This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com Arianna is a writer and businesswoman. She co-founded The Huffington Post in 2005, and after it was acquired by AOL, she became the president and editor-in-chief of The Huffington Post Media Group. She’s currently the CEO of Thrive Global and the author of 15 books, including Thrive and The Sleep Revolution. A polished transcript is here, including money quotes. Below are timestamps for the main sections of the pod: 5:05: Arianna’s meteoric rise at a young age and challenging left-feminism 28:05: IQ, meritocracy, and what sets humans apart from AI 50:10: A crisis of meaning and the “false god of productivity” 114:07: The importance of sleep and how to improve it For two clips of the episode - on the desperate need for grace in our discourse, and how to sleep better - head to our YouTube page. More topics: Arianna’s upbringing in Greece; her dad’s anti-Nazi magazine in WWII; the power of maternal love; her time at the Cambridge Union as its first foreign prez; her first book The Female Woman; her love affair with Bernard Levin; the feminism of the Gospels; meritocracy; AI surpassing us in intelligence; our culture’s distrust of nature; Arianna’s burnout in 2007 and my own in 2015; silent meditation retreats; Matthew Crawford and craftsmanship; Loren Eiseley the anthropologist; mental illness; psychedelics; God as love; Maslow’s pyramid; and Arianna giving me tips for my insomnia. Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy. Coming up: Emily Eakin on the French postmodernists, Sean Illing on the relevance of Camus and Nietzsche, Jake Weisberg on the cowards who caved to Trump, and Michael Lewis on the bureaucrats who fought back. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to dish@andrewsullivan.com.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Hi there. Welcome to another Dish cast. Now leading the products, products, God, the things we give you every week under the auspices of The Weekly Dish. I had a rather nervous weekend. I will be completely frank because we had no idea if you would all just suddenly abandon us since I'm not giving you a column every week. And I'm taking some time to write a spiritual memoir and to think about some And moving this podcast away, not entirely because we've got to cover the world,
SPEAKER_01but to more philosophical, historical, spiritual, religious, philosophical dimensions. I kind of increasingly feel that in our politics, as I've written about it and thought about it, there is a moment at which I don't think the solution is political. I think the solution is spiritual. And that's particularly true, I think, when liberal democracies end in this terribly toxic and difficult way.
SPEAKER_01Because the key thing we will need in the next few years, in my view, is forgiveness. We're going to have to forgive each other for the last 10 years, each side, if we are going to put it back together again. And we've got to wait for the person who can help us do that. But I think we need to get to a place outside of the frenzy of our current discourse to get the spiritual resources to put liberal democracy back together.
SPEAKER_01That's where I'm at. And I know some of you will agree and some of you disagree. And I think that's what we're going to talk about over the next few months. We have some Some wonderful guests coming up, some of them political, some of them not. In the short term, we have Emily Aitken coming on, who's going to talk about, we had a fantastic discussion about the French postmodernists and what they've done to our culture and what they've done to America in a strange kind of way. Jacob Weisberg, my old friend, fellow intern back together in the 1980s at the New Republic.
SPEAKER_01He's written this book called Profiles in Cowardice. It's actually the design of it is fantastic. It's just a parody of John F. Kennedy's, a.k.a. Arthur Schlesinger's, profiles in Courage. On all the people who have appeased Trump, people who didn't have to, didn't need to, who were members of civil society and decided that money and sucking up was more important than the independence of their institutions. So we'll name and shame some people. And Michael Lewis is coming in to do the opposite.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you. I didn't finish the punchline. I was nervous because I was worried you were not going to listen to me anymore. And in fact,
SPEAKER_01we looked at the subscriptions over the weekend and we have not seen any real change at all. You are sticking with us. And I can't tell you what that means to us. It means I will have more space in my head to do the things I want to do and write the things I want to write. And that Chris will be able to continue to do what he does here with the winter contest and with all the other features The Dish provides every week and also his role in the Dish cast. And we can keep this going, you and us. And I can't tell you how thrilled I am that that will work out anyway.
SPEAKER_01But this week, an old friend, someone I first discovered sitting in the bathtub listening to the radio as an English schoolboy.
SPEAKER_00That's how I read a file. I go back.
SPEAKER_01Arianna Huffington is a writer and a businesswoman, entrepreneur. She co-founded The Huffington Post in 2005, and after it was acquired by AOL, she became the president and editor-in-chief of The Huffington Post Media Group. She's currently the founder and CEO of Thrive Global, a tech company that helps people improve productivity and health. She's the author of 15 books. We'll talk about a few of them, including The Sleep Revolution, which we'll get to,
SPEAKER_01and Thrive, which is really a manifesto for what she's currently doing. Ariana, you look fantastic. Lovely to see you. Welcome to the Dishcast.
SPEAKER_00Great, great to see you, Andrew. So many years.
SPEAKER_01I know, I know. I was going to say that we were just earlier before we came on. I first listened to you on a show in England, a very important show, actually, called Any Questions, which was broadcast on their equivalent of NPR, Radio 4, on a Friday evening. And it would take four panelists to Around the country to village halls and town halls. So it really did go all over the UK. And they would ask questions from the audience. The audience would ask questions. And this very distinctive Greek accent came on.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, who on earth is Arianna Stassinopoulos? Which is how she was then introduced. So that's how I remember. And I remember thinking she was so funny and smart. And I look forward to whenever she was on that show. Little did I know that I would go on to become good friends with her. And Arianna, I just want to... Do you remember those days when you...
SPEAKER_00Yes, and I was terrified because I was still a student at Cambridge. And the only reason I was plucked out of obscurity is because I was the first foreigner to be president of the Cambridge Union. And so they had me...
SPEAKER_01Not just the first foreigner, but the first woman, actually.
SPEAKER_00Well, I was not the first woman. I was the
SPEAKER_01first woman.
SPEAKER_00But being a foreigner, having an accent made me definitely an anomaly. And so I started doing Any Questions and Face the Music. Do you remember Face the Music?
SPEAKER_01The English used to have these amazing radio shows of discussion of people. I remember that there would be a level of knowledge and of wit that you just can't imagine hearing today on any public broadcast. But let's go back a little bit to where you started. Tell me about you grew up in Athens. Tell me about your parents. What were they like? What influence do they have on you?
SPEAKER_00Huge influence, especially my mother. My father was a journalist who, during the German occupation of Greece, published an underground newspaper, was arrested by the Germans, spent the war in a concentration camp, met my mother while he was recovering from the camp in a sanatorium and she was recovering from TB.
SPEAKER_01Good law. In the same sanatorium?
SPEAKER_00Yes. So they told them that they could never, that she could never have children. She promptly got pregnant before she was married to me, with me, and decided to keep the baby, which was pretty amazing at the time. And they got married.
SPEAKER_01Why amazing at the time? Because she was out of wedlock?
SPEAKER_00It was so many years ago and she was living in Greece and And having a child out of wedlock was not the norm, although my father did marry her.
SPEAKER_01You were conceived in the sanatorium?
SPEAKER_00No, not in the sanatorium. That sounded romantic.
SPEAKER_01Subsequently, okay.
SPEAKER_00The meeting was in the sanatorium.
SPEAKER_01What a father to have. What a legacy to live up to.
SPEAKER_00But I think the thing about my father was that he, because he survived the camp and most of his friends died, he felt somehow that life owed him and he could do anything he wanted. So he was a terrible philanderer. And when my mother complained, he told her not to interfere in his private life.
SPEAKER_01Good God.
SPEAKER_00So they divorced and my sister and I lived with my mother in a one bedroom apartment. I paint the picture because one day coming home from school, I saw a magazine and on the cover of the magazine was Cambridge University. And I get home. Around the kitchen table and I tell my mother, I want to go there. I want to go and study there. And I told everybody who would listen and everybody said, don't be ridiculous.
SPEAKER_00You don't speak English. We don't have any money. And it's hard for English girls to get into Cambridge. My mother said, let's find out how you can get there. And she found out that I could take my GCs through the British Council. I could apply for a scholarship, et cetera, et cetera. To cut a long story short, I got into Cambridge. And she was kind of my big believer. But Andrew... In a very different way,
SPEAKER_00like she always made me feel life was an adventure and trying to get into Cambridge was part of the adventure. But if we didn't get into Cambridge, no big deal, there would be another adventure and she wouldn't love me any less. So there was no pressure, there was a lot of hard work, but there was somehow trust and fun and she was my partner on the journey.
SPEAKER_01My mother, too. I mean, I'm just relating to it because no one in my family had been to college, let alone Oxford. And I, too, at the age of like 11, 12, 13, decided out of the blue, I want to go to Oxford. This is my way out. So we did the same. And my mom, God bless her, she definitely believed in me. She herself was brilliant, but never had to leave school at 16 to work because her parents,
SPEAKER_01her father was disabled, her mother was a cleaning lady. And exactly what you say, I had all this emotional support, but none of the pressure. None of the sense that if I failed, I would somehow be a failure. It was, I mean, she just, the only problem with this is she had such sublime confidence that I would clearly go wherever I wanted to that I could never satisfy. I mean, when I got that, do you remember the day you found out you got into Cambridge?
SPEAKER_01Of course. Tell me about that day.
SPEAKER_00I remember a telegram arrived because I'm so old.
SPEAKER_01Well, you were in Athens too.
SPEAKER_00No, by then I was in London because remember I had to go, you have to also go and have an oral exam.
SPEAKER_01Oh, right. Of course.
SPEAKER_00And I remember actually going up to Cambridge and there were eight girls that made it. And one of the girls in the elevator says, one of us is going to get in and I'm planning it to be me, trying to intimidate the rest of us.
SPEAKER_01Like a reality show.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And basically the telegram arrived and it said, awarded Girton exhibition. Girton was the college I went to and exhibition was a form of scholarship. I had no idea what the hell exhibition was. So I got a scholarship too, which we had applied for. And it was really, really the moment when my life changed. Because everything that happened since,
SPEAKER_00including becoming president of the Cambridge Union, including getting an offer to write my first book, While I organized a debate on the changing role of women, and I spoke, which you remember, I think it's the same tradition in Oxford, the president speaks in the farewell debate, as they call it, the final debate of the term.
SPEAKER_01That's not how I remember it at Oxford. In fact, if you were president, you couldn't speak.
SPEAKER_00In the final debate, the farewell debate, the president spoke. So I spoke in that debate, which believe it or not, the Cambridge Union and the Oxford Union were so important at the time that the BBC carried the debate.
SPEAKER_01Really?
SPEAKER_00And this English publisher saw me Okay. And he wrote back, his name was Reg Davis Poynter. He had a real sense of humor. He said, can you have lunch?
SPEAKER_00And I said, yes, I can have lunch. And so he invited me to London. We had lunch. And by the end of lunch, he had given me a contract with a modest advance. I remember 6,000 pounds to write what became my first book at the age of 23. And that book tapped into a moment.
SPEAKER_01What was the book? Remind and tell people what that book was called.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the book was called The Female Woman.
SPEAKER_01The Female Human? Woman.
SPEAKER_00Woman, which was like a response to Germaine Greer's The Female Eunuch. Remember that book?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course.
SPEAKER_00So basically, my thesis was that women, of course, should have equal opportunities and equal pay, but also equal respect if they choose not to have a career. Remember, at the time, it was assumed that if you didn't have a career, you were a complete loser. Not only were you a loser, you were somehow betraying your sex.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00In fact, when my book came out, the head of publicity at Random House refused to publicize it because it was seen as so...
SPEAKER_01Retrograde and reactionary.
SPEAKER_00And that's what
SPEAKER_01interests me. Why, here you are, you're a young woman who's blazed a trail, actually, for who you were from a foreign country. And then you might imagine that such a person would then project that as the way to live everybody's life, as opposed to turn around and say, hold on a minute, this might be right for me, it may not be right for everyone. Yes, absolutely. And you spent the next 10, 20 years in a way taking positions that were against or questioned sort of a monolithic liberal establishment view.
SPEAKER_00Well, my point in that book, I interviewed so many women who made that choice. And I mean, I remember a woman who said, you know, I haven't had a new coat for three years, but I love being a mom. I love bringing up my children. And my whole point was, Why can't we give this woman equal respect than the woman who is climbing the corporate ladder? You know, I personally have worked all my life, and I wanted to work, even...
SPEAKER_00Even when I could have said, okay, I have enough money, I don't have to work. I love my work. It's part of what I love. But we're all different. So all I was saying is that let's give equal respect to people's choices.
SPEAKER_01Which is a little ahead of its time. But that became pretty much the prevailing view. Isn't that basically consensus today? Isn't that where we really are?
SPEAKER_00This is totally the consensus today. So tell me about...
SPEAKER_01Bernard Levin, you fell in love with a man that I knew from reading his columns and his reviews. And unbelievably, Americans may not know who he was. One of the most brilliant individuals. Intellectuals in British Life, Public Life in the late 20th century. And somehow you, this young Greek woman, decided to become, we didn't decide, we fell in love with him. Can you tell me that story and what it was about him that compelled you so much?
SPEAKER_00I fell in love with him through his writing before I met him. I would literally cut his columns out of the London Times and his theater reviews out of the Observer. And literally, I would cut them and underline them and save them and memorize them. He was an incredible craftsman, right? He was... A magical wordsmith. And I totally fell in love with him. And then I was invited to do this show called Face the Music where they play
SPEAKER_00a little piece of classical music and you have to guess what it is. And he was there. I was petrified. I was so nervous because he was there. And at the end of it, he asked me to dinner. And we were together for seven years. I was madly in love with him. I would have loved to marry him.
SPEAKER_00And have children, but he didn't want to marry. He didn't want to have children. He would have stayed with me. It's not like he wanted to leave. But he was very clear he didn't want children. He used to say, I want cats. I don't want children. And I made this super tough decision. To leave him because I really wanted children. That was very clear to me. I have a lot of friends who don't have children, are perfectly happy, but I wanted children.
SPEAKER_00So the reason actually I left London where I was living at the time and moved to New York was to put the ocean, the Atlantic Ocean between us because I didn't trust myself not to go back to him if I had stayed in London.
SPEAKER_01It's not interesting. For my part, this wasn't a conscious decision. But I realized, having done that same trip to America, that finally I felt free from the pressures of my family. That I needed the only boundary that would ever contain my mother would be the Atlantic Ocean. And actually back then when I went to America, and you too... You were further away from Europe.
SPEAKER_01The internet didn't exist. Telephone calls were incredibly expensive, if you recall. You really did get out of, you didn't know the news cycle in another country. You waited. I waited a couple of days to find the papers from London. You know, it really was a little different. I just felt liberated. It's like sometimes people come to America to put a boundary between them and something they're trying to leave behind and get away from. And it's the only country that can do that, I think.
SPEAKER_00I remember you writing that you first came out to God. By the time you moved to America, had you come out to your mother? No.
SPEAKER_01No, it was soon thereafter. And I think that's also something that I think gay people often go through is the getting away from where we're from to sort of try out our identity somewhere else safer. Yeah. You know, where not everybody who's always known us is going to know. We just got this sudden bit of freedom somewhere else. In America, you know, people don't realize in England, you never escape your peer group in England. If you went to Oxford or Cambridge, that's it.
SPEAKER_01They're going to be around you for the rest of your fucking life. They're going to remember if you got a first or a second or a third in your deathbed. They will. You know that. And I just got a little breather from that. And... And with that self-confidence, I was able to go back and deal with my family and deal with all of it and integrate my life again. But America gave me that moment to sort of be free of them. And once I realized, it's a long story about my issues with my family and my mom in particular,
SPEAKER_01it was a very difficult decision to do to get away. But I realized I had to do it to save my life. Or like you, I would have been trapped there forever. I also felt if I hadn't didn't get away from Oxford, I was seduced by that place in a way that's very like you. I came from somewhere very different and I saw those spires and I saw what that represented. And for me, that was just it was an unbelievable experience, an intoxicating experience of escape.
SPEAKER_01Until my mom showed up in my rooms. That was part of the problem. But I found eventually I could get away altogether to America.
SPEAKER_00She showed up in your room?
SPEAKER_01Just to get away from my dad, yeah. And because she was bipolar and she needed me. And I would either have to spend my life helping her or I would get my own life. And it was a very hard thing to do.
SPEAKER_00And that's all going to be in the memoir, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, it is.
SPEAKER_00Because my mom gave me my faith. Yes.
SPEAKER_01And she also revealed to me levels of suffering, human suffering, that I've never seen before or since. I think mental illness is an unbelievably difficult thing, more difficult than people really give it credit for. And you watch your own mother experience. In total despair. And when you're seven or eight, it's a really tough thing to get past because you love her. It's horrible. So that's part of the memoir I'm thinking about a little bit more these days.
SPEAKER_01And I wouldn't have been able to write about it until she died. She died a couple of years ago now, and so I was able to really think about it again. And I think that's where the memoir impulse is coming from. But anyway, this is not about me, Ariana. Let's talk about you.
SPEAKER_00It's always about both of us, but she also gave you the faith in you.
SPEAKER_01Yes. It was... I mean, in some ways it was a little, because I remember the first, when I found out I got into Oxford, the mail was late. I thought I'd failed, and everyone else had been told that the letter had come, and mine hadn't come, and I was, okay. Anyway, they called up, my teacher called up, Oxford said, what's happening? We want to know. And yes, I got a demise ship, which is this top scholarship to Oxford in history. And my history teacher was...
SPEAKER_00They were all incredibly excited.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, oh, can I call my mom? And they said, sure. So I went down to the school office to call my mom. And I'm like, can I call my mom? Mom, I got the top scholarship in history to Moral Oxford. And she's like, well, of course you did. You're a son of mine, aren't you? And that was it. I mean, she would never... So in some ways that was harder in a way. I would never surprise her. She expected absolutely anything I did I had to succeed in. But again, it was with such love and confidence that I never felt pressure from her, ever, ever.
SPEAKER_01Just love.
SPEAKER_00Such a gift.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. A mother's love is about as important. That's why... Talking about the value of motherhood as also value of careers, I'm not joking, but there is a unique human value to a mother loving her children that is, I think, one of the most sacred things in the world. And one of the things, you grow up a Catholic, they teach you that. Because Mary is such an important figure in our faith. Yes. And the picture of her looking at our Lord as he dies,
SPEAKER_01and the Pieta, you know, when she's holding him afterwards, and just that dynamic, so potent in Catholicism. And my grandmother, too. And Christianity has always been sustained by women.
SPEAKER_00I mean, just because on the surface, it looks like they're all men and all the priests.
SPEAKER_01No. Women keep the faith, generation after generation after generation. And And the great thing about the Gospels is they really do give credit to the women, too. Unlike any other text of the era, there are women in those Gospels that are absolutely agents of the Lord, really characters, people. They're the people, the first people to whom the resurrection is announced. You know, they find out first. And Mary Magdalene is such a compelling figure, Mary and Martha comparing figures. And of course, my mother's called Mary, too, which just adds.
SPEAKER_01And she was buried on the Feast of the Assumption. So we kept it going. But you're in America and you start over. What was that like?
SPEAKER_00So I came to America with my third book, which was a biography of Maria Callas. So my first book was a big success. My second book was a total failure. In fact, first of all, it was rejected by 40 publishers before it was even published. And then it was probably, you know, read by three people.
SPEAKER_01You are not among them, Andrew.
SPEAKER_00But when I came to America, I came with this very successful biography of Maria Callas. So it made my arrival in America easier. And I arrived here and my publisher, do you remember George Weidenfeld?
SPEAKER_01I never met him, but I know of him. Yeah, obviously.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I kind of celebrated English publisher. And he said to me, you know, you arrive in New York. You're this young Greek woman with a big bestseller. Make sure you talk to the women at dinner parties. Don't talk to the men. You are going to make the women nervous. Don't talk to married men, even ignore them. He was giving me all this advice of how to handle a New York society.
SPEAKER_00But we shouldn't forget that second book, Andrew, if we're going down memory lane, because that second book was the book that I'm focusing on right now, because it was a book called After Reason.
SPEAKER_01Hmm.
SPEAKER_00It was a book that really looked at what had happened to the West. You know, it was an incredibly ambitious book for a 20-something. When we took kind of a detour with the enlightenment of worshiping reason and intelligence and leaving spirit out of it and the consequences The consequences of the 20th century,
SPEAKER_00which was the most scientifically advanced and bloodiest century, you know, the century of the Kulag and Auschwitz, where clearly reason betrayed us, you know, intelligence betrayed us. And it was a book that I think now has a catalyst To have the central thesis of the book addressed, because now that we have AI surpassing us in intelligence,
SPEAKER_00we actually are forced to ask the question, if we're not our intelligence, if we're not our IQ, because clearly we don't want to be identified with something that machines can do better, then who are we?
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't think, I mean, I've never identified humans by IQ or intelligence. I know you have, but culture has. To some extent it has, yes, there's no question.
SPEAKER_00Yes, with the whole meritocracy, the whole idea of meritocracy.
SPEAKER_01Well, the whole idea of a market economy is also that, that the smartest are going to become the most successful. But that can exist kind of not alongside a cultural balance to that, which like religion, or as you see in the 19th century, the big romantic... I agree. My concern, of course, is that...
SPEAKER_01You're right that we're not just intelligence. We're human beings. In my view, we have souls. We're all equally worthy and have dignity under the eyes of God. And so this intelligence will become greater than us if it isn't tempered with spirituality, if it's tempered and balanced with morality of some kind. We're in the most dangerous moment humankind has ever been in.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. But I believe also that we now have a catalyst to, first of all, ask the question, who are we? Which, let's face it, most intelligent humans do not ask. I mean, unless you have a faith... And I've always had a faith. Your faith is very structured. You're Catholic. Mine is more eclectic, but incredibly deep and totally drives my life.
SPEAKER_00And it takes the form of my feeling that I'm being held by a benevolent universe.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Which goes very much against the existential 20th century indifferent universe.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was asking myself this question about when did I first have faith? When do I first remember having faith? Because I've often asked, when do you first realize you were gay? And of course, it's actually... It's very complicated because it comes in stages and wrapped in confusion. But faith, what is it? You said you believe in this benevolent power. When did you first feel that, know that?
SPEAKER_01That somehow the earth is good, that life is to be affirmed, that this is not meaningless, irrational atoms with no greater meaning at all.
SPEAKER_00I was a little girl, like four years old, praying to the Virgin Mary. And nobody told me to pray to the Virgin Mary. My mother was just as likely to do yoga and meditate as to be a traditional Greek Orthodox woman. But I had this very, very deep connection with And I pray to her all the time.
SPEAKER_00And she remained like a huge part of my life. And I would fast on her day, her big day in Greece of August 15.
SPEAKER_01That's when I buried my mother that day. Assumption.
SPEAKER_00My family did not fast, I fasted. So it was my relationship with her. And then when at 17, I went to India to study comparative religion, I saw how the mystical form of every religious tradition, whether it's Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, is the same.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Which is that we all have a place of wisdom, strength and love in us. It's our birthright. Most of the time we're away from it. But for me, if you can have a pathway to return to it, nobody lives there all the time. Maybe there is a saint somewhere who lives there all the time. But tapping into it.
SPEAKER_01And sometimes the course... Sometimes life forces you to tap into it. Sometimes life smacks you over the head and you have no other place to go but that place. I'm thinking of, I mean, the Virgin was a big part of my childhood too. My grandmother, I mean, she spoke about Our Lady. With such familiarity as if she would come over for a cup of tea at any moment. Our lady will help. Our lady will do this. We'll just talk to our lady. Our lady will help you with that. And I'd listen to her. And again, this is one of these things you find out early.
SPEAKER_01I'm a very smart kid. I mean, not to blow my own, toot my own old battles. Very intelligent. My grandmother. Who lived with us. And she was from Tralee in Western Ireland. She was the seventh of 13 children. She came over to be a cleaning lady for priests. No real formal education whatsoever. And I would watch her occasionally at mass saying the rosary. And she was in another place.
SPEAKER_01Another place. And that's the place you recognized in India. That's the place you'll recognize in where I recognized it when I went to Burma and I saw these monks in deep meditation. She was reciting the rosary in this chanting way as if to just be with God. And that was the moment I realized I may be smart, but smart is not the most important thing. She
SPEAKER_00gets it.
SPEAKER_01And she was the most carefree, happy-go-lucky, incredibly irresponsible mother, just constantly. I mean, she was, you say, very structured because that's your understanding of what Catholicism is. And yes, it is, objectively, but not my grandmother's. Yes. There was no, it was, Just this absolutely intuitive love of creation and the sense that at any moment we had to ask help from everywhere around us. I mean, saints were all over the bloody place, you know.
SPEAKER_01St. Anthony was there, St. Jude. You know, all of them were always called into. And it was just a mystical, magical world to grow up in.
SPEAKER_00Oh my God, she would have loved my mother.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00That was my mother living in a mystical, magical world where she could not have an impersonal relationship. Like you would go shopping with her. She would find out the life of the shop assistant. The postman would deliver the mail. She would invite them to have some of her spanakopita or whatever she had cooked. That was really who she was.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they see the souls around them in a way that most of us don't. We just block it out. Or we're so busy in what we're doing and what we want to get to that we don't see it. And I mean, I wouldn't say I'm not making my grandmother out to be a saint. She wasn't. But there was an ease and childlike feeling. Equality to her faith. And Jesus says this too, you know, if you're not as a little child, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.
SPEAKER_01So for me, if you strip faith away, and I have a moment I can remember. It's early spring. It's like late April. I'm in the woodlands around where I grew up. I spend most of my time outside in the woodlands. And it's that moment when the spring is about to happen. And the leaves are that electric bright green that's just coming out. And below, bluebells. Just a blanket of bluebells underneath this canopy.
SPEAKER_01And I just slipped and found myself eye level with the bluebells. So you just saw this incredible blue blanket of beauty. And the sun was coming through and I could see the sun coming through the really electric green. And I was just like... I didn't say it in so many words, but I said hallelujah in my heart. Hallelujah. This is good. This is nature. God loves me. God creates this. This is all a good thing.
SPEAKER_01And how old
SPEAKER_00were you?
SPEAKER_01Six, seven years. Something like that. Sorry, I shouldn't say six, seven. Six or seven or eight, something like that. When I just felt this sense of calm in nature, some deep stillness there that was good. Good. And it took 30 years, what, 25 years for me to have a moment when, 20 minutes of my life when I thought for a minute that it wasn't good. Not that it was meaningless.
SPEAKER_01Not that it was irrational madness, but it was evil. And I think that's a moment that every person of faith, I think, has to at some point, if they're lucky, if they don't have that moment, but there will come a moment when life will give you, expose you to such awfulness that you will say, really? Have you had those moments? Have you had a moment like that where you really like, no, maybe God exists, but is evil.
SPEAKER_00Not that God is evil. I never had that. I had moments of extreme pain, like when my first child was born, stillborn. When, you know, when you realize how much I longed to be a mother, and I have a stillborn child. So I had moments of intense pain, but I never felt... That the universe was meaningless or evil.
SPEAKER_00What I find is really sad now is, as Thich Nhat Hanh said, that it's never been easier to run away from ourselves. Like that place that we've identified as the center of every spiritual tradition is kind of harder to tap into because we are So embedded in social media and noise and the internet
SPEAKER_01and health and flourishing and comfort and all the things that conspire to... To take you away from reality, which is that you're going to die, that you're human, and that, yeah, at some point. And that's what happened, by the way, on the retreat I went on eventually. Have you been on a silent retreat?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yes.
SPEAKER_01Yes. That too, it was a kind of revolution. I've written about this and I don't want to repeat myself, but you give up your phone at the beginning of it, which in today's world is kind of a real, you know, it's a real thing. And they give us, do a ceremony for it. And it's kind of, I don't know, it's a strange thing to give it up. It's like going to communion, but you give up your phone. And the thing is that then you're not allowed to read anything. We weren't allowed to look each other even in the eye. It was meditation all day long with breaks, walking meditation occasionally.
SPEAKER_01Total silence, no reading, no speaking, no words. And some of these people were in there for six weeks like that, which is quite... Half of them were in there for three months like that. I was only in there for 10 days. And the reason it was an interesting experiment is because you realize... That all they've done is take away everything that can distract you. Which our world has done an incredible job of providing distraction. And so eventually,
SPEAKER_01day by day, as the spaces open up and the silence expands, you are forced to confront what it is you've been distracting yourself from. And what are we as a society distracting ourselves from? And are we not getting to a point where we have to just acknowledge that? I mean, my feeling with AI and my feeling with the greater power of our technologies in general is if we don't learn to live better lives,
SPEAKER_01we are going to destroy ourselves.
SPEAKER_00Well, but here is where my optimism comes in, Andrew.
SPEAKER_01Hi there. This is not the end of this podcast. In fact, we're only just getting going. If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast in full. No extra charge. Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again
SPEAKER_01and go back to exactly what you've been doing. And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. It's very easy. AndrewSullivan.softfact.com is 50 bucks a year. Great value for money. You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast.
SPEAKER_01So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. Andrewsullivan.substack.com. Subscribe and get the whole thing. Join the debate. Join the fun. Subscribe.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com Gregory is an economic historian. He’s currently the Danish National Research Foundation Professor in Economics at Southern...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com Hamish is one of the co-founders of Substack and its chief writing officer. He’s a former reporter for the tech blog PandoDaily...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com Michael is a journalist and historian. He’s currently the senior political analyst for the Washington Examiner, a resident fellow...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com Catherine is a philologist with a particular focus on Augustine of Hippo. She’s both the Leslie Clark Professor in the Humanities...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.com My old friend Chris - the most intelligent, sane, and well-read conservative thinker writing in America today - returns to the...