In this conversation, the hosts discuss various topics related to the cryptocurrency market. They touch on market conditions, regulatory developments, the impact of institutional investors, the performance of altcoins, and the rise of meme coins. They also discuss the legal implications for developers of privacy-focused tools and the erosion of privacy rights in the crypto space. In this conversation, the hosts discuss the recent developments in the crypto space, including the Tornado Cash developer's concerns about increasing regulations in Europe and the Medboost exploit. They also touch on the topics of crypto social platforms like Friend Tech and Fantasy Top, as well as the FTX bankruptcy and the exorbitant fees paid to lawyers. The conversation highlights the need for decentralized governance and more efficient legal processes in the crypto industry. Chapters 00:00 Introduction 00:42 Market Conditions and Regulatory Developments 10:38 The Rise of Meme Coins 25:28 Erosion of Privacy Rights in the Crypto Space 33:21 Crypto Regulations and Concerns 34:18 The Medboost Exploit 43:22 Crypto Social Platforms 52:20 The FTX Bankruptcy 01:03:23 The Need for Decentralized Governance Disclosures This podcast is strictly informational and educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any tokens or securities or to make any financial decisions. Do not trade or invest in any project, tokens, or securities based upon this podcast episode. The host and members at Delphi Ventures may personally own tokens or art that are mentioned on the podcast. Our current show features paid sponsorships which may be featured at the start, middle, and/or the end of the episode. These sponsorships are for informational purposes only and are not a solicitation to use any product, service or token.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02All right. Hi everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Hive Mind Podcast. Today, with me as always, we have uh Jan Lieberman, managing director at Delphi Ventures, Cederis Parabus, uh head of research. I gave you giving your full name today, and uh Flood Capital, also known as Duncan, who is our altcoin gem hunter coming at us from his uh Michael Saylor-inspired office. So we have a bunch to get through today.
SPEAKER_02Um maybe to start with, just markets. I believe it appears as of today that we're back, but maybe you guys have some more in-depth uh takes on this.
SPEAKER_04I mean, uh we're in the banana zone, right?
SPEAKER_00Think how how hard banana gun is gonna pump when we enter in the banana zone. It's like a perfect lineup. We we we need to we need to get Raul in into banana gun.
SPEAKER_04Um but no, I mean, well, we're at 66 now. Um what's softer inflation print? There's that there's that SAB 121 vote that's like going on right now, which I think is pretty critical. Um it's basically like who can it's the things that who can custody uh the assets. Um and it was something put through by like the SEC. Um and like this is the thing that Biden said that if it got to him, he would veto it.
SPEAKER_04Uh so it's pretty important because it like changes market structure on like allowing banks to actually custody these assets for their clients. Um that's like something big that will impact the market uh like today. And then I don't know, the ETH decision is next week, right?
SPEAKER_01And just have 13 Epsy's and on on the before leaving Bitcoin side.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01All the uh announcements of uh millennium, yeah. But yeah, you just find out you know who where did all these flows come from in Q1? And so now you you kind of get exposure to random pensions and and funds that that people put positions in, and it you know it offers signal to the market that there's appetite across these funds and and um a lot more demand that can still come from those buckets, which is kind of really what's needed to to put in a floor and and move us higher.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I guess like the flows like first they come from the hedge funds, kind of more capital, and then hopefully you start to get um you know the the next level of of flow is for like you know, different personal investment accounts, maybe like pensions take a small position slowly. Yeah, I think things are uh Wisconsin, Wisconsin bought it, it was a decent chunk, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_04Like 100 mil?
SPEAKER_01Like 100 mil, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But millennium was two B's.
SPEAKER_04But Millennium is like trading it, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, which is still good, but it is signal though, right? Um, in the sense because like the the counter would be, oh, they've already bought that's that's not as bullish, but this is the you know, we're still in the very early innings of of players like them buying, and so I I still see it as more signal rather than uh for upside rather than you know being quote unquote late.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and crypto twitter seems pretty bearish. Maybe it's just maybe it's just my feed.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, because it's because Bitcoin's down 15, and then but all your altcoins are down 60. So it's like literally if you were going based on like crypto Twitter sentiment, you'd think we're at like 50k right now, just because everyone is all in alts, especially like a lot of people were in on memes, and like you know, some like Whip is held up pretty well. I think it's at like 280 or something, and the top was like 450. It's like, but like some stuff, like whatever the one Bowden was down like 80. I think it's had a decent bounce, but like a lot of these alts, especially and like the low float high FTV ones got crashed, like a lot of them are down like 60 plus percent from the highs.
SPEAKER_00So it's like pretty big dispersion versus Bitcoin being down.
SPEAKER_01That's the big one, yeah. The the dispersion, exactly. Yeah, that like that that makes it so different where people are so many like yes, prices are up, but so many people are are are still in a decent amount of pain and below their high water mark from a month or two ago.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I put that I put that little like chart out the other day that like five people took and tweeted it themselves. But like I broke it by sectors, and uh I mean, yeah, we've been talking about this dispersion the whole time. Um, but when you really kind of just bucket stuff, it's just really like anything cosmos related, modular related, like very they're all down this year, and then you have a couple L1s that have done well.
SPEAKER_04Um, like ETH, uh everybody kind of like shits on ETH. It's not like ETH has been terrible, uh, especially when you account for like all the LRT stuff, uh, you know, all the like the yield and like pendle and things like that. It it hasn't been terrible. What's been terrible is too is like ETH beta. Um and like like Lido, for instance, is like down versus USD over the past year, which is pretty impressive considering where we were like a year ago, right?
SPEAKER_01So I think that's like yeah, there's like definitely a lot of pockets. Yeah, ETH isn't terrible against USD, but it just it's it's bucketed against BTC and Seoul, right? Uh they're kind of three on that standalone and and it's just massively underperformed.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, definitely hasn't done well, but it I think like the worst, the worst areas were basically just Cosmos and uh like ETH beta stuff.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the other the other thing I see a lot on the CT is this consensus that there are no catalysts coming and like no new flows, just like take summer off, come back. I'd say no. In my view, like yeah, exactly. Whenever that whenever there's like a broad consensus like that, it's just it's just so dangerous. Uh like Kang has that really good post, like how to avoid getting bareholed, and the the the basic summary is just like you you can't see all the flows, right? And like people in crypto, especially on crypto twitter, just have this idea that they can see all the flows and all the catalysts and like time them perfectly, but but in reality, you just have no idea what's happening with like 99.9% of of this stuff, and and that's why I think most people who do the short-term trading stuff end up getting wrecked.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and whenever I there's been so many times I feel like that the there's been that consensus and crypto just like rips rips up of it.
SPEAKER_04I mean, also like think about these ETFs K. BlackRock has been pitching this to like all their institutional clients and everything. They have a reputation to maintain, like there's a lot of energy behind like you think they want to launch this and then have their clients take like an 80% haircut like in the first six months or something, and this is before a lot of like the uh the banks have even been approved to like pitch it to their clients and stuff.
SPEAKER_04So I don't know. I feel like there's just a there's a lot that you can't see because this is a totally new market structure that none of us are ever used to, right? It's like totally new um participants, and like I just you know it's not it's it's like that doesn't mean that BTC can't drop a lot, but there is there are these like new big participants that have like a vested interest now to like know that have it kind of I think the constant drip also changes that you know before it felt like if BTC wasn't going up, it had it had to go down, right?
SPEAKER_01Because it it it felt like you'd have these periodic inflows uh of demand, and then once those people allocated it would you'd either have internal movement or or it kind of go down. Whereas now with the passive flows, I still think people are kind of convinced that if it's not going up, it kind of has to go down, but you know, it's not necessarily the case. It can chill, especially with with funding being the slow, people can sit in longs for for pretty long, and so um, and then you have these surprise flows, right?
SPEAKER_01Like iBit yesterday was 100 or it wasn't iBit, it was um RFB out of nowhere with like a big inflow. And so you know, that was something that was never present in previous market structures.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that the ETF as a whole, like that whole machine behind it and the flows behind it is just kind of getting started, and that's what like this 13 maps are showing us. It's like these more nimble hedge funds that can move really quickly, are getting in, but like we haven't seen you know the longer term allocators like start to dip their toe in, which like takes the marketing engine, takes like the churn to actually happen. So, like saying that there's no catalysts, I think that like the ETF is still just like ramping. Um, and uh the other thing is like we talked about this a lot in the previous podcast.
SPEAKER_00So, like I'm happy that we talked about it, just this low float that like just because Bitcoin like does it goes up doesn't mean that like some of these altcoins are gonna go up. Like the low float high FTP, like we've seen a lot of those names get absolutely crushed this month, and like you know, I don't know if those coins are gonna make new highs, but I think you know, we're pretty constructive on Bitcoin and then like selective alts that like don't have these big supply overhang dynamics and maybe have some sort of product, hopefully. I think memes will probably do well, but uh I think crypto Twitter is definitely misleading because you could just see like everyone was allocated into memes and alts that just you know bitcoin was like down 20 after rallying a hundred, and people are like saying that they're down on the year.
SPEAKER_04There's there's also crazy, yeah. Like there's also a lot of survivorship bias in memes, right? Like you don't really know what memes are like worth tracking until they go up a lot, and and so people don't talk about their thousand snipes of memes that all went to zero, and that's why like a lot of people are probably down, right? Because you're just like trying to snipe all these like new launch memes, right?
SPEAKER_04There's there's like 10,000 new tokens coming out a day or something like that, yes. And that was a big thing that we talked about.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it just like how do you size into some of those things like with conviction and actually hold them where you know maybe the established ones you can now because they have some sort of mind share, but it's really difficult to you know buy new, like you're literally just rolling the dice, and the the higher those like you know, big ones go, like the more people want to get on the next one and the more gonna be created, and the more difficult it's gonna get. So it's really difficult to like find like a new meme and get in early. It's it's pretty uh random, or you're just you know, god dear meme picker.
SPEAKER_04I mean, the the way to look at so the Ombroda pumped off fund revenues, and I've seen a lot of people talking about this um because of like how successful it is. But the other way to look about that is that's just all lost money from traders trying to like snipe these launches, right? Like that that is just money, like you can just look at it if that's how much lost uh like the minimum amount that people have just like lost trying to also all the get it on memes early.
SPEAKER_01It's also like it's a it's a as it's a proxy for so because there's like the meme investing kind of breaks down in different demographics, right? You have smaller PA sizes that are basically trying to snipe and sell within hours kind of thing, and and do it in in much, much smaller size because it makes sense for them. And and and there is there's definitely an edge there, right? But it it can only really be captured by smaller PAs because it just doesn't you can't really do it in size, and so like that's still continuously happening, which you reflected by pump revenues, right?
SPEAKER_01Because that's solely focused on on kind of launches, and then you have like the larger demographic, the the the I think the the much larger position sizing where people are trying to catch the move from like 50 to 500 or something like that, and so yeah, it's a tricky one where you know where's the highest EV, uh what's the highest EV way to allocate on the meme side? I think like you mentioned, you know, it's hard to size into a lot of these because so many tend to go to zero. And so it's it's almost rather than trying to be counter trend and and and identify ones that you think can return, it it's almost you know, you can sleep better at night, just picking winners with lower risk, lower return, and and versus kind of yeah, in the trenches trying to do a little bit of sniping.
SPEAKER_00And and what else, what do you mean? What else could you buy if you wanted to get meme exposure? If I didn't want to pick a certain meme, I'm trying to get him to say banana. Um, but yeah, so, anyways, I so I just pulled up the dashboard in the past seven days. Uh Trojan, Bonkbot, and Banana Gun combined have done around let's round up a little, 600 million in volume at a 1% fee. That's six million in fees they're taking out of the market. And then pumped up fun. This article's from a week ago, but it said they did three million in fees last week.
SPEAKER_00So we're talking about nearly$10 million just extracted from fees on those like three tools, or like you know, Bonkbot, Trojan, Banana Gun, and Pumped Up Fun on those four. So that's actually like a decent amount of money money. And you just like see the like people this chasing, because you know, you see whiff go up a gazillion percent, you see Bowden go up, you know, a gazillion percent. You makes you think that you can get in on the next one, um, which maybe you will if you get lucky, but really it since like set or set 10,000 new coins a day, it's gonna be pretty difficult.
SPEAKER_04I mean, Pump made over a million in one day, the other day.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, like yeah, so it's pretty crazy. And and these are relatively low volumes, right? Like you go back to March, instead of it being 10 million a week that these four are making, it's probably more like 30 or 40 million a week, which is pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so it's obviously not sustainable, I guess, is what we're saying, but for now it for now it lives on.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, it's just like when do people get burned enough or they're gonna stop chasing the new memes, right? Because it seems pretty consensus that like memes are like these meme coins, and even with like the the Roan Kitty stuff, like it seems pretty consensus that that's what's gonna perform, you know, it's performed the best year to date, um, and that's gonna continue to be one of the best performers.
SPEAKER_02So it'll be interesting to see like how long I think it's consensus in in like what people say, but my suspicion and seeing different polls on on Twitter and stuff is that people still aren't really allocated accordingly. Uh, like I think most people have probably sub five or sub ten percent of their portfolio in in memes, right? So uh I don't know. I think even if it is consensus, the it's probably reasonable though.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. I'm there um but it's also like you have you have I think what is gonna keep them alive and is just the fact that every time we bounce, they bounce the hardest, right? And so it's it's hard to to to fight that, right? Or or you know, like if that that trend continues, then you're gonna see consistent allocation.
SPEAKER_00The reason people really got burned in the drawdown is yes, they had gains, but they just recycled those gains into the next thing, and it's unless you actually take that cash out when there's a drawdown, even if you made gains in the previous thing and put them into the next thing, like you're gonna experience that massive drawdown, and so um it's yeah, that's like especially on-chain lines, like the liquidity is so thin that you know it happens really fast, it's like people start to do that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, especially on um Solana because there's way more there's less liquidity, it's like Solana always boasts they're like volume to TVL metrics, and there's a lot of like concentrated liquidity, but that's because the ranges are like tight, right? And there's also more like professional market makers kind of doing stuff there, and so yeah, it can really drop out pretty quickly on some of those.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the the ratio of of market cap to idle liquidity to volume is is nuts, right? You have very little idle liquidity, a lot of volume, and a lot of market cap, and it's just like very high churn on that idle liquidity. But you know, that that doesn't mean you have a lot of exit liquidity at the same time. It's just like there's a lot of buying and selling happening, but the second a lot of the buying slows down, there's not that much exit liquidity for pure selling.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, no, exactly. Because you you lose that side, there's no idle liquidity there to support it. Um I think another thing, like a meme coin, I actually think is and it's not exactly a meme coin, but like the one of the big things about meme coins, I feel like that gives them their value is like the distribution they have, right? The holder base, like the network effect. One of um the analysts on the research team just put out a really good piece on like the attention economy, or attention is all you need, I think. But basically it's it's all about just like eyeballs on the the meme, and that's really how they kind of blow up.
SPEAKER_00And so on Telegram, there's so so Telegram has 800 million users, and they have like an exclusive deal with this, like you know, the Ton blockchain to have it implemented in the Telegram wallet, and basically they give you a free wallet as long as you don't have a US phone number. So they have like pretty crazy distribution, like probably like 700 million wallets created all in the Telegram blockchain. And like the biggest altcoin over there right now is like called Knotcoin, which is you know kind of a meme, kind of like uh, but like they're they're leaning more into the distribution angle where they have I think like two million followers on Twitter, they have six million subscribers, it's like the third largest Telegram group ever.
SPEAKER_00It just launched on like Binance, OK X, like all the big exchanges today, and they're kind of like I guess getting new projects who want distribution to like pay them money, and then they'll uh or buy not coin and then like they'll distribute it like through their channels to people. So, like that's just like one idea. I thought that that's like the first meme coin that I thought is kind of interesting this cycle because of just the sheer distribution it has, you know, being the third largest Telegram group, having the most like two million Twitter followers, and being like really integrated in into Telegram natively.
SPEAKER_00And it's like not very big in North America, it's more of a rest of the world thing. I own some some not coin because I thought it was cool, but it just launched today, and I think it's an interesting uh idea.
SPEAKER_02All right. Um, I feel like we've juiced the meme coin and markets to to the max. Does anyone else have have some more stuff to say on that? Or we want to move on.
SPEAKER_04Well, I mean, the only thing on meme coin angle, I guess, is like, do we want to talk about how DGen Chain was out for two days?
SPEAKER_02I didn't even know that. You didn't know that? No.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I still don't like totally understand everything what happened, but because like when you have a centralized sequencer, the benefit is that when you have an outage, like you can just start it yourself. There's no coordination needed, right? Like when Solana has their outages, they have to get 80% of the network to agree on like this fork and to run the new labs like release or whatever. And so it takes time, right?
SPEAKER_04Um, but DGen Chain was out for uh two days, and there's like a 500k block reorg, so which is like really bad. Um and this is like one of the risks of using, I guess, like a there was two chains that were by one roll-up as a service provider, and like both of them went out. This is like just another like centralized centralization risk, I guess. If like a lot of people start using one provider, whether it's like a roll-up provider, like RPC, I know Mert was talking about this.
SPEAKER_04Like, if a lot of people are just using one RPC provider, like that RPC provider goes up. There's a lot of hidden centralization pockets in a lot of this stuff, and so yeah, I don't know. It was pretty bad. Like, I still haven't read like a full post post mortem that I'm sure we'll get some point. I think a lot of people are just kind of confused as to how like single sequencer roll-up was out for two days.
SPEAKER_01One last point on the meme front that we could maybe use to transition to another topic we want to chat through is uh was Trump related uh activity and basically how he came out as massively bullish. And so uh well, he he's such a wild card, right? Like he he'll he's always gonna have an Opinion on something, and and so people were trying to get takes on him about uh just crypto and and and and bowdoin it was you know he obviously spoke bullishly on on crypto, and so the the polyfy memes started doing well, like you know, Trump in particular, but then he when someone asked him directly about Bowden, he just started funning it and and it actually started nuking, which is pretty funny.
SPEAKER_01Um, but I I gotta imagine that's gonna be a continuing trend. Um just yeah, getting his his one-off takes because of how much he can move markets and and how just blunt he'll be about certain things, but um, yeah, it it's it seems like he is really gonna both raise a decent amount of money and uh win over some some uh voters because I can't imagine a lot of people are gonna be voting for him for his anti or for voting for Biden for his anti-crypto policy, but I think you'll definitely get some Trump voters for his pro-crypto policy.
SPEAKER_01So it seems like a pretty DV positive bet to go that way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then you had the drama, the the sort of block works drama on the piece that that uh whoever that kind of journalist was that wrote, you know, about not voting just because of crypto, uh, that caused a lot of blood and scare for a while. I don't really know why.
SPEAKER_04I understand her point. I understand her point. Like, especially if you're what was the point? I mean, especially if you're a woman, like there's a lot of like abortion topics that are important in this election, right? So, but the but the thing is, even if you're not, even if you don't identify as like a single-issue voter, I think when people vote, they're normally have one thing in their mind, regardless about why they vote a certain way. And the only yeah, the thing that I guess would turn people off is that it was kind of trying to like morally shame people for like voting Trump because he's pro-crypto.
SPEAKER_04Whereas I like I agree with the point that you should I don't know, look at everything, but for a lot of people in this industry, this is their livelihood, right? And so is yeah, right.
SPEAKER_01I also think because it's it's not even like you know, you the other side is trying to do it with good faith, is the problem, right? It's one thing if one's pro and the other's kind of neutral, but here you have a scenario where one side is just irrationally trying to kill it, and so I think you know, downplaying that was a bit disingenuous on her part.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I also think like crypto for a lot of people, especially the people that got in early, maybe less of the sort of people from from this cycle, is is about freedom, right? And and it is like a very like they got in because because they care about freedom, and and so they care about freedom, so they're gonna prioritize that in their in their voting. And this kind of leads us uh a little bit towards this uh these issues. Like we've we had two big kind of crypto legal rulings this week. One against uh the tornado cache dev, uh Alex Pertsev, and then one against the the Mev Boost exploders, right?
SPEAKER_02And I think obviously the MevBoost Explorer Exploders was just uh was was just like an action, whereas the the Tornado Cash Dev was an actual ruling. And I don't know how many of you guys followed this, but it was pretty pretty terrible. I'd say like the worst ruling I've personally read for for crypto, because the judges sort of like it's not it's not a case where the judges don't understand how all the stuff works and and and and said some stupid stuff, made some stupid interpretations.
SPEAKER_02They understand exactly how crypto works. They like acknowledge that uh they and this is a quote due to the nature of how the system works, it is virtually impossible to make the user interface inaccessible. This fact combined with the use of smart contracts makes it virtually impossible to take Tornado Cash offline. So they acknowledge that this stuff is is unstoppable. Um, but they basically argue that the fact that the Tornado Cache devs built it and knew uh knew that it could potentially be used for criminal activity when they built it is enough to make them liable, which is pretty wild.
SPEAKER_02Um, so they say, yeah, in other words, the Tornado Cache founders are the inventors, creators, and implementers of Tornado Cache. As such, they're also responsible for the consequences of the operation of this tool. The autonomous, immutable, and unstoppable nature of the smart contracts does not work in this context as a disultory factor. After all, this is not a fortuitous circumstance. These properties are the result of conscious choices made by the designers. Tornado Cash works as was conceived. In the court's opinion, the defendant can therefore be classified as a perpetrator of the money laundering acts carried out by Tornado Cash.
SPEAKER_02So, and and interestingly, they also acknowledge, like in the court case, that uh they they came up with a figure of 84% of uh Tornado Cash transactions are are like normal people who just want privacy. The the DOJ came up with a 93% figure, and they acknowledge that. Um, they acknowledge the fact that the Tornado Cash devs built in a bunch of compliance tools, like being able to to to provide a proof of history if you if you needed to, and having KOC on the front end, and none of that matters uh to them.
SPEAKER_02So basically the the precedent this creates in in my mind, especially for a dev in Europe, is that if you deploy a smart contract on-chain, you are basically liable for all potential future criminal activity that might happen on that smart contract for the rest of time, right? And the only thing they really need to prove based on this case is that you could have reasonably foreseen that there would be criminal activity. And so I don't know who the hell wants to deploy smart contracts in Europe knowing this, right?
SPEAKER_02Because this isn't this isn't even a case where you can like do something. It's like if you've deployed it and people are using it criminally, you can't like undeploy it, right? So you're just you're just kind of fucked.
SPEAKER_00Um, like this is like let's say someone sells a gun, yeah, and they use the gun to commit a crime.
SPEAKER_02It's like or a smartphone, right?
SPEAKER_00Like that, yeah, like yeah, there's like so many examples where this doesn't like obviously. I can understand where they're coming from. Like, I understand the argument that they're making, but like there's so many, like you could apply this to so many, like any tool, like anything.
SPEAKER_01It just yeah, it undermines the the whole criminal justice system and just shows how much bias can impact rulings and and how how things are viewed and and and what's reasonable despite having you know uh like one set of norms applying in in one area and then applying that same set of of norms in another one ends up falling through, which is it's yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04That was the by far the worst part of the uh because let's face it, criminal activity is taking place on literally like every smart contract in some sense. Like if you just talk about the money flowing through and like what it's touched and everything, and the whole the whole like you you needed basically you need to be able to foresee everybody who will ever use what you deploy for the rest of time, which is like what you were saying, which is just impossible to um kind of comply with that.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, it was a pretty sad it was pretty sad ruling because of like the logic that they used.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the precedent is is pretty terrible. Um it's crazy this is happening in in Europe, like yeah, I think privacy tech and and privacy has always had these because you can always for any like marginal increase in sort of surveillance technology, you can always argue that it'll make you safer, right? Like if you have cameras in everyone's houses, if you track everyone's computers, people will be safer. But like democracies have always protected the right to privacy.
SPEAKER_02Like people have uh have the ability to like protect certain information and things that they do from from the government. And I feel like recent recently with the AML laws, the KYC, like in Europe, you can't transfer. I think it's over 5k, supposedly, without without like doing KYC on your counterparty. Like, we're just eroding all of that, like eroding financial privacy completely.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's arguable though that it makes it safer. Like what is kind of sad about this is that the Netherlands are the ones that had the worst massacre of like Jews in the Holocaust because they required a fully public database that had like where everyone lived and like who was like Jewish or not, basically. And this turned this is why they had the most deaths out of any country in Europe. So like the framing of privacy as a bad thing is just it's just like what needs to be fixed.
SPEAKER_04Um yeah, because it's really it's really not, and there's tons of times like you think the gay rights movement would have ever gained steam without people being able to like talk in private, right?
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of things that people need to discuss in private um to kind of like progress society in a sense, so and definitely like with the COVID stuff, like there's a lot of this like trade-off of you know protection for like lack of freedoms, at least in Canada, like it was really bad in terms of like lockdowns and vaccine mandates, and um for like a very long time, like and even with like the truckers, which is like uh peaceful protests, you know, take like banning or closing people's bank accounts, like definitely a growing trend in the world.
SPEAKER_01It's rare that governments don't take advantage of a crisis to increase their reach and power.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But that's like I think a reason why a lot of people in crypto are you know, it's a balancing act. Because a like a huge way they actually enforce this is through the monetary system, right? Because that's how you really like when the rubber meets the road, if you can um, you know, destroy someone's livelihood or like close their bank account, like people aren't fucking around when that's on the line. Um, so an alternative money system where that that can't happen is is you know obviously threatening to their ultimate power.
SPEAKER_04A good so I said there's this is a really good tweet the other day from Jake uh Shernewski lawyer said 21st century democracies claiming to be a bulwark against authoritarian to uh fuck I can't say that word, authoritarianism are ravenous for powers that would make 20th century dictators salivate. And it's true, like it is just crazy how much in the last basically since 9-11, I guess, um the amount of authoritarian like powers um governments have just continued to like seek.
SPEAKER_02And in Europe, it's it's kind of the worst. I mean, the US has much stronger like First Amendment protections and I think constitutional rights to to privacy. And hopefully the case against the other Tornado Cash developer, which is in the US, will yield different results. But in Europe, it's just you know, these sort of bureaucrats in in Brussels that really believe like the regulation is the is the answer to everything. Um and it's it's yeah, it's it's getting getting pretty intense.
SPEAKER_02Um do we want to talk about the the MEV boost exploit? I mean, I'm I'm I'm curious how we can actually help like with this appeal or something like that. I don't know if there's a I ping the mean to see if there's a there's some way that people can get involved. If so, we'll we'll post it maybe alongside the episode, but seems pretty important for crypto and for for freedom generally. But um, yeah, if we want to talk about the the MEV boost exploit, that was like really impressive. Yeah, I think someone tweeted that uh the SDNY understands crypto better than most VCs uh from this enforcement action.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, I kind of agree. It was uh it was really impressive. Cedar is you want to give the maybe the the the lowdown on on the exploit and yeah, why why it matters?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so basically two, I think there's two brothers. One of them was a polychain intern before um low carb crusader, and what they did was the way MEV MEV Boost works, the sidecar piece that like searchers, uh like builders and validators will run. Um basically how it works is like a builder builds a block with a bunch of transactions and then sends it to a validator, and like the highest bid um is the one that they kind of take and then they propose that block.
SPEAKER_04Um but when you send this block, the a validator could unbundle this block that you've sent them as the builder and then insert their own transactions. Okay, and so the way they kind of get around this is that you have to like sign, um you have to get like a signature or something committing to that block before you see the contents of it, so you can't like unbundle it. And these guys figured out a way to like forge that signature, and so what they did was um when they got this block, they like did this fake signature that basically guaranteed they wouldn't unbundle it, and then they got it, and then they inserted their own transactions into it, um uh, which like sandwiched, so the the builder put like their own sandwich transaction in it, and then they put their own to to like sandwich the builder because the builder would have put like the way sandwich transactions work is you'll like buy like 20 mil of something and then sell like 20 mil and 100k of something, okay, to make like 100k profit, and so it's big numbers, uh, but it's to make like kind of a small profit.
SPEAKER_04But when you're the builder, it's kind of riskless in a sense because pretty easy to just extract that sandwich profit. Um, so essentially these guys by forging the signature were able to take like 25 mil um with this sandwich attack. So it is different from like normal sandwich attacks that happen. So, like when this happened, a lot of people felt no sympathy for the MEV bots that got exploited because they're just sandwiching users all the time, right?
SPEAKER_04And there's a really good tweet from uh Doug from Ambient, and he said the closest analogy I could come up with this is like the Baltimore police deciding to go after Omar and only Omar in from like the wire. So if you remember the wire, Omar was this like criminal, but he only went after other criminals, he didn't go after like ordinary people, he only stole from like the drug dealers and the other crimer, and so this is so basically it'd be like them arresting Omar, but then leaving everyone else kind of like free, and that was his analogy.
SPEAKER_04Um, which is like kind of it's like pretty it's like the closest one you can kind of get, I guess. Um, but yeah, like the DOJ understands this. Um, it's also seems likely that the DOJ didn't just alert authorities of this. I mean, the the DOJ didn't just come onto this their own, someone who got stolen from here or someone a part of the MEV like supply chain went to went to them, but so there's a lot of people just like in this industry that are constantly going to law enforcement now to like fix their problems, which is not ideal in my opinion.
SPEAKER_00But do we think that this will end up making like sandwiching uh illegal or like I mean sandwiching is like they can do it from like a non-extradition country or something, and just like you know, I think this was a specific case though, where there was like pretty clear like fraud and so the signature, the signature is considered false signature, the signature is considered the fraud.
SPEAKER_04That makes sense. Um, but also the DOJ is like enshrining MEV boost here in the indictment. They talk about how uh it's relied upon to make the Ethereum network function, and like Ethereum MEV Boost is this third-party software developed by a private company, right? Um, that people in the Ethereum protocol use, but it's not like enshrined in the protocol or anything, and the DOJ is essentially enshrining it with this statement.
SPEAKER_04Um, so yeah, I don't know. But to your point about sandwiching and front running, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I I have a tweet about this from a year and a half ago, which is kind of tongue-in-cheat, but it was like the most likely way that this is solved is out of protocol, and by out of protocol, I mean jail, and like I don't I don't I don't know how from like the North Korea is just gonna spin up an MEV mod and do it.
SPEAKER_04I know that's the thing, right?
SPEAKER_02It's like I don't think that's the you can make that conclusion from from this though.
SPEAKER_04No, not from this, yeah, because this is specifically this is different than just a normal sandwich. This is you're you're intentionally baiting someone, right, to steal like you're trying to get an MEV bot to do this big sandwich attack with a lot of money. Um but I don't know, they obviously understand how this works. Like when it came out, I didn't know like the number right away, 25 mil. I remember that number from when this happened, and I was like, no way, is this like the MEV boost exploit?
SPEAKER_04Uh and then like I started reading it, and yeah, sure enough, it was. So I remember when it happened, people were like cheering, like normal users were like, good, like fuck the MEV bots. Um, why should we have sympathy for them? Right, because they get sandwiched all the time by these MEV bots. Uh, but obviously the powers that be decided that I don't know, like yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I agree that that yeah, this is different than your standard sandwiching, but I think it would be optimistic to assume that the current regime would stop their persecution at this and and not continue reaching but it's like how is it lighter payment for order flow or any of that other stuff, right?
SPEAKER_00Well, I guess like the difference is because you're consenting to a certain amount of slippage when the user makes the swap.
SPEAKER_04Same thing with the payment for order flow, like you're consenting like that you're giving them or like some sort of fee you're consenting to, whereas the the fraud of the signature is like you know that's no, but in even in like payment for order flow, there's still there's still there's still laws around like best price execution and everything, um which doesn't hold up in the slippage setting.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, but I'm just trying to think like you know, it's harder to go after a sandwich or when it's like okay, like the user accepted they're willing to take up to this amount of slippage, and we just gave that to them, kind of right. Like if you set your slippage tolerant to nothing or you use like a like a private RPC, like you won't get sandwiched.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean you use a private RPC, though, you're just now adding another like party that you're trusting. You're trusting one party, right? But you're still trusting someone.
SPEAKER_00So I don't know, like um, I just think it's a it's a bit of a leap to go from you know, them faking the signature to yeah, I agree. I I will agree on that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we can talk social if I like. I don't use any of these things because I don't really want people trading my likeness. Um but but I do understand why people use them, right? Uh uh like I I think it's good to see experimentation in this kind of like weird social stuff, uh, other than just you know DeFi. I'm like, I just I think it's good that we're kind of progressing into a bit of a different domain here.
SPEAKER_04Um yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I like the I think the Soci stuff is is pretty cool. I mean, I guess uh you know it was worth distinguishing what specifically so fantasy tops um is is yeah, I like the fact that we're we're branching out of DeFi, right? Where I think it's just important for the growth of the space as a whole and and in terms of onboarding new users and and interesting ways to participate in the ecosystem. Uh but it it so and you have like the the financialization of everything, right?
SPEAKER_01That's what kind of what crypto enables via tokenization, uh, which makes it makes previously potentially uninteresting games much more interesting. Um, but it also creates uh reasons for people to start trying to game everything when there are financial benefits. And so I think what you're seeing now on like on fantasy tops is the people trying to bot accounts to inflate engagement and and and users and it and it's tough when this game when when
SPEAKER_00when when like the when this game is based on an ecosystem that it doesn't really have any control over uh being twitter uh to keep this game kind of honest because there's no way to to really control for that element yeah i'm kind of surprised that like friend friend teams at 135 mil i guess like it obviously had that explosion i think that was near one of our first episodes like we ever recorded in the summer which is crazy it's almost been a year since we started this does not feel like that but it was like last summer we did uh an episode when friend tech was exploding i remember talking to you guys about that um but now like the airdrop is over it'll be really interesting to see if people still use it or like you know more groups get created um i think like a lot of people like you know created groups back then and then kind of like slowly fell off like but they also felt like a weird obligation that like people bought their keys that were like expensive so like a weird obligation to like keep posting but then like a lot of people fell off it seems like in the new update Jose you probably know more than me but um like there's different pricing models there's like bigger groups like which I think address a lot of the issues initially because it just got so expensive for like the common person to to join a group and now it seems like they've made like custom price curves so it can be more of like a a bigger group but uh it'll be interesting to see if activity like continues on that now now that the eardrops over obviously the kind of attention has shifted to fantasy top because there's a potential airdrop there but yeah um yeah I guess I'd split them into like uh crypto socials there's maybe lens far caster front tech and now fantasy top right and I'd say like lens and and and far caster are a little bit more uh maybe this is unfair but a little bit more skew morphic and that they look more like the traditional social media but like uh you know they have this decent I mean I think Farcaster is really cool decentralized social graph um and you have the frames you can build on top of and stuff but I do think there's something interesting about both front tech and fantasy top in that they tap into this speculative crypto element which I think is uh for better or for worse going to be like a necessity to have to have a crypto app really succeed.
SPEAKER_02The front tech like I'm I'm long friend so you know to take everything with it with yeah I've never used that though I've I I used it uh I I think it's pretty underwhelming like they had over six months that they generated like 50 million in in fees and had all of you know crypto twitter's attention to build the v2 and they basically shipped like these groups a token and a fork like in app AMM like to to to some extent you know uh like the back end went down on launch there's like all sorts of kind of issues I think they haven't grown the team very fast um so I think they have like something really special with like I'm I bought like a lot of the blue chip keys on on launch and most of those people are still active like responding right they feel like some obligation to respond and they also leak alpha in a way that they don't on Twitter.
SPEAKER_02Like I think Hisaka first announced his like ina position to his friend tech followers right and and some of the other people that I the whose keys I bought are also like they get asked pretty pointed specific investment questions and they're answering them. So there's clearly like something happening there. I don't know if this is the team to to capitalize on that but I think they have enough of a of a movement behind them where uh and and like just the I feel like the front tech Twitter is is just like goated in terms of yeah they have a good Twitter.
SPEAKER_02Yeah just like so keeping keeping those like main I don't know you want to call them KOLs but like keeping those main people um engaged is obviously very important most of them dump though right like it was bizarre seeing all these people dump like four four figures like on some of them like four or five figures on chain like rushing to dump like it's been a hard a lot of LARPs.
SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah a lot of um it it'll be like I really want to see uh with especially like the bigger groups and the cheaper pricing like some non-crypto people make a group right I think Grayson Allen is like made one I think I saw that he's pretty crypto he's he's been in crypto for a while though yeah like that's it's hard to rationalize non-crypto users participating though whereas right because like what's the what's the benefit versus just making a group chat if you're non-crypto kind of thing yeah that's a good point but but like yeah so that's why I struggle like with the front tech stuff where it looks too much like existing could be cool like versus the group chat you know what I mean like a group chat you gotta like manually add remove they're paying like subscriptions over time it could be like a one time fee it'd kick you out if you sell your thing like you're automatically in there um but yeah I'm sure there's solutions for that in web too but it's just like that would be make me excited it'll be it'll be interesting to see what happens after the fantasy top like airdrops over if like attention shifts back to front tech or if it goes to something new.
SPEAKER_04It just depends on where where there's money to be made right like the reason front tech was I I I well uh front tech you had both the the first order way which was you know buying and selling keys and then the longer term uh airdrop that that people were you know engaging for right whereas with fantasy top I think you know there's less people playing right now for the airdrop but more because there's I think you know more alpha to be had and more edge to be made if you you're really into weeds and trying to figure out you know who's who's cheap and you're playing with these packs and I think there's a lot more to do on fantasy top and and which is it which kind of adds to the argument that I think it's gonna be hard for crypto socials it that look too similar to web their like web two counterpart yeah yeah that's it yeah points for engagement though right which is maybe not the best I've also had like five people steal something that I made because they think they're trying to get engagement or that they like get fantasy points and stuff no I don't know it's uh it's weird uh incentives because also whenever you you pay for engagement which I guess twitter does too right um it's just you don't get you don't get the best true like most truthful honest content when you're paying for engagement yeah because like it's I mean like if I wanted to it's pretty easy to like know the formula of how to get like a lot of impressions and a lot of people liking and like retweeting your stuff right but it's just dumb it's just like dumb fluff and bullshit most of the time right so that's the problem with like the model yeah all right want to do FTX quickly before we wrap up or altcoin corner we kind of sprinkled in an altcoin corner in the middle what do you guys think yeah I think the sprinkling is unless there's a lot of stuff we haven't covered on the altcoin side uh a better way to kind of go about it what do you think gem hunter just talk ftx i think about banana and it's not coin so those the all right Jan FTX and Jose showed a friend and what else you showed something else yeah setters what are when when are you gonna show something said I own showing his I own the friend oh you own friend too that's too that's true and what do you own anything else that I was mentioning friend uh all right so FTX announced their creditor plan the TLDR of that is basically that if you had less than 50k you're gonna get 118 back within 60 days of the plan being confirmed which I've seen some estimates it's like Q1 2025 um and this is about 96% of customers and then if you have more than that um it's uh I had it written somewhere I can't find it now but it's it's slightly more basically um and the TLDR is the government claims like if you guys remember the DOJ and the SEC all piled in once FTX went bankrupt with like ridiculous claims of uh what they wanted and and like tax that was unpaid and stuff uh those got subordinated to to everyone else which is exactly as it should be and preferred equity and ft both got zero uh darn hilariously ft pumped super hard off the news it was like uh on the 8th of May it's like a bunch of people got i don't know it was it was really funny clarity pump man it's still on buy it's still on Binance it's still like I think it's 400 million or something market cap uh let me let me check no it's 540 million market cap when FTT is out before most of crypto operators and yeah it's it it was on the 8th of May it was announced and then it like pumped like 40 or something or 30 that day but I mean let's let's talk about like is this going to be a big stimulus when it yeah people get these because I think it's I mean it's so far away a lot of people there's a lot of people that sold their claims at like 10 20 30 cents to non crypto like you know these people that just buy claims as like a trade uh and then if for a lot of them like if you if you sold your claim at like 10 20 cents and then you just like bought soul then how many people do that I mean FTX like had a lot of soul people on it right yeah so but no but my point is like um it's probably not as big of a stimulus as people are expecting because a lot of that is gonna go to these people who are just buying claims right and they're not gonna like deploy into the market.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I think you had a decent yeah you had some selling like you had some real panic selling in the uh like sub 30 cents price range like 10 20 30 that was basically immediately that's probably um uh funds where LPs needed like yeah we're just like get us anything back and and had to do that um because it it's really hard to rationalize selling at that value right like at that point you might as well I feel like it just makes sense to to hold out for some clarity um because what is 10 cents on the dollar really going to offer you um and then I I think you had a decent amount of selling in the 40s and 50s for sure where you know this was actually like a meaningful amount and you can if you think the markets are going to heat up the opportunity cost is massive and so I do think you had a decent amount of selling because of opportunity cost.
SPEAKER_01That whole 96% thing right that's that's of customers but not of money right and that's what really matters like 96% times a bunch of small accounts is is a meaningless amount of money. Whereas it it's like it really boils down to the larger peeps and and kind of what they're doing. That being said I do think there was a decent amount of selling and it'll kind of continue um dripping around right it's it's just funds that are are basically because now it's selling at like 90 cents and say okay if I need to hold for seven months because it's basically like ARBing um not Arbing because there's different levels of risk but it's it's just like distress funds that are where their mandate is to return you know low teens percent or something like that on an annualized basis and uh this is is part of what they do.
SPEAKER_01So I think you'll you'll still continue seeing that there's definitely going to be some distros uh whenever some kind of stimulus whenever that happens but I I think it's been kind of sprinkled throughout rather than being this one lumpy stim um middle of next year.
SPEAKER_00Because if you know like if you are eventually going to put this money back into crypto and you know you're not gonna get it for seven months like and there's pretty clear clarity that it's gonna be what's going to be a return it's like why wouldn't you sell it now?
SPEAKER_02It's like if you're bullish on crypto you're gonna put it in you probably think stuff's gonna go up more than 10% I'm as a claim holder it's just like annoying to go through the the process honestly like it's just yeah I haven't really I looked into it a while ago and it's it was seemed really annoying to to to go through maybe maybe now it's easier but I I think it it's like my my claim's decent uh like size and and still I'm not really incentivized to go look into it because yeah so I assume there's a lot of lazy people in the same boat.
SPEAKER_02I don't know.
SPEAKER_01There's lazy and then yeah I I have an unfortunately large claim but there's also not all claims are treated equally and it's a very PvP environment because there's a finite amount of money and so um you know every dollar that they can hold for you for various reasons they will attempt to and so I think you had one interesting one useful I think point would be to see you know what percentage of claims are in a clean standing and and it's all public so you can kind of do the math on the claim size and and and what standing it's in and if you if it's in good standing you can probably assume with some high level of confidence that it was sold.
SPEAKER_01And then it's the ones that have weird quirks and and other things that are going to be pretty big hurdles on the selling process and speaking you know personally to that that I think those are where most of the STEMI can potentially be. So if somebody wants to go and do some of that math where you just scrape all of these PDFs you can probably get a good estimate of of how much has been sold.
SPEAKER_02Yeah that would be interesting for sure um and then also worth noting the lawyers got paid one and a half billion dollars which is to me just insane. Yeah I mean at the I've tried to think about it a bit like what they they could be doing. Yeah I don't I've had unfortunately through the years in crypto dealt with and and we we have at Delphi like spent a good amount of money on lawyers and to me I have to say it's the most broken industry I've ever interacted with like you you literally have uh you you just get sent like how many hours they spent on things uh you're paying like for the top law firms like thousands of of dollars an hour you have like zero transparency um you're often like paying them to basically learn to teach them about crypto like to to tell explain like very basic concepts to them they're they're billing you for all of that they're billing you for time spent reading emails like by the minute um and they just like have no incentive really like this this model of getting paid per hour has creates like the reverse incentive for efficiency right you you just end up paying out absurd amounts for things that that aren't aren't clear up front and I've also been just like really unimpressed with their work honestly like the quality of their work like you even in some of these defenses like I don't know the the uh we never talked about it but I thought the TFL case maybe we should speak about at some point like that I thought the defense was was was was pretty terrible there um I thought the the SPF defense wasn't wasn't super great either and yeah these people are making like in this case in the in the case of the FTX bankruptcy like one and a half billion dollars for what seems like basically an like administrative job right you're just finding all the assets and selling them like how is this a horrible job at that too by the way yeah like some of the like the the the the amount of money that was lost on some of these sales to you know time timing is one thing um right it like everyone has has poor timing sometimes and and it's so much easier to judge that in in hindsight but others that were were you know there's a rush sale at a discount just to get it out the door when there was no other sense of urgency for anything else made no sense right like why are we urgent in uh on something that that needs that like you can actually extract more if you're patient with and then very you know slow on on kind of the the the other sides um yeah like if you do the math on on on how much was spent per hour through the the life of this thing is is just egregious like there's just there's no way to rationalize even the tech yeah don't let you calculate like how long it's been and do it per hour at the 1.5 billion well what it's been in like a year and this is where this this is where I'm way more bullish decentralized governance than than most people because you realize that like governance in general is just hard and and like the thing with decentralized governance is you you see it and so you see all the chaos but like with with with this stuff and you it's like these guys were getting liquidated on Ave right like that that that's the part we could see like the tip of the iceberg that we could see I imagine the the hours and hours of waste that were that that were spent in the background with this.
SPEAKER_02And I honestly think a decentralized governance process would have done a better job like picking uh like like handling this even when you see like especially the mature communities like maker and Ave I don't know like the governance is really hard and when you see this kind of stuff when you see Congress discuss things and like all the lemmings there it just uh yeah I do think there's there's room for for a better system here. It would be interesting to see like what would happen in a because we haven't really had a a DeFi protocol with significant bad debt where like where you really have to decide because it because at that point like it's the the the governance token holders have control right have governance control like in the case of Ave or something they'd be like pretty significantly diluted to make uh depositors whole and it would be interesting to see whether they would act in the benefit of the protocol or in their own benefit.
SPEAKER_04But I probably their own benefit well I mean what's the token going to be worth if they don't do it it depends on the size of the of the hole I guess.
SPEAKER_02I don't know why would you ever use Ave again if they voted against your interest as a depositor it could theoretically be done programmatically right like there's some Oracle that identifies whether there's been bad debt and then governance control just shifts to like the the a token holders you know like and and now all the depositors are locked and they have governance power proportional to their to their holdings and they vote for you know who they want to distribute these yeah I don't know I feel like there's there's a lot of inefficiency in this in these bankruptcy processes and with with legal industry generally yeah so I just did the math 550 days since the FTX bankruptcy so that's 2.7 million a day in lawyer lawyer fees if it's 1.5 billion income over 100k an hour yeah it's a lot um I would have done that for way cheaper all right let's thanks Duncan well they had to learn MetaMask that's like a couple they also just got like hacked and stuff too it was ridiculous hacked liquidated everything there's definitely seven figures paid for people spending hours learning to use MetaMask like more what else is there to do what else is there to do yeah 2.7 million a day yeah it definitely took them a couple weeks it's fucking wild looking for liquidation bankruptcy services altcoin gem hunter is branching out uh he's studying for his bar all right guys I think we uh yeah I think let's let's wrap it there thanks very much um I think it was a good episode see you again in two weeks yeah nothing said on the hive mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens this podcast is strictly for informational purposes only and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions not financial advice