PJ Gunter tripled her income after graduate school and nothing changed. Same debt, same borrowing, same cycle her parents modeled, her dad used to brag his credit was "bad enough to stand up and fight you." When she sought help, she got caught in a loop. The financial planner sent her to a therapist, and the therapist sent her right back. Neither had the training to address what was actually driving her. She paid off her debts through credit counseling and went right back into debt, because no one had touched the money scripts running underneath. That cycle eventually pushed her toward a master's in financial planning, the presidency of AFCPE, and a career spent teaching people what she was never taught, that how you feel about money matters more than what you know about it. #PJGunter, #RickKahler, #FinancialTherapy, #AFCPE, #FinancialPlanning, #FinancialLiteracy, #MoneyScripts, #BehavioralFinance, #MoneyMindset, #FinancialWellness, #DebtFreeJourney, #DebtRecovery, #CreditCounseling, #FinancialEducation, #FinancialHealth, #PersonalFinance, #WealthPsychology, #FinancialCoaching, #MindsetMatters, #EmotionalIntelligence, #MoneyHabits, #FinancialFreedom, #PersonalGrowth, #AdvancedWellbeing A podcast that blends the nuts and bolts of financial advice with the emotions that drive our money decisions. Join Rick Kahler, CFP®, CFT™, as he blends practical financial wisdom with the emotional insights that shape our choices. Discover how financial therapy can help you make money decisions that truly align with your values..
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Financial Therapy. It's not just about the money. I'm a personal financial planner, columnist, and financial therapist Rick Taylor. Research tells us that 90% of all financial decisions are made emotionally, not logically. For nearly four decades, I've been helping people make better money decisions. So, what makes my financial worldview different from most financial experts? I blend the nuts and bolts of financial advice with the emotions that drive making good money decisions are not just about the money.
SPEAKER_01So let's get started with today's episode. Welcome back to another edition. And I am excited to have PJ Gunter. Did I get your last name right?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And PJ is just uh has an intoxicating um vibe to her personality. Maybe we call it magnetic. I don't know. Um, but she uh is uh um just uh delightful. And I'm really interested in getting to know more about PJ, about your journey, uh, about what has attracted you to some of this uh this work. How did we first come together?
SPEAKER_01Was it true uh talking financial uh therapy, the office hours?
SPEAKER_02Yes. I was so thrilled when I saw you were offering those. And I'm thinking, oh wow, I get a chance to sit with Rick, and so I'm gonna sign up for all of these. Yeah, I did. And so I was really, really happy. I mean, you know, you're out there, you've authored all these books, and you've got this thing going on at the university, and Sandra talks about you all the time, Sandra. And so um, yeah, and so I was just I was just thrilled.
SPEAKER_02So I showed up and it was it was awesome.
SPEAKER_01Well, you did, and and it's awesome to have you on those calls. And just in case uh somebody's listening to this that doesn't know what we're talking about, once a month I do something called talking financial therapy with Rick Kaylor. And it is just an open invitation to anybody in the world that wants to show up and talk about something related with uh emotions and money. And I started that as uh an outcrop of my class of having office hours. And I found it so helpful when people call me and say, hey, I'd like a little bit of your time.
SPEAKER_01I'd like to learn more about financial therapy, this, this, and this. I said, well, I have something, I have something better. I want to uh show up at this particular gathering. And guess what? You get more than me. You get a whole group of folks. We never know who's gonna be there. But uh you've witnessed that, that those discussions can get really rich. And I don't have to say a word.
SPEAKER_02Right. Lots of questions, lots of insights, resources, referrals, insights, all kinds of things.
SPEAKER_01It brings the power of group together, which I don't think is any secret. I'm a huge fan of group therapy and the group dynamic. And it was um uh stated to me early on in my my group therapy experience that you don't have just uh two pairs of eyes on you, meaning the therapist. You've got eight pairs of eyes and brains in the room that get to look at things from all different perspectives and can give all sorts of uh information and pers uh and perspective.
SPEAKER_01So um I I enjoy it because there's no preparation needed and I learned something almost every time like, huh? I do too. I didn't know I am interested in knowing more about you, uh PJ, and your your trail in life that has led you to be excited about being on an open forum called Talking Financial Therapy. And uh and I I do know you have some very interesting experiences, education, and vocations in your past.
SPEAKER_01Tell us kind of where you started and how you got here.
SPEAKER_02Oh, wow. You're asking me to kind of narrow down decades of life and put it into this funnel and all 50 years of it. A little bit more than that, Rick. And I ain't ashamed to talk about that part either. Actually, what got me started was in graduate school. I went to the University of Houston, and um, you know, I mean, it was 20 years between my bachelor's and my master's, the graduate work I did at the University of Houston.
SPEAKER_02So when I graduated, I got a job making three or four times what I had been making. And our situation, our financial situation really didn't change. So I didn't understand that part.
SPEAKER_01And what what did you uh what was your uh undergrad in?
SPEAKER_02My undergrad is in English. Okay, and I I actually have two masters. I have one in human resources development, and I have another in personal financial planning. That one came about 10 years after the first master's in human resources development. So I was wondering, okay, I graduated, making more money. Why haven't things changed? And then I realized I never got any financial education.
SPEAKER_02The only financial education I got was the modeling in the household. And I modeled my parents' behavior. And I'll tell you one thing about um that in particular. I remember growing up hearing my dad say, My credit is bad enough to stand up and fight you. And it's isn't that comical? I have never heard that. That's what he used to say. My credit is bad enough to stand up and fight you.
SPEAKER_02And Dougie, I sure do hope you don't mind my sharing that. So that's exactly what happened to me. And I don't think I realized I was modeling that behavior because it was so deeply ingrained within my subconscious. When I graduated from undergrad, they were standing around with tables, just giving away credit cards like it was cotton candy. And so, you know, that was the days that I graduated in 76.
SPEAKER_02For anyone who wants to do the math, be my guest. So, you know, and that's that's the kind of days we grew up with.
SPEAKER_01I what were the money scripts, PJ? If I I can interrupt, I'm fascinated over this that my credit's bad enough to stand up and fight you. What were the money scripts that you took from that? What were the the beliefs around that?
SPEAKER_02There's never enough, never enough money. We can't afford that. I need to save, but I don't know how. It's okay to spend more than you make. When I graduated, I made$7,000. That was probably the equivalent of, you know, annually. I was a recruiter, college recruiter, enrollment recruiter for the school where I went. I graduated from Maryville College in Tennessee. We call it Marival. That's how you can tell the difference between the locals and the people who just come in.
SPEAKER_02So I made that much money. It was enough for a young single woman, but I had grown up with the money script that there's not enough, there's never enough. And I also grew up with a psyche of borrowing instead of saving. And so I modeled all of that. And when I graduated from graduate school, when I came out of graduate school, and I realized, whoa, you got this master's degree, and pardon me, but you don't know shit about money.
SPEAKER_02You you just don't. So um I looked around for some help, some education, realizing you know, there's a point at which you come to understand and to know, realize you don't know what you don't know. And I didn't know what I didn't know, especially about money. And I did not understand how in the world I could get through graduate school with no financial education and no awareness that I needed financial education.
SPEAKER_02So there was that piece. And then we got, we were getting ready to buy a house, and I thought about borrowing some more, and we got turned down. And so I called the bank lady and cussed her out. And it was because it I thought it was that they made the decisions. And um, that's when I realized I didn't really know about a credit score. So looking around for education, of course, back then you don't find anything. We're talking about maybe the late 80s or so.
SPEAKER_02You know, you there was no financial education, organized financial education back then. So I went to a personal financial planning. Susie Orman said that's what she wanted to be. And she was all big at the time with the nine something of financial peace. Or anyway, I went to a personal financial planning, a planner, and she was wonderful, red-headed lady. And she said, Well, honey, you know, Texas, Houston, Texas.
SPEAKER_02Well, honey, you gotta get out of debt first because I didn't know anything about investments and how personal financial planning really worked. And so I thought, okay, I'll go to a therapist, a social worker, and they sent me right back the circuitous route to a financial planner. And I'm thinking, I'm doing all of this. You know, I went to consumer credit counseling, we enrolled. There was really no real formal financial education there.
SPEAKER_02We got on the debt management program, of course, got out of debt, and then got right back into debt. I just really didn't understand the psychology behind money. So we went through that cycle until I really figured out that this is what I needed to do. This is how I needed to learn. And I really, really want to help other people discover what they don't know about money and the emotional aspects that are driving their money behaviors.
SPEAKER_02You see, most people really think it's all about the money, that everything will be okay when you have the money. I even know someone who won eight million in a lottery. I know him personally. And um, he's working at FedEx today.
SPEAKER_01So is he working at FedEx still with his eight million or is that gone? Oh wow. Um, how how many years from the time he got it till what what you perceived that was gone?
SPEAKER_02Maybe about 10 years.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And I know that's a little bit off off the trail. I um there's some studies done that 43% uh of people that come into sudden wealth, it's gone in five years. And so that's that's not not shocking at all. Um, so I I find one thing really fascinating here. Um and that is that the therapist sent you back to the financial planner. Now I'm gonna read into that and see if this lands correctly.
SPEAKER_01But the story I'm making up is the financial planner thought this was about the money, or not the planner, sorry, the financial therapist, the not the financial therapist, the therapist thought this was about the money and sent you right back to where you had been.
SPEAKER_02Right. Now, I failed to mention that the planner mentioned a social worker or a therapist. Uh-huh. So what you can deduct from that, reasonably deduct, is that the planner wasn't trained in the emotional aspects of money.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And the social worker was not trained in the financial aspects of the money. And here I am in the middle going round and round, you know.
SPEAKER_01Wow. That that is such a succinct, lived experience of what we've described kind of academically. But I want to say what a beautiful example. It wasn't beautiful for you to be caught in that. Um, so how did how did you get out?
SPEAKER_02We paid all our debts through the debt management program at CCCS, not really understanding the impact it was having on our finances. Again, I didn't even know you had a credit score. I didn't know what that was. I was so deeply unaware that I just had no idea of all these different pieces, the different parts, and how they all begin to work together. And I'm not professing to know everything about it right now.
SPEAKER_02I know I'm aware of what I don't know. So at least I can address the gaps in knowledge.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, uh just uh just profound. I mean, uh, the money script that um it's okay to um overspend, you know, that that's just normal, that debting is just the lived sense of normalcy. Uh powerful, powerful money scripts.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's what I grew up in. When we ran out of money, we borrowed. We didn't stay.
SPEAKER_01So you you got into the uh uh consumer debt program, you paid off your debts. What happened then? We got right back in debt. That's right. I thought that's what I thought you said.
SPEAKER_02We did, we did. That's when I did start it. We we did wow. So what happened? Well, we went to a first home buyer's seminar and we learned more about that, and I simply became fascinated with learning more and more about money. I joined, um, I found AFCPE. This this this was the early days of the internet, and so I was just hunting around for financial education on the web, and I ran across AFCPE.
SPEAKER_02And oh, I thought I had died and gone to heaven. Oh, that was just exactly the organization for me. And I reached out to Dottie Bagwell. I don't know if you know who she is, but she's part of the financial education, financial therapy association. So I'm a member too. Um, she has a married name, and I forget her married name because I knew her for so long as Dottie Bagwell, but she also worked with CCCS.
SPEAKER_02And so I reached out to her and we had a great conversation. I joined AFCPE, got on the board and eventually became president and got became very, very active within AFCPE. I was part of the first committee to write the first formal certification exam. So I'm really wow that was. You were before the AFP, right? Yeah, well, no, not exactly.
SPEAKER_02I I was I was pretty new, but we had been we had been using a certification exam that was not accredited by an accreditation body, and so I was part of that first committee to get the exam certified. Wow, it was fun, it was hard, and it was fun. Dottie um Christy Archelletta was on that group. Oh, really? She was part of that committee, and then a bunch of other good folks.
SPEAKER_02If I call their names, you'd probably know. But I did a lot of work with AFCPE and am still a member, and I am still I still hold my certification. So I learned a lot in that group, learned more of what I didn't know. Um, and then I applied for a scholarship with the College for Financial Planning and got that full scholarship to the College for Financial Planning to work on that second master's.
SPEAKER_02I fully expected to get that scholarship when I applied. It got to the point where I would call and leave messages. Hello, this is me. When are you gonna award that scholarship? And then when I finally got the word in the mail, I just jumped up and down and screamed and ran across the post, ran around the post office. You know, I had the P.O. box, ran around the post office, just I was so, so excited.
SPEAKER_02And then I learned a whole lot in that program too. So it's been a journey and um the journey continues.
SPEAKER_01Nice. When did you when did that happen? When did you get your when did you start your uh master's in financial planning?
SPEAKER_02Um, I'd say about 2004. I completed it in 2007.
SPEAKER_01Okay. I think oh I forget when I I got in. Oh, I I think I got in around um 1992-ish, maybe 93, and it took me six years and 50 weeks to complete it because you had to have it done in seven.
SPEAKER_02That's true, right? That's true. You have to have it done.
SPEAKER_01I pushed it within two weeks, or you would have to start all over, or you would have to start all over.
SPEAKER_02All of the money, all of the time, all of the effort, new textbooks, textbooks keep changing. You did that right within two weeks.
SPEAKER_01Two weeks. It's like, oh my god. Oh, that is such a fascinating trail to have been president of the uh of the AFCPE and being involved in that uh uh getting the certification approved. Um uh I mean what uh what a career now as you traveled this career, what was your vocation?
SPEAKER_02I put together a lot of things, mostly teaching. Okay. Teaching. And it's in the classroom where I delivered personal finance concepts, helping the people that were right in front of me learn more about money. I was also regional recruiter and regional trainer for ah, you remember kinko's, don't you, Rick?
SPEAKER_01Yep, I do remember kinko's.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, the 20-somethings do not remember kinko's anymore. They know FedEx office, but they never knew a Kinko, and they never knew of the business Kinko's. So I was the regional recruiter and the regional trainer for all of Kinko's in Houston and and Beaumont, Texas. So that was a very huge area to work with.
SPEAKER_02And so as part of the training classes, I would offer personal finance tips.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow. Wow, to the to the employees of Kinko's.
SPEAKER_02Yes, taught them about their 401k, taught them about saving in general, staying out of debt. Because you know, the cash handlers want to handle more than the their paycheck, you know, the in the registers and all, they want to handle more. And so we talked about those things. Um, we talked about credit, um, just a lot. And if they they usually had way more questions about the money aspects than we ever had time for.
SPEAKER_02So I taught them. I also taught GED classes, I taught at the community colleges. There's only one community college in the Houston area that I did not teach in, and that was Wharton. But I did um a whole lot of teaching. Um, it's been so long ago that I can't think of everything I did, but a lot of work. I also worked for an employee assistance program, teaching personal finance classes. Believe it or not, we taught at Enron.
SPEAKER_02And we told them to yes, we taught it Enron, the crooked E. And so um we went in and did the seminars, lunchtime seminars, and we begged them to please diversify your savings. Well, why should I do that? It's doing just fine. And then a few months, a couple of years later, they were going out of the building with boxes. So taught at the University of Texas at Houston Medical School.
SPEAKER_02I was director of communications for the Foundation for Financial Literacy for a few years. And that's when I discovered AFCPE. That was a lot of fun too. I even went to the Texas Education Agency to beg them to please include personal finance in the curriculum. And that was like maybe even 2005 or somewhere back there.
SPEAKER_02Um they approved it, but they didn't fund it. Wow. Yeah. So it's it's been a fun ride. It's been a bumpy ride. And um I wish I knew the lives I might have touched along the way. You know my favorite quote: you can count the seeds in an apple, but you cannot count the apples in a seed. So I would really like to know if I had any impact at all, but it really doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_02If I had some impact on helping someone somewhere lead a smoother financial life, then that is deeply gratifying.
SPEAKER_01That's uh that's a pretty profound quote. And uh it takes me to a um a scripture that says that, and I'm gonna paraphrase this, uh that the the student needs to return to the teacher and let the teacher know the impact that they've had on them. And I thought about that, yeah, you have no idea of knowing unless that is communicated to you in some form or fashion, right?
SPEAKER_01And what a gift it is to return to your mentors, to your teachers, and say, let me tell you how this statement, how that class, how that moment impacted me.
SPEAKER_02Wow. You know, I haven't done enough of that myself.
SPEAKER_01Well, and I was thinking there's probably some seeds of yours that you need to hear from them. If any of those seeds are listening, give PJ a call.
SPEAKER_02Once in a while I do run into somebody here and there and they they say something.
SPEAKER_01It's profound, and I I'm going off on a bit of a tangent, but it's like when I when there's an artist, a musician, maybe, and I'm moved by their music. And let's say that they're relatively well known, they're good. And these and I communicate, you know, that just so moves me. I just so much appreciate your music, blah, blah, blah. Almost to a person. It's like it's the first time they've ever heard this. Like, oh, really?
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow. Thank you. And I'm like, has anybody ever told you that before? And maybe, maybe they have heard it enough they've learned how to receive. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, this is a bit of a tangent, and I'll make it brief. My my husband um was program director at Atlantis Jazz Station, WCLK. And so he ran into many, many artists and booked concerts and all of that, and he would say that to people, and some people would be shocked, just outright shocked, that he knew who they were and what they played and who they played with, and all of that.
SPEAKER_02And I think you bring up another core belief that so many of us feel like we're not good enough.
SPEAKER_00Not enough.
SPEAKER_02Not enough, not good enough, which is how I've often felt. And I know there's still a trace of that. Um mostly though, I feel like I'm at 51%. One of my mentors says you don't have to get a hundred percent of the vote. I mean, it might be a sore spot these days, but you don't have to get a hundred percent of the vote to win the election. All it takes is 51% more belief than not.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. PJ, we are up against time. How can somebody get a hold of you?
SPEAKER_02Well, I'm in the process of rebuilding my website. So I'm thinking um reach out to PJ Gunter at PJgunter.com. Reach out to PJ at pjgunter.com.
SPEAKER_01Excellent. Okay. Yeah. Thank you so much. And would you be willing to uh come back and continue our conversation? I would absolutely love that if we have more to talk about. Oh, I wonder. Well, maybe we'll give it a try. Thank you so much, PJ.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Rick.
SPEAKER_01Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_02Bye.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for joining me, Rick Kaylor, for another episode of Financial Therapy. It's not just about the money. This is where I combine the nuts and bolts of financial advice with the emotions that drive making them. Remember, every financial behavior, whether it appears illogical to you or others, makes perfect sense when we understand the underlying beliefs, feelings, and thoughts. Sign up for my weekly blog at financialawakenings.com.
SPEAKER_01I hope you'll join me again for our next episode.
PJ Gunter spent 23 years in school and came out not knowing what she didn't know about money. In this second conversation with Rick Kahler, she gets into what it actually cost her to step out of that - the anger, the...
Most financial planners want the tools first. Give me the exercises, the frameworks, the scripts. Breanna Blaney says that impulse is the exact thing holding them back. In this conversation with Rick Kahler, Blaney lays...
Breanna Blaney spent years at war with herself - one side chasing money in private equity, the other on a meditation cushion wondering if any of it mattered. That tension broke open when she looked around at clients who...
Every time a caregiver sets something aside to deal with later, a box gets added to the attic. Then the garage. Then the crawlspace. Then the storage unit down the street. In this conversation with Rick Kahler, death...
Nobody on a first date asks about money scripts. But according to Dr. Kristine Anthes, that silence is where relationships start breaking down. In this follow-up conversation with Rick Kahler, Kristine gets into the...