Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY artwork

Judicial roulette: Will the courts protect your rights or crush them?

Sep 12, 202657 minAudio

The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - A lower court judge decided the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobb’s doesn’t really matter. The Catholic Church is suing the State of Illinois in District Court over a law that requires its adherents to assist in the suicide of terminally ill patients. The State of Missouri is asking SCOTUS to protect them against their own state supreme court...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our austerity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Network with your host, Paul England. As Scotus's summer vacation approaches an end, there's plenty of work being lined up for them. And it's not just the Supreme Court with things to do. Inferior and state courts are going to be busy as well. Hello there,

everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacher Action Generation be free. Glad you could join me today. People are looking at the Supreme Court, right? They're October, they open their new session, and we're already lining plenty of stuff up for them. So I thought I'd start today by looking at a few of the cases that the court is considering and probably will hear arguments on.

One case, Crowther versus Board of Regents, the University System of Georgia, has been scheduled to hear the end of November, and the court's being asked to decide whether or not Title IX of the Federal Education Amendments allows employees of federally funded schools a private right to sue for sex discrimination at work. Meaning, you know, can they actually sue the school? Interesting question. In other words, can they sue to get uh a job back? Or or I I mean again, none of these have I gone

into details on the cases. So I'm just looking at some summaries uh from some articles that are being brought up. Uh, thought that was interesting. Um there's another case, a couple of cases actually involving uh gun rights. Uh early December, the court will hear uh Veramontes versus Cook and Grant versus Higgins. And they're gonna they're basically being asked whether the Second and 14th Amendment protect the right to possess what they call an AR-15 style or similar semi-automatic weapon. Again, these these uh

the the these euphemistically called assault weapons, which is um a term that that really doesn't have a good definition, but these are basically these are semi-automatic weapons that look scary. And uh that's the interesting question. Um the are they covered uh by the Second Amendment and the 14th Amendment, which means states deriving people of their property without due process of law, should be an interesting case, or pair of cases. Uh, in fact, the U.S. government is getting involved. Uh, the Solicitor General, John

Sauer, asked justices to overturn rulings from the appeals court for the second and seventh and the seventh circuits that uphold ban upheld bans on AR-15s. So we've got the the Trump administration is going to be involved in this as well. And I believe the solicitor generals arguing based on what's called the common use debate, uh, from I think it was the Bruin decision that said the Second Amendment uh argued by default covers weapons that are in common use. And considering the AR-15, I

think is the best-selling rifle, if not the just selling firearm in our nation's history, it certainly is in uh common use today. But there's also the the myth versus reality of how these firearms are used. I've talked about this a lot before because these aren't really gun control debates, these are gun owner control to debates. Um, and uh one thing that's been uh controversial has been a lot of the CDC research. Um,

the the Congress actually prohibited the CDC from doing um uh uh gun research, gun gun ownership, gun violence research, because their methods were so bad that even Congress said, no, this is propaganda, we can't do this. Now things have gotten better. But I there's an interesting update to the CDC reports that I find interesting. Um, so the the CDC, they've been doing some of these reports, they found they recently upped the number of defensive gun uses per year. Um, on average,

they went from 2.1 million to 2.5 million times a year on average that guns are used for legitimate defensive purposes. So when you talk about prohibiting or getting rid of these guns and the scary guns, what you find is you're not only preventing people from using they're they're trying to prevent bad people from using guns for bad things. Or let's forget bad people, they're trying to prevent guns from being used for bad things, right? The problem is the people who use guns for

bad things are generally criminals, meaning they're not really gonna likely to follow the law to begin with. Um, so uh that doesn't really help them. What it does do is it prevents otherwise law-abiding citizens from using a firearm in self-defense. And if that happens two and a half million times a year, that tells me that these firearms that these hoplophobes are so terrified of, and we have to get rid of them, are actually used quite frequently to defend people's

lives. And if that's the case, well, then when you restrict access to these firearms, you're restricting access for their ability to be used to defend human life. That's an argument I think we need to have. It's one I hope that that will come up before the courts. We'll have to wait and see. Again, that's happening, I think, in December. And also to consider that I think on average, between 75 and 80 percent of defensive gun uses don't actually involve the firing of a firearm, meaning simply displaying a firearm

is enough to stop what's going on. So uh these are gonna be interesting cases that I'll follow. And of course, I will do deep dives um definitely into the decisions. I'll probably do the oral arguments. I'll have to see how the schedule goes. But these are types of things that that uh you know really caught my attention in the um uh in what the court's gonna be looking at. Going back to what the court is gonna be going over in its next uh term. Uh December 7th,

2026 may also be a uh a day that will go down as an infamous day, not just the one in 1941, because that's when the court's gonna hear the International Partners for Ethical Care Eagle versus Ferguson about whether or not parents have the standing in the legal right to sue uh a Washington State policy that removes them from decisions about so-called gender transition of their children. Again, very interesting, something uh uh very uh important. Uh also early in December, they're

gonna hear a case called uh Jupee versus Alaska, um, a case where a uh a pilot had his uh airplane seized by troopers after they found a six-pack of beer on a flight bound for a dry village. In other words, is this an excessive fine? I mean, uh a $95,000 plane because the guy had a six-pack of beer that he was that on a flight to a dry village. Didn't say he drank the beer there, it was just

going to that dry village. And yet, that that to me is a little on the is an interesting case. Another case uh said to be heard the early December is the Republican National Committee versus Mi Familia Vota. Uh, and it asked really two questions about Arizona voting rules. First, can the state require a passport, birth certificate, or other proof of citizenship from people who registered to vote on a state form? And the second is whether 90 days before a federal election, can Arizona remove voters from uh

a from their voting rolls uh after officials confirm that they're not U.S. citizens. All right, so voting being a big issue. A lot of people talking about lady lately. There's a couple of things in there that are truly um uh uh truly interesting. So I expect to have a lot of content from um from oral arguments and stuff this fall, going into the winter. It also means it may be another interesting, silly season come next June when the court puts out its most

controversial and important uh decisions in these cases. Good content to look at. So, like I said, the courts they're on the right again, and it's not just the Supreme Court. So, do you remember the Dobbs decision? That's a decision of the Supreme Court that said the rogue decision was wrong. There's nothing in the Constitution uh that uh uh protects the right to an abortion, it's not a federal issue, it's a state issue. Now, I agree with the first half of that statement, right? That it's not a federal, that that there's nothing in the constitution protecting the

right to an abortion. I question the the point about uh whether or not it's truly a state issue, since the 14th Amendment says no state may pass any law that deprives any person of life, liberty, or property. And an abortion deprives a human being of life, which gets in the question of when is it a person? I've discussed this ad nauseum. If you'd like me to discuss it again, let me know. I'd be more than happy to, but uh we're still dealing with it. However, that has not stopped um

well, that's not stopped some judges from continuing with their political agenda. In this case, uh district judge senior district judge uh B. Lynn Windmill, uh, he's based out of Idaho. Uh he how'd he put this? He he had a decision saying that Idaho pro Idaho's pro-life law violated the Constitution because the 14th Amendment's due process and equal protection clauses establish a narrow but

fundamental right to abortion when a pregnancy threatens a woman's life or health. Okay, um it's that's not exactly what the 14th Amendment says, either the equal protection or the due process clause. Right? The the the equal protection clause that says that uh no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws, which doesn't appear to be here. And of course, the due process clause already quoted that the state shall no state shall deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. So that doesn't technically protect an abortion.

In fact, I would say it it protects people against abortions. Now, he was pointing to the woman's life or health, and that's where the due process clause is explained. That's why due process is important. If you're talking about uh due process, the mother has a right to her life, right? So if a pregnancy threatens her life and she simply has to say, hey, look at I've got a doctor's thing, I have a medical condition, this is going to cause me to die, then

the state can have a law that deprives a an unborn of their life because it infringes on the rights of the mother, right? That's a that that's a perfectly valid due process claim. Health becomes more interesting because health has been interpreted in many ways. For example, if it if by health you mean the major biological functions of the mother, right? In other words, if it's something that's going to uh physically harm her for an extended period of

time, right? If it's a threat, maybe, maybe she won't die, but maybe maybe she'll lose a limb. All right, maybe she cannot get treatment for a certain thing that may seriously shorten her. There's a lot of scenarios. The problem is health has been reinterpreted to be, well, it makes her feel bad. That's bad for her mental health. That's what a cause that that's a just cause. That, ladies and gentlemen, is not due process. It's again, it gets back to understanding due process, which this judge apparently either doesn't, or dearly just more

accurately, I believe, doesn't care because he's pro-abortion, he's pro-death. Well, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has put a temporary uh stay on that judge's decision, uh, I'm assuming so that they can hear it. But I'm curious how the Ninth Circuit looks at this because the Idol Hole law has written into it exceptions for it for to allow abortions in circumstances such as rape, incest, and dangers to a mother's life. So uh Judge

Winmill's argument is already kind of half blown apart because it includes the mother's life. The question is going back to mental health. Is the judge trying to say, well, if she can't do it because it makes her feel sad, then that's an infringement on her rights. That's the craziest. So again, more courts are involved. Uh, I think this is going to be an interesting case. Uh certainly one with with which I'll be keeping an eye on. And there's another one, this one

out of uh Illinois, where the Catholic Church is suing, uh, let's see, the suing to block what's called the End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act, or EOLO. Now, according to the church, this law would require their members to help terminally ill patients kill themselves, which of course is in violation of both Catholic doctrine and Christian teachings. Um, the uh law, I guess, is it was

signed back in December of 25 by Governor Pritzker and is expected to go into effect September 12th. Now, the church is being represented by the Beckett Fund uh and their lead attorney, Mark uh uh Resny. Uh, and again, this should be an interest because you're saying that a does a person's right to die, as Dylan I recognize it, include the right to force people to help them. And that really is the question. It's when does your right uh, you know, I

I believe suicide is wrong. I I believe that life starts at conception and ends at natural death. Um uh, but I I I I'm not saying I don't understand why certain people do it in certain situations, but I think it's wrong. But the question is not, does a person have a right to die? The question is, does a person have the right to compel people against their will to help them? And that again is a very interesting question. One I'm you know we'll keep an eye on. It's as this uh makes its

way through the courts right now. It's at uh I believe it's the district court in Illinois that's seeing this. And again, we'll have to wait and see how things go. Okay, I have a break coming up. Uh before I go though, uh, I do want to remind you, you know, like I said, my my wife wants me to eat healthier. It's like she wants me around for a while. I'm not entirely sure why, but she does. Now, there are lots of supplements and vitamins because some reports say as much as 85% of the nutrients we used to get from

our food, we don't get from our food anymore. It's literally been farmed out of the soil by commercial farming. And what do you do? Do you take a handful of pills? Do you go on some um some crazy diet? Well, our friends at the chemical-free body have another option. It's called organic energy juice. Used to be called green 85. It is a juice powder. You mix it with water before you eat twice a day, and it gives your body the nutrients it needs. It's 100%

organic, it's it's probiotic, and it's got the the the nutrients your body needs. It promotes natural energy and weight loss, it helps you sleep better, helps build muscle, helps strengthen your immune system, all by simply drinking a juice twice a day. Find out more. Go to americaoutloud.shop and click on the organic energies use formula. Do your own research. You know me. I want you to be an informed computer consumer. I want you to know what's in it, I want you to know what you're putting in

your body, and I want you to decide whether or not this is the best solution for you. If it is, or if you think it is, use the code OutLoud at checkout and you'll get 20% off of your order. So if you're looking for a way to eat healthier, getting more the essential nutrients your body needs, getting organic probiotic food without the hassle of crazy diets or funky supplements, check out organic energy juice by going to uh americaoutloud.shop, clicking on the organic

energy juice panel, and do your research. Be that informed consumer. And don't forget, if this is for you, if you're willing to give this a try, use that code OutLoud at checkout and you'll get 20% off of your order. So you get to save money, you get to eat healthier, and you get to do it with a simple, easy to use, even tasty juice drink that you drink twice a day. Works for me, and I think it'll work for you.

During treatment, City Tap water molecule structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab-certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for

your home on the go at chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the wellness company, and I know this personally. I exercised, ate a healthy diet, and had no symptoms when a routine mammogram resulted in a cancer diagnosis. It revealed a hard truth. Even healthy people can get cancer, and much of modern medicine is reactive, not preventative. So I began asking a different question. What can we do daily

to support the body before something goes wrong? That question led me to formulate SHIELD. SHIELD is a two-part nutraceutical system designed to support immune balance, antioxidant defense, and cellular health. A chemical-free cocoa mix and soft gels containing medicinal mushrooms, turmeric, green tea extract, olive leaf, berberine, and black seed oil. Prevention is power. Visit twc.health slash outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. We wouldn't go a day without washing

our hands, brushing our teeth, and washing our nose. Well, wait, we wash our nose? Yes, the number one place where bacteria, viruses, and pollen enter the body is through the nose. So the average person breathes over 23,000 times a day. That's 23,000 opportunities for bacteria, viruses, and irritants to get into your nose and make you sick. For an extra layer of protection, wash your nose with clear. That is clear X-L-E-A-R. Clear's drug-free nasal spray features xylitol, an ingredient proven

to block adhesion of many nasty bacteria and viruses, and effectively clean, not just rinse like a saline, but wash your nose. Clear nasal spray quickly alleviates congestion, opens your airway, and ensures your body's natural defenses are strong. Read the research studies for yourself at Clear.com. That's X-L-E-A-R.com. Protect yourself from the pathogens and junk you breathe. Pick up a bottle for you and your family today. Well, digital

finally updated it to AIP principle to remove it.

Today we're saying the courts shall run it again. Well, you know it's an interesting day. When you have a piece of state legislation that's named after you, you'd know you've really made an impression when the name is trying to stop you. See, California Governor Newsom signed a bill, AB 2624, that got nicknamed the Stop Nick Shirley Act. It restricts publication of some certain identifiable information, but only about

workers that are involved in immigration-related services, and only when those workers submit a written request that information not be published. Now, it's interesting because why are they only targeting organizations that provide immigration-related services? Why not other services? My personal opinion is that, well, uh, people close to the politicians in Sacramento uh got exposed for what they were doing. And um, well, the he they're being done

by Nick Shirley, so they had to come up with an act to stop it. Uh Nick Shirley said in a post uh about a he, well, first of all, first of all, Nick Shirley is filed a lawsuit suing California over the Stop Nick Shirley Act. He said in his post announcing it now, in a world where we all want more transparency and not less, it is more critical than ever that we do not just sit back and do nothing. That's why I'm filing this lawsuit against the state of California. Again, because California is trying to hide information. Now

I understand this idea of doxing. Is there certain information that should not be exposed at any time, right? Personally identifiable information. Uh PI, when I worked in IT, when I worked in data centers, very often we were dealing with products that involve personally identifiable information. We had to be very careful that that data was highly protected. Um, name, social security number, uh things like that were really protected from outside viewing because of its critical nature. That's not what

I understand this this act is is about. Uh according to Mr. Shirley, it's about shutting him down because he was exposing the type of fraud in California that became such a big deal in Minnesota. Now, again, I'm not saying that's true. I'm just saying this is what he's saying. But I find it interesting that we're going to have a lawsuit about what information can be exposed and under what situations. Now, again, person identifiable information, your name, your social security number, uh, your

phone number, your home address. I agree that should be kept secure. Uh, the fact that you work at a certain agency or you work with a certain group and or activities you've you've done in public, not so much. So we'll have to wait and see. We'll have to see where this lawsuit goes. Um here's another one. The this we're going to cross the coast to New York, New York City, where uh Mayor Mandami is setting up his city-owned grocery stores. And as I said, there's going to be

a lot of um, there's a lot of issues with this, not the least of which is what it does to competition. See, an angel Rafael Nunez happens to own a full-service grocery store just four blocks from where the New York City Economic Development Corporation plans to open their first city-owned grocery store just next year. You can imagine with a grocery store which has a city mandate to price certain items

30% below market, in other words, to lose money and attempt to, well, help people buy food, it's going to put other people out of business. See, Mr. Nunez had just purchased a new refrigeration display. He wanted to put fresh produce and meat at his uh at his counter at his supermarket in the South Bronx. Um, he's got a nice supermarket. He worked, he's been in the community for decades, and now he's concerned

because with a city-owned grocery store just four blocks away, a store with a mandate to sell food, basic food items at 30% below market rate. How is he going to how's he going to be able to make enough money to pay off the loan he took out to get the refrigeration displayed to provide fresh uh produce and vegetables, uh produce and meat to his neighbors? Neighbors, by the way, he's had he's been for 40 years. He spent

40 years building this business in the neighborhood, and he may lose it because of Mare Mandami's uh socialist communist uh food takeover. You see, these these markets are not a zero-sum gain. It's not like uh uh they're going into food deserts, places where there are no grocery stores, they're going in where there's competent. And that competition is going to be hard because you have a city subsidized store that's selling food at a loss in order to

take business from where? From the existing stores. Now, what does that mean? Well, it may mean that that store has to lay off employees because they can't afford to continue when they're competing with they lose customers, they're gonna have to lay off employees. They may even have to uh close their doors because they can't sell, they can't raise the prices, their competition just down the street will simply undercut them. So what are they supposed to do? Right? What they're gonna do is they're gonna

put those businesses, those locally owned grocery stores, those private owned groceries, they're gonna put them out of business. And that's uh that I don't know if that's the goal of Mermandami, but it certainly is a quite logical consequence, not only of his plan to put in these grocery stores, but where he's putting them. See, if he was putting them in in food deserts, in places where there were no grocery stores, there was no food available, maybe, sorta kinda, you could come up with a weird, twisted argument that would make sense. By putting

your first grocery store just four blocks away from an existing business, what apparently is a thriving business, since, well, again, the owner said, let's expand, let's add some more disp refrigerated display shelves, then you're actually going after existing businesses. Is that really what he wanted? Or is that simply what's the old saying, to make an ominant, you gotta break some eggs? I wonder if Mr. Nunez feels like an egg right about now. I also wonder if Mr. Nunez is

being approached about filing a lawsuit claiming that the city is is committing unfair business practices by intentionally undercutting market prices in an attempt to distort the market. Might be interesting. Here's another action that's likely to lead to uh legal action. Uh Trump issued yet another executive order. This time he's claiming he wants to expand markets for uh ranchers, small meat, and poultry processors. Now, part of the policy again, I

I get I get nervous when presidents start signing EOs like this, but um apparently part of the order is to more vigorously enforce the Packers and Stockyard Act of 1921. So again, the president's job is to faithfully execute the laws of the United States. He sees a law that he believes is not being properly or vigorous, sufficiently vigorously enforced. He wants it enforced better. The law was enacted to what allegedly, right? Because this is Congress we're talking about, to promote fair competition in livestock meat and poultry

markets. This is what happened when there were large companies that uh were alleged to have engaged in unfair trade practices at the expense of producers and consumers. That's what the law created. I say allegedly, because again, we're talking about Congress, we're talking about politicians. How can you tell the politicians lying? Their lips are moving. Uh, so yeah. So what Trump has said is let's make sure that smaller and local meat producers have fair access to markets. That includes uh meat

processors. Now I have to be um admit I'm a little skeptical, even though if what the what I've heard reported on this executive order is true, it might actually help me. You see, I don't buy beef and pork from the grocery store, at least not usually, not unless except for special unique occasions. I have a farmer not far from me who raises pigs and cattle, and every few months he puts them for sale and I buy them from him. I

go right to the to the owner, I buy the the animal, he takes them to a processing plant to process the animal. I pay the the processing plant for the for that processing, and I have a freezer full of fresh beef and fresh pork. In other words, I've got a small local uh uh producer, beef and pork. I have a a small local meat processor, and I want them to have a fair shot. I like getting my my beef and pork locally. In fact, if I could find a place to get chicken and poultry, I'd probably

do that too. Uh it's nice having, again, I know what's in the beef, I know what's in the pork, I know the guy that's growing it. I like this. It's the way I've done this for several years now. It to me, it's the best beef and the best pork I've had in a long, long time. In fact, I think it's probably the best beef and the best pork since my or at least the best pork since my brother-in-law raised pigs many, many years ago. And we got some of the pigs off of him. So again, fresh, not the big processors. Now, I know not everybody can

do that. Uh, I understand that. I just want to make sure that the the playing ground is fair. The thumb isn't on the scale of the big producers, and the thumb isn't on the scale of the small producers. I want things to be open and fair. And again, I said I get nervous when when presidents are signing IEOs because sometimes, even if Donald Trump too, goes way beyond their constitutional power. So uh Donald Trump announced Friday, or last Friday, uh previous Friday, that um

here's a threat. He goes, uh he said he made an announcement from the Oval Office. What I'm saying is very, very simple is what we should be paying the lowest interest rate in the world. What is he trying to get at? He posted on Truth Social, lower the rate, or I'll stop trading with countries with which we have a deficit. He's talking about the Federal Reserve interest rates. Now, understand the Federal Reserve to me is a it's a constitutional disaster. Right? Because again, uh Congress doesn't have the legal authority

to create a central bank. Uh you've got the whole issue of the banks are the banks themselves are supposedly independent. Congress doesn't have the authority to create entities outside of the government, outside of the federal government. Uh the Board of Governors, though, is supposedly a branch of the government, at least according to Doc to uh uh uh Justice Thomas, but it claims to be independent, it claims to not to not be uh under the executive branch, so it's kind of a

rogue agency, which I do believe needs to be. But now you have Donald Trump that says, you're going to do what I want you to do, or I'm going to exercise a power I don't have. Remember, Congress controls foreign commerce, not the president. So unless the president has a law passed by Congress that allows him to interrupt trading with with certain countries based on a Federal Reserve rate, and

an independent rate, then it would just be another unconstitutional act done by this president. Again, one in a fairly long list of uh unconstitutional actions Mr. Trump has made. Now, I understand Donald Trump's frustration. He believes that the economy is being held back because of high interest rates. And pretty much since uh, well, since he was campaigning for his second term of president, he said that the Federal Reserve is hampering the economy,

holding interest rates unnaturally high. Uh and uh he's demanded that they go down. But of course, since the Fed claims to be independent from the president, they don't have to listen to him. He can't order them to lower the rates, according to what they've said. Uh again, I have an issue. Congress, if Congress creates an agency to execute that law, must be done by the president. The president, Article 2, Section 1, the executive power of the United States is vested in a president of the United States.

Only the president has the power to execute the laws of the United States, not the branches, not the boards, not the bureaucracy, the president. So, and that's an interesting uh case I covered. Uh I wrote an article recently about two cases decided by the Supreme Court that involved allegedly independent agencies. Um keep an eye on them. They'll be on AmericaOut Loud.news uh fairly shortly, I believe. But I'm also looking at the logic of the threat, all right, because the

Federal Reserve uh is allegedly trying to manage the economy through interest rates, the interest rate it offers to banks and other entities. But Donald Trump says, if you don't do what I want, I'm going to destroy another part of the of our economy, foreign trade. And again, where the where's the law that gives the president this authority? I'm not aware of it. Um, then again, how often have I seen Donald Trump write an executive order that says, under the authority you granted me by

the constitutional laws of the United States, I'm going to do this. When neither the law nor the Constitution of the United States allows him to do that. Happens time and time again. And again, that's why I believe we the people need to read instead of the Constitution. We need to know, we need to understand so we can look at what's going on and make a logical, logical, rational decision about whether the person we told our states to elect to execute the laws of the United States is actually fulfilling his oath to do so. And if he's not, what

are we going to do about it? Because ultimately the states cast their votes for uh decided who which presidential electors to choose based on the votes of we, the people, in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. So we need to be the ones deciding whether or not they're doing a good job or not. Okay, I have another break coming up. Before I go, though, you know, you have choices. It's amazing. We we still live in a mostly free market society, which means you have choices. Who do you choose to provide your

wireless service? More importantly, not just wireless service. Are the people you're doing business with supporting the things you support, or are they attacking the things you support? Are they protecting your rights or are they trying to violate your rights? Now, Patriot Mobile is America's only Christian conservative wireless provider. That's not why I joined them. I joined them years ago, not because they're Christian conservative, not because they've got great 4G and 5G coverage and all the same networks across the country, same networks that the major carriers use, not even because their

customer support is 100% US-based. It is nice to talk to a human being that actually speaks English as a native language. No, I joined Patriot Mobile because they take a portion of every dollar to support organizations that are fighting for your rights. First Liberty, Turning Point USA, uh Students for Life America. They also support uh the sanctity of life, our veterans and our first responders. That's why I not only became a customer, I became an affiliate, which means now when you

pay yourself when you pay your Patreon Mobile bill, you're also supporting the Constitution study. So the time is now. Join me and others who have made the switch to Patriot Mobile and use the code Constitution to get your cell phone activation absolutely free. Use your cell phone to stand against those that are trying to turn America into a Marxist dystopia. Go to pagermobile.com such constitution, find a plan that works for you, see if you're eligible for a discount. NRA members, families with multiple lines, veterans, first responders can all get discounts.

And then use the code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. Imagine taking your cell phone around the country and still be defending your rights with it. But only if you go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution, finding a plan and discount that works for you. And don't forget, you've got that code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. Now I also hope you'll join me at AmericaOutloud.news. I go there each and every day for news and information. But Paul, you've got the radio program. That's true, but that's not why I go there. We live in the information age. Information's

at our fingertips. But where do you go? What is your trusted source to give you that first cut at what information to see? For me, one of those is AmericaOutloud.news. I'd love you to join me, but I'd also like you to do your part. Do like I do. Read the stories, read the articles, then share them. Watch the videos, listen to the podcast, share them. Friends, family, neighbors, social media, civic groups, wherever you can. See, by sharing this information, by exposing the news that the corporate media doesn't want people to

know, you're helping to secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you

can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code out loud for an exclusive offer. Have you been looking for a healthy snack for on the go? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy savory

bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Bear bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together with syrups or sweeteners. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com slash outlaw.

That's because we're getting closer to the next term of the Supreme Court. Of course, they've got cases they're looking at. There are cases in state court, in lower federal courts, the inferior courts. There's a lot going on. But one of the things I always tell you is I love questions. And I got asked a very interesting question, one I had to really dig into. And it actually involves uh the state of Missouri, uh their redistricting, and the Supreme Court of the United States. Now, what happened is Missouri is one

of those states that created a new uh district map last year. Uh it was adopted, and it's been used for the state's primary election just last month. However, not everybody was happy with that, and there has been an attempt, a set of petitions to put a ballot referendum to ditch the new map and go back to the old map. But that referendum hasn't happened yet. That to me is is really important.

Okay, so the the uh plaintiffs in the suit um wanted the old map put back in place, which is kind of crazy because they've already had an election, but it gets weirder. So the the court said the the state supreme court said that Missouri officials wrongly dismissed a petition with more than 300,000 signatures on it to let the state voters decide on the map via referendum before it took effect.

Okay, here's the problem. How can you have a referendum that's gonna happen in November for a map that took effect last year? Right? It was the the law was enacted last year, it was signed last year, it took effect last year, and now they're saying there's got to be a referendum on it before it takes effect. I'm trying to figure out where they came up with that logic. But as I understand it, the Missouri Supreme Court has said that even though the primary was conducted under the new

map, somehow now you're supposed to conduct the general election under the old map, which has which means you have people that won a prime. As I understand, I was told by somebody that lives in Missouri, they have candidates that won a primary that no longer live in the district, which means they cannot run for the in the general election. This is crazy. Now again, I uh and again, I'm still looking for more details on this because um it it again it's crazy because here's

there's a couple things uh that I finally need to consider. So accord the state law put this new map in effect. It is legally in effect. Nobody challenged uh nobody I'm aware of at least won a challenge to the map before the primaries. Somebody might have challenged it, but nobody won a challenge. So there's no legal basis for the new the old the new map to be set aside. In other words, there's no court decision that says it's unconstitutional, there's no law that says it's unconstitutional.

What you have is a referendum that will be on the that won't be held until November to decide whether or not the people want to go with the old map or the new map. All right, but that hasn't happened yet. That's an important point. That hasn't happened yet. But yet the court says they have to use the old map, even though there's no legal standing, there's no legal decision that requires that that's found the new map unconstitutional. Now,

you would not be surprised if this seems to be more partisan gamesmanship, right? Because when the mis when Missouri redistricted in 2025, one of the districts they have one more district that leans Republican. Meaning, well, the Democrats are not happy. And of course, if the old map is put back in place, they believe that uh uh a Democrat uh contender uh will win re-election, which again

foils the republicans' plan to get another um Republican member of the House. And by the way, this is Donald Trump's been pushing this in several states. So which again, yet you have is partisan gamesmanship. That's what this is all about. So I this person asked me the question. They said, Can you please look at this? This is crazy. Um, you know, it's going, and by the way, now this the the I believe the state of Missouri has asked the Supreme Court to weigh in because the uh I guess the um

there are be they've asked the court to to weigh in by September 14th, no, just later this week, because there's a federal law that dictates when overseas and military ballots have to be mailed out. And the state needs to know are we doing the new map or the old map as part of that mailing? They've got to have time to print the ballots and mail them out. Now, the the Supreme Court's not going to hear this case. What they're really asking for is one of the justices to

issue a stay on the Missouri Supreme Court's decision to allow the election to go under the new map, which the primaries ran under. Uh, and uh then once the uh um the ballot referendum is happened, they then the state will have a decision for the people, new map or old map. Is it is is the case gonna happen? I don't know. I I truly do not know. But I keep coming back to the fact there has even the what the Supreme Court

said, the Missouri Supreme Court said that um uh you're you're that the state ignored petitions for a referendum that hasn't happened yet. Petitions are not votes. Petitions are not referendum decisions. This is merely saying you're going to have a referendum. The referendum doesn't have it yet. I still have not seen a legal action, a legal document that says the new map is unconstitutional and you have to go back to the old map. Right? Haven't seen

it. Even what came out of the Missouri Supreme Court. So we're gonna have to wait and see. But in doing my research and digging into this quagmire of nonsense, I found something very interesting. So I was looking through the uh the Constitution of Missouri. Now, uh according to one of the articles I read, um the the the claim is that Missouri's Constitution, once there's enough signatures

for a referendum, it should it would according to the Missouri Constitution, it would suspend the new map and replace it with the uh uh previous map authorized by 2022. But I looked at the Constitution of Missouri and I didn't find that anywhere. Nowhere. There's another point that was made, and this comes with the decision of the Missouri Supreme Court. Uh they noted that the Constitution of Missouri contains a list of prohibited legislations that

can be targeted through the referendum process, and it does not include uh that I'm sorry, let me say that again. Prohibited legislation to be targeted through the referendum. There are certain legislation you can't do via referendum, and according to the Missouri Supreme Court, it says it does not include federal redistricting plans. So I went to the Constitution of Missouri and I looked under the legislation, or more I could I looked at the details and I found uh Article III, section three, which is election of representatives, legislative redistricting,

methods of house independent bipartisan citizenship right. So this section deals with redistricting. And it says things like district shall be nearly as nearly equal as practical in the population, the district shall establish in a manner of law so as to comply with all requirements of the United States Constitution. All right, they're talking about districting. And as I'm reading through this, I found this line. Uh sub-item item I no redistricting plan shall be subject to

the referendum. Let me say that again no redistricting plan shall be subject to the referendum. Now, I'm not an expert on the Missouri Constitution. I haven't read through it, but it seems to me that under the Constitution of Missouri, no redistricting plan is to be subject to a referendum. Which means the referendum violates the Constitution of Missouri. Which means the Supreme Court of

Missouri not only made a mistake, they got their decision completely backwards. If they say that the Missouri Constitution does not prohibit um uh the the sections prohibiting legislation that can be done via referendum does not include federal redistricting plans, it seems to say so, right there in Article 3, uh section three, sub-item I, that no redistricting plans shall be subject to the referendum. Uh to me, that seems pretty straightforward. Now

we'll have to wait and see because again, you got attorneys and you've got the Supreme Court, and it's a royal mess. And I want to thank the person that brought this question to me. And uh I I appreciate it because she she brought it, she says she thought I would find it interesting, and I kind of do. I also find it a bit frustrating because to me the answer was really I just simply searched for referendum in the Constitution of Missouri, and in a couple of clicks found that.

So it can't be that hard. I'm I'm you know, I'm not a legal legal. It wasn't that hard to say, wait a second, though just so again, it's a mess. Um I can't wait to get a chance to answer. I haven't had the chance to talk to her since she asked me to look at this. I'm kind of looking forward to it because it's gonna be I think it's gonna be kind of a of a an interesting discussion. Because again, now you've got uh Missouri's basically been put into a constitutional crisis of its own constitution

by the Supreme Court of Missouri. They've made this mess, and I guess they're gonna have to figure out how to live with it. Because uh unless someone points out that uh excuse me, you can't the the that referendum is unconstitutional the referendum itself is unconstitutional, so um how are they gonna deal with that? And since we're talking about voting and law cases, apparently there's a group in Michigan that has been gathering petitions

or petition signatures to place an item on the Michigan ballot to uh uh require proof of citizenship in order to register to vote. Now, you know me, first thing I did, I went to the Constitution of Michigan, did a quick search. Article 2, Section 1, which is titled Qualification of Electors Residents, uh reads: Every citizen of the United States who has attained the age of 21 years, who has resided in the state six months, and who meets the requirements of a local resident provided by

law shall be an elector and qualified to vote in any election except as otherwise provided in this constitution. So the Constitution of Michigan says that every citizen of the United States is who's who's 21 years of age and resides in the state at least six months is entitled to vote in any or all of their elections. So there is a citizenship requirement in the Constitution of Michigan in order to vote. So why the big deal about actually proving that? Well, apparently, Michigan

has had an issue with people registering to vote that haven't proven their actually citizenship. So it's like, okay, let's add to that. In order to register vote, you have to prove your citizenship. You have to have some document that proves you're a U.S. citizen. Seems reasonable to me. However, the Michigan Supreme Court said, well, the problem is, well, actually, the problem started before that. Because according to Americans for Citizens Voting, uh, they made this emergency petition to the Supreme Court because the Michigan Board of State

canvassers refused to certify the petition for the November 3rd electron, despite the group having more than 700,000 signatures and needing only 446,000. In other words, they have like 40% more signatures than they need to put on the ballot, but the Board of State canvases refused to certify the petition. Uh that's why they said we need emergency action because it's September 14th, big day. They've

got to get this done. That's when they have to have the ballots printed. Now, again, the Supreme Court is not in session, so this went to Justice Kavanaugh. He covers that circuit, and he rejected the request by Americans for citizens voting for their emergency, um, their emergency grant, uh, their emergency request um to put this on the ballot. By the way, the Michigan Supreme Court also rejected the group, their measure uh at the state level.

Now, again, I find this interesting. You have you need 446,000, they got 700,000. All right, so not all of them are going to be effective. Why is the state board of canvassers divorcing, why are they refusing to certify the petition? And why are the courts not granting a redress for the grievance? I don't know. I don't have the details, but again, it shows how you've got courts that get in the middle of all this because we've gotten to a point where a law isn't a law until a court says it's okay.

And that's kind of the craziness that we've gotten to today. And it's also why I say the courts shall rise ride again, because they are right over top of us in many cases. Now, I mentioned that one of the stories came from a person asking a question. I love when people ask questions. In fact, if I had more questions, I'd actually do a whole segment on them. Now, if you have a question, it doesn't have to be a great question. I I as long as it's as it's polite and it's about the constitution, right? You don't want rudeness, something

to do with the constitution, the constitution study, or something we've done here. Well, then just go to um constitutionstudy.com/slash questions and ask your question. You can also email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com. Now, if you'd like me to answer your question on the radio, well, there's a checkbox in the form that says please enter on America Out Loud Talk Radio, or you can just mention it in your email. I'll be more than happy to. Now, I do need your name and email address because well, I'm going to email you a response. But again, if you'd also like me to answer it on the radio, I'd be more

than happy to. But I'd love more of this type of content. I think it's, well, it's interesting for me. I hope it's interesting for you. And I hope it's a type of content that shows, you know, these questions are uh can be very helpful for educating you and me. But I also think it's important to see what's going out in the world, not just what I see in my little corner of it. Now, I hope you'll enjoy the program. I hope you come back and join us for the Constitution study every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern time on America Out Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network.

You can listen on our media player. We've also got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, you can always listen via podcast. It does take a day or two for an episode to go from talk radio to podcast, but you get to listen to your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave me a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps algorithm share the Constitution study with more people. You can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news. But please share those links, share this program, and helps share the blessings of liberty with everyone who

calls this great nation home. home.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What to expect as socialism grows in America

    Nov 20, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The fundamental flaw in America’s gun control laws

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court packing, impeachment, and the race to act before January

    Nov 18, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Are we a nation of laws or ruled by judges?

    Nov 15, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. After the midterms: More of the same, with a left turn

    Nov 14, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...

    Credit the people on this episode