Natasha Donnelly is the Executive Director of House of the Redeemer, a historic retreat house on New York City’s Upper East Side. Before joining the House in 2025, she spent ten years in Catholic education, teaching theology, English, and serving in school leadership roles. Natasha holds a B.A. in English from Boston College and an M.Ed. and M.A. in School Leadership from the University of Notre Dame. At House of the Redeemer, she works to advance its mission of providing hospitality through worship, spiritual renewal, and cultural and community events. Natasha lives in Carnegie Hill with her husband, two-year-old daughter, and their Cavapoo. In this episode of The Élavive Edit, Jessica Oistacher speaks with Natasha Donnelly, Executive Director of House of the Redeemer, about bringing fresh energy and new possibilities to a historic retreat house on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. At the heart of the conversation is her approach to leadership: stay curious, trust your team, and look for ways to make meaningful ideas work. Her advice for anyone considering a new direction is to recognize your gifts, ask others what strengths they see in you, and stay open to opportunities beyond your résumé. Learn more about the House of the Redeemer at https://www.houseoftheredeemer.org/ or @houseoftheredeemer on Instagram. Explore the future of wellness and performance at www.elavive.com, and join our community on Instagram @elaviveus. Original music by Emily Gabriele. #LiveElevated #ElevateYourTeam
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Here's something that most people don't know. It takes just 90 seconds for an emotion to whisk through the body. Everything after that is a story we choose to keep repeating. So if you've been hearing stress, pause, take a breath, and let the wave move through. Welcome to the LFIB edit. So excited to have you here with me. I'm Jessica O'Satra, and today is Friday, October 16th.
SPEAKER_00New York is full of hidden gems, and some of its most extraordinary places are the ones you pass by without ever knowing what's inside. Tucked away on the Upper East Side, House of the Redeemer is one of those places. Today we're joined by its executive director, Natasha Donnelly, who has brought fresh energy, new ideas, and exciting programming to the house, opening more opportunities for people to experience its mission of hospitality, spiritual renewal, worship, culture, and community.
SPEAKER_00I'm here with Natasha Donnelly. She is the executive director of the House of the Redeemer. So welcome, Natasha. Thank you. Thanks so much for having me. There's so much history in this house, and it's incredible what you've done to bring that sense of culture and community to the neighborhood. First, I'd love to hear a little bit more about you and how you got to where you are now.
SPEAKER_01Sure. I studied at Boston College. I loved the Jesuit education there. I was inspired to be a teacher to use my education to give back to others. I applied for a teaching program at the University of Notre Dame called ACE or the Alliance for Catholic Education. I was placed in South Texas for three years, where I taught high school English. And after three years, I'm from Long Island originally, so I wanted to come to New York to be closer to my family. I taught in an all-girls Catholic school on the Upper East Side here for the next seven years.
SPEAKER_01During that time, I ended up getting married and having a baby. Our family moved close to the Upper East Side to be closer to my job. The opportunity opened up as executive director at the House of the Redeemer. So I applied and I had an open mind and I was really inspired by the mission and the opportunity to continue to steward the house and make sure that it's a place of hospitality and welcome for the next generation of people who come through the doors.
SPEAKER_00That's wonderful. Wow. So you had a background in teaching. Is that what you thought you'd do for the rest of your career initially?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a good question. During my time at Notre Dame, I studied both teaching and then also Catholic school leadership. Okay. I think I was interested in positions at Catholic schools, probably as the dean or principal head of a sounds like a leadership. Yeah, exactly. Something you were interested in. When I transitioned, I was the director of upper school campus ministries, planning a lot of chapels and retreats and working with young people in their spiritual journeys. The House of the Redeemer actually ended up being a good, an unexpected fit because we're a retreat house and we welcome many people on personal retreats, but then also churches and organizations who organize group retreats as well as different programs for the community.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. So someone can come on their own or if they're a part of a group. How many rooms do you have?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we have 14 overnight guest rooms on the third and fourth floor. And the priority is given to groups. So churches, organizations that reach out to us and they want to organize a retreat. So booking several guest rooms as well as meeting space to organize a retreat for their community. People also reach out for individual retreats or individual overnight stays for people who want to come and attend our chapel services or just have some quiet time away for spiritual refreshment and prayer.
SPEAKER_00That's wonderful. Yeah. The spiritual services, you have those every every day?
SPEAKER_01During the active year from September to June, every Monday through Friday we have morning and evening prayer. Morning prayers at 8 and evening prayers at 5:30. That's actually how I first learned about the house is that I came to evening prayer quite a few times. There's a rotating priest in residence program. So different Episcopal or Anglican clergy stay at the house for between two and four weeks and they celebrate services. But they also stand outside. And as neighbor, I would see them and get start talking to them when I was going for walks to the park.
SPEAKER_00They always give offer sake treats when we're walking by.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I really love that. There's always somebody new to get to know. And that was what first drew me to the house, the prayer services.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so you were a little bit familiar with the house before.
SPEAKER_01And some of the priests, it's a small community, so you get to know the other people who come to services. Sometimes they'll invite you for wine and cheese or try to get to know you and just be there, listen to your voice.
SPEAKER_00That's incredible. But you've done so much, you've only been here for a year now. Yeah. What would you say is your favorite project that you've worked on?
SPEAKER_01When I first started July 1, there was a theatrical production in the works, a director, Keaton Wooden, who wanted to bring Tartoof to the house. I met with him right away, and we had a run of an off-Broadway show of Tartuffe here in the library last year from September through November. And it was a great success. It was a big undertaking and it took a lot of planning and coordination. But we were able to welcome a hundred new people to the house at every production. And it brought so many people to the Upper East Side, to Carnegie Hill, to see the house.
SPEAKER_00And it brought Broadway to the Upper East Side. Right, yes. My husband is not a fan of going to Midtown. So when I told him the show was here, it was an easy yes. Yes. And it was a wonderful, wonderful show. Our parents came in and we all watched it together. It was lovely.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, that was it was a bit of a risk because the house had never done anything on that scale. There was a lot of logistical coordination to finding dressing rooms for all the actors, stairs. But it was great. It brought a lot of people here and as well as put us on the map culturally. And then we ended up hosting a second theatrical production, True, with Jesse Tyler Ferguson about Sherman Capote. That was a great success as well in the spring, continuing to welcome new people to the house. Those two productions were definitely a highlight of my first year. I hope to build on that to continue to host more theatrical productions and concerts at the house this year.
SPEAKER_00It's a really a wonderful thing for the community. It's so nice to have something in the neighborhood, something fun to do to bring everyone together. And the shows were phenomenal. Even true, unfortunately, we were not able to make it, but I understand the storyline was based in a living room. Yeah. So it was. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01The setting was the living room of Trimut Capote on the on the upper east side.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And the I love the history too of the library, how they brought it in from it was from Italy.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. The House of the Redeemer's history was founded by Edith Shepard Favrey and her husband Ernesto. And they planned the house around the living room. It's two stories, and it's from the Duke's Palace, the Ducal Palace of Urbino. And during World War I, they shipped it over on two boats in case one was bombed or torpedoed, that at least half of it would survive. So it really is the gem of the house, and so many people come to visit it. It's also been where we posted the Fabry concert series as well as the theatrical productions and different movie shoots as well.
SPEAKER_00Wonderful.
SPEAKER_01And the the ceiling is also from it is it's the crest of the Duke of Urbino. And when Mrs. Fabry donated the house, in her speech, she said that the crest was thought to be painted by Raphael.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Yeah. Incredible. Very cool. What is the mission of the house?
SPEAKER_01So we're a place of hospitality and welcome. We're a retreat house. We also host community and cultural events as well. Yeah, it's like the two pieces, right? The spirituality and the guest rooms. But then also we're we open our doors for different community and cultural events to welcome neighbors.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Did you have any community events last year that were really spectacular?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we have the events that as a house that we plan internally, but then also we're approached by all sorts of nonprofit organizations and churches who like to host their events here. Our in-house programs, we have Fabri Concert Series. We host about four of those each year, and we have a concert, a chamber music concert in the library, and then we have a reception downstairs here in the refectory. So fun. We also had a Christmas party that was sold out. We had 120 people come, and it was the 30th anniversary of the Christmas party.
SPEAKER_01We had a reading of a Christmas carol, singing carols, and then we came downstairs here for a party. Then we also have our two fundraisers, the Winter Benefit and the Spring Garden Party. We had about 90 people here for the Spring Garden Party in the courtyard. I was really pleased of how many people came out to support our concerts and our events, as well as numerous nonprofit organizations who reached out to us about hosting their benefits or presentations here.
SPEAKER_00It's your first year, and it sounds like you've already accomplished so much. You make it look very easy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01One thing that we did early on was we redid our website.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01The new website. It's really user-friendly, and we have a contact form. I love reading those. People write in with different ideas of events they want to host here or ways that we can collaborate. I think in my first year I've just been really receptive to reach replying right away to people who reach out and to exploring different partnerships or ideas. We've been busy, but a lot of people have reached out to us. Beautiful. It's beautiful plays.
SPEAKER_00I remember when you first started. I'm sure you get so many inquiries and being able to manage that with also the projects that you have going on. Like you said, you have plays going on, shows going on, you have guests coming in and out of the house and being able to stay on top of the inquiries as well. You know, you're a small team here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just flexible. That's something that has been important to me is I don't really, unless something is obviously not a good fit, I try not to say no, but I say, oh, these are the dates that we do have available, or if this room's not available, what about this?
SPEAKER_00Just having a flexible mindset. Yeah. Staying curious, saying, how can we do this and making it work?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. One challenge that we've had is in the summers, we don't have central air conditioning yet. So the guest rooms, there's only some rooms that are available because the windows are compatible with air conditioning units. Okay. In May, right before the summer started, I had three young people who are working at different churches who wanted to know if they could stay here as summer intern housing. Okay. So if you looked at our software, all of the rooms with air conditioning were booked, but we were able to take the dressing rooms. There's a mezzanine apartment that uses dressing rooms for the theatrical productions, as well as more of a conference studio space, but it had air conditioning.
SPEAKER_01So I with a flexible mindset, I was able to find three rooms for the summer interns. And it worked out really well. It was nice having folks here over the summer. Definitely. For example, like in the past, maybe I think this is still on our website that it says, Oh, we don't host rentals in the summer. But I say to people, I say, Oh, we don't have air conditioning, but here's a link to a company that we work with that can bring in air conditioners.
SPEAKER_00Perfect.
SPEAKER_01So yesterday we hosted a shoot commercial with CNN, and they worked with the company to bring in air conditioning unit. So just I I try not to say no to inquiries if it's something that could work or an exciting event to have here. I try to find a way to make it work.
SPEAKER_00As long as it aligns with the mission, like and you find a way. Anything is possible here, and you're really bringing that energy to the house. I love that. Yeah, thank you. I had my wedding here, and I heard you have quite a few weddings planned for wedding season.
SPEAKER_01Yes, we do. We have weddings almost every weekend in October and November, and then we already have two weddings for May and June coming up. So yeah, I think that's a really beautiful way to experience the house is by having weddings and inviting wedding guests to come celebrate.
SPEAKER_00Our guests were so impressed with the house, and I didn't even realize there was a secret wall in the bookshelf.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yes, there's actually like a service elevator in the bookshelf of the library. And it looks there's books on top of the elevator, so it looks like Lens right in.
SPEAKER_00I didn't even see it. That night one of our good friends sent us a video of it. Being able to have this beautiful space in New York City, the indoor, outdoor courtyard space is absolutely perfect. And to have to be married in a venue with so much history was really lovely. You're already booked out until June, so 2027. That's wonderful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The fall is going to be busy, like I said, in the summer right now, because we don't have air conditioning, it's a little bit of a slower time, and a lot of people leave the city, but especially October through June. Okay. We have quite a few weddings as well as concerts and rentals, nonprofit gatherings, things like that.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I love how this work really aligns with what you thought you would do in your career. It maybe is not exactly what you thought you would do, but it sounds like you always wanted to be in a leadership position.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the word flexible keeps coming up to me, just kind of like being open-minded and willing to pursue something that's unexpected or something new.
SPEAKER_00What would you say to someone who is in a role that they enjoy, but maybe they want to take that next step? What advice would you give them?
SPEAKER_01To know your own gifts, right? To know yourself and what gives you a sense of energy and joy, and also to talk to people that you know and to see what gifts that they see in you and to be open, always looking. And if you see something that's interesting to pursue it that aligns with, it doesn't have to align with your resume exactly, right? But if what you're doing and the gifts that you have align with something to take a chance and to pursue it.
SPEAKER_00I love how you said understand the gifts that you have and also ask someone else their perspective. That's great advice. Sometimes we're limited about ourselves to have another perspective can be really helpful. You've done so much in so many different areas from the the concerts to the theater productions to the events, you had some experience, but a lot of this is new to you. How do you approach something that's totally new?
SPEAKER_00You've never done it before. Do you have a process that you work by?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so even though we're a small staff of three, the other two people who are operations manager and office administrator, they've been working here for some time. When I was new, I asked them a lot of questions about oh, do you think this would be a good fit for us, or how would you go about this? And relying on their expertise. And then I always welcome people here for a site visit.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01I set up a lot of site visits, and I think we have a pretty high yield. Once people come and they see the beauty of the house and you get to know them, just meeting people in person. So I'd say first leaving in my team and asking for their professional advice.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01And then meeting people in person and seeing if it would be a good fit, and if so, how we can make it work.
SPEAKER_00I love that. Yeah. It sounds like you take it day by day. This is your first year in the role. It's very exciting. Now you've dipped your toes, you've done a phenomenal job. Do you have a vision for the next year and what you'd like to see?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'd really like to invest the money that we've made this year back into the house, especially into the infrastructure. This summer we did a hot water project where we made sure that there's instant hot water in the shower for guests who stay overnight. We're also working on an air conditioning project to bring air conditioning to all of the guest rooms. And then the next two years, I'd also like to make sure there's air conditioning in the first and second floor of our event spaces and the library and in this room in the refectory that we're sitting in now, as well as the second phase of the window project.
SPEAKER_01A few years ago, they replaced all the windows on the front of the building, and now all the windows on the back of the building need to be replaced. So yeah, I think a goal of mine is to invest in the infrastructure of the house and to make sure that it's well set up and that people who come here are comfortable.
SPEAKER_00Definitely. I still am amazed. It's like a museum. Yeah. Everything is so well kept. A lot of work goes into restoring the house and keeping it up to that same standard.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Before I started the house, it has won awards for cyclical maintenance. It's just been really well maintained without having to undergo major renovations. It still looks very similar to when the Fabry family lived here. Yes. So, in addition to those big projects like air conditioning and windows, also periodically to get different pieces of furniture restored. The piece right here, this table, we just had it restored and it looks great. Little pieces of wood were falling off. Okay. And then this silk screen and the paintings have recently been restored with the past 10 years or so.
SPEAKER_01Yes, every year to make sure that the house and all of its contents remain in good condition. That's also a goal of ours.
SPEAKER_00I love that. Very exciting. Yeah. You also have some community events coming up. Tell us a little bit about that. Sure.
SPEAKER_01I've really enjoyed partnering with Carnegie Hill Neighbors, which is a neighborhood organization. So in October, we're planning a Mahjong event where over the course of four weeks, we'll welcome people to the house between probably 12 and 2 to meet one another, socialize, but also learn mahjong and play with one another. And then hopefully down the line we'll have a big event where not just people who are able to come between 12 and 2, but also all neighbors will come and maybe 50, 100 people and all play and socialize and to raise money for the house and for Carnegie Hill neighbors.
SPEAKER_01I worked with them last year on a cinema series. We had a series of movies at the house, and the one in September had the biggest, the most successful attendance, but then it capered off. I think people don't want to just watch a movie, they also want to interact and maybe learn something and do something together. We're trying to build off the movie series and offer a game where people can interact and do something together. That's so fun. It's a game that four people can play at a time, and it'll be open to all different levels. And we're hoping to have an instructor come to teach people who are beginners, and then people who have some experience, they can play with it as a group of four.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah, so maybe it would all be in the library. Maybe we would have one group here with beginners, and then in the reception room, a group of intermediate, advanced. It really depends on how many people sign up and what their skill level is. Exactly. Yeah. So just again being flexible based on the interests and based on what experience people have.
SPEAKER_00And it's a fun game. I came last Thursday to play. Natasha was my instructor. It's a lot of fun. Yeah. Great way to bring people together. Yeah. Okay. As far as your career 10 years down the line, where do you see yourself?
SPEAKER_01I just started here. I'm very happy at the house, and I'm excited to see in the next five or ten years how it continues to grow. I have these series of projects that I want to get done. Also, restoring the organ. There is an Aeolian organ in the library that doesn't work. I'd love to have that restored. So I have a lot of goals here for the time being, especially having a young child. This is a great career fit.
SPEAKER_00That's exciting. Yeah. It sounds like you have such a big vision for the house, and you've already accomplished so much. So I'm excited to see where it goes. Thank you. Thank you again for joining. And yeah, we'll have to catch up soon so you can hear how everything went. Love that. Thank you. Before you go, take one more deep breath. Whatever you're carrying, remember it only takes 90 seconds to let it move through. So pause, reset, and begin again.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for joining me on the Elave Edit Jessica O'Stacher. If today's conversation inspired you, share it with someone who could use a moment of calm and clarity. I'll see you next week.
Aleksey Kernes is a hospitality entrepreneur and experiential marketing strategist known for building culture-driven brands at the intersection of coffee, nightlife, and lifestyle. As the founder of Have A Nice Day...
In this episode of The Élavive Edit, Morgan Salsman, founder of LQD Assets, shares her journey from engineering to building a $21M whiskey barrel investment business. Raised in the bourbon capital of Bardstown,...
Vanessa Pascale is a seasoned editor and luxury lifestyle journalist who has interviewed the most accomplished names in entertainment (hundreds of in-person celebrity interviews and 100+ cover stories), including...
Artem Mashkov is a Startup Executive, Founder, and Mentor with a career defined by building, scaling, and sustaining high-growth businesses. After immigrating to the United States in 1995, Artem grew up on welfare...
Kathy Yavari is a Certified Integrative Health and Wellness coach, Ayurveda Specialist, and Founder of White Orchids Wellness. With a background that spans international business, finance, and marketing, Kathy brings a...