A New Yorker, a Congressman, and a Supreme Court Justice walk into a bar
57 minAudio
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I know, it sounds like a joke, but trust me, it isn’t. New York is trying to get its hands on $75 million for their climate slush fund (superfund). A federal judge said no, not because of the state law, but because they claim the federal law, which was not made pursuant to the Constitution, supersedes it. Similarly, New York, both the state and the city, are...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Outlaw Network with your host, Paul English. A New Yorker, a Congressman, and the Supreme Court justice walk into a bar. I know the title of this episode sounds like a setup for a joke, but what's been happening in New York, Congress and the Supreme Court,
is no joke. Hello there, everyday Americans, Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacher action generation be free. Glad you could join me today. You know, I I know the setup for a joke just seems so obvious, I couldn't resist. But I want to take a look at some stuff going on in New York, both the city and the state, uh, within the House of Representatives and um, well, at the Supreme Court. So let's start with New York. Um, we have the this one's a state of New York, where uh, well,
Kathy Hokel and her attempt to uh well basically milk the American taxpayer for even more money, uh, seems to hit a snag. See, in 2024, New York passed a law, which Ms. Hokel signed, that would impose a $70 billion, $75 billion charge on companies that emitted carbon. Right now, we're talking about carbon dioxide, they're talking about plant food. But you see, the state alleges that this carbon dioxide has caused caused climate damage
between the years 2000 and 2018, for which they want their protection money. I mean, it's a racket. This is right up there with uh uh the the with Capone or um or the Corleones. I mean, it's it's this is a racket. Now, a district judge in Syracuse said uh, no, the were the attorneys general, all 22 of them that sued, as well as uh well, different industry groups and the chamber of commerce,
said the state measure was preempted by federal law. Now, again, uh uh Ms. Hogel signed the Climate Change Superfund Act back in 2024, and it looked at three dozen different fossil fuel companies that uh again would pay $3 billion annually for 25 years to fund all the damage that New York State was supposedly going to incur from their use of and production of fossil fuels.
But here's the twist. According to the judge, the Federal Clean Air Act uh delegated to the Environmental Protection Agency the authority to regulate carbon dioxide emissions, thereby being uh under the Supreme Law Land, the supremacy clause meant that federal law superseded state law. Well, there's two problems with actually there's three problems with that. So, problem number one, the environmental protection agency doesn't legally exist. I mean, I know it exists,
and I know there are laws that created it. There's just one problem. They were not made pursuant to the Constitution of the United States. Congress was not enacting a power vested in the government of the United States, therefore, that act was unconstitutional. And according to at least Alexander Hamilton and the Supreme Court in uh Marbury versus Madison, ex parte Seabold, Morton V. Shelby County, that act is void. So we've got an agency that doesn't legally exist. Second of all, the Clean Air Act. There's nothing in the Constitution that authorizes Congress
to regulate the environment. Again, means the EPA doesn't legally exist. The Clean Air Act doesn't have doesn't give Congress the ability to regulate anything in the environment, much less carbon dioxide emissions. Just because Congress said so doesn't mean they legally can, which leads us to problem number three, the supremacy clause. Article 6, clause two, which says this Constitution and the laws the United States made in pursuance thereof, and all treaties made or which shall be made on the authority of the United States shall be the Supreme
Law of the Land. Since was since the Clean Air Act was federal law that was not made pursuant to the Constitution, it is not the Supreme Law of the Land. That said, where does Kathy Hogle get the authority to uh basically charge businesses, entities that are outside of her state? The answer is nowhere that I'm aware of. Now, the Constitution of the State of New York does allow the state to enact uh sales taxes and certain other ex posts and excises, but only for business done in the
state of New York. Not some mythical, uh, oh, you're going to cause problems. And oh, by the way, this alleged money, which they say is caused the because of their phosphorus, this is not targeted for any sort of remediation of the alleged problems created by these companies. No, it creates basically a slush fund for anything the state of New York wants. I mean, the money was supposed to be earmarked for infrastructure work, stormwater systems, roads, bridges, and
responses to extreme weather. Uh, having lived in upstate New York most of my life, actually, having lived in New York City for 10 years when I was a child, uh, extreme weather wasn't caused by these companies over those few years. Extreme weather is part of living in the Northeast. Now, that hasn't stopped the state of New York or any other state, by the way, from using their position as a protection racket, trying to make these companies come to office they can't refuse. If not, they'll wake up one morning with
a horse head in their bed. And if you don't recognize that, I recommend you uh uh you watch the first Godfather movie. Meanwhile, there are over a dozen sheriffs in the state of New York that are suing the governor. Why are they suing the governor? Another law. The Local Cops Local Crimes Act. Uh, this law was filed in the Northern District of New York. Uh in the Renssler, it includes the Rensselaer County
Sheriff uh as lead plaintiff. And it it the law prevents local agencies from partnering with immigration and customs enforcement. Now, Broome County Sheriff uh uh Fred Akshar called the law aggressive and gross overreach. Because you have to remember, a county sheriff isn't appointed by this the the the governor. It's not an appointed position, it's not part of the state government. It is a constitutionally created law enforcement position. They are
elected by the people, they are accountable to the people. Now, I'm not that familiar with the constitution of the state of New York. Specifically, uh, some states do allow the state government to provide perform some levels of oversight of sheriff's activities. But they're claiming this goes uh beyond simply the the uh uh overseeing what they're doing. They're claiming it's interfering with their law enforcement powers as sheriff. A second uh law that was signed back in May uh handed uh the
uh uh Attorney General Letitia James, who's also named in the suit, uh the power to investigate sheriffs who actually cooperate with federal agents. Again, a lot of power that the that uh Ms. Hochler and her administration simply seem to think, well, they can do it because, well, we're the family, and we tell you what to do, and we make you offers, and it's up to you to follow them or suffer the consequences. Okay, that's a really bad godfather in British nation, but you get the
idea. This sounds a lot more like a uh a mob uh uh story than, well, I'd say then law enforcement, but then again, having lived in the in the empire of New York for so many years, it does kind of sound like the way they do business. One of the reasons why I left the Empire State, this idea that you know the federal gov, the state government, as corrupt as it is, believes it can exercise any power it wants. Constitutions and laws, to the contrary, be damned.
So let's see. Uh Ms. Hokel lost it, or is has so far lost a case uh involving a uh racketeering scheme to extort money out of companies because well, they they they they work with fossil fuels, and uh now they're be she's being sued for trying to bully sheriffs into going along with her anti-ICE, uh pro-illegal immigrant uh uh political scheme. But she's not done. See, both both Governor
Hokel and Mayor Mandami of New York City called on the Department of Homeland Security to release a counterterrorism fund that uh they clay had claimed had already been allocated to New York. Now, this Homeland Security Grant Pro, which is managed by the Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA, is designed to provide federal funds to help uh uh uh local governments, state and local governments, um
prepare, prevent, protect against, prepare for, and respond to acts of terrorism and other hazards. Well, the fact that the Constitution doesn't authorize the federal government to fund such things should be problem number one. Uh, the fact that the state and city of New York believe they are owed this money. Problem number two, problem number three. According to FEMA, uh New York State already has $300 million
in homeland security funding that it hasn't spent. In other words, it's not that the city and state are running out of money, they've got $300 million uh of that of money they haven't spent. This is just, hey, greedy. We want this. It's it's the old we need to have it because if we don't get it this quarter, we're not gonna get it next year. And yeah, that kind of sounds like a uh a scheme, at least it sounds like one from my standpoint.
Now, Governor Hochel's office, oh no, no, you don't understand it's spent over multiple years, that's why we haven't spent all this money yet, but we need this money to fund upcoming projects and all that. How about the fact that um you that that money is embezzled from the American people? Nowhere in the Constitution is the closest you can get is yes, the um the Congress can sp can uh provide money for the common defense. Um common common defense. But this isn't about the
common defense, is it? It's more about pro reacting to acts of terrorism. It's not about defending against terrorism, it's about how do we react to terrorist uh incidents. So I'm not sure it's the public defense, it certainly is not the common welfare of the United States. Uh what this is again, federal money being used to bribe states and cities to do what politicians in Washington, D.C. want them to do. And it shows how Ms. Hokel and Mr. Mondami are
just hooked like an addict on the money drug coming out of DC. But again, like I said, Hokel says, no, no, we need this money so we can can uh be better prepared statewide for uh counterterrorism activities. However, a spokesman for FEMA said that for more than two decades, New York has received substantially more federal funds than is traditionally received and allocated based on the risk formulas that
FEMA uses. In other words, New York's already been getting extra money. Why? Well, they're a target, right? But then again, the federal government isn't authorized to spend that money in the first place. That's embezzled money. So uh what do we see in New York? Well, we see a lot of greed, that's nothing new. We see a lot of federal bribery, that's nothing new. And we see a state government that uh, well, while they have their political positions, try to enforce those on the counties, even on law
enforcement that isn't that doesn't uh directly responsible to the state government, the county sheriff, which as I've said before, most powerful law enforcement official in the county is the sheriff. They have a lot of power because they are not an appointed position. They are elected, they are elected by the people. And uh again, uh there may be some oversight the state can provide, but only based on the state's constitution, which um I don't know that uh the New York State Constitu well, I don't I don't know off the top of my head the uh the what the New York
State Constitution says about those powers. What I do know is you have um well you have people in in uh Albany, New York that want to tell the um uh the the sheriffs and the rest in the rest of the state how they should handle their business and how they should do their jobs. And um, you know, again, bec it primarily it seems to me, because Kathy Hokel has shown herself to be
uh well let's just say disinterested in uh the actual issues with um uh with federal law enforcement. Again, I have issues with um uh I have issues with the federal immigration laws. Uh I think constitutionally there's a problem with them. Why? Because the power to regulate uh uh immigration is not delegated to the United States, and since it's not prohibited to the
states, it means it's really a state power to begin with. But then again, she's already admitted she's given up a lot of that power in order to get the state money, which again does it really surprise anyone that uh uh you know politicians are uh willing to sell their soul for more money they can use to buy influence with others. Okay, listen, I have a break coming up before I go, though. You know, we talk about terrorism and and whatever. Really, we need to be prepared. You never know what emergencies
are gonna happen. Now, granted, the odds of you being in a in a terrorist incident are pretty small. There may be a vehicle accident or a or a house fire, any one of a number of things that might happen. And proper preparation is important. In fact, it doesn't even have to be an emergency, sometimes it may just be an illness. Now, as part of my preparation, as I said, I've got fire extinguishers and first aid kits and and even trauma kits in my home, in my car, because you never know
when or where an emergency is going to happen. But our friends at the wellness company, they've come up with something next level. These are not the emergency kits you get at the pharmacy. All right, we're talking about prescription level medications, being properly prepared for whatever may happen. Imagine, you know, something happens and it's the middle of the night or it's a weekend, doctors' offices are closed, you go to urgent care, do you wait in the line in an emergency room? Uh, wouldn't you like to be able to have that initial treatment as soon as possible?
Well, that's where these emergency kits come in. Go to markoutloud.shop and click on the emergency kits panel, take a look, look what's included. Uh, you've got the contagion kit has ivermectin and uh uh uh hydroxychloroquine and erythemycin. The first aid kit includes an EpiPen, Keflex, a tourniquet, uh even glucose solution. Think about travel, right? Uh ZPAX, uh Zopran, things that you might need. That's what these
are all designed for. And I said, these are prescription-level medications, whether you need it for a medical emergency, a first aid, or even for children. Head to AmericaOutloud.shop, look, click on the emergency kit series, do your research, look what's included in these, and be prepared. Proper preparation prevents poor performance. When you go to checkout, use the code out loud, you'll get 20% off of your order. So I talked about before, we we try to teach the rising generation to be free to prepare ourselves for attacks on our
rights. These kits are designed with prescriptions and guidebooks and information so that you can be prepared for the emergencies that may crop up in your life. Now, whether you're someone who just wants to be sure, you know, hey, I've got kids in the house and I want to be be, you know, just in case something bad happens, or you're someone like my family where I have a person with a medical condition that uh frequently requires antibiotics. And there's nothing like getting up in the middle of the night and having to go to an urgent care. I want to be prepared. That's what these kits
are for. So again, head to americaoutloud.shop, click on the emergency kits panel, see which kit works best for you, and then when you check out, use the code Outloud to get 20% off of your order. Are you looking for healthy snacks? But you've had enough of all the sweet, sugary energy bars? Good news, there's new bars to try. That's savory, crunchy,
and packed with goodness. Bear bars are based just on six simple natural ingredients. A certified organic veggie, nut and seed bar. That's low temp dried, never baked or fried. Bear bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bearbar.com slash outloud and get the exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners.
That's B E A R B A R dot com forward slash outloud. Feeling run down, foggy, or constantly drained? Your body might be lacking the support it needs at the cellular level. Recharge from the Wellness Company is a doctor-formulated supplement designed to restore your energy, focus, and immune function. It features the first ever combination of methylene blue and urolithin A. Clinically studied ingredients that support mitochondrial health, boost cellular repair, and
enhance cognitive performance. With added NAD3, COQ10, and PQQ, recharge is the daily solution for deep lasting energy, not just a temporary boost. Visit TWC. Are you tired of struggling with low energy? We get it. That's why we created organic energy juice. In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle
with low energy again. And it tastes amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy juice is the right decision. With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. A man's country is not a certain area
of land of mountains, rivers, and it is patriotism, and patriotism is loyal to that. Patriotism loyalty is really loyal.
The House passed a measure denouncing socialism. They passed a resolution, uh 220 to 192, basically saying that socialism is bad. The resolution was introduced by Representative Jeff Crank of Colorado, and it stated that socialism necessitates a concentration of power that has, time and time again, collapsed into communist regimes, totalitarian rule, and repressive dictatorships. It also said that the ideology has repeatedly led
to famine and mass murder and the killing of over 100 million people worldwide. Now, okay, uh the statement is true. The resolution it's a show. It has no legal basis. And um they voted on it. And again,
220 to 192, it tells me something. It tells me that almost half of the people currently in the House of Representatives don't think socialism is bad. Uh two members voted present. That tells me a lot about their character. Uh, it was primarily partisan, right? Only eight Democrats joined in the Republicans in voting for this resolution. But this resolution is nothing but a statement of the House. Again, has no legal, it's not legally binding,
includes no law, no statute. It's just their opinion that socialism is bad. But I wonder if it's 220 to 192 with two abstaining, um, what's it going to be in a few years? Now, the the the resolution also targeted the Democratic Socialists of America, criticizing them for calling for non-citizens and incarcerated criminals to vote in American elections, uh pushing to abolish the Senate, uh seeking to implement uh ranked choice voting
in all elections, replace the two-party system. Now, listen, I have no problem with opening the elections up to more than two parties. Legally, it's open, practically, it's all but impossible once you get beyond local elections. Uh, but and again, ranked choice voting, I have some yes and nays with this. I mean, uh on the one hand, people say it's too complicated, it does delay the actual selection of the person, but it also breaks the stranglehold of the two parties because now
you basically, if if it's if ranked choice voting is used to eliminate primaries, hey, that'd be great. Um, right beyond that, ranked choice voting just says, listen, it I want to pick people in order, and it's kind of a way for people to vote what they really want as their first vote, but not completely throw the vote away. Uh, I know the political partisans hate it because it disrupts their control over elections. That's their the scenario. But again, understand what this resolution
is. This is simply a statement of opinion of the House of Representatives. And uh I I learned more, I I glean more from how close the vote was than on the actual resolution itself. I wonder, would you go to house.gov and and look up the voting record of your representatives and see whether or not they supported a resolution that said socialism is bad? And are you okay with that with them
doing that? Is that a an okay response for you? Or maybe are you looking for something a bit more than just than that? And let me ask you, if your if your representative voted for the resolution, did the resolution go far enough to simply say that socialism is bad, that maybe there should be more. What do you think? I think it'd be interesting. House passed another bill to fund the government at least past election day. Now,
I cannot remember the last time that the Congress actually passed a budget, uh, much less having a spending program that did more than band-aid their profligate spending for a little bit of time. And let's face it, the reason um the only reason they they uh did this is to get the the question of a government shutdown past the midterm elections. That's really what this was all about. It wasn't about having uh uh reasonable
spending, it wasn't about being fiscally sound, it wasn't about doing their duty as legislators. It's let's get this past the uh um the past the midterm elections, and we'll let the next uh House deal with it, the next Congress deal with it. In other words, it's another kick the can down the road. Now, the Senate had passed this 90 to 6 back in August. So the House, by voting on this 370 to 48, this they can discontinuing resolution, this
CR, this omnibus nonsense goes to President Trump for a signature, which I believe he's gonna sign if he hasn't signed it already, because it moves a problem past the midterm elections. And uh again, this is about party politics more than it is about actually running the government or funding the government. Uh all the talk, all the the spin of the contrary, everything I've seen is this is more about let's not deal with our problems, let's kick
them down the road and either deal with them after the election, or if you're retiring or you didn't win your primary, and you're not gonna don't expect to win the the it gets it out, it's a problem you no longer have to deal with, which I believe covers a significant portion of the members of the House. That means come December, as the the members of Congress are getting ready to go home to to celebrate the holidays, they'll be the specter of another government shutdown. And oh my god, we're all
gonna die because the government's gonna shut down and it'll be a holidays and all be tiny Tim and we're all gonna die and become crippled, and we'll do it again and again and again. And by the way, the government never actually shuts down, they always will they furlough unnecessary or no, I'm sorry, non-essential employees. If they're not essential, why are we hiring why paying them in the first place? And of course, as soon as they the politicians play their dance and and they come up with the funding again, well, all those people
that were furloughed get they get all the back pay. So it's basically a paid vacation. And some people do have some difficulties, right? There are certain services and operations that may be delayed and whatnot. But again, it's a all a bunch of of kabuki theater. It's not really what's going on. This is not really about being financially responsible. It's really just about, like I said, kicking the can down the road so we can have some more theater. Uh, this time just in time for the Christmas holiday.
Okay, a third vote. Still dealing in the House. This time, uh, they haven't voted yet, but the House wants to vote on another resolution that would propose an amendment to the Constitution of the United States fixing the sides of the Supreme Court to nine justices. Now, the resolution, House Joint Resolution 1, introduced by Representative Biggs of Arizona, consists of a single sentence. The Supreme Court of the United States shall be composed of nine justices, consisting of one Chief Justice and
eight associates, associate justices. Well, I'll give him points for being sweet, similar to the point. And of course, this is all about the being done because, well, Mr. Biggs is a Republican and the Democrats keep threatening to pack the Supreme Court, uh, which by meaning they're going to add seats when one of their presidents is in office, so that uh people who bel who believe the Constitution should be moldable and malleable as wax in order to get what they want, uh, can be put in the court so that they can
get their agenda the way they did, oh, for decades in the nation's past. You know, the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, into the early 2000s, where the court just made up of stuff out of thin air. And I've covered a bunch of that here. Um, now I I look at this uh in a couple of ways. On the one hand, it would eliminate this this talking point of packing the Supreme Court. Now, in order to pack the Supreme Court, well, if
this, if by the way, this passed the House and the Senate by two-thirds and was ratified by three-fourths of the states, uh, then in order to change it, well, they'd have to amend the Constitution again. Something that's a fairly high burden and done for that way for good reason. But I also think about it this way: is nine the right number? Now, right now, there are nine circuits and nine just as Supreme Court. And the Supreme Court only takes a small percentage of the cases. The only thing I think about
take about 10% of the cases that people petition. So you know the court doesn't take all the cases. There's a petition for writ of sortiori, meaning that the court will take the case. And again, I think on average, they only take about 10% of those cases. Um, now part of that is the process, right? There are uh the there's the Supreme Court, and the court has to, you know, they have to read all the briefs, and then they have to hear the oral arguments, and then they have to discuss it and debate it and assign someone to write the
opinion, and then people, some people write dissents and concurrences and all that. It's a very interesting process. Or it's a very cumbersome process. What makes it interesting is well, what if the Supreme Court worked more like the circuit courts did? See, very often the circuit courts, they the entire court doesn't hear the case. A panel of the court hears the case, and then it's decided that says, okay, the entire court will hear the case. So what if we said, okay, you know, we're going to take some cases. We'll be first heard
by a three-judge panel, right? Well, we'll pick three judges out of a hat, and you know, you get this case. And then, you know, we'll pick three more judges out of the next case, we'll take it, three more judges. Then the court could probably hear, well, you would assume three times as many cases, right? Because they're being done in three judge panels. Um, wouldn't entirely be true because some cases would be heard by the entire court. Some cases, you know, if the three-judge panel would hear it, then maybe it'd be appealed to the full court. Um, by the way, none of that is unconstitutional. Nothing in
the constitution simply says it will have a uh a Supreme Court, as many inferior courts as Congress shall make, and establishes the jurisdiction of the federal court. So this is none of that of what it says unconstitutional. So I have to wonder, again, there's nothing magical about the number nine. We've had more judges in the past, we've had fewer judges in the past. Uh, this to me is a move to remove a talk a talking point from Democratic candidates.
Uh, I don't know that it's the best answer. Uh, I think the court could be more efficient if it was structured a little differently. Knows that the Supreme Court didn't hear all cases in the before the entire court. But that's a discussion for another day. That's not what Mr. Biggs is proposing. Again, I think it's merely an attempt to remove a political talking point. Uh, I don't think nine is a magic number. Uh I I kind of like the idea of
getting rid of the talking point. I just don't know that the way the court is structured today is truly the best structure for a country as large and as litigious as the United States has become. That's my opinion. So we dealt with the New Yorkers, we've dealt with the congressmen. I do have some cases from the co the Supreme Court, but I'm looking at this and I want us to think, you know, uh again, it it sounds like a joke, and
well, I know some of what gets done by these groups is laughable, but we've looked at New York, my granted, the state of my birth. I was born in New York City, lived most of my life in upstate New York, escaped the empire about 11 years ago. Um, and the the the Congress, mostly in the House, we still have this joke, we gotta finish up. And like I said, what's going on here is not a joke. What's going on here is is really serious business. So I want to get into the questions of what's being done
at the Supreme Court level and by the Supreme Court justices, but before I get to that, I have to take a break. And I want you to consider this. You know, we talk a lot about our rights being under attack, and and they are. Our right to be free is being attacked, and again, not just by government. We've seen government attack, we've seen the you know in New York and in the House attacks uh on our rights. Um but those are often being prodded and promoted by other organizations, nonprofits and NGOs
that are promoting these ideas. These ideas don't come out of nowhere. Now I have to ask you, are you funding those organizations that are attacking your rights? You may be doing it and not realize it. How? Well, by who you do business with. Let's stop funding those core organizations that are attacking our right to live free. Join the only Christian conservative violence provider this nation has. Use your cell phone to defend your rights and the rights of your family, including your right to
life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Switch to Patriot Mobile today, get free activation with the offer code Constitution. Go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution, find a plan that works for you, see if you're eligible for discounts. NRA members, veterans, first responders, even family members with multiple lines can get a discount. And don't forget, you got that promo code Constitution that you can use to get free activation. So protect your rights with your cell phone and do it
easy the simple, easy way by just going to patriotmobile.com/slash constitution, finding a plan and discount that works for you. And don't forget that code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. Now, I also hope you'll head over to AmericaOut Loud.news. We live in the information age. Information is literally at our fingertips. Think about it. You take your cell phone and you've got access to the almost the entire sum of human knowledge right there. And of course, with the new tools, it's easier than ever to get to. But who
do you trust? Who do you go to? Are you letting someone else decide what news is important for you? For me, one place I go to for news is americautloud.com.news. Why? Well, because they've shown themselves to be pretty trustworthy, and I get to verify what they say. So I go there each and every day for news and information. And I'd love it if you join me there, but I want you to do a bit more. See, I'm in the habit of sharing that information. I go through my news feed, and every time I see an
article that I find interesting, I share it. I share it with friends, I share it with family members, I share it online. I have a whole email list on my website, constitutionstudy.com, that is just articles I think I find that I find interesting, and you might too. So please go to AmericaOutloud.news, read the stories, read the articles, then share them. Listen to the podcast, watch the videos, share them as well. You'll be surprised how often someone will say, I didn't know about that. I didn't hear that
anywhere else. That's right. That's because corporate media didn't want them to know. We needed to share it for them. You know what that means? That means when you go to AmericaOutloud.news and you share what you learn there, you're not just sharing AmericaOutloud.news. You're not just sharing the Constitution study. You're not even just sharing an article or a video. You're helping to secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. We wouldn't go a day without washing our
hands, brushing our teeth, and washing our nose. Well, wait, we wash our nose? Yes, the number one place where bacteria, viruses, and pollen enter the body is through the nose. So the average person breathes over 23,000 times a day. That's 23,000 opportunities for bacteria, viruses, and irritants to get into your nose and make you sick. For an extra layer of protection, wash your nose with clear. That is clear X-L-E-A-R. Clear's drug-free nasal spray features xylitol, an ingredient proven
to block adhesion of many nasty bacteria and viruses, and effectively clean, not just rinse like a saline, but wash your nose. Clear nasal spray quickly alleviates congestion, opens your airway, and ensures your body's natural defenses are strong. Read the research studies for yourself at clear.com. That's x-le-ar.com. Protect yourself from the pathogens and junk you breathe. Pick up a bottle for you and your family today. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful.
You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of
mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash outloud and use the code Outloud for an exclusive offer. Prepare for the next pandemic with the wellness company's Contagion Emergency Kit designed by Dr. Peter McCullough. Get life-saving medications like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, plus a free nebulizer and a guidebook for safe use. Order now by going to TWC.
Welcome back, everyday Americans. We've talked about Congress, and it is time to talk about Supreme Court justices. And there's some interesting things going on. For one thing, there's actually a uh there was a hearing in the House about the Supreme Court's recent decision about birthright citizenship. The House uh uh subcommittee, the uh the g and the judiciary had a a thing, and and um not quite sure
all the details, but it's an inter that they had an interesting lineup of people planning to testify. Um they had the Deputy Secretary of Homeland Security, Ken Cucinelli, uh Kansas Attorney General Chris Kobach, um uh the director of the Immigration Accountability Project, Rosemary Jenks, all came to testify on the subject of the jurisdiction thereof. Now, again, I've talked about this during the case, I talked about this before the taste, I talk about this when it comes
up all the time. Um, the words, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, I've done research on it. That language was actually added to the joint resolution that became the 14th Amendment by a Senator Merritt Howard. And in his own words, he said that uh, yeah, this would recognize what is already natural law and national law, that people born in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens. This would not include aliens, foreigners, or the children of
uh uh ambassadors or other foreign ministers. So he was quite specific in what he meant when he proposed adding that language, the language that was added to the resolution that became the 14th Amendment, adopted ratified by the states. The exact same language that exists in federal law that says, Congress says, in order to be born a citizen, you not only must be born in the United States, well, he says, Yeah, if you're born if you're born in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof. Uh, they go on a bit more about what a natural-born citizen is.
And this is exactly what Donald Trump put in his executive order, subject to their jurisdiction and uh uh born in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof. But the court decided, nope, we we are we're not gonna pay any attention to the Constitution, to the laws, to the history, to the the actual uh purpose of Congress, the intent of Congress. We're gonna stick with our own misguided uh understanding when we when a previous court had said that a gentleman whose parents were resident in the United
States, he was born in the United States, but his parents were were uh subject to the emperor of China. But we don't care about that. We're gonna change the rules. Now, Representative Chiproy of Texas, who chairs the subcommittee, uh said in an interview, says the 14th the Supreme Court failed the American people. The 14th Amendment was never meant to turn American soil into a factory for making U.S. citizenship. I wholeheartedly agree. I I believe this has got to be this is probably one of the worst decisions this court in its
current has made. Because again, they ignored the Constitution, they ignored the law, they ignored everything except an erroneous decision made a hundred years previously, that literally, again, turned the language of the Constitution on its head to come to their decision. Now, Representative Roy said Congress cannot afford to sit on the sidelines. He said the subcommittee is looking to confront the fundamental question the court failed to resolve. What does a citizenship clause of the 14th Amendment actually mean? I don't think
they failed to resolve it. I think they got it wrong. I think they made up their own understanding. Just look at when I look go to the website. I I covered the opinion. Uh, I wrote about it, I went in detail, I have quotes you can follow, even to the point of justices, supposedly the smartest legal minds in the country, that don't understand the difference between subject to the jurisdiction of the United States and subject to the laws of the United States. Apparently they don't understand that. But then again, you know, we're dealing with lawyers who, contrary to popular
belief, apparently not the smartest people in the room. But I think this also points out something else that I hear quite a lot, and it's I think it's really important that we understand. Some people said in response to the court's opinion that uh uh we need a new law, kind of like what Chip Roy is doing. Some said we need to amend the Constitution. And I ask you, what good is amending the Constitution when you have a Congress and a court, not in this case, Congress and other times, but when you have a court that completely ignores the
language of the Constitution to get to the outcome they want. That's kind of my point. A lot of people think that we can fix the Constitution by amending it. And there are a couple things I'd like to tweak in the Constitution. But the problem rarely is the language of the Constitution. The problem is people who simply ignore the language or make up language uh in regards to the Constitution of the United States. Uh, another example. Here we had something that doesn't happen very often. We had two justices of the Supreme
Court, Justices Kagan and Barrett, that uh testified in front of a committee of Congress. Doesn't happen very often. Remember, you got separation of powers. But during this interview, this is not an interview, during this hearing, an interesting question came up. And it had to do with prediction markets. Sites like Kalchi and Poly Market that allow people to effectively bet on just about everything. Now, they
don't call it betting, they call it investing. And the question really came up was uh are members of the court and maybe their their their staff or even others making money on these prediction markets based on insider information? Now a couple of things I want to I want to think about here because this this brought up another discussion I heard on another podcast. And it really is a question, are these prediction markets investments or are they
gambling? And like so many things, the answer really is it depends. It depends on how you're going about it. Because you're if you're investing money, you're risking money based on well, based on your your understanding of what's going to happen. Now, a lot of people think that uh uh the stock market is gambling. And to an extent, that's true, right? You're not assured an outcome, but you're making an educated guess, hopefully based
on your own studies and research. What about a prediction market where you're not investing in a company, you're investing in something's going to happen. That to me is a bet. Right. Uh now I here's the interesting thing. These prediction markets have found have generally been very good in predicting what's going to happen. Meaning, when people put their money where their mouth is, uh, we tend to get a much better outcome under a much better prediction
of what the outcome's going to be, whether it be an election or anything like that. But again, the problem comes in. If it's a bet, what about insider trading? In other words, let's say uh you're a justice or you're a court staff member and um you have information about the decision in the case that hasn't been published yet. Could you go to one of these prediction markets and lay a prediction wager that something is going
to happen? Sure you could. And that would be, you know, if if if you know that the court's going to decide things a certain way, you could go to the market and say, I want to bet a thousand dollars that that the court's gonna decide this case this way. And right now I don't think there are any laws that prevent that. Kind of depends on how you define a the prediction market. But there's but it's not just the prediction markets, right? So if you are a member a justice or a court staff member and
you're seeing a case involving say a large corporation and you know how the decision is going to come out, could you invest based on that? In other words, could you buy stock or short stock based on what's going to happen once the the decision is announced? Well technically, yeah, but that's considered insider trading in an investment market. Is if a prediction market is an investment
market, then that would also be insider trading. If it's a betting, well then insider trading is part of the gambling process, right? You have people who work with the horses and uh they they know when a horse is really on point, and maybe when they're running a little slow, and they either if they don't place the bets themselves, they tell people who place the bets. It's been part of gambling all along. Now, to me, the question is ethically, should people who work in government be
allowed to use these prediction markets on things that are impacted by government decisions? To me, that's an ethics violation. And of course, ethics rules for uh the court have been uh a bête noir over the last couple of decades, especially with those in the Democratic Party. Um the court, the the the Supreme Court adopted a code of ethics back in 2023, something they'd never done before. Of course, remember federal
judges serve during their good behavior, which means if the if the court I'm sorry, if the if the house doesn't think the justices are behaving good, they can impeach them. That's Article 3 uh section one, right? The judges of both the three courts serve during their good behavior. Who determines good behavior? Well, that would be the the House, the your the your representative, my representative. But again, it got to me to be an interesting question. Is there evidence
that um uh uh that that members of the court, either justice or their staff, have been using their insider trading for these websites because again, under U.S. law, apparently they're not considered gambling, but are they really investment because you're not buying anything, you're placing a wager, you're betting on something is going to happen. It's not like you're buying ownership stake in a company, you're uh that you're you're just
making a bet. So I think this is something that we're gonna people are gonna be discussing for quite a long time to come. Of course, something that has been cut uh a discussion for quite a long time. Are your rights under the Second Amendment, including uh not just your right to keep and bear arms, but does that right extend across state lines? Now, this comes up because the Liberty Justice Center filed a lawsuit back in 25 against the Minnesota Department of Public Safety and their commissioner Bob Jacobson, because the state
refuses to recognize out-of-state permits. There were two truckers that file that were part of this lawsuit. And uh this suit now they're requesting uh that it be heard by the Supreme Court. You see, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals held that your your Second Amendment rights are confined to the borders where you hold a permit, which again sounds irrational, but it's kind of what we've kind of used to for courts. Your right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Well, except we're going to infringe
them because you've got to get state permission, and that state permission is only valid within that state. And the they're basically saying that the states can write laws that supersede the Constitution of the United States. So uh this is another in a series of Second Amendment cases, major Second Amendment cases, that the court has been asked to hear in their upcoming term. Now, of course, I'm interested because, well, I've been a gun owner my entire adult life. Uh I've been a I've carried a
handgun for many, many, many years. And yes, I do sometimes cross state lines. In fact, I'm planning a trip uh in the near future, take care of some of my father's business back up in New York State. And one of the things that irks me is I'm not allowed to bring a firearm because New York State doesn't recognize any of my carry permits. And uh they're supposed to be able to issue me a permit um as an out-of-stater, but I haven't tried that because let's face it, I'm trying to avoid going back to the empire as much as humanly possible. So I find this interesting. Now again,
federal law allows you to transport um firearms across state lines as long as you're legal in your in your place of origin, your place of destination, but they must be uh they must be unloaded and locked where the driver where no the driver uh cannot access them, right? Which makes life really interesting, people with like SUVs where you don't have a separate trunk. But that's a whole nother a whole nother question here. And again, I remember when when I lived in New York, when I was moving out of New York, um I had to go through some machinations. I had to take my handguns out of
the state of New York and then go to the courts and say, I'm turning in my license. And of course, they well, where are your guns? They go, out of state. Well, where? Out of state. Well, we'd like to know. You don't need to know. They're out of state. I'm turning in my license. Um deal with it. And then I got a letter a few weeks later saying, A judge approved you. We're sitting giving up your license. I'm like, well, gee, that's nice. I really don't care. Go, you know, go pound sand. But again, here we have a New Yorker, a congressman, and a Supreme
Court justice walk into a bar. And I think in many places it does seem like a joke. It seems like people treat the Constitution as if it's a joke, as if it's not really important, as if it doesn't say what it actually says. And well, that's part of the reason I want us to read and study the Constitution so that we can defend our rights for ourselves when those we hire to secure our rights don't do their job. And as the declaration says, we have the right and the duty to alter or abolish governments that don't protect
our rights. But we have to understand what our rights are, we have to understand how they're protected. That's why I believe every member of the state ought diligently to read and study the constitution of this country, teach the rising generation to be free. Now, how do we do it? What do you do next? It's a question I'm asked all the time. And I understand why people ask the question. Well, most people don't realize is my answer, it depends. Because it really does. Uh have you read the constitution before? Why are you doing it? What are your goals? These
all factor into what I would recommend next. It's why I created the Constitution Study Wizard. Just go to Constitution Study.com/slash wizard. I do ask for your name and email address because I'm going to email you responses. Uh then I ask questions like, you know, well, when was the last time you read the Constitution? Have you read any other documents like the Federalist or Anti-Federalist papers or uh Washington's farewell address, stuff like that? Uh and then I ask, what are your goals? See, some people just want to know their rights, some people want to teach them, some people want
to run groups. Based on those answers, the system will generate emails with recommendations. Now, the wizard is free. Uh, many of the recommendations have free options. And oh, by the way, I read every entry, and if I see something unique, well, I'll I'll email you something special direct personally. But the point is, these are suggestions, these are recommendations. It's not like it's a rule. If you don't do this, you get in trouble. It's meant to give you ideas of things you may try, what you might try next. And uh it
I find a lot of people have said it's been very helpful. I think you'll find it as well. So please head to constitutionstudy.com slash wizard. Take the Constitution Study Planning Wizard, and uh let me know what you think. I I'm really curious if there's things that you think I should add or change about it. I also hope you come back and join us here for the Constitution Study on America. Heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern time. Now you can listen on our media player. We have Apple, Apple, Android, or Alexa, and of course, all the episodes
go to podcasts. Now, it does take a day or two for an episode to go from talk creative to podcast, but you get to listen to your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm show us to more people who will hopefully click the link and join us here for the Constitution Study. Speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news. But please, as with everything else, share those links, share this program, and help share the blessings
of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...