In this episode of The Equity Effect, host Kristin Shrimplin is joined by Lever for Change leaders Dr. Cecilia Conrad (CE0), alongside Dr. Kristen J. Molyneaux, (President and Co-Founder). Together, they share their journeys from academia and education into large-scale philanthropic leadership, exploring how trust-based models, open-call investments, and bolder risk horizons can tackle humanity's most intractable global challenges.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Equity Effect. I'm Kristen Shrimplin, CEO of Women Helping Women. What if the greatest barrier to a woman's safety isn't courage? It's opportunity. Every day, women face impossible choices because they don't have the financial resources to choose another path. Housing, child care, education, health care, leadership, and safety may seem like separate conversations, but they all begin with economic opportunity.
SPEAKER_01Each episode, I'll sit down with leaders, entrepreneurs, educators, policymakers, philanthropists, and innovators who are creating practical solutions that help women thrive. Because when women have economic freedom, families are stronger, businesses grow, and communities flourish. This is the equity effect, where one conversation can create lasting change. Okay, well, welcome. I am so excited today as we focus on this episode of the equity effect.
SPEAKER_01And this title is very important, and we're going to take a deep dive into it. And it's only three words move the money. And I am beyond excited to have two guests today: Cecilia Conrad, CEO of Lever for Change, and Kristen Molyneux, president and co-founder of Lever for Change. So before they come in and speak, um, I do want to go through their backgrounds a little bit because it is so impressive, and I think we'll give some good insight to where they're at today and the impact that they are generating.
SPEAKER_01So uh Cecilia, Dr. Cecilia Conrad, is the original founding uh CEO of Lover for Change, but previously she was leader, the leader of the MacArthur Fellows Program. Before that, she spent nearly three decades in academia. She was the provost and chief academic officer of Pomona College. Kristen is the president and co-founder of Lever for Change and previously helped design and launch MacArthur's 100 in change competition.
SPEAKER_01And we'll get more into that later. Since 2019, together, they have helped direct more than, and I probably have the number wrong because it probably keeps increasing. I'm gonna say about 2.7 billion, 2.9 billion, 2.7, 2.7. I'm sure the 2.9 or the 3 billion is about to happen to more than 500 organizations across the world, and they have a very strong vision to unlocking 10 billion by 2030.
SPEAKER_01Again, we'll get to that vision later on. Cecilia and Kristen, thank you both for being here. Thank you for having us. Yeah, thank you. I'm super excited because uh for anyone who uh follows trust-based philanthropy, uh, invests in trust-based philanthropy, or is impacted by trust-based philanthropy, knows without a shadow of doubt that Lever for Change is a strategic container, strategic rocket all of its own.
SPEAKER_01And so to have the opportunity to talk uh to two of the leaders behind this movement uh is quite special uh for me. So when we uh start, I want to just kind of take us back to some of your uh origin stories and how you both got to this uh space. Because I don't believe, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, uh, that either of you started in philanthropy. So Celia, I'm really interested in your background. Uh I believe you were an economist and a college president.
SPEAKER_01And Kristen, uh, you were also an education. I believe you were a fourth grade teacher, uh, and then did global work as a Peace Corps uh volunteer uh in Uganda and Cap I'm gonna do that one again, uh, and a Peace Corps volunteer in Uganda and Cape Verde. So I'm curious what did those first career points really teach you that you're using now every day to run this organization?
SPEAKER_04Well, I I'll start. Um so I spent most of my career as an economics professor and I was quite interested in a couple of topics. First of all, economics itself is about allocating resources.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04The second thing is that I was especially focused on the impact of race and gender on economic status in the United States and a little bit outside of the United States as well. That perspective, I think, has sort of influenced how I think about philanthropy in the sense that I'm interested in advancing equity within philanthropy, creating a more level playing field for organizations of all types, women-led, community-led, um, to get access to funding.
SPEAKER_04And I recognize that uh I will argue, if not even, I'll say I'll argue forcefully, that unless you have created sort of an open door, a level playing field, you're not finding the best ideas. That's right. You know, and that's a kind of core principle that gets lost sometimes in economics, that part of the argument for markets and other things is that they are mechanisms to try and open doors and create opportunities for the best ideas to emerge. As a faculty member, that's what I enjoyed the most was sort of nurturing and cultivating the students who were coming through, because what I recognized is that there's just there are so many people out there who are smarter than I am and who have great ideas.
SPEAKER_04And one of the best things I can do is to sort of help uplift those ideas and enable those individuals to be able to implement and act on them.
SPEAKER_01That's that's so incredible because I you drew a very clear line uh in really how you drill down and focused on uh economics around uh race and gender. And when you don't expand that lens and that container, you're not going to get uh the full picture or the best solutions and innovative strategies. Um, thank you for that. Kristen, what about you? Um in your early career, uh, what was it showing you that has kind of guided you a bit as a pathway where you are now?
SPEAKER_00It took a little bit of a different um perspective when I was thinking about this this um question. So, you know, before I I think for me, what being a classroom teacher and also being a Peace Corps volunteer volunteer um provided me with the opportunity to learn a whole set of skills that I had no idea were going to be really important for me as I as we started to launch Lever for Change. And I feel that those early career opportunities really positioned me to be an innovator and a risk taker and accept and learn from failure in a lot of ways and to take the bull by the horns and solve complex problems, right?
SPEAKER_00Because in both of those early professions that I had, I was incredibly passionate about social justice work. I was incredibly working in schools that, you know, were really struggling. I was working in the Peace Corps in very resource-constrained environments. And in both of those professions, you have a lot of space to play in a sandbox. And I don't think you realize this quite at the time, but you know, you're you're a classroom teacher alone in a classroom with a bunch of eight-year-olds looking at you to lead them through the day and hopefully teach them something at the end of it.
SPEAKER_00And as a Peace Corps volunteer, you're embedded within a community and you're hoping to make positive change by working with community members, but there's not a lot of parameters, right? You kind of know your goal, but you you don't have a very strict daily structure that you don't create yourself. And so I feel that um that self-directedness and that ability to think on my feet, pivot quickly when something's not working, not get too caught up in what didn't work, but just kind of think like this is not working, and I need to just stop in the moment and change course.
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of that really has come in quite handy. And I think I didn't realize at the time how much entrepreneurial spirit I had from the very beginning of my career. And that I could marry that entrepreneurial spirit with the social justice causes and the work that I deeply care about, which is how do we get money more efficiently to organizations that are doing the work that I care about. And so that is kind of how I come to this work and and kind of how my background really shaped, I think, where we are today with Lover for Change.
SPEAKER_01And I really love, you know, what you were saying, you know, in that trajectory. You know, I if, of course, if a lot of us go back, you know, to our younger selves and when we started uh our career path, we may not see, you know, where that's ending up. But what I'm hearing from you very clearly is a couple of things. One, your ad vocation became your vocation very clearly. Uh, what you cared about was social justice, what you cared about innovation, what you cared about, uh not having you know strict boundaries, right?
SPEAKER_01That sandbox that was pretty expansive, whether it's with eight-year-olds in the classroom, or whether it was really uh a community building and listening to community uh through the Peace Corps. Um and also that entrepreneurial spirit uh use the word pivot and the uh the ability, it sounds like throughout your pathway to issue spot, problem solve, collective problem solving, and pivoting uh to some larger uh solutions.
SPEAKER_01So we're gonna get to all that uh in a little bit. Um, but I love hearing uh about both um of some of your uh origin stories in the beginning of your careers. Uh Cecilia, I'm gonna go to you now. Um, and I'm wondering if you could talk to us a little bit about uh some of the impact when you were leading uh the MacArthur Fellows program before uh 100 and change got built. And we'll get into uh the impact and the nuts and bolts of 100 and change.
SPEAKER_01So with the MacArthur Fellows, for any of those who may be listening who aren't very familiar with that and uh choosing the geniuses that go into that, uh, can you walk us through that a bit and then that connection uh in choosing and identifying geniuses? What did that help you with as you guys were then with Lover for Change, looking at investing in 100 million,$100 million uh ideas?
SPEAKER_04Yes, uh, you know, the MacArthur Fellows program we think about now almost as an institution because it's 45 years old. But when it started, it was considered a very disruptive idea. And the idea was that we were going to identify exceptionally creative individuals with the potential to do more if only they were given some freedom and the financial resources to allow them to do that, to allow them to take some risk.
SPEAKER_04Uh, the program is unusual because people can't apply. So this is a little different from our other things we're doing now. But what we do in order to identify those individuals is we rely quite a bit on expertise outside of the foundation, outside of our staff, and outside of our board. We each month go out and invite people to nominate. We then go out and ask people to and keep it secret, secretly give us reviews of those individuals.
SPEAKER_04It's amazing how much people keep this secret. Um, and and then we have an external committee that makes the recommendations ultimately about Hill Gets the Fellowship. So even though the MacArthur Fellows program is kind of famous for being mysterious and secretive, and we like to think of what we do with 100 in change and what we're doing with lever for change as having a big emphasis on transparency and so on. There are a couple elements that they have in common. And the first is that reliance on expertise beyond our walls to try and make sure that we are getting the best advice we can about what decisions to make, about what to fund.
SPEAKER_04And then the other really critical one is the fellowship, the MacArthur Fellowship is an unrestricted, no strings attached award to these individuals. So it recognizes that if you've identified people who have great ideas, you should trust, you should give them the freedom to decide how to best deploy those financial resources to help execute those best ideas. And that concept of giving organizations the agency and the flexibility to define what the work is and to execute it is really deeply embedded in what we're doing now.
SPEAKER_01You know, and in listening to you and with those commonalities. So would it be safe to say almost 45 years ago when a MacArthur uh fellows program started, that that was showed uh infrastructure uh commonalities of trust-based philanthropy.
SPEAKER_04Oh, I think of it in some ways as the original trust-based philanthropy program, right? Because it it truly it's this no strings award to these individuals. Um, one of our fellows commented, and it's a fellow who got the award. It's an award that is meant to be at a particular point in a career.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh where it maybe you're at a trajectory and you're sort of you're we want to accelerate that trajectory to coming up with the really big idea. But it doesn't have, you know, the age, the youngest fellow, I think, was 19 and the oldest was in their 80s. One of the older fellow, one of the fellows who was older when he received it said, it's really something to get this award because you think, okay, I'm winding down. They go, no, no, we really expect you to do more. We're going to give you this funding and we trust that you're going to be able to produce something really great.
SPEAKER_01That's fantastic. And also just thinking about uh the age range, uh, whether that has been the youngest at 18 or one of you know the elders of wisdom at 80, when we're thinking about um, you know, there's a book that calls strength to strength and thinking about uh fluid intelligence around uh folks with the with the younger ages, and they're really just firing away, taking a lot of risks, a lot of creativity. Or when uh you shift to crystallized intelligence, you have a lot of things that have informed your experience.
SPEAKER_01And the key thing is to dare to risk still uh to bank on the wisdom you've gained and to be open that there's more uh to learn and do. Um thank you for that. I can definitely see uh how the MacArthur Fellows Program uh and and with you at the home has definitely shaped what we're seeing uh today from uh Lever for Change. Kristen, I I want to go to you. Um very interested uh in this concept.
SPEAKER_01Um, and I'm really wondering if you can help us understand it uh when we think about venture capital. You've talked a lot about that philanthropy should look more like venture capital, in that uh have some of the typical characteristics taking risks, uh willing to fail, fail, um, innovate, being creative. Um, can you say more about uh what you mean by this and uh where you're seeing venture capital working in a space, social venture capital, uh, or how we can get more of a mindset this way.
SPEAKER_01Um when it comes to investing in lots of creative entities out there who are the experts of what they're trying to solve within their own communities.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I think, you know, and it does tie into failure and it ties into some of what Cecilia was just talking about with the MacArthur Fellows and trust-based philanthropy. But I and I think too, my background of being a teacher was just like, you know, things fail. Uh, you know, you can have the best-laid educated, you know, like lesson plan for something, and it and the kids are just going, you know, they're going bonkers because it's not working, you know, and you have to change, you have to change direction. So I think too often philanthropy and philanthropists can get very caught up in the nervousness around taking risk and what it means if something that they invested in fails or if a project that they invested in fails, um, as opposed to looking at that as a real opportunity for learning and pushing the boundaries of philanthropy forward and the boundaries of our work forward.
SPEAKER_00And to be honest, the problems that philanthropy is trying to solve are intractable problems. These are system failure problems, right? These are not easy problems. If they were, if there were market solutions to these problems, those market solutions would be in play and people would be making money, right? And a lot of times these problems are so challenging and rooted in difficulty, but the organizations themselves are so resource constrained that even if they have new opportunities that show up on their plate or they have new innovative ideas, they don't have the funding or the structures or the trust of donors and philanthropists to make those shifts, to go after those new, those new partnerships or those new opportunities.
SPEAKER_00And so I think really is what I would love to see is philanthropy to really take risks. We often say it's risk capital, but in a lot of ways, it is not risk capital. In a lot of ways, there's a lot of constraints put around what organizations can and can't do with that funding. Um, there's a lot of fear of, well, I don't want you to do that because it might be too risky or it's, you know, not gonna work out. And I think we we need to let go of some of that and really trust organizations to be able to shepherd and steward the resources that they have in ways that are more productive.
SPEAKER_00So, what what I think we should be pushing philanthropy to think about is a portfolio of organizations, right? And your portfolio of organizations should have your blue chip stocks in it, you know, your your big organizations that you know are are in the field and they're there and they've been doing good work for a long time. You might have those middle organizations that are up and coming, they have some tested models and they're doing a lot of good work, but you know, they might still be innovating and failing a bit. And then those ones that are just like, I have a great idea, I've got my laptop and an idea, and I need the money, right?
SPEAKER_00Like just like what we do in Silicon Valley. But if you, if you, you know, and you have to go into that thinking it's okay if some of these fail. And I think, you know, we we are about to wrap up and announce um an open call recently that's focused on emerging climate champions. And the funder who is funding that is also a woman. And she came into this and said, I want to fund youth-led organizations. And that is an area where a lot of foundations and a lot of philanthropists are like, no, no, no, that's too risky. They haven't had the they haven't had the pathway, you know, they they've never had a grant this big.
SPEAKER_00What would they do with that money? And she said, youth are inheriting this world. And this isn't this, it is up going to be up to them ultimately to also find solutions for climate change. And we need to be funding those organizations now. We need to be supporting them so that they can continue to grow and innovate in this space. And we need more folks that are doing it. We need more philanthropists willing to take those risks and step into uncertain spaces.
SPEAKER_01And that's such a great example. That's the going back to what you were saying of really we've got the systemic failures, right? And if the market could uh address that, solve it, profit off of it, uh, perhaps climate change wouldn't be exactly where we are. But, you know, this uh this generation, right? Uh who maybe on their cell phone is able to gather and and they're doing the things that they need to do, may have those uh ideas.
SPEAKER_04Cecilia, uh, did you I just wanted to add on to that um because there's also this strange concept of risk in that it it really focuses quite strongly on the risk that you don't know how to run a spreadsheet and not on the risk that we're going to to to give money to an organization that actually doesn't understand the specific needs in the community in which they're going to operate, or that is um more focused on sustaining sort of the problem as opposed to trying to solve it.
SPEAKER_04So there's there's the risk of yes, you may not, you may need some support in terms of managing money, which is actually quite doable, versus the risk that you're actually not going to really tackle the problem at hand, the root causes.
SPEAKER_01And and the risk if if if we're going to continue to have the systemic uh failures Or the systemic design, uh, if I'm understanding what you're saying, that the risk is really getting centered around is this entity going to be able uh to run a spreadsheet? Right? So that's coming from a very different type of system. Um, but you're not saying that they're they're really centering on whether or not that this, you know, these entities have an idea for the solution.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_01Also, you didn't say this, but also if if we're not moving forward um in these attempts for creative investments, then we run the risk of never taking the chance at a solution to absolutely what is some of the uh and and I find this to be really you know interesting area when when you both are advocating uh around not just trust-based philanthropy, but also kind of I love the language Kristen, you are using around the portfolio, right?
SPEAKER_01That that can click in the minds of a lot of people. Um are you seeing uh growing support for that mindset nationally, internationally, or are you still seeing some um pushback or challenges? Uh, where those who have power and influence are not quite there? Or is it not that uh simple and cut and dry the way I asked the question?
SPEAKER_00See, I think funders and donors and philanthropists run the spectrum. Everybody from I'm gonna give to my alma mater because that feels safe and easy and comfortable for me to do, and is and I'm passionate about it to folks who are really taking high-risk, you know, um investments. I do feel that the that there has been a growing base of funders who really understand the need for more trust-based philanthropy. And when we say trust-based philanthropy, we don't mean just give to any organization, right? There is still diligence, there is still a process and that where people are you know making that decision.
SPEAKER_00But then when they're giving the money away, they're saying, you know what, I trust you to take this forward in the way that makes the most sense to you. And I'm not going to micromanage you after. And I definitely see a growing cadre of funders who recognize the need for that. I think the pressure, um, particularly right now, for funders, foundations, DAFs to spend, be spending, spending down their assets, is also pushing people to work in new ways, work faster, and and cut out some of the red tape that they had put in place before to help move the money in a bit more efficient way.
SPEAKER_00So I definitely think there's a growing movement, but it's also not going to be everybody. And I and I don't think every funder needs to operate that way. There needs to be the spectrum and diversity of funders who are working in all parts of the funding system and bringing their different um perspectives to bear. But I do want to see, and I am seeing a much larger percentage of funders coming in and saying, yeah, let's do this a little bit differently.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but you know, we are we are seeing that uh as well in in the region that we're in, uh uh greater uh Cincinnati, Ohio, um, where we do have, I would say one significant entity that's really lockstep with trust-based philanthropy, uh, and all the elements of the principles of that. And then some uh smaller foundations who they are trying that on for size. Uh, and it's great, you know, part of the areas of where the you know they may start trying that on is uh the unrestricted uh gifts.
SPEAKER_01Um they're trying to do multi-year uh gifts, um, the the entry in uh to getting uh uh moving that money uh to uh you know uh proximity, you know, those who are most impacted uh know are the experts of what they can do with it. Um so we are seeing uh uh some of that shift. Um, and I appreciate what you were saying uh about the uh the spectrum.
SPEAKER_01And I'm also interested when you're talking about uh moving the money um in these large ways. Um I'm wondering if you both can speak to um, if if I'm correct, recently um that 100 and change decision and investment in moving the money came to fruition, uh, where a hundred million dollars uh was invested in an entity called Seteno, um, an initiative to help prevent the next uh pandemic.
SPEAKER_01Um, can you walk us through a little bit uh through this? Because just as you were talking about venture capitalism, I don't think in a for-profit world with uh VCs and entrepreneurs, a lot of people would blink at that number. Um but yet on the nonprofit side and you know, innovators trying to take on something as huge as a pandemic, uh, that is a nice uh uh investment uh for uh such a grave, complex, and wicked issue.
SPEAKER_01Um it's very exciting. Can you talk to us a bit about that? Yes.
SPEAKER_04So as you noted, we announced this past year the third recipient of one of the 100 and change grants, um, Sentinel. Um this project when it started back in 2016-17, um was designed to do a couple several things. The first was to try and focus attention, focus philanthropic effort on the idea that problems were solvable, that there were problems out there that if we really put our our our minds and our energy and our resources, we could move the needle and make some progress towards solving them.
SPEAKER_04And that the second part of that was the thought that as philanthropists, we had perhaps historically been a little too timid to look for those opportunities. And we wanted to design a process that would allow us to identify those opportunities informed by what came from outside of the foundation. So there was also a kind of democratization part of this. Like we're gonna figure out where we can really best use$100 million to make a difference.
SPEAKER_04We designed this process that was at the base of it was this open call, the model that we now continue to do with Lever for Change. And it involved impaneling a group of people from around the world in various different disciplines and areas to be evaluation partners for us, to read applications, to write comments on the applications, and to help us narrow what was, as you can imagine, a huge pool of initial applications. Um, I think in that first one we had close to 1,800 uh around the world.
SPEAKER_04That now actually we've had some that were bigger, but 1800 in that first one uh was stunning to have to to to to go through and evaluate and to also to try and do it in a way that was respectful of the work that organizations had put in to submit those applications. So we wanted to make sure that everyone got feedback, that everyone got some information about what we what we valued or what the evaluators thought was great and what wasn't so great, or maybe could be framed differently.
SPEAKER_04So through that process, we got all the scores, we narrowed it down to an upper tier of applications. In that first one, because of the size of the pool, I think we identified our top 200 as uh as a special category. There was recognition to those top 200. And then the uh ultimately our team took all of the information from the evaluators, not only the scores, but also what their commentary, uh, what comments they had to offer.
SPEAKER_04We identified a subgroup of projects that needed that would go into additional review. So we had technical reviews done, we had financial due diligence, we had legal due diligence, as Kristen said. There's a lot of diligence that goes into making one of these trust, trust-based awards. Uh, and then the MacArthur Board of Directors had the really difficult task of picking a recipient. And so, in the very first iteration, the recipient was an organization. Um, it was a collaboration between Sesame Workshop and the International Rescue Committee to address the the youngest refugees, to provide an intervention to help support early childhood education for the youngest refugees in the Syrian refugee region.
SPEAKER_04Then the second time that we had the 100 in change, the grant recipient was an organization called Community Solutions that wanted to accelerate an end to homelessness in U.S. cities. So these are ambitious, very ambitious. Um and that particular project is a model in which Community Solutions has developed an approach to uh reducing homelessness in cities and helps each city and county or community create the infrastructure, the data infrastructure, and it's also partly a mindset.
SPEAKER_04It's it's it's called by name data, where you you need to know every person who is unhoused and what they need to get them housed sustainably. That's been enjoying quite a bit of success. It's it's an area where people frequently feel it's hopeless. It's not. I invite people to go look at community solutions built for zero project to be inspired. So this third one follows along in that tradition. We've been using essentially the same general framework. Every time we run one of these, though, we try to learn from what we had done before.
SPEAKER_04We refine the criteria, we try to make sure that we're communicating accurately to all of the organizations what those criteria are. Um we're always looking is is the judging process working fairly? So we make little tweaks, but um this third one just resulted in um the Sentinel award to Sentinel. But the other part of this that is built into what we do is that there are other great ideas. We have these other, just start with the finalist for these various 100 and change projects.
SPEAKER_04So from the very first one, we put a lot of energy into working with the finalists to get them in front of other funders, to get them opportunities to help to begin to realize what their great ideas were and their projects were. And we have some examples, and you'll see success represented in some of the data when we talk about that 2.7 that we've moved. Um, you know, not it varies a little bit from time to time. At the moment, it's less than half, but slightly less than half of that has come not from the original award from one of our open calls, but from the work we've done to support the organizations in bringing other funding to the table.
SPEAKER_01And really, you know, when you're saying that, uh, so am I understanding you correctly? Um, you have these mechanisms for lever, uh, you know, for change with the investment, uh, the trust space, the 100 million. And then those who may not make it to that final end, uh, you're leveraging, you're pulling that lever through collaboration and partnerships and other uh funders and investors and philanthropists to get connected, to have eyes on and really uh to see.
SPEAKER_01I love what you said that indeed uh problems are uh solvable, right? And and you know, whether we're we're thinking of the complexities, the geopolitical, uh humanitarian-based complexities of refugees, or whether uh we are thinking about the complexities and the pervasiveness of those who are unhoused or the next pandemic to really go through not only the major investment, but those who were in the pipeline uh who made it to the finals can still get uh invested in.
SPEAKER_01Another thing I heard you say, you did not use the word equity, but it is a thing that I am hearing very much even in the process. So I think a lot with trust-based philanthropy, maybe uh some folks who are not yet into that mindset will say, Well, there's no due diligence, you're just giving money, it's willy-nilly. Uh, how do we know? XYZ, that people are going to use it as they need to use it. So you outline very strongly the due diligence, but I also heard an equitable process in that of all of those applications going through the process when they did not receive the the top final uh position that they were communicated back to and used the word respectful in a respectful way that said, uh, here's what we saw, here are the comments, here's where you were rated, this is what was working great.
SPEAKER_01Maybe here are some areas to improve. Um, because there are power positions, right? When those who have large amounts of money and access and can make decisions on those who have proximity to the issue and expertise to navigate that gap where you are supplying supportive information to help them perhaps get to that next uh space where they can be invested in.
SPEAKER_01Um I I think that that that's a strong thing to point out, uh, because I think uh many nonprofits and others are very used to hearing a no, um but not necessarily a why or how to better position. Uh Kristen, anything uh you want to add into that uh uh space um around the 100 and change uh before we go on.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I'll just add a pick up right where you left off, which is, you know, we really value that part of our process. And one of the things that we hear all the time from organizations is that they are able to take that feedback, put it into practice. What makes sense? I mean, obviously, some feedback's not gonna make sense, but the feedback that they get that's really useful and take that and build it into their process, build it into their work, and actually be able to take that forward and put proposals, new proposals, better proposals in front of funders that then helps them unlock those dollars.
SPEAKER_00And so we hear all the time from organizations that that is one of the most valuable parts of the process. And sometimes we have organizations who say, listen, we know we're not gonna, we know we're not gonna get to the top of this process. But by us going through it, we can number one, we can bring our organization together and realign ourselves under what is our North Star, what is our, what is our vision for this community? Where do we want to go? What do we want to be doing? And what are the outcomes we want to see? And also it allows them to kind of build that narrative together in a in a stronger way.
SPEAKER_00Because a lot of times organizations are they are in the grind on a daily basis and just having a moment to pick their heads up and say, yeah, let's use this as an opportunity to really realign as an organization, that all of those pieces are valuable in and of themselves. And so we try and support that all the way through the process, recognizing that at the end of the day, only a certain number of organ organizations are going to be funded, but then we still want to take all of those organizations who have applied to the extent that we can and keep helping to support them, build them, and get them in front of as many funders as possible to unlock more resources.
SPEAKER_01And that is uh hugely powerful because uh I would argue that that is uh uh lever for change is demonstrating actions that are absolutely rooted in social justice because you're creating a pathway to access to information, access uh to others uh with influence, where it can be presented. Here is the huge unmet need. Here is where perhaps I'll just in a general say, general way, say, here is where some suffering of humanity is.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and then to have unlocked access to information of one of what may be able to be fine-tuned to get that need elevated more, and then access to positioning. Because you're so right, Kristen. Uh uh, so many entities uh throughout the country, internationally, uh, they're doing the work. It's the daily grind, head is down. And so the world uh the agency uh that I get to serve, um, we understand that that is also a form of uh when you're doing that a lot, it's a form of trauma in that uh you then are activating out of your amygdala, like it's gonna take a lot of bandwidth to get to your frontal lobe, where you can have that creative thought, where you can have that uh innovation, um, where you can also then believe, and it's a reason why you joined with whatever movement you're in, that problems are solvable.
SPEAKER_01Um I love that. And then I'm wondering if if we could go to a little bit, a little bit more around uh we discussed some of those spaces, whether it was a uh MacArthur Fellows program, maybe uh the pioneer of trust-based philanthropy, but how that was a uh very uh kind of known for being um, I don't want to say secretive, but but a quiet process. To now let's unpack uh some of the transparency of the uh open process and what uh Lover for Change you all have done such a great job in uh designing designing these open call investments.
SPEAKER_01Um, and and part of it this you know uh describing the elaborate review you all uh have done with this bandwidth of experts uh across the globe, frankly. Um but you know there's some real uh highlights um because I'm just gonna say it like I'm a huge fan of the work you're doing. And so uh it's been so exciting to me around the 2019 uh economic opportunity challenge, the 2021 Equality Can't Wait uh Challenge.
SPEAKER_01Uh Yari spoke to this, uh, the remarkable 2025 emerging climate uh champions, just to uh name a few. Um what do you see as the power and possibility of these uh open call investments? And do you do you think they're and maybe you can't navigate it to a single uh element, but but is there is there a spark there that must be present for that investment to open up?
SPEAKER_01Um is there an advocate who's behind the scenes saying I want to move my dollars here to the portfolio of lever for change? And then lever for change is saying, How would you like this to be designed? Um, so some of the power and possibility um of what we may see, you don't have to say the titles or the investments, but you know, it's 2030, we're sitting around. Uh what's what's this future looking like?
SPEAKER_00Do you want to go first, Kristen? And sure. I mean, typically what we see is, you know, we when we are thinking about designing an open call, we have two separate models in our in our minds in terms of what we do. One is we have funders who come to us and say, I am passionate about this topic and I want to put big resources behind it, and I want to move those resources and I want to do it equitably. I want to surface new ideas, new organizations, things I don't know about. I want to be open to the possibility because one of the things that an open call is really good at is helping funders source things outside of their typical strategy areas.
SPEAKER_00So one of the one of the reasons that we created this open call model was that when we were launching 100 and change, MacArthur wanted to flip the script a little bit, right? When you're when you're in philanthropy or when you're in a nonprofit and you're applying to philanthropy, often it's the foundations have their strategy, your organizations try to fit within that strategy and trying to figure out what's the best angle. And if you don't fit in the strategy or the outcomes or you know what they're looking for, then you know you're not going to get invited to put in a proposal. But we said, let's flip that script.
SPEAKER_00And so when we are working with a new funder who comes to us and says, I want to move money and I'm I care about this broad area. Let's use economic opportunity as an op as an area. We work with them to say, okay, what are the parameters you want to work within? You know, what would be interesting to you? What do you want to see? What are you hoping to see at the end of this process? What kind of organizations or projects would really excite you? And then we design around that, right? Both in terms of designing all of the transparent pieces that we've talked about, the criteria, the rubric, et cetera. But one of the most important things that we do is when we design the application process and the application itself, our goal is to keep that as broad as possible.
SPEAKER_00So we want organizations to say to us what how do you define the problem of economic opportunities within or lack of opportunities, I should say, within your community or within the work that you do? And how do you define the solution? That you are, that you either have evidence for or the innovative idea that maybe you don't have evidence for, but how are you defining that solution? And the reason we do that is we we say to funders all the time, if you know the solution you're looking for, you can go out and find those organizations doing that. But what an open call allows you to do is say, unburden the organization with trying to fit into the box that you've created and instead allow them to say, this is how this problem manifests on the ground in my community and how we are working to solve it.
SPEAKER_00And if you take homelessness as a, I use this as a perfect example because if you think about homelessness in Texas, for example, just picking a state, the way that that problem manifests, the people that it's impacting, the solutions that might be at play could look very different than how that problem would be described in, let's say, Portland or in Washington state, right? And the way that you might need to go about thinking about those solutions might be very different. So by having these tightly constrained strategies, organizations don't, they don't fit in there.
SPEAKER_00The other problem is that it doesn't allow organizations to really talk about the more holistic way in which we have to address these community problems, right? These are intractable problems. We know that. It is not just about homelessness, it's about economic mobility, it's about, you know, it's about real estate, it is about affordable housing, it is about education, right? It is, it is about all of those things. And so being able to um put these open calls out there, one of the other things that we see are organizations coming together and really unique partnerships to say, we've always wanted to work together.
SPEAKER_00We have this part of the solution, they have this part of the solution, but like this is enough money for us to come together and make a partnership work to say, can our one plus one equal three? Um, and so that's the kind of power of possibility that an open call allows you to elicit because you're not going into that conversation with an organization with a predefined solution, idea, concept that you have created within the walls of your strategy, but instead you're going out and saying, you tell us, you tell, and that is we we just launched the uh boundless um San Francisco open call.
SPEAKER_00And that is an open call that that is what they're, you know, those those funders are very much so rooted in that community, and they really want to support that community. But what and they say, we know a lot of the organizations working here, but what we're looking for now is how can they come together to create really powerful solutions to move our city forward. And that's what an open call for me, and I think for us, I don't want to speak for Sicily, but I think that is one of the biggest powers of possibility. It's it's surfacing and finding those new ideas.
SPEAKER_00Um, sometimes it's organizations that are already known, sometimes it's not, many times it's ideas that are unknown, right? And so that is the power of possibility.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I would I second everything. And then I would, I was two points I was going to make. One Kristen just made is that there are two forms of discovery that I think we've seen through these open calls. One is the discovery of ways in which people want to partner that wouldn't necessarily have been visible before, because frequently organizations are uh, particularly when you look at place-based funders, they're competing for the same funding mechanism. But when you commit a sizable sum that is going to be multi-year support, the organizations see that together we can really put that money to work.
SPEAKER_04We can make a stronger case. The other form of discovery are just ways of approaching problems that were not perhaps not on the donors' radar or not on the radar of the formal funding community. I think about the iconic impact award, the Larson Lamb Iconic Impact Award that was looking for durable futures for refugees. One of the projects that was became a grantee was an initiative to launch a group, international network of refugee-led organizations.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, to represent the refugee voice and also both in the term terms of the locations that they were based in, the countries, but also on the global scale. I don't know that a funder was a group of strategists inside of a foundation would have necessarily thought of that as one of the approaches that might help to create durable futures. And they just recently went independent. They're really fully launched now.
SPEAKER_01That's that's exciting because you know, in in thinking about that network and and broad-based coalition and and being led by refugee-led um voices in experiences when you're saying, I don't know if like, you know, sitting in the boardroom uh in in some city uh that a funder would have come up with that, and you know, I'm listening to you both, I'm listening to both of you, and I'm really struck with um a huge gift that has been manifesting globally and nationally from this framework and leadership vision that Lever for Change is doing.
SPEAKER_01Um, and it's this abundance mindset. So uh Cecilia, you had said, you know, you know, we shifted back in 2016 and saying, you know what, uh huge complex problems actually are solvable. That's a huge mindset uh shift. Um and then also thinking about um you know, where you may across a nation, you know, have community-based foundations and they've got the set sandbox, and it's a very small sandbox, and they have the strategies.
SPEAKER_01And uh um uh Kristen, I think you were saying, and then it is very real. I would imagine any city you travel in, um, especially you know, in in uh 2026, uh there has there inherently then is a deficiency mindset, there's limited dollars, and there's going to be competition, and there's not perhaps this creative influx of um proactive collaboration on solutions that work, standing shoulder to shoulder.
SPEAKER_01Um, because in in tough times, uh entities and and uh strategies may be we we gotta secure our nonprofit. Uh we we cannot even think about how else this might look. Um, but when a abundant uh investment is put center in front of entities, then that is where uh more collaboration and innovations uh can occur. Um and also listening to both of you, it's just clear.
SPEAKER_01Uh I don't know if if Lover for Change started off as an idea lab and an innovation lab, but it certainly has uh that is a huge ripple effect that has happened uh uh globally. And and one more point uh before uh uh we go on. Uh Kristen, I believe it is you that was really uh saying, you know, uh the applications for the um uh and and really looking at uh these uh open calls in some ways you'll have an issue, but they're kind of left uh general and open.
SPEAKER_01Um and it leaves it up to the entity to then really address, you know, in the ways that they're seeing boots on the ground in more holistic ways. And I and I love that, and and that resonates because uh the agency I get to serve women helping women, uh, we serve survivors of gender-based violence. And I think uh it's it's quite common when we advocate for safety for survivors, a lot of people think physical safety. Uh, and and so they have they have a visual of what that looks like.
SPEAKER_01And yes, we do that, um, but we are very clear that we are talking about economic safety, we are talking about economic justice, and that has been a mindset shift uh for philanthropists to really understand and saying, Well, what what what does what does economics have to do with this? What does money have to do with safety? And we're like, everything believe survivors, invest in survivors, um, give back the autonomy uh of self and that cash, uh, you have to move the money uh that way.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so you know, we've we've been very fortunate uh that we've been able to uh have an abundance mindset, uh and a collaborative mindset of no, just don't invest in our agency. Invest in the true experts, and that's survivors. Um I'm wondering if we can uh uh I'm gonna uh to be mindful of time. I I really wanna uh plug into here um some of the things that are just very uh obvious to me, and I'm wondering if you can unpack when we're looking at uh power influence, the ability to uh advocate, create change, um and and you may not like this description, which is totally fair.
SPEAKER_01Um you are both female leaders, you're leaders, um but you you are also women who are quite empowered, quite powerful in the change that has been able to happen from investment strategies. Um, when we think about these uh open calls, when we think about the portfolio, we think about the investors who invest in the portfolio, um, there are uh a lot of women uh who have shown up uh and advocated for critical change to what may seem like impossible uh solutions that or impossible issues that have no solution, you know, whether that's pivotal ventures uh with uh Miss uh Melinda French Gates uh or Mackenzie Scott uh through yield giving.
SPEAKER_01Um all coincidence, uh, or or do you see something here that is just different in giving or leadership of women?
SPEAKER_04I think they're um I certainly made an empirical observation, not one that gathered vast amount of data and so probably would not pass statistical significance test. But um we we so I'm gonna caveat all that because I'm an economist, right? But but we have seen a pattern uh in terms of women having um who have the resources, among those women who have the resources to run an open call with us.
SPEAKER_04I'm sorry, let me rephrase that. I've seen a pattern among the people who have the resources to run an open call with us, that there is an overrepresentation of women among that group. If you look at who's run who's supported open calls with us, um, we've had couples and we've had women as individuals, uh, more so than we've had men as individuals. I can hypothesize lots of explanations for that, and I I'm not sure which one might be the the main factor.
SPEAKER_04Um one does have to do with the ways in which women have been socialized and our lived experience. I think makes us um much more willing to understand that good ideas can come from lots of places, much you know, more willing to say that's a good idea, and I'm gonna help move that forward. So I think there's some element potentially there. Um it's also been suggested that um the the that there's a different mindset if you um how to put this.
SPEAKER_04The fact is that many of the women who show up on the fortune, the you know, Forbes, not Forbes, uh forbes, not Fortune, I'm sorry, many of the women who show up on the Forbes 400 list are people who either inherited wealth or who have their wealth is in part due to whoever their partner was. And there is some observation that when people have are the ones who have um made the first ones to make the wealth tend to have a harder time letting it go.
SPEAKER_01Interesting.
SPEAKER_04And so I don't know how much of this is is that as well, because I I think there is some, we're seeing some evidence that the next gen of some are much more likely to be willing to to participate in a process where they're not dictating everything that happens.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um the so I think that that could be an element of it as well. But um so I do I do think there is something here in terms of attitude towards risk taking, something here about um your comfort level with sharing power, um, all of those sorts of things that may have a component that's connected to to having grown up as a woman.
SPEAKER_01I I I really appreciate uh all those uh insights. Um a lot of that resonates too, I think, when you think on the the other side of the table of entities that are being invested in. I think they're I think it's safe to say without empirical data that I have at my fingertips, there is an overrepresentation, uh, whether we're thinking about social justice, humanitarian need, um, we're we're women are in the workforce. Uh, and part of that social socialization of coming into the space, uh uh perhaps to leave the world better than we found it and to take care uh of those in our uh community as we are part of community in that sharing.
SPEAKER_01Um, Kristen, any thoughts or Cecilia or you?
SPEAKER_04I wanted to just add one more thing that you just you kind of suggested to me too. Um you know, I'm I'm an economist and I've uh label would label myself as a feminist economist. And and one of the things that feminist economists have focused in on is the ways in which we tend to undervalue work and product productivity that happens outside of the market, the commercial market. Um and I think one of the other things that I've observed among the donors that we've worked with is a real recognition that to make this these things happen, organizations need resources.
SPEAKER_04And they need those resources to be able to not only sort of you know buy books to distribute or whatever, but they need those resources to make sure that their workforce is adequately compensated. Okay and that they need those resources uh to make sure that perhaps they have some economic security we were talking about earlier in terms of retirement and vacation days and all of those sorts of things. I think there is an appreciation that that to get this make this work happen, we need highly capable people to be compensated.
SPEAKER_04And that is is is a recognition that sometimes is missing more broadly because we think people will do this because they care so passionately, and they will, but it doesn't mean that we shouldn't make sure it's adequately compensated.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, which goes back to uh uh equity. Yes, it goes back to uh economic justice, and and I really uh it really struck me when you said um, you know, when we think about uh the marketplace, there tends to be an undervaluing of what happens outside of the market. Um and perhaps through through a centering through feminist uh uh looking at that through a feminist uh economic lens, um, can see uh all the areas uh of value uh and contribution.
SPEAKER_04Um and even inside the market, the work that involves care that's right, tends to be like, oh, you don't need to it's not recognized as something, a skill that someone's bringing. Yes.
SPEAKER_01That's that's so right. And so when we think about the systems of design, um uh when when you're thinking about inside the market, all you have to do is look at uh nonprofit, social services, human services, um, and uh look at how the compensation structures are set up because it is based on uh a double bottom line, the mission impact and the revenue you can bring in, the revenue that gets brought in, typically has two key categories: government, which is a very tight structure that even says you cannot put in for X amount for uh living increases, uh, or philanthropy, which we are still uh I loved what you said earlier about um creating a uh uh democracy in philanthropy.
SPEAKER_01Uh we still are navigating generations uh and decolonizing uh wealth within and in the systems for that. So there may still be a system very much in play um that dictates what goes into the marketplace for those who are trying to show up uh with care. Uh Kristen, anything in this space? Or you feel?
SPEAKER_00I feel like you all covered it quite well. I don't think I have anything to add other than just plus one to everything that you both have said.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll I'll say one uh closing statement uh underline uh on this, and then uh we can go with our uh closing uh ritual that we did in the podcast. Um but it's very clear uh to me when we think about what we value and how we view. Um again, our agency, our particular focus is serving survivors. I think a lot of people have a lot of different beliefs of who survivors are, what they're capable of.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so they may define them by the victimization, they may define them by a lot of uh different descriptors. Uh, but it's very clear to me uh survivors are entrepreneurs. You want to talk about taking risks, they take risks all the time and they have to mitigate risk. Uh survivors are uh builders, they are leaders, they are supreme uh strategists.
SPEAKER_01I mean, uh all the things that we may say, we are gonna value this in a corporate boardroom. Well, pull up the seat to the table because the survivor is gonna fit that very well uh with what uh their lived experience is uh and and what they are capable of. So I think it's really uh opening up uh that mindset of what we value and how we invest uh in that value. Um this has been fantastic.
SPEAKER_01I I've really enjoyed uh uh Juan, just your kindness and generosity. I know you're very, very busy. So to have access uh to your leadership vision and your journey uh and the crucial, crucial work uh of what uh Lever for Change is doing, um, frankly, with a global community of collaborators uh to really uh solve incredibly wicked issues with innovation, grit, heart, and expertise uh is remarkable.
SPEAKER_01Uh so I would like to ask both of you a question we ask everyone uh on the podcast. Um when you close your eyes and you hold the dream that you personally carry for humanity, what is the world that you see?
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, I see a world where children and families can really soar and where kindness reigns supreme, um, where they're not constrained by economic status, what country they're from, their belief system, you know, how they make the makeup of their personal identity, but where really our collective humanity values um the future of those children and families um over the short-term gains of the of the here and now and the moment, that we're really starting to vision out what do we want that future to be and how do we start making those steps to get to a future that looks like that.
SPEAKER_01I love that. And you know, it reminds me uh, if any of that is what you were exploring back when you were a teacher in grade school and in setting up the generation for part of that uh vision for humanity. Thank you for that. So Celia, what about you?
SPEAKER_04Well, I have two granddaughters, so it's a very Concrete version of this. One will turn, one turned three last week and the other will turn five in next week. So when I think about what I hope for the world, I do have them kind of front and center center, along with children like them everywhere. I'm sure we all do.
SPEAKER_04That you know that that it it I understand that sometimes things will happen, but I'm wanting it to be short-term and short-lived so that so that the association is um with an individual is limited, so that there's an opportunity to kind of be resilient and move to another step, another phase. Um that's what I hope for everyone, that there's this possibility that you can see, and sometimes even if you can't see it, I you know, there's this book called Hope in the Unseen.
SPEAKER_04But that, but that requires this um sort of safety net that I would like to see beginning to be to be strengthened, beginning in our country, but also globally, that kind of makes sure that you you have a bounce back. Maybe it's not safety net. I'm just this is I'm trying this out here for the first time. Maybe it's not the safety net, maybe it's uh like a trampoline that only goes up, right?
SPEAKER_01You know, and in listening uh to both of you, um, it it really uh strikes me that with your uh careers, with your advocacy, uh, with the work you've done with Lever for Change, the work you will continue to do in the vision, in the impact, um, that that has all that has all been about uh hope in the unseen because you create a space where we see it, and then we can invest in it, and then solutions and innovative innovations can be created.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much uh for today. Uh this has been uh lovely. Um and I just want to say thank you again. Uh, we'll include everything from today's conversation in our show notes. And until next time, everyone, let's build the equity effect together. Thank you for joining me for the equity effect. If today's conversation challenged your thinking or inspired a new perspective, please subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with someone who believes stronger communities begin with greater opportunity.
SPEAKER_01Because every conversation sparks an idea, every idea inspires action, and every action creates an equity effect. Until next time, remember this. Economic opportunity is more than financial security. It's the foundation for safety, independence, and lasting change. I'm Kristen Shrimplin. Thanks for listening.
In this episode of The Equity Effect, host Kristin Shrimplin is joined by Camilla Worrell, Executive Director of the Women’s Fund of Greater Cincinnati. With a deep background in law, policy advocacy, and community...
In this episode of The Equity Effect, host Kristin Shrimplin is joined by Barbara Turner, founder and CEO of BT Rise and former President and CEO of Ohio National Financial Services. Barbara shares her remarkable...
In this episode of The Equity Effect, host Kristin Shrimplin is joined by Matthew Randazzo, President and CEO of the Greater Cincinnati Foundation. From navigating early life challenges in Detroit to leading a regional...
In this episode of The Equity Effect, host Kristin Shrimplin sits down with retired Procter & Gamble Chairman and CEO John Pepper to discuss the enduring legacy of his late wife, Francie Garber Pepper. For over five...