Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY artwork

From voter rolls to locker rooms: Where does due process begin and end?

Oct 23, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - The Fourth through Eighth Amendments are called the Due Process Amendments because they protect your due process rights. But do you know what due process actually is and when it’s violated? When non-citizens are removed from the voter registration rolls, is that due process? What about how we, as a society, deal with mass shootings? Is it due process to regulate gun owners

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Out Loud Network with your host, Paul Engel. The fourth through eighth amendments to the Constitution are called the due process amendments. In today's world, it appears we the people must search in order to find due process. Hello

there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacherizing Generation Be free. I'm glad you could join me today. You know, this idea of due process, it gets talked about a lot, but I don't know that people spend a lot of time understanding what is due process. I mean, due process literally is a process to make sure you get what is your due. Now, in general terms, it seems like, well, are your rights protected? So you think about the Fourth Amendment and uh unreasonable searches and seizures and

warrants. You know, the Fifth Amendment, where you have protections for your life, liberty, and property, uh, double jeopardy, things like that. Uh the Sixth Amendment, which has rules for criminal proceedings, seventh for um civil proceedings, and then the eighth, where you're dealing with cruel and undual punishment. These are all rights that are designed to protect a due process, a process to make sure your rights are protected. Now, as we look again at life around us, well, how do we make sure that our rights

are we truly searching for due process, a process that protects not just our rights, but the rights of everyone? And I've got some stories that may that I want to look at these from a due process standpoint. We'll start with this one. The U.S. Department of Justice has filed a complaint against the state of California allegedly because they have 20,000 likely illegal aliens registered to vote. This was in a 16-page complaint that was filed again by the Federal Department of Justice and was

addressed to the California Secretary of State, uh, Dr. Shirley Weber, um, the Los Angeles Registrar Recorder and County Clerk, Dean Logan, and it claimed that the Department of Homeland Security found names through an analysis of voter rolls and federal data of, again, likely illegal aliens. Now, a reading from the complaint, it says based on a thorough analysis of voter rolls and federal data, agencies within the Department of Homeland Security found thousands of likely non-citizens registered to vote

in California who would automatically be sent federal ballots under state law. Now, I got a couple things I want to bring up here, and it's important to understand. Um, in the complaint, the the DOJ claims that federal law prohibits non-citizens from voting in federal elections. Title 18, United States Code, Section 611A. Well, except that federal law is not made pursuant to the Constitution, because the Constitution says nothing about non-citizens voting, about citizens voting, but

only citizens vote. There's nothing in the Constitution of the United States that requires citizenship to vote. There are several amendments that say if you're a citizen and you're denied the right to vote, there are problems, but there's nothing about saying a citizen must vote. Now, California, like every other state I've checked, requires you to be a U.S. citizen in order to vote. Specifically, Article 2, Section 2 says a United States citizen 18 years of age and resident in this state may vote. So we have problem number one here. We

have a federal law, which, by the way, is no federal law because it was not made pursuant to the Constitution. This was not necessary, this law, this Section 611A, is not neither necessary nor proper to executing the to putting in execution the powers vested in the government of the United States. So this law itself is unconstitutional and therefore void. But California does have a problem because you know if you've got non-citizens registered to vote, it violates the California Constitution, Article 2, Section 2. But here's the other part

I want you to notice. Um, the based on their analysis, they the Department of Homeland Security found thousands of likely non-citizens who are registered to vote. Um I'm sorry, uh due process requires that you be considered innocent until proven guilty. Likelihood is not proof of guilt, right? So and again, we're talking about registered to vote. Voter registration is not a power vested in

the federal government. So as much as I agree that having non-citizens on California's voter is problematic, especially with California's automatic uh uh mail-in ballots, right? So every registered person, get every registered voter, gets mailed a ballot. Well, then if you have people ineligible for vote for any reason that are on the voter registration, that becomes a problem. They're getting a ballot, they're getting the opportunity to vote, and you're just what hoping that they'll be they'll

not only be honest about uh not voting if they're not a U.S. citizen, but uh be aware that that's even a requirement. I I agree there's there's a lot of problematic issues. I just think the way Department of Homeland Security and Department of Justice are doing this is questionable at best. And it's not just California. Out in Kansas, um, apparently third parties have been mailing out pre-filled absentee ballot applications where where at least part of

the application is already filled out for the user. Uh now, Kansas uh passed a law that says uh no, uh, you cannot send out pre- you want to send out the form, that's apparently fine. You cannot pre-fill it out. You you can't answer some of the questions for them ahead of time. And uh, of course, that went to a lawsuit, and uh the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals um said, yeah, uh no. Um there's a a you unanimously, a panel

of the 10th Circuit unanimously said no. Um they said in the in the decision, because the prohibition was enacted without an improper purpose, we apply intermediate scrutiny and find the prohibition constitutional. Now remember, the it is perfectly fine for third parties to send absence ballot applications to anyone they want. They cannot complete any portion of it. And this this was a law passed in 2021. Uh, they actually overrode the state, the governor's veto, and they said the purpose was

to reduce voter confusion and uh again, reducing the workload for election officials. Well, how would this happen? Well, again, you receive in the mail an application for voting that's already partially filled out. How do you know they got all that information correct? Right? Uh you're you're getting an application and then you're being asked to sign to affirm that all the data is correct. You didn't fill in all the data. I'm not sure how it impacts workload for election offices, because, well, uh, I imagine that the the pre-filled

parts would be printed and easier to read or scanned, but I don't know. The point was uh uh if if someone wants to apply for an absentee ballot, they must be the one filling out the form, the entire form. So not and not someone else doing it for them. Because again, uh you know, I'm I'm not saying this was happening, but this the opportunity for, let's say, sneaky people to put in, word it this way in order to get the answer you want. Right? I'm not saying it happened. I've seen no evidence that it happened, but it certainly is

a possibility, which is what apparently this law was meant to protect against the possibility, the issue of um uh uh of uh again putting in information that someone says, well, maybe that's right. I don't know. Maybe this is the state controlling their ballot process, which is legal, right? Remember, Congress can only change the time, place, and manner of elections for House and Senate. The Congress has no say in voter registration. The federal government has no say in voter registration.

They don't run the elections, they can set laws that involve the time, place, and manner of elections for house and senate, and that is it. Not presidential electors, not anything else. Now, again, when it comes to due process, a lot of us think about the actual legal process, what happens if you're uh deal dealing accused of a crime. And of course, that's gonna take us the rest of the way across the country to New York. Uh, according to a report I saw came coming out of the New York

Post, um, the state of New York has ignored more than 16,000 detainers from immigrations and customs enforcement. Now, what is a detainer? A detainer is when ICE says, hey, we see you have this person in custody for some criminal activity or alleged criminal activity, and we're on our list of people that are here illegally. When you're done with them, let us know, detain them, and we will come pick them up so we can deal with our part of the problem.

Now, we have these sanctuary cities and sanctuary states that say, no, no, no, we don't like the actual enforcement of federal immigration law, so we're just going to ignore these detainers. And I'm sure they're thinking, oh, well, it's it's due process for the alien, right? Because, you know, why should they be held and picked up? You know, I should be have to find them themselves. That may be the logic. But there's another side, there's a more to that story. The rest of the story, as Paul Harvey used to say. Again, according to the New York Post, those 16,000

illegal aliens have committed more than 50,000 crimes within the state. Now, I want you to back up and think about this for just a minute. Not all of those 16,000 illegals were convicted of crimes. They were some were accused, some were convicted. I don't know what that ratio is, I'm not sure. Uh, the 50,000 crimes I haven't noticed in the report, does it

say these crimes are committed before they were detained? Or is it after they had been detained, they committed further crimes? The question of due process comes in and protecting rights. So, on the one hand, you know, if you are the accused, you have rights that need to be protected. Does that right include the ability to escape other jurisdictions that have criminal complaints against you? No, you don't have the right to do that. On the other hand, the federal government doesn't

have the right to regulate immigration because there's nothing in the Constitution of the United States that gives that power to the federal government. Now, should the federal government should we have a centralized immigration plan? I believe so. All right, I believe we don't need 50 different immigration plans. But the problem is we've never actually assigned that authority to the government of the United States. So here we have a big hole in our immigration plan. All right, we

did not give it to the federal government, but we're expecting the federal government to enforce these laws. Laws, by the way, that was neither necessary nor proper for commerce to put into execution, or Congress to put into execution, because it didn't put into execution a power vested in the government of the United States. But I also see what about the rest of the people, right? When you have people who have been convicted, I'm not talking about the accused now. Whatever percentage of these illegal aliens have been convicted, why are they uh and they're being let

go? Again, if there's another jurisdiction that has another criminal proceeding against them, why would you not? You wouldn't do it if it was, say, um murder, right? If this is New York State, and let's say uh, you know, the the state of New Jersey has a murder charge against one of these people, I'm sure they would detain them for New Jersey. If there was a assault and battery charged in California, I'm sure when New York State was done with them, they would hold them and and

and at least be willing to extradite them to California, let California officials come and collect them to be charged there. It's only ICE, it's only immigration. And based on what people have said, this has nothing to do with the question of constitutional authority. I've yet seen claiming that this is, see, we can't do this because, well, you know, it violates these laws, violates the constitution. I haven't seen anybody point that out. Nobody but me have I heard really point out the fact that this immigration is not a power vested in the government of the United

States. They claim it is, but it's not actually in the Constitution. So I look at this saying, well, what is due process? How do we protect the rights? On the one hand, I can look at it and say, well, listen, New York State's saying these the ICE has no legal authority because immigration is not a power vested in the federal government. And if that was the argument they were be they were making, I'd be willing to support them in that. But it's not. The argument is, well, we don't think that's right for the government to actually enforce federal law.

Not that the federal law is unconstitutional. We just don't like this federal law, so we don't want you to enforce it. But we still live in a in in under federalism where there's separation of powers between the state and federal governments. But I want you to think of this as a resident of the state of New York. I want you to think about this more. I want you to think about it as a resident of the state of New York, of someone who has broken the law to enter this country. That's the definition of an illegal alien. You broke the law, you entered illegally, you've committed a crime. The first time you commit that crime, it's a misdemeanor, every other time it's a

felony. So you've committed a crime to enter the country. You've then committed additional crimes once you've entered this country. After you entered illegally, you can't but yet the the state of New York doesn't want them actually held accountable to those crimes. Um that seems to be a rather lawless that that seems a lack of due process. Because if you're if if due process is getting what you've you're due, well then committing a crime should include punishment, should it not?

If you commit a crime, is aren't you due once convicted of punishment? I mean, yes, you get your day in court, you get your jury, you get your counsel, uh, you get to provide evidence. Absolutely. Once you're convicted, well then your due is to be punished for it. Because it is due to the rest of society to punish criminals to dissuade further criminal activity. But that seems to be beyond the scope of the conversation and what's

going on here in New York. Now, I have also some other things I want to take a look at, but I have a break coming up before I go, though. You know, my wife wants me around for a while. Not entirely sure why, but she does. She wants me to eat better. Now, yeah, you know what, I really should. One of the problems we have is according to some reports, as much as 85% of the nutrients we used to get out of our food, the nutrients our body needs to be strong and healthy, have been farmed out of the soil. They don't come in our food anymore. Which probably explains why we've seen an explosion

in supplements and in strange diets. But again, who wants to take a fistful of pills in the morning and who wants to be on some strange diet? Our friends at the Wellness Company have come up with a solution. It's called organic energy juice. It's a juice powder. You take it uh twice a day with water uh before you eat, and it gives your body the nutrients it needs to be healthy without the pills or strange diets. Now, I want you to look up more because I want you to

be that informed consumer. Go to AmericaOut Loud.shop and click on the RG organic energy juice panel and do your own research. Look at the testimony, see what happens, see what's in what's included, be involved, right? You know, this should help you get better energy, promote weight loss, mental clarity, build muscle, strengthen your immune system. These are all good things. But I don't want you to take my word for it. I want you to do your research. So again, go to AmericaOutloud.shop and well, click on the organic energy juice panel. By the way, since you listen to

America Out Loud, you can get 20% off of your order simply by using the code OutLoud at checkout. So if you're looking for a better and more flavorful way to get the nutrients your body needs without pills or strange diets, check out organic energy juice from chemical free body by going to AmericaOutloud.shop, click on the organic energy juice panel, do your own research. When you decide to buy, use the code Out Loud to get 20% off of your order.

Successful weight loss is about changing the gut-brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor designed solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy fats. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing

sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit Twc.health slash outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount.com.com

before your nose looking on the greenest promote in the universe. Are you looking for healthy snacks, but you've had enough of all the sweet sugary energy bars? Good news. There's a new bar to try that's savory, crunchy, and packed with goodness. Beer bars are based on just six simple natural ingredients: a certified organic veggie nut and seed bar that's low temp dried, never baked or fried. Beer bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get the

exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud. Never before American Cultural Economics and Mortwork most of the Apple.

Welcome back, everyday Americans. You're rejoining the Constitution study. Today we're talking about searching for due process. And first we have to we have to understand what due process is. And I took a look at some examples in the first segment. Before we went to break, I was talking about New York State and the fact that they do not honor detainers, and they've not honored detainers for some 16,000 um illegal aliens that have been accused or convicted of committing 50,000 crimes. Which,

again, as a citizen, no longer a citizen of New York, but do you have an expectation that the the government would the due process includes punishing people who are convicted of crimes? Again, I'm not talking about people who are accused, they get their day in court, people that are actually convicted of crimes. Well, let's head back to California, where we're again dealing with ICE. This involves a California law that required ICE agents to um show identification uh while doing

uh uh immigration operations within the state of California. And this included a couple things. Include they had to have ID, uh they couldn't wear masks, and this got into an interesting question about the right to privacy of government actors when in commission of their duties, and uh there was a lot of discussion about this. Well, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that section 10 of that law violated the Constitution's supremacy

clause. Now, in reporting from the Hill, um the Justice Department sued California because the the no vigilante acts demands that plainclosed law enforcement officers operating in California shall visibly display identification. Now, again, I um I I see a little bit of both sides, right? If you're working plain clothes, the idea is you're you're trying to go about without being identified by a uniform.

However, if you're going to enforce police uh power, you have to identify yourself as an officer. You have to, otherwise, anybody could come up and say, hey, I'm the police, do this. Right? So there's got to be identification and credentials. Now, this also involved uh California's No Secret Police Act, which banned federal law enforcement officers from wearing masks while carrying out operations within the state. Uh again, there's a problem because you say, well, federal law enforcement can't wear a mask, but state law

enforcement can. That is a violation of the Equal Protection Act under the under the 14th Amendment. But the argument was made under the Supremacy Clause. Specifically, it claims that the California was trying to uh regulate the performance of governmental functions of federal uh uh law enforcement officers, and that the the that the Congress had not authorize that that regulation. Well, part of it comes from a complete misunderstanding of the supremacy clause, right? The supremacy clause does not say

that federal law always wins, the supremacy clause says the Constitution and laws of the United States which shall be made under the authority thereof, and all treaties made or which shall be made under the authority of the United States shall be the supreme law of the land, meaning not all federal law is supreme. In order for it to be supreme, it must be made in pursuance of the Constitution. Now, do states have the authority to regulate federal law enforcement, i.e., this mask law.

No. Do states have the authority to regulate how law enforcement acts within their state? Yes. States, you have to remember, the states create the federal government. States have their own level of sovereignty. They have the ability to say, you know what? If you're acting within our state, you must follow certain rules and certain guidelines. Now, we may think these rules and guidelines are crazy. In fact, I think many of them are. But that's the idea of

the people of the state get to set the rules for the state. I think the problem where California ran into was the attempt to regulate specifically federal law enforcement. They have no authority over federal law enforcement. But they can set up rules that say, hey, law enforcement in the state, when you are enacting the powers of the state, you have to have an ID, you have to display credentials, and uh you can't hide who you are. You, in fact, many states they are required, agents are required to

identify themselves, often with a name and a badge number. The problem the issue I have is, again, with this supremacy clause nonsense, is because it assumes that Congress can do whatever Congress wants, and Congress needs to give the states the authority to do something, which is completely backwards. Because the Supremacy Clause says, no, no, no. The states, when they ratified the Constitution, they told Congress what they can do. They the states put the limitations on the United States, not

the other way around. Now, again, general regulation of another party's law enforcement is verboten, but general rules of conduct within a state, they are not automatically a violation of the supremacy clause. I'm just, you know, again, I'm not surprised to see this. This is the type of stuff I see all the time. Okay, let's look for due process in places other than government actions. Uh X, right, recently suspended more than 13,000 of their accounts, claiming that

they were involved in three different suspected foreign influence operations uh linked to China, Russia, and Iran. And that they were trying to influence the political discussion in the United States coming uh with this coming uh midterm uh elections in just a couple weeks. Now, according to a statement X made back on October 14th, uh, they said they that the these networks used fake accounts to publish and amplify political content targeting U.S. candidates

and public figures across the political spectrum. I'm not entirely sure about the how across the political spectrum, but I'm okay. We'll we'll give them that. The company says they identified the accounts through their monitoring and investigatory system by their safety team. Um and again, there were uh um roughly 13,000 accounts that were suspended. They were they were uh uh they're no longer active. Now, I I want to think about this for a couple of ways. First of all, X is a private

company, the X platform is their private property, meaning they get to decide who does and does not use their property and under what conditions you're allowed to use that property. It's no different than you saying who can and cannot come out onto your property and what they can and cannot do while on that property. The X platform is private property. Now, they looked at it and said, listen, we think, right, these are suspected influence operations. They looked at what was going on

and they said, we don't like this. And of course, I'm sure there are people like out there that are saying, well, wait a minute, this is just X being, you know, political their own political manipulation. To a certain extent, yeah. I mean, you remember, I got booted off X has left me alone. But remember, I got booted off of Facebook, and Facebook refused to tell me why, other than I somehow violated their their terms of service, but they never told me what I did that actually violated the terms. They refused to give me any real answers. My best guess

is I was teaching about it, it was 2020, and I was teaching what the Constitution and Laws of the United States said about how we actually elect a president, not the nonsense I hear so often on TV. But uh that again, Facebook is a private platform. If they don't want that content, they can have that content. I don't have a due right to access to a third party's platform, whether that be Facebook, X, YouTube, or Apple, they own that property. They have the right to determine who and under what circumstances they're

on that property. They that that property gets used. Now, they also have their own self-interest, right? Because when you know if these social media platforms start throwing people off, if they get less eyeballs, they get less revenue, they make less money, but that's their choice. That's the idea of what is actually uh due. I don't have a right to access to a platform. Neither does anybody else. Now, the question is if these people were attempting to influence the election, if we had foreign influence in the elections, were any of these account

information handed over to the Department of Justice for investigation into criminal activity? Specifically, Congress has the authority to regulate foreign commerce. Uh, was there money used on these accounts? Um, you know, with these these platforms, was, you know, was there any monetary involvement here and was that going on? Or is this simply a question of uh uh apparently not uh not money spent in the United States, foreign money spent in the United States, just foreign actors, which

again they can express their opinion. And to me, part of the problem we have in this country is we too often are influenced by other people's opinion without having any facts behind them. And uh again, X may just say, you know, we don't, we're not happy with what they're doing, we're concerned with what they're doing. So our response is we're gonna kick them off of our platform. And as much as people get pissed off when they get deep when they get uh you know kicked off these platforms,

this is private property, and they have every right to do that. Uh look, let's look at a uh at high school cross-country. See, uh up in Washington State, about a dozen girls on a high school cross-country team literally forfeited a race rather than compete against a dude. There is a guy who literally switched from the boys' team to the girls' team mid-season. The the match was between uh was it

Camus High School and Battleground High School in southwestern Washington. And uh to me, well, it shows a very interesting uh uh question of due process. Now remember, we set up rules that allowed uh for men and girls, male and female sports, men and girls, men and women, boys and girls, because men have a distinct physical advantage. It's part of being human. And that, like anything else, kid, you know, the the that was put in place to protect our girls and women. Well,

again, about a month or so ago, a sophomore at Camus High School who competed in cross country on the boys' team, finishing 76th, right? Way back. He suddenly said, you know what, I'm gonna compete on the girls' varsity team, and uh let's see, he won one meet and played second in two others. In other words, he went from 76. I don't know how big the pack was, but 76 is far away from the top three.

And he ended up top three because he's peting against girls. He's showing his unfair advantage. Now, what's the what was the process for dealing with this uh deprivation of a fair shot to the women, to the girls that are playing uh that are running cross-country in this high school division? Now, this is also interesting because in this midterm election, Washington voters are considering initiative 638, which would prohibit male students from competing in

female-only athletic competitions. So this has a political statement to it as well. But I I I like the report I heard about how the girls handled this, right? These this was a decision made by the girls. About half of the girls on the team uh took the start and then walked off the field. In other words, they didn't just not show up, they said we registered, they were set, they were ready to go, and as soon as the gun went off, they crossed the start line and then walked away. They

were making a statement, and I think it was a good statement. I think it was an appropriate statement, but they were making a statement, and that statement was this isn't fair. And we're not going to pretend that this dude is actually a girl, that this is a fair race, this is not fair. We are not getting our due process, our chance to compete in a fair race, therefore, we're gonna make this this thing. And I'm curious how this impacts the the

vote on Initiative 638. Will people look at this and say, ah, see, we have a problem, we do need 638? Will people look at the girls as bad sports and saying, you know, okay, um, no, we're gonna vote uh against 630? Interesting question. Because again, due process, now again, this isn't a due process of rights. You don't you don't have a right to a competition, you don't have a right to a fair competition, however, the law has established that we are going to have men's

and male and female sports to allow fairness in competition, and the state of Washington has basically ignored that and allowed this dude to cheat in order to get awards. Now, again, probably looks at this going, he's really just cheating himself. Because everybody now knows that he is not a good runner, and the only way he can win is by competing against people who are biologically not as capable as he. They don't have the lung

capacity, they don't have the the uh lower body strength, the upper body strength, they don't have the the the same strength and capacities as boys do. This guy had to cheat in order to win. And um, I think this uh this genetic says a lot about the boy, I think it says a lot about his parents, and I think it says a lot about the character of the girls that were willing to say, no, we're not going to say that the truth, the lie is a truth simply for politics. This is wrong, and we're willing to give

up even a chance at at a finish in order to point out just how wrong this is. I appreciate that, and I wish them all the best. And I also hope that uh the the voters in Washington State figure out the difference between boys and girls. Okay, I've got another break coming up before I go, though. You know, think of the the the groups that are promoting this nonsense, this transgender nonsense, or a lot of the other nonsense, right? The question about supporting

about illegals and about non-citizens voting and about all this crazy. There are a lot of organizations that are supporting them, and many of them are probably being funded by you. Oh, not directly. You're not cutting them a check, but you're doing business with companies that are supporting them. There are a lot of companies I don't do business with anymore. I refuse, even though they have got good products or good services, I refuse to do business with them because they take a portion of their money, of their dollars, what they make, to support organizations that are destroying our rights. It's

one of the reasons why I switched to Page or Mobile. Not because they're America's only Chris Conservative wireless provider, not because of their great 4G and 5G coverage, not even because they're 100% US-based customer support. I joined them for a simple reason. Because they take a portion of every dollar to support organizations that are defending and protecting our rights. Join me by going to patriotmobile.com/slash constitution and finding a plan that works for you. Oh, by the way, if you use the code Constitution at checkout, you'll get your new line activated absolutely free. Use

your cell phone to take a stand against those that want to turn the United States into a Marxist dystopia. That want to pretend that boys can be girls and girls can be boys and and that uh you know want to use that that illegal aliens somehow have have uh uh the right to break our laws and not suffer punishment. Do this by going to patriotmobile.comslash constitution, support The Constitution Study by signing up for a plan, see if you're eligible for a discount. Uh a lot of of groups of veterans, first

responders, even families with multiple lines can get a discount. And don't forget, use that code Constitution at checkout for free activation. Now, I also hope you'll swing by AmericaOutloud.news. I go there each and every day for news and information. Why? We live in the information age. Literally, information is at our fingertips. But where do you go to find it? See, I'm looking for a place that I can trust but verify, meaning I've looked at what they've said, I've verified it enough that you know what? I'll give it a try. I I trust what they're saying. So do me a

favor, head to AmericaOutloud.news today, read the stories and articles, then share them with friends, family, neighbors, maybe listen to a podcast or watch a video and share it on social media or other platforms. See, it's the act of sharing, it's the act of exposing the news that, well, let's face it, corporate media doesn't want people to know about that helps secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You

can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere. City apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of

mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code outloud for an exclusive offer. During treatment, City Tap Water Molecule's structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure,

just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. Feeling run down, foggy, or constantly drained? Your body might be lacking the support it needs at the cellular level. Recharge from the Wellness Company is a doctor-formulated supplement

designed to restore your energy, focus, and immune function. It features the first ever combination of methylene blue and urolithin A. Clinically studied ingredients that support mitochondrial health, boost cellular repair, and enhance cognitive performance. With added NAD3, COQ10, and PQQ, recharge is the daily solution for deep lasting energy, not just a temporary boost. Visit TWC.

Power up your body and mind with recharge. Welcome back, everyday Americans. They involve shootings. Two mass shootings have really caught our attention recently, and they happen.

Continued killing people. The responding officers found two women dead outside the building. They found more inside, again, including children, and the uh assailant was believed to have taken his own life. He he took again, he self-inflicted gunshot wound. Now, again, this is a terrible situation. Because again, if you're in your home, you want to feel safe in your home. But this was a, and again, I'm sure more information, more details will

be coming out, even probably since I've recorded this episode. But this is a situation where I don't even know why the gunmen opened fire, why they targeted this family. I I I honestly don't know. What I know is that evil exists. And um bad guys with guns are out there and they committed this heinous crime. And it appears nobody was able to stop this crime until the criminal stopped it, in this case, by shooting himself. And it's sad and it's a tragedy, and I'm sure as more information comes

out, um other people will be more than willing to delve deep into the logic and rationale behind what led to this this particular shooting and the overall impact. I want to compare that to another shooting, this one out in Oregon. Now, let's just say that Oregon is not exactly known for their gun-friendly environment. Now, what appears to have happened is a an individual um there were

911 calls claiming a person was shooting into a car. Uh that person then later entered the uh uh elementary school, the Civil Rare Rail Elementary School, and started shooting. Um there were people taken to the hospital, and um the uh let's just say again, it it was another potentially huge death toll was possible, except for one thing. An armed member of the public.

According to reports, uh this young man, he was uh le his uh uh 16-year-old is what was reported, uh, opened fire in the in the school and uh uh killed, I believe, three children and one of the teachers. And was set to go, uh, could easily have gone on a on a rampage. This could have been uh another deadly school shooting, which again would have been absolutely terrible, except for one thing. Um an armed member of the public who originally

was not identified but later was, uh saw the suspect enter the school and followed him. Now, again, sadly, school shootings happen and uh they frequently to a lot of and there's been a lot of debate about um firearms in schools. And should certain people have them, should pe uh should they be denied because what's going on here? Well, here you have a scenario, and again, they say, well, no, no, we don't need guns, we'll just have locked doors, we'll

just lock all the doors and control access that way. Well, that didn't work here, according to reports, the the gunman um shot through the door to gain entry. Uh, but what do you have? You have a good guy with a gun that was willing to risk his own life to walk into a situation in order to save others, and he he killed the the gunman. He killed the young man that was killing others. And I bring this up uh from a due process for a couple of reasons. Because we have a scenario where uh this

person uh was did use deadly force in defense of others. And he was there. You know, we often talk about police and fire and EMTs as first responders. This was the first responder, this was the first guy there that was able to respond to the threat, and he did so. Now, in the light of these two shootings, how long did you take before people started calling for more gun control? If your response was half a nanosecond, you're probably pretty close. It didn't take very long.

Now, as I said before, Oregon has a a history um of fairly strict gun owner control laws. Um, they enacted extreme risk protection orders, um, community violence intervention programs, uh, they had safe storage laws, um, a bunch of laws that are supposed to control gun owners to make sure this doesn't happen. Um again, it still happens. Even going back to November 22, when an Oregon voters

uh enacted a ballot initiative to do more strength to do more for around background checks uh and licensing, uh, restrict large capacity magazines, provoke all these things. Again, all these laws trying to control them, but we still had a mass shooting in Oregon, one that could have gone a lot worse if not for the one individual willing to put his own life at risk for the defense of others. And uh I I look at the gun control groups, I saw a recent report

that were bragging about these great gun control laws in Oregon, and yet we have another mass shooting in Oregon. Um, if it wasn't so tragic, it would be ironic to say, here, let's brag about our gun control laws, and then we have a mass shooting in the very place that they said it shouldn't happen because of all the these gun control laws. So again, remember doing pro due process. It's a process that protects what you are due. Were the victims of these two shootings denied

due process? Yeah, they didn't, they there was no due for them, uh no due process for them to be have their lives taken, um, with the exception of the gunman, right? One shot himself, one was shot by another. You're a threat to another person, lethal force is due process. When you threaten the life of another, uh, you give up your right to have your life protected. And as long as you're a threat, you can be taken out. I that that's that's the way the laws are written.

And uh I'm waiting to see. Now, again, I haven't seen it. Wouldn't surprise me if uh some sort of of lawsuit or charges were made against the the hero, uh, the man in in Oregon who, again, dealt with a threat to children. Um, it's kind of the way some of these weird things go. But I also go back to again how long did it take for calls for um uh gun violence for for more gun control, gun owner control laws.

I call them I start calling them gun owner control laws because they're really not about controlling guns. They're about controlling gun owners. And I think this is more evidence that these gun owner control laws are not as effective as they would like us to believe. You know, the the the like I said, the the groups are bragging about all the gun control laws in Oregon, they still had a a mash shooting in a gun-free zone. Right? This is a the remember, these laws created these gun-free zones, these allegedly gun-free zones, which were not free of

guns. There were people with guns there. It's just, you know, there's no such thing as a gun-free zone. There's just a gun, maybe a zone where law-abiding citizens don't carry guns because they're following the law. Um due process. Due process. What are we going to do about this? And again, I look at this and I say, you know, I I feel for that family in Erie, Pennsylvania. Uh, I don't know their position on guns. I don't know if they I would say it's likely they didn't own guns, but maybe

they did. I don't know. As far as the um people in in Oregon, I think the guy that the the young man that decided he's gonna shoot the school got exactly what he deserved. And I I I think the person who dealt with the problem, I don't think he should be lauded. I I I don't think he should be paraded around as as as it's I'm not sure I should use the word hero to describe him as a lot of people do. Um I look at this and saying he saw a need and he took care of it.

He he, you know, it it's funny, I was preaching the other day about um, you know, what do you do unto the least of these you do unto Jesus? And I'm like, well, these least of these were under attack, and he defended them with the best tool he had possible. And that's why I always want to remind people whenever they try to control gun owners, you're not just controlling the ones that would do something illegal, you're more likely controlling the ones that would do something protective, something quite legal. Like this man in Oregon who, even

with all the gun control laws, he had a gun and was able to defend these innocent lives. Now, meanwhile, I want to take a look at something else. And this is actually uh Senator Blumenthal from Connecticut. Um, he's pushing for new legislation that wants to add additional violations of the Second Amendment because he wants to um prohibit people with a temporary restraining order from purchasing or possessing uh firearms or ammunition.

Now, Blumenthal made in a statement that said domestic violence should be a bipartisan issue. There should be no red or blue about protecting women. Okay, so far I agree there should be, you know, protecting it people, period, should not be uh donkeys versus elephants. But this legislation that he wants to promote doesn't say you, in other words, you're you're considered guilty until proven innocent. If somebody gets a temporary restraining order, all right, very often these restraining orders these are not

done um through a an adverse adversary partner. A person goes to a judge and says, I need a TRO, and here's the reason why. Well, did the accused get their day in court? Were they uh allowed to present their side of the story? There's no due process in a temporary restraining order. Right? So to deprive someone of a right protected by the Constitution without due process violates the Fifth Amendment. I understand Mr. Bloomfall's reasoning, or at least what what he

he claims reasons that you know what, if you are a victim of domestic violence, if you are a victim of any violence and you get a TRO, well does that person who has it who did the TROs can they be prevented from possessing a firearm? Well, okay, um where's the proof that they're a danger? How often are have TROs been used, especially say in messy divorces, as a bargaining tool rather than actual

threat? Now again, I've been involved, I've known people where there was a not a not domestic violence, but there was a a heated disagreement. And I was asked to take possession of some person's firearm for a period of time until things calmed down, and I thought that was a wise thing to do. Right. Temperature running high. I thought that was and I did. I took possession of the firearms um and kept them in a safe place until things settled down. Um and and that

that to me was my my responsibility. That that's what I I thought I was called to do. Um but you're talking about depriving someone of a right. And the problem is in a temporary restraining order, there is no due process, there's no uh uh uh requirement of oath. There may be an oath or affirmation, but I don't think there's a requirement for an oath or affirmation. The defendant doesn't have a chance, their day their say in what's going on, they don't get to provide evidence on their side saying that maybe this

is not true. That's my concern here. I understand the logic of someone who's dangerous, how do you treat them? There needs to be more before you deprive them of a right, and that's the concern I have. That's my point of view on the due process. Looking at this, whether it's the the guy who went into the home, uh domestic violence, the the guy who shot up at school, we're dealing with people, and sadly, we don't see the future, and that's why we have the due process clauses to protect your

right to due process, to make sure that your rights are protected in this process, and when we let our emotions about these shootings override our reason about and understanding the law, then bad things happen. And uh people get denied their rights. And I just wonder, you know, what would have happened if the guy who saw the shooting in in Oregon and followed in to stop it, if he had been denied his right to keep in barms

because, well, he just happened to have a a TRO against him for something that may or may not have been real. Now, I know people are going to disagree with me, and that's fine. I don't I don't have a problem with people disagreeing with me. I I hope that they would actually have the the study time to make sure that their positions are based in facts and data. Because a lot of people, you know, they they make a lot of claims and statements about what the Constitution says that isn't really true. As I said, when I started studying the Constitution, the two things that struck me of what I had not been taught about the Constitution and what I had been

taught that was factually wrong. Now, if you want to study more, well, I wish there was a real simple, easy way to do that. Well, actually, maybe I have made one. See, everybody's a different place. We've done different studies, we have different goals, and and you know, frequently people walk up to me and say, Paul, what should I do next? My answer is, well, it kind of depends. That's why I created the Constitution Study Wizard. Go to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard and fill out. I ask for your name and email address because the system is going to email you responses. And that's where it's going to ask you

questions, all right? When did you last read the constitution? Have you read the nuclear ancillary documents? What are your goals? And uh, based on those answers, well, it's going to email you some suggestions. Now, the wizard is free. Uh, most of the suggestions have free options, but the idea is to get you thinking of something maybe you hadn't thought of as a possibility. Now, again, it's free. If it doesn't work, it's cost you a few minutes of your time. But it's a great way to see if maybe there's something you hadn't thought of. So check it out. Go to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard and uh fill out

the wizard. Fill out the forum. Hopefully you'll get an idea, maybe a suggestion, something you're willing to try. If not, well, maybe you'll just open your eyes to things that you hadn't possibly thought of. That's the whole idea behind the Constitution Study Wizard. Now, I also hope you come back and well, listen to the Constitution Study every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern time on America Out Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network. You can listen on our media player. We've also got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, all of the episodes go to podcasts, generally

a day or two after they're heard on Talk Radio. So you get to listen in your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show. Leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share The Constitution Study with more people who will then click the links and join us here for the program. Speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage at america loud.news. But please share those links and help share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What to expect as socialism grows in America

    Nov 20, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The fundamental flaw in America’s gun control laws

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court packing, impeachment, and the race to act before January

    Nov 18, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Are we a nation of laws or ruled by judges?

    Nov 15, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. After the midterms: More of the same, with a left turn

    Nov 14, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...

    Credit the people on this episode