Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY artwork

The separation of powers Americans forgot

Sep 25, 202657 minAudio

The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - You’re probably not as familiar with Separation of Powers as you think you are. Most Americans are aware of the separation between the three branches of government. Few seem aware of the separation of powers between the states and the federal government. This lack of understanding has led us to some truly terrible abuses of power and of the...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Out Loud Network with your host, Paul Engel. We all learned about separation of powers in school. At least I hope we did. Nowadays, maybe I can't be so sure. No, well, usually they focus on the different branches of

government. There is also a separation of powers between the state and federal governments. As James Madison stated in Federal's Paper 45, he wrote, The powers delegated by the proposed constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the state governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be focused, I'm sorry, the former will be exercised principally on external objects as war, peace, negotiation, and foreign commerce, with which the last power of taxation will,

for the most part, be can be connected. The powers reserved to the several states will extend to all the objects which, in the ordinary course of affairs, consider the lives, liberties, and properties of the people and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the state. However, our failure to read and study the Constitution has frequently led us not only to misunderstand the separation of powers between the state and federal governments, but to actually invert them.

Hello there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study. This is where we read and study the Constitution. We teach horizon generation to be free. And I'm glad you could join me today. You know, the separation of powers, this division of responsibility between the state and the federal government is critical. It is critical to uh not just our liberty, to the federalist form, to federalism as it was properly understood. Um, the not only the division of powers between the state and the feds, but

the fact that different states could go about their own business how they saw fit, as long as they didn't violate the constitution of the United States, which put relatively few restrictions on the states. Um, you remember back to the 10th Amendment, the powers not delegated to the United States by this constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states are reserved to the states respectively or to the people. So there, if you look at it, there aren't a lot of things, especially there is a constitution that were designed to limit the states. But understanding both the separation of

powers and the proper orientation of powers. In other words, who has power over whom and in what circumstances really is critical to not just a constitutional public, but to a free nation. I mean, I've talked previously about uh Tennessee's consideration of no longer accepting federal education funds, and uh the my position on that, which is you shouldn't have taken them in the first place, but better to stop than to continue. Um, the recent letters

from again my Tennessee Attorney General to the federal government, along with others attorneys general dealing with the uh um the abuse of federal powers, the federal government exercising powers it doesn't legitimately have, um, and the attempts to uh uh hopefully educate my state and other states in the powers they have to regulate their creation. Yes, the federal government is a creation of the states, not the other way around. The

states didn't create the federal government, I'm sorry, the federal government didn't create the states, the states created the federal government when they ratified the constitution. And each and every state that has joined the union since has joined onto the compact that says, yes, these are the powers of the federal government, these are the only powers of the federal government, and uh anything else, well, I would call that uh theft or something along those lines. So the proper understanding uh of state and federal powers um really has a tremendous impact.

And if we not just on how we govern, but understanding some of the news we've been seeing, and not just what maybe should be done, what can be done, it it based a lot on that that basic understanding of federal power versus state power and and the limitations on both established by the Constitution of the United States. Because as Mr. Madison noted, the the powers um that are retained

or reserved to the states, well, they are numerous and indefinite. You know, those those powers to which remain in the states. It's even even listen to the language. The powers originated state, they remain in the states. We have to remember though, those state powers are also limited by the state's constitution. So the state government can only do what the constitution of the state allows them to do. And that's gonna vary from state to state because, again, differences. It's this idea

of distributed power and allowing for the differences between the states. So let's take a look at a couple of examples uh and and do a bit of a deeper dive into them. Uh, so I'm gonna start again right here. Good old Tennessee. Um, there's a uh a bill that has been pre-filed with our state house. Now, our state session every runs every year, I think, from January through June. So they're not actually gonna the legislature's not actually gonna come into session until uh after the new year,

but they pre-file bills. So this bill, HB uh was it 1609, um, it's called the Defend the Guard Act. And uh it's it's supposed to prohibit the Tennessee National Guard or a member of the National Guard from being released from state duty into federal active duty combat unless the United States Congress has passed an official declaration of war or has taken an official action pursuant to Article I, Section 8,

Clause 15 of the United States Constitution to explicitly call forth the Tennessee National Guard, or remember the National Guard for the enumerated purposes to expressly execute the laws uh of the Union, repel invasion, or suppress insurrection. So again, this is uh it I find it interesting. Now, you may look at and say, well, wait a second, I thought the f I thought the president called up the National Guard. Well, no. Or maybe better put, not exactly. Uh

Article 1, Section 8, clause 15 says the the that Congress has the power to provide for the calling forth the militia to execute the laws of the union, suppress insurrection, and repel invasion. So there's a couple things here in this bill that we should consider when we're talking about separation of powers. Uh remember, the militia uh the is run by the states, right? Um we don't have a national militia. Well, they call it the National Guard. They

try to use it to establish a national. We have state militias. Those state militias um can have the the Congress does set rules for training and have funding and provision for them. Um interesting the officers must be chosen by the state because they're meant to be state militia. This is a state military. Now, Congress has the the ability under Article 1, Section A, Clause 15, to provide for the calling forth of the militia.

Now, it's that provide for see here's a problem with the with the uh uh or I should say a potential concern with the the uh uh the law HB was it 1609, and they say uh uh that uh the the the Congress has to make an action specifically calling forth the Tennessee National Guard, or remember the National Guard. Doesn't say that the Congress is the one that calls the militia, they

have to provide for the calling of the militia, which could easily mean saying, here are the rules for calling forth the militia. I'd have to double check the laws to see uh how they were written, to see if they fit within the Constitution of the United States. So that one's a little, you know, if they if um Congress says that the president can call up the National Guard for you know X amount of time, for X amount, that is providing for the calling of the militia. But here's the interesting part, because that calling, as the Tennessee HB 1609

states, can only be for one of three per peer per purposes for enforcing the laws, you know, I should say to execute the laws of the United States. Not to basically act as a as a local police force to suppress insurrections and to repel invasions. Notice what it doesn't list. It doesn't list being sent overseas to fight a war. In fact, war isn't even listed.

Remember, the militia is there to protect the states. Uh the Second Amendment says a well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state. The militia is there to protect the state. So while they might have some legal issues with the um uh the the you know their claim that Article 1, Section 8, Clause 15 means that Congress explicitly calls the militia into per

into action, they are dead on with, oh, by the way, you can only use the National Guard for certain purposes. Execute the laws of union, repel the in an invasion, or suppress an insurrection. So again, um they could use the National Guard. Uh uh, we we we saw the National Guard being used to enforce the laws of the United States regarding uh racial integration back in the 60s. Um, we can see them being used to repel an invasion. So,

yes, you could put the National Guard on the border to repel the invasion. It's a little iffy, right? Because a lot of people um have a fairly loose definition of invasion. And again, to suppress an insurrection. So those are the only things purposes they can be used for. The fact that they are used as regular military troops is actually a violation of the Constitution. Congress doesn't have the legal authority to go ahead and do that.

Of course, it hasn't stopped them in the past, and it won't stop them in the future until we the people actually read and study the Constitution. We we learn what the Constitution says and the limits it places on them. So, uh, from my standpoint, as I talk to uh and I communicate with my uh state rep and my state senator, I'm gonna ask them about that Article 1, Section A, Clause 15, because that's a to me, that's an iffy one. But as far as limiting the uh the the uh the

purposes for which the Tennessee National Guard can be used to the three things listed in the Constitution, I'm all in on them. I'm I'm all with them on that. And uh again, it's constitutional. A lot of people say, well, but federal law is the supreme law. No, federal law is made pursuant to the constitution. A federal law can't does not supersede the constitution of the United States. Now there's another example. Uh back in June, uh Alabama Representative uh Gary

Palmer introduced uh H.R. 4316, the Citizen Ballot Protection Act. Um sounds good, right? Well, uh the text apparently isn't available yet, still being worked on. But the purpose as described says the bill allows a state to include on its male voter registration application form a re form a requirement that the applicant provide proof of U.S. citizenship. Now, what's interesting is the the couple of

people I've heard discuss this were focusing on, well, yeah, proof of citizenship. You you want to make sure that that uh only citizens are voting in this. Now, the funny thing is, so I'm I was looking at an article. This really got me started. Uh this article, by the way, came from Epoch Times, and uh the title of the article, Alabama Senate Republicans introduced bill to prevent non-U.S. citizens from voting in federal elections. Uh well, it's a bit misleading because it makes it sound like

it's something done by the Alabama Senate. No, no, no. This is a U.S. Senator, it doesn't say Republicans, it appears a U.S. Senator introduced a companion bill to a House bill, um, HB 4316, that's known as a Citizen Ballot Protection Act. But the interesting thing says uh to prevent non-U.S. citizens from voting in federal elections, um the people don't vote in federal elections. Let

me say that again. There are no federal elections in which the people vote. The only federal election is the one by the uh um the electors for president that that is voted, they uh vote in December. Right? So election day, you're not voting in a federal election. You are you're voting in election for a federal office, but that's not a federal election, right? I I see this all the time. It's one of the reasons I say details matter. But let's take

a look at the Citizen Ballot Protection Act. Again, I haven't I don't I haven't even seen a bill number in the Senate. Um, the House bill doesn't have text yet, but its stated purpose um as introduced is this bill allows a state to include on its male voter registration application form a requirement that the applicant provide proof of U.S. citizenship. Okay, we've got problems here. Um the states do not need the federal government's permission to require proof of citizenship to register a voter. Let me state

that one more time. The states do not need the federal government's permission to ask for proof of citizenship when registering a voter. Now, why is that? Well, there's a couple of reasons. Now, what most people focus on is the the citizen aspect. Uh interesting, you go back to say the 14th Amendment, when they talk about the right to vote, it's a it deals with male inhabitants of such a state,

not the word citizen. However, when you get to the 15th Amendment, they say the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged based on race, color, or previous state of servitude. The 19th Amendment says the right of citizens of the United States to vote should not be denied or abridged on account of sex. So there's a an obvious point of citizens that that when it comes to the right

of vote. The 24th Amendment, the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged based on a poll tax. Uh the 24th Amendment, the 26th Amendment, the right of citizens in the United States who are 18 years of old of age or older shall not be denied on account of their age. So there's definitely a requirement for citizenship to vote. And that's where a lot of people have been focusing. But again, we're here at the Constitution study. We focus on the details, we focus on the Constitution. The states don't

need that there's nothing in the Constitution that says Congress gets to determine who gets to register in a state to vote. Article 1, Section 4 says the time, places, and manner of holding elections for senators and representatives shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof, but the Congress may at any time by law uh make or alter such regulations, except as to the places of choosing electors. So I'm sorry, the choosing senators. Um so

technically they can change the the time, uh, the place, uh, the manner of elections, but not of registration. So all that needs to happen is the states say, you know what? Um we're asking the question. We want proof of citizenship before we allow you to register to vote here, because that's our power. Because these are all state elections. They are state-instituted, they are state regulated, they are state controlled, uh, and Congress can make and set up some rules as

far as uh times, places, and manners. But this the Congress is not in charge. I don't care what the laws of the United States say, because the Constitution supersedes those laws. Only laws made pursuant of the Constitution are supreme. Okay, I've been talking a while. I have to take a break. Before I go, though, um, do me a favor, head over to AmericaOutloud.news. It's a great source of information for news, for to find out what's going on. And best better yet, take

that information and share it. Take a story, the article, a podcast, a video, something, something you think is important and share it. Share it with friends, share it with family, share with social media. Um, it's it the it's amazing that the act of sharing, the act of supplying this information to others, does more than just hopefully make you feel good. It is the first step and probably the most powerful step in helping to secure the blessings of liberty.

During treatment, City Tap water molecule structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for

your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides that help repair and restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue, which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root

cause, literally. Visit twc.health forward slash outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair regrowth with roots. Are you looking for healthy snacks, but you've had enough of all the sweet sugary energy bars? Good news. There's a new bar to try that's savory, crunchy, and packed with goodness. Beer bars are based on just six simple natural ingredients: a certified organic veggie nut and seed bar that's low temp

dried, never baked or fried. Beer bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get the exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners. That's B-A-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud.

And uh we looked a little bit at uh some stuff that's going on here in the state of Tennessee. Uh we also look at the the work of a couple of Alabama politicians in Washington at the at the federal level during the elections. But what's interesting, I got asked a question the other day about mandatory vaccines, uh in this case dealing with school vaccines. Uh mandates to take a vaccine before you attend school. And then this article popped up. Um, and it it's a case that's been submitted to the Supreme Court for review uh

by a group called We the Patriots USA, and it's challenging a Connecticut law that uh eliminated the religious exemption to the school vaccination requirement. Now, there's been a lot of interesting discussion on this idea of school vaccinations, not just this Connecticut law, but school vaccinations in general. Now, this case went down at the district court and at the appeals court, which is why it's being appealed to the the Supreme Court. Um, the

lawyers that sent the petition for certiari, it's the official term for asking for review, said the court accepted without question Connecticut's assertion of a general interest in protecting the health and safety of students. That's is it they they didn't even review, they just simply stated that it was so. Now, get away from the political machinations of whether or not the state picks this up, or I should say the Supreme Court picks this up. Let's go back to 2022 and an opinion by a judge Alberton

saying that mandatory for uh vaccinations for school enrollment did not violate the violate the U.S. Constitution's free exercise clause. Okay, there's problem number one. I don't know how many times I've said it, but I'm gonna keep saying it because, well, let's face it, um, lawyers have been brainwashed into believing whatever some previous judge said. This cannot be a violation of the First Amendment. Why? The first five words of the First Amendment are Congress shall make no law. Congress did not make

this law. The Connecticut legislature made this law. Therefore, it's not a violation of the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. The question is, is it a violation of Article I, Section Three of the Connecticut Constitution? Now that reads, the exercise and enjoyment of religious profession and worship without discrimination shall forever be free to all persons in the state, provided that the right hereby declared and established shall not be so construed as to excuse acts of licentiousness

or to justify practices inconsistent with the peace and safety of the state. And that's, I think, where Connecticut may have a place to hang its hat. Because the Connecticut Constitution says the exercise and enjoyment of religious profession and worship. So you're really kind of on a knife's edge. Does profession include the act of saying, I profess that I that we I don't take vaccines? Um, because the you also have that the the final clause that says that uh that cannot

be used to justify practices inconsistent with the peace and safety of the state. What it really means is it what the state needs to or should be required to prove is that the religious exemptions um are inconsistent with the actual safety of the state. So really, this case should not have gone to the federal government if they're hanging it on a First Amendment uh issue. What could they hang this on? Well, you may be

able to hang it on a 14th amendment issue, right? Because you're being denied the liberty of not putting something into your body without due process of law, meaning has the state actually followed a process that will protect the individual rights? And of course, that's that doesn't come up. And this is one of the issues we run into with A, trying to make everything a federal case. Everybody wants to run to federal court. Um, maybe because they don't like the fact that the people that

the state of, in this case, the state of Connecticut hire to represent them don't agree with them. So the people that are following this challenge, this uh what do they call it? Um I forget the name of the group, uh, we the Patriots USA, they don't like the idea of vaccine mandates. By the way, I don't like the idea of vaccine mandates either. But rather than taking it to state court, maybe they took it to state court and I didn't see it. But they're saying that they they took it to federal court, and again, they looked at the religious exemption,

it's because the state does allow medical exemptions, and the logic the state uses is medical exemptions allow people, allow people that term is important to me, allow people to who may be harmed by the vaccine from not being forced to take the vaccine, but they're still allowed in the school. So if they are not dangerous, if not taking the mandated series of vaccines is not dangerous for people because of medical conditions, why is it dangerous because of religious conditions?

But the distinction between the state issue and the federal issue, the religious issue is a state issue from the state constitution, not a federal issue from the federal constitution, which is why um if we actually filed the constitution, the courts would have said, um, no standing. Congress didn't make this law, it cannot be a first amendment violation. Oh, but the 14th Amendment, right? The except the 14th Amendment didn't change the language of the First Amendment. See, the Fourteenth Amendment says no state shall make or enforce

any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States. It doesn't say anything about changing the language of the First Amendment. Doesn't say, oh, we didn't just mean Congress anymore. We mean all state legislature, we mean all state actors. It doesn't do that. See, just because I'm here in Tennessee, um Congress Congress can't make a law that violates my freedom of free exercise of religion doesn't say the state can't. And it's that those details that I think truly matter in understanding some of

these um in fact, a lot of these these issues. Now, as I said, someone did ask me about this um actually just last week, I think. And uh my response is simple. Uh when it comes to mandates to to attend school, um I believe non-invasive testing um is it would be okay as a reasonable search to make sure that you're not dangerous to others. Right? And I'm very important. Non-invasive testing. And that

gets into a lot of interesting questions that may be here as to whether or not a state from the federal constitution standpoint, a state could do this. It doesn't mean the state has the power. In order for the state to have the power, it must be authorized by the state constitution. What I'm saying is it's not a power denied to the states by the U.S. Constitution. I want to be a little clear of that. So non-invasive testing. Um, are you sick? Don't attend. Right? Anything invasive, which includes, by the way, taking vaccines, well, that's a

that is a an unreasonable uh seizure of your body because there's no probable cause on which to initiate the the seizure. Right? There's no there's no warrant and there's no probable cause. The you'd have to assume that a person is that everybody is sick, therefore everybody must be vaccinated, which actually is the point of vaccination is to prevent people from being sick. But that gets into a whole other set of questions because um, you know, when I was a kid, there were what five, six vaccines. Now

there's what 75, 80 vaccines that that children take during up to and including their school years and and FOIA requests from organizations like uh ICANN and and and others have shown that the CDC is not properly testing these vaccines, meaning they're not doing uh blind placebo controlled tests. Uh so we don't know the safety of the individual vaccines, much less the safety of merging these vaccines and the

schedule with which they are implemented. So to say that we have to do this to keep these safe, the the government has the burden of proof or should have the burden of proof to prove that these are both safe and necessary. In order for it to be reasonable, they must prove that it is safe, they must prove that it is necessary, and they haven't done that. They've claimed it, they haven't actually done that. When you ask them for the evidence, they they defer, they hem, they haw, and based on on one group, they they just basically make

stuff up. All right, let's take a look at another power assumed by the federal government. Uh by now you've heard that uh um the Congress has three authorized section 702 of the FISA, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The uh quote unquote, the ascending supposedly the ability for warrantless wiretaps and warrantless surveillance. Now, what's interesting to me is two things. One is um the fear-mongering that led to this, the claims

that, oh my god, if we can't violate the Constitution and violate your rights, well, um the terrorists would just come and blow us all up. I mean, that that's all right, that's a bit of an exaggeration, but really, is it that far from the from the the the truth? I mean, the the FBI, the people who have been caught violating the law, abusing this power, said we have to have these pro powers or we we we won't be able to identify terrorists.

Well, okay, so does does the Constitution delegate to the United States the ability to um to identify and protect us from terrorists? Well, we we've already seen the uh the the ability to call for them to determine for the calling off the militia to repel invasion. And in fact, um Article was a four section four says the United States shall uh guarantee to every state in this union a Republican form of

government and shall protect each of them against invasion, and on the application of the legislature or the executive when the legislature cannot be convened against domestic violence. So there is a situation where the federal government is responsible, but notice um they can you know they're supposed to repel invasion. Uh when it comes to uh protecting as domestic violence, it's only when the state asks for the help. Right? Either the legislature or if the legislature cannot be convened, the executive of

the state can do so. So there's a a little bit of an iffy thing from that song. Now, again, if you're talking about foreign um actors, the federal government deals with um with foreign policy via treaties and other things. So there's there's a little bit of an iffy thing there. But um as we look at this, does the federal government, does Congress have the ability to uh suspend parts of the Constitution in order to keep us safe? I mean, sure, you've got

the Benjamin Franklin quote, those who will give up essential liberty for the promise of temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. Basically, what Congress did is say, we're gonna take away your rights. Um we're gonna open you up to having your rights taken, I should say. We're gonna open all you up to have your rights taken in order to protect you. But is that really the role of the federal government to sit there and say, well, we're gonna basically suspend the Fourth Amendment for these actors? Now they play little interesting games.

They say, well, you know, the we're only targeting foreign personnel. The you know, there's a foreign intelligence surveillance act. So these warrantless, um this warrantless surveillance is not uh against Americans, it's against uh you know foreigners. Well, there's two problems with that. First of all, it's not limited to foreigners because they say, well, if you um if you are communic communication, if we discover an American that's in communication with one of these foreign potential

terrorists, then we can surveil them as well without a warrant. And we can not only surveil them, we can surveil anyone they've been in contact with. What's the old game? Six degrees of separation with Kevin Bacon? It's basically that. But I want you to notice something. The Fourth Amendment says the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures. It doesn't simply say the citizens, it says the people. And the question then becomes

where does the people end? When they talk about the people, are they talking about citizens of the United States, residents of the United States, people within our borders? Or is it the people in general? I believe it have to do a little more research. This one may be arguable, but it has to do a lot more research into the development of that language, the right of the people, as opposed to uh persons, as it's it's uh used in in other in other aspects. So there's a there's a

questionable bit to that uh particular logic. But the idea of, hey, once you start, once you identify somebody in the United States, without question, you need a warrant or an exigent circumstance. Meaning you need you need a a justifiable, articulable emergency, or you need a warrant. And I don't care what Congress wrote, I don't care about uh 702, there's nothing Congress

can do to supersede the Constitution. In fact, according to uh not only Alexander Hamilton in Federal 78, but at least three Supreme Court cases, unconstitutional laws are void and as if they never ever happened. You see, that's the limit of uh a limit on federal power. Congress cannot write laws. If Congress writes laws that that violate the constitution, they're void, they're empty, they're meaningless. Which means states can simply ignore them.

That includes, by the way, charging federal officials who violate the constitution under the uh auspices of being authorized by a law that is void because it violates the constitution. I'm amazed sometimes by the number of people who, um, when I point out that I never went to law school, say, well, where do you get all this stuff? Simple. By reading and studying the 8,000 words that are the supreme law of the land. Now, I I have

to take a break coming up. So before I go, though, please check out the website, The Constitution Study. Um, we are coming up to the holiday season. There's still time. Uh, don't know if I could get it to you by Christmas, but I could certainly uh get it to you by new year if you wanted to start, say, reading the Constitution or one of my books as a way of kicking off the new year with a constitutional event. The website's Constitutionstudy.com. Sign up for a mailing list. There's a lot you can do there. But as I mentioned, the holiday season is also entering,

well, the cold and flu season, the season when people tend to get sick. It's a great time to consider boosting your immune system. How do you do that? Well, I recommend Healthy Cells Immune Super Boost. It combines over a dozen immune supplements in a simple, easy-to-use travel ready gel pack. I use them especially when I travel. I throw them in my bag and I take one a day. You can find out more at AmericaOutloud.shop, including how you can get 25% off your first order from Healthy Cell. So again, visit AmericaOutloud.shop, find out more about

Immune Super Boost and the discount at Healthy Cell. Tyler sneezed on me directly on him twice. Let's face it, kids bring home more than homework from school. Clear nasal spray is a gentle mist of saline plus xylitol to clean and block bacteria and viruses in your nose. And it helps rinse away what they've been breathing all day. No drugs, no rebound.

Make it as routine as washing hands. Can I have a snack? Wash your hands first. Learn more at clear.com. That's xl-e-a-r.com. Clear. Breathe better. Live better. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no

fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere: city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code outloud for an exclusive offer.

Welcome back, everyday American Jabri. Join the Constitution study. And today we're taking a look at state versus federal powers. What belongs to the state and what belongs to the Fed and what powers are actually legitimate as we're looking at this? We've looked at several. There was an interesting um uh video that came up. Um Nikki Haley, I guess she was endorsed by uh Governor Sununu, and there was an interview going on on ABC when an interesting question came up.

Let me ask you, uh, speaking of Trump, um, he has claimed absolute immunity uh in his defense to the election interference case. Is that your view? Do you believe a president has absolute immunity for anything that happens while they're president? I'm gonna let the courts figure that out. Now remember, Ms. Haley is running for the Republican nomination to become president of the United States. And uh let me give you the hint. There is no such thing as presidential immunity. I don't care what the courts say, I

don't care what Congress says, I don't care what Ms. Haley says, there is no such thing as presidential immunity because it's not a power given to the president by the Constitution of the United States. Now, again, this is all swirling around Trump's indictments and his court cases, and the the interviewer um kind of comes around and um rephrases the question. I mean, the last thing you're gonna see me do is weigh in or learn the details about any of his court cases because I can't follow

91 charges, and I'm not going to. That makes total sense. But let me just ask you on the principal, forget his case. Do you think that a president of the United States, that if you get elected president, you would have absolute immunity for anything you did while you were president? Well, I think the court issues are do you have immunity when you're president? When you're not president? At what point does that line fall? I'm gonna let judges decide that. I don't know where the line falls. Now, I want to remind you again, Ms. Haley is running to become the president, which means she's going to take the presidential oath. Article one, I'm sorry,

Article 2, Section 1 of the last clause reads: before he enters on the execution of his office, he shall take the following oath or affirmation. I do solemnly swear or affirm that I will faithfully execute the office of president of the United States and will, to the best of my abilities, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States. There is nothing in the Constitution that gives the president any form of immunity. There is no presidential immunity.

That's basically a holdover from the idea of sovereign immunity, that somehow the president is sovereign, therefore he can't be charged. It is baloney. It does not exist. Well, you know, does he have it while he's in office or after he's in office? It matters not a whit. There is no such thing. The fact that President Trump said so doesn't make it true. It just proves, once again, that he knows diddly squat about the Constitution. All right, maybe he knows a little bit more than diddly squat, but he certainly

doesn't know much about the Constitution or his role when he was president of the United States, which to me is the bigger problem, is that I've yet to see anybody point out they actually understand the role of the president of the United States. But the interview had an interesting comeback to Ms. Haley's question about, well, you know, the courts have to decide. No, by the way, that's an abdication of your responsibility. If you wish to be president, that's your you have to answer these questions, not point it off on somebody else. That's what President uh W. Bush did.

And that to me was his disqualification for office. But there was something else that was pointed out by the interviewer. Because that sounds a lot like saying you're above the law, that a president's above the law. I mean, he can answer for himself. I am not in a court case. I'm happy I don't have to answer for that. So let him answer it. Notice how Ms. Hilly keeps coming back. Well, President Trump is in a court case. That doesn't matter. It does not matter. The whole idea, the very idea that anybody in the government has

immunity is offensive, not just to the Constitution. It's offensive to the idea of the rule of law. The closest you get, the very closest you get to any form of immunity for a government actor, comes from Article 1, Section 6, Clause 1, which reads, they, meaning the senators and representatives, shall in all cases except treason, felony, and breach of the peace be privileged from arrest during their attendance at the session or of

their respective houses or in going to and returning from. And for any speech and debate in either house, they shall not be questioned. So notice it's not absolute. Because the first thing is says, well, wait a second. If you're dealing with treasoning, treason, felony, or breach of the peace, they can be arrested. If it's something else, they cannot be arrested while uh in what while attending a session of Congress or in going to or from uh their place. Um but also notice they cannot be questioned for anything they say

during a speech or debate in either house. So a speech or debate, uh that's the speech or debate clause, anything they basically say in h in their actual house, no, the the the house of the senate, in their actual congress in the Congress, they cannot be questioned. That is as close to immunity as you get in the Constitution. Ms. Haley doesn't know that. Mr. Trump doesn't know that. I wonder who else doesn't know that. But that keeps going back. It's a

question of that's not a power delegated to the United States. That is not a federal power. It is not given to the president to be immune from anything. And it's our lack of understanding that looks at that and says, I'm sorry, you're not qualified for office. If you're gonna take an oath to faithfully support to defend the Constitution of the United States, and you have no clue what it says, you're not qualified. You would think before someone runs for a con a constitutionally established office,

they would have at least read the document and have a good understanding of it. Because they're gonna take an oath to support it. You'd think they'd have a clue. The fact that they don't bothers me some. The fact that the American people vote for these people really disturbs me because that's where the problem truly lies. Now, here's a uh another power we want a question. According to uh the monthly treasury statement, during the first two

months of the fiscal year, now the United States runs on a fiscal year from October to September. So the 2024 fiscal year started October 1st. In October and November alone, the government spent over one trillion dollars. In fact, it was $1 trillion $58,839 million, that's a big number. That's a big, big number. Now, from that statement, we also read that the federal government collected

$678 billion, $264 million, in taxes. Meaning for in two months alone, they were the federal government ran of $380.5 billion deficit in just two months. Now, a lot of people think that this is irresponsible, it's illogical, it's irrational. There's a whole bunch of adjectives. The question is, is it constitutional? Well, it's kind of a yes or no, yes

and no answer. And I want to be specific about things. Let's start with the spending. Now, Congress has the authority to spend money on several things, right? They can uh uh they they they can fund the military, they obviously have to fund the the federal government itself, right? The Congress, the White House, the the different courts have to pay salaries, they have to maintain buildings,

they got a lot of stuff uh uh they have to pay for there. As I said, they have to support the army, the navy, the rest of the military. Um, they have to provide for the uh arming of the militia. There's a lot the federal government has to do. The question is, was it one trillion dollars worth of stuff the federal government has to do in two months? Not even close. I haven't checked the details of the monthly treasury report, but the last time I looked at the numbers, which I think was through 2022, I don't remember if I

did 2023. About 80-90% of what the federal government money spends, they're not constitutionally authorized to do. That's a very important number. Well, actually, it's not the number, it's the fact that that is called embezzlement. They are taking funds, they are distributing funds where they're not authorized to distribute them. That is embezzlement. And before you go blaming the president, that's Congress. Right? No money can come from the federal treasury except by appropriation from Congress.

That's Article 1, Section 9, Clause 7, I believe. So all that money that the Treasury spent was author first authorized by Congress. So that's why I said it's it's some, right? Because some of the money was authorized. But my best guess would be the vast majority of that money was not authorized. Well, what about the collection of taxes? Well, Congress is authorized to collect taxes. Article 1, Section 8, Clause 1. The Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts, and excises to pay the debts and provide

for the general the common defense and general welfare of the United States. Capital U, capital S. That's important. So that makes it a proper noun. It's referring to the union known as the United States. It's the same proper noun used in the 10th Amendment that says if we if the Constitution doesn't delegate to the United States this power, they don't have it. Well, guess what? Think of how much money that Congress spent that they collected taxes for that didn't involve paying the debts, that didn't

involve the common defense, and involve didn't involve the general welfare of the United States. It involved whatever Congress thought would be a good idea. So, yes, some of those taxes collected were legitimate, many of them were not. Which of course leaves us with a $380 billion deficit. That definitely deficit has to be financed somewhere. They have to borrow money. And yes, Congress has the authority to borrow money on the credit of the United States. Article 1, Section 8, Clause 2. Now,

sadly, then the framers never put a limit or any restrictions on how much money Congress could borrow on the credit of the United States, which is why we have a $33 trillion, it's got to be close to $34 trillion by this point, $34 trillion deficit. Now, hopefully those numbers should click something in your mind. See, if Congress stopped embezzling money from the American people to pay to for their own little boondoggles, their pet

programs, their own agenda not authorized by the Constitution, well then the deficit would disappear. And in fact, we would be running a surplus. That surplus could be used to pay off the national debt, or at least get it down to a more manual, but I would say pay off the national debt. Uh, I haven't checked numbers recently. Last time I checked was about five years ago. It was estimated that if the federal government only spent money they were authorized to by the Constitution, um, and they kept taxes exactly the same, we'd

pay off this $34 trillion in about 10, 15 years. So we could get out of this mess. But you know what's going to take? It's going to take the American people realizing the limitations on the powers of the federal government and actually forcing them to abide by it, making it a requirement. If you want to work for us, you abide by the rules or you lose your job. So it you see how important it is that we the people understand the separation of powers? Yes, the separation

between the three branches, the legislative, executive, and judicial. That is very, very, very important. I'm not diminishing that. But we also need to know the uh uh the separation of powers between the state and federal government. The understanding that when government when the when a government exercises a power, it's not been delegated by the constitution that created it, that government is stealing from the people they supposedly represent. Now, how do we know this? How do

we how do we get to the point where we know the truth? Well, I keep I'm gonna keep going back to John Jay. This quote from John Jay is the founding principle behind The Constitution Study. It's it's our uh uh it's our founding statement. Every member of the state ought diligently to read and study the constitution of his country and teach the rising generation to be free. That's step one, right? Read the Constitution, study it, do it diligently, and then

teach the next generation to be free. John Jay said by knowing their rights, they'll sooner perceive when they are violated and be the better prepared to defend and assert them. See the logic? See, when knowing what the Constitution says, you would recognize when uh uh a Donald Trump or Nikki Haley says that the presidents have uh uh a sovereign immunity, an absolute no, they don't. It's obvious, right? As soon as you know the constitution, you recognize that that's a violation of your rights. That the right to control your

government. When you see Congress spending money on energy and education and food and medicine, you say, no, that's not constitutional. Why? Because I've read the constitution, I've studied the constitution, and I don't care what laws they've passed because those laws were not passed uh uh pursuant or following the constitution, which means they're not the supreme law of the land. In fact, it means they don't legally exist. It becomes automatic, it becomes part of

your just the way you think. Now, we may disagree on a lot of things about constitutionality and whatnot, but it's by reading and studying the actual language of the constitution we come to that understanding, even if we disagree on on certain points. But that follow-up, it's not just recognizing that your rights have been violated. A lot of people claim to recognize that rights are violated, some of them are legitimate, some of them are not. But here's the interesting point He said,

be the better prepared to defend and assert them. He didn't say be the better prepared to have Congress defend them, to have the president defend them, but you be prepared to defend and assert them. That was the point. We were never to hand over our liberty into the hands of a government. We defend and assert our rights. That is our job. And the fact that we have abdicated that responsibility is why the federal government is its size, and it's also why

our states are full of cowards who are unwilling to fulfill their oath to support the Constitution of the United States and stand up against the tyrannical government that simply ignores the Constitution and does whatever it darn well feels like. That's why in in so many of my classes, I go back to the Constitution to understand what are the powers of the state, what are the powers of the federal government, and what are the powers of the American people to hold, not only to exercise their rights, but to hold both of those entities

in check. And that education, that understanding, that getting people to read and be familiar with the Constitution and the powers delegated to the United States, well, that's the purpose of the Constitution. That's why I formed this. It's why I wrote my books, it's why I started this radio program. It's why I do what I do. It's by knowing these truths that have allowed me to live free in occupied territory. It's allowed me to be free in my mind and live how I want, even though

knowing that there are those who are willing to take control of my body that cannot take control of my mind. That means I am free. I am truly free because they may incarcerate my body, but they can never incarcerate my mind. Now I hope you'll come back and join us here at the Constitution Study. Every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern Time. We are on America Out Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network. You can also listen on podcasts. They generally go to podcast uh a day

or two after they're heard on Talk Radio. Listen with your favorite podcast app, but do me a favor, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating, a review. It helps other people find the Constitution Study as well. You can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news, but please share this information. You're not just sharing The Constitution Study. You're not just sharing my voice, you are sharing the ideas and the blessings of liberty.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What to expect as socialism grows in America

    Nov 20, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The fundamental flaw in America’s gun control laws

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court packing, impeachment, and the race to act before January

    Nov 18, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Are we a nation of laws or ruled by judges?

    Nov 15, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. After the midterms: More of the same, with a left turn

    Nov 14, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...

    Credit the people on this episode