This episode covers topics such as ETF flows, GBTC selling, the long-term outlook for Bitcoin, the potential approval of an ETF, the buyers of Bitcoin, the conviction of investors, the timing of ETF approval, 4844 and base rollups, Drip and Solana L2s, and scalable rollups. In this conversation, the hosts discuss memes and meme dilution in the cryptocurrency market. They talk about the rapid rise of new memes and the potential challenges of investing in them. They also discuss the Athena project and its risks and benefits. The hosts touch on the impact of higher rates on DeFi and the potential consequences of integrating stablecoins into various platforms. They conclude with some closing remarks. 00:00 - Introduction 01:03 - ETF Flows 05:55 - Long-Term Outlook 07:20 - ETF Approval 08:20 - Buyers of Bitcoin 09:47 - Investor Conviction 13:07 - ETF Rejection 14:35 - ETH ETF and Maker Endgame 22:31 - 4844 and Base Rollups 29:35 - Drip and Solana L2s 34:18 - Scalable Rollups 35:10 - Memes and Meme Dilution 50:35 - Discussion on Athena 01:05:26 - Impact of Higher Rates on DeFi 01:10:41 - Closing Remarks Disclosures: Nothing said on The Hivemind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. The podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Jose, Yan, Duncan, Ceteris, and our guests may advise or hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed. Delphi's transparency page can be viewed here. Get a 20% discount on a premium Delphi PRO or PRO+ for listening to this episode! Follow the links below or use the codes on checkout: 20% off Delphi PRO annual Code: PODCASTPRO Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastpro 20% off Delphi PRO+ annual Code: PODCASTTEAMS Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastteams Follow Delphi Digital Website: https://members.delphidigital.io Twitter / X: https://x.com/delphi_digital
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Nothing said on the hive mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions, not financial advice. Hi everyone, my name is Jose Masedu. I'm I'm back and welcome to another episode of the Hive Mind Podcast.
SPEAKER_00The goal of the podcast is to provide an inside look into the Delphi Hive Mind, uh combining some of our brightest minds from research, ventures, uh, and labs. So with us today, as always, there's Jan Lieberman, who's our managing partners at Ventures. Uh, there's Duncan, also known as Fluff Capital, and Cederis from from Research. Guys, I've been I've been out of the loop for like a month for various reasons. What are we what are we covering today? Where are we starting?
SPEAKER_01It's like the big thing everyone uh is tracking nowadays just because of the impact it has on a on a day-to-day basis, uh ETF flows.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, do we do we do we care that GVTC has like such large outflows every day? Or is it kind of just like rip the band-aid off? Maybe it's just a bankruptcy getting through it. Yeah, like I don't know. Did like do people care about this anymore?
SPEAKER_01I think so. It's it's more I think it's more not on a on a day-to-day basis, but is this a precursor for a prolonged trend? Right. And so if you think about the the size of the outflows on a daily basis, not that big of a deal. But if you think they're gonna persist for weeks, then that that's kind of where it gets worrisome. And um like yes, you're looking at stale data every time it comes out, but you know, a few hours stale, but it's it's more about what is the trend.
SPEAKER_01So I do think people care about it, but it it it's it it's still like a bullish element where you can rip off the band-aid uh to some extent and get beyond it and kind of you know, then it's just pure inflows, and you're worried less about the kind of uh permanent outflow from GBTC.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it would be a lot different if we saw like you know, iBit or Fidelities ETF like seeing outflows now, but like GBDC is kind of this like finite, you know, all these bankrupt estates are in there, they still have like super high fees. Um, a lot of people are super underwater on that trade. And so it's like kind of a one time, not a one time, but like uh a finite amount of selling that that keeps on coming out. I think it'd be a lot more kind of concerning for like the medium to long term if we saw you know, Bitcoin was at 73k last week and now it's at you know 64.
SPEAKER_02If we saw like iBid and Fidelity flows turn negative because you know it wasn't kind of the the long-term like capital allocators we kind of thought were coming into the ETS, but like maybe it was like these momentum traders who kind of like aped in at the top and now they're selling, that would be a little bit more discouraging. But since it's GBTC and we kind of know there's still this like overhang for bankruptcies, you know, maybe it's relevant in in the short term to midterm, but they can only sell one time.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, I saw a tweet yesterday. It's like okay, like a hundred more days of of these outflows and it's over. But obviously, you know, probably bought up or like um stops uh a decent amount before that, but it's not like uh I think it's not that bearish, like it's bearish like short term, short to midterm, but like any any sort of long longer term view, it's it's really not that big of a deal.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, this had the most I saw something yesterday since 2009, a CTM with the most outflows, and it's been trading for like a month or two. I mean, it just goes to show how dumb the whole this whole like situation is.
SPEAKER_01I think part of it is also so you you know when you redeem, yes, you know, you're dealing with the two percent um fee, which on a on a you know one-year time horizon doesn't really move the needle on something that that's the two percent redemption fee. No, it's just a two percent like management fee. So you're eating two percent one and a half. But so if you look like the discount started closing uh over the summer, right? So you have I think part of the calculus is people are sitting on massive gains, and and so you know, per uh I wonder if the flows slow down now and then pick back up over the summer when people are have done have uh captured kind of long-term capital gains on these, uh, since assume a lot a lot of it's Americans.
SPEAKER_01And so I think there's some argument where you know maybe flows slow down and then pick back up once people have uh passed the one-year holding period, right? Because if you're just gonna sell and recycle into Bitcoin, then then at this point you you're better off eating, you know, another couple of months of of you know a one and a half percent on an annualized basis fee and and waiting to reduce your tax burden by like 20 or something.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, do you think that the GBTC selling is way more likely not to like flow back in to their products at this point? Um, because yeah, you just do the math on like how long the fee would have to eat into like making it worth it to convert today. When those people sell, they're probably just buying something else with it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and there's also still like the some like bankrupt entities and some people who just kind of got blown out on that trade that they're still unwinding. But yeah, it it's a medium to to short term thing, so it's not I don't think it's something to be worried about too much. Like the IBIT and Fidelity flows have still been, you know, positive. They've slowed down a little, but it is like definitely interesting to see. Like we had in the first two weeks of March, like really strong flows every single day, like 500 million net flows every day.
SPEAKER_02And people got really excited. There's a lot of like leverage buildup behind that. So this I think is like a good test to see, you know, will iBit infidelity flows continue, even you know, with this 15% pullback. Um, and if they do, I think that's a pretty positive sign for who's allocating. Uh, I guess like the risk was, you know, some people kind of speculated that some of these flows were from more like speculative entities, they're kind of momentum traders.
SPEAKER_02And so, like, if we see you know, Bitcoin pull back 20% or something, are they gonna start to exit? And then that's where we could maybe get in the shorter term, like a deeper drawdown. But so far, we haven't had any outflows from from the big ETFs like IBIT and Fidelity. So, yeah, it's more of a just a short midterm thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, one point that uh I heard Alex Kruger make was that um just based on people he was talking to in the tratify world and and like working with RAs and all of that, is it takes a while to kind of get the marketing uh machine going at full capacity. And and he said something you know, based on kind of people he's talked to, it's at 25% now, and and realistically, it doesn't really crank up until uh to to closer to max capacity until end of year, right? So you have that as a as definitely a bullish uh uh tailwind.
SPEAKER_01The other uh interesting um tidbit would be to understand how much of the GBTC flows goes right back into right, and it and like if you look anecdotally, there doesn't really seem to be a big relationship between um outflows and inflows, um, right? Like on big days of outflows, you have an offsetting inflow and and vice versa. So uh yeah, it's it's hard to kind of tell. And and maybe it it would operate on the lag, right?
SPEAKER_01It takes a day to redeem, and then however long it takes to settle, and then you recycle, so it wouldn't necessarily even be seen on a on a daily netting basis.
SPEAKER_00And curious, who do we think is is buying this, these, these bitcoins, and like I guess how diamond-hearted, diamond-handed are they compared to existing participants? Because I've seen a few people kind of speculate that all the bitcoins are gonna get locked in the CTF, it's gonna be the it's gonna be different because of that, like let you need less capital to to to pump the price. To me, that seems like the opposite of what I would think intuitively. I would think these people coming in would be kind of more uh paper-handed, if anything.
SPEAKER_04But I mean they're not, but they're not locked in the ETF. That's what I mean. Yeah, you can just tell from um I think so. I think people who put it in retirement accounts, especially when you start working it into those target date funds and everything, that is not getting sold. Okay, that's just I mean, it gets rebalanced like as someone gets older, but that stuff is not really gonna move too much.
SPEAKER_01I think it's definitely more diamond hand than your average uh crypto investor. I think the longer people there's this like I probably ebbs and flows where people get into crypto at first, and then you know they're just buying and holding, then they spend a little more time in there, they get confident, think they can start trading, then they blow up, and then they go back to holding. And and and so I think your average crypto holder is turning over their portfolio or or their Bitcoin more than the average ETF buyer.
SPEAKER_00But you think that the people who are here now are like before the ETF are the most high conviction, right? Like if you wait until the ETF to get any exposure to Bitcoin, that's it's just like yeah, it's a it's a pretty specific demographic. I don't know how you know what I mean. It feels like the highest conviction would be the people who were here already and the people who are who were who are buying in later are like the people who wouldn't even touch this stuff until it had an ETF, until it was wrapped in an in an ETF. So it just seems like intuitively those people would be also like more paper-handed when when like bad headlines come out or the price just dumps a bunch, or or or whatever it might be.
SPEAKER_02But I think it's just like an access thing, right? It's like you know, a lot of the people don't care enough to like have bought it before, but now it's easy to do. They're they're buying it now.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, the the other thing, too, just to add on that people always talk about how like bomb and pop investors panic and are the one like selling in bear markets and everything. But if you actually look at the last bear market, retail was actually not panicking and selling, they were actually just continuing to buy. And there's the institutions that were selling everything down, and actually, for the most part, were the ones late to like realize the bull market was back. And so if you look at the BTC ETFs, you look at the average trade size, it's pretty clearly that most of this is retail activity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, what I don't know. I think that I think Jim Blanco, I think that's his name, put out a post on that, like thinking that it might be speculative flows, but I don't know how the relationship would work between like the ETFs all arving against each other, and then also the ETFs like arving against like Binance. I feel like that data point might be misleading. Basically, like he um put out an article trade size, right? Yeah, the average trade size for like i bit was like 17,000, and then like qqq was like 150,000, and gld was like 60,000.
SPEAKER_04So it's like so you're saying because there's like way more venues to RBIT. Yeah, that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02That doesn't that's what I would initially think. Like, I think his like the data points he he pointed to were like number of trades and average trade size, and I'm like, I feel like that could be pretty easily explained by it being ARB through all these different venues, which and then he said like the gut feeling about like the the uh like investment advisors he's spoken to haven't begin uh begun to allocate yet. But I think those are pretty like one that's anecdotal, and then the other two I think could probably be explained by ARB. So I think that's probably you know, we won't know until like next week if Bitcoin keeps going down, and then we start to see like iBit and FBTC outflows, then like, yeah, maybe that argument has some more merit, but I think it's a pretty big leap or pretty big stretch to to kind of assume assume that just given how many places and globally traded it is.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Want to talk about the ETH ETF and how the ETH maxis all hate the Bloomberg guys now because they don't like what they're saying.
SPEAKER_02Wait, and and one more thing on because I feel like that ETF conversation we just had kind of had a negative tone, but I think we're all super bullish on this, like longer term, and it's just like working through these bankruptcies, and we're a bit more sensitive because like we're watching it every day, like yeah, we're watching it every day, so yeah, like these guys aren't panicking, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, exactly. We very few these ETF buyers are as glued in on day-to-day moves and as sensitive to them. I mean, there there certainly some are, but I I just it because it's a passive flow that happens every two weeks, or or someone's actively rebalancing out of their 401k. Yeah, no, I'm right there with you. Yeah, so I think long none of the excited.
SPEAKER_00None of the people I spoke to in in TratBy, including some people that that uh have like RAA software and stuff, expected this kind of price action this quickly after the ETF launch, honestly. Like most people who spoke to them, uh like they speak to a lot of advisors, like they didn't even a lot of them didn't even know what Bitcoin was yet, you know, like they they would they they wouldn't put their their customers in Bitcoin or whatever, like and they they said it would probably take like it was more of a years thing in terms of the education and getting you know getting the the Larry Fink marketing machine going and all that.
SPEAKER_00So I think we're pretty bullish how ahead of schedule we are. So you're telling me the investors are sidelined in fiat? We will pump violently from the bottom. So next thing, yeah, you want to talk about the ETF and like commit.
SPEAKER_04Well, yes, a couple, so I don't know how much we need really to spend on it. Just interesting data points is like ethy, the grayscale trust discount is back to like 20 discount. That got bit up to single digits, like seven percent discount or so. And now people are just dumping that. Uh, which kind of just shows a lot of pessimist, pessimist, like pessimism I can't say this word. Pessimism, pessimism, pessimism, pessimism around the the ETF getting approved. The Bloomberg guys say this is like way different than uh way different than uh last like what would happen with Bitcoin.
SPEAKER_04And then yeah, this headline, we were recording our office hours. Um, check it out if you're a Delphi member on the portal. Uh, but we were recording that yesterday, and that headline came out as we were recording that. And yeah, I don't know, I don't know what to make of this. Like, is this it kind of feels like this is just a tactic to not have the eTF approved and kind of like Gensler's last big raw, it's never actually gonna like go to court or anything. But like I don't get it. If Ripple, if XRP isn't a security, how you how's I that's what I don't get. XRP listen, if you can't make XRP a security, I don't know what is a security.
SPEAKER_01Like yeah, yeah, losing a court seems inevitable for them. Then it's so I I just yeah, it's it's it would be an odd fight battle to take just to take another L because an L seems inevitable, right? Like Coinbase is gonna get involved, and and now they have a they've always had a big war chest, but it's obviously even bigger now.
SPEAKER_04And yeah, yeah, I mean, we should hear about that Coinbase case soon, too.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, it's it's just so bizarre. This guy like comes in in the bull market and like just goes after legit projects, loses most important cases, and like misses all the actual fraud that was going on with like three arrows and ftx and like all the stuff that was actually fraudulent that he could have he was like buddying up with SPF and then just keeps like keeps the Bitcoin ETF from getting from getting fucking done for for years, and then it does get done, Bitcoin pumps to new all-time high, and he he's like on on TV trying to say this is yeah, it's just like it's just crazy.
SPEAKER_01It's it's sad.
SPEAKER_04Listen, if you if you watch his old videos, like Gary Gensler's a G. Like he actually understands like he gets it. He under he's talking about when you would launch a token to bootstrap. He talks about how he literally says ETH is not a security, right? Like doing a lecture. He and like he talks about how you you you want to get a uh a token to bootstrap, and so he he got this all and he was in. And I just think, yeah, it's just kind of sad to see how people change when like politics.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's just political.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it pumped at some point, but he was he was saying that that was from like 2018 when when bootstrapping stuff like that that's that's pretty early to start using that uh term, right? For for for the role of a token.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but he was probably in sushi.
SPEAKER_02I I think it would be really or what would be interesting to come out of all this stuff. So have you guys seen the tweets about like the Ethereum Foundation that like they took down their canary or something and maybe they got subpoenaed? But it would be interesting to see like how much of the ETH supplies owned um by like these early people if they just like bought in a bunch of different wallets and like actually like how centralized it could end up being. That would be kind of interesting to see. It'd be worse than Ripple, yeah. No, no, no, for sure not, but it would just be really cool to see like from yeah, just like an out of curiosity standpoint, like how how much of the early ETH people like participate in the ICO, how much do they own, that sort of thing, just like across different wallets.
SPEAKER_01Because I know that's always kind of supposed to be released.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if that'll be released, but I could see it some of that coming out uh in the in the securities, like if they're actually gonna go after it as a security, which would be interesting, but we'll see.
SPEAKER_00Uh yeah. I mean, yeah, I think he just wants jurisdiction to assert jurisdiction over everything, honestly. Like even his latest videos, um, you know, he does he does these like cute officers videos with his with his fireplace in the back. I don't know who definitely um more of a face for radio, but he he does the uh he does these videos and he's talking about like corporate governance and and like this thing's a matter of state law, but like let me tell you why actually the SEC should be should be in charge of this, right?
SPEAKER_00And it's like pretty much with everything, like AI, like you he just wants the SEC to have to have mandate over everything. Um, and then he's just always also giving his his opinion on Bitcoin, right? Like in a really inappropriate way, like even at the end of the ETF approval, he has that paragraph there, like, by the way, this is used for crime and like highly risky and stuff. It's like, bro, no one is coming to you for investment advice, like and anyone who did has just gotten wrecked. Like, you know, this thing pumps every time you're not like, yeah, I don't know. He's just a really annoying character.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, he wants to be a main character for sure.
SPEAKER_02It's probably I think it's probably pretty political. Like, I don't know, like like Setter's just saying, you go back, watch his old videos, he he understands it.
SPEAKER_01I feel like it's probably like very political at this point, but I think for him, it's it's just like you know, he's he's been thinking about his next step for a while, and so it's kind of cozying up to those in power now with the goal of of leveraging that to move higher up the government totem pole.
SPEAKER_00He's pot committed for sure at this point. I wonder at what point Larry Fink just calls him though, like, yo, cool it now, like settle down, sir.
SPEAKER_01Uh would it would be probably I mean, yeah. So then I we we brought this up on last week's uh convo, but would it be it'd almost be more long-term bullish to get the ETF rejected now, just because it it is an inevitability, and so you know, push that catalyst out, let BTC continue to capture mind share and and flows, and then you know, launch the ETH ETF, you get to point at how much has already gone into BTC and all of that.
SPEAKER_01And and I do think, you know, comparing the two situations, if you launch one in May versus end of year or early next year, if you're thinking about where we are a year from now, I think you know everything is higher if we launch it later.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I agree with this 100%. Like, I don't even think it's a question that later is better. Like, to your point, there's still a lot of like RIAs and like institutional investors that that to uh Jose's point earlier are like not in yet, right? And they haven't gone through the whole marketing thing and everything. You got to give that like you gotta give the BTC ETF like a year to just have these people focus on one asset and not kind of make it confusing, not add too much to the mix and just let that build up.
SPEAKER_04And then, you know, you get Trump elected uh at the end of the year, and then you get the ETH ETF a few months after. That just feels like the best possible scenario. Like I like there's a risk, I feel like there's a risk that if it goes through in May, it actually ends up being kind of bearish because it's like too much too soon, and the market just kind of gets ahead of itself. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'd agree with that. Um, we have a couple of other topics on the on the docket. Of of all of those, I'm the one I find most interesting is Athena and and Maker Endgame and stuff like that. What do you guys think? Rid you want to talk about 4844 or base or any any of the other stuff first?
SPEAKER_04I mean, we can do there's not there's not a ton to talk about 484. Basically, um kind of went as expected, DA got cheaper, but you're not solving any execution scaling issues. So, you know, it changes the dynamic of like ETH's fee revenue, right? If you look at the other day for base, Coinbase made 1.4 million, optimism made like 300k, and ETH Ethereum made like 2K.
SPEAKER_02Mm made like uh hundred.
SPEAKER_04So basically, all this value now, all this value is going to Coinbase, right? Now that DA is basically free, and I think this is just something that the industry, I mean, DA has gone through like innovative destruction or whatever. Nobody's paying, nobody's paying for DA anymore, not in like a meaningful manner. And so if you're just thinking about like pure fundamentals of actual revenue, it's just it's just execution, right? It's just hot spots, like economic activity that people are willing to pay a premium for.
SPEAKER_04And so if all if all of that is shifted to like L2s and other layer ones, and that's all captured by like those L2s and those layer ones, right? And this is why there has been a pretty big like renewed renewed focus on based roll-ups recently, which is essentially using Ethereum validators to do the sequencing for L2s, right? So now all this like MEV, all this execution revenue can kind of flow back to the L1. And so I think that this new everyone talks about like ETH alignment and everything.
SPEAKER_04I think based roll-ups are gonna be like the new alignment. And there's a couple, there's like Tyco, and there's another one that are launching based rollups. And this is also like the bull case for TIA, like because TIA to me is like the most overvalued token based on what it is today. Uh, and same with like DIM dimension, like just really to speak to speak honestly. Um, but like if you can envision that Celestia now starts to offer other products, right? They start uh and they they start doing like this base sequencing where you you're using Celestia validators for the sequencing, that changes the dynamic, right?
SPEAKER_04Because now all like the MEV on these roll-ups can flow back to Celestia, right? So I think that if you're so like it's hard to tell who is buying Celestia for what, like if if you if if people are buying it because they think that all these roll-ups are gonna post DA to Celestia, and that's the only thesis, then yeah, that's super overvalued to me, even with all like the bridging and security benefits and everything. But if you do think that they're gonna start offering all these other services, and that's kind of part of the bull case, then I can then I can buy it some more because D just like DA on its own is not like not enough to move the needle.
SPEAKER_02How much did Celestia make? Like if they had you know all the current roll-ups on the posting, isn't it something like sale like zona specific of our industry?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's like yeah, but we got like they can they can increase, you know, like there's things you know Solana made a third of ETH's like revenue the other day, right? Obviously, it was uh extremely highly like big demand period, but I wouldn't be surprised if Solana's fees are above Ethereum for some days in the next couple months, like straight up, yeah. Definitely possible.
SPEAKER_02Sisyppus, I think tweeted something like if you had like 50,000 roll-ups posting DA to Celestia, it'd be making like 10 million dollars.
SPEAKER_04So so here's here's the nuance, okay? If you use the full capacity as it's at today, yeah, it's like five, 10 million a year. But the point of Celestia is that you keep making the blocks bigger, right? You keep increasing like validated requirement validator requirements because you have this economies of scale with like the data availability sampling with all the different roll-ups built on it, that you're able to like increase hardware requirements and you're able to increase it um like intelligently, okay? So it's not totally fair to look at it like just in what they're at now, right?
SPEAKER_04Because this capacity will increase more and more over time. Um, but I but still, like, yeah, I don't think you can that like why do you think this whole like Tia is money? Mean everybody wants their thing to be money, and that's just such a fragile narrative to me. Like, everything can't be money. Like, I understand everything is money to an extent, but if you're like just look at Adam, I don't know, man. Just look at Adam, like nothing else.
SPEAKER_02It is a good buy, what's it at 15 or 13 or something?
SPEAKER_04I mean, listen, I think when I say overvalued Tia 2, I'm also talking about legit projects that I'm kind of like talking about, right? I think Celestia's like one of them.
SPEAKER_00I think there are a bunch of projects like uh that if you apply the same logic to like a cash flows lens, are gonna look really overvalued. Solano was was probably not the best example. Say, I guess, would be would be a good example. A bunch of the all L1s, honestly, would be would be a good example. If you're like you're almost projecting out a lot of future growth, and I think in in Celestia's case, it's the the I'm not commenting on the current valuation, but projecting future growth is is warranted. I think there's gonna be definitely thousands of of roll-ups uh at end game, definitely more even more than that.
SPEAKER_00And we're kind of seeing that already, like with the amount of people launching L3s, including the the founder of Drip. Including the founder of Drip on Solana saying that uh we're gonna need L2s on Solana, some kind of dedicated block space and stuff like that, which was big narrative violation, got a lot of hate from from the Solana community. But that's like one of the builder of one of the most uh well, definitely one of the one of the most used apps, I'd say, on on Solana, uh saying that. So I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but so a couple things. First of all, absolutely Solana will have roll-ups, and so I mean you can say it's a narrative violation, sure. It doesn't matter, like they will have them. And then second of all, to yeah, the drip founders, a lot of his issues today. Actually, Solana has a lot of issues going on with like networking uh components and everything. Quick is my understanding is quick is just a disaster. So it's not even like fee markets, even Toli conceded on this the other day that it has nothing to do with the chain economics right now.
SPEAKER_04It's like all the networking components are kind of just not optimal, and so yeah, just going back to to the last year though. So I said I said T was like most overvalued. Okay, I'm saying that if you're just talking about it on DA, because I do actually believe kind of this narrative that they are will like offer a ton more services, like they'll verticalize, they'll do all this stuff, and uh and it is the most like elegant DA layer that we have.
SPEAKER_02Uh so okay, let's talk about some memes or something. That was that was a long monologue.
SPEAKER_00For those who don't okay, so we talked about this last week, but like just before the memes, it it is I do think the drip thing is more meaningful because if you can see that Solana will have L2s, then a lot of its design choices start to make less sense, right? Like you you you actually like I mean ETH design choices don't fully make sense either because it wasn't built for an L2 world, but in an L2 world you do want like the most decentralized and censorship resistant base layer because you're offloading all execution to the to the layer twos, right?
SPEAKER_00And so if Solana ends up looking the same as ETH, um where you know L1 is that has obviously like orders of magnitude, more capacity, but it's still congested and and activity eventually has to move to L2s, then why not ETH?
SPEAKER_04Well, I mean, so like you should we should remember. I'm playing devil's advocate here. I'm obviously Solana. So we should remember what drip is.
SPEAKER_02I don't even know what drip is. I thought you guys were talking about drip for a second.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so drip, drip, drip actually makes sense as so I don't I don't believe okay, so can you explain what it is? I drip is like some place for artists to issue NFTs, okay. And they use compressed NFTs on Solana and they do a ton, like they're they're pumping out a ton, they have the most, you know, as best as you can measure, actual users. Um, they have a lot of activity, okay. But so when you talk about like the future, people talk about this, you know, millions of roll-ups thing.
SPEAKER_04Some people talk about a single, you know, world computer, whatever. I do think for like the financial value, 80% of it is gonna be on like three to five chains. Um, and like drip doesn't really fit in that category of like financial value in that aspect. So it does make sense for drip to probably be. I mean, you know, it it'll be tough for drip if they do actually move to another chain because like right now it works seamlessly with like the saga phone. A lot of people use it on that.
SPEAKER_04People have it with like you know, like all the salon and native guys just have it open all the time. So it will, if they do move to an L2, like I mean, I don't know, we'll see if they lose users or something. I think it'll be a more challenging like migration to make, but but yeah, like that's that's like the kind of app. So if you talk about sure, I can see a world world where there's like a million roll-ups and you have a lot of these niche apps that make sense to be a roll-up.
SPEAKER_04I mean, drip is doing like hundred like I don't know, they're just doing a lot of they're just putting a lot of shit on chain, and so um, I mean, there's other L2s for Solana coming too, right? Grass is doing an L2, they announced last week. I mean, code is already an L2 in a sense, and there I think there's something there's like a there's a perp dex that I think it was Zeta that mentioned it, and so yeah, like you are gonna see Solana L2s.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I assume you're you want to move move on, Duncan. I saw it. Duncan just does not care about this at all.
SPEAKER_02This is why there's a good contrast on the show. Cedar is very, very deep into the research side, but it's interesting. It's it's interesting to listen to, but sometimes I get slightly bored. I want Cedarus to make a more of a point. Tell me what to buy, sir.
SPEAKER_04But the point, the point is that, like, sure, roll-ups on salon is a narrative violation, but that doesn't look that's not like a bad thing for soul, is is like my take. It's like it's just that's the new reality, and so you can you can talk about how they were wrong about this, but it doesn't matter now, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Right, like who cares? Like, it's still gonna be net beneficial for soul, sure.
SPEAKER_04If they're launched on Solana, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, one can yeah, there you go. So so buy Solana Center has been saying that since eight dollars. Genius, but yeah, but yeah, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00I I guess my uh I don't want to belabor this, it's whoever belabored it and Duncan might fall asleep. But the the um I guess the point is like if if everything converges to a roll-up architecture, maybe lends credence to some of the L1 designs we've seen recently that are literally just optimized for roll-ups, right? Or some of the things Vitalik said about how he would have designed Ethereum had he known about zero knowledge proofs at the time. Like, cuz because then there is no there there is really no like monolith, right? In the in that sense.
SPEAKER_00There's there's like maybe chains that are more monolithic than others that have more capacity than others, but there really isn't like yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I don't know. I don't even know if like monolithic.
SPEAKER_02Let's keep it brief, have you guys heard of the center chain without gone?
SPEAKER_04All right, let's uh how long has the center chain been coming?
SPEAKER_02It may not in like I think based on the last announcement, like in like three weeks behind three or four weeks.
SPEAKER_04Okay, I just want to say one thing on roll-ups. There is no need, you do roll-ups don't need to like um concede this like liquidity fragmentation thing. Like, you can actually build scalable roll-ups, and you'll see these designs way more.
SPEAKER_00And those are the roll-ups I'm like most interested in moving forward because I I just I just think for pickers, sir, or project names of these if these things are like none of these things are like launched yet, so like fuel and stuff, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Like fuel could be one. I know Eclipse is doing stuff. I think Mega ETH is another one. Yeah, mega ETH. Um, you could also take like some of these paralyzed EVMs, like maybe you can take those clients and do some stuff. So, yeah, that's what I'm kind of like interested in. Somebody will build like a scalable, a very scaled roll-up.
SPEAKER_00Nice. We wanna you you want to talk about memes or Athena? Uh Duncan wants to talk about memes, it seems like. Josie wants to show his bag. I want to show my bags, yeah. It's gonna be my my turn for once.
SPEAKER_02Uh well, I just wanted to touch on the memes because we were talking about it last week, and I think there's been some interesting develops, but I don't care if we go Athena first.
SPEAKER_00In the memes best? Go on, do do do the memes then.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so like last week we had Jason on the the king of dog coins at Delphi. He honestly uh nailed that trade like really early on, was really early to bonk and with.
SPEAKER_04But well, can I just cut you off for like one quick second? One thing about Jason that I find I like very much respect him for is that he was bear king, okay, for like two years and was super correct. And as soon as he changed, he like knew right away he bought dog coins, and like to be able to like switch because most people get into like a perma bear kind of mindset, right? And they can't get out of it. So I I find I found that like kind of crazy how he was able to switch from that to that so quickly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, he he did it well for sure. And um, but so him and I have been talking a lot like every day. I'm just telling him to get ready to sell his dog coins. I feel like we're kind of reaching a um kind of like a pivot point on the meme side of things, especially like over the past two weeks. We saw two two new memes launched in Solana, Bohm and Slurf, both hit like 24 or like within 24 hours hit a billion dollar market cap and had exchange listings on Binance and Bybit.
SPEAKER_02And I touched on this a little bit last cycle, or sorry, last podcast with Jason, whereas like in 2021, you know, you had Doge and Shib, which were kind of the only memes that were were really like turned massive, and they were available on like all the exchanges to buy, and they had pretty incredible runs. And now everyone who survived that cycle and is into this cycle, like Jason, right? Like, like you said, as soon as he stopped being bearish, he just jumped directly into memes because that's what did the best last cycle.
SPEAKER_02Um, but you're starting to get this kind of like meme dilution, is what I'm calling it, of like all these new memes, especially on Solana, where it's so cheap to create something. Like all these new memes are popping up, and where it was Doge and Ship last cycle, now you have like Doge, Shib, Pepe, Bunk, Whiff, uh like Slurf, Boam, um all of these, you know, multi-billion dollar memes, and they just keep on coming and being popped up. Like uh there's like probably hundreds of coins a day, maybe thousands of coins a day are launching on Solana, just like because it's very low cost to do so, just in the hope of kind of reaching escape velocity and getting a sex listing.
SPEAKER_02So I feel like we're kind of reaching a sorry, go ahead, Jan.
SPEAKER_01The Slurf thing is pretty hilarious, though. Like the the setup there is is pretty unique relative to the rest, in that so basically the backstory is uh 50% of supply is supposed to go to the LP, 50% to presalers. He raised 10 mil. That 10 mil was supposed to be you know paired with half the supply and put into LP and burned. And in the process of burning that LP token, he also burned the 50% that was supposed to go to presalers. So uh yeah, it's now you have this weird scenario where you have like a an insane ratio in terms of the uh liquidity pool size to market cap size, right?
SPEAKER_01Where you know, if you if you look at kind of any of the other meme coins, it's it's like uh obviously as the price goes higher, the ratio goes higher. But at a at a valuation of like 370 or whatever, 350, it's like three to one in terms of market cap. So there's you know 375 million in market cap and 125 million in the LP pool. And so it's uh it's a pretty interesting setup relative to like you know, Bowdoin, which is one to 100 almost. Um and so yeah, it's I think you can argue that that uh element goes both ways, right?
SPEAKER_01You could you could say it's but I think the the bearish argument is much weaker. Bearish argument being that there's so much liquidity that it's gonna take a lot more to pump the token. Um, but you know, as price goes up, that ratio becomes less and less. And so I don't I don't really see it. I don't really see the the the bearish argument as much for it. I definitely see the the meme solution component, but I I it's it's uh it's pretty hilarious to see that. And then plus like what that market cap, what that liquidity pool allows you to do is trade crazy volumes on chain and and and then all those fees are basically accruing to the the pool.
SPEAKER_01So you've had like five percent of supply get added to the pool just via the the fees of everyone trading on-chain, and so like and then the uh you know another counter to the bearish argument would be that uh once these things get listed on centralized exchanges, they're incredibly liquid anyway. So you're you're you're realistically thinking you're talking about a similar amount of capital to move the price, and so here you just have that on-chain. Um you haven't seen before, yeah. It's it's more just like specifically it's a setup you haven't seen before because it really literally requires burning of 10 million dollars.
SPEAKER_01Um, but yeah.
SPEAKER_00Unrelated to the to the meat of this discussion, but I'm I'm kind of shocked. Why have you decided to die on this anti-meme, Duncan? I wouldn't have expected you of all people to be to be dying on this okay.
SPEAKER_02I watched this is such okay. First of all, yeah, I don't like the fact that it can just be spun up and then like randomly one is just like makes it as like I think it's it's not a good look because a bunch of people are gonna be left holding a bag, and I think people are getting dilute like delusional on them. But more particularly to try and like because I watched this of a sped up or a slow down version of this happen in 2023. So GMX was like the number one performing coin in 2023, GMX and GNS, which is like the two big other like DIDX is just kind of like screwed with with its unlocks and stuff.
SPEAKER_02But GMX was like, you know, perp decks that pays um like uh fees back to holders. We had FTX happen, so there's like a massive narrative around perp Dexes. And um when FTX happened, GMX is at like 25 bucks, and then it traded all the way up to like 90 bucks in April. Well, Bitcoin maybe went up like 30, 50 percent, something like that. And the rest of the alts were just kind of dead. And what we saw on the VC side, and then also just like in general, was everyone was just like looking at GMX is like, okay, the market's like latched onto this because it's actually making money, and like everyone went to go build a perp dex, like literally everyone.
SPEAKER_02And now we have like you know, do IDX, GMX, um, hyperliquid, like Apex from Bybit, Rabbidex, like I'm probably missing a bunch, Vertex, like I'm missing a bunch, but there's a ton of actually like really good perp Dex now that have like launched out of that bear market, and I think it's gonna be really difficult to outperform on a perp dex token. And that's like a perp dex, which actually requires a lot of work and a lot of like capital and liquidity behind them to like build a product. But you've essentially had um this massive kind of dilution among the perp Dexes, where I think it's gonna be very difficult to outperform the market buying one of these tokens because you know it's kind of this weird game theory where whoever hasn't launched a token yet, right now that's hyper liquid, is is kind of the main one who hasn't launched a token.
SPEAKER_02You're incentivized to trade there because you're gonna get an airdrop and you get points. So it's bit and so they take you know most of the volume and the fees, but then they launch a token, someone new comes out. So that kind of happened at a very accelerated, accelerated version. And even though Bitcoin's up double, maybe two and a half times from from April, uh GMX is you know only at 40 bucks. So it's actually down like 50, 60% from the highs because you had this dilution of all these new perp decks coming to market. And what I think we're seeing in memes is like a hyper sped up version of that, where instead of actually there being like a lot to build with the perp decks and like requiring a lot of capital and liquidity and users and all these like you know difficult engineering problems, you have just these memes where there's like hundreds being launched every day.
SPEAKER_02And you know, you have Boehm and Slurf reaching a billion. Obviously, Slurf is an interesting case, I'll agree with with you on there. And so I just think this like cycle is just gonna be like hyper accelerated, and eventually it's gonna be very difficult to outperform on memes. Maybe some will outperform, like if they're on you know, Robinhood and Coinbase, and it's really the one that retail latches onto. But like I think Boehm and Slurf really messed up everything because they got tier one listings in within 24 hours.
SPEAKER_01Slurf doesn't have listing, his bohm is like a different beast. No, that had Binance immediately. Yeah, it has like some perps on Bybit, but like Bohm had Binance like right off the bat, which was yeah, and Bohm started this whole pre-sale thing, which is definitely the worst part of this whole bull market so far.
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, I my whole thing is like we're reading I feel like we're reaching a tipping point in memes where it's gonna be more difficult to outperform because there's all these new ones coming, but I could be wrong.
SPEAKER_01No, no, I think you're right, and like difficult, but like doesn't mean it they won't. I think it's just the difference with with those decks is it's it you anchored a fundamental value, and and so it's a lot the the the I think the game runs out a lot faster because the ceiling is is much more tangible, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And this is why like banana turn this into the I think that one like you see a lot of arguments around meme coins and like both sides, right? People hating on them and saying they're like the scourge of the industry, and then other people like really overintellectualizing them and making reasons why why this is like the next why this is like actually the threads that are a lot of meme coins are so yeah ridiculous. Yeah, there's a lot of ridiculous like that, and it feels like it really come it like highlights this rift that there is, I think, in crypto between I feel like some people now, even people who used to be on on the other side, there's like a fundamental side, which is people who are in this who believe in the in the tech, who think this is gonna do something important in the world, like we need DeFi, we need centralized identity, all these things.
SPEAKER_00And then there's people who are like on the financial nihilism part of the thesis, right? Where it's like this is all just this is just like the best way to express this bet on the debasement of of currency. And so like meme coins are are just as stupid as anything else, right? It's all memes, it's all just a meme anyway. I might as well go to the thing that will that will perform the best. And then there's obviously people that believe in the tech, but also think memes will make money and and and and and do that. But yeah, for me, I'm I guess very much in the in the first camp.
SPEAKER_00I haven't really done too much in in in meme coins. I can see how they're like how they're attractive, but I don't I don't find them super interesting.
SPEAKER_01This is just a higher EV casino.
SPEAKER_04Okay, the the only the only take you need to have on meme coins is to understand why they exist and people trade them, and that's it. Like you don't yeah, you don't need to you know write a a story about them or like they make sense.
SPEAKER_02This is a perfect segue into banana. So, how to express the meme coin stuff. I bought I like talk about banana in a bunch. This is also just like generally on-chain trading, but like for example, on the day that Flurf came out, banana did like 80 like 70 million in volume or something at Solana and made like a million bucks in fees that day. And it's like you know, you could own something like banana, which is like the infrastructure for trading these these meme coins and all these like new on-chain projects. And like Sanders was saying about how base like Ethereum only.
SPEAKER_00But I guess and like not to interrupt your show, but for the people who are on the financial nihilism side, it's like you make less money in the bull, and in the bear, there are no cash flows anyway. You know, like that that would be the you know, like people who want to be on the people who are betting on memes.
SPEAKER_01It's just like what do you mean you make less money in the bull?
SPEAKER_00Like banana pumps less than the memes, right? Even if you're making cash flows, like no one no one's valuing stuff on fundamentals, so banana pumps less than the actual memes, and then in the bear, no one's trading anyway, so there's there's like no reason.
SPEAKER_04Well, yeah, like if if banana's fundamentals are driven by memes, then it's all driven by memes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but you also have to take into account okay, you you cherry pick your one meme that is gonna outperform by a lot, but it's like, do you have like the conviction to go and put a lot into this meme? Because like what you know ends up you know driving memes, I feel like is a lot different than what would end up driving banana. Like, that's why I like it more. It's like I have a lot more conviction to put a bigger position on banana than I would on these memes because like the memes could disappear. Um, like for example, I bought this biden coin on ETH that was like Trump was like really pumping.
SPEAKER_02There's like a biding coin on ETH, it was like the highest liquidity. I bought it. I was like, okay, like Trump does well, this might do well. And then Joe Bowden on Solana launches and just completely wrecks me and takes all the market share. Where it's like, okay, that can happen. Like my thesis was right, there's gonna be a biding coin that does well. My thesis is right, but I just know it's just talking to X.
SPEAKER_01This is the word that you pick every meme, everyone's into the one in the game.
SPEAKER_02I just picked the wrong one. But basically, my whole point is moving forward, I can be way more confident just holding banana and getting exposure to all these new launches and all this dilution and whatever the hell happens, versus having to pick the specific meme which pumps completely randomly.
SPEAKER_01Good cope.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it is good cope, but also like Jan, what would you rather size into? Something like a project, like you know, banana or GMX where you can kind of can or like roll bit or something, like something with revenues where you can build some conviction around it, or just like a random meme. What would you rather size into? I think that's the real question.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I hear you on that. Uh the memes are also much more liquid than a lot of these other ones, too, which is it definitely contributes to to and and like the momentum element of them.
SPEAKER_02But you also are like on the computer all the time, where it's like, okay, if you had to buy one and fold it for six months, what would you rather buy? I'm gonna say 99% of people with like conviction, if they only had to pick one, would rather buy something that has like a little bit more of a moat, versus these memes, it's like okay, this meme could be the flavor of the month or the flavor of the day, and then it could literally be a zero in two weeks. Obviously, if you're managing that actively, like I know you are Jan, then it's you know much more doable on the meme side.
SPEAKER_04But that's I mean, you can you can take this thesis, and this is like always been kind of like the thesis for just buying ETH too. Like, if you think it's all just an on-chain casino, you just buy ETH, which is the house.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, ETH is goal, and then you can try and get some beta on it through through these different names. The banana ETH.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I don't think revenue is is necessarily definitely fundamentals, definitely. There's like I don't know, I feel like there's the actual future of finance and different industries being built, and like a lot of people are gonna get stuck holding memes and feel pretty stupid at the end of it, but a lot of people will make a lot of money with them too. So it's uh yeah, it's a casino, it's all you need to know about it, like Jan said. Moving on to uh my bags, should we talk about Athena? All our bags, all our bags, I guess. Yeah, we we we we act it with the fund.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, do we do we wanna? And by the way, yeah, the fund Delphine Ventures owns Athena. I own a bunch of YT and I'm and I'm farming it as well. So yeah, definitely some bag bias here.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, do you want to be the bear if you guys want to be the bull?
SPEAKER_00I think Center is can do the bear as well. Yeah, I think you guys can both do the yeah, I I don't think it's as hard to yeah.
SPEAKER_04Okay, I mean I think the bear is simple. There's just too many, there's just too many moving parts that thoughts that something goes wrong just seem pretty high, and that this basis trade has always failed, no matter how smart the people are that have been doing it. I think the like what makes it riskier is just the fact that you're tokenizing it this time, and then people are gonna like deposit this. Um, I'll throw like DeFi use it as collateral. Um I mean, there's there's a lot of ways that it can go wrong, right?
SPEAKER_04Like you just have a staked ETH exploit or something, right? Like that side of the trade all goes belly up. You have like some MPC like problem, um, there's like smart contract risk in a bunch of places, there's just a lot of risk. And so I think fundamentally, from like a pure initial engineering, pure like math, looking at it in a vacuum, it makes sense, uh, and it's sustainable, but yeah, it's hard to just not see something, especially when it gets too big.
SPEAKER_04And and Duncan made this point too that when it gets really big, um when it gets big, it actually pushes yield lower. So, like as yield goes lower, it actually becomes riskier too.
SPEAKER_01Well, then it naturally unwinds, right?
SPEAKER_00It's it naturally unwinds as yields go lower, though.
SPEAKER_02Well, but I don't know about that because it's like perceived as more safe. This is this is the thing. It's like as you have more money in it, and yields go well, we should just explain it really quickly for for people who don't know what Athena is. So basically, Athena is taking, I think right now it's it's ETH, but maybe in the future more collaterals. But basically taking ETH, staking it, so you write right off the back at a four percent yield there, and then it's going and it's shorting the the ETH perp, which you know, historically for for most of its life is positive funding. So like right now it's maybe 20 funding, so you're getting four percent on on Steeth, and then 20 on the ETH perp.
SPEAKER_02So you're earning like 25 on a on like supposed to be, and for for most times it is just like a delta neutral position, you know, you're long the ETH collateral and short ETH perp. So you should be delta neutral um earning the the funding and and the staking rate. I guess where Cedarist and I get a bit worried is like as you scale this product, right, and more money comes in, then you just have kind of this massive short position uh on ETH. And you know, obviously there's like nuances here, but I feel like as a position, like there's just like more risk in this like massive uh short position on ETH, which has collateral to back it up, but um kind of like as yields come down, I think people might perceive it as safer and just like more and more money comes in.
SPEAKER_02Like we saw last cycle with Luna, got 18 billion dollars into it at 20 yield. So it can be this like massive, and this is obviously much different than Luna. Like this is actually collateralized by by the ETH in the short position, but it just opens up the avenue for like small things to go wrong, and when it's like magnified so big, like at such a big scale, then like um you can have some issues.
SPEAKER_01I don't I don't think there are the economic risks are are that significant in the sense that I don't I don't like you know um each dollar is fully collateralized, and you might have scenarios where people want to run for the for the door, and you know you can only unwind so much of the supply uh so quickly. So you might have a scenario where it can you know depeg to like 98 cents, 99 cents, and that's just because someone wants to sell and not wait for a slightly more orderly unwind process, but that's someone else's edge to buy if they're comfortable waiting to unwind in a month, right?
SPEAKER_01And so I think you have a pretty natural barrier there where it's not backed by something that needs to be minted and burned, it's backed by an actual fully collateralized position. I I do think the bigger risk is the the technical acute one, right? Where it's just like all of a sudden, somehow a certain chunk of of the collateral is lost. That that I think I like and I'm I'm very bullish on it. I I think that's a bigger risk because there is no kind of immediate remedy for something like that if it happens.
SPEAKER_01Whereas the the more economic one, I think is okay. It's also on staking side, right? Right. And on the funding side, like what you notice, right? If you think about what happens before it goes into a negative funding rate environment, you have all right, so markets top, stuff's blowing up, there's a lot of on-chain activity, so you still have the steep side that's providing a pretty decent amount of uh yield, and and the funding is starting to kind of gradually make its way down. And if you look over historic cycles, that's kind of how it's played out. So you have months of kind of time to unwind before you get to kind of the depths of the bear where there's no on-chain activity, so steed is paying nothing, and funding is flat to negative, so the entire basis trade is kind of way less attractive.
SPEAKER_01But but there's historically been months of that transition, which should allow for an economic unwind. And plus, you know, if you think about it, it's generating a surplus and building the uh treasury on a much larger supply, and then when it's not earning as much, supply is contracting. So, like on a relative basis, you're actually, you know, like where we've seen with a lot of these like uh tokens where there's an issue, you're usually buying high and selling low. Here, you actually have a scenario where you're generating and and bootstrapping the insurance fund when things are good, and then the the penalty or the the kind of the the funding shortfall that needs to be potentially addressed is is when supply is much lower and times are bad.
SPEAKER_01So the economic stuff is pretty it's pretty re durable, it's more the technical stuff that I agree is a concern because it's unknown.
SPEAKER_00On the economic stuff as well, you have to funding has to be negative and outstrip the ETH yield, right? And I think if you look historically, that happened on something like 18 of 18 of days. Obviously, as Athena gets bigger, that changes, but even then, then they have the insurance fund, right? So if it's like an intraday move or like a short-term thing, like funding gets wiped because there's a bunch of liquidations, the insurance fund is just going to cover any negative funding for that period of time. So, really, where you're talking about the unwind is when funding is negative enough for long enough that it completely drains the insurance fund.
SPEAKER_00And then basically you start getting negative funding on principal, which erodes principal. Um, but even then it's it's it's like very different, it's like a very slow unwind, right? At the max funding rate on Binance, it's like 100%, right? So it's like something something like 0.2 something percent a day that you the that you're losing. And it's like the whole way down as yields come down, there's like an incentive for you know, different people will will see the risks of this at a different place, and like at 60% you have this much TBL, at 30% you'll have less, at 10% you'll you'll you'll have less.
SPEAKER_00And so I think it's very likely, and then that's all that's like negative reflexivity, right? Because as the funding rates go negative, then people unwind the the position, they close some shorts, and then funding like will will flip back like positive, hopefully. And I think there's some yeah, so I'm not too worried about that. I guess the the the biggest worry, as you said, is is uh technical. Obviously, there's like something in MPC that's like uh sort of an like an uh a black swan. Um something on with the on the collateral side, whether it's like a steeth um a steet hack, which I mean that would hurt a lot of projects, not just not just them.
SPEAKER_00And they're pretty diversified in their in their liquid stake and derivatives now would be bad. And then also like an exchange hack would be bad, right? You lose the like the the short leg basically of however much exposure you have on the short leg is basically how much this thing ends up depegging by. That's just just to just to jump in on a risk-reward basis.
SPEAKER_04I just want to say because you make like so the the first two things you talked about, like stake deeth, mpc, yeah, those are like industry-wide things that would hit, I mean, tons of projects, tons of people. I mean, fire blocks had like MPC, I would have kind of like screwed the industry, regardless of if you use Fireblocks or not, right? But the the centralized exchange one, that's like the more idiosyncratic one to an extent, unless like you have something like FTX that's just massive, but I don't think we will. That's probably the one that is the most like would hurt Athena like relatively more than everything else in that sense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but it's also not that big of a problem because they settle either hourly, I forget, I think it's like hourly or every two hours, right? So it's only an issue if um you know you have your steet and markets have nuked and you have a bunch of unrealized gain in your short position that is effectively what's collateralizing uh the dollar or the USDE, and you can't realize that, right? That's that like that's kind of the concern. But if you're realizing it every hour, then oh shit, they got hacked, we lose our short.
SPEAKER_01We have to unwind the Steve ASAP. And yes, you will lose some, I'm sure, unless Steve pumps, but like obviously there's a hack, Steve's gonna nuke, so you lose your hedge while prices go down. So you have that, but but you don't have this like unrealized gain that you're about to get rugged on. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I mean, that's the biggest concern that it gets so big, you have a big market nuke, um, like crazy 50% drop day. And does it survive that? Like, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Mathematically, it should it's a seven-day unstaking, though, right? Like, even even then, it's like uh like to actually unstake your SUSD for USD, it's seven days, so no, but I mean the exchange goes goes under, and you can't.
SPEAKER_04I'm talking about this realized unrealized game.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but it's they realize it every hour.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, but we have like a market crash, it happens in like a couple seconds.
SPEAKER_02Like, I think that there is potential to maybe lose, like you know, something like 10-20 of principle, but yeah, it's definitely not like these other stable coins that have been attempted where it's like you could lose everything. Like, I think kind of the max drawdown on this in a really bad case is maybe like 20 on the per mechanic side.
SPEAKER_01Yes, but then the attack vector is almost like if you have negative funding, you would need all of the USDE holders to collude and not redeem, right? And you force the protocol to absorb like to take on negative funding and basically pay to keep the shorts open.
SPEAKER_00So, like, yeah, this is literally require everyone to bring the insurance fund basically or two, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. You're holding USDE with negative funding.
SPEAKER_02The funding is just a good balancing mechanic, but I think what where it could get risky is like if the project gets greedy in a in a market where their TVL is like you know, ballooned up a bunch, they've kind of muted funding across the board because it becomes so big, right? It's only launched for the past like a couple months and already has like a billion dollars of TVL or something. Like ETH open interest is only nine billion. So they're a billion, they're like 10% of ETH open interest already. So like you could see in like six months from now, they get to like a really big part of the market.
SPEAKER_02Funding's like pretty muted, and they want to keep growing, or they want to like you know, they just get greedy and they do some like like restaking thing where like they you know add additional yield on on top of Steve. Like Steve has some decent Lindy already, and but like you could see like a situation where where that happens.
SPEAKER_00I don't think they can do that without the exchanges, the exchanges would have to would have to be okay with that, right? They would have to like honor the the short on whatever they're doing with the with the collateral. Yeah, they would have to like keep stone. And okay, just I just want to talk about the counterparty risk. Before before I want to answer Centerus' point on the because uh I agree they have counterparty risk with the centralized exchanges, but like every stable coin has varying levels of counterparty risk, right?
SPEAKER_04Sure, the Fed build out the entire industry, so like I'm not forgetting that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, depending exactly. So depending how you assess the the relative counterparty risks, right? Like, I mean, US banks, you know, US regional banks, uh, whoever the fuck tether is banking with, you know, no one knows, like uh if they get censored or whatever. Like, this is this is a a crypto native stable. I'd say it's between decentralized and centralized, right? It doesn't rely on TradFi banking rails, it's purely relies on on centralized exchanges. I think for a lot of people, tether has shown you know that there's there's demand for this, uh, for this trade-off space.
SPEAKER_00And like what I think is when you actually look at the risks and the yield, it is like very compelling for for a lot of people on a risk-reward basis. You're kind of seeing that with with the market, and like I personally have a lot of my my stables in it, and so I I think it'll like continue to grow and have product market fit, and then add like Bitcoin as collateral, taps into like 25 billion in open interest, and then you know, sold after that, which you know is definitely lower amounts. But yeah, I just think and and I think given like the degeneracy that we've seen with blast with these e-staking, I just think it's gonna get integrated like everywhere, like every perp decks, every L2 is gonna use this in the in the back.
SPEAKER_04Yes. Um, so that's like part of my hesitation with it, though, okay. Because if we if we go back to Duncan's point about how even in a worst case it's like 10 to 20 percent of value to lose, that's fine if if people are just like depositing in this trade and it's isolated, and those people take a haircut, but a 10-20 dpeg on a stable when it is integrated in so many places can be quite catastrophic to like the entire DeFi economy.
SPEAKER_04So that's my kind of biggest concern with it. Like, I agree, I don't think there's this scenario where it has like zero backing, right? Like, I'm not that's stupid. Uh, it's more so just like the knock-on effects of a 10, one one part of it kind of like blowing up and causing like 10 to 20 percent, uh, and then like the ripple effects across everywhere.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think it's a really great idea, like, and it's gonna be successful. And I think all of the risk we're talking about you'll see coming. And like, I think it just gets risky when it becomes too big, almost. Uh, like that's when it poses a risk to other things, like when it becomes too big and like regarded as like you know, as good as like USDC, which is like backed by treasuries and like a special account and like Bank of New York melon type of thing. So um, yeah, like I think it's a really interesting project, and it's it's very cool, and I like where it's going for for the space, but definitely something to keep our eyes on as as it grows.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, moving on. All right, uh I mean I should probably reference this. All right, I wanted to just I wanted to uh I was curious to touch base just quickly because it's a lead-on from Athena on just like the impacts of these higher rates on DeFi as a whole that we kind of saw. Um, especially like Thorchain. I mean, maker obviously up their rates, like kind of 3x their revenue, Ave's revenues up a lot. Thorachain is the most direct one because they have these like zero interest revenue, but not profit.
SPEAKER_01Because now borrowing costs for all those guys goes up too. So it's not like you know what I mean. Borrow costs across the space go up. So the cost of capital goes up. All these businesses are net interest margin businesses. So it's not like, yeah, revenue goes up, but so the costs.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So two impacts of Athena. It has been one, obviously rates are up everywhere. And then two, it showcased these Oracle platforms like Ajna, which we just had a report on yesterday, which you should definitely read. Um, and it kind of shows like how these Oracle is DeFi primitives, you're able to bootstrap these new markets a lot quicker because there's no protocol solvency um under these like architectures. So those are like the two most interesting things to me is how it caused like maker as put the die uh savings rates like 15% now, right?
SPEAKER_04And and Ajna has been seeing like they're the number one borrow lend for Athena Stable. So those are like been the two biggest takeaways for me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's tricky for a lot of these businesses.
SPEAKER_00How big is that though on Ajana? Because I don't I don't see why anyone would be lending USD on Ajina, it just makes no sense. Like you you would you could stake it and earn yield, you could or even DSR yield, you could just hold it in your wallet and and earn higher yield, like uh yeah, high savings rate.
SPEAKER_01Like, why would you even do that if you can do Athena?
SPEAKER_00If you can get rates to the yield on like just locking it in, Athena, depending where you think shards are, is is like 300 APY or something.
SPEAKER_01Well that's what I'm saying. Like, why even do like like I agree with your logic on auction? I can apply it. You can apply that to maker, also, right?
SPEAKER_04I don't know, man. Why buy Bowden instead of Biden?
SPEAKER_01Like well, you're still a stable coin and and getting cash in the strays.
SPEAKER_04That's a good point. Like, I don't know. Uh I mean I think die is like less risky, so I don't know. It doesn't make up for the problem, like this is my my hot prediction.
SPEAKER_00I think dye ends up becoming like uh SUSD wrapper rather than a treasury wrapper. Like, I think they'll move they're already moving some of their exposure. I actually didn't catch up on the latest governance proposal. But how here this is a great example.
SPEAKER_02How big is Dye? How big is SUSD?
SPEAKER_04Five DIE is like five bill, I think.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like I don't think you're gonna be able to fit that much. Like as as Athena grows, like the yield's gonna come down because they're they're suppressing funding, like it's less attractive as the yield grows, and there's also just like so much more infrastructure. Like in 2021, we saw uh the funding rate at like 50 to 60 percent for like months, and that was because there was like no infrastructure to put on this basis trade. Like there's a lot of infrastructure to put it on now, and like obviously Athena like on its launch week had like 80 yield because funding got super hot, but realistically, I think yeah, you're probably gonna settle around like long term, like something like 10 to 20 percent.
SPEAKER_01So part part like two things on that uh like the ETTF would be super bearish, I mean super bullish for Athena, right? Because now you just have all this massive demand. I like I think what actually helps Athena quite a bit is if you can uh get that stable coin uh as something that people use, it generates revenue on the existence of all the stable coins, right? But it only has to pay fees to the to the ones that stake. So if you can get a large amount of them to not stake, then you're actually generating quite a bit more in terms of profit and are able to pay as much if you're not staking it.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's the whole point. Like, if you can get this thing to be widely used to some extent, then then it it it helps with the whole thing with UST.
SPEAKER_02It didn't like that wasn't possible because everyone who's holding UST is putting an anchor, they're not using like you you like Luna meaning massive push to get UST integrated places, and it was kind of a flaw.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think part of the longer term vision is to try and get USDE pairs on sexes, right? And and then the idea being I just sound like it's a happen.
SPEAKER_02I haven't even thought about it. But like that's where things like that's they just can't get greedy with this. Like, I feel like that's just getting greedy with it. Just keep it as your nice basis trade, it's gonna print a lot of money, people are gonna do well. But if they try and get greedy with it and make it too big, something's gonna go wrong.
SPEAKER_01You just need a beefcake insurance fund, right?
SPEAKER_02Where you can it Luna had the two billion dollar Bitcoin hodl.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but that's that's apples to oranges.
SPEAKER_02I know it's not the same, but it's like it's it's the same point, it's just at a different extreme. Like Luna was at one extreme. This is like way safer for sure, not at all comparing them as the same, but it's like as you try like you're trying to push it into something it's not, it's like a structured product, and you're trying to push it to be like the base pair.
SPEAKER_01There's gonna be a scare for sure. Like it's just in the inevitable to some degree, yeah.
SPEAKER_00All right, that was a good one. Enjoyed that. Um, should we wrap it up? Anyone want to say anyone have any last words? Uh Duncan, you've been you only showed Center Chain once. Maybe you want to get another one in before before the end.
SPEAKER_02Well, all I want to say is Centerist bought banana, so finally. Soon he's gonna bice in, and then his podcast is gonna be a lot better.
SPEAKER_01It's just there, it's gonna be a two-person Hive mind episode.
SPEAKER_00All right, guys. Good to be back and see you all in two weeks for the next episode of the Hive Mind.