Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Front

The Front artwork

The new anorexia: Gender despair and the puberty-blocker fight

Nov 18, 202611 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

As international health bodies in the UK and Europe tighten restrictions on youth gender medical care, Australia’s National Health and Medical Research Council has recommended allowing puberty blockers for under-18s based on evidence rated as low certainty. In this episode of The Front, Claire Harvey and The Australian’s NSW editor Stephen Rice examine why Australia is defying global trends, the sharp rise in gender despair among teenage girls, and the immense pressure placed on parents navigating these life-changing decisions. Read more about this story at theaustralian.com.au and see the video by subscribing to our YouTube channel. ‘Business as usual’ finding on puberty blockers just doesn’t cut it Landmark review supports blockers despite overseas bans Trans lobby’s campus culture revealed This episode of The Front is presented by Claire Harvey, produced by Jasper Leak and edited by Tiffany Dimmack. Our team includes Kristen Amiet, Lia Tsamoglou, Joshua Burton and Jasper Leak, who also composed our theme.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1From The Australian, here's what's on the front. I'm Claire Harvey. It's Thursday, November 19, 2026. A power move by one of Australia's richest women, Nicola Forrest, intervened in a sensitive situation at mining giant Fortescue, writing to the board, which includes her ex-husband, Andrew Forrest, over the case of a senior executive accused of harassing a female employee. That intriguing yarn is live now at theaustralian.com.au. It's one of the

Speaker 1toughest issues a parent could imagine. A distressed child talking about gender and wanting to stop the course of nature as puberty advances. This was already hugely controversial and now the government's health standards authority has weighed it in with advice that is at odds with global trends. So what's right for individual kids and what's right for our society? That's today's story. Stephen Rice is the Australian's New South

Speaker 1Wales editor and he's reporting on a new finding by Australia's Health Standards Watchdog. It's about whether puberty blockers should be available to people under 18. Ricey, the National Health and Medical Research Council is saying that puberty blockers can be considered... where a young person is suffering signs of gender incongruence, that is, they don't feel that they align with the gender that's on their birth certificate, if they and their caregivers agree that this is the right thing to do. This is at odds with trends that we've

Speaker 1seen in some other parts of the world, in the UK, for example. What is the difference between Australia's position now and, say, in the United Kingdom?

Speaker 2Well, I guess the main point out of this recommendation is is that it pretty much maintains the status quo. And most Australian jurisdictions already have what they call a gender-affirming approach to medical treatment. So in other words, if a child believes that they are other than the sex that they were born, that the medical profession will pretty much go along with that. And that's essentially what this report is recommending. I mean, the surprising thing, I guess,

Speaker 2about it is that it's doing so on a real paucity of actual evidence. There's a separate evaluation report that was put together by some academics from Monash University. And when you read into the fine detail of that, some of the most basic things that are purported to be a benefit of puberty blockers, like decreased risk of suicidality, fixing your gender dysphoria, improving quality of life, it's all

Speaker 2rated as low quality evidence.

Speaker 1Yeah, I was really struck in that evidence review about the very low quality or low reliability of evidence that they found about whether this course of treatment, puberty blockers, actually fixes anything. What it does certainly do, according to the evidence review, is reduce breast size, reduce penile length in boys, and mean that if you then subsequently have a mastectomy, As an adult, you have to remove less breast tissue than you would if your breasts were bigger.

Speaker 1I mean, there's a huge amount of confidence in this report too that the effects of puberty blockers are temporary. That word is used several times. However, I really wonder if reduced penile length and reduced breast size are temporary things. Are these things actually temporary or are you left with these consequences for life?

Speaker 2Yeah, well, I mean, again, when you read this evaluation report, they seem to have backtracked. They seem to retreat from this idea that the effect of puberty blockers is reversible. And I mean, that seems actually quite logical, doesn't it? How can you hold up a child's sexual development, their adolescent development for two or three years and and then stop that treatment and expect that during those critical years that nothing has happened. And the other thing, of course,

Speaker 2is that even on the basis of these figures, at least 80%, most figures go, 90% of children who take puberty blockers will go on to take cross-sex hormones. So there's no question that a lot of the effects of these drugs are irreversible.

Speaker 1What really struck me too was one point in the evidence evaluation report. It said in 2021, 7% of adolescents aged 14 to 18 reported that they were trans or gender diverse. Three years earlier in 2018, that was 2%. So it went from 2% to 7% in a very short period of time. Human beings have not changed in millennia, certainly not in three years. that says to me, this is a trend. This is a trend in adolescent mental health.

Speaker 1This is kids talking to each other and thinking, oh, yeah, maybe this is the answer for my general sense of distress.

Speaker 2And that's what's lacking from this report is any sense of context, is any sense of the revolution that is happening in terms of children reporting gender dysphoria. And in this report, there is just no context about how and why this is happening, why so many, in particular, so many girls, children born as girls during their teenage years are suddenly deciding that they were meant to be boys.

Speaker 2You cannot go past the fact that children are being very heavily influenced by social trends, particularly by social media, but by what their friends are doing at school. And we know how this kind of contagion can take off. We've seen it before with weight problems, you know, bulimia and anorexia. We've seen it with children wanting to take their lives or starting to cut themselves. These trends flare up and there's clear evidence that that's what we're seeing

Speaker 2now and that a lot of these children left with appropriate psychological care, will eventually just decide that they actually were born in the right sex, but they were going through a difficult period in terms of their sexuality. Maybe they become gay or lesbian, but there is not necessarily a problem that needs to be fixed by taking drugs or having surgery.

Speaker 1There's been a stunning rise in the imbalance, I think, between boys and girls here. So several years ago, it was mainly boys who were identified as people who wanted to change gender. Now it is overwhelmingly girls. I really wonder about that from the point of view of we know that teenage girls hate their bodies. That's, I think, partly behind that surge in anorexia that was massive when I was a kid. At the time, we were blaming magazine editors. Then we had a very brief moment of body positivity. maybe 10 years, where it was you are

Speaker 1perfect just as you are. Embrace your body just as it is. And we had this wonderful moment where teenage girls were enjoying their curves and their breasts. It is confronting to grow breasts and grow hips and suddenly turn into a woman. I wonder if we've lost something if we're failing to even think about this through that kind of body positivity or feminist notion.

Speaker 2And your heart goes out to parents who are trying to desperately, so desperately to pass that message on to their kids. And as you say, especially to their teenage girls. But surely the answer cannot always be to put these kids on a path of medicalization for the rest of their lives, because that's what you start with puberty blockers. You then go to cross-sex hormones. Maybe surgery, maybe not. But even the hormones, that's a lifelong commitment.

Speaker 1It'll put an extra degree of pressure on those parents too, won't it?

Speaker 2Huge.

Speaker 1As an individual parent, you can have nothing but empathy for parents who are trying to just keep their kids alive. And I think we would all make the right decision for our child, whatever that is. If you're confronted with a kid who's saying, I'm going to kill myself, you would do anything to keep them alive. But we also have to make decisions as a society. a comparison would be the mobile phone ban or the social media ban to give parents some ammunition to say, hey, it's against the law actually, or it's against the rules at your school, or it's against the state guidelines for your education department.

Speaker 1If we take that away from parents now in Australia and they can't say, listen, it's not recommended to have puberty blockers. Let's make this decision later. Let's let puberty happen. That makes it even tougher. It does.

Speaker 2But when you're trying to do it on the basis of medical evidence, which is rated as low certainty, sometimes very low certainty, as it is with these recommendations, you've really got to wonder if the certainty of the recommendation doesn't match the certainty of the evidence, where are we going with it?

Speaker 1The recommendation is that to wait until a child is distressed would be unethical. What did you think about that?

Speaker 2It seems to me that that's the crux of the problem, is that we are going down this route of medicalization before the problem arises. And this is not a case where preventative medicine, I think, is appropriate when there is such a lack of evidence, even by the standards that the National Medical Health and Research Council are putting forward, you know, to back up such drastic, life-changing medical treatments.

Speaker 1This is open for review until January 2027 before a formalised recommendation comes down. You can see where it's going though. Do you think there will now be an onslaught of opposing views presented to this committee so that it doesn't go this way?

Speaker 2Well, look, I think there will be an onslaught of opinions both ways. And I've got to say that looking at the way that this committee has come down so strongly in favour of puberty blockers, disregarding a lot of what they, you know, has found to be low certainty evidence, I honestly don't think that there is much likelihood that these recommendations are going to change.

Speaker 1Stephen, thank you very much.

Speaker 2Thank you.

Speaker 1On Thursday, Stephen Rice is breaking a big news story that the NHMRC advice is out of line with the current law, which says doctors can only prescribe puberty blockers if teens are diagnosed with a That means any doctor who follows the NHMRC recommendation would be breaking the law

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. GTA 6: The female gamers crushing moral panic about Grand Theft Auto

    Nov 20, 202613 minAudio

    Grand Theft Auto releases usually trigger giant moral panics about misogyny, violence and law-breaking. But GTA 6 seems to be different, with a generation of gamers who grew up with GTA now becoming society’s...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Lamarre-Condon ‘lied to jury’ about service weapon, prosecution says

    Nov 20, 20264 minAudio

    The Crown prosecution says former cop Beau Lamarre-Condon lied to the jury about access to the police-issued Glock he allegedly used to kill his ex-boyfriend. Brett Hatfield SC is delivering his closing argument in...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Should Pat Cummins be out as Test captain?

    Nov 19, 202615 minAudio

    A young man sacrificed to Australian cricket’s dishonesty and ruthlessness: that’s the claim of Cameron Bancroft, the batsman caught cheating with sandpaper back in 2018, in a 4000-word essay that brings captain Pat...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Prince Harry ‘would return to military’ if Russia conflict erupts

    Nov 19, 20263 minAudio

    Prince Harry says he would rejoin the British Army if a conflict with Russia erupted. Plus, Australia risks recession as unemployment jumps to a five-year high, and Cameron Bancroft tells his side of the ‘sandpapergate’...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Grand Theft Auto Six launch to shake the economy

    Nov 18, 20262 minAudio

    Today on The Front’s afternoon headlines: Grand Theft Auto Six is finally here, bringing massive hype and billions in pre-sales - we look at its cultural legacy and enduring appeal. Plus, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode