In this conversation, the hosts discuss various topics including the ETH ETF, flows data, the recent governance attack on Compound, and the state of the Cosmos ecosystem. They analyze the inflows and outflows in the crypto market, the impact of ETFs on the market, and the challenges faced by Cosmos chains. They also explore the concept of app-specific rollups and the potential of the Initial ecosystem. The conversation highlights the lack of a unified community in the Cosmos ecosystem and the difficulty in expressing a bet on its success. In this conversation, the hosts discuss various topics related to meme coins, NFTs, and the gaming industry. They touch on the success and potential of meme coins like Banana and Trump, the cult-like following of certain NFT collections, and the intersection of NFTs and meme coins. They also explore the role of gaming in onboarding users to crypto and the potential for incentivizing certain behaviors through tokens. The hosts express optimism about the future of gaming and the opportunities it presents in the crypto space. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Discussion on ETH ETF 10:09 Governance Attack on Compound 21:41 Challenges Faced by the Cosmos Ecosystem 30:24 Exploring App-Specific Rollups and the Initial Ecosystem 36:34 The Rise of Meme Coins 38:27 The Cult-Like Following of NFT Collections 39:22 NFTs vs. Memes: Tech and Value 46:59 Banana Listing on Binance 50:43 The Potential and Challenges of Solana 55:55 Gaming as a Gateway to Crypto Adoption 01:00:19 Incentivizing Behaviors through Tokens 01:09:59 The Future of Crypto and Innovation Disclosures This podcast is strictly informational and educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any tokens or securities or to make any financial decisions. Do not trade or invest in any project, tokens, or securities based upon this podcast episode. The host and members at Delphi Ventures may personally own tokens or art that are mentioned on the podcast. Our current show features paid sponsorships which may be featured at the start, middle, and/or the end of the episode. These sponsorships are for informational purposes only and are not a solicitation to use any product, service or token.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_05Hi everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Hive Mind podcast. With us, as always, we have the usual crew, Cetteris, our head of research, Jan, managing partner ventures, Duncan. 100x searcher. 100x searcher. There it is. Um here to I'm sure we'll get some victory laps on banana today. And yeah, we and today, yeah, I think we have a bunch of topics to start off with. Maybe we can start with the ETTF. Much anticipated. We've started to have flows data.
SPEAKER_05What do you guys think? How's it looking? I think we had the first positive inflows day yesterday, right? After a bunch of uh grayscale selling. Yeah, how are you guys feeling about this?
SPEAKER_03What do you I feel like it's been relatively tame? And then we've had the grayscale outflows, obviously. So those seem to be they were they were really aggressive the first few days. Um, they seem to be slowing down a little bit. So I guess we'll start to get it's always hard to tell with the flows when there's so many grayscale outflows because you don't know how much is really leaving, how much is just being put into other uh ETFs. Uh, the first day, there was like this big bitwise, I think it was bitwise, there's like a big bitwise Bitcoin outflow, big Ethereum inflow.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, it kind of looks like maybe there's some rebalancing. People just want to get exposure to if the rule is like you want one percent of your portfolio in crypto and it was all Bitcoin, and now ETH is here, you know, you might just want to market cap weight it, and so maybe there's like some of that rebalancing going on, but uh yeah, I feel like it's been pretty, all things considered, kind of kind of like a non-event. Obviously, it's not a non-event, but um all the macro stuff is kind of down, all the all the macro stuff is kind of overweighed.
SPEAKER_06You always you see the two charts of people like uh tracking percentage of outflows of both grayscale's Bitcoin versus grayscale's ETH product, and um ETH seeing a larger percentage of outflows in the first couple days, which I guess is indicative of more people you know pulling off the carry trade on ETH or a larger share of ETH, grayscale holdings being the carry trade potentially.
SPEAKER_04Um or just like the market was like smarter to just like get out of this quickly.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, but but yeah, like like Sarah's mentioned, hard to exactly uh zero in on where those flows are going, whether they're recycling into the lower cost ETFs or exiting entirely. But yeah, I don't think I've been surprised either way. This is probably roughly in line with expectations.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I feel like what I've been surprised by just from crypto, since the ETFs have launched, I kind of felt like the market would become like more forward-looking. I feel like the crypto market isn't very forward-looking, it's kind of like always like here and now it's happening. Just because like the magnitude of these numbers, like with the Germany stuff, right? Like I was tweeting a lot about that, like the Germany selling, you know, the two billion dollars of selling, like really pushed Bitcoin down, and people were just kind of letting them like completely getting out of the way and selling. And then after they finished selling, like you know, obviously there's the Trump stuff as well, but a few days later, like we popped back up, like basically to to where Germany like started moving coins, you know.
SPEAKER_04Same thing with like the BTC and the GPTC outflows, like people just kind of got out of the way while that happened, and then once they were over, like the market piled back in. I guess I was kind of thinking that since we'd seen it happen before, the market might, I guess, like react differently, but it seems like it's the same thing. It's just since the magnitude of these flows, there's like$10 billion in ET um has to come out. Like the there's I feel like there's not enough capital in this space to like be smart to that. It's just like that's just like a big enough number where people just kind of get out of the way and let it happen, and the market goes down and like everyone knows it's coming.
SPEAKER_04And then you know, once the flow slowed down, we'll probably see some normalization in ETH price, but it's just been like interesting to watch.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think I think like obviously Soul has done really well the last couple weeks, right? And so ETH keeps it keeps like hitting that it's hit this all-time high against ETH like five times now. Um but is that is that is part of that to your point, people kind of getting out of ETH right now as this grayscale stuff goes. Um, and then like when the grayscale stuff stops, are we going back? Because like Sol ETH has kind of just been whipsiing around for like all year, it just keeps going up and down between like 3.6 and 5.5.
SPEAKER_06That applies to, I mean, you also like even BTC, a lot of the stuff is it seems like we need a a real surge in demand to break through kind of the resistance. Yeah, same thing with Bitcoin where it's been pretty range bound since March.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I just think there's like a lot of there's been like such a huge move, you know, in like from BTC BlackRock announced in June of last year, so like more than a year ago, I like 25 K BTC. So it's ran up, you know, 3x, which is like 700 billion or something in market cap. And you know, so that's a lot of I think just digestion that needs to happen in the asset class, and now it's like much more liquid and accessible to these like institutional investors, and I just feel like there's just a churn there, um, just like a period of digestion, and probably the same with Seoul, right?
SPEAKER_04Like Seoul teleported from like 20 to 60, spent like a couple weeks there, and then went from 60 to 120, spent a couple weeks there and then went to 200. And now we've been kind of ranging between 100 and 200 on Seoul. But I think these assets did have pretty insane runs, and you're getting to um the levels of market cap and also overhang from like you know, Bitcoin has all this overhang from like the government and and Mt. Gox and like ETH had all the overhang from the FGX estate.
SPEAKER_04And I just think it takes a while to kind of be digested and work through. It's more of a time thing, I think. Less so um, like I I at some point it's gonna I think we're probably gonna break out higher from this range just because now it's so much more accessible. I was listening to Novogratz on Bankless, and he gives I feel like he's always like really good perspective on kind of like where traditional finances is at with it. I like uh Bitcoin and crypto and is like a good kind of you know take you out of the the micro signal, like kind of the zoomed in crypto sphere that we can kind of get into on Twitter and stuff.
SPEAKER_04But I think this stuff is just taking time for them to like really ramp up the sales team and find their ETF products, and I mean they're still not allowed to pitch them, they're still not allowed to recommend them.
SPEAKER_03So once you get the recommendations, once you get the I mean, I was listening to another Tradfy podcast, like the reform broker, Josh Brown, all those guys. Um, they had like Matt Hogan, Bitwise, um CO on. I think he's the CEO. And they were and these are like TradFi guys, and they're like, Oh yeah, once the once like Morgan Stanley and all these banks are able to pitch it, that probably just sends it right to 100k. And then when it hits 100k, now you have this new psychological number, yeah, right. And these are the trad fi guys that are you know, it's like they kind of understand it's the flow game, and um yeah, and the Bitcoin ETFs have been wildly successful.
SPEAKER_04I think it's like two of the top six ETFs in all of flows. Like, I think IBIT surpassed QQQ and flows, which is pretty insane, right? Like that's what everyone talks about for tech. Um so that's pretty crazy. I just think it's a matter of time thing, and like crypto people like things happening really fast. Um but I think TratFi is just like kind of a slower in this regulation side of things, it's just slower and it's gonna take more time. But I think we're in a really good uh position right now, uh, in like uh like with like a year-long view.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, though the concern was always, you know, what what is the next kind of catalyst after the ETF? And and now, you know, the the previous really outlier event of of governments getting involved in holding this is kind of just becoming a lot more real now. Yeah, that could be huge.
SPEAKER_04Just the ETF like itself, I feel like is just an ongoing catalyst, and then also, you know, it's like if we get to 100k, like there's some point where retail stump comes back in. I literally on the day we topped on Bitcoin on like 72k or whatever, I had I got like three tacks about it. It's just like such like the indicator of like people like that.
SPEAKER_03No, I did too with the meme coin stuff, it was kind of crazy.
SPEAKER_04Literally, the day we topped, I got three tacks. And like people who are like kind of into finance, but like not really. And I was like, like we were so close to like kind of getting that next leg up to like the retail escape velocity, which I think just brings in like a whole new cohort of money and pushes us higher on the alt side of things. So, like, if we get BTC 100k, I think you know we could get that retail wage, yeah.
SPEAKER_03So I guess I mean, I don't know, today it's like Fed has their meeting, they're gonna probably signal that September will be a cut, and then there's been some good macro prints today. Um, so that's probably I don't know, those are like the most important things, I guess, on like the overall macro side of like flows and everything, getting through grayscale and then just like whatever happens here. Do you want to uh you want to move topics from ETTF? Do we want to talk about uh like is it over for Cosmos?
SPEAKER_03Is that where we're going to next?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, we could do that or the compound thing first, whatever you prefer. Um 11% today.
SPEAKER_03The compound dunken, pay attention. The compound thing is like the compound thing is pretty short, I guess. Um, some guy did this governance attack on compound, and he was basically it's humpy, right?
SPEAKER_05It's the same guy that's the balancer attack back in the day.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, maybe you can explain it.
SPEAKER_05Do you have like a good um I don't know if I have a good like I've been yeah, busy today with Cosmos stuff, but basically there was um there's this this humpy guy, he wrote a proposal to transfer some amount of comp from the treasury to a multi-sig uh controlled by him and and some some of his confederates or whatever, some of whom didn't actually even know they're they're on the multisig. And he he tried it once. And the idea, like his or what he's arguing is that he's gonna do this, this like gold comp, right?
SPEAKER_05He calls his his multisig the golden boys, and it's gonna be this gold comp, which is like a yield earning, a yield-bearing comp, which is gonna be put into like this 99.1 balancer pool, which is like 99 uh gold comp and one weath. Um, and so it's gonna be like this yield generating comp. Um it doesn't seem that interesting. Like the this the like it doesn't seem like uh and then basically that that proposal failed, and then he posted a second one for like three times the uh like I think the first one was 92,000 comp and the second one was 500,000 comp.
SPEAKER_05And the first one failed, the second one passed. So it seems like the governors didn't think he'd asked for enough for this.
SPEAKER_06For this there was less participation in the second round.
SPEAKER_05I know, I'm joking. It's just funny, it's just like how it's just governance, right? Um, and and the second one, he basically had this uh multi-sig that apparently has like some limits to what it can do, like you can only deposit or withdraw, it can't like um send send the funds to another round of address. So it's it's sort of like a Borg in in some ways, although like I don't know that it's been audited or the people have looked at it to see what loopholes there might be in in funneling the the compound, but it doesn't seem like a like an all-out rug, like he's gonna transfer this to himself and then sell it.
SPEAKER_05And markets kind of showing that too, like the price is trading roughly where it was before before the governance attack, which is which is kind of interesting. Um, I think that the game is probably just like he can accumulate all the governance power from this um from like the underlying gold comp. Presumably, like other people might deposit as well into this thing, and he he controls all the underlying comp, right, and can vote it and do like all sorts of governance attacks. Um, not sure exactly what he might do.
SPEAKER_05Maybe it's like an activist investor thing and he just turns on the fee switch and does actual cool stuff, or maybe um it could be darker than that. I mean, obviously, this guy owns a lot of comp uh and he's a pretty big whale, so he's sort of incentivized to to not just hack the the the protocol. Um but yeah, kind of crazy that this got through governance and that like the the developers on on Discord were like, Don't at me, bro. Like, that's against the rules, you know, while this while this thing was being passed, and yeah, yeah, that was so there's a few things from this.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, people were in the Discord asking like what was going on, and admins were just saying, Don't ask me.
SPEAKER_04Wait, but I don't even get what the issue is. So he vote himself a Tana Comp.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, he like controls what happens with comp now, and so he is turning on the fee switch, as far as I understand, and he's distributing like the treasury, but it sounds bullish, so yeah, but it's how is it bullish? Because it's not, it's like you're getting this one-time distribution of the treasury, and then comp makes like no money as it is.
SPEAKER_06Money markets are hard to generate a lot of revenue on, yeah. And then I think you know, yes, you know, you you have two sides to this. On one side, he owns so much that you know he's incentivized to do something valuable, right? And and try and and generate value where there wasn't any before because he's got meaningful skin in the game and can actually put through things that that one individual would previously wouldn't be able to because there was pretty well like you know distributed uh governance control, but on the other things that he can adjust are are are um you know like LTV requirements, and so uh the issues there, you you know, as a as a borrower or lender, it's it's kind of off-putting, right?
SPEAKER_06If you you can get kind of liquidated without your control because adjustments can be made quickly, and if you're not on top of things, that's that's a negative towards you. And so I think it probably moves some capital out of that ecosystem until there's additional clarity on what's going forward. Uh yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04How much money, how much money is in the treasury?
SPEAKER_05Um, I think I don't remember. I don't I don't know off the top of my head how much of the treasury. He took a huge chunk of it though, and I think he now controls um like over double the next biggest comp delegate. There's like a chart in um one of Ignis DeFi's posts that's pretty good. Um it's just crazy. This is like the OG DeFi protocol. Um, one of the most like pretty much gave birth to yield farming, and it's in such a state that like this guy can pass a governance proposal granting himself a huge amount of comp and and this thing this thing is.
SPEAKER_03It really was it really was a governance token from like day one.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, he also had like votes delegated to him and stuff. So I'm I'm like some people delegated votes to him, so which is kind of bizarre. And then and there's also a bunch of delegates that just didn't vote. I don't know if they're just like asleep at the wheel or if there's something else a lot of disappathy. I tried to figure out what's going on with this goal comp thing, but it makes sense.
SPEAKER_03I saw this one tweet, and it was basically saying how these big VCs just delegated all their voting power and liability to like these blockchain clubs. And so he was like, I understand why the blockchain clubs aren't voting. Um, also it's like summer, so a lot of these blockchain clubs are like not active right now, like university, so yeah, yeah. So this was kind of like the perfect time to just launch this attack because nobody is paying attention.
SPEAKER_03Um, and let's face it, let's face it, comp is like nobody cares about comp anymore, it's been abandoned pretty much, but it's still$500 million market cap.
SPEAKER_04Like, what the heck?
SPEAKER_03I know, but it's it's basically like Ave is still making. I have not seen one like compound improvement over the past like few years. I'm pretty sure it's just pure maintenance mode. So it's crazy.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, it's it's kind of the issue of of you know the regulatory environment, right? Yes, it it affects startups, but it also affects those that have you know, quote unquote, made made it and and are now in protect my nested mode rather than throw this at the risk of losing everything mode. So it's it's just the incentives are there for the the founders to kind of let it exist and allow the centralized community to do what they want with the with the government.
SPEAKER_05That's literally it, right? Like it's another case where regulate regulations end up creating the worst possible incentives, like the opposite of what you'd want to happen. Um, you know, like ICO is another example, and this is just another one where any entrepreneurial efforts the team makes uh are seen as as like ammo for an SEC case. And so if you already have a bunch of upside, maybe you've taken profit out of comp, like some of these founders and team might might have done, or you you just have like no legal risk tolerance, which is fair enough, if you're in the US and stuff, your incentives to work on this are just completely skewed.
SPEAKER_05And so like users are the ones that that that pay the bill for that, right? Um, and when you can put compound and Ave, like two project, two projects like in the same vertical, started off pretty feature parity. Ave has literally shipped, you know, so much stuff, like continuously shipped new stuff from a stable coin to the safety module to the new version of the safety module to a bunch of markets to deploying on a bunch of chains to like um the you know, their whole bridge, like the portals, like they've just continuously innovated and and and crushed that.
SPEAKER_05I think it's one of the best examples of the DeFi protocol and decentralized like community actually actually succeeding. Uh, and that's like obviously they're all based outside of outside of the US um and have structured things pretty pretty clever, pretty like well by all accounts. So yeah, just another Gensler victim, really.
SPEAKER_03Do you want to? I feel like that's a good transition into what happened today with the terror thing because I saw Gabe make this point that part of like the SEC's strategy is is essentially caused like no one to be able to like work on upgrades or something. Do you know what I'm talking about?
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Um I missed the initial bit. Can you say it? Can you say it again?
SPEAKER_03Uh I gotta find the tweet from but basically it was like so. If I understand correctly, um there's this Terra exploit today. Um, and it's because oh yeah, there's like a patch upgrade, right? And then it kind of like reverted Terra back to like a previous state that like this IBC bug could go through. So here this is what he wrote, okay? He said so. Basically, because the SEC decided the only way for tokens to comply is for no one to work on the system. The SEC shut down TFL.
SPEAKER_03There was no one to patch a well-known vulnerability on Terra, and someone minted Infinite Astro to dump it to Oblivion. That's like that was yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, it's not as as direct as that. I think they basically but like this was an a known exploit in in IBC in April. There was like a bunch of teams working around the clock to to roll out emergency patches to all the main cosmos chains um before like before anyone could could find out and exploit the vulnerability. Uh it's it's a vulnerability in IBC hooks. And what happened was it Terra patched it at that time, but then they did another upgrade in like late June, and basically the exploit went back in in that in that upgrade, um, which is obviously a mistake on their part and and sloppy.
SPEAKER_05But yeah, realistically, like like Gabe said, they're dealing with so much legal, um like they they're handcuffed in so many ways legally, like they're in receivership, they can't take in any money, all their good people pretty much quit. Um you know, or or yeah, so it's it is a situation that's sort of a function of the of the position they're in. Um, but I don't think it's as like they they clearly could patch the the vulnerability, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_05It's yeah, it's it's just a case of like yeah, it's more indirect than that. But yeah, that that sort of moves us nicely to Cosmos capitulation season.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, I feel like people always talk about how like Cosmos is dead and stuff, but there was still a lot of excitement with within Cosmos over the last couple of years, but now you're seeing a lot of people just come out publicly and are like moving to other ecosystems, um are like legitimately just Xing the eco. There's been a lot of you know things come to light that I've seen that I didn't know about the ecosystem before.
SPEAKER_03Um and you know, all these new projects, like Bear Chain, for instance, they want absolutely nothing to do with Cosmos. Like, I don't even know if they're gonna use IBC. Like, I feel like if you use IBC, people, even though IBC is like a good, it's like a great like messaging protocol and everything. But it's like if you use IBC, now people identify you as Cosmos. And that seems to be like a very hard um kind of like brand association to grow out of these days.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, I don't know. It feels like real it feels like real capitulation this time.
SPEAKER_04I feel like I haven't heard anything interesting at Cosmos since Lunar crashed.
SPEAKER_05I mean you you're you're the biggest user of a Cosmos chain called Hyperliquid. Oh like this this is the thing. That's Cosmos? No one, yeah, that's that's Cosmos. Like that that's the thing. I'm I'm very bullish on the Cosmos SDK, um which is used in you know two out of three of the biggest perp decks in in crypto, and I think will continue to be um like used by any team, like the best stack for any team that wants to do app specific stuff on their on their L1.
SPEAKER_05Um and it's also being extended to roll-ups by teams like Dimension and Initia, who we who we invested in. So I'm still bullish on that. I just think that uh like Cosmos community, and that's the thing with Cosmos, like the very token there.
SPEAKER_03There's lots of tokens, everyone made their own token. That's part of the token. Exactly.
SPEAKER_05That that and that's the issue, that's part of the problem, right? Um, I think that that that's part of the problem with with Cosmos is there is no shelling point central token for people to ape. Like it was meant to be Atom, but you know, obviously we we all know what what what happened there. Um, and I just think the the reality is you end up having like deploying an app chain has a bunch of costs. Like I'd say that maybe we can start with the benefits, like the benefits of deploying an app chain are you get to customize a bunch of stuff, everything from like uh MEV to like consensus to like yeah, I mean transaction ordering, what token you pay fees in, like uh privacy stuff.
SPEAKER_05Like there's been a bunch of experiments over over the years in customizing your L1. Um, and then also you get to control your block space, right? There's not an NFT mint that that can that makes your chain unusable. Um, and you have like sovereignty, so the ability to like roll back if if some shit goes down in your chain, um the if there's a hack or something like this, and and all the other benefits of sovereignty. And I continue to think that's like pretty differentiated. Like there's there's sort of Solana if you want to go really fast on a shared state machine. There's Ethereum, like maximum censorship resistance, and then there's like Cosmos for sovereignty.
SPEAKER_05And I think those are the three like L1 sort of like design trade-off, uh design trade-offs that kind of make sense. Um the issue is the cost of deploying an app chain are really big too. Like you have uh the the sort of practical costs of you have to recruit a validator set, you've got to pay them, you have to uh but then there's also stuff like you've got to integrate with wallets, you've got to do RPC stuff, um, you have to like make sure you get bridged assets into your chain. You have to integrate with exchanges if you want, if they if you want to get a centralized exchange listing, it's a new, it's it's a lot of work for them.
SPEAKER_05So there's all these like intangibles that that are that are big costs. Um, and then I think the the biggest intangible cost is this loss of a single community spirit, right? Which is when you launch on Solana, the entire Solana community is bullish on you because if your token succeeds on Solana, it's bullish Solana. There's like another great project on Solana, and and like everyone can can cheer for you. When you launch as a Cosmos app chain, you start at zero, right? Everyone else, if anything, is angry at you because you're you're pulling from the already limited Cosmos mind share.
SPEAKER_05Um, and that's obviously like a feature of sovereignty. Like for DYDX, that that's that's what they wanted. They didn't give a shit about the the the Cosmos users, they just wanted the benefits of of an app chain. Um, and I continue to think like the end game for a lot of stuff is app chains or app specific rollups, and a lot of them will choose Cosmos SDK, but I just don't see I think a lot of Cosmos chains that are kind of undifferentiated um will die, and the community, there is no real cosmos community, like there's no cosmos SDK community, right?
SPEAKER_05Like they're it there's no token, there's nothing to unite them other than the fact that they use this stack. But that's a huge problem.
SPEAKER_03Well, I don't know if that's a problem anymore.
SPEAKER_04What do you mean, kind of? It's clearly been a massive thing. Well, like even if Cosmos is successful, it's like, why are we even talking about it? It's like no, but now it's you can't even make money off it. It's no, but this is the point.
SPEAKER_03Why do we start if it's this is there's no cosmos anymore. Like you're seeing you're there's no cosmos anymore, is this the point, which is probably a very good thing to happen. Like you're seeing I saw the stargaze guy today or yesterday. He was literally he literally was like on Twitter, Stargaze isn't a isn't a cosmos chain, right? Like people are starting to just this idea of like cosmos chains. Yes, there's like IBC, there's this protocol, but yeah, I think Cosmos.
SPEAKER_04As a user, let's take hyperliquid for example. I had no idea it was a cosmos chain, right? It's like EVM, like you use Arbitrum to bridge to it, it's like very fast, and it's gonna have its own token. It has like nothing to do with other than it's like bear chain, right?
SPEAKER_03EVM, it's gonna be EVM.
SPEAKER_05None of this stuff. But this is this is kind of like uh if you're if you're thinking about it in terms of Cosmos SDK, it's it's bullish Cosmos SDK, right? Because unlike Ethereum, which is maintained by like a single foundation, um, and obviously like like researchers and contributors, anyone who uses like Cosmos SDK, uh, like even if the ICF runs out of funding, there's a bunch of like multi-billion dollar chains that are all incentivized to maintain and improve Cosmos SDK as a as a tech stack, right? And so the problem is that Cosmos SDK, we can all be bullish, Cosmos SDK is a tech stack, which I am, without having any way to make money from that, or there being a token.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, it's basically what's what's better for the token number go up versus what's better for the product improving over time.
SPEAKER_05But that's my bull case for initiative.
SPEAKER_03Like I just need new people. That's what Cosmos needs, is like a refreshing of new people. The tech is fine, and it's like you need a lot of people.
SPEAKER_04What are we even referring to as Cosmos? Just this technology chain calls call the map chains.
SPEAKER_05It's so cosmos is a chain that like any a cosmos chain like uses Cosmos SDK and has IBC enabled, I would say.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so it's a small group of developers that care about it. Like, there's no there's not gonna be any big community that care about this thing because it's not this well, it's like a combination of states basically. Yeah, it's it's a bunch of states, but the the thing is but which are competitive with each other, it's like the L2s, it's like Arbitron versus Optimism, but it's just even worse because they don't have anything like they don't have like a central, they don't have any financial incentive alignment.
SPEAKER_03It is I think like the worst it were the worst thing over the I remember over the last couple of years, there's been so many like osmosis versus Kajira, like just back and forth fighting on Twitter, and it's like you guys are arguing over like peanuts.
SPEAKER_04It's yeah, it's like Elton, like at least okay, like at least we're both on ETH, like Fuck Solana, at least Fuck Solana. It's like this is this is just even worse than that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but I know I think the point, I think the point is that these are just gonna be standalone chains that will have nothing to do with Cosmos. I don't even think like hyperliquid does even use IBC, like I don't think so. Thorchain doesn't use IBC. A lot of the most successful Cosmos chains don't use IBC, which is also kind of an interesting side note. Um which again, that has nothing to do. That's not saying IBC is bad, it's not, it's just like for whatever reason you get into this, like you get into IBC, and now this is your liquidity, right?
SPEAKER_03Like, this is kind of what you're dealing with now. You're in this like IBC zone.
SPEAKER_06Um yeah, the issue is kind of like onboarding user sides. What what you gain in in flexibility is you lose in this readily available pool of users and capital that have easy access to to what you're building, which is what you have everyone on one chain.
SPEAKER_04Like, no, like no one's even there, anyways. Sure, we can be bullish the cosmos SDK.
SPEAKER_05Well, I'm this is kind of my my bull case for initial though. Like, I think initial is the original Cosmos like Adam thesis, but built properly and around like app specific rollups rather than L1s, which I think makes a lot of sense. Uh it's basically like a settlement layer for app specific rollups, like interwoven rollups. And like if I had to explain it really simply, I'd say it's like how can you have Solana like UX with a bunch of app specific rollups where it feels like like you're interacting with different app specific rollups, but it feels like you're on one like a single chain.
SPEAKER_05Like a single wallet, like all the bridged assets, like it's it's you you basically like the way another kind of metaphor to describe it is kind of like creating the United States, right? Like you have a bunch of different states, but there's some common frameworks that you enforce. And if you think about it, what what is the stuff that matters?
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's like the Ethereum kind of was always people always said it was like US, and then Cosmos was like EU countries, yeah.
SPEAKER_05But Ethereum isn't Ethereum just isn't doing it, that's which should have been a sign, actually, to be honest, though.
SPEAKER_04But to wait, well, and it should be like a centralized like that. Well, that be ecome like the new atom type thing.
SPEAKER_05Well, in initial initial is like this the settlement layer, so I mean Cedarist wouldn't be wouldn't be bullish on a on a settlement layer, but yeah, it's the it's it's basically being the the settlement layer for all these app specific roll-ups, so similar to what and then they use celestial for data availability layer, but like if you think about what what do you want? You want canonical versions of all the main assets with like deep liquidity on the L1 so that you can take them from one roll up to the other without having like, oh fuck, I have the I have like wormhole ETH and I needed like you know, like native ETH or layer zero ETH here.
SPEAKER_05Like, you don't want to have those issues. You want to be able to bridge between the roll-ups. Um, you want to have a single wallet that that interacts with all of them and gives you a good UX, good access to the apps. So it's like solving all these, it's like a mixture of technical problems and and UX problems and trying to create this like interwoven roll-up ecosystem. And then Initias kind of like the shelling point asset and also ecosystem that everyone likes so that you have this dynamic where you have a community that's bullish on on like in it and it's bullish on all the all the projects that that launch on it.
SPEAKER_05Um and like yeah, you you you just want to make the cost of because I think app specific roll-ups make more sense for for a lot of use cases, like even the Solana maxis are increasingly admitting that like synchronous like atomic composability doesn't matter that much.
SPEAKER_04Um can't you do an app roll-up on Solana? Like an app, like can't you do a roll-up on Solana?
SPEAKER_03Um people will be doing that. Yeah, people will be doing that.
SPEAKER_04When is Solana gonna have a good perp stack? It's like what the fuck? That's been a long time coming on that. Like, how does how does Cosmos have hyperliquid and do IDX V4? That's pretty good.
SPEAKER_03I mean, app chains the one thing appchains have proven that they're good at is perp decks. Because you really don't because you don't need to deal with bridging assets like you do with spot exchange, you just need one asset, you just need USDC. Um, and then you kind of just don't want anyone fucking around with your block space, right? Yeah, like and so it makes a lot of sense for a pure trading protocol to be uh burp decks.
SPEAKER_05So far though, right? Like the reason hyperliquid can move so fast um and and like offer such a good X everything from like the way they were bridging from Arbitrum initially is is because of the flexibility of like owning your entire tech stack, and like ambitious teams will always want to or maybe that that's that's a bit of a strong statement, but a lot of uh ambitious teams will want to own their entire tech stack, like we've seen it already with the hyperliquids, dy dx's, um, like step-ins uh of of this world.
SPEAKER_05And I think you'll continue to see it. And it's just what is the ecosystem that's best positioned to absorb those teams? Right now it's cosmos. I think over time uh initial will will kind of steal or steal some market share there where you'll want to want to launch as an app specific roll-up on initial rather than as an app chain on Cosmos SDK. And the idea is that you can also like customize these app chains using Cosmos SDK, you inherit IBC and a bunch of this, a bunch of this other stuff. So I'm still I still believe in the thesis.
SPEAKER_05Uh, I just don't think there's a good way to express a bet on it, uh, in the other than like so something like initial, basically. Yeah, that's the tough thing.
SPEAKER_04So let's wait on the case.
SPEAKER_03Oh no, bad kids is like the only Cosmos asset I still feel like are worth holding. So which one? NFTs, bad kids.
SPEAKER_01NFTs still bad kids have done, they've held, they've like it's not bad.
SPEAKER_06The problem with like NFTs is if so few make it, it really makes the appeal of taking bets really show.
SPEAKER_04This is actually a good thing to talk about. NFTs versus meme coins. This is how I felt about meme coins last cycle when NFTs were blowing up, and I was like, This is stupid, I'm not touching this shit.
SPEAKER_06I bought one, which is like I just yeah, yeah, it's getting in and out of NFTs is so much more of a yeah, there's way more friction.
SPEAKER_04There's way more friction, but you could also say that there's like an element of like there's more of a social element to them.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's also like, but the thing is, using a PFP used to be like a flex, and now it's embarrassing. Like if you're on Twitter and you've got like a board ape or like a D god or something, it's like I think the the Malayides I can't say why are you saying it like that?
SPEAKER_06Why are you saying it's like have you never heard it said out loud? I have, but I haven't saying it. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04I mean this is how I felt about in 2021, 2022. This is how I felt about RMT. Like these are so fucking stupid, these aren't gonna exist. And now I feel like they've completely died. Maybe they'll come back, but it's kind of I feel like the same thing as meme coins. A lot of them say F as well. ETH, no, I say ETH. Leto, yeah. Leto's fanful one, yeah. Um Retiredio. I I'd buy some of I'd buy one of those.
SPEAKER_03I mean, the ladies are like an entire eco, it's it's not just uh PFP.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think the only collection I feel like is still kind of around and then NFC's, yeah.
SPEAKER_05No, the Pudgy Penguins are doing doing pretty cool stuff, building a consumer brand. I know like Azuki's doing a raise right now, uh Doodle Doodles did a big raise back in the day. I think Doodles raised it like 750 million.
SPEAKER_06None of those raises have turned out well. So what are you to see the I mean I saw this tweet the other day raise go through? I'm sorry, the Pudgy Penguins raise. Like I guess you know it's one of the more thriving communities, but after seeing how many swings and misses there were at raising uh really large vows to fund communities, which a lot of stuff seems super wasteful. Doesn't Apecoin incredibly wasteful.
SPEAKER_05So listen now, yeah, but that's an idea.
SPEAKER_03But let's talk about Abe though. Let's talk about them though. They raised 450 million dollars. Okay, 450 million dollars. Do you understand how much good you can do in the world? Like literally anything else that money could go towards, and that's so much money, that's like half a billion dollars. It is insane. Um, it's just like hard to wrap your head around the fact that 450 million dollars went to board ape eco monkey ecosystem.
SPEAKER_04It's like no, but this is like what the heck honestly, like what this is yeah, okay. What's this whole thing about like 2021 was a hell of a drug though?
SPEAKER_05There wasn't that wasn't the only uh yeah, yeah, there's a lot of super dumb thing to raise 450 mil with dust in 2021.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, what what were all these like uh like everyone's talking about these meme coins as like cults and that's why they're bullish. I don't really I'm not really sure I'm following. Everyone's there just to make money. Is anyone there really for like I could kind of see the like the malady people as cultish, but that's like the only one where I feel like those guys are like kind of like no, there are people that like really care about there's a few collections.
SPEAKER_03I mean in Solana, it's like people there's a lot of people that feel the way about mad lads. Um, you know, there's there's malades, there's penguins, like there's people that rock the penguins for like a few years. Um, I thought there's genuinely people that will never sell, man. There's people that round trip all their board apes. Like, this is a thing that's happened. Like, people do really become attached to these communities, it but it's just it's not necessarily bullish just because there's like a few people that are like that.
SPEAKER_04Um, I'm gonna see what the Malady chart is, but they keep on launching these like derivative collections. Well, they're not always launched by them, they're like third parties, and then it's like aren't there like three now?
SPEAKER_03There's a bunch, well, but it's like shizzo posters or like a derivative by somebody else. Yes, I don't know how to say it.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, I think NFTs are just an inferior way to get beta on crypto compared to memes. There's like less liquid, harder to buy, harder to sell. Um, maybe it's easier to tell like some techno optimist story about them being disruptive and like everything is gonna be an NFT and all this compared to meme coins, which are just like pure uh pure like financial nihilism. You know, NFTs, you can tell like a little story about how this thing is gonna become a huge brand and and everyone's gonna want to, you know.
SPEAKER_05I heard uh an unnamed person that will that will that I will not name say that uh quite famous say that punks were gonna be worth a billion dollars, like one punk was gonna be worth a billion dollars one day, like with 100% certainty. Back in yeah, I think that narrative kind of died in 21 for the most part.
SPEAKER_04Quite famous.
SPEAKER_06The the art on these schizoen much of the the that narrative come back since since 21.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean punks are like 25 ETH now. It's just like if you look at the punk chart, it is it's actually accelerated recently, so it was kind of trading in like this so from the end of from Jan 22 all the way until Jan 24, so like two years, it basically just ranged between like 50, 65 ETH. And if you look at the chart from Feb of this year, it's basically a straight line down below 25 now.
SPEAKER_03Um, yeah, it's like where does that calling bottom on a JPEG is tough. It's it's like yeah, it's when because it's honestly just meme coins cannibalize all the demand and and on on both ends, right?
SPEAKER_06On the on the early side, right, you have the ability to buy into some meme at 500k and sell it at five mil, and there's a whole cohort of people that do that. There's a whole cohort that are trying to do like the 10 to 100 trade, and then there's a bunch that that so like you know that that's on the lower end and the higher end. If you're if you're swinging a lot of money around, it's really hard to get size on and like there are derivative exposures to NFTs where you can do some kind of like leverage trading, but because it's it's really clunky and and not as liquid, the the larger players are also prefer to do uh the like you can do perps on memes.
SPEAKER_06And so I think they just cannibalize every stack, every part of the kind of uh the the stack of of kind of users, both on the lower and the higher end, and just makes trading NFTs a lot less interesting. And yes, you do have the supply sync element of the of the um the die hards that that are built a story around the NFTs, and that's just like part of the equation. You you also need this very speculative element, and so I think what they gain on the narrative side because of the uniqueness in the story you can tell on the NFTs, you lose massively on the liquidity and and and ability for for traders to just participate in that ecosystem.
SPEAKER_05I think the flexing was real, though. I and I do think there's something interesting probably going to be found at the intersect of this like NFT meme coin thing, you know, like the what was the thing that launched a few months ago? Well, that's yeah, that's what I was gonna say. I like that too.
SPEAKER_06We're being able to kind of like trade a certain amount of tokens. It was like uh what it was something defrogs with the second one. What was the first one?
SPEAKER_03I don't know but like what it was it was ERC404, right?
SPEAKER_06Yeah, you can convert a certain amount of of your meme coin into an NFT, which I thought made a lot of sense. The problem was you had like the the constant re-rolls, and so everyone would trade back and forth.
SPEAKER_05And I think the the the approach made sense because I agree the the flexing element is something that you can't really do on a meme coin digital flexing is is a big market in the same way that IRL flexing is a is a big market, right? Like every luxury good is an IRL flex. And I think people spend more and more time digitally, they're gonna spend more and more time um in these like they're gonna be more and more interested in flexing digitally too. Yeah, and in the in the metaverse, uh I I agree. I mean in the in the in the metaverse, it's already a thing though, right?
SPEAKER_05Like in Yeah, Fortnite skins are huge, man. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04CSGO skins, it's huge.
SPEAKER_05Ghostkins, yeah, and those are the real metaverses right now, right? Fortnite has like yeah, I think 700 million.
SPEAKER_06There's lore behind that stuff, right? I think that's that's part of it, and and a reason for there's you had to do something in order to get that rather than just purely deploy a bunch of money or or be early and buy it for cheap. You actually have to earn some of the stuff which makes sense.
SPEAKER_05I don't know if you guys read that interview with Neil Stevenson and and uh and the Epic Game CEO like T Tim Sweeney. It's just really interesting. Like the Epic's pretty much building out kind of like the crypto vision of the of the metaverse. They also address crypto in there and and and whether it's necessary to make this to make this happen or not, but they're pretty much building out the like this open items. Um yeah, they do say yes. Uh definitely new neil stevenson is is very bullish, right? He's building uh a project in crypto, um, which actually sounds pretty interesting.
SPEAKER_05And I think Tim Sweeney is is uh is is relatively bullish, I would say.
SPEAKER_04Um yeah, it's yeah. Well, I think like CSGO skins, like honestly, like you join a lobby, you have like a nice skin, like one of these knives or guns, because you can like drop them and like give them to other players to like look at, like people and there's like voice chat people like, oh my god, man, that's sick. It's like Fortnite, you can't really talk to people as much.
SPEAKER_05I mean, like there's every game had that, right? Like the party hat and RuneScape. Um, and but but a lot of the a lot of the most flex stuff is earned though, right? Rather than kind of paid for in all these games. It's like the stuff that you really need to work hard.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, even like back in like flaming skulls and halo, all that stuff. But yeah, exactly. That's what I was saying the earlier, you think you have to earn it, and it was a product of of accomplishment rather than just capital.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, I do think like in the same way, like uh Noor for all their that they had this like cool idea of NFTs being like moments from highly competitive games that then become like memorialized and imbued with meaning, but for from that, like for instance, uh owning Habib's gloves or whatever, right? Like I went to this charity auction in in Dubai and some guy paid like 60k for Habib's uh MMA gloves, right? And cool, yeah.
SPEAKER_05And it seems like if that were an item in in some metaverse or in Fortnite that I could take in to show that I owned Habib's gloves, it would be worth more, right? Like to and it's clearly worth a lot. There's a lot of stuff that's like there's a lot of examples of stuff like that, and I think there will be a lot of examples of like digital stuff like that too. Um, I just don't know about like starting a collection with some art that you think is cool and then trying to take that into a brand seems like hard. I think the closest people to doing it are probably the Pudgy Penguins, you know. Lucas and the Pudgy Penguins team have done the best job of it.
SPEAKER_05Um, I think the ape stuff is pretty cringe and like punks have kind of not done not done too much, but uh yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but speaking of meme coins, banana got listed on Binance the other week, which is pretty big.
SPEAKER_03Do we want to do we want to talk about all this talk about like the radium webs on an immediate cutoff on that?
SPEAKER_04That's a big deal, Cedarus.
SPEAKER_03As a banana holder, you should we're gonna talk about an exchange listing, like who cares?
SPEAKER_04The first liquid one of Binance of the Cycle, I feel like other than Tau, but Tau is like billions and billions. It's it's a it's an against the low float high FTV meta, Cedarist. We're we're bringing back the reasonably valued coins.
SPEAKER_03You are a scholar and a Saint Duncan. You are really out here just helping the people avoid the low float high FTVs, just very selfless.
SPEAKER_04I literally was going back to my tweets. I tweeted about the meme coin and all the like literally right at the top of meme coins. I was like, Yeah, yeah, you didn't just too many launching. Yeah, I literally I looked, it was a week before we were also bearish at the bottom, though.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you've just always been there, and some of them are still doing well, like some of them are still doing okay. But I think you have seen a little bit of a shift, at least in I think you've seen some more like non-memey stuff from dogs.
SPEAKER_06Yes, there has been a shift.
SPEAKER_04Banana versus all those meme charts is still so who is that? That was someone from labs, that was Kevin put in that poll. I'm winning that bet. I he said, What would you rather own, banana or like an equal weight of like the top six memes? Bananas, yeah.
SPEAKER_06I mean, most of them it's just like the the the takeaway is there's a certain threshold where if your edge is below that threshold, you should go banana, and if your edge is above that threshold, whose edge whose edge is above that threshold? Everyone in our chat, like like in like I think you have to be really damn good to I mean I mean edge being like are you just there's a bunch of people all all meme coins, yeah. But like are you aping all meme coins in random size, or is there are you are do you have some you know sizing that actually where you're you're allocating to the outperformers?
SPEAKER_03I don't think I've actually ever sold a meme coin for like profit. And I like had and yeah, I'm just it's like I don't know why I keep sold any it's like that it's like that it's that it's that meme from the Sopranos. Like just when I thought it was out, they pull me back in.
SPEAKER_06Like I just keep uh it's I don't put a lot of I mean I've definitely recycled meme coin profits and then ended up being down into other meme coins, but I've no I legit Trump Trump is you definitely sold something for a game. Yeah, Trump is probably my big my only big winner.
SPEAKER_01No, I brought I bought the I bought the Trump made sense.
SPEAKER_04The DJT Trump made sense.
SPEAKER_06All right, what's even what you let's talk about WIF has been a great trading one because it's it's usually gone on on runs, yeah. Where it's like the if it's when it chops every five-10 percent, it's really hard to trade.
SPEAKER_03But when it goes on these let's talk about like salon liquidity, I guess. Like to end this. We still have what I want to do. This is on the main point thing, so we can talk about that.
SPEAKER_05One last point, maybe on Cosmos before we get run to that. Uh Cosmos. ICF, ICF. What do you think the treasury of the ICF is like? Maybe you, Duncan, before you Duncan doesn't even know what the ICF is. For fuck's sake, that's true.
SPEAKER_03I think your point, I think your point about like though like Cosmos being this everybody is incentivized to work on it is not true because it's only the ICF that like maintains anything going on with Cosmos, and it's kind of has this tragedy of the commons thing where dude osmosis does does like uh I there's like a few.
SPEAKER_05There's like a few.
SPEAKER_03There's like a few. There's a few, but it's like most chains, most chains are just like, yeah, skip to so much, and they're like not they they don't reap any of those benefits, which is kind of like unfortunate. Um yeah.
SPEAKER_05I mean the SCF has has like uh from when I last checked, something like 400 million dollars in various assets. Um that they could like they could they those assets like that deployed intelligently could make a huge difference to to cosmos. And like I do think there's uh I'm actually right.
SPEAKER_04What does that even mean? Cosmos as in what the technology?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think you would I think you would basically um yeah, you you need more chains connected to IBC. Like the the interchain economy is like every chain that's connected to IBC, and I think there's and then you need to make the UX really seamless, like you need to do what what Initi is trying to do, like make the UX of using all cosmos chains super seamless, like fun things like bridges from from Ethereum, like UX aggregation layers. Um, like there's a bunch of other stuff you could do, like make Tendermint faster. Like people have been telling me for a year and a half, like, oh it's like it's it's it's trivial to make tenderment faster.
SPEAKER_05It's like just fucking do it then. There's literally nothing higher leverage than making this thing like faster, you know. It's like a consensus algorithm from from from like Astria generations ago.
SPEAKER_03Astria is doing what two second block times with with uh yeah.
SPEAKER_05I mean, say is doing sub sub one second, right? But that's like uh co-located validators, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um, I mean, listen, that's better than like a single sequencer, but yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, anyway, I don't think you're gonna go with Solana. Wait, let's do Trump because this is a good this is a good tie-in because I think Jan initially talked about Cosmos to Trump at four dollars. No, I'm just saying for the more than that. I think it was four, but it on the podcast probably I think it was like two or three.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, Jan talked about it pretty early when I was like I thought it was four when when I thought we I thought it was four.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it was early in that, I think. Yeah, so it would have been in Feb February. Okay, I I'm gonna go with four. It's at five fifty now. Are we buying? Fine, three and a half. We'll meet halfway. Three and a half. Are we are we rebuying at 550 before the election? It it ran all the way up to 17, and then had a bit of a pump on this assassination attempt, but sold a lot of people look like they use it as exit liquidity.
SPEAKER_06They're uh they so part of the barrier to getting on exchanges was the the tax or that has a one percent transfer tax that they've been using to donate and to bolster liquidity, basically. Um, and that was you know strong kind of narrative behind uh there actually being some good public-facing outcome from a meme coin. Um so what they've done, they've they've created basically a a bridged version to allow uh assets to move on to sexes without hitting that one percent tax.
SPEAKER_06That was an issue for exchanges, that was an issue for some market makers. So I think what that's gonna lead to is some additional uh sex liquidity, which is you know needed if you look at kind of what has allowed meme coins to go beyond the uh low bid nine figs is is those listings and the access that they provide. And so I think that that's gonna be the fuel for the next leg up. That plus like the probability of of you know the Trump campaign coming out.
SPEAKER_05Bear in mind, Jan's bags are are too big to ever sell, uh but and he will never be bearish.
SPEAKER_06I'm I'm going down. I know, but question or out up to Valhalla.
SPEAKER_04But it's like November's the election, like we're getting kind of close. Like, do you think this thing exists with any attention beyond the election? Like, if he even if he if he wins, why not? I guess he's gonna be bullish crypto. Yeah, I guess if he wins, but there's no like catal. Like, what are the catalyst? Like, the election is such an obvious catalyst, and that's why I like this trade like from the beginning. It's like, oh, this is a the election and all these events leading up to it. It's like so and like the betting odds, like so many catalysts now.
SPEAKER_05I can't believe we're discussing this like catalysts for the for a meme coin trade on high. This is not what I expected when we when we set out to do the hive mind.
SPEAKER_04I'm just trying to embrace the culture. I'm happy to never talk about meme coins on here. We can just talk about banana, the godfather meme, yeah.
SPEAKER_06Um, do we think it's just like a mind share bet. Okay. And and if he's an office in bullish crypto.
SPEAKER_04We're talking about stuff that matters, things we can trade, Jose. You're talking about tech stacks.
SPEAKER_06This is you can argue that this is more useful for our audience.
SPEAKER_05I cannot.
SPEAKER_06Exactly.
SPEAKER_05I can argue, but I won't. Um all right. We want to do the Solana uh, do we want to keep going?
SPEAKER_03We've already, I think, recorded for like an hour. Okay. I'm down.
SPEAKER_04I want to hear the Solana thing.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Well, did you see the all the stuff that was coming out?
SPEAKER_04So basically, yeah, people are just being like, it's meme coin.
SPEAKER_03People are launching, like, you know, no, that's not these.
SPEAKER_04Wait, wait, wait, wait. Tether announces 5.2 billion in profit for first half of 2024. Let's go. Yeah, bid.
SPEAKER_03So there's like a lot of these, um, there's a lot of wash trading, right? So people have been talking about like Solana Dex volume a lot and how it's like 50%. Even we've talked about that too, right? In some reports. Um, it's like 50, it's basically even with Ethereum now. Um, but yeah, there's a good amount of volume that is these people launching these meme coin rugs, and so what they do is they launch like a meme coin and then they just do a shit ton of like wash trading back and forth. This shows like a lot of volume, right? It's kind of like a marketing strategy in a sense, is like, and these the the amount of fees they're paying for all these pools is like 20-30k at a time, so it's obviously profitable to like keep doing this to like kind of get attention, and then basically they like rug these or whatever, okay.
SPEAKER_03Um, so there's like a good uh there's a decent amount of rating volume that is like those kind of scams. Um, but it's like people just take it to such an extreme and then just come to the conclusion that it's like a house of cards on Solana because it's like some people are launching meme coin rugs, and it kind of just reminds me of like why criminals use Bitcoin over Monero, you know, even though it's better. You would think it makes more sense to use like Monero, right? The reason why people and launch like meme coin rugs on Solana is because everyone is using Solana, and it's like that's where all the money is, that's where you can actually like successfully launch rights, right?
SPEAKER_05The scammers are here. This is mainstream adoption.
SPEAKER_03It's like it's just a byproduct of a permissionless system, right? Like, this is what we're dealing with. These are yeah, you know, these are blockchains. Listen, like I don't think anybody obviously some people think meme coins are like great and they're this you know amazing thing, whatever. Most people think meme coins are kind of dumb and they're not like quality assets, but I actually think most people within crypto are starting like almost everyone I talk to is like bullish meme coins. Okay, but they're bullish, like maybe the prices of them, but do they think they're like important, right?
SPEAKER_04The price difference, the price. Okay, true.
SPEAKER_03Whatever, whatever, whatever. I guess my point is like people, you know, the Solana critiques, they just like keep there's just new qualifiers all the time. Like the more, like, the more and more like success the eco sees, the more and more developers it gets. Like, this is just like a snowball that like keeps going, and it was a year ago, Solana had zero users, zero deck, zero dex volume. I mean, when I wrote about Solana, it was it went over half a year with not one million dollar on-chain trade.
SPEAKER_03Okay, really, so you can't, yeah. So you can't tell me that like it went from it, it literally was kind of a house of cards with SPF, right? And like serum being the core pillar there, and it did collapse, right? Like it literally did collapse, the house collapsed and went to literal zero, nobody used it, was for all intents and purposes basically dead, and now it does just as much volume as Ethereum. And you're gonna tell me because like 20% of the volume on radium are these people launching these rugs that it's just like a house of cards again that's going to zero.
SPEAKER_03Like, people just don't like you gotta you're missing the force for the trees, right? Yeah, like you're not really that's it.
SPEAKER_06It's like it's uh it's just showing that it can be used, it's being used because it works well to to facilitate trades quickly.
SPEAKER_04When are we gonna get some payments? Like, let's get something fucking real. Like, what are the tangible, close, real things that are are possible? Let's let's end off on an optimistic note. Payment. Um, this RWA stuff. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03I think I think Footarchy is cool, and yeah, own meta disclosure.
SPEAKER_04Uh oh, he's gonna bring that up during the comp proposal. Future archy figure.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it would have been a good because all you need with Footarchy, you don't need a lot of people paying attention to governance, you're basically just making governance and arbitrage market.
SPEAKER_04People are incentivized too because they can make money off of it. This is a meta DAO on salon.
SPEAKER_03That's like the that's like the point of it. They just yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_06But it's it's a band-aid for a I guess in this scenario, the the problem is is more so a DAO that's been abandoned and a protocol that's been abandoned, rather than something that's thriving and in a thriving scenario where the the the governance doesn't work even if it's thriving and everyone's paying attention, that you need something like this. This is more of a this is abandoned and can get hijacked, and so it would work well to solve that issue, but ultimately the problem isn't the governance design per se, it's more just the fact that no one's paying attention.
SPEAKER_04Well, I think it's just like even if a smaller amount of people are paying attention, like the market, like if there's an incentive to make money, it it de facto brings more attention to it, right? Yeah, like if I yeah, like it it de facto. So no, there's that.
SPEAKER_03There's also there's like there's like some mineral trading thing, trading like mineral rights. Seems kind of interesting going live on Solana called Elements. Um oh really that's kind of cool.
SPEAKER_04So I can buy like gold rights under the ground. I actually looked at doing that in Canada. You can buy you can buy like the mineral rights, yeah.
SPEAKER_03So it's called Elements, but I think it's like uh MNTS. Um, like that's how it finishes. I haven't looked too much into it, I've just seen a few people talking about it.
SPEAKER_04Um yeah, yeah, and wait, so where is MetaDAO right now? Because it honestly is a cool like product for governance.
SPEAKER_03IOS well they just finished their raise. Well, I mean, they just finished their raise, they raised like 2.34 mil, so that gives them like two years of runway. Um and then yeah, I'm assuming they'll announce something. I mean, they announced that they finished the raise, they didn't announce anything else about it, um, like the price they sold at or anything. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so we have payments, the future archy, which I don't know, maybe we could link an article in the show notes for people to read how it works.
SPEAKER_05But I don't think that's uh yeah, I mean the I think they'll have the provenance. RWA or stable coins, um DeFi and like speculation and decentralized speculation infrastructure, I guess.
SPEAKER_04Um I'm thinking new ones like paying. Oh, new ones have haven't really happened.
SPEAKER_05Gaming, I'm really so like we I don't think we can talk about it yet, but we've uh done one that Piers and I have been playing over the last few weekends that I think could be the one. And admittedly, I've uh said that maybe said that before, just once though, I think, to be fair. Um, but yeah, this one I think is like a world-class level shooter, like competitive with Warzone type of thing, with a really well-designed crypto economy on the on the back of it.
SPEAKER_06Um, huh? Um, and really good first player lore building that yeah.
SPEAKER_03I mean, if you guys are gonna you guys can't tease it this much if you're not gonna talk about it.
SPEAKER_05Uh yeah, we get we'll we'll we get we can't. We will we will next episode, probably. Probably next episode we can talk about it. And it's it's gonna be on Steam, it's gonna be yeah. I I do think we're gonna get one, uh, and I think gaming is the most likely way that we onboard um like millions of users, and like the I think the only evidence you need is like crappy games and like tapping, tapping your phone scams onboard tens of millions of users. So, what what's the real sorry?
SPEAKER_06I feel like you've been the most bearish gaming on our side from the venture perspective.
SPEAKER_05Well, I've I've been bearish us continuing to plow ridiculous amounts of money into gaming, considering it's gonna change the world.
SPEAKER_06I mean, we've had we've already had a bunch of good outcomes.
SPEAKER_05So if we didn't have, yeah, but we we had even without that.
SPEAKER_06I I we we still definitely have a bunch of good outcomes. So I think you're you're kind of over-indexing for that and and making that the basis for your bearish. Sir, this is venture.
SPEAKER_05I just we just get a lot, we we've just done a lot of gaming investments and a lot of money to get I feel like if that sector does well, we're gonna we're gonna be set anyway. And it's like I just don't feel like every we need to do every second deal as a game.
SPEAKER_06We don't need to bring the five ventures drama into the into the hive mind here. Well, I mean you can't you can't like take both sides of the of uh you can't I'm votable doing the public victory labs.
SPEAKER_04Well in the ice. Yeah, exactly. Well, like this thing isn't even live.
SPEAKER_05I hope it's a victory lab. No, I'm I'm I'm I've always been fucking bullish gaming, otherwise I wouldn't have uh I voted yes on most of the you're also outvoted if if you're the only one that's bearish on a certain deal. Yeah, well let's see the the the the deals that I that I voted no on. Um I'm definitely bullish gaming. I think it's the most likely way that we get a bunch of users into crypto. Um and I'm bullish this game specifically. Uh yeah, so I'm excited about that. Like other ways, like D Pin, I think could do could could do some some this could be a really good way of getting.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so on D Pin actually, one thing I saw that Ryan, what's his name? Ryan Beckman's or Berkman's or whatever. He talked about this whole Solana thing, whatever it was his Ethereum, but one thing, one thing he wrote in that is how like Solana embraced these things that a lot of like Ethereum leaders just said were straight up scams, right? And like D Pin was one of them, and I find that such an insane. Insane take to have after like a year, I mean, of D Pin or a year or two of D Pin's existence, because it's kind of like if we're not creating things that actually impact the physical world, it's all just like a massive self-referential system.
SPEAKER_03And so I do think like Solana, that's another thing, is they took D Pin, they became people associate D Pin with Solana now a lot, even though it's not all on Solana or anything. Um and yeah, I'm excited about to see a lot of like what comes out of the sector. I do think it's if we talk, we're talking about like there's no quality assets to trade. Um, you know, obviously you can put like funds like you know, money markets and all that stuff on chain. I find that kind of boring. Um, but this is one way to get some new kind of like quality assets.
SPEAKER_03There will be, yeah, there will be a few on the RWA stuff.
SPEAKER_04Like, you could put some interesting stuff on chain, like secondaries of like cool companies, like SpaceX or something, that would be really cool. Like that, that could be interesting. The other thing I think is could be cool is incentivizing certain behaviors, like kind of like the D-Pin stuff, but like we've seen it with the clicker games, like incentivizing like social media engagement and followers, but like you could take that to a whole nother level, incentivizing certain behaviors. I'm trying to think of a good example. I had one in my head, but but basically incentivize oh, like the world coin, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Like the world coin is like, okay, like we're giving you airdrop to go scan your eyes for something that could be much bigger. Obviously, that's just like one example, like incentivizing human action with these like new coins that you just like spin up out of nowhere and like giving your users like equity in the company. It's like a way to distribute, like, is if you had a startup, like get a bunch of customers for for giving away in return for equity, which is really cool.
SPEAKER_06No, I mean there's a lot of possibility there, the whole token route, right? Uh, like on the the DeFi side, I think one of the things it's discovered is it's really hard to make it so that what you incentivize is more valuable than the incentive because someone else can kind of go and spin up something comparable and try and undercut you or something like that. And so it it it it it creates issues on the sustainability front. Um, but the the deep inside where you have network effects, I think, is is a is uh is definitely an interesting one and and uh incentivizing basically the funding of of hardware that that creates a network that otherwise couldn't have existed.
SPEAKER_04Network effects and also like uh scalability and like more users, right? Like DeFi, they're all kind of fighting over the same capital and users, where it's like if you take this out of the just the crypto world into like anyone can do this, then like your cost per acquiring user or capital probably goes way down, right?
SPEAKER_06Because like people do stuff not even knowing returns, right? On like the DeFi side, think you have like diminishing economies is like diseconomies of scale, whereas on on things like deep in it it's it's more valued in terms of it being a network which has economies of scale, yeah, up until a certain point, and then like this economies.
SPEAKER_04What would be cool, I think, is like if you think about like Balaji's like network states where he talks about um like whatever the sh I think he gives an example of like the sugar-free or like the carb-free like network state, like you could probably start doing that through some sort of token and then like have people send in their blood work to like prove that they're not eating any sugar or something, like and then like start creating like a cult of people who are like against this one thing and then like prove it somehow. Um with that, like I feel like you could get really creative in the future to try and like incentivize a community or like create a community to to do a certain action, anyways.
SPEAKER_04There is there's more than I think people realize, it's just probably a bit further away than than we think, like Bitcoin and like that getting adopted. Like we're talking about, like the former president of the US is talking about buying it, it's like right here, right now, on like an institutional and potentially like governmental level. I even though I think that's still probably a few ways ago, a few, um you know, probably pretty unlikely right now. But that's at least like in the conversation, whereas like all this other crypto stuff is like there's ideas that make sense, it's just like still so far away, even like the payment stuff, right?
SPEAKER_04Like the payments has made sense for so long, it's gonna happen on blockchains eventually. It's almost like certain it just makes so much more sense, but we still don't have like a widely used payments app. So, anyways, there's definitely lots of opportunity, just the market's getting a lot more saturated, yeah.
SPEAKER_05So you just have to be yeah, I feel like we should wrap this up. Should we wrap? Yeah, I feel like we're we're rambling now. Yeah, good episode. Um rambling about the alpha.
SPEAKER_04This is just alpha at the end.
SPEAKER_01All right, good episode, guys. Bye. See y'all in a couple weeks.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and see you later.
SPEAKER_05Bye. Nothing said on the hive mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions, not financial advice.