The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - The Heritage Foundation sent a letter to Congress and the U.S. Department of Education encouraging them to continue their efforts to “return education to the states.” However, looking at the letter, we learn that this is not the goal of the federal government. Meanwhile, an apparently failing school in Memphis, TN, was about to be taken over by...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study of the American Love Network with your host, Paul Engel. One of the greatest things about homeschooling our daughter were the myriad of opportunities we had to educate her without using textbooks. I want to look at some of those examples today
in the news. Hello there, everyday Americans. Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read instead of the Constitution. Teacherizing Generation be free. Glad you could join me. You know, as a father, I have certain memories of my daughter and these are like tip-top memories, memories that just mean more than anything else. Of course, one was the day she was born, and and you know, watching her as they had her in the little baby warmer once they cleaned her up and having her reach out and grab my little finger. I mean, that's
a memory that is just tremendous to me. One of the others is actually teaching my daughter fractions. Well, not so much the teaching of the fractions. See, I used to make a big family breakfast every Saturday morning. I do still do that quite frequently. And when she was little, she liked to help. Now, frequently I'd make pancakes. And I had a recipe for a large batch of bancase, it was much larger than we would actually eat. So we had to do a little bit of math on it. And it was great. You know, I had teachers, you know,
we'd we'd multiply things and divide things and add and subtract. And it was a great opportunity to say, well, okay, we need uh, you know, uh uh half a teaspoon of this, but we need to we want to do triple it. What does it mean? Or, you know, it says we need uh a cup and a half of that, and we want to divide it by three. What does that mean? We did this all the time, and it was just natural, it was just life, and it showed me just how easy it is to learn outside of the structured
educational system. This, of course, would later become important to me as I decided to read and study the Constitution and then begin teaching it to others. But um, I want to go back to this idea of education and what we can learn outside of the schoolroom that has tremendous impact on our lives. Uh, for example, uh a group of organizations have sent a letter to Congress to basically call for the closing of the U.S. Department of Education, but with a
twist. Now, the letter, which actually came from was sent by the the Heritage Foundation, um, to uh Senator Thune, Speaker of the House Johnson, um Chairman Cassidy uh and and Cassidy at Wahlberg, as well as Secretary of Education Linda McMahon, talks about the the closing. But he listen to the this this is this is some of the early content, and it deals with, you know, hey, look at you know, Chairman McMahon, you you've helped downsize
the the the the uh Department of Education, prefer for closing. They went on to say uh under the leadership of Chairman Wahlberg, the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Education and the Workforce approved a slated proposal that codify an interagency agreement agreement between the education department and other executive agencies. These agreements share responsibilities between the education department and other federal agencies, and the IAAs will allow for a deliberate, efficient transfer of viable federal education actions from the Department of Education to other offices.
All right, this is what's called a shell game, right? Because basically saying, listen, we don't want to shut down the Department of Education, but we don't want to stop what the Department of Education is doing. We want to transfer it to other agencies. There's a critical thing I want you to notice in this letter that the Heritage Foundation gets wrong. And I'll post a link to the letter on the show notes, but they say uh viable federal education actions. There's a problem. There is no such thing as a viable federal education action.
Remember the 10th Amendment. The powers not delegated to the United States by this Constitution, nor prohibited by to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people. There is nothing in the Constitution that delegates to the United States any education action. None whatsoever. Well, Paul, they have to oversee their funding. Well, Congress is not legally authorized to spend money on education because it's not authorized by the Constitution.
Not the countries, not the individuals, not the states, the United States. This entity, capital U, capital S, proper noun. So what the House of Representatives is planning to do, and what the Heritage Foundation is promoting is not the abolishing of the educate department's education so much as moving its powers to other agencies to continue the illegal, unconstitutional federal influence over education. Now, I I kind of understand where they're coming from. I just wish that they actually,
oh, I don't know, bothered to follow the constitution. See, it's interesting they talk about returning uh power to the states, but they're not really talking about returning the education to the states because they're talking about moving it to other agencies within the federal government. So they're they're they're they're opening line about what Ms. McCann is doing is returning education to states, but what they're trying to talk about is not actually returning the power to the states. If you want to return the powers of the states, it's real simple. You shut down
the department of it, you don't transfer its powers elsewhere, you shut it down. You no longer fund it. You realize that under the uh necessary and proper clause, right? Article 1, Section A, Clause 18, the that Congress has the power to make all laws necessary and proper to put into execution the powers vested in the government of the United States. Funding education, regulating education, these are not powers delegated or vested in the government of the United States.
It was never necessary nor proper for Congress to pass these laws. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is an education I think not only do we the people need, not only do our legislators need, but it's one that um, well, I think the people who at the Heritage Foundation and others who signed on to this letter, they need to learn as well. It's not simply good enough to shut down the agency but leave its powers in place elsewhere. That doesn't fix the problem. That, ladies and gentlemen, is a shell game. Now, simply
moving that power to the states is not a guarantee that things get fixed. Let's take a look here at Memphis, Tennessee, right? Memphis the Memphis Shelby County School uh system. Uh, that's the Memphis is in Shelby County, um, they they're a mess. Uh an audit of the uh MSCS by the Tennessee State Controller's Office identified $100 million in suspicious spending just earlier this year. And uh again, Tennessee passed a law that says
if a school district where at least 50% of the students are below grade level expectations by the Tennessee Comprehensive Access Assessment Program, and at least 30% of the schools receive a D or an F from the Tennessee Department of Education, then there can be an oversight board to take over the operation of the school. Now, the Memphis Shelby County Schools met those criteria, and the state established an oversight board to oversee the
school district to help bring it up to standards. Well, they were supposed to have their meeting, their first meeting uh back in October, but that was blocked by a county judge, a county chancellor uh in in Shelby County, who um literally just minutes before the oversight board was supposed to meet, um said no. Uh they they they argued the plaintiffs, uh school district that they that they did not meet the law's qualifications for a takeover, and
that um the district would receive irreparable harm should the oversight board meet. Now, as I understand, this is actually the second order issued by Chancellor uh Joe Day L. Jenkins. Um, the first was overturned, of all things, by a U.S. district court. Uh, district court judge Waverly Crenshaw dissolved his order, which again, I'm trying to figure out where the U.S. District Court gets jurisdiction over this. What is the what is the challenge to constitution to
the U.S. Constitution under this? What is a challenge under U.S. law? Remembering that any U.S. law involving education is unconstitutional, therefore null and void. Now, I okay, if there, uh if the allegation is that the MSCS does not meet that criteria, right? 50% below expectation grade level on the TCAP, um, a D or an F from the Department of Education. Um, I also think there's something that they have to have uh 25% of their student body chronically
absent. All right. These are do they not meet that criteria? If that's the case, let's have the hearing. The I'm trying to figure out what irreparable harm MSCS would receive from the oversight board meeting. All right, not what the oversight board may order. They're not even they said you're not even allowed to meet. And I'm still wondering where uh the Tennessee courts, because this is a county court that did this, where are the Tennessee state courts in all of this? And let's get to the bottom, let's get to the bottom of
all this, these questions about um education. And if the state's going to oversee it, then the state should oversee it. Now, I understand uh local school boards can just as easily infringe on our rights as state and federal laws. We have to, we want to oversee them. And if you have a failing school, bad enough we're being taxed for that failing school, then the people who are paying the tax, they have a right to say, if you're not doing the job, we'll
bring in someone who will fix it. These are public entities, they are funded by public tax dollars, they are created under public uh uh rights of power. These are public entities, they should be held accountable to the public. But the question I have is you know, uh is if the if the state is funding this, then where's this where's the oversight? And is this a question of an overreach by the state? In other words,
maybe MCSC is bad, but not quite bad enough to trigger the law to create the oversight board. Um or to at least uh have the the review of the oversight. If that's the case, then why can't why has that evidence not been provided? Or is that something that will be heard in the court case that we're not getting to because everyone's playing games with these stupid uh injunctions about whether or not the board meets. We're not saying the board has done anything. I'm still trying to figure out what is the
the irreparable harm the school board has if the board even meets to discuss the situation in Shelby County. So you see, returning education to the states doesn't automatically fix the problem, right? The people who are electing the school board in the in the Memphis Shelby County schools, they have a responsibility to oversee the people that uh that are there. And the people in the state of Tennessee, because it's run by a state power, again, this is a state agency
and it is a power properly delegated to the state. We have to say, all right, guys, what are you doing here? You pass this law. Um, have you shown that that uh MSCS meets the criteria? Yes. In which case, why is a county chancellor allowed to overrule state law um without, again, any real evidence? Now maybe there's it more information. I agree. I mean, maybe there's more information here.
Um, but it does seem to be you have a county official who's not happy that their failing state, their failing school has been found out and is going to be held accountable and is attempting to block the the process of fixing the schools or overseeing the schools with an attempt to fix the schools so that students who go to these schools actually get, oh, I don't know, an education. I'm reminded of a discussion I had uh with a candidate a few months ago. Uh
this candidate worked in our county school system, and um he pointed out that uh our county spends less per student than any other school in our region. And my question was, well, why are we focusing? Why is the measure of the quality of the school the amount of money we spend per student? Why should it not be something a bit more practicable? Something more practical. How about the percentage of our students that graduate that are literate in reading, writing, math, and civics? To me, that's how you judge
a school. And if I can educate, if our county can educate students and graduate students that are literate in reading, writing, math, and civics for less money than any other county in the region, that's a good thing. That's something we should be shouting from the rooftops. Look at how good we're doing this. Come learn from us. Education is important. And I think too often education today focuses on money and not on outcomes, not on the actual students we're supposed to be educating. And uh
whether it's done at the federal level or at the state level, we still run under the same problem. It's still up to we the people to recognize it is our jobs as parents, it is our job to educate our children, and schools are there to assist us. It is our job as parents to educate our children. Schools, be they be public or private, are there to assist us. And if they are incapable of assisting us, why in heaven's name do we keep sending our
most precious resource, our children, to schools that are abject failures probably because we've been taught that that's the only way to do it? Well, that's not true, and that is the type of education, ladies and gentlemen, we need. And it's exactly a type of education that I try to bring here at the Constitution Study. Now, before I get into some more uh topics, I I have a break coming up. And let me give you a little bit of education, right? Um, sleep is important to good health,
right? Thankfully, I generally sleep pretty well. Um, occasionally, though, I have problems falling asleep. We all do. We have those days where the mind just doesn't want to shut down and we have a hard time falling asleep. Now, I know a lot of people reach for hormones like melatonin, and they often work, but they also can disrupt your sleep wake cycles if you take them too frequently. Same thing with pharmaceuticals, right? They build up a tolerance, and eventually you need more and more just to fall asleep. You end up with a dependency. Now, when I need help
falling asleep, I reach for restful sleep. Why? Because it uses natural ingredients to calm the mind and reduce stress for a better, more restful night's sleep without hormones or pharmaceuticals. Now, I'm not a doctor, I don't play one on TV, but when I look at the ingredient lists and I see chamomile and valerian root and other things that have been used for generations to help calm people and help them fall asleep, well, it makes sense to me. Find out more, go to AmericaOutloud.shop and click on the restful sleep panel. Oh, by the
way, if you use the code OutLoud at checkout, you'll get 20% off of your order. So if you're looking for a way to help you fall asleep based on documented research vetted by the chief medical board of the wellness company, without using hormones or pharmaceuticals, but just natural ingredients to help calm you down and get a more restful night's sleep. I recommend RESTful Sleep from the Wellness Company. Find out more, go to AmericaOutloud.shop, click on the RESTful sleep panel, do your own research, be that informed consumer, and then give it a try. And
when you do, don't forget, use the code Out Loud to get 20% off of your order. 20% off and a good night's sleep sounds like a pretty good deal to me. Have you been feeling off since COVID? Are you struggling with lingering symptoms? You're not alone. As Dr. Peter McCullough says, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Introducing
the wellness company Spike Detox Trio. This powerful supplement combines nanokinase, bromaline, and turmeric to support your immune system and fight off harmful spike proteins. Nanokinase improves circulation, while bromaline boosts antiviral defenses and turmeric reduces inflammation. It's not just another supplement, it's a scientifically backed solution to help you bounce back from COVID. Imagine waking up filled with energy, feeling clear-headed and vibrant again. It's possible with Spike Detox Trio. Reclaim your
health now by visiting tvc.health slash out loud and use promo code OutLoud for 20% off your first order right now. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the go but although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Bear bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contains six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most
energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together with syrups or sweeteners. But bear bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud. Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, are you ready? Because your nose is about to win it's the biggest breathing break through.
Well, education doesn't always happen in schools. It's a good thing because we try to do a lot of education here, education on the Constitution, what it actually says and what uh what it actually means. Uh I I found this story in, I wasn't quite sure where to put it, but I figured I'd throw it in here. Uh Huba remembers back in 2022 the the Dobbs decision, the decision that overturned Roe v. Wade. Who remembers the fact that the draft opinion was released, leaked actually,
some two months before the decision was actually published. Anybody remember that? And remember the calls investigation, we got to see who did this. And that was 2022. It was four years ago. Now, the court did its own little internal query, and well, they they never publicly identified a single leaker. Um last year, the FBI, an FBI official, said that the Justice Department was exploring the issue. Why? Well, now we find
out that prosecutors are pursuing a criminal case, which again is news to a lot a lot of people. Apparently, the investigation ramped up in recent weeks as prosecutors sent grand jury subpoenas for testimony and sought information from people who worked at the court at the time of the leaks. Um, this is according to people familiar with the inquiry. In other words, more leaked information about a case about leaked information. Yeah. Now, what does this mean? Well, a grand jury, the fact that
a grand jury has been impaneled and that they are seeking testimony for the grand jury leads me to believe that they have at least a suspect that um that that that they're trying. I mean, you don't can yes, a grand jury can is an investigatory tool. We think of grand juries as far as uh felony indictments, but it's also an investigator, an investigatory tool. Um it's a way of getting on the record testimony, which again leads me to believe that they've got somebody, they've got a
clue. And then now some four years later, and since it's a they're they've impanced a grand jury, they're I'm assuming they're they're considering charges. They're gonna ask the grand jury for an indictment, which means it's a it's a felony charge, not uh a simple misdemeanor. So here we are four years later, we might actually get somebody who's accused of actually leaking this data. Now, educational point here. Um there's been a lot of talk about how
to deal with that particular leak. What charges could be brought? What federal laws could have been violated by the leaker? And uh other people were concerned about the separation of powers. This is something the court should have dealt with internally. But again, the court is not the executive branch, the court doesn't bring charges, the court decides controversies, right? So there's a the there's a lot of of questionable information about that. Personally, uh, I'd be interesting to see the
grand jury testimony is is private. Um, I'll be curious to find if an indictment is released and what the facts and data in on the indictment, because the indictment would lead to an arrest warrant. An arrest warrant must have be based on probable cause supported by author affirmation. So there's going to be data there. We'll have to wait and see. But here we are, four years later, and maybe finally someone's looking to be held accountable for this leak of the the uh of the thing, which is again it's a breach of confidentiality. I'm just curious
what laws were allegedly broken. Uh, let me switch gears now to well, let's just call it the bête noir of certain people in this country, and that's the Federal Reserve. The recent story has to do, and again, this has been going on for two years now, um, about the Federal Reserve and interest rates. And you know, some people want the interest rates lowered, some people want them to stay the same, some people may even want them raised, and it's now it's become a political fight about the federal funds rate, which is controlled by the
Federal Reserve. Couple problems with this. Now, Congress, under Article 1, Section 8, has the power to coin money and regulate its value. It says nothing about regulating interest rates. This is part of my problem with the Federal Reserve, is Congress created this quasi-independent agency and said, you are going to be the nation's banker. You are when we print money, you're gonna be the ones that that uh uh bring
it into circulation. Um, you can do it by lending money to banks. That's the the uh federal funds rate. And uh by doing so, you get to have uh an impact on the economy. They're supposed to have this dual mandate, which is it's it's an oxymoron. This is this is true cognitive dissonance because their mandate is to encourage business while controlling inflation. And in other words, they're they're saying, listen, uh lower interest rates, because that includes that that
entices business, but raise interest rates to keep inflation at 2%, which means your money's being if the Federal Reserve is doing its job, your money is being devalued 2% every year based on their policies, right? This, ladies and gentlemen, is the antithesis of a free market. You have a government-created entity with powers that are, I'm not even sure, questionable. I mean, again, we're in the Constitution the federal government authorized to create a national bank, uh, a central
bank, and to let it make money by lending out the money that Congress can print money, right? They can make coins, they can make bills. That's not in question. It's this bank that they're trying to use to regulate the economy, which by the way, they've generally done a pretty piss poor job at, I would say. I mean, I'm not even talking about this latest news about the the rates. And of course, there's been an argument between Donald Trump and the Federal Reserve about the rates. Uh, but it's this whole idea that we can manage the economy,
we can regulate the economy, the the actions of 330 million people with a small board of governors that apparently they think no more than than 330 million Americans. What they generally do is they try to fix the previous problem. Right? Because remember, the the Federal Reserve was part of the entire um uh was the whole the whole uh mortgage meltdown because of interest rates that they try to keep down. And
it's inflation. Every time you complain about high prices, well, that's Congress trying to regulate that through the Federal Reserve, through their what that's called their open market committee. This is a monopoly created by the federal government without constitutional authority that literally regulates every aspect of your life. Because even if you don't pay interest, even if you have zero loans, no credit card debt, think of the businesses that do business that are impacted by these interest rates and the
impact they have on our economy as a whole. Just think of what that's teaching the American people, that your economic prosperity is not solely based on your work and what you do, but it's based on the decision of these quote-unquote governors of the uh open market committee, these Federal Reserve uh uh activists that say, oh no, we know better than you. We're gonna do this. Things, things, you know. Um, we're going to devalue the dollar. Our goal is to devalue the dollar by two to three percent
every year to make your dollar worth less every. That is their mandate. That is one of their mandates, is to devalue the dollar, to have inflation at 2%. And again, without a constitutional authority to do so. Yes, Congress created them by statute, but again, Congress can only make laws that are necessary and proper to put into effect powers vested in the government of the United States. Regulating interest rates is not a power vested in the government of the United States. Congress
can print money, they can regulate the value of that money, but not the interest rates. And the very fact that they've been doing this for so for so many decades, and we see the problems that have been made. Now, yes, sometimes the Federal Reserve, what they've done, has helped fix problems, but they always seem to be lagging behind what's actually going on. And um, meaning we got months of pain before they start fixing generally the mess that they had made. Now, I want
to contrast that, I want to bring an example of actual market forces at work. What happens when um you know we have a market that gets to decide? We're gonna head to Minneapolis, where a restaurant owner, who by the way, uh apparently uh is known for hating ice and thinks that socialism is the answer, at least that's what it appears. He he could he created a restaurant with an interesting concept. You see, the owner uh
temporarily renamed his cafe The Postmodern Times and announced that customers could eat for free or leave whatever donation they wanted. Now, again, as a charity, that sounds I got no problem with that. All right, this is not a business, this is a charity. If you're eating food, if you're offering food for free, you are a charity. But there's a simple thing that pretty much every restaurant owner should know. In fact, every household should know. Um, food isn't free. Somebody has to
pay for the food. Now, if you're going to buy the food, cook the food, pay for your where wherever your resident is, and pay people to actually cook and serve the food for you, you've got to have some money coming in to pay for all that, right? Now, the other twist of this was again, everybody was welcome except ice agents. Well, again, it's a private entity. He is well within his rights to say, I don't want ice agents at my restaurant. There's nothing illegal about that. There's nothing illegal about um
about not charging for food, uh about request accepting donations. None of that is illegal. Is it smart? I mean, this is supposed to be some bold demonstration against the federal government, uh, proving that kindness and community could triumph over the the evils of capitalism, as they call it. Well, guess what happened? This communist experiment failed. The restaurant is not closed for good. You see, when they first did this, when they
first announced that the the the free food, they got a lot of attention and a lot of people showed up, and well, people were willing to donate, but it didn't take very long for word about free meals becoming widely known. And as the word spread, so did the crowds. And the neighborhood got a whole new set of problems. So instead of a charming little community gathering spot, the restaurant was surrounded by homeless people, uh drug addicts, people looking for
freebies, some of them actually being aggressive about looking for donations, which drove the paying customers away who they didn't want to deal with this. So, with all the expenses going out and fewer and fewer donations coming in, well, it didn't take too long before it just fell apart, which to me is an educational lesson. This is an opportunity to realize that again, if you want to be a a charity, you have you still have to have funding
to pay for what you're giving away. Right? That's that that that doesn't change simply because you're trying to be kind, you're trying to be nice. Someone still has to pay the bills. And um saying, hey, um the people who when your actions drive away the people that pay the bills, well, then you don't have bills getting paid and things fail. Now here's the educational lesson. This
is socialism, and this is the socialism going from theory to fact. The theory behind this move is that, well, the people who can pay will pay, and the people who can't pay won't pay, and the two will even out from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs. It's a perfect Marxist uh utopian th theory, it just doesn't work in the real world. So here's the opportunity to learn. There's a reason why soup kitchens and other
charities tend to end up in the less nice pla neighborhoods in most cities, because that's where the people who need help are. And if you put the restaurant somewhere else, you're going to simply move the the the the the move those people from where they are to where your restaurant is. Now, I have no problem. If this gentleman wants to go in and wanted to go in and do this, he just didn't think through the funding. He thought that magically people keep showing up as his actions, or more accurately, the
actions of his target demographic drove them away. Great operat learning opportunity, not just for this cafe owner, but for all Americans. There's a great uh we tend to be generous people, and there are great ways to be generous, but you still have to deal with reality. Somebody still has to buy the food, someone still has to pay the employees, someone has to pay the rent and the taxes. Where's that money coming from? Now I would encourage, I probably would say
I disagree with uh this owner, Mr. Alverson, on a lot of things, but I'd recommend I say, hey, your idea you had a nice thought, but you had flaws. Can you learn from that? Maybe set up two cafes, right? One cafe where the food is free and uh or you pay with a with a donation, or maybe with work. Ooh, that would have been interesting. You know, you come in, you work uh 15 minutes, and you get a hamburger. Whatever. You find a
way to keep things going, to put some consequences in that, and then a second restaurant where you say, Listen, uh, here's your bill, and we're automatically going to tag on 20% that will be donated to the other restaurant. You could have done that, but this socialist communist Marxist idea that from each according to his knees to each it's just another example where it doesn't work. And thankfully, this one didn't involve the death of tens of millions of people, as
we've seen in the Soviet Union and communist China and other places. But that's also a good education for we the people. Who do you do business with? I I used to say back when you know COVID was running rampant and they were trying to shut places down. I would have said, you know, I would look for a restaurant. I was traveling a lot at the time, and I would look for restaurants. I'm looking for a good one with a sign that says your rights matter. You know, no, no masks, no shots, no problem. And I never saw it. I never found a
restaurant that advertised. I'm looking for companies to do business with that are willing to protect people's rights. There is a company I have found, Patriot Mobile. I joined them years ago, not because they're America's only Chris and Conservative Waters provided, though they are, not because they're great 4G and 5G coverage and all the same networks and towers as major carriers. Nope. Not even because their customer service is 100% US based. No. I joined Patriot Mobile because they share my values and they put their money where their mouth is. They take
a portion of every dollar to support organizations fighting for your rights, your freedom of religion, speech, and press, your right to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures, to not be deprived of due process. They also fight support organizations that are fighting for the sanctity of life, our veterans and our first responders. Those are all things I could get behind, and I was happy to be a customer. I was so happy I became an affiliate. Which means if you switch to Patriot Mobile today and use the code Constitution, you'll get free activation. Just go to patriotmobile.com says
constitution and find a plan that works for you. By the way, are you one of those veterans, first responders, or members of one of those groups? You could be eligible for a discount. Even families with multiple lines are eligible for discounts. Find out more by going to patriotmobile.com slash constitution. Find a plan that works for you. See what discounts you're eligible for, and don't forget, use that code Constitution at checkout to get your new line activated absolutely free. Don't support businesses that are promoting organizations that are turning us into a Marxist dystopia. Join us here at Patriot
Mobile and help fight for the rights of all Americans by going to patriotmobile.com slash constitution. Find a plan and discount. Don't forget, use that code CONSTTOUNT at checkout to get free activation. Now I also hope you'll join us at AmericaOutloud.news. I go there each and every day for news and information. Why? Well, information's at our fingertips. We have all these different sources of news. Where do you go? Do you trust where they go? Can you verify that what they're saying is true? For me, one of those places I go to is AmericaOutloud.news. But I want you to do more.
Do like I do. Yes, read the stories, read the articles, then share them. Friends, family, neighbors, civic groups, listen to a podcast, watch a video, and then share that as well. Social media is a great place to share that. See, it's the sharing of that news, the sharing of the information that others may not want us to hear that helped secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. During treatment, City Tap water molecule structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb
it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com
forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book, and I've devoted my life to helping people reconnect with food at its most alive stage, the sprout. When you germinate a seed, you're not just growing food, you're activating potential. Sprouts grow without soil, sunshine, or fertilizer right on your kitchen countertop. They're organic, fresh, and cost
less than a dollar a serving. It's nature's fastest form of farming, accessible to anyone, anywhere. Discover the joy of growing your own food and the power of living nutrition. Visit thesproutingcompany.com and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides that help repair and restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue,
which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root cause literally. Visit twc.health forward slash outlout and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair regrowth with roots. Welcome back, everybody.
The opportunity to learn. And you know, learning is something we should never stop doing. I don't care how old you are, we should always continue learning. And sometimes we have to learn that our theories sound great until they're put into practice and they just don't work. Perfect example, gun-free zones. Because gun-free zones are not gun-free zones. There are guns there. Sometimes they're law enforcement, sometimes they're criminals, sometimes they're law, otherwise law-abiding citizens who just want to protect themselves against
evil that the gun-free zones pretend that doesn't happen. And a great place is New York City. In fact, not just New York City, the subway platforms. Now, I I lived in New York City as a child. Years ago, I had customers. I used to go to New York City on business frequently. So I'm fairly familiar with the platform. And again, I've ridden the subways, used to do it all the time. Um, and uh again, New York City, even though I had a carry permit in New York State, it was not valid in the five boroughs of New York City.
And even if you could get one for the five boroughs, you're not allowed to carry one on the subway platforms because magically there's no crime on the on the uh subway platforms, right? Except recently, uh a man was shot uh during an attempted robbery on a subway subway platform in the Bronx. Uh, according to this police, a young man, uh well, 25, young for me, he was standing on a subway platform when two of
the individuals approached him demanding his stuff. And after a struggle, they one of those two gentlemen shot the young man and um both of them ran away. So this alleged gun-free zone, this gun-free subway platform was not gun-free because somebody got shot. And guess what? It was a criminal. Now, I don't live in New York anymore. I live in Tennessee. And in Tennessee, a lot of places they got no problem with you walk around with the guns. In fact,
Tennessee, you're allowed to carry openly. Uh, we don't have subways here. Um, but again, you know, you can carry. But there are businesses that do not want guns on the premises. And they put a little sign out front with the little silhouette in the red circle and slash. And in Tennessee, it's committed considered a crime to walk to arm walk past that sign armed. Uh personally, I think that's going a bit too far. I'd like to just call it trespassing, but okay. Uh but the point is, this idea of a gun-free zone is not true. There are
no gun-free zones because criminals look at this thing, hey, I know that if I come in armed, I don't have to worry about somebody shooting back at me. And of course, the the question is, this this this young man on the subway platform, oh, what if he had been armed? What if he'd been allowed to carry a firearm in self-defense? What if when these guys approached him trying to demand his stuff, he was able to demonstrate his ability to defend himself with a firearm? Would things have been different? What about a
knife? What about pepper spray? What about a baton? What if he had been had had had had the opportunity to defend himself? Now he was shot. He he was injured, shot in the leg, he was injured, he wasn't killed. But really, what is the long-term impact? Can we learn that gun-free zones are not gun-free zones? And can we also learn that when you prohibit people from defending themselves, you take on the responsibility of defending them? Meaning, I hope this man
sues the city of New York for not defending him when they will not allow him to defend himself. Now compare that to a bank employee in Florida. See, apparently, a a there was a disgruntled customer. Um he apparently had a delinquent credit card bill. He was upset. He decided to go into a bank and uh he wanted to hunt down workers because he was angry over his his credit card bill. Now, the employee,
some people refer to him as a security guard, but I'm not sure that he is. I don't think he is, because apparently the bank, Citibank, has a rule for its employees. It's a if you were former law enforcement, if you have law enforcement or military training, you can carry concealed within the bank. Now, again, this is Citibank. This is a privately owned company. Even they're open, though they're open to the pump. They have a right to control who has access to their property and to who can carry on their property. And they're decided, listen, if
you've had law enforcement or military training, you're allowed to conceal carry on the uh on the bank property as an employee. This gentleman apparently was a marine veteran, so he was allowed to carry at on the bank. When this person came in with a firearm, uh, a rifle in this uh semi-automatic rifle, uh, I believe he did take one life, but the um the bank employee heard the shots, he came out
armed. It's actually video of the uh encounter, and uh he shot and disabled the the uh the gunman, but this happened because someone was allowed to carry a firearm on the property, and um that to me, that's a big deal, right? This is proof that Citibank says we generally want our places to be, as employees are concerned, gun-free zones. I don't know what their rules are about customers, right? If that were the case, I wouldn't do
business with Citibank, right? I don't uh I'm I don't want to be the victim because some bank thinks I don't have the right to defend myself. But again, we see here's a person with a gun threatening it. Here's another person with a gun that's saving the day. The problem is not the gun, the problem is the person wielding the gun. The only difference between these two sit the this two situations is one place a person was allowed to have
a gun and use it to defend himself and others. The other place the person was not allowed to have a gun. Now we don't know. He may not like guns, he may not carry gun outside, he didn't have the opportunity. But again, one case, thankfully, um you know, in in the guy in New York didn't die. One person died in the bank in Florida, but the the assailant was stopped. And he was stopped with a good guy with a gun. But let's learn something else because everyone focuses on the gun,
even though you got two people, you got two situations with guns, you've got a scenario where one person's unarmed, one person is armed, and they're able to defend themselves, but everyone focuses on this inanimate object, not the person wielding the inanimate object. Case important, the point. This is about uh almost a month ago, I think. Did you hear about the uh the the attack in in in Wichita, Kansas, where a woman drove her her pickup truck onto a
soccer field during uh while while kids were playing on the field. Right? It was a weekend youth game in Kansas. She drove her truck onto the field, she killed two people and injured ten others. And not a I don't even think there was a firearm in sight. She used a pickup truck. And again, this isn't uh an isolated. There have been other examples of people using cars. Uh, there was one back last Christmas of people using vehicles to commit mass murder. Uh it's a vehicle, it's a
car, something most of us use just about every day of our lives, and they can be used because the problem isn't the inanimate object, it is the person wielding or operating the inanimate object. Now, I'm not I'm not sure the disposition of this case. I know that uh she was released while they did uh tests on some uh toxicology tests on her blood. Uh they did a mechanical examination of the vehicle trying to determine uh what happened, right? Did something go wrong? Was this
lady intoxicated or on drugs? Why did this vehicle end up on that is all very pertinent and to the case. To me, the educational opportunity is to recognize that that pickup truck would not have hurt a single person without somebody behind the wheel. The same way that firearm in Florida would have hurt absolutely nobody without somebody wielding it. Or on the subway platform in New York
City. The the opportunity for education is everywhere, and sometimes it comes at our expense, sometimes it comes at the expense of others. But I want you to see these as opportunities to look at things and and learn from what happens. The same way I want you to learn from the experience of the the restaurant owner in in Minneapolis. He had a theory, and he, for whatever reason, he tested his theory. Now he he may have tested because he was mad at Donald Trump or he was mad at ICE, whatever
it was, he had a theory and he tested it. And a lot of people say, well, that test failed. No, no, no. The test worked, it proved that socialism still doesn't work, that a socialist experiment doesn't work, and um maybe people can learn from it. He as he should have learned from it. The same way we should have learned the experiment in a central government and letting the federal government try to regulate interest rates was a failed experiment. It has caused a lot of problems. It's yes, there's been some good from it,
but I think if we look at the test of time, there's been a lot more damage done by the Federal Reserve than good done by the Federal Reserve. And now when they want uh um was a central bank digital money, they want to control not just interest rates, they want to control your money. I don't know that I'd put my trust in those hands. They've kind of shown to be a bit of a problem. The same way the experiment in federal regulation and funding of education has been an abject failure. Since what, 1976, I think the Federal Department of
Education was created. Ever since then, our test scores compared to the rest of the world have gone down. Because the question of our education is not a function of money, or not solely a function of money. Yes, you need money to run schools, you need money to pay teachers, uh, you need money to buy textbooks, absolutely. But it's not a function of money. It's a function, uh, it should be uh measured by money, it should be measured by outcome. And this experiment in fairly funded
education has been an abject failure because our students who cannot read and write or do basic math is growing. And when a state comes in and says, Hey, you're failed, you're a failing school. We're gonna come in and bring some oversight to bring you back into a good school. The judges say, No, no, no, you can't do that. We're not gonna we're gonna push back and help and try to prevent that. What do you see? That uh government-run schools are always gonna have
politics behind them. It's all it's a function of government. They're gonna have policy. So that experiment of federal-run schools is a disaster. Uh, state-run schools is somewhat better, but still shows a lot of problems, which means we the people, I think, have to come back to our education and look at the opportunities. Okay, maybe you can't afford to send your child to a private school, or you don't have the opportunity to homeschool. You're using public schools. That doesn't absolve you of the responsibility of educating your children.
That's the other thing we have to learn. We still have that responsibility, and there are plenty of opportunities in life to educate our children if we'll simply take that responsibility seriously. And you know what? It really starts by educating ourselves. Imagine you know, the a family where the parent, again, I'm not saying it's easy. Um sometimes it's gonna be really hard, but I think it's worth it to put in the time to educate our children. And maybe it's up to the rest of
us to help those struggling to educate their children by freeing up time for them to do so, and maybe giving them uh uh access to resources that will help educate, maybe where they're not really good at educating. I know some people they're really bad at English, at grammar, but maybe good at math, or vice versa, maybe great at grammar, bad at math. Let's find opportunities to help. Because every time we've handed off this idea of education to some school, well, I shouldn't say every time. I think
it's when the parents gave up responsibility. We've watched those schools not teach our children to be free, not teach the rising generation to be free, but to teach the rising generation to be serfs, to be subjects, to be slaves, to be led and governed by government. And uh that, ladies and gentlemen, is the antithesis of teaching the rising generation to be free. Now, if you want to find out more, uh please head to the website, constitutionstudy.com. I've
got not only these episodes, I've got articles I've written, I've got videos, I've got news feeds, I've got lots of content there, but I'm hoping you'll help. You see, nobody here at the Constitution Study takes a salary, nobody here gets paid. We pay for all of this. So it's very helpful if you go to constitutionstudy.com slash shop and you purchase something. Purchase a book, purchase a mug or a t-shirt, or hey, just donate to the cause. Because all the proceeds do one of two things. They help fund the Constitution Study. Yes. That means we can put on
this radio program. I continue with the articles and the videos and other content, but it also helps me bring this message to other groups without charging them for it. I get invited to speak at places and very often, you know, a lot of places you you to you have to pay to get a speaker. If I can go there, especially if you're putting on a free event, and I don't have to charge you, then I think that's something worth worth it's valuable. But I can only do that when people like you purchase products or donate to the Constitution
Study. So again, please head to Constitution Study.com slash shop and uh purchase a t-shirt, purchase a book, donate to the cause. Know that it is going to help educate not just the rising generation, but our current generation to know the constitution and how to defend and assert their rights. In other words, how to live free. I also hope you'll come back and join us here for the Constitution study on America Out Loud Talk Radio heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern Time. Now you can listen on
our media player. We've also got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, all of my episodes go to podcasts generally a day or two after they're heard on Talk Radio, which means you get to listen to your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. Both of those help the algorithm show us to more people. They see the links, they're more likely to click the links and join us here for the Constitution study. Speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news. But please
share those links. Share this program. By doing so, we're also helping to share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...