When government officials are accused of breaking the law
57 minAudio
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - You may be familiar with the novel “Crime and Punishment” by Fyodor Dostoevsky. Unlike that work of fiction, crimes and their punishments happen quite frequently, and government actors are not immune. Thomas Massie claims that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has committed crimes worthy of impeachment. I wonder why he’s going...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Outlaw Network with your host, Paul Engel. There are plenty of accusations of criminal activities that circulate around government actors. Today, I want to take a look at some of the more recent ones. Hello there, Everyday Americans, Paul
Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution, teacherized and generation be free. Glad you could join me today. You know, there are always people that think that what when something someone does is wrong, that it's criminal. And well, very often they they try to make it sound a lot different than it is. For example, um, apparently Thomas Massey is attempting to impeach Pete Hegseth. Uh now, again, as a member of the executive
branch, as a civil officer, Pete Hegseth is subject to impeachment, but only for treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. So, what is Mr. Massey accusing Mr. Hegseth of doing? Well, he claims that uh um uh that Pete Heggseth is operating in contravention of three specific uh provisions of the War Powers Resolution of 1973. Now, his article of impeachment have several specific
charges. Uh, weeding through some of the mumbo jumbo, uh, this claim that he violates the War Powers Act. And I find it interesting because he quotes section 2C of the Act, where it reads, the constitutional powers of the president as commander-in-chief to introduce United States Armed Forces into hostilities or into situations where imminent involvement in hostilities is clearly indicated by the circumstances are exercised only pursuant to a declaration of war, specific statutory authorization, or a national emergency created by attack
upon the United States, its territories, possessions, or its armed forces. Now, the the understanding is I believe from my memory of the War Powers Act, the president can do this. He has to notify Congress, I think, within 30 days, he can only keep troops engaged for 90 days. And this is where um, again, Mr. Massey wants to go after Mr. Heggseth. He states in the uh articles of impeachment we have the respect of the United States Armed Forces being entered into hostilities in the Islamic
Republic of Iran. On February 28, 2026, Secretary Hegzeth directed and caused the United States Armed Forces to be introduced into hostilities against the Islamic Republic of Iran. Notwithstanding that Congress had not declared war against the Islamic Republic of Iran. True. Congress had not enacted any specific statutory authorization for the introduction of the United States Armed Forces into hostilities against the Islamic Public of Iran, and no national emergency had been created by an attack by the Islamic Public of Iran upon the United States its territories possessions or its armed
forces. A little bit of missing history.
He ignored that. But I find something else interesting here that I want to get to a bit later on. I want to kind of get these justifications of the way, and then I want to get to what I think is the crux of the matter. Next major point is Secretary Heggs abused the powers of his high office through the following means: executing an unlawful order to commence hostilities despite the absence of a declaration of war, specific statutory authorization, or national emergency created by Tagwan, the United States' territories or possessions, or its armed forces, continuing to employ the personnel and resources of the Department of Defense in those
hostilities after their unlawful uh initiation and its continued absence of the subsequent declaration of war or specific statutory authority, uh uh authorization by Congress. I did point out that under the War Powers Act there could be a justification, but how long it would go without congressional authority was going to be a problem. Uh, see, there's several variations of you know, these people put people in combat without uh uh congressional authorization. Uh, he also points out, he said,
uh the the um article of impeachment says, using the powers of his office, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegzett directed the Department of Defense in a manner that resulted in the death or injury of more than 200 civilians at Sharat Taeb uh Elementary School in Minab, Horazan Province, uh Iran. He did so through a scheme or course of conduct that affected the systemic deterioration and removal of the Department of Defense infrastructure that Congress had mandated by law to limit collateral damage to citizens and non-military objects during military operations.
Um okay, you're saying that that an attack, the question is, and again, I don't remember this specific incident, so I don't know if it if the elementary school was the target attack. I thought the elementary school was it was an erroneous target. There was a problem with it. They weren't intentionally targeted, it was uh it was unintentional, but we're dealing with politics, which is what this is all about here. Um, and and he he the the articles go on. He also points to
the destruction of the drug boats as extrajudicial killings. Um, these were remember because we had uh uh at sea, this means it's under international law, um, not under the uh well, uh it's a little tricky because you got to deal with international treaties on this, and I'm not familiar with all those details, but the question was um, were these people an imminent threat to the United States? And according to Mr. Massey, uh they were not, therefore, their
uh their killings violated um violated the law. Here's another one that I found interesting, and this is you remember when when Senator Kelly um made a statement saying reminding our uh members of our military forces that uh our laws are clear, you can refuse illegal orders. Well, according to Senator Massey, um Mr. Hegzeth weaponize the Department of Defense to retaliate against and intimidate Senator Mark Kelly for such a
statement. Now, I remember that statement, I remember what it was put, and it was in a context of don't do what the what the president orders because it's an illegal order, but never actually proved the order to be illegal, right? So yeah, the again, this this is uh this is leading up to something I found interesting. I'm curious if you will as well. Uh, he also blamed Secretary Hegseth for the kidnapping of uh the Venezuelan president and his wife uh Maduro and
his wife, so he blamed Hegseth for that. And that is is where I want to kind of ask a serious question. Now, whether or not you believe that all these things are high crimes and misdemeanors, right? That's an interesting question. Because um the War Powers Act, I do not believe has a criminal punishment. I may be wrong. Again, I'm not an expert on federal law, I'm not an expert on the War Powers Act. I do not believe it has a
criminal punishment attached to it, but I may be wrong. So if violating the War Powers Act is not doesn't have a criminal punishment, then it's not a high crime. Is it a misdemeanor? Is it bad behavior? Potentially, yes. But I find this very interesting because he's targeting the Secretary of Defense, not the President of the United States. Why, Mr. Massey? I mean, after all, the president
is the one that ordered Mr. Hegseth to do these things. I believe in most of these cases, the president, as a commander-in-chief, ordered the armed forces into Iran, ordered them to attack Iran, actually, didn't they invade Iran? Uh, the president of the United States ordered the destruction of the drug vessels. The president of the United States ordered the capture of Nicholas Maduro. Why are you not impeaching the president? Why are you impeaching Secretary Hegseth?
Now, I'm not saying that the Secretary of Defense cannot be impeached for violations of the law. He's a civil officer, he can. I just find it um interesting, shall we say, that Mr. Massey is focused on Secretary Hegeseth and not on the president of the United States. Let's just say I believe politics may be part of this particular situation. And speaking of political, if not prosecutions, at least investigations, um, a
former FBI agent who uh launched an investigation into Elon Musk when he was the head of Doge, uh well, made a very interesting statement. In an internal email, he's claimed that the that that the Mr. The Musk's use of X to promote Doge. Um, by the way, he referred to it as Twitter in his emails. Um but he said using X to promote Doge was similar to the former Secretary of Uh State Hillary Clinton, using a private
email server to conduct government business. Now, are they really the same, or is this just more political sour grapes? Now remember, Ms. Clinton used a private email server to conduct government business in violation of the law and an attempt to hide what she was doing from federal FOIA um uh requirements. In other words, she wanted it, she apparently didn't want it to be
seen because you didn't want it on government servers and to be subject to search. She was hiding information. Meanwhile, what Musk was doing was promoting or basically talking about what Doge was doing publicly, exposing to the public what a government agency was doing. So, yeah, that uh that sounds to me more like uh sour grapes among the FBI agents than uh than uh actual uh a reasoned um a reasoned argument.
Uh he stated that he wanted to open a criminal investigation into an alleged conspiracy with Elon Musk uh as to in addition to do things in addition to wasting a colossal amount of official time encouraging and betting and aiding thousands or if not tens of thousands of government employees to violate government-wide security policies and transmit sensitive information outside of a strict need to know. Was any of the information that Musk posted on X classified? Need to know? Did he encourage people to do
that? Again, this just seems like, well, let's make a criminal investigation out of the person. It's like, show me the person and I'll show you the crime. I mean, that's what it sounds like to me. Sour grapes. It's the criminal justice system being used not for justice, but for political attack. Now, should we be surprised at any of this? Absolutely not. This is kind of the way uh a government's been running, especially the federal government has been running uh for a long, long time. So that brings up to
me the question I want to think about on this this segment. Are these three instances, right? Thomas Massey's impeachment of Secretary Heggseth, um, the actually two instances, it and the the attack, the FBI attack on Elon Musk, are these actual criminal these accusations, are there actual criminal offenses? Or are these political hit jobs? Are these an attempt to um to get at a political opponent or someone who's not real happy with,
uh, in an effort to promote your own political agenda? Now, at first you might think, well, no, see, Representative Massey's a Republican, and and Heggseth is part of a Republican administration. This is not partisan. I'm not so sure. This seems to be uh something that you know Massey's not happy with the Trump administration, and he's or at least with Mr. Hegeseth, and he's going after him. I understand this, you know, he doesn't like the policies of Donald Trump. To go after one of his
underlings for the actions of Trump seems to me kind of a backhanded way of doing things. And remember, the FBI, when Doge was was first set up and Elon Musk was overseeing it, they were still populated by a lot of the we'll just call them the Biden mentality, this internal uh uh secret police type scenario that said we know better and we have to go after Musk for actually, oh, I don't know, trying to make the government more efficient, trying to get rid of wasted abuse. How dare you do
that? This is where we get all of our sludge funds on, this is where we get paid for. This is nothing again, this is nothing new. This is stuff that happens all the time. I want us to get used to this idea, though, of looking at what's happening and asking yourself, before we assume it's what is being said is true, that there's a they there's actually evidence that's what that that what's being said is true, and that this is not simply a political political gamesmanship, which we get plenty of um again in this
government. Because if the government can criminalize policy differences, well then what kind of mess does that make the republic? One administration comes in and they criminalize one set of policies, another another comes in, they uh uh they criminalize a different set of policies. Here, though, we have a a member of Congress, meaning he is elected by people of Kentucky, by a district. Are you thrilled with that idea,
ladies and gentlemen? If you're represented by Mr. Massey, are you thrilled with the idea that, okay, you think there's a problem going after Heg Seth rather than Trump? I'd be curious as to know why. In fact, I just had we our our county commission just had a vote on a controversial subject, and I found it interesting that the two commissioners that represent my district voted opposite. One voted yes, one voted no. So you know what I did? I reached out to both to ask them why. I want to understand why you're doing this, because to me that's that's terribly
important. I understand why you voted for it, I want to understand why you voted against it. I have my own opinion, which I have not did not inject into the question because I want their honest opinion. I think that's what we should expect from our representatives. And maybe that would need a little bit more investigation. Then again, maybe not. Maybe if you live in Kentucky, you're more than happy with uh this impeachment attempt against Mr. Hegseth. Um, maybe you think he's, you know, he's he's the devil, he's evil, uh, he
needs to be stopped at all costs. Maybe that's the case. Maybe Mr. Massey's off uh uh properly representing or uh uh representing the opinions of his um of his district. I don't know. We'll see. Even if he gets this these articles past the House, it has to be tried in the Senate. So Mr. Hegseth is not guilty until he's convicted in the Senate, and then he can be removed. So we'll have to wait and see. I'm not expecting this to go very far at all. Now, I have to take a
break before I do. You know, I I I've heard more reports about how our food just doesn't have the nutrition it used to have. It's been farmed out of our food, even our organic food. Now, a lot of people they take a lot of supplements or they take a lot, they do a lot of weird diets. Oh, I have friends at the chemical-free body, though, they have an interesting solution. It's called organic energy juice. It's a juice powder. You mix it with water, uh, you know, in the morning, in the evening before you eat. And it's designed
to give your body the nutrients it needs without all the crazy diets or pills, right? To give you energy, to improve your sleep, your mental clarity, to help your weight loss, to build muscle, to strengthen your immune system, all with a simple juice powder. Now, don't take my word for it. Read up on it, go to America Out Loud PULSE and click on the organic energy juice panel and do your own research. I want you to be an informed consumer. See what's in it, see what's involved, look at the testimonials, and when you're ready
to buy it, use the code OutLOUD at checkout to get 20% off your order. So if you're looking for a way to get the nutrition your body needs without strange diets or lots of pills, check out organic energy juice from the chemical-free body by going to America Out Loud PULSE and clicking on the organic energy juice panel today. Are you tired of struggling with low energy? We get it. That's why we created organic
energy juice. In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle with low energy again. And it tastes amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy juice is the right decision. With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com
forward slash outloud. Successful weight loss is about changing the gut brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor designed solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy fats. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing sublingual
tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit Twc.health slash Outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. You know, this time of year, the windows close, the furnace kicks on, you're breathing the same recycled air at home, in the car, and at work all winter. You can't control the air, but you can control your routine. Clear nasal spray with saline plus xylitol blocks bacteria and viruses and keeps your nasal passages moisturized.
It's not a drug, it's not habit forming, and it's safe to use morning and night. That's it. Learn more at Clear.com. That's X-L-E-A-R.com. Clear. Breathe better, live better. You and I think you win. We will put your children.
And you know, sometimes the punishment is simply having to deal with the process. I talked a bit about what's you know, some of the crime allegations. I want to take a look at some of the things that are going on in the courts. Uh, for example, district judge Deborah Boardman uh is once again throwing cold water on the Trump's uh uh birthright citizenship policies. Uh, she issued an injunction for the remainder of a class action suit that was brought against the administration by immigrant families and activist groups. She
cited in her decision, the Supreme Court has spoken, children in the certified class are citizens at birth. Now, again, I point out all the time that uh judges seem less interested in the law than in the the opinion of the other judges. I point out, granted, it's not entirely scientific, but I've asked um I've asked uh uh judges and attorneys for years, every time I meet one, when they were in law school, did they study the language of the constitution or did they study constitutional law, which is nothing but the opinion
of judges? This looks like someone who studied the opinion of judges, because only one person I've talked to so far actually studied the the Constitution. Because she said the Supreme Court said that these people in this class are citizens of birth. The problem is the Constitution and federal law says they're not. I talked about this when I covered the case, uh the Supreme Court case, pointing out that the Supreme Court ignored not only what the language of the Constitution, that
subject to the jurisdiction of, they acted as if that didn't mean anything. Right? They didn't say subject to the laws of the United States, they said subject to the jurisdiction of the United States. They ignored that. They ignored that back in the early 1900s with the Juan Kimar case, they ignored it here in the in the recent case, and now you have a lower court saying, hey, they're citizens, therefore uh you have to treat them as citizens simply because they were born here even if they were not resident here.
And that brings to me is a something I've just discussed before, because what does it mean to be subject to the jurisdiction thereof? Uh Senator Merritt Howard, I think it was, who proposed adding the language and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, clearly stated that it would not include foreigners or aliens, meaning if you were here temporarily, um you uh uh uh you did not qualify. If you were here, I would say, uh, as a permanent resident, you're still an alien,
um, or you're a foreigner. I forget the which one is, therefore, it would he didn't think it would apply. So yeah, you've got uh uh you've got this misunderstanding. The court has simply looked at his previous decisions, ignored the actual language, and based on that, now we have more um we have more cases that say, nope, you can't you can't uh deport these people because they were physically born here, even though they were not subject to the jurisdiction of the
United States. I know a lot of people are out there screaming, but Paul, they're subject to our laws. That's not what that language means. I go all the way back to Wang Kim Ark, where the Supreme Court said, yes, when he was born, he was his parents were residents of the United States, but they were subjects of the Emperor of China. So they were subject to the jurisdiction of China. Therefore, by the language of the Constitution, Mr. Ark was not a citizen at birth, but they simply ignored it. And this goes on. Now again, I I don't
know if this was a political move, right? I don't know, Judge Boardman. I don't know if she's doing this based on politics. I don't know if she's doing this because she was taught, listen, I can I can't disagree with the Supreme Court, they'll just overrule it on appeal. But this kind of shows what happens when um the law becomes detached from the language of the law, when the practice of the law becomes detached from the language of the law, we end up with this mess. And of
course, this has led to a lot of problems with our immigration law, but that's a whole nother discussion for a whole nother time. I want to swing over to what's been going on with the Supreme Court. Now, this case is USPS versus California, and it was an attempt to lift a nationwide injunction prohibiting the U.S. Postal Service from implementing uh rules that were created under an executive order from President Trump. Now,
according to the unsigned order, we read the government is unlikely to succeed on the merits of its challenge to the district court's preliminary injunction, and the equitable factors applicable for obtaining emergency relief from this court do not favor a stay. Meaning the majority of the justices of the court don't think that the the uh government's gonna win, that that the postal service will be able to win its its argument, and leaving things status quo, meaning we're not gonna put in new rules, um are is
the favorable solution. You don't put in rules to only have them removed later. That was the scenario. What's interesting is while no justice signed the order, two justices dissented. Uh Justice Alito wrote a dissent that Justice Thomas joined, um, where they said the court incorrectly denies the government's application first a day of a universal injunction that bars implementation of a final rule concerning the election ballot mail. What's the reason for this? He says some of the Justice Alito wrote, some of the plaintiffs lack standing, while
the remainder are pursuing a claim that this court has already called a Hail Mary pass that rarely succeeds. The government has made the showing necessary first day, so I respectfully dissent. So justices Leto and Thomas say, listen, um, not everybody that's covered by this day is uh is actually has standing in the court. The uh challenge uh is is um uh what's the word I'm looking for? The the the challenge is uh problematic, all right, because uh uh uh the
or I should say the court said it's a Hail Mary. All right, so some of them are aren't some of it's it's a hail mary, it's unlikely to succeed. That's why he said no, we should we should dissent. I'm curious about this because again, I have this kind of love-hate relationship with with male in ballots. I I I think they are necessary in rare cases. Like I said, I've only used them once in my entire life, but the problem is this mass mail-in ballot and the rules that the president was trying
to put in place, I don't think he has the legal authority to actually implement. So, you know, I'm kind of looking at this going, this is a real mess. I mean, this is a tangled mess. It's like a bowl of pasta, it's all interwoven, it's all crazy. Because I I see the logic of mail and ballots need extra security in in when handled through the mail. Because you have this um this uh break in the chain of custody, there needs to be some extra security. But
I also see the logic of the question is does a president have the authority to order this? Doesn't that need to be federal law since it's the Congress that that can modify the time, place, and manner of elections for House and Senate? And of course, these ballots involve more than House and Senate. So there's another whole question there. Um, and and and the whole it it's a mess. It's a mess. Then again, a lot of our elections are a mess because we spend a lot of time focusing on what I think are the wrong things. Uh,
and then another thing coming out, and this time an order coming out of the Supreme Court, and it evolves a New York City law uh rule prohibiting the use of what are commonly referred to as stun guns. Now, here's where life gets a little interesting. So the Second Amendment Foundation asked the Supreme Court to hear the case, Kelsey versus New York City, and they argued that the appeals court ignored a 10-year-old decision by the Supreme Court. Um, now the case they're
referring to is uh Caetano versus Massachusetts, where the court decided that a ban on stun guns would violat the Second Amendment because, as the the court wrote in the decision, um uh the Second Amendment covers all weapons that may be defined as bearable arms, even if they did not exist when the Bill of Rights was drafted, and are not commonly used in warfare. All right, because again, the Second Amendment doesn't say anything, it says you're right to keep and bear arms. It doesn't say anything about having to be in war, doesn't
even say about anything having to be in the militia. The militia is the reason why, you know, the militia is about keeping a state free. The armed populace is where you end up with the population of the people in the militia, but that even is not the could the case here. So um the Second Amendment Foundation what is uh petitioned the Supreme Court, and the court said, okay, well, we want to hear from both sides. However, the lawyers for New York City said, you know what, uh, we've decided
we're not going to exercise uh our right to to respond. Uh they they they they said that they were they waived its right to respond to the petition and just wanted the court to go ahead uh as it, but the supreme court said, nah, we really want you uh to respond to this challenge. Before, I guess they were seeking uh a petition of uh for a writ of sortiory knows they want the case to be heard. Uh Second Amendment Foundation wants the case to be
heard by the Supreme Court. The they said, okay, New York City, tell us your side before grant cert. And New York said, nah, we're not gonna bother. Now, again, I find this interesting because, on the one hand, you say, No, New York City, we really want you to respond. We really want to hear. We have other people saying, listen, this is an almost an exact duplicate of the Catano case. Um, you know, so should we really spend the time and effort to put up a response? Just, you know, look at this. And and I mean,
you should just be able to grant uh uh and remand, saying, Nope, you got it wrong. The case got it wrong because of this other case. But I found it interesting, New York City didn't even want to put their side of the story out. And the court said, no, we we really want it. And maybe I'm kind of curious where this goes. On the one hand, because it's a Second Amendment case, and I love Second Amendment cases. Uh, I love the idea of stun guns. I want less than lethal weapons,
should they be protected? Um, you know, uh I there are I can see scenarios where someone would rather use a stun gun than a firearm, but in New York City you're not allowed to. So this again, it's interesting, and it's gonna come down to um how the court how New York City responds, and how the court, the the Supreme Court decides to react to that response or lack thereof. Now, again, in relation to the the previous case, here's my question. Actually, the federal court
case, is the court simply going to say, well, you know, precedent, starting decisis, we've decided this already in Caetano, um, New York City, your your ban is is unconstitutional. Are they going to hear arguments? And what are those arguments going to be? Uh, because just because New York City response doesn't mean that the court's gonna grant cert. They may still deny cert, they may still deny hearing this. It's again, to me, it's an interesting case, but maybe that's just me. Maybe it's the
the way I look at things. But I want us to remember not all court cases are criminal, not all court cases give us the outcome we desire, not all court cases give us the outcome the Supreme Law Land demands. Uh, we've seen that, and I've talked about time and time and time again. It's part of the reason why I say the nine people most in need of a reading comprehension court program are the justices of the Supreme Court, not because they're ignorant people, but because they seem to ref to well
not place the language of the of the law above the opinion of others. And uh, you know, they don't we're the people aren't held to that standard, but the courts and governments are, and that to me is a is a problem. It's it's an issue that we the people need to be concerned about. But again, I'm curious what you think about birthright citizenship, uh, what you think about uh stone guns, what you think about mail-in
ballots and the regulations, and uh should the U.S. Postal Service, and does the president have the authority to order the U.S. Postal Service to require uh more stricter handling of uh mail-in ballots than uh your your bill payment, right? You're right. If if you're still one of those people that write a check and put it in the mail to pay your bills, do you want your ballot handled a little more securely than your the your bill pay? That I I'm curious what people think because
again, I don't have all the answers. Uh I'm I'm not that ex that expert, but uh I think again, problem number one is is does the president have the authority to do that? And that to me is is the area where there may be an issue for Mr. Trump. Now, again, I have another break coming up, but before I go, you know, you think about it do you pay attention to the who you do business with? And do you pay attention to what they do with with the profits they glean from your from your patronage?
See, there are several companies I stopped doing business business with because I found out they were taking their profits to support programs and organizations that were a violation, that were a corruption of my rights. That's one of the reasons why I joined Patriot Mobile. Yes, their America is only Christian conservative widest provider. That's not why I joined them, even though I tend to share their values. They have great 4G and 5G support on all the same networks and towers across the entire United States. That's not why I joined
them. Their customer support is 100% US-based. That's not why I joined them. I joined them for one simple reason. So I became a customer because Pedro Mobile donates a portion of every dollar to organizations fighting for our rights. First Liberty, Turning Point USA, Students for Life, NRA. And now, yes, the Constitution study. That's right. I became an affiliate of them because I saw the great work they were doing with their profits. So the time is now.
Don't wait and keep spending your money with companies that are trying to destroy your rights, directly or indirectly. Let's stand together and support companies that share our beliefs and values. You can do that with your cell phone by joining me at Patriot Mobile today. Go to patriotmobile.comslash constitution, find a plan that works for you. By the way, see if you're eligible for a discount. Families with multiple lines, NRA members, veterans, first responders, they all are eligible for discounts. And if you use the code Constitution at checkout, you'll get your new
line activated absolutely free. So if you're looking for good wireless coverage and you're looking to work with a company that shares your rights and puts their money where their mouth is, well then please join me at Patriot Mobile by going to patriotmobile.com/slash constitution. Find a plan and discount that works for you. And don't forget, use that code Constitution to checkout to continue online activate absolutely free. I also hope you'll head over to AmericaOutloud.news. Why? Let's face it, corporate media has been lying
to us for decades and they've been caught. We live in the information age. We can get information from all different sources. And we still have to vet them, right? We still have to make sure that what they're telling us is true. Now, one of the places I trust is AmericaOutloud.news. Why? Well, I think they've earned my trust because I've been able to verify what they say, and what I found is generally true. So please join me to AmericaOutloud.news every day. Read the stories, read the articles, but then do like
I do, share them. Share them with friends, with family, with neighbors. Hey, share them with your representatives, your state, local, even federal representatives. Watch the podcasts or the videos. Share them as well. Share them on social media, share them with community and civic groups. See, when you share the information, you'd be surprised how often someone says, I never knew about that. So when you share this information, when you share the news that other people don't want to get out, you're not just sharing America Out Loud Death News. You're
helping to secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the globe, although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Beer bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contains six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit or
held together with syrups or sweeteners. But bear bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash outlouds and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash outlouds. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an
ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self-Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com
slash outloud and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides that help repair and restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue, which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root cause, literally. Visit twc.health forward slash
outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair regrowth with roots. Welcome back, everyday American Jeffrey. Join the Constitution study. And well, today we even talk about crime and punishment. And I've got a story here. I don't know about you. This made me mad. And uh I'm gonna use a term, I know some people are gonna be mad about it. Some people are thinking I'm
going too far, but um, I think it's based on the information I have so far, it's an accurate description. Kidnapping, state-based legalized kidnapping. I was born in the empire state. I was born in New York City, lived most of my life in the city. I understand the the it was it's the empire, and it runs like but that is nothing compared to what is going on right now in Massachusetts.
This this family, Joseph and Arlene Kutzo, um say when their daughter was 15 years old, Massachusetts state-run, government-run public schools began socially transitioning their 15-year-old daughter Sophie behind their backs. Staff decided to give her a male name, use male pronouns, they treated her as a boy, they didn't get parental permission, they didn't even inform their parents.
That's bad enough. However, when these parents refused to claim their daughter was a boy, when they refused to affirm that she's a boy, the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families, uh Families took their daughter. This should be the this is the Department of Kidnapping. They stole, they kidnapped her their daughter, because they said she's a girl, not a boy. She's a daughter, not a son. Now,
somewhere, somebody came up with allegations of physical abuse against the father. Yet that was found to be completely unfounded, right? So whoever came up with this physical abuse nonsense, whoever lied to DCF, whoever lied in court, they were found completely unfounded. You would think at that point, well, okay, let's return this young girl to her home. No, the state got a permanent restraining order against the mother, the father, and her older
brother. And since 2024, this family has been broken up because the state of Massachusetts kidnapped the daughter and got a court to claim an imprimatur of legitimacy. Absolute, this is absolutely horrendous. Now, the parents, they got they got an attorney. According to the attorney, this young girl has been housed in a boys'
dormitory. She's been denied Sunday Mass. Her her family is Roman Catholic. She's been placed on birth control and psychiatric medication. Stop for a second. If they really thought she was a boy, why would she need birth control in a boy's dormitory? They've got her on psychiatric medication. They're treating her for a psychosis, for a mental disorder while encouraging the mental disorder. They gave her a male name.
They are indoctrinating. The state of Massachusetts is indoctrinating this girl into her mental disorder, claiming that uh she's a boy when she's actually a girl. And now the DCF, they've gone to court, they want permission to put this girl on hormone therapy to give her high dose testosterone, and her parents object. She's a girl. That level of testosterone is not only
dangerous mentally, it is physically dangerous. It is it is medically detrimental to the girl. Now a judge has blocked it, but only temporarily. Let me say that. Only temporary. So you have DCF kidnap this child. They got a court to pretend it was legal, and now when they're when they want to effectively poison this girl, a judge is blocked but only temporarily.
Ladies and gentlemen, this is not being compassionate. This is not gender-affirming care. This is gender denying care. This is government overreach to the nth degree. Tell me, how is it any different than what Dr. Mengele did back in Nazi Germany? We're going to steal a child from a family, we're going to treat them, we're going to give them medication to deal with a mental condition, and we're going to give them hormones which
are known to be damaging in those levels to women, all because of an ideology. Now, do you live in Massachusetts? Then you should be concerned that Massachusetts, in this case, seems much more like Nazi Germany than the birthplace of liberty in North America. Remember, it was Boston where you had the massacre, you had the Tea Party, you had all of these, you had some of our
first faltering steps into liberty that has now kidnapped a child, brainwashed a child, medically transitioned a child in violation, and the parents have done nothing wrong. The only accusation made against the parents that would justify removing a child from the home was found to be unfounded. There was no basis for it. It was frivolous. It was literally, it should that should be criminal.
And now the state agency has taken over a child. I want to see some crimes and punishment for this. I think DCF, the agent DCF, they should face criminal charges of kidnapping. I think whatever judge issued that permanent injunction without any evidence of an actual crime by the parents. Any evidence that the parents were har that the parents were harming the child, oh, well, they didn't agree with her. That's because they're telling the truth.
Why isn't that judge facing criminal penalties? Why isn't DCF patient criminal criminals attempting to poison the child? You can't say that, Paul. The hell I can't say that. That's what's happening. And the more people uh sit down and shut up because they're afraid soon. Well, you can't say that, the more this type of nonsense is going to happen. Do you remember the case of uh Zashana Giavola, uh Gaviola? Uh she's facing federal kidnapping charges. Why? Well,
because she uh violated a restraining order. Her teenage son was being indoctrinated into a transgender lifestyle. She took him from California to a boarding school in Missouri in order to keep him away from the people that were quote-unquote mentally transitioning him. These are government actors, ladies and gentlemen. Do you know what that tells me? It tells me that at least in Massachusetts and California, your children aren't safe. And the threat isn't the predator on isn't just the predator on
the street. It isn't just the child molester that's on some list. The threat is the state. Why do you think we have a Second Amendment to defend us from this type of craziness? Am I saying we should take up arms? I'm saying that we should defend that family. I'm saying that we should be standing up and and and pushing back on Massachusetts and and pointing out the legal insanity that's going on there.
And until we do, this is gonna keep going on. So that's the coast. That's that's Massachusetts and California. What about more of the heartland? Kansas City, Kansas. See, Unified School District No. 500 has a policy, and they've had it since 2017. They have a policy for transgender and gender non-conforming students. This policy pressures pressures school officials to use preferred names and pronouns, at least according to
a complaint filed by the federal government, claiming that this policy violates the Federal Educational Rights and Privacy Act. FERPOP, as it's called. Why? Because it takes away parents' rights to access and review and oversee their child's education. See, they don't tell the the under the school policy, school officials will evaluate gender transitions. And if a student does not want to involve their parents,
they don't. Now again, I'm not for federal I I believe FERP is a f is is um I'm torn. Because on the one hand, you know, uh education rights, but I do see this as protecting parents' rights and a right under the 14th Amendment to not be determined to liberty of raising their child and overseeing their education because of a political nonsense like this uh school district 500's policy that thinks boys can be girls and girls can be boys
and parents can't be involved. That's just another form of kidnapping. In this case, it's mental, not physical. But we're saying we're going to establish a policy, and the parents don't get to know. They don't have to be involved. That's another, like I said, that's mental kidnapping. That's brainwashing. You know what that is? That's cultish behavior. Yeah. I'm telling you. State of
Massachusetts, state of California, the Kansas City School District number 500, they've formed cults. And they're getting people into the cult, and they're not letting concerned people around them access to them to protect them from the cult. Is your child uh being uh indoctrinated into a cult? Are they being brainwashed into a cult? Even if they don't believe they're transgender, are they being uh brainwashed into the idea that boys can become girls just because they
think so? That if you think it, the world will magically change around you to make your thoughts come true? Is that the cult that has been established? I'm beginning to think uh that that this whole transgender nonsense is not is is part mental disorder, part cult. The people who have who who who think they're the wrong gender, they have a mental disorder. But the cult are the people around them that encourage this, that promote this, that protect this, that literally
devote themselves with religious fervor to the insane and asinine idea that you can change your gender because you think you do. And I see this so often. I I I I'm working on an article out in two, three weeks, um about uh an Alaska Airlines case uh out of the Ninth Circuit where they fire two of their employees for simply commenting and asking questions about the airlines' support of
um well of transgenderism, of of the Equality Act, which enshrines transgenderism as a protected class. Even questioning that they called discriminatory and hateful and harassing. We live in La La Land. It's crazy. And one more tidbit, thankfully we'll get it away from the LGBT, but you know, we keep talking about we've talked about the mail-in ballots, we've talked about uh uh you know voter integrity laws and and having free,
fair, free, open, and transparent um elections in the past. Well, there's another one in the in the heart of Texas, back on September 15th, officials uh uh law enforcement officials arrested seven non-citizens who were indicted for voter fraud in the 2024 election. Texas, not Massachusetts or New York, not California, Oregon, or Washington, Texas. Now, six of these people are lawful
permanent residents, right? They have their green cards from several different countries. One, though, is an illegal alien, a convicted felon, nonetheless, who had previously been deported. Now, once again, we look at the Constitution of the state of Texas. Uh things article one uh I'm sorry, no, Article 6, Section 2, uh reads every person subject to none of the disqualifications provided by in section one of this article or by a law enacted under the that section, who is
a citizen of the United States and who is a resident of this state shall be deemed a qualified voter. That's right. You have to be a citizen of the United States and Texas to vote in any election. So seven, again, in the size of Texas, is seven non-residents a problem? It's it's not a huge problem. But you know what happens when you don't deal with little problems? You know what happens when you don't deal with little infections? They get to be big infections, they get to be serious problems.
And it's even in Texas. I'm glad they were arrested. I the went to see them be charged. Um they probably should all be deported. I don't have all the details on the cases, so I'll reserve a little bit of judgment on that. But again, every time someone says it's well, it's only seven, yeah. Well, how much how much uh uh how much dung do you want in your oatmeal? How much dung will you do with your oatmeal? People go crazy when they found rat poop and hot
dogs. What happens to the rat poop in the voting? Now listen, if you've heard all this and you say and and and you want to figure out, well, I Paul, I really need to study the constitution more. How do I go about doing that? Well, my answer is gonna be it depends, because it really depends on you know how much have you studied? Uh, what are your goals? So I created The Constitution Study. Just go to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard and uh check it out. You'll um uh you'll you'll it'll ask you for your name and email address because it's
gonna email you some suggestions and then it asks you a series of questions. You know, when was the last time you read the Constitution? Um, have you read any other things like the Federalist or Anti-Federalist papers? Even, hey, what are your goals? And based on your answers, the system will generate some suggestions of things you might try. Now, the wisdom is free. Many of the suggestions are free. And oh, by the way, I look at every entry. So if I see something specific, I I will also send you uh my comments as well. All free and all designed simply to help you think of well, here's a
suggestion of what you might try next. Hopefully, it opens up some ideas and will get you to read and study the Constitution, whether you've never done it before or whether you've done it and you want to figure out what you should look at next. All those are suggestions there. Again, find that at constitutionstudy.com/slash wizard. Now, I also hope you come back and join us here for the Constitution Study on America Out Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern Time. Listen on our media player or we have apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, you
can also listen via podcast. It does take a day or two for an episode to go from talk radio to podcast, but you get to listen to your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcast. It helps the algorithm share the Constitution study with more people who hopefully will click the link and join us here. Speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news. But please share those links, share this program, and help
share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...