Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY

THE CONSTITUTION STUDY artwork

Blaming data centers won’t fix America’s power grid

Nov 12, 202657 minAudio

The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Why data centers have become the scapegoat for the neglect of our energy infrastructure and what happens when a tech billionaire agrees to avoid further strain on the electrical grid by providing his own power. Today I want to look at stories that have absolutely nothing to do with elections...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Helping to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. This is the Constitution Study on the American Outline Network with your host, Paul Engel. I don't know about you, but I've had enough stories about elections for a while. Today, I want to look at stories that have absolutely nothing to do with elections.

Hello there, Everyday Americans, Paul Engel here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teacherizing generation be free. Glad you could join me today. I've got a couple different topics I want to talk about. None of them directly involve elections, and uh hopefully you'll find this respite well worthwhile. Then again, maybe not. We'll have to see. We're going to start with uh, well, transgender in the military. Uh now, uh uh understand, according to uh the Military Times, Secretary of Defense Pete Heggseth ordered

the uh um removal uh under Donald Trump's guidance of transgenders from the military. However, apparently um multiple review boards, military review boards, have recommended retaining transgender uh service members even against the the Secretary of War and the president's uh orders. Um there are reports that between the Navy and the Marine Corps uh separate, they were uh each have their own separation boards. They retained

nine of 12 transgender members of this of the service who claimed to be trans, who had the mental disease of transgenderism. Now, apparently these decisions were still waiting for the final approval of the Navy Secretary, Hung Kao. But um apparently now the Marines they've introduced a new policy which eliminates the temporary service extensions for Marines awaiting decisions about the involuntary separation, meaning if you're there, you

can't get this temporary extension because while they're while they're waiting. There may be some due process issues. I'm not that familiar with that aspect of the military, but uh the idea that um the the commander-in-chief has looked at the the impact of again, transgender is these people uh intentionally make themselves incapable uh uh on a voluntary basis make them incapable to fight. In other words, they they they are intentionally looking

for for drugs and treatments, in some cases surgery that makes them um unfit to fight, which is kind of the purpose of the military, which is why they were being separated. And uh, I claim they shouldn't have been included in the first place, but then again, that's a previous administration, yada yada yada, okay. Um, but at least now the Marines say, you know what, we're we're putting our policy in place that nope you no longer get a temporary extension while you're waiting for us to throw

you out, basically. Now, in another story, uh, you may have heard, you may not have heard of um a report uh pure uh a report put out called Kirth et al. uh back in 2022, which uh claimed basically that uh transgender that men who claim to be women, true with so-called transgender women, their um their brains actually change uh to be more like women.

I guess that'd be a perfect example of mind over mind, or instead of mind over matter, the the brain would change it. Well, like any good study, it needs to be peer reviewed. And there was recently released a peer review of that study. I'll give you a clue. It says flawed methods and overstated conclusions regarding brain sex, a peer review of Kurth et al. 2022. So, in other words, they they they they I'm looking at the at the abstract because

I'm I haven't gotten into the whole thing. It says, listen, this Kurth et al. study concluded that brain anatomy of transgender women is shifted away from their biological sex towards their gender identity. Now, I've seen studies that involve um uh you know questions, there is a a there is a difference between men and women in their brains. It has to do with certain hormones that are introduced during pregnancy, and it's one of the reasons why men tend to focus on a single task while women are better able to multitask. But

that they looked at the United States and said, listen, if you are a male and you were chemically biologically designed with a brain one way, thinking you're a woman, so they claim somehow magically changes your brain to be more like a woman. And apparently, this peer review says bunk. Again, reading from the abstract, we evaluate whether the study's evidence supports this conclusion by focusing on its statistical methods and treatment of sexual orientation and its analysis. In other words, we're not looking, we're looking at how they

dealt with the evidence. They looked at whether the evidence they have actually supports their conclusion by looking at the statistical idea methodology they used and how they they analyzed this brain uh sexual orientation, brain nonsense in the first place. Back to the abstract. The principal finding relies on a very small sample, a weak justification for parametric analysis, one-tailed post hoc tests, no correction for multiple comparisons, and limited

robustness testing. In other words, they said that the study didn't do a very good job. They said, first of all, they started with a very small sample. Um, don't know how big the sample was, but it was very small. They looked at their analysis and they said, no, there's not a lot of justification. Their testing methodology seemed to look at only one scenario, and when they looked at multiple compared, they they didn't do, they didn't do a very robust job in their testing. Uh back to the abstract, the study also did not properly account for

sexual orientation as a potential neuroanatomical confound, despite having the relevant participant data to do so. They said, all right, listen, um, are you homosexual or heterosexual? Did that have an impact on the uh on the uh and and anatomy of the brain? You had the data, you simply didn't look at it. In other words, we ignored, they ignored uh a potential confounding variable. Um concluding from the abstract, is this these methodology

choices consistently bias the results towards smaller p-values and stronger apparent support for the author's stated hypothesis? The evidence presented, therefore, does not justify the study's headline conclusion. In other words, this is a study that was apparently weighted to give them the answer they wanted, which again, not all that surprising. It happens probably more than we would like in a lot of scientific studies. So if you hear someone saying, well, listen, there was a study that showed that you know transgender women actually develop

women's brains, it's apparently hokum because it didn't stand up to peer review. Uh in another case in at the Supreme Court, in this case, Colorado case, this time involving the state's uh apparent animosity toward uh certain religious beliefs, including you know Christian and and Jewish and whatnot. Um the the court uh heard arguments in St. Mary's Catholic Parishes versus Roy. Uh this is

uh a dealing with Colorado has a a law, they provide assistance for uh I think it was preschool daycare, I forget what it was. I'm actually I have an article I've been doing some research on, I'll be writing in the next couple of weeks. But uh what I found interesting were some of the arguments that were made uh during the this particular oral argument case. And it really comes down to Colorado saying, listen, you can have this money, you just

have to agree that that uh into homosexual marriage and transgenderism, and you have to agree to all these things in order to qualify for that, which again is a religious matter for others. Now, let's start with a quote from Justice Alito asking about uh Colorado's history. And we have your state's record in recent First Amendment cases to which Justice Barrett referred. Uh

Childs versus Salazar last term, uh violating violation of the uh free free uh First Amendment rights of a Christian counselor, 303 Creative in 2021, violation of the First Amendment rights of a Christian website designer, masterpiece cake shop in 2015, violation of the First Amendment rights of a Christian Baker. What should we make of all this? Before we get to the response, I want

to point out something. Uh, none of the cases that the the Justice Leto mentioned are actually First Amendment cases. I I know the court said they were First Amendment cases, they treated them as First Amendment cases, but they cannot legally be First Amendment cases. Why? Well, I beat a dead drum, a dead horse here. A First Amendment says Congress shall make no law. Congress didn't make a law in any of these cases, therefore it cannot violate the First Amendment. It was a 14th Amendment violation, absolutely, but not a First Amendment

violation. But the the question is the point is um Justice Lito pointed to multiple instances where the state of Colorado has infringed on the rights of religious people and organizations, and he wanted the a response from the from uh uh Colorado's attorney. Your Honor, there is no evidence of any sort of any religious hostility or animus in the UPK program. The UPK program is a universal preschool uh uh uh that

program that that this is all about. And I find it interesting that they specifically call out certain things that certain religions would not find acceptable. So she claims there's no religious discrimination. We're only discriminating against certain religious beliefs. Yeah, that's that's to me the issue here. But and and she goes on to say lower courts haven't found this. Well, that's why it's at the Supreme Court. And uh, I want to look at the you know, I I I'm like I said, I've gone into I'm doing research

on the um on the oral arguments. Uh, I'm still doing that research, so I haven't been through all of it yet. But and I'll I'll have it on the website, right? When I publish the article, it'll take two, three weeks for me to get it done. You'll find it on AmericaOut Loud.news. But um at the moment, I want you to consider imagine you run a preschool, a day, you run any organization, and the state says, Hey, we will offer you money to help you run that organization. All you

have to do is give up your most sincerely held beliefs. Now, in this case, it happens to be that marriage is a man and a woman. Um, what if it were uh, I don't know, the uh the inclusion of uh aliens? Or what if it were uh you're not allowed to believe that uh uh uh uh people of different races should marry? Would that be acceptable? Well, no, people would be up in arms, but apparently in Colorado, the idea that uh uh

you have to agree with same-sex marriage, you have to not only endorse it, you have to accommodate it, um is problematic. And again, it's not as if these this Catholic uh daycare, this Catholic preschool, is the only preschool option in the area. It's not like there aren't plenty of preschool options they could go to where people could get um uh these types of uh services. The the state of Colorado wants to say,

you want our money, this is it. Now, again, I understand this is Colorado's money, and I do understand there's some limitations. The question is, is the government willing to offer services and say no to certain groups because, well, people in government disagree with them? That's the interesting question. How far do you take that? Does that include uh homosexual marriage? Does it include interracial marriage? Does it include interspecial marriage? Who knows when that's gonna come up? That's

the question that's for and again, I wait, I want to wait and see. Uh the uh based on some of the research I've done so far, it seems like the court is coming down on the side of the Roman Catholics that they really grilled um uh the the Colorado attorney. Uh why are you doing this? Why are you picking on these people? Why'd you focus on these things that you didn't say uh um that you know you had to it i I guess it's the language of how you went about doing it, why are

you picking on these people? We'll wait and see as more details come out. But as several say, I know we're not supposed to talk about elections, but I have to point out that a handful of states did pass amendments to their constitution that prohibit boys from participating in school sports, boys from girls' bathrooms and locker rooms. Um, you know, there are certain limitations that we the j they just go too far. And again, using a mental disorder to gain access to opposite sex locker

rooms, to compete unfairly against the opposite sex to me is wrong. And I've yet to see a good argument um on the side of uh why you should let boys compete against girls, against why you should let uh people with these types of mental disorders be in the military, or why you have to have schools that all believe in lockstep, what the what the the state believes uh in order to get um

in order to get funding. So again, those are my opinions. I've got some other content I want to look at, but I have to take a break first. Before I go, I want to remind you we're still dealing with the aftermath of COVID. The the the spike protein, that that inflammatory, toxic part of COVID-19. You know the part that they tried to get us to put a gene therapy in our arm to teach our body how to make it. Uh yeah, it didn't make a lot of sense to me then. It still doesn't make sense now. Of course, that vaccine also included shedding. We've got long

COVID, we've got a vaccine injury. We're still dealing with the aftermath. And some people are really concerned. Like I said, I'm on a board of a company where somebody had to resign because they had long COVID and they couldn't do the job anymore. I pointed them to this product, though. It's called Spike Support from the Wellness Company. It's designed to be taken to protect against the effects of vaccine shedding and COVID. It's designed to block and dissolve the spike protein, the toxic part of COVID-19. Now,

I'm not a doctor, I don't play one on TV, but this is backed by documented research and been vetted by the chief medical board of the wellness company. So if you want to find out more, head to americautloud.shop and click on the spike support panel. And then do your research. To me, that's critically important is that you do your own research. See what others have found. Uh look at the ingredients, see how it works, do all of that. And then when you're ready to give it a try, we'll use the code OutLoud at checkout, and you'll get 20% off of your order. So take control of your

own buy, take control of your own future. Start one of the ways to start is with deal with spike support from the wellness company. Just go to americaoutloud.shop and find the spike support panel and do your own research. That's right. I want you to be an informed consumer. Don't forget, use that code outloud at checkout to get 20% off of your order and start taking the spike protein out of your body today. The government may have helped us get into this mess, but guess what? We the people

can get ourselves out of it. Again, by being informed, doing our research, head to Mericautloud.shop, check out Spike Support, and start detoxing your body from the spike protein today. During treatment, City Tap water molecule structure gets messed up so your cells can't fully absorb it. Yes, we have to purify our water,

but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure, just like a mountain stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much water you drink, it's how much water you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. Get one for your home on the go at chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's

chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. Successful weight loss is about changing the gut-brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor designed solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy

fats. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit TwC.health slash outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the goe, although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. Beer bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contains six

grams of protein, and they're low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together with syrups or sweeteners. But bear bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud. It means country of money.

American Jury joined The Constitution Study. Today, we're talking anything but elections. And so let's talk about data centers. Again, I've said before, I've worked in the IT for 30 years. I worked in 20 for 20 years worked in data centers. I'm familiar with their operations and their demands on infrastructure. Now, what I find interesting is, well, especially around politicians, data centers, especially AI data, they've become the bet noir. They've become the whipping boy, uh, or

as some people like to put it, uh, the scapegoat of America's electricity problems. Uh comes everything from increasing electricity prices, and you know, again, it it's it's convenient. I understand it. The question is, is it really the problem? You see, because I've been around long enough to remember we've had electricity problems before the AI kickoff and uh before some of these massive data centers. The the problem has been everything from generation to the infrastructure to the

grid and the ability to deliver. Remember, when people were talking about electric cars and getting rid of gas cars and having electric cars, one of the big problems was well, how do you get the electricity to the homes? We don't have the infrastructure to handle it. We don't have the generational capacity to handle it. Well, some research from the National Center for Energy Analytics, um, they and the University of South Carolina's Marshall School for Business looked at what's been driving the electricity price increases. And they said, yes,

data centers have contributed, but not a whole lot. Not the the they're they're they've been relatively modest. Most residential electricity bills come from two things, the increase. One is what they call dispatchable generation, meaning how much of the generation capacity can we can as left to be to dispatch? Can we actually use, right? Um, you know, if you've got uh uh if you're if you're if your generators, if your power plants are running at 98, 99 percent, you don't

have any slack to add more power to the to the load. Uh so um that means we we we have to discourage people from using because it just isn't there. You have a a you know what what's the old thing, you know, supply and demand. Well, when you limit the supply and the demand keeps increasing, the price goes up. Now the other problem is our grid. We've got three major grids in the US, uh East, West, and Texas. And they

again are near capacity. There's no room left. So as we put more power demands on, and again, you it's not just data centers, electric vehicles, more electric appliances, homes that have more gadgets that run in them, uh uh you know, everything that that sucks up more and more power without pay without any investment in the infrastructure. How do you deliver that power? Again, you have increasing demand and limited supply, price goes up.

And rather than blaming the actual problem, which has been around for decades, right? That's inadequate electrical supply. People have picked on the bet noir. Hey, we can blame the data center. It's all the data centers' fault. Well, again, they're not causing that much. It's kind of like uh um you know global warming. Yes, humans have an impact on global, it just isn't that big an impact. We don't have the capacity to compare to the sun to impact our own global warming. But that hasn't stopped people from using this mantra of

uh of data centers to uh not only demonize the data center, but in many cases, well, harm their own causes, harm their own communities by uh putting up roadblocks to places that would be be really great for data centers and bringing some jobs and and and some construction and some taxes, but oh no, because they've been convinced that data centers are causing their price hikes. Now, I did a little bit of research, and uh according to uh this is what the U.S.

Energy Information Administration in in California uh the uh uh the current electricity prices run about uh $100 per megawatt hour, right? And I'm I'm looking at, and again, it goes up and down, right? But uh you're talking, depending on where you are in California, between 50 and a hundred uh forty and a hundred megawatt a megawatt hour. Well, according to this study, you know how much a data center increased the uh uh the

the cost of that how the the cost compared to that price? About a buck and a half to two bucks of a megawatt hour. In other words, not nothing, but certainly not a huge percentage of what's going on. So why are people focusing on data centers? Well, again, it's something you can target. It's again there are there are a lot of things. You talk about California, of course, they have a lot of regulations that helps prevent them from putting new generation in, new distribution in. There's a lot of things

that are holding this up that are squeezing our ability to get power. And uh that is a lot of what's causing the energy price to rise. Data centers just seem to be the latest bet noir. So, again, when I talk about data centers, I say the biggest problem with the data center, the biggest impact of the community is the amount of power it consumes. And uh so what can we do to make sure that the infrastructure needed to power that data center is well covered by the

data center. Well, guess what? Uh uh uh X, they have their AI data centers, and they came up with an idea that says, hey, I know we'll put our own power generation in our data centers. Now again, you'd think that would help solve the problem, right? We're not we're not uh on the grid, we're not uh uh taking power from your generate our own power. Well, that apparently is not the case because there's a lawsuit of all people, the

NAACP um is suing XAI claiming that their self-powered data centers are polluting. Why? Well, they use gas turbines. Now, this this is for their Colossus II data centers, which are located in Whitehaven and Memphis, Tennessee. Um the according to the claims that there are a total of 27 gas turbines that uh can emit uh NO uh NO2 uh

nitrous oxide and various forms of nitrous oxide, and that uh that that can create smog. Now, XII said, listen, the this court this case should be thrown out because these portable gas turbines, right? Portable. These are not fixed places, therefore it's a mobile source of of pollutants. It does not fall under the Federal Clean Air Act. Clean air act deals with uh permanent uh uh

non-mobile forms of of pollution. And again, I've pointed out that the Clean Air Act is unconstituted, doesn't fall within the powers vested in the government of the United States, therefore, Congress had no authority to create this. It's a whole thing. But to me, this is again an interesting case because we're because we're dealing with these varying ideas on uh uh data centers. So we we don't want them sucking power from the grid. They I guess they wouldn't mind them being

self-powered as long as they got permission from the federal government to do so, which is the interesting question, because the federal government's trying to regulate um air pollution, which is something a power not vested to them in the constitution. Should it be in the federal government since so well, obviously air pollution uh crosses state lines? Probably, but then we'd have to amend the constitution to give that power to the United States, and in doing so, put limits and boundaries on what the federal government could actually do. That's why the 10th Amendment says a power not delegated

to the United States resides with the states or with the people. Not uh they can't simply make it up because they think it's a good idea. But here's the other part I find interesting. People love they love AI, they love their Alexas, their their Apple homes, their their sorry, Google homes, their Apple home pods. They love these AI systems, right? They love the the AI on their phones, they love the AI, uh the AI on their computers, they apparently love it because they keep using it, but they don't want the

data centers that are necessary for it to run. And again, data centers are not just for AI. Smartphones do not work without data centers, right? There's no there's no Netflix, there's no YouTube, there's no Facebook, there's no X without data centers. There's no iPhone, there's no Android phone, there are no tablets, they do not function without data centers. I I know a lot of people say, well, what do you mean? They literally do not function without data centers. So we're back in the same

thing we've said before. If we want these tools, then we have to have data centers. And if we're gonna have data centers, we have to have a way to power data centers. Well, how are we gonna power data centers? We don't want them on the grid because they have a moderate impact, a minor moderate impact on prices. We don't want them to have their own turbines unless they get uh permission from the federal government. Um, you know, we we want them, we just don't want them. We just don't want them in my backyard, which to me has been the biggest problem with the electrical grid from the beginning. Nobody wants the grid power lines, those

high-tension power lines, we don't want them in our backyard. But we want what they deliver. It's the same old thing. You know, you you you can have your phones, you can have your cheap power, you can have your your your your energy your renewable energy, just pick two of them. You cannot have all three. Physically, you cannot have all three. So what are we going to do? Are you willing to give up your smartphone? Are you willing to give up your your AI assistant, right? Your Siri, uh, your Alexa, are

you willing to give that up to save power? Are you willing to let them generate power? What if it wasn't a gas turbine? What if it was one of these new modular thorium reactors, right? A nuclear reactor, a little small size of a of a shipping container that could power a data center. Would would people be okay with that or would they find a reason to complain? Again, this has been going on, we saw it with with cars, we saw we've seen the complaints about the grid every time there's a hiccup, but

nobody seems to actually want to fix it. And that seems to be a mantra, isn't it? And we've said the same thing about the national debt basically my entire adult life. We know it's a problem, we know it's getting worse, we have to deal with it, but we just refuse to. Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare. We know that financially they are unstable, they are not soundly founded, and if they're going to continue, we have to do something, but we're unwilling to do

it. These are all examples of we want a fix, we're just not willing to actually do the fix. We're not willing to actually do what it takes to fix the problem. We can't either because we can't make a decision or we're unwilling to suffer the consequences of our decision. And that isn't just the price of electricity for your home. It's also whether or not the United States maintains its leading role in artificial

intelligence or whether we let other countries take over that role and all the the possible possibilities and benefits that come from it. There's a lot to consider. And I I think this this simplistic view of data center bad, data center's a problem, we get rid of data center, all problems go away. It doesn't match the reality. It doesn't match the evidence. And it's exactly the type of head in the sand, do it I'm told mentality that um I think has a

truly negative impact on not just data centers and not just that, but in so many aspects of our lives. So now that we no longer have the distraction, maybe that's not the right word. Uh yes, elections are important. Yes, voting is important. Voting wisely is important, but it also becomes a distraction where all the attention is focused on the elections and we forget about the rest of this of our of our lives. All right, that includes things like, yeah, the price of gas and and the

price of electricity and and where do we place these dentists' data centers? I think if we're saying we don't we're not gonna have any data centers, we are shooting ourselves in the foot. But to turn and say, wait a second, maybe where do we put these data centers? How do we provide power for these data centers? How do we do all of this? That, ladies and gentlemen, seems to be well, the more adult way of looking at this, the more adult way of dealing with these things. Again, not always easy, not always fun, not always comfortable, but well, that's part of being an adult.

As my daughter likes to say, you know, so adulting is hard. Yeah, it is. It's but it's what's required. And uh now maybe that the focus it's gonna take a few days, maybe a couple weeks, for all the news media to get all the vote again out of their system. But maybe we can start focusing on other things and things that well not only need our attention, not only need our focus, but need us to be the adults in the room to focus

on what's going on and to try to start solving some of these problems, getting ready for what's coming. Now, I have another topic to pick up uh after this break, but like I said, I gotta take this break. But if you're feeling hopeless, if you're looking at the uh the the direction this country has taken in the election, and you're looking at the the the socialists and the Marxists and the communists and the Islamists and and uh all these crazy ideas that have been shown to fail through history that well,

people keep bringing back up. Well, all is not lost. There is something you can do. You start by buying from companies that believe what you and I believe. See if when we stick together, when we do put America first in these discussions, well, we can make a difference. For example, I joined Patriot Mobile years ago, not because they're America's only Christian conservative wallet provider. That's nice, so that's not why I joined them. It's not for the great 4G and 5G coverage on all the same networks and towers as a major carriers. It's not even because their customer support is

100% US based. No, I joined them for two simple reasons. One, Patriot Mobile shares my values. They support organizations that are fighting for our constitutionally protected rights, freedom of religion, speech, press, to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures, even to not be denied to process. They also support the sanctity of life, our veterans, and our first responders. All great causes. But they do more. They put their money where their mouth is, because they take a portion of every dollar to support

organizations that are fighting for your rights. Join me at Patriot Mobile today, get free activation with the offer code Constitution. Just go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution and find a plan that works for you. Then use the promo code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. By the way, if you're one of those veterans, first responders, or members of some of these organizations, you could be eligible for a discount. Even families with multiple lines get discounts. So check it out at patriotmobile.com slash constitution. Find

a plan and discount that works for you, and then don't forget, use that code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. Not only do you get great cell phone service and great customer support, but you get to know that a portion of every dollar you spend with Patriot Mobile is used to support organizations like The Constitution Study that are defending your rights. And let's face it, is there anything else we we would need more than to support organizations that are defending our rights? Now, I also want to encourage you to head to AmericaOutloud.news. Now I go there

each and every day for news and information, and not just for the radio program or for my websites, but because there's good information out there. We live in the information age. We live where news is literally at our fingertips. I'm old enough to have lived through the days of newspapers where the best you could do is maybe once a day, maybe twice if you lived in an urban area to find out what the news is going. We can get access to all the news we want in our pockets, in our pocketbooks, in our in our hands. But where do

you go to get the news? That's important. It's out there, but you got to go find it. Now I look for places that I can trust and verify the work that they're doing, and one of those is AmericaOutloud.news. So please join me. Give it a try. Go to AmericaOutloud.news and check out the news and then do something with it. See, it's one thing to read the stories and articles. It's another to actually share them. And you'd be surprised how many people don't hear the news stories that you'll find on AmericaOut Loud.news. You listen to a podcast, you watch a

video and share that. And you'll be surprised how many people said, Oh, I never heard it discussed that way. I never saw it described that way or explained that way. It's the sharing of this information, the sharing of the news that corporate media doesn't want people to hear about, or that is done in a way that people understand that helps secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your

kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self-Reliance Revolution. Go

to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code Out Loud for an exclusive offer. Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, are you ready? Because your nose is about to break this breaking breakthrough on Blender.com.

Before your nose, this is not on the greatest spray in the universe. Breathe better. Live better. Are you struggling with thinning hair or excessive shedding? I know I am. Discover Roots from the Wellness Company. It's a doctor-formulated hydrogel with seven powerful peptides to help repair and restore visibly thicker, fuller hair. It also contains methylene blue, which boosts mitochondrial function and nourishes your scalp without any oily residue. Whether it's stress, hormones, or aging, this formula targets the root cause literally. Visit

twc.health forward slash outloud and use code outloud for 20% off your first order. That is twc.health forward slash outloud. Experience the science of hair regrowth with roots. Welcome back, everyday American JV. Join The Constitution Study. Today we're talking anything but elections. We're still mentioned. I mean, we know they happen and there's still people following up, but our focus is on things other than elections.

Because I don't know about you. I'm pretty tired of hearing about elections. So let's talk a little about one of my other favorite subjects, well, after the Constitution, that's the Second Amendment. That's bit arms. I'm an arms, I love arms. I think they're cool. And there's some uh they're they're they're cool, they're a great tool, and there's some interesting stories. We're going to start out in Massachusetts, where the state Supreme Court upheld a carry ban on adults under the age of 21.

See, according to the state's highest court, uh, if you're under 21 or uh uh you know you can't get a carry license, also uh they they took what they refer to as quote-unquote large capacity firearms, they claim is constitutional. Well, it it might actually be constitutional under the Constitution of Massachusetts, right? Where Article 17 reads, the people have a right to keep and bear arms for the common defense. And as in times of peace, armies are dangerous to liberty, they ought not to be maintained without the consent of the

legislature, and the military power shall always be held in an exact exact subordination to the civil authority and be governed by it. So let's break this out. The people of Massachusetts have a right to keep and bear arms for the common defense. Now that's very interestingly worded because it says the only right reason you have to get is for common defense. Well, if you wish to carry a firearm, that's usually for individual defense. So the the the con the Supreme Court

of Massachusetts may have a point there with one truly serious caveat, and that is well, the Constitution of the United States is the supreme law of the land, Article 6, Clause 2, and the Constitution of the Supreme of the United States says under the Second Amendment uh that a well-regulated militia is necessary to the security of free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. So, yes, a as as the Massachusetts, they both recognize that the the a military, whether it

be an army, a militia, that in time of peace they can be dangerous of liberty, but they are important for a state's liberty. Uh, that's why in Massachusetts you're not supposed to have armies except with the consent of the legislature and under the uh subordinate to civil authority, absolutely. But it still says that they have a right to keep and bear arms. Now it says the people. It doesn't say the adults, it says the people. Now, looking at at the free legal dictionary,

I find that people means the aggregate of the individuals who comprise a state or a nation. In a more restricted sense, as generally used in constitutional law, the entire body of those citizens of a state or a nation who are invested with political power for political purposes. So uh okay, um so the people are the entire body of the citizens. What's interesting is it also says the qualified voters, which means if that's the case, and the general de general qualified

is a qualified voter, um someone 18 years old is able to vote, but you're saying they can't exercise their right to keep and bear arms protected by the constitutions of both Massachusetts and the United States. See, this is why it's important that we the people hold our elected officials accountable. Because what you have is you have a uh a court system that ignores the law that they don't like. Now, maybe that's the the common understanding of the people of Massachusetts.

Now, I'm certainly I know you know out in the especially out in the Boston area, uh, they are much less likely to be gun enthusiasts. They are much more interested in controlling gun owners, and maybe as a percentage of the population, that is that's the will of the people. But that's why we are a constitutional republic, not simply a democracy. The will of the people alone does not rule. We have constitutions that set boundaries, and the only way to change

those constitutions is with a supermajority of the people agreeing to it. Or in the case of the Constitution of the United States, a supermajority of the states agreeing to it. So uh, yeah, once again, you're living in Massachusetts, they're not interested in your rights if you're under 21. And the this definition of large capacity, which is again, how do you define large? Large is a relative thing, not a specific thing. And um, especially when you have firearms that come with a standard 30-round magazine, how do you suddenly call

that large? No, that's it's regular magazine. While we're in New England, let's head up to Maine, uh, where, well, let's see, a the Maine passed a law that requires a 72-hour waiting period on all firearm transfers, meaning you can legally own the firearm. You have every legal right to own the firearm, but you can't actually possess the firearm for three days after you've purchased it. The logic behind this being, well, you know, somebody might be uh in

a bad mood and they want to do something horrible, so they got to buy a gun to do this. Kind of ignores the fact that if someone's gonna use a firearm to do something bad, they probably already own a firearm. But we're talking logic and reason. We can't have that. Um, so that was the law passed in Maine. Now, a district judge issued an injunction in the case Beckwith versus Fry. That's a case challenging the constitutionality of the waiting period, denying someone their right to keep

and bear arms for a period of time without a good justifiable reason, uh, which is, by the way, not only deprivation of rights, it's also deprivation of liberty and property without due process of law, which also violates the constitution. But that's, you know, that's me. Well, the district judge issued the injunction, the first circuit court of appeals overturned the injunction. Well, not the whole court, the a panel overturned it. They said that uh the law doesn't implicate the second amendment at all as

merely a condition on the sale of firearms. But again, the second amendment doesn't say if you have to to purchase firearms, which is it's part of keeping and bearing them. But again, what is the what is the reason to deny someone the right to purchase a firearm and own it immediately and have rather than having to wait three days? So this challenge went up to the Supreme Court of the United States, which denied certiori. Now, for those of you who aren't aware, the Supreme Court gets thousands of petitions to

hear cases every year. And they only take uh generally, I think, between 60 and 80. So the the the request for the the Supreme Court to hear a case is called a writ of certior, a petition for a writ of certiority, which is you're asking the Supreme Court to issue a writ that says we're gonna take this case. And um the Supreme Court, uh, unless it's their primary jurisdiction as defined by the Constitution of the United States, isn't required to take the case. See, under Article III, uh section

two, we see that in all cases affecting ambassadors, other public ministers and councils, and those in which a state shall be a party, the Supreme Court shall have original jurisdiction. Now, this is again, that sounds interesting to me because apparently Mr. Beckwith didn't sue the state of Massachusetts, he sued one of the officers. So the state is not a party, so it's not original jurisdiction to the Supreme Court of the United States. Therefore, they're not required to take the case, it's an appeal, and that's they're asking for search here, and

it didn't go and it failed. Now, a lot of Second Amendment folk are not thrilled with it, but uh they really shouldn't be surprised because I look at this and it you know, first of all, the case the the courts tend to want to see cases that have actually been through the courts. In other words, this is just a a question about a an injunction, and um you know they they if it's gonna be an injunction, there's got to be a really good reason for it. So the the the the case isn't done, right? The the case still is being heard. Uh the it's it'll be heard

at the district court, probably go to the uh uh court of appeals uh for the first circuit, and then and maybe then uh will be heard by the Supreme Court. But this is a preliminary injunction. Uh no, they they don't have the injunction that you still in Maine have to wait 72 hours to exercise a right protected by the Constitution of the United States. Meanwhile, in the U.S. District for Western New York, uh a judge for the district court uh basically struck down New York State's ban on the

sale and purchase of body armor, claiming that, well, again, body armor um is encompassed by this Second Amendment and the right to keep and bear arms. Now, how could that be? You know, when we think of arms, we think of what most people tend to think of firearms, but we then tend to think of weapons. But if we go back to uh Webster's 1828 dictionary, remember Noah Webster was a contemporary of the Founding Fathers. Uh, he compiled his uh dictionary, he compiled his his spellers

during that time, which he eventually published as a um as a dictionary, which he published in 1828. Arms are defined as weapons of offense and armor for defense and protection of the body. So if you're wearing body armor, that is an that is literally armor for defense and protection of the body, it falls under the state of arms as was understood by the drafters of the Bill of Rights. Therefore, that falls under the Second Amendment. And as this judge found, and

I uh that yes, it does fall under the second amendment, therefore, people have a right to keep and bear arms. That includes body armor for the protection of the body. Now, while I look at uh Mr. Webster and a contemporary of the time, this judge, a uh John Sinatra, uh, he pointed to two Supreme Court decisions uh in 2008 and 2022, saying that arms at the time of the founding of the United States would have included protective armor.

As he wrote in his decision, the state's body armor ban violates the plain text of the Second Amendment, and the nation's historical traditions have not permitted such a uh curtailment of the right to keep and bear arms. Restriction character violates the rights of individuals to keep and bear arms for self-defense. So, okay, uh, I guess you know, we've got uh two decisions that didn't go a second amendment way. We had one that did. Uh, you know, well, that's the way the the cookie

crumbles. But it from a Second Amendment standpoint, from someone who listen, I've been around guns my entire life. When I was a small child, you know, my father had guns in the house. And I was taught from a very young age to be to to at first don't touch the guns, right? I was more afraid of my father finding out that I touched the guns and punishing me than I was any other thing. So uh I didn't touch the guns. And um, when I was old enough, my father taught me how to properly and safely handle the guns, how

to use the guns. I've been around guns my entire life. I, you know, the the fact that we can that that we can keep and bear arms, not just own them, but carry them for our own defense, or the defense of others, it to me is one of the more important rights bestowed or protected by the Constitution on the people in the United States. And it's one that uh I think a lot of pla a lot of of uh governments don't like for the very simple reason uh that our founding fathers reminded us that uh, well, in

in order for tyranny to rule, the people must first be disarmed. And uh it seems like it's a lot of the tyrannical governments that are interested in disarming us. So there you go. We got uh some basic topics that uh didn't involve the uh recent election. Uh I of course I can't say I didn't mention it, but they didn't involve that. And uh hopefully this break from election news uh was as as uh was as welcome to you as it was to

me. This idea that uh every that we live by the election, we die by the we live by the government, we die by the government is um well to me it's problematic, but it's something that we only change when we the people get down to the fundamental understanding of the Supreme Law of the Land, the reading and studying of the law and the recognition that we the people are sovereign, not the federal government, not your state government. We are sovereign. We hire people to represent us. And

um, that's to me an important truth that I think needs to be spread a lot more widely than it currently is. Speaking of truth, I want to let you remind you that I've got a new program I'm doing with a friend of mine by the name of Bo Gill. It's called Truth with Teeth. We sit down and we discuss topics of uh think looking at the truth and trying to put some teeth behind them. Uh, you can find us on YouTube and Rumble, uh, Facebook, uh, X, Instagram. Just look for Truth with Teeth. You can also find us

at our website, truthwithteeth.us. Uh, we're trying, we're just getting started. We've only got a couple videos out, but um take a look at them and please comment on those. Let us know what if there's a topic you would like us to discuss. Uh, we are based here in Bedford County, Tennessee, but we look at it state, local, and national news. So take a look, check it out, truth with teeth.us. Uh comment, let us know what you think. Let us know what topics you would like us to see. Let us know what you think about the program. It's it's

really just kind of a a couple of guys sitting around talking about it. We're using our expertise to try and put some teeth behind the truth. And uh, who knows if you like it? We may expand it to more topics more frequently. And we've even discussed going live with the program, but that really's gonna depend on how you react to it. What do you think about it? Let us know. Again, truthwithteeth.us is the website. Find us on Rumble, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, X, and uh

just search for and and check us out. Let us know what you think. Now, I also hope you'll check continue to check out The Constitution Study on America Out Loud Talk Radio heard on the iHeartRadio Network every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern time. Now you can listen to us on our media player on the website. We've also got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. And yes, all the episodes go to podcasts a day or two after they're heard on Talk Radio, which means you get to listen in your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the

show. Go to Apple Podcasts and leave us a rating because it really helps with the algorithm. Right? The algorithm looks at the number of subscribers, the number of four-star and five-star reviews, when it figures out where to sort us when people are searching for this type of content. So by subscribing and leaving us a good rating, well, you're more likely to more people are likely to see The Constitution Study, see the links, click on the links, and join us here for the program. Now, speaking of links, you can find all the links you need at the homepage at

americaoutloud.news. But the best thing you can do is to share those links, to share this program, to let other people know the type of content we're putting out here. See, by sharing this content, by sharing what we're doing here, letting other people know there's a place to get constitutionally sound content and to learn and ask questions from a constitutional standpoint, you're not just sharing The Constitution Study, but you're helping to share the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation home. home.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What to expect as socialism grows in America

    Nov 20, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Expect more and more cognitive dissonance as people ignore the history of socialism and believe the marketing campaign behind it. Ignore the lives lost in socialist...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The fundamental flaw in America’s gun control laws

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Laws about depriving people of their rights due to conviction of non-violent felonies have been in court lately, and Massachusetts and other states have tried to ban...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court packing, impeachment, and the race to act before January

    Nov 18, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Changes are coming, some coming soon. In January, leadership of both houses of Congress will shift to Democratic leaders. What preparations are being made? People are once...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Are we a nation of laws or ruled by judges?

    Nov 15, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - Does a court ruling settle what the Constitution means? Judicial supremacy raises questions about jury trials, agency powers, eminent domain, and gun rights. At stake is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. After the midterms: More of the same, with a left turn

    Nov 14, 202657 minAudio

    The Constitution Study with Host Paul Engel - I expect Congress to hold more investigations, kangaroo courts, and impeachment threats. Pretty much the same, just pointed at Republicans rather than Democrats. I also...

    Credit the people on this episode