Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Everyday Trainer Podcast

The Everyday Trainer Podcast artwork

Follow the Sun: What Dogs in the Wild Know About Rest

Nov 20, 20261 hr 2 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Your dog’s “behavior problems” might be a sleep problem wearing a disguise. I’m talking about the circadian rhythm that decides when your dog feels alert, when their nervous system can settle, and when their brain does the housekeeping that makes training actually stick. When that rhythm gets blurred by chaotic schedules, endless stimulation, and bright evenings, we often see the fallout as puppy biting after dinner, nonstop pacing, crate screaming, leash reactivity, and a dog who looks wired even in a quiet house. I share what I see when I’m living outdoors with dogs and very little light pollution: big energy and focus in the morning, lots of short naps throughout the day, then a clean wind-down as the sun drops. Then we connect that real-world pattern to dog sleep research, including what we know about polyphasic sleep, deeper night sleep, and why post-training rest supports sleep-dependent memory consolidation. We also talk about the “Monday dog,” why stressed dogs may sleep differently, and what changes in sleep can look like for senior dogs, including signs that deserve a vet chat. Next, we get practical. I walk you through my anchor load recover framework to structure a dog’s day with intentional activity blocks and real recovery, plus how to protect the midday lull and build a calmer sundown routine with lower lights, slower evening walks, and consistent bedtime cues. If you’re trying to teach settle, improve impulse control, or help a reactive dog come down faster, this one gives you a plan you can start today. Subscribe, share this with a dog friend, and leave a review. What does your dog do between 7 pm and bedtime? Visit us on the website here to see what we've got going on and how you can join our pack of good dogs and owners.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, hello, and welcome back to the Everyday Trainer Podcast. My name is Meg, and I am a dog trainer. Today we're talking about something that I think is the most underrated piece of behavior work out there: your dog's sleep and wake cycle, their circadian rhythm, the internal clock that decides when they're alert, when they're sleepy, when their brain does its housekeeping and repairing, and honestly, a lot of how they behave on any given day.

SPEAKER_00You know the drill. Grab yourself a tasty drink and meet me back here. Hey guys, welcome back. It's been a little bit, Took a little bit of a hiatus, but we're back. While I was on my hiatus, I actually spent a lot of time out in the wild with a whole bunch of dogs.

SPEAKER_00So we're gonna talk a little bit about that, what I saw when I was out in the middle of nowhere, and how it benefited me and the dogs. Circadian rhythm. We're talking about the sun in the morning and our sleep at night. All of it plays a huge role in ours and our dogs' behavior. So here's why I wanted to do this episode. A huge number of the dogs that I get called in for you know, the puppy who bites everything after dinner, the young dog who can't walk on a leash, the dog who just cannot settle in the house, the dog who's screaming in the crate, those dogs don't have a training problem.

SPEAKER_00They have a sleep and rest problem. Their day has no shape and no structure. And when a dog's day has no shape, you see it in their behavior. You've heard all the things. A tired dog is a good dog, and I'm gonna push back on that a little bit because there's a big difference between a tired dog and a rested dog. And most of the dogs I see are tired. Very few are rested.

SPEAKER_00So here's what we're gonna cover. First, I'm gonna tell you what I see in the dogs when we're out in nature and how different that looks from what I see in homes, especially being in on the outskirts of a relatively big city. Prior to where we're at now, I was in Orlando, which is also like city. And then we're gonna get into the research because there's some really good science on how dogs structure their day, and it lines up with what I see when I'm on these camping trips almost perfectly, like right up until the sun goes down.

SPEAKER_00So we'll talk about where the science falls short because it definitely does. I broke down a couple of the other studies previously, and there's not a lot of research out there on dogs. Um, and then we'll also talk about in our modern homes, our lights, our screens, how could that affect our dog's natural rhythm? And then how can we create our dog's day so that it's good for them and their well-being?

SPEAKER_00All right, let's start. So, what do I see from dogs in the wild? A lot of you know that I spend a good of my a good amount of my time outdoors. I am one of the very few people that actually gets to go live in the forest for a period of time and like be a complete dirt bag. It's like my favorite time ever. When I lived in the van full time for, you know, I think we did it for two years, two and a half years.

SPEAKER_00We did it for about two years. Um, I didn't get to spend all of my time out in nature. I think like in an ideal world, we would go on some national forest land and be forest creatures and live me and Toma and all of the dogs, and it would be great. And we would go to bed at 7 p.m. because that's when the sun sets, and we would wake up when the sun rises and go on a nice hike every morning. But that's not really what full-time van life was for me because so many of our obligations required other human beings.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, we had to like train dogs and like be in the city. We definitely got some tastes of that for sure. We're very fortunate that that is our lives. But now that I have the facility, I can kind of live this double life and I live in the city, and then I can also go and live in the middle of nowhere with all of my dogs in the van with like very little light pollution. So let me kind of paint the picture for you of what that day looks like.

SPEAKER_00So morning is when we're most active. As soon as there is light, the dogs are waking me up. They're whining, they're ready to go. Stony, especially, he's got that little cattle dog scream. The light of the sun peaks up just a little bit, and he's already screaming at me to get out. So the dogs are not lazy about it. They are ready to go. The morning time is actually when they have the most energy. They're sniffing everything. This is when we're doing our off-leash walks.

SPEAKER_00They're, you know, probably running like double the distance that I am, because they'll run far out and then they'll run back. They're checking in with everybody, they're wrestling each other. Like this is when they have the most energy. And honestly, they have the most focus too. So if I want to work on something with a dog when I'm out in the middle of nowhere, morning is oftentimes when I will do it. Then as the day goes on, we kind of shift, they start resting, and it's not one long nap like we'd take.

SPEAKER_00It's a lot of little ones. The dogs will find a patch of shade, they'll lay down, they'll doze away for a while, they'll get up, they'll kind of come and check in, they'll go and sniff something, and then they'll go lay right back down. And they do this all day long. They're just cycling, like, okay, I'm gonna get up, do some things, okay, I'm gonna come back, lay down, a little bit of rest. Nobody is telling them to do that. I'm not really crating them. There's no go to your place.

SPEAKER_00They are self-regulating and they know when they need to recharge and they do it. And then as the sun starts going down, they go down with it. Their movement gets slower, they're lazier, they start hanging out like closer to the vans, closer to us. And by the time it's dark, the dogs are done for the day. Even if it gets dark at 7 p.m., most of the dogs are like, all right, I'm good, put me in the van, let's go to bed.

SPEAKER_00There's no like second wind down at like 10 o'clock, like how it is when we live in the city in like regular people lives. There's no zoomies, like the day is over, they know it, they're loading up, they want to go to bed. So the thing that strikes me the most every single time is how easy rest is out there, like out in the middle of nowhere. Like, why is it that the dogs settle so nicely?

SPEAKER_00And I've had dogs who at home cannot settle, and their owners tell me that they pace and whine and they follow people from room to rune, and they can't lay down for more than a couple of minutes. And then I get them outdoors and on this routine, and these same dogs lie down without being asked. So, why does it work out there? And I've thought about this a lot, and I think it comes down to a couple things.

SPEAKER_00So, one, the cues are very clear. The lights come up, the lights go down, there's nothing confusing about what time it is. We're spending so much time outside. So they know that as soon as the lights, the light sun comes up, our day is starting and we're going into our routine. Two, there's nothing artificial pulling them back into activity. So there's no doorbells, there's no TVs or delivery trucks, there's no kids coming home from school at 3:30, no person walking in the door with a bunch of energy.

SPEAKER_00And the last thing is they're with their people in a calm, predictable way. So it's usually me and Toma or me and my friend Lex, and we're there, we're relaxed, we're not rushing anywhere. Like there is predictability in my behavior as well. So that is a big deal for dogs, and structure is very important for them. And out there, when we're out in the forest or the desert, the structure comes from nature itself.

SPEAKER_00So now let's talk about what I see in homes because this is kind of where it falls apart. Let's start with simply an overtired puppy. I see this all the time. And I want to be very clear because owners get this backwards. An overtired puppy does not look sleepy. An overtired puppy looks wild. It's like that fussy toddler that doesn't want to take a nap. They're getting zoomies, they're biting your hands, they're biting pipe pant legs, they're biting the leash, they're ignoring you, they're ignoring things that you definitely know that they know.

SPEAKER_00They're barking at you, and a lot of people read these dogs and they think, oh, he has too much energy, he needs more exercise. So they add another walk or they add another play session, and the puppy gets worse. Because what that puppy actually needed was a nap. And, you know, we see this literally every single day. I would say the the biggest thing that I do with dogs is teach them how to settle. I'm really slowing them down in every aspect of their day.

SPEAKER_00When we walk up to the front door to go for a walk, I have them sit and wait and check in with me. And I wait for calm. And then we do our walking drills that are the beginning of our walk, you know? So this isn't to say that you need to go live out in the middle of nowhere to solve these problems, but there are some things that we can do, like giving our dogs some structured downtime to make sure that they don't become this, you know, overtired dog.

SPEAKER_00So then there's the younger dogs who just can't turn it off. Not puppies, but they're kind of like the in-between. These are the dogs that I see go from one thing to the next all day long. They are going to daycare, they're going to dog parks, they say hi to everybody on the walk. Um, if somebody's sitting on the couch, they're like jumping up on them, they're like tossing their toys at them to get them play to play, they won't stop.

SPEAKER_00And the dog is never told to just sit and chill and do nothing. And so this level of arousal is just cumulative. It never gets a chance to come down and it just stacks up over and over and over again. So by the time you've reached evening, you've got a crazy dog who's maybe barking at the leash or barking at the leash, barking on the leash. So leash reactivity, barking out the window, jumping on the couch, just like being a bit of a menace and can't settle anywhere.

SPEAKER_00And then there's what I like to call the Monday dog. The dog who has a really big weekend, and maybe you had a bunch of people over, or you took your dog out all weekend. You did a long hike on Saturday and Sunday, you took your dog to a brewery, coffee shop. You did so much with them on those two days that Monday comes and the dog comes to us either totally flat or just like doesn't want to do anything.

SPEAKER_00And the work that we did last week, we kind of have to like give that dog a day to rest because they did too many classes or they did too many things over the weekend. So that is the dog that is kind of running on empty on that day. And so we need to be able to recognize that and go, okay, this dog, this dog needs some rest in their days. And that's kind of why it's important to implement that balance of maybe we don't throw too many activities at our dogs on the weekends and kind of spread that out throughout the week so that we don't have that dog that has to decompress afterwards.

SPEAKER_00I, as an introvert, I am I am that dog. I have to go and sit in a dark, quiet room if I do too much extroverting. And then I also have the senior dogs who are pacing at two in the morning. Um, that is definitely Zoe sometimes. If I mess up her sleep schedule, and you know, I have a few other clients, these owners will call their dogs just restless. And sometimes it is, but often that's a sleep wake cycle that's shifted, and it can be an early sign of cognitive changes.

SPEAKER_00So one of the things that I do with Zoe is I don't allow her to sleep all day as an older dog. She's gonna turn 15 or sorry, 14 at the beginning of next year. If I let her, she will sleep all day and wake up at like 3 a.m. and just wander around. So it's my job to kind of make sure that she's on a good schedule so that she doesn't get doggy dementia and just be a crazy gal.

SPEAKER_00But what do all of these dogs have in common? Their day doesn't have enough structure. There's no predictable wake-up time, there's no predictable rest, there's no winding down in the evening. The day is just kind of happening, and I think a lot of us live this way as well. We just are rushing from one thing to the next, and we're in this constant state of rushing, rushing, rushing, and our dogs are just following our lead.

SPEAKER_00And this is something that I am very intentional about at our facility at the Good Dog Club. Our day training dogs, our board and train dogs, like all our personal dogs, are all on the same routine. In that in the morning, we wake up, we get outside, we do our long walks, we come back, they get structured downtime in the crates. We'll do individual training sessions, work on individual stuff, and then they go back into the crate.

SPEAKER_00And we'll do another active session and then they go back into the crate. And that is the thing that I probably get the most pushback for, is you know, when I'm talking to people on the phone and they're like, Well, are the dogs crated? Yes, the dogs are created. And I'll usually just kind of pause there. Well, how long are they created for? So I explain to them we do activity and then structured downtime, and then activity and then structured downtime.

SPEAKER_00The dogs need the structure in the routine and the schedule, but we also want to make sure that we're fulfilling them properly. So outside of our long walk, they get short focused sessions and then they get genuine downtime in the crate. And we teach the dogs that that downtime is when you get to shut off your little doggy brain because that is what I've learned is that you can be in the training room or on the trail out in the middle of nowhere.

SPEAKER_00Rest isn't the absence of training, rest is part of the training. So is what I'm seeing out in the wild real, or am I just romanticizing a bunch of happy dogs napping under a tree? Well, it turns out the research lines up with what I'm thinking pretty closely. Right up until the sun goes down.

SPEAKER_00So here's what the science gets right. The dogs are built on two-peak rhythm. Let's start with the big picture. Dogs have a circadian rhythm, just like we do, a roughly 24-hour internal clock. And in a lot of ways, theirs looks like ours. They're awake during the day and they do most of their sleeping at night. The difference is how they sleep. We tend to sleep in one big block while dogs are what researchers call polyphasic sleepers, and that just means that their sleep comes in pieces.

SPEAKER_00Active rest. Sorry. Active rest, active rest all throughout the day and night. And this is exactly what I see with the dogs when I take them out of nature. So I want to walk you through the two studies that I think are kind of the backbone of this whole conversation. The first one comes out of Budapest from a group called the Family Dog Project. And if you follow dog cognition research at all, which I'm just now kind of getting into this, you've probably heard of them.

SPEAKER_00They're the ones who are doing a lot of this research on dogs. They've done more dog sleep research than pretty much anyone. In 2018, they published a study looking at 16 family dogs. And these were actual pets, uh, ages ranging from one and a half to seven, 10 different breeds. They recorded the dog's brain activity while they slept using electrodes that just stick onto the head. They're not doing surgery or anything invasive. And they compared three things sleeping during the day versus at night, sleeping after an active day versus a quiet day, and sleeping at home versus somewhere unfamiliar.

SPEAKER_00So here's what they found. First, night sleep is real sleep. At night, dogs slept longer, spent less time in that drowsy in-between stage. They woke up less and got more deep sleep and more REM sleep. So, yes, dogs nap all day, but those daytime naps are lighter. The deep recovery happens at night. Second, a good active day buys better sleep. After an active day, dogs slept more, got drowsy faster, dropped into deep sleep sooner, and got more deep sleep and REM.

SPEAKER_00So activity does matter. And I'm not telling you not to exercise your dog. I'm telling you to exercise. Exercise is like the setup for good sleep, and the good sleep is the payoff. Okay, third. And I think this one is very important for those of us who board dogs or travel with dogs or run a facility. When dogs slept somewhere unfamiliar, they were less likely to make it into REM sleep after their first round of deep sleep.

SPEAKER_00So a dog can lay down in a new place, close their eyes, and look asleep and still not be getting the full sleep cycles. And this is something that we're really big on here at the facility is I want to make sure that we wind down in the evening. We don't have the big lights on, we have our nighttime routine and set the dogs up for as successful sleep as possible. Now, the second study and Uh, this is the one that I really want you guys to remember.

SPEAKER_00It came out of North Carolina State University in 2020, led by Dr. Margaret Gruen, who is a veterinary behaviorist there. And I love why they did it. Dr. Gruen basically said that research on dog sleep had gotten ahead of our basic knowledge of what a normal sleep wake cycle even looks like. The studies people kept citing were more than 20 years old. Sounds familiar as far as dog research goes.

SPEAKER_00And they used only a few dogs, or they used dogs that didn't live in homes. So we're talking about like abnormal dog sleep without a clear picture of what normal actually is. They took 42 healthy dogs, 21 males and 21 females, ages two to eight, all living in homes, and put activity monitors on their collars for about two weeks around the clock. And the owners also filled out a questionnaire about the dog's sleep.

SPEAKER_00Here's what they found. Most dogs had two activity peaks a day, a shorter one in the morning, roughly 8 to 10 a.m. Then a dip in the middle of the day, then a longer active period from about 5 to 11 p.m. So we've got morning peak, midday lull, second peak is later in the day, and that's the general shape of a dog's day. They found a few other things I think you guys will find interesting.

SPEAKER_00Every single dog was more active on weekends than on weekdays. So think about that next time you've got a sleepy dog on Monday. Female dogs were more active than males during that evening peak. Smaller, lighter dogs tended to have a little burst of activity just after midnight. So if you have a small dog doing laps at 1215, they're not the only one. And older dogs were less active during the peaks, even in that two to eight range.

SPEAKER_00So aging shows up earlier than most people think, and it shows up at the peaks. And here's the line from that study that I want you guys to remember because we're going to come back to it. The researchers noticed the dogs were most active when their people were around, and they linked that to the fact that most of the owners worked outside of the home. So hang on to that. Now, this two-peak pattern isn't unique to pet dogs.

SPEAKER_00Researchers in India have spent years studying free-ranging dogs and street dogs who live around people but aren't anybody's pets. They found those dogs spend about half their time resting. And when they set up their observations, they actually skipped the middle of the day because that's when the dogs are resting out of the heat. And if you go all the way back to like wolves, wild wolves show a two-peak pattern as well, which peaks around dawn and dusk. And that's kind of the blueprint that our dogs started from.

SPEAKER_00So the morning peak and midday lull, science, street dogs, wolves, and my dogs out in the middle of nowhere all agree on that. So sleep is when learning gets locked in. Dogs are built to rest in pieces throughout the day, but why does that rest actually matter so much? Especially in dog training. This is where it gets kind of cool for us trainers. So in 2017, that same group in Budapest ran a study where they taught dogs a new set of command words.

SPEAKER_00And then they recorded the dog's brains while they napped afterwards. Two things came out of that. First, learning actually changed what the dog's brains did during sleep. And second, certain features of that sleep predicted how much better the dog performed afterwards. They also compared dogs who slept after learning to dogs who stayed busy doing other things. And what the dog did in that window after training affected how well they held on to it, both short term and long term.

SPEAKER_00The researchers called it the first evidence that dog's learning is tied to what's called sleep-dependent memory consolidation. That is the process where the brain takes something you learned today and files it away so that you keep it. A follow-up study looked at something called sleep spindles. These are short bursts of brain activity during sleep, during deep sleep. I'll specify that.

SPEAKER_00That in people and rats are tied to memory. And in dogs, the more spindles a dog had, the more it learned. They also found that female dogs had more spindles and learned more. Around a third of the female dogs learned the new words compared to about 10% of the male dogs. That is a big difference, guys. Girl dogs are superior. So here's how I want you guys to think about this.

SPEAKER_00The training session isn't just the little 10-minute, 15-minute session, and it doesn't end when you put your treat pouch away. The nap after is part of the session. So if you do a great training session and then you take your dog straight to the dog park, you may be getting rid of that part where the learning actually sticks. The Budapest group did another study, and I think about this one all the time.

SPEAKER_00They gave dogs either a positive experience right before a nap, things like getting pets or playing fetch, doing something with their owner, or a negative one, like being tied to a door and ignored by their owner, or having a stranger stare at them, which I think is so funny. And then they watched how the dogs slept. After the negative experience, dogs actually fell asleep faster. The researchers think that's protective, a way of escaping a stressful situation, but the quality of the sleep changed.

SPEAKER_00They got less deep sleep. So the lead researcher on that, Dr. Anna Kiss, said something I think that, I mean, sounds right. An occasional bad day isn't the problem. But if it happens over and over, poor quality sleep could get in the way of a dog consolidating memories and processing emotions. I don't think too many of you are putting your dogs in too stressful of situations. I would say it's probably the opposite. So let's think about this loop.

SPEAKER_00Stress goes in, sleep gets worse. Worse sleeps mean the dogs learn less and they can cope less, which means more stress. And that's that dog that can't settle. That's the dog who's been in a chaotic home. And breaking the loop is often the fastest behavior win that I can get as a behavioral mod trainer.

SPEAKER_00So this shows up in shelter research too. A 2016 study looked at shelter dogs and found that dogs who rested more during the day showed better welfare indicators. Another study compared shelter dogs to pet dogs at home and found shelter dogs were more active at night and had higher stress hormone levels, especially in their first few nights. Both of those came down as the dogs adjusted. And there's a study I love where shelter dogs went on overnight sleepovers with foster families.

SPEAKER_00During those sleepovers, they had their longest stretches of rest of the whole study and their stress hormones dropped. So here's the takeaway: a dog who can settle and rest during the day is usually a dog who feels safe. And a dog who can't might be telling you something. Now, how does aging show up in this sleep wake cycle? I've got a 13-year-old gal, so I really wanted to kind of dive into this as well.

SPEAKER_00The last piece of the science, and this is for anybody who has a senior dog, a 2016 study looked at older dogs 9 to 16 years old, and found that dogs who napped more during the day tended to have poorer memory, and dogs who are more active early in the morning tended to have better memory and learning. Morning mattered even for old dogs. And in 2023, the NC State team ran full sleep studies on 28 senior dogs.

SPEAKER_00The more advanced a dog's cognitive decline, the less time it spent in both deep sleep and REM. And when they looked at the brain activity of those dogs while they slept, it looked closer to being awake, and they weren't actually sleeping very deeply at all. Changes in the sleep wake cycle are one of the recognized signs of canine cognitive dysfunction, which is basically the dog version of dementia, along with disorientation, changes in how they interact with you, accidents in the house, changes in activity or anxiety.

SPEAKER_00So if your senior dog is suddenly up all night, it's obviously worth a vet visit, but there's some things that we can do. For me with Zoe, I keep her up during the day. I obviously let her nap sometimes. Like she's an old lady, she needs the rest, but I'm still very, very active with her. And I think this helps her sleep throughout the night. So some days, if I allow her to sleep all day, at night she's up at 2 a.m.

SPEAKER_00wandering the premises. So all of that research sounds good, right? Dogs are built on two peak rhythm, the sleep locks in learning, stress messes with the sleep, and it matters even more as they age. But before anybody runs off and starts quoting these numbers, I want to talk about what these studies actually measured because the picture is smaller than like the headlines of these studies make it sound.

SPEAKER_00So the sundown gap and where the science falls short. The NC state study, the morning peak from 8 to 10 midday lull, and then a second uh longer peak from 5 to 11 p.m. So that like active time twice during the day. Now think back to what I described in the wild, the morning peak, yes, midday naps, yes. But in the evening, my dogs are winding down with the light, and by dark they're done.

SPEAKER_00They're not peaking until 11 at night. So which one is most natural? Um, here's my take. The NC State study measured what dog, what pet dogs do. It didn't measure what dogs are built to do, and those are two very different things. And the researchers kind of told us themselves. Um, so remember, I asked you to remember something. The dogs were most active when their people were around, and most of those people worked outside of the home.

SPEAKER_00So 5 to 11 p.m. is when people get home. That's the walk after work, that's dinner, that's the kids coming home and running around. It's the TV on and the lights until bedtime. And on weekends, when people are home all day, eve every dog in that study was more active. So the dog's day mirrors the owner. And there's more evidence for this. Those street dogs in India, the researchers found they stay active when the people around them are active.

SPEAKER_00And there's a study comparing wolves and dogs who are raised and socialized exactly the same way, and human presence drove the dog's activity more than the wolves. The researchers concluded that people are a bigger timekeeper for dogs than for wolves. Our dogs set their clocks by us. So when someone tells you it's normal for dogs to be wired at 9 p.m., I'd say it's typical. It's what happens to dogs living in very modern worlds, but that doesn't automatically make it healthy or ideal.

SPEAKER_00And I want to be fair, nobody has actually tested any of this, whether shifting a pet um evening back towards like sun down, wind down improves their sleep or their behavior. That's like a big gap in the research and something that I would really love to get into. But I've watched it happen enough outdoors with a whole bunch of dogs that I'm kind of willing to say, to say that part out loud, that it seems like dogs should be winding down with the sun.

SPEAKER_00So, what's the biggest difference between my dogs out in the van in the middle of nowhere at sunset and a dog in a living room at sunset? It's mostly the lights outdoor, outside, it gets dark, and indoors, it obviously doesn't. We flip on the lamps, the overhead lights, god forbid, the TV, and we carry our little phones with us everywhere. There's really good research on what that does to people.

SPEAKER_00In a 2011 study out of Harvard and Brigham in Women's Health Hospital, researchers took 116 healthy young adults and had them spend eight hours before bed in either normal room light or dim light for five days. In room light, their melatonin, which is the hormone that tells your body it's time to sleep, lasted about 90 minutes less than in dim light. The researchers said that regularly keeping the lights on in the late evening disrupts melatonin and could affect sleep, body temperature, blood pressure, and blood sugar.

SPEAKER_00And this wasn't like a super crazy bright light. This was a regular living room light. A 2015 study compared people reading on a tablet before bed to people reading a printed book. The tablet readers took longer to fall asleep, felt less sleepy sleepy at night, made less melatonin, had their body clocks pushed later, and were less alert in the morning. Very interesting. So to be fair, a Stanford sleep researcher pointed out that in real life we get a lot more light during the day than people did in that study.

SPEAKER_00And that probably makes us less sensitive to light at night. So the real world effect might actually be smaller, but these sorts of studies are kind of pointing us in the right direction. So, what does the research show about animals? There's a lab in Ohio State that studied this for years. They exposed hamsters to dim light at night, not bright light. This is about five lux, which they compared to having a TV on in a dark room.

SPEAKER_00And those hamsters developed depression-like behavior and actually changes in their brains. The same lab linked light at night to weight gain in mice. But the hopeful part is that when they put those hamsters back on a normal light and dark schedule, the symptoms basically went away in about two weeks and the brain changes reverse. I love that because that's the same message that I give all of my dog owners in that this is very flexible.

SPEAKER_00We don't have to be perfect all the time. Your dog is not gonna go into psychosis if we keep them up late one night. And, you know, these studies are done on rodents, but it's not just rodents. They did some studies on crows, dim light at night lowered their melatonin and hurt their performance on problem-solving tasks. And a big review out of Germany found that even the faint glow from city lights in the night sky is enough to suppress melatonin across a bunch of different animals.

SPEAKER_00So what about dogs? And honestly, we don't really know. The one study that I found that looked directly at dogs and light at night was in a shelter. And it was just 10 dogs that were filmed overnight, some nights with their pens lit, and some nights it was dark and their sleep didn't really change. Either way. But the details on that is those dogs were walked twice a day and had tons of enrichment and music during the day.

SPEAKER_00It was 10 dogs, and they measured sleep by watching the video, not by any melatonin or brain activity or like sleep quality. They just looked at if the dogs were laying down. So I'm not gonna stand here and tell you that you're okay. Now let's talk about the limitations of the research overall, because I promised you I would, and I think this is where experienced trainers have something real to add.

SPEAKER_00First, the sample sizes in these studies are abysmal. They are so small. Most of the dog sleep studies that use brain recordings have used somewhere between seven and 16 dogs, and the recordings were usually scored by one person. When researchers had three experts score the same recordings, they didn't fully agree on the sleep stages. And that doesn't make the research wrong.

SPEAKER_00It just means that we're very early in learning about dogs' sleep and behavior in this way. And dogs learn, quote, dogs learn better after sleep is a strong, it's like a strong idea, you know, but we don't really know. There's not that much research out there on dogs. A lot of what everyone knows about dog sleep is old.

SPEAKER_00So the NC State team pointed out that most of the cited dog sleep study from 1993 looked at 24 dogs and 18 of them were only filmed at night. So when you see that dogs need 12 to 14 hours of sleep, ask where that number came from. Nobody has built a solid chart for how much sleep dogs need by what age, breed, and lifestyle. There's just not enough science out there. And then lastly, something that we should kind of take away from all of this research is the lab dogs are your average pet dogs.

SPEAKER_00So a lot of the research on aging and circadian rhythms used dogs living in research colonies on a perfect 12 hours of light and 12 hours of dark. Your dog lives lamps on until midnight, you know, TV, kids, maybe a partner who works at night and weekends that look very different than your weekdays. So a nap in the lab is not a night at home.

SPEAKER_00The learning and stress studies measured an afternoon nap in an unfamiliar room with electrodes on the dogs and the owners sitting right there. That's like it's how the studies have to be done, but it's not giving us a perfect picture of what life looks like in the home. And this is kind of the next thing that really matters to me. To do these studies, you need a dog calm enough to wear electrodes and fall asleep in a strange place.

SPEAKER_00So in the NC State senior dog study, sessions were stopped if a dog got anxious and only about half the dogs ever made it into REM sleep. So think about the dogs who are getting filtered out. Literally the anxious dogs, the reactive dogs, the dogs who can't settle, which is exactly the dogs that I work with every single day. So the research. Is very limited on the dogs who actually need it the most.

SPEAKER_00Also, last or sorry, second and last thing, what owners report and what the data shows don't always match. In a study on women who shared their bed with dogs, the dog's movement tripled the chances the woman would shift from still to moving during the night. But the woman almost never reported that their dog disturbed their sleep. So if we can't tell how our dogs affect our own sleep, we should be a little uh humble about how well we read our dog's sleep, you know?

SPEAKER_00Um, and then the last thing, and here's what all the dog trainers know that the studies just aren't capturing. Studies measure sleep. We measure the dog the next day. Nobody has connected sleep patterns to real-world outcomes like leash reactivity, impulse control, uh, how fast a dog generalizes, behaviors. And nobody has studies what happens when you deliberately build structured rest into a reactive dog's day.

SPEAKER_00Experienced trainers have been doing this for years, and we see the train, the changes in the dogs. And this is one of the most difficult things that it is that I have to convert people to is creating their dogs so that they can sleep during the day. So the science gives us some direction, but it is our job to turn it into something that you can actually do at home. So let's get into that.

SPEAKER_00Let me show you how to build a dog's day. Here's the framework. I call it anchor load recover. And the idea is to give a dog at home the same shape of the day that I see outdoors. So we have that morning peak, midday naps, and then the sundown, wind down. And you don't have to move into a van in the woods to do this.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So anchor is the morning. Morning is when dogs have the most to give. In the wild, in the research, everywhere. Okay, it says that. So let's use that. Put your hardest training here, your longest walk. Uh maybe you're going to a new place, a new trail, busy shopping center, practice around distractions.

SPEAKER_00Morning is when your dog has the most energy and the most focus. So that is when we ask the most of them. Then make the morning the same way every day. Uh, same time wake up, same time first potty, same time breakfast, and on weekends too. Um the internal clock will kind of set itself off of your consistent cues. And for dogs, food and morning activity are huge cues.

SPEAKER_00So remember that every dog in the NC state study was more active on weekends. And that swing is real. Your dog feels it. So we get them outside in the morning light, 10 minutes, you're literally telling their clock what time it is. And remember what I said about the senior dog study. More activity early in the morning went along with better memory and learning. So your mornings very much matter even into senior doggy age.

SPEAKER_00So next thing is load, load in short blocks. And this is where I want you to change how you think about exercise. So work, walks, play, training should come in focused blocks, and then they should stop. So think about that two-peak pattern of your dog's day. Your dog is not built for a 12-hour marathon. Build around their peaks instead of trying to fill every hour of their day and constantly entertain them.

SPEAKER_00And I want you to understand that exercise is not the only kind of load. So think of novelty as a new load. Maybe you go to a new coffee shop with your dog. Uh meeting new dogs or new people is a load. Uh a loud, busy house is a load. Training, doing a training session. A dog can come home from a new day at a new place and barely have moved, and it's still very tired.

SPEAKER_00So quality over quantity. A 10-minute slow, sniffy decompression walk can be worth way more than an hour of fetch that ramps your dog up and leaves them more wired than when you started. So we do little bursts of focused activity with our dogs. I'm not sitting there on my phone. I'm focused on my dog. We're doing something together. And then when I need to go back to work, when I need to do something, dogs go in the crate. They settle. So this gust gets us into recover on purpose.

SPEAKER_00And this is what most people skip. After a training session, give your dog genuine quiet rest. A crate, their place, a dark, quiet room. That's the nap that the research points to, the one where learning gets locked in in their little brain. So please don't follow a great training session with some being crazy and just letting your dog wander around the house or going to the park or, you know, like give them that downtime and teach settling as a skill.

SPEAKER_00A lot of dogs genuinely do not know how to turn their little brains off. So something like place could be an off-switch cue. Crate could mean calm. And we don't use these as punishments. These are rest skills. And for a lot of dogs, especially adolescents, we have to teach them the way we teach any behavior. So how you teach settling, we can do tethering, we can create train them in small bursts at first. We can hold on a leash and sit at a bench and do nothing.

SPEAKER_00All right. Now we need to protect the midday lull. So the middle of the day should look like the middle of the day. If you're out on the in the van with me, out in the middle of nowhere, we're going to nap. We're going to rest. We're going to take frequent naps. We're going to be chill. We're not rushing. That is fewer errands, fewer visitors, less stimulation in the middle of the day, especially for our puppies.

SPEAKER_00And if your dog goes to daycare, ask them whether there's real rest built in. Not just like, oh, they get a little break, but like actually a quiet nap time. A dog going that hard for eight hours straight has lost the lull in the day completely. And you're going to definitely see that in the evening and just in their general behavior overall. So we want to follow the sundown. And this is the piece that I think almost every home is missing.

SPEAKER_00And it's the one that I learned from being a feral forest creature. As it gets dark outside, your house should get quieter. Lower the lights, use lamps instead of the overhead lights, calmer activity, no crazy games or playing fetch in the hallway or wrestling. And I know that a lot of you work all day, and the evening is your only time with your dog.

SPEAKER_00I'm not telling you to skip that, but keep the evening walk, but make it slow. Make it like a decompression walk instead of a high energy workout and move the big training and work to the morning or to the weekend. And end every night the same way. Last potty, uh, you know, chew or lick mat or dinner or whatever. Lights down, bed. Try to keep it in the same order, especially in the beginning of setting a routine, because this routine will become the cue for bedtime.

SPEAKER_00Finally, I want to give you the signs that your dog is overtired, not under exercise, because those two look a lot alike and they need they need opposite fixes. So one is mouthiness and grabbing that gets worse as the day goes on, especially in puppies. I see this all the time. We have a ton of puppy clients right now.

SPEAKER_00They're very mouthy, they're biting their owner's sleeves. These are cues that your dog is a little bit overtired. So something else to look out for is let's say your dog knows sitting down really well, and then suddenly they're not listening. They're like, no, I don't, I don't want to listen. Like overtired. Third one, reactivity that gets worse in the evening or worse after a big outing.

SPEAKER_00Four, your dog can't settle even when everything around them is quiet. So maybe they're like pacing and circling and laying down and then popping right back up. And five, this one is for the senior dogs. They're sleeping more during the day and less at night. So pacing at night, maybe they're like whining a little bit more. That's like you definitely want to have a conversation with your vet. That's not just a training one, but something to look out for.

SPEAKER_00So if you see those signs, the answer is almost never more. It's less and it's rest. So that's what we know how to do. Now let's be honest about what nobody has figured out yet. I always like to end the research part of these research episodes with what we don't know. Because I think that's where the important conversations are.

SPEAKER_00And as somebody with a science background, I really like kind of fantasizing about dog research. I think we need re more research on our dogs. There's just so much that we don't know. So, first, how much sleep does a normal pet dog actually need at eight weeks, at eight months, eight years? Does a border collie from working lines need something different than a golden retriever or a basset hound?

SPEAKER_00Researchers themselves say our basic understanding of normal dog sleep is still poorly characterized. So anybody who gives you an exact number with a bunch of confidence doesn't actually know. And there's actually no science that tells us how much sleep our dogs should be getting. Second, does better sleep actually change behavior over weeks and months?

SPEAKER_00We have studies showing that a nap helps a dog hold on to one task the same afternoon, and that is great, but nobody has followed up with these dogs in the homes and asked if we improve this dog's sleep for a month. Does the reactivity improve? Does the impulse control improve? Like we don't have that study, and I would love to see it. Third, how much, sorry guys, I have a little bit of cold. My nose is getting so stuffy. How much are our schedules reshaping our dogs' schedule?

SPEAKER_00Like the late nights and all of the lights and the screens and people being crazy at night. Nobody has actually tested what happens when dogs in these homes, sorry, nobody has actually tested what happens to the dogs in the homes when you change the lighting or evening routine. Fourth, um, this is a big one for our industry. Does the way a dog is trained or the environment it lives in ripple into that's that night's sleep and the next day's learning?

SPEAKER_00So the Budapest study showed a negative experience changes a dog's sleep that same afternoon, which like is very helpful information, but I would love to see that uh studied in a longer term, if that makes sense. Uh, the fifth point that I would like to kind of do more research into is can we slow cognitive decline in senior dogs by protecting their sleep?

SPEAKER_00Like for Zoe, I keep her up during the day. Is that actually helping her? Because she's getting better sleep at night. I don't know. We need some studies. And this one is just kind of like silly, but would be interesting to research. Is your dog sleeping in your bed good or bad for you and your dog? So all almost all of the um co-sleeping research is about how the dog affects the human sleep. And we haven't looked at the opposite.

SPEAKER_00So I'd be very interested in studying that. All right, this has been a pretty dense podcast, so I'm not gonna keep you guys too much longer, but here are the things from this episode that I want you to walk away with. So, first one, dogs are built on a two-peak rhythm, morning peak, midday lull, which is like our naps, and then a slowdown later in the day. Two, the late evening peak we see in dogs looks a lot more like our schedule than theirs.

SPEAKER_00So I would still love y'all to follow the sundown, dimmer lights, calmer evenings. It makes a difference. Three, a tired dog and a rested dog are not the same. Exhaustion without recovery makes behavior worse, not better. Four, sleep is a part of the training. Rest after a session is when learning gets locked in and a hard day changes the sleep that follows.

SPEAKER_00And five, the research is promising, but it is very small and early and limited, and we can use research in dog training as a direction and we can watch our own dog, but your own dog is always going to tell you more than any bit of a study. So if you could take away my experience, and maybe if one of your dogs is those dogs that just can't settle, or you know, they're really struggling doing nothing, they don't sleep in the crate, they're getting fussy in the evenings, you're saying, Meg, I don't know what to do, I'm struggling with behavioral issues.

SPEAKER_00Give this a try. Look at your dog's daily routine. Look at what your evening routine looks like. Look at your morning time. Are you getting the exercise in? Are you fulfilling their needs and getting them out in nature and in the sunlight? It makes a huge difference, guys. I promise. So, dog training is not just training, it's about the environment that we create for our dogs. I'll wrap it up there. Thank you so much, guys, for being here.

SPEAKER_00I really appreciate it. I will go ahead and cite the studies that I used in the show notes, and we'll see you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Proof Is In The Poo

    Sep 18, 202645 minAudio

    The pet food aisle is full of glossy promises, but when you flip the bag over, the ingredient panel can feel like a different universe. From the Superzoo show floor, we sit down with Ruby from Real Dog to unpack how she...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Predictability Changes Everything

    Sep 11, 202642 minAudio

    Randomness is brutal on a nervous system, and dogs are no exception. We come back from a much-needed “touch grass” break and dig into one of the most cited papers in the e-collar debate: the Schalke study on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Science of Motivation

    Jul 3, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    If your dog ignores treats outside, checks out on walks, or looks “unmotivated” the second distractions show up, the problem usually is not your timing or your tool. It is that the reward has no value in the moment, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Crate Training, E-Collar Accountability, And Calm Routines For Real Life

    Jun 26, 20261 hrAudio

    Leaving a four-month-old puppy loose at night can feel like the “nice” choice until it turns into chewed remotes, fence-line chaos, or a true medical emergency. We take you inside one of our weekly community calls and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. When Loving Your Dog Too Much Is Keeping Them Stuck

    Jun 12, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    Too much tenderness can look like love and still leave an anxious dog feeling unsafe. We sit down for a real virtual coaching session with a caring owner and her five-year-old Aussie doodle, Coco, and we get honest...

    Credit the people on this episode