Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Hivemind

The Hivemind artwork

The Return of ICO’s, ETH’s Issuance Tinkering & DeFi Drama

Apr 4, 20241 hr 1 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The conversation revolves around two main themes: investment clubs and ETH issuance. The discussion on investment clubs focuses on the adverse selection problem and the potential benefits and drawbacks of using platforms like Echo and Legion for fundraising and community building. The conversation on ETH issuance explores the proposal to change the ETH issuance curve and the arguments for and against it. The participants also touch on the challenges faced by larger funds in the crypto space and the impact of stake rates on the moneyness of ETH. The conversation revolves around the recent developments in the MakerDAO ecosystem, particularly the introduction of the Ethena stablecoin and the controversy surrounding it. The hosts discuss the impact of Ethena on stablecoin yields and the overall DeFi market. They also touch on the feud between MakerDAO and Aave, as well as the potential risks and benefits of MakerDAO's plans to split into sub-daos and launch new tokens. The conversation highlights the competition among protocols to attract capital by offering higher yields and the importance of understanding the risks and reflexivity of these systems. Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Investment Clubs 01:15 Adverse Selection Problem 14:01 ETH Issuance and Stake Rates 16:19 Challenges Faced by Larger Funds 28:29 Impact of Yield Reduction on Staking 30:52 The Impact of Ethena Stablecoin 35:30 Feud Between MakerDAO and Aave 51:00 MakerDAO's Plans to Split 57:09 Competition for Higher Yields 01:00:58 Conclusion Disclosures: Nothing said on The Hivemind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. The podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Jose, Yan, Duncan, Ceteris, and our guests may advise or hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed. Get a 20% discount on a premium Delphi PRO or PRO+ for listening to this episode! Follow the links below or use the codes on checkout: 20% off Delphi PRO annual Code: PODCASTPRO Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastpro 20% off Delphi PRO+ annual Code: PODCASTTEAMS Direct Link: https://delphi.link/podcastteams Follow Delphi Digital Website: https://members.delphidigital.io Twitter / X: https://x.com/delphi_digital

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Set on the Hive Mind is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is strictly for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our own opinions, not financial advice. Hi everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Hive Mind podcast. I'm your host, Jose, and with me today, as always, I have Cederis, Jan, and Duncan. But yeah, Echo is Kobe's new sort of like investment club, like uh crypto angel list uh platform where uh yeah for for full disclosure, we at Labs we're we're incubating something like a competitor called called Legion.

SPEAKER_03And yeah, we we spoke to Kobe about it, so we're aware. But um yeah, I've I've I've used Echo. I think it's really cool. I think he's executing really well in it, and just given his his brand and stuff, it's gonna it's gonna do well. I guess my my main sort of like interesting point about the model, and we would be keen to hear hear your thoughts, is just um, and this is the issue with ICOs too, with all this stuff is the adverse selection problem, right? Which is with with investment clubs, you have this thing, okay, who who who are the users of investment clubs?

SPEAKER_03Like ideally. Ideally, it's someone who's like super smart, has a lot of alpha, but hasn't yet made it, right? And so they need and and also has access to deals but hasn't yet made it somehow. Um and so they need extra capital to be able to to maximize their their allocations in in these deals. And I guess the problem is there aren't that many of those people, right? Like just by virtue of if you're super smart and have alpha, you generally tend to make good money in this space, and then you don't really need external allocations. So it's so um, and then at the at the same time, like on the project side, I think like how are projects thinking about their rounds?

SPEAKER_03They're thinking about them in terms of how do I maximize the the sort of value add per dollar of capital invested in my round, right? Um, so you want to get the highest value like VCs, the highest value angels, and really try and get people that are gonna work for their allocation, assuming your project's like popular and oversubscribed. And and in that case, like the you don't really want to like give allocation to an and oh well, this is this is this is my thesis. I think it could be definitely proven wrong, but you don't really want to give allocation to an investment club, right?

SPEAKER_03Like if I want if I'm giving allocation to an angel, I want them to be fully incentivized themselves. Like I want to give the minimum I need to fully incentivize them. And if it's being diluted amongst a bunch of people I don't know, then it kind of like defeats the defeats the point. And yeah, obviously Icos have have have similar issues, but yeah, curious to hear your guys' like thoughts on this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I fully agree with everything you just said. I think there's some scenarios where it makes sense, uh is through like distribution to like a wider audience and getting them in at a good price. It's kind of the whole idea of like, you know, tokens that you know almost do no VC raises or launch organically, like grassroots ones that you know launch at a really low price and do well over time, they build a super strong community, right? Because they've made a bunch of people wealthy, and then like every one of those people is essentially just like an agent of you know promoting that project, giving feedback, you know, just it's a massive distribution channel, and you really see it when it's like okay, a few VCs have made a lot on this, or like you know, thousands of people have have made a lot on this, and or like even tens of thousands of people.

SPEAKER_01Uh, so I think that what where it could be cool is for distribution, where obviously like you need a KYC and stuff. Do you need to be an accredited investor to yeah, you do?

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_03Um I guess the I guess the main thing, like another point worth making, I should have probably made it clear, is like I think this is desperately needed. I don't think the status quo, I mean the status quo definitely benefits us as as Delphi ventures, but I I don't think it's it's like optimal for for the space. And and basically the status quo is um either projects do these like uh private rounds that are uh by necessity like like cheaper because there's less people that can bite into them, and then they eventually, when they go public, they're at like multiples of of that round, right?

SPEAKER_03And realistically, um some VCs add a lot of value. Um, you know, we we we think we're definitely one of them. Others don't add that much value. And there's definitely angels that that add a shitload of value and also random people that add a bunch of value. Like we've seen it in every community, the chain link gods, the Thor Maximalists, like the the there's these community members that come in and are MVPs and are almost team members. And so I think the promise of one of these ICO platforms is that you can like basically maximize the the utility per dollar of capital raised, right?

SPEAKER_03You can you can try and get the people that are going to be most value add and to to to come in and also like build a community, right? Like one thing that our Legion team says is like, yeah, your first 10 employees make your your project your team culture, and your first sort of like 100 community members make your community culture, right? So if it's a bunch of moon boys, you're probably screwed. Um yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So so I think that's where like obviously being an credit investor prices out a lot of people from from this platform, which I think that's just a regulatory thing. Like you can't really get around that. It sounds like maybe Legion is issues. Yeah, I thought I thought that you did.

SPEAKER_00I actually thought that you didn't have to be for this.

SPEAKER_03I thought that that was yeah, well, I don't know for sure. I I know I had to I signed up, I had to answer a bunch of questions about like net worth and risk tolerance and and stuff like this. I don't know what would have happened if yeah, uh I don't know. I assume you have to be you have to be accredited. Maybe maybe I'm wrong.

SPEAKER_01Um is Legion do you have to be accredited to do like the ICOs, or how is that being started?

SPEAKER_03No, based on the license that that Legion's Legion's going for, uh you won't have to be credited, but you have you do have to exclude the the US, uh, or do like Reg S, which has its own has its own uh things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I think let's just pretend that everyone can invest in these to discussion simple. I think obviously the biggest challenge, and you guys would be well aware of this, and Kobe is also obviously well aware of this, is just the adverse selection point in that like all the most prestigious projects are still, regardless of regulations, going to want to raise from the most prominent VCs.

SPEAKER_00When they do angel rounds, they're going to want to handpick the angels that they invite. They're not going to want to use some third-party platform. And there's like this whole meme, right? Where it's the guy who doesn't think and buys six figs of your token and leaves you alone, and then the guy who buys ten dollars is in your Discord 24-7, like asking questions, right?

SPEAKER_01And so But those people can be valuable too. Like, I guess where where I think it's interesting is like, yes, that's true, but there's also I think a scenario where, and like the adverse electron is real, but I also think there's a scenario where it's like, okay, you do you open up the seed round at like a very you know cheap price, and you have some sort of reputation system on Echo or something, and you let like you know, a thousand people invest, like you know, a few hundred bucks or something, or or however much you're you're trying to raise, and then you essentially get in, you know, a thousand people at a really low price that like if it does, like I think I don't know, like I think Monad raised at like low, like tens of millions in in their seed round, and you know, they'll probably gonna be launching a multi-billion dollar valuation, so it's like that could be you know potentially a hundred X.

SPEAKER_00So, like if you let you know, let's think the some of the launch pads have done this, like uh Bonanza's Launchpad did this thing where it's like you can buy a thousand dollars worth max, and then as soon as it was traded, it was trading like 50x that, yeah, and so it's just like a way to give a lot of people an easy win.

SPEAKER_02And launch pads are similar, but don't really get the benefits of of targeting your user base, right? That's like launchpads is just a bunch of Jeats for the most part. Uh, whereas here you have a scenario where you can kind of hand pick. So the I I agree with the adverse selection thing. It's it's kind of a question of so there's a few moving parts, right? Let's use I guess Ansem as an example. Do you um do you give him a 50k aloe? So yeah, let's say you have 250k that you'd go around to Angels, would you give five people 50 or would you do 250 to him, right?

SPEAKER_02And let's say it's a standard 20 of profit model, right? So like he gets 20 on the on the other 200, he takes the 50, he takes he gets 20 of profit on on the other 200. So depending on how high it goes, like his exposure kind of changes above 50. But the trade-off is you probably have a bunch of randos that that are gonna do not gonna do that much versus is it better to have like a targeted group of five people with much larger followings than the sum of the randos of the people that are but but but but I think let's let's let's take that example.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so Ansom has 50k, he gets 200k to like do to his echo group, you know. So you could get 400 people at 500 bucks each, and like if echo had some sort of like ranking, obviously, if it's just like random 400 people, you have no idea who they are, then I don't know, but like well, you're outsourcing the the whole thing of echo, I think.

SPEAKER_03So, like the what you're describing is is more so the approach of Legion, like what we're building is basically you want to have a reputation layer at the base layer that allows you to differentiate between different people, their value add, like what they contributed to different projects, like DGen scores, like on-chain metrics, uh like Twitter, the Twitter score, like GitHub commits, like get a get a feel for who these people are, and then you can like hand select who you want to participate in your in your sale, right? And yeah, with I feel like with with uh Echo, what you're doing is basically outsourcing that to Ansom, right?

SPEAKER_03In in this case, like rather than you handpicking each member, each per each participant, you say this influencer has a has a has a really cool community. I want to just like tap into that. And I think to the extent that these people do a good job like uh nurturing their communities and stuff, it it could work.

SPEAKER_02Um hundreds of people in their thing, there's no way they're they're they're selecting, you know, they're being very kind of yeah programmatic with the entry.

SPEAKER_00Well, uh it is like do you want wait? Do you want I actually think it's if you get Anselm's following because he has a massive following now, then you're gonna get a lot of like free marketing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but it's like who's like a bunch of people that are following with 10 followers, like I know, yeah, yeah, yeah. Or you get like five Ansomes each with a bunch of following and uh massive following and them being the megaphone.

SPEAKER_01So imagine having like 400 people,$500 each, but they all have like between 100 to 1000 followers on Twitter. It's like that's some really good distribution, and like those people, you know, if you were to figure out the reputation around that, and those people are like trying to grow their following, and like that's a really strong community, and like some of them are really thoughtful, some of them are not. But like if you were able to hand pick or like have some reputation layer, like Jose's talking about, where you put people who are just like on the come up, you know, maybe this is their first cycle, their first time in crypto, they don't want to invest too much money, but you give them a good deal, and like they're active on Twitter trying to like you know learn and build their following.

SPEAKER_01You give them a good deal for like$500 to a thousand dollars, that hundred X is it's like all of a sudden it's 50k to 100k, and you have 400 people that just got in on that, like you're gonna get a ferocious community, just like literally constantly talking about this. I think if they are able to do that, and that's a hard thing to do. Can they do that? Does Legion have a better chance of doing that with their model? I think that that's incredibly valuable because yes, Ansom and five other guys might have like a big following on Twitter, but there's some problems with them. It's like, you know, they might already have a lot of money, uh, their communities could be like very similar.

SPEAKER_01They're not gonna like they have other investments, so they're not gonna be focusing all their time on this. Like these like 400 random people, like you're gonna get probably a hundred of them who this is like really life-changing money for them, and they're literally going to become like your project naturally as as your number gets large, like they can't write like their exposure, also gets you know I know.

SPEAKER_02So that's what we were saying between 500 to 1,000. Yeah, so hundreds of people, right? That's like tens of people.

SPEAKER_01Well, at two on the example you gave, where you have a 2,000 uh 200k, yeah, 200k allocation to give to people, 500 for 400 people, or 200 people at a thousand dollars. It could, I think that could if it was successfully done and it would take a lot of time, but it's like not only just the Twitter following, it's telling your friends about it. It's you know, it's all these other things that like yeah, I think Anton has like a big follower number on Twitter. Like, I don't know if he's worth like more than a hundred people who you've just 50 or 100x that are now like literally like dedicated to shilling project.

SPEAKER_03The most the most like sort of fertile market segment for this because um is is basically like the the big private rounds that projects do before they launch their token, right? Like that's really because I think the early stage stuff you benefit, you kind of just want a VC that'll give you money, stamp their their brand on it, ideally if it's a if it's a brand name VC, and then like leave you alone, or at least like maybe introduce you to some people. You don't want a bunch of random people spamming all the time at the early stage. But once you once you're getting closer to launch, like projects are basically uh because there's no ICOs, they're doing these like discounted private rounds, right?

SPEAKER_03The the the exception maybe being Jupyter, they're doing these discounted private rounds and then going live with their token. And and I think like rather than a discounted private round where you're giving it to like four or five VCs, that that's where like the EV is definitely for me way higher in like distributing to tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people in smaller size who can now all participate and and basically capture that that alpha instead, uh is how I'm thinking about it.

SPEAKER_01And this is almost like a better way of doing an airdrop where it's like people have to put up capital so they feel more invested, more tied to it, you know, less likely to dump. You can put them on a vesting schedule, and also you get to make sure there's no uh like civils, like because they have to attach to their identity in some way, and you get the you know, a similar distribution if you were to do it at a private round or something. So I think that like this is just a much better way of doing an airdrop, right? Because you know, you could get a hundred real people with like a few hundred followers and like you know, actual repeople, or you could get a hundred of Sysapus' wallets, and it's just one guy who's not gonna tweet about your project.

SPEAKER_01He might be like, Oh, dupe, go up and just dump his entire stack. But it's like, what would you rather have in terms of like this?

SPEAKER_03Also, much harder to Sybil, like much harder to Sybil and ICO, much harder to do, yeah, than this. So I think it's I think it's like very promising. I think and I think like there is clearly market demand for this. I uh to me, like the pendle yt craze and like meme coins and uh the pre-sales and stuff. To me, that's all like people want to get into stuff earlier and feel like they have a fair, a fair shake. I don't know. Um ICO platform right now.

SPEAKER_03Uh like that that's their main, I feel like business is just people who want to buy eigenlayer or who want to buy um like yeah, Athena pre-market.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I agree with your point that this makes most sense for like the late stage of it.

SPEAKER_02It can actually scale because otherwise it doesn't really scale. There's just not enough capital. Yeah, this I think is for distribution. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03All right. There's also like we uh we touched in some of the pre-show on like how this affects like funds as well. There's the this adverse selection also kind of applies to to funds, right? At a certain size. Uh I know Paradigm announced like their$750 million fund. Obviously, those guys are one of the one of the best in the space, but there is this uh, I think, uh, adverse selection that also happens with with larger funds, where you know um you're you're basically like when you you're more incentivized on the management fee side than the performance side, like bigger funds drastically like compress your performance, especially in this industry when there are that many opportunities to pin to, and the really like to some extent, the really smart people, if they really have alpha are incentivized to just manage their own money or squat up with their friends like like we did and manage manage our own money together, right?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, what do you guys think of that?

SPEAKER_02No, definitely I mean, I think you if you look at the numbers, you know, in in terms of uh the amount of VC dollars getting invested, uh if you look at you know the the previous cycle, so how much money was going in 2021, 22, uh and compare that to what it is now, it's it's night and day, right? Um part of it is is you know uh the previous setup was kind of a late zero interest rate phenomenon type of dynamic where there was always kind of exit liquidity, money was free, and so it was just growth at all costs, and and and VCs, you had the soft banks and and and sequoias that were going to be writing these gargantuan checks.

SPEAKER_02And so everyone before them was also comfortable investing because you knew that that money was coming in behind you, and and so once you kind of had the big washout in liquid markets, the appeal of doing these nine-figure rounds, right? Not even like or like high eight figure, low nine-figure rounds, um still happens, but to a much, much smaller degree if you kind of look at what the trends have been, and so which makes sense, right? And and it and it bodes well for us as well, where we kind of focus on the early stage, um and and you know it's it's part of an edge there.

SPEAKER_02And it's great because now uh teams are also really kind of focused on on doing that earlier stage and then trying to go liquid afterwards. So it I think it's a it's a it's a much harder market to invest uh as a larger fund now. The returns aren't there. We we and we've also yet to see what the reckoning is of these unlocks, right? We've harked on this a bunch, but it's especially relevant now because uh what a lot of the the funds and this happened before was in reinvesting on paper gains, right?

SPEAKER_02You're not actually realizing anything. There's no there's no actual realization, it's just markups and and raising on markups. And so I think with crypto, we we've seen a lot less of the of the nine figure uh raises, and so we'll kind of see what happens. I think there's probably going to be some level of reckoning where where narrative can't really uh offset the the increase in in new supply. And so it it it's it just in the the venture stage or venture crypto ventures really the edge is it's kind of always been in the early stage, but even more so now.

SPEAKER_02And so um it's it's tough. Like we've we've thought about trying to go with a larger fund, um, but but ultimately decided against it for you know a whole host of reasons. Uh, but but one of them is certainly just the the massive alpha decay and um and and you're just playing kind of a different game, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because like I guess with crypto, right? Like the really good deals that we've seen are like these pre-seed and seed arounds where there's only a certain amount of allocation, and if someone has like you know a multi-billion dollar fund, it's almost always better to like for do that allocation.

SPEAKER_03They can't spend the time to DD it and stuff for for for that. Yeah, because it's like a nothing burger to them.

SPEAKER_02They just in order to deploy that much money, if they were to do an early stage, they'd have hundreds of hundreds of portcos, right? And so you kind of assume it's just money and nothing else, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then also, I guess on this point, you know, and cure a question from my end is so I think like uh A16Z raised like a three billion or three and a half billion dollar fund kind of last cycle in like 2021 or 2022. Um, when do they start collecting management fees on that? Is it like because obviously there's gonna be capital calls and stuff, but is it like the second they raise the fund or like as they call the capital and deploy it? What is how does that work?

SPEAKER_02No, it's you you you collect management fees on committed capital.

SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah.

SPEAKER_02So, and then the committed capital is probably based on you know how quickly you can deploy it, is how quickly what's being committed falls down is what I I I so you say I'm in for I'm into this fund for a million bucks. Um, I'm starting to charge a management fee on that, but I'll deploy that for you know for 250.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but and then but then the carried interest is only now you understand upon selling. Uh yes, exactly. Yeah, so it's not when they actually deploy the deals, it's just but do they have like I think that I've heard that there's um there's some guidelines or restrictions around like you need to deploy X amount by this date.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, but if you're charging on the entire amount, then you think about it, you could like sit on the first capital call for like two years.

SPEAKER_03I know exactly the deployment period, yeah. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So so if there's deployment periods, right? Like it creates this weird incentive structure where it's like, okay, there may not be enough good deals to actually take this amount of money. So what we're doing. Is just bidding up rounds so we can fit in more money to like reach our deployment schedule, doing rounds that like you know we think are good but like not the best, just just uh to deploy those money. So that's where like kind of the adverse selection comes in.

SPEAKER_02Like I think a three and a half billion dollar fund is a lot to even in the and is part of the other reason why they won't draw it down immediately is is um you know the the the main calcs bas are are a function of when the money was called down, right? So if you basically call the money down and don't deploy it, it it really reflects poorly on your return calculations. Because it's just a drag on on performance.

SPEAKER_01I'm wondering, like they might still be deploying that if they raise that in 2022.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's if you if you look like yeah, if you look at the numbers, CryptoRank has a is a site that has pretty good um like monthly uh distribution, and and you'll see like the the vals or rather the amount um raised per month is basically uh it's kind of hovered between like 500 and one and a half, or rather the amount like deployed into deals, but the the deal count has kind of gone up. So you're seeing you know deals deal count's gone up, but but deployable capital hasn't.

SPEAKER_02So just more early stage stuff. And and it's something we've seen as well. There's there's only been a handful of these um larger rounds that that have really kind of happened.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I guess that's like for for some of our listeners, it's like kind of be careful about like if you want to get because there's all these crazy returns in crypto VC, and it's just like you know, be careful about giving money to these like crypto VC funds and like really do your diligence because this problem definitely exists on these kind of mega funds because there's like really not enough good deals to deploy that level of capital, especially if there's time pressure around the deployment period or like for them.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think Andreasen's pretty smart, they have like a very long time horizon for this stuff, yeah. And they've made they have some good stuff in their in their portfolio.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I'm not meaning to I'm just more like calling like I'm just kind of pointing to them because you know, picking on them because they have you know, they're obviously having an incredible track record and stuff, but still nonetheless, like three and a half billion or so to deploy in crypto is difficult for sure.

SPEAKER_03All right, we had one last thing on the docket, which was ETH issuance. I like read through a little bit beforehand, but I honestly don't have uh a great a great take. I assume Cedarus, you you do, so maybe we can just all this.

SPEAKER_00I can like give the I can give like the TLDR. Basically, there's discussion in changing the ETH issuance curve. Reasoning is that so they don't want the stake rate to get too high because there's a lot of like negative extern externalities with that. Um there a quick example you could give of that.

SPEAKER_01The negative externality, like why is it bad when there's too much? That's what I was about to do, Duncan. Oh, sorry. I thought you were gonna move on to the next thing.

SPEAKER_00So okay, there's this, yeah, yeah. Okay, so basically, first of all, ETH has made this big push on like making ETH money, right? And so the high the more people that stake, the more ETH is issued, and so you have like a bigger tax on non-stakers, okay. And that is seen as like a bad um making ETH more expensive to hold, just as like native ETH and not as a staking representation, uh, is seen as like detrimental to the to the moneyness of it, okay?

SPEAKER_00Uh to like the money thesis. And so that's kind of one of the side effects. Yeah, and another side effect is um, so if you think about I guess should we because that's gonna be hard to like remember.

SPEAKER_02True, we can talk about that. Yeah, I think that's like massively overblown. So part of part of it is the idea is like you're taxing those that don't participate at an increased rate because with ETH, uh issuance goes up as more stake, but it's not that much. Like we're we're talking about relatively negligible amounts of of issuance, and so I think like directionally that's correct, but the magnitude of it is so muted that it it it's really doesn't make sense for me as an argument that it's like taxing the non-stakers is if the group gets the stakes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't I don't think that one's the strongest one. Um the strongest argument, which I guess I can go to now, is yes, so e so ETH doesn't have like in protocol delegation, right? Um, and so if you're a retail staker, you're either gonna be a solo staker, which is not really retail, it's like sophisticated individual, I would say. Um, otherwise you're just gonna buy like a liquid staking token or something, right?

SPEAKER_00And so if you don't stop the incentivization of stake, what you're gonna have happen is more and more ETH is gonna be staked, and then more and more ETH is gonna be staked in like liquid staking protocols or LRT protocols, right? And then these protocols end up becoming like too big to fail, and Ethereum now is now dependent on the colour. They're already too big to fail.

SPEAKER_01Um Lido is too big to fail.

SPEAKER_00Well, Lido's Lido's declining now because the LRTs are taking its market share, right? Like Lido's under 30% now.

SPEAKER_01I think that if Lido were to have a bad issue, they would definitely do something.

SPEAKER_00Well, this is the point. This is like something like that.

SPEAKER_03And so you if you think it's already too big, then sure, but like this is the rationale for why they don't want it getting too big, is because the governance of Lido and governance of Lido and Eigenlayer would effectively be the governance of Ethereum, is like the other issue that they point out, right?

SPEAKER_00Right, and then if you think about it too, like if everybody stakes, then the real yield to everyone is zero, but there's still risk in staking because you still get slashed and everything, and so what that also incentivizes is people just to chase other external yields, which is why you get all the LRT stuff, and people will start chasing like more yields with those. Um, and so that's like, in my opinion, that's the biggest side effect that I think has merit to it.

SPEAKER_00Another one was around like solo stakers. If you think about like solo stakers, they're probably not too swayed by the yield they're getting. Um, because a lot of them are just kind of like diehards, they're passionate about this, they do it as a hobby. But if you think about the institutional staker, they only really care about yield. And so if you reduce yields, you are not going to really reduce the solo staking amount, but you will reduce the institutional demand for it in a sense. Um, so yeah, there's been these proposals to like change the curve.

SPEAKER_00Uh, there's like this hard fork coming up, and so that's kind of the time to do it. There's been a ton of pushback in the ETH community. I think that the ETH community is kind of like insecure about the way like Bitcoiners have always framed them changing the issue and schedule all the time. And since they have been making this massive like moneyness push, um, there's a lot that don't want to touch it like anymore for the rest of the protocol and just like leave it as as it is. And like there's also you know, I don't know if the argument is necessarily overwhelming enough to change it because you can always kind of tinker with something and you can always change the monetary policy all the time.

SPEAKER_00Um, yeah, I think it makes sense.

SPEAKER_02And then like, yeah, just to go back. So um, in terms of like the it's all trade-offs, right? So um like you can make arguments both ways, and there's nothing that's absolute, but yeah, I'm I'm pretty heavily in the camp that it doesn't really make sense to lower it. I because way back when we we pushed that it would make sense to raise it. This was like in in 2019, but that was more so an issue of of kind of uh financial sustainability relative to the costs that were needed to operate um uh to to be a validator.

SPEAKER_02And so that there it makes sense when it when when it you know when there's like an existential issue with um having the economics um actually be profitable. But here, you know, uh the LRT stuff is gonna happen either way. Uh the like adjusting this yield won't change that dynamic because the yield itself is so small that you know the the the amount of boost you get with the LRT tokens and everything else makes a material difference. And so I think like those would exist either way.

SPEAKER_02And I agree, it's it's kind of bad for narrative. And yeah, I think the institutional point is is a very good one too, where part of the sound moneyness is this uh I think that narrative takes a big hit, and um you you certainly lose a lot of demand in exchange for you know what really interesting.

SPEAKER_01No, I agree. Yeah, I think that makes sense.

SPEAKER_03I don't know. When I initially I was I hadn't really looked into it and I was firmly on the side of don't fuck with it. After reading the arguments from the researchers, I felt like they were actually like pretty convincing.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think they're yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03My main like counter argument to it is I think all that shit happens anyway, even if you lower the yield. Like that's the thing, is it? People will still people will still, if anything, they'll they'll they'll chase more, you know, if if you lower the yield, they'll go chasing LRTs and and all sorts of stuff more. Um, and you're really just trying to deal with the fact that like ETH was designed to optimize for this like solo staker utopia, and you you literally now have Lido and and like a few liquid staking protocols.

SPEAKER_03And so it is just like yeah, so much engineering effort went into like solo staking, right?

SPEAKER_00And yeah, yeah. So my I've always had this take on a solo staking thing, and from like a philosophical standpoint, I totally I get it, I respect people who like feel strongly about this. Um, but you are designing for a world that doesn't exist, right? And you're just you're making like a conscious trade-off decision to design for something that will never exist, and you do kind of see a lot of the downsides of that.

SPEAKER_00Um personally, I think that val do being a validator is something that should be left to professionals. It's like a hard service that requires a lot of attention. Um, and I don't think individuals should solo stake. I mean, they can if they want, if they're like a crazy hobbyist, you still have people on Solana, even with the hardware requirements that are like super diehards that still do it, right? And so those people are gonna do it regardless of how much it kind of costs. Um so yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, um yeah, I'm curious to see where this goes. Who wins this this political battle? Uh yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, they already slowed down, they already slowed down the churn rate so that state can't, and a lot of people were pissed about this when they did it too. Um, that state can't grow as fast over the next couple years. I don't quite know what that means, but it sounds well to enter and exit being a validator. Okay, there's like a queue that you have to work through, and they just made it longer. Okay, because because like the amount staked went up super fast after Shanghai, like way faster than a lot of people expected.

SPEAKER_00And so there's kind of like this panic of oh shit, if we don't change this soon, Lido is gonna have like 80% of stake in a year, um, which was a bit overblown. But one thing too on the Lido thing, seeing them go into the Lido, the Lido thing, whatever the liquid staking thing is so they're kind of like fixing, quote unquote, fixing the the Lido problem, but they're replacing it with these LRTs, and so it's like objectively a more risky product to have because you have these because because an LST versus an LRT is a completely different product.

SPEAKER_00Like an LRT is an underwriter of AVS risk. Like you're selling, you're you're creating, and they're all different, like you're creating your own like products of of risk and yield, and you're making conscious decisions of so what happens when one LRT is just like max DG and yield and just goes for the highest yielding stuff, and then another LRT takes a more like diversified approach to get a lower yield, maybe less risky, and like you know, where does capital go? This is these are like the new incentives now, versus an LST is not making any conscious decisions, it's just staking, right?

SPEAKER_03They're not they're not actually doing any like an LRT is a much more active uh participant in that sense, and so you're replacing the vanilla LST with with now these like LRTs, and so you're fixing the lead problem, but you're making a worse problem potentially, and it's just like one letter different, but it's actually an entirely different set of risks that aren't even like fungible with each other. Um, but all right, we had a we had a we had a good episode where I think we're gonna skip altcoin corner, right?

SPEAKER_03Because it already went on kind of long. Um, but just imagine Duncan shilling banana and and synapse uh or or listen to one of the previous episodes. Um Germany. I have been uh prohibited from shilling Athena on this podcast, but we'll start with a derivative topic of the maker of a drama caused by uh Athena. So who wants to start there? Maybe we can maybe someone can like set the stage and give some context on what happened.

SPEAKER_00I think um so yeah, if you take a step back, uh the launch of Athena caused um yields to like rise all through DeFi, right? Because Athena started putting on this uh Delta Neutral trade, and the yield on the stable coin was like 40 plus percent organic, and then also all these incentives, and so it caused uh like stablecoin yields just everywhere to go up because if you could borrow dye at like five percent, people would just borrow dye, um, you know, take it, put it into Athena's, and you know, by nature, this just kind of like raises all yields like across everywhere, and so more recently, so it's kind of like the backdrop of the impact Athena has had on yields.

SPEAKER_00Uh and now recently Maker's done this whole endgame thing, right? Where Maker has always been this very conservative, like boring protocol. Um, for a while, like it was only backed by USDC. Then they started doing this RWA stuff, like T-bills and everything.

SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, when they started off, they were pretty they were they were pretty avant-garde. Like uh yeah, Maker was my first altcoin back in in 2018, and like yeah, it was it just they got I think rune leaving uh like solidified them more and more over over time, but but yeah, okay, keep going.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, um so, anyways, they're doing this whole endgame thing, and they're trying to make like toss a bunch of like incentives on the protocol and everything. They're really trying to get DAI like they they they scaled DAI relatively conservatively, I would say, um over the last few years, and now they're kind of going full force on it, and they're also trying to like product like own different parts of the stack, right? So they have this spark lending thing that's like this money market that competes directly with like Ave uh and others, and so the recent drama is that Maker has decided to um allow Athena stablecoin to be used as collateral to take out dye loans, right?

SPEAKER_00And so now DAI has some of its backing with this delta delta neutral synthetic dollar. I'll call it. I'm not gonna call it stable coins, like synthetic dollar, and so this caused a lot of uproar because it does fundamentally change DAI's model a bit from being backed from by like T-Bills, USDC, uh, and like ETH predominantly to now relying on this other new dollar. And so Ave responded by uh pretty aggressive uh tactic where they I don't know if it's gone through yet, but it seems it has full support of the of the team that they're gonna turn like they're gonna change LTV to like zero percent and not allow uh die to be used as collateral on their platform anymore.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I didn't even know that happened.

SPEAKER_00Because of the thing, no prep for this. It was on the docket.

SPEAKER_02I don't think it's gone through yet, though. I was just proposing it hasn't.

SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, I think there's two, yeah. The yeah, I think uh relations between Ave and Maker have definitely been worsening, right? They were like very close partners. Um, but then I think Maker launching Spark was a big was a big hit, right? Uh Stani posted after they launched, like because they said they developed this new primitive and the Stani said it was a fork of Ave, and it also went against some some deal they they they had made previously, so that caused a lot of hate.

SPEAKER_03And then I think their issue with this was not so much the deployment, because they've only deployed like 100 mil of dye, but the the forum posts basically authorized up to a billion right of of dye to be to be allocated to this. And so far they've only deployed 100 and they're gonna be pretty conservative. Like I think maker in general has like one of the best risk teams in in DeFi. Um, so that's that's I think part of the FUD. And then there's also this like related FUD that Mark posted today, right?

SPEAKER_03About how maker is basically just like pocketing this this this Athena yield and not really passing it on to DSR holders, and at some point die, like the DSR holders will just go direct to Athena. Um, but yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, so another thing too is yeah, so maker and Ave did have this partnership for a while, but this is this is a trend you're seeing in DeFi, something that you could kind of see from like two years ago that all these DeFi protocols are trying to own all these different products, and so Ave launched their own stable coin that competes with DAI, DAI launched their own money market, curve has launched their own stable coin, right? And they're all like going after the same market now, and then also Maker chose Morpho to do this USDC, you uh this Athena pool, which is again using like a different competitor, it's like a newer protocol, and so I think that kind of um there's a lot of like politics involved in this that it's not just like pure yeah.

SPEAKER_03I don't think you could do what what maker's doing on Ave though, because of the cross-collateral model, right? It's just a much harder process to get things approved to through governance, whereas Morpho Blue has this cool like isolated model, and you can also choose your parameters, right? Like, for instance, on on Morpho, um the Oracle price right now is is like hard-coded to one, right? Which means that as you're levering up on these like 94% of the rules, hard-coded to one for what for USD.

SPEAKER_03So the the the Morpho thing is basically die has put yeah, die like maker is lending. Sorry, it does make it does make sense given the risk analysis, I think. I remember when people hard coded UST to one.

SPEAKER_02No, it's yeah, but the couple is the the I think the main reason it's it's it's beneficial is because when it's not the second order effects of it not being hard-coded make it actually so much more risky, right? Because anytime there's even a mild risk of of there being a DPEG here and DPEG being, you know, somebody selling into the curve pool and and the price being off, what that kicks off in terms of a reflexive sell-off because um you know you're borrowing stable against stable is is is far more catastrophic um than kind of uh well basically because it can get uh because a mild DPEG can cause a big unwind, uh it just makes the whole system unnecessarily risky, whereas um I think hard coding it makes a lot of sense and then parameterizing elsewhere in terms of the amount of capital in there and and other stuff.

SPEAKER_03Um maker's willing to hold makers just willing to hold it until a repeg, right? Like they've done the risk analysis and and and that's the case. And it's it makes it a much more attractive product, right? Like I think Gearbox is is offering like the same thing, but it's just much tougher to sleep well. Uh speaking as someone who's who's who's doing who's done both, like it's just harder to sleep well on Gearbox when you know it's like an Oracle price, right? And you know on a 5% move basically on on USD, and you know the pools aren't that deep.

SPEAKER_03Uh I think that was the other problem that that sort of um Mark had with with uh with what Maker was doing. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's a you know, this was the big topic on Solana like. Like four months ago, maybe the MSOL DPEG. And it's a bit different because it's a liquid staking token. But um Solend just pegged the MSOL price to the ratio of Sol that it could be redeemed for. And Margin Phi used the free floating price. And I mean the problem with using the fixed price, at least like in the MSOL situation, is that there's always a risk that a liquid staking token can get like a pretty bad exploit.

SPEAKER_00And then if you don't liquidate, then like the whole entire protocol is kind of just screwed.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, I feel like that's kind of the tale where if there's an exploit that's not necessarily like we've talked about Athena before on the podcast, but you know, I think we kind of were all aligned, even in a really bad scenario, you know, you're probably looking at like plus the insurance fund, like maybe like a few percent, like like that you don't get back on. Maybe you get like you know, high not like 90% uh of your money back, like 90 cents on the dollar plus maybe like high 90 cents on the dollar in a really shitty scenario, uh, in terms of mechanics, but in terms of like you know, a black swan hack or something, then that could obviously be a lot, a lot greater.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I guess for make yeah, this is on makers like balance sheet, right?

SPEAKER_01Using like yeah, and I think just it would be useful because I know like a lot of people know what maker and Ave are, but just like as a quick refresher, like like Ave, you can deposit assets like Ethereum and then like borrow, you know, I don't know what the LTVs are, but something about like you know, 70% of your Ethereum in like US dollars or or like USDC or USDT. Um, and then there's kind of all these different pools for a bunch of different assets, uh, and kind of different assets have to get um approved through governance to to be borrowed against.

SPEAKER_01And then there's kind of like an interest rate uh based on on utilization and and how much is borrowed. And then for maker, they have their own kind of native stable coin where it's backed by kind of a basket of different assets, and you know, as Jose was saying, they just added USDE into this, which you know is super highly yielding to kind of make DIE more attractive, but yeah, and they have a search in there and all these different yield opportunities.

SPEAKER_00But just as a bit of context, if people needed a also, yeah, I saw today that Synthetics is allowing it now to mint uh to mint synthetics uh stable.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so all the DeFi apps are gonna be competing with each other, but it's kind of interesting because it's like they all took different routes to get to ultimately what would be the same thing, and I think you know, someone who's done this really well is honestly Frax. Like they I think it's like very methodical. Like from the beginning, Frax was just like the Yeah, but Frax doesn't seem like it has market share in like any I know because they were focusing on on the stable coin in the beginning, and that is kind of how they thought like once you have like a distributed stable coin, then you can kind of build these other products on it easy, like more easily, versus like you know, the other way around, where like oh they built the lending market first and then is adding on the stable coin, or curve, you know, built the decks first and then is adding on the stable coin.

SPEAKER_01So it's cool to see them all kind of converge.

SPEAKER_03I've heard real hedge fund, like that's the thing that this a lot of people have been saying, oh maker, maker is now a hedge fund or whatever. And to me, it's the like almost has been meme, you know, like the these things have have always been hedge funds, like maker reallocated to to treasury bills in the in the bear, right? It's just I think Athena is a a better hedge fund, like uh, or at least a higher a higher like risk adjusted yield. It's definitely less decentralized than maker, but yeah. And then the other thing I'm curious, yeah, sorry, go ahead.

SPEAKER_02It's more just um uh the the economics of it, right? It's you like I I would you can classify them as hedge funds, you can also classify them as banks, they're just borrowing at one rate. Think of our industry, please. No, but like they're the same business model, right? They're borrowing at one cost and and and and yielding a different one, and so um it's just like a net interest margin business. Uh and that's kind of what is you're see, you're starting to see issues come up on the maker side, right?

SPEAKER_02It's like why should I deposit die into DSR and and and then be the like the recipient of the shit yield and allow the protocol to come back? Well, do you want to explain what the DSR is quickly for people? Yeah, so uh the DIE savings rate basically it's it's uh a yield that um depositors of DAI can receive. And you can think of it, you know, same way you deposit cash into a bank, and then they take that cash and do something else that earns a higher yield than pass through very little to you, right?

SPEAKER_02So it's directionally similar. And so, in the same way that people are you know waking up and saying, Why should I uh collect 10 basis points in my checking count when I can put it in a money market? Similar dynamic here, where why should I kind of deposit into DSR? I you you can argue that um the like the risks are slightly different, but I think you know the magnitude of the yield probably doesn't offset yeah roughly how much their collateral is earning and then how much they're paying on the DSR or not quite something if I remember they're paying 15 now, they raised it a little while ago.

SPEAKER_01It was five earning like this the thing is that is that it's only on a it's only on a small percentage of the die, right? Yeah, yeah, the that they're earning other places, yeah. Yeah, so I think what is interesting is like makers started off as like, oh, like ETH was collateral, and so it's like people can go deposit ETH and then you know create this stable coin out of it, and then that was like you know, attractive to a lot of people to kind of have this like ETH-based stable coin. Like people are saying, oh, this is like decentralized stablecoin, like it's gonna be massive for crypto, this is what's needed, and then it's just kind of like morphed into uh as Jan was saying, you know, the same business model as a bank, just kind of chasing this this net interest margin and and these higher yields, so it's now like not decentralized at all.

SPEAKER_02It's like being like a USDC wrapper, right? So it it started shifting away from that original ethos pretty early on, yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's still it still has a lot of centralization vectors, but it is a lot more distributed and what those are versus when it was purely USDC for a while, right? So now they have like T T Bills, RWAs, they're doing this Athena thing, yeah. But yeah, I don't know if there's like much more to say on this little feud or spat.

SPEAKER_03No, I think I think it would be interesting to hear get you guys' thoughts on on maker because I personally again like it was my first altcoin, I haven't held maker since 2018, and like it's it's uh a decent sized position now, and I just feel like um yeah, the the end game plan. I don't know if anyone has taken the time to read through the the the sort of testaments that that rune writes up for the forums periodically, but those are really good. And the podcast he did on Blockworks was actually really good. It's like the Empire pod that he did with um with Jason and Sante.

SPEAKER_03And I just feel like it makes makes a lot of sense. Like splitting up Maker into these highly incentivized sub DAOs with tokens, uh rebranding the whole maker system. Like they're working with top branding agencies and marketing companies to like literally rebrand the entire maker system, give it one brand rather than like these two, like maker, DAO, and die, thinking about that, redenominating the token. So it's gonna have a new ticker, a new chart, um, you know, like get rid of this like old token um sort of bias that people have these days.

SPEAKER_03Uh, and then just like launching a bunch of tokens around this from these sub DAOs that are all um, yeah, I mean the the the that are all like gonna be able to to to be pretty synergistic, I think, and also just make the governance less heavy um on the on the maker side. Um yeah, I don't know. I think I think the the plans make a lot of sense. And I'm also like since Rune came back more active, I just feel like they move so much quicker. And it just shows like the power of having a founder still active in the in the protocol, right?

SPEAKER_03Like founders just founder energy just like gets shit done. And since he's come back, like even the speed at which they did the risk analysis and stuff on on Athena, like to be first to market on this, like maker would never have would never have been first to something like this, like before, right? Um and now they are, and it's like I don't know, it's still like you know, I think there's like what five billion die circulating. Um it has a big brand already. Like I don't know. I think it's uh I think it's in a pretty good pretty good spot.

SPEAKER_03Um as like an actual, it's the only like yeah, I mean that there's others, but at scale, it's the the the biggest decentralized, like truly decentralized stable coin.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, as I I I also have a decent uh maker position. I mean uh it's it's one of those probably where you just don't even need to mid-curve it. You can kind of you know look under the hood and and try and figure out uh how high you think it can run is is one way, but so uh you know, in the same way uh stock splits favorably impact uh stock prices, like unit bias is is even more of a thing in crypto, and and so um that will will is is certainly gonna be a catalyst, even though it's already kind of telegraphed.

SPEAKER_02I think there's that element. Um from like a fundamental perspective, it's it's it's it's not like super cheap, right? But it's still pretty good. Uh it's trading, I think like 20-ish times earnings. The tricky thing is, you know, yes, their revenues crank up, but um eventually you kind of expect uh the the cost to also ramp up, right? Uh as people decide, I don't really want to lend to you at 15. I'd rather either go elsewhere, which means they need to raise rates to attract the same amount of capital, which kind of squeezes their profitability.

SPEAKER_02So you'll have that. Uh on the uh the sub Dow stuff, I think you know that makes sense for sure, uh, in in terms of governance and and being able to move swiftly and having uh deeper focus on on certain areas. The the counter, I guess, is that it cannibalizes some value from maker because now you have new tokens, but you know, it's kind of like a um it's it's the the value of those tokens is still embedded in maker until those are out, right? Because you assume some of them will be distributed to maker.

SPEAKER_02So there the way to kind of capture that upside right now is I mean, yeah, I was looking through, I didn't really see anything specific in terms of how the thing is. Maker chain, right? Like they've been they've been doing a lot of research into that too. So um, yeah, I mean, I think in the grand scheme, you'll have a scenario where some of the parts is likely bigger than the whole with all these new tokens, but you imagine maker post split will certainly take a dip as value accrues to the other tokens, but up until that point, all of the value in those tokens can only really be reflected in in maker.

SPEAKER_02So um part of the thesis.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, and I think splitting it is subdowns, and I don't know exactly what the plans are, but I think the thing we've seen like really clearly in DeFi last cycle, and now again this cycle is like capital will go wherever yield is, and that's what like really like kind of gets things silly and like juices uh returns. And so, you know, last cycle it was like in the basis trade as well, like in you know, start of 2021, 50 to 60 percent for a few months on the basis trade, and like you know, a lot of capital went into that to kind of bring it down in in the second half of of the run-up.

SPEAKER_01And then, like, obviously, Luna like offering the the 20% yield, brought a lot of capital in, like 18 billion dollars. Um and then like now we're seeing it obviously an evolution and like a safer version with like Athena tokenizing the basis trade, which was a big one last cycle. And you know, they've what's Athena's TVL now, Jose, like a couple billion? I think it's over. Two billion, I think. Yeah, two billion. And then I so I think that you know, maker doing these subdows, new tokens, they can incentivize more yield, attract more capital.

SPEAKER_01It's just kind of this constant fight between protocols on you know who has the most natural yield. And obviously the basis trade is a great way to generate that like natural real yield, but then it kind of evolves as the market like goes later and later stages into who can throw the most incentives at the yield to try and attack attract the capital. And that's when we just see like really silly rates and a lot of capital come in, and um, you know, some some pretty crazy things happening. Even an example of this, right, is rune doing the uh basically on on rune or or Thor chain, you can borrow against your Bitcoin or ETH at a 50% LTV.

SPEAKER_01So if you put in one Bitcoin, it's worth$70,000 right now. Uh, you can borrow 35,000 USDC against it, and they give you a 0% interest rate and no liquidation. And so obviously that's just like a form of yield, and then what they do is they take your Bitcoin, they sell it, and they buy Rune. So that's like a very reflexive system to like attract capital and like really competitive rate because you don't have to pay any funding to get leverage on your BTC. And you know, there's reflective dynamics there that's capped at 4% of Rune's FTV. If that were to expand beyond 4%, I could see it being a problem at 4%.

SPEAKER_01I think it's it's probably all right. But it's just like these different protocols, you know, all trying to fight for this capital and giving more and more attractive deals, um, because that's what we've kind of seen in crypto, like capital flows to where the highest yields are. Yes, so yeah.

SPEAKER_00Basically, it's like where how do you get exposure to the best like risk-adjusted yield as all these you know other things are juicing it up? And so I think that's part of like Mark from Ave's thing with DAI is he doesn't like now how DAI has exposure to and I mean Athena is a lot different scenario than like Thor Chain. For instance, ThorChains is not it's like an insolvent by design design, but it's fine right now, but I could see it getting bad.

SPEAKER_01I think it's it has potential to get really bad, but it's only if you really raise the four percent, sure.

SPEAKER_00But it's like it's my point on that is like design is not sound, it doesn't work at it doesn't work at size, so it's not a sound design, right? Right, but yeah, like but us like just like plain USDC and like a money market or something will rise because of this, right? Because of all this stuff, and so yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I just think like you know, for opportunities for people like looking at crypto, it's like you know, there's a you there's a lot of opportunities in these reflexive systems, like if you can kind of time them well, but also like have to be aware of their their reflexivity because it works, it cuts both ways, right? Like things can get really cap like crazy when the market's going up, and then things can get crazy when when the market's going down. So, anyways, I just think that's gonna be the driver that re-invigorates DeFi's just higher yields. It's like literally as simple as that.

SPEAKER_00That's what it always is.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's what it always is, and just the later you get into the cycle, the more crazy things people are doing, like throwing more tokens at it, or you know, taking on more risky designs. And so it's just something to you know be be aware of and kind of watch it play out, and it's also a really good indicator for like where are we in this cycle? Like when people start doing some really like designs that are not sound and like they you could see them going wrong or just like throwing silly amounts of tokens at it, um, or just that get crazy, those yields get crazy, uh, is kind of a pretty good indicator of of prof and also leverage buildup in in the cycle, right?

SPEAKER_01Like the amount of leverage buildup that kind of like UST caused, and then that had to unwind was a lot. And you know, if if you were kind of paying attention to that, you could see like a lot of things happen, like yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, should we should we move on? Or does do people have more to say about this? Okay, cool. Um, we've been told we're we're we we have we're awkward with uh with the goodbyes. So uh maybe we can all say goodbye this time. Thanks everyone for huh. Thanks everyone for tuning in, and we'll see you again in two weeks.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thank you everyone. Follow me on Twitter at Plug Capital for the real alpha.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Anthropic's IPO Could Drain Crypto

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    Anthropic goes public with no six-month lockup and an unlock schedule José calls more aggressive than any low float, high FDV token. Is the selling about to drain the market? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Something Is Wrong With Bitcoin

    Nov 11, 202659 minAudio

    US equities just lost $2 trillion. Is the worst behind us? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris split on it. Yan says the bull market is intact and the setup for a short squeeze is there; Jason's macro models say wait....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why A Broken Congress Is Bullish for Crypto

    Nov 5, 202658 minAudio

    Two years of gridlock just started, and the crew thinks that's good for crypto. Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris are joined by Omnia, co-founder of Kinetiq, the day after the midterms. Yan explains why chop into the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Hacking Just Got 1000x Cheaper

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    What happens when a cyber attack costs a thousandth of what it used to? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris are joined by Jake Sylvestre, founder of Hypercall, the options protocol from Synapse built on Hyperliquid....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Worst Is Behind Us

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    Is the bottom in for crypto? Kevin, Jason, José, Yan and Ceteris break down a market that just shook off weeks of selling, from the 10:30 AM seller who finally ran out of coins to the year-end unlocks and what the...

    Credit the people on this episode