The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Accountability means more than imposing fines or announcing investigations. It requires identifying who breaks the law, who bears the consequences, and whether those harmed receive justice. Corporate privacy violations, sensational media coverage, partisan inquiries, and government abuses raise questions about how fairly the law applies...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Outlaw Network with your host, Paul Engel. Contrary to popular belief, laws do not stop crime. The enforcement of laws do. Or at least it discourages lawbreaking. So what happens when bad actors are not held accountable for
their bad actions? Hello there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution, teach Rising Generation Beef. Glad you could join me today. And as we see so often, there are certain people that, well, sometimes they act as if they're above the law, or sometimes it's human nature to simply point to someone else.
It's not my fault, it's their fault. So I wanted to take a look at some at accountability today and some examples of, well, what I think is often misplaced accountability. There's there's there's accountability that's targeted part of this target accountability that points in the wrong direction. So let me give you an example. So I saw this article. This came out of the Daily Caller. And the the the headline is Rogue AI Access Public Voter Info in King's K Swing State. Now, I don't know about you, but
that sounds bad, but my alarm would start going off. And it's oh, Rogue AI. Um yeah, I know so I already know something's fishy in here. That's because I've got 30 years of IT experience. I've dealt with these types of things. I know what's going on. So let's look at the story. It says a rogue artificial intelligence model access public Georgia voted data without human authorization as regulators remain concerned about AI safety one week ahead of the midterm elections. Ladies and gentlemen, this is fear mongering. Let's start right off the bat. A rogue AI, define a rogue
AI. A rogue AI is doing something that is exactly what the people who told it to do did. If you simply say, hey, I want an A, take the actually example, right? So this is this is Claude from Anthropic. And it was asked to conduct an internal statistical analysis of voter data. And in doing so, it accessed, oh
my god, voter data. Now, here's a funny thing. It didn't go after private data, didn't go after secure data, it went after publicly available data. This is data, it pulled data from a database that state allowed, that makes available to the public for a fee. It did not penetrate the voter registration system, it did not obtain voter records, uh uh, but at least according to Anthropic, but now
it's this quote-unquote rogue artificial intelligence that accessed data with it accessed a database that, well, you're supposed to pay a fee for. Now, I don't know if the AI, when the agent was set up, was informed which sources of data it was allowed to use and which sources of data it was not allowed to use. But if it was not properly instructed, it's not a rogue AI, it is an insufficient human programmer. How they got access to a four-fee database
without paying the fee. That's the other question. How'd they pay the fee? Did the AI have access to a state credit card to do some some, or was there a security hole in this? Now, I bring this up because this to me is another example why I don't trust the media. All right, you've you've got it, you gotta prove it to me first. Because this type of stuff, right? This is a rogue AI goes after Georgia voter, it's designed to scare people. That's the purpose of this article. What do we see? We see
an AI agent that was given a task, analyze, do an internal statistical analysis of voter data, meaning it has to access voter data, and it's being done internally to some system. I'm assuming it's since it's the Georgia uh uh database, I'm assuming this was done by some agent of the Georgia government. That's why I said in they were doing an internal statistical analysis. This is not a rogue AI. This is not the Terminator, this is not the matrix. This
is a computer doing exactly what it was told to do an internal statistical analysis. And in searching for data, it apparently got access to a database that it was supposed to pay for, but it didn't. Now I have a question for you. Who should be held accountable? Should Anthropic be held accountable because of their quote unquote rogue AI doing pretty much exactly what it was told to do? Uh should the the owner of the database that was accessed without
the fee being paid, well, should they be held accountable for their lack of security? You can't hold the AI accountable, it's not a human being. You tell me now you're gonna shut down the AI because uh an agent won't have no this how about this? How about the Daily Caller being held accountable for hyping this uh insanity? Now, the the interesting is um uh the AI lab that that used this did tell the Georgia Secretary of State and the White
House about the incident weeks ago. Um now the Trump administration wanted the incident to be disclosed sooner, but apparently the Georgia Secretary of State decided not to. But again, what happened? Apparently there was no this was publicly accessible data. They just ask you to pay a fee. Why are people going is Daily Caller hyping this idea of a rogue AI? Maybe Daily Caller needs to be um ignored a bit more, kind
of like I'm starting to do. Every time one of these news outlets puts this out, I devalue their data that much more, to the point where essentially I'm gonna stop listening to them because uh uh uh you know, the because of this type of nonsense. But who are we supposed to hold accountable? Again, the AI did nothing wrong. They did nothing, the AI did exactly what it was told to do. It accessed the database, it found access to. The fact that the database was supposed to charge a fee, and apparently that
was not, I'm guessing that was not charged, um, but it was publicly accessible, it was public information. It was not any of the confidential information. Why are people doing maybe maybe we need to hold them a little bit more accountable? You know, kind of like New Mexico's doing with uh Meta, right? Uh a Santa Fe judge uh ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury found that a they uh the company committed almost 44 million violations of
the state's consumer protection law. Now, this grew out of the uh the case in 2021 of Cambridge Analytica and the scandal where they found that Facebook was sharing information, private information. And the lawsuit claimed that uh Facebook, now Meta, intentionally misled the public and specifically New Mexico users, about it hand how it handled personal data. Uh looking at the special verdict form,
uh the jury found a couple uh a couple things. They said, has the state proven that Facebook engaged in an unfair or deceptive trade practice with respect to the following statement made by Mark Zuckerberg, May 24th, 2010. You have control over your information, how your information is shared. We do not share your personal information with people or services you don't want. We do not give advertisers access to your personal information, we do not and never will sell any of your information to anyone. Well, apparently that is specifically a false
statement. So they they go on and say, well, if that's yes, did the state prove their that that was false? Yes. How big of a deal was it? They went on. Question two. Has the state proven that Facebook engaged in unfair practices with respect to the following statement? Again, Mark Zuckerberg, this time uh April 4th, 2018. There are other internet companies or data brokers or folks that might try to track and sell your data, but we don't buy and sell. Well, yeah, they claimed that that they the state did prove
that that was a false statement. Question number three, again, did the state prove a false statement? When uh Cheryl Sandberg uh on on April 5th, 2018 said, We do not sell data or give your personal data to advertisers, period. Yes, that was deceptive. They they lied. Uh question four. Uh so uh Mark Zuckerberg, uh July 18th, 2018. So we don't sell data, we don't give the data to anyone else,
but overwhelmingly, people do tell us that if they're going to see ads on Facebook, they want the ads to be relevant, they don't want bad ads. Again, jury said that's misleading. They they do sell and give away data. There's evidence that they have done so. And again, this goes on and on and on. So, is Meta being held accountable? Well, again, a a $25 billion fine uh doesn't seem to be a significant uh um piece of accountability. You know, I don't know about you, but uh, you
know, a billion here, a billion there, pretty soon you're talking real money. Now, but this is interesting because this is only in New Mexico. I wonder if the other 50 states, 49 states are gonna look at this. I wonder if the federal government is gonna look at this and say what you have was deceptive practices and and are they being held accountable? Now, the other question I have is what is the state of New Mexico, New Mexico gonna do with that $25 billion? Is part of it going to the the
people for whom the the almost 44 million violations of the state law? Is any of that money going back to the people that are actually harmed? Um is New Mexico gonna take their, I mean, okay, you want to take a car cost out of it, legal costs. Fine. What about the people that are actually harmed? In other words, accountability to me is not simply that the bad get punished, but that the the victim should also receive some form of compensation, some sort of of redress for the
grievance. Because the grievance wasn't against the state of New Mexico directly, it was against the people of the state of New Mexico, was it not? They were the ones that were actually harmed by these deceptive practices. So we've got uh some questionable practices by the news media and the Daily Caller. We have deceptive practices from by Facebook, Meta, and uh what about this one? Again, this one I saw, this is from uh the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. And uh again, it says uh the title of the article is Your Speech, Their Rules, How Ford
Governance Censor Americans. And uh okay, that's got my attention. What's the big deal? Um, you know, it it's and they they spin this interesting story about, you know, you're sitting at home, you read a news item, you post it to social media, you make some comments about a politician you don't like, and the next thing you know, the idea is, you know, you're you're you're you're attacked, right? Uh they say under the First Amendment, the United States cannot reitaliate against you for constitutionally protected speech and expression.
But the First Amendment does not necessarily protect you from a bureaucrat in Brussels, a judge in Brazil, or a police force in Hong Kong. Well, that's absolutely true. The Constitution of the United States is only legally binding on the United States and its its citizens, its states, and its components, right? And they give an example. Uh Saad Ibrahim Al Mahdi. Now, Mr. Al Mahdi was a retired engineer. He was living in Boca Raton, Florida. He held citizenship both of the United States and
Saudi Arabia. And um he uh he made some posts criticizing the government of Saudi Arabia, which again there were he raises concerns about this and uh thinking apparently that the uh the Constitution of the United States would protect him. Except in November of 21, he took a trip to Riyadh to visit his family, where he was almost immediately arrested and accused of harboring a terrorist ideology. Now, again,
I want accountability here. Understand, you're the the they're correct. The First Amendment protects you, prevents the United States. Remember, the First Amendment starts with Congress shall make no law. But the way this was worded leads you to imply that this this, you know, you're here in the United States, you say something bad about a foreign government, and their actors come in and attack you. That is not what happened. Right? Mr. Al Mahdi made a comment against a foreign of a foreign nation, a nation of which
he is a national. He holds dual citizenship. That's a whole nother question about dual citizenship, but he went to another country, and under their laws he was arrested. This has nothing to do with the First Amendment, and this has nothing to do with censoring Americans. It has to do with censoring a Saudi national who also happens to be an American national. They brought up another example of Grand Lenham. Uh he uh um lives in Arizona.
Um uh he was living in Arizona. Uh he made a handful of posts uh about uh trans women in female spaces. And then when he flew to Heathrow, which by the way is in London, England, when he stepped off the plane, he was arrested for his comments. Now, again, you when you talk about the Constitution, the c just because you're an American doesn't mean the Constitution follows you around the world. It protects you in the United States, it governs the it created the government
of the United States, it restrains the governments of the United States, it certs limitations on people in the United States. It does not follow you around the world like a cape, you know, like Superman's Cape, and suddenly you can't be touched because you're an American citizen. No, when you go to another country, you're subject to their laws. So I look at this, and again, I love the work the fire does. I've had multiple uh people from them on this program. But when I look at this, to me, this is fear-mongering and
scare, this is scare porn. Oh my god, another country can come in and arrest you. Yet that's not what we see here. The examples here are all of people who were who went to other countries and under those countries' laws were arrested. Outside the jurisdiction of the Constitution of the United States. So I want to know who we're gonna hold accountable here. This is why I keep saying, just because it's in the news doesn't mean it says it means what it says. And it doesn't mean that you're
gonna get the outcome that you expect to get. So uh again, you know, what are we talking about here? I'm talking about holding others accountable. Now, I I've got some other examples that I want to get to, but before I do that, I do have to take a break. But first I want to remind you that you know sleep is is important to a good, healthy lifestyle. Now, thankfully, I generally sleep pretty well. I know a lot of people who don't. I know a lot of people that reach for hormones like melatonin, which do, they do help you fall
asleep. Some reach for pharmaceuticals, right? Because again, they can help you fall asleep, but each comes with their own concerns. They can, they, you know, hormones can disrupt your hormones, um, they can both disrupt your sleep wake cycle, cause dependency, and interact with other products. Now, on the rare occasions I need help falling asleep, I don't reach for hormones or pharmaceuticals. I reach for restful sleep from the wellness company. Why? Well, I look at it, it it I'm not a doctor, I don't play one on TV. It's backed by documentary research.
It's vetted by the chief medical board of the wellness company. But when I look at the ingredients, when I look at things like chemomile and valerian root and kava, things that have been used for generations to help calm people down and help them sleep. I see what I what I'm looking for, right? A something designed to calm the mind, reduce stress to get a better, more restful night's sleep. Find out more, go to americautloud.shop and click on the restful sleep panel. Do your own research. Be that informed consumer. And when you're ready to give it a try, use the
code out loud at checkout and you'll get 20% off of your order. So if you're looking for a better way to get a good night's sleep without hormones or pharmaceuticals, check out restful sleep at americautloud.shop and click on the restful sleep panel. Do your research when you're ready to purchase, don't forget that code out loud to get 20% off of your order.
Today we're talking about accountability and the need to hold bad actors accountable. But we still need due process, right? We need our investigations, our days in court, the chance to bring witnesses. Accountability that's not held itself held accountable is more dangerous than accountability without accountability, if that sound makes any sense at all. The reason I bring this up is because in recent years, one area where people have been calling for a lot of accountability has been the Biden administration. And again, we keep seeing information coming out about Jack
Smith, and it seems like every week or so there's there's uh a new revelation always coming out of a political office. Well, we've got a new one, this time not about Mr. Smith. Memos released by the White House Government Transparency Task Force, right, get out of the White House, political entity, claim that um, well, the the cover-up and protection of the Biden uh family goes even farther than we originally thought. These documents claim that there's evidence showing that both
the FBI and the State Department tried to keep a witness, the Ukrainian witness, um uh Andreli Teleshenko, I think is his name, to keep him out of the country so he could not meet with uh U.S. senators that were investigating the Biden family and their business in both Ukraine and China. Now, uh the the Mr. Teleshenko has was alleged to have spread quote-unquote false claims that Hunter Biden uh that his service on
the Ukrainian energy company uh Barisma, uh, that it impacted U.S. policy, that they were you know that it impacted their ability to fight corruption in Ukraine, that um uh the Joe Biden had withheld a billion dollars to force the firing of uh uh Ukraine's chief rivals. All these things, by the way, turned out to be accurate. And it was the claims that that what he was claiming was false were actually, it was the claims, the the false claims that were false. He was actually spreading real information. But it
kept being called false information. And but so to bring him in again again, senators are not supposed to be doing investigations. Congress makes the law, they don't enforce the law, they don't investigate violations of the law. But um uh accordingly, apparently the FBI and the State Department both moved to uh to uh uh revoke uh Mr. Teleshenko's visa to prevent him from coming into the United States to meet with the senators. They only found out that uh guess what? The uh the U.S. Embassy had already revoked Mr.
Teleshenko's visa to again keeping him out of the United States because of false claims that what he was claiming was false. Uh and of course, this lines up with a bunch of other things. The the 51 former intelligence officials that claimed that uh Hunter Biden's laptop was Russian disinformation, which turned out to be a single person writing a letter that 50 other people simply regurgitated. Um the uh the agents that were investigating, quote unquote, the
big guy, um, well, they were blocked from their investigation. There are all these accusations. Now, again, I want to point out that this is coming out of a White House office, which means there's politics involved. But I have to ask, where's the investigation of some of these, the actual criminal investigation of these alleged crimes? You know, you basically do have the Fox guarding the hen house. Um, because every time the someone in the Trump administration investigates
something from the Biden administration, it's simply uh written off as politics. It's just politics. There's no there. And again, if people are not held accountable, and I don't just mean Joe Biden, I mean Hunter Biden, I mean the 51 intelligence officers, I mean the the whoever in the FBI and the IRS that uh uh uh meddled in investigations into what appear to be legitimate claims that uh
um of malfeasance that should have been investigated. When are they held accountable? So that to me is part of the problem. And it part of it comes back to this idea of uh us versus them, right? The you know, well, we we gotta protect our guy. Um, we got to do something about our guy. And we're willing to overlook things because it's it's our guy. I also see this, by the way, in the thin blue line, right? Where uh we see uh district attorneys, attorneys general, and courts protecting law enforcement,
even when what they do is not only wrong, but criminal. And it it seems to be rare when uh uh they're even charged, much less investigated, to uh deal with their with the uh the accountability of their malfeasance, their bad actions. Now that's not to say no one's ever held accountable, but sometimes even the attempt to hold someone accountable is its own malfeasance.
Uh two FBI officials apparently have been charged with lying to Congress about their roles in the Hunter Biden probes. Um according to uh a senior uh uh FBI agent, I'm sorry, you to the the district, the U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, uh Gene Pierrot, lying to Congress by anyone strikes at the heart of our democra democratic system. But when senior FBI agents lie to Congress, believing they are above the law, it's time to bring the hammer of justice down on them. Okay, let's break this down for
a second. Why, what makes lying to Congress a crime? Well, Congress passed a law that said you can't, you know, lying to Congress is a crime. There's a problem with that. That law violates the First Amendment. Congress wrote a law abridging the freedom of speech. Lying is part of freedom of speech. Again, now that you have the other question. Uh, you you have this whole thing about, well, when you testify before Congress, you're under oath. Why? Again, I I uh you know uh
uh you don't have to be under oath to testify to Congress. You you know it it's it's a question of in other words, it's not lying to Congress, it wasn't lying under oath. Well, why do you have to be under oath to talk to Congress? Part of the problem is this idea that Congress is itself above the law. See, I've always found it interesting that courts have upheld that law enforcement can lie to people, but people can't lie to law enforcement. In fact, it's a federal crime to lie to the FBI, but it's not a federal crime
for the FBI to lie to you. That is the unequal protection of the law. That well, well, the 14th Amendment protects the the states have to have equal protection of the laws. That fun that fundamental concept that you're not above the law simply because you get a government paycheck is at the heart of what's going on here. So um uh again, the question of okay, you lied to Congress. Why is that a crime? Why is that first of all, uh, Ms. Pierrot, uh, we don't have a democratic system. This is a republic. The United States
is not a democracy, we are a republic. And these members of Congress are employees of we the people. In the United States, we have a First Amendment that says Congress can't make a law that abridges a person's freedom of speech. Meaning when they punish you for what you say, that's a violation of the First Amendment. Now, I agree. When you know, when you have senior officials, senior FBI agents lying, that's not good. But if they can lie to the people, they should be able to lie to the people's representatives.
I have a better idea. How about we make all law enforcement, while acting in that manner, we make lying a crime. That includes not just the FBI agents, that includes the the uh the police officer that pulls you over on a traffic stop. Let's make lying to sus to people a crime. Let's have equal type. If it's a crime for me to lie to the police, it should be a crime for the police to lie to me. But we don't hold people accountable for their actions for those lies. We don't treat that as malfeasance. And then we
wonder why we have members of Congress and FBI agents and all that. We have wonder why they're lying. Well, they're never held accountable for it. And this whole, even this whole question of, well, they lied to Congress. Well, boo-hoo. Um lying under oath may be a crime, but lying to Congress cannot legitimately be a crime. Now, were they under oath when they talked to Congress? Then maybe you have a chance of lying under. But again, we have the that's not what the U.S. district uh the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia is
saying. You lied to Congress. That's bad. That's that just distracts. Why? What makes Congress above the law? What makes the FBI above the law? So I have a better idea. How about you not charge with lying to Congress? How about you charge with lying under oath? Because think of it this way. We think about the Fourth Amendment, right? You have the right to uh be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures that a warrant must be based on probable cause supported by oath or affirmation. Meaning you have to be under
oath or affirmation to provide evidence for a warrant. And when you if you were to lie while providing that evidence, that would be a crime, would it not be? See, there's this is where I keep getting into we have different sets of standards. We had different set of standards for the president. Even the FBI says, uh has made up rules about what you can and cannot do to a president while in office that have nothing to do with the Constitution or laws of the United States. This to me is a problem, and until we hold people accountable
for their bad behavior, and I don't mean lying to Congress, I mean lying under oath, absolutely. But that should be the I I still think that uh law enforcement, governed actors should be held accountable when they lie. At the very minimum, if they lie to you, anything you say in response should be not admissible in court, and it should go up from there. Because that creates an equal playing field between government actors and the regular people. And that's what this is supposed to be about, isn't it? At least that's
what I think. Okay, let's shift gears a little bit. Uh let's talk a little bit about Social Security. The the Ponzi scheme. Social Security. Uh the this this uh Social Security Administration announced that they are looking to clean up their list of Social Security numbers. Now, this is apparently the largest, uh largest scale uh cleanup of Social Security information that's ever been done. Uh, what they want to do is they want to add death dates to 17 million Social
Security numbers. No, there are 17 million Social Security numbers that have of dead people that haven't been flagged as that person's dead. Uh they want to add uh citizenship information to 25 million of these, and they want to correct another 8.5 million where the citizenship information is wrong. Uh, I thought Social Security was for citizens. Why do non-citizens have Social Security numbers? Maybe it's maybe it's legal residence. I don't know. That that I just found that kind of curious. And they also want
to put in uh mechanisms and policies in place to help fix and prevent inaccuries in the records in the future. Okay, that sounds kind of good. We've had years, decades of bad information. I remember when my father passed away, um I'm the executive executor and minister of his state, and I had to notify the the actually the funeral home notified the Social Security Administration that my father had died. Uh he didn't get any Social Security checks. Uh they notified a bunch of banks and stuff. I understand the the desire to
keep this data up to date, and it's something that I think too often falls through the cracks. The fact that my father is flagged as deceased uh means that people could not use his social security number for uh um identity fraud in an attempt to collect social security uh checks that would have gone to my father if he were still alive. Um, so I I don't really have a problem with this, per se, right? This is cleaning up the house, good idea, good data. The problem I have is with Social
Security itself, because as I said, it's basically a Ponzi scheme. It works only by using the income of current workers to pay off the promises to retired workers that, well, the government never had a legal authority to make in the first place. But you see, there's more to this because again, we the whole the whole financial problem of Social Security. Now, Social Security just announced a 3.6 cost of living adjustment, meaning you're so if you get Social Security, your benefits are going up 3.6%. Does that keep up with inflation? I
don't think so, but that's not what I'm here. That's what I want to talk about here. Uh according to Senator Cassidy, um, Social Security's financials are in a really bad state. And uh he's actually urging Congress to finally take action. Now, people for decades have been complaining, have been warning that uh the financial projections on Social Security are not good. Um, according to Senator Cassie,
they believe that if if nothing is done within the next five years, there would have to be a 28% across the board cut in benefits because the Social Security Trust Fund is out of money. Because the money was never actually invested. The money was simply loaned to Congress, and uh now Congress has got to pick up the tab. Now, the other option would be to subs uh to substantially increase the payroll taxes that fund Social Security, which uh again, nobody likes to pay more taxes. Uh so uh we're approaching a
point where again, this is this is the slow motion act crash. This is a vehicle crash. We've been watching this coming, we've known it's coming, and no one has been willing to do anything about it. And I'm wondering who's gonna be held accountable? It's certainly not gonna be the members of Congress that created, that illegally created Social Security in the first place. They are long gone. It's not gonna be the people in the Social Security Administration that have um, well, that that have not uh sufficiently warned of the of the problems coming up. It's not been the member
of Congress that have kicked the can down the street. Nobody that's actually made the problem is going to be held accountable for this. It's going to rest on the people who foolishly trusted the federal government when they said, we'll take care of you. Or on the people who said that the federal government's going to rob in order to cover the cost of the uh the the of the checks that they made that they just can't cash. You know, the the promises they made that they they simply don't have the ability to cash. The question I come up to is
all right, uh, what are we gonna do about it? Who's gonna be held accountable for this Ponzi scheme? My guess is probably no one. But the American people, or at least those who just decided they were gonna depend on Social Security, they're the ones that are gonna pay the price. But the people who do who did the wrong are not gonna be held accountable. Okay, I have another break coming up, but uh before I go, again, I want to remind you freedom isn't free. Now, what's interesting is how you exercise your rights has an impact on
your rights. How you spend your money has an impact on your rights. There are plenty of entities that want to destroy your rights. They want the government to take over, they want uh open immigration, they want the laws to not matter to certain people, and they're often funded with the dollars you spend with different companies. That's why I don't do business with certain companies anymore, because I found out they were supporting things directly and indirectly that are antithetical to our rights. So, what do you do? One of the things I did is years ago I switched to Patriot Mobile.
I didn't do it because they're America's only Christian conservative wallets provider. I didn't do it for their great 4G and 5G coverage. I didn't even do it for their 100% US-based customer support. I did it not only because Patriot Mobile believes what I believe, but they put their money where their mouth is. They take a portion of every dollar to support organizations fighting for your rights, your freedom of religion, speech, press, to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures, to not be denied due process. By the way, they all support the sanctity of life, our veterans and our first responders. So join me today. Go to
patreomobile.comslash constitution, find a plan that works for you, and see if you're eligible for a discount. Veterans, first responders, families with multiple lines all are eligible for discounts. And if you use the code Constitution at checkout, you'll get your new account activated absolutely free. So if you're looking for a way to have great cell phone service and still support organizations protecting your rights, join me at patreomobile.com slash constitution. Find a plan and discount that works for you. And don't forget, use that code Constitution at checkout to get free activation.
I also hope you'll join me at americaoutloud.news. Now I go there each and every day for news and information. Why? Well, we live in the information age. Information's literally at our fingertips. But where do you go to get it? I want a place where I can verify what's being said so I can build trust in them. For me, one of those entities is AmericaOutloud.news. That's why I go there every night looking at the news, not only to bring content to you here on the radio, but just to share with friends and family, which is what I'd like you to do. So don't go to just go to
AmericaOutloud.news. But when you read a story or an article that really says something to you, share it. Share it with friends, family, neighbors. Maybe you listen to a podcast or watch a video and there's something great in there. Share it on social media, maybe with civic groups or anywhere. See, it's the act of sharing information that the corporate media and other entities don't want people to know, that, ladies and gentlemen, is how we help secure the blessings of liberty for all of us.
And sometimes, well, it's actually people who did the bad actions that are holding others accountable for doing bad actions under their bad actions. I was talking about before the break, Social Security, right? And the fact that Social Security is a complete violation of the Constitution of the United States, no one seems to care about. I guess we're more than welcome to be bribed. Well, here's another one. It's the Center for Medicaid and Medicare. There's been a lot of news lately about uh CMS's attempts to, well, deal with widespread fraud and misuse of funding
from Medicaid and Medicare. Remember, Medicaid and Medicare are themselves fraudulent. There's nothing in the Constitution that authorizes Congress to collect taxes to pay for, or fees or anything else to pay for people's medical services, whether they're old, poor, or whatever. So CMS itself is bad action, and people should be held accountable. But now we have the question of fraud. Now, um, in the latest one, officials from the CMS had a
press briefing a week or so ago, and uh they focused on the state of New York in their current target for alleged fraud, waste, and abuse across Medicaid and Medicare. Now remember, one of the weird and unconstitutional features of Medicaid and Medicare is this idea that Congress passes laws that require states to spend money. Congress has no legal authority to tell a state to do something outside of the powers vested in Congress, much less that
the state has to pay for it. But again, this is this is nothing. And again, fraud and abuse in New York State is nothing new either. Now, under a compliance warning letter that the CMS has sent to the state of New York, uh, New York has 30 days to answer and 90 days to comply with the agency's orders. Wait a second. Again, where's the agency get the legal authority to order? The whole thing is is unconstitutional. Now, I'm not saying there isn't waste, fraud, and abuse in New York's
Medicaid Medicare system. There most there probably is. But what we see here is the the uh lack of accountability when federal government goes beyond its legal authority, and then they use that as a bludgeon, they use that bribe to get states involved, and then they use that money as a bludgeon to extort them into doing things the way the federal government wants. Now, according to the CMS, they they audited, uh they did some audits, they found um 15
adult daycare centers, social adult daycare centers that had uh pre-filled Medicaid and Medicare billing information for individuals who were not participants in the program. They found one senator that was claiming requests for wheelchairs and disability aid that there were no wheelchairs there. Those disability aids were not there. They found fraud and abuse. But the only reason the federal government is involved in this is because the federal government has embezzled billions of dollars from the American people to help fund these programs.
So, where's the accountability for the federal government in embezzling money from the American people for something they're not legally authorized to spend? Now, I like most Americans, we we abhor waste, fraud, and abuse, and we wish there was less waste, fraud, and abuse. But we really should start with the waste, fraud, and abuse of the federal government. This CMS program is itself, it's wasteful, it's fraudulent, and abuses the powers delegated
to the United States by the Constitution. It is unconstitutional. And rather than looking at it saying, okay, where's the accountability for this? No, no, no, we're we're okay. It's the states that are making a mess out of this. No, you didn't have the legal authority. This is embezzled money to begin with. And I'm sure someone out there going, but the courts said it's okay. Well, when did the courts get to be the final word? Well, they are. No, they're not, not according to the Constitution. According to the Constitution, they're there to decide controversies based on the law, not
to decide, not to make the law. And um, the only power entities with the power to actually interpret and and uh change the constitution are the states themselves. So, what about the the uh accountability for the cowardice of the states to stand up against the federal government because they got bribed with money? Where's the accountability for the where's the accountability for state actors in that? Where's the accountability to the of the American people who, rather than being true citizens,
then that rather than looking at and studying the supreme law of the land, then holding their elected employees accountable when they violate their oath of office, just let it ride because they're getting the bribe. Where's the accountability for that? Well, the only place that accountability happens is when we the people hold ourselves accountable. And that is uh to me, that's a large part of the problem. Most Americans have no clue what the Constitution actually says. I just heard one today. Someone uh talking about um uh Abraham Lincoln and
uh how he suspended habeas corpus under the Constitution of the United States, except the question of habeas corpus is in Article I, Section 9. Article I is all about Congress. None of the powers of the president are in Article I. The powers are in Article, uh I should say, in general. The only power I think in Article I is his right to sign or veto legislation. So this idea of suspending habeas corpus is not a power delegated to the to the president, it's actually delegated to Congress, because it's in Article I.
But most people don't know that. They keep going, oh, that's that that's fine. The other one I'm hearing a lot is uh the Fourth Amendment protects your right to privacy. It does no such thing. It protects your right to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures, and assess the requirement for warrants, but privacy is your responsibility. Now, I I agree that New York State has a mess and they need to be clean, they need to be held accountable. But I'd like to see CMS and the federal government held accountable for the crime of embezzlement,
for the crime of violating their oath of office, for the crime of stealing from the American people. Now, not all taxes are stealing. When you authorize Congress, we authorize Congress to collect taxes to do three things pay the debts, uh common defense, and general welfare of the United States. Capital U, capital S, proper noun. That entity known as the United States, whose government is uh seated in Washington, D.C. Not the general welfare of the states, not the general welfare of the people, the general welfare of the entity known as
the United States. But most people don't know that. So when they Congress says, hey, I'm going to spend money on this, they simply think, well, Congress can spend money on whatever they want. Not legally, but they get away with it because there's no accountability for them when they do that. Speaking of accountability, let's let's look at the states. I'm going back to Illinois. A story I did in Illinois about a school district that placed male students with female students on overnight trips, right? And then withholding that information
from the parents. Now, according to reports, the Liberty Justice Center is trying to put together a case against the school district to sue them for, well, their bad actions. Now, the Liberty Justice Center has sent a demand letter to the uh Community High School District 128 in Northern Illinois, claiming that their policies to direct staff to not disclose a student's transgender status, to assign overnight
rooms according to a student's gender identity, not their actual sex, to incorporate transgender material into the curricula and libraries. According to this letter, it violates federal law, and they demand that the district reconsider them. The obvious implication being if you don't, we're going to put together a lawsuit. Now, the school district's attorney responded with, well, this is an evolving area of law, but they also defended the policies, claiming they are
based under current state and federal privacy laws. Again, that little thing about the Constitution of the United States, that uh the liberty to raise our children belongs to the parents, not the state. So when you hide information from the parents, that violates the 14th Amendment. Yeah, I guess they didn't they kind of ignored that part. But I'm curious, other than this lawsuit, are the the members of the district board, are they going to be held accountable for this policy? This policy didn't pop
out of nowhere. The the district board approved this policy. Um, and what about the parents? Were the parents unaware of this policy and did nothing until now? Um, there's a lot of accountability going around. And I think that's to me one of the big issues. Because when I talk about accountability, we all make mistakes. I try not to get too wound up about a mistake. I get wound up about how someone responds to that mistake. You know,
uh it can be as simple as you know, uh a waitress getting a wrong order in the restaurant. I don't get upset about the wrong order. I wonder how they are going to respond to the wrong order. Do they make it right? Do they give me a hard time? That's the that's how I uh I look at things. And it's the same thing here. You know, I look at the board and say, well, wait a second, you should have known better. And if this is your idea of governing, of overseeing the schools, maybe you're not qualified, right? If you're going to ignore the
basic biology of male versus female, if you're going to place male students with female students on an away trip and then hide it from the parents, not only do you have legal repercussions, uh, but uh yeah, I I I why are I'm kind of curious if the the parents in that school district are going to look at the school board and say, what were you guys smoking? You're all fired. And find something else. Because ultimately,
the only way we can hold others accountable is we have to hold ourselves accountable, which means we have to recognize when we make a mistake and then do the best we can to correct it. And that's kind of what I'm seeing here is a lot of people have made a lot of mistakes, but nobody wants to be held accountable. Nobody wants to be held accountable. But holding people accountable is the only way we discourage bad actions in the future. If the members of the school board are not held accountable for this ridiculous, crazy, and dangerous, potentially
dangerous policy, why would they stop it? And why would other school districts not follow it? Why wouldn't that they'd not mirror that? If if they're not told that if they're not held responsible for it. And I don't mean that we should take the law into our own hands. We need to make sure that the law is equally applied. And we need to make sure that the people who are doing that are held accountable when they don't. And that includes who gets elected, um, what happens with the people they appoint,
and what happens when they make a mistake. I know they're gonna make a mistake, but how you deal with that mistake, how they deal with that mistake, is important. And I think that's what I'm looking for, and I think that's what the American people need to know. But if we're going to be holding holding others accountable for based on the Constitution of the United States, we have to be held accountable for our ignorance of the Constitution of the United States. And that starts by actually resolving that ignorance. How do we do that? Well, you start by reading and studying
the Constitution of the United States. As I said, the first time I sat down and read it, I was in my, I think it was in my 40s. And I was shocked not only by what I had not been taught in school, but what I had been taught that was absolutely wrong. And that's why I read it and study it for myself. And that's why I encourage other people to read it and study it for themselves. Now, when different people read and study the same document, we're gonna have differences. We're gonna have questions about how we we analyze and look at that. And I love when people ask questions. To me, that's the greatest way
to learn is to ask and answer questions. It's why I've set up a whole section of the website. You go to constitutionstudy.com slash questions and you can ask your question. Now, I do ask for your name and email address because, well, I'm going to respond to you via email. By the way, you can also email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com. Both end up in the same place, both come directly to me personally. I'll read your question and I'll answer your question to the best of my ability. I I only really ask that it be that it not be rude. And you know, I I'm
if it's rude or vulgar, I'm gonna trash it. Uh and that it has something to do with the constitution, the constitution's like something here. I get I occasionally get questions that have absolutely nothing to do with what we're talking about here. I I can't answer those. That's not my my area of expertise. But I will answer them and I will answer you directly. Now, I love answering those questions here on the radio as well. So if you'd like me to answer them on the radio, well, there's a checkbox on the website form. Just answer on America at Loud Talk Radio. If you email me, just mention it
in the email, and I'll be love and I'd love the idea of answering those questions right here on the Constitution Study. Because if you're asking that question, chances are someone else has that similar question. They just haven't asked it yet. And again, I love when people ask me questions because it makes me look at my responses and make sure I can support what I'm saying. So it's helpful to you, it's helpful to me, and it's helpful to others. So please, again, head to constitutionstudy.com slash questions, or email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com with your relevant question. Tell me if you want to answer it here.
I'll be more than happy to because, ladies and gentlemen, that is not only how we learn, that's also how we hold ourselves accountable for our reading and studying of the Constitution. When we when we bring our ideas before others and we debate the truth based on facts and data, not simply uh opinions and appearances. Now, I also hope you come back and join me here for the Constitution study on America at Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern Time. You can listen on
our media player. We've also got After Apple, Android, and Alexa, and all the episodes go to podcasts generally a day or two after they're heard on Talk Radio. So you get to listen in your favorite podcast app. If you do that though, do me a favor, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share the Constitution Study with more people. The more people who share it with, the more people are likely to click the links and join us here for the Constitution Study. Speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage of AmericaOutloud.news. But
please share those links, share this program, share the work that we're doing. And by doing so, help share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...