Getting stood up by a potential sex wingman was one thing. Accidentally sending my parents the update intended for my lover was quite another. More admin than sex? You have no idea. This week, I’m talking dating, desire, a vindictive catfish, and the relationship “wisdom” we keep embroidering onto cushions. Who decided that being chosen by a man makes us enough, or that a relationship only counts as successful if somebody dies at the end? There’s love, there’s letting people be who they are, and there’s working out what you want without disappearing into the vortex of messages, anticipation and checking your bloody phone. Recorded in my car, with unsolicited contributions from the local seagulls. Content note: Strong language, frank sexual discussion, catfishing and manipulation in dating. Family members: consider yourselves warned. 🎙️👀 What worked? What dragged? What made you mutter “Jesus Christ, Catharine”? Tell me. Content Note ~ This podcast gets into bodies, panic attacks, trauma, sexism, mental health, and the occasional emotional sinkhole. Please look after yourself only listen when you feel safe to engage with potentially triggering material. Also, I swear. Support ~ These aren’t here as a formality. I’ve used some of these myself. Lifeline 13 11 14 (24/7) Kids Helpline 1800 55 1800 (ages 5-25) 1800RESPECT 1800 737 732 Emergency 000 Outside Australia, local crisis services are available. ~ The Socials (I'd love a follow) Instagram https://www.instagram.com/catharine.redden/ LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/catharine-redden/ Support The Pod Substack (where I write stuff) https://catharineredden.substack.com Buy Me a Coffee (where you can financially support the pod, and me!) https://buymeacoffee.com/CatharineRedden Credits Recorded on the lands of the Ramindjeri and Ngarrindjeri peoples. Sovereignty never ceded. Recorded & edited at Ridley Farm Studio by Luke Ridley https://ridleyfarmstudio.com...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00If you're a member of my family, I suggest you stop listening now because this episode is going to get hairy. You're going to find out things about me that you probably don't want to know, and then, if you are my family, you will never ever be able to unhear them. My parents have already had a proof you accidentally by text. On Monday, I got stood up by a potential sex wingman. And if you're wondering what a sex wingman is, it's someone you might go exploring with, someone you trust who has your back.
SPEAKER_00But you'd never ever live together. You don't have a joint mortgage. You do not want to have discussions about whose turn it is to take out the bin or pay the electric bill or walk the freaking dog. Anyway, when you are looking for a wing person, a potential sex wingman, you have to have conversations, compatibility to establish, even though it's not a traditional relationship.
SPEAKER_00There's stuff that you want to figure out. It's a lot of admin to do. Anyway, on Monday I had arranged to meet this potential wingman, and I got stood up. And afterwards, I sent a message to the man I call my fighter pilot. Except I didn't send that message to him, I sent it to my parents. Hi, I'm Catherine, Catherine Redden.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the C-Word. This week, more admin than sex. I realized immediately that I'd sent it to the wrong people. I deleted it, I panicked with a friend over the message, we laughed and ha ha ha ha called it character building. And then I convinced myself that they hadn't received it because Apple technology is really smart. And then when I was staying at hotel mum and dad last night, mum said to me after tea, so that message wasn't meant for us, was it?
SPEAKER_00And I got up really quickly and I said, no, nope, it wasn't, and I left the room because there are limits to my commitment to open communication. Nobody wants that. The message described being stood up, it described meeting a couple who weren't for me, and the disappointing ratio of administration to actual sexy time. And also it said something quite tender at the end that while I was waiting for this man who stood who stood me up, have I mentioned that I got stood up?
SPEAKER_00I've been thinking that my fighter pilot wouldn't leave me sitting there without a message. And when it finally dawned on me that my date was not arriving and was not going to text me or call me to tell me that he was not arriving, I was actually relieved because the person I really wanted walking through the door was my fighter pilot who FYI does not live in this state. Um and I'm gonna leave the particulars of our relationship there.
SPEAKER_00But it got me thinking about all the things we're told we're supposed to do when love and attraction doesn't look like the way we expected. Aphorisms like, oh, have I just said that right? Aphorisms. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. You know, like if you love someone, let them go. If they come back, they're yours. And if they don't, apparently they never were, except like, what about all the time you shared? Were they a fucking homing pigeon? I understand that these sayings can comfort people.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes a sentence gives you something to hold on to when you're hurting. But I think an awful lot of relationship wisdom is just somebody else's opinion that's been embroidered onto a cushion or written in a mythical little book that for some reason a lot of people want to take as fact. Am I talking about Christianity in the patriarchy? Yes, I am. And once it's written down, to have and to hold, we don't say to love and obey, to honour and obey.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know. From this day forward till death do us part. Once it's written down and those words are said, we see it as a rule. Oh, by the way, just FYI. I'm gonna break the fourth wall. I'm sitting in my car overlooking Encounter Bay at Freeman's Knob. There are a lot of birds around, and because it's spring, oh my god, there's a seagull on my car.
SPEAKER_00I can see its web little bloody feet on my windscreen. Get off my car. Look, I love a seagull, I just don't love it shitting all over my car. Once those words have been said, society tries really hard to make them reality, whilst ignoring the fact that 50% of marriages break up. And then if we think about those 50% of people who stay together, are they all being faithful?
SPEAKER_00And even the word faithful, you know, like there is a lot of pressure on human beings to quote unquote do the right thing, to quote unquote be loyal. And if someone doesn't choose the relationship you want, so if I know I'm gonna sound like I'm dancing around the subject, but if you're involved with someone and they don't choose you, what do you do?
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of rhetoric out there about cutting them off and deleting them and blocking them, and I do that with most people, but but you know, like we say to ourselves, if they really loved you, they would do this, if you respected yourself, you would do that, and sometimes leaving and blocking and deleting is absolutely the right thing. You need distance, you need to stop reopening conversations that keep hurting you.
SPEAKER_00But I don't think that's the only possible answer to every complicated relationship. I've found real peace in accepting in meeting the other person where they're at. You know, let people be where they are. Not trying to force an outcome, and in fact divorcing yourself from any outcome, and that's really bloody hard.
SPEAKER_00When I got stood up on Monday, I was late, so I sent a text saying I was running five or ten minutes late. I sent that text about a quarter of an hour before we were due to meet, a couple of hours before we were due to meet, he sent me a text just confirming everything. And we'd been flirty for a week, and you know, I ominously said at one stage to him, Oh, this is a bit too easy.
SPEAKER_00Because when you get stood up, the thoughts running through my mind were that I've also been gas lit. Like I don't know, and possibly catfished, like I I don't the whole trifecta, because you don't know, I didn't know this person who had agreed to meet me because I hadn't met him before, and I I'd first come into contact with him on the dodgy dating site, and so you know, was it really that person?
SPEAKER_00Was it a was it someone just setting me up? Is it someone that knows me that was trying to make me look bad? You know, there's a whole lot of stuff that runs, well, there's a whole lot of stuff that ran through my brain, and I didn't cry, I just I just I still think surely he's in a coma somewhere, like that can be the only explanation I've been catfished before, and actually that was a lot worse.
SPEAKER_00Um I was on another dodgy dating site and met this guy who was a little bit younger than me, really attractive and really into me, you know, and sometimes I can now recognise it as love bombing, but back then I didn't. And we agreed to meet and we walked, I walked into the cafe, I think it was a cafe, and I couldn't see the guy. And I, you know, I'm sort of my glasses.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if you wear glasses, I'm in a perpetual state of not having the right prescription, you know, and I take them off and I put them on, I still can't see the person. And this other this this bald, much older man said to me, Oh Catherine, it's blah blah blah, and I sort of it was not the it was not the person I'd been talking to. Like, well, it wasn't the photograph, and I said, Oh, and then I didn't know what to do because the good girl in me has been taught to accept people for who they are and not judge someone when you first meet them on their looks, even though I was there on a date, and of course I can judge whether I'm attracted to a person or not.
SPEAKER_00And so we sat down and he said to me, 'Oh, you look a bit shocked,' and I said, Yeah. He said, Oh, that's not me in the photo. Um, you and I were talking about six weeks ago, and you told me I wasn't for you, and I just wanted to teach you a lesson. And I had a lot of very complicated emotions at that point because I I and again I wouldn't do this now, but I thought that I had to sit there and take it.
SPEAKER_00Because I'd rejected him because I'm not, I'm not, I wasn't attracted to him. I can tell before I meet the person if I'm going to be attracted to them. I've been doing this long enough that I just know. And this this man was not I was not attracted to him, and I was not attracted to him in real life. And when he I should have left. I didn't, we were sort of awkward for a little bit, and um then I sort of said, look, I'm gonna go now.
SPEAKER_00But I should have I should have just I should have left dramatically when he wasn't who he said he was. Oh, by the way, it's perfectly okay, and you should block people like that. And when I when I went back and tried to do a reverse photo search, which everybody seems to be able to do except me, I couldn't I couldn't find whose photo he'd used or anything like that. You'd think that would make me more cautious, but it doesn't.
SPEAKER_00Like I'm s I'm always hopeful. I'm always hopeful. When I look at the stories we're surrounded by, romantic love takes up an extraordinary amount of space. Televisions, streaming services, cinema, theatre, books, poetry, art, reality television shows, scripted television shows.
SPEAKER_00Be chosen, and the there's a heavy emphasis on heterosexual couples. Be chosen, become a couple, stay together forever. Roll credits. And yes, there are other stories, but that particular narrative, man plus woman fall in love, and then they just stick at it forever. It has a lot of authority in our society, particularly for women. Being chosen by a man can still be presented as the thing that confirms we're desirable, worthwhile, and successful at being a woman.
SPEAKER_00I'm just going to stop here and remind every person listening that it is a woman who gives birth to you. Women give birth to humans. We do not. Even if we don't give birth to humans like me, I haven't given any birth to any non-humans either, but you do not need to be chosen by a man to be enough.
SPEAKER_00And in fact, the more enough you can come to yourself, you the more enough you are to yourself, and the more you divorce yourself from the outcome, in my experience, the more you really do have to enjoy the fucking process. There is no other way. I wish there was, because sometimes I do not like having to enjoy the process. I just want to get to the end where you're old and wrinkly and grey and you you hold hands forever in the nursing home.
SPEAKER_00The patriarchy is everywhere. And the idea that a woman's life finds its proper shape once a man has chosen her. I want love in my life. I really want sex in my life and affection and someone I fancy walking through the door. But I resent the suggestion everything else is the waiting room. And I resent the suggestion that that that love needs to exist in a particular way that society wants it to exist in, for everything to be okay, and for me not to be called weird or different or unusual or dangerous or unsafe.
SPEAKER_00And I question the idea that one person must be our everything, or that a relationship only counts as successful if it lasts until somebody dies. A relationship can end and still have mattered. Those 17 years that I spent married to my ex-husband mattered. And I don't see our marriage as a failure. I see it as something that ended.
SPEAKER_00You can love someone, and this is a hard one, and realize you don't want the life that they're offering. You can be in love with someone, and they can be in love with you. But if that the life that they're offering isn't what you want and isn't what you need, then well, that's a really tricky situation. You can want someone who can't give you everything you want.
SPEAKER_00And take some time to work out what you're gonna do about that. You don't have to turn them into a villain to justify leaving. And you don't have to stay because they're not a villain. I'm gonna say that again because I really like it. You don't have to turn them into a villain to justify leaving. It's and you don't have to stay because they're not a villain. Marriage marriage divorce leaving your spouse is not illegal in Australia and it is not immoral.
SPEAKER_00It is not wrong. There's still, yes, there is still a lot of pressure on us to stay and work it out, and I understand that children complicate things and money complicates things, but again, you don't have to turn your partner into a villain to justify leaving, and you don't have to stay because they're not a villain.
SPEAKER_00I also want to be clear: wanting a different kind of relationship and deceiving someone are different things. People deserve to know what they're agreeing to. You can question monogamy and still expect honesty. You can be sexually adventurous and still expect someone to send a bloody text if they're not going to meet you on the date. Which brings me back to Monday. Because the question for me is how to keep exploring without getting sucked into the vortex, the messages, the organizing, the swapping of pics.
SPEAKER_00I have a very hard rule on that. I've had some very cute boudoir photos taken. There is no nipple or puss showing, nor will there ever be. I will never, I will never send a nude. Never say never. I will never send a nude. I'm gonna have a caveat to someone I haven't met. There's a lot of time in that, and there's a lot of dopamine hits.
SPEAKER_00And so I walk a line, and perhaps you do too, between really wanting to enjoy this part of my life, but not wanting to get sucked into all of the attention and everything, because I want to live my life as well. Not just doing sexy things, I mean a little bit more would be great, but you know, like an idiot.
SPEAKER_00I think I don't know, perhaps it happens to men as well, but I can get really sucked into that feeling of being wanted and desired and doing something a little bit new and a little bit naughty because society's consumed with that. You just have to look at the amount of Instagram posts about people getting engaged and married and having babies, or people just um starting a new relationship. Society's obsessed with it.
SPEAKER_00In this part of my life, and I I mean post-menopausal, I'm nearly 55. Yes, you can send me a birthday present in early December. Contact me for the address. But I want to write, I want to see my friends, I want to walk the dogs I'm walking, I want to read a book without checking to see whether some man has replied. I want to watch a whole episode of something on Netflix without checking my phone. I want to notice what I'm feeling. I want to have coffee at my favourite coffee shop, I want to get my hair and nails done for myself.
SPEAKER_00I want to be enough for myself rather than for someone else. Am I excited about meeting a new person? Of course I am. Or have I become so invested into arranging the meeting that I've forgotten to ask whether I even want to go. Am I enjoying what's actually happening? Or am I spending most of my time imagining what it could become? Look, and I don't have a neat answer. Monday.
SPEAKER_00Sounds like I'm fixated. I really am over it. Oh shit, I thought that was a person, but it was a seagull. Sorry, got very close to the car. I'm just gonna wind the window up because I'm recording with the windows down and now I'm getting a little bit cold. I haven't got a neat, tidy answer. Monday involved being stood up and then accidentally briefing my parents on my sexual adventures. And some of them are a little bit unconventional. So I'm hardly presenting myself as the finished product.
SPEAKER_00But I'm learning that I can want more without trying to force another person to provide fun and excitement and love and happiness. I don't need to patch somebody's happiness onto my own to enjoy my life. I can care about someone and still make a choice for myself. I'm allowed to work out that I'm allowed to work that out without obeying every word in that mythical little book.
SPEAKER_00If you want to obey the words in that mythical little book, and it's whichever mythical little book belongs to your chosen religion, I respect that. You knock yourself out, but don't expect me to have to do it as well. Anyway, I as this podcast winds up, I like when I've got a guest, I like to say to the guest, tell me what's bringing you joy right now. So I want to say that to you. First of all, how are you going?
SPEAKER_00Hope you're well. If you're not well, I hope this podcast made you smile. And if it didn't, there's many others that will. I hope there's something bringing you joy, something that deserves a bit of your attention this week. Something that's just for you. Oh, and by the way, before you send anyone an intimate update on your sex life, check the recipients and then check it again before you press end.
SPEAKER_00Bye! God, that was a weird way to end, Catherine. Bye!
Not every uncomfortable emotion is a mental health crisis. And not every woman is responsible for fixing a man’s feelings. In this episode of The C-Word, I explore something that’s been giving me the absolute shits for...
CONTENT WARNING: Discussion of sexual assault, rape fantasies, rape role-play, BDSM and explicit sexual scenarios. Two men. Two dating platforms. Two conversations in 48 hours that left me wondering what the bloody hell...
After a month away, I’m back, recording from my car with Sadie the Wonder Dog and a brain that’s had enough dark shit from Instagram. How the do we begin fix this world-wide crisis that is male violence perpetuated on...
CONTENT WARNING: This episode discusses rape, sexual assault, suicidal thoughts, mental health crisis and involuntary psychiatric treatment. Melanie Wrest went to hospital after being raped. She told police she was...
Surrogacy in Australia: What Happens When Key Relationships Break Down? When Hayley agreed to become a surrogate for people she knew and trusted, she imagined she wasn’t simply helping create a family. She imagined...