The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - The failed execution of Christa Pike brings up several questions about both the death penalty and the methods of execution used. What does the Constitution say about the ultimate sanction? Is the death penalty cruel and unusual punishment? What are the due process requirements before the state can deprive a convicted felon of...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
This is the Constitution Study of the American Lord with your host, Paul Engel. What is the ultimate sanction for criminal behavior? A recent failed execution in Tennessee has brought this topic front and center. What are the issues from a constitutional standpoint? Well, that's what we'll take a look at
over the next hour or so. Hello there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacherizing generation be free. I'm glad you could join me, even though this is a rather somber topic. This may be something that you don't want little ears to hear. You know your children best. Um, you know, a lot of people have a lot of emotional issues when it comes to the death penalty, and and rightfully so. Um again, I refer to it as the ultimate sanction because, well, it's the one thing you
could never take back. I mean, if you put a person in jail for life and then find out 20, 30, even 40 years later that he was wrongfully convicted, you can at least let him go and say, uh, we apologize and and try to make some sort of compensation. You can't do so with an execution. And this has brought up a lot of interesting topics, both from a constitutional and a biblical standpoint. Um, so I wanted to take some time because of this uh Krista Pike attempted, and I should
say failed or botched, execution and look at some of the issues and ask this question about the the ultimate sanction. Now, for those of you who may not know, uh, Krista Pike was uh convicted of a fairly heinous murder back in 1995. Uh, she was convicted of uh taking an 18, uh an 18-year-old girl, um, I'm sorry, a 19-year-old girl, into the woods with her
then boyfriend, uh, cutting her throat, uh, uh attacking her with a meat cleaver. They even took a piece of asphalt that they had carved into a pentagram and just carved it, put shoved it right into her forehead and her chest. It was a fairly um uh hands craft. In fact, according to court documents, she actually kept a piece of her victim's skull. Now, this is back in 1995, um, when she was 18 years old. I mean,
this is a seriously disturbed person. And she was not only found guilty, she was sentenced to death. Uh, I believe the sentence was imposed in 1996. I think that's what I I'm dealing with a lot of information from different sources that are don't always jive. But um uh while uh she was um in jail, um she was also convicted of an attempted first-degree
murder of another inmate. So again, this this but it's now 2026. In other words, it's 30 years, I believe 30 years after her conviction. But this was noteworthy, and it made the national news not simply because it was an execution, but she because she would be the first woman executed in Tennessee in 200 years. So this got a lot of attention. Of course, she went through all the pleas, she did everything she could to try to avoid
the the execution to try to prevent it. And uh, well, it eventually said they her her appeals ran out. Like I said, 30 years. And she was uh strapped to a gurney uh September the 30th, I believe it was. And um, she was given not one but two injections of phenobarbital. That's the the the the the lethal injection uh uh pen I'm sorry, pentabarbital that uh that's that's what they use for the lethal
injection. She was given two doses. Now witness has stated that she was she they heard her snoring and making other noises after the drug. And of course, my first reaction was this is an execution. Why are we playing, you know, playing cheap with the drugs? Why are we not making sure there's a dose, certainly high enough to uh ensure that death comes about? Well, I found out a little bit more. See, medical experts said that it would be difficult to
to access uh this woman's veins because of a blood condition she had. So now I want to back up for a second. Now I have a different question. Well, if we thought that a a lethal injection would be difficult to because of of her blood condition, why not choose another form of of execution? I mean, this was the the state imposing this sentence on a convicted felon, but they don't offer any sort of you know
the the there should be a a point that says, wait a second, if this is gonna be if if a medical uh execution is going to be problematic, may lead to to other issues, then why persist with that? Um that that's a question I think is gonna have to be answered at some point. Now, let me back up a little bit. Let's start with uh the whole question of uh of execution, of the death penalty. Because I know a lot of people have a lot of strong feelings, and and I understand that. Uh,
I know a lot of people that say, well, you know, the Bible says thou shalt not kill. Actually, if you go back to the Hebrew when you read the Ten Commandments, it's thou shalt not murder. Because if you look at the Old Testament, there's lots of scenarios. There are a lot of crimes where the penalty is death. So, yeah, it's not thou shalt not murder, which is exactly what this woman is has been convicted of doing. She committed a heinous murder. But what are the constitutional questions? Let's start with the constitutional questions here. Now, uh there
is no promotion or prohibition of the death penalty directly in the constitution. Right? Uh, Congress, the only place we get close is Congress does have the power to declare the punishment for treason, but they're limited in that it cannot work what's called a corruption of blood. Meaning uh there cannot be anything that impacts the rest of the family. You can have a forfeiture, but only during the life of the person. It is limited to the person that committed the
crime. Um now, some people look and say, well, what about the what about the Eighth Amendment and cruel and unusual punishment? Well, there's an interesting question here, right? So um is the death penalty cruel and unusual punishment? Well, some people think so. Some people think it's it's it's it's it's better to spend your life in jail, in prison, than to be killed. And uh other people claim, well, if you're for the death penalty,
you don't value life. And here's the interesting thing what about the life of this woman's victim? Again, she was lured into the woods with her and her boyfriend, she was killed, her body was mutilated. Um, there's some pretty nasty stuff. What about the life of that woman, the the victim here? That's been my issue. Is is is um when you talk about life, you can't just talk about the life of the criminal, you gotta talk about the life of their victim, and what
is the value of that life, and what is the proper punishment? If we want the punishment to fit the crime, what is the proper punishment? Now, for those of you with a more biblical standpoint, I've already mentioned the Ten Commandments say, Thou shalt not murder, not you shall not kill. Uh it's a flaw in the translation. Um but there's also the question of well, we value life. Yeah, you know what? I'm I'm in a scenario where could I sentence somebody? If I were
sitting on a jury, could I convict someone of a heinous crime? If the evidence was there, could I apply a sentence of of execution? For me, there has to be a higher standard than the one we currently use. See, to be convicted of a crime, you need uh beyond a reasonable doubt. In other words, the state needs to show that that person is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If there's anything that raises a reasonable doubt, you can't find them guilty. But as I said,
execution, the death penalty, it's the ultimate sanction. And to me, the ultimate sanction requires the ultimate proof. In other words, it has to be more than beyond a reasonable doubt. In my mind, before the sentence of of execution sh could be available, there must be beyond any doubt. There must be evidence so so uh confirming that um well that there's absolutely no doubt at all.
I could say, you know what, I I can find it yeah, all right, you're beyond a reasonable doubt, but I have to be convinced that this person committed those acts and and and uh again, I wasn't on the jury. I don't have access to all the the data. I'm not saying I would make this decision in this case. But I think from both as a Christian and as a citizen of the United States, we need to have a a standard when it comes to the death penalty that uh recognizes that you know what, we're human beings.
And if there's a possibility we got things wrong, we have to have an opportunity to correct that. That's why when I look at this and say, it took 30 years to execute this woman. Now, personally, I think 30 years is a bit excessive, but because that's 30 years, she's behind jail. Right? You've already if you if if you're gonna kill her, why did it take 30 years? I I agree she should have opportunities to appeal and to to prevent to present new evidence and and even to the mitigation
of not necessarily the criminality, but to the mitigation of the sentence. I agree she should have that. How much is enough? Should you know because let's face it, 30 years behind jail behind bars, and then you're gonna kill her. That to me seems somewhat cruel. Now, is it crueler than doing it after 10 years? Five years? I don't have a good solid answer. There's there's way too many variables for me to come up with a a quick and easy
solution. But here's what I do know. Right? I do know that it appears that the state in the uh the state of Tennessee in the the in their attempted execution of Ms. Pike, they failed. They took a person that they knew had a medical condition that would make uh uh a lethal injection difficult, and they used lethal injection to try and kill her. Now her attorneys say that uh, you know, hey,
she may have been 15-20 minutes when she was suffering. But she was s suffering. That's their again, this is this is her lawyer, so well, um I I gotta take that with a grain of salt, right? I wasn't there, I don't have the evidence. I I'm I'm speculating based on the information I have. But that does seem to be like, you know, it it it it was a cruel and unusual to to you know to
actually to attempt a lethal injection to someone for whom that you know they they may not have good access to the veins to properly deliver the medication to make sure that the that the death is at least humane. It is it is doesn't involve pain and suffering. That it it's uh you know, basically it's quick and as humane as we can make it. That I think uh might be an interesting issue. I was listening to uh a report uh this morning, and uh one attorney said that uh now because
of the injury she has suffered, um she was, by the way, she was taken by ambulance. She's in last I saw as uh is in critical condition. Um she is receiving life-saving care. Uh, and this one uh uh attorney, granted he was a news commentator, was saying that while she could not be attempted to execute again. He said it would be against the law. And I he didn't say what law, and I'm kind of curious. Is it because of the cruel and unusual nature of her first
attempt? Is it because she's no longer competent? Well, she's already been sentenced to death, so I don't think her competency would be the issue. But then again, I don't know the law he's referring to. More things that we that I think uh we need to stop and consider. Um so far I haven't heard anything from the family of her victim from their attorneys. I I don't know how they look at this, um, but uh
the way it stands as of this recording, uh again, she's in crit uh the Ms. Pike is in critical condition. She's receiving life-saving care. Um, and uh the hope of her lawyers is that her sentence will be commuted. Again, depending on her current condition, she may not survive. Um, what would the outcome be of this? To me, there's a lot of things that we need to, I think we need to really stop and have a serious discussion about.
Um, however, before I continue, I I have a break coming up. Now, before I take that break, uh, I want to remind you, you know, we we we've we're talking today about the death penalty, but there's a lot of things that government can do that have long-term, sometimes even lethal effects on us. And uh, well, I think our reaction to COVID-19 was one of them. And include, I mean, we we're we're still dealing with with the the aftereffects of it. Of course, you've got the the mRNA quote
unquote vaccine, which uh not only did not do what they said it was going to do, and that is remain in the in the injection site, it was designed to spread throughout the body. It's led to shedding, it's led to long COVID, it's led to vaccine injury. And what do we do? I mean, what do we the people do? Well, our friends at the wellness company have put together a product called spike support that's designed to protect, to dissolve and block the the spike
protein, the toxic part of COVID-19, the part that your body reacts to in a fluorinflammatory um nature. So if you have someone who is dealing with uh the long-term effects of the spike protein, or you're concerned that you know you may be exposed to someone based on shedding or COVID-19, check it out. Go to AmericaOutloud.shop and click on the spike support panel. Do your own research, right? I'm not a doctor, I don't play with MTV. Uh it's
it's backed by documentary research. You may want to check that. It's been vetted by the chief medical board of the wellness company. You want to do your own research, you want to be an informed consumer. And if you decide to give it a try, well, use the code OutLoud at checkout to get 20% off of your order. So if you're dealing with the effects of the spike protein, again, from COVID, from the mRNA, from any of these things, check out spike support. It's I've recommended it to people by going to AmericaOutloud.shop, click on the spike support panel,
do your research, right? Be that informed consumer. That's what we want. And then when you're ready to check out, please use the code out loud at checkout. Not only do you get 20% off of your order, but it helps them know that you're listening to America Out Loud and helps us bring other deals and products to you. Again, take control of your health, be in charge of your own health. And when it comes to the spike protein, check out spike support for the wellness company by going to americaut loud.shop, click on the spike support panel, do
your research, be that informed consumer, and use that code Out Loud to get 20% off of your order. Feeling run down, foggy, or constantly drained? Your body might be lacking the support it needs at the cellular level. Recharge from the Wellness Company is a doctor-formulated supplement designed to restore your energy, focus, and immune function. It features the first ever combination of methylene blue and
urolithin A. Clinically studied ingredients that support mitochondrial health, boost cellular repair, and enhance cognitive performance. With added NAD3, COQ10, and PQQ, recharge is the daily solution for deep lasting energy, not just a temporary boost. Visit TWC. Power up your body and mind with recharge. During treatment, City Tap water molecules structure gets
messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com
forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere
city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self-Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer.
We're taking a sober look at the ultimate sanction. After the failed execution of a woman here in Tennessee, it's been in the news, it's gotten a lot of attention, and I wanted to take some time and well uh to make a take a serious look at the situation. I want to pick up now with what happens now. Right? Uh Ms. Pike, the the convicted criminal, the convicted murderer, um, she was they they attempted to execute her.
And after the failed execution, uh Governor Lee put a pause on all executions in the state. Uh he said uh he wanted a comprehensive third-party review to determine exactly what occurred. Uh he also said carrying out a lawfully imposed sentence is among the state's most serious responsibilities, and the people of Tennessee expected to be done in a manner that is not only legal and constitutional, but is effective. All right, that sounds that sounds good. And the the Department, the Tennessee Department of Correction says it followed every state
of the steps, lawfully established execution protocol, which is also approved by the Attorney General's office. In other words, we did everything we were supposed to, but there's something there's still something I'm I'm concerned with here. And again, I'm a Tennessee citizen now. I live here. Um let's start with the fact that uh leading up to the execution, for the weeks leading up to the execution, um Pike's legal team requested an all-female lethal injection team. I don't think that would have made
a difference, but she wanted uh a female team. But she all she said, or she wanted to be killed by a firing squad or hanging. Now, to me, this is interesting. She requested either an all-female team or a different form of execution, knowing that, again, now I found out that the medical experts said this is going to be a difficult lethal injection because of a blood disorder that Pike has. They knew it was going to be difficult. Why did the state not choose another form of execution? If
this was going to be difficult, why not? By the way, this is not the first recent botched execution in Tennessee. Uh, I think it was May of this year. Tennessee attempted to execute a Tony Carruthers again by lethal injection. And again, it failed. And uh the governor postponed his his sentence until May of next year, May of 27th, got a one-year reprieve. And now we have a second lethal. So to me, there
are problems with lethal injection, at least how that's being implemented here in the state of Tennessee. I don't know, I don't know what the problems are. Uh I believe the governor uh is correct. Let's get a review, let's figure out what happened here. Why did this not work? Was it due to her blood condition? Was it due to how the drugs were administered? Was it was it due to the amount of drugs that were administered? Now say I'm not a doctor, I don't play one on TV, but as I understand it, lethal dose varies by person to person.
It's not a binary decision. This much is lethal, this much is not. It depends a lot on the person, on their medical history, their blood chemistry, any possible resistance they might have to or or or or you know, if they've used certain drugs over time, their body builds up a resistance to it. To me, there could be a lot of function uh of issues. Is is a two lethal doses that sufficient to deal with her medical condition? I don't know. These are concerns that that I have. And these are, by the way, are concerns I've
had with with the um lethal injection in the past. Um, no one's been able to tell us what it feels like. That's another concern. What does it feel like we can we can estimate, we can guess. Uh, and again, as I understand it, there are drugs given to the patient to calm them, uh, so that, and uh, I believe to help keep them from feeling any pain. But, you know, again, but again, she asked for or said, well, if I can't get all female team, how about another form
of execution? She wanted, she asked for her lawyers asked for firing squad or hanging. Um, I don't know what the odds are of a failed execution by firing squad. I suppose people could miss um hanging, same thing. Uh, again, hanging can be done correctly or incorrectly. There, there, there's concerns. If we're going to perform to use the ultimate sanction on a human being, well then we have to be sure that
we're doing it right. We cannot uh I there may be some for whom the idea of a slow, painful death seems just, but as a society, I don't think that's a place we should go. I don't think it's a place we can go. And uh that again, that's a consideration that we have. So uh yeah, I agree with Governor Lee saying, let's figure out what's going on, let's put into place steps in our process to make sure that people with can medical conditions that
might have a uh a negative impact on a lethal injection are either accounted for in the process or another form of execution is is is given. Uh again, if she had a known medical condition, I don't know what this medical condition is, just something about her blood. I don't know how that would impact um a lethal injection, right? Uh I know that you know some people, uh especially intravenous drug unersers, it may be hard to get a vein. And that you
know let's take that into consideration. And I I think if we're going this is the death penalty, it is serious. And I need to make sure I think we need to make sure that we treat it seriously, that we don't leave somebody potentially in a vegetative state. I I don't know what state other than you know, she's in critical condition. I know what state she's in. Um I know she's receiving life-saving care, but could that be the rest of her life because of how
the execution was attempted? Again, it was fail it failed, but to me this is this is serious. And uh I think we need to look at the process to make sure that if we've sentenced someone to death and they've gone through all their appeals and they are going to be executed, that it is as quick and painless as possible with as little opportunity for there to be problems. That's my opinion, and uh, I think that
would fall under the the cruel and unusual punishment clause of the Eighth Amendment. All right, let's switch gears a little bit. Let's look at another ultimate sanction. I know people a lot of people don't don't like to talk about that way, but that's basically what it is abortion. You did only this time, instead of punishing somebody for what they did wrong, uh you're punishing them as a consequence of what you did. Right? Now, uh after the Dobbs decision, uh this idea that uh you know the that abortion is the quote unquote the
law of the land, it never was, right? Roe v. Wade was never law, it was the opinion of a court, um, a wrong opinion of the court, as it turns out. I'm not the only one to think that. Uh, the Supreme Court came to that same conclusion uh a few years ago. But this has also led to the rise of medical abortions. That's not directly, but with the with so many states now prohibiting abortions within their states, other states have found out that, or I should say, drug manufacturers, drug distributors have found out
that they can do business in those states and still get abortions into states where it's illegal. Uh, states like uh California, Massachusetts, and New York, they've all enacted laws that allow for abortion for anyone. There's no punishment for a doctor who illegally prescribes an abortion drug and then has it sent to a lot a state where such a drug is illegal. Now, attorneys general Liz Morel from Louisiana, Tim Griffin from Arkansas, and
Steve Marshall from Alabama have filed a motion with the Supreme Court saying that these shield laws are not about availability of abortion within those states. They exist to perpetuate abortions outside of those states. In other words, in states that are where those abortions are actually illegal. Now, the the feckless food and drug administration says, hey, we can't do anything until we've done our own review of Myth of Pristone, which you would think that that would have been done before they
actually uh uh approved it for going into the market. Um they they say, no, well, we and we need to go through this remove before we put in some more regulatory uh uh requirements uh with for the the safety of these bills, which their purpose is to kill uh uh a nascent and unborn human being. So I don't know what the definition of safety is. Uh several uh attorneys general did call on Congress to, well, write laws for about interstate
commerce that prevent the uh the distribution of um uh of these abortion-inducing medications into states where the procedure is banned. And of course, well, Congress didn't, right? That really wasn't really wasn't a surprise. But uh A.G. Morrell is is leading this this lawsuit um against, I guess she's going against the FDA and their mail order scheme for Miffit Prestone, but also going after the states, claiming that New York, California, and and
and Massachusetts are actually facilitating criminal conduct within their other states, nullifying their own state laws. She's in Louisiana. She says these states are literally attempting to nullify our state laws simply because they disagree with the policy. That's interfering with another state. And that to me is going to be an interesting question from a constitutional standpoint. Now, I've not heard if SCOTUS has decided to pick up this case or not. If they've granted Sergiari, um, it would be an
interesting discussion. If so, I plan to follow it and and and see what's going on because I'm curious of how the court would look at this scenario of um states shielding actors from criminal activity they're conducting, they are perpetuating or facilitating in other states. It gets real interesting, and something I think uh is worth spending some time looking at. And for again, for anyone out there who's saying, well, Paul, how dare you equate abortion with the death
penalty? How dare I not? Again, both actions involve the death of a human being. One that's been born, one that hasn't, but it still involves the death of a human being. And the the difference is, at least in uh in the case of the death penalty, it's after that person has been convicted generally of a heinous crime. Where with abortion, it's the the the unborn child is the victim. They've done nothing
wrong. There is no due process for them, yet they're being deprived of their life without due process of law. That violates the Fifth Amendment, that violates the 14th Amendment, but yet we kind of wink, wink, nod, nod. We use our euphemisms. Oh, it's not really, you know, we're not really depriving them of the we're not really alive yet, even though, well, basically science and medicine says, yeah, they are alive. They're a unique, well, they're just a a growth inside the mother. Well, no, they have their own DNA, and and uh given all given
without interference, they would eventually be born, and uh suddenly somehow that magical trip down the birth canal changes them from a non-person to a person. Uh, no one's really explained to me why that is supposed to be, but so yeah, I I again I see abortion as the ultimate sanction against an innocent. And as as well, I'm willing to condone the ultimate sanction against a convicted criminal as long as certain hurdles are met, right? Beyond any doubt, that
it's done as as as painless, that the actual act is as quick and painless as possible. Um, you know, that there the right of there should be a right of appeal, but how long should that right appeal? Interesting question. When you're talking about terminating an unborn child for nothing they've done wrong, that to me is is is a heinous violation. And it it is it it it truly is, I think the one day history will look back at that and say, what kind of cruel and evil people were Americans and were
Western society as a whole, to count the the the innocent punishment for the acts of um of the parent. You know, oh yeah, well, you know, I needed you know I was I was too young to have a child. Well then why were you doing things that could lead to childhood, to to parentage? I mean, it's not like we don't know how this works, it's not like it's a mystery how babies are made. At least not to anybody old enough to actually have babies. At least I hope not.
So again, we're still looking at the ultimate sanction, this time against an innocent, uh, as opposed to against a person who is convicted of a crime. And again, people may disagree with capital punishment, they may dis uh disagree with the death penalty. They they may have reasonable arguments. I'm willing to uh to entertain reasonable arguments. Uh maybe I'm wrong, maybe there's something I haven't thought of. But I think if you look at my position, that again, it has to be beyond any doubt,
it has to be an especially especially heinous crime, where the the it's a question of justice for the family of the victim. Not we're not someone, not simply justice for the the accused or the convicted, but you got to remember the family of the victim. Um but we need to do it right. And I think Governor Lee is correct. Let's let's figure out what happened wrong here, and then let's fix the process. Let's make sure that if there's going to be a lethal injection, that person's gonna die. Right? Lethal needs to
be lethal. And if we can't guarantee a lethal injection, then we need to provide for some other form of execution on those rare and extremely rare situations where the ultimate sanction is really the only punishment warranted by the by the the crime. Now I have another break coming up. Before I go, though, you know, who do you buy from? Do you know who they donate to? Are are they donating to organizations that are,
well, opposing your rights? Your your right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures, to be to not be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. Are there people opposing those rights that are being funded by you because of who you did business with? It's time we pay attention to the companies we we work with. Now, I remember a time when everybody was like, yo, buy USA, buy USA, but I think we need a bit more. I think we need to buy from companies that support organizations that are defending our rights. One of those, ladies and gentlemen, is Patriot Mobile, America's
only Christian conservative wireless provider. Now, I joined them several years ago, not because they're Christian conservative, not because they're great 4G and 5G coverage on all the same networks and towers as the major carriers, not because of their 100% US-based customer support. Now, I joined them for one simple reason. They believe what I believe and they put their money where their mouth is. Meaning, Pedro Mobile takes a portion of every dollar and supports organizations that are fighting for your constitutionally protected rights, your freedom of religion, speech, press, to be secure
from unreasonable searches and seizures, should not be deprived of due process. By the way, they also support the sanctity of life which we were talking about. They support our veterans and our first responders. Join me on Patreon Mobile today. Get free activation with the offer code constitution. That's right. When you go to patreonmobile.com says constitution and you sign up for a plan, not only do you support the constitution study, but you get free activation with the offer code constitution. Oh, by the way, are you one of those veterans or first responders? Are you a uh a member of the
NRA or other organizations? Are you a a uh family with multiple lines? You may be eligible for a discount. So you get not only do you get good, great coverage, but you get at a discount. But only if you go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution, find a plan and discount that works for you, and then uh don't forget that code Constitution at checkout to get great cell phone coverage and to support organizations like the Constitution study that are fighting to protect your rights. Now, I also hope you'll swing, you'll join me and swing by AmericaOutloud.news. I go there each and
every day for news and information. Now, someone out there saying, Yeah, but Paul, you got the radio program, you've got your websites and your articles, you need that. Why do I need that? Well, we live in the information age, but many of us have our news curated for us. Somebody decides what's the news we're fit to see. And we rarely uh uh verify that what they're saying is actually true. So I go to AmericaOut Loud.news every day because, well, I've vet I vetted their sources, I get good content from them. I still verify everything that comes out of them,
but I get good content. But it's important that we do more. See, now I take this content and I share it. I want you to as well. Read the stories, read the articles, then share them. I share them on my website, social media, you can share them with friends and family. You listen to a good podcast, you watch a great video, share with friends and neighbors, let them know. Let them know the news that the corporate media doesn't want them to. See, it's by sharing that information, by sharing the news that, well, government and corporate entities don't want us to know, that we help secure the blessings
of liberty for all of us.combar
dot com before your nose, this is one of the greatest bread in the universe. Breathe better, live better. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the go, but although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Beer bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contains six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together
with syrups or sweeteners. But bear bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash outloud. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides that help repair and
restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue, which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root cause, literally. Visit twc.health forward slash outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair regrowth with roots.
Welcome back, everyday Americans. You rejoin the Constitution study. We've been talking about the ultimate sanction, but let's let's shift gears, right? That's that's pretty heavy. Let's shift gears. I still got some serious stuff that we need to talk about. How many of you remember that withdrawal, the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan? I can even remember where I was when I first heard about it. I was in a I was having dinner uh out in uh in uh it was in Wyoming on one of my tours, and I heard about this. And it was a it was a mess. I remember seeing the video of the transport
planes taking off with refugees with Afghans hanging off the wheels, trying to get out because we had worked with them. There were people that we worked with, that we put in harm's way, and now in many cases, we were abandoning them. And and that would that just seemed terrible to me. So, in response to this, the Biden administration created what they call Operation Allies Welcome. And it was meant to uh to resettle the almost 97,000 Afghans that had helped us during the Afghan War
to settle them in the United States. Uh, sounds like a great idea. What could possibly go wrong? Well, according to the Department of Homeland Security's Office of Inspector General, they analyzed a sample of the applications for asylum from these Afghan nationals to be settled in the US. They found errors in 40% of the 4-0, 4D, 4 out of 5 out of 10. They found uh missed aliases, unresolved records,
missing security checks, missing other documentation. 40%. Now, this is a sample of the uh of the applications. Now, according to the report, uh, most of the errors were they missed someone's alias or there was incomplete documentation. Um, two of the cases, however, well, those individuals would have been potentially not allowed into the United States on terrorism-related grounds. Now, listen, two out of the uh was roughly uh 700 uh
files analyzed, that's a small number, but in the wake of the recent attacks in in the UK, um the uh the attempted uh uh hijacking of the uh of the of the flight uh to Tel Aviv, um, we realize it doesn't take a large number to have a big effect. What 20 men killed or almost 3,000 in a single day on 9-11? Think of how many men think of
two what could have been what could have happened, and it again brings into an interesting question. If we're if the federal government is going to allow people in this country under asylum rules, shouldn't that same government be required to follow its own rules? I mean, I agree. If people helped us over there, they risked their lives to help Americans during that conflict. We owe them something. I I agree. Don't we need to make sure that we're actually getting the right people?
That uh oh, by the way, yeah, this person helped us, but oh yeah, they also had an alias that were working for the Taliban. Oh, we didn't get all the you know what's funny. I've been going through my you know my my I've been going through my father's estate. I can't tell you how much time I spent just trying to make sure I got all the documentation I needed. I spent months working with the courts trying to get all the documentation just the way they wanted it, in order to simply settle my father's estate. Yet people were let into
this country from a war zone where we had an active enemy against us and uh they were in with uh incomplete documentation, that to me is a concern, and it's something I think uh should should concern others. Are they truly asylus or are they simply people looking to take advantage of the American people and our way of life? I wonder how many of them would uh
well would would would think they could could come here and vote. Right? They can come here as asyles before they become citizens and and and vote. Um now there's been a couple of interesting uh uh things come up. First, the Supreme Court cleared the Trump administration to use their their citizenship verification database uh to make that available to state, local, and federal agencies, so that if there's a situation where someone uh they need they need to verify
someone's citizenship, they can go to a database and verify a person's citizenship. At least for now. See this pay this stays uh uh a uh uh an act of a a district judge who said that the federal officials were violating privacy rights of Americans by disclosing the citizenship and social security numbers, among other data, in the restructured database. Now, citizenship, I don't think he has a thing. Social security numbers, yes. And this is one
of the issues I have with the modified database. I understand the logic. I understand you know how to identify a per an individual. You got half a dozen people with the same name. How do you know which one's which? Well, if everyone's supposed to have a social security number, there's let's use a social security number. The problem is the Social Security Act, it was never meant to be a national ID, right? Your Social Security number is merely an account number with this fictitious Social Security uh trust fund, it is not an identification number. So he's kind of got a
point with the social security number. I don't think so much by the disclosing of citizenship. Your citizenship is public in is public information. Um but I f so I found that interesting. The Supreme Court basis, listen, we're gonna stay that until the case that the case gets heard and all the facts come out, and um then well it'll probably get appealed and this will go on. But it means that at the moment uh states and can use uh uh among they can use this
database to verify the citizenship of people uh registering to vote. Which leads me to a case this time a uh of a district court in Florida of a judge that uh threw out a case against a Jamaican woman who was not a citizen but voted in elections. And this was interesting. Let me read you from the from the decision. The best reading of the actual statute that underpins this criminal case yields an
inescapable conclude, inescapable conclusion. 18 U.S.C. 611 is a voter qualification statute, and the Constitution does not authorize Congress to legislate voter qualifications for federal elections. Okay, let's break this down just a little bit. So I looked up 18 USC 611, and it says it shall be unlawful for an alien to vote in any election held solely or in part for the purpose of electing a candidate for the office of president, vice president, presidential elector, member of the Senate, member of the House of Representatives,
delegates for the District of Columbia, or resident commissioner, unless it meets certain other conditions. You know, oh, they can vote in the state part, but not in the federal part. But here's the interesting thing. Go back to the decision of the judge. He says the Constitution does not authorize Congress to legislate voter qualifications for federal elections. All right, let's start with the federal elections. So listen to 611 again. These are the elections that they're talking about. Uh the candidate for president or vice president. Well, let's face
it, the people don't vote for president and vice president. I know we think we do, but we don't. Let me say it again. The people do not vote for president or vice president. Now we do vote for presidential electors. Okay, that's one of the listed presidential electors. Okay. But that's the but a presidential is not a federal election. Remember, president elections are appointed by the state legislatures. These are state elections, not federal elections. Now, member of this House and Senate, okay,
that's that's cool. Delegate for from District of Columbia or resident commissioner, that is a federal property, and Congress can can regulate, or Congress has the sole legislative power of power over the District of Columbia and other areas that are federal, that the federal government legally owns. Now the judge went on to say, except for very specific constitutional provisions that cannot support this statute, um, Congress has no power to say who can
vote and who cannot vote in federal elections. That foundational power is reserved for the states and limits Congress. All right, let's go back to the Constitution. Remember, Article 1, Section 4, the times, places, and amendment of holding elections for senators and representatives shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof, but Congress, but the Congress may at any time by law make or alter such regulations, except as to the place of choosing senators. So, first of all, let's understand that the only elections that we're dealing with here are elections for
House and Senate. So that requirement about president, vice president, presidential election, uh nonsense. That has nothing to do, Congress doesn't have that power. Now it's generally done by the state, although Congress can make laws, but they can only affect the time, place, and manner. It says nothing about the who. They can place the times of the elections, they set election day. They can set rules about the places of the elections, and they can set the manner of holding elections,
but they can't determine who elects. Now, I've said this before, I'll say this again. There's nothing in the Constitution that limits the power of voting to citizens. You the the the there are amendments to the Constitution that says you cannot be denied as a citizen, you cannot be denied the right to vote based on the color of your skin, your nationality, your sex, um, as long as you're over 18 years
old, whether or not you've paid a poll tax, right? You can't be denied the right to vote as a citizen. However, there's nothing in the constitution that says you have to be a citizen to vote. But ever I've checked about half the constitution, about half the states uh over time. And there's not a single state that I'm aware of that doesn't say you have to be a citizen of the state or of the United States andor of the United States in order to vote. In other words, this is a state power. So again, my my first reaction, many of
people first are, well, here we got a judge playing games. No, I actually see a judge that's saying this is a constitutional requirement. This is not a violation of federal law because Congress is not authorized to create a law regulating who can vote in elections, even for federal office, right? This idea of federal the people don't vote in federal elections. There's not a single vote that the people make that's a federal election. As I said, um House and Senate, those are those are are apportioned
to the states, and the states choose their the those people. Presidential electors apportioned to the states, the states choose. People don't vote for president or vice president, no matter what Congress says. So the only uh the only f uh national vote, the only federal election we have is when the presidential electors appointed by the states vote for president vice president. That's not the one the people vote in. They choose they tell the the legislator which slate of electors they want
them to use, but the people don't vote in those elections. So again, my first reaction is what's this guy doing? Then when I read when I actually went in and read the decision, I'm like, oh, he actually got a point. He's got a point. The Constitution doesn't authorize Congress to legislate qualification for voters, period. They can set the time, place, and manner, but only for House and Senate. 611, Section 611 tries to go beyond that. They say, oh, president, vice president, presidential elector.
No. They have no authority over that. The Constitution doesn't remember the 10th Amendment. Powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor are prohibited by the states, are reserved to the states respectively or to the people. I would take this decision, and I've only read the the opening parts of it, but I would take it a step farther because not only does this violate the 10th Amendment, which again, he the judge quotes me says the foundational powers is reserved to the states, but the the necessary and proper clause, since
Congress only is empowered to make laws necessary and proper to put into effect powers vested by the Constitution in the government of the United States. And this is a power not delegated, not vested in the government of the United States. So Congress had no power to make this law. I actually like this decision. Surprise, surprise. I actually like this decision because it's a judge that's actually following the Constitution. And I find that so rare I'm very happy that it's happened. And um
we'll have to take a look. We'll have to see uh uh where this goes. So let's roll back to the beginning. This this idea of the ultimate sanction. You know, scripture says that government has the power of the sword. Well, this is the ultimate use of that power of the sword. And I think it needs to be done with a lot of humility and uh I agree and a lot of protections for the uh the uh convicted. I've made my position, I think, pretty clear.
The question is I want to see now what happens in Tennessee. I want to see this review. What is the review they what do they find when they review this case? Why did this was this execution about why was the other execution botched? And then what are they gonna do to fix that? Now, you may have constitutional questions about the death penalty, abortion, or anything we've talked about here. If you're looking to study more and you're trying to figure out where well, unfortunately, that really depends on where you are and what you want to do. That's why I created
the Constitution Study Wizard. Just go to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard and uh fill out the form. Yes, I ask for your name and email address because I'm gonna email you responses, but it's gonna ask you questions about your study and and your goals. And based on that, it's gonna the system's gonna email you suggestions of things you may try. Now, the wizard is free, and most of the suggestions have a free option. Uh, and by the way, I review each and every submission. So if I see something specific, I may email you directly. But it's meant to say, you know,
if you if you're looking for ideas, these are supposed to give you ideas, suggestions. There's no you don't have to follow them. You can ignore them if you want, but it's worth getting some ideas of how to take your study to the next level. So give it a try. Go to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard and uh check it out. I also hope you'll swing by and listen to the Constitution Study on America at Loud Talk Radio. I heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern time. You can listen on our media player or apps for Apple Android and Lord Alexa, and of course, you can also
listen via podcasts. It does take a couple of days for an episode to go from talk radio to podcast, but you get to listen to your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share the Constitution study with more people. You can find all the links you need at the homepage at AmericaOut Loud.news. But please share those links, share this program, and help share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...