Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Double Pivot: Soccer analysis, analytics, and commentary

The Double Pivot: Soccer analysis, analytics, and commentary artwork

The State of the Premier League in 2026 with Ryan O’Hanlon

Nov 18, 20261 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We are joined by ESPN staff writer and author of Net Gains, the best book on modern soccer analytics, Ryan O’Hanlon for a long and in-depth and somehow only part one of two discussion of the state of the Premier League and the state of analytics in 2026. Talking about the new world of parity, why we all remain a little confused by the teams that seems to be the harbingers of parity (Bournemouth, Brighton, and maybe Forest?), and how this is affecting the competitive dynamics and the tactical development of the sport. We also begin our discussion of the state of analytics but come to the realization that will have to be a whole nother hour. Follow Ryan’s writing at his No Grass in the Clouds newsletter: You can also watch on YouTube: This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.expectinggoals.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to the Double Pivot, the world's most agreeable soccer analytics podcast. I am Michael Caley. We are back. It remains the international break, although only for like the remainder of this week. We're not doing that three-week thing again. And I just think that this is like a great idea. The international break should happen at exactly 10 matches into the season. 10 matches and we've all decided that you can start to make stronger and more... Confident claims about what's going on in football.

SPEAKER_01And so now here we are, we got two weeks, we got time to like really step back. And we're going to really try to talk about some of the new trends in the Premier League this season, how they appear tactically and statistically, and what we think is going on and starting to make some tentative hypotheses about big questions. And We've got a perfect guest for this conversation.

SPEAKER_01So I'm joined by Mike Goodman. I was bold. Perfect guest at the beginning instead of the end of the podcast.

SPEAKER_03That's confident. And I agree. The music you heard on the way in as well as... Please download, subscribe, make us happy as podcasters over on YouTube, Double Pivot Pod, down below, hit the buttons, ding, all of that stuff. And we've got a great guest today, an old friend of mine from back in the Grantland days where he was my editor, currently a staff writer at ESPN, author of Net Gains, which is, you know... The best soccer analytics book you're going to read. And I'm going to guess that by this point, 98% of our listeners know who I'm talking about.

SPEAKER_03Please welcome Ryan O'Hanlon. Hey, Ryan.

SPEAKER_00What's up, guys? I want to know who the 2% of people that are listening to this podcast who don't know who I am are. And then I need to find out how I failed to reach them.

SPEAKER_03We've been making a heavy pitch the last two weeks, you may have noticed, for the expanded launch of Double Pivot and Expecting Goals. So I imagine, I hope... That like our like sort of sphere of influence is like extended on the margins to people who like discovered soccer analytics a week and a half ago and thought we were pretty cool and would give us a try. And maybe they don't know who you are. That's what I'm going with. So, you know, our newest listeners.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And who knows, like YouTube, like you might have found this from God only knows what. Welcome. Thank you. And Ryan is one of the... Media analytics OGs. And so this is like one of the perfect times to bring this conversation around.

SPEAKER_00I feel like I have either... Massively succeeded or massively failed because the relationship between writer and editor is an incredibly fraught relationship. And then the relationship between writer and subject is also an incredibly fraught relationship. So the fact that I was invited on this podcast either means I did both of those things well or both of those things incredibly poorly. And I don't know the answer.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you really should have taken me down a peg in that book. I mean, seriously.

SPEAKER_00If we ever do a paperback, I'll add an addendum.

SPEAKER_03Before we get too far up our own butts, let us talk about soccer to some degree or another. I think where we want to start is we have all in our various work sort of looked at the ways in which the Premier League has gotten better. And, you know, we talked a lot about the meat wall last year. And in fact, Kaylee has a meat wall newsletter out shortly before you were listening to this, depending on when you were listening to this, which we might come back to.

SPEAKER_03Even more so this year, I think, the Premier League trend of weirdness has continued. And I don't think on the podcast, at least, we've sort of tried to take like an overarching, like top down, look at what the heck is going on. And Ryan, I think you have a little bit in your writing. I think that, you know, we've looked at a whole bunch of sort of factors in micro. And I think you've done a really good job looking at kind of big picture things. What is going on with the Premier League at the moment?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think the easiest answer, which is something you guys have talked about, you haven't like, I don't know if you've done like a specific episode on this specific idea, but you've talked about this idea. With everything that's happening, I keep going back to this idea that the Premier League as a whole is getting richer and richer in comparison to all of the other leagues in the world. But then within that, what you have happening is that The big six are not getting richer in comparison to the other teams

SPEAKER_00in the Premier League. It's actually that gap, you know, if you look at transfer market values, things like that, that gap is closing. I guess for Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea to take a next step up in, let's say, transfer market value, they would have to be taking players from PSG and Barcelona, because there's only so many $100 million players. And because of the economic situations in those leagues,

SPEAKER_00those teams are all super wealthy still, despite their leagues as a whole trailing behind. So you have this situation, right? Where like the Rest of the Premier League team, like the other 14 are better than they've ever been. I think we would all agree on that because they've gotten a lot richer. But then like the teams at the top of the league have sort of just kind of stayed where they are, I think. And to me, that's kind of like the biggest factor behind all this.

SPEAKER_00I don't think it's the only explanation. But when I think about the league being weird, and I think by weird, maybe the way to frame that is like kind of the normal ways we look at this sport and predict what's going to happen. Expect what's doing to happen those things don't sort of match up as much anymore

SPEAKER_01to me at least Yeah like the very Straightforwardly, a rising tide has lifted all boats. And when that rising tide lifts all boats, what happens is that teams that were not just, say, $100 million in revenue ahead or whatever exactly the numbers are, they were like 2 to 1 or 3 to 1 in revenue ahead, and now they go down to 2 to one or 1 .5 to one.

SPEAKER_01And so the size of the gap if you subtract is the same, but the size of the cap if you divide is not the same. And that really matters for competitive balance.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that that is the right way to put it, and that's what I would expect from I don't know if I want to call you the most numerically inclined of the three of us, but the most adept at using numbers. Because I looked at it, and I think around 2018-19, the big six was like 60-ish percent if you do transfer market values of the Premier League. And this season, they're below 50%. So that kind of makes total sense to me, that framing.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we sort of looked at it. Actually, I had James Bench write something on CBS. So we were looking at it in the wake of the Manchester City stuff. And one of the claims from Manchester City fans was, well, if we... We didn't do this. The Red Mafia would return, right? And Liverpool, Manchester United, Arsenal would dominate because they would be the only ones that could spend as much. And when you dug into that, you just found exactly the thing that we're finding here, that over the last 10 years,

SPEAKER_03that's just not going to be the case anymore. That everybody, to some degree or another, is keeping up more than they used to. But to some degree, I don't find that to be totally explanatory. So I guess when I look at the Premier League, to me, what I think is okay. So if that's the case, then shouldn't we be able to see the talent gaps shrinking, right?

SPEAKER_03Shouldn't one thing that we see happening is... The best, richest teams in the Premier League are no longer buying the best players from the rest of the Premier League because they can't afford to and those other teams can keep them. And I think maybe we saw that for a few years, but if you look at the last two to three years of transfers in the Premier League, one thing you've seen is actually like this return of... The Big Six spending a lot of money to buy players up from the rest of the Premier League.

SPEAKER_03You know, whether it's Isak and Tenali going from Newcastle, you know, whether it's, you know, look, I had my things to say about Manchester City buying and drive from Everton, but clearly that was a big purchase that happened within the Premier League. Depending on how you want to define these things, Enzo going from Chelsea to Manchester City, Elliot Anderson going from Nottingham Forest to Manchester City. We've seen in the last couple of years really a lot of this spending.

SPEAKER_03And so... To me, I guess the second part of the trail of dominoes you need to look at if we're looking at it from this way is, does having more money... Empower the rest of the Premier League to keep up when their stars get bought better in that way? I mean, is that what's going on? Is that what we say is going on? Or are we just in a weird little lull where talent identification is a little bit mismatched? You know, what is actually happening with player movement as a result of the sort

SPEAKER_03of changing financial landscape?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think those are all really good points. And I think, yeah, a lot of this sometimes it's like maybe we're just in some weird sort of transitory time period and it's all going to shake out. Like as you're speaking, if I think of it just from like what we know about transfers online, Historically, intra-Premier League transfers are the most inefficient transfers, because they cost so much money. All transfers tend to be inefficient, if you just look at the market as a whole. If that's happening, the big teams are now delving

SPEAKER_00into the most inefficient transfer there is, which is Premier League to Premier League. Then the rest of the league are like, oh, we'll just get this guy that would have went to Dortmund, but now he goes to Nottingham Forest, and they're maybe fishing in a more Sort of more likely to be successful, less likely to be inefficient transfer area. So like that maybe could be a driver of it. But also, as I'm saying it, that feels like too cute potentially to also be true.

SPEAKER_03But as you're saying that, I have another suggestion to sort of counter my own question, which is like if three of the big six buy stars from the Premier League, And then you have six mid-table teams all spending money to bring in talent from wherever. It only takes one or two of those six succeeding to upend what we think of as the Premier League. From a numbers game-wise, every single one of the big teams has to be successful,

SPEAKER_03whereas only some of the mid-table teams have to be successful to really upturn the structures that we're used to.

SPEAKER_01And the other part of this, I think, you know, Ryan, I think that's exactly right to bring up where are they signing players from? Like Nottingham Forest, they lose Elliot Anderson, and they're bringing in McAtee from the City Academy, and they're bringing in Jarvis Schlager from RB Leipzig. Like, a team in the Champions League fight in Germany is now selling a key player, not super young, but still a good key player, to Nottingham Forest, who are maybe by XG one of the best teams in the league,

SPEAKER_01but certainly not a traditional powerhouse here. Like Leipzig—like a Champions League competing team in Germany selling to a team like Forrest is not typical, not what we expect. And this is the thing about The Rising Tide. The Rising tide is the Premier League TV contract. All of these different leagues are in different bays with different title patterns. And so the money that is available to sign players from the Premier League is also

SPEAKER_01That is not available to keep players in Germany, Italy, Spain, and so on. And so I think that's the other part of this. How does this maintain an equilibrium? By destroying the traditional equilibrium between the leagues in Europe.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I think that that is right. And like, as we're, you know, I think it's interesting, like, if... All of this or some of this is true. I think it's interesting to think about all the different ways it has effects in different directions. Potentially because the rest of the Premier League has gotten so good, the biggest teams in the Premier League are like, okay, we have to sign players from the Premier League because those are the only players we actually know are capable of competing against other teams

SPEAKER_00in the Premier League. And it kind of creates this reinforcing loop that brings the teams closer together. Because like we're saying... Forest can sign a player from Man City's academy. They're not going to sign a player, really, from another Premier League team to become a starter unless it's the Daniel Munoz situation, basically, where it's two clubs going in different directions and a manager switching teams or whatever.

SPEAKER_00So, yeah, I don't know. I also think... Maybe there's a world, too, where Zaver, Schlager, that type of player, the risk of signing him is way lower for Forrest than Liverpool signing Florian Wirtz is. Even transfer market value aside, because what they have to get from Zaverschlager for him to be a useful player is very from what Liverpool has to get,

SPEAKER_00and then Liverpool has to play a different way because they have to sort of control the ball more often to win as many points. So I don't know at all, like I'm going to lose my mind on air here as I think about it all.

SPEAKER_03But I was also going to go right back to Florian Verts who we've talked about obviously a bunch here and it's like, I think it's right that one thing that's happening is that you have to be So right when you now go and buy players from not the Premier League because the Premier League as a league has risen in such a way that it is so competitive and so athletic and everybody has good players in a way that is qualitatively different now than I think every other league in the world.

SPEAKER_03And... That makes it harder for Liverpool to go out and buy a star who can be a star from somewhere not in England. So what you've seen is English top teams have gone and resorted to once again spending a lot, a lot, a lot of money for players from other teams in the Premier League. And it's just like the rest of the Premier League doesn't have that problem, right? Like the rest of the Premier League now has access to like a lot of little bets that they can spread around in a way that the top of the Premier League does not.

SPEAKER_03And it used to be the top of the Premier League, you could make these much littler bets. Like even now, it is a different world for Liverpool signing Florian Wirtz than Liverpool. Six years before when Chelsea signed Kai Havertz. You know, same sort of structure of those deals, but six years of money later, like what you need for those things to be successful has changed a lot.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it sort of gets into some of the weirdness too. Like if we take Liverpool, like I feel like five years ago, seven years ago, whatever, I'm losing track of time. Like Florian Verts, I mean, even at the time, I thought it was like, this is like, The best possible big money move you could make, right? He's producing at an elite level before he's in his peak years. He's doing it for a team that beat Bayern Munich. He kind of does everything well, also.

SPEAKER_00And all the underlying numbers are amazing. And yet, a lot of those underlying numbers, or at least the important ones we would look at, haven't really tracked over in the Premier League. And then, even Bradley Barclay, I think we would have... Putting ourselves in the five years prior bucket, we would have had some more questions about him, partially because PSG's best players just don't play soccer ever. And then what you do in Liga is almost meaningless at this point.

SPEAKER_00But also very young, sort of absurdly good underlying numbers from goal and shot production from the wing. And yet both of these players, I think it's still a very open question of like, Can you win the Premier League with either of them starting? Can you win the Premier League with either of them as like a top 15 player?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I wanted to sort of pull apart two things. I think that the thing that we're getting into is what we want to do a lot of this podcast on and many future podcasts and columns as well. But I do think one thing that's important to pull apart before we get there is just the more straightforward math of soccer and parody. There's a classic newsletter by Teodal Football on randomness in sport And how much,

SPEAKER_01How many more games it takes in soccer for you to be confident that the better team is going to be able to beat the worst team and how much larger that gap needs to be. And the effect of this is that at a certain level of parity, which does not have to be perfect one-to-one parity, does not have to be like a salary cap in MLS, but MLS offers this great example that if you have equal parity, Revenues if you have equal resources.

SPEAKER_01Even the gaps that can be created at equal resources are so small that it's very hard to make confident predictions of what will happen in soccer games. There's just so much randomness in an MLS season. And as you get narrower, narrower gaps in the Premier League, you also just start to get more randomness. And so one of the problems that these teams have is simply that it's not just that This bet needs to hit. It's that the bet needs to hit harder in order to open up a gap

SPEAKER_01with a smaller resource advantage. And so that's the other problem with these teams, the big six are having, that even if they do still have this advantage, they actually need to make more of that advantage because of purely the structure of the game of soccer.

SPEAKER_03And I actually think it's a little bit more than that for a second here because it used to be that if a not big six team had a magical season where it turned out they were a lot more talented than you thought and they challenged the top six and their players then as a result were bought by the biggest teams and they became less talented, the gap was reinforced. I think now what we're seeing, what we're talking about here with the rising tide is that, hey,

SPEAKER_03maybe one year Brighton has a great year in results and they are in the mix for the top six spots and three of their players get bought afterwards. But that is not the result of Brighton being a team that has obviously put together a collection of talent that is head and shoulders above everybody else. Just happen to be the team out of three or four or five or six teams that put up the So maybe they get worse, but the gap is not reified when that happens.

SPEAKER_03These other teams are still also good. And then the next year, another one or two of them puts together a season. One of the things that the gap shrinking means is that it's not just a challenger or two challengers, but it's a lot of challengers. And when it's a lot of challengers, that gap can't be re-extended nearly as easily.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it already goes back to what we were saying. And then if it's like, okay, the 14 other teams in the Premier League are all signing the best young players from Germany, France, Spain, etc. You have this situation where one or two teams are going to get three guys that were the players that, for whatever reason, translate to the Premier League from the Bundesliga and... La Liga, and like you're saying, yeah, maybe it's Bournemouth that takes Brighton's spot the next season. So, yeah, I think part of what's happening, or what is interesting about it,

SPEAKER_00is these things feel like they're kind of building on each other. These other little smaller factors, in addition to this larger thing we're talking to, are kind of reinforcing, potentially, the parity or a little more randomness that we're seeing.

SPEAKER_01One thing that we've been covering this season, I just don't know if you have any insights on this purely because I'm still kind of at a loss, is exactly how good do you think Bournemouth, Brighton, and Forest are? Because right now the story is that Brighton are in the top four. Bournemouth and Brighton are third and fourth in expected goals difference. Forest is fifth. And so we have in the table, we've got one team that's way up there.

SPEAKER_01In the expected goals table, we've got three teams that are way up there and ahead of Liverpool. And... I don't see in any of them the obvious makings of a, yeah, this team is just like right up there, top three, top four quality in the way that I think of it in a normal season. Yeah, I'm still like really trying to work it out with all three teams.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think if we like go through each one, not that I want to just try to write them all off, but like if I was going to, Forest... Again, I'm applying my pre-weird Premier League era way of thinking, so I could be wrong here. But the way Forrest play, we haven't seen that be enough to produce the requisite level of performances over a full season.

SPEAKER_00Dominate the quantity and quality of chances in the way you have to over a full season to hang at that level. And I think, unfortunately, their points haven't matched their performances most of the time, so it's very unlikely they get to that level anyway. And then I also think some of the weirdness of the state of their games also probably plays into them having such good numbers. Bournemouth, I'm probably the most confused by of any team in the league. My theory there is, I feel like this is something Goodman has talked about before.

SPEAKER_00You could say this happened at Liverpool with Slott, where a new manager comes in and certain things about him just fix the handful of issues that had arisen under the previous manager. You are correct.

SPEAKER_03I wrote about this is the Roberto Martinez after David Moyes at Everton season.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and that was very correct. But you get to live off of all of the good stuff the manager created, too. And perhaps that's happening with Marco Rosa, where he's not as much of an advocate of the Uriola man-to-man marking strategy, even though Uriola says he's more of a hybrid pressing. But maybe there's some little tweaks that Rosa is making to the way Iriola did things.

SPEAKER_00I guess if you look at the underlying numbers, they're probably somewhat close to where they were last year anyway. Or if he adjusted it for the league average or whatever. And he's also benefiting from all of the good things that Iriola had set up there, too. Because if you look at Bournemouth's players, it's like, of course David Brooks has, like, Insane numbers if you do per 90 minutes, but then you look and it's only played like played 150 minutes or whatever. That happens every season.

SPEAKER_00And then it's who like, who else is... Like Evan Nielsen is having a pretty good season and he's like a fantastic pressing forward. And you could sell me on like, okay, he's 27 -28, he's having kind of his career year. But then it'S kind of just like, I don't... You guys have talked about Alex Scott. I don't know if I believe that's a driving force in creating a great Premier League team. Kruppi has been injured for most of the season. There's just the personnel story there.

SPEAKER_00I don't really see that. I think Antonio Silva is maybe really good, but even still, how much of an effect? Can he be having? So if you guys want to stop me there before I just throw my brain theories at you.

SPEAKER_03You're getting it something that I was feeling when we were talking about the transfer values and the rise in power of the middle class of the Premier League's buying power, which is that despite that, when I look at the talent collections at Brighton, at Bournemouth, at Forest, I don't see teams that I'm supposed to think are only half a step behind the talent collections at Liverpool, you know, even at Chelsea.

SPEAKER_03Like, it doesn't feel to me like when you just look at the names on the sheet of paper, when you look at Elliot Anderson going to City and, you know, McAtee and Schlager going to Forest, that... That's not a gap. That's a gap that's shrinking. Those collections of talent still seem to me instinctively to be really, really disparate. Even as we can look at the money and we can look at the numbers and say, hey,

SPEAKER_03things seem like they're getting pushed together. And it makes me start to ask, is there a tactical question here? Why? Is it just the upper end of the Premier League is sort of pushing against how good you can be at the sport of soccer? What is actually going on here when I feel that gap?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because I think what we would normally do, right, if it's like, okay, we're looking at this collection of talent, and it's not, you know, not to keep harping on Liverpool, but like, they have theoretically amazingly talented players throughout most of their roster outside of, you could make an argument that Kirk is like, I don't know. You could argue he's performing at a relegation team level for Liverpool and use that as your way of explaining what's going on here. But for the rest of the team, these are really good players.

SPEAKER_00Also, a lot of these players have been really good in the Premier League before. And then you compare them to Bournemouth players, and if we look at the underlying numbers, Bournemuth have been a better team than Liverpool this year. Even when they played, like Liverpool won, You didn't watch the game thinking, oh my god, Liverpool are so much better than Bournemeth. It was kind of what you see every weekend in the premier league where it's like One team gets half an expected goal more than the other team, and it's kind of like, OK, I don't know if I can definitively say that they're a better team than this other team,

SPEAKER_00but are any of us willing to say Marco Rosa is doing a better job with Liverpool. That doesn't feel satisfying to me for an explanation for this, but maybe the managers and Chelsea is another team that their underlying numbers are horrible for a team of what we expected from Chelsea. Genuinely bad, right? They think they might be negative still, expected goals-wise.

SPEAKER_00And then a lot of their step beyond expected goals numbers are also just kind of insane and bizarre. And so, like, maybe Xabi Alonso just doesn't really know what he's doing in this environment, but also, like, we've seen Xabi Alonso be a really good coach at Leverkusen, and he was a really good coach at Madrid outside of Madrid. Of understanding what Madrid's players would actually allow him to do, which shouldn't be an issue at Chelsea.

SPEAKER_00So like I guess what I'm saying here is even if you want to use manager performance as the thing that determines how talent gets converted into underlying performance, that just feels wrong to me still using that as an explainer here too.

SPEAKER_01Before we get completely into things that we don't have a handle on. I think that two pieces of this story, my hypothesis is that these are part of the story and one of them is something that you've written about, one of those things I wrote about recently is that one thing that these teams at the top in the Premier League have to deal with is playing twice a week. They have the expanded Champions League. They have a lot more. They have to rotate. They just all have to run more.

SPEAKER_01And... There is evidence from the last 15 years that it clearly does cost teams when they especially move into the Champions League. Being in the Champions League has some cost. Moving to the Champions League for the first time has larger costs. And like, you know, Manchester United kind of a bad season this year. There's some things that fit together. And... It seems plausible that as the Premier League gets more intense

SPEAKER_01and Premier League week-to-week competition gets more intense, that these costs would get larger, that the benefit of having a week off would get larger. That's a hypothesis. Then, the other thing that you've written about is the increasing intensity of the game in terms of pressing and man marking. And that this is something that I have struggled to find numbers in the on -ball data to really capture, while at the same time we all watch the games.

SPEAKER_01Dirty secret, we actually do watch the game and You can see, if not insane Bielsa stuff where like the team loses the ball and the player runs forward because the person that they're marking, but it is very much, you can track those man markings all over the pitch and you can see how much work everyone is doing and This style is going to change the way the game is played, and it's going to increase the intensity of the way

SPEAKER_01the game is played. I want to know sort of how you've been thinking about bandmarking, just sort of thinking about it and measuring it, and also how you think it might be affecting this story.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't think it's like the easiest thing to measure. What I, in the piece that I wrote... I got some numbers from Gradient, who just have humans doing a bunch of things. Not that Opta hasn't historically done that either, but they've taken the football, we watch football, and grade players' actions approach and applied it to soccer. They also just measure different things, I guess.

SPEAKER_00They found that attacking third pressures are just increasingly going up and up in the Premier League. Makes some sense, right? If you're marking a guy, you're more likely to pressure him once he receives the ball. So I think that checks out. I think if you also just look at John Muller at footy, they came up with a number that's just attacking half, I forget what they call it, high defensive actions or something. It's just like all the defensive actions added together,

SPEAKER_00including clearances and fouls, In the attacking half. And that number is like creeping back up in the Premier League. So like that stuff's happening. You also see that shots from turnovers higher up the field are happening more often, and then you're also seeing deeper counterattacks are happening much more often which Kind of makes sense, too. Like, you'd expect the press to get broken through more often now. So it would lead to that. So I found a bunch of, like, little things that felt like they kind of backed it up.

SPEAKER_00And then, as I wrote in the piece, like, I try to just, like, ignore what coaches tell us most of the time. Because, like, I don't know. Like, what's the... Why should I believe what this person's saying? But, like, they've been talking about man marking for, like, a long time now. Like, last year, Arteta... After everyone was mad after the Brighton game about Arsenal slowing things down, he was like, if you want to fix the sport, man, marking. That's what we need to fix. If you took that out of the sport, the sport would be different. Liverpool players have talked about it a bunch since switching coaches, Iriola, Guardiola.

SPEAKER_00It's like everyone talks about it now. So I'm willing to trust them given that there's no... There's not any league-wide conspiracy to have all the players and coaches talk about man marking. So I think that plus these little indicators make me feel like it's enough to kind of be like, okay, they're not bullshitting us. So that's what I did there. And then I think what is interesting to think about with it is...

SPEAKER_00I feel like you guys might have talked about with this, too. I guess in the past, if we bring us back to the increasing financial power of the rest of the league, in the past you could get guys that were athletic if you were a mid-table team, or you could get guys that were skilled, So, like, you could try to man-mark, but then, like, once you won the ball, like, nothing happened. And then also you had the ball for, like, 15% of the game because your players couldn't pass.

SPEAKER_00Or, you know, you could be like the Brendan Rodgers Swansea, right, where you can just, like, pass the ball around your own half, have a couple games where everyone's like, this is amazing what they're doing, but then you kind of just get, like... on how this works, if the better players are available to these teams, they probably are able to get players that are converging at least a little bit closer of having the skill to do things with the ball to punish you when they win it back when they press you and also being more able to press you

SPEAKER_00in making things difficult higher up the field. So I think that's kind of how I fit it into the Just larger story we're talking about.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, a couple things that I think about because a little bit what you're sort of describing to me is like the Premier League is now the Bundesliga except with all the best players. Like that a little bit of like the stuff that took over the Bundesliga five to ten years ago is now everywhere in the Premier League but the players are better. And I think about a couple of cross-sport things as you were talking about this. One is like from an analytic side, like the process of like Billy Bean and the Oakland A's doing this

SPEAKER_03and getting results. And then all of a sudden the Yankees and the Red Sox and the Cubs were doing this. And it's like, well, when we do this with money, we're better than when you do it without money. And the other thing I'm thinking about, because I have like such a very specific and limited set of references at this point in my life, is the Jason Kidd Nets. The Jason Kidd, Kenyon Martin, Kerry Kittles, Richard Jefferson Nets, who ran the Princeton offense. And they ran the motion and cut offense,

SPEAKER_03and they brought in the old Princeton coach as an assistant. And what he said is... When I tell these guys to cut, they cut like a mother effer. And it's like you take a style that was developed to cover for having less athleticism than your opponents. And you implement it with guys who are as athletic or more athletic than their opponents. And it turns out it really, really works. Right?

SPEAKER_03And so I do wonder... If what we're seeing in the Premier League is this idea of the adoption of strategies and tactics that were developed by very smart, very committed people without resources, and then the application of resources to them. And that we're seeing it, as we talked about before, not only at the top of the Premier League, but throughout the Premier League. And then I think the implications of that are pretty fascinating.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it goes back to almost everything we've said, right? Because then it's like, it's just like a new environment, both from like a difficulty perspective and like a strategy perspective and like a what Florian Verts sees on the field when he receives the ball perspective. Like that situation is just like... Just very different than what he's ever seen before, right? From where the players are, how big the players are,

SPEAKER_00and then how capable they are of taking the ball from him or keeping the ball from him. I guess man-marking, there's no In the piece I wrote, I was like, this just feels like the latest dumb guy strategy that actually makes sense. It's like, oh, just following players around the field is the best way to defend? What idiot at a bar could have come up with that idea? Why did we not always do that? I guess the increase of money in the Premier League didn't have to become man-marking.

SPEAKER_00I think it had to become—it become, it makes sense that it's not like we're just seeing other than Hull, we don't see teams just sit deep and concede the ball anymore. But What you're doing by not conceding the ball doesn't have to be man-marking, doesn't have to be that version of pressing. But it was probably right because Andone Iriola came to the Premier League and Bournemouth were really good. It feels like that's kind of like... And then everyone copied him after Pep Guardiola did that interview

SPEAKER_00where he was like, this is the future of football. And then that has created this situation where... Maybe most of these players and coaches just like, when have they played against teams that are super athletic trying to chase them around the field? And so maybe that's where I was getting at earlier. Maybe we're in this interregnum period where the big teams will eventually maybe figure out how to play or what players in particular are the ones that are going to break through this.

SPEAKER_00Maybe. Probably.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because the German pressing style is developed as a weapon of the week. It is teams that are trying to deal with the fact that Bayern is there. And how do you get something out of these games? And they're also playing against these, if they're Dortmund in the Champions, they are playing against the elite possession sides of the time. They're playing against Barcelona and then suddenly a Pep Guardiola at Bayern.

SPEAKER_01And they're trying to respond to that problem. And it was effective. And I think that like what we're seeing right now, I don't think I agree with you. I don't think this is like the end point of football, you know, but it is clearly taking some time for anyone to come up with a response to this. Or for anyone to come up with a response to teams with lots of money also doing this.

SPEAKER_03I think to that end, right? Like there are two things I was thinking of. One, obviously I was thinking of exactly the same thing you were, which is like the question of, is this just an epicycle, right? Like a tactical epicycle where everybody plays this way and somebody plays a different way and then it's like, oh, wow, look at that. But one way we used to get these epicycles, one way we used to get the sort of tactical refreshment of the game Was countries competing against other countries. You know, there are still people in the English game who talk about like

SPEAKER_03the pressing of the Marseille team in the Champions League, right? That like blew everybody away in like 2010 and like, oh my God, you can do this? And it like changed the way they thought about the game, right? Like you would have Pep Guardiola doing something entirely different at Barcelona, and then like a couple of times a year, the big teams from England would see it and get wrecked by it and be like, oh,

SPEAKER_03we need to have something else in our locker. And we don't really have that now. We don't have the one possible thing you can look at is kind of like Luis Enrique at PSG. But for the most part, last year Spurs were fighting relegation in the Premier League and like... Fine against Atletico Madrid in the Champions League, right? There's no other ecosystem of ideas

SPEAKER_03that imposes itself on the minds of people coaching in the Premier League and says, hey, there's another way to do this that you need to pursue.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it makes me think of the first leg of PSG Bayern. It was like, oh my god, this is the greatest soccer we've ever seen. The Premier League, everyone's scoring on corners, and these teams are doing it for the love of the game. Those teams are just so hard for me to even conceptualize in any way because the leagues are just—they're not fake, but it's just like they're not—it's not competitive at all. What they do in the leagues is—it's really hard to—even with trying

SPEAKER_00to do league adjustments, I'm still like, I have no idea what these numbers mean. And then the Champions League, there's so few games that I'm also like, I can't judge this one game Bayern played bad and be like, they're a fraudulent team or whatever. But like— You bring up PSG, and like, could Would PSG win the Premier League if they came into the Premier League? I think they would probably be the best team, in my opinion. But they don't play games.

SPEAKER_00Their players don't play soccer until the Champions League. Can you do what they try to do in the biggest Champions League games for an entire 38-game Premier League season? I don't really think you can. The other thing that I think about... Thinking about it less after Barca has kind of struggled a little bit recently, but like you look at Barca earlier in the season and it's like they're scoring like six goals a game. They're pressing like absolute maniacs. And then you look at like the defensive line in the mid And it's like,

SPEAKER_00there's Pau Kubarsi who I feel like you guys agree with me. His reputation as a player is way beyond what he actually is as a player currently, especially as a defender. And then it's random Barcelona Academy kids are the three other defenders. Then the midfielder is Rodri, Fermin Lopez, and Pedri. And we saw Rodri last year in the Premier League. He's not the same player without the ball that he used to be. And yet, Barca's just murdering teams with that setup.

SPEAKER_00So, in some ways, you could look at that. And it's like, oh, yeah, like we just need the biggest teams not need to stop being so scared. They just need to like go out and play and press like crazy. But then it's like, no, like that. I just when I see that it's like if that team came to the Premier League and did that, it just wouldn't work like a lot of the time in the Premier League, even though they have the players they have on the front line. I don't know if you guys disagree, but like I've had a hard time being like how is a team with these defenders that good? And it's like well because this just wouldn't work in the way the Premier

SPEAKER_03League currently is. Look we've seen In the Champions League, it's not that they're not a really, really, really good team, but it is when they play other really, really, really good teams, that margin is smaller, and just a couple more of those chances that almost come off do come off, and then it's a much more even XG battle.

SPEAKER_01And to the degree that it works, and I think that it not working in the Classica was very striking, and some of the Champions League games have been striking, but It was also true that Lamine didn't have a great game in those games. And if Lamine and Rafinha have great games, I think that can work. But I think this goes to the previous problem we were talking about, which is how do these new ideas come through and populate at the top of the game? And if we're talking about new ideas coming through from...

SPEAKER_01Like, that's not an efficient way for these ideas to come through. Instead, the Premier League is hiring the best managers that they can find out of – from other leagues, other setups, and then bringing them in often before they've done some big thing. And Danny Arriola had an impressive, interesting resume in Spain. But really he develops as a manager in England

SPEAKER_01and that pipeline now works differently. And I think it's an interesting idea of whether that coaching talent pipeline working differently means that also the way that tactics are, the way the dialectic functions changes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and then I think you also have to add in the Premier League teams, the way they're being run is it's being increasingly more Americanized, for lack of a better term. We're even just seeing more people are named head coach rather than manager, which seems like semantics, but it actually is a pretty important thing. I feel like there's also a situation where the manager... Managers have less say in who their teams are signing.

SPEAKER_00And I think I'm of the opinion that most of the Premier League teams are very bad at actually still running this model of creating a cohesive system that exists beyond the manager and identifying the right players for a certain style of play. I think most of the teams are terrible at it still, other than maybe the two of the teams we were talking about earlier. So you're also probably creating a slightly more dysfunctional environment for your managers to come into where they could actually have any sort

SPEAKER_00of tactical effect. Instead, it feels a lot more like... The idea is we're going to get the players who we think are the best values on the market, and then what a good coach does is figure out the best way to align these specific players on the field, rather than you figure out the best way to play soccer and then you build around that idea. So I think also

SPEAKER_00what you're saying is right, Kaylee? But then I think the like Effect a manager can have has also probably been lessened or the ways they can have an effect has been lessened. And then that builds on itself because it's like the ways they can have an effect aren't in the ideas of tactics. It's in like figuring out like which players to put on the field.

SPEAKER_03I don't know that it's an accident that like... Man marking defensively and scoring goals from set plays are two things that have become more prominent as you have seen this manager effect that you're describing happen. Where it's like, man marking and set pieces are two things that can be pretty consistent manager to manager. They are overall tactical ideas that require less variation from players.

SPEAKER_03The person in your ear to the person in your ear, as opposed to complicated possession systems, as opposed to complicated zonal defensive systems. Those are things that can be quite individualized from manager to manager, can take a while to bet in, and are perhaps... It's like, we could get lots of athletes

SPEAKER_03who are pretty good on the ball to man mark and play a system. Who you need in your possession system at various points on the field to be a difference maker can vary a lot from possession system guy to possession system guy.

SPEAKER_01It's interesting in that context that, like, We've been talking to these teams, I think that Bournemouth and Marco Rosa are like the paradigmatic one here, but Brighton are signing players for their possession. They're signing players from their whole underlying Brighton player system, but they're also like... Getting a bunch of passers that work in Herzler's system, and it is just a little bit off from the narrative. Yeah, it is.

SPEAKER_03Brighton seemed to have, like, two very, like, specific ideas that, like, should be in a little bit of conflict but aren't, which is that, like... We go out and we sign the players that our model says are good and they come and play good for us because our model says these players are good. And two, we have a way that we want to play and that way is very position, possession heavy. And we go out and sign managers who we think will implement, you know, our possession style well, but like what they don't do is be like,

SPEAKER_03this guy is talented in exactly the right way that we need for our tea. They're just like, Doing the thing that we're talking about, except with having and passing a ball.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. They have like Herzler is like the only coach who's still doing what people were doing when they played against Jose Mourinho in 2006 being like he doesn't want to play soccer. We wanted to play football. Even though we lost 3 -0, we were the only ones that wanted to pay. Like he's the only coaching the league that's doing that, which is It's hilarious because he's younger than all of us, I think. Going back to not really understanding what's happening, I think Brighton, if you look at it now, I think even if you account for the points they already have,

SPEAKER_00like looking at, I don't know, I like looking at Sporting Index, they have the market projections with points. I think they're... Projected to finish third right now in those markets. But then I think they're also, if you look at rest of the season points, they're projected to have the fourth most points over the rest of the season after Arsenal, City, and Liverpool. So, the markets are bought in. Legit top -four quality team, in addition to a team that could finish top four.

SPEAKER_00And then you think about they've had probably the hardest schedule in the league also, and they have these amazing underlying numbers, and they're in a good spot on the table. And like you guys have talked about, arguably their two best players have barely played this season in Mitoma and Minte. And then it's like, I look at the team and it's like, at least for my sort of analytical player assessment, like Pascal

SPEAKER_03He is the most Billy Bean, Oakland A's guy in soccer on the planet. And he

SPEAKER_00was that when they first signed him, and then he left, and then he was that again because they did it to him when he was old, also. It's amazing. But is Pascal Gross at, what is he, 35? In a league that we have all now been like is by far the best league in the world. And then I look at the rest of I'm like, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea. There are all these players that they should be signing to make themselves

SPEAKER_00a better team. So even then, I'm still kind of Confused there. I think maybe there is a little bit more of like the they just like wanna they're like very focused on the ball and they've signed a lot of players that are adept on the ball. So maybe they are. You could tell me that they're then equipped to like. Deal with man-marking better, because they're so comfortable having the ball. And then everyone on their team is young, other than Pascal Gross and Boscagli, basically. So they still have the energy to keep up with the Premier League pace.

SPEAKER_00But even still, I'm still like, I don't quite understand why this team is so good.

SPEAKER_01I'm stretching. I'm stretching. And then on top of that, like the red cards make such a huge difference. And so they're very hard to just get a handle on simply like what do you think the right way of saying their expected goals difference is, is a harder question with Brighton. So I think all of this has entered in us toward another conversation that we wanted to have with you. I think that bringing up Brighton sort of is a way in, and you wrote this book, Net Gains. And so obviously, we're not going to have that conversation right now

SPEAKER_01on this podcast, hopefully soon. But I did want to just mention Net Gains briefly at the end, because I think that It's the best book if you want to get a handle on what's going on with analytics in soccer, especially up through the point where you wrote it. And there have been, I think, real changes. I think it's a grounding point. And I just wanted to ask you sort of very broadly how you've thought about that book

SPEAKER_01as the game has progressed over the last several of years.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's funny. When I wrote the book, I was like... The hard thing about writing a book like that is I'm writing about what feels like, like Mike said, the Oakland A's era of Major League Baseball is where the Premier League was at in terms of how the sport was thought about. But I'm writing that book. It takes over a year to write it. It takes almost another year for it to come out.

SPEAKER_00A lot of things can change. Theoretically, everyone's going to do better with all of this stuff because we've seen it happen in every other sport. The nerds win, basically, most of the time. Measuring stuff and trying to have objective things that help you make decisions is better than just being like, Our scout watched this guy dribble through seven people in a non-league game,

SPEAKER_00and he's going to be awesome. He's got the burst to split the double. Yeah. Or like, damn, he played well against us. He must be good. The sort of Doc Rivers, honestly, Jurgen Klopp, latter years approach to player identification. But I actually, like, I was alluding to this earlier, I don't really think that... Teams feel like they're that much better run in how they make decisions than they were when I wrote the book. In some ways, they might be a little bit worse for some reasons,

SPEAKER_00which might go to what we're saying, how the Premier League has so much money, so who cares? Um, but I think like, I mean like Bournemouth has sort of emerged as maybe like a third team alongside Brighton and Brentford as teams that are like, if everyone did things the same way and everyone had an equal amount of money, those teams would probably be the best teams in the Premier League, is sort of how I look at it. So maybe we're adding like one more team to that group.

SPEAKER_00But in terms of the way like... Teams make better decisions. I actually don't think that the Premier League as a whole has really noticeably gotten that much better. Granted, it is complicated by what we're talking about. I don't think the XG plus XA per 90 scouting works quite as well as it used to, but also I do think it's pretty much better if you just did that on average rather

SPEAKER_00than signing Ileman and Jai for 80 million, which just happened. So I think for the effect of how teams make decisions, I actually don't think much has changed since I wrote that book.

SPEAKER_03I do sort of feel like everybody has analytics employees now. One thing I think that's interesting, pro sports were big business before analytics took hold. And once they decided they wanted to use analytics, they were able to incorporate it into their decision-making processes as big companies in the way that big companies make decisions all the time. That's not the case in international soccer.

SPEAKER_03These clubs were not And the sort of rapid influx of money and scaling up of business to one degree or another happens at the same time as the analytics stuff. And I think one thing that you've sort of seen is that it's like everybody was like, oh, okay, analytics is a thing. We should probably spend money on it and have it and use it. And they had no idea. And they still, I think you're right in a lot of ways, have no idea how to effectively incorporate that into their decision-making process, which I don't think is something any of us really anticipated as like,

SPEAKER_03A path problem in the sport, but I think it really has proved to be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I completely agree. Every Premier League team, if you go on their websites, I think you could find that there's an analyst working for every team. But when you talk to these people, they're just like, they're not going to say it on the record, but it's like, I have to do what the coach asked me to do. And the coach doesn't really understand what the value in what I can do is. And they kind of just hire these people because they... It would look bad if you didn't have one a lot of the time.

SPEAKER_00You saw this happen with Todd Boley. The idea of signing a player became such an endorphin rush for Todd Boley that he was just like, oh my god, this is awesome. I feel like when teams are making decisions still... They don't have good top-down structures outside of those three teams that we talked about, basically. I think Bournemouth, how their situation works is a little less clear. Honestly, when they, like, fired Gary O'Neal and replaced him with Iriola,

SPEAKER_00when everyone thought Gary O'Neal saved the team, that's how you just know this team is, like, thinking about things the right way. But everyone else, like, it just feels like there's so many people involved in, like, who you get to sign because, like, the idea of signing someone is just, like... It's more like college football recruiting, the way it feels to sign someone, than signing an NFL free agent or an NBA free agent, for the most part. It's like NBA free agency times 80 people instead of one big NBA

SPEAKER_00So I feel like it has this cultural thing that gets someone like, I need to have say over this big signing. Or because we're spending this much money, I, a person who doesn't have any idea how soccer works, I'm actually going to be involved in this thing. So I feel like you kind of saw it with Liverpool. Last summer, where it did feel like the EZAC signing was like, we're just going to go nuts here.

SPEAKER_00We have so much money. We won the league. This guy has an injury history. He's older than what we usually sign. We already just signed a striker. That felt like a non-classic Liverpool signing. I would say Kerkhez, as well, felt a little bit like it. If you look at his underlying numbers, they were fine, but it wasn't like, oh my god, this is a great passer, or whatever. But then Eketike felt like a very classic Liverpool signing.

SPEAKER_00If we were going to be the Michael Edwards big-money signing, Eketike would be what we would predict. So there, it felt like you had the analytics team had some say in the players that were getting signed. And then there were also the Richard Hughes kind of, like, we're just going to go crazy. And those things didn't go together at all. And that's a team that we kind of think is one of the best run teams where the owner is not letting people do whatever they want. So then it's like, you go a step below that, you can see how there's just no linked up overarching

SPEAKER_00You can tell all

SPEAKER_03sorts of stories about boardroom intrigue and who has influence and who doesn't and who has the ability to stop a bad idea and who doesn't. And who knows if the stories are right, but it absolutely feels like in these situations you're getting into... Not just at Liverpool, like across the board, like questions of corporate governance a lot more than like, can you figure out what analytics says is a good player to sign and not?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Like we haven't even talked about like... What's the next thing that we want to see measured? It feels like expected possession value, expected threat, that's becoming a more common thing. It's more available out there. But what's beyond that? We haven't even really talked about that. I do feel like just being able to make better decisions, and I do think, although it's harder To identify successful transfers, I think I would say that's true.

SPEAKER_00When I look at transfers, I'm now a little more like, this might not work out. Even though this guy has great numbers, fits the team, I'm just less confident that the transfers that look good are going to work out. I still think identifying the bad transfers, this is something Ted says all the time. That is very easy to me still. We can be like, those transfers are probably not going to work. AKA Newcastle's transfers last summer, we were all just like, these are not good.

SPEAKER_00Way too much money. These don't make sense. And what do you know? They were not good. So I think there is still like teams could glean a ton of value from like using some of the more basic analytical thinking to like cross players off their list, I think would be just a huge benefit for teams still.

SPEAKER_01So there are obviously a dozen more directions that this could go. And so I think the only obvious answer is that, Ryan, we're going to have to have you back on the podcast to really get into, I think, this question of what is analytics in the modern game? What is analytics doing in a world with much greater inequality between leagues? And what What are the new kinds of analytics? How do they fit with what we're talking about as classic analytics? And how does it all fit with the business story? There's just so much here.

SPEAKER_01And so we're just going to have to come back and have you on again and continue this conversation. This has been fantastic. So, yeah. Ryan O'Hanlon, staff writer at ESPN, author of Net Gains. Check it out, not just because I'm in it, but also because I'm in it. I mean, come on. And yeah, where else can people find you on the internet? Anything you want to plug here while we're heading out?

SPEAKER_00I am not as active on social media anymore, but my newsletter that used to be an actual publication, I still update it with everything I've written. It's just no grass in the clouds. It's at Substack. That's the newsletter. So the ESPN interface is not really designed for you to find things I've ever written. But in there, I link to everything I've written each week. So that's an easy way to follow what I'm writing, I think, if your inbox isn't. Yeah, thanks, Ryan.

SPEAKER_00We appreciate it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, thanks, Ryan. We'll be back with more podcasts. Cheers, y'all. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Mauricio Pochettino, Manchester United, USMNT

    Nov 13, 20265 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.expectinggoals.com/subscribe Manchester United are hiring Mauricio Pochettino to be their next...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Moneyball Picks in the PL, plus: the Future of Expecting Goals and the Double Pivot Podcast

    Nov 10, 202631 minAudio

    We kick off the Expecting Goals - Double Pivot integration with some of our Moneyball picks. Which striker is maybe a little goofy but who cares he’s getting shots? Which team has successfully recreated their lost star...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Introducing the Double Pivot on Expecting Goals: Our Preseason Takes on Christos Tzolis

    Nov 9, 202620 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.expectinggoals.com/subscribe I have hosted the Double Pivot Podcast along with Mike Goodman for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. El Clasico Pod: Real Madrid's winning tactical approach, Yan Diomande's big role

    Oct 28, 202629 minAudio

    This podcast is mostly about El Clasico. Real Madrid got a late winner, but they had been the better team for most of the match in both surprising and unsurprising ways. We break down their effective defense, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The new rules on injuries are creating a massive hidden advantage and no one has noticed?

    Oct 21, 202625 minAudio

    The various rules that the IFAB implemented to speed up play across soccer appear to be working. The ball is in play more, there are shorter delays before restarts from throw-ins and goal kicks, and there are many fewer...

    Credit the people on this episode