousand dollars and it spikes to eleven hundred on an exchange, uh the LP on chain will effectively sell from one thousand to one thousand one hundred in like incremental ticks. And so 99% of that trade is at a stale price, right?
SPEAKER_01Um I think it's helpful to kind of put that just to uh understand uh the the how it works relative to kind of IL as well, just to kind of rewind. So IL impermanent loss was kind of the main initial concern with LPing, and the whole idea was IL just says if I'm holding two assets in equal quantities, and you compare that to putting those two assets in in a Uni V2 pool, when price moves from X to Y, how much did my AMM underperform the buy and hold strategy?
SPEAKER_01And so that and then the idea is why it's called impermanent is if price goes back from Y back to X, uh the two are equal, right? Both the AM the value in the AMM and the value of your buy and hold strategy. What LVR basically means is saying is when it goes from X to Y back to X, you actually shouldn't be sitting with uh your starting value of assets. You actually lost money and you should actually have more. And and the reason being what what Setter is kind of described, where you know price is because lost first rebalancing is basically you comparing um the performance of the position in the AMM versus someone replicating the AMM strategy but doing it on Binance, right?
SPEAKER_00So the idea is if like it's kind of like if I can just jump in, it's kind of like how much money you left on the table.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Like what do you leave on the table?
SPEAKER_01Right. And so like yeah, price pumps uh yeah, like 1%, right? So you start at$1,000 right a thousand dollar ETH price moves to$1,010. Uh uh the the the decision tree is okay, I need to sell some ETH to go back to 50-50. I'm selling at$1,010. On the AMM, that that that's more of a price taker. And so those rebalance late. So basically what happens is the price pumps to$1,010. The AMM is effectively still selling it at$1,000. Like you can go into the AMM and buy it at$1,000 and move it to$1,010.
SPEAKER_01So the AMM, the the liquidity provided in the AMM, instead of selling it at$1,010 like you did on Binance, sells it at at basically the midpoint between 1,000 and 1,010. And so that kind of over time is is uh is the issue. And so yeah, I I part of the reason why it's useful to do in that context is kind of you know, with those difficulties in mind, who is kind of the ideal, like what what where does it make sense to AM to be an LP?
SPEAKER_02So it's it's I don't want to get into that too much now though. The the because we're we're gonna get into like the LPing and AMM stuff stuff later. Maybe just continuing to like that was useful context, but continuing to set the context, uh, yeah, like One Inch came about, then I guess like CowSwap, eventually Uniswap X, the difficulties with and inefficiencies of LPing meant more and more of volume has has flowed to those, which are effectively being served by like off-chain market makers and and centralized exchanges, right? And then I guess that plus like off-chain order books with the likes of DuIDX and vertex and stuff means that a lot of uh I mean price discovery sort of always happened on chain, off-chain, at least for the for the majors, but we're you're starting to see that link uh also trading volumes and stuff move move more and more to these to these off-chain solutions, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I mean the the off-chain stuff like CalSwap, all these intent-based protocols, Uniswap X, uh, the whole Noma thing. That is better for traders, right? Because you're not getting sandwiched. Like when you when you sign uh when you want to trade against an AMM on-chain, you're just you're signing like this execution path that says, yeah, I'm I want to go through this pool and I can afford this amount of slippage and just get it done. Um and so you know, people get everyone who's used on chains probably had a bad sandwich or two in their lifetime, um, which is just you know, someone in uh in an advantaged position essentially reordering transactions to make you lose money.
SPEAKER_00And so with these intent-based designs, they're they're kind of like limit orders, they happen off-chain. Um, and then they're based around solvers. Uh, and so something like CowSwap, you know, someone goes in, does I want to buy one ETH for XUSDC, and then a solver goes to like look to fill that. And they can use their own inventory, they can use pools on-chain. Um, but basically, they're trying to like fill that order directly. And so the the shift in moving to this kind of like intent-based architecture is that for liquidity providers on chain in these AMMs, they start to get less of the organic flow because um they start to get less of the organic flow because now when this like retail trader with no alpha, no like uh knowledge, whatever comes in, instead of going directly through the pool against the AMM, they go to this solver, and the solver has their own inventory and they're they have money on centralized exchanges, and they're they they're the ones that like are able to fill this retail trader, and then the solver just goes and arbs the AMM pools themselves.
SPEAKER_00So the AMMs are now starting to get like more and more of just this toxic flow, which is you know, they were always arbitraged against C5 exchanges, but now that they're also losing some of the organic flow, uh the the ratio of their toxic flow goes up, and then also their volume goes down a bit because you don't have the organic volume anymore. Uh, and so now we're kind of you know, we did everything with AMM, we've had some of these, all these intent things are coming along now, and now we're kind of moving.
SPEAKER_00You're gonna start to see AMMs kind of like defend this now, right? Um, and kind of like fix some of these problems. And we can, I don't know if we want to get into that now.
SPEAKER_02Um Yeah, so I guess before so that's basically like the I guess the barricade for on-chain liquidity, right? It's a a future where we move to this fully intent-centric model. Um, it is a future where you don't really like AMMs would just be purely exposed to like toxic flow or mostly toxic flow, and then eventually no one wants to LP, and like all price discovery moves to these to these like intents-based off-chain models. Is that right? Is there anything you would add to that?
SPEAKER_00Like before, because no, that's that's right. Like, also the intent architecture, it's also not just like AMMs, it's bridges too, right? Like, you don't need these passive liquidity bridges either. Yeah, um, it's a lot of things. If you go to like the extreme of the intent architecture, then applications are merely front ends with their own solving algorithms, um and blockchains are basically just used for settlement of assets, but a lot of the complexity happens you know in this off-chain and like in this peer-to-peer gossip layer.
SPEAKER_00Um and so like I don't know if that's the exact end state we're going to go towards, but um that would be like the full-on bear case for on-chain liquidity.
SPEAKER_04So, what are like the negatives of of this if that happens?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean it's it's more centralized, it's like regulatory pressure, basically everything that is, in my opinion, everything that's easier is also a bigger regulatory target. And so think about like the L2s right now, okay? The L2s are all taking extremely easy paths, they are multi-sigs with a single sequencer, okay? And so they can offer like a clean UX. Um, there's not a lot of like complications, uh, the architecture, but it is uh most likely like an easier regulatory surface to attack, right?
SPEAKER_00And then if you think about like solvers and intent architectures, if you have if you have like two, three solvers that are filling like all the orders on on blockchains, then that again is an easy regulatory target. Versus if you have all this just passive retail liquidity that's all over the place, it's less efficient, but it's also just it's just just just this massive, can't go after like hundreds of thousands of people, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Because like the solver is essentially just bridging Binance or wherever the deepest liquidity is to the user directly on the blockchain and like using it as settlement, right? So I think that's where like I definitely agree with like the bear JMM takes. I feel like I've thought that for a while because they simply just like don't have as much information or complexity as the solver, but I think this is where like some more complex like Oracle models.
SPEAKER_02Let's let's uh hold off on that for a second. So yeah, we we we we we will get into that, but so yeah, I guess we we went through over the bear case for on-chain liquidity, and now yeah, we're gonna move on to like what the bull case is, and I guess it starts with the fact that even though everyone knows LPing is incredibly unprofitable, there have been like 3,000 studies on how everyone is losing money on Univ3 and Unv2 and stuff, there's still like billions of dollars of demand for LPing on-chain, and like that's kind of like hard to argue against, right?
SPEAKER_02And then I think the argument that people like Matt would put forward, and and I think John to some extent, is that if these like highly and and and myself actually, is that if these highly inefficient models can attract billions of dollars of capital, there's something here, and as the models improve, which they are, and we're seeing like really cool stuff happen, uh, then they'll capture even more of this of this of this flow. Um, and so I don't know, uh Matt, do you want to give like kind of kind of your thoughts on on I guess like the bull case for for on-chain liquidity?
SPEAKER_03Sure. I I mean I think um having on-chain liquidity at all is really valuable to lots of different people in the ecosystem. Um uh so like uh it's really valuable for traders to have on-chain liquidity um so that they can trade against a decentralized source. It's really valuable for issuers to have on-chain liquidity so that they can bootstrap it really easily. Um and when it is that valuable for them, um, they offer incentives. So um, like in DeFi Summer, we saw a lot of incentives, and a lot of people thought AMMs were like these magic money machines with triple-digit yield.
SPEAKER_03Uh, we're not seeing that so much anymore. Um uh but um uh people offering incentives, um, uh they're offering incentives for a reason. It's because that that liquidity is valuable. Um I think we're seeing a lot of LPs lose money right now because uh A on Uniswap, there's not a lot of incentives that are that are external.
SPEAKER_00I mean the volumes are down too, right? So like you're getting less trading fees.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you had all the money flowing into the space and then all like a bunch flowing out.
SPEAKER_04But the and the liquidity mining stuff isn't really like sustainable.
SPEAKER_03Well, people are are underpricing the service. So like the the LPs that are uh putting their money into these pools, um, the fees that they're collecting are not commensurate with the risk they're bearing or the value that they're providing to those other people. Um and even with off-chain liquidity, so like a market maker that um is hired by an issuer, um, they're giving that that market maker either money or some kind of sweetheart option deal to hedge away the risk, um, or the exchange is giving them rebates. So like a lot of the profit for an off-chain market maker comes from these external incentives.
SPEAKER_03Um so if we're looking at on-chain liquidity to compare apples to apples, you kind of have to include those incentives as well.
SPEAKER_00Umbody actually wants to trade these assets.
SPEAKER_03Well, what I'm saying is like if you look at a market maker purely on a like inventory PL basis, a lot of them are losing money too, because market making is hard, right? You're not you're not really um taking an opinion on which way the price is gonna move.
SPEAKER_01You're just saying uh give me money for providing you liquidity for providing the AMM so it's just like more on the bull case for AMMs, just before we kind of gear off this. So, you know, it it's I think a lot so a lot of people are losing money on UniV3. I wouldn't really put Univ3 in the AMM bucket, right? It's not automated, it's basically order an order book, but like with with without the benefits of being able to do that type of market making on a centralized exchange. So it kind of boils down to you know where can it make sense for someone to do this completely passively?
SPEAKER_01Um so you know the intent stuff is is beneficial for the trader side, but there isn't a lot that's the there there's still issues with the LP side, one of it being the fact that LPs are constantly taking stale prices. And so LVR is really hard to completely undo, but but there, you know, there are things you can implement, whether that's and this isn't exhaustive by any means, but a dynamic fee. So LVR is worse the more price moves. And so if you have a dynamic fee, which increases as the the size of the trade increases, um that that's something that can help mitigate it using an Oracle uh for the AMM, right?
SPEAKER_01So the the the pool isn't um isn't trading on a purely stale price, but it can use an external Oracle price, which introduces some kind of centralization risks, or you can do the the decentralized kind of equivalent, which is what curve v2 does. So I think a lot of those types of kind of implementations can help reduce LVR. And then you're kind of rationalizing it. So then you think about, okay, so who is the user that that wants to LP? I think part of it is is is based on your opinion on price direction, right?
SPEAKER_01If if if you're bullish on an asset, then then more often than not, it's really hard to rationalize LP. But if if you are are pretty neutral on it, you think we're range bound for an extended period of time. And or if it trends higher but doesn't necessarily go up too much, or if you don't necessarily trust yourself to be able to sell when it goes up and you kind of want to gradually sell as it as it goes up, I think there's there's arguments in in that scenario where it makes sense to kind of uh LP it's so it's not necessarily like it's it's I think it boils down to what you're comparing it against.
SPEAKER_01If you're just bullish on the asset and want long exposure, then there is no scenario or almost no scenario where it makes sense to LP. But if you're pretty neutral and want to generate passive yield, then I think there are some of these solutions that help avoid LPs constantly uh transacting at stale prices and improves kind of their like experience by reducing the LVR. And and I think in in that scenario, you can really begin to kind of rationalize LP.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, Matt. Uh sorry, Matt, I know you have a metaphor I really like with with index funds. It's like maybe like it's the hopium meme a little bit, but yeah, uh, yeah, this this definitely might be hopium.
SPEAKER_03Um uh but uh if you compare like investing to market making, so uh the conventional wisdom for a really long time was that uh investing was this you know very specialized skill set that only the best people in the world could do. Um it was kind of this like black box of of uh people who could could make a lot of money investing. Um and then index investing came along and said, like you can just kind of do this passively. Most of the people who pretend to do this aren't very good at it and don't really beat the index.
SPEAKER_03Um and then passive investing became this huge boom of an industry, and there was a huge market for it. Um market making is very similar in that um there's a small number of people who do it with a very specialized skill set, and this sort of this, you know, black magic voodoo that people don't really understand how it works under the covers. Um, maybe there's a place for passive market making in the same way that there was for passive investing. Um I think like the fact that a lot of LPs are losing money right now means that um they're not pricing their service appropriately.
SPEAKER_03They're not pricing selling volatility appropriately. Um and there's been very little experimentation with how fees work. You know, a lot of the fees on AMMs is like flat 0.3%. Um, no market maker in the history of the planet has said we're always going to have a 0.6% spread no matter what the price is, no matter what the volatility is. Um it's kind of a brain-dead market making strategy. So uh I would love to see more innovation in how fees work and and how um LPs charge for the service service that they're offering, both to traders and to issuers and to exchanges and things like that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think like to add on that, um like the psychology is a big is a big reason. And humans are like not necessarily rational, especially in in markets. And this is like why people you know people always want to try and outperform the market and out trade, even though all the like data on it shows that most traders like lose money, right? But it's kind of like that arrested development meme, it's like it didn't work for them, but it might work for us, right?
SPEAKER_00And so you're always gonna have people that will like no matter how much of the data shows them that they're probably losing money, will try it, and some will be successful, right? Uh there's also just the fact that people want to do stuff with their assets, and if you have like ETH in your wallet and you have some other asset that is like kind of correlated to it, it's much easier to like rationalize and and justify you know doing something with those, uh, and kind of like trying to LP with them uh because like you people will have these assets and they want to do stuff with them.
SPEAKER_00And so I think that the market will come up with better solutions uh that we're kind of seeing now where you kind of I don't think LPing needs to be perfect, but you need to be able to capture a lot of that C5 DeFi ARP because that's like the main place where LPs lose. And so if you can you get some of these AMM designs where you have like these top of block auctions, right? So when the price changes on a centralized exchange, uh that first trade into the the AMM, instead of like uh a searcher coming in and bidding up to the proposer and then all the value going to the proposer and the searcher, um, instead the AMM itself becomes like aware of this auction.
SPEAKER_00And so uh that bid to be the first one to arm that pool actually ends up getting distributed back to LPs, right? And so mechanisms like that we're gonna see way more because if if AMMs don't become more aware of like what's happening off-chain, then they will go away. Um and if you can recapture a lot of that that C5 D VI ARP, then I do think that will be like good enough that you will see um a lot of passive liquidity still.
SPEAKER_00Because passive liquidity, it's very useful. Like um, especially if people like die with their keys too, and like you just have this liquidity sitting there forever. Like yeah, it is kind of useful, like it is it is useful to have that for like liquidations, for DeFi, like for everything.
SPEAKER_02Um useful to the traders, admittedly not useful to the dead person.
SPEAKER_04If LP Yeah, I guess it doesn't really matter to the dead person.
SPEAKER_03If LP passively can be made into a profitable endeavor, then you have this new avenue to take idle assets and make them productive, which is like uh uh a huge product, right? There's a lot of people with idle capital that want to make it productive that you know they put in products like bonds, they they try to lend it, they try to do lots of things to make that capital productive. And if if LPing is a way to do that, that's it's a it's a huge product.
SPEAKER_02Duncan, I'm gonna let you loose in a second, but the the so the I guess what we're hearing is AMMs, um, there's interesting improvements that can be made, like the top of block auction auction, like playing with with variable fees, curvy two style, doing more experimentation around that. And uh, if those improvements are made, given the demand, there is already like uh we think this could this could go up even more and it could become a way of passively generating yield on on idle assets, right? Um and this also has a bunch of benefits, like you said, and I think importantly also the the other model has a bunch of costs, right?
SPEAKER_02Like integrating with with uh like onboarding with a centralized market maker requires like negotiation. Uh often they're they're pretty extortionate, like you have to onboard them to centralized exchange. Uh the the market maker has to have the regulatory sort of like uh risk appetite to to trade these assets, which is getting less and less the case. So like there's a bunch of I mean there's a bunch of benefits to having this this on-chain always on liquidity, also for for protocols, for liquidations, for for for stuff like that. Um, and all that, I guess, has to has to be pressed into the to this.
SPEAKER_02But Duncan, I know you you uh you've been raring to go. Give us your uh yeah, go on.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but yeah, so I definitely think there's cases where uh it makes sense, like like in in the current state, like passive liquidity or on-chain liquidity in its current state makes sense. Like, for instance, we're talking about a protocol wants liquidity on their token. You know, I'm not a massive fan of like uh liquidity mining, but something where like the protocol were to deploy um a bunch of its like governance token in like a uni v3 like LP range, and then like you know, as if the protocol is successful, people buy that and they uh like have uh like protocol on liquidity as the price goes up and they they can kind of like provide their own liquidity.
SPEAKER_04That's a lot of what uh GMX has done. Something like that, I think, makes a lot of sense, and like from the protocol's point of view, right, like they don't really care that much if they're losing um you know, versus what they could be doing on like Binance market making, because like like you guys said, like for that for them it's worth it to to provide liquidity for the token. Also for like smaller cap tokens, like it doesn't really make sense to use an order book or off chain or Oracle. So like being able to deploy like a new project with like a little bit of liquidity uh in an AMM I think makes sense.
SPEAKER_04I think like the the big point, and I agree with like everyone that these AMMs are gonna get um better over time, right? Like Matt said, the Uniswab um pool doing like a three bips fee is is just insane, like regardless of the market conditions. So we've seen stuff like Curv2 where like as volatility increases, like it'll increase the fee and the spread, like kind of like a market maker would. Market maker would like pull the spread uh out during uh more volatility. So I definitely think it's gonna be like smarter models, uh what Cedar's is talking about, like the the auctions to capture the C5 D5 ARB.
SPEAKER_04I think what it comes down to probably at the end of the day though, is that like these on-chain systems, um, if they're like odd if they're like truly automated, are never going to like have as much information as kind of like a market maker or like someone running these solvers. So it's gonna be very difficult for them to be as um like performant in in all scenarios. But I definitely think there's things where you could kind of like help bridge that gap where it's like instead of just like DeFi being a front end into Binance through like all these solvers, you can have like passive pools of liquidity uh on-chain, and then like some slightly more complicated Oracle model, which will try and get you pretty close to what you know your execution would be on a centralized exchange, but also like having that liquidity um on-chain, and it can't just kind of like disappear versus like these like front ends and solvers.
SPEAKER_04So like some sort of middle ground, um or even like I don't know how you would like solve the kind of like alignment problem here, but like you know, if there's on if there's capital on chain, like you have a solver like quote for the pool, you know, they probably have to take some sort of fee or some sort of alignment um problem there, but like passing information from like centralized exchanges and like the the place of price discovery and liquidity to on-chain, I think, is possible. I just think it's like really inefficient to um right now because like the models for AMMs we have are like really inefficient, and then you run into also like the gas issue where like as we've seen with like curvy 2, I think it's like twice as expensive as like a univ3 swap, which when gas um gets pricey on on Ethereum can make like a really big difference.
SPEAKER_04So like if you're gonna continually make these AMMs more and more complicated, then like you also have to factor in like gas and in that execution side. But I think there's definitely like a path forward. I just think like how they are in their current state is pretty bad. Uh and they're never gonna be as good.
SPEAKER_02And and to be clear here, we're talking about like for for for the majors, right? Because for long tail tokens where price discovery happens on AMMs, like the you know, robots and unchained things of this world, it doesn't it doesn't matter, right? And I think AMMs will continue to be the best for that, for for for for foreseeable future.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean I think it makes sense though, right? You you you you aren't able to you don't have the skill set to do what a centralized market maker does, and and so in exchange, and and you don't actually have to do any work, right? It's it's the idea is set it and forget it. I I I I've you know similar uh directionally similar returns, but but worse on all fronts.
SPEAKER_02Can we um maybe maybe sp spend like a segment like each pricing, like name dropping some projects that they're excited about in this space, like that in the in the on-chain liquidity space or approaches that you think are are interesting? I was surprised, Duncan, that you didn't put like a GMX V2 shill in there, so I'm now giving you the opportunity to Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, yeah, I think like GMX, so they came out in maybe um September of 2021. And like right away, I think they started getting like a lot of traction because like they're the first, I think the first people to like really make the Oracle model successful and for for BTC and ETH. And they've assumed.
SPEAKER_02A lot of people think it's just leverage trading, right? So like maybe you could clarify the spot side, because I think may most people don't know about that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so like V1 launching is basically like a pool of like Bitcoin, ETH and some stable coins, and they allowed like two different types of trading. So um margin trading, right, or leverage trading, where you could essentially just like go long on BTC or ETH by like kind of renting out the assets in the pool. It had uh price feeds and oracles to like Binance and kind of like the top exchanges to give you like a fair price, um, plus plus like a set fee to kind of reduce the ability for like people to arbitrage because there's like obviously a little bit of latency uh in the Oracle.
SPEAKER_04But then they also like allowed spot swaps between BTC, ETH, and USDC up to like you know really large size, and especially in the early days on Arbitrum, that was probably the best way to kind of swap between those three assets, um, because like the Uni V2 or V3 pools didn't really have much liquidity, and um GMX would give you like the the Binance level pricing. And then they kind of like iterated beyond that, where it's just like okay, we're just gonna take the flat Oracle um plus 10 bips uh to their their V2 model where they're kind of factoring in kind of order book depth.
SPEAKER_04Um they can kind of go down the the longer tail of assets because like before how they were like limiting manipulation is like okay, you need to buy like a lot of BTC in order to move the price like more than 10 basis points, but you know it's that's not really true with every asset. So they've kind of gone down the the list of long tail assets they're they're offering. It's still like primarily majors, but in the future they're gonna try and open it up as much as possible, and they're gonna factor in kind of like order book depth, like on-chain depth, uh, to try and simulate the best sort of price.
SPEAKER_04And then from the LP's point of view, they're not taking still prices uh as the setters said. So I think a really good example that just happened this week was the BTC ETF news where BTC's up like 5% in like a minute. And it's like if you're in an AMM or like anything that doesn't have like real-time data getting fed into it, like you took still prices like all the way up on that move. And it happened to be fake, so it retraced it, but you still have like the LVR issue, and if it were to be real, like you got kind of screwed in any sort of passive product.
SPEAKER_04So at least with like an Oracle, even though liquidity is still sitting on chain, you have some of the decentralization like benefits, it is updating in kind of real time, so you're not getting just like really bad execution when the price gaps up like that.
SPEAKER_02That's interesting. I know does anyone want to respond to that? Or uh otherwise I'll give the floor to Cedarist to discuss. Yeah, go ahead, Matt.
SPEAKER_03I I think um Oracle models, especially for perps, are super interesting, and we're seeing so much of the volume that used to be in spot trading on-chain move to perps because um, if you are just trying to get exposure to assets, perps is just a much better model. Um, and the Oracle perps pioneered by GMX and GNS, um uh it's seeing so much usage. I I think um they do have a scalability issue because they require Oracle prices from some source of price discovery that happens off-chain. Um, and so if you have more volume running through your um your exchange than is happening on those external exchanges, you have manipulation attacks and and uh trouble kind of scaling past the amount of activity that's happening on those centralized exchanges.
SPEAKER_03And you're also dependent on those centralized exchanges for a source of price. Um so it's not truly decentralized in the end. So um I think they're super interesting models and uh uh I think there's product market fit there. Um in terms of like end game of decentralized on-chain uh trading. Um I think A, it's not spot. So like you know, you can't really hold the assets. Um and B, um uh it it's um it's got a scalability issue and decentralization issue.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say, I think that this this the scalability is is, yeah, I I agree, it's it's a concern, but I mean most of these markets, right? It's you you kind of have power law where it's the the BTC pair, the ETH pair, and like Sol and a handful of others are just making up most of the volume. And so because it's like these guys actually benefit from the fact that you have this one exchange that dominates all the volume, right? Because typically, you know, it it's you end up having to do it like on a combination of exchanges with a lot of small volume, but because you have this one massive whale that that's taking up so much market share, you can it it simplifies the Oracle process where you basically kind of just use them and then you can add in some you know um kind of slippage based on the order book depth on those centralized exchanges.
SPEAKER_01So I I I agree there's definitely a limitation issue, but I think there's still so much kind of capacity for that limit to grow. And I think part of like part of so the the Oracle element is is really useful here because it it allows for you know every dollar of underlying LP liquidity in your GMX GNS to support a lot more activity because um and so it makes the the LPs a lot more capital efficient, and I think they don't have to deal with L VR, and um you also get the benefits of being the counterparty to traders, which generally lose over time as well.
SPEAKER_01And so it's it's I think that's also part of what might kind of cannibalize long-term the um the demand for on-chain liquidity uh for some of these majors because yeah, it's just it's it's hard to argue for yeah, for for the majors for sure.
SPEAKER_03Um I I think like uh long-tail assets are like if you're launching a new token, um, the presence of these kinds of Oracle base exchanges don't really help you. So like uh it's there's it's a different product um than you know somebody trying to launch a token and boost strap liquidity.
SPEAKER_00I think the Oracle model is it it's interesting. Um I guess my critique against it is just that you're like relying on an Oracle. And like I have seen some of these AMMs that use Oracle's before, kind of like missed price at times. Um I think the cleanest, I I just think that the the top block auction is the cleanest because you're not really relying on um.
SPEAKER_02Can you talk about the times that are that are doing that?
SPEAKER_00Or yeah, I mean skip is like the first one that's done it, right? Uh building. Yeah, it's on Cosmos, and I mean there's not a lot of MEV there, so you don't see it too much. But basically, at the beginning of every block on Osmosis, um if someone wants to be first in like first transaction in that block, there's a bid for it. It's like a separate part of the block that is done with this like auction, and then you know, all the value, let's say the price moved by like ten dollars, and so the value of that bid will be bid up to like ten dollars.
SPEAKER_00Um, and then that all gets redistributed to I mean in Osmosis case it's like the stakers of the token, they can choose where it goes. Uh on Ethereum, there's like different ways to do this. Uh Cerella Labs is doing it where they actually have a contract. So they have their AMM pools, and then they have another contract, which is the only contract that's actually allowed to trade against those AMM pools, and then that contract runs the auction, right?
SPEAKER_00And so it's the cleanest way, it's the cleanest way to like recapture that value because you're just solely relying on like this auction mechanism working, and you don't have um like an oracle that you're dependent on or something like that.
SPEAKER_04And since they're uh the only like entity that can trade against it, do they like solve like they don't leak much value to like the builders or right?
SPEAKER_00Right. That's the point. Like that's the thing, right? So like all the value captures it from is being that and that's where like AMMs are going. Like all the value is being captured by searchers and proposers, right? And proposers actually don't right now, you're saying. Yeah, right now, and and proposers they capture a lot of MEV from um just like standard ARB, like rebalancing pools and everything, but the percentage that they actually capture from these C5 DeFi ARBs is small, right?
SPEAKER_00They have like less bargaining power in the sense, and so the searchers doing this because like they take on this big inventory risk and everything, um they actually make like a good chunk uh of money from this. And so if you can just shift a lot of that value from like if if you can't ARB the AMM without doing like the auction, it just solves a lot of no, it does seem like it solves a lot of the problems.
SPEAKER_04In like a scenario like the like the BTC scenario, like gapping up, or like something where like in a traditional sense market makers would like widen their spreads or like pull uh liquidity, does it as affect like can it react to to those scenarios or like how what would happen?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's just like it's it's like natural competition. If you only had one person for whatever reason put a bid in, then they would win. But if you if there's a competitive marketplace of searchers that are gonna bid in this auction, um you want to be first in the block, right? And the like the ego that goes to the highest.
SPEAKER_04And what um is like the underlying pool or is it all through this auction mechanism? Like is there like a curve or something?
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, you can still have like an XYK type pool that it's like a side, it's like the the auction value, the pool still gets arbed because it's still XYK, right? But there's like this side, like a tip, right? Like tip your LP. Um and then that goes to them too as kind of like a side piece, right? So if the arbitrage is gonna make a searcher ten dollars, you know, all these searchers that are all trying to ARB this pool are gonna bid close to ten dollars to be the first in.
SPEAKER_00And that's just like a very clean way to um make LPs a little bit better off. Yeah, and I like it without relying on like outside as much outside shit. That makes sense. That makes sense. And like just on just on like they're not charging fees enough, too, though. Like this week Uniswap added 15 bips to their front end, right? And uniswap LP, they charge like one one to five basis points. So that right there, you know, and I think they're on pace for like I if if people actually keep using Uniswap front end like 30 million or something over the course of a year.
SPEAKER_03Traders have shown to be uh not very price sensitive in terms of like retail flow. It's I mean it's the reason MetaMask swaps uh continue to be used quite a bit. Yeah, MetaMask is charging 85 bits. Yeah, it's all airdrop farming, it's not it's not real activity.
SPEAKER_00As a side note though, this is the hardest thing about being an analyst, is that whenever you're looking at data, it's like, all right, is there a token yet? And how do I like adjust for this? Because I remember when I was doing the Wallet Wars report, um, you know, MetaMask has great numbers for their in-wallet apps and everything. But you you know, I think people, I don't know if people are still expecting that though. Uh I think people spent a lot of money trying to get an airdrop there, and I think I'm not sure that's gonna happen anymore.
SPEAKER_02With I think the other cool thing about uh, yeah, so we kind of um landed on improved AMM models and like Oracle models being like some of the most interesting, I guess, forms of on-chain liquidity in the future. I think the other thing that's interesting about the Oracle model is you can really trade any asset, at least with with like uh a G-DIE like gain style model or these like synthetic models. You you can trade any asset without actually having to onboard a market maker to trade it, um, and or like bootstrap liquidity and an LP pool or have the asset on-chain, right?
SPEAKER_02Which which I think is is really powerful. Um and yeah, you you mentioned the Uniswap labs taking 15 bips. Some people were melting down on Twitter about it. Well, does anyone have some any any interesting takes on that? Uh like is anyone super super like outraged by it?
SPEAKER_00I'm not outraged, like they it um so they never they obviously never want to do a token. Like that should kind of that's something to kind of point out is that the only reason I think they launched the token to begin with was because of sushi swap's vampire attack. And this is I this is I guess one of the problems is that you have like equity and tokens in a lot of these protocols. Um and it's just uh like this will just encourage people to use other front ends, I guess.
SPEAKER_00Um you know, just stop using Uniswap front end. You know, I think that I think Uniswap, so my thing with Uniswap is that I'm not even sure that in three years from now people think of them as AMM protocol. Like what they're trying to be is just this consumer finance application. And so that means the front end, it means their wallet, like their app, right? Like go to Uniswap to do literally ever anything you want on chain. Um and especially you know, moving towards Uniswap X, which is small right now, but I imagine it's gonna be used for a lot.
SPEAKER_00And I think Uniswap X is gonna be is gonna kill a lot of these bridge protocols too, okay? Because you can do like bridging, you can do cross-chain swaps with it and stuff like that. And so Uniswap is their their every good application is its front end, like yeah, that is what I kind of think the end state is. So I'm not surprised they did this, I'm not outraged they did it. What ends up happening is that the people who pay this are like new entrants, right?
SPEAKER_00So like the bad, like the the the bad side of it is that the people who get screwed here are like the noobs because they don't like understand it's it's all this stuff that's going on. Like retail unit aggregators.
SPEAKER_01I guess everyone else who's like uni holder from the beginning, they're up massively, even if it kind of keeps trending down, right? Like relative to what they bought in. So it it's irrelevant for them. It's kind of everyone else who who bought in expecting the potential for a fee switch. And and I think this just makes it less likely.
SPEAKER_02It's just kind of you know reflection of of their regulatory risk aversion and and kind of like I mean, I think it's like perfectly reasonable if you run a front end, operate like servers, uh like take the regular like regulatory risk of doing that, that you charge, charge a fee for it. And I think if anything, that should be like the business model for like crypto apps. Like you have sort of contracts at the base layer, and then a bunch of front ends competing to capture user flow and charging fees on top of it. And I'm a big fan of like the liquid and thorough chain model where protocol actually incentivizes people to run front ends.
SPEAKER_02And I think until we have distributed kind of front-end solutions, that's the right, that's the right model. So if anything, I feel like it just creates a bounty to decentralize uh and and to make less people use the uniswap front end, right? To to to kind of yeah, so yeah.
SPEAKER_00To you to Jan's point though, like the uni holders are massively, it's trading at like the same airdrop price. So I I guess you mean like people who got a big airdrop and they're just like committed to or just people who bought, you know, like uh investors are fine.
SPEAKER_01Airdrop holders, I mean, if they held it, I'm assuming very few people have held their airdrop and have traded it, but it's more so just everyone else who bought with some future expectation of a fee switch, which is like a lot of people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I was early, I was early. I just want to say I was early on calling no fee switch ever. Like like four months after they launched, everyone from I was early on that, so I'm taking the W on that one.
SPEAKER_04I think um why I'm would be more why I said I was outraged, is more on the uh like this the whole misincentive or like misaligned incentives between like these companies having equity and token, and it's like kind of and obviously this is like a take from just like a person who likes to invest in like shit coins and is like looking for good investments and like not a legal one at all, because I have no legal knowledge, but it's like more and more teams seem to be launching this way where they have like the equity and the token, and because of regulatory uncertainty, or because they can just like have the ability to like kind of like double dip and in into both, um, just like end up uh just kind of screwing over the token.
SPEAKER_04And I think one, it's like kind of bad for you know, if you truly want some of these protocols to be decentralized of like all the value capture and all the real decisions are being being made at like the equity level, or even with like the Uniswap fee switch, it's like that fee switch vote has been up, I feel like a few times, and like the the retail community like overwhelmingly wants it, but just kind of like the team and the VCs behind it uh you know, like won't allow it to happen. So from that kind of perspective, it's uh you know, a bit disheartening.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it makes sense though. If you think right, like the regulatory risk is is pretty binary to the downside, and then like the the slow rug is basically the upside risk where it's like, yeah, yeah, sure, we'll add value to the token, but like you never really do.
SPEAKER_04I'm not saying it's like not expected, it just kind of sucks.
SPEAKER_02Um I just think though, like if this were uh even if this were like uh a startup, like it wouldn't really make sense to monetize this early, right? You Uniswap is is is what like four, maybe, maybe, maybe five years old now. Um like it's still a market share game. Like, why would that why would they turn on the the the fee switch now? Then they're like crushing it on on every on every metric.
SPEAKER_01Like uni the well part of it is is the whole uh the whole role of the token and its ability to help you gain market share, right? If you use it as an example, but they don't do that right benefit. And have never done that.
SPEAKER_02So like it they don't they don't need to add a fee switch to to the token. They're getting it all all their volume and stuff is organic, all their liquidity is organic. So I just don't see the need to like it would basically shoot themselves in the foot to to appease like token holders short term, assuming we don't think it's the right long-term like move.
SPEAKER_04I'm not even saying that they necessarily need to just like I guess the problem with that is like someone could come in and displace Uniswap like really quickly, and it's like even if they're like dominant market share now, it's like you could just get rugged in the future. Like like Uniswap could not exist in a in like a couple years from now if like someone comes out with a better model. Obviously, they have like a pretty really strong brand and a pretty strong moat uh right now, but uh I think I de I definitely agree with you. Like a lot of these tokens like shouldn't necessarily be distributing revenues from day one, but I think that the ownership between like okay, what is the token entitled to and like what is the equity corp entitled to needs to be you know more clarified um to yeah, I definitely agree with that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, like you don't need to you don't need to distribute anything, but yeah, to Duncan's point, like if there was no Uniswap equity, then yeah, Uniswap's token would probably be trading like four or five times higher, right? Because if there ever if there ever is like distribution in the future, you know it's going to the token. But you you really like nobody really has any idea if uni will be ever be used for anything. Yeah and like that's a problem.
SPEAKER_02I think this this is a situation where like yeah, securities laws actually make sense. Like this was Gabe's tweet last week, right? And I I do think when there's equity and tokens, token holders normally are always gonna get the short end of the stick, right? Because like equity holders have established fiduciary duties, like it's actually a crime if you screw over uh uh you know equity holders in certain ways, whereas it won't be for token holders anytime soon. And also founders and investors generally have a lot more ownership of the equity than they do than they do of the token, just just naturally because of like the distributions.
SPEAKER_02So I in general, like definitely not a fan of the of that model, but worth noting that they started, they were like a pioneer, like one of the early projects where there was really no roadmap as to how to do this stuff, right? And like they've done, yeah. I mean, they're the there's hard to hard to argue they're one of the most successful dApps on chain. So like I don't know, don't don't want to overhate on them. For sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they get they get shit on a lot because they're the most uh successful.
SPEAKER_01Like unfortunately, the nature of crypto is just a lot of anuns on Twitter who it's easy to spew.
SPEAKER_04And it's also just like a perspective thing. Like, obviously, like you know, if you want to try and make money on the uni token, you're gonna be pissed with these decisions. But like, you know, if you're looking from a different perspective, then yeah, you could argue that they, you know, like made a lot of really good decisions.
SPEAKER_03That's just more like their moves are indicating that most of the value of Uniswap is in its brand and in capturing order flow. Unfortunately, the uni token doesn't own the brand.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like you just got screwed as a unit. I'm not sure that's true. Uh that that most of the value is is is there.
SPEAKER_01But well, you'd actually you could also argue that that most of the value of the Uni token is is in the brand, right? There's no actual monetary value of the token.
SPEAKER_02But especially with Uni V4, like they could really become, I think, even more dominant. Like if people start, and we're kind of seeing it on the on the venture side, some of the deals we see coming in that would normally be new AMMs are actually just like hooks on Univ4, right? And I think at that point, with it with a sufficient like network effect of like hooks building in and all the integrations and stuff like that, I think at some point it will make sense to turn on the V switch, even just like I guess I don't know if it's even possible to buy enough tokens to to like outweigh the investors and and early holders.
SPEAKER_02I don't think it is. Absolutely. Which is unpumping their bags.
SPEAKER_00You could you could maybe you know you could maybe use uni as like uh anti-Sybil for solvers that want to solve on Uniswap backs. Like like CowSwap makes cow swap solvers have cow tokens, right? So there's like there's different things you could maybe do with with it besides just pure fee switch. So I mean I think that's one of the reasons why it still trades at whatever five billion or something high.
SPEAKER_04Um we should talk about tokens that are good at some point. So just these equity corporations.
SPEAKER_01Pretty pretty bullish reaction. I think uh it was pretty obvious that it was a fake headline within I don't know, 10 minutes when it was basically just Cointelegraph and and no one else. And um I think it was yeah, it was just clear to see how many people were kind of caught off sides. Um and so it kind of depends on um, I mean, and and now with with BlackRock's date being uh Jan 10th, that's why you see the really higher probability for an ETF by then.
SPEAKER_01Um I think at the very least, you probably see some some front running. Um it seems like BTC is gonna kind of suck up the liquidity in the space as well to some extent, aside from like a handful of coins with strong narratives. So um but yeah, it seems like a lot of people.
SPEAKER_00Okay, this is so the reaction was kind of crazy because it's not just that it was off a fake rumor, it's that it was off a fake rumor where the only organization that reported was Cointelegraph, which like 99%, you're probably sure it's like not fake if nobody else was reporting this, right? Sure, they have two million followers on X.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think algo is well, I'm sure a lot of it was algo driven too.
SPEAKER_02It quickly was was on the Bloomberg terminal though and stuff.
SPEAKER_01But it was a it was a good reaction, like because you we needed that after like the the ETH ETF, uh the futures kind of um how how weak that was. Obviously, it's not apples to apples, it's it's a futures and um it's not spot and it's ETH, but I think you know it was uh a narrative that's certainly going around. It's like all right, there's genuinely very little demand for it. And then I think it was that plus Larry Fink coming out, and and that probably was more bullish than the reaction to the headline. Yeah. So you gotta imagine they're going ham on sales team.
SPEAKER_00That's that's what I'm yeah, that's the thing that people are not really paying attention to is how crazy the marketing is gonna be when these things get approved. Because I've seen Jeff Dorman make this point a lot because they're all there's gonna be like 10 approved at once, and they're all competing for the AUM. You're just gonna be bombarded on every you know, Sunday night football, Thursday night football, uh morning, morning talk shows. Um, they're gonna be going after soccer moms.
SPEAKER_01Like they're yeah, and if you look historically, a lot of these ETFs are are winner take all for the most part. Like if you look, you know, like SPY, GLD, a lot of these big ones are are winner take most. And so it like you're gonna see an an insane amount of marketing because you know getting that market share early on means you're the most liquid and and and there's just reflexivity there. Um yeah, so the marketing marketing dollars will be spent. Plus, you can charge a higher fee, right? You assume it's gonna be a gradual race to the bottom on fees, but early on, every dollar of AUM in these ETFs is gonna be a lot more valuable than a dollar of of uh value in other ETFs because these are gonna be able to charge a much higher kind of management fee on top.
SPEAKER_04No, I definitely think it showed how out of position a lot of people were because I feel like like right before this happened, like the narrative was like pretty peak bearish, especially with like the ETH Future stuff.
SPEAKER_02How are you positioned, Duncan? I thought you were bearish.
SPEAKER_04I I closed my short after the uh after we like nuked 10% that one day, like a month ago. But I still have like a decent amount of cash. And you know, holding all the good money-making coins. But it was it was fun to see. I'm I'm always here for a green candle on Bitcoin. Even if I'm short, I'm happy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean it I think like it's it's clear that BTC obviously still runs the market. And people trying to make it seem like ETH or something can't Yeah, the ETH futures thing is so such a bad take. People want people want BTC, right? Like and then that just has massive follow-on effects for everything else.
SPEAKER_02Like alright, guys. I think that's a wrap. That's a good good episode. Thanks, Matt, for coming on and defending the honor of AMMs. Um you handled yourself very well. Cheers. And yeah, I hope people enjoyed it. And uh we'll try and do these more often now with our improved sound. Uh, hopefully see you again in in in two weeks. Bye. Don't get stuck in fiat. See ya.
SPEAKER_03See ya, cheers.
SPEAKER_02See ya later. Nothing said on the hive mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions. Not financial advice.