ALIENS OVER MANHATTAN! In 1989, Linda Napolitano claimed three extraterrestrials floated her right out of her apartment window and into a UFO hovering over New York City. According to UFO Investigator Budd Hopkins 23 witnesses saw something that night but secret agents, a mysterious political VIP, hypnosis, alien implants and conflicting stories soon turned Linda’s incredible tale into one of ufology’s most controversial cases. The Henchmen tackle the Brooklyn Bridge Alien Abduction: was Linda really taken…or were we all taken for a ride? Tune In to Find Out! Want more terrifying abduction stories? Buy Nightmare Alley: Fearsome Accounts of Alien Abduction by Timothy Green Beckley available now on ConspiracyJournal.com and amazon. Support the show If you've seen or experienced anything unexplainable call us at the Strange Exchange +1 (929) 445-3705 we want to hear about it!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
BobbyThe transmission starts now. Yeah, this is the Conspiracy Journal Podcast. You came to the right place if you were looking for the Conspiracy Journal podcast.
MichelleI was looking for the Conspiracy Journal podcast. I'm so happy to be here. My name is Michelle.
BobbyYou did a great job, Michelle. Bobby. My name is Bobby. Bobby's my name is Bobby. Bobby, Michelle. I'm Greg. What's up, Greg? Hey.
MichelleWhat are we doing?
BobbyToday we are talking about the Brooklyn Bridge UFO alien abduction. Brooklyn Bridge Alien Abduction, I think, is the party line. It's changed a little bit. There's a recent documentary that kind of gave it a different name, but it colloquially for a long time was known as the Brooklyn Bridge Alien Abduction. And this story is man, it's all over the damn place. You know, it's it's very hard to tell in a linear fashion, so I'm I'm I'm not gonna attempting to tell it.
BobbyAttempting to tell in a linear fashion is like you're just gonna miss a lot of stuff and uh a lot of parts you wouldn't understand.
MichelleSo of course, yeah.
BobbyAnyways, this is yeah, it was a real it was a real doozy to research this one. So to to start to kind of understand it, we're gonna start talking about a guy named Bud Hopkins. Bud Bud Hopkins, who was pretty big time in in the UFO world for a long time. Bud was born in Wheeling, West Virginia, starts a drawing as a kid, goes to art school, moves to New York City, and becomes a really well-established artist in the abstract expressionist world. So we're kind of in the 1960s.
BobbyAt this point, he's got a serious professional career. He's in a lot of galleries, his work is in the Met, in MoMA, the British Museum. He's doing great. No big deal. He's a a great artist. I have a question. Go ahead.
MichelleIs his name Bud? Like, is that his born name, Bud?
BobbyNo, his his born name, his born name is Elliot, which is also that's also his dad's name.
MichelleSure.
BobbySo oftentimes a junior will get a little nickname like that.
MichelleYeah, yeah, yeah.
BobbyIt's Bud with two D's, double D.
MichelleCute.
BobbyBud Double D.
MichelleSo do you think he was just like Buddy? Yeah. Like, hey, buddy.
BobbyYeah. Yeah. That's probably like what his father called him or something.
MichelleThat is so cute. I love him.
BobbyYeah. I don't, I I don't know off the top of my head, but I don't think that's his given middle name. But that that's what everybody calls him. Buddy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Love it.
BobbyUm, so yeah, he's doing great as an artist. He's in the scene, he's doing the thing. His work's pretty good. I looked it up. Like it's it's like, yeah, that's good, that's good art. It's I mean, it's abstract expressionism, so it's pretty open to interpretation of whether or not it's good, but you can tell he's he's uh knows what he's doing as an artist for sure. Well this is happening, he takes a fun, fun romp to Cape Cod with some friends in 1964, and he sees something weird out there. Yeah, he sees the UFO.
BobbyWhat? And he's like, What's that about? Yeah.
GregSo this is like the first of many UFOs he's encountered.
BobbyYeah, this this kind of kicks it off for him. And I don't know, maybe at some point we will we will do a full episode about Bud Hopkins, which you could easily do. This is not that, this is about this one specific encounter. Um, I mean, we can talk about them as much as we can. Let's talk about as much as you want.
MichelleBut this is the problem with research for this podcast is every single time you start a story, within the first 10 minutes of your research, you could already have a full other story. And so depending on where you decide to go in that moment is gonna determine what episode you're doing first.
BobbyFor sure. And and and I mean, this is the story will introduce Linda here shortly, but this is a story about Bud and Linda. So we're gonna get a lot of Bud. We'll get plenty of Bud.
MichelleI already love Bud. Dude, so Betty and Barney Hill also met in Cape Cod. Was there some like crazy Cape Cod UFO experience happening around the 50s and the 60s?
GregSounds like yes. Okay. There's a conspiracy all in Cape Cod. Yeah. There's there has to be. Yeah.
MichelleLet's go there and research.
BobbyAbsolutely. Okay, yeah. Sounds great.
MichelleOkay.
GregYeah. We'll take a little vacation to Cape Cod and Oh, we're doing research.
MichellePause this episode. Everybody stop. We're going to Cape Cod. We'll be back.
BobbyGet on the bus. We're going to Cape Cod. Yep.
GregAnd we're back from Cape Cod.
MichelleIt was a wonderful, uh little outing. Quaint little town.
BobbyTons of UFOs. Those nothing but UFOs there. Yep. And so that's kind of how Bud felt. And he sees the UFO out there and he starts researching it. And UFOs slowly takes over more and more of his life until that becomes his main thing. Right. Kind of takes over the art thing. Meaning like he doesn't. Yeah.
MichelleYeah. Meaning like he stops doing art and he's just obsessed with UFOs, or his art becomes UFOs or both.
BobbyUh I don't know if he stopped doing art, but researching UFOs, sightings, and the like becomes his primary focus. Yeah. Oh, I see.
GregSo I thought maybe like his paintings or something became UFO really.
BobbyI didn't deep dive into his whole art catalog, but I did not see in the art that I looked at any kind of UFO specific. But I mean, again, it's abstract expressionists. So he he might be like, they're all UFOs. Yeah, totally.
MichelleEverything's an alien.
BobbyThere are a lot of circles and lines and stuff. Yeah.
GregSo he has like an agent that is like, you know something? These UFOs really aren't hitting. And he's just like makes them all weird and abstract. We love these. Yeah.
BobbyYeah. That's kind of, I mean, abstract expressionism. You can kind of say it's whatever you want it. That's right. You know?
MichelleArt is in the eye of the beholder.
BobbyThat's right. And so he gets very into UFOs. It becomes his main focus, his deal. And in that process of it becoming his main deal, he really shifts to the specific abduction side of things. That becomes his forte, and that's what he's researching and what he's into. In 1981, he publishes a book called Missing Time. In 1987, he publishes a book called Intruders, in which he argues that people experience abductions without consciously remembering them.
BobbyBut kind of in the place of that, they experience Missing Time, title of the book. Strange dreams, unexplained fears, phobias, fragmented memories. So a lot of this weird stuff happens to the mind. And so part of this establishes support groups for abductees where they compare their experiences and look for patterns.
MichelleSo wait, if I am one of these people, do I remember an experiencer? Is it because like listen, I have unexplained fears and I'd be having a bad night's sleep, but I never got abducted. Or did I just forget that I got abducted and my fears and things that I experience as a human person are actually because of aliens? Okay.
GregI'm curious about that because you always hear about people that are vaguely in pieces remembering abductions. I want to know how many people have been abducted that go their entire life without remembering they have been.
MichelleYeah. What if we all got abducted and we don't even know it?
BobbyWhat you both just talked about is is this story. Oh.
GregYou are intro in the episode. I'm a psychic.
BobbyBud has these support groups for these abductees and he's getting all these stories. Um, and he he starts to understand that extraterrestrials can suppress or interfere with memory. He's seeing these parallels in these different stories. And then he's like, What if I hypnotize these people?
MichelleYeah, fuck yeah.
BobbyNo formal psychological training? No problem.
MichelleNo, who is it? No problem. Oh, we need a little pendulum. Yeah. That's it. Watch it on TV. Yeah.
BobbyYeah. So he's got his he's got hundreds of subjects, you know, these people from support groups, and they're they're like, Yeah, let's get into it. So he uses hypnotic regression to recover suppressed memories. Of course. In these people who were abducted. Yeah. Which is a therapist hypnotizes somebody and then helps them, helps them quote unquote remember events buried in their subconscious. That's kind of in a nutshell, that's what hypnotic regression is.
GregYou might be getting into this, but at any point did these people or subjects of his know that that's what was about to happen? Like was it possible that he was implanting ideas into them and they're just kind of recurgitating it back?
BobbySome of his detractors would would say that. Okay, so yeah, as as he gained in notoriety, uh you know naturally there are more eyes on him and and more skeptics. And so, yeah, people did have those questions. Are you leading these people right handing these things? Um, the power of suggestion is is strong.
GregLike if you're going in thinking that, like, oh, this study is on um regressed memories of UFOs, then you're probably going to be if you're wanting to be part of it, you're probably going to give them what they want.
BobbyWell, in and most of his subjects are from his like UFO support groups. There, yeah.
GregSo I'm just I'm acting as a skeptic. I'm not saying I I don't believe in anything that is about to be told to us, but yeah, I'm just like looking at it from a point of view of uh, I guess just devil's advocating it.
BobbyNo, totally. And and there was skepticism from within the community, because this abduction is quite is very different than sighting. You know, so there's these it it kind of gets lumped under the umbrella of ufology or uophology, depending on how you want to say it.
MichelleTomato toma.
BobbyThat's right. Uh but it but it is a very different, very specific thing, and and the the skepticism of abductions is much heavier than it is of sightings. You know, people are much more willing to believe a sighting, it's much harder to challenge a sighting.
SPEAKER_03Sure.
BobbySo yeah, that it definitely gets brought up. The are you planting seeds? Are you suggesting these things?
MichelleIs Bud doing the hypnotizing himself? Sure. Or sure, okay, of course.
BobbyYeah, okay. And I mean, there's there's tons of video footage of this. We'll get into uh his wife Carol later. Carol was a filmmaker. So there's a there was a woman around with a video camera for a lot of this stuff. So you see, yeah, he's like in people's houses, they're in his house, maybe. Like there's all all these different settings. And yeah, Bud's like next to a bed hypnotizing a person or or with a person under hypnosis. He's asking him questions. And does he have like a metronome or anything?
BobbyHe doesn't, unfortunately. But maybe, I mean, these are all all the clips I saw were like mid session. Okay. So I didn't get to see the start necessarily. I hope so.
MichelleI hope so too. You know? Yeah.
BobbyYeah. Yep. He's got an old pocket watch.
MichelleSo he's just Yep, that's what I want.
BobbyYeah. Um, and so through running these groups and his hypno hypnotic sessions, he's like, wait a minute. I think there might be an organized extraterrestrial biologic genetic hybrid program.
MichelleOf course.
BobbyWhich control. Yeah. Yeah. I was like, I don't see how you could not get.
MichelleI can't believe he's the first person to think of this.
BobbyYeah, exactly. Exactly.
MichelleSo give it to me again.
BobbyUh just an organized extraterrestrial biological genetic hybrid program. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Totally. Um, which is aliens are abducting us, doing some experiments. Sex experiments. That's right. Okay.
BobbyI'm sure I'm not the per first person to say that, but I did come up with it on my own when I was researching. So they're doing some sex experiments and create, yeah, creating uh alien human hybrids.
MichelleRight.
BobbySo that's that's part of what is going on, and they're suppressing the memories of the people that this happens to. Enter Linda Napolitano. Linda, Linda, I love Linda. Linda is a New York lady, dude. She is she's born and raised in Little Italy.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyAnd she's just like now, present-day New York, you have to go to Staten Island or like Deep Queens to find this lady. But she was they used they were just there. Really? They were just there right now. New Yorkers used to live in Manhattan. It's not not that way necessarily anymore. But Linda is a New York lady through and through. Uh she worked as a singer and model when she was younger under the name Lynn Long. She had some success, had a record deal with Mercury Records. You can look up her songs, they're on YouTube. You can check them out. Not bad.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyUm, but eventually.
MichelleWas she a babe?
BobbyYeah, for sure.
MichelleOkay, cool. Linda.
BobbyAnd so I think the the music and modeling thing, like for a lot of people, you have a little bit of success, but not quite enough. So as she gets a little bit older, and she's also got a Catholic mom who's like, you gotta get married, you gotta have babies, and so she kind of decides to go that route. So she gives up the entertainment side of her life, gets married, starts a family. Her and her husband Steve, two sons, living in a little apartment in Little Italy, just blocks from where she grew up. So she's working as uh executive secretary, pretty ordinary mom, pretty regular, regular life, just doing the thing.
BobbyIn April 1989, Linda reads Bud's book, Intruders.
MichelleUh-oh.
BobbyAnd immediately in the first chapter, she's like, wait a damn minute.
MichelleOh shit, this happened to me.
BobbyThis happened to me. I have been abducted.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyAnd so there's just things in the description in the book that that she's like, This is so familiar to me. There's another woman in the book that's recounting her experience, and it's just bringing these things back to Linda's memory. And so Linda, Linda calls Bud and she's like, I think this happened to me. Bud starts to interview her in conducting his hypnotic regression sessions. These are on tape. And then they're scissoring. Sorry, it's experiments.
unknownYeah.
MichelleThey sex experiment at me, Bud.
BobbyYeah, well, you know, I we don't know that that's true, but maybe, you know, we'll we'll touch on that later. Okay.
MichelleOkay. Did we get a DNA test for her sons?
BobbyWell, I not to my knowledge. Okay. Not to my knowledge. I think when I think she had the sons before she met Bud.
MichelleRight, but when did she get experimented on?
BobbyWell, that yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. She met a DNA test to see if they're aliens, not not Bud's kids. I got you.
MichelleYes, that's what I meant. I didn't, I didn't, I was not accusing Bud of being the father of these children. I was accusing aliens of being the father of these children.
BobbyMy bad.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyUm so she starts this uh, you know, kind of, I guess for lack of a better term, this working relationship with with Bud. And so they're working together to discover Linda's repressed memories about these abductions. And so she recalls an encounter, I think from like 13 years prior, uh, sometime in the in the 70s, of small extraterrestrials inserting something into her nose and like having a nose bleed. There's a little bit of around the nose thing, a little bit of conflicting information.
BobbySo I wasn't able to get like all of the facts of it. But it does seem to be that uh Linda was abducted and like a little device was implanted under her nose.
GregUm I've seen that before where it's like in the like the crease of like the nose between nose and the face, like right in like that area is kind of where like these small like rice size implants get put in. Exactly.
BobbyOh and so there, like there were some images of like some x-ray images of like a thing in there, but I think that those were maybe like this is what it might have looked like and not actual x-rays. But she did go to the doctor and they did do x-rays, and a doctor did find this weird uh this area where the cartilage had like grown around there was nothing in there at that point, but where cartilage had grown around something in her nose that was like an anomaly.
GregUm like what your body would do to like any like foreign object or something where it's trying to expel it or like kill it.
BobbyExactly. So uh I like to think that the aliens inserted a device and then she's working with Bud and kind of is like, oh shit, I think they put something up my nose, and then the aliens were like, shit, we gotta get it out. Yeah, and so they go take it out. Yeah, I think it's a good idea. And then she goes to the doctor and they're like, There's nothing there, but there was something there.
MichelleThat's what happened. It's very X-files, yeah, yeah, totally.
BobbyTotally. So this uh this nasal implant thing is a pretty big part of this story, which we're we're just getting started on with with with Bud and Linda and what's going on. So about 3 a.m. November 30th, 1989, she first contacted Bud in April of 1989. Linda is in her Manhattan apartment, she becomes aware. She just gets she was just done saying her prayers. I don't know what she's up to until 3 o'clock in the morning. Go to bed, Linda.
BobbyYou know? Yeah, but she's going to bed about 3 a.m. Just got done saying her prayers, and she notices these like small little grays, these little extraterrestrials at the foot of her bed.
MichelleAliens. Yeah. Full on in the room.
BobbyIn the room, yeah.
GregShe's in the room, she's in bed. I think that's more than a notice. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Hey, wait a minute. Yeah, yeah. I don't I don't remember seeing you there earlier.
BobbySo she she throws she throws a pillow at him.
GregOf course.
BobbyShe's like, it was a heavy ass pillow. I made it myself. It might have been filled with rocks. This is what she said.
MichelleSo she didn't say that.
BobbyYeah, yeah, she did. Absolutely did. There's videotape of her saying there's a lot of there's a lot of video of Linda recounting these stories. So uh so she throws her pillow at the extraterrestrial.
MichelleHer rock pillow, her pillow full of rocks didn't work.
BobbyNo, they were still there. Okay, yep. And so they she kind of recounts like um being lifted up. She says maybe like a machine or little tiny fists hitting her back with a little bit jump like a little massage, like or like a little extraterrestrial. I was like punching.
MichelleYeah, you know, but you ever sit in like the airport, one of those massage chairs. I was there this morning.
BobbyGo to the airport just for that.
MichelleYeah, don't even have a flight. I have seen Bobby in the airport just sitting in the massage chairs. Little little tiny fist just hitting you. You gotta do something with your life. Next time I do one of those, I'm just gonna envision little alien hands.
BobbyThat's what they're inside the chair.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyYou know, that's that's what's going on.
MichelleThat's what is going on, that's how they work.
BobbySo these three little ETs they float Linda out of her 12th floor window on a blue beam of light. So boom, outside of the apartment. She's in a long, flowy white nightgown.
SPEAKER_03Cute.
BobbyAnd she's carried upward toward a large glowing reddish-orange craft accompanied by these three little creatures.
MichelleIn the sky.
BobbyIn the sky.
MichelleAbove Manhattan, above little Italy.
BobbyThat's right. That's exactly right.
GregNot to cut you off. I'm I'm just maybe misremembering something, but I'm almost certain I know the story. Um, and this is where like the police are involved.
MichelleUm my god, no spoilers, Greg.
GregNo, no, I just want to make sure, like, I'm because I'm I might be thinking of something else, and like I'm just attaching police and quotation marks.
BobbyRight. But I believe you are thinking of the right story.
GregAnd like one sees it. Okay, yeah. Just go on, yeah.
MichelleSo the police see the okay. Don't tell me. Yeah, yeah.
BobbySo I thought it was interesting. Some of the depictions uh of this reddish-orange craft were pretty similar to the craft uh that was described in Travis Walton's experience.
SPEAKER_03Oh, organic sky.
BobbyKind of organic, kind of lava-y with the the thing opening up. I just thought that was an interesting parallel. So she gets up there, she's in the craft, it moves away towards the Brooklyn Bridge. Um, the aliens, they're communicating with her telepathically, and they tell her to shut up in a foreign language. So somehow she like they they speak in a foreign language, right? And she knows that they are telling her to shut up.
MichelleOkay.
BobbySo someone's like I said, she's a New York lady. Yeah. Okay. She's letting them giving them what for. Yeah. You know.
MichelleAnd also sometimes shut up is universal, you know, like you don't need the actual words. You know.
BobbyYou know what they want.
GregLike 3 a.m. in Manhattan, though, someone had to have seen a craft, right?
BobbyYeah, we'll get to that for sure. Um, so they telepathically communicate with her. Shut up, Linda. They're move towards the bridge, and then the next thing she knows, she's falling. Oh no. She she often recounts she's falling from two inches or two feet. She's not sure.
MichelleInto the East River?
BobbyInto her bed next to Steve.
MichelleWeird.
BobbyShe falls back down into her bed next to Steve.
MichelleI know what she means about two inches or two feet or whatever. You ever like fall off a curb? Yeah. You know what I mean? Like that feeling.
BobbyMiscount the steps.
MichelleYeah, yeah.
GregMissing a step is exactly what I was thinking.
BobbyIt's like, oh, you fell six inches, but you almost died. Yeah. Yeah.
MichelleYeah. So that that part's legit.
BobbyYeah. And so, yeah, her senses are pretty wild or out of whack at that stage. And so then the next morning she calls Bud. She's like, But they took me. They took me again. You know, they they came and got me. Bud is like, goodness gracious, great balls of fire. I can't believe this is happening. Like, let's I'm on my way. Yeah, I'm on my way. Um, and and so that is something that is different about this case, uh, at least initially at this time, is that there is a claim of outside witnesses in but. He says that he identified 23 people who were witnesses to various portions of this event.
BobbyYeah.
MichelleShut up.
BobbyYeah. 23 people saw various portions of this event. And they witnessed different pieces. Some people saw some weird lights in the sky. Some people saw the UFO. Some people saw a single person floating. Some people saw the whole crew. Linda plus her three little friends floating up. And then some people reported the ever ambiguous strange activity near near the apartment. Sure. So it's unclear of what that was, but certainly altogether. Some some weird stuff going on. So yeah, a lot of people did see things happen.
MichelleI feel like 23 people is not enough people. 23 people to me in New York City means they're lying. It needs to be like 2300 people.
GregI don't know. I think for a story like this, 23 is like more than you would normally get.
MichelleAbsolutely. And that's why it's a lie. That's why it's suspicious.
BobbyWell, so many of these people, and then this is some issues that people have with this later. Many of these people remain anonymous, use pseudonyms, they're communicate these confirmations, these sightings through letters, phone calls, tapes in the mail. This is 89 that we're talking. So it makes public public verification of these corroborating statements difficult. I'm sure you guys have had these experiences in researching a lot of the stories that we research, you're like partway into it.
BobbyAnd then like the the writer or filmmaker will drop a like, now here's where it gets strange. Oh yeah. I think we're already in the strange territory, but like here's where it gets strange.
MichelleYeah. Maybe. Okay.
BobbyIn in 1991, Bud gets a letter from two men calling themselves Richard and Dan.
GregYeah.
BobbyOkay.
GregOkay.
BobbyThis is this is what I'm saying.
MichelleThis is Greg's cops.
BobbyAnd so, yeah, Richard and Dan initially are like, we're New York City police officers. And we saw the subduction from our car underneath the FDR. Bud's like, tell me more.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyVia letter, apparently.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyAnd they're like, look, Bud, Buddy, Bud, we're actually running security for a very high-level VIP, is what we're what we were up to. We're driving this person who shall remain nameless. We're taking them to the Helo pad down in Lower Manhattan. Our car breaks down under the FDR. They witness, they see a person floating out of the window. And Bud's like, that's my friend Linda.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyAnd Richard and Dann is like, the VIP saw it as well. And Bud's like, that's great. I'm actually writing a book. And they're like, we can't tell you who it is. But if you try to figure it out, then you can then maybe you could figure it out. And Bud's like, I'm gonna figure it out.
MichelleOkay.
BobbySo they're like, it's a major international political figure who would have had security personnel and would have been in Manhattan that night.
GregIs this information that they're saying to him? Yeah, I like that they're trying to like tease him into who it could possibly be. Like, if here are some clues, and it's like a weird game show that he has to figure out now.
BobbyIt it it is it's so strange, but like also not not like not that uncommon with like journalism where they're like, we're gonna give you a nugget, but like we I'm not gonna confirm, I'm not gonna tell you, but I'll give you some clues. And I don't know, maybe it's like their job as as security that if you know somebody comes back or they're subpoenaed that they can say under oath that they never said who this person was or something like that.
MichelleThis part of the story, I believe. Sure.
BobbyYeah, yeah. So they're like, it's a major political figure, you figure it out. But fast forward to Bud at the 1992 MUFON presentation. Bud's there, he's speaking at the conference. He's talking about Linda's case. Bud says, We know the identity of the third man. That's what we started to call him. I received a letter from him signed to the third man. I've been able to check on his identity in another way, and it's clear beyond a shadow of a doubt. And Hopkins, Bud, eventually discloses that the person was Javier Perez de Quilar, then Secretary General of the UN, is who they were escorting in his book Witnessed.
BobbyBut also he tells about there was a time where a reporter had arranged an interview with Perez d'Equilar in uh during a layover at Chicago O'Hare. Uh, and Bud sneak attacks him. Bud goes there and sneak attacks him. He's like, What about that UFO you saw? And Perez d'Equilar is like cagey, and he's like, I don't know what you're talking about. And Bud's like, that's exactly what someone who saw a UFO book would say.
MichelleAnd then he's like, fucking P.S. Tell Linda to call me.
BobbyYeah, and like, so yeah, Bud's on some gotcha shit with this guy like surprise, motherfucker.
MichelleThat's exactly what someone was saying.
BobbyYeah, and I mean that that kind of is he's Bud's like, I could tell from the way that he reacted that he knew about the incident. Oh, yeah.
GregYou scared the shit out of him at an airport.
BobbyThat was Bud's interpretation. He knew Vanity Fair contacts Perez Dickwilar. He's an international politician, like he's a very famous dude. Um they contact him in 2012. He claims he does not remember being questioned by Hopkins, cannot definitively confirm or deny the claims due to the passage of time. But I don't know if you if you if you're a politician at that time and you drop a can't confirm or deny about a UFO story.
MichelleThat's a confirmation. Right. Yeah.
BobbyThat's like that's not a no. Yeah. Why would you just not be like, I don't know what you're talking about?
MichelleYeah. Is he saying that he cannot confirm confirm nor deny that that uh bud assaulted him in the airport? Or is he saying I can't confirm nor deny that I saw Linda flying above Manhattan?
BobbyIt's unclear, but maybe both. Sure. For sure about Bud, but I think that they also referenced the UFO when they when they followed up with them. So I did, I yeah, I did find that interesting that he dropped a can't confirm or deny. And there are there are reports, however, that he did privately confirm this sighting. So unconfirmed. I think they reports that he confirmed it.
GregThey might use something like that because they don't know what you're talking about, or it's just a way that like if you worded something in a specific way that could be a gotcha when it comes to journalism, and if you were like, Oh, I don't know what you're talking about, but like if you listen back to like what the question actually was, they're gonna be like, Oh, well, now you're lying, and like I don't know. I feel like that's like it's such a safe way to answer something for sure.
BobbyAnd it it does, I don't it says Vanity Fair contacted him. I don't know how they might have sent him a letter that one of his aides responded to in a super ambiguous manner, right?
MichelleYeah, he can't confirm nor deny anything you just asked.
GregHe's an old man, leave him alone. Good day, sir. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I was thinking back to um Louis C.K. asking Dick Cheney if he was a lizard person, or was it Donald Romsfeld? I forget which one it was, but it was like on a radio uh interview. I I think it was Dick Cheney, and then Louis C.K. was like on the panel. He's like, Yeah, but are you a lizard person? And like he just keeps skipping the like he didn't hear it. Right. And he's like, We're not saying no.
BobbyYeah, yeah. Well, he didn't say no. Okay, he didn't say no. So again, the timeline on this is fucking whack. So we're backing up. Okay. We're backing up now. That's kind of the I went there because that's the end of that arm of this story, the politician story.
MichelleDo those two dudes come back? Yeah, don't you worry. Okay, good. They're coming back strong.
BobbySo like these guys. April 29th, 1991, not for long. Okay, Linda walked her son Johnny to the bus stop. Johnny sounds so fake.
MichelleJohnny is totally fake. Also, no one takes the bus.
BobbyYeah, so she's walking him to the yeah, that is strange. I good good catch, Michelle. Yeah, he lives in, they live, he's walking to a school. Yeah, kids aren't really taking buses. I mean, maybe he was going to a private institution somewhere. We don't know.
MichelleUh he may have gotten into a fancy school, also. Yep, that's possible. Or like a school for the arts.
BobbySo she walks Johnny to the bus stop and she's on her way home after she after she drops him off. Richard and Dan roll up, the two security guys. And they're like, Why don't you get in the car?
MichelleNo, don't get in the car.
BobbyYeah, she said, kick rocks. Get the fuck out of here. I'm not getting the car.
MichelleKick rocks.
BobbyYeah, kick rocks. Get out of here, Richard and Dan.
MichelleLet's bring that back.
BobbySo Richard, Richard forces her inside the car.
MichelleRichard, you can't do that.
BobbyWell, he did. And they drove her around for three and a half hours.
MichelleThat's too long.
BobbyInterrogating her about the November 1989 abduction, the one that everybody saw her coming out the window.
MichelleWhy?
BobbyThe ones that they the one that they saw. They want to know, tell us about the abduction, where you were working for the government, show us your toes to prove that you're human and not an alien hybrid.
MichelleYour toes. They may are they related to each other?
BobbyRichard and Dan?
MichelleYeah.
BobbyI don't know.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyThey're security cops.
MichelleHow do they find each other? They're matchmade in heaven.
BobbyYeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, it's like, you know, it's like Mulder and Scully. Sometimes you just get a partner that works.
MichelleYeah, but she wasn't up. She wasn't trying to hear his antics a lot.
BobbyBut that's what made him great.
MichelleYeah, but I guess she would be like, all right, let me see the toes. There's like a yinning yinning to it. You know what I mean?
GregYeah, exactly. Let's pop them toes out.
BobbyYeah. So they're like, show us your toes to prove that you're not a human alien hybrid. And so, like, I they they forced her to show, like, I think they just took her shoes and socks off. Pass the test.
MichelleThis feels like this is kidnapping. This is assault. I uh call the cops, Linda.
GregUh we're not they drove me around and forced me to show them my feet.
BobbyWe're not quite done with Richard and Dan. Okay. Man, people are crazy as hell.
MichelleRichard and Dan are crazy as hell.
BobbyMen and women alike in this story, it's men. Uh, but like, man, they're crazy as hell. So at some point with these interactions, uh, Dan gets a thing for Linda.
SPEAKER_03Of course.
BobbyHe's vibing Linda. Don't maybe, maybe he saw those toads and things. Dan, for sure. You know, I couldn't get him out of his head.
MichelleThat's what this is all about. He had a boner for this lady, the halt for years, and then kidnapped her off the street.
BobbyWell, he had a crazy boner because he kidnapped her again on October 15th, 1991 by himself. No, takes her to a beach house on Long Island.
MichelleNo.
BobbyAnd to do what, who knows? Right. I just he's just like, this could be our life, Linda. We could be out here on the beach. I think it's he's more of like uh obsessed with her rather than like assault, sexual assault.
MichelleYeah. Okay.
BobbyNot uh bad. Bad, bad, bad, bad. It's all bad, yeah. He's like, we could live out here on the beach, we could play Parchey, this could be our life. What do you think? And Richard is Richard shows up at some point. He's like, Dan, you're out of your fucking mind. Yeah. Uh this was our spot. Yeah. It's a Linda. Linda escapes. She she gets she gets out of there. She's away. And so, like, put a pin in that for just a second. Uh that that's October 1991, 1992.
BobbyA group of UFO investigators interview Linda, and that group is led by Joseph Stefula, who's a former special agent with the U.S. Army criminal investigation. But at the time, he's the MUFON state director for New Jersey.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyI run Mufon in North Jersey. That's okay.
MichelleThat's right.
BobbyHe's got that going on.
MichelleYeah, and he has a crazy name.
BobbySo he's there with his buddy Richard Butler, who's a former U.S. Air Force law enforcement officer, security police specialist, who also became a UFO investigator. So these guys are both ex-military investigators into UFOs doing the thing. Butler had been a part of Bud's UFO abductee group. So he'd been coming to these groups for some time, knew the circle, knew Linda from these groups, was very much involved with these people. In the fall of 1991, he invited Stefula to the group, Joseph.
BobbyAnd after the second kidnapping, Linda reaches out to him because he's like a former law enforcement military guy. She's like, I'm scared as hell. Like I'm in fear for my life. And so she kind of develops a little bit of a rapport with him based on these interactions. And so in February of 92, they do kind of a formal interview with her, in that they they find some contradictions in her statements and the information presented by Bud. And so Linda starts to kind of sweat a little bit in this interview, and she's like, Don't tell Bud.
BobbyPlease don't tell Bud about these questions.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyAnd so then back in July of '92, this is that same move on presentation where Bud was like, I know who the third man is. Right. Same speech. We're back there. We're kind of these timelines have converged back to this point.
SPEAKER_03Got it.
BobbyLinda's been kidnapped a bunch of times. So fucking crazy. The UN secretary. I just I it's the UN secretary when I was a kid was Boutros Boutros Gali. And so I keep wanting to refer to him as Boutros Boutros Gali, but it's not. Yes. But I might, I might at some point.
MichelleSo just so I have this right, she doesn't call a cop, she calls her buddy at MUFON who used to do security for the army or whatever.
BobbyYeah, I think because there are some people that are like Richard and Dan are the men in black.
MichelleRight.
BobbyYou know, so that they're and I think that Linda's more on that side of things rather than like I was just kidnapped by a by a guy who is obsessed with me. You know, not like she's in like an episode of X-Files, not like an episode of Dateline.
GregGot it.
BobbySo she so that's why she yeah, for sure.
GregShe's kind of aware of like who these people are and like what they're capable of. And like if they if she m mentioned it to the police, like they're above the police. Of course, yeah.
MichelleYeah.
BobbyAnd she doesn't think the police are gonna believe her or do anything.
MichelleAnd they probably wouldn't, you know, but like maybe they would arrest him for being a stalker ass stalker.
GregHe would flash a badge or something, just get out of it.
BobbyYeah, what am I gonna do? Arrest myself.
MichelleI am the law. That's right.
BobbyYou know, typical Richard.
MichelleFuck, dude.
BobbyDude, so Bud's at Mufon, he's presenting the case alongside Linda. Linda's there with him. They're recounting the Brooklyn Bridge alien abduction at Mufon. Bud says this is the most important case of my career. This is the case of the century. All that you can read in the the MUFON UFO journal article.
MichelleBud dabbled in the MUFON journal before.
BobbyYeah, yeah, absolutely. And Bud believes that this case objectively proves both physical alien abductions. Uh, the implant is part of that. You know, there's that like physical evidence.
MichelleBut there was no physical evidence. You mean the scarring? The scarring. Or whatever.
BobbySo Bud believes that the scarring in Linda's nose objectively proves both physical alien abductions and the accuracy of his hypnotic regression technique. These are part of these things. Double whammy for Bud. Totally. This is good news for Bud. Check. Yep. This case is going great. A few months after that, the group that interviewed Linda, the kind of UFO investigator skeptic military guys. Yeah. They meet with Bud at his house to discuss the discrepancies in the case.
MichelleOh my God. Thank fucking God. I thought you were gonna tell me they did it at MUFON and embarrassed everybody. And poor Bud went home crying. That's what I thought was gonna happen. Thank God they were decent men and did it behind closed doors.
BobbyThat's right. Okay, that's right. Thank you. The discrepancies there's a lot. A lot of it is just there are a lot of different accounts of these things. And when you get into the repressed memory stuff, it makes everything, not that it it discounts everything, but it makes everything a little bit muddy and more difficult to parse out.
GregYeah, because like you you'll get into some situations where people are talking about being dinosaurs and stuff and repressed memories and it's like okay, like yeah, is it a repressed memory or is it a dream?
MichelleYou know, is it you're are you having imagination? Is that what's happening? You're suffering from imagination.
BobbySome people with a lot of doctorates ask those very same questions.
MichelleI should have a doctorate.
BobbyYeah, yeah. Um, and so you know, when they're talking to Bud at his house, he's like, I'm not gonna talk to you guys about this because guess what? You want to know the details? You gotta buy the book. Hell yeah, dude. Fucking sell that book. Yeah, and so in four years, four years, you know right now. You gotta buy the book. Pre-order now. Yeah, and these guys they do publish like a detailed critique showing the the skepticism was like ripe in the UFO community early on with this one.
BobbySo there were they were poking some holes in it for sure. And and a lot of those holes were centered around what you guys just talked about with the uh that you can transform dreams or fantasies into false memories in hypnotic regression. You know, the the hypnotist, hypnotherapist can take subtle clues, suggestive questioning, and can create in the person like a completely authentic feeling but inaccurate memory. That's what people say, the the you can do this, which is just a really interesting phenomenon in itself that you could potentially create a suppressed alien abduction memory in a person.
BobbyAgain, man, I I didn't don't intentionally keep coming back to this, but a belief is true to the person who holds it. Yeah, that you you put this memory in a person, and so all this person now has this authentic abduction experience that was suggested to them. And like our minds are are so susceptible to suggestion, you know. We've talked about psyops a lot and things like that, and it's it it makes so much sense that if you're at a a UFO support group for a long time, you know, and then you start to get put under hypnosis, it just makes sense that you you want to be a part of that thing.
MichelleYeah, you know, you want to be a part of that thing.
BobbySo not not to say that this is what happened with Linda, but this is the argument against hypnotic regression for for a lot of this stuff.
MichelleI always think about like true crime shows where the detectives are always talking about eyewitness accounts and how over time we've discovered how unreliable they are. Yeah. And you can watch people like live changing, oh yeah, it was a white shirt. Now that you mention it, maybe there was a black stripe on the van. Or now that you said that, you know, I am remembering this or that. And it's not that people are lying, it's just that we're we're we can visually see the memory in our mind and it can change right before our mind's eye, you know.
GregIt's like what happens in um interrogations too, when you have someone that like, well, like why would someone confess to something that they didn't do? Right. And it all comes down to like psychological stress and like a lot of other reasons. And what people will end up doing and lawyers will check is the actual videotape or they'll listen to the audio of the interrogation. And it's like, well, is the detective giving them all of the details or are they offering it up without being prompted? And a lot of times in those cases, it's like the detective is prompting those persons and like giving all of the details to which they're saying, Yes, that's what it was.
MichelleYeah. Yeah, I've even seen ones where the audio is different than the video in the sense that like the officer who's conducting the interrogation might be saying, like, and then what did you do? But he's like has his hand on his neck or something, like you know, like just visual clues to tell the person what to say or where the injury was that the person wasn't getting beforehand, you know.
BobbyThere's some really egregious ones where they'll do that and the person giving the false confession is like, I stabbed him. And then they do like the throat thing and they're like, You sure you stabbed him? Yeah. And they're like, No, I strangled him. Yeah. They're like, Yeah, that's right, you did, didn't you? Yeah, it's crazy. You liked it.
MichelleIt's so crazy. It's like, who should be in jail? Yeah. You know, the cops. The cops should be in jail.
BobbyMaybe Bud should be in jail.
MichelleHop take Linda needs to go to jail.
BobbyUh, Bud disputes that he led anybody in his hypnotic regression sessions. And he had professional observers there. Um, a psychologist, Nicholas Humphrey, who'd done a lot of work in consciousness, had observed Bud doing these sessions with people, a psychiatrist Donald Klein, who was well versed in psychoanalysis and psychopharmacology, countless, endless hours in patient observation. Also observed Bud doing these, and they did not conclude that he was leading subjects.
MichelleGreat.
BobbySo Bud has some a little bit of backing there. Um, but yeah, that to say, there was a lot of skeptics about this process and this case in particular. And in 1996, the 400-page account laying out the entire premise of Linda's abduction is published. Oh, we've got multiple witnesses, security agents, major political figure, physical evidence, hypnotic evidence, human extraterrestrial hybrid breeding program.
SPEAKER_03Hell yeah.
BobbyThis summer.
MichelleFuck yeah.
BobbyVin Diesel is Linda Napoleon. Vin Diesel is Linda and witnessed the true story of the Brooklyn UFO abductions, Brooklyn Bridge UFO abductions.
MichelleVin Diesel is someone I haven't thought about in a long time.
BobbyYeah, you go see that movie.
MichelleVin Diesel is Linda. You guys cracked me up.
BobbyAgain, just prior to this because of the fucking timeline. So we're backing up just a hair. Of course. Carol Rainey enters the chat.
MichelleCarol is the wife.
BobbyYep. Carol met Bud while he was still working on witnessed the book. And the the same year it's published, they marry in 1996. Carol's the filmmaker, she's documenting Bud Bud's process, these groups. She's the one who's taking all this videotape. And and generally documenting everything that he's up to. She's she's married to him, but she's also a fan. She thinks the work is fascinating. It should be documented. So there's a lot of footage about this. They co author a book called Sight Unseen Together in 2003. She's in it.
BobbyUm, she knows Linda, knows her well. Linda was really close with Bud. They worked together for years. They did speaking engagements, they traveled together. And it's not explicitly said. I watched some some interviews and some documentaries about this stuff. It's not explicitly said, but like for yeah.
MichelleThey were scissors.
BobbyThere's some there's some uh some pretty serious animosity between Linda and Carol. And so it seemed like maybe I don't know. Maybe Carol didn't like how close Bud and Linda were.
MichelleSure.
BobbyThat's all I'm saying. What wife was there's also some lawsuits around this, so I'm gonna leave it at that.
GregSo I was gonna say, I think it's like it gets into like a weird, like true crime sort of area at a certain point with the story.
MichelleOh, does Carol try to kill Linda?
BobbyCarol, well, she tries to kill her with words. Fuck yeah. Which are stronger than the sword.
MichelleMm-hmm. So sticks and stones and whatnot.
BobbyThat's right. And so over time, Carol starts to Carol was raised in a religious cult and she starts to make some connections with the zealousness which with Bud is going about this UFO business and presenting and defending these accounts. Um she's like, there's a familiarity. Trauma response. Yeah, with the with the cult the in which she was raised, and she's like, oh, this is this is familiar, and and I don't I don't like to see the when holes were start to poked or people were asking questions, the complete lack of like openness to anything, just like a very closed-minded no it's a this is what happened, this is what it's about.
BobbyJust like, yeah, wouldn't hear any criticism or any have unwilling to have a conversation about this stuff. Um, so her eyes are open to a lot of the discrepancies in the story, um, the different accounts, the different timelines, the lack of evidence. And eventually Carol publishes an essay laying it all out, which is essentially a takedown of Bud and Linda.
MichelleShit. In the essay, I think while she's still married to him?
BobbyIt's a little bit like I think this was the end of the thing.
MichelleYeah, one foot out the door. Yeah. Shit. And so all the people to marry, she marries someone just like her father. Dude. Or whoever got her into that cult.
BobbyPreach her father, for sure. Yeah, for sure. Yeah, so a couple of excerpts from the essay is he continued to tout the major significance of the case long after he knew that Linda had lied to him on multiple occasions. They're driven by the rules of the game they're in to whip up their best cases to drive them hard. They can no longer extricate themselves from the surreal, richly imaginative blend of fantasy and reality. So, again, that was a lot of gray area, a lot of imagination, maybe dreams, fantasies that you talked about. And for Bud and everybody in the inner circle, it's just like betrayal.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, that be Carol.
BobbyYeah, just the ultimate betrayal. For sure. Still many years later, people got a lot of choice words about Carol and what she did, that bitch Carol Rainey. That's right. Uh rest in peace, Carol, by the way. Yeah, and Carol consequently becomes one of the case's most prominent critics, and she's banging the drum on saying that Bud's emotional investment in the story compromise his objectivity.
MichelleAnd do we think that's what it like do you think that there's almost like a drug addict or an alcoholic? Like, if you admit that you're wrong, then the whole fucking thing, like your conscious, like you're your subconscious and your psyche can't handle it if this isn't true.
BobbyI I think that's part of it. I also think that he has a view that if he comes off any of this stuff, that his credibility is gonna be his whole life. Yeah, his career any credibility he has is gone. Yeah, you know, and and so like we talk about a lot, the nugget of truth to this, and then everything that's built on top of that. And I believe that Bud was a believer, but Bud was also had uh bills to pay, had a career, you know, and um he's publishing books, he's doing speaking, and it's like, man, if you come off it or change your mind that this case was not true, there goes your speaking engagements, your book sales.
GregI think that happens with a lot of people in a lot of different areas. Like if you think of people that are let's say head of their field in archaeology, and they've built their whole entire career on, say, like Egyptology and like understanding the timelines and like everything that goes into it, and then you find out that like Egypt isn't real? No, no, but like maybe there was something older, or like the what you believed and like were spouting for the past 25 years probably isn't true, and you're gonna have to change your whole outlook on everything.
GregYou no longer are like an expert. Yeah, well, like you still can be, but it's all in how you frame it and like how you come across it, be like, hey, all of my information was built on X information. Now that this new information came out, I'm I'm gonna have to change my outlook and like we we can do better and more deeper research. But a lot of those people don't want to do that.
BobbyIt's all ego, it's a yeah, and it's a crazy it's all ego, it's a crazy twist of human behavior, an all-too common one that that person who who built their whole career on that thing, and then the new information comes out, they'll go whole hog to discredit that new information. Exactly, yeah.
GregYeah, instead of accepting it and looking at it and like doing the same scientific method that you did on everything else, you'll just be like, nope. Yeah, and it's like that does that's not real.
BobbyI'm the expert.
GregYeah, well, and then it goes to show like everything that they're now doing is discrediting themselves, like you're not even gonna bother looking. Like what you're trying to stay away from by like saying that is bullshit information, yeah, is now making you look worse because you're going so hard at like that isn't like a real thing.
BobbyAnd this is such a great example of the wrong way to go about that, because if you're in the field of oofology, paranormal research, any of this open-mindedness is like what this field is based on, right? You know, and then you get to this point where you kind of establish yourself and all of a sudden you become closed to any to anything outside of that or any any new information or any criticism.
GregThat's why I like Dan Aykroyd, because Dan Aykroyd is like he's uh on a poster child for being open-minded to the point where he it's just if you say something to him, it's like, yep, that's real. Like it doesn't matter what it is. But like I think you kind of have to have that outlook and that mindset when it comes to a lot of this stuff where it is just tell me what it is. Like we can disseminate the information and figure it out. But like, yeah, to just wholeheartedly just say no, that's not that's not real, or like we're just trying to like, well, now we have to discredit that thing.
GregIt's like, well, you already believe in something that's kind of a wild thing. So it's like you may as well just bring this new information in as well.
BobbyAnd it's just it is so wild in that field to be like, no, absolutely not. Yeah.
GregLike when you're when you're talking about aliens and UFOs and things like that, and then it's like a hybrid breeding program.
BobbyExactly.
GregAnd then to point at something that could make, I don't know, more sense and like be more logical to be like, I don't think so. Yeah, that that's fucking crazy. Yeah, yeah.
BobbyYou're trying to take me down.
GregIt's always fun to see like what those little details are, like oh, the government wouldn't do that thing. Yeah, it's like you're talking about fucking like what are we talking about here?
BobbyLike, of course they would. That was a side thing that I couldn't even go down. Was there was speculation that this like government built abduction vehicle.
MichelleFuck yeah. And that like I believe it.
BobbyThat was what was what happened to Linda, and it was like, and that's why the head of the UN was like covering it up because there was this like government course, this government side tangent on the thing. I was like, I can't even can't even go there.
MichelleI believe that story though.
GregYeah, it's it's it's so crazy when they're just yeah, a lot of these people will, especially in the UFO community, like they'll say, like, the idea of a government, I don't know, a secret government program to build this like new technology, or at least have some sort of like vehicle or some other way of like flying. And they'll just be like, no, that wouldn't be possible. And it's like, well, but you believe that it came from outer space like interdimensionally, yeah. That makes sense, right?
GregBut the idea that it could possibly be some like secret government program, that's that's where you're drawing the line. Like it's so interesting to see how people will like rationalize these ideas.
BobbyThis makes me think of the documentarian John Wilson.
MichelleOh god, I thought about him like three times because when you were talking about Carol recording everything, I was like, yo, like John Wilson be recording everything.
BobbyOne of the things that make John Wilson great is he just goes wherever the story goes and just follows it wherever it goes. Oh, yeah. And and it at no point does he seem to be like, no, we're talking about this, you know, and that's kind of become this thing. It's like, we'll just meander wherever this goes. Yeah, man, in in truth seeking and filmmaking, that's just such an interesting take. And like, how crazy would it be that you you start to make an alien abduction story and come across this government conspiracy? That's a great I watched that, yeah, for sure.
BobbyWatch that documentary in a heartbeat.
GregDid you ever see that documentary uh Icarus?
BobbyOh, dude.
MichelleThe dope I've never seen that.
BobbyThat's a great example of following the story. It won the Oscar. Yep, following where the story goes, and it goes places you would never imagine. It's incredible.
SPEAKER_03What is it?
BobbyNo, but I know it's a documentary about competitive tickling where a bunch of people are like extorted for money.
MichelleIt goes, it's on HBO. It's on HBO, it's so fucking good. Yeah, and it's like all the documentaries. I don't know because I didn't see yours, but this one.
GregWhat the fuck is competitive tickling?
BobbyYeah, well, you gotta watch it. Yeah, I need to watch it as well. I want to see it. So and maybe okay. I don't know. We I guess we don't usually do documentaries, but maybe we do an empile on Icarus, or maybe that story is just a wild. Or maybe one on Tickled. Yeah, maybe that's the first time hearing of this.
GregIt's awesome. Yeah, yeah. That's right up my alley of shit that I get into.
BobbyAll that to say in 2011, Bud Hopkins dies in the city in New York.
MichelleOkay, hold on. I wasn't ready for that.
BobbySo we're just kind of this everybody's mad at each other.
MichelleRight.
BobbyEverybody pokes holes in the credibility.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyCarol betrayed everyone. Yeah. And that's just where we stay.
MichelleOkay.
BobbyThat's just kind of where we stay. This went down. Linda was abducted in 89. That we were talking at Move On in the early 90s. The book came out in '96. We're just kind of in that zone. And so there's the community just kind of stays this way. There's this fracture with a lot of people and with Bud and his methodology. I think uh life goes on, you know.
GregMaybe you could uh correct me here, but I think there was part of Carol's story too where she started doing the circuit of discrediting Bud. And like, so she was like making money.
MichelleThat's some vindictive ex-wife shit, if I've ever heard it.
GregSo it's almost it's the opposite side of the same coin where she's now like her business is to discredit, so she like has to go all in on making sure that's the case.
BobbyIt's the same thing, and it's it's kind of yeah, she's basically served up on a platter to become a prominent skeptic. Yeah, it's like here you go. Do you want to be a prominent skeptic? It's just right right there. Yeah, you can make a living on being a prominent skeptic if you so choose. And I mean, I don't even mean this in a bad way, I mean it more of in an understanding way as as a a creative person that Linda Linda was a singer, she was an artist. And and I I think, especially when you get a little bit of a taste of it, of making a living as an artist, of like being a real artist, a singer, and and having that beat your life.
BobbyI think that that desire stays with you to to make a go of it as an artist. And there is a weird parallel to this kind of I don't even know if it's a parallel. Maybe the parallel is not having a real job, but to like make your living on the UFO circuit, right? You know, to be in that space for me. There, like I understand that there's a connection between living as an artist, and and there's a level of fame that comes with this. Linda's being interviewed, people know who she is, she's popular, she has some fame. And so it makes sense to me that that she would pursue this and lean into it.
BobbyYeah. Um, because she was an artist and she has that in her. Yeah. Um, and it's so hard to make your living as an artist. Yeah, it's so.
GregYeah, so when something like clicks in, it's just that's what you're going for.
BobbyAnd the same for Carol as a filmmaker, you know, that's like to make your living as an artist that she didn't necessarily want to become a prominent skeptic, but becoming a being a prominent skeptic and going and giving these speeches and showing your films that you made um is so much closer to to making your living as an artist than it is working at an insurance company or something. So I kind of understand the desire, and I understand how people end up in these positions and maybe what causes them to bend the truth, fracture the truth.
BobbySo Bud's dead. Okay. He left behind a legacy shadowed by this defense. Yeah, you know, like he was, he was was and still is very well known in that, but this is kind of part of part of his legacy now, whether he accidentally or intentionally generated the memories that he investigated. Um in 2024, a documentary came out, the Manhattan Alien Abduction. That's how a lot of people know this story now. Revisiting the case through Linda's account, old footage of Bud, Carol Rainey is there a lot.
BobbyBud's longtime assistant is in it. He hates Carol. That's in there. Um and Linda participated in the documentary, and I don't know what happened behind the scenes. Like she very much is was obviously a willing participant in this, but at some point before its release, her and Bud's estate sue Netflix.
SPEAKER_03Shit.
BobbyThey're like, You misrepresented us as unfair treatment, unfair portrayal, um, and trying to restrict its release. They put it out anyways, and the lawsuit is still pending. Um, but in in in that documentary, it's listener and whoever is throwing lawsuits out, don't sue me. It's not a good documentary. It's it's it's it's more like Greg said earlier, it's more of like a true crime vibe than like an interesting documentary about extraterrestrials. Yeah, these women hate each other.
BobbyLinda and Carol in this documentary, and it's essentially the two of them going back and forth, and like, man, there is some like serious vitriol between these two women. And I I don't that was why I was kind of like, maybe something with bud, because it's like there shouldn't be that much hatred between them. Yeah, um, it doesn't, it doesn't necessarily make sense unless there was like an interpersonal thing that sucks too, is because it like it was all born out of the a very interesting story. Yeah, absolutely, absolutely.
GregAnd yeah, that it's and it's like pro wrestling, like they just got so far like into the weeds with hating each other that like that's the spectacle now and not this like wild UFO abduction story.
BobbyThat's that's how the documentary feels is that it's not about it's not about the Manhattan Alien abduction, it's about Linda and Carol hating each other. So that's my that was my interpretation of it.
MichelleYeah, that's a bummer because I'm sure that there was like a really good budget and all of that, and to I don't know, spend all that time and money and energy and just make it kind of a soap opera. That sucks.
GregYeah.
MichelleWell, I guess I won't be watching that.
GregI guess too, like if if you're gonna sell like a UFO story, like what's the new angle? Right. And it's just like this comes with its own like full like drama package built into it already.
MichelleYeah, cat fight.
BobbyYeah, but I mean, yeah, it's it is such an interesting story. There's so many interesting characters in it, and there might be some truth in there to to some of this. What happened? I I I think that Richard and Dan as as men in black is a really interesting theory, probably the most interesting theory about that.
MichelleAbsolutely weird.
BobbyAnd also the most guys potentially true. Like it's such a weird part of the story.
GregI was gonna say it's weird how like how little it was part of it, but like I know um again, I couldn't, I'm I might be misremembering it. Like their part was actually kind of bigger in terms of like how much influence they had over the story itself, but it was all just like minor little things that would happen, like of like how long they were actually following her around and things like that.
BobbyBut you're right, it it was for for from Bud's point, their their involvement and Boudros Boudros Gali witnessing this along with them, like gave credibility to this. So when he's doing his MUFON presentation, he's like, We found the guy, we found the witness. So they do loom very large in this story as witnesses, and they're a lot of what Bud is is banking on and building the story on is these eyewitness accounts, in addition to the like implant evidence. So, yeah, they're a small but like very significant part of the story for sure.
MichelleUgh, I uh it's also crazy that they waited like a year.
BobbyTwo years, two years, that's and then they send them a letter, but again, this is 1991, so sending somebody a letter is not that now. You're like a letter?
GregWasn't there like uh there was some like skepticism over like whether or not they were actually like the quote unquote men in black, how like the letters would like be named different, or like there was like something that went on with the letters themselves and like how far like they were spaced out, they were like coming from different people, the handwriting was like yeah off on like some of the stuff there.
BobbyAnd I mean their their their story was a moving target as well. Initially, they're like, We're we're New York City police officers. Yeah, and then they're like actually We're security, we're doing security, which I don't I don't know if that was like blown out of proportion as well because very often police officers work security as a second job, yeah, like Moonlight or whatever. Yeah, and also like NYPD officers are assigned to security details, exactly.
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
BobbySo I don't know if that was just like a yeah, exactly. If that was just someone misinterpreting that, um or or if their their story was changing and these letters are are different. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03But they're crazy, yeah. They're so crazy, yeah. They're the craziest beat. They're the craziest part of the story.
BobbyI know that's kind of like when I when when Dan kidnaps her and takes her to the beach house in Long Island. Well, I'm like, this is what makes this a movie.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
BobbyFor somebody to watch is like this scene right here, the other stuff is like a normal alien abduction movie. Yeah, but like this part, one of the men in black has a crush on her and kidnaps her. Yeah. It's like, what the fuck?
MichelleFor some reason it reminded me of the bodyguard movie. Oh, yeah. But in a like if her security detail was the killer and not her sister. Yeah. You know?
BobbyYeah, spoilers.
MichelleYeah. Shit. Whoops. Yeah.
GregYou see the bodyguard with Houston and Kevin Cosby. That's right. Great movie.
BobbySo, yeah, that's the story of the Brooklyn Bridge alien abduction and a little a little glimpse into Bud Hopkins and a lot of Lyndon Napolitano.
GregAnd how long of like a of a story it actually is. Like just how long of a time it took place over is kind of interesting, too. Where it wasn't just like, here's like this little story, and maybe over the course of a few months, like we get the full package. It's an ongoing yeah.
BobbyWell, it's like, where does it even start? Yeah, because she contacts him in April of 89 and was like, I was abducted in 1976. Yeah, and then they got me again. It's like, does this start start in 1976? Yeah, you know, yeah, I don't know.
MichelleYeah, is his art still in the Met in the Mama?
BobbyI don't I don't know if it is.
MichelleI want to go check him out. I want to see a circles and lines.
BobbyActually, I did see somewhere that some of his works are part of their permanent collection. So I don't know that doesn't mean they're on display. Of course. But um, yeah. Yeah. One of my favorite things to do, uh, I like to do it at the Smithsonian and at the Met is to go. They have like a lot of their stuff that's not on display, they still have it like on display in a back room that you can go into. It's really all like tight together. Um, I really enjoy cruising through that back area.
MichelleI've seen one of those back areas at the Met over by like the colonial houses. Exactly. Yeah, yeah, youep, yep, yep.
BobbyYeah, it's like the floor above where they have the Frank Lloyd Wright house on like a mezzanine back there you can get in there.
MichelleYeah, I went back there by accident.
GregThere's like a little area like that at the Brooklyn Museum as well, where it's I forget what floor it is, but it's just like it almost feels like you're not supposed to be in there. That's why but it's all like on display. Like they they want you to go in, but it just feels like yeah, there's like a lot of drawers and like a lot of things that I'm like, am I allowed to like go through that? And like they encourage it.
BobbyYeah, but yeah, it's very cool.
MichelleYeah, same. I felt like at the Met that I was there by mistake, like I stumbled upon some secret room that I wasn't supposed to be in, and I was like, I'm gonna touch it.
BobbyYeah, it's like yeah, it's a regular, regular stop for me when I'm cruising through there. There's also a secret bathroom back there. Oh, nice, so yeah, nice, yeah.
MichelleWell, this was a doozy. Shit. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Carol. Carol, man.
MichelleYeah. Dang.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Bud, Carol, Linda, scissors.
MichelleMen in black. Experiments. Stalkers.
BobbySo I mean little tiny aliens. It kind of had it all. It did. If you were sex experimented on. Oh, experimented. Give us the rule. It's a strange exchange.
GregIf you've ever scissored a gray.
Bobby929-445-3705. But you know, keep it. I mean, I don't know. Greg listens to him before I do. I was gonna say keep it PG 13, but Greg probably wants. Greg wants it all. Nah.
GregIf you have a wild story, we want to hear it.
MichelleGive us the details.
GregJust let us know.
MichelleJust tell us the truth. It's experiments. It's experiments. Specifically. Yeah. We won't we we need to know. Call us immediately.
BobbyOr I mean, yeah, if you have got a hypnotic regression story, that's true.
MichelleYeah. If you if you know Carol. Yeah.
BobbyIf you know, if you know if Bud used a pendulum on his people.
MichelleYeah, yeah or a um or a metronome. Yeah. Or whatever. Sure. Whatever. Yeah. Charles.
Snuff Films, Sinister Elites & Nicolas Cage! This week the Henchmen open an M-File on 8MM (1999), Joel Schumacher's twisted thriller starring Nicolas Cage, Joaquin Phoenix, and James Gandolfini. Michelle, Bobby, and...
FBI SNIPERS! GOVERNMENT LIES! A FAMILY UNDER SIEGE! This week the Conspiracy Journal Henchmen expose the botched operations, deadly shoot-to-kill orders and the government cover-ups behind RUBY RIDGE the bloody...
Have you ever woken up in the middle of the night, unable to move, only to discover a dark figure standing at the foot of your bed… WATCHING YOU? He's known as THE HAT MAN a mysterious, faceless figure dressed in a long...
Every October 31st, millions of kids put on masks and go door to door, and almost none of them know why. This week the Henchmen trace Halloween back to Samhain in ancient Ireland when the dead were said to walk among...
Grab your candles, call the corners, and remember whatever you put out comes back threefold! The Henchmen revisit the 1996 cult classic The Craft to investigate its real-life witchcraft connections, Hollywood's pagan...