Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Emotionally Healthy Leader Podcast

The Emotionally Healthy Leader Podcast artwork

Why I Wrote Emotionally Healthy Success

Sep 15, 202628 minAudio

Pre-Order Pete Scazzero's forthcoming book, Emotionally Healthy Success, at www.emotionallyhealthy.org/success and get a free chapter. What if you could succeed brilliantly at something God never asked you to do? Is it possible to succeed at the wrong thing? I spent a good part of my ministry answering yes to that question without knowing it. I built something big at New Life Fellowship while becoming increasingly unhealthy. The numbers were up. My joy was down. It took a church split and two years I never would have chosen for me to face what I'd been avoiding: who am I when I can't prove I'm successful by the world's standards? This episode opens a seven-part series walking through the book Emotionally Healthy Success, three and a half years in the making. I'll tell you the story that forced me to ask what success actually looks like to God, and why I think this question is one you're already living with every time you set a priority or lead a team. If you've built something that looks impressive while quietly wondering if it's the wrong thing, this one's for you. Listen in. Join Us for a Free Webinar Are You Measuring What Matters Most to Jesus: A New Scorecard for Success in Life and Leadership, Nov. 10th, 2 PM ET. Learn more at emotionallyhealthy.org/webinar.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hi, my name is Pete Scazaro. I want to welcome you today to the Emotionally Healthy Leader Podcast. Great to be with you. Our topic today is why I wrote emotionally healthy success. And I'll throw in a bit of how as well. Why I wrote this book, Emotionally Healthy Success. So let me ask you: what if you succeed brilliantly at something in your life, at something God perhaps never asked you to do? Is it possible to succeed at the wrong thing?

SPEAKER_00You know, what if others are applauding you for things that God has not even asked you to do? We live in a culture with powerful scorecards about what success looks like: growth and bigger, better influence, more visibility and power, money, achievement, you name it, productivity. And it's just easy for us, so easy, it's so common for us as Christians and ministries to just take those scorecards of what success is and we just bring it into the church. We just bring it into our work for Jesus.

SPEAKER_00And this is a question it's taken me almost 40 years to answer. What does success actually look like to God? So a bit of a story of that exposed, you know, my own wrong definition of success. And I'll just begin with the planting of the church that I founded, uh called New Life Fellowship Church in Queens, New York. For the first uh six, seven years, uh, I thought I knew what success was. I was quite sure of it actually. Growing the ministry uh numerically, uh greater power, fulfilling the great commission, going and make disciples of all nations, maximizing my gifts and talents, as well as maximizing the talents and gifts of everybody around us as we built this community.

SPEAKER_00But the result was we were very active, we were, we were busy, we were stressed, uh, we were growing, uh, but the our joy was diminishing. I was tired, so was a lot of other people. There was a there was drivenness for sure in the culture. And I saw uh clearly, at least in other people initially, that a person can be doing uh a lot and apparently growing this a ministry and yet internally becoming less and less like Jesus. I just didn't see it in me. And then we had a a church split, a crisis.

SPEAKER_00And uh in one of the congregations we planted, we were one church in two languages, and and our Spanish congregation in the afternoon split. And I had invested so much of my life, five years to build it. And I ended up on a descent for a couple of years that I would never have chosen. And I had to face questions that I was previously avoiding. Questions like, what happens uh when what I'm building, what I'm investing my life in, is not producing the kind of results I had hoped?

SPEAKER_00How much of this actually is about me not being a loser? And who am I when I don't appear successful, at least by the standards everyone's put around me and uh the world standards, the church's standards? And I realized that I had spent a good part of my leadership life, my ministry succeeding at things for God that he never asked me to do. I thought they were for God, but he never asked me to do them in the first place. And so eventually I realized God used this crisis that lasted a good two years to get my attention, to shift me, to get me to listen to him, because I wasn't listening.

SPEAKER_00And uh and actually he exposed uh my definition of success really for the wrong thinking that it was. And so I hit rock bottom uh eventually, and I discovered that at rock bottom, Jesus was waiting for me there, uh, not at the top of the ladder, like I thought he was waiting for me. He was actually waiting for me at the bottom of the ladder. And um he met me. Uh and I saw how possible it is to be build something big while actually becoming more unhealthy and diminishing actually in uh formation, my formation in Christ.

SPEAKER_00So, and that Jesus was not simply interested in me becoming more productive. He was actually interested in me becoming a different person. That's what was the need was. So uh that success began to look differently to me. And it began less like climbing higher and more like following Jesus more deeply. That was a big shift. It was frightening and it was liberating because I didn't have a lot of models around me, but a number of questions emerged for me, questions, deeper questions that that was not simply what am I accomplishing, but who am I becoming as I'm serving Jesus, as I'm working for him. And there was formation internally, I realized that was key, as well as doing the work, in a sense, accomplishing, working for Jesus.

SPEAKER_00So it was both and it wasn't either or. And I feel I felt called by God to stay as a lead pastor in Queens, uh, New York, and build a church that was going to actually make it um reach the world and proclaim Jesus in our, in, in our community. So Jerry and I and the leadership, we slowed down and we got really serious about formation and discipleship and building a quality church, a quality community. We still remained committed to uh preaching the gospel, but we slowed down uh a lot uh to do both formation and uh the doing of the ministry for God.

SPEAKER_00So, uh as many of you are probably familiar with, I began to do things like emotionally healthy spirituality, things that are an emotionally healthy relationships course, those two courses that many churches do began to build out discipleship much more seriously than simply uh doing a Bible study, but actually getting people to live scripture and change, be transformed by Christ. And we began to invest in the three and the and the 12, uh, in the few, as well as uh dealing with a larger church that was still growing, uh, and the 70 and the 500s.

SPEAKER_00And we began to measure things like reconciliation. Are we bridging racial, cultural, economic, and gender barriers? Are we building a quality community? And of course, I wrote some books along the way as a way of sharpening my own thinking as we began to see fruit uh all around us. And so, besides emotionally healthy spirituality, which is probably the first large book that you know came out into the world about this new paradigm of uh how to follow Jesus with emotional health and a slowdown spirituality. And then I began to develop some leadership books.

SPEAKER_00I wrote Emotionally Healthy Leader, which really dealt with the person, uh, the person of trans, it's called the emotional healthy leader, transform how transforming your inner life will deeply transform your church, your team, and the world. And so the focus was you, the person, uh, who am I becoming? And how the interior, our interior lives, our formation impacts every decision we make, uh, every relationship, the way we do team building, culture, endings and new beginnings, that we cannot give what we do not possess.

SPEAKER_00And then I wrote Emotionally Healthy Discipleship a few years later, moving from shallow discipleship to deep discipleship. And the focus here was building a culture that was grounded in actually forming Peter. What does that culture need to have in it biblically? Limit grief and loss, be before we do. And we're gonna look at seven marks of this culture to deeply transform people. And I wrestled then, I wrestled in those books. I touched on this issue of success, and the best response I could offer was this success according to scripture is becoming the person God calls you to become, and doing what God calls you to do in his way and according to his timetable.

SPEAKER_00I'll say it again because I think it's a great general definition. And it took me a number of years to get to that, the writing of two books for that one sentence that success according to scripture is becoming the person God calls you to become, and doing what God calls you to do in his way and according to his timetable. But I didn't have much specificity beyond that. I felt quite free, but I kept getting pressed with the question, how do I actually measure success, Pete?

SPEAKER_00It's not numbers. And it was such a deep-felt need all over the world. The question just simply wouldn't go away. Because it's the question, let's face it, we wake up with every day uh before God. We set priorities, we make decisions, we build teams. And so I began to cry out in God to God, like, God, help me get more specific on how do we actually measure success. And uh, I asked God for direction and clarity for what might a new scorecard look like. And over time, uh it began to take shape.

SPEAKER_00There's actually like a I tell it was like a moment as I was wrestling with this, uh, where I could get beyond just doing God's will to actually something more concrete, something that would apply not just in the United States, but uh all around the world. And so I began to work on a book called Emotionally Healthy Success, which is I've just completed. And uh the title is Emotionally Healthy Success. The subtitle is What Measuring What Matters Most to Jesus? It's a very important subtitle.

SPEAKER_00What measuring what matters most to Jesus? And uh it's a new score that there we just passed numbers to something, again, that uh much larger, much more nuanced, et cetera. So I just never imagined it was gonna take three and a half years. I expected it to take one year. In my imagination, I never imagined it was gonna take as long as it did. Because the, and I realized because the question is so multi-layered, it's so deep, it touches on all of our families of origin.

SPEAKER_00For example, what did you learn about success in your family growing up? What did I learn? Uh, what were the unspoken commandments? What are what's our need for validation from others because we didn't get enough of it, perhaps growing up? What are the things that your family would say, oh, you're a loser if you do this, you know? And it's just so deep. We say great, Jesus may live in your heart, but grandpa lives in your bones. Well, when we get to the issue of success, your family of origin, those unspoken, unconscious commandments, they're so deep in our bones.

SPEAKER_00So it's going to take serious formation to basically rip that out and replace it with Jesus. But it's not just our family of origin, it's Western culture and our society. Our society, what does it reward? What does it celebrate? We live in the 21st century West. We have the social media, we are, it's on our phones, it's coming with at us from every direction. And, you know, as one pastor said to me, I do, I feel okay about pastoring and leading on Sundays. It's till I, it's not until I go to Instagram that I get so discouraged because according to the culture and the wider culture, my church isn't anything.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't look like much. And uh, so I got the culture and society screaming at me a whole different scorecard for success. And then, much like it was in Jesus' day. And then, of course, we have the church, uh, which has taken on the world scorecard and uh in the conferences, publishing, and for sure, 50 to 75 years ago, there was a huge shift uh into what's called uh growing numbers, church growth movement. And uh so, and then then it's a question, so look at Jesus and and and what does it mean to let Jesus redefine the whole thing of success?

SPEAKER_00And I realized, wow, that's a gigantic question. Uh, what's a biblical scorecard with specificity and how do we live, how do we actually live it? How do we become that kind of person? It's easy to preach, but it's hard to live. And there's actually a number of factors that I ended up having to deal with in writing the book. There was there was a personal factor. I had to do a deep dive, a painful dive, into my own journey around success over decades and really beginning in my late 20s, my 20s, that personal wrestling.

SPEAKER_00And there were stages for me. I clearly I got free on a, you know, but I still had some grave clothes on, kind of like Lazarus. As I entered the emotionally healthy spirituality space, my goodness, I what a freedom it was. It was liberating. Uh, however, there was great, there were levels of interior freedom that happened over the years that it became a deeper and deeper freedom around success. So, and I realized I was reviewing my journals recently, and I every periodically I go away for a you know, time with a day with God or a couple of days with God.

SPEAKER_00And I review my journals. And as I looked at my journals over, you know, a 10, 15 year period, I said, oh Lord, every growth moment for me, in especially around interior freedom, being able to let go, just relax and in God, and that kind of freedom, every depth of level of freedom had a crucible with it, had a labor pain with it. Uh there was a death to it. There it nothing was, oh, God just handed it from heaven.

SPEAKER_00Uh, it was a journey of formation with Jesus in the context of the crucible of life. And I suspect uh it may be the same for you as you get on this journey. So there's a personal factor that was huge. There was a practical factor. Uh, you know, and as you're leading, serving Jesus, your reality is you have people, you have teams, you have money issues, budgets, and volunteers and staffing and planning and all that. And and so there's a practical how do I actually work this thing out if I'm actually continuing to serve Jesus?

SPEAKER_00Then thirdly, there was the biblical material. I and I I'd been, you know, I I I had to dive into Jesus and his understanding of success in his context, which wasn't that different than ours once you get underneath it, and dive into Jesus, his understanding of success, his clear redefinition of success over and against the religious leaders of his day, again, which was not that different than ours. And I had to wrestle with the verses that people use quickly and flippantly to re in our in our culture, in our context, in Western culture, taking Acts 2, just simply baptizing numbers, they had 3,000, then 5,000.

SPEAKER_00And uh it was a deep dive because we want to be like Jesus. He is the God man, he he is who we want to become like. And I realized, wow, so I I needed to dig deep in a new way into all four gospels, into Jesus' deep definition of success. That took time. Then there was the historical material. Uh, how did the church redefine success? How did the church define success over the last 2,000 years? And we are very limited. We live in a moment of time in the 21st century that it's the air we breathe, how the how the world we live in defines success.

SPEAKER_00Well, the question is, how did the church define success in the first century, in the third century, and in the fourth century, in the fifth century? Again, we don't see things unless we see the larger, longer arc of God through actually human history. And then finally, there's a global piece. God's church was birthed uh, you know, in the Mid East. Uh, North Africa was a center, and it's all over the world. And so I had to look not just at the centuries, but the different streams of the church all around the world over these 2,000 years.

SPEAKER_00So I remember going to uh a theological library, um, actually Princeton Theological Library, one of the best theological libraries in the world. And there was a scholar there who his job is to help people do research. And he's free. And I was, I so I ended up working with this guy. And I said, listen, how I'm researching how the church defines success over the last 2,000 years. And I told him what I was working on, and he said to me, you know, I've done research for a lot of people, but no one's ever asked me that question before.

SPEAKER_00And he there wasn't one resource he could point me to. Uh, we ended up in all kinds of places, but it's a question obviously coming out of our context. And it was fascinating to do to look at all that. And uh, so I felt a great responsibility in writing the book because I knew a lot of people were gonna read it, and uh many people are gonna, and churches are gonna actually do it. And uh, so I wrote one book called Emotional Things Success, but actually there's two other books that never got in this book because I didn't want to write a 500-page book.

SPEAKER_00I wanted to keep it as a vision, as a prophetic summons, as a clear biblical, prophetic word for us today and an invitation to get on a big journey. And so I I wanted, uh I was very clear. I didn't want to make it a how-to book. I realized that's going to be uh well, all these resources that we can provide on our website and much of them for you know for free. And so I so I spent a lot of time studying, thinking, and pondering. And I also spent a lot of time praying in stillness and silence before the Lord.

SPEAKER_00So it was both these two things. It was the study, writing part, thinking part, but it was also the praying thoughtful part. And so I, every paragraph, every page, every chapter was written literally hundreds of times. I I didn't rush, I just I I didn't have a timetable on it. I just waited on the Lord as it as it began to take shape. So here's an overview. And I'm gonna call it a journey because it's a it's a seven-chapter book, but it's a seven-part journey. And uh I'm gonna take you over the next seven episodes, uh, one by one, through on this journey with me.

SPEAKER_00And we're gonna walk through the, I'm gonna call them seven movements in a journey. They're now each one's a chapter, because it's more of a journey than a table of contents. And so it starts with a part one. Uh the first two chapters are around the problem of how we measure success. So it begins with chapter, you know, chapter one or part one is uh the lies we call success. And that it sounds like, oh, that's so easy. No, it's had to be very nuanced, and it's actually a very deep question to ask.

SPEAKER_00What are the lies that we believe about success? And I chose the five most common ones today. Uh, and it's painful to look at. And then the second chapter is the wreckage of a wrong scorecard. And I'm reading right now a book written by a Methodist pastor from Hiroshima, Japan. And he was pastoring a church of several hundred members in Hiroshima when the atomic bomb exploded there. And it's his story of pasturing, you know, serving people, pastoring a church in the midst of all this.

SPEAKER_00And the horror of what's on the ground, because he's talking about people by name who's the wreckage of the atomic bomb. It's very different than just talking about geopolitics. And uh I realized when you talk when we talk about the wreckage of a wrong scorecard, it's also painful to look at. But we we have to look at it because the answer is so large, we have to look at the problem is so massive and the wreckage is massive. And then that's part one of the book, first two two two parts of the journey, the first two chapters.

SPEAKER_00So the part two of the book, the center of the book, is how Jesus redefines success. And so chapter three is Jesus' four great reversals of success. Uh, that's chapter three. And again, trying to put in one chapter everything Jesus has about success, and I get it down to four great reversals. Um, and then then it's the new scorecard. Chapter four and five is an is chapter four is a new score scorecard for success. I call it movement one, personal formation assessment. And then chapter five is a new scorecard, movement two, culture formation assessment.

SPEAKER_00So it's one scorecard and two movements. And again, it took years to get it's very specific, uh, eight marks in each. And uh we'll get into it when we get there, but it it's it's it's a lot. And then the last part of the book, the last two chapters are how do we become the kind of people, the kind of leaders, and how do we build the kind of churches that actually live this, that Jesus imagined? That's actually the title.

SPEAKER_00So uh uh chapter six, chapter before the end, two last chapters are embrace a rule of life strong enough to hold the weight of your calling. What's it going to take in terms of our formation to live into Jesus' new scorecard or Jesus redefinition of success? Because it's one thing to preach it, it's another thing to live it. And uh so that's chapter or part six. And then the final part and final chapter is called Choosing Choosing God's slower, truer way.

SPEAKER_00How do I live this out long term? This is not a program, this is not a turning of a switch. Uh, so my dream for you is that you're gonna change the way you define success uh on this journey uh through the book, Emotionally Health Success. I hope you'll pick it up. But more than that, more importantly, is you're gonna actually uh begin to take this in and ponder it. Uh and I pray these next seven podcasts will be helpful for you uh to supplement your reading. But I trust you'll begin to look at people with a new set of eyes. I pray that you'll notice God, you'll see God differently, you'll have a fresh revelation of Jesus, things that you've overlooked.

SPEAKER_00I pray you'll actually set priorities differently, you'll you'll lead differently, you'll live differently, you'll you'll discover a steadier inner life, a more an easy yoke that Jesus actually promises us. I pray you'll serve now without leading, without losing yourself, without, without rushing. Uh, you'll serve without fear, uh, without looking over your shoulder, what people think, without guilt. You won't you'll feel free from the crushing weight of people's expectations. This isn't about surviving. Uh my prayer for you is that you'll enter into this journey of emotionally healthy success, and you'll actually flourish over a lifetime, not just for a couple of years, but for 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 years of your life serving Jesus that you can continue to flourish.

SPEAKER_00And imagine your capacity for loving God and others. Matures and grows with time, not diminishes. Imagine your joy growing with decades, with that past, not diminishing. Imagine finishing well, not merely being faithful, but seeing yourself, seeing those around you, seeing those you've touched of actually they're flourishing in God, and that you're leaving behind lasting fruit that will endure beyond you, of transformed lives, uh, people who are spiritually rooted in Jesus.

SPEAKER_00This can be yours, uh, but it's not, it doesn't just happen. It's not by accident. It requires a profound reordering of your life, of uh what you pursue. Uh, it requires formation, not simply information. Uh, it's a fresh revelation of Jesus that one wants to live into. So I hope for those of you you're listening to me now, this series that we're going into is for all of you. It's for those who spent a lot of your life, like I did, trying to prove that we matter. So it's for you who are pastors in churches, for sure.

SPEAKER_00Maybe your church is growing, but your spaciousness and inner life is not. Uh, it's for those any of you who are serving in churches, uh, and maybe your relationships are are strained because you don't even have time, but the ministry may even look impressive. It's for you, maybe you've achieved a great deal in life, uh, but you sense inside that maybe something's, maybe I didn't, maybe I'm not on track here. Uh, is this really it? Or maybe you feel like a failure because you haven't done quite enough or achieved quite enough. Or maybe you're a young person, you're just getting started, and you're trying to say, well, how do I build?

SPEAKER_00How do I even go forward with what is success? Or uh or maybe you're actually an older person and you're looking at the final decades of your life and you're saying, what does it look like to actually succeed in my second half of life? So in every arena, whether you're pastoring, whether you're serving in a church, whether you're a nonprofit leader, whether you're in a parachurch staff, uh, whether you're a volunteer in your church, a board member, uh, I want to invite you to on this journey with me uh through these next seven podcasts. And so the invitation is I started with the question, what if you could succeed brilliantly at something that, but actually God never asked you to do it?

SPEAKER_00And is it possible to succeed at the wrong thing? And what if the thing, people, things that people are applauding you for is not even the things that God's asked you to do? So that's the questions we're going to explore together in these podcasts over the next couple of months. But let me let me pause and close with a story from C.S. Lewis in his uh great book, The Great Divorce. And it's a story that so stuck with me. I have uh referred to it many, many times over the years.

SPEAKER_00And it's helped it kind of encapsulates the reshaping of my own vision. And I pray, I think I think Lewis gets at the kind of reshaping Jesus wants to do of our vision of what success is. And uh, it's an allegorical novel, The Great Divorce about Heaven and Hell. And so the character's name is Sarah Smith. And she's portrayed as a virtuous woman, but of she was a woman of little importance on earth. She lived without regard of recognition by other people or influence.

SPEAKER_00She appeared to have very little visible earthly success during her life. By every category that mattered on earth, her life was small. But when a visitor goes to heaven, has a goes into heaven, he encounters Sarah. And he's stunned because she's preceded by a massive procession of men, women, and angels. And they're throwing flowers, they're dancing, they're celebrating Sarah's arrival uh, you know, on the scene in heaven.

SPEAKER_00And the visitor assumes she must have been an extraordinary person in her earthly life. And so he asks his guide. He says, She seems to be a person, well, of particular importance. Aye, yes, says the guide. She is one of the great ones. You have heard and here that fame in this country and fame on earth are two quite different things.

SPEAKER_00I'll say that again. His response, the guy's response is she is one of the great ones. You have heard that fame in heaven, fame in this country, heaven, and fame on earth are two quite different things. Isn't that awesome? It captures what Jesus says in the gospels to us. Fame in heaven and fame on earth are two very different things.

SPEAKER_00Remember that name, Sarah Smith from the Great Divorce, that allegory by C.S. Lewis. So let's pray the prayer of Psalm 131. It's a beautiful prayer to close our time together. And this is David's prayer to the Lord. And let's make it our own. He says this, O Lord, my heart is not proud, nor my eyes arrogant, nor do I involve myself in great matters or things too difficult for me. And he writes this I have I have quieted, I have soothed and quieted my soul like a weaned child resting with his mother, like a weaned, my soul is like a weaned child within me.

SPEAKER_00And may we rest on the bosom of the Father, content, joyful, receiving what he has for our life for us. God bless everybody. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A New Scorecard: Personal Formation (Breathing In)

    Nov 10, 202627 minAudio

    Before you listen, I want to give you two free tools. The Leadership Scorecard takes about ten minutes and helps you see where you actually are, personally and as a leader, measured by what matters most to Jesus. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jesus' Four Great Reversals

    Oct 27, 202631 minAudio

    If you're reading Emotionally Healthy Success with your team, start with the introduction videos and discussion guide we created to go with it at emotionallyhealthy.org/success. This episode is meant to supplement your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Wreckage of a Wrong Scorecard

    Oct 13, 202629 minAudio

    Pre-Order Pete Scazzero's forthcoming book, Emotionally Healthy Success, at www.emotionallyhealthy.org/success and get a free chapter. When I finished the first chapter of this book, I was ready to move on to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Lies We Call Success Part 1

    Sep 29, 202628 minAudio

    Pre-Order Pete Scazzero's forthcoming book, Emotionally Healthy Success, at www.emotionallyhealthy.org/success and get a free chapter. This is Part 1, and we're starting where the book starts: the lies we call success....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Reversal No. 4: From Critical Mass to Critical Yeast

    Sep 1, 202629 minAudio

    Pre-Order Pete Scazzero's forthcoming book, Emotionally Healthy Success, at www.emotionallyhealthy.org/success and get a free chapter. For years, I measured ministry impact by one word: bigger. I remember walking into...

    Credit the people on this episode