Automatically generated transcript. Not manually reviewed. Names, quotations, and speaker attribution may contain errors.
All right, today I am finally going to be shifting away from the concept of attacking libertarian free will in order to begin setting the stage for a more positive case for what I think the will is. We've spent the previous episodes setting the stage for a discussion on the problem of evil by exploring the human will.
Specifically, I've been dismantling the idea of libertarian free will that most people seem to hold to. I've been making a case against it based on a variety of lines of argumentation, but in today's episode, I'm going to be shifting from making a case against libertarian free will to making a case for what I think the will actually is. Now, I'm not going to claim that I can make an airtight case that is going to be satisfying for you in every dimension.
But I do think I can make a case that is far more explanatory than the libertarian case. So over the next few episodes, I want to fill out this case just a little bit by addressing some common misconceptions, and then offer up a positive case, a more definitive case for what I think the will actually is. In this episode, I want to begin by addressing a common misconception about libertarian alternatives.
Now, many are probably thinking to themselves, if libertarian free will doesn't exist, then what's the point of doing anything? My fate is already determined, and nothing I can do is going to change that. Now, let's not forget that on a libertarian perspective, what one does is random. We've seen that in a number of our episodes.
And were the world to rewind and play again, you may make a totally different choice and suffer rewards and punishments based on how that playthrough happened. Not because of anything different. You're not a different person who made the choice. You just so happened on a rewind, on that playthrough, to make a different choice. You just so happened. It was random, right? It's the roll of a dice. But if we get rid of libertarian free will...
Does any of that really change? Isn't something still just determined? Maybe not randomly or haphazardly? I think things do change, of course. And I think the distinction lies in conflating the concept of fatalism with compatibilism. Fatalism is a belief that no matter what you do, event X will occur.
So no matter what your motivation, your actions, your desires, event X is inevitable. It's going to come about, or you're going to perform action X. It's really the horseshoe opposite of libertarian free will, right? Sort of like if you've seen
The right and the left in politics really are essentially the same thing. They're kind of on a horseshoe as opposed to being on diametrically opposed ends. It's more of a horseshoe. They end up embracing authoritarians and all kinds of stuff. You can find if you just search up horseshoe politics or something. I don't know what it's called, but it's kind of the same thing here.
This idea that fatalism is the opposite end from libertarian free will is mistaken. It's really more of a horseshoe. It's the opposite in the sense that instead of utter randomness, regardless of the circumstances, it is utter determination of outcomes despite the circumstances. But that's the same thing. It's not really opposites, right?
Whereas the opposite would be more compatibilism. A more compatibilistic view of the will wouldn't argue that event X occurs despite the circumstances, but rather, event X occurs because of them.
Now, if you would change the actions and the circumstances, the outcome would change. It's not fatalism that the outcome is going to happen no matter what. And it's not randomness, which is that the outcome is going to happen randomly in an event. You might not know what the outcome is going to be, but the outcome will be determined by randomness.
Let me provide you with what I think is a really good example of this occurring, this more compatibilistic idea occurring in Acts 27. Now, I want to read the whole passage just so you can work through discerning the story as well, and in case you feel that I'm taking any liberties here. I want to make sure that you have the whole text in front of you. So here's the story from Acts, Acts 27, 13 through 38.
When a gentle south wind began to blow, they saw their opportunity, so they weighed anchor and sailed along the shore of Crete. Before very long, a wind of hurricane force, called the Northeaster, swept down from the island. The ship was caught by the storm and could not head into the wind, so he gave way to it and were driven along.
As we passed to the lee of a small island called Kauda, we were hardly able to make the lifeboat secure, so the men hoisted it aboard. Then they passed ropes under the ship itself to hold it together. Because they were afraid they would run aground on the sandbars of Sirtus, they lowered the sea anchor and let the ship be driven along. We took such a violent battering from the storm that the next day they began to throw the cargo overboard.
On the third day, they threw the ship's tackle overboard with their own hands. When neither sun nor stars appeared for many days and the storm continued raging, we finally gave up all hope of being saved. After they had gone a long time without food, Paul stood up before them and said,
Men, you should have taken my advice not to sail from Crete. Then you would have spared yourselves this damage and loss. But now I urge you to keep up your courage, because not one of you will be lost. Only the ship will be destroyed. Last night, an angel of the God of to whom I belong and whom I serve stood beside me and said, Do not be afraid, Paul. You must stand trial before Caesar, and God has graciously given you the lives of all who sail with you.
So keep up your courage, men, for I have faith in God that it will happen just as he told me. Nevertheless, we must run aground on some island. On the fourteenth night, we were still being driven across the Adriatic Sea, when about midnight the sailors sensed they were approaching land. They took soundings and found that the water was a hundred and twenty feet deep. A short time later, they took soundings again and found it was ninety feet deep.
Fearing that we would be dashed against the rocks, they dropped four anchors from the stern and prayed for daylight. In an attempt to escape from the ship, the sailors let the lifeboat down into the sea, pretending they were going to lower some anchors from the bow. Then Paul said to the centurion and the soldiers, Unless these men stay with the ship, you cannot be saved. So the soldiers cut the ropes that held the lifeboat and let it drift away.
Just before dawn, Paul urged them all to eat. For the last fourteen days, he said, you have been in constant suspense and have gone without food. You haven't eaten anything. Now I urge you to take some food. You need it to survive. Not one of you will lose a single hair from his head. After he said this, he took some bread and gave thanks to God in front of them all. Then he broke it and began to eat. They were all encouraged and ate some food themselves.
Altogether, there were 276 of us on board. When they had eaten as much as they wanted, they lightened the ship by throwing the grain into the sea. Now, the first thing I want to say here is that I don't at all think that this story is intended to speak to us specifically about how the will works. I'm just using this as an example of how we see the will playing out.
And second, I fully acknowledge that the writer of Acts probably did not provide us with every single detail of the trip or of Paul's conversation with the angel. I don't know what the angel said to him or if there was any nuance to what the angel said. But what I'm trying to draw out here isn't tied to any of that really. I'm simply providing a hypothetical example based on a historical event. Okay, so let's think about the story.
An angel came to Paul and says that everyone on the ship will be saved. God is granted that. It will happen. That seems like a determined outcome, right? It's going to happen no matter what, right? It's fate. Fate has determined this. And because God is always right, it will happen as the angel said. Great.
So, does that mean that after this message was received, the men on board could start dueling with each other? Like, hey, we're invincible. Why don't we have sword fights to the death, but we won't die, even if you stab me in the heart? Or anything else like that. Could they start drinking cyanide and none of them would die? Of course not.
In fact, later on, we see Paul exhorting the crew not to leave the ship or else they're going to die. And he doesn't just say that the people getting into the lifeboats are going to die. He tells the centurion, hey, if they get into the lifeboats, you can't be saved. Presumably, that means the condition of them being saved is that they stay on board, even though God determined that everybody's going to be saved. Graciously, all those lives are saved.
Lest they die? Like, what do you mean? I thought the outcome was determined. Yeah, but it wasn't determined independently from the circumstances or actions. We see something similar, Paul says, hey, unless, how does he say it? I urge you to take some food, you need it to survive. What do you mean I need it to survive? Like, God's granted me that I'm gonna live. Like, I could just not eat, and I will survive.
But no, like, yes, their survival was guaranteed. God said it was going to happen. It was going to happen. But it wasn't determined independently of the circumstances or actions. It was because Paul received that message from the angel, and because Paul relayed that message, that the crew had the confidence and the resolve to stay on the ship. They had already determined that it was best for them to go
...into a lifeboat, but when they heard Paul say, hey, don't get into that lifeboat because an angel gave me a message, and Paul had already told them not to set sail because of the storm that was coming, they're like, hmm, you know what? Paul's God seems like he kind of knows what he's talking about. He said not to leave and look what happened, and now he's telling us not to get into the lifeboat? Okay, you know what? We'll just not get in a lifeboat. We'll trust Paul here.
Because his God seems to be powerful. Whereas, had Paul just been some other random sailor, he was like, hey guys, I don't think you should get into lifeboats. They probably would have gotten into lifeboats because they determined that that's the wise thing to do. These sailors who know what the sea is like and what's going on.
So it was this message given by Paul, based on the circumstance of Paul having already been right about something, that made them say, you know what, we'll stay on the ship. Had God not given Paul that message through the angel, they probably would not have stayed on the ship. And it was their staying on ship, that circumstance, that particular action that they took, which led to the outcome of them being saved.
They weren't going to be saved no matter what. They were going to be saved if they stayed on that ship, and it was the message that God gave which provided them the confidence and faith to stay on that ship in order to be saved. The salvific action was taken because the message was proclaimed. If any of those steps were removed that we talked about, then salvation would either not have happened, or God would have enacted salvation by a different means.
Now, you know, it's very common for people to make a retort against Calvinists or those who don't believe in a libertarian free will, that they can't help but believe in libertarian will because God determined it, right? It's kind of a...
A really sarcastic comment like, oh, well, if you're right, Calvinist, and I'm a libertarian, then I can't help what I believe. I just believe it because God determined me to believe in libertarian free will. It's funny, but it's a snide remark that I think just doesn't show a quality understanding of the will.
Because that's not really a compatibleistic view at all. That's fatalism. That's saying, if the will isn't free in a libertarian sense, then your belief system is just fatalistically set in stone. You just will believe, no matter what, because that's just what God said you're going to believe. You jump from one end of the horseshoe to the other. You believe in a libertarian free will? Dice roll just so happened because of the dice.
You believe in fatalism? You just so happened because God determined that no matter what, that's what you were going to believe. It's one pendulum swing to the other. A compatibilist would say instead, you believe what you believe for a reason. A reason not tied to a dice roll or to God pulling your puppeteer strings, right? You're not a marionette.
Not at all. You believe what you believe for reasons. Reasons related to the relationships that you have, to the things that you are taught by people that you trust, to experiences you have, etc. Like, tons of different things. All these variables that you just can't even fathom all the different variables. So this isn't a random dice roll or the pull of a marionette strings.
Conversations, loving relationships with people who differ in their beliefs, and all kinds of stuff can come to change the shape of your beliefs and actions. Because your beliefs and actions aren't dice rolls or string pulls, they are rational. They're there for reasons. Neither a string nor a dice determines you, but rather your God-given human nature.
You are a rational being, and when you come to see truth, you are drawn to choose that which is true. You are a relational being, and when you come to experience love, you are drawn towards that which is loving. So as you, in relationship, come to see what you believe is truth and what you believe is love, your affinity for those things leads to a change in belief and action. It's not the determination of a puppeteer or a roulette wheel.
It's the action of a rational, relational creature embracing their true natures and purpose. Of course, we can be mistaken about what truth and love looks like. And that's the story of humanity, isn't it? Misguided loves and affections, as well as self-deceit and external deceit, along with human limitation and ignorance. But we pursue what we believe is in our best interest based on what we think is true and what we think is loving.
For some, that means pursuing that which they think will lead to their pleasure in the pursuit of loving self. For others, it may be what they think is true and good for the love of their family or community. And for the Christ follower, it will be what they believe is true and good for the love of God and all others, even enemies. We can be mistaken in our perceptions of what is true and what is love, but as human beings created in the image of God, we will choose what we believe is true and loving.
Does that mean if I know the exact information and experiences I can provide for you in order for you to see truth and to perceive love, that I can get you to a particular outcome? I mean, theoretically, I guess I'd have to say that this would be consistent on compatibilism, though due to our human limitation, I can't imagine that we could determine all outcomes and events to that extent. But if you think about how we see society or treat our children,
We act in a compatibilistic fashion. I mean, libertarians all the time are like, well, you act like libertarian free will is true because you hold people responsible and stuff. And here I'm saying, well, you all act like compatibilism is true, right? We don't rely on a dice roll or fate to explain things. We rely on reason and relationship. Why are there so many parenting books written on how to raise and disciple and discipline children?
Why are there so many leadership books written about the psychology of people and teamwork and how to relate to others and encourage them and build up confidence and loyalty? There we go. Why are so many parents intent on spending quality time with their children despite the inconvenience in time and money that children so often are?
And often the boredom that comes in this, especially when your kids have different affinities than you, different desires, and maybe when they're really young, it's hard to relate to them. Why is socioeconomic status linked so heavily with crime? Why are those who embrace the means of violence, those in the military and in the police force, at a much higher risk of suicide or divorce?
All of these things happen because we live in a world where we are rational and relational creatures who determine our actions based on the truth and love that we perceive or that we're able to perceive. And the things that happen in the world impact our views on things and what we perceive as being true and loving. The world works causatively, and it's foolish and ignorant and just a lot of times dishonest not to recognize that.
Understandably, the problem that most have with this is that it seems extremely mechanistic. It seems just like dominoes falling. Might not be puppet strings, but it's dominoes. Now, we do what we do merely because the domino prior bumped into us. That's what it seems like. Now, I completely understand the discomfort with thinking about the will in this fashion.
I urge you to remember, though, that the alternatives to this—dice or strings—aren't any better, right? So before I tell you how I think this is—combatablism is better, remember that the alternative that I've laid out is dice or the strings of fatalism. But I would really think about the will a little bit differently.
And it's something that I will hopefully be able to fill out a bit more in future episodes. But here, I'll just give you a little taste.
If I offered to you for lunch right now or dinner, whatever you're going to eat, breakfast. If I offered you two foods, let's say lutefisk and pizza. Hopefully you're not eating breakfast. I eat pizza for breakfast, but some of you might be averse to that. Let's say we've got lutefisk or pizza or chocolate or pancakes or whatever you want, right?
Compared to lutefisk. Now, lutefisk is a Norwegian dish where they soak fish in lye, which is disgusting. Lye is essentially like ash and water. You make lye this super bitter caustic substance that is basically like eating codfish soaked in soap, right? Lutefisk. So if I offered you lutefisk...
Or some of that, I forget what you call it, like, also from like Scandinavia, this like rotten fish stuff, or what is it from Asia, there's this like balut, like duck eggs, but the eggs are like, the embryos are developed for a certain amount of days, so you're actually crunching into the embryo, any of that stuff. Compared to pizza or chocolate or pancakes, what would you pick?
The majority of people would pick the... not the lutefisk, not the balut, right? Not the food that's really disgusting, not the durian, not whatever is just absolutely disgusting to you. Why would you pick the other thing? The pancakes, or the pizza, or the chocolate? You'd pick those things.
Because you desire them. You like them. Not based on anything you did. You didn't just choose to like one over the other, but you just, you do desire what you desire and you desire the thing that tastes good, that seems good to you, that feels good to you. And of course we could use any other analogy, right? Would you choose life or would you choose death? Pain or comfort? Million dollar profits or a million dollar debt? You get the point.
Those decisions aren't really decisions in a certain sense, because their good is so seemingly apparent, you know that you would wretch up lutefisk and it wouldn't provide you any pleasure or sustenance. You know that a million dollar profit would allow you to do much good in the world, whereas a million dollar debt would enslave you for the rest of your life. If any one of those options, if we can call them that, came across your path, they wouldn't really be options, right?
Because there would be only one obvious choice for your good. Barring, of course, hypothetical circumstances that all these wrenches you can try to throw in and say, well, what about this and what about that, right? You get the point that I'm trying to make. The good choice is so obvious that you would inevitably make the good choice. But it's not really that you have no option. It's that your sanity, your reasoning, and your perception of what is good for you is accurate.
That there's only one choice that makes sense, so you'd make it. That's really all compatibilism is saying. It says that your perception of truth and love will lead you to make a decision based on that perception. It's not a decision made by a dice roll or the pull of a string, but a decision based on who you are at that very instant and all the information you have, the perceptions you have, all of that.
Based on what you perceive as true and loving, what you perceive as being good. Of course, I know that's not going to be fully satisfactory for a lot of people because dominoes, which they still seem like dominoes because you can't control all of those things, right? Dominoes don't seem all that much different than dice or strings. So maybe I can try to change the analogy just a little to make it what I think is a little bit more accurate and palatable.
I can't think of anything better at the moment, so hopefully this analogy is a little bit more helpful. And if it's not, I'm sorry. Instead of thinking of events like dominoes falling, let's think of it more like a relay race. If one domino knocks into another, physics could tell us exactly how that second domino is going to fall. And if we replace that second domino with any other domino from the box, it would fall the same. But what if events were more like a relay race?
If an event bumps into you, if the baton gets handed off to you, so to speak, then you will determine your actions by a vast number of calculations. Is your team ahead or behind? Are you an explosive starter, or do you have a stronger finish? How many laps are you going to run, or what's the distance? Who are you running against? If that baton would be handed off to another runner, they would take all of those factors into consideration.
But they may run differently than you based on their abilities, their strengths, their weaknesses, and their team, and how smoothly the handoff goes. The event, the baton, does not determine you, but rather, based on who you are, you determine how to handle the handoff. Now, were you to be handed the baton under these conditions, there's one choice that you would inevitably make, because you are who you are.
But that choice isn't caused so much by the event that determines you, but is determined by you based on the event. And because you are a rational creature in relationship with your team, you will respond in such a way that it corresponds with what you think will bring you and your team the best chance of victory.
Just because you'd make the same decision under these exact same circumstances every single time doesn't mean that you're determined by the event. It means you're a rational decision-maker who perceives the world and seeks the good and seeks to make the best decision. Now, hopefully at least some of that makes sense to you because I don't think I can do any better at the moment. There are small but very significant nuances in all of this, I think, and I've spent decades thinking about it.
I've had to come back to it over and over because it definitely makes your head spin very quickly, and there are a lot of times where it doesn't seem like there are any perfectly palatable options. So I understand even if you accept the relay race analogy, it still seems unsettling that you would make the same choice over and over again, and that in some ways makes it seem like
You are fatalistically determined, right? I get that. But again, that's why we started the season off the way that we did, because what's the alternative? That your action doesn't really represent you? It represents a dice roll? Or that it perfectly represents you? It is who you are. Because I believe in I'm a rational creature.
I keep bumping myself into this material, this subject, in order that I might come to understand it better. And hopefully, by understanding it better, I might help and love others better. I know that this is an issue that can seem rather unimportant, and it can certainly be an issue where we all end up arguing about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. But when we get to the problem of evil, which we will soon enough...
Having a strong understanding of the will is going to be vital for us to deal with accusations leveled against a supposedly evil god, or diminishments leveled against mechanistic humanity. I'm hoping that as you keep bumping into this topic, because your life is not a random roll,
And there is no puppeteer pulling your strings, but you are a rational creature who is bumping into this information. I hope as I hand you the baton that it will have an impact on you, just like when Paul was talking to the sailors, that message had an impact on them and is the thing that caused them to change their minds.
And I have confidence that you are seeking truth and goodness, and that hopefully, if what I'm saying is true and good, you will be able to come to hear that and accept it. So hopefully this episode is a stepping stone for you on your way to the deeper discussions that we're going to get into. That's all for now. So peace, and because I'm a pacifist, when I say it, I mean it.
This podcast is a part of the Kingdom Outpost Network. Please check out the links below to find other great podcasts and content related to nonviolence and kingdom living.