Children falling behind. Teacher shortages. Classroom disruption. Questions over what our kids are learning, and whether the system is giving every child the chance to succeed. Education is one of the few issues where the consequences of political decisions can last a lifetime. Are our children learning enough? Are schools getting the support they need? Is the curriculum working? And are we doing enough for the children who are falling behind? This week on The Front Page, we're asking the parties what they would change and how they plan to improve outcomes for New Zealand children. Follow The Front Page on iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. You can read more about this and other stories in the New Zealand Herald, online at nzherald.co.nz, or tune in to news bulletins across the NZME network. Host: Chelsea Daniels Editor/Producer: Richard Martin Producer: Jane Yee
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Kia ora, I'm Chelsea Daniels and this is The Front Page, a daily podcast presented by the New Zealand Herald. Each week up until Election Day on November 7, we'll be taking you through each party's policies on issues.
Speaker 2That matter to New Zealanders.
Speaker 1Children falling behind, teacher shortages, classroom disruption, questions over what our kids are learning and whether the system is giving every child the chance to succeed. Education is one of those few issues where the consequences of political decisions can last a lifetime. Are our children learning enough? Are schools getting the support they need? Is the curriculum working? And are we doing enough for the children who are falling behind? This week on The Front Page, we're asking the parties
Speaker 1what they would change and how they plan to improve.
Speaker 2Outcomes for New Zealand children.
Speaker 1We're joined by a Nationals Education spokesperson, Erica Stanford. Erica, what's the biggest problem in education right now, do you think?
Speaker 3Look, for many decades, we've had declining achievement. You know, if you look back over all of the international results or even our own results here at home, you've seen this gradual decline of achievement. And actually, when I became the Minister of Education, one of the first things that it said in the briefing to the incoming minister or the BIM document, as you all know it is, it said, the ministry said, we do not provide equitable or excellent outcomes. And I thought, well, that's a very confronting thing to
Speaker 3read as a new minister coming into the Ministry of Education that says, actually, we're not providing a very good education in New Zealand. And so, you know, it was my mission when I came in, this North Star of raising achievement and closing the equity gap. Because, you know, if you look back 20, 30 years, we used to achieve at the top of the world And ever since then, everything has slid backwards. And so I want to be able to restore what is a world-leading education back to New Zealand and have our kids achieving at a rate
Speaker 3that they deserve to be so that they can go on to live the life that they want and close that stubborn equity gap. For too long in New Zealand, if you are born into a family with means, then it's likely that you will succeed. And if you are not, it's likely that the stats will show that you won't. And so for me, the most important thing of raising achievement and closing that equity gap is equity across the system. And that's why you see stuff like an hour a day everywhere, a curriculum that is the same and consistent
Speaker 3across the sector everywhere. So no matter where your child goes to school, they walk into the same school that's got a quality, internationally benchmarked, year-by-year, knowledge-rich curriculum. teachers that are trained in the best teaching practices. They've got access to structured literacy. They've got access to workbooks for mathematics. And it's the same everywhere. And that's how you raise achievement. And you'll see the results have just started to turn, which is great.
Speaker 2Yeah, how has National addressed that in the last three years?
Speaker 1And I suppose, what work would you like to continue to do if you are re-elected?
Speaker 3When we were in opposition, I worked really hard to work out what were the key underlying drivers of of raising achievement.
Speaker 4And that's, you can look at.
Speaker 3Our six-point plan in education, which is underpinned by that quality curriculum, which is internationally benchmarked to the rest of the world that sets out what has to be taught every year, in what order, especially in things like mathematics. It's very sequential. And that was the first thing. The second thing was, what is best evidence-based teaching practice? Like, we used to teach children to read by looking at the picture and guessing the word. That is not evidence-based. That's what reading recovery was based on, and it did not work for our kids, hence why everything went backwards. So we've moved to mandate structured literacy across the system,
Speaker 3which at its heart is sounding out words using phonics, you know, cat, cat. But it's so much more than that. It is a structured, explicit way of teaching, writing, and spelling, and grammar all the way up to build those foundational skills. So there you've got the curriculum, the teaching practice, assessment practices, twice yearly assessments in reading, writing and maths from year three to year eight. We are one of the only countries in the world that don't do that to make sure we're tracking progress, reporting to parents early so they know when we need to intervene. And then the next
Speaker 3point on my six point plan is then the intervention, the learning support, intervening early, as early as we can, because if you leave it too late, It's really hard to make sure that you can accelerate progress, whereas if we can identify it early, we can put those things in place to make sure children are accelerating their learning. The next thing, of course, is investing in our teachers. We have trained more than 30,000 teachers in structured literacy, more than 22,000 teachers in structured mathematics, and consistent across
Speaker 3the board. And then the last point, of course, is using really good data and evidence because the ministry for too long has not had good data and evidence to be able to know where to put resource. And now we do.
Speaker 2And so what does the future look like?
Speaker 3Well, now that we've got our base in place, which is the primary school reforms, now we're looking to what does secondary look like? Because once we've got children coming through at curriculum, confident in their abilities, what can a revised national qualification that really sets them up for success look like? And it's unfortunately not NCDA, not a grab bag of credits. It is an internationally comparable national qualification based on a world-leading curriculum that's really going to give our kids some choices in life.
Speaker 4And I'm looking forward to that.
Speaker 2Thanks for joining us, Erica.
Speaker 3Thank you.
Speaker 1And now we're joined by Labour's education spokesperson, Jenny Anderson. Jenny, what does Labour want to do to improve our education system here in New Zealand?
Speaker 2Well, Kia ora.
Speaker 5Thank you for having me on. I think the biggest improvement we can make going forward is to really depoliticise education. We have seen a huge increase in blaming others for academic results and not really focusing on the best outcomes for our children. The Labour would like to see a move away from putting politics in education, getting some stability in the sector. And we see the best way of doing this is creating an independent council for curriculum and assessment,
Speaker 5which would mean there's some distance between the beehive and how education curriculum are developed.
Speaker 1And so who would be in charge of creating the curriculum then?
Speaker 5So the idea was picked up by New Zealand Principals Federation, and they've looked overseas, and Ireland has a similar model. So there would be an interim model with representatives from early childhood, primary, secondary, Māori medium, and there would be a group of people who are professionals, who are educational professionals making those decisions, not politicians making those decisions. And while they give advice to the minister, that process is transparent in terms of what advice they give us.
Speaker 1Because there's a lot of curriculum changes at the moment. So would that all be placed on pause?
Speaker 5So we've said if schools are ready to go with the curriculum, some are and some aren't. But basically, there's been a massive rush over the past two years. Someone just actually told me today, a teacher said that Australia took well over a decade for their curriculum to be changed and we've done that in two years. So the pace of change is just unsustainable for schools, for parents, for teachers. So we would say we want the independent council for curriculum and assessment to be able to take
Speaker 5a good look at what's been going on and come back pretty quickly. here in order to have some stability and take the heat out of education.
Speaker 1And I suppose one thing that's on top of a lot of parents' minds right now is NCEA.
Speaker 2That is right.
Speaker 5So we actually had bipartisan agreement. This was one of the things that when Labour was last in government, we agreed with National that they needed some changes to NCEA. And before those changes were even implemented to address some of the issues, that was all thrown out. So we don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater. We think that needs to be strengthened. And we think that that independent curriculum and assessment unit can come back with how we strengthen NCEA. But one important point to make here is that everyone I speak to in the
Speaker 5education sector says that you need the curriculum in place first and then put the assessment first. And so what we've had under national is half the curriculum or even less than half out the gate, the assessment dropped and now the curriculum is still being rolled out. So the level of uncertainty and the amount of rapid change without it being able to bed in has not helped our young people being able to learn.
Speaker 1And one thing that I just wanted to touch on as well, 10% cut to eligible student loan balances.
Speaker 2That's for tertiary education, obviously. Can you speak on that?
Speaker 5Yeah, we think this is a really good incentive to enable young people to want to stay here in New Zealand. We know that student debt is a big problem for young people and we want to be able to provide a bit of hope for those New Zealanders who are studying that they can still stay here and get ahead.
Speaker 2Thanks for joining us, Jenny.
Speaker 6Thank you.
Speaker 5That was great.
Speaker 1Now we're joined by ACT Party leader David Seymour. David, how would ACT fix education in New Zealand?
Speaker 7Well, the number one issue is making sure that children actually attend, because you can run the best education system in the world, but if 60% of children don't regularly show up, which was the case in 2022, then there's not a lot of value in running the system because the children aren't there. I'm proud as the Minister responsible for school attendance that there are now 200,000 more children regularly attending than where I started. We're up from 40% regular attendance to about 68% regular attendance. That's still not high enough, by the way. I want to see it
Speaker 7get to 80% of kids regularly attending. But we've made massive progress over the last three years. The second thing is let's acknowledge that the government's done a lot of good stuff. We've got the curriculum boosted. We've got one classroom with one teacher teaching a knowledge-based curriculum, not You know, three classrooms joined together with three teachers, 100 kids, lots of beanbags and just see what happened. We've actually got a transfer of knowledge from one generation to the next. And we've actually decided that, you know, the teacher should be in charge of the classroom, but we need to
Speaker 7go further. One of the biggest challenges we have is poor classroom discipline and bullying. We have some of the most disruptive classrooms in the developed world. That's not fair on the teacher or on all the other children trying to learn. Teachers should have the power to evict a child from the classroom, send them to a place from the school where there are consequences. And if they don't reform their behavior, there's a mandatory meeting with the parents. And if the parents aren't prepared to back the school, there should be a penalty for the parents. We've got to get communities backing teachers to control classrooms or we
Speaker 7all lose. We also need to give new choices. I'm proud of what we've done. We've got 20 charter schools now, 2,000 children. They are forecast to go from 2,000 children right now to 5,000 or 6,000 by the end of next year. This is because there's so many children out there that education hasn't worked for them. And we need to ensure that there are choices out there that show education can be different And you see the self-esteem that's been built by these children who say, I thought I was dumb. Now I get it. That is the most touching thing I've done in politics.
Speaker 2And what about school uniforms? Are they too expensive at the moment?
Speaker 7Yeah, they are. There's a lot of parents who just dread school uniform costs. It's so expensive if you have to have to bring your own device in your stationery in a school camp. But one area where we can make it more affordable is to say, look, hang on a second. Yes, a school has pride and identity and a school can require up to three branded items. But when a school requires that you've got to have a very specific type of sock that is suspiciously expensive, people just say, what's the point of all this? We're here for education. So we say, look, everything else other than
Speaker 7a maximum of three branded items. have to be available generic. You can say black shorts. You know, I went to an intermediate, a DSI one intermediate, you had to have black shorts. But there's a lot of places you can get black shorts and they're very affordable.
Speaker 2Thanks for joining us, David.
Speaker 7Hey, thank you very much, Chelsea.
Speaker 3Pleasure.
Speaker 1We're joined by Green Party spokesperson, Laurence Junan. Laurence, what would you, or what would the Greens, like to change to our education system?
Speaker 6Fundamentally, Education is a universal human right. It is not a commodity. So the Green Party's base position has always been a quality public education system. And education should be about curiosity, about confidence, about creativity, about being proud to be in the system and being flexible enough to deal with the challenges we're seeing in the 21st century. It should not be a one-size-fits-all approach that we're seeing with
Speaker 6the current government. It should also not come from any minister who may not have a background in this area and not listening to the voices of our sector. So when it comes to the Green Party, well-resourced quality public education system from ECE all the way up into secondary and even tertiary is absolutely crucial. And it also means that we need to be able to trust the sector itself to know what's best for our children. So that's
Speaker 6kind of the core aspect. And of course, we have more details within that as well.
Speaker 1In terms of the NCA, would the Greens kind of put a halt to changing that?
Speaker 8Absolutely.
Speaker 6And in the most recent, I guess, exposure of the survey result we've seen, we're seeing about 80% of the people didn't actually want to scrap NCA. NCA can always be improved. Any qualification can always be improved. But I want to say specifically that we already have a world leading education system through our NCA qualification. We see our students going to some of the top universities in the world. It is an internationally accredited and benchmark qualification. And anyone
Speaker 6who says otherwise is not frankly not telling the truth to the New Zealand public. So there are things that we can do, but we have also seen records that when it comes to change of qualification, you want to make sure that qualification is available and is what's best for all of our students. And in the Ministry of Education's own research, we have seen that students who are struggling before under the old school cert, which is what this government is trying to reintroduce, will also suffer under the new system they are proposing. That is your Mali students, Pacifica students, disabled and rainbow students. So when we are
Speaker 6deciding any sort of changes, we need to really consider who are we really serving with this new system. Are we serving the masses or serving only those really well-sorted, wealthy schools in Tameka Makaurau, Auckland?
Speaker 2And you mentioned fees-free.
Speaker 1Obviously, that's no more. What would the Greens do for tertiary students?
Speaker 6So when it comes to tertiary students, again, fundamentally education is a universal right. So poverty should not be a right of passage for our tertiary students. And Fees Free has always been not so much about admissions and completions, but about having a reduction in debt for our students. So that way students can go into the workforce without having all of that debt. So, we are working towards reintroducing a form of fees-free, but also in terms of
Speaker 6paid placement for tertiary students for roles such as doctors, for nurses, for midwives, for teachers, any degrees that actually have a paid placement attached to it. Because again, if you are in the defense force, you get paid. If you're in the police, you get paid. If you're in apprenticeship, you get paid. But yet, we don't do that for these particular roles with paid placement. That is something that we're introducing pay placement at living wage. One of the really important aspects and one of the things I'm really proud of the Green Party's policy around is our position
Speaker 6with ECE because, again, we believe that we need to have a quality public early childhood education system. That's what ECE stands for, early childhood education. And with that, what we're hearing is how much parents are paying and the lack of transparency when it comes to fees for ECE.
Speaker 8We've heard of parents.
Speaker 6in terms of the private EC sector paying up to beyond the 20 hours free up to $ 650 a week per child. We're seeing a lot of hidden fees such as a non-refundable $ 500 bond. We're seeing $ 5 per minute late fee if you're late to pick up your kids and parents being slapped with $ 100 additional cost. So one of the things that the Green Party is going to be pushing for really hard and going to be promoting really hard in this election is how we're looking at ensuring we have a quality public early childhood system and
Speaker 6bringing early childhood education and the importance of early childhood education into the fore when we're looking at any policy adjustments. Because, again, our young parents are doing it really tough right now. We want to ensure that there's a level of transparency, that they can trust that the child are being saved and they're getting the best out of the early childhood education, whether it's qualified teachers or fees transparency or ratios.
Speaker 2Thanks for joining us, Lawrence.
Speaker 6Thank you so much, Chelsea.
Speaker 8I really appreciate this.
Speaker 1We're now joined by New Zealand First's education spokesperson, Andy Foster. Andy, what would New Zealand First do to fix education in New Zealand?
Speaker 4I think the first thing to say is that education is something that's absolutely essential to our country's economic performance, our social performance. And so we do need to make sure that it is functioning really well. What we want to do is to make sure that all of our citizens are, you know, they get through the education process to be the best they possibly can be, to have, you know, high quality international citizens of the world who are able to think for themselves, who've got the master of the basics, but also able to fly in the areas that they want to be able to fly. And the thing that I've heard from right across the spectrum
Speaker 4is that every part of our education system.
Speaker 8It's getting criticised by the next step.
Speaker 4So the ECE is getting criticised by primary, primary by secondary, secondary by tertiary or by employers. And employers are saying that, you know, we're not getting people who work really when they get through the tertiary or the secondary system. So we've got to be clear about what it is that we want from each part of the system. And some of those bits of the system we need to provide some significant extra help for. I think when we started the conversation, you said, you know, what are you going to do to fix education? And that says that it's
Speaker 4not working as we want it to work. And we've been on a long-term downward trajectory. It's started to tick back up again. With the changes that have been made, particularly in the compulsory sector, and that's a good thing. We've also seen post-COVID the huge drop off in attendance. And again, a lot of work gone in under this government to try and start turning that around because the education system doesn't work when you're not actually there. So those things, we're starting to turn those around. An area which I did particularly... want to focus on is to say, well,
Speaker 4if you start at the beginning, we think that the.
Speaker 8The new parents need a bit more help.
Speaker 4So we want to put a bit more resource into supporting the likes of Plunkett and Barnardo's and so on. When you've got a young child, a new baby, how do I operate this thing? How do I look after it? So that's important. And then when you go to ECE, ECE has got to be much more than a babysitting operation, allowing parents to go back to work. We've got to get the ratios right. We've got to get the expectations right of what we want. from the ECE system because so often I hear from the primary sector, they're saying, look, we've got these young people. Some of them, some of
Speaker 4these five-year-olds come and they're ready, they're fired up, they're ready for school. Others aren't. And so we need to make sure that we lift the performance there in that part of the sector.
Speaker 8And part of that is better ratios. It's having a higher proportion.
Speaker 4Don't agree with all ECE teachers having to be ECE trained because there are some great people who haven't gone through the formal training, but we do need to have a higher proportion. And then when you get to the compulsory sector, we do believe in the focus on the basics of the reading, writing, arithmetic, science.
Speaker 8Those things are absolutely critical.
Speaker 4But we also say that once you've got the mastery of those things at any given level, we should be allowing our young people to be able to explore, to be creative, to be able to fly in the areas that the things.
Speaker 8That turn them on, to switch their lights on.
Speaker 4When we get through to the area where we're getting into the 12s, 13s, year 11, 12 and 13, I think it's great that we're now introducing the ISB courses. So these are the industry skills training courses. So there's the connection between school and business. post-school is really important because, again, you hear a lot of stories of young people for whom the academic pathway.
Speaker 8Just didn't work, is not working.
Speaker 4And if you can give them a pathway, maybe it's exposure to different employment opportunities, to different employment experiences, to different courses. As I said, there's a very exciting range of courses being developed with industry for year 12 and 13, and there are requests to bring some of it down to year 11. The lights go on. And that's what we want. We want our young people being excited by the opportunity to learn, to grow and to develop. And
Speaker 4then if I take it one step further into the post-secondary sector. So whether that is vocational or academic through universities, etc. We do believe that we need to be more supportive there of particularly things like where you are learning and working at the same time. So Apprenticeship Boost, which was brought in with New Zealand First, got halved by the labour operating alone.
Speaker 8It was originally $ 1, 000 per month for two years.
Speaker 4Labour halved it, and then the coalition government has put funding in because there was no funding left, but it's halved it again. And what's clear from many employers is that that is just not enough to take on an apprentice because it's costly to take on an apprentice. So we need to raise that back up again because we've got real– Aging issues within many of our workforces, particularly in areas like aviation, the electrical industry, plumbing, and then the services like the medical areas as well. We're going
Speaker 4to need a lot more people coming into those as that aging workforce starts retiring.
Speaker 8So that's a good investment. So we want to do that.
Speaker 4We also think the paid placements are important too for those areas where we have people, again, who are working while training.
Speaker 8So you can think about nurses, social workers, teachers.
Speaker 4We've got 700 plus teachers a year going through with about $ 20, 000 each at the moment. We think that that kind of approach to paid placements is important for the likes of nursing and so on because the dropout rate at the moment is far, far too high.
Speaker 8It's sort of 25% to 30%. Now that's a huge waste.
Speaker 4For those people, but it's also a huge waste for the country that's put resources in to get them partway only to drop out because it's just too expensive. They've got to train away from home or do placements away from home, whatever it might be. So that's an important area. And the other one is just to make sure that we try and invest and prioritise those areas through the post-school, you know, whether it is the, whether it's the vocational process or the academic process in those areas where we actually have a really large demand for those sort of skills.
Speaker 4So we ought to prioritize that as well.
Speaker 2Thanks for joining us, Andy.
Speaker 8That's okay.
Speaker 1And now I'm joined by the Opportunity Party leader, Kule Wong. Kule, when it comes to education, what would the Opportunity Party change first?
Speaker 9On education, we think it's really important to have a long-term plan here. And similar to health, we would like to see a 10-year plan, ideally with cross-party support. When I've been getting around the country and talking to teachers, Many of them think that the current reforms are moving in the right direction. They're not opposed to some of the ideas, but it's happening far too fast. And they are exhausted from constant curriculum changes, changes in the way we do assessments, changes into the way we design our classrooms.
Speaker 9And if they are feeling exhausted and overwhelmed, then they can't put all of their effort into teaching our children. And so we need to be mindful of that and make sure that they are part of that process. there is always going to be some differences around what exactly should be in the curriculum. And for that, we are supportive of the Independent Curriculum and Assessment Council. This is an idea that's been proposed by the Principals' Federation and I think would help to depoliticise some of that decision-making and ensure more stability over a longer period of time.
Speaker 9So we'd really like to see that happen, as well as more independence restored to the Teaching Council, because it is really important that teachers in the profession understand feel like they have a substantial voice in the direction of our education system.
Speaker 2And so that review panel, what would that entail?
Speaker 9So the independent council would be responsible for overseeing the development and maintenance of our curriculum and assessment standards. We've proposed that they should make the final decision on whether NCEA should be scrapped, for example, or whether we should move to a new certification system. and that means that it's not up to the minister of the day. It brings some of that independence back, and it means that the profession feel like they have a voice and an independent voice that they can trust. And, you know, these changes aren't going to happen overnight, so they will make
Speaker 9sure that we can stick to that long-term direction.
Speaker 1Yeah, the education system seems like one area in particular where there's some really good examples of things chopping and changing every three.
Speaker 2Years, hey?
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 9I mean, yeah, how much time was spent putting walls up back into classrooms because we decided to change that design and it's just a distraction that we don't need. In the meantime, we've seen achievement levels and equity outcomes continue to fall. This is success of governments. It's no one failure of any specific government, but that chopping and changing clearly is not good for teachers. It's not good for children. It's stressful for parents. we do need to see some consistency and stability. And we need to focus
Speaker 9on the things, follow the evidence around what is going to achieve those two goals of lifting achievement and increasing equitable outcomes.
Speaker 1If a parent was kind of on the fence and they were thinking, well, my top ticket item is going to be education because I have a child, they're five years old, and then I've got another one in high school, they're 12.
Speaker 2I mean, what would you say to that parent? How would you quell their fears?
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 9I would say that the stability component and a good relationship between government and the profession is the critical thing here. And that's what we are advocating for. If we don't have that stability and a positive working relationship, then no matter who comes up with the solution, it's going to feel fraught if they're not working together on it. And that's what Opportunity is advocating for. And I think we are uniquely positioned to support that in our education system.
Speaker 1And finally, Te Pate Māori wants to build a Māori Education Authority and establish a Kohanga Reo Act and embed Matauranga Māori and Aotearoa history into the curriculum. This would ensure compulsory teaching of history, tikanga and te ao Māori and make Te Reo Māori a core curriculum subject from primary school up to year 10. They also want to extend the school lunches program to all kura and public schools, make public transport free to all students, including tertiary, fund
Speaker 1free counselling in schools, make mental wellbeing a core part of the school curriculum and write off the living cost component of all student loans. They promise to work towards full student loan write-offs for those who live and work in New Zealand for five years.
Speaker 2That's it for this episode of The Front Page.
Speaker 1You can read more about today's stories and extensive news coverage at nzherald.co.nz. The Front Page is hosted and produced by me, Chelsea Daniels. Kane Dickey is our studio operator, Richard Martin, our producer and editor, and our executive producer is Jane Yee.
Speaker 2Follow the front page on the iHeart
Speaker 1App or wherever you get your podcasts and join us next time for another look beyond the headlines.
We’re now in the final hours of the election campaign, and Christopher Luxon is fighting to secure a second term as Prime Minister. When National came to power, it promised to get the economy back on track, deliver tax...
We’re now in the final stretch of the election campaign, and Chris Hipkins is hoping to lead Labour back into Government. Labour has been campaigning with a focus on easing the cost of living, improving public services,...
The major parties are making their last pitch to voters, crisscrossing the country, trying to win over undecided Kiwis and convince them they deserve another three years in Government. But while the party leaders are...
There are some new Warrant of Fitness rules that could save Kiwis billions. The changes mean people who buy a new car will only need to get their next WOF after four years. Vehicles aged 4 to 14 will only need a WOF...
The Warehouse built its name on being the place where everyone gets a bargain. But with Kmart winning over shoppers and Temu competing for their dollars online, the red shed has struggled to keep its place in Kiwi...