Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY artwork

The Constitution’s forgotten promise: Government has limits

Sep 19, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Unique in world history, the Constitution of the United States not only established what we now call the federal government, but gives We the People tools to both defend and assert our rights. That has not stopped Congress from passing laws and creating agencies in violation of the supreme law of the land. Sadly though, most...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Out Loud Network with your host, Paul English. Happy Constitution Day. That's right. 239 years ago today, 38 men signed the proposed constitution, sending it to the states for ratification. Well, hello there, everyday

Americans. Paul Engle here with the Constitution Study, where we read instead of the Constitution. Teacher Ison Generation be free. Cloud, you could join me today. You know, Constitution Day. It is, believe it or not, a federally recognized holiday, although it's not a day off, but it there is a constitution day. There's actually a constitution week defined in the federal calendar. And uh it's something we don't even think about. We don't talk about. Most people don't celebrate Constitution Day, but we do here at the Constitution study. Why? Well, because it's so important to our lives, to

our rights, to our freedoms, to our liberties. So we like to celebrate it here. We like to remember what happened. I want to back up a little bit because I've seen, you know, this is the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. And I saw a lot of people make a lot of, we'll just call them wrong statements based on a misunderstanding about the finding of this country. And I talked about it back in July, so I'll talk about it here now. And September being it's Constitution Day. So on July 4th,

1776, um the Second Continental Congress announced the Declaration of Independence. That's when they presented it to the people. Now it wasn't signed, well, it wasn't signed on that day. In fact, it was signed, originally signed on July 2nd. That's when they voted to uh adopt the Lee Resolution. Uh that's when they voted to uh um uh the the the fourth is when they voted to accept the document, part of the lee resolution, which they decided to

create a document to explain why we were declaring independence. But the United States of America did not exist on July 4th, 1776. It did not come into being until the Articles of Confederation, 1777, when they said the style or the name of this union would be called the United States of America. That's where that phrase, that term actually come from. It wasn't a Declaration of Independence, it was the Articles of Confederation. And that

those articles did not work, they did not function as promised. So the Continental Congress got together. Uh, the the there was a second continental second continental congress, they got together. Um, original plan was to modify to amend the uh uh the Articles of Confederation. There were some problems though. Uh, first of all, under the Articles of Confederation, to amend them required a unanimous consent of all the parties. And that was gonna be really hard to get. But there was

more. When they looked at the um, when they looked at the actual uh articles of Confederation, they said there's there's a there are structural problems here. So each of the states sent they each state 13 states and had sent delegations to the uh second continental congress. They sent back and said, Hey, can we try rewriting this to make it better? Those rather than you know putting lipstick on this pick, can we rewrite it? And the state said yes, as long as we get

the it doesn't take effect until we ratify it. So that led to the drafting of the constitution. And uh one of the parts of the constitution, Article 7, said the ratification of the conventions of nine states shall be sufficient for the establishment of this constitution between the states so ratifying the same. Meaning, in order for the constitution to take effect, at least nine states, every state was going to have a ratification convention, and at least nine of those states had to

ratify it in order for the constitution to go into effect, but it would only affect the states that actually ratified it. A lot of people talk about uh a runaway convention. Um, no, the the uh uh the delegates went back to get permission from their states to drafting to attempt drafting a new constitution. Um, they didn't impose the constitution on any state. If a state's convention did not ratify the constitution, it was not bound by the constitution. And that's one of the reasons why

there were so many compromises built into the constitution in order to ensure that um uh uh that they could get a unanimous states to to sign this. They wanted all the the states to sign on. They didn't want to kind of leave some under the constitution, some under the Articles of Confederation. It would have made a mess. That's kind of way, and again, that led to a lot of compromises, some of which have been fixed over history, some of which not so much.

But again, it was a big deal. It was it. This is what created the federal government we understand today. The the uh uh the the the previous government, they didn't call it the federal government. Um, what did they call it? They called it the uh confederation government, I think, had a a legislature with a single body in it, uh, didn't have a lot of the powers we think of the federal government having. Not what they actually exercise today, what they uh uh actually have. There were the federal government was basically an

agreement, a bunch of friends getting together, and they didn't really have any power over each other. And the Constitution of the United States gave the federal government some power, some teeth behind the expectations. One of the biggest limitations of the Articles of Confederation was the the central government had duties, but it had no power. I mean, that's like saying here, go out and uh and uh arrest somebody. You've got no power to actually do it. You can't actually enforce any law, but go do it anyway. That's kind of where they

were went. Um, that kind of led to some of their problems. But again, they said, let's fix this. Again, constitution is not perfect. It's been uh it's been amended 27 times, uh, one of which was repealing a previous amendment that was bad. But again, we've worked on this, and and we ended up with this document that, although not perfect, really created the framework by which the United States and the states and its people could thrive and prosper the way we

did. I believe it was Madison that said the Constitution gave the central government uh uh power primarily over foreign affairs and left the states to deal with domestic affairs. In other words, the federal government dealt with you know foreign commerce and commerce between the states and and and things like that. The states themselves were to deal with their own internal domestic policies. Um the the it it it created a system that, well, in addition to just creating a nation

that had that could use the resources we have and use them to great effect, um, you know, provided the the freedom to decide what did you want to do. Now again, it wasn't perfect, right? We still at this point we still have slavery in the south. And uh, you know, a lot of people claim that the constitution was built on slavery. I I argue that. Um, for example, the three-fifths clause was actually an attempt to restrain slavery in the in the states, because uh, you know, in

order to get all the states to sign on, the slave states had to have some count had to count some of their slaves, they wanted to count all their slaves as their population, as if they were human beings, to uh account for it to count in the census. However, that would give them a lot of power. They they wanted them treated as you, they didn't want to treat them as human beings, they want them counted as human beings, which led to the three-fifths compromise. You only get to count three-fifths of people who are not free. And that's been misrepresented many times over the years. But if

you read the three-fifths clause, uh it's Article 1, Section 2, Clause 3, representative and direct taxes shall be a portion among the several states which may be included in this union according to their respective numbers, which shall be determined by adding the whole number of free persons, including those bound to service for a time of years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three-fifths of all other persons. So if you are a free person, you are counted in the census. If you are an Indian not taxed, then you didn't count in the census. And if you are not a free person,

it says nothing about race. If you are not a three per a free person, they only counted three-fifths of those. And the express purpose was to make sure that slave states didn't hold undue influence in the house to perpetuate slavery, and it would uh eventually, they hoped, die out. Now, sadly, it didn't work that way. Um, it didn't die until there was a war, but this was their their the what they set up. Uh, they also, under Article 1, Section 9, clause 1, the migration or importation of such

persons as any of the states now existing shall think proper to admit, shall not be prohibited by the Congress prior to the year 1808, but a tax or duty may be imposed on such importation, not excess exceeding ten dollars for each person. So the whole idea of the slave trade, they said, listen, okay, in a concession to the slave states, we're not going to allow Congress to write a law prohibiting the importation or migration of slaves until the year

1808. Right? They wanted to give them time. There was 20 years when they knew that there would be no prohibition on this on importing slaves. So that the states again, they didn't prepare, it didn't stop. Uh, so it took a while. It's a human document, it's not gonna be perfect. But you think about what had happened. 1787, um, you have the um the the Constitution is

drafted, it's send it to the sent to the states for ratification. Of course, that came into a whole nother set of issues, right? The constitution almost was not ratified because the anti-federalists were upset there was no protection of individual rights. So uh the first handful of states ratified the constitution quickly, then they kind of hit a snag as more and more of the anti-federalists saying, wait a second, there's no protection of rights here. And that was an interesting argument because, well, they said, listen, what's to prevent the

federal government from infringing on people's rights? And again, the federalists said, Well, listen, we've given no power to the federal government to infringe on people's rights. And if you write them down, if you come up with a list of rights, well, some fool in the future is going to figure they can regulate them. All right, I'm paraphrasing, but that was kind of the general idea. And what did we see? Well, they said, okay, um, the Massachusetts compromise, the Massachusetts delegation said we will ratify this constitution if in the first session of Congress you propose a Bill of

Rights. Um, it it passed, it was ratified by Massachusetts. Many of the other slate states turned around and did the same thing, and that's why we end up A with a Bill of Rights, and B, why it's not part of the original Constitution. But it I find it interesting that it appears that both sides of that debate were correct by you know but by writing down, by specifically protecting our rights, that has been used again for centuries as a power to defend our rights. But it's also been

used by many a politician to say, well, see, we can we can regulate our rights. I just had uh uh somebody um make a comment today about the the Second Amendment. Only the first 13 words matter. You know, a well-regulated militia being necessary to security of a free state. They just ignored the rest of the state, the rest of the rest of the amendment. And of course, I made a comment on their comment, but that's the you know, somebody got the idea we could regulate this, it's in there, see? Of course, they ignore the part that says

the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Again, that gets ignored. So uh we both sides have that's why I look at this, it's an interesting history. And uh to me it's an it's I I you think of of of what we take for granted today. You know, I heard of another uh case going to the Supreme Court about a First Amendment issue. Of course, people can't read the First Amendment because First Amendment says Congress shall make no law. But think

of those things, think of the things we hold dear, right? Freedom of religion, speech, press, peaceable assembly, the petition of government for readers of grievance, a right to keep and bear arms, our due process rights, everything from being secure from unreasonable searches and seizures to uh uh having a right to counsel, uh to compel witnesses, um, you know, all of those things are fundamental to the rights we think of as Americans, and they wouldn't have existed most likely without the

Constitution and then the fight for the Bill of Rights. Now, I doubt most people are actually celebrating Constitution Day. I don't think there's gonna be parades or memorial services. Maybe there are, but whether the people as a whole are celebrating or not, let's you and I take this time and celebrate the Constitution of the United States. Celebrate the men that, again, though not perfect, created a pretty awesome document. A document based on a a

framework of ideas, not specific laws. Right? It was it was it dealt with general concepts. The right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, not okay, you can have these arms, but not these arms. That you'd be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures. What makes a search reasonable? Well, you've got the warrant clause, you need a warrant, but are there other situations that are reasonable? And who defines what is reasonable? Right? It was not a set of specific laws.

It was meant to establish this framework. It created the federal government, but the Bill of Rights was all about protecting certain rights, uh, or I should say, establishing a framework of rights to be protected. And the Constitution, in addition to um, again, creating the federal government, they also limited the powers of the federal government. Congress, under Article 1, Section 8, only has the power to make laws which are necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing powers and all

other powers vested by this constitution in the government of the United States or any department thereof. Congress cannot make laws unless it's executing a power vested by the Constitution in the government of the United States. That hasn't stopped them, but there's power there. And I think that's one of the things that we the people need to remember. So under a form of government, the people collectively are sovereign. It's not the federal government, it's not the president, it's not the Congress, it's the people. We hire people to represent

us. It's important that we act as uh as though that that again, group sovereign. I'm talking about I'm not talking about sovereign citizens who think that they individually are above the law. I'm talking about as a group where it's recognized that the people of the United States are sovereign, we're the ones that oversee the Constitution, we're the ones that oversee our governments, we're the ones that create our governments, and I think this would be a good day to not only remind ourselves of that fact, but to ask ourselves how can we live our lives

following the Supreme Law of the Land rather than simply going along to get along. And uh again, there's some interesting stuff that I think is gonna come out of that. Now, I've got some other things I want to look at, but before I go, I have to take a break. I want to remind you though, you know, proper preparations prevents poor performance. I use that line a lot, but what do I mean? I mean you have to prepare for what might happen, not just hope it won't happen. Now, how

do I do that? Well, part of what I do is I prepare for situations that may involve the protection of my rights. Uh, around my house, I've got, uh, and in my car, I've got uh fire extinguishers and first aid kits and and even uh trauma kits in many cases. Are you prepared for what happens if something happens and you can't get help right away? Like it's a weekend or a holiday and you can't get to the doctor's office, urgent care is backed up out the door, the the emergency room is overflowing. Our friends at the wellness company have

come up with a set of emergency kits designed to help you in those situations. From basic medical emergencies and first aid to problems with travel and kids. Head to AmericaOutloud.shop and click on the emergency series. Take a look at these kits. These are not the kits you buy in the in the pharmacy, these are prescription level medications that you may need, and it's got a guidebook to help you use them. Best of all, if you use a code outloud at checkout, you get 20% off of all of your order. So if you want to

prepare for emergencies or just little things that may cause your life, uh make your life difficult, head to AmericaOutloud.shop and click on the emergency series. Look at what's in these different kits, figure out which one works best for you and your family, sign up today. And by the way, don't forget that code out loud to get 20% off of your order. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company, and I know this personally.

So I began asking a different question. What can we do daily to support the body before something goes wrong? That question led me to formulate SHIELD. SHIELD is a two-part nutraceutical system designed to support immune balance, antioxidant defense, and cellular health, a chemical-free cocoa mix and soft gels containing medicinal mushrooms, turmeric, green tea extract, olive leaf, berberine, and black seed oil. Prevention is power. Visit TWC.health slash outloud and use code Outloud for an exclusive

discount. During treatment, City Tap Water Molecule structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get

one for your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. And I'm also a father with a three-year-old daughter. And that's why we grow sprouts. Did you know that you could take seeds, add water, and get fresh organic vegetables in three to five days without soil, sunshine, or fertilizer for under a dollar a serving? That's the

miracle of sprouting, and I want to share that with you. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code outloud for a special offer. Well did you see Google finally updated its AIP principle to remove it? Do not use AIPOS survey.

Today we're celebrating Constitution Day. And sadly, the Constitution is very frequently ignored, not just by those in government, but by the people of the United States. And probably the biggest way it gets ignored is by the uh allowing Congress to make laws they're not legally authorized to make. And most people just don't even know there's a problem. They know what they may know what's wrong, but they don't understand the constitutionality of it. And the problem you have is again, when you when you have these big government programs, well,

no one's held accountable for malfeasance, at least not usually. For example, uh the Treasury Department recently identified $17.5 billion, billion with a B, in suspicious financial activity that they claim is linked to health care fraud. Uh Treasury Secretary Bessant said in a statement: by identifying and reporting this suspicious activity, financial institutions have given law enforcement critical insight into the illicit actors who deliberately exploit U.S. health care benefit programs. I.e., federal

government created an illegal healthcare program. Constitution doesn't authorize the United States to fund health care, to provide health care, to subsidize health care, to spend money on healthcare. So that whole program is um embezzlement. It's it's it's its own version of fraud. But then again, of course, it gets out to the people, and there are people that are um uh that are again committing fraud against the federal government, which means they're committing fraud against you and I. Now, that's $17.5 billion is not all money that went out the

door. Some of it was attempted transactions that were flagged and and having to deal with this. Now, the other thing they noted is where are the largest amount of these uh of this fraud coming from? Well, California, yeah, that was a big one, Puerto Rico, Florida, New York, and Minnesota. Uh, and they claim that uh over something like a percent and a half are actually living overseas. These have foreign addresses. Now, again, you can't say this is all a

left-right issue. You got Florida in there, but again, where do you see the largest populations? Where you tend to see a lot a lot of this of this fraud. And I'm not saying fraud wouldn't happen if the federal government wasn't involved, but guess what? It wouldn't be going after your federal tax dollars, might be going after state tax dollars, but then again, the the impact would be smaller. But that hasn't stopped Congress from creating these illegal agencies and these illegal funds and just bribing the American people with their own money.

There was De Tocqueville said that that would be the end of the Republic when Congress figured out that they could bribe the people with their own money. For example, Dr. Oz, right, Dr. Mehmet Oz, uh, the uh administrator of the Medicaid and Medicare, uh, he made uh an announcement. He was in during interview, he made a statement. He says Medicare costs are gonna increase. Now, let's back that up for a second. So, yeah, I expect medical costs to increase. Why? Well, we have inflation, uh, the

government keeps debasing the money, whether it's in small part or in large part. Uh, so the money is worth less, therefore, things cost more. That's that's true. But remember, the cost of Medicaid and Medicare are taken from the American people illegally. This is the law that created Medicaid and Medicare. Congress did was was not uh exercising or putting into execution a power invested in the government of the United States. They made

it up. But they said they bribe the American, here we're gonna give you money. We're gonna, if you you know, you you have an elderly family member, we'll pay for their care, their care. We'll get some other schlub in in the United States to pay for it because they'll take it out of your taxes. You don't want to help the poor, fine, we'll take care of it for you. We'll just take it out of your tax dollars and in violation of the Supreme Law of the Land. So that's problem number one. Problem number two, with a program the size of Medicaid and Medicare, you have to wonder

just how efficiently can this program possibly run? The the the opportunities are not just for fraud and abuse, like we were seeing in the in the previous article from the Treasury Secretary, but just the efficiencies of government. Let's face it, government is only efficient at one thing, wasting your money. Everything else they do, they're not that efficient at it. They are they they they can run a military. How efficient is the military? When you talk, we when we start looking at at how they spend money. So now you have the

the federal government saying, we're gonna pass a law to steal money from you to pay for things we're not legally allowed to pay. That's called embezzlement. Um, and then we're going to keep expanding it. And now, when people are in a crunch, they're saying, well, listen, gas prices are through the roof, diesel prices are through the roof, that makes everything more expensive. Oh, by the way, guess what? Uncle Sam's gonna be holding their hand out because they want to steal more of your money to spend it on things they're not legally authorized to spend it on. Now, don't get me wrong, I agree that as a

society, we individually have a duty to take care of the elderly and the indigent. We have a moral duty, not a legal duty, a moral duty. I had this debate with uh with my grandfather, actually, um back when uh uh uh well this is decades ago, and we were talking about Social Security. And uh I laughed because he said, Well, he wanted Social Security because uh he wanted social security increases so that he could live without being a burden on his sons. He was my my grandmother's second husband,

and so we weren't related to that with those of his sons. He goes, but I said, Where do you think your Social Security is getting this money? I mean, you've burned through more than you've paid into it, right? Yep. So where's that money coming from? Well, among other people, your sons. It's this idea that someone else is paying for it. And it just doesn't work that way. So this these these bribes of um uh uh you know, we'll we'll get somebody else to pay for it, not realizing that they keep telling other people that you're gonna pay for

it. And of course, again, the government doesn't do a very good job of it, so you end up with this um this program, this behemoth, this beast that is driving between Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security, is driving a large part of our deficit, which means it's driving the United States into debt, which means you as a per as a citizen of the United States, you owe money, you hold uh tens of thousands of dollars individually because of what the government has spent that they can't pay for in order to

give you stuff that they can't afford to give you. Anyone else see a problem with all of this? Well, I see a problem. The problem comes to the fact that um we let Congress do what they're not legally authorized to do, and we sat back and didn't do anything about it because of the promise of free stuff. So I keep laying this in the in the laps of the American people. A lot of people like to point at the Democrats or the Republicans or the federal government or this program or that program, but understand the people that created these programs all work for

us. We hired them. The people in the House of Representatives were all hired by the people, and after since 1913, every member of the Senate has been hired by the people of that state. We hired these people that passed these illegal laws, and we've done nothing to hold them accountable. And that seems to be the problem. Now, this idea of wanting other people's money, it's it's it's common in human rights, all right? But there are some people that like that seem to just love to exploit it.

Uh take, for example, uh there's two uh state represent state uh legislators in New Jersey. Uh uh a Verlina Reynolds Jackson, who is a state assemblywoman, and a state senator uh Angela McKnight. She's again, she's a state senator, and they have a proposal that they want all of New Jersey to adopt. And among those that proposal, those policy changes, they want to have direct reparation payments to all of their black residents, even if

they aren't the descendant of slaves. So these two legislators are sponsoring a bill known as the Truth, Reconciliation, and Repair Act of New Jersey. I believe the name is a bunch of hogwash, but uh the bill reads the recent report of the New Jersey Reparations Council tells the often overlooked and largely unknown story of slavery in New Jersey and outlines a clear, compelling, and courageous path forward, the development of meaningful policies that address the racial wealth gap,

invest in black communities, and confront the systemic inequities that still exist in this state. Okay, let's back this up for a second, because this is supposed to be about truth. And you're right, we don't focus on slavery in the northern states because it was primarily something that happened in the southern states. There was slavery in the northern states, absolutely true. It did not disappear, it slowly died, but it didn't disappear with the Constitution. That's absolutely true. Um, and uh the when you talk about the the racial

wealth gap, you know what I often wonder here is, well, have you done any investigation onto what actually caused the racial wealth gap? Because when you do some research, I I love the research from Thomas Sowell. Uh, for those who don't know, he is a black economist who does a lot of reason uh of research, and he said, you know what? Uh during the 1940s and 50s, during you know, things like Jim Crow and and and the before the civil rights movement, um there was the the the financial disparity between black

and white communities was not as heavy, not as much as it was as it is today. There still was some, but it was it was smaller than what's today. And in fact, the the wealth gap didn't seem to be a qu a portion of of slavery, because again, in the 40s and 50s, slavery was dead. Uh granted, we still had you know Jim Crow in some of those states, but yeah, you know, you know what seems to correlate a lot closer to the the racial wealth gap? The destruction of the family, especially in in black and

hispanic neighborhoods, where the the government, the state decided you don't need a father in the house, we'll provide, we'll encourage women to just simply pop out babies, we don't care who the father is, the father doesn't need to be in the home, we'll take care of them. And that seems to have led to a lot more of the racial wealth gap. But if you want to tie this to slavery, then I have two simple questions. Actually, they're both related. Why are you looking to take money from people who never own slaves to pay to people who are not the descendants of slaves?

If that's the case, this has nothing to do with slavery, this has to do with greed. I want somebody else's money, and this is an excuse for somebody else's money. This is a racist attack on society, not just white people, on society as a whole. We want money from you because we feel like our ancestors had a bad had a bad time. I ask you, um, why would you give, say, would you give reparations if he lived in New Jersey? Would you give reparations to Barack Obama?

I mean, obviously he was president of the United States, he's uh a multimillionaire. Um, does he deserve reparations because his father was black? And of course, there's one other question I want to ask here. So let's say you come up, you you you throw money at these families, which by the way, have been trained by the government policies to simply be dependent on others. How long do you think that any money you throw at them is going to help them survive? How long do

you think that money's gonna last? Let me ask you a similar question. Do you know how long? I think it's about seven years it takes for a big lottery winner to go bankrupt. On average, if you win one of these big lotteries, people go bankrupt, regardless of race. In between seven and ten years, I believe, is the last number I remember. Now maybe that number is wrong, but I know a significant percentage of them go bankrupt. Why? Well, it's because poverty is not simply a lack of money, it's a lack of understanding how to deal

with money. When my wife and I got married, we didn't have a lot of money. I was using a borrowed vehicle. Um, we we you know we could we could barely get by, but we had been we had grown both grown up learning how to deal with money, and we were able to grow ourselves as we got older to a much better place here that we are now, after, well, let's see, 38 years of marriage than we were when we first got married. But if you don't learn those lessons, that money

disappears. In other words, throwing money at the problem doesn't fix the problem because uh I believe a lot of the problems in these neighborhoods are are dealt by people who are become dependent, who have in fact become enslaved to these government programs, to the point where rather than trying to find ways to improve their situation, they simply are looking for ways to um well better to to better scan the system. How do we how do we how do

we scan the system in order to uh uh make things better? That to me would be a question that's worth uh worth looking into. I mean, are we fixing the problem or are we just playing games with the with the symptoms? Now, I have another break coming up before I go though, you know, it's not just the the people looking to reach your hands into your pocket. Our rights, our liberties, our very foundation of our ability to live free is under attack. And it's under

attack not just by government, but by organizations that are trying to get government to well infringe on your rights. Are you helping to fund those that are attacking your right to live free? You may be and not even realize it, because there are plenty of corporations. If you look at where they donate their money, they're donating to organizations that, well, they're supporting reparations, they're supporting uh taking away your rights, getting government to do more and more in your life. If you don't want to support them, well, join me at the only Christian conservative waters provider this nation has,

Patriot Mobile. Use your cell phone to defend not just your rights, but the rights of your family, including your right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Join me at Patriot Mobile today, get free activation with the offer code CONSTOUTION. Just go to patriotmobile.comslash constitution, find a plan that works for you, see if you're eligible for discount. Uh NRA members, uh veterans, first responders, even families with multiple lines are eligible for discounts. Don't forget, you got that code CONSTOUN at checkout to get activation absolutely free

as well. So if you love great cell phone service, great customer support, they've got great 4G and 5G service across the entire country, they've got a 100% US-based customer support. I joined them because they take a portion of every dollar and they fight uh support organizations that are fighting for your rights. Uh NRA, Turning Point, uh uh and others. And now, by the way, that includes the Constitution Study, which means if you go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution and you sign up for a plan, when you pay your

cell phone bill, you're helping to support the work that we're doing here at the Constitution Study. Don't forget that code constitution and checkout gets you free activation. So you get great cell phone coverage, good, great customer support, and support organizations that are defending your rights. Seems like a pretty good deal to me. So please join me at patriotmobile.comslash constitution. Find a plan and discount that works for you, and don't forget, get free activation with the offer code Constitution at checkout. I also hope you'll join me at americautloud.news. We live in the information age. Information is literally at our

fingertips. You know, you think about it, you can have the sum of human knowledge right there on your cell phone. But where do you go? Who do you trust for news? Who do you trust to get information from? One of the places I trust is AmericaOutloud.news. Why? Well, I've seen the work that they do, but I've also been able to verify the work that they do. And it's more important than ever that you and I do our part. We need to make sure that we're getting good news and verifying that what we're being told is true. So again, join me. I go every day to Americautloud.news and

please read the stories, read the articles, but then share them with friends and family and neighbors. Watch the video, listen to a podcast, maybe take it to a social group or post on social media, maybe a civic group. See, by sharing this information, you're not just sharing AmericaOutloud.news, you're helping to secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. Oral hygiene hasn't changed in 50 years. Brushed, flossed, repeat. We're told to use fluoride, which doesn't really address the

acid-creating bacteria. That is where the dentist-recommeded spry dental defense system shines. Spry products contain xylitol, a natural sugar, which helps get rid of those nasty, smelly acid-creating bacteria in our mouth. The best way to care for your teeth and gums is by using spry. The spray dental defense system has a wide variety of products: toothpaste, mouthwash, mints, and chewing gums that are designed to work together to keep your teeth clean and mouth healthy and smelling sweet all day long. To

get your oral care back on track in an easy, effective, and very tasty way. Switch to spray today. Ask your dentist about xylitol and the spry products. Spry can be found online and at all fine natural product retailers. Are you looking for healthy snacks? But you've had enough of all the sweet, sugary energy bars? Good news, there's new bars to try. That's savory, crunchy, and packed with goodness.

Bear bars are based just on six simple natural ingredients. A certified organic veggie, nut, and seed bar. That's low temp dried, never baked or fried. Bear bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bearbar.com slash outloud and get the exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners. That's B E A R B A

R dot com forward slash out loud. Welcome back, everyday Americans. You've rejoined the Constitution study. Today we're celebrating Constitution Day. And of course, part of the Constitution was the Bill of Rights was were amendments after that. And you know, some of those amendments caused a lot of controversy and a lot of enthusiasm. I'm reminded of the words of Noel Webster, who said, before a standing army can rule, the people must be disarmed,

as they are in almost every kingdom of Europe. The Supreme Power in America cannot enforce unjust laws by the sword because a whole body of the people are armed and constitute a force superior to any bands of regular troops that can be, on any pretense, raised in the United States. A military force of the command of Congress can execute no laws but such as the people perceive to be just and constitutional, for they will possess the power and just jealously will instantly inspire the inclination to resist the execution of a law which appears to them unjust and oppressive.

In other words, being armed helps control government. It's not about hunting, right? Bambi's not coming after your guns. It's preventing government from passing unjust laws. Now, again, I was born and raised in New York State. When it comes to gun laws, there are a lot of unjust laws. Recently, the Supreme Court said states like New York had to allow non-residents to get some sort of license to carry a firearm. Um, it's it is a violation of their rights to prevent

them from carrying simply because they don't reside inside your state. Well, as frequently happens in New York, they they like to play a little fast and loose with how that goes. You see, New York City places a limit on non-resident concealed carry handgun licenses to being only to register a single firearm, and that's the only firearm they're allowed to carry under that license. Now, when I lived in New York, I get I eventually got a carry license. And yeah, you had to license, you had to take each and every handgun you purchased, you had to get a

judge's approval to be put on that license, and those are the only handguns you could carry. It was quite an onerous process. But interesting now that New York said, well, in New York City, you only get one gun. Now, I'm interested, it says the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Not the right to keep and bear a single arm. Well, a group of non-residents uh are suing in the district uh court of southern New York. Um, the the case

is Hendrik et al. versus New York City, claiming that that violates the Second Amendment, it violates the precedent of the Supreme Court that it is an unconstitutional limitation and uh should not exist. Now again, New York City's always been a bit special. So again, when I had a license in New York State to carry, it did not include New York City. The the my right to carry was was prohibited in New York City. Um, you have to get a special carry license to carry in New York City. Now, if you're

a New York State resident, you can register two handguns. But if you're a non-resident, you can only register one handgun. Why? Are are non-residents more dangerous than residents? And why those numbers? What's wrong? What if you want to register three? What if you like what if you like carrying a different handgun every day of the week? Not recommending it, but what if that's what you want? Or what if you're in a situation where uh uh you know the handgun that you have registered, you can't get to it.

I I I don't travel like I used to, but imagine, you know, you're somewhere carrying a different handgun, and now you get uh you find out something's going on and you gotta travel to New York City, but you can't carry that handgun because that's not that's not the one that's been registered. Uh, do you have a place where you can store that handgun? I mean, it creates a whole bunch of problems because of this hoplophobic reaction of we can we gotta do everything we can to restrict people's rights to carry a firearm. And what I always find interesting is people always talk about look at the look

at the bad things that are done with firearms. What about the good things that are done with firearms? Give me a example. So uh again, the Supreme Court, I think it was in the Berlin decision, said that uh states could regulate the carrying of fire in or prohibit the carrying of firearms in quote unquote sensitive places. But they couldn't simply make every place a sensitive defines a sensitive place. Well, a a recent uh decision by a federal judge ordered the

Montgomery County, Maryland, to allow uh uh members who attend a synagogue to can carry concealed weapons. Now, I can again I understand not just as a religious person. I mean, you go to church every Sunday, but especially if you were a Jew, there's kind of a history of some anti-Semitism. It would be nice to have the ability to defend yourself. Why should you be able to defend yourself on the street, but not in your place of worship? Whether it be a synagogue, a church,

a mosque, in in past years there have been attacking attacks against churches, there have been attacks in churches. Why do we want people disarmed in those? Well, then there won't be shootings. Well, except the only people then that are armed are the ones that are breaking the law anyway. So you know, it it is a foolish statement to say that prohibiting guns in certain places prevents people from getting shot because all you have to do is break the law. If you're if you're willing to shoot somebody, you're probably willing to break the law to bring the gun where it's

not supposed to be. Again, because as I talk about it frequently, you know, if you look at the at the numbers, the actual FBI crime stats, firearms are used much more often to stop crime than they are to commit crime. Now, granted, they aren't always fired to stop crime, but it happens repeatedly. And I don't mean it's a little bit more. I mean multiple times a year uh uh more are firearms used to stop crime than they are to

kill someone, which is what everyone's worried about, right? Even even including the suicides, much less criminal uh activity. Take, for example, a story out of Mobile, Alabama, where uh uh police responded to a to a call claiming a shooting shortly after 9 p.m. Eastern time, uh, I think it was a week or two ago. Uh what apparently happened is a gentleman uh by the name of David Lee, 37 years old, forced his way into a home by breaking a window

and unlawfully entered the domicile, where he had a fatal confrontation with a homeowner who happened to be armed. Now, Alabama happens to be a stand-your ground state. Uh, I know that gets a lot of bad press, but all a stand-ground state, all the stand-your ground laws mean is if you're somewhere where you have a legal right to be and you're not currently breaking the law, you do not have to run away in order to defend yourself with lethal force.

That's what a stand-your ground means. You don't have to run if you're being threatened and you're legally allowed to be where you're uh where you are. Now, under Alabama law, a person can use a reasonable amount of force, including deadly force, if he or she reasonably believes someone is about to use unlawful, deadly force against them or another person, or is committing or about to commit certain violent crimes like robbery, burglary, kidnapping, or forcible rape. All right, you're breaking into somebody's house. That's uh robbery or burglary. And of course,

uh, you have a if someone's breaking in your house, you have a reason to believe they be maybe willing to use uh deadly force. So this person used deadly force to defend himself. Now, this person, and he's not been identified, and I that's I got no problem with that. He shot and killed another human being because he broke into his house. And for everybody out there going, Oh, that pork, why did they have to shoot and kill him? He broke into someone else's house. He threatened by breaking in, just by breaking in, he threatened that

person. Um some people say that he may have picked the wrong house. What he received are the consequences of his criminal activity, his illegal actions. Similarly, uh in St. Louis, in a housing authority, a man in a wheelchair uh had to defend himself against an armed robbery. Uh this man's name is uh Tori Holliday. Uh he was the victim of an armed robbery uh

by a gentleman by the name of Randall Taylor. Uh according to reports, uh, they argued over a firearm that uh Mr. Taylor allegedly stole from Mr. Holiday back in July. Taylor pulled a gun, announced a robbery, and uh apparently Mr. Holiday defended himself. Now, according to a letter, which I'll get into in a second, that he received from the the housing authority that he lived in, he said security camera on August 26th shows

you in a verbal altercation and then pulling out a gun, firing it multiple times inside the lobby of the useless plaza, uh, and shooting someone. Now, here's the interesting thing. They they didn't mention the fact that the someone he shot had pulled a gun on him, that the person that he shot was charged with first-degree robbery, armed criminal action, and two counts of unlawful possession with a firearm. No, they didn't care about that. They simply called it a check that box said criminal activity and evicted Mr. Holiday from

his home for defending himself. Now, in an interview with the Daily Call or News Foundation, uh, the Housing Authority said the safety of our residents remain a top priority for the St. Louis Louis Housing Authority. While federal privacy requirements prevent us from discussing individual tenancy matters, the SLHA takes conduct that threatens the health or safety of residents, staff, or other or the community seriously. Well, I believe that if you were concerned about the threats made against Mr. Holliday, he said, uh, he told the interview, he said, I woke up

the next morning, they're not even trying to ask me, Am I alright? What happened? Is it okay? Nothing. All they hit me with was a big blank packet saying, You gotta be out. So, in other words, they're more worried about a guy defending himself with a gun. They claim to be worried about the this the safety of their residents, while saying a man who's being robbed, uh armed the victim of armed robbery should have just let himself be robbed, possibly shot. If that makes no sense to you, it's kind

of where things have become in the Second Amendment community. The idea that, um, in this case, I guess the victim has more rights, that uh again, that they there there's some anti-firearm policy. You're not allowed to defend yourself, apparently, in a St. Louis Louis uh housing authority. Um, doesn't that violate the Second Amendment to say you can't be armed? Uh, the the senior director of legal operations for the Second Amendment Foundation, Bill Sack, uh

told Daily Caller, he says, the government cannot make a condition of living in public housing that as residents waive their fundamental rights. Put simply, gun bans and public housing violate the Second Amendment. SEF has brought and won multiple cases exonering the Second Amendment rights of public housing residents, including most recently Hunter View Courtland Housing Authority in New York. But again, you have here two perfect examples of where firearms being carried stopped a crime. Um, you have yet you still have

places that say no, you you can't carry a gun to defend yourself because, well, you may be a criminal. Again, criminals really tend not to pay attention to those laws that say you can't do things. I mean, these laws basically say you must be a victim. You're not allowed to defend yourself. You must be a victim and you must be dependent on government for your protection. Uh, anybody we were talking about reparations and slavery, you're talking about saying you must be enslaved to us for your own protection. You are not allowed to protect. We make

it a crime for you to defend yourself. Or at least in the case of one gentleman, um, we're gonna throw you out of your home, not because you didn't pay the rent or because you damaged your property, but because you defended yourself and you happened to do it with a firearm. I suppose if he had been uh uh beaten or uh or uh beaten to death, that'd have been they they'd have been fine with the how they'd have been fine with that. Just don't you actually defend yourself? And that to me is the irrational state of well

so much of the American people. So let's roll this all back to Constitution Day. Because remember, the Constitution is ink on parchment. It's not a superhero, it's not gonna fly in like Iron Man or do some some incredible pose like Black Widow or or even strike you with with lightning like Thor. It's uh it's ink on parchment. It is ideas. It is up to we the people to implement those ideas. Remember, the declare uh the constitution starts at

a preamble, starts with we the people. We the people, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this constitution for the United States of America. This is our document. It is for us to defend our rights, to defend, to make sure that we get justice, that we have tranquility by being able to protect ourselves. And

whenever we abdicate our duty, our powers under this Constitution, we abdicate our liberty, we abdicate our freedom, we abdicate our rights. That's why I say it's up to we, the people, to, as John Jay said, um, defend and assert our rights. It's our job. Yes, we may get help from governments, we may get help from attorneys. It's our job to do it. It's our job to teach the rising generation free. It's our job to teach ourselves to be free. It's something we must do.

Now, of course, all this talk of doing this is gonna lead to questions. People I love when people ask me questions. If you want to ask questions, two ways of doing it. One is you can go to constitutionstudy.com slash questions, or you can just email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com. Both will get to me, and I only ask that you're you know you not be vulgar and that your question has something to do with the constitution or uh the constitution study, something relevant to what we talk about here. And I'd be more than happy to answer. Now, if you go to the website, I'm gonna ask for your name and email address because I need

to email you a response. Uh, if you'd like me to answer the question here on the radio, I love doing that. I'd love to get more questions that I answer here on the radio. Well, just check the box on the website or mention it in your email. I'll be more than happy. I will email you a question and answer directly, but I'll also answer it on the program if you would like me to. And I think that's very helpful because I'm sure there are people out there that have similar questions to the one that you would like to ask. And again, I'm I'm not out to embarrass anybody. I'm not out to show up anybody. I love when people ask me questions because

it actually helps me, not just from the program content, but me double checking my facts. Very helpful. So please go to constitutionstudy.comslash questions or email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com. I'll be more than happy to answer your questions. I also hope you'll come back and join us here for the Constitution Study on America at Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHot Radio Network every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern Time. You can listen on our media player. We've got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, you can always listen via podcast. It does take a day or two for an episode to go from talk radio

to podcast, but you can listen in your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share us with more people. You can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaloud.mu. Please share those links, share this program, and help share the blessings of liberty with everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What to expect as socialism grows in America

    Nov 20, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The fundamental flaw in America’s gun control laws

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court packing, impeachment, and the race to act before January

    Nov 18, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Are we a nation of laws or ruled by judges?

    Nov 15, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. After the midterms: More of the same, with a left turn

    Nov 14, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...

    Credit the people on this episode