Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE Bitcoin Podcast

THE Bitcoin Podcast artwork

Bitcoin Will Never Be the Same Again | Alex Thorn

Aug 24, 20261 hr 31 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Alex Thorn joins THE Bitcoin Podcast to discuss whether the Bitcoin bottom is in, the next Bitcoin bull market, changing market cycles, institutional adoption, Bitcoin price analysis, the Coldcard exploit, self-custody, multisig, AI-powered cybersecurity, hardware wallets, and why Bitcoin may be entering a fundamentally new era. JOIN THE SUBSTACK TO GET NEW EPISODES DELIVERED STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX: https://walkeramerica.substack.com/ FOLLOW ALEX: X: https://x.com/intangiblecoins PARTNERS & DISCOUNTS: LEDN: Bitcoin-backed lending. Go to ledn.io/walker and unlock liquidity WITHOUT selling your bitcoin. BLOCKSTREAM JADE: BLOCKSTREAM JADE HARDWARE WALLET: Head to https://store.blockstream.com/ and use coupon code WALKER for 10% off! BDICâ„¢ is building an insurance marketplace on the bitcoin standard. Sign up for the waitlist at: http://bdic.io/walker Own Bitcoin Miners. Keep 100% Of The Bitcoin. Get 1st month of free hosting with https://abundantmines.com/walker Buy Bitcoin with River: http://partner.river.com/walker GET FOLD ($10 in bitcoin): https://use.foldapp.com/r/WALKER If you enjoy THE Bitcoin Podcast you can help support the show by doing the following: FOLLOW ME (Walker) on @WalkerAmerica on X | @TitcoinPodcast on X | Nostr Personal (walker) | Nostr Podcast (Titcoin) | Instagram | YouTube | Everywhere else

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This thing can go from the most boring asset on earth to the front page of CNBC.com in like an hour. Sailor sold like 100 million of Bitcoin and the worst self-custody exploit in the history of Bitcoin. And Bitcoin was up like three or four percent. So I would say it has been a very exciting time. I think it's very likely that we have bottomed. I just think 58 looks pretty durable at this point. It's held multiple times. There's a whole meme around it. If you look at the time frame between prior cycle tops and prior cycle bottoms that would put the cycle bottom here

and it's almost perfect the prior cycles this is exactly what you would observe near a bottom is overconfident bears right just like at the top you observe overconfident bulls i think this is sort of the opening salvo in the clanker wars that are going to be a big feature of our lives going forward, you know, every new step function increase in an AI capability is going to also come with step function increases in vulnerability identification. And everything is at risk, to be clear. Every piece of software is at risk.

This riverside we're on right now, it's at risk. On the surveillance stuff, I mean, obviously George Orwell's British, you know, like we We're well aware that the Brits have, I would say, much higher tolerance for their government surveilling them than the Americans do, though ours, I believe, is is too high our tolerance as well. And but like, you know, there's that stat they you know, and I can't verify this, but they say that the UK puts more people in jail annually for social media and China.

like i think it also helps me watching the brits helps me appreciate the u.s constitution and the bill of rights a lot because they don't have a bill of rights um and we do it is kind of war it yeah well it's pretty remarkable to where we're at right now i think the you know these last few years and by the way you know uh caveat america is by no means perfect we saw the reactions to COVID and everything were a very clear example that like, hey, we have to stay vigilant on

this front. Like we, you know, we should not be silencing people for speech of any kind, particularly not speech that, you know, is labeled as a far right conspiracy theory then turns out to be admitted by the, as truth, by the powers that be six months later. And there's a New York Times op-ed about it. But it also, these past couple of years, kind of, let's say post COVID have made me ever more appreciative. of America in terms of like, wow, what we have here is truly unique. It is incredibly powerful

and it is not something that should be taken for granted because look at what the heck is happening in the rest of the world in purportedly, you know, Westernized free modern democracies, you know, where it's like, boy, like it's kind of scary. Uh, I don't know. I I'm very bullish on America, as I assume you are as well. Yeah, I am. I am. And I think, you know, again, like the First Amendment, when you look at other, you know,

comparable liberal Western democracies, of course, America is one and, you know, lowercase liberal as in liberty. And you still forget that there is no we have a nearly absolute right to free speech, free expression, freedom of association, freedom of religion in the Bill of Rights and the First Amendment. Other countries don't have anything like that. In fact, almost maybe none. Right. So you can get arrested for merely offensive speech in most of Western Europe. And that is not

something I believe in. And you don't you know, when everything's going great, you know, in the 90s, the sort of Pax Americana post-Cold War era, right? The end of history, I think, as Francis Fukuyama had called it, like, you know, it doesn't come up that much. You don't notice that maybe, you know, some, you know, far right-wing Nazi was getting arrested in Germany. But when you have things like populism, COVID, you know, economic turmoil, mass migration that are sort of mainstream issues.

And now you see it rearing its head, the inability of Europeans to speak. I even saw on X, there's a guy, a Euro founder, who's a European VC or whatever, who's got 100K followers on X and is a, you know, a mid-tier, you know, X influencer on mostly on venture and on tech. He was sent basically a cease and desist letter by the European Commission, which is like the executive branch of the European government for saying false and offensive things about

Europe. I mean, that is not something that I agree with. And it's shocking the extent to which, you know, peer nations of ours don't have the same basic, what we consider basic human liberties that we have in America. And whether or not those things were actually false and offensive of course is probably a very subjective matter Well and also like if I say false things knowingly false things about you right that could be slander or some forms of civilly punishable speech in the U that you cannot be get in trouble for saying false things about the U government

There is no you've a nearly an absolute right to freedom of political speech. Most of the, you know, legal exceptions to the First Amendment's free speech clause involve inciting violence. Right. And knowingly. And by the way, the bar for that's also pretty high. and I'm not a constitutional lawyer, so I won't like literally enumerate what the exceptions are. But even just saying like everyone, you know, bring a gun down to the public square, it's typically not illegal.

It requires like knowledge that it will be taken seriously and a bunch of other prongs, right? So we have a near absolute freedom to criticize our government, whether or not our facts are in line, which I love. Last digression, then we'll move on. but I think it was American HODL was, I believe it was him, when I was getting my 40 hours per week of just American HODL, he was talking about this idea that one of the reasons that the British have developed such a, like, dry sense of humor is because they don't actually have the ability to speak freely,

and so they have to be able to fall back on, like, oh, no, I was just taking the piss, mate, you know, like, it was just making it funny, you know. And I was like, damn, I hadn't thought about it that way. Yeah, even without, like, outright censorship, like still like their polite like culture probably dictates not telling the truth a lot of the time um yeah that that's pretty funny i mean that sounds like a hodl uh you know identified item there whether or not it's true i believe it because it came out of his mouth you know he's very convincing that's that's my president right there uh someday someday a guy can dream

but alex mr thorne i'm stoked to have you here we've been playing a cat and mouse game for a while trying to get you on here so i'm very glad to make it happen thank you for doing this on short notice as well uh a lot has uh a lot has happened in the last few weeks i've been sort of watching from the sidelines because we were as we were just discussing just uh brought a brought a beautiful baby girl into the world and now i'm coming back and i'm like wow i you know i don't know if i picked the best or the worst time to sort of be a bit checked out like because there's just been

there's been a lot there's been a lot you've been in bitcoin longer than i have does this feel like is is this time different in terms of like the you know the deluge of shit that hit the fan all at once or is it just is this still just par for the course in terms of shit hitting the fan in the bitcoin world well i mean the cold card exploit is um pretty unique i would say but in terms of the volume of news. I mean, Bitcoin has been a very in a very sleepy pattern here for really

months. People forget that Bitcoin was at like 82, 84 K just in April. It ran that high and then came all the way back down to 58. And but like really for all of June and July, Bitcoin was just like pinned in like the 62 K area with effectively no news occurring. Some news about sailor, you selling some coins to fund his dollar reserve. Obviously, at the end of July, the cold card news. But that exploit was primarily conducted on a Thursday night and Friday

with some follow-on after, and we can talk about that. But that next week, Saylor sold like $100 million of Bitcoin and the worst self-custody exploit in the history of Bitcoin had occurred. And Bitcoin was up like 3% or 4%. So I would say it has been a very exciting time. Obviously, we're recording now on Thursday, August 20th, and Bitcoin has ripped 15 percent in three days and five days and is trading in like above 72 K. So there's that news as well, which has its own sort of catalyst.

But, you know, in the history of Bitcoin, there have been busier times than the last couple of weeks. And I will say, obviously, and I will say most of those in a bull market, but I will say that, you know, following periods of very low volatility and there are several people I happen to tweet this like two days ago. Look how low volatility is. It looks like it's a spring that's coiling and is going to pop. I didn't actually necessarily mean the price. I meant the volatility. Obviously, both did it. We tend to sort of pop out of these quiet periods with like big moves and stuff coming to the surface.

I think the nature of this the last couple of weeks since the end of July is different than others. I mean, the cold card, I think vulnerability makes it noticeably different. It's not the first time in crypto history that a seed entropy failure has occurred at the hardware wallet level or at the wallet level. It is the first time it really happened to a major Bitcoin wallet and it the cold card vulnerabilities by far the largest in terms of dollar damage So and as we talk about I mean I think that the cultural demographic

that was impacted by the cold card exploit also makes it a uniquely Bitcoin story that really sort of it is a it is I don't know if it's a pivot point, but it's certainly a milestone here and that I think will have really wide-ranging effects on how people custody, how people talk about Bitcoin to the public, but also to newbies, how Bitcoiners judge each other, what it means to be a pure Bitcoiner. I think it will affect all of that. So pretty unique in that sense, the things that are happening.

But I would say, you know, we've been through quiet periods and bursts before. I want to get into the cold cards side of things. in a little bit. But before we do, I do kind of want to double tap on just where we're at right now in the market because I think a lot of Bitcoiners have sort of, you know, they've been doing the right thing. They've been, you know, trying to stay humble and stack sats. Easy to stay humble in a bear market, right? Not so easy in a bull market. But we've been sort of, you know, to borrow a phrase from James Check, chop solidating for a while.

Chop solidating down. A 58K gang was, you know, the best TAs out there was 58K gang, apparently. like they you know they called it right but that's been happening for a while now and meanwhile the vibes um as two members of vcm you know we do a lot of vibes based analysis and the vibes have just been weird the vibes have been bad uh then you throw all this other stuff on top of it and you know we'll get into the cold card stuff you've got a new you know a new shit coin fork that dropped as well pardon me and and somehow bitcoin comes out of that after all of this you

Nobody cares. This peak apathy, to use another credit, James Check and Michael Sullivan, with that one. Nobody cares about Bitcoin. Bitcoin price is in the shitter. Horrible self-custody exploit happens. Data leak from Trezor happens. Shitcoin fork is launched with all of the FUD around that. And then Bitcoin just rips. So was this something where, I mean, like it's kind of incredible, right? but it also feels just like it felt like 58k was sort of the bottom or close to the bottom

is that what you're seeing because you're looking at a lot more metrics than the average person uh what are you seeing in terms of that do you still abide by what a lot of the analysts are saying that actually the bottom's coming on this exact date in october and then we'll go up from there or or is are they missing something throughout this yeah I just I want to double tap before I go into that on your 58k gang they they 58k is held multiple times here as the bottom it's sort of like in a world where fifty eight thousand dollars was the only price for Bitcoin

like one man decided to launch a fork to destroy it all but it didn't work you know it's like Like the best in a world voice. My voice is a little sick. We got to go back and forth later on some in the world. Yeah. Look, I mean, in terms of like bottoming indicators, I mean, it's a great question. And like I've been, you know, in 24 and 25, I was questioning the validity of the four year cycle. Remember, that was a big question then. Like, is the four year cycle over?

And it makes a lot of sense to say yes, because, you know, the having impact in an absolute basis is so small at this point. You had all these, you know, non-Bitcoin native market participants, primarily through the ETFs. And once those ETFs are in like managed portfolios, they tend to become like like contrarian reflexive, right? Like when the position grows above one percent, they may sell some when it falls below one percent, they may buy some.

And so that can compress volatility and like all these things should have. And I still believe in the long run should dampen this concept of a four year cycle in Bitcoin. But with October 6, 2025 is the all time high. And then, of course, the events of October 10th, like causing that huge deleveraging that empirically was right about the time that the four year cycle would have suggested the top be in. And I think if you look at the time frame between prior cycle tops and prior cycle bottoms, that would put the cycle bottom here.

I mean, it's almost it's almost perfect, the prior cycles. And if this cycle followed that same pattern, then you would be looking at a bottom in like early October ish. Now, here we are in August, not October, and we haven't been at 58 K for, I don't know, a month and a half or so. So, you know, should then people be waiting till October for the bottom? I mean, no, because the the pattern itself, it's empirical. It's not prescriptive.

Like we don know There no reason why Bitcoin should bottom in October We just saying that in the past there an identifiable pattern if we replay it here But there were also things of the last cycle that didn't line up to the pattern, the all time high before the having. Right. And to James Chex, chop solidation. That was the famous period between February 2024, all time high and November 2024, all time high during the Trump election. It was like something like 237 days of no new all-time high in between all-time highs. None of that makes sense from a

prior cycle analysis. And just like 2021, 2024 in the initial peak, most of the topping metrics actually topped in March 21 and February 24, not in November 21 and November 24, right? So the topping metrics didn't quite hit properly. And in October 25, I mean, most of the most of the topping classical topping metrics either never hit or hit a year plus earlier during the prior

run up to all time highs in 24. So the cycles do look different. But I would say, you know, another reason to not hold out for it to play out exactly, you know, one of my theses has been that, you know, we didn't quite top high enough. Most of those most of the metrics topping metrics didn't hit at all. And I've got a scorecard of, you know, 13 bottoming metrics that hit reliably on all three prior cycles and only like four have hit now. And so, you know, and also we're looking at, I think, a max like 54 percent drawdown that's happened from the current all time high to today. And, you know,

prior ones are like 75 to 85 percent. So I think part of my thesis is that, you know, we had a dampened cycle top and that probably also contributed to a dampened cycle bottom, right? So compressed cycle as opposed in terms of amplitude, if not in time. I mean, time looks pretty like accurate overall. I mean, I wouldn't be quibbling about, you know, a July bottom versus an October bottom. I mean, it's, you know, it's close enough like that.

I think if we're in cycle five and four years from now, looking back, wondering whether that cycle's bottom will be the same length as these will probably look. back on this one and say, yeah, August, October, like whatever. It's basically the same thing. Right. So I think you're close enough from a turn. You know, James also James check also has a phrase time pain. You know, you do need time pain. Right. When people when markets go down a lot, like it takes a while for people to get interested again for the people that did make profit to feel comfortable entering again, et cetera.

I think it's been enough time. I think I don't think that means we're headed straight up here. at all. But, you know, like if you look at the macro backdrop as well, like, you know, valuations are stretched across the other hot trades. Right. So there are people looking, you know, if you asked me five months ago, you know, in February or March, like, yes, a normal investor, like, what do you think you don't own enough of right now? Is it Bitcoin or NVIDIA? And I think most, almost all people would have said NVIDIA. And, you know, I think a

lot of those people own like ai stocks now and also they're really stretched and so now maybe you've got profits you're taking from other trades or you're looking to allocate cash and you're looking at something trading at like historic p levels um versus something that can provably go to 125 and is you know was trading in the low 60s like that the risk return on a long there looks a lot better to me when Bitcoin's in the 60s than, you know, the AI trade that's perpetually

at the top. And then also, like, you know, a huge factor here is just like, who is left to sell this thing? Even if you meant to sell Bitcoin at 125, oh, no, I missed selling the top. You didn't sell at 110 as it was going down. It goes all the way. It went back to 90. It later in April went to 82, 82 and above. Like you had multiple chances to get out at higher prices than the 60K range chop solidation we just had. So by the time you get to cold card and and like, you know, sailors selling Bitcoin like, you know, nobody else is there aren't any speculators and tourists left.

They've all already sold. Right. So and that's why if you look at that URPD chart, like I think the biggest change of hands in coins in the current UTXO set is all between like 62 and 65K. That's basically the range of the last several months and earlier in the year. I don't know, people like me buying from tourists who are selling because I to me like the 60s looks pretty cheap. And to them, I don't know, they wanted to sell their Bitcoin to buy AI stocks. I don't know why. Right. Who knows why?

So I think it's very likely that we have bottomed. It doesn't mean that even from 72.6 when we talk today, can't go back to 58 again. I just think 58 looks pretty durable at this point. It's held multiple times. There's a whole meme around it that 58K gain was right, apparently, or they were at least right as of the importance of the level, right? I mean, that we have to give to them. And so I think you're in a pretty good spot for Bitcoin at this point. Most of the juice has been squeezed on the short. I can't believe the amount of shorts that were carried out during this move the last couple of days. Who in their right mind is shorting Bitcoin at like 63 K? Like you meant to be shorting it. James said this, too. He's totally right. Like you meant to be shorting this thing like in January, February, March. Like that's when you knew it was probably trending lower and it was still elevated.

And shorting it, it's in the 60s in July, 2026, the year of our Lord. I don't know what you were thinking. Wish you could access cash without selling your Bitcoin? Ledin makes that possible. And the global leader in Bitcoin backed lending, Ledin, has introduced their lowest rates ever. No complexity, no fine print. The larger the loan, the lower the rate. These new rates apply to all new loans, refinances and renewals. You'll see the rates up front before you apply.

The new lower rates come with Ledin's gold standard protection. Your Bitcoin remains custodied and is never lent out for interest. Perfect 8-year track record of keeping clients' assets safe, auto top-up, LTV alerts, and partial repayments to keep you in control. Repay whenever you want with zero penalties or monthly payments. Ledin's perfect $10 billion plus track record through every market cycle in the last eight years speaks for itself.

Don't choose between a great rate and the safety of your Bitcoin. Get both at Ledin. Check out your rate by using their loan calculator at ledin.io slash walker. That's L-E-D-N dot I-O forward slash walker. If you're hodling Bitcoin personally or for a business, here's the uncomfortable truth. You probably don't have insurance. Most policies exclude Bitcoin, and the ones that don't,

they only pay you back in fiat. What's the point of that if you need to claim a loss when number go up? That's not insurance. That's liquidation. Now there's another option. BDIC. They're building an insurance marketplace on the Bitcoin standard. One Bitcoin lost equals one Bitcoin paid. They've integrated with Liana Business for enterprise self-custody with personal wallet coverage options coming later this year. If you care about protecting your Bitcoin as Bitcoin,

sign up for the waitlist at bdic.io slash walker. That's bdic.io slash walker. Insurance on the Bitcoin standard. Blockstream Jade Plus delivers robust security with fully open source hardware and software. Its unique genuine check feature ensures your device is authentic, giving you ultimate peace of mind.

With versatile connectivity options including Bluetooth, USB-C, built-in camera, and SD card, Jade Plus offers unparalleled flexibility in managing your Bitcoin. Whether you prefer wireless convenience or air-gapped security, Jade has you covered. Its innovative design features a durable metal case, a bright 1.9-inch color screen, and intuitive navigation buttons that make managing your Bitcoin straightforward and enjoyable.

Jade Plus also supports secure, air-gapped transactions via QR code signing using the Jade Link storage device, keeping your Bitcoin safe without compromising convenience. Visit store.blockstream.com and use my coupon code walker for an exclusive 10% discount on your Blockstream Jade Plus. Protect your Bitcoin. Sleep better. Stack harder. This is just a fluffing James Check episode, by the way, guys. Sorry if you're doing it for anything else. But another thing he points out is like this is exactly what you would observe near a bottom is overconfident bears, right?

Just like at the top, you observe overconfident bulls. One thing I do want to get your thoughts on is you mentioned that depressed amplitude, that decreased dampened volatility that we've seen this cycle. Assuming we don't nuke down to 30k and it becomes, oh look, it just followed exactly the 70 to 80% drawdown that we've seen in prior cycles. Let's say this holds. Let's say 58k was the bottom. We're dealing with this set of numbers. is that dampened volatility that depressed amplitude is that simply a function of like

a market maturing is that a function of institutional adoption i mean are those just basically the same thing also do you know what i mean yeah it's a i don't know um i do have the thesis that you know bitcoin's growing adoption is an institutional macro asset will also feature reduced volatility if you look at the historical realized vol like chart like it is compressing to the downside for years So that shouldn be a surprise as it gets bigger right Like and you know more adopted by long holders as you know percentages of portfolios or whatever else let alone if you

have like, you know, sovereign wealth funds or, you know, central banks or whomever, you know, they're less short-term traders than people had traded Bitcoin in the past. It is also like a little bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy, right? A huge reason that people have been drawn to Bitcoin is the chance for outsized returns. If that's not the case anymore, you know, what is the transition to a new buyer and holder base look like, right? What is the composition of that base? I don't think that's a bad thing. I think you're always about to,

you're always striving to get there. You know, gold is less volatile, not because, not for some inherent reason. It's because, you know, the world is so familiar with it as an asset. But investors worldwide have already made up their minds how they think about gold, generally speaking, how they're going to trade it. It doesn't mean everyone owns it. It means people, they're aware of it and they've decided whether to own it or not. I think as Bitcoin gets closer to that level of knowledge and adoption, and we are not there yet by any means.

I mean, go ask an average person about Bitcoin and then ask them about gold. I think you'll find they know more about gold than Bitcoin. But I do think it's probably a feature of growing adoption. You know, people like Jeff Park have argued the opposite. I just don't see the data to support that. To me, the data shows clear dampening and volatility over time as the asset has grown in market cap. And so I don't know if that means the tops are going to be lower. I mean, I think there's a good argument to be made that 21 should have been higher and so should have 25. Like it didn't. 125 is pretty anemic for a top, given that we opened the year around 100. I mean, all it could do is a 25 percent in the entire year of 2025. Like that doesn't seem like a Bitcoin level return, you know.

but I also don't I don't think that caps it in the future I don't I don't think it really tells us much of anything unfortunately but I do think you're going to see reduced volatility empirically you have seen that just as more people own it not everyone is going to be you know buying Bitcoin on Bitfinex in 2016 to send to an exchange and then buy an ICO like that was a huge use of Bitcoin in the past. I think now you're, I mean, the thesis of holding it for a number of years,

thinking of it as non-sovereign, non-debasable money is a widely believed thesis. And that thesis inherently means less volatility. Do you think that part of the, let's say, disappointment with Bitcoin's, you know, performance, let's say, again, you talked about how this was a fairly anemic top at 125. Is part of that just a framing issue? Like if you look at cycle top to cycle top, right? Like I think that tells one story. If you look at cycle, you know, prior bottom

to next cycle top, like that tells a different story. Do you think, I mean, is looking at these tops the best way to look at this from, in terms of a trajectory standpoint? Or is that just what we've become accustomed to? Because people think about the big number, right? They don't want to look at kind of the small number or the change. I love the question. I think it is more instructive to look at the bottoms, the cycle bottoms or the yearly lows is another way to say it. I think there's reasons in different cases, even in 21 and 25, possibly why we topped where we did that are not systemic or structural, but instead were idiosyncratic.

You know, 1010 is a possibility as a catalyst for, you know, a deleveraging that simply can't be recovered from in 25. You know, FTX could be a reason in 21. There's theories that they were selling Bitcoin, you know, at the end of the cycle there to, you know, try to shore up their own balance sheet and stuff like that. There could be reasons why the tops, you know, I think were disappointing to some. I think if you look at the cycle lows or the yearly lows, another way, you see a steady rise, right, year over year, cycle over cycle.

I mean, you know, we started 2023 at like 15.7 K, you know, a month or two after FTX collapsed. We ran to 30 K ish around this collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in March of that year. Then BlackRock announced their ETF in June. Grayscale won their ruling in August. And then all of the fall of 23 was this drumbeat into the ETF launch, which was January 24. And like, you know, 15, seven as a bottom to start 2023, you know, 58 K as a bottom in this cycle, you know, assuming it holds the material uplift. I mean, that is four plus X, you know, four X over the prior low. When people ask me, like, is the digital gold thesis dead? Because gold traded a bit higher, like slightly longer than Bitcoin did at the end of 25.

You know newsflash gold also did come off And and and by the way in the last couple of days it wasn equities that rallied when the Treasury signaled their intent to buy the long end of the curve It the dollar went down Stocks were flat to down. Gold, Bitcoin, commodities all went up. Right. Like hard money assets went up. So but again, where's the digital gold thesis? They said when Bitcoin was coming down and gold ran a little longer. Well, I'm sorry. It's right there at the, you know, 58K level, like the people buying at 15.7 in 23 or at, you know, 3,200 in 2018 or at 58K in 2026. That is the digital gold

thesis. Those buyers are the long-term believers, you know, buying at levels that look cheap to them because they expect, you know, appreciation both in real and nominal terms. So like, I think it's It's very intact. I think looking at the the rising floor is possibly more instructive about Bitcoin's long term adoption than, you know, any any topping. and it's interesting too because i think part of the the bad vibes out there has been because

while bitcoin has been uh languishing at these you know deplorable levels it seems like every like everything else you could have bought has been running right like you could have bought s and you know the s&p 500 and you'd be outperforming right so i think there's a lot of sort of fomo from some bitcoiners who are like oh why didn't you know why didn't i put it all into x y and z i don't think you see that as much from the hard you know hardcore stackers who are like well great this is a depressed price level for me to accumulate more sats at like you said like yeah bitcoin hit 58k amazing i'm buying as much as i possibly can uh but i'm curious if you think

i mean obviously generally markets have been performing pretty well while bitcoin's been just kind of dumping around, right? Do you think we have a bit of a, and there's a bit too much froth in, let's say, traditional markets, a bit too much froth in the AI trade? Or is it like, hey, that bubble just never pops because it's never going to be allowed to pop. Yeah, Bitcoin will run up, but these things are going to keep running. We're not going to see a rotation of capital, in other words, from some of these other assets, which may seem, you know, short-term toppy,

and Bitcoin, which is very much obviously in a bottom formation, if that makes sense. No, I think that's right. And I mean, look, the NASDAQ and S&P are up like 11 and 12 percent on the year. It's not they've been up higher at other points. But I mean, like, you know, they're up 20 and 21 percent one year, you know, year over year. You know, Bitcoin is down 17 percent on the year and down 37 percent year over year. that's not that bad for a Bitcoin drawdown.

And people know that it's volatile. I would say, you know, that is a reason for, you know, people being upset with Bitcoin, I think is true. I mean, you know, they're saying, well, I could have just bought S&P 500. I could have bought, you know, industrials, chips, AI-themed names, the Mag-7 or whatever we call it now. And yeah, during this period, they'd have been better off. It depends on the period, though. If you bought Bitcoin at 15, seven, like I've been buying at 58 and 60, like you are doing great. Right. Like this is the thing that people are, you know, they get mad at Bitcoin. Like and I do think like everybody gets caught up in the bull market.

a lot of influencers and, you know, professionals in the space and whatnot and like, you know, arguing it's going up forever. Like if you look at like people's predictions for Bitcoin price at the end of a year, like if you look at the January 25 predictions, I mean, they're insane. I was called a bear because I said 185. And of course, I was I was like fifty thousand dollars above where we even got to. So others were calling for, you know, 500K, a million.

I mean, that type of rhetoric makes people think you might be going there. And the reality is, well, those didn't play out. But, you know, it's not nearly as safe an asset as like U.S. stocks. I mean, in terms of volatility. Right. And you're right that like, you know, you're not buying, you're not buying, you don't have pensions buying Bitcoin every day, putting it in their plan participants accounts, the way the

perpetual bid exists for U.S. equities. Right. You may one day, you know, for Bitcoin or through the ETFs. So there's some truth to that. I think, you know, the prudent course, and this is something that, you know, Bitcoin people on socials and, you know, if you don't live on a Bitcoin standard, you're not a real Bitcoiner. I mean, the reality is people need to live in a fiat world today. and they need to diversify their investments and cash positions in a way that works for their lives. So, you know, if you if you don't want to stomach, you know, volatility hasn't been that bad now,

but historical you know 50 100 vol asset as your entire portfolio or net worth then don you know if you you know I own stocks like it not crazy to not put everything into a thing that you know yeah, it goes up three or four X pretty frequently historically, but it also goes down 50% plus, like, you know, this is the same type of question though. This is just like, is it deja vu all over again? Like, you know, yeah, Bitcoin's down. So all the questions, you know, no one's going to be

Same thing with the CAGRs and the, you know, if you look at like a five-year CAGR from today backwards, it doesn't look as good. If you start it from October 6, 25 backwards, it looks good, right? I mean, it's just a volatile asset. So I think that volatility historically has been positive, drives a lot of attention to the asset. But it also drives a lot of speculators, and they pile on like price on top of what is that growing floor of digital gold buyers. like i almost think of price as like an air stacked area chart and you've got like the yearly lows is

like the long-term believers and then you've got these waves of fluctuation on top which are you know hype cycle driven business cycle driven liquidity cycle driven and you know you should never be surprised when that happens yeah i think that that point and this actually just maybe a good bridge into the cold card saga. Because that point about, look, it's okay to diversify. It doesn't make you an inferior Bitcoin. I think that that becomes abundantly clear to when you have kids,

at least it became clear for me, like it became clear that now your job is not just looking out for yourself and how much you can make personal number go up. It is about making sure that you are managing risk appropriately for your family. And everyone's individual situation is different, right i'm not going to tell anyone what to do with their money but like the ability to uh handle unforeseen expenses during a bitcoin bear market you should be able to do that and it may be more difficult and require you to actually sell bitcoin if you are not uh otherwise let's say uh diversified

now i'm not saying that you need to uh there's anything bad with being all in bitcoin if that's what works for you i own some stocks as well guys i also keep a little bit of fiat cash you know like yeah like just in case right because shit happens if this year's taught me anything it is that but that's okay to do and you really need to make sure you look at your own personal risk profile your family's risk profile what it is going to take to make sure you can still be a provider for that family regardless of what drawdowns there may be and the reason that made me think of the

cold card side of things is because and first of all i'd like to say this is fucking horrible like this was the night but this started happening the night before my uh uh carla was scheduled to go into surgery and my daughter was scheduled to be born so it happened that thursday night friday morning and boy it is horrible and i'm so sorry to everyone who's affected and i know you've had more probably firsthand experience with people who lost a lot of bitcoin than maybe anyone else in the industry at this point because you've been doing a ton of great let's say pro bono

investigative work. So thank you for that. But one of the things, Alex, that really just stuck out at me was hearing that there were so many people who not only like, again, being all in Bitcoin, completely fine, right? Like Bitcoin is by far the largest bucket of things that I own. But the people had everything, all of their sats on a single device, on a single key. Like I use a distributed multi-sig now. I still have some other single sigs too. Like I don't even trust all of mine to just multi-sig like i i spread some things out right i keep a little bit

on an exchange i keep a little bit on river shout out to the river guys not sponsored just love what leishman and the team are doing because they're awesome it was kind of mind-blowing to me that people had everything at one single point of failure but the hard part is they did everything that you were supposed to do that they were told was the right thing to do which is use the most cypherpunk device that you can use you know that you you're not locked into vendor software you know generating your own entropy all of these things hooking up a battery to it so that you

know the NSA can't backdoor your USB cable or whatever like doing all these things and then getting screwed like it was like it it did not affect me uh personally but seeing people that I know and you know respect in the Bitcoin community get wrecked that was that's brutal that is gut-wrenchingly brutal and my heart goes out to all of these people and I would love if maybe you can share like now with a little bit I know you've talked about this in a decent number of podcasts already but if you can sort of share like where we're at right now with the state of

this because I think a lot of people rightly so are still looking for answers looking for someone to be held accountable looking for the actual culprit in this whole thing is there anything new that we know or what can you sort of tell us about the state of things from your uh your observational point which i think is quite unique in the industry yeah it is truly devastating and um you know i think these people thought they did everything right right they didn't it's sad anytime anyone loses money. I dare say it's even sad if you gamble on low cap meme coins and lose your money.

It's less sad, though, than people who just stack sats and thought they were storing it in cold storage. They weren't speculating. They weren't putting it on even on an exchange, which, you know, has risks. They weren't bridging it to DeFi and chasing yield down a risk curve. Right. They were storing it in their safes, in their homes, in their closets. many of them had never spent before right so they're only sending in savings into these addresses the average dormancy of coins stolen is like four years so like they're not they're

not even recent right these are long-term hodlers you know i think that that makes it particularly sad and like i said it's sad anytime something like this happens even to a low-cap alt corner I'll dare say. But again, this is sort of the purest, longest term thinking cohort in all of crypto. And yes, among in the Bitcoin community, like particularly low risk, taking long time horizon, having individuals.

So, yeah, very sad. I've talked to more than 200 of them. And some stories are truly devastating. Talking about, you know, someone who realized they might be vulnerable on that Thursday night, but their wife was in labor. And so they could not race home. And by the time they got home to their cold car the next day, it was gone. People who had moved to a new country to set up a whole new life and were going to use their coins to buy their house there and set up their family there that lost everything.

tons of stories that are as heart-wrenching as you can imagine. I would say, you know, I think where it stands today, you have about 1,800 Bitcoin confirmed stolen, that I am confirming as stolen. High confidence is what I call it, stolen. Probably almost half of that directly confirmed by the victims themselves. The rest of it is either co-spent by attackers along with other confirmed victims funds. Remember, because the attackers possess the private keys to the coins, they can spend many victims coins in the same transaction to themselves.

So wave one and two featured a lot of this, like co-spending multiple victims in the same transaction to the attacker's address. So when some victims send me a transaction ID and I look at the transaction, it's got 200 inputs. I have to say, you know, unfortunately, can you go into cold card? Can you go into Sparrow? Can you actually export a list of all of your addresses? Because I can't figure out which ones are yours by looking only at the transaction. In some instances, I've helped people send me their X pubs, which are the master public keys from which all other of the wallets, private public keys are derived. I've said this to them and said it before, like there are privacy implications to doing that. I can derive all possible addresses in your wallet from that.

I don't have the keys, but I could see all of your spending. So if you don't want if you have anything you want to hide, don't send me that. But it's the surefire best way for me to get all of your addresses. That way I can give you a report that is fulsome and complete about the state of your coins. Many have done that. Right. You know, if you don't have anything to hide, you're never using that seat again. So it's frankly, in my view, no, no real issue with sharing the XPUB again, unless they're spending. And by the way, I also tell them, like, I have absolutely zero interest and have spent exactly zero seconds interrogating prior spends from those addresses. Like, you know, I technically I would possess the X pub so I could, but I don't give a shit about that. I'm only looking to confirm all the addresses that were stolen.

So it's about 1,800 Bitcoin. It's $1,16 million stolen at the point that they were stolen. You know, with this uplift in price, we're now talking about about $130 million in actual value. Something like almost 90% of it is still held by attackers in their initial collector addresses. So most has not been attempted to be exfiltrated one way or another, sent to an exchange, sent to whatever. There are some later copycats in the hack that once the vulnerability was disclosed and understood, if you had compute, you could direct some computer trying to grind these private keys and execute the attack yourself.

I'm very confident there's at least 10 to 15 operators that have, you know, exploited this vulnerability beyond the sort of biggest chunk, which is the first three waves, which is, you know, 1500 of the 1700, 1800 BTC. Some of those have very different profiles. The funds are not always sitting. One smaller wave and I call those footprints one of the biggest footprint E which is a pattern very likely the same attacker inside that footprint They sending funds into coin joins doing peel chains

elaborate things, bridging to other networks. It's all different modus operandi than wave one, two, and three attackers, which are just sitting inert on chain. So there is a variety of things that people are, you know, attackers are doing, most of the coins are sitting inert, right? And we're monitoring those addresses. Every day or two, I send an updated CSV to the FBI, to FinCEN, to Chainalysis and TRM and Elliptic and other exchanges just flagging, like,

the updated set of attacker addresses, right? The hope being that, you know, if the attackers one day move funds to a centralized intermediary, they'll be flagged by compliance software because I told the entity to flag it, because the law enforcement is telling them to flag, whichever. I mean, at this point, I'm trying to propagate those around the crypto industry and law enforcement agencies as widely as possible in the hope they get frozen if they land at a centralized intermediary.

And that's why, you know, I encourage, I've been giving back to the, you know, the victims helped me by providing, you know, information about their the theft and in sort of an exchange, I'm providing them with a report that traces their coins and they can use that report to file with law enforcement, you know, these victim reports with FBI's IC3. So, you know, one of the really interesting things from an investigative standpoint about the cold card incident is that we have to trace the funds upstream and downstream.

So what I mean by that is normally when, let's say a crypto exchange is hacked, Bybit was hacked, right? Or, you know, a smart contract in DeFi or a bridge is hacked. These are centralized points. And so the forensic exercise is tracing the funds as they flow out of the, you know, exploited address. We don't have to trace up. We can see that they started here at the exchange and now they're being stolen. And so it's all about following the funds as they move around on chain to try to figure out where they go and notify law enforcement.

Here, the funds are flowing from many, many disparate addresses with no prior connection to one another. Right. Because these are regular people's self-custody, you know, wallets. They're not sitting in a centralized point of control. So the only way to trace the attackers is from victim reports. So the engineers at Block, who identified wave one, they published a blog about this and they highlighted the features of the wave that they used.

they occurred between, you know, in 41 minutes across just a few blocks that they used the same like lock time and wallet fingerprints and fixed fee rates and blah, blah, blah. So I mapped, I was easily by their description able to find all those transactions and that's wave one. And that's subsequently been confirmed by dozens of victims that it is a true wave one. And in wave one, the attacker co-spent a lot of inputs from any victims in the same transaction. So like if I confirm one or two, then I can just fold in the rest of them as all being thefts.

Every other wave and footprint that I reported on up to like footprint, like AP now, like many different patterns of attack, all the ones that I published as high confidence or victim confirmed, every single one except wave one was discovered by victim reporting, right? Discovered, not just corroborated and further mapped, but actually identified in the first place because a victim came forward to say that their funds were stolen, right? So it's essential that victims do that reporting

so that we can widely identify and then propagate these attacker addresses to hopefully not just freeze the funds, but maybe also catch these assholes. But that from an investigative standpoint is very unique for a crypto hack, quote unquote. Like they almost always start in one centralized location and flow out. Here they start in many locations and sometimes flow together, other times flow into a whole new path because it's an ongoing vulnerability that's being exploited by a new copycat. It's not even the same person.

So there's many different threads to pull, and it makes the investigation really complicated. It also means that once I became a shelling point for these victim reports, which, you know, was incidental, was not a goal of mine, I started mapping it and posting about it, And then people started sending me their stories. So then I started cataloging them and then it sort of snowballed from there. You can't really do this without the victim reports. Right. So that's why I've also been working so hard to make sure I share the, you know, threat

actor information, the on-chain addresses, the patterns with law enforcement and, you know, freely. It not I not treating it like proprietary information I just happen to be the only one that has it So like I also sharing right like those addresses as widely as possible because I also can you know track these funds downstream in perpetuity. Like I can't be following one piece of coin that goes through five peel chains into a coin joint and eventually on a bridge and is now in a DeFi smart contract. I simply don't have the bandwidth for that. Others may. Right. So I've been sharing it widely, but it makes it a

very, very unique exercise in data analysis, the sort of topography of the cold card exploit. You know, that topography also is a really good marker to tell the story, again, of how tragic it is. I'm curious, too, because this is something that I sort of, I guess, thought was interesting from the initial reports. And you've sort of just corroborated here this idea that whatever this initial whoever this primary attacker or attackers group you know individual group whatever was

seems to have perhaps not been the most uh like sophisticated like the fact that they didn't start just immediately coin joining this before anybody even got wind of it the fact they didn't you know go through these steps to obfuscate what they had done uh that they were even like i think i saw one report that they were like paying for some sort of uh blockchain analysis tools they had an account So there's all these different things that if you were a sophisticated attacker, either individual or group, you would presumably never have done because that would just be like rookie mistake number one.

Do you have any hypotheses around why that's the case? Like, was this just somebody who was like just, you know, prompting one of the frontier models and stumbled across this? Like, did they just say, you know, get me as much Bitcoin as you can? And then all of a sudden you're like, oh, shit. Like, do you have any thoughts on that? It definitely could be that. for the early waves. The report you're talking about was Clay from Block who posted that they had seemed to identify, I think relating to the Wave 1 attacker, that they may have used

a common RPC data service which exists to query Bitcoin blockchain data in service of committing the attack, right? And so this is like, you know, either you're a business that can't solely rely on their own node for the state of the Bitcoin blockchain. There are many such totally legitimate businesses that serve Bitcoin data to others over API or through an RPC endpoint or whatever. Even if you do run your own node, you may still also need these things, right?

For whatever you're running a big exchange or any kind of brokerage, even if it's just for redundancy. I don't know how they did this, but they said that they figured out that the attacker was querying a popular data provider with a paid account, using a paid account, and that they talked to the provider, and they confirmed that it was the same, I don't know, maybe the attacker was looking up all the target addresses right before they enacted the attack, right? I mean, that, something like that, and that they've been in touch with authorities. Haven't seen any updates

on that, so I don't know. If the attacker did do that, you're totally right. That is sloppy, Right. This is like Mars spits bars. Right. Not going to node. Even the attacker couldn't run a Bitcoin node. Right. Like I have a Bitcoin node. I can easily query the balance of every address. The reason, by the way, just for background for the audience, like the nature of this vulnerability is such that if you know the cryptographic space that a key could have been generated in because it had insufficient entropy in the beginning, what you do is you go and grind and create as many keys as possible.

I don't know. I'm not a mathematician. I haven't been working on this part of it, but bajillions of possible private keys. Right. Then you derive addresses, maybe like the first hundred or some number, however much compute you have and want to devote to this, to deriving all the possible addresses those keys could have created. Then you search those addresses on the blockchain to see if any of them have money. Then you go and construct transactions using those ones private keys to take the money. Right. So you do need to query the blockchain here to know which transactions to actually build, which theft transactions to go ahead and create and submit.

if they used a paid service rather than just spinning up a Bitcoin node for that, which you absolutely could do, I can query all these now. I can use Kimmy, a local model, to actually, if you give me an XPub or a private seed to generate every private key, if I have a million seeds, I can, with AI, generate all the correct private keys and then drive the first hundred of all of those addresses and then query my node to see if any of them have money. that you could use a local model locally with a local Bitcoin node and you wouldn't have had this

leak that may have happened that block engineers identified. So that that is positive for victims for wave one. The funds haven't moved. And again, I don't have an update on the state of that, but it's possible the attacker can be identified. Right. If they even paid with a credit card, there's some paper trail for that node, that node data service. There's some paper trail to follow. So I think it very clear that the first wave attacker wave one wave two wave three and I happen to believe wave one and two are the same and wave three might be a second Wave one swept many addresses and

over a thousand Bitcoin in 41 minutes, like early in the morning on Thursday, July 30th, UTC time. So like the evening East Coast, Wednesday, July 29th. To construct those transactions, they almost certainly used AI just again to just operationalize the attack. They didn't need AI to find this vulnerability. If you have been following, if you're a security researcher following hardware wallets or crypto wallets,

like you've known that an entropy bug is one of the main bugs that could make those wallets insecure. And these have been found in the past, you know, to a lesser blast radius, but in crypto wallets. So like it's a known vulnerability type. It's not totally novel. So you didn't need it to find it, need AI to find it. They probably used it. They probably did use it to find it. I mean, Kimi K3, very, very powerful local model, open source model came out like two weeks before this was exploited.

but they almost certainly used it to operationalize it. I don't see necessarily a lot in wave one or two that in terms of on-chain patterns and topography that suggest they were definitely not sophisticated. I will say those two. So wave one swept a bunch of coins and left a few UTXOs in some victim addresses unswept. The ones they left unswept, wave two mostly came and drained, right? So it's sort of like a cleanup wave two, which is why I think wave one and two might be the same person or attacker wave three.

And those funds were swept into like three collectors and now sitting in two or three like holding addresses that we presume belong to the attacker. So they co-spent, they co-mingled, and now they're sitting there in a pile and a couple piles. Wave three, mostly something like, I don't know, 290 out of 293 transactions only had inputs from one victim, each of them. And they each went into one intermediate address and they're each sitting at one scripted vault address, one per attack, per victim.

So they're segregated almost. I think there may be one or two where I noticed that they might not be segregated, but the vast majority are totally segregated by victim. That alone is a much more sophisticated topography. There is no co-spending across vaults. The way I know this is a wave is that I've got many victims and they all look the same right across the same blocks with the same types of transactions landing in the same types of holding addresses, right? But there isn't like direct spending history between those 293 attacker output vaults.

They just look the same, right? And I've got enough victim confirmation of victims in wave three that, to me, prove the pattern is high confidence. And so I call it one full wave. But it's a much more sophisticated topography than one and two. Still haven't moved. Then you look at something like what I call footprint E, which is the largest of the footprints. That's the one that, honestly, it looks like a sophisticated actor that's done these types of thefts before. Or we may see waves one, two and three eventually go into coin joins, eventually go into peel chains to try to make it difficult for me to track, eventually bridge to other networks and blah, blah, blah, like the whole sort of money laundering MO.

Maybe they need to figure out how to do that. And that's why they haven't done it. Maybe they never intend to do it. We don't know. But footprint E knew exactly what they wanted to do with the funds. They instantly started peeling and coin joining and bridging. And like, that's not something you learn in the time between stealing the funds and enacting the transactions on chain. This is an actor who knows, has a modus operandi, knows how to execute it. So for something like that, I mean, it's much more likely that it's a, you know, common hacking group, even possibly a nation state.

Like they have a whole process for trying to launder these funds and exfiltrate them. so I don't know that's a long answer Walker to your question like wave one and two also if it's the same party if they leaked their ID to a paid service like that's a huge fuck up for them but you know commingling the funds and one thing you know that's helps us categorize the blast radius of their operation

more easily than say wave three where technically I don't have co-spends to definitively state that they're related, but we can still trace pretty well. I don't think it's the on-chain topography as much as the leaking of the ID to the RPC provider. Last thing I'll say, if you look at the Bitfinex hacker, Razzle Khan and her husband, they sat on billions of dollars worth of Bitcoin inert for years. I think if I recall correctly, they were eventually caught because they peeled some off to buy Walmart gift cards.

and they were caught that way. They were not sophisticated. I've never quite learned how they managed to get those funds. I'd seen disputes between BitGo and Bitfinex on the timeline in the past as to who was to blame. I guess Bitfinex used BitGo for some portion. But we never quite understood. Most likely that was some kind of insider or phishing situation, you know, meaning not that sophisticated. not like they breached the firewall and hacked through the matrix right and not as sophisticated

frankly as enacting this attack which requires compute and you know even if ai helped you it's it's i mean you're reproducing private keys from a vulnerable entropy like keygen like that's you know more sophisticated than bitfinex but the bitfinex hackers also sat on the funds for years before doing anything with them so whether or not the on-chain behavior of waves one two and three means they're sophisticated or not, no matter what. I mean, it could just sit there for a long, long time before it could sit there forever.

I mean, for all we know, the attacker could decide it's too risky to even try to move and they just never move it. It's totally possible. So I do. All of that being said, the RPC, possible paid account leak as a nuance. I don't think there's quite much to say how sophisticated the attackers are or not. With the exception of both the paid RPC endpoint and the difference in behavior, footprint E and a couple of the smaller ones are immediately being laundered.

So those are at least people with experience. But we can't say for certain that the others are not experienced attackers. i mean it is uh it is horrific and tragic it is also fascinating just because i think one of the reasons this really and doesn't seem to have gotten much coverage outside of the bitcoin community actually you didn't really see headlines like you probably would have a few years ago saying

bitcoin has been hacked you know what i mean that would have been the the fud that was thrown out a few years ago then you would have had to have a bunch of people explaining well no bitcoin wasn't hacked bitcoin is you know we didn't really see that maybe that's an another example of market maturity here but something you and i were just talking about a bit before we got recording was this idea of what this actually means for the culture moving forward because this is very much an earth-shattering thing again as you highlighted these are people who did the right thing they did

what you were supposed to do they did they didn't keep their key their their bitcoin on exchange they you know they had their own keys right not your keys not your coins they got a super cypherpunk uh you know kind of not the best like ux hardware wallet right they struggled through that and then they still got rugged and so if you do everything right and you can still be rugged i think a lot of people fairly lost or you know feel a bit lost or lost a lot of confidence in that and it's like meanwhile they see people with bitcoin sitting in coinbase or in you know

Obviously, if you have a Bitcoin ETF, you don't have the Bitcoin, right? But you've got exposure to the price. And I think a lot of people might be sort of rethinking this whole paradigm a bit. Can you give your thoughts on that? Because again, it's like you're hearing 200 plus of these stories. Like you're on the front lines of this. Are people giving you any indication of kind of what they're going to do next? If they even want to keep holding Bitcoin, maybe they just feel too burned by this to even try again. I don't know. Yeah, I've heard some of that.

I've also heard stories of, you know, I'm going to rebuild and start stacking again. I mean, I've heard both across the spectrum. Total disillusionment forever going forward, as well as, you know, this is a wake-up call about better self-custody. In terms of, like, the media not covering this, like, there's been a little bit, but I agree. Like, this was not widely covered in mainstream media, even in, like, mainstream financial media. You know, a story here or there. I went on Bloomberg. They talked about it there. They did an episode about it. So I think in sort of Wall Street and traditional like active markets finance, this was known and like and understood.

And it didn't impact price and it didn't hasn't, I don't think, impacted institutional interest in Bitcoin. One, because they are a lot smarter about Bitcoin than, you know, they were a couple of years ago. You know, not saying it's just because of me, but I've been trying to teach these people about Bitcoin for a long time. And I was very clear and I continue to be and try to be that this vulnerability is related to a specific hardware vulnerability. It is not a Bitcoin protocol vulnerability. This specific vulnerability does not impact other hardware wallets, as far as we can tell.

Not saying they're always going to be safe either, but like this is a limited to one hardware wallet key gen. And by the way the demographic that owns Cold Card I think both of us included are you know a cultural like cultural specific cultural niche in Bitcoin ownership It is not the, and I think the largest victim reported loss is about 60 Bitcoin, which is fucking tragic. That's an enormous amount of money.

But the, you know, the median is like one BTC, right? And for some of these people, that's they've told me that's their life savings. So one, that's absolutely devastating for them. But, you know, two, from a mark, you know, even 116 mil in, you know, at the point it was stolen as the blast radius here. It's really just not that big in terms of the overall Bitcoin market. So it hasn't dramatically impacted the market. I think the institutional investors and by, you know, along the way with them, also the financial journalists realize this isn't, you know, systemic to Bitcoin price, like in the scheme of things.

It may, though, have a lot of implications for how people get exposure to Bitcoin going forward. Right. You know, in some ways, I think HODL had a great American HODL had a great tweet that was like, you know, the upside is like not that many people listen to us. Well, some did. And I don't want to downplay the tragedy that's befallen them. But, you know, many didn't, you know, to be frank, if it had been Trezor or Ledger, the blast radius would have been way larger. Like those are much more widely owned like than cold cards were. So that's one reason is that although incredibly tragic to many people in terms of the size of the blast radius in the market, it's not quite big enough to make a real impact here.

And that's just I mean, it's now been three weeks since it happened and you just you've seen Bitcoin flat to dramatically up in the more recent days. It's not being impacted by it. But I think people are right to wonder, you know, if they rolled their own custody with cold card and didn't work out clearly if, you know, if they were in a single SIG or, you know, no passphrase, no entropy. And to be clear, like I've used cold card in a multi SIG. I didn't introduce any entropy. Like the idea that you should have known, I totally disagree with like hardware wallets supposed to create a good key.

Like that's that's not your fault. Right. It's kind of nothing wrong. Right. Like, yeah, it's kind of. Yeah. I mean, I don't get me wrong. I think if I'm going to roll my own custody in the future, self custody, I probably will do dice rolling. Now, it's not actually that hard, but it is a ridiculous thing to ask a like a new entrant to do. They're supposed to just be able to buy this device and it makes the key for them. And, you know, and they did the irony is, you know, a lot of people were powering them off batteries and keeping them in Faraday bags. And it turned out, you know, to protect from the NSA, like we were talking about before, and like turns out that the actual primary function of the thing was catastrophically broken. So that did nothing.

Look, I think it's reasonable for people to wonder whether self-custody is for them. And, you know, I'm still a huge proponent of self-custody. I think there's ways to do it safely that mitigate even the risk of one hardware wallet or several being compromised. specifically, I like collaborative custody, multi-sig, Nunchuck, Casa, Unchained, like Anchor Watch, Liana Wallet, like it's a bunch of ways to do that, which I think people should

look into. But honestly, no one should store Bitcoin in a way they feel uncomfortable doing, you know, especially if you're doing self-custody. You really got to know how to do it. And you can watch, you know, Walker or my pods or BTC sessions, you know, excellent tutorials, but like you need to feel comfortable doing it. Know that you're taking it into your own hands and understand that there are risks. And I don't think we as a, you know, Bitcoin educational community did a good enough job explaining that like you really can't take a shortcut.

You can't rely on a podcaster to make you feel comfortable storing your own coins. So if you don't, do not stretch yourself. Like, you know, River is highly regulated. Coinbase is highly regulated. They have, you know, they're not without risk. It's a different risk, right? And you should know those risks, but totally reasonable, I think, to either use whatever you feel comfortable for custody, whether that's a custodian, whether that's just owning the ETF. Jeff, you know, I think the era of judging people for those decisions really has to be over.

I think that that's fair. And again, I, you know, I will continue to, as you just said that you will as well, be a proponent and personal user of self-custody. I also like collaborative self-custody or if you want to do it all yourself, you know, as you mentioned, a bunch of things that you can do there. But like, I like that. I like that, that peace of mind. And like the fact that, you know, as my wife was about to go into surgery in a few hours, the next morning, she asked me are we affected by this And I could say nope we good That was a pretty great feeling because I mean the story you shared about like my God someone wife being in labor and like that that was that that very much could have been could have been my story

That could have been my story. And that's just horrific. Like you, you don't want to be in that position, but I think that it is fair. I was going to say just real quick too, like the ETFs, I think can make a lot of sense for some people, but you don't own coins if you own the ETFs. Yes. And you may want to use coins in the future. So personally, again, this is just me personally. And by the way, I do own the ETFs in accounts where I can't own coins like that, where I want Bitcoin exposure. I think they're really useful for certain investors at certain

times and maybe many types of investors. However, if I want to own Bitcoin and I don't feel comfortable self-custodying, I can tell you I'm storing it at a regulated exchange that I have an account with, because at least I can decide later to withdraw them. And I think that's an important caveat about the ETFs. The ETFs give you economic exposure to the asset that you're not going to be able to, you know, in a, you know, economic catastrophe, like, you know, it's not quite clear

whether you're going to be able to access your, you know, fiat brokerage accounts in which those are held. Whereas Bitcoin, you can send around the world for, you know, a dollar or less at any time, as long as there's internet. And even without the internet, possibly with a ham radio or the Blockstream satellite, like I am, I would prefer personally to own Bitcoin at an exchange than Bitcoin in ETF. Of course, with all the caveats necessary about exchanges and, you know, making sure you trust, you know, have the level of trust that you can be comfortable with

with that exchange, like a river, which I also use. Big fan of river. Again, also, I don't have any sponsors on my podcast. Thank you, Galaxy, for paying for my podcast. But I am a user of River. And again, like I like River and I would rather have coins on River than in an ETF as an individual. I mean, obviously, there are different situations. And again, I'm not here to judge. Certainly, I think less so than ever before am I not here to judge how people choose to store. This is people's money and livelihood and savings.

I think you should store it however you feel comfortable. one of the things and again this is not to make light of it but just to like look at the kind of absurdity of this situation how shocking it was i might have been i forget what account made it so i'm sorry for not crediting you maybe you know because you've been deeper in this than i have but they were like you know get your bitcoin on exchanges now you know and it's like boy you know like shit yeah i like that for a lot of people that's exactly what they did it was like to keep

my Bitcoin safe. I had to transfer it out of my self-custody onto the exchange. This is like the reverse. People have called it the reverse FTX. So like when FTX collapsed, coins fled into self-custody. They didn't know if the contagion was going to spread or if other exchanges were implicated in it. Whereas here, I know Sani from Time Chain Index, I think in the first three days, there was like a net inflow of 22,000 Bitcoin into exchanges. I saw CryptoQuant had posted something saying that, I forget the timeframe, but like, you know, at least a very

long time, it was the largest count of sub one Bitcoin deposits into exchanges. So yeah, there was a lot of fear. I think there's going to, it's going to take some time, I think for the, you know, Bitcoin, general Bitcoin investor and owner to feel comfortable self-custodying like this. This has done some damage to the self-custody narrative, but it is not dead and it will not be dead. And I really, like I said, like I love using collaborative multi-sig. I think it is,

it gives me great peace of mind. I don't even, you know, in a multi-sig quorum, you don't even have to store the seed phrases necessarily for those hardware wallets because you have redundancy in other ways. So you're not, because that's also been a thing. Let's say you store it perfectly. It's another thing that these cold card victims didn't do that makes it further not their fault. A lot of times people get funds stolen out of cold storage because they store the seed phrase somewhere in a last pass and last pass gets hacked or they, you know, store it in their Gmail and their Gmail gets hacked.

I mean, searching for 12 or 24 words on a fixed list of possible words is like one of the very first things cyber criminals do. Like it is easy for them to locate a seed phrase. And oftentimes people who self-custody and did everything otherwise correctly accidentally leak their seed phrase. Right. And so that's another thing I like about multi-sig is that you don't necessarily have to keep all the seed phrases because you have redundancy from your signing threshold in your quorum. Right. So you can not only could I lose the cold card seed phrase, I could lose the whole device and throw in the ocean and still recover my funds with redundancy.

So I think I tweeted this. Some people are mad. They're like, no, no, the perfect single seed treasure is still safe. I not saying it is or isn I just saying that multi I think is the pinnacle of self And there are some great services that can help you do it for pretty cheap you know a couple hundred dollars a year And they also provide redundancy if they go away right And they won't go out of business or whatever. So I really recommend that if I had to pick a way to do self-custody going forward.

That's what gives me, I'm good at Bitcoin. I still am pretty worried about fucking up my own self-custody. And these things help me sleep at night. yeah and if you are going to do single sig even single sig with a passphrase like i would just again do whatever you want but personally i wouldn't be comfortable having more than a third of my stack on any single single sig like at least you know at least spread that out so that if there is another unforeseen vulnerability that you can't get totally wiped out by that at that time right uh and maybe the the last thing we're running out of time here but i did

when I ask you just in these last couple of minutes, though, perhaps out of this horrible tragedy, one thing that has been, I think, very positive is this red teaming effort. You know, Callie, Rob from Anchor Watch, Charlie, like, I can't even list all of them, doing incredible work to basically go down the line. And I know OpenSats threw some grant money Adam. So it wasn't just Rob maxing out his credit card for tokens. Like this to me has been this

incredible thing. That's the best example that I have in recent memory of like, you can just do things like you can just go out there and audit every open source Bitcoin project and check for vulnerabilities. Like, was that as heartening to you as it was to me? Cause that was like a coming together moment that I thought was just beautiful to see. Yeah. It's one of the good things to come out of the event and it is good. And it's this, you know, we used to say, don't trust verify. And the reality is most people weren't verifying and most people couldn't verify. I mean, I couldn't, I'm not a software developer. I wasn't going to be auditing,

you know, code repositories for vulnerabilities in the hardware wallets I use. It's not possible for most users, but it also turns out, I think a lot of people just assume somebody else was doing it. Um, in the case of cold card in particular, I think, you know, there's some history there of the team, you know, being hostile to other open source developers and creating an environment that discouraged other qualified open source developers from reviewing their code. And that I think contributed to why that vulnerability at Coldcard went unfound for so long, five years,

five plus years it existed and wasn't, you know, probably wasn't exploited, but also wasn't publicly identified. But now you can. Rob, I'm a big fan of Rob and Calais and James O'Byrne and the others that are working. I think Rob said maybe 25 people have been officially working with them. Now with the quality of AI, you can. And by the way, you can run a pretty strong version of Quinn or Kimmy or GLM locally and do a little bit anyway of your own verification on open source code.

But, you know, Rob and the team, I think, identified a real gap here, which was that no one was doing this at scale. And you've seen a couple. I saw Atomic Labs, which is like a cross-chain Bitcoin bridge, Bolts, both also basically said like the volume of AI-enabled attackers is like far exceeding their capability of defending their project. So they like have to close the project like they don't want people to lose money. They literally are trying to fight back against a deluge of attacks. And so AI has dramatically altered the threat environment for cybersecurity

generally. I think Rob and the red team have they're sort of in the parabolic blow off top phase of catching up here, I think you're going to reach a bit of a plateau, not just in the Bitcoin repos, but in all and everything. Everything is at risk, to be clear. Every piece of software is at risk. This riverside we're on right now, it's at risk. You know, like there's the amount of effort you used to have to devote of highly trained developers, pen testers to identify

zero-day vulnerabilities or new bugs. It was an enormous amount of resources that type of research required. So even when hackers found one, it had taken them a lot of time, typically. Now, like, it's not that the AI is better than any pen tester that's ever existed or hacker that has ever, you know, hacked. It's that the scale at which you can deploy it is so much grander. And so, I mean, vulnerabilities are being found across every, I can assure you, it's not just the open source, It's not just Bitcoin.

Every company on Earth right now is finding like, you know, dozens or hundreds or thousands of previously unknown vulnerabilities and patching them. And I think this is sort of the opening salvo in the clanker wars that are going to be a big feature of our lives going forward. You know, every new step function increase in an AI capabilities. going to also come with step function increases in vulnerability identification. And I think part of the goal that Rob and his team are doing, they're playing catch up on the open source repos

that service the Bitcoin ecosystem. Once they have caught up and I think they've done a lot already now, we're in a pretty good spot, I think now. But, you know, then there'll be a cooling off period where, you know, all the repos that could have had a bug have been scanned by both hackers and defenders alike to a large extent. But then you'll have a step function increase. And the goal, I think, from a policy standpoint is how to get the tools into the defenders, at least at the same time, if not before the attackers. And this is like a very common thing across history, right?

Like the Mongols like took over most of the world because they had this crazy offensive innovation, which is basically shooting arrows from a horse that was just decimated all the defense all everywhere they went. Right. And there's probably, you know, tons of other examples. But think forward to the American Revolution, like turned out that hiding behind trees and popping out and shooting people, guerrilla warfare, which was an American invention, absolutely decimated the British line defense. Right. The attackers tend to have better technology because the incentive of war drives the

innovation in the first place to create the new weapons. And, you know, you think about the phrase on defense, right? By definition, it's a reactive. The question is how, whether it's U.S. policy, maybe just policy at the Frontier Labs, you know, how can they get the top tier models in the hands of the good actors faster? Ideally before they're ever in the hands of bad actors, but just generally faster One of the big things that Rob has pointed out I encountered myself just in tracking this stuff You know I use frontier models and local models to traverse my own Bitcoin data stack

right? You know, I'm not like thumbing through, you know, 300 million UTXOs to find the one you told me was stolen. Like I use AI for that. Sometimes merely asking, saying, hey, you know, a new victim reported this address was stolen by the cold card hacker. Literally, Fable will be like, oh, he said victim, like downgraded to Opus. Like this is just asking the AI to traverse my own data set, right? Not even doing penetration testing. That has to change. And so, you know, shout out to Rob and the team for doing, you know, this first initial

wave of stuff I guess we thought always should have been being done, but definitely exposed the lack of resources, human resources in eyeballs on a lot of this code. And I think now if you're a software developer, open source or not, like you need to be writing a lot of your code with AI and then auditing your code with AI all the time forever. I mean, this is the new paradigm. Well, I know I've kept you a little bit long here, so I do apologize for that.

But I appreciate you giving that breakdown here at the end. Real quick, where do you want to send folks, you know, your own podcast, perhaps your voice acting work, anywhere you want to direct people? Yeah, well, look, first, if you're a cold card victim, message me on X, DM me on X. That's the best way to reach me. I've triaged everybody on X. That's intangible coins. And yeah, I mean, I have a podcast. I got to have you on, Walker. I have a strong bias for in-person recording in New York. So whenever you in whenever you in New York at some point you know I know whenever you leave your orchard that you have there come to New York and I love to have you on Galaxy Brains We cover markets and Bitcoin and you know sort of crypto adoption We don talk much about other coins but I interested in regulation tokenization of real things like stocks

Anyway, I think it's a good show. I've done like 260 episodes or something. It's been like five years of episodes. But, yeah, also, I would just say, like, you know, hang in there, guys. Bitcoin ain't going nowhere. it's got a long history ahead of it this is a hiccup cold card but as you can see like this thing can go from the most boring asset on earth to you know the front page of cnbc.com in like an hour i saw like 400 million in short liquidations in one hour um the other day and i think now as we

record like it's now been about 24 hours since this rip and it's like 1.3 billion in short liquidations again who is shorting bitcoin 11 months after an all-time high you know near a cycle low i don't know what you're doing i think that is hubris like james said so um yeah and just you know maybe in a world where there's only one bitcoin podcast you can watch one man and his orchard bring to you by the way whatever happened weren't you building something you ever finished

that thing was like swing set oh yeah yeah yeah well i got sidetracked by the uh i built all of the uh the relevant parts to play on there's just some exterior finish work that needs to be done but i got sidetracked building the wife of pergola and then building like 50 different other at home projects i think you do well i'm assuming you do pretty well on bitcoin content because i know i like it so it must do pretty well but there's a huge you got a huge future and like the those really nice clipped edited like uh tick tocks of like building stuff like here's how to build

here how to build a pergola in like 12 hours and it like the really nice chopped up like cut cut like drop log drop lot you know like because that what i need i need a zoomer i need a zoomer intern is what i need if you a zoomer who is just innately good at that stuff and yeah the edits are hard i will pay you in bitcoin uh or in fiat or whatever you want uh whatever you want no no meme coins i appreciate you brother thank you for coming on here uh stoked for people to uh to dig into this a little bit and

thanks for the ongoing work that you do. I know there's, I've seen a lot of appreciation out there for it. Uh, you didn't have to do it, but you're out there doing it. You know, you can just do things and what you're doing is genuinely, I think helping a lot of people. So thanks, man. Thank you, Walker. Thanks for having me, buddy. And thank you to everybody at Noster. I almost forgot to thank you guys. Yeah. You didn't think I'd forget you. Appreciate the Zaps guys. Much love. We'll see you next time. And that's a wrap on this Bitcoin Talk episode of The Bitcoin Podcast.

Remember to subscribe to this podcast wherever you're watching or listening, and share it with your friends, family, and strangers on the internet. Find me on Noster at primal.net slash walker and this podcast at primal.net slash titcoin. On X, YouTube, and Rumble, just search at Walker America and find this podcast on X and Instagram at Titcoin Podcast. Head to the show notes to grab sponsor links. Head to substack.com slash at Walker America to get episodes emailed to you.

And head to Bitcoin Podcast dot net for everything else. Bitcoin is scarce, but podcasts are abundant. So thank you for spending your scarce time listening to the Bitcoin podcast. Until next time, stay free.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Bitcoin Should Steal From Mastercard | John McCabe

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    When Steak ’n Shake started accepting bitcoin, one Bitcoiner said the nearest location was 20 miles away and he was loading the family into the car. John McCabe used to help merchants win new customers at Mastercard....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Why the Next Bitcoin Bull Market Could Be Bigger | Joe Consorti

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    Joe Consorti joins Walker to explain why he still thinks Bitcoin’s bottom is in - and what would make him change that view. We examine the 200-week moving average, the comparison with 2022, Strategy’s market reaction,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Bitcoin’s Disbelief Rally: Who Is Left to Sell? | James Check & Michael Sullivan

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    Who is left to sell Bitcoin? James Check (Checkmate) and Michael Sullivan are back for round two after Peak Apathy. We put Check’s on-chain analysis alongside Michael’s language-based sentiment research to explore the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Bitcoin, AI, Astrology & the Cycles Shaping Our Future | Erin Redwing

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 38 minAudio

    Could AI change how society makes decisions - and why is Erin Redwing watching 2032? Erin joins Walker for a conversation about Bitcoin, artificial intelligence, astrology, historical cycles and keeping your human...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Bitcoin Taxes, Inheritance & Knowing When You Have Enough | Jessy Gilger

    Oct 16, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    How much Bitcoin is enough - and what is it actually for? Jessy Gilger, CFP® and founder of Verify Wealth, joins Walker to connect Bitcoin conviction with the practical work of taxes, inheritance, cash flow, and making...

    Credit the people on this episode