Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Forensic Narrative

The Forensic Narrative artwork

The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 3: The Suspect(s), The Hit, and The Mask

Oct 23, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In the 3rd part of our foray into the Nathan Weekes case, Morgan is caffeine deprived, slightly hangry, and on a mission to astound (or terrify) Tyler with her criminal connections, backbone of steel, and forensic insights into the case that has all of us scratching our heads in utter bafflement. We finally get some answers to the absolutely chaotic connections between the death of 88-year-old Bobby Kicklighter, young father Jerry Lee Davis, and Inmate Nathan Weekes along with the multi-million dollar criminal enterprise he ran from within the walls of Smith State Prison. Welcome back to The Forensic Narrative!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02When a former forensic analyst and a delightfully innocent public relations specialist team up to talk true crime, things become unhinged. Hi, I'm Morgan Leslie, and welcome to the Forensic Narrative, where we take a look at some of the wildest crime stories in history, analyze the forensic elements, and expose my dear co-host to the horrors of the criminal underworld. Sorry, Bestie, but you asked for this.

SPEAKER_02Alright. Last time on the forensic narrative, we talked about the shenanigans of Smith State Prison, how horrible it is, the 93-page Department of Justice report that pointed out how horrible it was. And that is where I introduced you to inmate Nathan Weeks, the leader of the Eve's Saint Laurent squad, also known here forth with as YSL, the prison gang that does the contraband introductions at Smith State Prison.

SPEAKER_02Is this all coming back to you?

SPEAKER_05Oh, yes. I am back on track and ready to learn about the uh criminal underworld in this prison.

SPEAKER_02All right. And just as a reminder for our friendly audience, YSL in particular is known for introducing contraband-like cell phones, narcotics, luxury clothing, jewelry, weapons, and tobacco into the facility. And then back in episode one, which if you're new to the show, I highly recommend you going back and listening to because I will not be recapping the murders of 88-year-old Bobby Kicklider, the local.

SPEAKER_05It is just because she's lazy that she's not gonna do that. Just gonna put that out there.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Or am I efficient?

SPEAKER_05You can be both.

SPEAKER_02I am both.

SPEAKER_00I am both. I'm lazy and I'm efficient because I'm lazy.

SPEAKER_02Anyways, all right. So in our first episode, we talked about the murder of 88-year-old Bobby Kicklider, the local historian of Glenville, Georgia, who was murdered in his bed. Seemingly a random act of violence because nothing in the house was taken, nothing was disturbed. He was just shot while in his bed. But then two weeks prior to the murder of Bobby Kicklider, we had the murder of Jerry Lee Davis, who is a 32-year-old father who was also shot while he was sleeping.

SPEAKER_02But again, same thing. Nothing was taken, nothing was stolen. He was the target. It was evident because they hurt nobody but him. All right, we're caught up, we're refreshed. We are moving on because now we're getting into the meat and potatoes, as the hobbits like to say.

SPEAKER_05The hobbits like to say. So it's gonna be that kind of episode where we're gonna be talking about death, mayhem, murder, contraband, and all the while joking about anything and everything.

SPEAKER_02Hobbit food.

SPEAKER_05Hobbit food.

SPEAKER_02Mainly because I'm a little hungry right now. It's snack time. It is, but I'm here instead.

SPEAKER_05Exceptionally surprising that you are recording this episode without cake. That's it's kind of unsettling.

SPEAKER_02It is. It feels a little weird. I don't even have my afternoon tea. I have not had that, and the lack of caffeine. It is going to make this episode a little bit more chaotic than most. So good luck. You're along for the ride, whether you like it or not.

SPEAKER_05Well, yes, now that our audience has received that reminder about what we went over in episode one, I believe we are ready to carry on into this one.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So we had the murders of Bobby Kicklighter, Jerry Lee Davis. That happens in January of 2021. So for about five or six months after that, everything's relatively quiet. You don't really hear any updates. Like we know the GBI is involved, but they were called into both cases by the local sheriff's office. Because remember, GBI cannot just do what they want.

SPEAKER_02They're a request agency or an assist agency. Term is kind of interchangeable, meaning certain people can request that they come in and help on the investigation. Sheriff's offices are one of those people, and that is what has happened here. So GBI is involved, they're doing their thing, but they're doing it quietly. They're doing it behind the scenes, which is not uncommon. Cops like to keep things quiet, keep things close to the chest, because when information starts trickling out at an uncontrollable pace, that is when investigations get ruined.

SPEAKER_05You speak with experience. You you say that with such conviction that I am assuming you speak from experience. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_01Maybe.

SPEAKER_05Are you not willing to say because you're gonna keep it close to the vest? Yes.

SPEAKER_02Moving on. So we're in July at this point, okay? The end of July.

SPEAKER_05I didn't say anything. Don't worry.

SPEAKER_02It's it's for the plot. It's for the suspense. Okay?

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_02It's July. July 27th and 28th. And all of a sudden, news breaks that there have been arrests in the murder of Bobby Kicklighter.

SPEAKER_04Ooh.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So all of a sudden we go from hearing nothing to, oh hey, by the way, we've arrested people. Cool. So we have four main players in the murder of Bobby Kicklighter, which is what we're going to focus on right now. We'll come back to Jerry Lee Davis, because of course he plays a part. I have not mentioned him for no reason. We'll come back. So right now we're focusing on Mr. Bobby Kicklider. So four arrests are made. You have Christopher Reginald Sumlin, Ariel DeShea Murphy, Keisha Jones, and then our good old boy inmate Nathan Weeks, who is housed in Smith State Prison at this time.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So Christopher Sumlin, Ariel DeShey Murphy, and Keisha Jones are charged with the murder. And then you have Nathan Weeks, who is charged with conspiracy to commit a felony murder and party to a crime.

SPEAKER_05Okay.

SPEAKER_02So, and then just because that's not enough, GDC is also like, you know what? We want to nail our own charges onto Nathan Weeks. So they slap 19 contraband-related warrants on him, possession charges, and then 16 counts of items prohibited for possession by inmates.

SPEAKER_05That's a lot. So they are throwing the through the book at Nathan Weeks.

SPEAKER_02Um, which when you hear all of those charges, you're like, how does any of that interconnect? Yeah, that's like, what is this inmate? These three people, how does any of that interconnect? And we don't know yet.

SPEAKER_05I'm gonna guess that you're about to tell me.

SPEAKER_02We're going through the timeline. You cannot rush my carefully curated timeline. I worked hard.

SPEAKER_05Oh no, I did research.

SPEAKER_02Really, really are.

SPEAKER_05Ladies and gentlemen, I have the perfect opportunity here to annoy Morgan more than I have ever annoyed her in our lives. And I'm going to take this off. My eye is Oh, oh, this opportunity has to be seized. Okay.

SPEAKER_02Use it wisely. You use it wisely.

SPEAKER_05I shall shut up now, especially because you have my mom's phone number.

SPEAKER_00I do. I do indeed.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So that all takes place on July 27th and 28th. Those arrests are made, charges are placed, and we're left wondering what the heck, how does any of this interconnect? What is the story here? We don't know at this juncture because they just put out the news announcement and we're left to wonder. So then a month later, on August 31st, Christopher Sumlin is also charged with the murder of Jerry Lee Davis. Luckily, he's already in a Taton County jail.

SPEAKER_02So at least they didn't have to track him down.

SPEAKER_05Okay, so this is August 31st of 2021.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_05The same year that this happened. So this would be exactly six months.

SPEAKER_02Yes, when the first set of charges are brought. So the murders happen in January.

SPEAKER_05Right.

SPEAKER_02Then at the end of July, the first set of charges are brought against all four of them. And then at the end of August, which is your seven months. So a month later, after the initial charges are made, Christopher Sumlin gets the additional charge for the murder of Jerry Lee Davis.

SPEAKER_05So he has been charged a month prior with the death of Bobby Kickladder. And then a month after now is charged with Mr. Jerry's death.

SPEAKER_02Yes. But again, we still have no context to any of this.

SPEAKER_05We don't know how they're connected. We don't know anything like that.

SPEAKER_02Very, very little. Like we know the circumstances of the murder, but like the specifics are still very much up in the air. Until September 29th. So two months after the initial charges are made, one month after the next set of charges are made, we're finally getting some answers, and how all of these things kind of interconnect. I shouldn't say kind of. They do. And I'm about to lay it out for you. Are you ready?

SPEAKER_05Okay. I am not ready. I need I need a break. Her eyes twitching again. I'm sorry, I'm kidding.

SPEAKER_03I was ready to go.

SPEAKER_05Alright, alright, alright. All joking aside. Oh my god, you look so exhausted with me.

SPEAKER_00The things I do. The things I do. Okay.

SPEAKER_05I appreciate the restraint that you are showing right now in attempting to not end my life. Oh, that's the only reason. Got it. Alright. I kid.

SPEAKER_02I kid. I kid. I kid. I would never. I would never.

SPEAKER_05That that looks as otherwise, so I'm gonna shut up again.

SPEAKER_02All right. On September 29th, GBI agent Christian Johnson gets on the stand.

SPEAKER_05Okay.

SPEAKER_02And this is where we get the details for how these three people and an inmate all collide. So now we're going back to the night of Mr. Kickslider's death on January 30th. GBI, as just a reminder, has been on the scene for 17 hours going through the house and the surrounding area where they fine-tooth comb. Investigators find a camo COVID-19 mask. You know, like one of those cloth ones that don't really do anything for you, but people used as a fashion statement back in the day.

SPEAKER_05Yes.

SPEAKER_02Of the plague.

SPEAKER_05As your as a PR professional, I'm gonna say that this is not the opinion of the TFN podcast. I understand what you're saying.

SPEAKER_02Anyways.

SPEAKER_05Okay, so yes. They were cloth.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Now, if you had a medical grade mask, that was different. These are just like those little cloth masks that people were using in moments of desperation. Because you couldn't buy the medical grade masks anymore. They were out of stock.

SPEAKER_05Uh-huh. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Anyways, we all remember this time where people were literally wearing anything over their faces. This is not the point. A camo patterned COVID-19 mask was found in the roadway by Mr. Kit Clider's house. And inside of that mask is the name Pat Jackson written on the tag.

SPEAKER_05Oh, you fool.

SPEAKER_02No, no, no. Follow me. Follow me. So when I first read that in all of my research, I immediately flash back to my days as a digital analyst because that clue could seem very obvious, but it sometimes isn't. All right. People think that it's these big aha moments when it comes to investigations, like these big pieces of forensics, like DNA or something like that, that that is what is going to break your case.

SPEAKER_02But no, usually, and this is where like criminal intelligence analysts and digital analysts like me really, not to like toot my own horn, but can really be like the backbone of a case because it was our job to like dig through all the layers and muck of information to find little things that helped paint the picture of the whole.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, that makes sense. You guys are you have the biggest pool, I would say, of information, and you're trying to scan through this, get whatever connects to the case, and then hand it off to the detectives so they can look at it and be like, ah, yes, we're geniuses. We've cracked it.

SPEAKER_02Yes. Yes. Now I will say, I don't know if it was an analyst that did this particular piece of digging, although I do know that the GVI does have their own criminal analysts. Um, and from my experience with them, they seem good. I don't know. My experience has not been that extensive, to be honest. Um, but they find this name, Pat Jackson, written on the tag inside of the mask. And it's this one little thing that is going to blow this case wide open. So the GBI search for all individuals with that name or variations of it in the region.

SPEAKER_02And then they go door to door to see if anybody recognizes the mask. This is the boring part of investigations that does not get put in documentaries, or in Law and Order, or in CSI, or whatever cop procedural show of your choosing is. But this is how real police work actually happens is literally going door to door is hey, do you recognize this or this person? You know, something like that. And eventually.

SPEAKER_05Oh man.

SPEAKER_02I know. Breaks your heart, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_05It it really does. Also, I mean, just like, all right, if I'm a criminal.

SPEAKER_02Hypothetically.

SPEAKER_05And I know I did something hypothetically. This is this is all hypothetical here. If I had done something like that and left a mask behind at the scene with that name on it, and somebody came knocking on my door and was like, hey, do you recognize this mask? I'ma just say no. Just just no, I don't. I'm so sorry. I wish I could be of more help.

SPEAKER_05Have a nice day. And then what? What can they do?

SPEAKER_02That's assuming it's your mask. In this case, they eventually made their way to a woman in Vidalia, Georgia, a Miss Patricia Jackson, who recognized the mask as hers.

SPEAKER_05Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_02She then tells the agents that she kept that mask on the rearview mirror of her 2016 Jeep Patriot. So the agents probe a bit deeper and find out that Miss Jackson had lent her vehicle to her granddaughter, a Miss Ariel Murphy, the night of the Bobby Kicklider murder. The agents then tracked down Ariel Murphy, who did admit that she was in Glenville that night, but it was hours before the murder had even taken place, which I think, yeah, so Mr.

SPEAKER_02Kicklider was murdered somewhere around midnight. So she was saying she had been there hours prior and had only stopped at a gas station on her way home. Now, for some context, Vidalia, Georgia, which do y'all have Vidalia onions over where you are?

SPEAKER_05I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh. This is where they come from. Vidalia Onions are from Vidalia, Georgia.

SPEAKER_05Are you sure about that? Could be two different names.

SPEAKER_02Yes, I am. No, no, no. Same spelling and everything. Anyway, Vidalia is about a 50-minute drive from Glenville. I looked it up. 50 minutes apart. So the agents, however, are like, hmm, something isn't matching up with evidence they had already collected. So her statements did not match up with what they already knew. Mainly because they had obtained some surveillance footage from the gas station.

SPEAKER_02And in that footage, they found the car parked outside the store at 9 16 PM.

SPEAKER_05Okay.

SPEAKER_02Okay. And in that video, it shows Murphy leaving the car with another woman and an unidentified man. So all of this was suspicious suspicious. I should have drinking the caffeine. All of this was suspicious enough to obtain a search warrant for her house, which she shared with co-defendant Keisha Jones, the other person.

SPEAKER_02Who had been indicted. Oh my gosh. I don't know how to silence those. I'll figure that out for next time. Okay. Which she shared with codifend. Oh my god.

SPEAKER_04Her sister was fine. Everything's fine.

SPEAKER_05We should not be recording today.

SPEAKER_02Which we should not. We should not. But we're committed at this point and we're gonna finish.

SPEAKER_05That is that is happening.

SPEAKER_02All right. So all of this was suspicious enough for the GBI agents to obtain a search warrant for her house, which she shared with her co-defendant, Keisha Jones.

SPEAKER_05Ooh, okay. Yep. Police are getting somewhere.

SPEAKER_02So yeah. So the agents go into the house, they collect the electronics, mainly a cell phone, where upon a forensic extraction, they found that there were no messages from before, during, or after the murder.

SPEAKER_05It uh okay, no messages. Does that a good thing for her or for the police?

SPEAKER_02I'm glad you asked. So, as a digital forensic analyst, that particular bit piqued my interest.

SPEAKER_05You really love bringing up that you're a digital forensic analyst.

SPEAKER_02I do. I do. It's my only claim to fame. So a lot of times, what you don't find is just as telling as what you do. So when I would go through a cell phone and I know that the incident I'm trying to find evidence for occurred at a certain time, I would like to apply some date filters and whatnot to specifically narrow it down to that time. And if I see that that time period is completely blank, that's that's an anomaly, especially when you compare it to the rest of the phone's usage.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, so if I'm taking a phone call at 9 30 and I'm suspected of killing someone at 9 30, that's evidence to suggest I didn't kill him because I was on the phone. But if I'm usually on my phone at 9 30, and for some reason on this night, from the period of 9 to 10, I was not on that phone at all. I had to have been doing something different.

SPEAKER_02It shows that it's it shows a pattern of trying to hide something. Right? Because people think, oh, I'll just turn my phone off. Well, that blank gap, phones record so much data that you never think they record. Like so much data, so much background data that when you're doing a forensic extraction, all of that is pulled. Okay. So when you have all this other data that's filling in all the gaps on either side of this one incident. That shows a certain level of intentionality that is suspicious.

SPEAKER_02It's not indicative or it's not confirmation, it's suspicious.

SPEAKER_05So I have one question. We're gonna side quest for a minute.

SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh, I love a good side quest.

SPEAKER_05If I was trying to set up the perfect murder.

SPEAKER_02Oh my god.

SPEAKER_05Obviously. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Allegedly.

SPEAKER_05For those who are curious as to why she has reacted like that, for a period of like two months, usually once every week, I would send her a text and be like, I think I've figured it out. And give her a detailed explanation of how I would commit a murder, to which she would then respond almost immediately, telling me that I was an idiot and explaining how none of what I said worked.

SPEAKER_05So I see an opportunity to redeem myself and I'm gonna take it.

SPEAKER_01Alright, let me hear it.

SPEAKER_05If I wanted to do this and I wanted to have my cell phone not be a suspicious thing that could prove where I was, alright?

SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_05What if I had gone out to say like a bar that night? Okay, but my phone is already close to dead. I've used it all day, it's only got five percent battery left. I'm at the bar and it can show that I've been there at the bar for however long. Alright? And then my phone, I use it to call an Uber, go into my house, and right after that, the phone dies.

SPEAKER_05So now the phone is off, but it's off because the battery has depleted itself. I get an Uber and go home. When I go home, I plug it in to the charger. Sure, maybe. And that's when I go out to then commit the murder. My phone is sitting in my room on the charger while I am not at the house anymore. Does this take away the police's ability to use my phone as evidence?

SPEAKER_05Because there is a plausible reason why my phone is off. There is evidence to show from the last time I used my phone that my destination afterwards was to go home. And we know my car was at the bar and I Ubered home, which means I couldn't have necessarily left.

SPEAKER_02Am I only limited to cell phone data?

SPEAKER_05If it helps me commit the murder better, then yes.

SPEAKER_02So that's a no, because nobody is just limited to cell phone data. Okay.

SPEAKER_05Dang it. Okay.

SPEAKER_02Do you want me to point out the flaws in your plan, or do you just want me to let you believe that that could work?

SPEAKER_05I mean, it's not like I'm actually gonna go out and kill anyone, and I don't want to necessarily give our audience a step-by-step instruction on to how to kill someone. So I'm just going to live in my delusion for the next five minutes. Or however long it takes for us to finish this episode, which is probably another five hours. And then you'll tell me afterwards and crush all my hopes and dreams of becoming a serial killer.

SPEAKER_01You're welcome.

SPEAKER_05The only cereal I kill is Captain Crunch for our audience, just so you're all aware.

SPEAKER_02I do not lucky charms.

SPEAKER_05You are 34 years old.

SPEAKER_02It doesn't stop me. Mainly because it's like one of the last sugary cereals I can eat that's gluten-free.

SPEAKER_00It's not my choice.

SPEAKER_05We have established now that um, first off, I do not know how to commit an effective murder. I would just get caught immediately, which is good news because it means that I'm not a murderer. Because I would be caught.

SPEAKER_02What does that say about me?

SPEAKER_05Um that you probably have bodies hidden in the backyard. You literally have a notebook that you showed me earlier that's in this pastel pink color with this really cutesy hand-written thing on the front that says list of where the bodies are. Like, come on. Stop looking at me like I'm gonna be the next body, please.

SPEAKER_02I would never. I would never.

SPEAKER_05So we've established I cannot be a killer.

SPEAKER_02But I could be.

SPEAKER_05Apparently. This you could absolutely would not doubt that for a second. And we've established that this person, a alleged killer, is apparently not a very good one because her cell phone data is now showing a discrepancy from her normal usage, and the police have just latched onto that.

SPEAKER_02Yes, but it gets more interesting.

SPEAKER_05How can it get more interesting, Morgan? Tell me.

SPEAKER_02Because she left open an incognito browser where she had the following searches pulled up. How to delete incriminating texts.

SPEAKER_05Oh my.

SPEAKER_02How to delete the GPS system of a 2016 Jeep Patriot.

SPEAKER_05Oh, you fool.

SPEAKER_02And the last one, if cell phone providers can see the content of text messages. So I feel like I need to provide some facts to the audience at large.

SPEAKER_05This has immediately given me a migraine. Just hearing those three Google searches.

SPEAKER_02Like it should be the in see, it was the incognito browser that got me. Because people automatically think that if you do something in an incognito browser, you're safe.

SPEAKER_05No, incognito is not like that. That is not what it does.

SPEAKER_02That's what people think. That's what they think. So according to the research, because I wanted to provide the best facts possible because I am nothing if not a perfectionist. Incognito mode is designed so that the browser doesn't persistently save certain types of data. So, like browsing history. And if you're entering information into like fillable forms on the website, like it won't save any of that. Um, cookies and site data are also deleted, but only if you close the window.

SPEAKER_02So her problem was she left it open on her phone. And so when they did the extraction, it was able to capture that data.

SPEAKER_05All right, tell me this.

SPEAKER_02Is it gonna be a question I can actually answer?

SPEAKER_05Oh, I'm positive it is.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_05If she had closed the browser, would they still have been able to extract these searches?

SPEAKER_02Depends. A lot, a so a lot of cell phone extractions are dependent upon multiple factors. So, like, is the phone unlocked when you're doing the extraction, or did the software have to bypass the lock? What is the operating system? So Android versus iPhone. Both record data differently. Um, the amount of memory space on your phone also makes a difference because phones constantly rewrite data as the memory runs out.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, here's a little tip for all of you guys. Uh, if your phone is running out of space and you say delete something, it does not get deleted. It gets slated to be written over when you have more data there. So our dearest Morgan here can easily find all those secret pictures that you have attempted to delete because they're still there until they've been overwritten by something else.

SPEAKER_01I'm flipping my hair.

SPEAKER_05That's how data works.

SPEAKER_01Flipping my hair for the people who can't see.

SPEAKER_05Yes, she is flipping her hair, uh, but she also has her hair in a bun. It's a claw clip, my friend.

SPEAKER_02Mainly just so I can stab people with it when they make me angry.

unknownOh.

SPEAKER_02Rage bait me in the comments. Anyways, so we're moving on. Now, so we have our cell phone data, we have our incognito browser with some very incriminating evidence. Not enough to put her in prison?

SPEAKER_05So, what was that not enough to put her in prison? She literally searched how do I get rid of evidence?

SPEAKER_02It's indicative, it's circumstantial, and that on its own is not gonna put anybody in prison. You need more. So, what does Agent Johnson do?

SPEAKER_05I guess he's probably something to find these people and actually put them in prison, right?

SPEAKER_02He goes for the toll records.

SPEAKER_05That's my boy, Agent Johnson. I don't know what that means, but you go, man.

SPEAKER_02I was waiting for you to ask me what it means.

SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah, I have no idea, but I'm supposed to be excited right now, so I'm gonna do it. So it says in your script that I have to be enthusiastic right now.

SPEAKER_02So I'm yes, it's a it's an asterisk right there. For the public, he does not have my script. He I made him go into this entire case blind. He has no idea what's happening.

SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah, I'm so lost.

SPEAKER_02Are you really? I'm talking about this trying to get you lost.

SPEAKER_05Oh, but there's a lot of forensic stuff, but it's okay because you know what? We're clarifying it as we go. Oh, we are, which is what matters.

SPEAKER_02We are. I'm trying to give it this case is so convoluted, and I'm trying to give it in a chronological fashion that also still makes sense. I'm trying my best.

SPEAKER_05That's why I'm here to ask questions that the general public wants to know.

SPEAKER_02Yes. Toll records.

SPEAKER_05So toll records.

SPEAKER_02A lot of people will confuse toll records with a cell phone extraction. Like one time when I went to court, that was one of the questions. Like, what is the difference? So I'm gonna tell you. A cell phone extraction is literally just pulling the data directly from the cell phone. We has nothing to do with the cell phone carrier, like Verizon T-Mobile, ATT, none of that. We don't contact them, reach out to them, or my team didn't. Other cell phone or digital forensics teams, my team did not.

SPEAKER_02We would only go off of data that we were able to pull directly from the device itself.

SPEAKER_04Okay.

SPEAKER_02Toll records are when an investigator reaches out to the actual cell phone company. So they would reach out to in this situation, I don't know who the provider was. We'll use Verizon as an example. So it's when an investigator could reach out directly to Verizon and be like, hey, I need all the records or records for a specific time frame for this cell phone number. And then they can go onto their servers and pull that data and provide it to them.

SPEAKER_02No, and it usually comes in some sort of Excel spreadsheet.

SPEAKER_05What exactly is in that spreadsheet? Are we just talking like time frames or are we talking things all the way up to the actual text messages that were sent?

SPEAKER_02Both. So you get call logs and text message content. You can get the towers that the signal was pinging off of, we can which can help you triangulate the position of where the cell phone, a rough position. It's not, it's not exact, but a rough position of where that cell phone was at the time it was doing that particular phone call or sending that particular message or receiving whatever.

SPEAKER_05Whoa.

SPEAKER_02Yes. So it can give you a lot of very specific data, but it might be time sensitive because again, server space is finite. So whereas sometimes I've had cell phone extractions that go back 10 years, depending on how old the cell phone is, a cell phone provider or a service provider might only keep it for six months, right? It just kind of depends on the cell phone company and that kind of thing. One of the downsides of toll records is it takes forever to get them back, which is exactly what happened in this case because you're going through legal measures, right?

SPEAKER_02You have to get a subpoena, you have to send that subpoena to the cell phone company. They have so long to get it back. Like it's it's a whole process, right? Um, and depending on the state of the cell phone when you bring it into the lab, it can be an extradited process, right? You can potentially get information faster. But anyway.

SPEAKER_05So this is not something where police can just be like, hey, Verizon, I've got this phone number here. I need all the text messages and the call logs from January 12th, 2021 to January 31st, 2021. You actually have to go through the subpoena process, the warrant process, all that stuff. Make sure that you have exactly what you need to make sure it's not, I believe what the phrase is is fruit of the poisonous tree.

SPEAKER_05So that way it can actually be used in court.

SPEAKER_02In court. Yeah. A lot of the reasons why cases take so long, A, because the court system itself is just slow, but B, yes, you're having to do all of this documentation to make sure, like you said, fruits of the poisonous tree, because the first thing a defense attorney is gonna do is try to get evidence thrown out of court. So Agent Johnson does his due diligence, gets requests the toll records. They take forever to come in, but when they finally come in, the record shows Ariel Murphy and Keisha Jones texting with a number that links back to our inmate Nathan Weeks sitting in Smith State prison.

SPEAKER_02Are you ready?

SPEAKER_05I guess I'm ready.

SPEAKER_02For the contents of these text messages.

SPEAKER_05Oh man, these these have gotta be good. All right. So what's the first one?

SPEAKER_02The text messages, I'm not gonna read them to you verbatim. We'd be here all day. But the text messages are regarding a murder for hire plot on a CO, a correctional officer, that include his address, which was a house right next to Bobby Kicklighter's. No way. Bobby Kicklider died due to a mix-up in the houses, and both houses had similar-looking white trucks in the driveway.

SPEAKER_05So these people who killed Bobby Kicklider were going in to do that not for him, but for his next door neighbor, and they just got the houses wrong. Yeah. And dear old Bobby Kicklighter kicked the bucket because of this.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_05That's a massive screw up right there.

SPEAKER_02Yes. The intended target was a correctional officer known for seizing large amounts of contraband, specifically YSO contraband, because they were the major contraband movers at the time.

SPEAKER_05So a correction officer, which let's go back to episode two for a short moment here.

SPEAKER_01All right, take me back.

SPEAKER_05I believe it was episode two, where we discussed that the Georgia Department of Corrections has a massive issue where there was a 50 to at most 70% vacancy rate for uh positions in the Department of Corrections, specifically with prison guards. And so you've got that. You have an understaffing issue mixed with the issue that also in that same report showed that these prisons were overpopulated.

SPEAKER_05The pay, as we've also discussed, is nowhere near a good enough compensation for the danger that these people are in. Clearly, because this man who all he was doing was going to work and doing exactly what his job was. Make sure that every prisoner is doing what they're supposed to do, and make sure that contraband that gets into the prison is removed from the prison. He had a hit put out on him from someone in that prison so that he would get killed and the contraband could keep on flowing.

SPEAKER_03Yes.

SPEAKER_05So we have understaffed, underpaid, overpopulated prisons and a hit gone wrong now.

SPEAKER_02And you want to know what's crazy? I have met this correctional officer.

SPEAKER_05No way.

SPEAKER_02Yes, I've met him. He still works there.

SPEAKER_05Still?

SPEAKER_02Not at Smith State Prison specifically. He has since been promoted.

SPEAKER_05I mean, yeah, I wouldn't know.

SPEAKER_02Um rightfully promoted.

SPEAKER_05Um yeah, no kidding.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, he still works there, which I really admire because it was a running, it was a running joke, but not really a joke, that I used to tell my uh my ASEC all the time that the moment a hit got put out on me, I was done.

SPEAKER_05Just done. Like you're quitting.

SPEAKER_02Done. I was leaving. I was quitting. I was leaving.

SPEAKER_05And what is ASAC?

SPEAKER_02Oh, it stands for assistant special agent in charge.

SPEAKER_05Okay.

SPEAKER_02So again, GDC is they're very hierarchical, kind of like the military, um, just with special agents. So over certain units, you would have the SAC. So that's the special agent in charge, and then you would have the ASAC, the assistant special agent in charge. So those are like the two people that kind of headed up our unit.

SPEAKER_05And you just told yours that the second someone put a hit out on you, you were you were done. You were cool. I was done.

SPEAKER_02You were just yeah, because all right, here's a fun side quest for you. I had gone to a to testify at a trial one time. It was a RICO trial. Ah. So gang related. Um, and I was testifying against the oh, who what was he? I don't remember his name. I'm not gonna say his name for reasons. Um, but he was the member of one of the blood subsets here in Georgia, and he was getting RICO trials or two RICO charges brought up, which a one RICO charge is a mandatory 20-year sentence.

SPEAKER_02So with two, you get 40. Whoa. Yeah. Um, and so I didn't think anything of it. It was my first quote unquote big trial, like important big, meaning RICO is my first RICO trial. So I just go in, I do my thing, I give my testimony, and as I'm leaving, I'm met at the bottom of these stairs by these very well-armed giant men from the sheriff's office. And I'm looking at them like, am I about to be arrested?

SPEAKER_02What is happening? Did I say something wrong? Like, what is happening? He's like, No, we're gonna walk you to your car. And I was like, Why? Why? He's like, We've had some threats. And I was like, Uh-oh. Oh, oh. So a common tactic that gang members will use for intimidation purposes of witnesses, is while the trial is going on, they will essentially assemble around the courthouse, like just making their presence felt, I guess.

SPEAKER_02But it can be very intimidating when you have all of these people surrounding the courthouse and they're wearing their gang colors, and you as a witness have to walk through the front door. Like it's it's scary. Now, luckily, they walked me to my car and there was nobody there. Like they had disbanded or whatever, because it was the end of the day. And maybe it had happened on previous days, and I don't know. I didn't see that. But yeah, they were like, We're gonna walk you to your car. And I was like, I appreciate that.

SPEAKER_02So yeah, after that day, I told my boss, I was like, Yeah, if a threat ever comes for me personally, I'm done. I'm out.

SPEAKER_05I think I would have been done right after they had walked me to my car. If they had just said that one sentence, oh yeah, we've we've had some threats. Like, oh, okay, that's great. Well, um, everything I said in there was off the record. I'm gonna disappear now, and that's the end of it.

SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, I do remember as so I get in my car and I'm like pulling away. I remember calling my boss in like this manic state. I don't I don't really remember what I was saying, but I know there was a lot of blabbering because I was trying to give her the recap of the trial and how it had. Gone, you know.

SPEAKER_05And then I was like, yeah, and then they're a massive adrenaline dump and all that because of all the stuff that just happened.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and my hands were like visibly shaking as I'm like clinching the wheel and I'm keeping my eye on the rear view mirror to make sure nobody's following me to my house. Oh man. Because I was going home and I was like, hmm, that's an experience. Luckily, it never happened to me again. That was the one and only, but it was enough.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's um no thanks. Yep.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it was not the reason I left the lab.

SPEAKER_05So Morgan is made of sterner stuff. That is what we are learning today.

SPEAKER_02So the problems persist, but so do I.

SPEAKER_05Put that on the t-shirt. Yeah. Alright. So our correctional officer here was the target of a hit. A hit that did not make it to his front door, but instead made it to the front door of his next door neighbor, Bobby Kicklighter.

SPEAKER_02Bobby Kicklighter, yeah. And what's even more sad about the situation is at the time the murder took place, the CEO didn't even live in that house anymore. He had already moved out.

SPEAKER_05Wow. So either way, the wrong person was dying that night.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_05Man. Yeah. And this happened on the 30th, right? January 30th.

SPEAKER_0231st, I think. The night of the 30th day of the 31st, yeah, in January.

SPEAKER_05So we still have a murder that took place a little over two weeks prior. That's unaccounted for up to this point.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Mr. Jerry Lee Davis. We're not done yet.

SPEAKER_05All right.

SPEAKER_02So the GBI showed the CEO the video from the gas station. The video showing Murphy, the other woman, and the unidentified man getting out of the Jeep Patriot. And the CEO immediately took one look at that man and was like, that is Christopher Sumlin.

SPEAKER_05Wow.

SPEAKER_02Because at one point, Christopher Sumlin had shared a cell with Nathan Weeks.

SPEAKER_05And there's the connection.

SPEAKER_02And there's the connection. So the GBI then gets a hold of Sumlin's text messages, where they found Sumlin and Weeks discussing the murder for Higher Plot, where they shared the address for the unique boutique, which is a business that is owned by one of the female co-defendants. I don't remember which one. I want to say it was Keisha Jones. I think it was her, her business, but Murphy then worked for the same business.

SPEAKER_02Um, so that address was going to be the meetup spot for the murder for hire. So all three of them were gonna meet there and then they were going to drive.

SPEAKER_05Yes, very smart. Pick the location that's tied to as your meetup location for this.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_05It's just geniuses here with this. I suddenly feel little bit better about my texts to you about my alleged murder plots because clearly I'm at least please tell me I'm at least somewhat smarter than these people when it came to You try. Ouch. Okay. Do you want to tell me that you're good at be good at it?

SPEAKER_05Like, that's the wrong thing to say. That's not I'm okay.

SPEAKER_02Um I would like to remind the audience that this is our supposed uh PR person who is supposed to be keep me from getting canceled.

SPEAKER_05I I mean, like, okay.

SPEAKER_02How about I just keep going with the story?

SPEAKER_05That's a really good idea.

SPEAKER_02I'll save I'll save you from yourself. All right. The text messages also show that the three defendants were supposed to leave their phones in Ludovici, where Jones and Murphy lived. I know I couldn't decide if it was put because fun fact, my family is of Italian heritage, and my great-great grandfather may or may not have been part of the Italian mafia.

SPEAKER_05I am gonna consider myself lucky then that I have not been dealt with by you after all of the shenanigans that I have pulled today.

SPEAKER_02So yeah, I couldn't decide if it was Ludovici because that was like the Italian heritage coming out, or if it was like Ludowiki.

SPEAKER_05Which just sounded wrong. Alright.

SPEAKER_02So uh either way, I'm sure somebody will correct me in the comments. Um, so the GBI has the video from the gas station that puts all three defendants together, a witness also placing them in Glennville at the time of the murder, and because everybody loves DNA, they have someone's DNA matched to the saliva found on the inside of the camo COVID-19 mask.

SPEAKER_05The thing that started this whole saga and findings.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. So it seems like a pretty open and shut case, right? You would think we were done.

SPEAKER_05I would. I would absolutely think we were done at that point.

SPEAKER_02And you'd be wrong. Because we still have to consider the murder of Jerry Lee Davis and how a 32-year-old father who lives in a completely different county figures into this whole mess.

SPEAKER_05And you're just gonna leave me pondering until we meet up next week to finally tell me what this is, because it's not like I can even look it up, because if I do that, then your Italian mafia side will come out and I'll just be done.

SPEAKER_02Yes, it takes the saying, I know a guy, to a whole new level.

SPEAKER_05Thank you for joining us for today's episode of the Forensic Narrative. We hope you enjoyed this chaotic venture through crimes I didn't even know existed, and Morgan was all too happy to point out to me. Join us next week as Morgan continues to traumatize me and simultaneously leaves me with cliffhangers that fill me with more begrudging anticipation than a child on Christmas Eve who knows his only present is socks. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 6: The One Where the Warden Gets Arrested

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    We've finally reached the finale and yet, Morgan and Tyler continue to bring shame upon their ancestors as they speak like sickly Victorian children, suffer from amnesia, and gape in confusion at subtle innuendos...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 5: If You're Going to Accuse a Warden, Bring Receipts

    Nov 6, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    In this week’s episode of The Forensic Narrative, Morgan struggles to talk in coherent sentences, Guinevere (Morgan’s cat) makes a grand entrance that derails the conversation multiple times, and Tyler announces that if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 4: A Pattern of Corruption and Coverups

    Oct 30, 202643 minAudio

    In the 4th part of our seemingly endless twist and turns in the Nathan Weekes case, Morgan is prepped with snacks and caffeine, yet the chaos seems more unhinged than ever as Tyler makes jokes that are morally...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 2: Behind the Walls of Smith State Prison

    Oct 16, 202655 minAudio

    Welcome to part 2 of our unhinged discussion on the Nathan Weekes case! In today's episode, we're deep diving into the shenanigans happening behind the walls of Smith State Prison. The very facility that houses our main...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Nathan Weekes Case, Pt. 1: Two Murders Tying Back to One Prison Cell

    Oct 9, 202637 minAudio

    In part one of our unhinged discussion on the Nathan Weekes case, we pick apart into two murders. Separate towns. Different MOs. No connections. Or are there? Join us as we begin our deep dive into a case of a...

    Credit the people on this episode