Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Crossover

The Crossover artwork

Is It My Turn To Talk? 🗣️ | The Crossover 10.20.26

Oct 21, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your own Card research like the pro's with Card Ladder. Go to http://www.cardladder.com and browse thousands of cards for free and you can unlock more great features by going pro for $15/month (with a 7-day free trial). Follow Card Ladder @CardLadder on instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/cardladder/ Follow Josh @Carboard_Chronicles on instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/cardboard_chronicles/ Follow Chris @Chris_HOJ on instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/chris_hoj/ Follow Kristina @KristinasPC on instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/kristinaspc/ Follow Stiff @StiffArmWax on instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/stiffarmwax/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Welcome one and all back to the crossover. Today is Tuesday, October 20th, and we open this show with mail days. So, Christina, I know that you don't have any to show today. Josh, what about you?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I got one. I picked this up a few weeks ago. This is the 2006 Tops Chrome Superfractor Terrell Owens. And this is the first year that Tops Chrome had superfractors in football. And it's uh pretty unique with like the red border. It's like an interesting card. I like it. Nice.

SPEAKER_02That's awesome. Congrats.

SPEAKER_04All right. And I've got one real quick here. This is the 2014 Don Russ, uh Zach Levine, rated rookie, press proof black one-of-one from the first year that basketball had bass at black one-of-ones. Any base at one of one. And Zach Levine, if you uh never heard of this guy, it's because he's a bum. No, it's uh Zach Zach Levine's main claims to fame are a two-time slam dunk champion and a two-time NBA All-Star and a former member of the Chicago Bulls.

SPEAKER_01He would be my favorite fantasy pick this year. Because he's like the only got the only person I got left on that Kings team.

SPEAKER_04Right, that's true. That's true. Even Ben Simmons won't be making appearances for the Kings this year.

SPEAKER_01No more DeRozan.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's good.

SPEAKER_01No more Westbrook. It's his ball.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. All right. Let's go. Let's jump into the questions. We're gonna cap this at an hour. So uh let us dive right in. So warm-up question here from PAX That Slap. What are your early season NBA takes and picks, please? Give you the floor, Josh, just get this going and we'll we'll volley off of what you serve up.

SPEAKER_01Well, I didn't even know the NBA started tonight, so we're off to a terrible start. Yeah. Uh I'm like really not super excited about this season with like the Thunder and the Spurs, and I'm rooting for the Lakers, I'm rooting for the Sixers, and I'm rooting for the Suns. Uh, we'll see. Are we are we making like MVP picks and all that kind of stuff?

SPEAKER_04You can go as short or as long as you want on it.

SPEAKER_01Finals, Lakers, Sixers, MVP, Luca, done.

SPEAKER_04Nice, nice. Yeah, I I've got a I'm gonna uh zag against the question. Of course. I haven't been really thinking much about this season. Same. I didn't know it was gonna start tonight or this afternoon, but uh that's about it. And I've spent the better part of the 2020s really deeply following basketball, probably one of the more uh in the weeds fans of the sport that there are.

SPEAKER_04And I just have sort of reached a natural place where I want to take a break and not intensely follow it this season nearly as much. So I think this is gonna be a much more casual season of fandom for me from afar. Uh also I just think I was I was wondering, is there any other reason besides maybe just a little bit of uh sports fan fatigue? I think the other reason, Josh, is that the possibility of collecting active players is so inhibited by the prices that it's tough to want to like the stakes are so high if I choose wrong or uh if I even just want to participate, that it's just so expensive, and also that players from other sports or players from other eras of the NBA seem to have really appealing cards at appealing prices right now, and I think that has created a little bit of a disconnect too.

SPEAKER_04What about for you?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I completely agree. It's interesting we both came to that same take on not being as excited about the NBA this year, and we haven't talked about it. Uh, we probably haven't talked about it because we're not super excited about it.

SPEAKER_04Right, right.

SPEAKER_01But I have my one of one save searches. This is a good example. I have my one of one save searches, and it's not specific to basketball or football, and I just keep finding myself buying football because of the value. For example, I can get like a TJ Watt, best player at his position potentially over the last 10 years. He's the equivalent of like a bench player in the NBA price-wise for similar cards. So, to your point, you if you want someone that's like top tier, and there's just less top-tier guys in the NBA because NFL you have different positions and guys can dominate individual spots.

SPEAKER_01So there's more like great players, if you will, more all pros, etc. So for basketball, you're having to really like take a shot, you know, and like the young guys that you're excited about are overly priced, and then the like established guys, you know, they're they're battling over one championship. Whereas in football, you're not as worried about like the championships.

SPEAKER_02I just want to say welcome to the other side of fandom because this is where I was last year, where I was just like, I'm not really into it. Like, I'll watch the case.

SPEAKER_01What's your reason though? What's your reason?

SPEAKER_02My reason is because the NBA screwed over my fandom, they moved Luca to the Lakers, and we did not go, so I was just like, I'm kind of over it.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, still uh NBA is still paying for that one.

SPEAKER_02The Mavs are dead to me, like that's not even a team.

SPEAKER_01Like, there's no like I'm on ESPN's main website, and it's literally a picture of cat flopping. Yeah, like I'm I'm really trying not to complain about the complaining and the foul baiting and all this stuff, but it's like yeah, it feels like it sort of sucks the air out of the game how much attention it gets. Because uh, let me also say this I was watching the whole game and I was way more excited and like uh enthusiastic about specific plays than I am the NFL because it's more fast paced, and like there's like a steal and a three and then a dunk, whereas NFL, you kind of have to like wait for all these things to happen.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so they're just like really fumbling that ball, you know what I mean? Yeah, yeah, I agree. I agree.

SPEAKER_02I think part of the problem too is like you can't be like a team fan in the NBA right now, like it feels like everyone's moving around so much that it's just like oh I'm a I'm a so-and-so fan. It's like a a blin-the-blank team fan, and it's like your roster is just completely decimated every year. I don't know. I just I'm over it. Like they keep rewarding people who do like horrible basketball, and the people who put up the stats aren't getting the MVPs, and even though they deserve it for the last six years, and so I go to games that seem like they're gonna be fun, otherwise, I don't really pay attention.

SPEAKER_04Nice, all right. Uh I I did uh my one NBA take from watching a bit of the games today is that I think the 76ers are gonna be really, really good if they can stay healthy, but I don't know if they're gonna be able to do that.

SPEAKER_01You know who's really good? Simons.

SPEAKER_04Dude, he's like their ninth man.

SPEAKER_01Dude, I we were watching, uh, my daughter was watching, and she's like, Who's number five? Let him shoot. I was like, exactly.

SPEAKER_04That's that was one of the things that stood out to me about the 76ers was like, oh man, there's like guys coming off the bench and like here comes KCP and here comes Anthony Simons, and but they're low-key, like not deep.

SPEAKER_01They only played eight guys, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, that's gonna be a huge problem because you can't count on Embiid to be healthy for full season, especially once the playoffs hit. I don't even know if you want LeBron to have to play more than 55 to 60 games.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's uh that 10-point streak is going down soon, by the way. He's like hanging on for deer life.

SPEAKER_02Also, though, like LeBron has a cool 24 patch on every jersey this season, and they're going to go into cards, so get excited about that.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Because 24 is just such like an iconic number.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. I thought Maxie looked uh really good in this setup. Where like uh Mac Maxie's like uh that second wide receiver who benefits from the attention that the first one commands. Like when the defense has to worry about Embiid over here, LeBron over here, and Jalen Brown over here, and then Maxie can just kind of fly by a one-on-one defender. He's he's gonna look really good.

SPEAKER_01He would be a fun guy to collect. I and I haven't like ever looked into his prices, but I assume they're expensive.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yes, they are. Whenever I would tell people I collect Maxi thinking Kleba, they'd be like, wow, you cle like that must be expensive. And that was like years ago, so I can only imagine like what he is now.

SPEAKER_04All right. So I've uh brought together the following two questions. So I'm gonna read the first one, explain how it sets up the second one, then read the very long second one. So just be patient as we plow through this. So the first question is from Zips Cards, who says, please talk about examples of social learning theory that you see in cards. And social learning theory is this idea that we learn how to behave by watching others in a nutshell that behavior is inherited through observation.

SPEAKER_04And so that question is a nice setup to the question that comes after from Andy from Bye bye Baby Cards. He asks Are PMGs, Star Rubies, Essential Credentials, Prism Golds, National Treasures RPAs, and the like essentially the gateway drugs of high-end collecting? Are we confusing the most celebrated cards with the most historically significant cards? Have collectors become so conditioned to chase what the hobby has anointed as important that we've stopped asking why. Is the hobby intellectually lazy, substituting consensus for curiosity, popularity for significance, and price for historical importance?

SPEAKER_04Are we collecting what we love or simply what we've been taught to admire? All right, so that's his riff or his rant or his uh his rebellion. And then he asks us a practical direct question. He says, What are your ranked top five gateway drug cards of the hobby? Feel free to separate them by era if you'd like, such as 90s versus ultra modern. The starter pack of high-end collecting, the recognizable names, the established mythology, the cards collectors are conditioned to chase because the hobby has collectively anointed them as important, not necessarily the rarest, not necessarily the most innovative, not necessarily historically significant, but the ones whose prestige is simply accepted without question.

SPEAKER_04So that's how I'm tying together the two the two questions. It's like Andy is sort of calling out that, like, hey, it looks like there's a lot of imitation going on that sort of these cards got consecrated, and then uh others sort of just sort of imitated and followed the path without a ton of uh critical thought. And then he says, Okay, so since we do have these cards that have been anointed in the high end in particular, what are they? And so maybe we could collaboratively develop this list.

SPEAKER_01He's gotten a soft a good start.

SPEAKER_04Dude, his list is like I okay. So he says PMGs, yep. He says Prism Golds, yep. He says NTRPAs, yep. There's two that I would add to complete my five. One would be PSA 10s as a general category, and one would be logomans slash shields. And then here comes G in the comments with kabooms as the code. That's a that's a really good that might be the best one, actually.

SPEAKER_02I was gonna say kaboom in downtown, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Oh, we could just say uh uh SSP cake at this point. Yeah, because now it's transition. That that's sort of like jumping over to tops right now. We're seeing that with some of these interesting tops inserts like the uh kaiju or whatever.

SPEAKER_04Very true, very true. Christina, what other ones are we forgetting?

SPEAKER_02Um I mean there's like the helix.

SPEAKER_04Oh, true, true, true.

SPEAKER_02I don't know, like does two parallels count? Yeah, because you said hobby, uh prism gold. Um I think that uh like if we want to go back a little farther, we could do like silver base cards. Like people were all about that. Like remember, like, oh, there's 18,000 PSA 10 silvers, but there are base, but there are 20,000 people who go see him every week at like to play his game.

SPEAKER_02If all of those people bought yeah, bullshit.

SPEAKER_04Josh, are there any others we should throw on? Oh uh G throws in superfractors, stiff arm wax throws in the ultraviolet all-stars.

SPEAKER_01I was just gonna say high grade so that it can encompass like the vintage PSA 9-8 stuff. Someone tells you a player, uh, an older player, it's like, oh, just get their tops base PSA 8, or get the buy the most expensive one you can afford, the grade.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yep.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Yeah, Maxi's expensive.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yes, he definitely is.

SPEAKER_02He's really nice though. We saw him in uh Denver after a game that they lost, and he was the only Sixer who stayed and like signed for the kids that were in Sixer jerseys. So I I just like remember that.

SPEAKER_01Like yeah, his 2020 Mosaic Nebula Choice one of one. That's a rookie. That's a rookie. I think those are sick, sold for 7800. It's not insane. No, but for a football player, that's probably like two, you know, 1500 or so.

SPEAKER_04Right. Yeah, could be worse. Definitely seem worse. The other thing I want to say to Andy on this question is that I think social learning theory is a very useful tool here. That these two questions just happen to be asked, but that they complement each other because I think social learning theory could be a way to explain why all this happens, that people imitate the behaviors that they see, especially if they're new. And that uh some of the social learning theory can be just literally copying without thinking, and other uh imitation can inherit the thought process too.

SPEAKER_04Like, uh, well, you know, okay, so prism golds are very popular, uh, but uh, but but maybe they don't just imitate that the prism gold is collected, they imitate why it's collected because it's rare, because it invokes the color of gold, because it comes from a very well-known and established brand. So there's different levels, there's different and and the people who like get the most out of the imitation are the ones who extract the thought process without needing to mimic the behavior, but instead they can then investigate the thinking and see if there are any mistakes being made.

SPEAKER_04And I can assure you there are, and then they can course correct for themselves. But then the question becomes to somebody like Andy okay, well, if you've found a better way, now what? And I think you have to now use the mechanism of social learning theory for yourself. You have to now go out and show people so that they can have the opportunity to imitate, mimic, and observe what you're doing and give them the opportunity to do it, which I know he does. He puts a lot of effort into his card posts. What do you think about that, Josh?

SPEAKER_01I agree. Uh, the other thing I've noticed is those types of cards are the ones that are in the auctions as well. So a lot of it is like it's not like people aren't trying to find the cards that are quote unquote undervalued or whatever. A lot of it is like they just don't have access to them or they don't know any other way to search for them other than looking at the Fnatic's premiere, sorting by price, and then you see logo mans, you see PSA 10s, you see RPAs, you see superfractors, you see uh rubies.

SPEAKER_01These are the cards I'm literally listing out. PSA 10 Jeter rookies. So everything we've named basically. Kaboom Gold Curry. And so they see these and they just sort of assume okay, these are like the best cards or whatever, these have these are the safest for me to invest, and so I'll just kind of follow this uh this path.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. The hobbies research right now is mostly based on sword by price, yeah. So it's good, it's very good. All right, uh, let's get to the next question here from Frankie3500, who says, Is the hobby still about the cards or is it about the experience? Are people more focused on jumping from one experience to the next instead of the actual cards themselves? Can the focus be brought back to cards?

SPEAKER_04Josh, what do you think he means by experience here?

SPEAKER_01I think he means like jumping from one fad to the next of like, oh, I need to be in on Disney, I need to be in on F1. Like F1. Nobody talks about F1 anymore. What happened to F1? Is that do people not collect that anymore? Wrestling for a little bit, and it's like we just hear the noise from whatever's the current fad, and I guess right now it's like entertainment, Pokemon, Disney, or whatever. I think he I think maybe he's talking about that. I usually think of experience as like us at the national hanging out, but I think he's maybe taking it that direction.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think there's a breaking component to this too, that like the hobby is now like watching a stream or uh rolling the dice figuratively on what you're gonna get out of the next pack. And I do think it's hard to reverse course to go from like a highly stimulated environment to back to a more cautious, deliberate one. Like I think I think it's tough to reverse that. It can be done, but Christina.

SPEAKER_02Um, I wouldn't have uh associated it with fads until Josh said that. I was thinking he meant experience like going places as well. And I was like, what the hell? Like Frankie hung out at our booth like all fucking national, and now he's like, oh, experience is he was he was dissing your booth experience. That's what I thought. I was like, come on, what what are we doing here? Um but yeah, uh with when it comes to fads, like yeah, I'm just I don't I don't pay attention.

SPEAKER_02Like I I see what people are doing, but I just ignore them and keep collecting what I want to collect. Like, I think, yeah, I don't want to.

SPEAKER_04Frankie chimes in with uh to clarify, he says fads, gimmicks, and similar stuff. So I think Josh hit the bell on the head there. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Total guess. Let's go.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's good.

SPEAKER_01We uh try very hard to keep the focus on the cards, you know, like because we're we are really into it ourselves outside of the show. But then the show topics kind of lend towards what's what's going on this week, you know, what's uh what's like the drama or whatever, what's overhyped, and we we get sucked into those conversations, but like privately and to ourselves, we're always just like, as you see this card. I would love to see more content just on the cards. Uh that's always what we complain about.

SPEAKER_02Wouldn't that be nice?

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02Like actual collectors, too.

SPEAKER_04Like, yeah, so General General says so, has the next question, and I'm gonna give my answer to it first, and I'm gonna kick it to you, Christina, so you can start getting ready, and then Josh will have the most time to prepare his. The question is this how would you grade Tops' performance since they acquired the licenses? And I'm gonna say it's a little soon because uh if you look at like when Panini acquired the NBA license, that was headed into the 0910 season, uh, they didn't start introducing products like Prism or Panini Select until the fourth season, and they didn't really hit their stride, I would say, in terms of like a really compelling coherent offering of product lines until the late 2010s.

SPEAKER_022015, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's fair too. So I just think it's like it's a little bit early to be handing out uh grades. Now I'm taking a very product-oriented, card-focused perspective on that. So I'm not really talking about like like one thing you can say is that like the industry's volume, as far as how card letter tracks it, it has never been higher than under this fanatics regime, and they haven't been the beneficiary of everybody being locked at home while generating it.

SPEAKER_04So, in that regard, but that's not tops, that's fanatics. But uh, I think uh if that's part of the discussion, then they have been instrumental in marketing and growing. You know, I was thinking about uh marketing and Social learning theory because that question from zips and like marketing really seems to be trying to activate social learning theory. It's just sort of showing you like, look, this is what people are doing. Now you should do it to mimic this. You know, like and the whole angle is just like to convince people to mimic something. Uh, or at least in some of the cases, it is.

SPEAKER_04And so that was just an aside that I wanted to bring up on that person, but I didn't get a chance to. But anyway, that's kind of I'm I'm like, I'm just withholding the grade right now. I think uh mostly they've like in terms of products, I really I just haven't collected very many. I've got like a one or two cards from Bowman. I've got one or one card, I think, from or maybe two from Topps flagship. Uh I've got I guess I've got one Topps Chrome card too, but just I've kept it very simple. I haven't filed the products. I don't really I haven't reviewed them. So, you know, I've I've kept it very light.

SPEAKER_04So I just I'm not really in a position to judge it. Go ahead, Christina. What what what's the perspective you want to bring to this?

SPEAKER_02Well, I was just gonna say, like, there are people at Topps, I think, that are super focused on the collector, including um that pop podcast, Collect, I collect, you collect. What is it? You just did it.

SPEAKER_04Christopher. Yes, from Packy, from Jeff.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like, so like there are people who are like super focused on the cards, like we're talking about, and that we like want to hear the stories of the collectors who are putting together amazing collections, even if they're not something that I collect, like even if it's a baseball collector, it's something where I'm just like, oh, like that is an awesome PC that this person curated and put together um and has been doing quietly for so long. Um, and they're focusing on that. And I think that's really awesome. So, shout out to Jeff and his team um for focusing on the collector for things like that.

SPEAKER_02I'm like really happy. And then we have um like for the cards themselves, I think Topps is trying to be innovative. Um, I think you know, marketing sometimes gets gimmicky, but that's a marketing issue, not really a like it's not just a hobby or industry issue. It's all like across the board. Um but yeah, I agree with you. It's a little too soon to like fully grade, but I would say that what I see is promising.

SPEAKER_02Um, and some of the people that like I know who are working at Fanatics uh and tops uh are are trying to do right by the collector. So there's hope.

SPEAKER_04All right. How about you, Josh?

SPEAKER_01Uh I'm also optimistic about the product side. I think the I also haven't been collecting them or purchasing them mostly just because it's just way too hot out of the gate and there's too much, there's way too much focus on it from the breakers, and every everyone's focused on the new products, breaking them and uh opening them and getting excited about them, the prices are just way too high. Like the super fractors are like 10x the prices of panini one-on-one right now, for example. So I'm just kind of like going around that, and that that's doesn't speak to tops at all.

SPEAKER_01If the prices were more equivalent to the Panini stuff, then I would probably be doing more research into it. And what I have seen, I do enjoy the products. I don't think there's anything my my complaints are more like they're not really like tops' fault per se, because my complaints are like the gambling side of it again, which I always bring up. Sorry for everyone who hears me complain about gambling all the time, and then like making everything a superfractor, but a lot of that is just like that's where the demand is. People just like want they want the the low fees and they want the ability to flip and vaulting and making money, and they want more superfractor hits on their brakes.

SPEAKER_01So, like this is what the market is demanding out of them, and they're just producing.

SPEAKER_04So fair enough. Uh, but yeah, I'm I'm interested in the question too. Like uh why are we grading tops? This is or maybe it's maybe it's not as early as I think it is. I don't know. I'm I I would love to know uh why why the question, but it but a very interesting one. All right. So next up we have a question here from Drake's PC. Drake says, as a Yes?

SPEAKER_02Sorry, no, go ahead. I was just thinking about uh last time when kind of Yeah, he's still working on that one. Yeah, I know he is, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Drake says Okay, would would you like to read the question?

SPEAKER_02Or would you like me to read the question?

SPEAKER_04I don't know. I don't know whose turn it is to talk right now. Okay, from Drake's PC, it says this. As a kid, I bought cards and packs of cards because they looked cool and because I was a fan of the team or player. It was neat to see the up arrow next to a card you owned in Beckett's, but I don't recall that ever influencing my decision to buy, sell, or trade cards. As an adult, I'm not naive to the fact that cards have value and in some cases significant value.

SPEAKER_04But I feel that as a collective hobby, we've gotten too focused on value and too focused on needing to only buy a card if we feel like we can quickly sell it for more. My question is simple. Does anyone collect anymore? Or are cards simply another tool to make money?

SPEAKER_01Josh, let's if someone doesn't write, is it my turn to talk in quotes and put in a comment right now? I leave this stream. Uh Becky. Well, I mean, he's talking about a time when the prices were literally like one percent of what they are today. It's just a completely different world, you know. It's it's to the point now where like the prices are so expensive, you have to think about this stuff. Even if you don't, even if you and I do not want to and we want to 100% purely focus on collecting, we don't have a choice because it's now like a percentage of our net worth.

SPEAKER_01We have to have some thought towards this. We can't just literally close our eyes and buy everything. And I know it's probably relative, like people had less income back then or whatever, so the the ratios uh closer, but I mean it's still like fractions of a price of the price.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. So uh the sheer value of the cards makes it unavoidable to think about value. Christina, what do you have to say to this?

SPEAKER_02I think that Drake is too interested in the social theory, like, and should just focus on cool cards that he wants to collect, then. Like, what are we doing?

SPEAKER_04Drake needs to stop worrying about everybody else.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, like what like when I was a kid, it was awesome to buy cards that I thought were cool, and now I'm being peer pressured into buying cards that are expensive. Like, no, you're fucking not, you're an adult, like responsibility.

SPEAKER_04But maybe he's just trying to help others see the light.

SPEAKER_02Okay, then like they should also see the light. You're an adult, choose to like buy what you want to, what makes you happy. Fucking Marie Kondo your collection.

SPEAKER_03What is that?

SPEAKER_02Does it does it bring you joy? Does it spark joy? If not, get rid of it.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, I saw a tweet from a guy named uh I think I think uh I had I haven't engaged with a ton of his content, but but this tweet came across my radar was Ryan Seaver. I think he's called Cardboard Prophet or something like that. And he the tweet was very simply paraphrasing here. Uh people buy cards or people uh value cards highly when they expect that the the value can go up further.

SPEAKER_04So the idea that like people buy cards because there's an expectation that it could be worth even more in the future, and I think that is also kind of what Drake is targeting here. But I think that value can mean a lot of different things. I think uh even monetary value can represent different things for some people. A monetary like uh expecting that a card's price is going to go up is like this bet that the player's gonna have a breakout game or something, they can exit for 20% or a 50% gain quickly, and that's a very short-term mindset, which I think Drake uh made mention of.

SPEAKER_04He was sort of explicitly concerned about this quick turnover, buy something, it goes up a little bit, sell it, keep going, keep going, keep going. But uh, but there's a whole other uh theory of monetary value that might actually truly be tied to the collecting principles that Drake likes. That uh that there's a happy coincidence that the things that made him like cards independent of value, like a cool-looking card of a player that he likes from a set that he thinks is well made, that actually might also be the formula for a card to have an upside proposition from a monetary value point of view.

SPEAKER_04So there's also that other side to this question, which is that uh it also, if if if if the market is operating on collector principles, it also might just so happen that when a person operating from collecting principles looks at a card and says, I expect that its value can increase. What they're saying is not, well, I think this is a hot potato that I can move quickly. What they're saying is that I think there's a lot of solid material supporting this card that makes it really attractive to me. And if I don't get it right now, other people might latch on to this too, and then it might be more difficult for me to get it later.

SPEAKER_04So I like it now. I fear or I suspect that there's the possibility of a price increase, and therefore I'm getting it now. So it's a totally different way of how price and value propositions can be interpreted. Uh, but in this case, they're aligning with collecting principles rather than being directly opposed to them. So I wanted to uh serve that one up to Drake. And you know, I'll give I'll give Drake himself as an example. Drake wrote some very moving uh messages to the crossover over the many years explaining why he thought Peyton Manning might be undervalued.

SPEAKER_04And I don't think he was saying that to have a quick turnaround. I think what he was saying was that he identified something that he really wanted to collect. He thought it was cheap, and he was preaching the good word about it. What do you uh Josh? Let me pass the mic to you and see if there's anything for you to knock around with from what I just said.

SPEAKER_01No, I think you did a good job covering a lot of good topics. Nice, nicely done. You saved it.

SPEAKER_04There you go, Drake. All right. Um, okay, and now two questions together on the topic of the heist, the FedEx truck heist. The first one comes from WTF Frankie Podcast who points out that sports cards are becoming so mainstream a FedEx truck is robbed making national news. Josh, you said something similar. You said something similar to me about how holy crap. This is this is like on ESPN.com, right?

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. No, my I have people that don't don't do anything cards texting me about it. And they're like, Do you know about this? I mean, of course I know about this. How do you know about this? It was on ESPN's headlines or whatever for for a couple hours, and I was like, why do you guys even care? What does this have to do with sports?

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Uh well, yeah, it reminds me of the Mona Lisa story. Like, one of the reasons why the Mona Lisa became one of the most famous paintings of all time is because it was the subject of a heist. It was stolen and uh taken for two years, and that it that uh did a it was a force multiplier on its popularity. Christina, what do you think about the mainstream education and how sort of uh oh what is what's the uh scandalous topics?

SPEAKER_04Topics uh involving criminal activity, theft, um indirectly bringing to the fore the the uh the the the high valuations of these cards, making them the the target of the theft, and uh and that becoming headline news.

SPEAKER_02Um I think it's interesting. I didn't realize it was national news. Um I I'm not on ES Pen, so I didn't know. And you guys obviously uh were chatting about it like privately, but that's fine.

SPEAKER_04Christina, can you please read Cage's comment?

SPEAKER_02Cage says, I heard the FedEx truck, there was a freshly graded neon maxi kleba out of five, gone forever now.

SPEAKER_04Well dang, you were so close. It was it was coming to it was coming an eBay auction near you, but now and now it's gone. Now it's changed it, now it has to be fenced.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I mean, like, there's a reason Ocean 11 was so popular. Like everyone loves a good heist, like, right, so the news is obviously gonna latch on to something that is like sports adjacent, uh like monetary value, uh, and a theft, like in especially in today's world where we only report on bad things, it just is like the trifecta of like sensational news to talk about and get people riled up.

SPEAKER_02It's salacious, yes, is it though?

SPEAKER_04And and it's uh it all it also has the effect, although I don't think this is the uh not that I can read the mind of the criminals here, but I don't think this is their main goal, but it has the effect of signaling to anybody who encounters the story that wow, these are things that people are risking serious prison sentences for. These are things that uh have uh a value and have the ability, theoretically, to be you know uh fenced, uh recycled, reinserted, uh for sale, cleaned, or whatever the process would be to circulate them back again and capitalize on the theft.

SPEAKER_04I think it has that indirect Mona Lisa effect of like signaling to people like, well, why wait, somebody stole baseball cards? Why would you do that? Like, what is and so it it becomes an object of fascination uh in a different light, not because that's what the thieves intended, but that's what the headlines generate. And I think one of the consequences of that is it can lead to more people believing that more theft is possible, that uh it can it can embolden criminals who may be sitting on the sidelines, and it should definitely embolden the vigilance of all of us who are here to be extra careful, take extra precautions, and quite frankly, urge the development of better shipping transportation methods for cards.

SPEAKER_04Josh, what do you think about that as a takeaway from this situation? That I mean, has that thought running through your head? Like, well, what am I how am I supposed to get my cards to and from my vaults, to and from grading, to and from buying and selling and trading? Have you thought about that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, this story more so makes me nervous about just the shipping companies in general. Uh I'll get to PSA in a second, but I'm this makes me more nervous about UPS, FedEx, USPS because it seems like they aren't able to catch up to what's happening here security-wise, uh as quickly as the other pieces of this industry have done. Like FedEx is just seeing this as like I, you know, move box from point A to point B. Whereas now it's like, okay, you're actually moving like very expensive items, and not only are they expensive, but they're often one of one pieces.

SPEAKER_01They're collector's items for people, they're not replaceable. So the monetary value isn't even a part of the equation here for a lot of people. It's very frustrating. And FedEx, like having terrible protocol with like leaving the truck or whatever. This is these are terrible, terrible pieces of information to find out about these FedEx drivers. Because we just sort of like give them the box, assume that it's going into a secure location, it's going into a locked truck, it's getting to the final destination. And there's a lot of discussion around like, oh, you shouldn't put like uh you know PSA on the box.

SPEAKER_01So now you have to like go out of your way to drop it off in person, and now PSA is gonna have to figure out a way to hide where they're going or you know, prevent PSA wording on the boxes and things like this. It's very frustrating. Um, but the two takeaways for me are I'm surprised no one's tried to play like the Robin Hood role of like, oh, this is like, you know, people are stealing because PSA is like robbing everybody, and this is like capitalism, and we need to like distribute these cards out to everybody.

SPEAKER_01I've I'm surprised I haven't heard that take yet. Because there has been a lot of people like quickly jumping to blame PSA, but PSA has like five steps that they follow. This is like protocol for them. They have insurance, they have these tiers where you submit the card at a specific tier, you pay for that, and it's insured. And this is what happens when something bad happens, you now get the insurance of what you claimed. So they're gonna go through the steps. PSA is doing what they need to do. Like I said, I'm more worried about the uh shipping FedEx side of things.

SPEAKER_04Isn't it a little bit surprising that it's taken this long for shipping insecurity to bubble up to where it is? Well, I had my first like major package theft about two months ago, or I guess three months ago now. Like uh right there in the middle of July. Uh actually, as we were driving out to Fanatics Fest in New York, I was up late on eBay.

SPEAKER_04Two Ladanian Tomlinson Superfractors from Topps Chrome popped up on eBay, and I binned both of them, and then they got shipped to me, except they never made it to me. They made it to a Jacksonville, Florida distribution center, and then they still haven't had a tracking update in over three months. Now I went through all the hoops of uh uh receiving a refund from eBay, which I did, and I'm in contact with the seller and I'm helping him.

SPEAKER_04Uh, you know, the insurance adjuster wanted to talk to me to help get more information about it. I gave another 30 minutes to do that. Happy to do more just to help make this right because the seller didn't do anything wrong here either, at least not to my knowledge, he didn't. So I'm just trying to help facilitate rectifying the situation. But these are super factor one of ones, like you said, Josh, these are cards that can't be replaced. So I got my monetary value back, and I'm I'm grateful that that mechanism was in place, but I really would like the cards even more. And now the seller is having to go through the insurance process and provide receipts of when he purchased them and like there, he's had them for over 20 years, and it's just it's a big mess.

SPEAKER_04And that's really quite annoying uh for these for this package that uh got uh got a scan at a Jacksonville USPS center and then nothing else after. So I've I've dealt with this uh about three months ago. The first time, first time I've dealt with I've I've probably had thousands of packages to and from me in the mail. This is the first time that it hit me.

SPEAKER_02Just this week, thousands of packages.

SPEAKER_04Well, right. So like I'm I'm kind of surprised a little bit because like I I always sort of was a little bit blown away that like four-figure, five-figure, six-figure items are just going to and from in these mail trucks, and like we're just kind of hoping that nobody knows what's inside these packages, is basically what it boils down to.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, yeah, these shipping companies are pathetic, honestly. Like, this is joke, this is their only job. And they're leaving trucks unintended, like what the heck is going on, and then they're like in the USPS. I had one time where they just like, oh, it's it's sitting in the USPS, it's been sitting here. Sorry, we just lost it. It's like, what the crap?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that yeah, so well, and right, and I and we we have to try and figure out is it incompetence or is it a mistake, is it an innocent mistake, or is it an inside job? So the inside job theory is like the driver was in on it or something, yeah, or somebody, or not the driver, but somebody at the post office, or somebody with knowledge of which packages will be coming through.

SPEAKER_01Ugh. So now PSA has to like add in a security guard to watch the truck or something. It's just like it's a good idea. We just keep like having to increase things for the lowest common denominator of our society over and over and over. We have to continue to increase all these security measures to account for all the lowest common denominator people.

SPEAKER_04I've seen a few hobby businesses sprout up, grant they're definitely targeted towards the highest end, but uh concierges who will pick up the card and take it from you to the destination for you. And it's it's expensive. You have to do it. I know, but Brian Wells does that.

SPEAKER_02Shout out, Brian.

SPEAKER_04There's a new hobby company, um Grail Guard, maybe or something like that, that does this too. Uh I you know, it could be it honestly, like if somebody could find a way to scale that, yeah. I think they could they could do very well right now.

SPEAKER_01Lock themselves to the briefcase kind of scenario.

SPEAKER_04Right. Right, right. Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's like the shipping insurance thing isn't even enough anymore because you got the money back for the Tomlinsons, but you already paid that money to get the Tomlinsons. You made the transaction, not you didn't want the money.

SPEAKER_04Right. Right. Yeah. And yeah. But it's like it's this uh the tricky part is that when you do mark the package for insurance, yeah, you almost put a target on it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. I I always think about that, and I hate that I have to do that, but it's like if I'm at the FedEx store, if I'm sorry if I interrupted you, you can I just thought of this.

SPEAKER_02Oh no, it's only fine when you do it.

SPEAKER_01If I'm at the FedEx store and I'm talking to the person at the cashier, how much insurance do you want? And I'm supposed to be like, I want$20,000 of insurance. What do you think they're gonna do? They're gonna be like, What's inside of here? What is this? And they're gonna start asking tons of questions. It's like a lose-lose. Christina, go ahead.

SPEAKER_02I hate that question, by the way. Like when you go to like even the like USPS and you ship something and they're like, Oh, what's in here? It's like none of your fucking business. If I wanted you to know, it would be in clear plastic. Like, obviously, I wrapped it at home.

SPEAKER_01Like it's Mercury, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Like as long as it's not one of your like, agree that it's not any of these dangerous, not actually dangerous things that we just decided to put on a list, like it's none of your fucking business what's in there.

SPEAKER_01It's crazy. I always tell them it's a book. Fuck off.

SPEAKER_02Nice.

SPEAKER_04How how many uh cards of a four-figure valuation or higher? Or no, sorry, how many hobby packages, like so it might maybe have 10 cards in it, that are worth at least a thousand dollars or more are shipped around the United States in a given week? If you had to spill all that, this is such a good question. Well, I love questions like this, just like the MM in a jar.

SPEAKER_02Can you like we get in like of any card?

SPEAKER_04And by the way, Dylan Double D makes a very good point here. If you have collectors insurance, typically policies, uh, those policies provide for shipping to and from you up to a limit as long as you put signature required. Just uh worth noting that too. Yeah, but uh what Christina, you're questioning the question.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so I'm saying like yesterday, no, I'm I I'm asking for clarification. I'm not questioning the question. I'm asking for clarification. Thank you. Yesterday alone, we took in 325,781 unique sales into card ladder. Like, not all of those obviously will be shipped, some are in vaults or I said four figure, four figure.

SPEAKER_04How many packages in a week have uh are being shipped around from one buyer to another of four figure that have a valuation of four figures or more?

SPEAKER_02Oh, I'm sorry. I was trying to actually solve the fucking hypothetical, but please continue with your like little like MM in a jar. Let's just guess a number then.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to like okay, go ahead. Yeah, I'm going to guess a number. Yes, please. Are you guys done? Yes. Are you are you both done? That's my favorite interaction between you two, by the way. Are you is it your turn? Uh I think it's like a ton. I think it's like 25,000 or something crazy, like some huge number. Well, there's cards, just cards, Pokemon, whatever, cards.

SPEAKER_04Then there is a massive business waiting to be built there. A massive one.

SPEAKER_01Uh, did anyone did you did you mention this? But like, how stupid are the thieves here? Like, it's gonna be so hard. I mean, there's some ways to make some money on it, but like it's gonna be really tough, and you're like risking a ton for 900 grand. Oh my gosh.

SPEAKER_04Right.

SPEAKER_01You could get this could be real bad.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_04But you know, as I started thinking to myself, like, well, maybe the businesses would just like like the whole idea would be like, okay, so you can still take your package, like like this business would sync up with like FedEx and UPS and USPS, and like they would just involve. Well, well, exactly. Because I was thinking like maybe those hubs would like just hold the car, like hold the package. Like you would you would say, like, okay, I know I can go to my USPS, you hold the package, and this company goes to all the major hubs and just kind of like just has these loops where they just loop around and pick stuff up. But then I was like, but that actually wouldn't even deal with the heist here because the basically the heist was like those cards got put onto a those packages got put onto a FedEx truck, which is then left unattended.

SPEAKER_04So that that same sort of malfeasance could happen. But but I guess maybe it's a little bit different. But yeah, I'm just trying to think of like how would the business work?

SPEAKER_01Like a PI following around the FedEx truck, and he's like he's like correcting his side mirror and he's like looking at the car behind him as he's parked on the side of the road.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and plus like then I'm now I'm thinking about like we how many card shop break-ins have we seen so many come across our socials, and those are just the ones we hear about.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like at least once a month.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02And it's like every show has one stupid person try to do something as if there's not cameras all over a fucking show.

SPEAKER_04So it's almost like unless you're flying or driving to the place, picking up with your hands, and then leaving, and even then risking uh if somebody is hot on your trail that you could be mugged, it's almost like you just have to build in a tolerance for risk, maybe at this point. I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Isn't that what insurance is like our tolerance for risk?

SPEAKER_04Yes, but it covers the monetary. But you know, going back to Drake's question, if we're buying something that we think is uh is that a good bargain, or you're buying something that's irreplaceable, you know, you're losing more than the monetary value. So all right. There's uh anyway, yeah, we don't we don't have all the answers here, but we can we can certainly highlight a problem that could use an answer. So we've got about 10 minutes left. We've got another question on this that gets into more specifics.

SPEAKER_04I've I've sort of like whipped up an answer to it in my head as I was thinking about it, and then I can I'll pass the mic to you guys if you guys want to take a stab at it too. This one comes from Rex Cards24, who says the FedEx truck full of PSA orders was burglarized. Disclaimer noted, Card Ladder is a sister company of PSA owned by collectors. So he takes care of uh the disclaimer for us. That disclaimer is very important, though. Uh it is it is like something to keep in the front of mind at all times when we talk about things card ladder-related, which is the business we operate. We talk about things PSA related, we talk about things hobby company, hobby industry related, just it's always good to keep in mind that there's a real chance of bias on our behalf.

SPEAKER_04And even if we try to correct for the bias, that could end up still reflecting the bias in unintended ways. But anyway, thank you for noting the uh bias for us, Jonathan. Okay, moving on. Here he goes. As far as PSA compensating those customers whose cards were stolen, since the cards were stolen after they were graded, parentheses, where most damage-related issues occur within the facility and the grading process, close parentheses, and PSA has the opportunity to adjust the grading fee or tier in the case where the fair market value of a graded card exceeds the maximum for the submission tier.

SPEAKER_04Would you agree that the logically consistent and equitable outcome would be for PSA to fully compensate fair market value as opposed to fair market value only up to the maximum insured value at the time of submission? So Jonathan here is advocating, I think, pretty clearly for that position for a compensation above and beyond the marked fair market value. And that's a nuance of the policy that PSA has uh based on the tier of the submission that you submit it at.

SPEAKER_04And I don't fully understand that policy. So I can't forcefully substantively comment on that. My understanding is that if you submit a card for grading, the card grades and ends up in a holder that is at a value that is above the submission tier that you valued it at, then you get that the infamous upcharge email. And a consequence of being upcharged is not only that you have to pay more money to get the card back, but also that you now have purchased a service tier that has a higher level of coverage.

SPEAKER_04That's my understanding. So it basically what's built into that process is that you know, if you you get upcharged, well, you're getting a higher service for the upcharging. And the whole kind of idea there is that this is that this is an insurance that exists for for situations, very unfortunate situations like this. But again, I that's that's I just wanted to kind of throw that out there because I was talking to ChatGPT. I think that's how that works, but uh my comments here are provisional at best.

SPEAKER_04I it would certainly be worth a deep dive for somebody to look into that more carefully and scrutinize it. But here's here's the thing I want, here's the commentary I wanted to do on this quickly. Uh noting the bias, it's it's it's we are probably some of the last people that uh should be weighing in on this. But um I think there's a I think like some of the ways, some of the angles that we can approach this that are valuable and interesting are this. First of all, I think we can give our mindset as operators, we can hypothetically say what would we do if we were in this situation? But uh at the same time, acknowledging that like if we have any genuine good ideas here, we would just try to find a direct channel to share them with PSA.

SPEAKER_04And same would go, I think I would say for anybody out there who has a good idea or solution, like the most charitable thing you could do would be to get that idea to them so they could implement it. Uh so with that being said, I think like one thing we can do is we can sort of share our perspectives, operators. And in situations like this, outlier situations where customers have been harmed, there are procedures in place to cure it, to the but but policies have to be followed, and these policies have been established and are known and agreed to, even if imperfectly, that if there's a very easy win-win, and the very easy win-win is that go above and beyond to make these customers satisfied.

SPEAKER_04It's an out assuming it's an outlier situation, which I hopefully after this scale is, there's a very easy opportunity to really engage, really try to make these customers as happy as possible, understanding the issues that they went through. That can win a great amount of goodwill for the company, and it can do the most it can to make the customers whole again. So that's one side of my sort of operator philosophy. And I mean that's how we operate. Uh, anytime that we can go above and beyond to make a customer happy, we will do that.

SPEAKER_04But the other side is this the real concern and risk is precedent because these policies do exist. There is a tiered system that is employed here for different submission levels that get you different levels of coverage that uh provide for not just the insurance policy in case of theft, but also the guarantee program uh that protects the secondary market participants, not the original submitter. Uh all these things are sort of theoretically functions of the cost of grading at the different service levels.

SPEAKER_04If the precedent gets set that, hey, I can submit my cards at the lowest service level, but if anything terrible actually happens, then I can still expect to be compensated at a higher service level anyway. If that becomes a precedent that gets set, then why would anybody ever submit at the higher appropriate service levels that the company has tiered out? So that's the other balance, that's the other equity that has to be considered here, is the risk of what precedent gets set.

SPEAKER_04So those are two business concerns. I think there's on the one hand, there's a great opportunity for goodwill, there's a great opportunity to make customers whole and really go above and beyond. But there's also the concern of precedent and that it can be very dangerous to the entire business model if the precedent gets set that you know you can you can submit at the lowest level because if things don't work out, you can still access the highest service level anyway. So I wanted to give those thoughts. Sorry that took a really long time. Let me pass the mic to Josh to see if he has anything he wants to say.

SPEAKER_01Nope, you covered it all.

SPEAKER_04Christina.

SPEAKER_02I just want to like push back a little because my understanding, and I don't have any insider knowledge in this, but like my understanding is PSA like doesn't check every card that comes through to see if it was submitted at the correct service level. It just like like randomizes or chooses ones that they think were incorrectly submitted because something in the system flagged it, like uh whatever.

SPEAKER_02Like, I don't know how it works, but my understanding was they were not going through the thousands of cards that they grade, just checking the value up against what someone submits it at. So the question says, like, unless I'm a misunderstanding, the asker, is like, oh, well, they just submitted it, so fair market value should be assumed no matter what you're like because like you you went through it and like verified that it didn't get upcharged, and it's like, well, no, like there's still opportunities for people to slip one through.

SPEAKER_02So I I I just wanted to push back on that front too.

SPEAKER_04Like, yeah, and if uh the criticism ultimately is that the person, the the critic doesn't like the tiered system where like submitting cards add declared values and like uh up charges if the card is worth more, and how that relates to the guarantee and cut the item being covered and uh while in in possession and insurance and everything. That's a totally fair criticism. I just think that it just it's worth noting that's a slightly different topic than this one, which is like actually, what do you do in this specific situation?

SPEAKER_04What do you do if there's you know, like as the question askers pointing out, like sort of there is this sense of this in-between potentiality where somebody submits a card at too low of a service level, it grades high, but PSA doesn't apply a higher service level for whatever reason. That could be so I don't know, there's a lot of there's there's there's a good opportunity to sort these things out, and in the meantime, there's a good opportunity to potentially earn a lot of goodwill, but uh with the very careful approach to not incentivize people and by setting a precedent that says you don't need to submit at the proper service level.

SPEAKER_04Just some those those are just my thoughts, and uh I would just put it I value them if you were valuing those thoughts for the application of an upcharge, value those thoughts for as much as they cost you to receive them, which is nothing unless you're paying for YouTube premium. Yeah, I guess that's true. Well, we are at the hour. How are we how are we doing?

SPEAKER_02I'm doing great. I have this uh apple soda that's delicious. I'm not being paid, it just is delicious.

SPEAKER_04Let me fire through like maybe like a few more really quick questions. This one from Squint's sports cards, I thought was interesting. He said, When you know an athlete's top-selling cards and card ladder are not their best cards, how do you go about pricing their actual best grails? So, what I'm thinking, what this means is that like Squince is going to sales history, he's sorting uh by price to see Lamar Jackson's most valuable cards, and he's actually not seeing the ones that he thinks are Lamar Jackson's best.

SPEAKER_04So, how does he go about pricing them? What would you say to that, Josh?

SPEAKER_01Try to look for ratios for another player, like find the sale that is the highest, find uh another player that has a sale of that one and the card you're after, and try to like distinguish the ratio between those two cards.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's uh that's great. Yeah, try to find the nearest comp possible. Is the closest possible player from the same exact card type, or vice versa, the same player but the most comparable card type that isn't the same. Christine, do you have any advice for trying to price same?

SPEAKER_02Same card, different player, same player, different like our uh same, same card, similar player. Similar card, same player. I think I did that right. I don't know. It's been a while since I've had to give that advice.

SPEAKER_04What if a customer writes into card liner and asks that question? What would you what do you like generally say there?

SPEAKER_01A customer? Yeah. Like I would ask, oh go ahead. Yeah, as like the product side, like the company. I don't really feel like it's appropriate to give like purchasing advice like that.

SPEAKER_02Well, so what I would probably do is I would ask for um like details on who the player was, or give an example of like, oh, well, we can't give the actual price of what that is, but here's what I do. Like, Maxi Kleba is someone I collect. He's a bench roll player. So I look for other bench roll players on other teams that have the same card that has sold to be like, oh, here's a comparable sale that I can use to price my card.

SPEAKER_02Or okay, well, this is the Prism card of Maxi Kleba. It hasn't sold, but the select in the same like numbered variation has. So then you put a ratio on it to be like, okay, select uh prism.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think that's great advice. That's that's uh that's you know, it kind of blows down to like what even is a comp? Like, like let's say you had a direct comp. Why would you use that? How why is the direct comp helping you? And it's because the theory behind a comp is that a comp is hopefully or or ideally, it's evidence that there is somebody else out there who is willing to pay this. And so that should give you confidence in this hypothetical reasoning chain that, well, you can buy it at this price too, because if you end up not wanting it, there's somebody else out there who would want it at that price.

SPEAKER_04Yes, Christina.

SPEAKER_02No, I was just I was responding to uh a collector's dream.

SPEAKER_04Oh, oh, sorry. Okay. Shout out to Orlando. Okay, so the the idea there with comps is that like the the idea the the the mechanics of a comp at its in its best version, in its ideal version, is that it's some sort of evidence that if you ever get tired at the price of the comp, there's somebody else out there who's willing to pay it at that price, so you can cleanly get in and get in and out of it at that price if you want to. Now, obviously, that's a very flawed theory for many reasons. Namely, that uh the biggest one is that you can't necessarily bank on somebody who at one point in time expressed their preference for paying the card at that price would necessarily express that preference again later.

SPEAKER_04Cards change price all the time. But that's kind of the the underlying basis for it. And so if that is true, then even if you don't have a direct comp, are there other ways that you can sort of go out there and find out what other people might be willing to pay for that card so that you can practice this theory of the comp, which is if you get it and then you suddenly decide you don't like it, that there's an opportunity to exit it cleanly without making or losing money. That's kind of like taking, going back to social learning theory, that's sort of imitating the behavior of what we're doing when we make a comp. But instead of imitating looking at comps, it's it's borrowing the structure from it and applying it in a different way.

SPEAKER_04So that's another thing you could do, but that's a very sophisticated move. But like if you could informally survey and poll a bunch of collectors or market participants who are in sort of a similar market as what you're in, and sort of if you could really find out what they are would be willing to pay for something like that, then you can sort of synthesize a comp without a comp existing. But you're you would have to be quite confident that your research and your surveying is substantive and it's and it's not all puffery and to and talk and and no substance. All right.

SPEAKER_04We good guys, we want to call it here.

SPEAKER_01Imagine asking Steve Jobs if he was sick of seeing all the iPhones everywhere.

SPEAKER_04Do you want to do that one real quick? Perimeter Collectibles would like to know. Do you guys also feel the use? I saw the also.

SPEAKER_01I jeopardied this one.

SPEAKER_04Do you guys also feel the use of card lighter value as a negotiation point has gotten out of control? Go ahead, Josh. I think you already gave your take on this, but go ahead.

SPEAKER_01I gave my take already. Of course not. We invented it.

SPEAKER_04Okay, Chris.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh, I don't I I think that it's uh the only estimation in the entire industry that is uh published, how we come up with it, uh and we're trying to. Transparent about the formula and the decisions of why we did certain things. And when I say we, I mean Chris and Josh. I had no part of it. Um, and I just explained it to people. I don't actually, I didn't build it. Um, and then like uh we're also the only people who vet sales and make sure that there is a system in place so that you have the best data in front of you and not dirty data because no data is better than bad data because bad data is malicious.

SPEAKER_04Right. Well said by both of you, and I think those are two like on the on points, on the nose answers that directly address it. Now I want to address the question beneath the question, and and that is should any data point be outcome determinative in the bartering or negotiation in a transaction of a card? And that's a question that is now depersonalized from any card ladder relationship, and it's just asking a bigger question that could apply to a value estimate, it could apply to a comp, it could to a it could apply to an average of comps.

SPEAKER_04And there's always people sort of making the observation that like people are too dependent on comps. Or now, more recently than ever, I've heard people saying people are too dependent on card ladder value. It's it's being over-relied on. And generally speaking, I think that there's substance to that. Not because it's card ladder value, not because it's a comp, not because it's this marketplace, not because it's that marketplace, but because it represents people turning off their brains and represents people not exercising critical thought.

SPEAKER_04Card letter value is just a math equation. And like Christina said, it is completely spelled out so that anybody could replicate it if they wanted to. And so that requires a little bit of understanding. Take an hour or two to go through the FAQ, pull up your artificial intelligence of choice, paste the FAQ or give it the link, ask it questions until your heart is content so that you understand the mechanics of how it works. But once you do understand the mechanics, which is just the last price times the change in the applicable index, then now you can more intelligently negotiate against somebody who's using it in a way that you might find is inappropriate.

SPEAKER_04But the flip side of that is it's not just necessarily inappropriate because it's a math equation. It might actually not be bad. What if the card letter value is based on the average of, you know, it's coming from it's being generated by one of the profiles that the card had eight sales yesterday, the card letter value is the average of those eight sales from yesterday in that profile multiplied by the change in the index over the last day. Like there's not a ton to argue with there. Like maybe you think like one comp should be thrown out, another comp should and then that's great. Then you get into the weeds and you and you exercise your critical thought and you push back and you turn the negotiation into something of substance.

SPEAKER_04So I the spirit here, the underlying idea here that whether it's a comp that's being overly relied on, or the average of comps is being overly relied on, or value estimates being overly relied on. Uh, in any of those cases, I'm I'm always gonna be in favor of somebody pushing for independent thought and say, no, hold on, let's actually look at those comps. Let's let's look at the IPL of the cards that were being used, or let's look at the conditions under which it's sold. Did that sell at four in the morning? Or let's look at what might have changed in the market since that sale happened, because maybe there's information that isn't included in that.

SPEAKER_04Or why let's question the integrity of comps in general? Like, do we do we even want to strictly base our valuation off of that? So, anyway, I'm in I'm in favor of critical thoughts, but uh anyway.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the issue here is that like people don't want to spend any time understanding what it is or how it's derived. For example, we'll get question I get questions a lot of like a card will sell for, especially in Pokemon, it's happening all the time. A card sells for a thousand, a thousand, fifteen hundred, twelve hundred, uh like a week ago. And then today it will sell for like twelve thousand. And people are like, why is your sale value not twelve thousand? I thought it was just the most recent sale. I will paste the FAQ article that explains why the twelve thousand dollar sale is not applicable given the volume of sales at the thousand dollar price leading up to this week.

SPEAKER_01They every time reply to me and say, I'm not reading all that. You explain it to me right now. So you want me to re-explain the article that I've already written to explain it to you of why it didn't work. You don't want to understand it, you don't care, you just want the higher number. So there's a lot of like, I just need the CL value to be the number that I want it to be. People message us, can you just manually change this number? Well, you clearly don't know anything about it because we don't manually set these numbers. They're derived from math. It's automated, it's all a system.

SPEAKER_04Well said. The ugly truth of it is that I'm and I'm not attributing this to perimeter collectibles because I like I know that he's a very sophisticated savvy operator. But in many instances, the main thing that's happening here is people love the card letter value if it's helping them and they hate it if it's hurting them. And it doesn't matter if it's accurate or if its methodology is useful or helpful. All those things are not there. This isn't a good faith action. This is just literally somebody trying to increase their ability to gain and profit from a transaction, and they understand that the card lighter value is a metric, has some level of influence and purchase in in some situations, and so they want to they're they're they love it if it's helping them and they will hate it if it's hurting them.

SPEAKER_01I already have my title picked out.

SPEAKER_04Oh, okay. Nice. All right, Christina. Did you want to add anything to that topic before we get to title selection?

SPEAKER_02No.

SPEAKER_04All right.

SPEAKER_02Okay, I said my piece.

SPEAKER_01Now you get to guess what I would title based on that.

SPEAKER_04Nice. All right. So, Christina, will you please read the 10? And we'll uh figure out which one Josh is voting for.

SPEAKER_02Okay. First up, we have if you never heard of this guy, it's because he's a bum. Sports fan fatigue. Nick's won the cup, then the finals last year. Wait, who put that? That's not that's just that's just Nick. Like that's not the title. Oh, okay. Don't forget the hashtag. Then the finals last year.

SPEAKER_02Hashtag never forget, heart's thumb up front, up frontson's bum. I couldn't even read it. Uh is it my turn to talk? I don't know, is it Mona Lisa effect? Their only job, accounting for the lowest common denominator. How stupid are the thieves? The question beneath the question, or I'm in favor of critical thought.

SPEAKER_01That's your guess.

SPEAKER_02I think that is if it's actually been written, or you were like, someone should have written this and it wasn't captured. I think that this was what you were gonna say.

SPEAKER_04Nope.

SPEAKER_02No, how stupid are the things?

SPEAKER_04I I hope it's is it my turn to talk?

SPEAKER_01Nope. It was I was reminded of this title during the last conversation where people do not care about understanding the seal value, they just want it to be for them.

SPEAKER_04I don't know, what is it?

SPEAKER_01Accounting for the lowest common denominator. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yep. We have to build all these tools to account for every single person.

SPEAKER_04And there, and I'll I'll take that to the next level. There is no accounting for it. Because it's it's not it's never it's not in good faith in the first place.

SPEAKER_02It's always gonna get lower.

SPEAKER_01Approaching infinity. You'll never actually get there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um if we're looking for clicks, we should just feed into it.

SPEAKER_04Uh I'm not looking for clicks. Uh I how can we not do is it my turn to talk? I feel like that was like the pivot point of this whole episode.

SPEAKER_02I like their only job.

SPEAKER_04All right. Two votes for is it my turn to talk?

SPEAKER_01I get to decide. Yeah, I already voted on that one. Unless you're taking it back. No. Well, I could make a three-way time just to really Is it my turn to talk? That was so good.

SPEAKER_04Then we'll let Mohammed pick.

SPEAKER_01No, isn't my turn? And then do like the talking emoji.

SPEAKER_04Alright. Thanks for uh running overtime here, guys. It's been uh second episode of the crossover for October. You never know when the next one's coming, folks. Nice apple soda, Christina.

SPEAKER_02So delicious. I'm upset.

SPEAKER_00We have virtually every card in our system. If the card you are looking for ever sold on one of these platforms, you can find it using Card Ladder's sales history. Easily find recent comps and get a better estimate what your cards are worth. See why Card Ladder is the most trusted and the most reliable sports card analytics app on the market. We know what you want because Card Ladder was created by collectors for collectors. Join the innovators, not the imitators.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. I Will Take My Victory Lap Later 🏁 | The Crossover 10.6.26

    Oct 7, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Chopped or Not Chopped 🔪 | The Crossover 7.24.26

    Jul 25, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Cascading Hype Bubbles 🫧 | The Crossover 6.5.26

    Jun 6, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Am I A Chopped Unc? 🫪 | The Crossover 5.22.26

    May 23, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Hobby Bicycle 🚲 | The Crossover 5.15.26

    May 16, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    Josh (@cardboard_chronicles) and Chris (@chris_hoj), the founders of Card Ladder, join forces to bring you the most entertaining and educational sports card discussion on the internet every Friday night. Conduct your...

    Credit the people on this episode