Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Commission Files

The Commission Files artwork

JR87. RE and Assemblies in NI Schools

Feb 16, 202640 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A Special Extra Episode. A look at the JR87 UK Supreme Court ruling which will see changes in the way Religious Education and Assemblies are conducted in Northern Ireland's Schools. Will hears from educationalist Dr Andrew Brown and Ian Bingham of CARE NI, both of whom know what the ruling says - and what it does NOT say. This interview is reproduced with the kind permission of the producers of the Graciously Confident Podcast from the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. Get in touch with us. Produced by Commission Christian Radio

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hello, and welcome to a special extra episode of the Commission Files. I'm Will Leach. What's going on in our schools in Northern Ireland? Back in November 2025, there was a court ruling about the teaching of religious education in the classroom and also collective worship at assemblies. The Supreme Court, the highest court in the whole of the UK, issued a ruling known as JR 87. It's about an unnamed family which felt that it didn't want their daughter to be taught to be a Christian, and also felt that simply withdrawing that child from RE or assembly wasn't good enough.

SPEAKER_02The Supreme Court ruling used words like objective, critical, and pluralistic, and a much more emotive word which hasn't gone down all that well, indoctrination. Unsettling for Christians. And that legal ruling means we will see changes to the way RE is taught in our schools, both primary and secondary, and it'll change the rules on assemblies as well. Now you can see why people might have immediately wondered, is teaching Christianity in RE going to be illegal?

SPEAKER_02Is it going to have to stop? Is it going to be replaced with teaching about other faiths? Will Christian focused assemblies be banned? No. None of that is going to happen, but don't take my word for it. It would help, wouldn't it, to hear from experts who know about the teaching of R.E. in Northern Ireland, know about running assemblies, and who've actually read the ruling all the way through and who understand what it does mean. Fortunately, I've been able to meet two such experts, and it's thanks to the Presbyterian Church and its graciously confident podcast series that I was able to meet them and ask them all about this.

SPEAKER_02And thanks to the Church for allowing me to let you hear our conversation via the Commission Files now. So who are these experts? Dr. Andrew Brown is an educationalist. He lectures at Strandmillis College in Belfast and has held many roles of responsibility in how religious education is taught in our schools. In Bingham is the head of Care Northern Ireland. Care helps Christians pick their way through the ethical and moral issues in society, and Ian also taught RE for fifteen years.

SPEAKER_02So I began the conversation by asking Ian what JR eighty seven is and how it came about.

SPEAKER_00So it's really about a young girl, anonymised, as she said in your introduction, as JR 87, and she attended a primary school here in Northern Ireland. She was taught RE and attended the school assemblies, but her parents, who would not claim to be religious in any way, in fact the judgment, said that they would be, quote, broadly speaking, humanist in their outlook, was concerned around the fact that they were that their child was being taught Christianity as opposed to learning about Christianity. And so they challenged the system.

SPEAKER_00They felt it wasn't right that she would be taught in this manner, and so they took the the school to court and uh went through the High Court and they won that case at the High Court. It then went through the appeals process and at the appeal. The Court of Appeal disagreed, saying that the right of withdrawal was enough and which means they could have taken their child from lessons.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. They assemblies whatever.

SPEAKER_00They simply removed their child from the lesson from the from assembly, but it was then taken to the the Supreme Court, the highest court in the land, and they have then agreed with the original judgment that the school it breached Article two, Protocol 1 and Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and so they've declared that RE and school assemblies must now change to become more objective, critical and pluralistic in their delivery of R.E. and assemblies.

SPEAKER_02Interesting, isn't it, Andy, that they could have withdrawn their child, their daughter, but chose not to.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it is. I mean, you say that some people were agitated about this result, and I must say I was too, but for different reasons. And my agitation came from the fact that we never needed to go here. Okay? Um one of the things I've been very privileged to do in my life is is to work with what's known as the Transfer Representatives Council. That's the body for the three main denominations of in the Protestant churches in Northern Ireland and their interests in education. And we've been lobbying successive ministers and officials about this over the last five years to say, look, Northern Ireland is changing, it's a changing place.

SPEAKER_01People's understanding of R.E. may not be what R.E. actually is. And I I think one of the things that's really clear is that R.E. in schools is not the teaching of religion, it's about what religion teaches us. And we have a society where, yes, we remain majority Christian in Northern Ireland, but there are folks of other faiths, folks of no faith, folks who are humanist. And in our high schools, key stage three and four, we already teach about how we coexist with each other and how we understand other worldviews and other world faiths and religions.

SPEAKER_01And we've been asking that that should come into primary schools, obviously in an age-appropriate way. We've also been asking that the RE curriculum should be overhauled because of this. And that, and this is really important, and that RE should be subject to inspection by the educational. It isn't. It's the only subject in the school curriculum where it's not inspected. And that has or could, and maybe can, lead to some rather poor delivery of R.E.

SPEAKER_01out there where people do misunderstand it. I mean I'm a okay, so I'm an educationalist. I also go I go and see my students teach lessons, etc., etc. And I can see RE at times delivered in a rather mundane way. I I'll give you an example of a May, and I'll not take too long over it. I remember seeing a student teach a wonderful lesson on Jesus Calms the Storm. And she had it all beautifully set out, and she started with uh a video, cartoon of Jesus Calm in the Storm.

SPEAKER_01She then read the story, the kids then did a newspaper report, and the fast finisher in task was a tweet about this. Super on the surface. I said to her afterwards, I said, Okay, you taught the same story four times. Was this an English literature lesson? She looked at me. I said, Okay, you taught the same story as fact four times. Was this a history lesson? And she says, I don't understand what you're saying. I said, The purpose of teaching the story of Jesus calming the storm is not about the reinforcement of the story again and again and again.

SPEAKER_01It's about the fact that this RE lesson is and should be about the application of that story. There are things in life, boys and girls, which are bigger than us and we can't deal with. Christians believe that Jesus, etc. etc. And so I think there can be confusion over this. So we've been asking for quite some time for a look at the revision. And it was just well, it wasn't quite ignored, it was, mm, yes, with other priorities. It didn't happen, and this didn't need to happen, and it was just something that was going to happen unless the changes were made.

SPEAKER_01So we were agitated because of that. I was also surprised actually, I was surprised that the Supreme Court made this judgment. It's not like them to to get into something which is as sensitive in a jurisdiction as this is. And so it did lead, as you said, to the some sort of somewhat sensationalist reactions from some people that came on. But I know that probably as this conversation goes on, you're going to be considering, well, what are are there any positives in this? And what might they be?

SPEAKER_01And well I'm sure we'll we'll we'll get into a bit as we move on.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. But uh a as you've pointed out, it didn't need to happen. It did. And we are where we are. I want to deal very quickly, and we will move on, with the fact that there was misinformation in, and I know you've written about this, where people chose to take what they could take from this to make other political points social points. So though there were the people who said, Well, this is a result of letting all the immigrants into the UK. So how how do you react to that?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think y you're right in what you say, uh, because I don't know what your social media was like um in the minutes and hours after the judgment. Mine mine completely lit up and I sat uh completely flabbergasted, if I'm if I'm perfectly honest, uh reading through my social media comments of people um and and uh fairly public figures as well, uh making comment on this within minutes of it being released, and there's no way that they could have ever read through. I mean the document, the judgment is 39 pages long, and so there's no way that they could have ever read it.

SPEAKER_00And so as as uh you've rightly said, there's these sensational headlines and tweets and posts that were put out. And the difficulty with that is that then others jump on the bandwagon and share those and so on. So what I decided to do was I just took a back seat, I I I I watched from afar for probably the the guts of a week just to let the uh the dust settle a little bit. And then what I did was I I I penned an article on this and you've referenced it already, and I just felt it was important to get a bit of clarity out for people and a bit of reassurance that it's not as bad as what is being made out.

SPEAKER_00It's not as bad as the the headlines that you've been uh you've read at the start of the this podcast, and it's not as bad as the uh social media posts. And I think that's what I really want to get clear to people who are listening to this. We'll we'll thrash it out a little bit uh throughout this, but it really isn't just as bad as it as it's being made out. And as Andy rightly said, as a former R.E. teacher, it is time. It is time that we looked at the content of R.E. and it is time that it was updated.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell I mean it is interesting that teachers have been saying for some time, to come back to your point, Andy, that we need to change the way R.E. is taught, and we would like to see changes to the way and that was Christian teachers saying that as much as anybody else. So don't forget that children have been learning about lots of other faiths for a long time already. And any children we know who've grown up to adulthood could tell you the basic tenets of other faiths because they learned about them in school. It's not like it wasn't happening, it's not like this is a big change. Andy, let's get to this uh three-word phrase objective, critical, pluralistic.

SPEAKER_02Most of us go, yeah Help us.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so I I suppose in many respects it goes back to the little example that I gave. Okay. So it's not about teaching something as compulsory truth and it is about teaching that there are alternative viewpoints, and it is about teaching the fact that people have differences of opinion. And in many ways it's about not expecting or hoping or demanding that people b agree with the position that's being put across.

SPEAKER_01I I I know within teacher education uh at Stramillis, our students are taught from an early stage that when you're presenting these stories, it's Christians believe or the Bible. The Bible teaches. Yeah. I mean I I I I have a huge, huge a huge affinity for Scripture Union in Northern Ireland. And they come in and do wonderful work in schools. And our local E3 worker in my area has a really wonderful way of how she introduces And that's an SU member of stuff as well.

SPEAKER_01So she could she'll come in and she'll do local assemblies and and SUs and stuff in in our local schools. But when she's standing talking to a group of primary school children, she starts with, You know who I am and my name, and you know that I have this really special book that's very important to me, that teaches me a lot of truths in my life and and not everybody agrees with me. But and then she unfolds the story. What she doesn't go in and say is, here's the truth, and if you don't believe it, then sorry you're wrong.

SPEAKER_02Which is what you generally politely get in church and from pulpits, but you can't be doing that in our e-lift.

SPEAKER_01No, because the fact is that the people who come to church are people who either believe or are seeking to believe or are just wanting to find out something. They're there in a voluntary basis. People who go to the schools and who go to control schools in Northern Land, which are open to all faiths and none, aren't going to necessarily believe as well. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_02We're gonna look at the content of R.E. and assemblies, and uh a very interesting take on a strong word, and that word is indoctrination, and and quickly at it inspections and withdrawals, although we've mentioned those already. So, in terms of what is now going to be in R.E. lessons, Ian, what can be there and what might change?

SPEAKER_00Well, that is the big uh question, well, isn't it? You know, that the the the Education Minister and the Department of Education have to figure out what is uh what is going to be the uh the the content. I think it's uh again has been uh referenced already that this is not new territory. Well I I taught in a post-primary school uh and since 2007 there's the introduction of uh world faiths and world religions into schools. And speaking personally as a teacher, I loved those lessons. I loved teaching that content because there's there's something about journeying alongside students on that journey.

SPEAKER_00I'm not there declaring that I have all the answers. I saw myself as a a studying alongside and learning alongside, and there's something I always told my students there's something positive to be gained by the study of other faiths. And that might come as a surprise to say that, but actually, you know, if you take, for example, uh Islam uh as a faith, there's something incredible that can be learned for by by studying, for example, the fact that they fast for a whole month. I mean I know Christians who who struggle, and personally speaking, I I struggle to to fast even for a day or a couple of days as a Christian.

SPEAKER_02Or take for example that And if you do take a look at Ramada.

SPEAKER_00Exactly, at Ramada, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Or or take a look at the the And fasting is of course a biblical principle as Christians.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. You know, or take a look at for for example of uh Judaism, how they treat their holy scriptures. It's it's very carefully handled, very carefully uh put away, covered in a mantle, beautifully decorated, and so on. And yet I know Christians who who you know come and throw their Bibles down or whatever, and so on. And so there's just there's something to be learned, there's nothing to be gained. The Buddhist faith is another example, very, very big on caring for others and looking after others because of the whole reincarnation idea. And so I used to tell my students that this is nothing to be feared, there's something to be gained actually by by studying faiths.

SPEAKER_00I suppose the question is, where do we introduce this now? As the Education Minister builds a team to to uh relook at the core syllabus and revise the core syllabus. Where do we introduce this? Do we introduce it into foundation stage at P1, P2, or do we hold that off until Well, it will be.

SPEAKER_01I mean, this is what's going to happen. It will be introduced from foundation stage. But it's it's about age appropriateness, isn't it? It's about the different clothes that people wear. It's about why someone might come into school at a particular time of the year doing something that's different. I mean for me this whole thing is about it's about trying to diffuse ignorance and trying to understand difference. And you know that in Northern Ireland we're not very good at this. I remember being at a conference and there was a there was a lady at the front, uh, a Muslim lady, and she was talking about she was talking about how we didn't need less religion in schools, we needed more religion in schools so that we could understand each other.

SPEAKER_01She gave an example, it was a horrific example. Okay, horrific, so it was a bit hyperbolic, but she talked about going to a parent-teacher interview uh in her kids' school and th her primary school teacher was talking to her about her her child's development in English and said to the mum, of course this must be quite difficult for him because he speaks Muslim. Oh, you're joking. Yeah, that's I mean now the teach the teacher was being nice and generous and kind, but literally thought that speaking Muslim Do you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01And this is I mean, you don't have to go farther than my part of the world and the events that happened this summer and then other events to, you know, to know about So coming up against fundamental ignorance. Fundamental ignorance and how and again, you you mentioned it about uh earlier, Will, and uh in Ian's article about you know people blaming us on migrants and things like this. It's absolutely incredible and and and so it it does need to come in the foundation stage. It does need to k come into key stage one. So and that's why whatever happens next with regard to this, it's really important that the department involves educationalists in this, as well as obviously, and I'm gonna say this as a church representative, but as well as the churches.

SPEAKER_01But I think some some of the counter-arguments against this are, you know, people will say, Well, why would the churches be involved with writing the curriculum? What do they know? It's I'm sorry, we're we're we're not just gonna get the Reverend Jones from second whatever Presbyterian to go in. The churches will choose people who work within education, who are s experts in the field in education, and they will be in there involved in that curriculum.

SPEAKER_02That's an interesting point about churches being involved in developing this curriculum, because Ian, I know again that's concerned you where you said, Look, yes, there need to be all sorts of people, but it needs to reflect the society we're in. And if you look at what Evangelical Alliance did, they did a study for the UK and a specific one for Northern Ireland. They were both called Good News People. It was at the start of 2024 Good News People for Northern Ireland, but they they started with a census reality that 80% of people in Northern Ireland identify as Christian.

SPEAKER_02So surely the curriculum in Northern Ireland should start from that point and say eighty percent of the people, therefore the families coming to us, may have Christian exposure culture and an expectation of learning about that.

SPEAKER_00I think it's it's a very, very valid point. And I think if you take a look at the uh the the previous core syllabus, the previous core syllabus uh was developed uh in 1996, I think it was, and the population statistics, the demographics of Northern Ireland were were 90%. And so the vast majority of of uh that curriculum was was Christianity. In fact, it was it was all Christianity. However, in 2006 it was revisited, and given the nature of of Northern Ireland society, it was decided that there should have been more world faiths.

SPEAKER_00And I think we're we're in in that same situation as well. You know that as we now look at the core syllabus, we have to admit and say, listen, statistically and demographically, Northern Ireland is changing. But I think the robust piece of data that we have available is the Northern Ireland Census of 2021. It found that uh 80 percent, both Protestant and Catholic, ticked the Christian box, and only 20 percent ticked the uh other or no faith. And so if we're looking at developing a curriculum, then uh surely it should reflect the demographics of the society that we live in.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell, let's be clear.

SPEAKER_02Neither of you is arguing that the twenty per cent should be ignored or overridden. It's just a case of accepting that it is eighty and twenty.

SPEAKER_01And and the judgment was quite clear about that. The judgment made clear that Christianity will remain the primary faith taught in schools. Says that. So it didn't say you can't teach Christianity in schools at all anywhere. The judgment's quite clear that Christianity remain remains the core faith in Northern Ireland and will remain the core part of the R.E. curriculum. But that, as Ian has rightly said, you know, and it's about an iteration that happens 2006, 2010, 2026, um, that that we need to ensure that R.E.

SPEAKER_01remains relevant to all sections of our society.

SPEAKER_02Let's move on from the content of R.E. to assemblies, because that was the other issue. And there is a distinction here, because what happens in RE will ultimately be part of the curriculum, and therefore that's what teachers must teach. And there's very strong, strict and clear guidelines on that once they're produced. Assembly is a bit more difficult, a bit hard to tie down because it's not the curriculum, it's the thing that sets everybody else up for the days. And a lot of cases they are faith-based assemblies. So we get down to issues of who takes them, if there are visiting speakers.

SPEAKER_02And Andy, J.R. 87's, the family involved, said we don't want to withdraw our daughter because we think she could be stigmatised. So it was based on a fear of something that might have happened, but as far as I can tell from the reading it, never actually happened. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. There are some wonderful organizations and people out there who come in and take assemblies, and they're brilliant, and they do it in a way that is gentle and understanding and age-appropriate and uses age-appropriate language and uh resources. And there are those who maybe aren't. And if you weren't from a Christian faith perspective, you could see that uh as as being an uncomfortable situation.

SPEAKER_01Well, uh in the churches we we've been recognizing this for some time and actually one of the things that we did, we we came up with this concept understanding that many of our school leaders, even prior to JR 87, but certainly exacerbated by this, were getting concerned about potential litigation and potentially folks in in the the community of their schools not being not feeling comfortable in spaces like like collective worship.

SPEAKER_01We convened a meeting of we we contacted about 20 of the main providers Christian organizations who go into schools. Who go into schools to take RE, collective worship, curricular and other non-curricular. And with them we created a charter which is actually just today being presented to all primary school, pre all controlled primary school principals. As we record the post-primary school principals in Northern Ireland. And we offer that charter as a helpfulness and a way of saying to folks, look, here's this charter.

SPEAKER_01It's been agreed with many of these organisms, most of these organizations. When people come in, you can ask them to sign up with us. You don't need to use the charter, it's there for you. You can publish it on your website, you can advertise it to parents. It's there as a way of going, look, you see your concerns, your potential concerns? We've already thought through this. And the charter looks at things like the purpose of the engagement of the organization, the values that it shares with the school, how it adheres to the school's policy and ethos, how the organization will share without expectation of agreement, how the organization has committed to respect those who don't share its views, how the language used will be careful, and how the delivery will be age appropriate, and how the organisation will support the school community.

SPEAKER_01And and we offer that charter then as a public infir affirmation of our intent to contribute positively and respectfully to the life of schools in Northern Ireland. So that for us is a very tangible way of how we're going to do this. And so, in the in potential tinterbox situations where parents come in and say, Look, or that organization that came in, and a principal's able to go, but this charter that we've got in our school, read that really carefully. That organization says they're not going to stigmatize or isolate, or they don't expect your child to agree.

SPEAKER_01They're part of the overall educational picture and we bring them in. So we hope it's something that that is of tangible benefit and use.

SPEAKER_02You can see that it could be useful because you want to get this right. You don't want Christian speakers getting themselves into trouble. Yeah. And you don't want some people who we might consider to be bad faith actors coming in and saying stuff that we're not happy about. And this is a good time in to bring in this word that the Supreme Court used a lot. Indoctrination. Now, the judge accepted this can be a very negative word, but in this case, indoctrination was taken to mean evangelization, or this very old-fashioned word proselytizing, basically, saying this is the truth preaching and so on.

SPEAKER_02So there are issues that do need to be thought about in assemblies around that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think in both R.E. lessons and in assemblies, it can be very easy to drift into this indoctrination mood. Particularly if that person is a Christian, and it's a very tight uh very hard road to walk as a Christian teacher, because obviously you want I'm not just talking about R.E., I'm talking about any any Christian teacher because obviously we we we have our mission to our commission is to make disciples of all nations and so as as Christians we want to do that.

SPEAKER_00But suppose the big question is where is it appropriate to do that? Is it appropriate to do that kind of thing in an RE lesson and an assembly? And I'll be perfectly honest and I'll I'll I'll say I don't think either of those occasions are appropriate for evangelising or indoctrinating of students. In fact, the judge, very helpfully in in the um the judgment, declared what they understand to be uh indoctrination. The word indoctrination ordinarily has negative connotations, they say, but in the context of Christian faith it's a synonym for evangelism or proselytizing.

SPEAKER_00It means winning others over so that they believe in and practice the Christian faith. And I genuinely do not believe that on a school assembly floor is the place to do that. I have sat through hundreds, if not thousands, of assemblies uh in my time and I've seen some really good practice and I've seen some, shall we say, not so good practice. But I do know that there are schools around, particularly primary schools, who uh will use their their school assembly uh as a as a floor and as an opportunity to evangelize to their students, to present them with the gospel.

SPEAKER_00Um I've heard of church leaders who've been invited in and have been given free uh free flow and say, listen, hit them with the gospel and then lead them afterwards into a prayer. And I genuinely believe that that is not an appropriate place to do so. My thinking about the whole indoctrination is that indoctrination is not so much a content issue, indoctrination is more of a delivery issue. Now, what I mean by that is it's not so much about what the the content of a core syllabus is or the content of an assembly is, it's how the teacher, principal, or whoever's invited in delivers that.

SPEAKER_00The way you say it. The way you say it is exactly right. So, Andy, for example, you and I could be in the same department and you and I could teach this exactly the same lesson from the core syllabus. But you don't indoctrinate while I do, because I choose to use that platform to then uh evangelise and to encourage my students to commit their lives to Jesus. I don't believe that that is the right place to do that.

SPEAKER_02So the language would be you saying you must believe this, it's true, and Andy, you saying in that case, Christians believe.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it it's all down to me. Indoctrination, and this is where I where I uh find this judgment difficult because there the the judges are are claiming that the indoctr that the way the core syllabus is written is is indoctrination. But to me it's not. It's it's how that's interpreted.

SPEAKER_01Christian teachers and this th this has been one of the things that people have been scared about. Christian teachers should not be scared about openly being Christian teachers in schools. They should not be scared about the pupils knowing what their beliefs are. But they can do that as a teacher of science or a teacher of drama. It's it's where you you you kind of feel that there are two key areas where you're allowed to do this openly, you know, or or there are two key areas where you hijack it to to be evangelical.

SPEAKER_01The school is not the place where there are official times of proselyticism, indoctrination, or even evangelicalism. Schools have at their core a Christian ethos. How they live that out on a daily basis sends a bigger message. Who was it who said preach the gospel always if necessary, use words? I think it was St. Augustine possible. Yeah. Okay, and and so that's how we should and how we serve, how we serve our pupils and their families and our local communities.

SPEAKER_01But we shouldn't be using RE lessons to teach religion, we should use them to teach about religion and to apply that to the big questions of our lives. Collective worship, collective worship by its very name is a different one, it's a difficult one, it's one we have to get this right. Within a Christian community or a Christian society, how can we ask people on a Tuesday to worship Christ? Collective worship? How can we ask them the following Tuesday to worship Allah? How can we so we've got to get that right about what the purpose of collective worship is.

SPEAKER_01But there's nothing, and there's nothing to stop Christian teachers, and there's nothing in this judgment, and there's nothing coming down the line where Christian teachers should feel scared about saying, I'm a Christian teacher. You know it because of how I live my life. You know it because of how I love you as a child, because of how I care about you as a kid, because of how I realise your potential as a child, how I go the extra mile and mark in your work, all of the things that make me Christ-like. They shouldn't ever feel I have to hide that.

SPEAKER_00And that that's what I did. My first lesson with every every class I did uh was to introduce myself, get to know them, yeah, and and and say that exactly as you've uh eloquently put it. I I'm a Christian teacher, and that means I'm gonna do this, this, and this. But what I didn't want to do is to then influence them to think that throughout this year I'm gonna force them to be uh to become Christians. That's not what it's about at all. But if I can just say this, there is a place. I believe in schools, there is a place for evangelism, and that is a scripture union.

SPEAKER_01That's scripture union, that's exactly what I was going to say.

SPEAKER_00You know, and so that's I think it's a wonderful uh way in which Christian teachers could come.

SPEAKER_02Because it's a club you go to in your own time. Exactly. You have chosen to go there. You're not forced to be at a club.

SPEAKER_01Or you've maybe been invited there and you've gone for a look, but it's not that you have to be there. Totally.

SPEAKER_00And Christian teachers and students alike can present the gospel, can encourage the students who are there to come to faith. There's absolutely no problem. For many years I was involved in the SU in my own school and invited into other schools to take their SU, and it is a wonderful, wonderful way to be a Christian in that environment and to, from the front, to be able to promote the Christian faith and encourage others in their Christian walk as well.

SPEAKER_02As all broadcasters do, I'm looking at the clock. So I'm going to jump on a couple of things. It looks quite obvious that they're going to have to have some system of inspecting how RE is done, not least because it's got to be got right. And that makes perfect sense. And it's quite clear that schools are going to have to have very good policies on what happens if somebody asks for a withdrawal. Where does that child go? How does that be managed? How do they avoid this fear of stigmatization? Who looks after them? Child protection, all the obvious things that schools think about all the times.

SPEAKER_02At the end of this, there are teachers and parents who've been listening to what we've talked about, who I think want reassurance or want to say, tell me it's going to be alright, but what do we need to be thinking about? So primarily for parents, but for teachers too, I'm going to ask each of you, what would your advice be at this stage whilst we're waiting, the time of recording this, for the formal guidance to come and the changes to happen?

SPEAKER_00Ian The first thing I would say, I suppose, is don't panic. As we've already said earlier on, this is this is not as bad as being made out. It's actually an opportunity. It's an opportune time for us to to look at the core curriculum and and to embrace the change that's coming. But on a practical level, if I sort of think about my my teacher colleagues and friends within the world of education, I would I would advise anyone, particularly in the primary school, to get ahead of the curve. We don't know what the Education Ministry and Department of Education are going to produce in this guidance.

SPEAKER_00We don't know at the minute what the core syllabus will look like, but we do know that there will be some element of world faiths. And so I would suggest to any teacher out there who doesn't really have awareness of any other face, I would suggest take a look. Go and do some research into some of the world faces out there. You can do it from the current curriculum. You can indeed, you can. Look at the world's top five faces as an example, uh, top five religions, and go from there. Take a look into some secular organizations, some secular movements, the like so the humanist movement, just to see what they're saying and get yourself ahead of the curve.

SPEAKER_00I would also encourage all teachers out there to, whenever the guidance is produced in the court syllabus, is there to explicitly make sure that any world faith is mentioned in any lesson plans and any uh schemes of work to ensure that there's uh transparency and if anyone asks any questions, it's all there. In terms of assemblies, uh I suppose I would I would just advise people to be very, very careful who they allow and who they invite into their assemblies. There is no doubt that schools and school leaders will will uh be flooded with invitations now by people who are very keen to come in.

SPEAKER_02We'd love to come.

SPEAKER_00We'd love to come and help you out in this and so on. I just would advise just to do their due diligence. Take a wee look and and and and see who they are as an organisation. Is there a wider agenda? Is there ulterior motives to what they are trying to do? If at all possible, to keep keep it in-house. You trust your own judgments. You know, if you if you um if you don't want to invite somebody in, trust your own judgments. That way you can control what is said. And as a very practical piece of information, I suppose I would say I would encourage if somebody's leading an assembly to ensure that there's another member of the SLT in that room or another Sorry, SLT.

SPEAKER_00The senior leadership team, so the kind of leadership team of a school. Um and taking notes and just to ensure that anything that is said by an organisation is is scripted and and there's written evidence for that. And I suppose on scripting, I know that as teachers we don't really like to script things, but when it comes to an assembly, I think it's always good practice to script your assembly and to stick closely to the script. I know teachers like to go off on tangents here or there. But having a kind of digital record, uh it would mean that somebody could then, if somebody does come and say, Listen, you said this, there's a digital Here's our script and we stuck to it.

SPEAKER_00We we stuck to that script. Yeah. Um other other, I suppose, examples I would give is just be creative. I used to love coming up with really creative stuff for in MIRE lessons. Be creative in in and around how you teach religion, how you teach world faiths. It is really exciting to learn about other cultures and learn about other faiths as a teacher, but also then uh to learn that as a as a student. And I suppose I would just make sure you've mentioned it already, Will, that the all the processes and protocols are in place. Get it right. Get it right.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Andy, do you want people to calm down or what's your take?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I do. I mean I so I would give maybe five or six different key pieces of advice for schools and and first of all, continue delivering R.E. and collective worship in line with the current policies and syllabus because that that's what we have. As you deliver R.E. just to incorporate simple comparisons with other religions as you go along. I I want to make sure my words aren't misconstrued here. Avoid presenting Christian truth claims as compulsory belief.

SPEAKER_01Are you with me? Okay. Provide guidance to external speakers. We believe this. It's your choice whether you believe it. Provide structured and non-isolating alternatives for pupils who withdraw. I think it's really important that there if any parent exercises with their kid the right for withdrawal, that is something that is useful and productive and worthwhile. And involves them thinking about whatever the themes were that were going on in assembly that day.

SPEAKER_01As Ian has said, keep brief written records of RE schemes and assemblies, engage early with parents about the school's approach to RE and collective worship, and then await further guidance from the Department of Education. And I know there are many stakeholders, the churches included, who look forward to being involved with that guidance and helping to work with the Department of Education.

SPEAKER_02Well, you know this world so well. When can we realistically expect that guidance to arrive?

SPEAKER_01The minister has tasked some key members of staff in the department to get started on that one. I think probably within by the end of late January, early February, there will be the first reach out. Yeah, yeah. Um to different folks. There will be a timeline will be produced at that stage, and then they'll start the revision of the curriculum.

SPEAKER_02So it might be there for the next academic year, September 2016. So I would say it would definitely be there for the next academic year. Not least because there's been a Supreme Court ruling.

SPEAKER_01Not least. But also because a new curriculum has already there's been work going on behind the scenes on a new curriculum anyway, which does this. And then that new curriculum, you know, the Department might look at that and consider that and present that to various stakeholders, and they might completely change it, or they might add to it, they might tweak it.

SPEAKER_02And thanks to the Council for Public Affairs at the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. They kindly let us use that interview originally recorded for the Graciously Confident podcast. You can find Graciously Confident on the PCI website or just Google it. And thanks to you for listening to the Commission Files. I'm Will Leach, and we'll be back very soon to think about the Christian response to AI, artificial intelligence. But for now, bye bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Join the Story!

    Oct 30, 202651 minAudio

    The first ever episode of The Commission Files recorded LIVE in front of an audience at the Commission "Join the Story" event. And now available on video as well for users of Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube! Join...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Tipping Point

    Sep 29, 202644 minAudio

    It's estimated there are at least 50 million people caught in a modern form of slavery across the world. The Christian organisation, International Justice Mission, (IJM) seeks to tackle that, and has an impressive track...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. "Yes Chef..."

    Aug 29, 202655 minAudio

    Chef Stephen Jeffers has cooked for celebrities, VIPs and Royalty. As the boss of the successful Forestside Cookery School, he's a well-known contributor to Northern Ireland's' food scene. As a restaurateur he knew...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Sonas means Happiness

    Jul 31, 202642 minAudio

    Julie Hoey has learned a lot about risk recently, and the way you approach big challenges. Despite having an important job as a Civil Servant, she also runs Sonas Cooperative in Lisburn, a refill grocer, café and events...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. "You Are Incredible" - the Madlug Story

    Jun 30, 202647 minAudio

    Dave Linton, the founder of Madlug, joins Will to explain how a former youth and church worker became a modern entrepreneur with a difference. Madlug sells bags - and each time it does, a child in the care system is...

    Credit the people on this episode