The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - A recent case out of Oklahoma helped by throwing out evidence a deputy collected via their Flock system without a warrant. If you’re concerned about data centers, you may be interested to know who in Congress opposed legislation encouraging states to require those data centers to pay their own energy costs. I guess the question of...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Outline Network with your host, Paul Engel. We all have secrets, things we don't want generally known. But how do we keep secrets in our modern digital world? Hello there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with a Constitution
Study, where we read and study the Constitution, teach horizon generation be free. I'm glad you could join me today. Um, you know, there's an old saying that uh three can keep a secret if two are dead. And it's just the basis of human nature. The more information spreads, the less likely it is to keep secret. Now, we all have these ideas of secrecy and privacy, and well, very often they're not based in actual law. They're based in our preferences, our opinions. So I wanted to take a look at
some examples. I'm going to start today with an interesting decision by a district court judge, uh Sarah Hill. And it involves a case of a Tulsa County, Oklahoma deputy uh that was trailing a lady, um, apparently for no reason, other than the fact that, well, it's had California license plate. Now, he then queried the Flock system. Yep, we're talking flock, uh, to uh for her for her uh plates, he
queried her plates, to see if there were any anything, any warrants or wants or warrants, I guess, before observing any traffic violation. Now, his search logged more than 50 times across multiple states that this lady's car, a Mazda SUV with that license plate, had been recorded by Flock Systems. Now, he initiated a traffic stop, and according to the judge, that traffic stop was valid. He did observe, apparently, I'm guessing he observed a traffic violation. No, she objected to
something much more interesting. She claims that the the deputy lacked reasonable suspicion to hold this lady, a Melissa Kyle, after returning her license plate. Now understand, if you're pulled over for a traffic violation, as I understand, I'm not a lawyer, I don't play one on TV, but what I but from my research, I find that uh if an officer pulls you over for a traffic stop, they cannot extend that traffic stop without some reasonable article of suspicion of
another separate crime other than you know the the the the traffic stop. No, they can't go fishing for stuff, there has to be some article of suspicion. Now, what the judge did is they had an evidentiary hearing, and the judge threw out this deputy's search of the flock database for this lady's license plate, right? She had he accessed more than 50 records of this driver's movement without a warrant. He had no warrant, he had no reasonable
article of suspicion of a crime, he had nothing to initiate the search with, according to the court. Therefore, that that search, that warrantless search, violated the Fourth Amendment. It was an unreasonable search. He had no remote reason to search other than he was looking for something. Now, the judge described it as a type of indiscriminate mass surveillance and went on to say freedom from persistent dragnet style surveillance while in public is not a foreign concept in
our society, and it's a reasonable expectation that society already accepts. Now, a spokesperson for Flock uh rejected that idea, saying the ruling goes against an overwhelming weight of authority in similar cases across the country, including multiple decisions in Oklahoma, and we expect it will be appealed and ultimately overturned. Now, let's back this up and look at the constitutional question here, right? Because here's the first scenario. Um, was there a reason for the search? I've always said the idea of having a camera
pointed at you in public, you don't have a right to privacy in public. What you do in public can be observed and recorded. It's the search that is the problem. And to me, this is a perfect example of the problem. According to the reporting I'm seeing, I haven't seen the the court, all the court documents and stuff, but according to the decision I've seen, um this deputy had no reasonable articulable suspicion to search. And I use those words for a reason. That's the legal definition. In
order for an officer to detain you, they have to have reasonable, articulable suspicion that you are have, are about to commit a crime, that there's some participation in a crime. They can't just say, well, this is a suspicious person. No. What's the crime they're acting suspicious of? What's your articulable suspicion? They need that to detain. By the way, this is Terry versus Ohio, the infamous stop and friskus case. There must be real truth. They they can't demand your ID without that reasonable articulable suspicion. And here we have what appears
to be a deputy searching a person's license plate without any reasonable articulable suspicion. So, does that mean that the search violated the Fourth Amendment and should be thrown out of court? I think so, even though Flock does not. Now I want to ask you: do you feel comfortable saying, well, the police can follow you and search you simply for having an out-of-state license plate? Because that from what I've read in the court
documents, that seems to be the only reason the deputy followed her. She had California plates in Oklahoma. Oh my God, this must be a terrorist. Now, to me, what else is interesting, and I haven't done a deep dive into this yet, but it's it's on my radar, is um the deputy after following her for nothing more than having a California plate and and apparently doing this ill illegal search. By the way, it's not only uh uh get she get this stuff done on a
court, he committed a crime against this lady. Uh he he he saw two traffic violations. Um the driver failed to signal a lane change at least 100 feet before making the lane change several times, which violates uh Oklahoma law. Um he he also believed the driver was following too closely than was safe. Um not quite sure. Uh again, but I have to go back. Would he
have been following her in the first place if it wasn't for this illegal search? I mean, again, it's it it it there are a lot of questions, and that's why I said I need this to be a deeper dive than than I've done so far. So, you know, keep an eye on uh um on the website on you know on AmericaOutloud.news and on constitutional.com because I will probably do uh a deeper dive into this in the near future. But this has come on the history of several stories about Flock
and other automatic license plate reader, license plate readers, ALPRs. It's flock has kind of become a generic name like like Kleenex for tissues. But uh interesting, uh representatives uh Ocasio Cortez, uh Jeff Merk, uh uh Merkley, sorry, and Bernie Sanders introduced legislation recently to effectively end the use, the federal use at least, of automatic license plate readers. Now it's literally called the Ban Flock Act.
Uh it would prohibit the federal government from purchasing, using, or possessing uh ALPRs, uh accessing any of its data or using federal funds to purchase or use ALPRs. It doesn't ban the cameras, Constitution does give them that authority, but it does um it does prevent the federal use or federal funding of the use of these ALPRs. Now, as I've already stated, my issues is not so much the camera as the the warrantless
search of this data. But uh what this act, should it actually pass, which I'm not holding my breath, um, means a couple things. Again, state and local governments would not get federal funding to uh to do this. Also, um, it would allow Americans to sue the federal government for violations if an agency uses these ALPRs, right? Think of um well, Homeland Security, FBI, ICE. If any of these agencies used ALPRs, well, they
could be sued. Not a criminal act, a civil act. Now, again, what would this mean in the law if it were to pass? Well, we probably would have less flock cameras because I'm sure many of the state and local governments that are implementing these cameras are using federal funds to do this. This would basically dry up those funds, so fewer of those. Um, if it was actually followed, which I again I have questions, um it means you'd probably be more lawsuits because
I can't imagine the FBI, Homeland Security, ATF, uh any of these actually giving up searching this these data, this data. Uh, but again, you know, uh uh it's a my my issue is with the warrantless search more than anything else. We have to understand that we think there's there's privacy. There is you have no privacy in public. What you do in public gets seen. And based on that, it can be used. I
just want to make sure that the government actors, especially because I want everybody to follow the law, but especially the government actors, don't use this as an excuse to bypass the law, as we saw in this case in Oklahoma, where uh a deputy, simply seeing out-of-state plates, did a search of the plate and found that this person, again, had been caught 50 times in the last month between Oklahoma and near California. And he thought that was sufficient to actually follow the person to try and
find a tikky-tacky uh um traffic violation to pull them over and initiate an investigation. I mean, that's kind of the whole thing that the the Fourth Amendment is supposed to protect us from, isn't it? At the same time, uh there's a a the St. Lucie County in Florida uh decided, you know what, they wanted to remove these flock cameras. And I've seen several stories of of cities and counties deciding there's just
too much controversy, they want to remove the flock cameras. But to me, that isn't the that's a story. But to me, that's not the story of this particular incident because while they decided to remove these, you know what they found? They found 14 cameras that somehow had been installed, but without a single permit. Now, the local sheriff's office is the St. Lucy County Sheriff's Office, claimed three of those unpermitted cameras as their own. What about the other
11? So you have to remember, Flock is a private company. They can contract with anybody to put in these cameras. Now, according to a spokesperson from St. Louis's St. Louis Lucy County, they said, Oh, well, you know, we're we're investigating to identify um which agency installed the unpermitted cameras. Okay, wait a second. Uh, that's an assumption that it's an agency that did it. Now, it's a fairly safe assumption,
but it's still an assumption. Where were these cameras? Could it be that a private business put these cameras up? Maybe they wanted to watch their own parking lots. I mean, you can imagine you've got a uh a Walmart or or or other uh big chain store, maybe put these up to for their own security. Who knows? But again, it's it's unpermitted, which to me has always been an issue. If it's on my private property and I'm not impeding on anyone else, why do I need a permit? Now I don't know
where these cameras were, I don't know where they were focused on, which is again brings the whole question over permit. If I have, if I own a business and I have and I decide I want to put in security cameras, regardless of what company that I use and what pro service I use, shouldn't I have the right to monitor my own property for my own security, whether I use flock cameras or not? Now, based on the wording, I'm assuming these were not covering private property, these were covering public property. Which again, who's doing
this? And if the public is doing this, did where again you're trying to observe public areas? Why was there no permit? What's going on here? Maybe opens a bit bigger issue, a bit bigger concern into what's going on with these with it with all these cameras. Because again, a lot of people are focusing on Flock. First of all, Flock is not the only automatic license plate reader, but I want you to think about how many of you have one of those fancy doorbells? You know, the one with the camera on it, the one that alerts you when someone comes to the door and drops
off a package or something like that, ringing and others, you you realize all of those are recording everything that happens in front of your door. And all that data goes up to a cloud service for analysis. In other words, it's not likely not the camera on the door that's deciding, oh, that's a package being delivered and notifying you. That's some data center somewhere with some cloud services that's actually doing a lot of the of the heavy lifting. The the cameras probably do some initial processing, but it's the big guys that that are doing
it. So what about those? See if you're worried about Flock, are you worried about these doorbell cameras? Or what about just other security cameras? Maybe you put a security system on your home and used one of those nice, easy-to-use internet-managed services, meaning all your video goes up to some cloud service somewhere, some third party has all of your video, and you get all the great services of, hey, you know, notified when people come in or anything like that, but your data is out there, and is that being searched? Well, no,
they wouldn't search Apple. You want to bet? I've seen reports of you uh uh you know when you you you use Amazon and you go, you say Alexa, and the stupid little device bings at you and responds. Well, that's not all being done at the Alexa. A lot of that's being done in a data center. Those recordings are sent to Amazon for analysis, and they're supposed to, I think, under contract, delete them after 30 days. And well, there have been multiple reports of Amazon not deleting this data, and that's now available for just, you know, hey, I want
to search. Hey, what how'd you like it if, you know, uh the local police office department said sent a subpoena to Amazon saying, hey, I want all of this guy's uh this per this family's uh orders, uh all their Alexa stuff, or all the stuff off their ring doorbell. I want the security footage. I actually have seen video footage of officers coming to someone's home and demanding their camera, their their doorbell camera footage, not asking for it, demanding it, and actually uh uh you know,
I believe breaking in one case, breaking into the home in order to get this data. See, that's my concern is how far are the police following the law when they do this, or are they going far beyond the law and what's happening to them when they do that? I have a break coming up. Before I go, though, you know, getting a good night's sleep is important, and thankfully, I generally sleep pretty well. I don't have a lot of problems sleeping, but I know a lot of people who do. Now, some people they use
melatonin and other hormones, which again it works, but it can actually disrupt your sleep wake cycle. Some people use pharmaceuticals, but again, you can build up a dependency, a tolerance to them, and well, they may interact with other medications you're taking. Now, me, when I do need a little help falling asleep, which thankfully isn't that often, but when I do, I don't reach for a hormone or a pharmaceutical, I reach for restful sleep from the wellness company. It uses natural ingredients to calm the mind and reduce stress, so
you can get a better, more restful night's sleep without hormones or pharmaceuticals. Now, I'm not a doctor, never played one on TV, but when I look at the ingredients, I see these things like chamomile and valerian root, things that have been used for generations to help calm people down and help them sleep. It makes a lot of sense to me. Now, since you're an American Outloud listener, guess what? You can get 20% off of your order by using the code Out Loud at checkout. Just go to AmericaOutloud.shop and click on the restful sleep panel. Do your research, right? I want you to be an informed consumer. When
you've done that and you're ready to buy, use that code out loud and you'll get 20% off of your order. So if you're looking for a better way to get a good night's sleep without hormones or pharmaceuticals, I recommend RESTful sleep from the wellness company. You can find it at americautloud.shop. Click on the restful sleep panel. Once you've done your research and you're ready to buy, don't forget that code out loud to get 20% off of your order.
Successful weight loss is about changing the gut-brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor design solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy fats. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing
sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit Twc.health slash outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. You know, this time of year, the windows closed, the furnace kicks on, you're breathing the same recycled air at home, in the car, and at work all winter. You can't control the air, but you can control your routine. Clear nasal spray with saline plus xylitol blocks bacteria and viruses and keeps your nasal passages moisturized.
It's not a drug, it's not habit forming, and it's safe to use morning and night. That's it. Learn more at Clear.com. That's X-L-E-A-R.com. Clear. Breathe better, live better. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the GOB, although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Beer bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Beer bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free,
contains six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together with syrups or sweeteners. But beer bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit beerbar.com forward slash outlouds and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud.
So today we're kind of talking about keeping secrets, and sometimes they're secrets that really shouldn't be kept, and sometimes, well, the secrets are the fact that the story isn't necessarily true. Recent allegations have come up about another fraternity party at another university that uh points to the both the the dangers of uh well certain sorts of activities, but the importance of making sure that you got the right facts.
This time it's a it's a 2024 fraternity party at Cornell University that has been making the news. Again, it reminded me a lot of what happened back at Stanford uh a few years ago. And and even was it, there was one at Penn State where a woman makes an accusation. Now, I understand I raised a daughter, and uh, you know I guess what, man, you know, you gotta worry about scenarios. There's a lot of people that like to take advantage. The problem I run into is it it is
a that we have a serious problem where you know you've got young people getting drunk and doing stupid things, right? That's not something to be, oh well, they're just young people. No, that's a that's a problem. The problem I have is when accusations are made. Now, let's take the example in Cornell. According to what I've found out so far, this unidentified lady, they're calling her Jane Doe, claims to have consumed 10 alcoholic drinks before arriving at the fraternity house, where they
said she then continued drinking and using ketamine, both voluntarily. Now, according to the complaint, she her, I should say, her initial plea statement, um, she arrived at the fraternity drunk and willing. Uh, she later claims that she had been hit, she became tired, that she wanted to stop, and eventually gave up as the fraternity brothers kept uh coming on to her. Again, you know, putting herself in
a really bad situation, but she's accusing these young men of sexually assaulting her. There's another problem though. First of all, at least some of the men well they were drunk too. And according to uh this lady's own account, multiple of the participants had been excessively involved in illegal drug use. They had been drinking excessively and using drugs, so they were also impaired. And
okay. So you have a situation that is right for sexual conduct. But Ms. Doe doesn't cry rape until what, 18, 19, 20 days later. And and it's it's a civil complaint, it's not a a criminal complaint, at least that's what I understand so far. Um something doesn't smell right there. Now what we obviously have what appear to have, I should say, is a a
well a a prestigious university with students using drugs and alcohol engaged in a debauched even an evening of debauchery, shall we say. And now one person is claiming rape, but not criminal rape, civil rape. In other words, she wants she wants money. And I'm sure someone out there is saying, Paul, don't blame the victim. I I I'm I'm not blaming the victim. I I'm I'm I'm actually blaming our
society. I mean let's start let's start with the fact as I know them so far. These are of course subject to change. Um first of all, we have a uh uh we have a young person, we have young a young person, in this case a young female, who is intoxicated and continues to drink and take drugs at a fraternity party, which turns debaucherous. Now, there it may not be your fault, but there are consequences for your actions. Right?
If she were to if she had gotten drunk and gotten in a car and driven uh somewhere and uh hit somebody, well she'd be held responsible for driving while intoxicated. Now, does that excuse uh a sexual assault? No, it does not. But it certainly shows the dangers of putting yourself in such a compromise situation. Then we have the other side. We have the boys that were involved, and again, according to reports, they were just as drunk and just as high as this person was,
meaning if she was not able to consent, how are they able to consent? Now the question is when she said no, did they stop? Or did she actually say no? I mean, uh again, there's a we're dealing with intoxicated memories, there's a big issue here. But what I find is this belief that this this willingness to believe the woman and not even consider the boy's point of view. Right? This this allegation of of misconduct. And again,
I'm not saying what the boys did was right, I'm not saying it's excusable. I'm saying don't we need to look at the totalitary totality of what was going on? I also think this says a lot about the parents. The parents? Yes, the parents. You raise children, granted, I understand. I was a teenager once too. I was a young adult once too. I spent a year in college, I did things I probably shouldn't have. Probably my things my parents wish I hadn't done.
But not nearly to the extent of what's going on here. And I think that's part of the problem. See, I I'm I I keep seeing people looking to have a system to protect the children rather than training the young people about the dangers of what's going on so that they don't put themselves in those situations. In fact, the president of Cornell pledged that the school is committed to institutional reforms in the wake of the outrage over this allegation of uh gang rape.
And if you're looking for the institution to fix the problem, I think you're looking in the wrong place. Yes, we have a problem. The problem is in our society. I think it's in our society that um encourages this level of you know, this this time of of uh, oh, they're just uh adolescents, you're just teens, let them get away, sow their wild oats. That's a problem. To me, that's a serious problem. That there are not consequences for our actions, not necessarily
culpability, but consequences. You you know if you're if you're a young lady and you're drunk in public, it is more likely you're going to be taken advantage of. Is it your fault? No, but if you hadn't put yourself in that situation, maybe you wouldn't it wouldn't have happened, right? Not culpability, but consequences. And then on the man side, right? What are your responsibilities? This this this you know again, drunken debauchery
that seems to be acceptable in colleges and universities, uh, I think is part of the problem. And I think if parents had trained their young people to be aware of the consequences, to be um uh to to be able to um consider those things before things went too far, well then maybe we'd have fewer examples of this. Now I'm not saying we should have more. We'd have fewer examples of this and other scenarios, other things. I mean, this is
a big deal. A an allegation of gang rape is a big deal. It's a national story. But how many smaller stories have have gone unnoticed, where people's lives, young people's lives, were changed forever because they put themselves in situations where bad consequences could happen and they had because either because they hadn't been taught or they hadn't been to to recognize
the consequences of certain decisions. Now I I'm a little qu I'cause I'm wondering, you know, what is Cornell University supposed to do about this? Other than the fact that it happened at one of their fraternities, these are the actions of people who are 18 years or old, older, they're adults. Granted, it's not legal for them to drink, but they did it anyway. So obviously the law isn't the problem. I I I think this is I I
think the solution is not gonna be an institutional one. I think it has to be a moral one. I think it has to be a social one. Um that's my opinion. But I doubt that's gonna happen. Why? Well, Governor Holkl has decided to politicize this particular incident. You see, rather than leaving this in the hands of the the the district attorney of the county, Governor Hokul has uh
set up a special prosecutor. And who did she choose as a special prosecutor on this case? Attorney General Letitia James. That's right. That political hatchet lady of the state of New York, the the one that ran on let's get Trump, let's put Trump in jail. And with New York's history of false calls, claims of rape, I mean, you go all the way back to Tawana Brawley. It's not that it that all claims are
false, but if your answer to this is to put a political person in charge of the investigation, this now becomes a political case, not a criminal case. And again, now even if Miss James comes up with the legal rights uh answer, she does her investigation, and what whatever charges are brought are the legal rights, they're always gonna be colored. They're always gonna wonder well, was was uh was Miss
James going after them because they were boys? Was she going after Cornell University? Was she going after was it a political thing? It's always gonna have that that uh that shadow of politics on top of this. Because what people would have wanted to have kept secret, right? The obviously the uh the night of debauchery, I'm sure most people would prefer to have kept at least a bit secret. I'm sure the the members of the fraternity didn't want their their parties, their
debauched parties made national news. Uh, I'm sure they didn't want to get accused of anything. I'm sure the the the Jane Doe didn't want her uh licentiousness made uh tabloids across the country. Yeah, there's a lot of people that want to keep the I'm sure Cornell University is not happy that this information got out. I'm sure they would have much happier been dealing with it internally than publicly. But when you have the governor of the state saying we have a we have an
issue, uh I'm I'm kind of curious why the district attorney, who who'd already um was seeking a grand jury review, had to be overtaken by uh again this this governor's political hatchet woman? Is that I mean it it uh the the the mens rea, the evil mind just seems to be percolating here, and it makes me wonder is the goal here to find out what really happened and if any
crimes were committed, having them prosecuted, or is the goal here to make political points? See, we're going out, I'm putting my bulldog on this one. I'm not sure. I mean, does does Governor Hokel and Attorney General James do they want to keep secret the politics behind this? Are they looking for truth, justice in the American way, or are they looking for a political bump? Or are they just looking to cover their backside, right? Oh, how'd this happen in New York State? Is it the state's fault that uh you
know young people went crazy? Is it the university's fault? Have we asked you know, is it the is the university established a um kind of a standard of of outrageous behavior that gets w whitewashed or ignored? There's a lot of questions here, and I'm sure there's a lot of things that a lot of people would rather keep secret. Um I think it's uh I think it's important that uh we make sure that that uh now this is out in the open, that all the investigators,
from Cornell's president to Ms. James and Ms. Holkel to the the exit the with the district attorney, that that not be secret. Now that it's been put out in the open, now that it is it is public record, I think that's something that we the people need to make sure is done properly, following the rules, following the constitution, doing things by the book as they say. Um to me that's uh that's important. And to me, that's something that uh needs
to not be kept a secret. We'll have to wait and see how things work out. Now, you know me, I put a lot of stock in everyday people understanding the supreme law of the land, as John Jay said, right? Every member of the state ought diligently to read and study the constitution of his country, teacher rising generation be free by knowing their rights, the sooner perceiving they're violated, be the better prepared to defend and assert them. I still get a lot of people to say, Well, how could you know the law if you didn't go to law school? Which usually makes me chuckle inside.
One, because based on my granted, limited research, um, they don't teach the constitution in law school. They teach constitutional, they teach what lawyers and judges think about the constitution, not the actual constitution. Um, so that's problem number one. But there's more. You see again, if if the Supreme Law of the Land is not the the volumes of law books we think about. It's 8,000 words. It's not that difficult to understand. Once I can I I realized I
hadn't read it, once I convinced myself to read it, it was amazing how enlightening it was to recognize what the supreme law of the law that supersedes everything Congress does, everything your state legislators, everything your county commission does, superseded by the supreme law of the land, which is written in plain, generally plain English and easy to read. But I know a lot of people don't. It's one of the reasons why I created my book, The Constitution Study: Returning the Constitution to We the People. That's my goal. I want we the people
to know the law that we put in place that's over that created and oversees the federal government, that uh uh is supposed to protect our rights from state, local, and federal actors. Find out more. You can find by the way, you can buy the book wherever books are sold. You can find it on Amazon, or you can get at the website, constitutionstudy.com slash shop. It's under the book sections with all my other books. Um it's uh it's it's an interesting read, right? Uh first of all, it's a clause-by-clause study of the entire Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.
And I wrote it in plain conversational English. I I didn't use big fancy words. This is not an academic tone. It's meant for everyday people. Everyday people should be able to read and understand the Supreme Law of the Land, because that's what the founding fathers expected. Because they understood that it is our job to keep our elected representatives in check. And if they take an oath to follow the Constitution, they have to know what it says. We have to know what it says to know if they're doing their job and to hold them accountable if they don't. So find out more, please head to constitutionstudy.com slash
shop and order a book today. Again, you can get it wherever books are sold, you can get it at Amazon, but only at the website constitutionstudy.com slash shop can you get a signed copy. And if that's something you'd like, I'd be more than happy to sign a copy for you. But I think if you take the time to read and study, and then you realize you don't need all the big fancy Latin words and all the long advocates, a 20-30 minutes with this document will teach you more about the law than three years in law school and
Lord knows how many years of practice will. At least that's what been that's been my experience. Now, of course, we all are looking at news. We live in the information age where news is at our fingertips, information's at our fingertips. But where do you go? To paraphrase, you know, Ronald Reagan, I want someplace I can trust yet still verify. For me, one of those places is AmericaOut Loud.news. That's why I go there each and every day for news and information. But I do more, and I want you to do as well. See, I share that. I I have a mailing
list, I post on social media, I put all sorts of content out. You can too. Sure, read the stories in the articles, and then share them with maybe friends, family, neighbors. Watch a video, listen to the podcast, share it on social media or or maybe with a civic group. Do this. See, which when you share this, when you share the news that the government and the corporate media don't want you to share, they don't want people to know, you're not just sharing the work we're doing here, but you're helping to secure
the blessings of liberty for all of us. Are you tired of struggling with low energy? We get it. That's why we created organic energy juice. In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle with low energy again. And it tastes amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy juice is the right
decision. With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer.
Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere: city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a
doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides that help repair and restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue, which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root cause. Literally. Visit twc.health forward slash outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair
regrowth with roots. Welcome back everybody, American Jerry. Join the Constitution. So today we've been talking about keeping secrets. And there's a couple of things that people may want to keep secret about uh some of the news I'm coming up with. There's been a lot of talk, and in fact, a lot of fear mongering around data centers. Now, for those of you who don't know, I spent 30 years working in information technology. I spent 20 of those working in data centers. I've worked in data centers across this country on projects. And I know a little
bit about how they operate and how they work and well, what they do. Now, I a lot I I agree data centers consume a tremendous amount of electricity. This is nothing the the amount of electricity. I'll give you an example. When um when I first started, now this is gonna be close to 30 years ago, um, a server, right, that would do some of the data center was about seven, eight inches tall and consumed about 150 watts max 150 watts of power. Right? About
two light bulbs, two incandescent light bulbs. Well, when I left 10 years ago, that same server was less than two inches tall and had 500 watt power supplies, meaning it consumed um about eight incandescent light bulbs worth of power. So a fifth of the space and three times the power. It became very dense, and that's the issue. Things get power density.
Now that that that power density also leads to a fair amount of heat, which involves cooling. But again, a lot of people think that cooling involves consuming water. It it doesn't. Um, they use they do use chillers. They only they never I've never seen a data center with an evaporative chiller. It's no different than say a big refrigerated warehouse or factory. They use that type of stuff. But again, everyone's very concerned about these, uh, and and there's been a lot of of fear-mongering. And because of that, well, the House of
Representatives passed a bill that uh allegedly would encourage states to require data centers to pay for their own energy costs. To me, other than the fact that it's unconstitutional for the Congress to make any law that would require this, um I this is kind of my understanding. As I'm dealing with questions of data centers in my area, this is what I'm telling people. We want the data center to pay for the infrastructure cost. We don't want this cost shifted onto consumer. How do they do that? Well, one way we
do it, and of course, a lot of people blame the data center. The problem isn't the data center, ladies and gentlemen. The problem is frequently the politician. The politician that offices, hey, you know, to come here, to bring this data center, we're gonna give you tax breaks, we're gonna give you energy bill breaks, we're gonna do all these things to encourage people to come, which shoves the cost onto others. Now, again, this was the bill. And again, I haven't read the entire bill. It was described to me as um it would uh encourage states to
require this, but it died in the Senate. Now, it really shouldn't be a surprise to anyone that this is a party-line vote, um, that all the Democrats voted against it except for four. And uh again, I'm I I'm not sure the logic behind it. That's one of the things is we don't often understand the reason why people vote the way they vote. So that's one of the reasons why when my representatives do something, the first question I have is why did you do this? Whether I approve of it or not, I always ask why before I
tell them my opinion, because I don't want them, I don't want them shading their information based on what they think I want to hear. But I have to ask you, what does the federal government have to do with uh local energy rates? The answer is nothing. Again, the problem tends to be local uh politicians who are many of whom are so encouraged to bring in the jobs of a data center, which again, most data centers I've worked at are mostly dark, so there aren't actually a lot of jobs there. But in order to
bring in this tax revenue, they're willing to sell the farm. And well, that becomes part of the problem. Again, I looked at this and I said, well, you know, part of the problem is we have um uh we have we have the federal government that's trying to solve a local problem, which is not their job. They're not constitutionally authorized to do this. This is not interstate commerce, this is nothing Congress has anything to do with, they're wasting their time on this, and it just creates more polarization and more finger pointing
based on what was going on. But which to me kind of proves another point is how often the federal government comes in and prevents a better answer from being found. Right? They come up and they say, This is our answer, this is how we're going to fix it, and then um, well, they never consider that well, maybe there's a better solution. Perfect example. Energy generation, power generation. There are politicians who say we have to shut down coal and natural gas-fired power plants because
carbon dioxide is suddenly not plant food, it's a pollutant, and it's gonna kill everybody. Okay, forget the fact that carbon dioxide is plant food. Uh, there are noxious uh emissions for some of these plants, which is why people developed technology to clean up the emissions from these power plants. But again, for some people that's not enough. Well, then the other thing we had was well, nuclear power. Well, nuclear power sounds great, except it has this natural thing called nuclear waste. And
oh my god, what happens if there's an accident? Now, I find this interesting for a couple of reasons. Most people I talk to don't realize that there is not a type of nuclear power plant, different types that use different chemistry to generate power, and they have different issues. The nuclear power plants in this country, and in fact, mostly most around the world, were actually designed to create nuclear uh uh nuclear material for weapons, which of course uh creates all sorts of
their other problems, but there's a been a move on for what's called a um small modular reactor. And what is this? Instead of having these ginormous nuclear plants with multiple reactors and and and centralized, the idea is how about we distribute these nuclear, make them small, make them modular so that we can drop them in and out. They don't take the same level of construction, and um, oh yeah, let's make them safe.
Now, I tried to find a good analogy for with these these small nuclear, these SMRs, small modular reactors. And I think I've got one. And think of a of a modular home. All right, think you know, you ever see them driving down the road where you they they build a house in a factory, and then they take the parts of the house and they bring it on site and they stick it together, and voila, you have a house. Well, as I understand it, that's how these small modular reactors work. The components are built in a factory, meaning it's
in a controlled environment. They're then shipped on site and assembled into a functioning system, a functioning modular reactor. Now they're smaller than normal. In fact, uh the reason I bring this up is Tennessee Valley Authority just received approval from the UN from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, another unconstitutional agency, to build the first commercial small nuclear, small modular reactor in this country. They're going to do it at uh Clinch River near Oak Ridge.
Now, to me, this is interesting for a couple of reasons, besides the fact of the small modular reactors. Um, because they're smaller, they can be built closer to the demands. Right? In other words, instead of building a really big reactor complex and having to put in a lot of high-tension power lines to get the power to where it's needed, they can build smaller reactors that are closer to where they're needed. It requires less infrastructure in order to include it to uh deliver this power,
which is again one of our major problems is the grid as a whole is not in the best shape. And if you want to get power, I mean, this is in in Oak Ridge, Tennessee. What if the power is needed in Memphis, Tennessee? Or in Louisville, Kentucky, or Atlanta, Georgia? Right? You got all that, you got to get that power from wherever it is. Well, if it's a small nuclear reactor and you can put one near Memphis or near Louisville or near Atlanta, you don't need as much infrastructure. And to me,
that would be a A, it would be a way to create a lot of cheap power, uh, without pollutants, right? Without the fossil fuel pollutants that people are all worried about, uh without have with smaller infrastructure requirements, which means if you wanted to build, say, a data center, well, this might be a better way to power a couple small data centers in a region than just putting that load on the grid as a whole. At which point,
someone out there saying, But Paul, I don't want a nuclear reactor in my backyard. I understand. You probably watched the the China syndrome or maybe the mini-series Chernobyl, and I understand. But as I said, there are a lot, there's more than one way to create a nuclear reactor. Uh, I'm not sure what technology they're using at the one in the in Clinch River, but one of the ones I found very interesting is called a thorium reactor. Now, why the big deal? Besides the fact, you know, there well, the difference between the
design of a thorium reactor is if something goes wrong, anything that goes wrong, it's designed to fail safe. Right? You think of Chernobyl, where they had, you know, they they were they were screwing around and um you know they had uh they they lost coolant, and that's what caused the thing to overheat and build pressure and expose the air and explode. I mean, this is uh Three Mile Island, right? You had a problem. The way the thermometeractor is designed is if it starts to when it
overheats, it automatically dumps all the radioactive material into a containment vessel to keep the radiation from escaping, making them a lot safer. So I want you to think of the secret that's been kept that in a society that wants more and more electricity, you want your electric cars, you want your electric lawnmowers, you want everything electric. We don't want they're trying to get away from, and we don't have the energy for it. The ide the the technology is less
the problem. The politics is the problem. Sometimes it's politicians, sometimes it's the regulatory environment, sometimes it's the uh not in my backyard idea. But this step, this TBA uh complex, maybe a first step to uh getting power more locally available and less expensive. We'll have to wait and see, right? Because nothing's nothing's guaranteed. But this idea that you know we we we need
to keep these secret because people are afraid of uh nuclear power, well uh sometimes we forget that everything comes with a risk. Coal comes with a risk, oil comes with a risk, wind comes with a risk, even hydroelectric comes with a risk, everything comes with a risk. The question we have to decide is what type of risk are we willing to take in order to have more power, cheaper power, and all the prosperity that comes along with
it. And we're not all gonna agree that that's you know human nature. But rather than hiding information, let's let's let's break the secret and and let's we the people consider what um what risks we're willing to take, and how do we hold those accountable if the worst does happen. Because it's not just uh nuclear reactors, it's not just data centers, it's not just young people in colleges, it's
these fli it's these automatic license plate readers, it's the facial recognition, it's every technology you have, right into the V what's in your car. Um, I didn't get to it. I was looking for an article on literally the data your car collects about you and transmits to others. You know, that all ever all these conveniences we have, all these greet neat tools that make our life faster and easier and and uh more automated, they all come with their own risks. And when we keep those risks a secret, is when they tend
to turn around and bite us in the backside. So there are things that we should keep secret. There's secrets I have with my wife that nobody else needs to know about. But I think a lot of things in public, we need to start talking more about them because there these are secrets that can really they can truly harm us. For example, this is there's some secrets I've I've encountered. How often have you heard about a company you do business with um donating money to organizations that, whoa, you want nothing to do with? You know, maybe they're promoting the
uh the crazy agenda, you know, open borders, out of control spending, uh, you know, maybe they're supporting uh promoting abortion or other things. And you do business with them, you buy their products, and you find out, well, they're taking your money and they're spending it on promoting things that, well, are destructive to you, destructive to your rights. I think it's time we, the people, start buying from companies that believe what you and I believe, especially those that will put their money where their mouth is. Patreon Mobile is America's only Christian conservative wireless provider. And I joined them several years
ago, not because of their 4G and 5G coverage. They use all the same networks and towers as the others, but nope, that's not why I joined them. And I didn't join them for their 100% US-based customer support. No, I joined them for one simple reason. They not only share my values, they put their money where their mouth is. Every year they take a portion of their proceeds and they support organizations that are protecting your constitutionally protected rights. Freedom of religion, speech, press, your right to be secure from unreasonable searches and
seizures, to not be deprived of due process. By the way, they also support the sanity of life, our veterans, and our first responders. I was so happy with that, I not only joined them, I became an affiliate. Which means if you go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution and sign up for a plan, part of every dollar helps support The Constitution Study the work we're doing here. Use the code Constitution at checkout, you'll even get free activation. So join me at Patriot Mobile by going to patriotmobile.comslash constitution. Don't forget the code constitution
at checkout to get free activation, and use your cell phone to not only protect your rights, but the rights of your family and your children. Now, I also hope you come back and join us here for the Constitution study every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern Time on America Out Loud Talk Radio heard in the iHeartRadio Network. You can listen on our media player. We've also got after Apple, Android, and Alexa, and of course, all the episodes go to podcasts, generally a day or two after they're heard on Talk Radio. So you get to listen in your favorite podcast app. But do me a favor, subscribe to the
show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share the Constitution Study with more people who will hopefully click the links and join us here for the Constitution Study. You can find all the links you need at the homepage on AmericaLoud.news. But please share those links, share this program, and help share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...