Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Contemplative Dad

The Contemplative Dad artwork

Why Belief Is Not Enough In The Second Half of Your Spiritual Life

Sep 10, 202648 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A few weeks ago I walked into a crowded coffee shop in White Bear Lake looking for a place to work. The only open seat was next to a guy reading Richard Rohr’s Falling Upward - and that book on the table opened a conversation I couldn’t have planned. AJ Hofstetter grew up inside a container built by tragedy: He married young, went from one authority to the next without ever learning self-leadership, and carried unhealed trauma for decades. Then, at 36, taking out the trash, he told God: either you are who you say you are, or you’re not. What happened next - a surprise pregnancy, a lost job, twins, and a daughter pronounced dead in the delivery room - became the anchor point for everything that followed. How do we make sense of failed relationships, trauma, a creative approach to faith? What do you anchor to when the old certainties come apart? What does the journey into the abyss of darkness - the one that turns out to be spiritual growth - actually look like? We cover that and more in this conversation. About AJ AJ Hofstetter is the author of Take Time to Be Brief. Find him at https://www.ajhof.co/ Timestamps * 0:00 - How we met: a crowded coffee shop and a Richard Rohr book * 1:54 - Why AJ was reading Falling Upward * 4:22 - The two halves of life: container and contents * 7:23 - Deconstruction, or an inventory of belief * 10:51 - A childhood container built by tragedy and death * 13:04 - The dark passenger * 14:40 - Marrying young and the lost art of self-leadership * 19:44 - 25 years of marriage: crawling across home plate * 21:53 - How unresolved trauma gets inflicted on the people closest to us * 24:07 - The beginning of the unraveling: the age of accountability * 28:31 - Pursuing only what’s true - and being honest about your motives * 32:20 - The trash-can prayer * 33:43 - Twins, a lost job, and nine minutes * 35:49 - “In the name of Jesus, breathe” * 38:12 - The anchor point * 41:05 - The fruit: mystery, mercy, and the death of sacred cows * 44:38 - Willing to be interrupted This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecontemplativedad.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I want to start with how we met. Just a couple of days ago, I was in the coffee shop and I want to share this story first because it's definitely sort of a providential cosmic coincidence, I think. And, you know, I watched in the coffee shop here in White Bear Lake and I was looking for a spot to sit. This is my experience of it. It's really crowded, more crowded than usual, I'd say at that coffee shop. It was really hot in there and it was loud. And I couldn't really find a good spot to sit down and start doing creative work.

SPEAKER_00I look over. I see you in the corner at a big table all by yourself. Like, oh, that guy has a whole table. Looks like an interesting dude. He looks like somebody I'd want to talk to. Just, you know, out of the gate. I sat down and, you know, we were polite. You know, I exchanged some polite pleasantries. But then I got into working. And oftentimes when I see somebody interesting where I just kind of have this sense like, Right. Spiritually. I don't know why. Like there's something about this person like I just feel like, tell me about yourself.

SPEAKER_00You just look interesting. Right. And so I was waiting for a door to open to do that. And then I look over after about 15 minutes of work and I see the book that

SPEAKER_01you're reading. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00By Richard Rohr.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, aha, there it is. There's my in. The writing and the theology of Richard Rohr is something that I'm familiar with in my circle. Right. Of Christian, you know, tribe that I run in. Sure. He is a bit of a controversial figure. Right. And some would call a heretic. Yep. In certain circles. And so it was very intriguing to me, given where I'm at spiritually. We're going to talk about that more.

SPEAKER_00But I want to start by asking you, why were you reading that book at this point in your life?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Two answers to that. One is it's a group of guys that I meet with regularly, weekly, and we've chosen to go through it and read it. And we've read everything from books of the Bible to more traditional devotionals to books on art. And we read Brother Lawrence, Practice of the Presence of God. We've read a bunch of different things. We've been meeting together for years.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01This one was presented by one of the guys saying it has had a profound impact on his life. So we decided to do it. So I don't know that I would have picked it up otherwise without his recommendation, not because of any issues other than just Limited bandwidth, lots of books to read. I don't know if that one would have been on my priority list, but it became part of my curriculum, if you will. This group of guys were reading it, and then I started reading it,

SPEAKER_01and now I've read every chapter twice as I've gone through it. Each chapter I read, and then I go back and I read it again. Given where I'm at in life, given the season of life that I In some ways what I've just come out of and in other ways what I sense I'm moving into, I don't know that I've had something with more... Consistently clarifying postures presented, if that makes sense.

SPEAKER_01I don't know that I've read many things that have been a little bit like a, this guy's reading my mail so much as this book. I don't care if someone is known as a heretic. I think we're all heretics on any given day. All truth is God's truth. And so for me, it's a matter of if it's valuable and it's true, I pick it up and I apply it. And if it's hogwash, I move on.

SPEAKER_01But out of any one of us at any given time can come both truth and hogwash. And the same is true of Richard Rohr. And I think he would agree with that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. What specifically about what he's saying in that book and his perspectives is resonating?

SPEAKER_01So the book is called Falling Upward. And it's essentially a reflection upon the two halves of life. And I wrote a note in the opening page of the book that said, is this book an observation of reality or is it him presenting a perspective of reality? In other words, is he speaking of something that is true or is he giving us his version of what is true to help us navigate it? And I don't need to know that answer, but for me it helped me frame the conversation that I was going to be having

SPEAKER_01with God, with my friends, with myself, with others. But the basic premise of the book is that the first half of life is spent building the container The second half of life is spent creating the contents of the container. My perspective, my worldview for years, and we'll, I'm sure, get more into this, was built entirely around the narrative of tragedy.

SPEAKER_01And tragedy as my reference point, death as my reference point, And then moving into adulthood and not having any other narrative by which I measure my life, I couldn't envision anything else. I didn't know what anything else would look like. When I was presented with Richard Rohr's view of first half, second half container contents, I was able to appreciate my story in a way I never had before.

SPEAKER_01Not even resenting the darkest moments, but instead just saying, oh, that was building a container. I really like the container. And not like I really like myself. Some days I like myself more than I should, and other days not nearly enough. But to more say I'm thankful for the way that I'm made, I recognize areas of working genius and sweet spot, and I don't want to be like anybody else.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01For the most part. So I actually quite like the container. So what if all of these things were just building that and I don't need to sweat them anymore. I just get to appreciate the container that they built. So now I can fill the container with the contents of the next half of my life. Pivot, that switch. And I think I was ready to read it through a lot of personal work, therapy and EMDR and spent a lot of money in therapy in my day. So I did a lot of work leading up to this read.

SPEAKER_01But the pivot in my posture, my posture toward my life, toward reality, toward why I exist, toward my story, my history, all of that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Drastic.

SPEAKER_00Really meaningful. I first came across some of his stuff when I was, I would say, going through this deconstruction process about six or seven years ago. We talked a little bit about that. That word came up pretty quickly in our conversation. And I think that's another thing that early on I was very resistant to the idea of deconstruction just because it started to pop up in my life when a lot of other really... Seemingly destructive things popped up. My nervous system was kind of shutting down for the first time.

SPEAKER_00I stopped going to church because I was getting triggered by a bunch of the abuse scandal stuff that was happening in the Roman Catholic Church. My marriage was hitting a crisis point. All these things seemed to be really destructive, negative things. And then I was also starting to wrestle with some of these ideas and come across some of this content. Like Jung, Rohr, you know, some of the voices that have been popular in the deconstruction movement.

SPEAKER_00And so I think you're completely right about the timing of like when you come across stuff, like how fruitful it can be. And I think now the point I'm meeting you and seeing you read this book, I'm at a much different point because there's so much more clarity and awareness around... The trauma and some of the stuff psychologically that's happening. Being able to parse through, okay, what's good here, what's not, what's, you know, what's like genuine healing, what's still like trauma responses, you know, fight or flight, fawn or freeze.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, the word deconstruction, I don't know if it's the best word. I mean, you're big on communication and like what words mean. I mean, you know, I think some people associate that with like, I've got to burn it all down, throw the baby out with the bathwater. To me, it feels more like the container analogy to me sounds more like, hey, this is more of an expansion and evolution, a building upon the foundation that's already there. It's not a response to me.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think what scares us about deconstruction is that the word itself sounds so much like the word destruction.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Taken apart. When you come, I come from a deeply religious background where I was warned for decades about the slippery slope of the big scary world and don't be deceived, God cannot be mocked and there's nothing new under the sun and he who doubts is like a wave tossed to and fro in the sea. So then that began to mean that doubting was wrong.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And that questioning was wrong. So I viewed my deconstruction, if you want to call it that, words lose their meaning all the time, but whatever we want to call it deconstruction, I would say mine was more of an inventory. And I began to run through the inventory and I was like, okay, what if this inventory belongs to God, Inc.? What falls under, what if this inventory belongs in this warehouse that is following Jesus, and what does not belong here?

SPEAKER_01That inventory led to a deconstruction of many of the belief systems that I held, but none of the belief systems that I held onto going forward were outside of who I see Christ to be and what he represents.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So back to that container then, you know, you mentioned words like tragedy, death, being really the foundational part of your container. Why was that? What was the story growing up for you that built that container?

SPEAKER_01Some of my earliest memories were memories of death, or memories of death. My mom's mom, my grandmother, her name was Grace, she died in a house fire. I remember hearing stories, it was just before I was born, but hearing stories of my, so my mom's mom died in a house fire. A couple years before that, my mom's sister and her husband and their four kids died in a house fire. And I remember losing my grandpa when I was very young, my great grandpa to cancer. And then my uncle was shot and killed. And there was a bunch of these stories, just bam, bam, one after the other.

SPEAKER_01And you find yourself when you're very young, Learning how to bounce back, there's an agility that a child has. And the agility is not because it doesn't affect the child. It's actually the child's survival mechanism. I remember when my second born was two days old, I was holding her.

SPEAKER_01And I dozed off and my arm fell and I dropped my poor baby. And she fell on a pillow next to me, which really worked out well for me and for her. But I remember when she fell, her arm was like twisted all behind her. And she just looked like spaghetti. And I just untangled her and she was totally fine. That flexibility or malleability of a child is not because they are unaffected. It's because it's how they survive. And the difficulties of childhood and the things that seemed to happen almost as

SPEAKER_01if I was watching it happen on the screen. Those things developed within me a subtle expectation of tragedy. And intrinsic within tragedy is despair. And so that became the pool in which I swam. A constant girding of my loins to prepare to know that I would be ready. There will be no surprises.

SPEAKER_01It amounted to a despair, a melancholy. I referred to it as, for years I referred to it, and I did not coin this phrase, but I latched onto it as soon as I found it, my dark passenger. I carried with me this dark passenger for years. I remember when I was 14 years old, my sister was dating, maybe even engaged to a young man that I looked up to him a ton. His name was John. And I remember he killed himself.

SPEAKER_01And I was 14 years old. And it took me years to recover from that. So I can't imagine my sister's journey with that. Because I know what it did to me. And I didn't even really know him that well. Years later, I remember I said this in my processing of it. I said, when he took his life to escape his hell, he gave his hell to me. That's the most tangible reflection that I can come up with of what that tragedy did to me.

SPEAKER_01It became this reality for me. It was the air I breathed. It wasn't something I thought about, just like a fish doesn't think about being wet. It's just the environment. And that was where I lived. So then when I was thrust into adulthood, way before I was ready, and I was facing adult problems I could never envision myself outside of a survival mindset, outside of making it through the day.

SPEAKER_00Getting married is a huge commitment. I think that on one hand in the church, there's understandably a desire to move people into that serious commitment as a way to maybe provide some boundary and direction. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_00In a place where they're ready for that type of commitment, being able to step back and say, look at the whole person. Now, given that, it's where we find ourselves. But what would you say that sort of foundation of tragedy and death, how did you see that effect in your marriage?

SPEAKER_01How did that make things a challenge? Yeah, and the reality of what I'm about to say, I have to tell you, is entirely my wife's thoughts. And she literally just said this a few weeks ago. We're sitting on the back porch and we're talking about this and we just celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary. Thank you. And we were reflecting on marriage. We were reflecting on how incredibly young we were. And we were just like, where were our mentors? Who were like, slow down.

SPEAKER_01Why are you in such a hurry to be old? You know, whatever. But she said, what happens when someone marries young, and I think she is spot on, at least from my experience and what I experienced, you go from one authority to another and you never learn the art, the skill, the dance of self-leadership. You go from mom and dad telling you what to do. Then I went to a very conservative college with standards,

SPEAKER_01and I lived under an immense legalism and rules-based theology.

SPEAKER_00Which is somewhat appealing because... 100%.

SPEAKER_01I know when I'm succeeding, I know when I'm failing. My success is rooted in... Zero alcohol consumption, virginity, language, whatever it was. I mean, these are the metrics for success. So I go from mom and dad to that environment, and then you move into marriage. And now I'm looking to that other person to provide me with the stabilization that I got from here and from here. And the problem with marrying young, most of the time, Is that you've never learned self-leadership.

SPEAKER_01So it's not necessarily to say, I shouldn't have gotten married when I did, even though on paper there are arguments for that. It's to say, these were the headwinds that I faced, that Rachel and I both faced because of that choice.

SPEAKER_00I just started trauma-informed therapy recently. One of the first things the therapist taught me was the law of duality.

SPEAKER_01Two

SPEAKER_00things can be true at once. I can say I was not a person who was ready to make that commitment.

SPEAKER_01Someone should have slowed me down and said, you need to think about this, you need time. I can also say...

SPEAKER_00You know, that I'm grateful for, you know, the lessons I've learned, what it's done for us. You know, you're still married 25 years, right? Right. There's a story there. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Yeah, that duality is true. I think there's always a third option,

SPEAKER_00you know?

SPEAKER_01I think that's generally true in any scenario. There's always a third option.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And... Yeah, it is true. She and I will look at each other and say, yeah, we absolutely shouldn't have gotten married. We're not saying we wish we weren't married. We're just kind of laughing, actually, and saying, holy cow. And in fact, as our anniversary came and went, it was just at the end of last month, we talked about who we were going to celebrate with. And we were able to point to some people that are the reason we're still married,

SPEAKER_01And by default, we were able to point to some people who really contributed very little to the success. So to really say that this is a win, not because we arrived at some magical destination. I mean, couples still get divorced after 25 and people are still incredibly unhappily married after 25 years. But to know that this landmark occasion happened... At times, crawling across home plate. At times, severely dehydrated.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes, she has me thrown over her shoulder like a fireman and sometimes it's the other way around. It has not been an easy path, obviously, but knowing that The win is not in the number or in whatever, but to know we pushed. We did it. And it hasn't been like, it's not a good advertisement for marriage to be like, just a lot of perseverance.

SPEAKER_01But I remember hearing that. I remember hearing this when I was young. I heard this when I was in Bible college. Marriage is intended for our holiness and not our happiness.

SPEAKER_00That's your cross.

SPEAKER_01I was like, what a horrible thing to say. Marriage is intended for our holiness, not our happiness, so hurry up and get married, young person. What a terrible thing to say. But you go from mom and dad into marriage, one authority figure to the next, essentially. No, I will now look to this person to provide for me what I used to get over here. And then that's our mentality.

SPEAKER_00Man, preach. Oh, my gosh. Right? Oh, man. Yeah, I think that lack of opportunity to self-lead is very profound. And obviously you can still learn lessons about yourself in a marriage. But the reality is, too, I think the other dual aspect there, too, of marriage is that you're becoming one. You hear a lot of theology around you're becoming one flesh.

SPEAKER_01At least in the Catholic tradition, we talk a lot about that. Right, right.

SPEAKER_00You know, spiritually, mystically, you're becoming one. And so now you haven't had this opportunity to develop self, individual. And you're going right into, I am one person. And so like, oh my gosh, for a traumatized person, who it's all about attachment in relationship, right? It's like, we don't know how to attach in a healthy way.

SPEAKER_01And there are so many areas of our Our trauma is telling us things that are untrue about ourselves, about our childhood, but our trauma is also telling us things that are untrue about our partner. And if we don't learn that, we end up ascribing to our partner the The title of or maybe even like inflicting upon our partner the punishment for

SPEAKER_01the trauma that we encounter. She says it a certain way that reminds me of how my dad used to say it and now she's the problem.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01We attribute to our partners the trauma that we do not resolve.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01We do it all the time. We don't just do it in marriage. We do it at work. We do it everywhere. You know the comedian John Crist? He had a brilliant thing talking about men's retreats. And I generally speaking hate men's retreats. And he had a thing where he was talking about going and tug of war and eat meat

SPEAKER_00and do manly things. Smoke cigars. Smoke cigars and do all the things that men do.

SPEAKER_01And he's like, come on guys, wouldn't it be easier if we all just forgave our dads? I was like, that is so real, right? It's like, come on. But no, we do. We bring this trauma with us. And remember, kids are malleable not because it doesn't affect them, but because that's how they survive. Because their dads drop them. And so that malleability... My daughter had to go to the chiropractor after that.

SPEAKER_01She wasn't unaffected, but thanks to her malleability, she also wasn't severely hurt. But that survival cannot, and I'm setting up your segue into the next part of the conversation, survival cannot remain your reference point and your standard for success moving into the second half.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And that second half can start when you're 25 if you're doing the work. And I know people who it still hasn't started and they're old. So when did that start for you?

SPEAKER_00When did the perspective shift, the second half sort of transition start to happen?

SPEAKER_01I remember the day that I recognized I didn't want anything but what was true. I... Began to see a lot of baggage and things that I did not believe Christ himself would be crazy about having attributed to him. And yet it was being done and I just was like, wait, where else have I done this?

SPEAKER_01And kind of a silly example of it, and it's not silly because it's It's implicational, but it had to do with the, what's it called, the age of accountability. And that's the question of, does a child who dies, do they go to heaven, do they go to hell? And I was listening to this discussion, and the answer was given, they go to heaven, because of the age of accountability.

SPEAKER_01And then I began to think, and I have a degree in theology, biblical and theological studies, I've memorized, I was in, when I was a kid, I was in something called Bible quizzing. I memorized books and books of the Bible front to back. So much of the scriptures are up in here. And I was like, I don't, I do not remember the age of accountability anywhere in scripture. I remember hearing things about God being merciful. Okay. Yeah. But age of accountability. Hmm. And I think there's, there's ultimately like two references to something that could allude to it in

SPEAKER_01the Old Testament. But then I was told that the Old Testament was fulfilled and Now what? I didn't know what to do with it. But I knew that the Bible says that all have sinned and fall short of the glory, that those born into Adam's helpless race are destined for eternal punishment, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. So I looked through the Scriptures. Well, let's be honest. I didn't really study. I thought about everything that I already knew. And I was like, wait a minute, what I do know is that the Bible says that people who don't,

SPEAKER_01what I always learned was people who don't pray this prayer of salvation involving Jesus entering my heart, those who do not pray that will go to hell. Babies don't do that. So, babies go to hell. If, oh, if it's not in the Bible, it's only true if it's in the Bible, well, okay. Are you really willing to say that God sends babies to hell? That was the beginning for me of what I would call a deconstruction or really like an inventorying of my beliefs because I didn't believe that babies would go to hell.

SPEAKER_01I have experiences of the opposite. I've seen tremendous mercy poured out by God. I do not believe that he would send babies into eternal damnation, but I couldn't find the verse. So am I willing to believe something that's not in the Bible? And so that was the beginning for me of this kind of unraveling. And the unraveling was not, I don't know what's true anymore. It wasn't chaotic. It was a focused, intentional, almost desperate pursuit of only the truth.

SPEAKER_00And how old were you when this started to happen?

SPEAKER_01It started around the age of 40. I'm 47 now. It started just before that through some stuff that happened with my daughter and everything where I was beginning to see God at work. And then over several years, and really when I went into the deep end of the deconstruction, for lack of a better word, I was talking to a friend of mine about it. And he kind of laughed. He's like, AJ, this is not two days old or two years old or two whatever.

SPEAKER_01You've been thinking this has been a long time coming. You've been talking this way for years. And he was able to identify within me the beginning of the unraveling long before I even saw it.

SPEAKER_00So what were some of the first steps you took in that pursuit of just pure truth? What did you do?

SPEAKER_01Read books? I actually didn't read books. Intellectualism has always been my escape from accountability. I've always been able to rationalize and intellectualize my way into and out of situations. I knew that it wasn't information I needed. I knew that I wanted to anchor into something true and that was the only rule I was going to apply to my process.

SPEAKER_01It scared my wife. Because she really felt like this is the only thing keeping us committed and in unity and whatever. If you're not a Christian anymore, whatever. And it's like, well, I'm not saying that. And I remember when I shared with her the age of accountability thing. And I was like, maybe babies go to hell. And I remember my wife's like, ooh, I don't like this. And she kind of was saying that tongue-in-cheek. But just the idea being, oh, like...

SPEAKER_01If you really go there, you're going to ask some questions that look irreverent. You're going to say some things that feel like you're no longer going to be welcome in some communities.

SPEAKER_00I imagine the fear of what

SPEAKER_01if he decides he doesn't want to be a Christian anymore. Where does that leave us? Where does that leave us? What about our kids? We said we were going to raise our kids in this belief system, and now he's... Too wounded or too wandering to go the distance.

SPEAKER_00Did you balk at that at all? Just seeing that? Did you ever feel like I shouldn't put my wife through this?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I did. But I had always had a reason to not go there. There was never a good reason. There was never a good time to ask the hard questions.

SPEAKER_00It's like your friend said, this has been happening. This has been there.

SPEAKER_01This has been there for a long time. And also I had to have intellectual integrity. I had to have integrity about my motives. I've had friends who have used this feeling as a reason to not keep their commitments. They want to trade her in for a newer, younger model. And so they're like, I'm off doing my thing. I've never made any choices of my own or whatever. I've had friends who I know used it as an excuse to do whatever they wanted.

SPEAKER_01And I know myself well enough to know that I shouldn't do whatever I want. There's some things that I don't do. An example would be, I don't watch MMA anymore. I don't watch UFC or MMA. I don't. And I have no issue with people who do. I don't think it's a moral thing. For me, I have this... I'm no better than a Roman in ancient times. I have this innate desire to watch one dude beat the tar out of another dude.

SPEAKER_01And because I want it, I do not watch it. Right? And so I had to have honesty about my motives. Knowing like... What am I really looking for here? If I'm looking for an out, I need to be honest about that. And then do what I'm going to do with that honesty. But if it's really truth, I'm after. And so being honest with my motives. And like I said, I didn't really read anything at that time. But I spent a lot of time contemplating.

SPEAKER_01A lot of time thinking through all of the things I'd ever learned. And measuring it against... One anchor point.

SPEAKER_00What was that anchor point?

SPEAKER_01I'm glad you asked. Softball. Yeah, right over the point. When I was 36 maybe, I remember I was taking out the trash and I had gone just job to job to job. Just felt like a Broken machine. There's no use for this machine. He doesn't do anything.

SPEAKER_01We haven't figured him out yet. Kept trying, kept trying. And I basically, I said to God, I was taking out the trash and I said, God, either you are who you say you are or you're not. If you are, I'm all in. If you're not, I'm out. But I want to know that you are the God who can raise the dead. That's what I want to know. And then, and I just put that out there.

SPEAKER_01A month later, found out that my wife was pregnant. Surprise pregnancy. We were done having kids. So I thought, surprise pregnancy. The day after we found out she was pregnant, I lost my job. I was working for a marketing firm and I didn't actually lose the job. I kind of discovered the job never existed in the first place.

SPEAKER_00It makes sense for some reason. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, okay. I heard what I wanted to hear, right? And so I was unemployed, underemployed, all through the pregnancy. Halfway through the pregnancy, we found out it was twins. And so here I am, unemployed, find out we're having twins. So now it's going to be four kids in my family. And I'm not making anything. Yeah. Time came for the twins to be born, boy-girl twins.

SPEAKER_01My little boy was born first, no problems. But then there was an abruption in the placenta. Little girl was in danger. They kicked me and my mother-in-law out of the room. They performed an emergency C-section. It took nine minutes to get her out. From the time of the abruption of the placenta till the time they got her out, it was nine minutes, nine and a half minutes, something like that. And then they started doing CPR. And I was down in a waiting room with my mother-in-law and heard code pink going

SPEAKER_01over the speakers and panicking, scared to death. Doctor came in and said, we're doing everything we can. We don't know. It doesn't look good. And at that point, I didn't even know if they were talking about my wife or my daughter. And I found out they were talking about my daughter. And then they invited me in. We want you to come in and see her. And I walked in and I have a picture on my phone. I don't know why I took the picture. As I look at it, I realize it's a picture of a dead baby.

SPEAKER_01She's gray. She's three pounds. She's gray. And my wife's a musician. I begin to play my wife's music from my phone, from my daughter. And I start talking to her. Well, my mother-in-law said, AJ, your daughter needs to hear your voice. And they're continuing to do CPR. And I'm talking to my daughter. And then the doctor called time of death. And he said, we're done now. And I had my hand on her. I don't have big hands, but they look giant on top of her.

SPEAKER_01And I just said, the summary, I basically said, I said, in the name of Jesus, breathe. And I watched that little girl gasp for air and come alive. And she got all pink and pudgy, like in a hot second. They were like, oh, she won't live through the minute. She won't live through the hour. She'll have severe disability. She's gonna have this. She's gonna have nothing. She's like my snarkiest child. She's the healthiest, snarkiest of them all.

SPEAKER_01She's wonderful. Here's what I discovered. When I watched my daughter come back from the dead, it was when I said, in the name of Jesus, It was in that moment. That was my anchor. And it wasn't because I read about it. It wasn't because I knew it was right. Because someone told me. Because my parent told me or my college told me or my spouse told me.

SPEAKER_01I knew what I saw. So when I began to inventory my life, that was the only thing that I held on to. So I don't know what to say to someone who doesn't have that. It's like anchor into my story. Maybe. I don't know. But I know that nothing was guaranteed for me on where I would arrive on the other side of this thing.

SPEAKER_01Except that that was true. She was dead. Doctor called it. In the name of Jesus, breathe. And that little girl, like she'd been holding her breath for 30 minutes, that's what it was. It was 29 minutes from the time of the eruption of the placenta to the time that she took her first breath. And that's what I anchored into. That was it. So that was the moment that God in His mercy allowed me to experience,

SPEAKER_01that allowed me to navigate A re-inventorying of truth in my mind.

SPEAKER_00Two things that stick out about that anchor point in your story. At the beginning you talked about the container of tragedy and death. You also talked about coming into marriage without the self-leadership and going right into another authority. So God uses this moment, this really pivotal anchor, you know, hinge point in your story.

SPEAKER_00Literally brings a child back to life through the name of Jesus. And then... It's a moment for you to literally have this kind of authority and this moment of truth that's not coming from an ulterior sort of external authority. You're experiencing that yourself.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's a redemption of the tragedy narrative. It's the upside. It's the happily ever after. It doesn't end here. It is like, whoa, at their darkest moment, then it's like,

SPEAKER_00It's the introduction into that second half. Correct, correct.

SPEAKER_01Wow. Yeah, and so looking now at the container that was built for so long and for so many years, the script in my mind was... Things like, I break everything I touch, or I'm just a lemon, or I'm just never going to find my groove, or whatever it was. So much of that was rooted in these mindsets, rooted in tragedy, all of that. And then it was an awareness that I haven't quite found my groove yet, but I will. I just need to be patient. There were all these different variations of it.

SPEAKER_01Some of it was rooted in trauma and self-loathing. Some of it was rooted in just what it means to be human. Some of it was truly circumstantial. I turned down some good jobs because I didn't want to relocate to places in the country that sounded terrible to live in. So it wasn't like this. I didn't feel like a victim everywhere I went, but I could not envision a reality where my container was anything that I'd be thankful for, if that makes sense.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think that debunks the whole idea, too, of deconstruction as this sort of destructive process that is sort of like a burning down of everything good. It really is a process that seems necessary. And so for you going forward, you have your anchor point, this really powerful truth that you can kind of hold on to as you're stepping into the abyss. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Of taking this inventory of truth. Can you tell me about a few conclusions you came to? Or, you know, what are some fruit from this last decade or so? You kind of mentioned coming out of that. Like, what, you know, did you solve the problem of, you called it child accountability or the age of accountability? Age of accountability, yeah. You know? Yeah. Was it like, did you get some of those questions answered, tied up neatly in a little bow?

SPEAKER_01Some of this comes right out of even what I'm reading within what I've read with Richard Rohr. But the beauty within mystery, you know, we are told to seek and find, but we're not told to seek and find answers. We're told to seek and find Him. St. Francis, without the way, there is no going. Without the truth, there is no knowing. Without the life, there is no living. He is those things.

SPEAKER_01And so, to discover that I walked away from it and my dark passenger stayed back there. I've not Felt the melancholy that came with me all the time. And here's why I believe that is. Because I burned down some structures that turns out weren't sacred.

SPEAKER_01And I was putting them on this shelf of untouchables. And even if people need to not call it deconstruction, but call it inventorying, or call it honesty, There were all of these things that I was treating as a sacred structure and therefore not touching. No, that's off limits. Age of accountability. No, no, no, no. That's true. Maybe it's not. But if that's not true, what else could not be true? Maybe I get to encounter Jesus as he's revealed in the scriptures and realize

SPEAKER_01the mercy of That drips off of this man. My favorite line in any song that we sing in any worship service is, on the cross as Jesus died, the wrath of God was satisfied. To see him take on the wrath, his mercy is like that it's truly consumed and gone. To recognize now, like, all of these things that I'd held onto as sacred cows were not.

SPEAKER_01And there were very few things that I needed to worry about. And those things were made very clear to me. So the fruit for me is an understanding of a life that isn't tragic, but is in fact... It has an upward swing to it. It's an appreciation for a container in all of its crazy dysfunction. A willingness to be interrupted.

SPEAKER_01Because when we're not willing to be interrupted, it's mostly because we think that what we're doing matters more than the interruption. When really the interruption is often where the good stories are found. But we're not comfortable with disruption or interruption because it takes us off our plan. Because our plan is something that we have put on the shelf there.

SPEAKER_00What it gets down to is like... When you let go of the sacred things that you saw as untouchable before. And you start to identify, okay, that actually, what I was afraid of was I was afraid of losing God and losing my faith or what have you. But when you realize what's happening is you're actually getting in touch with who God really is. And one of the, I think, the insights that I've gotten to know about God as I've been on this pursuit of truth is that He is truly like his unconditional love is truly unfathomable for us.

SPEAKER_00Like how how true that is that he loves us unconditionally. And I think to be able to sit with that and and to experience it in a certain sense. It's one thing to know it intellectually. It's another thing to experience it. And there's another thing to experience it from other people. And I think in talking to you and as I've been sharing some of the things I'm not kind of delving into on camera yet or on this channel yet because it's so raw and it's hard stuff. It's like heavy things I'm going through.

SPEAKER_00And so often when I'm sharing these things with other people, the challenge is you have people who want to come in and they want to fix everything right away. They want to give you, like, stop doing that, start doing this. Here's what you need to do. It's prescriptive, right?

SPEAKER_01There's a prescription for that. There's a prescription for that. There's an answer for that.

SPEAKER_00Or there's a projection of my own fears. And just here, you know, talking to you at the coffee shop the other day and just... For you to be able to hear what I'm saying, to be able to share with me and encourage me and, you know, share some of your own story and give, like, real truth and feedback, but also to be in a place where, like... That's my story and you're on your path and I'm, you know, like I'm with you in it.

SPEAKER_00It's like it's more of like, you know what, I'm standing next to you and I'm just with you in that. I'm not coming in. I'm not giving you a command. Yeah. And, you know, that's not that's not me saying like I'm just looking for people to condone everything I do or like not. Not really, like, even if you have in your head, hey, here's what I think you should do, Max, or I'm kind of seeing something, maybe there's a blind spot there, like, you're holding that, and you're saying, this is your story, this is your journey, and I'm here with you in it. Right. That means so much,

SPEAKER_00because I think that really is a quality of God, I think it's a virtue of God that we don't quite get right as human beings. Sure, yeah. And we have a hard time grasping, and, um,

SPEAKER_01So I want to thank you for that. That's good, man.

SPEAKER_00And say that, yeah,

SPEAKER_01I really am grateful for... And I think I go back to being interruptible, right? Like, the best things happen when you're willing to be interrupted.

SPEAKER_00Well, thanks for letting me interrupt you, and I'll take that as an invitation for future interruptions.

SPEAKER_01100%. Good stuff.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, AJ. One last thing. If people were going to check out some of what you do, where would you want to send them?

SPEAKER_01Ajhoff.co. A-J-H-O-F dot C-O.

SPEAKER_00All right. I'll link in the description.

SPEAKER_01The book is called Take Time to Be Brief. Take Time to Be Brief. And yeah.

SPEAKER_00I'll say it's a brief read. It has to be. Otherwise, it'd be a blow to my credibility. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Volumes one through seven on brevity wouldn't really work. Well, I'll link to that in the description. Make sure you check it out.

SPEAKER_00Thanks to AJ again. Appreciate your brother.

SPEAKER_01Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Dancing Naked in The Jungle, Bardic Storytelling, and Irrational Faith w/ James Burke

    Oct 21, 202653 minAudio

    A conversation with James Anthony Burke - storyteller, musician, writer, and self-described bard - we get into the story of how James grew a large following on instagram and how he is using the opportunity to grow in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Death of The Cog

    Sep 21, 20265 minAudio

    You’ve been taught that you need permission. You grew up in the aftermath of the industrial revolution, which brought incredible technological achievement. But with mass consumerism and mass production came the mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Watch one of my 1:1 creative strategy calls

    Sep 18, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thecontemplativedad.substack.com One of my favorite things that’s come out of this community - is the 1:1 calls. Founding Members ($125/year) get everything...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. God Is Inviting You Back To The Creative Life

    Sep 9, 20266 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecontemplativedad.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Very Personal Update On My Creative Journey

    Aug 26, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thecontemplativedad.substack.com Hello friends, It’s been about a year and a half since I made the leap into full time self-employment. There are three areas...

    Credit the people on this episode