How do you turn a long executive career into a board proposition that a nomination committee will read? In this episode of The Boardroom Path, host Ralph Grayson speaks with Joanna Meager, a portfolio non-executive director who chairs the remuneration committee at TP ICAP's UK regulated entities and at SMBC Bank International. Joanna explains why she rewrote her CV around competencies rather than job titles, how she reads every board paper twice so that she arrives with fewer, better questions, and why she tests her own questions with a red pen before a meeting. She also describes what she does when a transformation programme feels off track instead of stepping into management, and the two questions she asks before a board approves an AI proposal. IBM research published in October 2026 found that eight in ten UK executives report an AI-related incident, with governance and accountability lagging adoption. Joanna's starting point is plainer: understand the business first, then ask what happens when the technology fails. (00:00) - Welcome to The Boardroom Path (02:41) - Deciding Whether a NED Portfolio Fits You (06:47) - What the NED Role Really Involves (10:00) - From Executive CV to Board Proposition (13:24) - Accountability From the First Meeting (15:03) - A Two-Pass Approach to Board Papers (18:11) - Owning Your Board Induction (21:47) - Offering Help Without Overstepping (26:25) - AI, Mindset and Understanding the Business (31:49) - What Remuneration Committees Really Do (35:16) - Groupthink and Constructive Challenge (37:17) - Choosing a Board and Reading the Room Joanna Meager: Joanna Meager is a portfolio non-executive director with a career across international financial services, including capital markets, prime brokerage and asset management. At Royal Bank of Canada she was global head of client operations and chief executive of investor and treasury services in the UK, with earlier responsibility for operations, technology, regulatory governance, mergers and acquisitions and global transformation programmes. She joined the UK regulated entities board of TP ICAP in November 2023 and chairs its remuneration committee. In June 2025 she became an independent non-executive director of SMBC Bank International, where she chairs the remuneration committee and sits on the audit and risk committees. Ralph Grayson: Ralph Grayson is a Partner in the Board Practice at Sainty Hird & Partners, bringing extensive experience in board-level recruitment, assessment, and advisory services. With a deep understanding of the corporate governance landscape, Ralph specialises in guiding senior executives as they transition into impactful boardroom careers. His thoughtful approach, combined with a passion for developing effective leaders, enables him to facilitate insightful conversations that equip aspiring and newly appointed Non-Executive Directors with the tools they need to succeed. Through The Boardroom Path, Ralph leverages his extensive professional network and expertise to empower listeners on their journey into the boardroom. Episode Insights: A non-executive portfolio suits people who enjoy preparation, judgement and influence; if you loved control and execution, the role will not satisfy you. Rewriting an executive CV around competencies rather than job history changes how interviews are run and how nomination committees read you. Reading board papers twice, once on arrival and once two days before the meeting, produces fewer questions and better ones. Boards need diversity of thought, and a room where every question sounds the same is a sign of groupthink. AI helps with prompts and personal productivity, but it does not replace an understanding of the business; boards should ask about fallbacks and continuous checks. Action Points: Audit your motivation first: Write down what you enjoyed in your executive career and what you did not. If the list is dominated by control, accountability and doing the work yourself, a NED portfolio will frustrate you. Test those themes against what a board actually does, which is reading, questioning and nudging. Rewrite your CV around competencies: Rebuild your CV and LinkedIn around the skills a board needs rather than the jobs you held. Expect your longest role to shrink to a few lines. Ask someone who knows you and knows the NED market to check that the proposition reads clearly. Split your board prep in two: Read the papers once when they arrive without writing anything down, then read them again two days before the meeting and write your questions then. This stops you asking what the pack answers on page fifteen and keeps the detail fresh. Check every question for an executive tone before you go in. Coach the executive, do not collect the data: When something feels off track, ask the executive to bring the evidence you need to the next meeting rather than sourcing it yourself. Work through the executives, not around them. Offer your experience outside the meeting, where it cannot read as instruction. Set your own induction standard: Treat the formal induction as the minimum and decide what else you need. Ask for extra meetings, briefings or reports on the parts of the business you know least well. Ownership of that process sits with you, not the company secretary. The Boardroom Path is the essential podcast for aspiring and newly appointed Non-Executive Directors (NEDs) navigating the journey from executive leadership to the boardroom. Hosted by Ralph Grayson, partner at Sainty Hird & Partners, each episode offers insightful conversations with industry leaders, seasoned board directors, and governance experts. Our guests share practical strategies, valuable perspectives, and actionable advice on how to effectively transition into board roles, maximise your impact, and build a rewarding NED career. Subscribe now, and take your first confident step along The Boardroom Path. Learn more about Sainty Hird & Partners at saintyhird.com. The Boardroom Path is produced by Story Ninety-Four in Oxford, UK.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Joanna Meager: I don't think you can ever rely on a technology to replace your understanding of a business. Use the technology as much as you want, but you've got to understand the business first. Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom Path by Sainty Hird & Partners. I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a partner in the board practice. In this series, we'll offer practical steps and useful perspectives for aspiring and newly appointed NEDs. When you've spent your career making things happen, leading people, transforming businesses, and taking responsibility for delivery.
What changes when you join a board as a non-executive director? Your experience remains valuable, but how you use it must evolve. You need to establish credibility, exercise independent judgement, and help the executive team succeed while recognising that running the business is their responsibility. My guest today, Joanna Meager, brings a particularly relevant perspective to that transition. Joanna's executive career has encompassed international financial services,
including capital markets, prime brokerage and asset management, with substantial experience in operations, technology, regulatory governance, mergers and acquisitions, and major global transformation programmes. At Royal Bank of Canada, her leadership responsibilities included global head of client operations and CEO of investor and treasury services in the UK. Those roles placed her close to the connections between commercial ambition, client service, technology, people, and operational risk.
She subsequently developed a portfolio spanning non-executive and advisory responsibilities. For listeners contemplating the first board appointment, Joanna's experience opens up several practical questions. How do you translate an executive career into a clear board proposition? How do you contribute beyond your particular specialisation? How do you challenge management without becoming an alternative management team? And how do you decide whether the chair, culture, and expectations of a prospective board are right for you?
We'll also explore technology and AI, diversity, risk, and the REM committee, assessing where questions about performance, behaviour, fairness, and long-term success come together. Joanna, welcome to The Boardroom Path. Joanna Meager: Thank you very much. Ralph Grayson: So, before we discuss the mechanics of becoming a NED, what made you want to do this? What were you hoping to contribute and I guess most importantly, what did you want from this next stage of your career? Joanna Meager: So it was both an informal and a formal process that I went through.
So when I left my executive career, I really tried to work out what it was I enjoyed about my executive career. Not in the detail of the job, but did I enjoy the strategy, the direction of the company, joining the dots, mentoring people? I went through a long list in my head to try and work out what my next step was and I think that's really important for anyone leaving an executive career. There will be things that you loved about it and there will be things
that you loved not quite so much about it and once you've listed those out for yourself, it will be clear as to whether that adds up to a NED portfolio. Some people just aren't cut out for a NED portfolio. If the aspects of your exec career that you loved were the control and the accountability and doing the execution yourself, don't take on a NED portfolio. Ralph Grayson: Great advice to start with. Were there things you consciously thought about wanting to retain
from your executive life and things you particularly wanted to change? And I guess within that, was this a deliberate plan or just an evolving opportunity and a certain amount of serendipity? Joanna Meager: There was a certain amount of serendipity. But one of the biggest things as I've changed roles through my executive career is I've made a conscious decision never to do the same job for a competitor. That doesn't give you a great learning experience. You learn how to answer the phone with a different corporate title, but you're
doing the same thing for somebody else. So I've always swapped around and when you read the intro, and thank you for that glorious intro, you told of all the different parts of financial services I've worked in and that was absolutely a conscious decision because I like learning new things. So when I took on the various NED roles that I've done, one of my key lenses that I was looking through was, was I going to learn something new? Ralph Grayson: So is there a tipping point at which you woke up one morning and thought now's the time to be a NED tomorrow, but at least now is the
time to start thinking about this? Joanna Meager: I should have thought about it earlier. I should have thought about it earlier purely to build the transition but I had quite a clean break from my executive career because we sold a business. And I thought initially that I was going to take on another exec role. It was only when I had the pause and I actually could think about what I really wanted to do, that the NED route seemed more logical for me.
Ralph Grayson: And the question I always love asking is, what was the distinction between being attracted to a board appointment as opposed to enjoying the work that you thought it would entail? Joanna Meager: For me, it was very much looking at the company as the first point. Could I learn something from that company that I would be sitting as a non-exec director on? And then as I went through the interview process, and you know better than most, those interview processes can be quite long.
You got to learn a lot about the company and the people that you were working with. That was a key decision point for me. Ralph Grayson: And was there a particular experience, conversation, somebody you spoke to, a mentor or a coach, that helped you decide? Joanna Meager: I speak to a lot of people, and I did have help from people that had already taken that NED transition and gave me advice more on what not to accept and making sure that I didn't put myself in a conflicted situation right from the get-go.
So that was exceedingly helpful. Ralph Grayson: And was there anything you wished you'd asked yourself at that point in your career or that pivot moment? Is there something that you would advise somebody to ask themselves before concluding that a NED role is the right next step for them, crucially for the right reasons? Joanna Meager: I think it's really being clear on what a NED role entails and whether that is something that you are truly interested
in because it's a very different aspect than your executive career. There are parts of your executive career that are completely applicable, but it's things like, are you prepared to wade through quite lengthy tomes of board papers? Does that interest you? That preparatory work that you do on your own and joining the dots and asking the right questions, does that interest you? And being able to coach and mentor and direct in a nudging kind of way rather
than a controlling directive way. If that's not something in your executive career that you enjoy doing, you're not miraculously going to enjoy doing it in your NED career. Ralph Grayson: And as we touched on, your background has a huge breadth to it, operations, technology, transformation, regulated financial services. So I guess it would be quite simple to say there are a lot of things here I solve for but is the reality of the NED roles that you've now got are you solving for what you thought you were going to solve for?
Joanna Meager: Yeah, for the most part yes. I do think that when you look at your previous executive career, the breadth of different things that I've done, and even the breadth of the different week or month that you may have, especially if you've done international executive roles like I did. One week was nothing like the next week. One board meeting is very similar to the next board meeting. That's the good thing about it. You're building on foundations of work that you've done for the April board
meeting and the June board meeting and in the October board meeting. But you do not have the variety doing a NED portfolio in the actual role aspect that you had in an executive career. You get the variety by having a portfolio of NED jobs across different companies. Ralph Grayson: And I really want to touch on here the difference between an executive CV and a board proposition because delivery I think is a constant theme in your executive CV, which I know fairly well.
Yes, any board role is all about good judgement and that difference between influence and authority. For somebody who was stereotypical delivery, did you find it tough to make that decision? Did it come naturally to you? What did you have to learn and unlearn? Joanna Meager: A really good question. Yes, my career up to executive had been all about delivery, absolutely, across multiple different things. But once you get to a certain level, you're not doing the delivery yourself.
You're coaching the people that are doing the delivery. I think as I got older, it's not a maturity thing, but as I got older, I realised that coaching was much more about getting the best out of those people than stepping in and doing it yourself. So that very much aligned to moving over to a NED role. The one thing that I didn't do very well at the outset is reposition my resume and my resume was written as an executive resume.
I spent all of the time on the areas of work that I'd done most in. That's how we all write our resumes. We go, "I did 13 years in this job, so that's better take half the page." And that's not how you need to write your resume for a NED role. You need to write your resume based upon the skills and the competencies that you have that will translate into the NED role. So you may end up writing not very much about that big executive job
that you did and don't try and make your resume equal the years of effort. It needs a complete 180 rethink and that I didn't do right from the get-go. I did learn how to do it and it felt a bit like you were giving something up. It's like, "Oh my goodness, that job that I did for 10 years has only got three lines on my resume now." But it makes it much more relevant for somebody looking for a NED. Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think this labelling point is really interesting that you touch on there and it's both sides of the table.
It's how you as the candidate label yourself, but also how somebody on the Nominations committee labels you. And I guess in your context, Joanna, it would be very lazy but easy for people to label you as the operations person or the delivery person or the technology person. Did you consciously try and deconstruct that? Or was that something that came out of practice of doing interviews? Joanna Meager: I deconstructed it on my LinkedIn and I deconstructed it on my resume which then led to the interviews being conducted in a different way
because most of the interviews are led by what you've written on your resume. What was important and useful for me is if I look back over my career, I was around when operational risk was first being formed and talked about. So the elements I could put into my resume around what I'd done around operational risk, what I'd done around looking at target operating models and driving strategy, it was just pulling those themes out rather than pulling the jobs out.
Ralph Grayson: So if you're going to advise a listener to think about how to structure their board proposition in kind of three sentences or three lines, what do you think it's crucial that those sentences establish? Joanna Meager: They've got to establish the competencies and the skills that you will bring to the board table, not the jobs that you have done. Ralph Grayson: And how does somebody rationalise that when they're reading their own CV and looking in the mirror? It's. Joanna Meager: It's actually really difficult to do yourself.
Ralph Grayson: That's why I asked the question. Joanna Meager: You can make a stab at it, but the best thing is to find a trusted ear. Someone that knows you relatively well but also somebody that understands the board and the NED space, and they will be able to put the turn on it for you. Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think that's really good advice. Take us into your early experience as a NED then. What surprised you about the reality of the role even after you've had such a substantial and successful executive career?
Joanna Meager: I think what surprised me in a good way was the accountability and the responsibility right from the get-go. It's kind of good and bad. So you think if you take on an executive role and you take on a new job, a new executive role in the same company or even in a different company, you have some help, you have a team of people that work for you that will make sure that you are brought into the firm in the right way, that you're brought
into that new role in the right way, and you've got a lot of people to lean on that you don't necessarily have to make any of the decisions on your own right from the get-go. When you join a board or any subcommittee of a board, you have no team of people to go to and validate a question or validate something that you are looking at. You are thrown in at the deep end a little bit and this is nothing to do with the companies I work for, it's the nature of going into a board.
You've got to use your experienced NEDs that have been there a while. There is the adage of no question is a stupid question. There are stupid questions. Make sure you ask those in private and then when you can turn up to the board meeting, and the great thing is you get a lot of prep time, you can deal with all of those qualifying questions with your co-board members. But the accountability you get right from the get-go, that was the biggest surprise for me.
Ralph Grayson: There's a lot to unpick there. So how do you teach yourself how to be efficient going through some board papers? Joanna Meager: I have a prep model that I've evolved over the last couple of years that really works for me. Doesn't necessarily work for everybody, but it works for me. So I read all of the papers and I write no notes and I write no questions. I just read them as soon as they've come out and then two days before the meeting, I read them again, and that's when I write my questions.
Why? I learned really early on that I used to write lots and lots of questions that all got answered 15 pages on in the deck. So I don't do that anymore. I also learned really early on that if you do all your prep, the minute the papers come out, you've probably forgotten it by the time the meeting comes around. So that's why I split it in two. I've taught that model to quite a few people now, and it works very well. There are great tools out there as well. Lots of the board tools allow you to write Post-it notes on them,
electronically, and of course, there's all of the AI enablement now that allows you to summarise things. So kind of whatever works for you. We've all gone through lots and lots of documents before, so I'm sure everyone's got their own way of doing it. Ralph Grayson: How did you learn the difference between management engagement as opposed to management in an executive sense and this key skill of observation rather than direction? Joanna Meager: That's a really good question and very tricky.
Some of it is in the language, so you have to think about how you're asking the question and your question is always a clarification question, a help me understand question, can you give me some more information around that? Whereas when you're an executive, it's like, "Well, I don't necessarily agree with that." You've got to really change your language and I was very conscious of that from the start and it might have even sounded a little forced to start off with,
but you soon get into the rhythm of it. And then I also, as I went through and did my prep work, I made sure that I went back to basics of you're there to make sure this is sound, you're there to make sure this is appropriately governed, there's always more than one way to do something as an executive. You're not there to tell them how to do it. I challenged myself as I was going through my prep and then when I went
back and read my questions, if any of my questions sounded executive-like, and believe me they did, I used to take a red pen to them and cross them out. Ralph Grayson: Yeah, learning to ask open questions as opposed to closed questions is something I've certainly learned in 12 months doing podcasts. And without being specific as to your roles but more of a generic open question what could people do better in terms of induction onto the board and having you prepared before you arrive? If a chair's listening and thinking, have I got my induction right for a new
board member, what would you stress? Joanna Meager: I think a number of the boards do the induction really well, right? So they do the induction of getting you into the company and onto the board exceedingly well. It's a well-trodden path and a well-oiled machine. The bit that I would encourage is that the new NED themselves doesn't just take that as exhaustive. I would suggest that's the minimum. So that's being put to you as this is the path that we've always
used in order to get new board members into the organisation. That doesn't mean that that's all you need to do. So as you go through that induction, work out what else you need to do. You may be sitting on a board of a company and a business that you know really well and you did that business as an executive. You're going to need a different level of induction to if you're sitting on the board of a part of a business or a part of financial services that you don't know.
Don't feel that you can't go back and go, "Can I have this extra meeting? Can I have this extra report?" And I think the biggest learning is you as the new board member, your induction is in your hands. The CoSec or the chair of the board is helping you, but you have to own that induction yourself. Ralph Grayson: And I think most new NEDs that I talk to have some combination of imposter syndrome or they worry about their credibility.
So how do you get the balance right between feeling you must demonstrate your expertise at the first few meetings, but also knowing when to listen and when to speak? Joanna Meager: Yeah, definitely more listening than speaking. In all meetings, no matter how good you've become, because that's the nature of being a board member. I found that the best thing was, especially as I was learning, was to have the meetings with the other board members before and after the board.
So I would ask my questions to them beforehand. Probably that meant that half of them got taken off and I didn't need to ask them in the board meeting and then after the board meeting, I would circle back with them on anything that I didn't understand or I wanted clarification on why we went a certain route. That's the best way to build up your confidence because you're doing it in the board meeting and outside of the board meeting. As time goes on, the outside of the board meeting just drops away
and it's all in the board meeting. Ralph Grayson: Did you spot somebody on the board, may have been the chair, may have been the SID, may have been just an old, wise, more experienced NED. But is there somebody that you picked out to say, "Okay, should I create a relationship with this person to be able to have those offline conversations with?" Joanna Meager: I did it with everyone. I probably was a pain in the neck. So depending upon the question kind of depended where I went. I thought about what is it that I've got a gap on that I need some help with? If it was something risk-related, I might go to the chief risk officer.
I used all the executives as well. As I say there, I probably was a pain in the neck as I'm looking back on it. So yes, I just went to the person that I thought had the most expertise. Ralph Grayson: Okay, makes a lot of sense. Joanna Meager: And probably built a great network as a result. Ralph Grayson: Yeah, which is not to be underestimated, right? And as somebody, going back to your delivery running through you like a stick of rock, how did you learn to check yourself when you saw a problem which you knew how to solve? Joanna Meager: It's tricky. I can't honestly say I've completely solved for that one.
But the way I do it, rightly or wrongly, is to offer help. So if I see a problem coming up that I've seen a variety of, I offer coffee. I jokingly say for the price of a cup of coffee, I can probably give you some advice on that. So I take it out of the board meeting, out of the risk committee, out of whatever meeting it is, and then I'll just spend time with the executive and say, "Look, you can use this if you want or feel free to throw it away with the coffee cup. But this is what I've done when I've seen one of these
before." You don't do it in the meeting. Ralph Grayson: And what might tell you you're getting too close to executive territory, even if it's the executive asking for it? Joanna Meager: You can only really spend the time that you've got available, and if you've got a portfolio that time is quite precious and quite juggled. One of the things that I would advise anybody taking on a NED portfolio is when you worked for one company as an executive, you had one diary, and even though your diary might have felt full, it was full with one company.
There's a lot more juggling to do when it's more than one company. I don't find I have the capacity to overstep the mark. You also don't get all of the information to be able to overstep the mark, because you're getting summary papers, you're not getting detailed project plans or… it's pretty easy to stay on the right side of the line. I also work with some great executives that would clearly push me back across the line if I overstepped it. Ralph Grayson: So let's try and bring that to life a little bit.
Transformation is one of your key subject matters. So let's say you're being told by the executive a transformation programme's on track, but just something in your experience is making you a little queasy, uneasy, whatever it may be. What would you ask, what evidence would you seek, and how and when might you escalate? Joanna Meager: So one, be careful what you ask, because once you've got the information, you probably need to do something with it. I would probably coach them because they've been given that information
probably by people in the organisation that are actually directly running it. So I would coach them on the questions to ask, "So next time you come and present, it would be great if we could see, da da, da." I wouldn't step in and go and get the data myself. You've got to work through the executives, not around the executives. Ralph Grayson: And you've worked in some big international businesses. How does an international context make that different if maybe some of the important strategic decisions are shaped elsewhere in the organisation?
Joanna Meager: That's the nature of international business, isn't it? I've never, until very recently, worked in organisations where the head office has been in the UK and I've worked outside of the UK as much as I've worked in the UK. So I completely understand how you have to balance local priorities with global strategic decision-making. It's second nature to me. I'm more surprised when everything's in one location.
I think it just gives you a better appreciation of the nuances, either of how to work with different types of people who care about different types of things, but also to understand what you really can influence and what you can't. Ralph Grayson: Just love to pick up on that word nuance there, because I think that's so interesting because it raises the question about cultural norms and how do you challenge and how do you use judgement and what do people understand by independence? Have you felt that experience? Joanna Meager: Definitely, and it depends on how you mean the word cultural.
So cultural doesn't have to attach to a country. Cultural can attach to a type of company and how they would like to be challenged and don't like to be challenged. It can also attach to just an individual person, like how somebody reacts to a different type of challenge. For me, the analogy I always use is it's like giving birthday cards and I know you're giving me that scowly face, but when you send a birthday card, you send a birthday card, the card the person wants to receive,
not the card that you want to send. Otherwise everyone would get the same birthday card from me. So I always try and think, how would the person like to hear this ask, not just how does Joanna want to say this ask? Ralph Grayson: Gosh, that's so interesting and where does AI, the dreaded AI, fit into all of Joanna Meager: Oh, I love AI. I was one of the earliest proponents of AI. But in my personal life as well as in my work life, and I've got children of
a certain age that should be teaching me, and it's the other way round. I have friends that have sent me hilarious little cartoons. One of them says when your kids are teaching you how to use tech and getting frustrated, just remind them that you taught them how to use a knife and fork. But I am the one teaching my kids because I've just got so into it. I find it so helpful. My biggest tip is AI will write the prompts for you.
You can ask AI, "What prompt should I tell you to do this?" And it will write the prompt for you. AI is all about having the right prompts. So for your personal life, it's about having the right prompts. For your personal productivity, it's about having the right prompts. And then using AI more broadly in the business in order to make things more effective, better quality, time to market, all of those things. It's just changing and evolving every week.
So it's not like running projects of past eras where you could have multiple quarters or even multiple years to implement something. If you take that long, the technology will have evolved too many times over. Ralph Grayson: As somebody who is technologically much savvier than me, I'd love to ask you this question. I was on a panel earlier this week about AI in the boardroom. Seems to be every panel I seem to be invited to join these days and it was fascinating because we were talking about the demographics of who should be
on the board and whether we need younger board members who actually understand the technology that goes around AI and the balance with perhaps more seasoned people, should we say, who understand its context. And one person made a really interesting observation, said, "I'm of a certain age. I haven't grown up in the AI generation, but I am old enough to remember Y2K and I remember all the palaver we got in about tech being the disruptor as we came into Y2K, and planes were going to drop out of the sky and how it fitted into the risk register." And she said, "I find it enormously valuable now
just to be able to go back 26 years and remember that thought process and remember how we put it in the risk register." What's your perspective on that? I mean, you smiled, so I hope it resonates. But I'd love your perspective on that. Joanna Meager: See, I'm going to go back to one of your first comments, which is about the demographics and the age of the people on the board. I don't think it's about that. I think it's about mindset, and it's that most adaptable to change mindset and that growth mindset. The reason I have adopted AI quite so broadly is because it helps.
If you can find a reason to do something that gives you personal gain and productivity, I think most of us would do it. So for me, having the right mixture of mindsets on the board is probably far more helpful than a different level of demographics. I also think that you've got to understand a business first before you can apply technology to it of whatever type. I remember years ago, and I'm talking a long time ago, a system on the trading
floor stopped and it stopped being able to calculate accrued interest on bonds and I looked across the trading floor and the suggestion was that we stopped trading bonds for the afternoon because the booking system couldn't calculate accrued interest. And I said, "Don't be ridiculous. We'll just manually calculate the accrued interest,' until I realised that I was the only person on the trading floor that remembered how to calculate accrued interest. So after a very quick lesson in one of the meeting rooms, I suddenly taught 20
people how to calculate accrued interest. We were back up and running. I don't think you can ever rely on a technology to replace your understanding of a business. Use the technology as much as you want, but you've got to understand the business first. Ralph Grayson: And what's the balance of reliance there? Is the danger we all become overly reliant and therefore you're abrogating your responsibility as a board member by saying, "Well, what does the AI tell us?" Joanna Meager: You know what? We can all still add up and Excel's been around for a while.
So I won't worry about that too much. Ralph Grayson: What are the three questions then that any new NED should feel comfortable asking about an AI proposal at their next board meeting? Joanna Meager: Oh, that's a tricky one. I think it depends what kind of AI proposal it is. If it's just a plain personal productivity proposal, that's simple and easy. There's less risk involved there. If it's taking out of activity, processes, et cetera, I always ask the fallback.
If this isn't working, what's the fallback? Back to my accrued interest example. I always ask about how we are sense-checking that it's still working and not hallucinating, et cetera? So what does that continuous activity look like? Ralph Grayson: Lots to think about there. Let's turn on to REM committees, because I think they're very misunderstood. You may or may not want to speculate on the balance of risk and reward of being a board member these days and the amount of published days there
are, the actual days you spend doing it and what you get rewarded for. But what do most people underestimate about the work of a REMCO? Joanna Meager: I think when you look at REMCO responsibilities, it's probably not quite as defined as some of the other board meetings. So different companies want the REMCO to do different things, and that's fine. Ralph Grayson: Bring that to life for me. Joanna Meager: If you look at what's expected from a risk committee, I think the reporting might be slightly different, but the expectation of what's covered
in a risk committee is fairly standard. When you look at what's included in a REMCO, there are different perceptions of whose compensation should be reviewed, what the risk process should be, how much detail should you go into on conduct. So it doesn't quite have the same defined parameters around it, which makes it interesting. What I would say is always go back to your terms of reference.
So go back to your terms of reference and make sure that you're covering everything in your REMCO that you should be covering. Sometimes terms of reference can be written and put to one side, and like objectives, they should be a living document and reviewed on a regular basis, and you should be reviewing them against the agenda to make sure that you're covering everything in there. Ralph Grayson: Where's your personal north star as a good member of a REMCO in terms of, I mean, let's take a hugely successful trader whose behaviour
perhaps is not what it could be. Where's the balance there? Where's the responsibility of a REMCO member? Joanna Meager: So the company will have its own processes and procedures. It will have documented disciplinary and conduct activity. As the REMCO, you're there to make sure that they have followed those processes and practices. You're not there to change them. You're there to make sure that they're followed and interpreted appropriately. Ralph Grayson: Data, data, data then. Joanna Meager: Absolutely. Ralph Grayson: Okay, and same rules apply when it comes to diversity, ESG?
Joanna Meager: So for me, I have a slightly different view of diversity and I'm old, right? So I remember when we weren't even talking about diversity as a particular aspect. I know that it's easy to measure certain aspects of diversity because they are obvious. But to me, the most important thing is diversity of thought and making sure that you've got people who are across those board meetings,
across those subcommittees, yes, have got different experiences, but think in a slightly different way. That is the biggest safety net any company can have. Now sometimes we short-circuit that by going, "Let's pick someone with a different experience. Let's pick someone from a different gender. Let's pick someone from a different background." But that really is just a short-circuit to get a different type of thinking, and that's just so important. Ralph Grayson: And what might tell you that we've got outward diversity, but
not inward diversity if I can express it Joanna Meager: like that? If you end up with a whole load of questions that are all looking exactly the same around a narrow field, you know that you've got groupthink going on. I know on the boards that I sit on, we have a full spectrum of questions. And if you've read the same documents, you've read the same documents, you sit in the same room, and you can come at questions from left field and right field, you know that you've got the right kind of thinking going on. Ralph Grayson: But how do you make space for that disagreement?
Murray Steele, who runs the FT NED programme, he calls it the Zone of Uncomfortable Debate. You're not adding value if it's not uncomfortable, but it can't be so uncomfortable that it leads to bad boardroom behaviour. How would you recommend people steer that? Joanna Meager: A good friend of mine and a former boss always used to say to me, "We like to disagree, but we're not disagreeable." And I think that's absolutely true. You've got to be able to challenge. One challenge on data, I think that's really important.
You're challenging on an issue, you're not challenging a person. Disagree, but don't be disagreeable. Ralph Grayson: Let's turn that scrutiny around the other way perhaps. So when you now look at a board opportunity, how do you decide whether the organisation deserves the commitment you would have to give it if you joined the board? Joanna Meager: Oh, that's a good question. Well, obviously, first of all, you've got to get over the conflict thing. So making sure that it's not a conflict with the portfolio you already have. For me, personally, it's interest.
I've been asked to join a number of boards because of my executive background that were very aligned to things I did as an executive, not so interested in doing those. Also just looking at where that particular company is in its journey. Is it growing? Is it trying to diversify? What's its footprint across the world? All of those things are really important. Ralph Grayson: And who might you ask to meet from the employer's
side rather than who the Nominations committee want to put in front of you? Joanna Meager: You normally get a good cross-section because I think, as I mentioned before, the process can be a little long-winded. One of my personal tips… I'm giving away all of my tips now. One of my personal tips is you're normally collected from reception by a more junior person. I tend to grill them on the way to the meeting room in a very nice way, I hasten to add. But you get a lot of information out of that person.
"How long have you worked here? What's it like to work here?" That's my top tip, is speak to that person. If for any reason you are not meeting a number of the executives, that would be a red flag for me. You need to be meeting a few of the executives. Ralph Grayson: What's the role of the headhunter in all of this? Two-thirds of board positions don't use a headhunter. What's your experience of the role of the headhunter? Joanna Meager: Well, I've done both and I actually think it's really valuable as a candidate having a headhunter there because you've got a sounding board,
you've got insight, you're better prepared going into your interviews because you've got insight from that headhunter and then when you've come out of the interviews, let's face it, we don't all walk out of interviews high-fiving and going, "That went brilliantly." You get much better feedback if you've got a headhunter in the space. Plus, if there are things that you then reflect on, I'm not the best reflector, but I'm trying to get better at it. If there's things that you then reflect on and go, "I'm not 100% sure that I really
understood the answer to that question or the implication of the answer to that question," you've got somewhere to go. So I much prefer having headhunters in the process. Ralph Grayson: And once you've read the job spec, you've read the brief and you've asked the right questions, how do you move beyond the job spec to the fit? Joanna Meager: I'm a touch it and feel it person. If I thought it looked about right and it looked interesting, I would go through the interview process because I think you learn more in the interview process
than you'll ever learn theoretically. To me, and you've got to remember when you're doing the interview process, you're interviewing them as much as they're interviewing you, maybe not with 200 questions, but you at least are getting a great feel for the organisation that you're going to be joining. Ralph Grayson: And when you look back now, is there a particular board discussion or something that's made you think, "Gosh, my presence made a difference there. It's been worth all the angst."
Joanna Meager: I don't have much angst, which I'm quite lucky about. I think for me, it's not one in particular. What was a lightbulb moment for me is when I first became a NED, every company talks in such a variety of acronyms, and there was a period in one particular meeting where I was like, "I think I'm understanding every fourth word." It's now that I've gone, as you say, seasoned and through a cycle, I sit in the meetings, I'm like, "I understand all of this." I did exactly what I would
encourage everybody to do is if you don't understand something, either ask in the meeting or ask outside of the meeting, because that's the only way you're going to end up like me and now understanding everything in the meeting. Ralph Grayson: Joanna, thank you. For anyone considering their first NED role, this transition raises questions we've touched on here around preparation, judgement, relationships, personal motivation. I think your experience has given everybody a really practical way to think about the contribution they would make and the conditions
in which they could make it well. Any one last piece of advice, wisdom you would give? Joanna Meager: Don't feel you have to do it. Just because you're semi-retiring as an executive doesn't mean that you have to become a NED. Think about whether your particular characteristics and charm would lead you to being a good NED or not, because if you're not a good one, you won't enjoy it. Ralph Grayson: That's really good advice when people come to see me and say, "I
want to be a NED." The first thing I ask is, "Have you looked in the mirror first?" Joanna Meager: I think you asked me that. Ralph Grayson: Joanna, thank you so much for joining me on The Boardroom Path. Joanna Meager: Thank you. It's been a pleasure. Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed listening to this podcast and have found it helpful when thinking about how to approach your own path to the boardroom. If you would like to push this a little bit further, Sainty Hird runs a bespoke one-to-one programme designed specifically to this end. For more information, please visit our website saintyhird.com, follow
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the Boardroom Path to receive new episodes. Thank you for listening.
What should you ask before joining a football club board when the owner funds the losses? On The Boardroom Path, Ralph Grayson speaks with Adam Crockett, director of Game Plan Strategic Advisory and senior adviser at...
In this episode of The Boardroom Path, Ralph Grayson speaks with Jonathan Greenstein, co-founder and director of Lagom Sports Compliance, about football club governance and the responsibilities of directors under the...
How should a board respond when its decisions and conduct come under public, regulatory or political scrutiny? In this episode of The Boardroom Path, host Ralph Grayson speaks with Duncan Mavin and Kate Brader of FTI...
What changes when a seasoned executive joins a board and must influence decisions without executive authority? In this episode of The Boardroom Path, host Ralph Grayson speaks with Quintin Price, Chair of Oxford...
How do you judge a leader's contribution when the most important results may not arrive for another four years? In this episode of The Boardroom Path, host Ralph Grayson speaks with Andrew Strauss, former England...