Welcome back to Season 4 of The Battle with hosts Matt Sidhom and Jenn Tully! This season, we’re heading to the movies to crown the ultimate music biopic champion. In Round 1, each matchup faces off across two core criteria: historical accuracy and lead performance. Here's the mixtape for this week: https://my.superawesomemix.com/mix/walk-the-line-vs-get-on-up-f006 This week wraps up the first round of the tournament with our final Drugs Division matchup: James Mangold’s 2005 Johnny Cash standard Walk the Line taking on Tate Taylor’s 2014 James Brown portrait Get On Up. Matt and Jenn break down: Joaquin Phoenix & Reese Witherspoon's Off-Screen Work: Performing their own vocals as Johnny Cash and June Carter Cash, capturing the cadence and chemistry of the famous country duo, and how the movie shifted the narrative regarding Cash's first wife, Vivian. Chadwick Boseman’s Dynamic Physicality: Boseman’s dedicated performance doing his own dancing, splits, and stage movements to capture the "Hardest Working Man in Show Business," despite jarring face prosthetics. Fact vs. Fiction: The compressed timeline, Folsom Prison context, and love-story focus in Walk the Line versus Get On Up's glossed-over PCP addiction, the dark reality of the "Battle Royale" country club scene, and Boseman's performance carrying a disjointed narrative. The Verdict: Which film claims the final spot in Round 2 to move into the Drugs Division Final against Ray?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to season four of the battle. This season, Gentulli and I are going to the movies to try to find out the winner of the music biopic battle. Each round, we'll cover a different set of criteria, so the deeper the movie goes in the tournament, the more you learn about it. For round one, the focus will be on historical accuracy and the lead performance. We've got four divisions the all-women division, gone too soon, groups or bands, and then drugs. Um we'll publish a mixtape with every episode, but you can make your own at my.superawesomix.com.
SPEAKER_01It's free and can be shared on any major music streaming service. This week, it's our final first round matchup again in the drugs division. We've got Walk the Line versus Get On Up. So Jen, talk to me about Walk the Line.
SPEAKER_00Wow. We've had I mean we've had a good run here. There's 16 biopics. Like I know. We really like it. That's a lot of biopics.
SPEAKER_01That's a lot to uh a lot of great movies.
SPEAKER_00It's a lot of great movies, a lot of great movies. And I feel like we finished strong um with this with this last matchup. Um Walk the Line was one of my favorites in the whole shebang. Um, I like this movie since I saw it. I will say, uh I think uh the watching it again, this was only my second, maybe third time seeing it since it came out in 2005. So this is a 21-year-old film. I couldn't believe that either. That blew my mind whenever I was re-watching it.
SPEAKER_00And I will say I I liked it better in earlier watchings, but still really loved this movie. So I think this is one you can't watch over and over. Whereas I think I, you know, admitted early on in the show, I've probably seen Coal Miner's Daughter, I don't know, if I'm being honest, at least 20, 30 times probably in my life. Like I've built this is one where I'm like, yeah, I'm good. I'm just gonna leave this one because I love it. I do love this movie. Um, but the more I watched it, the more I started nitpicking at it a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Um, but of course, this is Walk the Line is the story of Johnny Cash. And and honestly, the love story between Johnny and June Carter Cash, almost more than just exclusively about Johnny Cash. This one leans in heavy to that relationship. And um, you know, people that are fans of Roseanne Cash will know that famously this movie upset her terribly because it painted uh she felt like it painted her mother, um, Vivian Cash, Johnny Cash's first wife, in a really bad light. Um, and and he felt like, or Roseanne Cash felt like it was just an a very inaccurate retelling of her mother.
SPEAKER_00Um and so I I think you know, you do have some issues with Walk the Line, but in terms of just if if you like Johnny Cash, if you like his music, especially you know, some of the well-known hits um Folsom Prison Blues, Cry, Cry, Cry, Um Jackson, um, when we're talking about a duet between Johnny and June, like you get these amazing performances, you know, uh, of some of their biggest hits. You get, I would say you get some of Johnny Cash's life story, but like, you know, like all of these films, they have to pick an end point, you know, and so it usually ends on a happy note in most cases.
SPEAKER_00They're not right, they're not taking us to, you know, to dark places for the finale. But um uh this was one where I I felt like you definitely it ended on a high note. They leaned in hard to the the Johnny Cash, June Carter Cash love story. Um, but I felt like you got a pretty accurate retelling, at least enough to understand Johnny Cash on a on a cursory level. Um but I don't know that I don't know that this movie that walk the line is gonna win for um historical accuracy.
SPEAKER_00We'll we'll get into that a little bit more, but yeah, I I don't know that this one is uh uh we might need a fact checker.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's fair. That's fair.
SPEAKER_00Um but talk to me about Get On Up. What what about what was what what was that about? Who was that about?
SPEAKER_01Well, uh Get On Up came out in 2014, and it stars the late Chadwick Bozeman as James Brown. Um and really, like it's this is this one was interesting because I know for me, I didn't know a ton about James Brown's background prior to this. So, you know, you're watching this and it's kind of eye-opening, and then you know, of course, you've got to check, like, all right, how how accurate is this movie, right? And um, it is to some degree, like he had a really brutal childhood growing up.
SPEAKER_01He he did live in a brothel for a time, and that's that's depicted in the movie. You definitely see that. Um, there's a scene where he is fighting other children, like for sport, and that was said to be an accurate scene. Like that was something that was part of his childhood as well. Um, and then his friendship with Bobby Bird. At one point, James Brown is in prison, and and you know, he ends up meeting Bobby Bird, who you know helps him get out of prison, and then kind of helps him sort of get into the music business, and of course, James Brown just kind of takes off from there.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think that's a that's sort of a running theme in these biopics, and maybe there's no other way to depict it, but it's kind of like one one scene nobody's ever heard of him, and then the next scene it's like he's the biggest thing in the world, right? After like one performance. Um, but yeah, one thing I I think that it it's really interesting in this movie because they really do show James Brown as they go along as as kind of mean, right? He he's not very nice to his bandmates, he's not very nice to uh his family, they do show him abusing his wife, they they gloss over his addiction to PCP, which is how he made this division to begin with, but they just sort of gloss over the fact that he is a drug addict.
SPEAKER_01Um but and and then you know, similar to Rocket, like we talked about Rocket Man, the end of Rocket Man last week, and how it had this sort of cutesy ending to it, and like same thing here, where in the end there's just sort of this homage to James Brown and like all he contributed, and it's like you just spent two hours showing me how he's kind of like not a nice guy, and then in the end it's like we'll never forget James Brown.
SPEAKER_00Well, and we'll never forget it for reasons they didn't even really show. I'm like Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So it's a very uh very it's kind of an odd movie in that sense.
SPEAKER_00Uh you know what? Uh uh, yes, I completely agree. So this movie was the only movie out of the 16 that we ended up settling on for the battle that I had never seen before.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00So this was a first watching for me. Um, and I love Chadwick Bozeman. I Black Panther's my favorite of the Marvel movies. Like I like love him. So I was so excited about this. And I did not like this movie, Matt. I didn't like it. I I I thought I'm like, I don't know anything more about James Brown really than I did when I stepped in. It didn't, it didn't, I didn't feel like I got what he contributed, other than a whole bunch of crazy, you know, like he spends a lot of time in the movie, like ask anybody, but you know, their sound, and it comes from James Brown, and you're like, really?
SPEAKER_00Well, show me. Like, I don't, yeah. I it just didn't, and and I felt like in that opening scene, like the prosthetics that Chadwick Bozeman is wearing on his face are so jarring that I was like, he looks uncomfortable, I'm uncomfortable, like this is, and I just felt like for such a character, like James Brown is so dynamic. Like, even if you just think of like like Eddie Murphy doing him on SNL, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00Like James Brown is like so iconic and crazy, and then you just get this kind of boring movie that falls flat. I was like, I don't understand how this is about James Brown. It was almost like they told the story of James Brown in the tone of Ray, you know, or something where you're just like, what is happening here? Like, this is not. I feel like of all the movies that should have been Elvisy or Rocket Manny or whatever, it's this one. And mm-mm.
SPEAKER_01Well, and and I'm glad you brought up Ray because I do think sort of the the reason you make a movie like this or or about James Brown is because similar to Ray Charles, he has a unique physicality and a unique voice. And I do think I I'll give credit to, you know, I'll I'll jump ahead to kind of some lead performance commentary, but like Chadwick Bozeman does a great job of kind of performing like James Brown.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And he doesn't sing all of the songs, but he kind of fills it. Well, my understanding is like he filled in some vocal gaps and things like that. But like so he he looks and sounds, maybe not facially, but like his physicality. Yes. Like he gets that right. He gets um so I do think the performance part, and I think that's almost like the driver for the movie, is let's show somebody performing like James Brown.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think they really left so much on Chadwick Bozeman's shoulders for this, you know. Like I it's true, and he does, you know, he does his own dancing, he does the splits, he's not a dancer, and he learned to move like that. Like, again, I will not say anything bad about Chadwick Bozeman ever. I think he's brilliant. I'm gone too soon. RIP, I would have loved to have watched him into old age. He was such a talented performer, but uh, this movie just, yeah, it felt it it really fell flat for me. And I and I feel like I didn't, I didn't get as much as I wanted.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, oh, I'm excited to dig into James Brown. He's like a character I don't know a whole lot about, and I left the movie still not knowing a whole lot about him. You know, I told you I had the section of things I learned from watching the movie. I had two notes on this one. One, little Richard was gay question mark. And two, was the battle royale. What the fuck? That was real. That's what you're talking about. The little boys fighting each other for the entertainment of white people at a country club. I mean, they call it the battle crowd.
SPEAKER_01I was like, there's no way. There's no way this is accurate. But then you you look it up, and sure enough, that was a real thing.
SPEAKER_00So those are two things that had nothing to do with James Brown, really. That I was like, oh, this is all I learned from this movie.
SPEAKER_01Well about James Brown. The hard part too, because like, okay, I'll contrast it to like a movie like Rocket Man, where there's a lot of moments in Rocket Man where Elton John does not seem very likable and he's kind of mean to people. But then you also gain some empathy because he's clearly kind of suffering throughout his life, right? Like that so there's there's sort of reasons behind it, not to excuse it, but at least you kind of go, well, I I get it, right? In this movie, I he's just kind of mean throughout the movie to everybody and kind of uses people, takes advantage of people just time after time.
SPEAKER_01And then at the end, the way it wraps up, it just makes you like, hey, don't you love this guy? And it's like, I don't. And I don't know what part of the movie was supposed to make me love him, outside of, boy, is his music incredible, which I I I won't deny. Like, I think his music is incredible, but like you said, there's nothing in that movie that makes you be like, Yeah, but he did so much for people, didn't he? And it's like, not not really. Like he was if they stepped out of line, like he was all over him, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, he did so much for like don't do PCP, and we didn't even get a lot of that. You know what I mean? Like it's like a cautionary tale of like, like that's how I learned what PCP was, I think, was like, Hey mom, what's PCP? You know, like uh from watching one of the crazy stories, like, and then yeah, you get you you just really don't get any of that. Like they show you the one crazy thing which was wildly exaggerated in the opening scene, and then you like think you're in for this wild ride, and then I just feel like it gets like more and more boring from there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So let's talk about. I mean, we just touched on kind of the lead performance, and we got into um get on up quite a bit, but let's let's talk about the lead performance and walk the line.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I you know, of course, we have to talk about Joaquin Phoenix playing Johnny Cash, but you almost can't talk about him without talking about Reese Witherspoon playing Jude Carter because they really do figure so prominently, the both of them in this movie. But I I really liked what Joaquin Phoenix did with this character. Again, he doesn't he doesn't look exactly like Johnny Cash. You know, I I've I don't know if I mentioned this when we were talking about Rocket Man, but like Taryn Edgerton didn't really look like Elton John to me either.
SPEAKER_00But he embodied the character, and I feel like that's kind of what happened here, right? Like like Joaquin Phoenix embodied Johnny Cash. I felt like Reese Witherspoon did a good job at embodying June Carter Cash without necessarily looking like them. And so I I thought that was interesting, and and this is that other film in the list that I where I really appreciated the the vocals. Um they both did their own singing in this movie, um, both Reese Witherspoon and Joaquin Phoenix. And again, they they didn't try and mimic, they did their interpretation of what they thought these embodied characters would sound like, right?
SPEAKER_00What they thought these characters that they're portraying would sound like. And so I really love that too. You know, Johnny Cash's voice is so iconic that um it's hard to nail. And this is one of those where you'd almost think, like, ugh, just for like the sake of the fans, we're gonna let you lip sync because Johnny Cash's voice is so unique and so distinct. And so I was glad that Joaquin Phoenix took on that challenge and was like, nope, I want I want to do my own songs, I want to do my own singing. And I think you've got a really enjoyable version that yes, you can tell, like if somebody plays Folsom Prison Blues for me, you know, like I I know which one is Joaquin and which one's Johnny, but um I felt like it had it was close enough that I I really I enjoyed both performances so so much.
SPEAKER_00But I I think Reese is slightly less successful than Joaquin in her portrayal, but I like them both.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, I agree. And and I think what Joaquin Phoenix did, which is a a part of like impressions that I think some people miss out on, is yes, you want to try to sound like the person, but there's everybody kind of has a certain cadence to the way they talk and a rhythm. And I think he got that down with Johnny Cash's voice, even if his voice didn't sound exactly like him. And I think that's why it was able to match well enough to to so as to not kind of bump you a little bit while you're watching it, you know?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I agree. I I agree. And I I think one of the hard things about this movie for me though, I I love the way they they embodied their performers. I think, and this is not a Joaquin Phoenix or a Reese Witherspoon issue necessarily, but I felt like the um there the arc wasn't as as big as I wanted it to be. Do you know what I mean? I feel like the character arc is so weird for Johnny Cash in this. Like he literally goes from like he's in the Air Force one day to he's like on national TV, effortlessly, you know, performing a number one song.
SPEAKER_00Like you you don't really get to see him evolve into the performer that is that is Johnny Cash. So I although I think he embodied Joaquin Phoenix does a good job embodying him, I felt like the story kind of let him down a little bit and not giving us a moment to sort of see him becoming Johnny Cash. Like he's not J.R. Cash anymore, he's becoming Johnny Cash, this persona. And even in his audition, you know, for Sam Phillips, like he goes in, he's singing gospel. Sam Phillips, who's played really well, I thought, by Dallas Roberts, um, is kind of like, yeah, nobody's listening to gospel music.
SPEAKER_00Do you got anything else? And like on the spot, allegedly, he comes up with the song he's writing. The bands never even heard it again, allegedly, and all of a sudden he's Johnny Catch. You know, like you're just like the there's nothing amazing about the performance. Like, there's no way Sam Phillips would have recorded him on the spot with what you see on the movie, right?
SPEAKER_01Like well, and that's why this movie was the inspiration for Walk Hard the Dewey Cox Story with John C. Riley.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Which which hits on all these like kind of tropes and biopics so well, just like that, where it's just like, I'm gonna sing you a song you're completely disinterested in, and then oh, you don't like that? Well, I have this other one that's gonna be the greatest selling song of all time that I'm just gonna start playing, right? And it's like, yeah, it's it's just it's a little ridiculous. But the second point I'll make is I do think that sometimes the challenge in these biopics is when you're trying to cover 70 years of somebody's life in approximately two hours, I think you do have to kind of squeeze together moments.
SPEAKER_01And I know you and I have talked about the Bruce Springsteen movie that came out a year or so ago. Neither one of us liked it, but to its credit, it covered about 18 months of Bruce's life. It did not try to cover everything from Bruce as a as a child to Bruce now, right? Like, and so in that sense, I think it had the right idea. I think it was poorly executed, but we don't have to talk about that right now. And um, yeah, I mean, so I do think that sometimes the challenge is is they almost are forced to skim over that for the sake of of timing.
SPEAKER_00But you can't skim over the like the point of the artist. Do you know what I mean? Like Johnny Cash is Johnny Cash, not because he's like Adele and has a four-octave range, you know, like he's he's Johnny Cash because of his persona and uh, you know, like I I don't know. There were parts, especially whenever he's really trying to win June's heart, where you just see him as like I don't know, he's not the man in black at all. He's like this kind of pathetic version of himself that I was like, no, you can't.
SPEAKER_00Like, if you're not gonna give us the story of how he became Johnny Cash, then I then don't give us the story of how he is so love sick with June that he's sort of ruining everything. He's ruining Johnny Cash. Do you know what I mean? Like, I don't know. It felt like they leaned into the wrong thing for me a little bit.
SPEAKER_01Well, and it's almost like there's this emphasis on the uh Folsom Prison concert.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01As if it's this pinnacle. And in fact, he performed in prisons all the time, and and there there wasn't this huge issue with him performing there. There just happened to be this this concert that was recorded there, you know, like that that's famous. So it's it is one of these things almost like when we when we were talking about Bohemian Rhapsody, it's like they sort of built up to live aid being this pinnacle thing when it's like that they kind of messed up the timeline there and and everything was just sort of jumbled, and it it's again they were trying to build a story around these things that people know, right?
SPEAKER_01And and I think that's what led to some of the the glossing over. I'm not trying to excuse it, I just think that's sort of what I saw as the source of the problem.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that that's accurate, and I think, you know, I I think I was a little um I I had read back from whatever, since the movie's been out for 21 years, you know. I remember famously. I I love Roseanne Cash, and so I remember whenever this movie came out reading about her, like, nope, I'm not gonna see it. This is like not accurate, blah, blah, blah. And so I all I don't know if it's because of that or because I really did have an issue, but I really did not enjoy Jennifer Goodwin's performance as as Vivian Cash at all.
SPEAKER_00I thought she was a terrible character. I think she wasn't like that in real life. I think she couldn't have been like that in real life, or Johnny Cash would have never been Johnny Cash. Do you know what I mean? Like she, you know, they portray her as really like not supportive and kind of a spoiled brat, and she wants to go home to her daddy, and it's just that just was not anybody that you talk to, you know, that ever knew Vivian Cash was like she was incredibly supportive. She, you know, like, and I and I think again, because Reese Witherspoon is playing June Carter Cash, they everybody loves Reese Witherspoon, you're not gonna make her a villain.
SPEAKER_00Um, but by all accounts, she was kind of nasty and kind of openly nasty to to Vivian Cash. And, you know, there's a famous confrontation that she tells about where she says, you know, Vivian basically stops her backstage at one of the one of the shows. Um, June Carter Cash stops Vivian and says something to the effect of like, he he's gonna be mine, or something like that, you know, like some chick code violation where you'd be like, oh no, you didn't, you know, like earrings are coming off and like hoops are coming out, things are gonna throw down, like, you know, so uh that bothered me throughout a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Like I just I wasn't loving that aspect. Um, but uh again, uh the are there problems in Walk the Line? There are. I thought that the character arc was was really not there, and you get such great performances from you know, from Reese and Joaquin that you do get sucked in. Like I found myself being um entranced by the movie and less bothered by the inaccuracies.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. But I I agree with you. It's also interesting when you see a couple on screen and you can't even tell why they're ever together, right? And that was kind of the case here where it's just like this just seemed awful from the jump. Like, why would they ever be a couple and have multiple children and all these other things if this was always the relationship? But um, well, Jen, I don't think I need to ask you, but but I'm going to anyway for the sake of the show, which one of these movies do you feel like advances?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think that this is an easy one for me. It's going to be Walk the Line for this gal. And and Andy, again, we we there were some issues. I'm not saying walk the line is a perfect film, but I did not. I'm so sorry, Chadwick Bozeman. I love you to pieces, but I did not like get on up.
SPEAKER_01I I didn't I didn't dislike uh get on up. Um but I also was just confused by it, right? Like I was just kind of like, I don't I don't understand what I'm supposed to take from this, right? And and I don't think it did a good enough job of, you know, the lead performance part was strong, but again, just leaving out certain things in his life and and kind of not getting us to really care about James Brown in the end, I think, is is kind of a failure on their part.
SPEAKER_01So I am going to agree with you in advance, walk the line in this one. So there you have it, folks. Our last first round winner will be walk the line. So come on back next week. We're gonna go back to the top of the bracket and get into the finals of the all women division. Okay, and in that one, just to remind everyone, we're gonna go into what's love got to do with it taking on Coal Miner's Daughter.
SPEAKER_01So that will be a battle for sure between two very strong women and two very strong movies. Of course, you can make your own mixtape at my dotsuperaw mix dot com. We're gonna publish a mixtape with every episode. But join us next week as we get into the quarterfinals of the battle in season four for Jenny. This is Matt, and we'll see you then.
Welcome back to Season 4 of The Battle with hosts Matt Sidhom and Jenn Tully! The quarterfinals roll on, pushing the remaining group and band biopics through Round 2 criteria: supporting cast, cinematic crafts (visual...
Welcome back to Season 4 of The Battle with hosts Matt Sidhom and Jenn Tully! The tournament continues into the quarterfinals, putting remaining biopics through Round 2 criteria: supporting cast, cinematic crafts...
The tournament moves into the quarterfinals where the remaining biopics are put to the test by Matt Sidhom & Jenn Tully across Round 2 criteria: supporting cast, cinematic crafts (visual style, pacing, editing), and...
Welcome back to Season 4 of The Battle where Matt Sidhom and Jenn Tully head to the movies to crown the ultimate music biopic champion. In Round 1, each matchup faces off across two core criteria: historical accuracy...
Welcome back to Season 4 of The Battle with hosts Matt Sidhom and Jenn Tully! This season, we’re heading to the movies to crown the ultimate music biopic champion. In Round 1, each matchup faces off across two core...