Marco: Good morning — today's show is worth your full attention.
Klara: We're looking at Google finally telling advertisers exactly how much they're losing to fake clicks — and what that actually means for your budget.
Marco: Then we're digging into a surprising split in the fraud prevention world that ecommerce teams really need to hear.
Klara: And Hobbycraft is back in profit — and the story behind it is bigger than it looks.
Marco: Let's go.
Marco: Google Ads just started showing advertisers exactly how much money they're getting back from fake traffic — and it's a bigger deal than it sounds.
Klara: Let's rewind for people who aren't deep into this world. When you run ads online, not every view or click comes from a real human. Some of it is bots — automated programmes pretending to be people. That's called invalid traffic, or IVT. Google has always filtered this out and issued credits back to advertisers, meaning you don't pay for the fake stuff. The problem was, you had no idea how much that actually was.
Marco: Until now. Google Ads is rolling out exact credit figures — a real number, in pounds or euros, showing you precisely what you got back for invalid traffic in your campaigns. Before this, it was essentially a black box. Google said "trust us, we handle it." Now there's an actual figure on the screen.
Klara: And for anyone running significant ad budgets — whether you're a Zalando-scale retailer or a mid-sized brand spending fifty thousand euros a month — that number suddenly becomes very useful. You can track it month to month, spot patterns, and walk into a budget meeting with real data instead of estimates.
Marco: My take is that this is long overdue. Third-party fraud detection companies — businesses that independently measure bot traffic — have been giving their own estimates for years. Now brands can actually compare Google's figure against those independent numbers. If they're wildly different, that's a conversation worth having.
Klara: I'd say it's a step forward, but let's not overstate it. Seeing the credit is useful. Understanding whether the credit reflects the true scale of the problem is a different question entirely. The figure tells you what Google decided to refund — not necessarily what was actually wasted.
Marco: A fair distinction. Watch this space.
Klara: Our second story is coming right up.
Marco: New research has just surfaced a split inside fraud prevention teams that should make ecommerce brands genuinely uncomfortable — especially right now.
Klara: A bit of context. Every online retailer has to manage fraud — fake orders, stolen card details, account takeovers. To do that, they use fraud prevention tools. These tools cost money. And the question of how much to spend on them versus how much fraud loss is acceptable has always been a background tension inside companies.
Marco: Well, it's moving from background to foreground. New data from Practical Ecommerce shows that nearly one in three fraud prevention professionals say their organisation prioritises keeping tool costs down over actually preventing losses. That's not a small minority. That's a third of the people whose job it is to protect your revenue.
Klara: And the timing is brutal. We're heading into Black Friday and the holiday peak — the period where transaction volumes are highest, and where fraudsters are most active. The two things are directly connected. More orders means more opportunities for fraud. If your defences are underfunded going into that window, you feel it fast.
Marco: My read is that this is a commercial philosophy problem, not a technology one. The tools exist. The question is whether leadership sees fraud prevention as a cost centre — a bill to be minimised — or as a revenue protection line. For brands running thin margins, particularly direct-to-consumer sellers, a bad fraud month in December can wipe out what should be your best quarter.
Klara: I'd soften that slightly. Some of this pressure comes from boards that genuinely haven't seen the fraud numbers laid out clearly — which, as we talked about earlier, is a data visibility problem as much as a mindset one. Better reporting might shift those conversations faster than any amount of internal persuasion.
Marco: That's worth holding onto. We've got one more story to cover — coming right up.
Marco: Hobbycraft has returned to profit — and it tells us something interesting about where UK retail is heading.
Klara: So for anyone who doesn't follow British retail closely, Hobbycraft is a speciality chain — crafting supplies, art materials, knitting, that sort of thing. During lockdown, the whole crafting category went through the roof. People were stuck at home, they picked up new hobbies, and sales surged. The question everyone had afterwards was whether that would last — or whether people would just go back to their old lives and forget about it.
Marco: The assumption from most analysts was that the crafting boom was a lockdown blip. Hobbycraft's latest results suggest that was wrong. The business has come back to profit after a significant turnaround programme — tightening up operations, reducing costs — but crucially, it's also been carried by demand that simply hasn't faded the way people expected.
Klara: What I find worth sitting with is that this isn't just a demand story. Hobbycraft had real operational problems to fix on top of everything else. So the fact that they've managed both at the same time — while most mid-market UK retailers are still finding their feet — is a decent signal.
Marco: My read is that this matters well beyond Hobbycraft. We're heading into what's forecast to be a £9.8 billion Black Friday period in the UK. If a speciality retailer with genuine structural challenges can quietly stabilise and flip back into the black, it raises a real question about which other niche category players are on the same trajectory — and just haven't made the headlines yet.
Klara: I'd just be careful about reading this as a universal template. Hobbycraft has a very specific, loyal customer base. That kind of repeat behaviour is harder to replicate if your category doesn't have the same emotional pull. The crafting community is genuinely passionate — not every niche has that.
Marco: A loyal customer is worth more than any amount of acquisition spend. That's the real lesson here.
Marco: The single biggest idea from today — transparency is becoming a competitive advantage, whether that's Google showing you where your money went, or knowing exactly how much risk you're carrying in your fraud stack.
Klara: So look at one number you've never questioned before, and ask whether it's actually telling you the full story.