We are about to say goodbye to some basic water protections as the Trump Administration looks to undo decades of science-based work focused on keeping toxic chemicals out of our water supplies. Right now on the Defender, Amy talks with Clean Wisconsin attorney Evan Feinauer about how bedrock protections like the Clean Water Act could be at risk as the new administration targets regulations, research, and expert staff at the EPA. Find out what's at stake and how Wisconsin can fight back. Host: Amy Barrilleaux Guest: Evan Feinauer Resources for You: Under the Lens: What we know about PFAS in Wisconsin's Water Nitrate pollution's impact on Wisconsn's health and economy Neonicotinoid pesticides and their impact More episodes with Evan: When Judges Rule the Environment: How bad are the new Supreme Court rulings? What Trump 2.0 means for our environment
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Amy: Hi there and welcome. Amy: I'm Amy Barrilleaux and this is Amy: The Defender, Wisconsin's Amy: environmental podcast. Amy: The Defender is powered by Amy: Clean Wisconsin, your Amy: environmental voice since 1970. Amy: So it's pretty clear there are Amy: not a lot of things Americans Amy: can all agree on right now. Amy: But one thing is for sure, we Amy: do all need water to survive. Amy: Which makes it pretty Amy: concerning that we're about to Amy: say goodbye to some basic Amy: drinking water protections. Amy: New rules protecting us Amy: from lead and toxic Amy: PFAS in our water are about to Amy: be rolled back under the new
Amy: Trump administration. Amy: But that's not all. Amy: In this episode I'm talking Amy: with Clean Wisconsin attorney Amy: Evan Feinauer about how even Amy: bedrock protections like the Amy: Clean Water Act are at risk. Amy: Because this new federal Amy: government isn't just going Amy: after regulations and Amy: science, it's going after Amy: people. Amy: At the EPA. Amy: That's right now on The Amy: Defender.
Amy: Just one day after taking Amy: office, President Trump quietly Amy: withdrew a Biden administration Amy: plan to limit the amount of Amy: toxic PFAS allowed in Amy: wastewater flowing from Amy: chemical and manufacturing Amy: plants. Amy: It's one of what will likely be Amy: many actions to strip Amy: safeguards from our water Amy: supplies. Amy: In his first term, Trump Amy: removed protections from more Amy: than half of America's Amy: wetlands, rolled back rules to Amy: protect the Great Lakes, Amy: scrapped a regulation that Amy: prevented coal companies from Amy: dumping waste into local Amy: streams, weakened limits Amy: on toxic effluent from power
Amy: plants into public waterways. Amy: I mean, I could go on, but I'm Amy: going to stop there because I Amy: do have a guest. Amy: Evan Feinauer is an attorney Amy: with Clean Wisconsin who works Amy: on state water issues. Amy: Evan, thanks for being here. Evan: It's great to be here. Amy: There is a lot happening, so Amy: much going on with the Trump Amy: administration. Amy: There's news out every day. Amy: You've been looking Amy: specifically into what we Amy: might see as water impacts here Amy: in Wisconsin. So let's start Amy: with the big ones, the Amy: regulations, the things that Amy: keep pollution out of our Amy: water supplies. What are we
Amy: seeing happening on that front? Evan: Yeah, so starting with the Evan: regulations is good because it Evan: kind of allows you to Evan: understand the Evan: options, for lack of a better Evan: word, that the Trump Evan: administration has to roll Evan: things back. So there's Evan: something called the Congressional Evan: Review Act, which allows a new Evan: administration to get rid of Evan: regulations that were put in Evan: place pretty close to the Evan: election. Evan: So the idea here was like, Evan: well, if an administration Evan: rushes up some regulations and Evan: then there's an election, Evan: those can get taken a second Evan: look at by Congress.
Evan: So the one that Evan: we need to be particularly concerned Evan: about here are the lead and Evan: copper rule improvements. Evan: So these were the Biden Evan: Administration's efforts to Evan: safeguard folks from lead in Evan: their drinking water. Evan: And the main way it did that Evan: was requiring water Evan: systems to get rid of their Evan: lead service lines within a Evan: decade of the implementation Evan: of that rule. Evan: That rule was promulgated late Evan: enough in the game that Evan: Congress could use the Evan: Congressional Review Act to Evan: rescind it. Evan: It hasn't happened yet, but Evan: somebody has put in a proposal
Evan: to do it. And we're just going Evan: to have to watch that space to Evan: see if it's enough of a Evan: priority for this new Congress Evan: to do that. Evan: But even if they don't, there Evan: was a lawsuit that's in the D Evan: .C. Evan: Court of Appeals there Evan: challenging this. Evan: The American Water Works Evan: Association challenged this Evan: rule that's in mid -process. Evan: So we don't know how that Evan: litigation is going to play Evan: out. And also the Trump Evan: administration could just do a Evan: repeal rule. They could put Evan: out a rule that says we're Evan: hereby repealing the lead and Evan: copper rule improvements and we're Evan: going back to the way things
Evan: were before, which was kind of Evan: just not a whole lot happening Evan: to protect folks from lead by Evan: getting these lead service Evan: lines out. So that kind of Evan: shows you they have different Evan: ways of rolling back these Evan: regulations. Evan: And we just need to see for Evan: which of these rules Evan: they're going to use which Evan: tool to try to go after them. Amy: Yeah, because when this came Amy: out, the new Amy: Lead and Copper Rule, I want to Amy: say maybe it was November Amy: of last year, relatively Amy: recently, there was kind of a Amy: lot of finally
Amy: feeling people were celebrating Amy: this because it was kind of Amy: saying you need to get lead Amy: pipes out. Amy: And then there was some funding Amy: along with that, I think, Amy: through the BIL that was going Amy: to the Bipartisan Amy: Infrastructure Law. Amy: How does it feel to now Amy: be thinking, well, Amy: this is all going to go away, Amy: this finally trying Amy: to do something about lead in Amy: our water supply? Evan: Yeah, it's disappointing. Evan: I think we knew that, Evan: depending on how the election Evan: played out, that the Lead and Evan: Copper Rule improvements could
Evan: be vulnerable to a new policy Evan: change. Evan: I think what's so frustrating Evan: about this situation in Evan: particular is that people have Evan: been clamoring for decades for Evan: proactive mandatory lead Evan: service line replacement. Evan: And then the Biden administration Evan: did what it needed to do, Evan: which is it married the Evan: mandate to get rid of these Evan: service lines, which are Evan: poisoning our water with money Evan: to do it. Evan: So it wasn't just this here's Evan: a big requirement, you figure Evan: out how to pay for it or tax Evan: your customers. Evan: It was we're going to cost Evan: share this, we're going to socialize Evan: the cost of these toxic
Evan: metals in our water and Evan: we're going to do it to Evan: protect public health. And Evan: it's this investment that's Evan: going to pay off many times Evan: over. We know what lead does Evan: to developing minds in terms Evan: of IQs and all kinds of Evan: developmental stuff. Evan: This is a no brainer in terms Evan: of over the next couple Evan: of generations, what this is Evan: going to do to protect our Evan: minds of our young people who Evan: we need. Evan: And we finally got Evan: it after people knew that this Evan: was the policy solution all Evan: along. Evan: And so just sort of just kind Evan: of ignorantly go back to where
Evan: we were before is really a Evan: triumph of just sort of people Evan: not wanting to spend the money Evan: over reason. Evan: And it's unfortunate, I think Evan: a theme we're going to see in Evan: a lot of these environmental Evan: regulatory areas. Amy: I think, you know, Amy: Wisconsin had already been Amy: allocated, set to receive money Amy: from the Bipartisan Amy: Infrastructure Law to replace Amy: lead service lines in Amy: communities across the state. Amy: And now, as Amy: far as we know, a lot of that Amy: funding has been put on hold by Amy: the Trump administration. Evan: So, yeah, so this is
Evan: complicated, right? There was Evan: the Infrastructure Evan: Investment and Jobs Act, or Evan: IAJA, and then there was the Evan: Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, Evan: which allocated money for this Evan: kind of work to get lead Evan: service lines out. Evan: Wisconsin, along with a bunch Evan: of other states, is now part Evan: of a lawsuit. Evan: They've gone to federal court Evan: to challenge the Trump Evan: administration's funding Evan: freeze because there's genuine Evan: ambiguity about what's Evan: going to happen with the funds Evan: that haven't already sort of Evan: been spent, that aren't Evan: already out the door under Evan: what are called these Evan: revolving funds.
Evan: There's one under the Clean Evan: Water Act and one under the Evan: Safe Drinking Water Act, which Evan: is the relevant one here. Evan: And Wisconsin is a part of Evan: that lawsuit because we need Evan: to know, is that money coming Evan: or not? Congress allocated it Evan: for this purpose. Evan: The president really doesn't Evan: have authority just to say, Evan: I'd rather not. Evan: But that seems to be where Evan: we're at. And there's a lot of Evan: genuine ambiguity. And I know Evan: that's causing a lot of Evan: problems for agencies across Evan: these states, like our DNR Evan: here in Wisconsin, because Evan: right now you've got to Evan: replace these service lines. Evan: And this money was for those
Evan: purposes. Evan: Do we have the money or not? Evan: And it's a good example of the Evan: kind of chaos that's really Evan: unsettling water systems Evan: and other folks' ability to Evan: plan for the future and to Evan: know what they're going to be required Evan: to do and if they're going to have Evan: money to pay for it. Amy: So let's talk about another Amy: high -profile water Amy: contaminant that's PFAS, known Amy: as the Forever Chemicals. Amy: You know, we in Wisconsin Amy: just Amy: passed our own, maybe not just Amy: passed, but relatively recently
Amy: standards for drinking water Amy: systems. And then the EPA came Amy: in with an even tougher Amy: standard for drinking Amy: water. Amy: How do you see those standards Amy: playing out? This has been kind Amy: of a long time coming. Amy: These have been Amy: a concern for probably Amy: about a decade now. Amy: And then finally, again, Amy: finally we got some kind Amy: of standards, health -based Amy: standards for these things in Amy: the United States. Amy: What do you see happening? Evan: Yeah, I mean, this is another Evan: area where you're going to
Evan: have an opportunity for both Evan: litigation to knock out the Evan: rule and also for Evan: the administration to do a Evan: repeal rule. Evan: And they could do that a Evan: couple different ways. Evan: They could do a regulation Evan: that says we just don't need a Evan: PFAS drinking water standard. Evan: Or they could do one that Evan: says we Evan: don't need one or maybe we do, Evan: but we need more time. Evan: So that would be a little bit Evan: of a do nothing rule. Evan: You know, we'll convene a Evan: group of people who are Evan: invested in this and then Evan: we'll spend 24 months figuring Evan: out what the number should be.
Evan: Or they could just settle on a Evan: higher number, a less health Evan: protective number. Evan: So any of those things could Evan: be the way that plays out. Evan: But there'll be an Evan: opportunity, though, whatever Evan: they do for environmental Evan: groups and public health Evan: groups to challenge Trump Evan: administration's actions in Evan: court because they still have Evan: to comply with the Evan: Administrative Procedure Act Evan: and the Safe Drinking Water Evan: Act. And so there is a chance Evan: that if they do this poorly Evan: that it could get blocked by Evan: the courts, which would be Evan: good. But at the end of the Evan: day, it's a very Evan: vulnerable standard,
Evan: which just like the Lead and Evan: Copper Rule improvements, Evan: which we talked about, we're Evan: very celebrated because, Evan: you know, after years of Evan: advocacy, we had finally Evan: gotten a thing that the Evan: science was telling us we Evan: needed. And it's now on the Evan: chopping block as well. Amy: You know, you talk about that Amy: the courts could Amy: be making these decisions, but Amy: it feels like we're kind of in Amy: a lawless time now. Amy: Does the Trump administration Amy: have to listen to what the Amy: courts say? Evan: Well, of course it does. Amy: Does it?
Evan: It does. Amy: Because it feels like maybe I Amy: don't know what's going on. Evan: It does. Evan: You know, we Evan: need to be thoughtful in Evan: distinguishing different kinds Evan: of cases. Evan: If the federal court hearing Evan: this Lead and Copper Rule Evan: improvements lawsuit, for Evan: example, says the Evan: Lead and Copper Rule Evan: improvements are illegal Evan: because they exceeded EPA's Evan: authority, for example. Evan: You know, the Trump administration Evan: might actually like that Evan: ruling or not want to appeal
Evan: it to the U .S. Supreme Court Evan: or whatever. Evan: But when the court does that, Evan: that's supposed to be kind of Evan: the end of the story. Evan: And usually what agencies do Evan: then and administrations do if Evan: they don't like it is they try Evan: to do something like a Evan: workaround. They'll do a new Evan: rule that maybe superficially Evan: complies with the court's Evan: order, but is substantively Evan: not as protective or is Evan: in other ways, Evan: you know, kind of, I guess, Evan: complying with the letter of Evan: the ruling, but not maybe the Evan: spirit of it, to put it a
Evan: different way. Evan: And I think that that's just Evan: what we're going to see. I Evan: don't think we should anticipate Evan: in advance that, you Evan: know, Trump will try to do a Evan: repeal rule of one of these Evan: regulations we like. Evan: And the court will say you Evan: didn't do this correctly. Evan: You know, your repeal rule is Evan: illegal. Evan: The old good standard stays in Evan: place. And he just says, oh, Evan: no, it doesn't. Evan: I don't think we should just Evan: assume that's going to be what Evan: happens. I understand people Evan: are fearful of that. Evan: And there have been comments Evan: made by folks in the Evan: administration that, oh, we'll Evan: just ignore the courts. Evan: But I don't think we should Evan: just assume
Evan: we're going to go to that Evan: craziness until it actually Evan: happens. In part because I Evan: think talking about it like Evan: it's, oh, that's what's going Evan: to happen does sort of Evan: anticipatorily normalize Evan: that. And it's such an insane Evan: thing to do that's at such Evan: odds with the history of Evan: this country that Evan: I think we need to like kind Evan: of call their bluff and Evan: actually have them refuse to Evan: comply with a court order in a Evan: more substantive way. Evan: We've seen some instances Evan: already. We were talking about Evan: the funny and freeze where Evan: it's not clear that they were
Evan: complying with court orders Evan: from the federal district Evan: court. But there's also a Evan: plausible explanation that that's Evan: just due to sheer incompetence, Evan: that they didn't comply Evan: because they don't know how to Evan: because they don't know what they're Evan: doing. And because they're Evan: basically chaotically Evan: ransacking through the federal Evan: government rather than having Evan: a plan. Evan: But we'll see. Evan: We'll see what happens. Evan: And we have to be prepared for Evan: that eventuality, but I want Evan: to assume it's going to be what Evan: happens. Amy: OK. You're looking on the Amy: bright side of just the Trump
Amy: Administration, you Amy: know, promulgating Amy: rules that are just Amy: toothless. Evan: Well, I think that they're Evan: more prepared now than they Evan: were the first time to act in Evan: ways that comply with Evan: the Administrative Procedure Evan: Act, which I mentioned before. Evan: And that's the that's this big Evan: federal statute that controls Evan: what a lot of agencies do. Evan: And it's kind of like, you Evan: know, this is what tells you Evan: how to dot your I's and cross Evan: your T's, get all your Evan: paperwork correct to provide Evan: the right kinds of reasons for Evan: the right kind of actions.
Evan: So you don't get bounced by a Evan: judge who says you didn't Evan: comply with the APA. Evan: And they're clearly more Evan: prepared to do that. Evan: They lost in court a ton the Evan: first time around because they Evan: were just incompetently acting Evan: because they just they weren't Evan: prepared to govern and they Evan: were kind of disinterested in Evan: how to govern. Evan: I still think that they're Evan: disinterested in how to Evan: govern, but they clearly have Evan: hired more seasoned people. Evan: And at the EPA, at least a lot Evan: of the same people have come Evan: back. So they've, I think, Evan: learned the hard way that they Evan: actually have to follow the Evan: law to get their Evan: policy outcomes. Amy: But you think they
Amy: will they could Amy: successfully target the Lead Amy: and Copper Rule and the newer Amy: PFAS standards. Evan: Absolutely. And one of the Evan: things that we should keep in Evan: mind, and this is dynamic to Evan: your question about the court Evan: says, you Evan: know, they only have to defy a Evan: court order if they don't like Evan: it. And what we've seen from Evan: the U .S. Supreme Court is a Evan: real enthusiasm for Evan: rulings that Evan: reduce federal Evan: agency authority, namely EPA. Evan: And so I could see them Evan: saying, oh, this lead and Evan: copper rule improvements, it's
Evan: so expensive because replacing Evan: lead service lines are Evan: expensive, even though there's Evan: nothing in the statute that Evan: says anything about that. Evan: And it's a completely non Evan: -textual, non -historical Evan: interpretation of what the Evan: Safe Drinking Water Act Evan: requires. It's a major Evan: question, then. It must be a Evan: major question because it's Evan: expensive. Evan: And then there's nothing there's Evan: no ruling for Trump to defy. Evan: Right. I mean, if the court lays Evan: down and agrees with them on Evan: these legal issues, then we Evan: won't come to that. Evan: And I think that that's the Evan: thing that is the first order Evan: question we should be worried Evan: about is, are the federal Evan: courts going to going to
Evan: say no? Evan: These requirements and these Evan: statutes mean something and Evan: you have to meet them versus Evan: just the executive branch gets Evan: to do what it wants to do. Evan: So we'll see. And there'll be Evan: a number of rules like that. Evan: We've talked about the Evan: PFAS drinking water standards, Evan: lead and copper rule Evan: improvements. There'll Evan: probably be another round of Evan: regulations on WOTUS or Waters Evan: of the United States defining Evan: which waters are Evan: protected by the Clean Water Evan: Act and which ones aren't.
Evan: That's going to be a big deal. Evan: There's a lot of stuff like Evan: that. Amy: So I guess there are a number Amy: of different scenarios that Amy: things could play out. Amy: But are you thinking that Amy: we're going to see the Amy: dismantling of Amy: some of these protections at Amy: the federal level? Evan: Yeah. And that gets into that Evan: there's there's ways of Evan: dismantling protections Evan: without having Congress Evan: pass a law that says the Clean Evan: Water Act doesn't exist. Evan: Because even under a
Evan: less full throated position of Evan: like what Trump can get away Evan: with unilaterally, Evan: the executive branch clearly Evan: has discretion over how to Evan: administer and enforce Evan: the law. Evan: And then often can just mean Evan: not doing that. Evan: So a really simple example Evan: of this is just enforcement Evan: actions. Evan: EPA has an Office of Evan: Enforcement. They'll work with Evan: the U .S. DOJ when there's Evan: environmental crimes. Evan: And I would expect to see very Evan: low levels of enforcement. Evan: So the Clean Water Act is on
Evan: the books. They don't roll Evan: back any standards, but they Evan: kind of just don't enforce it Evan: very fully. Evan: And that's a way in which communities Evan: aren't protected from water Evan: pollution because polluters Evan: are kind of being given the Evan: signal, now's your chance. Evan: If they get that signal, Evan: that's how these businesses Evan: are going to act because it Evan: increases their bottom lines. Evan: And so I think low levels of Evan: enforcement up and down the Evan: line could really leave Evan: communities vulnerable to Evan: increased water pollution. Amy: And it's not just they're Amy: getting signals. I mean, I Amy: think there's been actual words
Amy: spoken like, OK, if you're Amy: a company that has Amy: this much value, Amy: then we want to get rid of any Amy: kind of regulation that might Amy: impede your... Evan: Well, there's been reporting Evan: there's been reporting that Evan: the Department of Justice's Evan: environmental section, those Evan: lawyers were basically told Evan: we're going to reassign you to Evan: doing immigration enforcement Evan: cases and Evan: you can either do that or you Evan: can quit. Evan: So it's not, you know, and Evan: they're just moving folks Evan: around in the department,
Evan: which they have some level of Evan: authority to do. Evan: But if you don't have any lawyers Evan: at DOJ working on Evan: environmental enforcement, Evan: then nobody's enforcing the Evan: law. Evan: And so that's a way you can do Evan: something without the Evan: courts or Congress having to Evan: bless it or say it's OK or Evan: it's constitutional. Evan: But the result is, in some Evan: cases, going to be similar to Evan: just we roll back the Evan: underlying standards Evan: themselves, at least in the Evan: short term. Amy: So we think of ourselves as, Amy: you know, three branches of Amy: government, right? But when you Amy: have this system, these
Amy: agencies that are basically Amy: under the control of the Amy: executive branch in terms of Amy: how they're staffed and what Amy: they're doing and all that, Amy: you start to kind of see the Amy: vulnerabilities in Amy: this in the system because we Amy: have so much that we Amy: rely on for these agencies, Amy: EPA, FCC, FDA, Amy: USDA, you know, all of those Amy: important big Amy: federal agencies. Amy: So when we look at the EPA, Amy: I think we're all aware
Amy: that the Amy: way it works is going to be Amy: targeted. Amy: What are we kind of seeing that Amy: could happen? Evan: Well, there's a lot of stuff Evan: that's happening that is going Evan: to be kind Evan: of business as usual in terms Evan: of this is what happens when Evan: you go from maybe a Evan: more environmentally minded Evan: Democratic administration to a Evan: less environmentally minded Evan: Republican administration. Evan: And that kind of stuff isn't Evan: shocking or really that new,
Evan: right? We saw similar things Evan: when George W. Evan: Bush was elected. We're going Evan: to emphasize this or Evan: deemphasize that. Evan: And so we need to be careful Evan: about distinguishing those Evan: kind of things where it's just Evan: the prerogative of the Evan: administration. This is Evan: normal. Evan: They care more about this than Evan: they do about that. Evan: And that's their job. Evan: That's their role. They got elected, Evan: so they get to do that. Evan: In contrast, that was Evan: situations where it's really Evan: undermining the nuts and Evan: bolts of how an agency works Evan: in a way that is really Evan: contrary to Evan: the mission and purpose of the Evan: agency as Congress designed
Evan: and as the courts have Evan: interpreted their role to be. Evan: And so what that looks like Evan: is, you know, Evan: this stuff about, oh, we're Evan: just going to move you over Evan: here and we're going to pay you Evan: not to work because, Evan: you know, we don't want you Evan: to look for environmental Evan: justice problems. Evan: You're basically laid off or, Evan: you know, we're going to put out Evan: a memo that interprets a Evan: statute in a completely bad Evan: faith way in Evan: order to basically Evan: dare somebody to sue us. Evan: And that's what we're seeing Evan: now is like going after Evan: the employment and the labor
Evan: situation at EPA, going Evan: after the staff, Evan: creating an atmosphere of Evan: fear, frankly, Evan: an anti -science mentality Evan: that is obviously Evan: completely unworkable. Evan: That's what the Environmental Protection Evan: Agency, which is supposed to Evan: run on science. Evan: And all of that is so clearly Evan: contrary to what EPA is Evan: that it's not just Evan: overshifting our priorities. Evan: It's we're trying Evan: intentionally to make Evan: it so that this agency can't Evan: function so
Evan: that the employees in it feel Evan: as though there's no point in Evan: trying and therefore they quit Evan: and then we just won't hire Evan: new people to replace them. Evan: It would be like if you bought Evan: a business and then Evan: intentionally tried to run into Evan: the ground. Evan: And that's what we're seeing Evan: that's going to be different Evan: than previous Evan: administrations that just had Evan: less of a policy emphasis on Evan: environmental protection. Evan: It's going to be a bunch Evan: of bad faith attacks on these Evan: folks as corrupt. Evan: And, you know, they'll do all Evan: this insane stuff trying to Evan: say that this is somehow what Evan: people want. The reality
Evan: is that these are people who Evan: have jobs that are often kind Evan: of the boring stuff we take Evan: for granted that the government Evan: does. You know, looking at Evan: monitoring reports, did this Evan: chemical plant near your house Evan: blow through the limits in its Evan: permit for horrifying Evan: chemicals in the water? Evan: Well, if nobody's looking now, Evan: we just don't know. Evan: And the idea that that's Evan: somehow vindicating people's Evan: freedom or something or, Evan: you know, take that on elected Evan: bureaucrats is just Evan: a bizarre attempt Evan: to claim that what you're
Evan: doing is supported by the Evan: people when there's no mandate Evan: for that. Nobody asked for Evan: that. But that's where it Evan: is going to be what we're going Evan: to see. Amy: I mean, let's talk about what Amy: life was like in this country Amy: before the EPA, before the Safe Amy: Drinking Water Act, the Clean Amy: Water Act. All these acts that Amy: we think of as, Amy: oh, of course they're here, Amy: like almost as though they've Amy: always been here. Amy: What were things like when Amy: polluters did have free reign? Evan: Well, what you had often was Evan: a patchwork of Evan: local and sometimes state laws
Evan: that tried to get a handle on Evan: this. Evan: And a hope more than an Evan: expectation, I think, that the Evan: market would incentivize Evan: business actors to reduce Evan: their pollution. Evan: And it created kind Evan: of a patchwork of places where Evan: pollution wasn't so bad, other Evan: places where it was really Evan: bad, industry by industry Evan: differences. Evan: But on the whole, it just Evan: didn't allow for the outcome Evan: which you need, which is water Evan: that's safe to drink, water Evan: that you can actually eat the Evan: fish that come out of, those Evan: kinds of outcomes.
Evan: And that's the reason that you Evan: needed federal action. Evan: It's a solution to a Evan: collective action problem, Evan: which is if everybody has Evan: to meet the same standards, Evan: then we don't have some Evan: problem of, oh, well, this Evan: business over here is at a Evan: disadvantage versus this other Evan: one. We have clear rules of Evan: the road. We know how the Evan: rules will change. Evan: If you want to update a Evan: standard, you have to go through this Evan: process. And it created Evan: massive benefits, not just Evan: for public health and the Evan: environment, but also for Evan: certainty for everybody else Evan: involved.
Evan: And going backwards isn't Evan: just going to mean that the Evan: waters get dirtier. Evan: It's going to mean that. But Evan: it's also going to mean it's Evan: not totally clear what the Evan: legal obligations for Evan: businesses are to avoid water Evan: pollution. It's going to vary Evan: from state to state. Evan: And it's going to be chaotic Evan: and not efficient really for Evan: anybody, which is why I think Evan: you're seeing across some of Evan: these issues, folks saying, Evan: you know, we're actually fine Evan: if some of these standards to Evan: stay in place as opposed Evan: to, yeah, burning all down to Evan: the ground. Evan: You know, it's sort of a myth Evan: that everybody wants
Evan: no regulation. Evan: They just want regulations Evan: that are feasible and that Evan: they can work with. Evan: So it's kind of this bizarre Evan: situation where they're, in Evan: some cases, doing more than Evan: I think even what the Evan: regulated community would want Evan: in terms of rolling back these Evan: standards. Amy: So one thing that I Amy: didn't understand about how Amy: the EPA relates to Amy: folks here in Wisconsin is that Amy: the EPA or the federal Amy: government actually funds some Amy: positions in Wisconsin at
Amy: the DNR to carry out Amy: those federal programs like the Amy: Safe Drinking Water Act. Amy: So the folks on Amy: the ground here in Wisconsin Amy: who are working with water Amy: utilities in towns and Amy: governments to make sure the Amy: drinking water is safe, make Amy: sure that they are complying, Amy: that they are testing correctly, Amy: when there was that sort of Amy: brief freeze on everything, Amy: those folks found Amy: out that their funding was Amy: frozen. I don't know if it's Amy: all been released. Amy: I think we're still in the gray
Amy: area, but what's Amy: at risk if all of a sudden Amy: those positions, Amy: which are DNR positions but Amy: funded through federal Amy: EPA dollars, Amy: start to be lost? Evan: Well, then all of Evan: a sudden you're going to have Evan: an agency, DNR, that already Evan: is resource constrained and Evan: has a hard time implementing Evan: all of the laws it's required Evan: to implement Evan: be even more
Evan: limited in what it can do. Evan: And the only way to address Evan: that is going to be we're Evan: going to have to spend more Evan: money at the state level or Evan: we're going to have to live Evan: with a situation where Evan: we can't really guarantee that Evan: our air is clean to breathe Evan: and our water is clean to Evan: drink. And that's going to be Evan: going back to those bad old Evan: days that you referenced Evan: earlier. Evan: There's really no other way Evan: around it. I mean, we need a Evan: certain number of people to be Evan: doing this. Evan: And just to put a finer point Evan: on it, what I've Evan: heard is that for some
Evan: departments in DNR, a Evan: majority of the positions are Evan: funded through federal grants. Evan: And so you're looking at Evan: potentially losing over half Evan: the staff in a particular area Evan: where they, for example, Evan: monitor water systems in the Evan: state to ensure that they're Evan: complying with these Evan: drinking water standards. Evan: Well, I mean, if you work for Evan: a private for -profit business Evan: and you laid off over half the Evan: people in a division, Evan: do you think performance is Evan: just going to stay exactly the Evan: same? Evan: You don't hire anybody new? Evan: I mean, that's crazy.
Evan: And that's potentially what Evan: we're looking at. Now you're Evan: right that it's ambiguous Evan: about this funding. Evan: Is it permanently frozen? Evan: How much of it was ever Evan: actually supposed to be? Evan: And that gets back to the Evan: incompetence of the Trump Evan: administration and those Evan: memos that they've put out. Evan: We're going to find out over Evan: the long term what's really Evan: going to be there or not. Evan: But right now it's creating a Evan: lot of Evan: concern that DNR might not Evan: really be able to do its job Evan: over the next four years. Evan: Like it's legally required Evan: to by statute because of Evan: funding constraints, which
Evan: shows yet another way Evan: that you can, without changing Evan: the law, functionally change Evan: the law, which is you starve Evan: the agency of the resources it Evan: needs to implement it. Evan: And then the agency can do its Evan: best. But if you've got less Evan: than half the staff, I mean, Evan: it's just not going to happen Evan: at the same level. Amy: So back in those Amy: bad old days before the EPA, Amy: before Safe Drinking Water Amy: Act, Wisconsin, Amy: I think, was one of those Amy: places, one of those states Amy: that did try to Amy: have protections that really
Amy: kind of started Amy: along a good path to Amy: protect our natural Amy: environment, to protect our Amy: waterways. Amy: What do you see happening this Amy: time around if the EPA is Amy: kind of brought to its knees Amy: the way we're talking about Amy: here in Wisconsin? Evan: Yeah. And this is the dynamic Evan: again that we've seen some Evan: version of in the past. Evan: I think this will be a stronger Evan: version of it. But when that Evan: federal backstop essentially Evan: gives way, Evan: what that does, that has a
Evan: couple of different effects. One Evan: is it puts more Evan: responsibility on DNR to Evan: make sure standards are being Evan: met, which, as we just Evan: discussed with the resource Evan: constraints, is hard because Evan: they rely on those federal Evan: resources to do things. Evan: The other thing is that the Evan: way a lot of our environmental Evan: standards are set up, if Evan: they're not purely state law Evan: issues, oftentimes Evan: DNR, as Evan: the state's environmental agency, Evan: has to go to EPA and get Evan: approval in one form Evan: or another for changing Evan: something or implementing Evan: something or a certain way.
Evan: And when they go to Region 5 Evan: of the EPA down in Chicago the Evan: next four years, Evan: they might just not answer. Evan: They may not allow us to do Evan: things that are protective of Evan: the environment. Evan: I mean, think about it this Evan: way. Evan: If you're somebody who doesn't Evan: want to have to meet environmental Evan: standards in Wisconsin, you Evan: don't have to go convince DNR Evan: now or convince the state Evan: legislature to change the law Evan: or the governor to change the Evan: law. You can just tell a Evan: bureaucrat in Chicago, just Evan: deny Wisconsin's request Evan: to change their program
Evan: with regard to large animal Evan: farms, for example. Evan: And it doesn't have to be Evan: correct legally. They can just Evan: say no. Evan: And those kinds of things have Evan: happened, and I would expect Evan: them to happen over more of Evan: the next four years. So it isn't Evan: just that they're doing Evan: nothing. They can do active Evan: harm to undermine our state Evan: standards for these Evan: programs that are joint Evan: federal -state, Evan: what they call cooperative Evan: federalism programs, which is Evan: your Clean Water Act, your Evan: Clean Air Act, those kinds of Evan: things. Evan: The good news is that there Evan: are some state -level Evan: protections that EPA doesn't
Evan: have its hand in. Amy: That's what I was just going to Amy: ask about. Evan: So that's, you know, the Clean Evan: Water Act federally doesn't Evan: cover most groundwater, and so Evan: we have a groundwater protection Evan: law in Wisconsin. Evan: We have a state wetlands law Evan: that protects more wetlands Evan: than federal law does. Evan: And so those are pretty robust Evan: protections, and we just need Evan: to be particularly Evan: kind of protective of those Evan: now because there's nothing Evan: behind them. Evan: You know, it used to be the Evan: case that, well, a Evan: lot of wetlands are joint Evan: federal and state jurisdictional,
Evan: so if the state doesn't do a Evan: good job with this permit, the Evan: feds might anyway. Evan: We can't depend on Evan: that. And so we need to be Evan: particularly suspicious of any Evan: effort now to Evan: weaken state laws in areas Evan: where there's nothing behind Evan: it federally. We always needed Evan: to be, but now it's clearly an Evan: attempt not just to align Evan: state and federal law, but Evan: it's an attempt to deregulate Evan: the area entirely. Amy: So let's get back to these kind Amy: of Biden Administration laws Amy: that were passed, Bipartisan Amy: Infrastructure Law and others,
Amy: that are helping clean up Amy: legacy pollution in the Great Amy: Lakes and our waterways and our Amy: rivers. Amy: A lot of that funding has been Amy: paused. Do you expect it to Amy: stay that way or? Evan: I don't know. That's one of Evan: these issues where one would Evan: hope that, Evan: you know, there's always been Evan: a little bit less political Evan: opposition to clean up Evan: efforts. Yes, they're expensive, Evan: but they're not preventing Evan: any Evan: business actor from doing Evan: anything today because
Evan: they're cleaning up legacy Evan: pollution. So what it is is Evan: we're basically socializing Evan: the costs of cleaning up one Evan: private entity's pollution. Evan: So who's going to be opposed Evan: to that other than the fact Evan: that we, the taxpayers, end up Evan: paying for somebody else's Evan: mess, right? Evan: So, you know, things like Evan: cleaning up the Great Lakes Evan: and doing things like that, Evan: you would hope that when the Evan: dust settles on these pauses, Evan: that continues to come through Evan: as something that has Evan: bipartisan support. Evan: And a lot of these cleanups Evan: do affect more than one state,
Evan: so they often cut across Evan: Democratic and Republican Evan: districts. Evan: But, Evan: you know, there's been something Evan: about the kind of blunderbuss Evan: approach to this that does Evan: make you wonder if they're Evan: just more interested in Evan: just creating chaos Evan: than actually stopping Evan: projects that they have policy Evan: objections to. Evan: And so we'll have to see. Evan: I mean, an example of this Evan: just the other day, there was Evan: reporting that the governor of Evan: Illinois is pausing moving Evan: forward with the invasive
Evan: carp project to keep the carp Evan: out of the Great Lakes. Evan: Well, you know, keeping carp Evan: out of the Great Lakes, that Evan: affects people all over. Evan: It shouldn't be this Evan: partisan thing that Evan: gets paused because, Evan: you know, they're worried Evan: about runaway spending or Evan: something. It's a project that's Evan: already been approved. Evan: It makes sense. Evan: It's important to do. Evan: There's already a plan in Evan: place. And now we're at the Evan: 11th hour just pausing Evan: it because why? Evan: So I hope Evan: that reason prevails on
Evan: something like that. Evan: But, you know, sitting where Evan: we are, it's hard to assume Evan: that that rational outcome is Evan: going to be what happens. Amy: So here we are sitting in Amy: Clean Wisconsin's offices. Amy: You're an attorney. Amy: You work on water issues every Amy: day. Amy: What is on your Amy: plate, I guess? What's next for Amy: you to try to Amy: work to keep what Amy: protections we have in place? Evan: Yeah. Evan: So we've talked about that Evan: there's good state laws in
Evan: many areas, and that can help Evan: us be a little bit insulated Evan: from stuff at the federal Evan: level. Evan: So I mentioned groundwater law Evan: and wetland law. There's some Evan: other laws like that that are Evan: good. We need to fight to Evan: protect and to have the Evan: department implement fully Evan: and correctly at Evan: the federal levels for stuff Evan: that is interactive with what Evan: these federal changes are Evan: going to be. Evan: We can still pursue things Evan: like federal litigation. Evan: You can still go to court and Evan: get the court to toss out a Evan: bad federal action. Evan: And I understand that some
Evan: people will say, well, are the Evan: courts going to really stand Evan: up to the Trump administration Evan: or not? But we have to try. Amy: Yeah. Evan: And I think in many cases they Evan: will. Evan: The other thing to keep in Evan: mind is, you know, some of Evan: these things are just not, Evan: you know, candidly, I don't Evan: think Trump cares about. Amy: Okay. Evan: And so I don't know how much Evan: political capital would be Evan: spent on, you know, we're Evan: going to defy this court order Evan: on this niche environmental Evan: issue that we care Evan: deeply about. Evan: But if he's busy trying to Evan: have a trade war with China or
Evan: something, he may not care so Evan: much about. Evan: And I think it's important to Evan: not view everything Evan: through, you Evan: know, Trump is doing this and Evan: we need to fight back. Evan: You know, it's Evan: there is a long standing Evan: contest in this country Evan: between folks who want more Evan: health and environmental protective Evan: standards and folks who Evan: think that business should Evan: have to pay for the pollution Evan: they cause, which obviously Evan: we don't agree with.
Evan: And some of these are these Evan: fights are going to be more in Evan: that boring register than this Evan: like ideological fight for Evan: democracy stuff. Evan: And in that Evan: vein, we need to keep going to Evan: things like the federal courts Evan: and being like, stop this. Evan: This is illegal. Evan: You know, that's not Evan: going to stop happening. Evan: But we also need to be Evan: prepared for weird Evan: eventualities. Evan: Like, what if they defy an Evan: order? What if, you know, Evan: that's this kind of stuff that Evan: that's what feels kind of new Evan: is that we're in a position Evan: where the traditional tools to Evan: advocate difficulties as they
Evan: were, we're at least there. Evan: And now we're wondering about Evan: their durability in a way Evan: that's scary, but also Evan: legitimate. Amy: So if somebody is listening to Amy: this and they're feeling kind Amy: of like we're at a unique Amy: moment in American history Amy: where things might Amy: get unraveled pretty Amy: quickly, what what can they do Amy: or what should they pay attention Amy: to? Evan: Well, I would I would pay Evan: attention to what's actually Evan: happening versus what people Evan: are saying is happening. Amy: That's a little tricky.
Evan: It is tricky. But I mean, what Evan: I'd say about that is Evan: there is going to there's a Evan: clear public record in Evan: all of these instances. Evan: If they're going to do or if Evan: they're going to try to repeal Evan: rules, they have to go on the Evan: record and writing with all Evan: this stuff. And that's not Evan: always going to be what they're saying Evan: publicly. And I think by Evan: us focusing out, you know, Evan: Clean Wisconsin and other Evan: folks focusing on what they're Evan: actually saying, it will Evan: reveal the hollowness of a lot Evan: of their actions and their Evan: explanations for their Evan: actions. Evan: Because at the end of the day,
Evan: what this is about is allowing Evan: public health to Evan: be weakened, the environment Evan: to be weakened, to Evan: allow corporations Evan: and rich people to keep more Evan: of their money. Evan: You know, that at the end of Evan: the day, that's what a lot of this Evan: is. The reason that folks Evan: don't want to comply with these regulations Evan: that make them internalize the Evan: costs of their, you know, Evan: pollution they cause is Evan: because they want to keep their money. Evan: And, Evan: you know, we just need to kind Evan: of keep our eyes on the prize Evan: in that regard and understand
Evan: the reality of what's Evan: happening and speak truthfully Evan: about that. So people can Evan: understand that this Evan: isn't something that should Evan: and doesn't have public Evan: support to basically funnel Evan: more of our limited resources Evan: and to trade my health for Evan: your money. There's no Evan: mandate for that. Evan: And I think the best thing Evan: that we can do is Evan: be aware of that and talk to Evan: one another about that and Evan: make sure that that's breaking Evan: through, which is really hard. Evan: Because we have these Evan: ideological lanes that people Evan: get in and there's
Evan: so much misinformation out Evan: there now. Evan: But that's Evan: the reality of what's going to Evan: be happening over the next Evan: four years. And we just need Evan: to keep saying it so that Evan: people know that's what's Evan: happening. And the next time Evan: there's an opportunity to Evan: folks get involved, the next Evan: election or whatever, that's Evan: what's front of mind to them Evan: versus a bunch of Evan: distractions. Amy: Clean Wisconsin attorney Evan Amy: Feinauer, thank you so much for Amy: providing your perspective on Amy: all this. I appreciate it. Evan: Thank you. Amy: For more information on water Amy: protections in Wisconsin, log
Amy: on to our website, Amy: cleanwisconsin .org. Amy: And if you have something you Amy: want to ask, show ideas Amy: or just a comment, feel Amy: free to send me an email Amy: podcast at cleanwisconsin .org. Amy: I'm Amy Barrio and thank you Amy: for listening to The Defender.
In this episode, why faith communities went into Midwestern homes to test the air and what they discovered. Host: Amy Barrilleaux Guest: Rev. Brian Sauder, President & CEO of Faith in Place Resources for You: Air Aware:...
...but not in a good way. On this episode, a look at the fossil fuel boom caused by AI and the cry for help from state regulators who say they're powerless to stop it. Host: Amy Barrilleaux Guest: Ciaran Gallagher,...
The DNR just revealed a long list of violations at Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline construction site. In this episode, a deep dive into what Enbridge is doing to Wisconsin's Northwoods, and whether the DNR can or will do...
If you think growing hazelnuts is just for Europe or the West Coast, think again. Turns out, we've got a wild, native variety right here in Wisconsin, and people are getting excited pretty excited about it. In this...
Our neighbor to the south - Iowa - has a cancer problem. In this episode, we look at a new study that paints an alarming picture of rural America... and cancer rates. Host: Amy Barrilleaux Guest: Kerri Johannsen, Senior...