Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Getting Spooked Podcast

The Getting Spooked Podcast artwork

[#38] Expanding Fringe Horizons w/ Erica Lukes & Jack Brewer

Nov 20, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

Two of my favorite folks in UFO land and adjacent concerns are Erica Lukes and Jack Brewer of Expanding Frontiers Research. Rarely do independent researchers have this much thoroughness, especially in the fringe. They dropped by TGSP to discuss the history and goals of EFR, their own feelings on recent events, and the keys to decent alt media literacy and independent inquiry. Check them out at Expanding Frontiers Research, full of excellent resources for seasoned and rookie researchers (+ support them on Patreon). You can also find their work at these locales: Expanding Frontiers on YouTube Erica Lukes’ wonderful UFO Classified Jack Brewer’s excellent The UFO Trail Read Jack’s books The Greys Have Been Framed: Exploitation in the UFO Community (2015) and Wayward Sons: NICAP and the IC (2021) We also talk a bit about my prior article “The Hill Abduction, MKULTRA, and the Targeting of American Activists” Music: Emerald Web - “Lights of the Ivory Plains” Emerald Web - “Nocturne” Greg Truckell - “Linear” Contact: gettingspooked@protonmail.com Twitter Instagram Bluesky This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit tannerfboyle.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_01y'all, Tanner from Getting Spooked here. Today I'm joined by two of my favorite researchers in not only the UFO field, but just in general, they've really expanded their frontiers as time has gone by. I've got Jack Berger and Erica Lukes of Expanding Frontiers Research. Which does some pretty incredible work in terms of like archival research, streams with very interesting guests.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes I've been on, but there are other actually interesting guests at other times. And yeah, I just wanted to do a temperature check, see how they're both doing, how they're feeling about the world today, how they're feeling about ufology, how they're feeling about the fringe. And all of those interesting things. Erica, Jack, thank you for joining me.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for having us.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, great to be here. Thank you, Tanner.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I should note for the listener, we're recording in the midst of a, Well, it's gone on for about three hours now, a national grounded flights emergency situation that seems vague at the present moment. But luckily, we have nowhere to go at present.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm happy. I couldn't think of a better place to be on a crazy Friday the 13th.

SPEAKER_01Oh, it's Friday the 13th. I didn't even think of that. Dun, dun, dun. Yeah, I guess that makes sense. I heard someone say it was a software update, but I mean, I'm not a software engineer, but typically you don't do that on a Friday evening. Maybe they just made a bad decision. I have no idea.

SPEAKER_00It definitely coincides with some very interesting activities across the globe, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, it certainly does. I don't know. You guys sometimes feel like we're all in a can of soda that they're shaking up every now and again from time to time.

SPEAKER_00Pretty much every day. Yes. Morning, noon, and night.

SPEAKER_01In more fun news, do you guys have any updates from Expanding Frontiers, your wonderful research organization that's done some great work, not only in terms of FOIA requests, I find myself diving into the Andruffle stuff every once in a while. Just incredible stuff. And I'm sure readers and listeners are already well aware because I wind up citing Jack's UFO Trail blog, Erica's UFO Classified,

SPEAKER_01and Expanding Frontier stuff all the time, which is why I wanted you both on because, you know, it's hard to find people you can cite with confidence in this sort of arena of But if I cite one of you two, I feel like, well, that's a little bit better than citing basically anybody else in the UFO world.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. And I feel the same about you. I know Jack does as well. We have to stick together in this crazy world, especially in the UFO, that aspect of things. And I just want to say that I'm really grateful to know I love his old blog, too. I've looked at that for many, many years. Thank you both, your generous to which he goes. To really do incredible FOIA requests, ask amazing questions and then put pieces of the puzzle together that helps all

SPEAKER_00of us. And I love his old blog too. I've looked at that for many, many years.

SPEAKER_02Thank you both. You're generous. We do a lot of FOIA work at EFR. The kinds of things we're most recently working on, I've done some requests this month on various organizations that have come up in interactions I have with people and see if perhaps we can get Responsive records

SPEAKER_02on agencies or organizations from the FBI. That's my go-to. I start there and then I might branch out to local law enforcement and things as responses from the FBI come in. It is a long-term process. It's definitely a long game. There are requests. We're in our fifth year of operation now,

SPEAKER_02and there's requests from before we started that I still haven't gotten final responses on. Got a response just this week from the FBI on an interim response informing us that They have located some 4,600 pages of records responsive to Edward Condon of the Condon Committee.

SPEAKER_02I'm aware of about 1,700 pages that have been obtained and published in the past on the Internet Archive. Very good resource there, too. But that's a far shot short of 4,600. So I'm kind of wondering what's going on there. And we're like in a back and forth on appealing a denial of a fee waiver.

SPEAKER_02And the latest has been that the Office of Information Policy, which is the appeal authority for the FBI, says that there will be No fees assessed on this. So that's encouraging. It's something that I wonder how in stone is that when, you know, another administration and five years later, it actually starts getting, getting,

SPEAKER_02you know, discussed and PDFs being made or whatever the case may be. So So yeah, the process is interesting. I find it entertaining and it's definitely a long game. And I have for sure been reading your stuff, Tanner. And I really appreciate it. Like with your latest, with Exploring the Hill Mysteries, that one of the challenges

SPEAKER_02about that is how do you present it to people That you cover the bases, yet every time you bring it up, you don't start at square one and go all the way through it. That's challenging. What audience are you... Are you talking to people that know left, right, and in between about the hills?

SPEAKER_02Or do I start at the beginning? And I appreciate the way you handle that and write about it. I think you do it well.

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you. Yeah, that was great. I just have to say that was so in depth and it just had my mind going a million miles a minute when I read that. It's incredible. And I think, too, it's also very interesting that people would rather believe that they were abducted than actually look at some facts here about what was taking place in that period of time and the organizations that they were involved with and their political leanings and things. It's just amazing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I thought you two would find this interesting. I won't name any names, but I actually got a good response from most people I would assume to be UFO believers in the believer camp. But one debunker said that I was spinning a tale of conspiracy theory Which was based entirely upon dreams that Betty had.

SPEAKER_01And I thought, well, wait a minute. No, their experience can be entirely from Betty's dreams. That doesn't really matter to what I was talking about. And I just, I found that kind of frustrating, you know?

SPEAKER_02One of the logistics... Of the writing process itself, like I alluded to, is in The Greys Had Been Framed, for instance. I did a chapter on the hills.

SPEAKER_01Which is extremely helpful and cited in that article.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. In the beginning of that chapter, I stated that Overtly and directly, that it was my opinion that the most likely explanation for that event was confusion, misinterpretation, as is the case. I mean, that's high hand to beat for any circumstance that you don't have a valid explanation.

SPEAKER_02I mean, pretty much. Yet a lot of people seem to miss that. And I got saddled with what I felt like were in some instances straw man arguments about conspiracy mongering and that I was just way off base, that I couldn't prove a government agency did A, B or C, which I made no attempt whatsoever to prove or to claim that I proved.

SPEAKER_02I'll tell you one thing, though, that I gave a lot of thought. If I have a one paragraph disclaimer followed by 20 pages of speculation, they're going to forget the disclaimer. And that's one of the things I meant when I said I really appreciate the way You laid that out, that you don't have to keep going back to repeat everything over and over,

SPEAKER_02yet you clarify enough. And so I felt like some of the criticism I've received, Erica sent me a review she saw floating around a couple of weeks ago that made some of these Typical criticisms about the grades have been framed that I have come to think, OK, you know, I'm glad they read it.

SPEAKER_02I'm glad they're interested. And I'll take those criticisms to heart that if I'm not suggesting necessarily that person A or person B was a targeted mind control victim, Well, then why am I spending 20 pages writing about it? That's a reasonable point. Yet, I completely agree with you, too,

SPEAKER_02that it's not all or nothing, and it's not a matter of Saddling you with that or not. If they were completely confused, how come the authorities at least pretended to be so interested? So many authority figures, so many Air Force officers. I had some really, what to me are just basic questions like,

SPEAKER_02How often did Dr. Simon tape his sessions and why? You know, like maybe it was just the MKUltra culture that all the psychiatrists and psychologists are taping their sessions. And why a photo shoot? Why are Betty and Barney in dress clothing and pictures being taken if you're just

SPEAKER_02at the psychologist to work on trauma?

SPEAKER_01You know what? I never really thought of that. And I used one of those images as the thumbnail. But for some reason, I never would have occurred to me like, who's the photographer here?

SPEAKER_02And I've thought, yeah, I guess you could just recreate it for Time Magazine or whatever may have happened. But I've had trauma treatment at mental health facilities, mental health offices. I am an advocate and none of mine ever suggested a photo shoot.

SPEAKER_01Even with the recording and the photo shoot, it leaking essentially is another pretty big no-no within the therapeutic community. And I can't remember the full story of how it eventually leaked out. I don't know if it's ever been.

SPEAKER_02I would assert one way or the other, CIA culture is evident in that. Doctors are taping their interactions with clients as if they're to be studied or shared or photos are being made. The doctor is going on Talk shows to talk about what happened with his patients.

SPEAKER_02I would assert that whatever the exact circumstances are behind it, that that's a reflection of like Martin Orn speaking to college students and doctors and conferences on his work for the CIA. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I would largely agree with that, too. It is just interesting, right? Because that, in some ways, was like the mold of the abductees that would show up in later years. Like, you know, you go on Sarah Jesse Raphael in the 90s with your hypnotherapist, and it's the same sort of dynamic. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And Oprah, and yeah, and I mean, to me, this is all very National Enquirer-esque, you know, the whole setup.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, and the leaking of the story, I feel like, is National Enquirer-esque, and the Enquirer, of course, has, let's say, alleged ties to the intelligence community, and at least the mob, definitely the mob. Yeah, yeah. But even in the MKUltra era, those two things kind of commingled frequently. So it is interesting.

SPEAKER_01But thank you both for the kind words. When I found that article about Simon being at a speech, a conference really, with Martin Orrin, I thought, oh, I know at least three people who are going to be so excited about this.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, it's rather profound that it's so commonly overlooked. That Simon and Oren had the same employer, and they've seen each other around, okay?

SPEAKER_01Let alone Greenblatt, who Simon would write papers with. He was a Conferences with and Greenblatt was doing a lot of the early LSD research on, I think, primarily college students and maybe some mental patients. It is, it's just... It's like the... I'm trying to think of a good figurative way to say it.

SPEAKER_01It's like the nest, you know? It's not a fledgling bird. The whole family is in the nest, you know? Because, you know, the line to Jolly West from that point, too, is like one person. Yeah. And I say one person. One other psychiatrist.

SPEAKER_00And do you know what I've got to tell you really quickly, that when I used to have, I've had a lot of conversations with Eric Davis, there was a certain point in time, and that was his idol.

SPEAKER_01You're talking Eric Davis, the UFO guy. His idol was Jolly West. Erica, you're going to have to elaborate on that.

SPEAKER_00You know what? It's in my notes. I'll have to go back. But I just remember thinking, oh, that's something else. But yeah, that's weird.

SPEAKER_02I knew a psychologist that I met through UFO people that thought highly of Dr. West due to His perspective was West as a professor at UCLA. And that was when I first started really noticing how little there is in college

SPEAKER_02and higher education curriculum about MKUltra and conspiracies that are confirmed, that are verified things to have happened. That professionals in that field don't know about because the people that were assets of the CIA were heads of the AMA and the APA

SPEAKER_02and the Canadian Psychological Association. And they were professors at universities. And so it never made it to the curriculum Things that the three of us could just talk about as relatively common knowledge from MKUltra files and released FOIA documents and things.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I guess I wanted to ask you two also about, I mean, Anna Paulina Luna almost lost her Her congressional race, I assume, I mean, I think her other elections have kind of been blowouts, but this one was probably a little too close for comfort. What do you make of her bringing together these congressional hearings about MKUltra and UFOs? And I mean, you'd think that those things put together

SPEAKER_01Would be kind of interesting to people like us, but for some reason, it leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

SPEAKER_00You know what, I think that, you know, they are getting a lot of her and her group of people who are financed by some interesting people. You know, people and countries or whatever you want to call it. But I think that they're trying to take something that really had merit and confuse the situation and use it for their own agenda. And I think that's unfortunate. I know that one of the fellows that was there, and I can't remember his name off the top of my head, perhaps one of you guys can help me, but he has written quite a few books and he was testifying.

SPEAKER_00And interestingly enough, like right before Maybe a few months before he testified, he was asked to Peter Thiel's house for two weeks.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so, I mean, I don't know, make of that what you will, but

SPEAKER_01highly suspect to me. I think that was Tom O'Neill, who I found it interesting that while he was on Capitol Hill for that MKUltra meeting, he bumped into some congressional aide, He started talking to him about UFOs. And then O'Neill is on the podcast circuit going like, well, these are serious guys and these are serious people. And they say they've seen things they can't explain.

SPEAKER_01So it seems like, I don't know, is it Grush who's the congressional aide right now? I don't know who he ran into. Erica, I thought you'd be happy to hear that Anna Paulina Luna After narrowly winning her seat back, said that she was going to take no more foreign money towards her campaign.

SPEAKER_00Okay, well, I mean, they could disguise that type of money in all sorts of ways, can't they?

SPEAKER_01I don't know what you mean. That could never happen.

SPEAKER_00I know. I know. Never.

SPEAKER_02Representative Boebert won't be taking any foreign donations either.

SPEAKER_00Such a shame.

SPEAKER_01We're losing all of our UFO congresspeople, unfortunately. We might have Burchett for a long time if he becomes a senator, as he seems hopeful to do.

SPEAKER_00You know what, and I think the funny thing is, is when you look at some of the Democrats that are involved in this, I mean, Gillibrand is quite enmeshed in the cryptocurrency culture, as is her son, who's been in a lot of controversy with regard to that, so.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's interesting.

SPEAKER_00And I think Jared Moskowitz as well, if I'm not mistaken, so.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. What do you make of that, Erica?

SPEAKER_00Well, I make of that that I think there might be lots of things going on behind the scenes to make people appear like they're having this bipartisan disclosure and that we're really honing down on some of these issues. Trying to get actual information, but it just seems like it's just a big... I mean, obviously, it's a smokescreen. I don't believe there's anything genuine in this. And so when you start to look at the people who's funding them,

SPEAKER_00what they're saying cohesively and by themselves, it's a very interesting thing. And I think as we both know, there are... As we all know, there are people on both sides of the aisle that are... Quite interesting and maybe don't have the best intentions at heart.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I don't know. It is. I guess this is a question. Do you think that. For both parties, the UFO issue is seen as something safe and kind of a. Because I don't think it used to be something ridiculed, but I think it's kind of left that area. And now it's almost sort of like a, you know, not always totally positive, but at least, you know, at least they're not screwing something up position to take.

SPEAKER_02I think part of the reason that Representative Luna was interested in it is, and I'll just say it, It's not out of her depth, and a lot of things are. She has a way to go from, in my opinion,

SPEAKER_02to catch up with the knowledge of some of her colleagues that are intelligence professionals that are well-versed on the economy, on National Security. And I think Erica's right that there's ulterior motives. And I also think it looked like something she could be an authority on without really having to know it.

SPEAKER_00And two, you look at what's happening with the fence contractors, who's trying to start up a new company. I don't know. I just think there's so many things. And then isn't she the one that invited a certain government to tour places in Washington, D.C.?

SPEAKER_01I think so, yes. Yeah. And I think she... Was getting flack for that, this election. I think that's, I think it's, I think that's literally put the fear of God in her, but obviously it won't change anything, but maybe she'll be a little less blatant.

SPEAKER_00You know what, that'll be interesting to see because right now it seems like everybody's just blatant about, you know, hey, we're, you know, this is what team we're playing for now and It's unfortunately, yeah, we're living in some strange times.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and Jack, I got to say, you're being a little unfair because, you know, she was very serious when she said that she wanted to bring all living members of the Warren Commission to speak before Congress.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. She could have done a little more background research on those situations. I think That people get disappointed with Luna and Boebert digging into MKUltra because it in itself devalues the subject matter when it's not given the respect

SPEAKER_02and almost seems like there's an intentional effort to To politicize it and come at it in a way that just spins it as a story that they can use for their own agendas, whatever those may be. It's kind of like I think the UFO people might empathize

SPEAKER_02that, all right, we're going to have some hearings. We're going to talk about this stuff. And you hear something rehashed from a 1980s paperback that people have known for 40 years that it was a rumor when it started and people have known it for 40 years and it's never been confirmed. And then it's clearly targeting people that never heard it in the first place.

SPEAKER_02As Erica and I have talked a lot about on YouTube and our stuff at EFR, the UFO genre has to frequently turn its audience over or it's painfully apparent that it's mired down and repetitive.

SPEAKER_01You two have both been in the UFO field for quite a while. Would you say there's a lot of churn in terms of the population interested in the subject?

SPEAKER_00You know, and I just want to say one thing, though, really quick before we answer that, because that's a great question. But I want to also say that, you know, with the MKUltra hearings, they, you know, brought in somebody from the former CDC worker and then brought in that, you know, the vaccine and what kind of equated that to MKUltra and stuff, which was most unfortunate. So anyway, thanks for letting me add that.

SPEAKER_01No, yeah, I mean, you're absolutely correct. It was like they don't understand... What the CIA is. I don't think the CIA is like, you know, I mean, a lot of them were like prominent liberals, but it's not like the CIA is not the commie pinko bogeyman. But, uh, I think these people imagine when they're, when they're talking about like,

SPEAKER_01you know, the horrific inhumane vaccine treatment, uh, Yeah, it's just, it seems like a complete misunderstanding of both the sciences and the history of American defense, you know.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Thank you. Go back to your great question with regard to turnover. I think there's too much turnover and too little. You still have some of the great – well, you still have some very big names in – The UFO history and the diehards that have been there for 50, 60 years that are either making sure

SPEAKER_00that they're tamping down on information getting out to people. So you've got the old guard gatekeepers. And then you've got the new group of nameless, faceless people that are coming into chat rooms and people that are They've got these great YouTube shows that have hundreds of thousands of followers, and they've got slick productions and all of these things. So it's just a real trip. And then the poor people that just want answers or enjoy

SPEAKER_00the topic are getting pulled in by all of this stuff, and they have no truly good place to go for factual information.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, that's something I've noticed, too, with... YouTube specifically has become ungodly frustrating for the UFO subject. Let alone some of the AI-generated stuff that's now choking the platform to death. You've got just the rehashes of stuff that's...

SPEAKER_02My thinking about the... Audience and the demographic and how often does it have to turn over? You've done some work on the seedy sides of the UFO community. I don't think that an objective researcher can address

SPEAKER_02the UFO topic without Giving that its fair share. I've, of course, addressed that. Eric has addressed that. A lot of my earlier work was on things like that.

SPEAKER_01May I just say, I think the first place I saw your work was your coverage of the Paracast e-bagging situation. Yeah. And I thought, I like this guy. I'm going to stick it out.

SPEAKER_02Scheme Gene Steinberg. Yes. Yes. And his, uh, eight times a month financial emergencies that he just needed a bump to get through and he'd be in the homestretch. Yeah. And there's a whole lot worse going on. A whole lot worse. Um, Emma Woods, Carol Rainey, Leah Haley,

SPEAKER_02you've written about some of it. I bring it up because it's on my mind because that's something I've been working on the past few weeks is these stories haven't stopped. They don't stop. There's some that are current. Is there more exploitation of people taking place

SPEAKER_02in UFO disclosure movements and paranormal groups than other aspects of society? I don't know. I don't have any data on it. I bring that up because I've heard the argument made and It's a poor argument. What difference does it make? I'm not even going to use an analogy.

SPEAKER_02It's not relevant that exploitation and unethical, possibly illegal circumstances are taking place among people like Erica says. That just thought they were coming to get some answers. They may have been traumatized and wanting to learn about what somebody told them is responsible for their trauma,

SPEAKER_02right or wrong. They get in situations that make it worse. And I think that deserves its fair share of attention. I haven't decided how much I'm going to go back into that. Everyone on this conversation knows it takes its toll. It takes its toll in your personal relationships. It takes its toll in your productivity and other areas of your life to really dive

SPEAKER_02into that stuff. But it's still going on. And it's often minimized by people that just want the relevant story to be David Grush has something to say. It's an insult to intelligence. It's disturbing on a number of levels.

SPEAKER_02And The overall point, in my opinion, is the UFO topic offers an area to draw people for a lot of ulterior reasons. And a lot of demographics do it, ranging from charlatans that want to make a buck to politicians that want to change someone's political orientation.

SPEAKER_02To fascists that want to bring people further into right-wing ideologies. And including predators of various types that use the topic as a means to try to develop trust with people. And yeah, they have to keep turning that audience over to do it again and again and again. And they are doing.

SPEAKER_02In some circumstances. And then to make it even more challenging, people that are running conferences, that are heading up agencies, that are writing books, that are making talks, have vested interest in minimizing it because they want their message to be The labs, they want to sell tickets to their conference. They want to have their policy recommendations looked

SPEAKER_02at seriously all the while the exploitation just continues.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, and I don't want to bring up specifics about, I think we'd be talking about the same thing, the like current day example of this. I just want to note that some prominent UFO people have, rather than address the problems with the subject matter and exploitation

SPEAKER_01within the community, they are crying about how UFOlogy isn't about UFOs anymore. And it's like That's your statement when people are going through horrific, horrific times in a community that was supposed to be welcoming and spiritually useful and engaging. It wasn't supposed to be anything beyond that, you know?

SPEAKER_00Or was it? And has it always been that way? I mean, to me, it always has been that way. And that's unfortunate to see and having had, you know, different experiences and knowing many people in the topic, you know, over the many years, like I just, it's never been a safe place. No. And I think that, you know, I always try to, and I think Jack does as well. I mean, it's like we're always, I feel very strongly that we, you know, people should just know that from the outset.

SPEAKER_00Like I don't, like I feel, you know, we've got a great community here with the community that we've all created and we care about people. Other human beings and people that have been put in dangerous situations and You know, but it's just there are, there's a lot of money involved. There are a lot there, you know, a lot of people in important positions, the heads of organizations or, you know, people that can get their stories in the front of the New York Times that have a lot

SPEAKER_00of power to make things, you know, go away, you know, like you with MUFON, you know, and some of the things that went on there, you know, it was just very easy to create another message and, you And kind of sweep things under the rug and that's unfortunate. So I caution everybody wanting to get into this topic to do it at your own risk and to make sure you're really grounded and you take a lot of time away from the subject and check in with people, you know?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I definitely agree with that. And I'm also not certain about the Assertion that some people make that ufology is about UFOs. I think it often isn't about UFOs. It's often about people almost exclusively. And I think that speaks to your point that like people are going to be affected by these things.

SPEAKER_01It's not just some vague Nebulous objects. It is people. And in both like a physical and mental sense, that's what we're dealing with.

SPEAKER_00I agree.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And some of the people that are doing the current enabling, it's not their first rodeo with doing that enabling either. And I wonder how many of the younger folks are aware of that, that what they thought was their mentor's histories

SPEAKER_02as being well steeped in ufology and knowing all the contacts and having all this knowledge about all these cases, that there's another perspective. Like in the grays had been framed of what these people have been doing for 30 and 40 years. And I don't think a lot of the newer people, the current UAP disclosure people are aware

SPEAKER_02of what their community leaders have been doing and enabling.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I don't think there is. It's been an interesting thing to behold. I'm sure it is for both of you, too. Being aware of the field in sort of a broad sense and then seeing new people come in without that. Yeah. Jack, what would you tell somebody who's coming into ufology for the first time?

SPEAKER_02I think Erica put it about as well as you can that you just need to be aware that there's a lot of projection. There's a lot of misinterpretation. There's a lot of exploitation. People want to pull you into their camp.

SPEAKER_02For a variety of reasons, a lot of different reasons. And pretty much none of it's good. You know, if people have vested interests in leading you to believe things instead of encouraging you to learn for yourself and giving you direction of where you might learn it and That's the whole problem. It targets a demographic that doesn't know how to learn.

SPEAKER_02And if you don't know that, you don't know that. Like we don't know what we don't know. And if you can't watch a video or read a paper or an article and tell the difference between assertions that are backed up by facts and sources and just opinion and speculation and unverified assertions, that's square one.

SPEAKER_02You have to learn how to do that because that's how they're pulling the demographics and of people that and it's not necessarily even uneducated.

SPEAKER_00It's the same with the new age community. I mean, it's the same with a lot of different communities. Unfortunately, you've got people that don't know how to critically think. And then also, unfortunately, we haven't done a good job. Our leaders, the people in You know, the education, they haven't done a good enough job, I feel, teaching the general public how to discern what is good information. You know, we've been looking at ABC and NBC and CBS and all these news sources for information.

SPEAKER_00So decades to give us factual information, and we're learning at the end of the day that's not necessarily the case. It's propaganda TV in a lot of ways and that has enabled other factions to insert all this nonsense and that is not helped us learn how to critically think so I feel like we're very destabilized in that sense but I feel like a lot people are waking up now and beginning To understand this, which is great.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I certainly hope so. It feels like we're close to the breaking point in a lot of ways. I don't know if that's true of ufology too, but what is it that Carol Rainey used the term? Sort of like diminishing returns. I forget her exact phrasing.

SPEAKER_01What does the culture and what does ufology do once those returns have diminished to the point of nothingness? You can no longer shock the American public into something. Do you even reach a point like that?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And it's not just exploiting the uneducated. Educated or without degrees alike that are a passion that may have been traumatized by something or a series of things that happened to them that are curious and want to learn more. And then that's how we end up with these people

SPEAKER_02that it will just like defy my my I'm like, how does this even happen? Defy my understanding when I see an educated person respected in their field talking about what somebody told them somebody said they saw and stuff like that. And it's just like, wow, do you even hear yourself, Matt? You know?

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, the major whistleblower for UFO stuff currently, as far as I'm aware, is whistleblowing secondhand knowledge of a crash retrieval program, which wouldn't you think it'd be a little better than secondhand? Yeah. Because we've had many a secondhand knowledge crash retrieval story before.

SPEAKER_01But again, as you both said, it's people that don't know that.

SPEAKER_02And how do you explain that, okay, they got their day more than one with Congress. How come the representatives aren't going down the trail and saying, this guy said to talk to you, and that guy said to talk to you, and where does the buck stop? How come they just drop it and go on and bring it up now and then when they feel like it's going to get them a headline?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Rhetorical question.

SPEAKER_01I think it is because they just want that headline. They want their picture in the paper. They want to be on the news for a bit.

SPEAKER_02So part of the question becomes, how does the demographic that keeps making the supplier motivated to supply, how do the people that buy that keep convincing themselves that Representative Luna, Representative Burchette, if they're acting in good faith,

SPEAKER_02are just somehow unable to do anything more. And I think trauma and desire to believe and identify

SPEAKER_00with it,

SPEAKER_02like, Living vicariously through it. Like identifying that I saw something, I believe it was genuinely paranormal, if not alien. And if Burchette and Luna are wrong, that means I'm wrong. And so then we're back to You gotta be able to think critically and reason

SPEAKER_02and think stuff through properly in the first place. [music]

SPEAKER_01We've gotten a little more dour than I expected, but I think that's okay. Let me reorient. I have this question actually written down because I figured it was one you two didn't get a lot. What brings you joy?

SPEAKER_00Thinking about David Hasselhoff naked.

SPEAKER_01That's a good enough answer for me.

SPEAKER_00No, I'm kidding. I'm so kidding. That actually is quite disturbing, but I just needed to. Just wanted to lift the mood in a very inappropriate way there.

SPEAKER_01No, I don't think it's inappropriate. I get it with the Hasselhoff.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I know. Yeah. Quite the stud. The pizza video was wonderful. I, you know, for me, something that gives me joy, like is knowing both of you. And that's been, you know, especially working with Jack over the years, like having, knowing that, you know, Jack and I have formed this connection and that we've done great work and that we can, we have, you know, each other to kind of bounce stuff off of and maintain our one foot on the ground,

SPEAKER_00you know, hopefully both. But, and so that's great joy. And like, I love, I love connecting with people and hearing stories. I don't know. That gives me joy. And my art. So there you have it.

SPEAKER_01I think that's a really nice answer. Thank you, Erica. Yeah, it's true. I feel lucky to know both of you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Erica. I get joy when I see in my email inbox a message from FBI with the subject line, FOIA files are available. And then you click on it and you get your little key and you add it and you download your file. That gives me joy.

SPEAKER_01It's like Christmas except near weekly, right?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01No, I think at least some of my listenership will appreciate that sentiment as well. Yeah. What's on the horizon for EFR?

SPEAKER_00Oh, boy. We always like to cause trouble, don't we, Jack?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. We have some FOIA stuff in the works that I'm thinking about how to present. We have records as well that we share on Patreon. Freely, that we share on Patreon, that it almost becomes overwhelming.

SPEAKER_02There is so much that could be written about or explored that it's a matter of identifying what to do next. And then sometimes during periods of making that decision, It might get put off because, and I know you and your listeners can relate to this,

SPEAKER_02it would require more of an effort than I'm willing to give at the current time.

SPEAKER_01You're calling me and my listeners people who don't want to give a lot of effort.

SPEAKER_02Not in the least. I'm saying that you do it thoroughly and that you can identify, wow, this is going to be a deep dive. This is like a 200-page FBI file, and that's going to lead to 20 more FOIA requests on groups that are named in it and individuals that are named in it. And to explain this to people, what I'm doing and what I'm looking at,

SPEAKER_02other things are going to have come up before I'm through this, so I'm not even going to start on it because I know in two weeks such and such is coming. And that happens a lot, a lot. In fact, I laugh sometimes when I think about one of the stories that Eric and I were working on when we incorporated some five years ago, we still haven't ever presented systematically all of it.

SPEAKER_02That was one of the main reasons we incorporated, that we were like, yeah, this is good. Let's do this story.

SPEAKER_01Can I ask which one it is, or is it a secret?

SPEAKER_02No, it's not a secret. It has to do with Utah goings-ons and circumstances.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it's just like you want to be able to bring something conclusive or you want to be able to bring something that adds to the collective record. Mm-hmm. Sometimes it's just not there yet. You know, it's just like, well, everybody already knows there's a lot of implications and there's a lot of coincidences.

SPEAKER_02And wow, this is wild that you do this, that and the other. You want to comment on that? And then if they're just like, Yeah, I did that. What about it? Well, I mean, what are you going to do? Oh,

SPEAKER_00sorry, Jack.

SPEAKER_02I was just going to finish up by saying, so sometimes you don't want to build a story for more than you really got, but we thought that was going to be a good one. But then we got into other stories that even wound up being picked up by the news and the New York Post and things like that. That we didn't foresee when we incorporate. So go ahead, Erica.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was just going to say, I think, too, with what we're talking about, there's so many interesting areas that I would say. I love and I have for many, many years looked into about, you know, it's pretty, it's big. It's not just a little, you know, okay, we've got this ranch and yada, yada, yada. There's a lot that can go into that and there's a lot that I'll continue to look into as I have for many years and then ask different experts and then weave

SPEAKER_00that together when the time is appropriate and, you Like you said, there's just so many other things to focus on and we'll get there. But it's just, yeah, we've just taken a little journey down another path.

SPEAKER_01No, the thing is, I feel a lot of joy whenever I see an EFR Patreon notification because I think, oh, this will be a nice break from whatever mundane or even the non-mundane task I'm doing. EFR is always doing something interesting. Erica, when is the UFO classified coming back?

SPEAKER_00I am thinking about, you know, starting it again next month. I've just been taking a little break to deal with other things. And then you've got the holidays and all of this stuff happening. But I will be, you know, I know I say this, but I will be getting that going again. And I think when I do it, I'll just do like a series of maybe six interviews, like a season or something. And then, you know, instead of doing for every Friday night, which I did for many, many years, that was Sometimes you just got to have a little Friday night

SPEAKER_00to yourself, I suppose.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was going to say, like, I mean, you've done the legwork already. The back catalog of UFO Classified is some of the best stuff in terms of, I mean, you're talking about like ufology on YouTube now. No, no, no. You want to go on UFO Classified. You want to hear Erica interview these people. You don't want the teal capital investor interview some guy

SPEAKER_01for the umpteenth time. Erica's actually done a decent interview of him, you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you. I appreciate that. It really is fun to have, I mean, just like with Jack's blog, just to have that like out there for people to see and then to see the process of me being somebody who believed or put merit into stories that I learned over the years and very publicly. Okay, maybe we need to ask some questions and Use the critical thinking skills and see kind of the behind the scenes schemes taking place and things. And so it's, you know, I'm glad that you've have enjoyed it. And that means a lot to me.

SPEAKER_00Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Well, I, I should say you're a great interviewer. In fact, I, every time I do a podcast, I'm a little nervous, even though this is a very casual podcast, because I mean, I think of people like you and you're a great interviewer of all of these people. And, uh, You never seem nervous. How do you manage that?

SPEAKER_00You know, I would say it's probably 25 years of like singing or performing. And I never, there wasn't a time that I, you know, didn't get nervous and things. I still, I still get nervous, but I just, I love talking to people. It's so much fun as Jack knows, because sometimes he gets on the phone with me and it's like, well, Two hours later, you know, because I love hearing people's stories. And so I think when you can just make people feel comfortable and not like you're going to be pouncing on them at every second,

SPEAKER_00you can have a wonderful conversation and then maybe get more out of them than, you know, if you were harsh on the spot, Johnny on the spot kind of person.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's sort of what I try to go for. I, for instance, love it when a guest talks a lot, because then I can just sit back and think, oh, they're doing so good. I hope I'm doing that good.

SPEAKER_00You are. And I think that's great. I think a lot of hosts don't do that enough. Just let people get people to feel comfortable and then You know, give them a place to talk and you never know where it's going to go. And that's why for me with UFO Classified, I've never like really followed like a set kind of a script. It's always like I'm just going to take this organically and see where it goes. And sometimes it goes really interesting places. But I think you do a great job.

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you. I realize it sounds like I'm fishing for compliments, but-

SPEAKER_00No, no. I mean, I wouldn't say that. I would just completely avoid the topic if I didn't mean that.

SPEAKER_02I'm a big UFO classified fan too. In fact, Erica had invited me to be on and we'd done a show or two, But then the way EFR really started was during COVID, it was just on my Friday schedule. And every Friday I was watching and I'd take notes of stuff to do FOIA requests on.

SPEAKER_02Because like you say, she'd have really interesting guests that had all of these crazy things to talk about and interesting things to talk about. And then when I started getting returns, I'd be contacting her and going, hey, remember when so-and-so said, I got a request and blah, blah, blah. Do you want to take a look at it? And she'd be like, well, what do you think? Of course I want to look at it. And that's kind of how it started.

SPEAKER_02I would be listening to UFO Classified just taking notes on Like, oh, no, he didn't just say that. Yeah, he did.

SPEAKER_01And so, all right, you know. You know, that's crazy. I knew you guys were friends, but I would have had no idea that was the origin story of EFR. That's a really beautiful origin story, Jack.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, about, I guess, 10 years ago, maybe more, she first reached out and just wanted to chat. I was aware of her and she had seen my blog and our research interests were kind of going in the same direction. And then, yeah, we, you know, she had me on a couple of times. But yeah, during COVID, every Friday night, it was Erica at seven and Tim Banal at nine.

SPEAKER_02And that was my Friday night. And yeah, I would take notes about FOIA requests. And yeah, then eventually I said, you know, hey, I think, you know, if you ever want to talk about a nonprofit, I can, you know, answer any questions you have. Because I think with your archives and stuff, that might be something interesting and She thought about it a little and then was like, yeah, what are the questions?

SPEAKER_02And obviously we decided to proceed.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was fun. I mean, I was always like, I mean, Jack, you know, back in the day, you know, when I was kind of bopping around and, oh, I might believe this. I need to fill this person out and da-da-da-da-da. Like he was like, Jack Brewer, dun-dun-dun. Like I was... Like, I mean, he was, that was the true test. Like, okay, is this going to pass the muster, you know, there? And so I, it's been a fun journey to get to know him over the years.

SPEAKER_00And yeah, it's just, it's been very, it's fun. And like I said, this is like one of the Obviously, there was a dark period in my life. And COVID was dark for a lot of people, too. So that was a great joy to have those connections and just to reach out to people. And I don't know. I love that.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think you two have made a really great organization. Yeah. Just in terms of the variety of things you're doing, it's like a self-sustained ecosystem of interesting and well-sourced UFO stuff. I was going to ask you a bit about the archival aspects of it. What do you see as the value in archiving this kind of material? It's become more in vogue, but it used to be that people did not...

SPEAKER_01This was considered like detritus. You know, it's like the stuff you'd throw in the pulping machine so you could get some recycled paper. And nowadays it's becoming more in vogue. But why do you see this as important?

SPEAKER_00For me personally, having had some behind the scenes, lots of behind the scenes conversations and watching, you know, different holdings, people's research, getting kind of swept up and pushed into different locations where there might be a question of access or there might be Potentially a motivation to just look for UFO stories and not to be really forthright with the correspondence

SPEAKER_00or what was driving a particular researcher. I think that for me, that is the importance of having the holdings that we do and putting out that information without bias and without trying to... To train a whole group of young people that UFOs are real and use your critical thinking skills. Here's why they're real. For me, it's like preserving that. Preserving somebody's lifelong body of work is really special.

SPEAKER_00I think with Jack and the FOIA requests, that's something that is so valuable for other people. Not only researching... This, like looking for UFOs, but I mean, understanding the human element, like you were mentioning, Tanner, like looking at the psychological aspects of things, like looking at the sociological aspects of things and really looking at from the intelligence, you know, community, their activities. I mean, there's so many areas that are very, just incredibly fascinating.

SPEAKER_00And so that's why I think EFR is important in that regard.

SPEAKER_02I would add to that that something Erica often talks about is the value of the correspondence between researchers and two researchers and how they replied to some of the things that are preserved. We did an article, for instance, on the EFR blog about a letter that Erica has there in Salt Lake City That Betty Hill wrote to, I believe, Ann Druffle.

SPEAKER_02The gist of it is Betty's calling out UFO hypnotists. And she gives some specific reasons why that's the case. And something she's observed herself that was real out of line that a UFO hypnotist did that was clearly... Really attached to getting a UFO abduction out of the research subject. And that kind of stuff's really important to preserve, I think.

SPEAKER_02We can see their statements on YouTube or get just a photo shot, like a snapshot of how they might have felt about any given topic. But like the stuff that you and Emily shared with me that you got from the archives in West Virginia, I mean, that goes a long way, a lot further than their paperbacks do of giving us insights

SPEAKER_02into people like Morris Jessup and Gray Barker and people like that. And I think that's real important. I also think it's important to Make available, like archiving is one thing, and then making available what we get in FOIA requests, such as the Ramtha files. I mean, those are thousands of pages

SPEAKER_02on police interactions with Ramtha followers that we've posted and made available at the EFR website. I think that this gives people insight that are considering getting involved, people that have gotten involved and are starting to have doubts. That's more of that turning that audience over thing that we've talked about. When you just hear people talk about love and light and that kind of thing,

SPEAKER_02you might think, why not? That sounds cool. We touched on earlier when the common denominator among different groups is anti-authority. Then you end up with everybody from the right-wingers to the yoga teachers in the same basket of being against the authority. And I think that Archives like the Rant the Files and things like that,

SPEAKER_02let people for themselves go look and see what happened to people that were following that lifestyle. Even if not that specific lineage of UFO and paranormal or occult circumstances channeling, they can at least get examples of of what happens with the prepper lifestyle, that she brought people out there and told them to take their money out of banks

SPEAKER_02and keep it in trailers and things like that, that was in a very depressed area where they got killed in some circumstances for their life savings that were just sitting in a double wide in the woods. And people need to know things like this, in my opinion.

SPEAKER_00You know, and too, also, like I think for me, especially with the holdings that we have here in Salt Lake, I have not only Ann's, but other researchers and people who've donated things over the many years. But like to see again going back to the personal correspondence to see like even with James McDonald and the NICAP group to hear the frustrations, to see different people stepping in not necessarily with James

SPEAKER_00but with other researchers that I have, Files for 50 years, you know, seeing that different people come in at specific points of time to try to insert a narrative. To try to get this researcher to go down the path like we've seen today. But I think that the fear that I have is now that things are, the Wild West or whatever we've got going on with internet and potential restrictions and things disappearing, it's important for me We need to have that paper

SPEAKER_01archive here. No, I 100 % agree with you.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's one of the concerning things about the medium is always changing. Yeah. And so I have all of the PDFs on the internet and I also keep them on a hard drive. But neither one of those are etched in stone. You always have to just back up and keep backing up and keep backing up.

SPEAKER_02But another point while I'm thinking about it of that archive material, you know, we touched on the Hill case earlier, and that's a great example. That has been embellished so much by so many researchers and people that It's really important to be able to go find those first reports written within days, the interviews with the Hills by NICAP,

SPEAKER_02within days of interacting with them, and seeing how much it changed by the time they were interacting with Simon a couple years later, and then how much more was added to it by the time Stan Friedman decided that he needed to tell it, that If that's not archived and saved somewhere, then the earliest tellings of the story become what Bill Moore

SPEAKER_02and Stan Friedman write about something 20 and 30 years after the fact.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I just encountered that recently because I was looking for something on Carl Allen. God forbid I look into Carlos Allende. That was something interesting out of the Barker archive, actually, is just these pages upon pages of Carlos Allende sending Gray Barker, here's my passport, here's my birth certificate, here's my social security card. It's like, what are you doing, man?

SPEAKER_01But where was I going? I completely lost my train of thought. That gives you insight. This is what Carlos Allende did to everybody who encountered him, really, is just my train of thought is gone. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00We were going there with you, though.

SPEAKER_01I had encountered, did either of you know the UFO researcher, Rich Reynolds? He was a little older. Yeah, I think both of us did, Jack. Yeah, I was familiar with him, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And I think he knew he was going to pass away because he sent me all of his correspondence with Bosco Metalkovic.

SPEAKER_00Wonderful.

SPEAKER_01Recently. And I was actually going to ask you two for tips because I really want to digitize it primarily for his family. But the university nearest to me, their archival scanning document, Room essentially is under renovations, so I haven't been able to use it. I don't even know if I can use it as an unaffiliated researcher, but I was going to ask you guys if you had any tips on that.

SPEAKER_00You know what? That's a really great question. And I think for us, we are, you know, I mean, trying to upgrade the equipment here and, and do a lot of it here, which I've done over the years, but it's, it's, you know, you also have different, you know, you've got, you know, VHS and you've got cassette tapes and all sorts of things, which hopefully you're not dealing with that. Luckily I'm dealing with all paper. Yeah, I mean, that is an interesting, a great idea to think about going there to do that if you could,

SPEAKER_00because that would just make things so much quicker to have that kind of a printer available.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it'll be an undertaking.

SPEAKER_00How many papers do you have?

SPEAKER_01Uh, so the, the interesting thing is it's letters and they're all in the original envelopes. Wow. So everything's folded. So I have to unfold everything, uh, make sure everything there's, Bosco Nuttalkovic would send just like news clippings and just, just a assortment of things to basically anybody he corresponded with, um, Rich Reynolds included. And, um, It'll take some work because there's like,

SPEAKER_01I think there's one in there that he just put in the whole like business edition of a newspaper into an envelope with a small note with it. But it's been an interesting thing to look through because they, I mean, you two will find this interesting. They don't talk about UFOs at all. Not once. And I think Bosco mentions it once

SPEAKER_01in passing as something that Rich is interested in, but he really doesn't take any interest in it. And I find that odd, right? So I don't know. I'm still working through that. Weird, weird allegation, I guess we'll call it.

SPEAKER_00That's going to be wonderful. And I mean, just like I know with the things that I have here, like some of the papers are, I mean, 50, 60, you know, years old and taking staples out or taking paper clips off and making sure that even like with the print, because we got, you know, there are a lot of articles from different publications that are, you know, that 70 years old that are so fragile and then getting that out, unfolding them. Getting them put in a place where obviously you don't have sunlight and moisture

SPEAKER_00and just a lot of things to think about. But I'm really excited for you. That's cool.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thank you. I might just send them to you guys since you have like a functioning archive and they're just sitting in a box on top of my bookshelf currently.

SPEAKER_00I love it though. Don't you just, aren't you intrigued? Even if they're not talking about UFOs, just to, what's going on here?

SPEAKER_01Well, no, there's a story in there that, because another thing I noticed is Bosco doesn't, he's not prone to telling whoppers, let's say. He doesn't, he will sometimes exaggerate, but he will certainly never make something up whole cloth. And that's true not only in the Rich Reynolds letters, but it's true in letters throughout other university collections across the country,

SPEAKER_01really, because he would write to anyone and everyone. The Washington Post called him a poor man's Buckminster Fuller is something I remember, sort of this like utopian visionary who's trying to get his vision out there. And it seems immensely unrelated to ufology, which I don't know. I'm still trying to square the circle a bit. But there's certainly a story in those letters.

SPEAKER_01But it's more the story of a visionary trying to get funding to see his vision through, as opposed to somebody who would just trick ufology for the heck of it.

SPEAKER_02And his story of, as relayed to Rich Reynolds, of being an interpreter on a crew that he believes was a CIA experiment on Vias Boas, that would have been like 59? What year would that be?

SPEAKER_011957.

SPEAKER_02Thank you.

SPEAKER_01So he was in Brazil at that time or around that time. He's sort of all over South America, really, which is, I mean, for an intelligence asset, that's not that uncommon. So it fits with his story that he'd sort of be moving all around. Yeah, I think there's certain aspects of his history Statements to Rich Reynolds that simply just don't track.

SPEAKER_01But there's others that kind of make you scratch your chin a little bit.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, there are interesting aspects of it. Like, why would he do this even? Like, if it weren't true, even. True or not, whether he believes it or he doesn't, whether it's a whole cloth, hopes or not, what the point would be, is interesting from a lot of perspectives and justifies further research

SPEAKER_02without being accused of being a conspiracy-mongering researcher. Just kind of... Kind of, you know, just here or there kind of thing. It's been said that if an agency is distributing funds from the United States government as aid to other governments, well,

SPEAKER_02then that is an intelligence operation in some way, shape or form. You can kind of count on that. And I bring that up because you'll recall, and listeners may recall, that in the NICAP story, as you aptly pointed out in your Hill article recently, that the Economic Cooperation Administration

SPEAKER_02that was a covert arm of the CIA was Per a Roscoe Hillencoder letter and collected intelligence for the CIA was absorbed into a international aid organization that was then Absorbed into UCEDD that Bosco worked for. So that's kind of an odd connection there

SPEAKER_02with council services and the ECA, the Economic Cooperation Administration, and Roscoe Hillencoder and the whole UFO gang that it's always one tight-knit little family there, you know?

SPEAKER_01Well, correct me if I'm wrong. And I want to say to the listeners, everybody needs to go read Wayward Sons, NICAP, and DIC. It's a tremendously useful book. Excellently written. Jack, you're the only person who goes at NICAP with the fine-tooth comb that's really needed. Because, like, I mean, you even talk about it in the book a little bit. UFOs. Interested people will even be like, oh, NICAP was destroyed by the CIA.

SPEAKER_01And you find, oh, no, it's so much more interesting than that, actually. But was Nicholas de Rochefort also in South America at some point? Or was he stationed other places?

SPEAKER_02I don't know that he was in South America personally. His field of expertise seems to have been the Far East and China.

SPEAKER_01Was he in the ECA?

SPEAKER_02No. He was a State Department man, almost certainly a CIA asset. May have been in the ECA that I have not verified, but But he was officially a State Department man and cleared by the FBI to work in the State Department. While NICAP archives let us know

SPEAKER_02that he was literally in the NICAP offices. Yeah. Working on drumming up support and Those great statements that we see all the spooks making about UFOs and whatnot.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Didn't you ever feel ashamed of being a conspiracy monger like this?

SPEAKER_02That is interesting that people that think the government is actively hiding An alien presence over multiple generations. They had to do this from generation to generation. And as the Secretary of Defense hands it off to the next one, they say, and shush about those aliens.

SPEAKER_02And everybody just keeps doing it. That then, I might be accused of being a conspiracy theorist because I point out that I obtained a letter that says Roscoe Hillencoder was getting intelligence from the ECA. I got to say, too, that there's a lot of topics we've talked

SPEAKER_02about tonight UFO interested people seem amazingly not to be curious about and don't want to know about these different agencies, these different organizations. That like if someone like me can read a book and understand that How the memory can be affected by traumatic events and how

SPEAKER_02that might it literally might freeze parts of the brain from developing at certain ages and cause you to have confused memories about who perpetrators were and timelines of events. Like a familiarity with that would be like a veteran that is traumatized by firecrackers or a low flying plane, like that kind of inability,

SPEAKER_02like the trauma just overrides, untreated trauma can override that ability. If I can read a book and learn these things, How can Ivy League psychologists seem to be oblivious from that? Again, rhetorical question, but there are just an amazing amount of things about these connections between agencies and a lack of curiosity on the part

SPEAKER_02of UFO interested people as to why Intelligence agencies and certain academics would be so involved with each other and then have this apparent breakdown in critical thinking abilities when they're discussing UFOs.

SPEAKER_00I was going to say, it is interesting because we've all noticed the importance of understanding what people are doing in academic institutions or government organizations. But I'm just thinking about looking at Dr. Frank Salisbury's work, which is up at the University of Utah, Special Collections at the Marriott Library. And I mean, I genuinely... That he was down with all the UFO stuff.

SPEAKER_00Even though, I mean, he was like literally, you know, just a God-fearing Mormon man. He was involved with NASA and was involved with Russian scientists and different things. But like looking at his start and he was involved with the National Enquirer, you know, the board, the blue ribbon panel and things like that. But to go through what, you know, all of his personal letters and You know, kind of journal entries. I mean, I really, that guy definitely was all in on the UFO thing.

SPEAKER_00And so it is very interesting. Not that he was towards the end, I think, but it's just, it's fascinating.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it is. And there's definitely some sincere belief. There's no doubt about that. Like we were discussing earlier, that that's how you end up with your people that are well educated and in positions of authority that Associate it with a religious experience or a personal experience and then end up with a dog in the hunt of validating the whole topic, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, it's just, again, there's so many fascinating aspects to all of this. And to your point, Jack, it's funny to see how people are so limited in their scope of wanting to understand all of the layers to this subject.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, it is. I think a lot of it comes to from a lack of interest in the intelligence community, which leads to a lack of understanding of the intelligence community. And I don't necessarily fault people for that, that are living their regular civilian lives. They have careers. They're raising children. They're living their lives.

SPEAKER_02And they want to learn about what might be flying around in the sky so they don't feel like spending 20 years studying the intelligence community and reading dense books about how it operates. I understand that. But it matters. It really does. It matters to know what you might be looking at

SPEAKER_02It's important to understand. During the discussion of Wayward Sons, we came across on the video series that Edward Condon, who had done the infamous study on UFOs at the University of Colorado, Solicited Russian scientists to help with that study.

SPEAKER_02Now, when I saw that, I immediately thought he might have been... Like, my first suspicion was acting on behalf of the FBI. Or if he wasn't acting on behalf of the FBI... The FBI is going to red flag that and want to know who he's interacting with and what's happening. And they're going to get in that chain of communication. There's something to study here that Condon's reaching out to the Russians.

SPEAKER_02And I noticed the talk about it was more like, yeah, he didn't find nothing. They were a bunch of cranks. And I thought that's a UFO community that doesn't understand and doesn't care to understand the intelligence community.

SPEAKER_01Well, and I find it interesting, especially in recent years, that the authority that being in the intelligence community gives a person is highly welcomed. By the UFO community at present. And yet there's not much interest of what their day job is for the most part. I mean, I think they just picture that they're all Fox Mulder or something.

SPEAKER_01As much as I wanted that job when I was a kid, it doesn't exist.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, like, hi, I'm Jim Smith, Counterintelligence. Mind if I sit down?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So what do you want to leave the Getting Spooked audience with tonight? Is there anything of your work that they should go out and read immediately that I haven't? I mean, I've already linked a lot of stuff that I hope they went and read or watched already. But is there anything you want to draw their attention to?

SPEAKER_00Well, I just have to say, I mean, obviously, and thank you so much for the plug with EFR. I just can't believe that EFR has been in existence for as long as it has. What a trip. But to your audience, just... I love doing this. I love the connections we've made. And I know that Jack and I both know people in your audience. And so to me, having that, just this nice group of people who are using their brains and asking questions and delving deeper into the layers of this,

SPEAKER_00I think that's really great. And together, all of us can Can really kind of shine a spotlight on areas that have remained hidden for a long time and that can do great harm to people. And I don't know. I really appreciate being part of this community.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Erica. Folks can go to expandingfrontiersresearch.org. And from there, you can pretty much find our stuff. There's News about what we do. There's a blog. There's a couple pages of videos that we've made. A couple sections of many videos we've made since we started.

SPEAKER_02We're on YouTube. You can find us there. You can find us on Blue Sky. Follow Expanding Frontiers Research on Blue Sky. You can find in that stuff a lot of topics you might be interested in, ranging from the intelligence community to social issues, all kinds of issues, including UFOs is in there too.

SPEAKER_02And we love, love, love our Patreon followers at The EFR Patreon, you can follow and support our work, which helps financially with our FOIA fees and operating the organization. It all goes towards that. So that's very helpful. And you can browse all kinds of stuff on the Patreon as well.

SPEAKER_02Collections of videos, articles, a lot of it from the FOIA requests that we've submitted and the replies we get. So you can access all of that online. And if there's anything that sticks out to you, please let us know.

SPEAKER_01Thank you both for the work you've done. I know I'm on the Patreon, as I said earlier. Every time that notification comes in, I'm like, oh, they found something good. So I would recommend everybody check it out. And thank you both again.

SPEAKER_02Thank you.

SPEAKER_01This has been a long time in the works. I'm sorry it took me so long.

SPEAKER_00No, you know what? I'm just happy to... Have this conversation tonight. And I think, you know, I know I could talk to you for forever. Like, I mean, you are just so, you know, so much and you've done so many great, you know, things with research. And I've really had a blast and I can't wait to do it again. So we'll make it happen.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. Everybody who appears on the Getting Spooked podcast is always welcome back. I haven't had anybody that I've excommunicated yet.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for having us.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. And happy holidays, everybody. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. [#37] Gnome 12: Selling Dowsing Rods Door-to-Door

    Nov 4, 20266 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit tannerfboyle.substack.com Where twice there was three, now there are four: A full house of Gnomechat participants reunites to discuss political developments,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. [#36] Mystifying Marian Apparitions & More w/ Martin Cannon

    Oct 19, 20262 hr 10 minAudio

    Today, researcher extraordinaire Martin Cannon joins the program to discuss his new book, Mysterialis, and reveal the complexities behind one of the most understudied examples of Fortean phenomena: Marian apparitions...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. [#35] Gnome 11: Investigate Gnome Eleven

    Sep 11, 20261 hr 53 minAudio

    Come one, come all: The gnomechat is back, though the group is playing duck duck goose with the attendance. Bradley unleashes a very strange woodland story that baffles Emily and Tanner, we discuss some random...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. [#34] Scrutinizing Soldiers of Fortune and Adventurism w/ Bo & Reid

    Sep 1, 20263 hrAudio

    As these fringe subject repeatedly intersect, friend of the show and independent research Bo (not Bo Gritz) has volunteered to share his findings on the history of Soldier of Fortune magazine, a publication run by a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. [#33] SQUONK TALK 1: Cryptid lore, UFOs and Religion, Conspiracy Chatter, Manson, Mirage Men and More (CU Crossover)

    Aug 21, 20261 hr 39 minAudio

    Consensus Unreality has hundreds of other great episodes at https://consensusunreality.podbean.com/, including some with Timothy Grieve-Carlson...

    Credit the people on this episode