Can a 240-year-old Constitution protect your digital privacy?
57 minAudio
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - How do we protect our rights from big-tech abuses? Is it a form of union, or must we be willing to give up the latest thing to protect our rights? What about those Automatic License Plate Readers? Can we defend our rights from the abuses of this technology? And really, is it the technology that’s the problem, or the public servants we hire that abuse it?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study of the American Love Network with your host, Paul Langley. The Constitution was written before the internet existed. How do we protect our rights in a world where your papers are ones and zeros flying across ether? Hello there, everyday Americans,
Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacherizing generation be free. Glad you could join me today. Yeah, I've talked about this before. Remember, I spent 30 years working in IT. I spent 30 years working with ones and zeros. And as I study the Constitution, one of the things I see quite frequently gets kind of caught up in this question are the definition of uh papers and effects. You know, the Fourth Amendment, your right to be secure from unreasonable searches, uh, and your persons, houses, paper and effects from unreasonable searches. Now, person and
houses, those are pretty simple. But the papers and effects, how much of you don't deal with paper anymore? How many of your documents are now binary? They're digital files. And where are they? Are they on your hard drive? Are they in a cloud somewhere? Do you storm with somebody else? That to me brings up uh some interesting questions. And I think some minor tweaks to the constitution could be very helpful in resolving some of these issues. But I think we can still recognize our rights and how they are to
be protected in a digital world. Now, what brought this to my attention was an article uh I saw called New Study Proposes Creation of Data Rights Associations to Counteract AI abuses. Uh according to the report, uh, this was actually an article done by Elizabeth Troutman Mitchell. She said, uh AI threatens to disempower American families and communities in large part because those bedrock institutions lack a voice in shaping AI's course of development and its governance.
Consequently, the incentives of tech corporations are often fundamental, out fundamentally out of step with those. Okay, uh I see a lot of fear about AI. And I I kind of understand it because a lot of people they they they fear don't don't understand, and very often people prey on that and and intentionally or unintentionally kind of have this view of or promote this view of AI as something fundamentally dangerous. First of all,
recognize AI is a bit of a misnomer. It's not artificial intelligence, it's imitation intelligence. The most famous quote-unquote AI test, it's called the Turing test, which is can a computer imitate a human being well enough that a human being can't tell the difference? That's the foundation of the Turing test. Now, again, AI has some really powerful tools. Um, AI, as most people use it, is primarily it's a language interface, right? You think Star
Trek, right? Where you simply talk to the computer and the computer answers. That's a lot of when people talk about AI, that's what they're really dealing with. It's a large language model that you talk to or you type, it interprets your words and then goes and does something for you. In other words, rather than going to a search engine and saying, uh, find this information for me, you simply ask the computer, computer, you know, answer this question, and it turns your words into actions. It goes out and does a search and then returns it. I mean, that's that's what most of it is. Now, there are other
things that that AI can do because of its speed. For example, we talk about, and I'll talk a bit about flock cameras and the ability to recognize license plates. It's been trained to pick out the letters and numbers of a license plate. And uh it can do that very, very fast and it can store that data. And of course, that data becomes easily searchable. Where the problem comes in is what do we do with this? And everyone's terrified of AI. To me, what terrifies me about
AI is not AI, it's people's blind acceptance of what AI says. Now, this report says that as a result, individuals, households, civil society, institutions, and small enterprises should be able to join or form new intermediaries called data rights associations to secure terms governing data collection and use from tech corporations, the institute are according to the institute. I'm trying to figure out because first of all, the the the article doesn't link to the report, and nothing in the article describes
what are these data rights associations are talking about and how are they supposed to govern data collection? Because if you create a data rights association, what legal power does it have to actually do anything? Is this just more again, fear marker? Oh, I'll I'll join an association. Okay, what's that association gonna do? Let's say you and I decide we're gonna create a digital rights association, we're gonna write up rules governing data collection.
How do we enforce that? How do we actually stand against anything happening? And again, there are methods, right? We have we have governments, they can create laws within the sphere of their powers. We have courts where we can get uh uh redresses, uh uh we can get redress to our grievances. But I I see this this reaction, that this this uh fear of AI driving people to a lot of strange things. Now, maybe these uh data
cent these data rights associations, maybe they've got a point. Maybe this I haven't seen it because it's not in the article. My guess is it probably not. Probably this is just a uh we'll just create another guild and it won't let it do anything. I'm not entirely sure how this is supposed to level the playing field between a digital rights association and say Anthropic or Google or Microsoft. But I wonder how many people are gonna go running
for these digital rights associations simply because, well, there's a report that says it'll save protect my rights. Really? How? Now again, I talked about Flock, and Flock is getting a lot of pushback. Now, Flock is not the only manufacturer of automatic license plate readers. Um, they are, I think, one of the largest, but they've got they have quite a few. Uh, according to uh one study, there's there's uh over 120,000 Flock cameras across the nation. And uh, in
fact, there you can even find maps where you can see where they all are. But uh, and again, people get very upset about being photographed in public. Well, again, understand that you have no expectation of privacy in public. What you do in public, people are going to see. If people can see it, they can record it. The same thing with a flock camera, the same reason, the same way police officers can wear body cams and you can take pictures of your kids running through the park and pick up
other people while you're doing so. The the the collection of the data uh you know, you don't have a right to not be photographed in public, I guess the best way I can put it. To me, the problem is how these images are being used. Because flat cameras no longer are just looking at license plates, they're categorized, they're actually scanning vehicles, make, model, color, bumper stickers, uh, damage. In other words, they're they're they're they're not simply keeping
a record that they can search if they need it, they're taking a record and they're building an entire database of information about people. Now, again, if you're the victim of, say, a crime and this camera will help find the criminal, that's a great thing. But we have to remember in a digital world, our rights don't disappear simply because they're in ones and zeros, not physical paper. So to me, the issue is less the
photo the photography, it's more how is that data accessed. We've seen multiple instances of law enforcement officers uh reprimanded, some of them even criminally charged, for abusing their access to this data, right? Or having the the flock camera spit out an analysis and unreasonably seizing people because some tool spit out some data
and never actually vetting it to see was it accurate. And of course, this has led to a lot of backlash. There are several uh cities that have canceled their contracts with Flock and other license plate readers. Uh, some people have gotten a bit more directly involved. Um people cutting down uh uh cameras, uh covering them with spray paint, destroying them with you know uh baseball bats and other things
because of this view. Again, whether that's a speed camera, right, where you've got the little thing set up and it shows you your speed, it takes your picture. A red light camera, where if you go through a red light, it takes your picture. Flock cameras are nothing different in the photography side, it's the access to the data side, and that is where things are problematic. And that's where I think we need to see a lot more. We need to see a lot more aggressive uh redress of the grievance. For
example, um, if someone searches the database for your car, let's say, I mean, we've had examples of law enforcement uh using these camera databases to search for uh loved ones, right? Family members. That is a deprivation that that is an unreasonable search. There's no crime involved, there's no reasonable article of suspicion of a crime. That is an unreasonable search, which means it deprives you of a right protected by the Constitution, the Fourth Amendment, which makes it a federal crime, punishable by a fine and up
to one year in jail, 18 USC section 242. If it's done under color of law, meaning if law enforcement, people have access to this, are doing this, then that is a federal crime. Why are we not seeing more federal prosecutions? Not because I'm a fan of federal prosecutions, but if we're not, but we should see, we should see state and local prosecutions. It is a crime to deprive someone of a right. And we have these, why are we not seeing these? And again, people argue, well, you know, it's it's it's the problem, my problem is surveillance. We live in
a surveillance state. Well, where's that line? Where's that line between okay to photograph and not okay to photograph? Like I said, is it the is it the red light camera? Is it the speeding camera? Because they at least have a a traffic violation that was observed to initiate the quite possibly. But if you do that, you understand that in a situation with, say, a child kidnapping, you may not be able
to find the perpetrator's vehicle as quickly because you don't have access to to the data, uh, which brings up another question. Is it simply the fact that this is collected and held historically? Right? Could the system be set up where yes, there's a kidnapping and we have a picture of the car, we have the license plate, you feed it into a system, and you say, Go find it. But do you trust Flock to actually manage the database? Do you trust Flock to actually
delete these photographs once they're taken? Do we trust them? Because remember, anyone of you have one of those uh Alexa in your home, you know, where you just say, Hey Alexa, and it it responds. You do realize that Amazon is collecting all of that data and processing it. They use it to help train their systems. You have a ring doorbell camera, any of those cameras, those cloud-based security cameras, they're collecting all that data and they're using it to process their data. And generally, their
their user agreement says they're going to delete it after a certain period of time. But Amazon's been found not deleting the data. I think they're Amazon said 90 days, and they've collected and held on to data for much longer than that. We need to look at this, to my mind, a little differently. And uh, I I said there's a tweak I'd like to see to the Constitution, there's a tweak I'd like to see to the Fourth Amendment, and uh not a replacement of it. I think it's great, but it would help us deal with the digital world.
And that is to simply add uh uh not just uh persons, paper, uh persons, houses, papers, and effects. Let's add, you know, documents and information about a person. Think of it this way. Remember when they passed HIPAA, you know, the health and the privacy act? Uh because you don't want your uh medical information being open to the public. Well, gee, um that modification of Fourth Amendment, it's information about you. Shouldn't that be secure
from persons, houses, papers, and effects? Let's say that you're working on a project with a friend and uh you share it via Dropbox or iCloud or or uh Google Docs or something. Wouldn't you like that to have the same Fourth Amendment protections as a piece of paper you have in your home? That's the scenario I think that uh would would fix a lot of this. That that to me is my recommendation is that we look at it this way. And again, um I think I I see Flock being
uh a a and not Flock specifically, the automatic license plate readers. It is a tool. And it's a tool that's supposedly hoping helping to keep us safe. But I also go back to Benjamin Franklin that said those who will give up essential liberties for the promise of temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. I have to wonder. And not just the the photographs, but the the collection of that data and the use of that data um
about other people. Are we giving up an essential liberty in order to give to be to take the promise of safety that maybe isn't as promising as we hope, as we hope, that it's so easily abused and there's so little consequences for people who do abuse them? I don't know. It's certainly worth something, but I've got some more ideas I want to cover, but before I get there, I I have to take a break. And if we
talk about surveillance states, boy, remember when they tried to surveil us during COVID, right? They wanted you to have uh uh uh uh a vaccine card and they wanted on your phone and they wanted to track you and they wanted you to scan to come in. They it truly was creating a surveillance state. Thankfully, we were able to stop that. But there are plenty of other respon uh uh effects of COVID, not just what government did, but COVID itself,
long COVID, vaccine injury, shedding. What do you do? Well, our friends at the wellness company have come up with a product called Daily Spike Support. It is designed to block and dissolve the spike protein. That's that's the the toxic part, that's the inflammatory part of COVID-19. It's the part that actually makes you sick. Best of all, you can take spike protein both to protect against the effects of vaccines, shedding, COVID. Now,
I'm not a doctor, not an epidemiologist, don't play one on TV. But it's this product is backed by documentary research and it's been vetted by the chief medical board of the wellness company. So I suggest you do your own research. Go to americautloud.shop, click on the spike support panel, do your research. Look at the documents, look at the testimonies, look at all that information, then decide for yourself. If you decide to give it a try, use the code out loud at checkout and you'll get 20% off of your order. So whether you've had COVID or you've you're concerned about
the uh having taken the the uh fake vaccine or or you're worried about just encountering it in the wild, take a look at go to americaoutloud.shop, click on the spike support panel, look at the product, see if it'll do, if it'll help you, and what you're concerned about. And don't forget, when you check out, use the code Out Loud, and you'll get 20% off of your order. Isn't it amazing that we can find a product that will protect us from the worst effects of not just COVID, but the vaccines the
government pushed on us. And we can get 20% off while we're doing it. Are you looking for healthy snacks? But you've had enough of all the sweet, sugary energy bars? Good news, there's new bars to try. That's savory, crunchy, and packed with goodness. Bear bars are based just on six simple natural
ingredients. A certified organic veggie, nut, and seed bar. That's low temp dried, never baked or fried. Bear bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bearbar.com slash outloud and get the exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners. That's B-E-A-R, B-A-R.com forward
slash out loud. Successful weight loss is about changing the gut-brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't like needles, you'll love oral-dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor designed solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy fats. And unlike injections, these are
fast absorbing sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit tvc.health slash outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. You wouldn't go a day without brushing your teeth or washing your hands. What about washing your nose? I mean, your nose does filter the air you breathe, air loaded with bacteria, viruses, and irritants. Make nasal hygiene part of your routine with Clear. No messy bottles to fill, no drowning sensation. Clear
is a natural drug-free saline with the added benefit of xylitol, which blocks bacterial and viral adhesion. Available in stores and online at clear.com. That is X L-E-A-R.com. Only one of the other two people will be able to become great. This is Melody Mother. Join me in the studio.
Today we're talking about protecting our rights in the digital world. Recognizing that when the Constitution was written, computers didn't exist. And even the latest amendment, um, the one that ratified in 1992, actually written back in the 1780s. Uh so it, you know, it was computers are new. But the beautiful thing about most of the Constitution is it was written with general ideas in mind. So when they talk about persons, houses, papers, effects
in the Fourth Amendment, it's designed to encompass a lot of things, right? And I contend that your digital content are your effects, regardless of where they're currently being stored. Although courts have disagreed with me, but uh I would make that uh thing, which is why I suggest a minor modification, amendment to the Fourth Amendment that would protect information generated by us or about us by the Fourth Amendment, but that's another. But the
biggest issue to me isn't so much the digital world, it's the people we have that are creating and enforcing the laws. For example, uh New York Attorney General Letitia James, she's kind of got a reputation uh for being an anti-Trumper, right? She's definitely been out to get Trump. In fact, I think she actually ran on getting Trump. And now we have a new report. Uh Assistant Attorney General Daniel Weisenfeld, uh, who was a formerly a Brooklyn prosecutor, um,
he sent an email to the entire agency, uh, including the New York Times and just the news. And um he claimed that his bureau chief, uh Shamiso Masawose, had instructed him to find and pursue crimes committed by specific individuals and organizations affiliated with Donald Trump. Now, this is the old adage, right? Show me the person, I'll show you the crime.
I believe that's attributed to Stalin. But again, going after not just Trump, but organizations affiliate with him. Uh true social, even apparently Hewlett-Packard, not sure their association with Trump, but that's part of the the article that's written, is is even after their merger with Jupiter Network Juniper Networks was approved, the the uh New York uh Attorney General's office went after them, uh, or targeting them um because they were affiliated somehow
with Trump. Now, I ask you, how are your rights protected when you have people like that in office? And again, she ran for office and she ran claiming that she was going to get Donald Trump. That was kind of her her mantra. Um whether your rights are whether you're talking about digital properties or not, how are your rights protected with people like that that are executing the laws of the United States? Remember, the attorney general of the of the state
is the chief law enforcement officer of the state, part of the executive branch. Um, and uh, you know, again, it has a lot of power. But these are this is the person that was put in place to exit to faithfully execute the laws of the state, and she's targeting a person for federal office. So it's not simply I understand that that you know some of the rules are written in a way that doesn't necessarily directly relate to digital products automatically, but
again, the constitution was looked at at things more generally. But does it really matter? Does it really matter what the constitution says when somebody says, Hey, I'm going after this guy, and you should you should vote for me for office because I'm going after a political opponent. I'm gonna I'm looking to prosecute him. Now, again, if you if the assumption is that he did something criminal, then you investigate him. But yeah, again, it's not simply whether our rights
are are are protecting the digital world, it's who's supposed to be protecting our rights. Here's another example. Uh so the Department of Health and Human Services, on constitutional agency, uh released a study by researchers from Rutgers University, the Manhattan Institute, and the Network Contagion Research Institute said, you know, there's been a lot of studies about, you know, those who oppose uh what they call gender-affirming treatments. Uh, I call them, you know, gender-denying treatments because yeah, it denies a person's
uh sex or gender. Um, but they said, you know what, no one's ever looked at the other side of the equation. Is there a way to predict support for this gender ideology? Uh what they found was that uh this gender really plays into what they refer to as left-wing authoritarianism. From the report, I see a quote uh psychological profile characterized by aggression toward perceived oppressors, enthusiasm for top-down censorship and institutional enforcement, and hostility towards conventional social
institutions. In short, an authoritarian disposition organized around left rather than right political content. Okay, that to me is a little interesting. Um, maybe we can expand on that a little bit. Uh again, there's in according to the looking at the report, uh, the the author says, uh, in the case of gender ideology, much of the political content has been generated by supposedly neutral organizations such as medical societies. Um according to the report, these groups' clinical guidance documents are presented as
science. Now, what does this have to do with rights in a digital world? Well, what we're finding is, first of all, there's nothing new about yellow journalism. You go all the way back to the beginning of the country. You should see the uh presidential race between John Adams and Tom Jeff Thomas Jefferson. Oh, the vitriol in the papers, from the very beginning, but even before we were a country, that's you know, the the papers are nothing new. What I see most interesting is two things. Uh, one is information seems
to come faster. You know, it used to be if something happened, you had to wait for the evening news to come on or for the newspaper the next day to find out what was going on. The rate of information coming at you was was much slower. That changed in the digital world. The other thing that changed is both has had a lot of benefits and a lot of of detractors, and that is what's often referred to as democratization of news, meaning you don't have to go to the the major networks to get your news. You
can be just a a person with a web account that can create news articles. Now, the problem, the the the great thing about this is it means corporate media isn't shaping the news. The downside is we often don't bother vetting so-called news. So-and-so said this. All right, what's their evidence? Well, so-and-so said it. Yeah, but where's your evidence? Well, so-and-so said it. Yeah, I heard you. I heard you the first two times, I heard you first three times. Where's the
evidence? See, a lot of people make a lot of claims and there's no evidence behind it. We now have to take on the role, a role we should have had all along of verifying the information. What was the old Reagan saying, trust but verify? We need to verify. That's our now our responsibility. Now, when it comes to protecting your rights, people can say anything they want. They can have their opinions, they can express their opinions. I encourage them to do so. It not only tells me who to
trust, it tells me who not to trust. When I see someone says that a boy can be a girl because they think so, I know not to trust pretty much anything that they're saying. Uh when, you know, when when someone tells me that uh, you know, the United States is a is a federal corporation. Well, where's your evidence? And they point to like the what's often referred to as the Corporation Act or the uh DC Organic Act. And I said, It says no such thing. I've read it, I've looked for it. Where's the the data? See, protecting our rights now becomes something we must do more.
We can't simply take a word. And again, even from this um HHS study, just because it came from the federal government doesn't mean it's true. Uh I think they've got a fair amount of basis. And again, it's not an all or nothing, right? I know a lot of people who are pro-transgender delusion that are not violent. I know a lot of people who are not pro-tran that are violent. I think violence is violence, and I think
there's a uh mentality that has been developed where this idea of I am so right that I can do something wrong in support of being right, and uh it's okay. It's kind of the the it's the false Robin Hood presence, right? Because what we're all talking about, Robin Hood stole from the rich to give to the poor. The fact that stealing is wrong didn't matter because he was giving it to the poor that made it okay. There's a couple problems with that. One, it's historically inaccurate.
Um Robin uh the Robin Hood didn't steal from the rich, he stole from the people who stole from the poor. He stole from the the the you know the the the illegal taxes and whatnot. And he gave it back to the people it was stolen from. But this idea that it's okay, uh, the Jean Valjean, right? He went to prison for stealing bread to feel it to feed his starving family. Well, stealing is wrong. It's it's it's it's a criminal
act. And the fact that he the way he was treated, that that I believe the punishment far outweighed the crime, he stole. He made a decision that breaking the law was not as you know, uh following the law was not as important as feeding his family. He made that decision, he suffered the consequences. I think the consequences, again, it's a story, it's fiction, but they were they were way beyond a reasonable. But it's this idea that it's okay for me to burn and loot because I'm protesting for some great thing like you know, George Floyd. In the
digital world, news follows so fast and people are so obsessed with getting it first, we've lost this idea of verifying first. So one of the reasons why the Constitution Study is not a news program. I'm not looking for the news. I'm looking to analyze, I'm looking to take a breath and see what's going on. But again, coming to this idea of protecting our rights in the digital world, again, we can't just focus on the digital world. I see a new report from uh we we have the House uh Education and Workforce Committee,
chaired by Tim Wahlberg, who I guess they're investigating the use of these um transgender dolls in elementary school. See the University of Minnesota Medical School Institute for Gender for Sexual and Gender Health has created a product called these transgender dolls. And basically it's dolls of well, it's boys and girls with interchangeable parts. Now, again, in a world where news flies everywhere and
and ideas can can morph and grow like a contagion, this idea of transgenderism has grown to the point where now you have allegedly allegedly medical institutions uh promoting children to believe that they can change their gender with uh surgery and hormones. And of course, this gets spread through the Ethernet, right? Through the ether. They've got the My Gender Dolls actually has a website that
talks about having expansion packs. Not quite sure, since apparently they don't describe it. So the question, but the other question I want to bring up is well, is it up to the House, the Congress, to investigate this? Now, I suppose you could say, well, Congress can determine whether or not they're going to fund schools that use these products. Of course, those funds are unconstitutional to begin with, but okay, I I I could kind of see that. But I'd love to have a real a real realistic conversation
about what these schools are trying to teach their the children. They're ignoring science, they're ignoring biology in an attempt to teach, to propagandize uh uh a political idea, ideology. But I also love to talk about funding and why is the federal government funding schools? Funding education is not a power delegated to the United States, it's unconstitutional for them to do so. It's embezzling money for the American
people. Now, the advantage I have is because this program is digital, well, it can spread really far and wide. And I want to be careful because make sure that I'm the message I'm spreading, I can I can support. But think about it, until recently, unless I was a somebody on a major network or a major radio station, you wouldn't you may not hear about this. You may not hear about the the my gender dolls, you may not have heard about the HHS uh report or
study that was released. You may not have heard about this. Like anything else, technology is neither good nor bad, it's how we use it. Now, I've got some other things I want to get into, but before I do that, I do have to take a break. Uh, I want to remind you though, you know, we all have choices. We live in an internet world, we live with wireless phones. We have our phones on us all the time, and uh we generally pay for those services, right? Where's that money going? Well, yeah, it's going
to your service provider. Once that what are they doing with it? See, there are a lot of companies I stopped doing business with because I didn't like what they were doing with my money once I paid for their service. That's one of the reasons why I joined Patriot Mobile. I wanted to buy from a company that believed what I believed and put their money where their mouth is. Yes, Patriot Mobile is America's only Christian conservative wallets provider. That is not why I joined them. They've got great 4G and 5G coverage on all the same networks and towers as the major carriers. That is not why I joined
them. Their customer support, 100% US based. Again, not why I joined them. I join them because they take a portion of every dollar to support organizations that are fighting for my rights. Freedom of religion, speech, press, to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures, to not be denied due process. They also support the sanctity of life, veterans, and our first responders. All things I'm 100% behind. I join them. So join me. Switch to Patriot Mobile today, get free activation by using
the code Constitution Checkout. See, I became an affiliate a while back because I so and uh not only did I enjoy the service I got, but I was so impressed by how they spend their money. That means if you go to patriotmobile.comslash constitution and find a plan that works for you, when you pay your cell phone bill, you're helping to support the Constitution study. By the way, are you one of those veterans, a first responder? Are you just a family with multiple lines? You may be eligible for discounts as well. So get great wireless service, get uh
support great organizations, get great discounts, all by going to patriomobile.coms as constitution, finding a plan and discount that works for you, and then use the code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. And you're doing that with a great company that not only supports our veterans and our first responders, but these great organizations that are fighting for our rights and for our liberties. Now, I also hope you'll swing by AmericaOutloud.news. We're talking about news. Where do you get your news? We live
in the information age. We get digital news everywhere. Where do you get yours? See, I'm looking for a place that I can trust yet still verify. For me, one of those is AmericaOut Loud.news. I trust them because I've looked at the news I've gotten from them, and it's pretty good. When I research it, when I verify that the data is correct, it comes up true. That's why I go there. But it's more important than ever that we do something with this. In other words, don't just read the stories and articles, share them. You'd be surprised how many people
will come back and say, I didn't know that was going on. So when you listen to the podcast, you watch the videos, share them. Friends, family, neighbors, social media, civic groups, anywhere you can. See, it's the sharing of this information. It's letting other people know the news that the corporate media doesn't want them to know. That doesn't just promote America out loud, it helps secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. During treatment, City Tap water molecule structure gets
messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab-certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for your home or on the go at chemicalfreebody.com
forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer, just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere.
City apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer. Feeling off lately? Bloated, brain fog, low energy? It could be parasites. These silent invaders that weaken your gut, immune system, and mental clarity. That's why Dr. Peter McCullough and the doctors at the Wellness Company formulated Ivermectin
and Mebendazol cleanse, a medical-grade solution designed to help eliminate parasites and restore balance. No gimmicks, just real medicine trusted by top doctors. Go to twc.health forward slash outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. Take control of your health today. Welcome back, every day, American Jerry. Join the Constitution study. Today we've been talking about protecting our rights in a digital world. And let's face it, the digital world's a bit of
a wild, wild west. Um, there's a lot that goes on out there that well, we have to take care of ourselves. If we're waiting for someone else to protect us, we're probably in trouble. Uh, for example, X, formerly Twitter, they just uncovered a ginormous Chinese botnet. 200,000 bot accounts linked to uh uh Chinese, the the the communist Chinese government. Now, according to the the uh X's safety team,
uh they made a statement back on August 27th that said just 200 accounts within this network posted material looking to influence U.S. debate over guess what artificial intelligence and energy policy. Gee, if that was just 200, I wonder what the rather the other 199,800 uh bots were doing. I've been uh I've heard people say thank this was a a a scam, this is
a an influence operation. Um wasn't entirely sure, but if this is true, if these are counts, these Chinese accounts were trying to influence our debate about artificial intelligence, then maybe the statements I've been making all along are right than I thought, more correct than I thought. Again, I spent 20 years working in data centers. And yes, they consume tremendous amounts of electricity. When I started back in the uh late 90s,
uh an average server was about seven and a half inches high and had 150 watt power supplies. When I left back in the uh well, late uh late 20 nine, 2010s, I guess, um a server was about less than two inches tall and had 500 watt power supplies. In other words, the amount of energy got packed into a smaller and smaller area, so you had a huge amount of of power consumption, and of course that
power creates heat, and dissipating that heat is an issue. Now that's we oh, it's the water they're using. They don't use water as a primary coolant, they use water as a heat conduit, right? So they run chilled water through uh uh through systems to um dissipate heat, and sometimes they will chill that water with uh uh ammonia-based refrigerant. Sometimes they'll use if they have a large body of water, they'll use that as a heat sink. But it's you
know, this whole idea of we can't get rid of these data centers, we have to get them, getting all these cities and counties and states to to stop data centers, maybe that's part of a Chinese influence operation. Because again, you want to get rid of data centers, you got to get rid of your smartphones and your smart TVs and your Amazon and your Netflix account, all of that disappears without data centers. So let's be a little more intelligent about that. But also remember that just because you so someone you said that someone said doesn't mean it was actually
human that said it. It could have been a bot. How do you tell? You look for actual evidence you can verify through uh other sources. Hmm, what a concept. Facts and data. Speaking of facts and data, you remember when uh was it the Richmond memo? That's the FBI memo about uh you know having to to spy on on the Roman Catholic churches and and how churches with uh Latin mass had you know had to be were what were spied on? Well, a new report from the DOJ claims
that FBI personnel opened investigations into two Roman Catholic preach uh priests and conducted surveillance all based on that Richmond Catholic memo that was later claimed. First it was claimed didn't it didn't exist, then it was debunked. Uh the report shows how this you know violent extremist uh uh uh investigation led to well uh watching out, you know, investigating traditional Catholic
masses. It also showed new light on internal disputes about how reliable the Southern Poverty Law Center information actually is. No, there's how much of it is just again fake data. Add that to the fact that that uh they were funding, they call them insiders or informants on some of the very groups they were trying to shut down. Yeah, makes you wonder. Maybe in a digital world, we need to be a bit more circumspect about what we actually trust
because these are not inconsequential activities. I mean, this report showed that the uh the FBI opened investigations into two Roman Catholic priests, they looked at their travel, at their contacts, uh, they conducted surveillance on them. Um, how would you feel knowing that maybe you went to one of these priests for some for confession or for some advice, only to find out that, yeah, you are being tracked by the FBI because one of their
contacts? And maybe the next time someone throws out uh, well, you're on the SPLC's hate map, maybe you'll ask yourself, well, is that really a hate map, or is that just a we disagree with the SPLC map? Could be. You'll have to see. One more I want to take a look at, and that is ivermectin. Do you remember when ivermectin was considered a horse paste? It was horse paste. They said if you eat horse paste, you're you deserve to die. I'm I I remember those. Now, yes, I've used ivermectin
in horses to prevent worms, yes, as a paste, but ivermectin has also been used as an antiparasitic and other treatments in human beings. In fact, I believe it won a Nobel Peace for a Nobel Prize for its effectiveness, and especially the fact that it's inexpensive. Well, ivermectin will once again be coming to the rescue. Have you heard about the New World screw worm? It's this nasty little parasite, it's a bug that lays its eggs in animals, and the eggs, when they
hatch, literally consume the animal from the inside. It's nasty. Well, the FDA, another illegal agency, they've recently uh approved using a generic form of ivermectin as an injectable for cattle to help prevent uh uh screw worm. Now, I do hold some concerns because this was an emergency use authorization. Uh the EUA allows it to be used within 24 hours after birth or when other procedures are
upon when or when a wound appears and it's uh being used in well, dairy cows. So once again, we see ivermectin maybe coming to the or this case gerring form coming to the rescue when America is most in need. And I wonder just how much of the stories about ivermectin and how it was not safe in in uh in human beings after being again not only approved by the FDA but winning a Nobel Prize, um
how much of the fear-mongering about it was generated or hype because, well, it's in the digital world. Then again, there's also a lot of facts native disproving that hype in the digital world, which kind of brings me back to my point. See, the digital world is neither good nor evil. It's populated with people, sometimes real people, sometimes programmed bots that are programmed by people, but it's people and we have all the same human failings in the digital realm that we do in
the physical realm. You know? In fact, uh, I would say in the digital realm, since we are not in direct contact, some of our worst aspects like to come out. We tend to be meaner in the digital realm than I think we are in the in in-person realm. And maybe that tells us a lot more about us than uh we may want to admit to. So let's get back to the original question. How do we protect our rights in the digital world? Well, start with
recognizing that um anything you put on the internet is basically fair game. Uh, even if you if you if it's encrypted. Let's start with with the most common things, email. Uh what most people don't realize is that email generally travels across the internet unencrypted. All right, it's not uh unless you're using software that encrypts it, by default, email is unencrypted, which anybody can see it. And it it's not a direct point-to-point, it passes through several servers from your email
to the destination email, and anywhere along the is logging that uh that information, and the that email is sitting on their server, it's visible, right? So email is not secure. Uh, you think about a snap like maybe uh or a chat uh product like a telegram or these others that are say we're we're end-to-end encrypted. That's better, right? Because the data is going uh uh is encrypted end-to-end. That's important. It's it's
end-to-end encryption. It doesn't mean the systems in between don't know that you're talking, it merely knows doesn't know the content of what you're saying, and that's important uh from certain uh uh legal and privacy standards, right? Because remember, no matter what, governments like to have they they have these things called subpoenas, and they like to go to these tech companies and say, give me everything on John Doe. Here's the account, give me everything on John Doe. And most companies simply turn it over
because there's not uh uh a benefit to them defending John Doe's rights for the most part. So anything that goes through there, assume that not only could a hacker get access to it, but a uh the government can get access to it via a simple subpoena, not a warrant, right? Not probable cause, not author affirmation, just a request from a government entity. Uh once you get past email, of course, that that also covers all of your social media, Facebook, X, True
Social, all of that stuff, the the data is on those servers, and even if a hacker doesn't get them, the government generally just has to ask and they gain access to it. Uh what if you use an online uh accounting software, right? You use something that like a quick in where you know it's it's easy, it's convenient. Anywhere you can do, you can pay your bills, you can do all of that stuff. All of that data is stored on their systems. All of that data can be accessed not just by a
hacker, but by a government actor with a simple subpoena in general. Sometimes they push back. Uh, but for the most so pretty much everything you do online, you understand that not only could it be attacked by a hacker, but it could be requested by the federal government and generally it's turned over. That's why for me, I drive my my my accountant nuts, right? He for years he wanted me to use an online bookkeeping software, and I refused because that was critical information. That information doesn't
get stored on the internet. Uh, you think about Dropbox, iCloud, OneDrive, all these still Google Docs, they're very helpful. But again, all that information is on their systems, all that information they often use to train their own algorithms and AIs, and all that data they generally hand over if the government simply asks for it. So you don't really want to put anything critical on any of those. Now, does that mean I don't use those products? I use those products, but what I put out there
is is something that um I don't find uh uh um secret, right? It's not confidential. I don't put my my bookkeeping out there, uh, I don't put uh a lot of private information. Now I have an advantage, again, 30 years in IT. I have a home cloud setup, and a lot of people I I couldn't possibly do that. Um need to find somebody a little bit of help, and you can actually set these things up uh that that uh provide pretty much
the same services as a Dropbox or an iCloud, but uh without the security exposure. But you have to make a decision, and everyone's gonna be different. How much is your privacy worth? Is the convenience of using the Dropbox or the online accounting software or the messaging outweighed by the concerns of what is what could happen if that data got loose? Right? We we
think just think about all the stuff you do on text and email and all that. What happens if that data gets loose? And I think that's what we have to do is we have to decide for ourselves how we're going to protect our rights. And yes, it may mean giving up certain conveniences, but you're doing it as an exchange for greater security, and that's a decision you have to make, and you have to make it for all the different products you may use. That's life, or as my daughter says,
that's adulting. Now, if you have questions, I'm more than happy to answer questions. Just go to constitutionstudy.com slash questions and ask your question. You can also email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com. Uh, I I do need your name and email address because I'm going to email you a response. And uh I'm I'll do the best. I I I the only thing I ask is that you be you not be mean, right? I want you to be polite, and that your question has something to do with the the program or the constitution or
something around the constitution. Right. Uh I I've occasionally had people ask me questions that have nothing to do with the and I'm like, uh no, I'm not researching that uh at this point. That I don't have I don't have the time. But I love answering questions. By the way, if you'd like me to answer the question on the radio, just check the box on the web forum or just note it in your email, and I'll be more than happy to answer your question right here on the Constitution study. And as I said, I love answering questions.
I love it for two reasons. One, well, actually, I love it for three reasons. So, reason number one is if you have a question, you need an answer. That's how most people learn, is by getting their questions answered. Uh, it helps me because it makes me double check my sources to make sure that the answers I'm using here that are supported by evidence. And the third thing is, well, it really gives me a clue as to what my audience is thinking. If you ask a question, that may be a topic for another future program, which by the way is a question you can always ask. So again,
head to constitutionstudy.com slash questions or email me at questions at constitutionstudy.com and ask your question. I'll be more than happy to answer to the best of my ability. Now, I also hope you come back and join us here for the Constitution Study on America Out Loud Talk Radio heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday, 4 p.m. Eastern Time. You can listen on our media player. We've got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And of course, you can always listen via podcast. It does take a day or two for an episode to
go from talk radio to broadcast, but you get to listen on your favorite podcast app whenever you want to listen. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the show, leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the algorithm share us with more people. Of course, the more people we get shared with, the more likely they are to click and join us here for the Constitution Study. You can find all the links you need at the homepage at americaoutloud.news. But please share those links. Let other people know about the great content we're developing here. Let them
know where they can get good and solid constitutional information, hopefully in a way you find entertaining. And by sharing this program, by sharing that news, by letting people know they can learn the constitution for themselves, you're helping to share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. nation home.
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...
The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...