Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Debrief with Jon Becker

The Debrief with Jon Becker artwork

DME-11 - HR with IEDs

Mar 18, 202614 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

DME-11 - HR with IEDs

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to today's decision-making exercise brought to you by the California Association of Tactical Officers and the Debrief. My name is Toby Darby, and I'm a board member and instructor for Cato. Now, today's exercise is designed to challenge your ability to analyze complex situations, make critical decisions, and discuss them together with your peers. But before we dive into the scenarios, let's talk about what a decision-making exercise is and why it is so effective for law enforcement. A decision-making exercise, or as we call it a Cato, a DME, gives you the chance to step into a realistic scenario, consider how you would handle the situation, and then discuss different points of view and approaches.

SPEAKER_01What makes it so powerful is that it allows you to test your thinking in a safe, controlled environment before the real world stakes are at play. It's a learning experience where you can see how your decisions might unfold in an actual incident, challenge each other's thinking, and come to an agreement on the resolution your team would take following your local law and policy guidelines. Before beginning today's exercise, please select one person to act as the facilitator for the exercise. As the facilitator, your role is critical in guiding group discussions, ensuring thoughtful analysis, and maintaining alignment with established law, ethics, policies, and national standards.

SPEAKER_01Your responsibilities include pausing the video at key moments, encouraging participation, and challenging answers where appropriate. After each section or scenario prompt, you will pause the video to allow the group time to discuss and respond to the specific questions presented. Ensure that all participants have a clear understanding of the scenario before beginning the discussion. Encourage each group to answer the specific questions thoroughly. Ensure that every participant has an opportunity to contribute to the discussion.

SPEAKER_01And if needed, prompt quieter members to share their thoughts to foster a diverse perspective. Listen carefully to the group's responses and challenge answers that may cause disagreement or do not align with legal, ethical, or policy standards. Use your knowledge of law enforcement policies, best practices, and national standards to steer the group back if their answers conflict with what is being trained or applied across the country. When disagreements arise, encourage the group to explore the reasons behind each stance. Push the group to justify their decisions, asking them to consider potential consequences, risk, and the balance between tactical action and safety.

SPEAKER_01If any supporting documents, reference materials, or handouts are provided, distribute them at the appropriate times. Ensure participants review and incorporate this information into their decision-making process. Remind the group that the exercise is designed to stimulate real-world decision making. The objective is not just to get the answer right, but to understand the thought process behind each decision. In the words of Simon Sinek, understand the why. In today's session, you'll be divided into small groups of three to four people per table. We will present you with the several questions pertaining to today's incident.

SPEAKER_01After each question is asked, I want you to pause the video, break into your groups, and discuss the problem. Talk through your solutions, frame how you see the issue, and consider what the dilemmas are that make it a challenge. Use this opportunity to share perspectives and think critically about the factors at play. Each breakout session will be about five to ten minutes. Each small group should determine their answers to the questions asked. Before today's scenario, I will briefly cover a principle or concept related to tactical science, critical decision making, or other considerations that will help you approach a problem.

SPEAKER_01That said, make sure to include these concepts in your solutions and discussions. By the end, you will not only have an understanding of your own decision-making process, but also how to incorporate these concepts into real life incidents. Finally, make sure that each time you return from your breakout sessions, you use a different person to brief back what your table discussed. If you are more tenured at your table, I would encourage you to let those at your table who have less experience talk first. You will see that not everyone sees the problem the same way and may have a different way on how they handle the problem.

SPEAKER_01This happens because people in your class or your group have different levels of training, education, experience, and cognitive biases. That's what's great about these exercises, exposing different points of view and applying different tactics to these situations. Now let's get started. For today's scenario, your department's patrol officers were dispatched to a 911 call where a female caller reports that a man has broken into her home, tied up her relatives, and is holding them a gunpoint. When officers arrive on scene, they are contacted by the reporting party who tells them that she was awakened this morning by a commotion in her living room downstairs.

SPEAKER_01When she went to see what the commotion was all about, she saw her ex-boyfriend holding a gun over her father who was tied up on the ground. She says she immediately ran out of the house and called 911. She also stated that her 17-year-old daughter and her current boyfriend were also still inside the residence, thereby making it three hostages and one suspect. Now, while officers were gathering information from her, an object is suddenly thrown from inside the house toward the exterior of the residence. The object detonates.

SPEAKER_01Officers are unsure whether it was a bomb, an IED, or just a large firework, but it did get their attention and raise their level of concern. Based on this information, your SWAT team is activated. This is where you come in. You respond to the location. Upon arrival, you begin establishing initial tactical priorities with the limited SWAT personnel available. You deploy a React team, you establish a long rifle observation position, and begin containment while additional SWAT personnel are still responding with extended ETAs.

SPEAKER_01A short time later, your long rifle observers advise they can see inside the portions of the residence. They report seeing suspicious devices with wires protruding from them attached to multiple doors leading into the house. These devices appear to be consistent with improvised explosive devices or booby traps. You now have a barricaded suspect, confirmed hostages, and possible explosives rigged to entry points. Here are your first set of questions.

SPEAKER_01Number one, how are you framing this incident right now? Is this primarily a hostage rescue problem? A barricaded suspect with hostages or a bomb threat environment that changes your tactical options? How does your framing affect your strategy? Number two, what are your immediate concerns and priorities of life? Or we would say safety priorities. What risks are you most concerned about right now for the hostages, your officers, and the surrounding community?

SPEAKER_01Number three, what additional information do you need right now and how are you going to get it? And the last question, based on what you currently know, what is your initial plan? At this time, you can pause the video, break out into your groups, and answer these questions. The questions will be displayed on the screen during your breakout session.

SPEAKER_01Let's now move forward to the second dilemma. Your full SWAT team continues arriving and you begin building out a more complete operational picture. Your negotiators establish communication with the suspect. Based on the circumstances involving explosive devices attached to the entry points, your local bomb squad and the FBI are notified and respond to assist. After reviewing photos taken by your sniper observer team, bomb techs advise that the devices attached to the doors appear to be legitimate and consistent with the improvised explosive devices.

SPEAKER_01But negotiations continue. During conversations, the suspect begins using terminology that sounds very familiar to law enforcement. He uses phrases commonly used by crisis negotiators and appears to understand how police operations work. He tells negotiators that he has a dead man switch and claims the house is wired to explode. If anything should happen to him or entry is made by law enforcement. He also tells negotiators they may want to remember that schools are currently in session and suggests that they also may want to check a local Walmart for additional explosive devices.

SPEAKER_01While this conversation is happening, your sniper observer team suddenly sees an upstairs bedroom window open. Two hostages climb out and escape, who are safely rescued by the containment team. These hostages turn out to be the reporting party's daughter and boyfriend. That leaves only two people inside the house, the suspect and the reporting party's father, who is the owner of the house. It does not appear the suspect realizes that two hostages had escaped. He continues talking of his negotiators and even asks why officers haven't gone to his apartment yet and searched it.

SPEAKER_01You now have fewer hostages, possible additional threats outside the scene, such as the Walmart, his apartment, and local schools, and a suspect who appears to know how law enforcement incident works. Here are your next set of questions. Number one, what are your thoughts about the suspect using law enforcement terminology in operational language? For example, why do you think he's mentioning schools being in session and suggesting additional explosive threats at other locations such as the Walmart?

SPEAKER_01Is this a distraction, manipulation, or something you might consider to be credible? Number two, what information do you want to obtain immediately from the two hostages who escaped? And your last question, how does this information now influence your next decision? At this time, you can pause the video, break into your groups, and discuss these questions.

SPEAKER_00The questions will be displayed on the screen during your breakout session. Let's move to the final phase of this incident.

SPEAKER_01Now negotiations suddenly stop. The suspect hangs up and no longer answers calls from your negotiators. A short time later, you are contacted by a local media outlet. They tell you the suspect has called them directly because he wants to tell his story. The media provides you with their phone so you can continue communication with the suspect. During this conversation, the suspect makes several concerning statements. He says things like, We're all gonna die here. The house is wired to blow. He also says he is ready for law enforcement to come and get him.

SPEAKER_01During the call, you can hear the remaining hostage in the background. The hostage appears to be able to speak freely but states that he cannot leave. The call suddenly disconnects. Moments later, an unidentified male is seen at the rear door manipulating one of the suspicious devices previously identified as a possible IED. At the same time, your sniper team advises they have a clear shot and are requesting direction. You now have a possible suicide mindset from the suspect, a potential trigger man, a remaining hostage, suspected explosives, and potential opportunity to intervene.

SPEAKER_01This is where probabilities of success become very real. Here are your final set of questions. Number one, how does a suspect now stating that everyone is going to die, influence your decision making? Number two, if you are now communicating with the suspect through a media phone, what should you be cognizant of? Number three, you have a sniper with a potential shot while a male appears to be manipulating a suspected IED at the back door, but is not 100% certain that it is the suspect.

SPEAKER_01What guidance, if any, are you going to give? The last question, if you were the sniper, are you going to take that shot? At this point, pause the video, break into your groups, and discuss your decisions. Be prepared to explain not just what you would do, but why you believe your decisions gives you the highest probabilities of success.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back.

SPEAKER_01We hope you enjoyed today's decision-making exercise. More importantly, we hope it caused you to think. This scenario was designed to challenge the way you look at risk, safety priorities, and probabilities of success during a critical incident. As you saw, these decisions are rarely simple. In incidents like this, leaders must weigh the risk of action against doing nothing. They must think about the safety of hostages, officers, the public, and everyone involved. They must gather information, frame the problem correctly, and make the best decision they can make based on what they have at that given moment.

SPEAKER_01That is what professional decision making looks like. The goal of this exercise was not to come up with the perfect answer. The goal was to think through the problem, talk through the options, and be able to explain the why behind your decision. That is where learning takes place. Thank you for taking part in today's exercise, and on behalf of the California Association of Tactical Officers and the Debrief, thank you for watching. Stay safe, keep learning, and we'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Understanding Operator Syndrome

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Dr. Chris Frueh joins Jon Becker to unpack "Operator Syndrome" - the term he coined to describe the cluster of medical, psychological, and social injuries common among special operators, military veterans, and first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. HRT of a Toddler With Port and Cover Tactics

    Oct 14, 202656 minAudio

    On July 19, 2024, Orange County, Florida deputies responded to a domestic shooting where a woman escaped with 16 stab and gunshot wounds, leaving behind her three-year-old daughter with the armed suspect still inside....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Current Threats to Tactical Units & Less Lethal Evolution

    Sep 17, 20261 hr 45 minAudio

    Steve Ijames has spent over four decades shaping how American law enforcement approaches force - less lethal and otherwise. From building Springfield PD's tactical team from scratch in 1988 to authoring IACP model...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Protecting Your Brain From Blast Injury

    Apr 29, 20261 hr 33 minAudio

    In this critical episode, Jon Becker examines the hidden epidemic of blast-induced brain injuries affecting tactical operators, breachers, and military personnel. Following groundbreaking New York Times reporting that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Culture First Leadership

    Apr 1, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    In this special episode, Jon Becker turns the tables and becomes the guest on his own show to discuss his new book "Culture First: Nine Leadership Practices That Build Elite Teams." Drawing from four decades of working...

    Credit the people on this episode