In Episode 590, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about pitchers who made at least 29 starts and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. The Frauds are Dead, Long Live the Frauds: Rays up, Craig. 2. The Sickos World Series Preview: Rays/Brewers is just fancy Rays/Guardians when you think about it. Also, is they key to this series Nick Martinez?3. Staffing Up: Front office, managerial, field staff news 4. Around the Horn: Gold Gloves and NPB posting. 5. How badly does Craig actually want to win this game? Five and Dive is listener-supported, you can join our Patreon at patreon.com/fiveanddive. If you want to get in contact with the show, the e-mail address is fiveanddive@baseballprospectus.com. Our theme tune is by Andy Matthews, who you can follow on Bluesky @andymatthewsmusic. You can listen to him on Spotify and Apple Music. It was produced by Barrie Maguire and Tim Ferguson.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Thank you. Welcome to episode 590 of Five and Dive.
Speaker 1It is, I don't know, it's October 20th, guys.
Speaker 2Tuesday, Craig, Tuesday.
Speaker 1Tuesday. I know what day it is. It is Tuesday, October 20th. I'm your host, Craig Goldstein, joining us as usual.
Speaker 2You remember your name, that's good.
Speaker 3Yeah, we're working on it. Show me the cognitive tests of the animals later and we'll see how it goes.
Speaker 2Yep.
Speaker 3That voice you heard was Jeffrey Paternostro. The voice you haven't heard and might not hear for several minutes, depending on his mood, is Patrick Dubuque. We are back to five and dive. Oh, Patrick, I just remembered what I wanted to do for banter. You don't have to remind me.
Speaker 1Well, I mean, we have an open spot on number five, so maybe you should just save it. No, there's a... I thought.
Speaker 3Colin sent like three games then. Colin sent like three games, so we're.
Speaker 1Not doing that. Why waste one of your... You're wasting a game as banter. It's like one-tenth of a game. All right, fine.
Speaker 3Jeffrey, I'm giving you a pop quiz.
Speaker 1Not you. You and Patrick. I would like you to tell me there are 44 pitchers. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 3That threw 30 plus starts last year.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3I want to do essentially a small version of a game that Patrick, you know, where you get, you get three guesses and you can have, I'm not even going to keep tracking that thing, but I just want to see some of these names absolutely blew me away.
Speaker 1I suspect there are enough that are obvious. Sure. That you can avoid any real landmines here. Yeah. But. Oh no.
Speaker 2I'm just going to, since this doesn't count for me, I'm just going to try to pick the funniest ones I could think of.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3There are some wild ones.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So, so I, there are someone made 34.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3So they will get the most starts or the most points or whatever that I'm not going to keep track of, but you know, and it descends from there. So, uh, you, we do this usually not in a booth. So, you know, feel free.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Um, I think it'd be somebody that got traded, you would think.
Speaker 1I'm going to go with Alcantara.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's fair enough.
Speaker 1That's the easy one.
Speaker 3He is number five on our list. He's tied for second.
Speaker 133 starts.
Speaker 233 starts.
Speaker 136 games. Yeah, 36 games. 36 games, yes.
Speaker 3I will go with Cam Schlittler. Cam Schlittler, also tied for second.
Speaker 133 starts.
Speaker 233 starts, okay.
Speaker 1Now I feel like I've got some names and I there's certain pitchers that you're like I didn't hear this person's name spoken all year so they must have started 32 games right because there's only one there's two ways that you never get talked about and that is if you don't pitch and that is if you don't stop pitching so like the name Landon Roop really I did not think about Landon Roop at all but he also didn't get hurt like I don't think it hurt. I think it was just there.
Speaker 3Patrick, I am sorry. This is a landmine. He did make 29 starts. 29 starts, yeah.
Speaker 1But not 30. Okay.
Speaker 2Sometimes you're just going to skip Landon Roop's turn if you get a rain out.
Speaker 1No, you're not. Not with the other Giants pitchers. All right.
Speaker 2I will go with– I'm trying to think of who might be 34, and I feel like it would be someone that would load on either side of the all-star break to do it that way. So I'm going to go with Sonny Gray.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3It is not Sonny Gray. Sonny Gray had 29 starts.
Speaker 1What? Sorry, so you've both hit a lead. Wow.
Speaker 2I should have gone with the... I thought Sonny Gray was very safe.
Speaker 1Another guy I did not think about once all year. We probably talked about him, but I also talked about him and did not think about him. Shane Boz. Shane Boz had to be pitching constantly.
Speaker 3Shane Boz had 31 starts.
Speaker 1All right, there you go.
Speaker 2All right, so I got to beat 31 because we both got 32 on the first one.
Speaker 3That's right. Well, you both got 33 on the first one.
Speaker 233 on the first one. All right, I am going to go with Freddy Peralta.
Speaker 1Switching teams. I think you got an extra one. You did it, Jeffrey. Yep, 32.
Speaker 3You matched him by one start. 32 starts. Now, first in the category.
Speaker 2Can I guess?
Speaker 1Yeah, sure.
Speaker 2If I say it, for some reason it would be very funny in my mind if it was Chris Bassett.
Speaker 1See, I was thinking Jeffrey Springs.
Speaker 2Springs was hurt.
Speaker 3Chris Bassett got hurt.
Speaker 2Oh, Bassett did get hurt. Okay. I don't know.
Speaker 1I know that because I just edited his comment.
Speaker 2Bassett missed time and I didn't hear about it because it's Chris Bassett. Yeah.
Speaker 3It is Mackenzie Gore.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2That's a good, that's definitely a guy you just did not hear about this year.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, and also like a guy who routinely used to miss time.
Speaker 1Yes. Yeah.
Speaker 3I know he's made a lot of starts the last couple of years, but the names, so like the obvious names I thought you would have gone for, Christopher Sanchez, Aaron Nola, the Phillies guys who just post.
Speaker 1One of the Mariners pitchers that I own, probably Logan Gilbert.
Speaker 3Yes, Logan Gilbert had 32 starts. Tanner Bybee had 33. I thought Patrick might have gone with Bybee.
Speaker 1You're right. I actually had to look that up at some point. Yeah, I think last night. Because game one starter, right? Like your opening day starter. Yeah.
Speaker 3Seth Lugo with 32. I just like the number of guys who had missed a lot. Like Shota Imanaga had 32 starts.
Speaker 2The Cubs had a lot of numbers. He was like the one guy. They're one number three starter that stayed healthy.
Speaker 3Yeah. Jacob DeGrom and Dustin May each made 31 starts this year. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3Anthony Kay made 31 starts.
Speaker 2I mean, choices were made there.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2That's like you are active. It's like, You know, there's like this, I don't know, like this like relationship advice you hear sometimes where you like, you have to actively wake up and choose your partner every morning. Like the White Sox woke up and actively chose to pencil in Anthony Kaye's name.
Speaker 331 times.
Speaker 231 times, yeah.
Speaker 3Joey Cantillo, 30 starts.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2It's very funny that there's all these guardians pitchers.
Speaker 1Kyle Lane.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's a good one.
Speaker 130 starts.
Speaker 2Did Peyante get there too?
Speaker 3Did who?
Speaker 2Peyante get there too? I feel like he's never.
Speaker 1I feel like every Cardinals pitcher just pitched 30 starts.
Speaker 3Pallante got 29.
Speaker 1Oh, well. Yeah.
Speaker 3It's just, like, the number of guys that I associate with, like, did you know Grant Holmes made 29 starts?
Speaker 2I mean, I believe it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I thought he was hurt.
Speaker 2I did not know, but I believe it. No, he was never hurt.
Speaker 1He's just not really a starter. Everyone in that rotation was hurt. I like how every team's Landon Root got 29 starts.
Speaker 3And I do have to say, the inspiration for this was I was editing another comment.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Legitimately floored by the fact that Walker Bueller made 32 starts this year.
Speaker 1Yeah. Honestly, that was another, never heard of him. I'm doing a moment. It hit you. Like it hit me.
Speaker 2No, I'm trying to a Padres. It took me a second.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2It just took me a second. He was there with Marquez. I mean, it all makes sense when you're.
Speaker 3Like, they have no one better. But again, like, Walker Bueller has not ever helped.
Speaker 2It is very funny to listen to you just list off a bunch of Guardian starters they refused to start in the playoffs.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Oh, also, yes, absolutely.
Speaker 1You can take more than.
Speaker 2Half of our starts this year in the regular season, but we will not start.
Speaker 1In the playoffs.
Speaker 3By the way, in the mold of always hurt, but somehow made 32 starts, Cade Cavalli.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, that's him.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, sure.
Speaker 3Like, yeah, sure.
Speaker 1It makes sense.
Speaker 3Except he's never had, he had been unhealthy for like three and a half years.
Speaker 2How many Casey Mize make? It feels like he might've, uh, well, he got hurt with the, uh, with the, uh, Padres.
Speaker 1Yeah. I don't know.
Speaker 3It's just, uh, I don't know. Dumb, dumb little game to start us off. I don't know if you, uh, want to contribute any other banter on top of that.
Speaker 2I have, I have a small piece of banter. Cause I was sure I was going to keep something short since we have like a hard out, but Craig decided to start with the game. Um, I do most of the cooking in the house because I like to cook. It's not a big kitchen. It's not a great setup, but whatever. I have my little... One of the most important things you need, you need your little kitchen towels to wipe out pots. Most people hang them over the little handle on my oven. Lately, I've noticed they keep
Speaker 2ending up on the floor. I'm like, what is happening? You have to They keep sliding off. We'll get, we'll get there, Craig. They keep sliding off on the floor, but just like, but, and then finally this weekend while I was making chili, the, uh, the puppy just walks up to me, like puts it like stamped on his hind legs, pulls it off. Doesn't take it anywhere. Just drops it on the floor. Like you would think he would take it somewhere where he smells food, but no, he just, all he does every time I tested it, it grabs another towel, put it on the thing, walks
Speaker 2right back up, takes it off, puts it.
Speaker 1On the floor.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1First of all, that is very cat behavior.
Speaker 2He is very much a cat. Like the cat behavior is very, very present.
Speaker 3And as someone who has been around cats, I immediately knew that this was a pet.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, it was like a child or a pet and it felt more like a pet.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Patrick, anything you want to contribute?
Speaker 1No, no. My life has been the recaps that we will talk about.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3Our first segment the frauds are dead long live the frauds the rays have advanced to the world series uh they did it behind junior caminero and yandi diaz and some questionable decisions from the opposing manager.
Speaker 2A shamefully forgetting Rishi Palacios in here.
Speaker 1I apologize.
Speaker 3There was a, a weird, uh, like he had to really reach out and poke slash pull.
Speaker 1Pull. Yeah. I love those.
Speaker 3Like, well, can poke be a pull?
Speaker 1It's, um, it's more of a slash at that point. No, it's not. It's more of a, of a, can poke only be the opposite field or up?
Speaker 2I think poke on the opposite field. That's kind of like a, it's a scoop. You just sort of scooped it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Flared it?
Speaker 2Flare, I feel like, is off the hands.
Speaker 1Oh, interesting. Okay. All right.
Speaker 3Anyway, he yanked one with zero strength into right field for a base.
Speaker 1Hit or RBI early?
Speaker 2RBI double.
Speaker 1Oh, right. It was a double, yeah. Two RBIs.
Speaker 2I think he had the highest OPS on the Rays in the series.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2Not that that's saying much.
Speaker 1Everybody else had one game, so yeah.
Speaker 3Uh, so the rays took three straight. They were down to one. They, they walk off the series four to two.
Speaker 2Um, I'm a little annoyed. The game yesterday didn't end three to one just for the, yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3Yandy DS had other ideas.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I guess that was even later.
Speaker 2That was, that was the first one.
Speaker 3They both teams tacked on some runs, uh, junior came an arrow just to start with.
Speaker 1Well, I guess it was Palacios to start with, but yeah.
Speaker 3Um, Junior Cameron Arrow got into another one, let's say. Taylor Walls was on. Let me ask you this. Did you have any issue with Brian Anderson's phrasing of on base for the fourth time?
Speaker 1Yes. He did clarify.
Speaker 3He did explain it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Three walks and a fielder's choice.
Speaker 2Yeah, he did the same thing.
Speaker 1For Kwon, actually.
Speaker 3But fielder's choice is not part of your on base percentage.
Speaker 1Yeah. It's reaching base, but it's not reaching base safely.
Speaker 2But also, reached on error, you would reach on base. I think we would consider on base if you reach on an error. Yes. Even though it does not go into your OBP? It should be in your OBP. It should be in your OBP. Catcher's interference? I don't know if catcher's interference goes.
Speaker 3In or not.
Speaker 1It does not. I wrote an article about this like 10, 15 years ago, scathingly.
Speaker 2What about a call? I mean, obviously, third strike, wild pitch that you reach on isn't.
Speaker 1Out. That's an out and an error, yeah.
Speaker 2That's out and an error, but.
Speaker 1Hmm.
Speaker 3You've given me something to think about. I do think reached on base is... I do think you can reach base when you reach on an error.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1But you're reaching... But, yeah, if you were racing somebody else's runner to reach base, you were, like.
Speaker 2You were net zero base runners.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's the issue.
Speaker 3Anyway, Taylor Walls, four times physically on base.
Speaker 2Yes, you made it.
Speaker 3But when you walk Taylor Walls.
Speaker 2Three times.
Speaker 1Three times.
Speaker 2Is that worse than walking Garrett Mitchell left on left?
Speaker 1Absolutely. Oh, yeah. No, Taylor... Plus, Taylor Walls... Not that four games matters or five games matters, but Taylor Walls looked like somebody who was actively trying to get a prize for not reaching base.
Speaker 2Like.
Speaker 1He could not hit.
Speaker 2He bunted a fair bit.
Speaker 1Yeah. One of his two pre-ALCS game six hits was a bunt. And it was like, everybody agreed, yes, it is good for Taylor Walls. The traditionalists, the advanced guys. Do it, man.
Speaker 3I posted something along these lines yesterday, but there was something to the effect of like, you know, a lot of people talking about the small ball stuff. And what I said yesterday was, it's been a complete and total victory for the small ball contingent. Thanks to these teams rostering guys that are so bad at offense. You can't do anything but the Alonzo morning nod when they sacrifice someone.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2It's like, you know, Cooper Pratt, lay it down.
Speaker 3Like Cooper Pratt is above the bar.
Speaker 2It's like a six 80 OPS.
Speaker 3I don't mean these teams. I don't really mean Milwaukee. Although if I was going to talk about, you know, maybe Joey Ortiz, you're like, okay, maybe, you know, Luis Lara, if he wants to bunt for a hit... I mean, any of these guys, if they want to bunt for a hit, like, okay. A lot of people, and I understand why, did not like Kike Hernandez's bunt that moved a guy over to bring up Shoya Otani with a guy on third. And, like, look, I think you can quibble with that in terms of Shoya Otani was bad, so, like,
Speaker 3why are you moving a guy to third for a guy who's been terrible? But at the same time, like, If we're going to call, I am legitimately thinking of Joe Sheehan here because he spends a lot of time talking about the Dodgers bench and specifically Kike Hernandez as a mascot. And I don't think he's generally wrong. But if the guy's so bad that you're calling him a mascot more than a baseball player, I don't know that we get to be upset about when he bunts a guy over. He's so bad that you call him a mascot, right? Like that is at least the class of player that
Speaker 3should ostensibly be doing this.
Speaker 1Although this is the moment that he is supposed to turn into a real boy instead of a football player.
Speaker 3There's a huge cognitive difference between what the Dodgers are doing and whatever. But like, if you think he stinks, then you probably don't think The bunt shouldn't be that bad.
Speaker 2They should have rostered Hysong Kim, who definitely wouldn't have been bunting as well, and that's fine. Right.
Speaker 1Well, yeah. He would have run faster first when he did bunt. Yeah. I mean, anyway, I don't mean to go back to the Dodgers. This is the Rays' Guardians.
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 1Do we want to go back?
Speaker 2I mean, all of these games were kind of the same.
Speaker 1They were kind of the same. Yeah. I mean, especially 5 and 6 had the same template, right? The Rays... Scratched out a few runs early. Couldn't quite finish the body off, right?
Speaker 2Had their chances, but yeah.
Speaker 1Well, I mean, right. Yeah. But it also never felt like, you know, sometimes when... 12 hits and three runs for the mix.
Speaker 2I said this on For All You Kids Out There. My biggest issue with this series, which I thought was, you know, compelling in its own way to, I guess, you know, damn with faint praise, I suppose. It never felt like anything could change on one swing of the bat, even though these games were reasonably close, right? It was a lot of like Patrick Bailey is just going to pop up now.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, in game five, the Guardians got the tying run to the plate in each of the last four innings. And it also did not feel like they were going.
Speaker 2How many of them got erased on double plays, Patrick?
Speaker 1Yeah, well, until the last two innings of game six, like it just felt like there might never be a home run again. Right. Everything seemed to die. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, it was cold for the games in Cleveland.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Like there were a few. Caminero definitely hit one that would have been out on a even like average weather day.
Speaker 1Right. But also, usually when a team strands eight runners in the first three innings, you think, oh, that team's going to lose. Karma that I want to believe in will destroy this team for leaving that many runners. And in this case, it didn't feel like that. It just felt like, yeah, they got three runs.
Speaker 3Well, when their opponent is so enfeebled.
Speaker 1And it's not. I'm taking shots at Cleveland, but Drew.
Speaker 3Rasmussen was starting, was the other person. It was the Cleveland lineup versus one of the best pitchers in baseball. You know, it's the hydrogen bomb and coughing.
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 1I thought they were good games, though. Especially, I thought both games were.
Speaker 3You've really been enjoying this, and I kept thinking, like, the American League has gotten to Patrick.
Speaker 1Well... So, no, it wasn't explosive. It wasn't, like... It never felt dangerous. It never felt exciting. But it did, like, compared to... It was a nice picnic.
Speaker 2It sounds like, yeah.
Speaker 1Picnics are great, man.
Speaker 2This sounds like very much Patrick baseball, yeah.
Speaker 1Everyone loves picnics. Especially compared to the expanded playoffs. Everything felt so competent. There were no mental mistakes. What a thing to say about the Guardians. They were, though.
Speaker 3An AL Central team.
Speaker 1They weren't good, but they weren't screwing up. It was really just both teams were playing good defense. Except Patrick Bailey when it came to challenging a strike. You know, it was fine. Like nothing felt like this didn't feel like the first two rounds of just like, why are these teams here? It made sense that these two teams were here. Yes. On a scale of Milwaukee, Los Angeles.
Speaker 2Two top seeds in the AL, we should mention again.
Speaker 1Having the other series be done and not having, you know, like these great stars playing on the other day or like earlier in the afternoon, it did help.
Speaker 3I follow your logic. But I also, I cannot, like, the Guardians should not have been here.
Speaker 1I mean, yes. In a properly seated situation, I don't think they would have. I think it would have been another AL East team, but they got to knock each other off. Cleveland didn't have to face any of those teams.
Speaker 3One reason it's tough for me to go along with it felt like these were the teams that should be here was Sean Armstrong started yet another playoff game.
Speaker 2There was so much Tim Herron.
Speaker 3That's not the point.
Speaker 2There was so much Tim Herron.
Speaker 3Also, I didn't get to address this the last time, but when I kept screaming about using Matt Festa. It was not like this.
Speaker 1Not exciting screaming about Matt Vesta. Those guys, hold on.
Speaker 3Use Matt Vesta when there's no reason to use anyone else. Why is Matt Vesta repeatedly in this series in leverage moments?
Speaker 2I know he was obviously gassed as we saw when he came in in game six. But it's very funny to me that you're throwing a bullpen game down 3-2. And you create a situation where you can lose the game with Sean Armstrong, Tim Herron, and Matt Fessa.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 2Like, you like.
Speaker 3And then Joey Cantillo.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3They went through those four arms before Espino, Sobrowski, Smith, and Gattis.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Now, again, as you said, several of those arms were gassed.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And look, the Rays.
Speaker 3They might have been gassed because you kept using them for two innings while you were up four and five runs, Stephen Vogt.
Speaker 2And look, the Rays... didn't actually break it open like they could have in the first three innings. They could have been down five or six nothing. And they were only down three.
Speaker 1Yeah, Vogt kind of got away with it. Although in the end, he did not get away with it because in the end, he couldn't have.
Speaker 2I feel like if you're throwing a bullpen game down, you've got to use Smith and Gaddis as soon as you can. Because you don't know if you're going to have a... You might be up a bunch.
Speaker 1In the eighth.
Speaker 3I don't mind holding them for like mid to later innings.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3But like, you probably do gotta use a Spino.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3Like, it shouldn't be Matt Festa.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And like, Matt Festa was in trouble.
Speaker 1And the Spino, by the way, was the only pitcher on the entire team that velocity wasn't like a tick and a half down.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1He was the only guy throwing as hard as he usually does, which is very funny.
Speaker 2He had a day off, I'm pretty sure. That's probably why.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And like, Joey Cantillo's not bad.
Speaker 2Sure, I mean, this all started by.
Speaker 1But also, you.
Speaker 3Weren't willing to pitch him, which is why we had Sean Armstrong and Tim Herron.
Speaker 1Yeah. So, like.
Speaker 2I mean, this was all started by just using Parker Messick for two in Game 5.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Look, he didn't look great, but.
Speaker 1He did not.
Speaker 2You gotta give Parker Messick a chance to find it against that lineup before you go to Matt Festa and Tim Herron and for whoever else. You know you're playing... You know, probably at least three days in a row, probably four. Oh, they didn't end up being four.
Speaker 1Yeah, it wouldn't have.
Speaker 2It might have been four if they'd done it a little bit different in game five. But, yeah, I mean, look, at the... I don't like the way Vogt managed, I think. He was also limited by not trusting Bybee or Cantillo to start a game here and go once through.
Speaker 3And that's the thing, is that you don't have to... We're not saying, like, Throw one of these guys five innings.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2And if you want to throw him behind an opener, you want to throw Cantillo behind Armstrong for three, whatever. That's like planned, whatever. Fine.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3I guess give them 10 batters or whatever.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Like nine, nine, 10 batters and see what happens.
Speaker 2I will never forget Sean Armstrong is on the guardians and not the raise now, though, based on how much he pitched.
Speaker 1Especially since the raise, like the raise, they got a lot of hits. There were a lot of flares. There were a.
Speaker 2Lot of flares.
Speaker 1Those hits were, some of them were pretty cheap.
Speaker 2There were a lot of, like, opposite field singles by righties when the second baseman was shifted over, right? Right.
Speaker 1Yeah. And to be fair to the Rays, like, it's not a criticism because they didn't strike out, especially in game six. They just, like, of course they were going to get some flares because everything was going into play. Yeah. But also, like, especially for the Messick thing, being like, yeah, he's not finding the strike zone, but.
Speaker 2And again, it's 2-2 in the series. You know you're throwing a bullpen game tomorrow, right? You have to be able to plan past the next inning. I know I said this for the White Sox, and it came due for the Guardians of.
Speaker 1The Series.
Speaker 3The White Sox truly did not have.
Speaker 2Yeah, but eventually tomorrow comes, right? If you try to win the game in front of you, eventually you've got to do it tomorrow, and eventually... And Kate Smith didn't even make a bad pitch, I suppose, to be fair. It wasn't a good pitch. It was a ball. Like, it was a bad splitter.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Weighing off the plate. And it just ended up not mattering because somehow Junior Caminero kept it.
Speaker 1Yeah. Because Caminero wanted to swing it anyway.
Speaker 2He wanted to swing it anyway. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. So I will say, like, we vote on awards are due the day after the play of the regular season ends.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1And for every other award, that makes sense. You don't want a rookie who is good in the playoffs having that interfere with everything. Managers, so much of what managers do are what they do in those three weeks in October. Like, they're so much more visible. They're so much more, like, it seems weird that we are going to evaluate Stephen Vogt on the games that didn't count. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, also, he was going to get Kevin Cash.
Speaker 3The regular season counts, Patrick.
Speaker 1Kevin Cash was.
Speaker 2The best manager in the AL and won best manager in baseball probably, and won the AL East in a division with the Yankees and Red Sox and Blue Jays, right?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And look, he pushed, he didn't like, again, when you have Drew Rasmussen go in seven innings, you don't have to push a lot of buttons. It limits the number of buttons you have to push.
Speaker 3It certainly helps. I mean, but, but.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know.
Speaker 3I mean, like, I guess he got the luxury of Rasmussen going twice. Gavin Williams gave, you know, gave Steven Vogt the reset and stuff like that. Yeah, but again, he used these guys so weird throughout, right? Like, this wasn't a one-series issue.
Speaker 2Right, and he was pulling Williams and Messick earlier than you would expect generally for those quality of pitchers in the playoffs. Like, I get you're.
Speaker 1Going to be aggressive. Let alone what he had later.
Speaker 2Let alone what he had later, right?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Freddie Peralta?
Speaker 2I said you were going to say Drew Asmussen going against the Guardians lineup. Freddie Peralta pitched into the six twice against this Guardians lineup.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Go ahead, Patrick.
Speaker 1And he pitched in game four in relief. This throw day stuff's got to stop.
Speaker 2It's pretty clear. Any day you throw is your throw day now. Throw days are a state of mind.
Speaker 1Peralta did not look as good in game six as.
Speaker 2He did in game two. It didn't matter.
Speaker 1It didn't matter, but like He got a lot of help. He was missing the zone with everything. It was not missing the zone like Kate Smith was missing the zone, right? It was chaseable stuff, but it was still like that could have gone badly if Cleveland had been a little more disciplined. He looked tired. Everybody looked tired. Everyone's too tired. Government, they should get their 15-minute breaks. It's the law.
Speaker 2Well, they get three days off now, at least, so.
Speaker 1All their 15-minute breaks are piled end-to-end.
Speaker 2So, I don't.
Speaker 1Know. Do we have anything else on the series actively? No.
Speaker 2The Rays were just better, right? Is what it comes down to. The Rays were the better team. And they beat them in six games.
Speaker 1Again, Cleveland didn't... It's going to sound rude. Cleveland didn't deserve to be here. I'm sorry.
Speaker 3They're not that good a team.
Speaker 2They probably should have lost in five, but Petey Halpin.
Speaker 3Hit a homer. Did they put up more wins against the Rays than the Dodgers did against the Brewers?
Speaker 1Absolutely. Doesn't matter. They're not that good. I don't know what to tell you. I don't know. I touched on this in the recap last night. I was probably too tired to really drill into it as far as I wanted to. The Rays are interesting because they don't have players who are good at everything. But they've done a very good job of stitching together people who are good at one thing. into a lineup that is just barely good enough at everything. Like, yes, they have their Taylor Walses for defense. You've got Chandler Simpson, who can do
Speaker 1two things. He can run and he can play defense. Taylor Walses can only do one. Junior Cananero is good at defense and has power. He's not good at defense. According to our stats, he is.
Speaker 2The metrics are all over the place on him.
Speaker 1Yeah, the metrics are all over the place. I understand, but he's not. If you want to give him two things he's good at, it's grounding into double plays.
Speaker 2He gets on base, too. He walks a fair bit. Because nobody wants to pitch to him in that lineup.
Speaker 1But the fascinating thing about the Rays is that for people, no team, I think, reflects what the viewer wants to see more than the Rays. They can be whatever you want them to be. Or whatever you want to hate.
Speaker 3They can be anti-analytics somehow.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2Yeah, they can be analytics.
Speaker 1And anti-analytics at the same time. It is a fascinating experience to be the person who you hate. That's their favorite team because they'll find something they love and you'll hate them because that guy you hate loves them. There's something to hold on to from every angle. By the way, shout out to Provo Flagmat for sending me a picture of Ryan Valade. He's so happy.
Speaker 2I did receive it. With what there is on Raze Twitter, I agree. It is easy to find something that you hate there.
Speaker 1That one bald guy loves the Raze. Anyway.
Speaker 3What's next for the Guardians?
Speaker 2Exactly this. Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 3Maybe a little bit cheaper and a little bit worse?
Speaker 4Maybe.
Speaker 2I mean, they've got to replace Nathaniel Lowe, I guess.
Speaker 1They do.
Speaker 2They have to replace Nathaniel Lowe, Patrick.
Speaker 1Who was there to replace Kyle Manzara? Who was there to replace Carlos Santana? Who was there to replace... I'm going to run down their lists of free agents.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3Reese Hoskins.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Foster Griffin.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3Nathaniel Lowe.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1End of sentence. Yep. They're obviously going to need to find a third starter they can actually trust. And maybe Joey Cotillo is that eventually.
Speaker 2I'm still sort of in on Bybee. He was good at times this year.
Speaker 3Now, here's a fascinating situation with Tanner Bybee. Are you aware of the structure of his contract?
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1I don't know if you recall, but he had a multi-year extension.
Speaker 2Yeah, I know he signed an extension.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So he's getting $ 7. 4 million next year, $ 10. 4 million in 2028, which, you know, they can stomach if he's going to go out there and be a fourth starter or whatever. He's getting $ 21. 4 million in 2029.
Speaker 2Well, they'll cross that bridge when they come.
Speaker 1Not from Cleveland, he's not.
Speaker 2Probably not, no.
Speaker 1Well.
Speaker 2I mean, I think, I mean, I'm curious what happens with Drew Rasmussen this offseason because he's getting $ 20 million next year. They should be able to keep him. do ownership and play money and everything else but he's the number one starter he is you would think they'd go on and.
Speaker 1On tanner by me they wouldn't pitch in the playoffs like but the.
Speaker 2Race the race will just they traded tyler glass now right yeah.
Speaker 3Sure yeah he had a balloon payment coming and they traded him and and that's fine and they might trade drew rasmussen um and and not pay him that but they will they will get something good yeah in return because he's good yes tanner by me Does not offer the same proposition at present. Yeah, I mean, it's going to be.
Speaker 2They're going to try to win 85 games in the division again next year, and it might work.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1I guess.
Speaker 2I guess. They will, you know, fill in around the margins. I get, like, the infield outside of first base seems pretty set with Ramirez at third. Rokio at shortstop and Bazana at second. Given how much Hanau struggled in his first taste of Major League. Actually, I assume they'll send him back to AAA, but I think Hanau long-term will probably take over for Rokio, but Rokio hit just enough
Speaker 2this year where.
Speaker 1Yeah, but he won't again, though, right?
Speaker 2He won't again. He was bad in the second half, too. And the outfield is pretty much set as well, somehow.
Speaker 3It depends on.
Speaker 1I mean, Stephen Kwan got $ 7. 725 million this year and is going to ARB3. It depends if they want to pay for that.
Speaker 2I mean, I assume they will.
Speaker 1I assume they will.
Speaker 3Joe Adele is going to ARB3. He's going to get less than Stephen Kwan based on what they got in ARB2.
Speaker 1Yeah, but Joe... Yeah. Yeah, this team can't go... Like, this team can't go in to the next year.
Speaker 2They had to go out and get Joe Adele in the first place because they needed.
Speaker 3No, I'm saying I think they'll keep him because he'll be less expensive.
Speaker 2Than Stephen Kwan.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And you have DeLauder's, again, on his rookie deal here.
Speaker 1And then you have DeLauder.
Speaker 2And I guess you can live with Petey Halpin in center. Like, you probably, like, they're going to live with Petey Halpin in center.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, I mean, they'll do Kwan, DeLauder, and Adele if they have all of them.
Speaker 2Sure, but they've been DHing Adele a lot.
Speaker 1Yeah. Well, they shouldn't.
Speaker 3I guess you have that luxury when you don't have a designated hitter.
Speaker 1Yeah, they need to get a first baseman, and then they have to get another first baseman to DH. That's just what this team has needed for five years.
Speaker 3And they keep trying to find the 2027 Ryan O'Hearn.
Speaker 1Stop being clever about this.
Speaker 2Like Ralphie Velasquez might be the answer. At first base DH.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2I mean, he might be. I mean, he's probably going.
Speaker 1To be at some point.
Speaker 3We'll probably see Kyle Manzardo as the answer again in one of these capacities.
Speaker 2CJ Kaifus is still around, right?
Speaker 1Yeah. The real answer is Josh Bell. let's do it again yeah i mean it's just it's just more of this.
Speaker 2Yeah and like they'll probably be pretty good okay pretty pretty good yeah pretty good yeah about this good.
Speaker 1That's good maybe it's not pretty good the lcs.
Speaker 2Next year probably will not get to the lcs next year but they might actually.
Speaker 1Have an american league refs team worth playing.
Speaker 3Yeah maybe maybe maybe which which team patrick.
Speaker 1I don't know Which team would you like to throw out there for that title? Maybe it'll be the Athletics here. Okay.
Speaker 2Can you imagine the Athletics winning that division and having to play playoff games in that stadium?
Speaker 1I do, by the way. We're about to get World Series games at the Trop, my friend.
Speaker 2I mean, it's a major league.
Speaker 1It is.
Speaker 3And my understanding is with the renovations, it's actually not bad. Not that it was bad before, but even better than before.
Speaker 1I was going to write about that, and I forgot.
Speaker 2I guess it's because they didn't get World Series games in 2020 because they were all in Texas.
Speaker 3Right, right.
Speaker 2Since 2008?
Speaker 32008, yeah.
Speaker 2I don't remember what else I was going to say.
Speaker 1Okay, and then I'll wrap up the topic. Why don't we go to our second one?
Speaker 3It's the Sickos World Series.
Speaker 1We've got.
Speaker 3The Tampa Bay Rays and the Milwaukee Brewers.
Speaker 1We'll do our normal format. The Brewers will win if.
Speaker 3Patrick? I left this one, so I think you should start with it.
Speaker 1I appreciate you doing that. The Brewers will win if they are leading after four and the bullpen just does what it did against the Dodgers. If Stephen Vogt's button works... Can I also point out... I just want to go back for a second.
Speaker 3There was a point in the.
Speaker 1It was game three of the.
Speaker 3Milwaukee LA series where Ken Rosenthal is reporting on Dave Roberts plan. And he was like, he wants to have a lead after six so that they can't just go to the bullpen. And I just, I just need to say like having a lead at a certain point in a game is not a plan. That's, that's how you win.
Speaker 1Yeah. Having a lead after the ninth is a plan. Like that's like, that's there.
Speaker 3That is not a plan at all. So I, Kevin cash do better.
Speaker 2This is like the Hillary Clinton, how do we defeat ISIS? We defeat ISIS.
Speaker 3That's right.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 3By winning.
Speaker 2By winning, yes.
Speaker 3By having leads and then holding those leads. And yeah.
Speaker 2He should have said, what's your plan? I plan to have a lead after the ninth inning.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's right. That's it.
Speaker 3That's how you do it. So yeah, I think that is the one way to do it.
Speaker 1Jeffrey?
Speaker 2So I'm taking the inverse of this. I think they, look, they need to get more from Mizorowski and Logan Henderson.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2Than they've gotten so far. Not that they've been awful or anything, but, like, you know, the. The Rays can make this annoying for them. Specifically, I think.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think... Like, I considered this, too.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3For the same reasons. And part of the reason I didn't was because maybe they don't need more.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2Well, I do think there's... I know the Brewers have had a lot of time off, but I think... This is like trying to this like trying to this is like sleeping in an extra six hours on Saturday after you've been right. It doesn't out till 2 a.m. the last previous week. Like Aaron Ashby has thrown all those back to backs.
Speaker 1Right. Like, yes, I think I want the Brewers to need more. Right. Like I want I don't want this.
Speaker 3But that's what.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3That's how I feel. But I'm not sure that they do. Yeah, they just they just they might not. Because the reality... You're right about Aaron Ashby, but the reality is they might just be able to go out and do the same thing, the three-inning closeout, the game thing that they did with Ashby.
Speaker 2They might just throw five scoreless against this lineup or whatever.
Speaker 3They might just do it with D.L.
Speaker 1Hall.
Speaker 3He's been that good thus far.
Speaker 1You know what I mean?
Speaker 2You say that, but he's still going to use Aaron Ashby every day.
Speaker 3No, I know, but you know what I mean, right?
Speaker 2Yeah, I know what you.
Speaker 1Mean, yeah. What I said, essentially.
Speaker 3filling the lane not filled by these other two uh roots here is robert gasser can out pitch nick martinez right i had to bring up nick martinez here i i think you know neither of these teams really has a game four person right right so it really game and you're gonna get rasmus well i don't know if he lines up i guess does he isn't.
Speaker 2Yeah rasmussen can go on uh It's Sunday. So he'll be on regular rest.
Speaker 1On Friday. Yeah.
Speaker 2So we'll get they can line up uh rasmussen peralta.
Speaker 3Okay so we're gonna get rasmussen mizorowski yeah peralta and henderson.
Speaker 2Yeah i mean they might they could i guess they could throw nick martinez game two and give peralta some extra yeah i guess martinez hasn't pitched in a while i don't know how.
Speaker 3They'll yeah but i'm assuming it'll be those two yeah and then it's gonna be you know yeah yeah you know game three is pivotal regardless really how the first two go, whether it's a split or, or one team gets both of them. I think that that comes down to like, can, can Gasser give them four innings basically? Can he do what he did against the Dodgers?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Which was more than enough. Um, so I, I think if he can, and then they can go to that bullpen, they're in pretty good shape. The Rays will win.
Speaker 1If Patrick, Yeah, so, I mean, this is, they will win if they did what they did in five and six. Like, what they did to Cleveland is that every time, Cleveland got base runners, but it felt like every time Cleveland got a base runner, it wasn't necessarily even, like, just cheap double plays. It felt like, you know, Taylor Walls would dive, or Ben Williamson would dive for something, knock it down, get one out. If the Brewers, like, the Brewers can hit home runs, and they can theoretically win
Speaker 1just hitting home runs. They did, like, they showed this against the Dodgers. But the Rays are going to at least need to make sure that they hit home runs. They can't also give up the single-double combos, right? If they can keep Milwaukee to scoring two or three runs because they hit two or three solo home runs, then they've got a chance. Jeffrey?
Speaker 2So originally I put down, if the Rays play clips of every time Craig called them frauds over the PA while they take batting practice.
Speaker 1The fraud is finally came.
Speaker 2They need motivation. Motivate them.
Speaker 3Um, but I'm going to go, I'm 90% sure. I'm in the, in the Milwaukee opening day.
Speaker 1Oh yeah. Yeah. We need that.
Speaker 3Just remember there's some power in this.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Uh, but I said, uh, basically if Nick Martinez pitches well, right? Like I think their biggest advantage on paper is Nick Martinez against Robert Gasser.
Speaker 1I mean, certainly.
Speaker 3See, here's the thing. Everyone gets mad at me, but you can't say that without laughing.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1When I wrote the preview for Game 4, I looked at Nick Martinez a lot, and I'm like, I get why it works. It's been working for a long time, guys. It's been five years of this. He's had three 5 ERAs since he came back from Japan.
Speaker 3And if he had a 3.5, I wouldn't be calling him a fraud. I would probably be saying he's still getting away with it. But 3-5 will do the job. If he can give five innings, and that's what he's been doing. He's been pitching five innings of one or two-run ball. And that is, like, the five innings is the important part right now.
Speaker 1Yes. Sure. Yeah.
Speaker 3I also want.
Speaker 1To be clear. Kevin Cash, trust him on that. Give him, let him give those five innings.
Speaker 3It's been some time since I thought the rate, like, I... there was a point I thought the Rays were not going to make the playoffs or whatever.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3But I'm saying it's been a while since like, I've been like, okay, I don't think, I still think a full health Yankees series would have been, I don't know that it would have been different.
Speaker 1It would have been much more competitive.
Speaker 3I think, but like, if you had told me that they were the, the, I guess the four seat, because the first three go to the division winners, but like the second, essentially second in the AL East or whatever, and went to the world series anyway, like that happens.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Like, I don't think, it's insane that they've, they've survived the playoffs. But yeah, I know my, my raise will win. If is, I said, Taylor walls gets, gets on base three times.
Speaker 2How about four? Did he got on base four times?
Speaker 1He, he, he reached.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3If he, if he walked, no, I mean, it's not, it's not about Taylor walls, but it is, it is having someone on for Yandy Diaz to hit a home run.
Speaker 1They need to get, yeah.
Speaker 2They need to get something out of the bottom of that lineup in this series.
Speaker 1That is what I'm using that as. And where we're linking here is that they did get something out of the bottom of their lineup because they actually played defense in those last couple of games. One of the reasons why the Rays were struggling is because they had these guys who were only good at defense and also couldn't play defense because there's nothing to defend. Right.
Speaker 2I would also include Richie Palacios here, but he had six.
Speaker 1Yeah. The bottom of the lineup for the Rays is the long bottom of the lineup. It is.
Speaker 2It's true.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, well, and especially when like Victor Mesa isn't hitting.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, look, yeah. Chandler Simpson might be hitting third against Jacob Miziorowski in game one.
Speaker 1I mean, he's a good matchup, honestly. At least he might not strike out.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1I don't know that that makes it a good matchup. Compared to if he's on. He's striking out 16 guys, just putting the ball in play as a victory.
Speaker 3That takes us to our predictions.
Speaker 1I can start. I took Milwaukee in five.
Speaker 3I think everything that the Rays do, Milwaukee does, and Milwaukee does a little bit more.
Speaker 1I don't think that.
Speaker 3There's really anything that Tampa does that and, and, and I'm not saying Tampa doesn't do anything well. I think they're, they do things well. And I think Milwaukee does those things as well or better. And then also does some stuff on top of that, that Tampa doesn't do. Um, so I think it's just, it's a short series. Anything can happen, but I'd expect it to play out of Milwaukee's favor.
Speaker 1Yeah. I took six. I think ironically, like the team that has a little advantage is a little harder to win in five because you have to play three in the road to do it.
Speaker 2Hmm.
Speaker 1That's kind of why I gave Tampa an extra win because I think they'd take two or three from home. But I think Milwaukee cleans it up as soon as they get back. Jeffrey?
Speaker 2I said Rays in six. Look, I've been running and riding the Rays since to be oppositionally defiant to Craig, but I thought they were pretty good. But I've been running them in the playoffs too.
Speaker 1I don't... I....
Speaker 2Just feel like Milwaukee starting pitching. It hasn't really been there. And that's true. I think I, again, I think like, like the Chandler simply, they're going to make it hard for Ms. You're asking.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2They're going to foul good slider. Like they're not like, they're going to get like hit home runs off. I mean, Caminero might, and I suppose Yandy could, but I think they're going to make it hard. And I think they're going to be able to wear down. the Brewers pen over the course of this. It's not going to be pretty. They're going to lose a game like 10 to two in here. Probably.
Speaker 3I don't have Milwaukee is going to make Tampa Bay look like Tampa Bay made Cleveland. Maybe like the, because the other part of this is like you said, like the Cleveland kept getting guys on, like they had to go bring in Kevin Kelly. And I had to watch Brian Rokio take one of the worst at bats I've ever seen in my entire life.
Speaker 1But like the difference, I think Aaron Ashby is going to do that to Taylor walls. Sure.
Speaker 2But I do think unlike if they get guys, Cleveland, they have like the top four guys in that lineup can all hit home runs. Diaz, which, which Aranda and Caminero can all hit home runs. And the Cleveland just didn't have that potential. Really?
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3I mean, like, again, I'm not trying to dunk on either Liam Hicks or Patrick here, but like, Liam Hicks was a guy Patrick wrote about and reasonably was like, he might not hit six home runs the rest of the season. Can he hit a home run?
Speaker 1Yes. Okay. Okay.
Speaker 2I'm just saying.
Speaker 1It doesn't ever feel like he can hit a home run.
Speaker 3It's, it's not, let's not lump him in with, with Junior Caminero.
Speaker 2Junior Caminero is the ability to hit home runs. So, uh, yeah.
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 3I also, yeah, I don't know. I just think, you know.
Speaker 2Yeah, we know what you think, Craig.
Speaker 3That's why they play the game.
Speaker 2And we know what you think. What does Pakoda say, Craig?
Speaker 1I haven't looked. Yeah, we have to set up the roster.
Speaker 2We even set up the rosters last night.
Speaker 1No, I was busy writing last night. I thought I was.
Speaker 2Teeing Craig up there, but apparently not.
Speaker 1That's what I should have been doing, Patrick. I guess so. Well, we have plenty of time before the preview is ready. So, like, we should get a day off, too.
Speaker 2Yeah, fair enough.
Speaker 3I suspect it will favor Milwaukee.
Speaker 1It doesn't have the roses. I'm less certain than Craig. Oh, you don't think? No, given Pakoda's proclivities towards the Milwaukee Brewers, I feel like it's going to be 50-50 is what my guess is. That's fair.
Speaker 3I didn't think it loved the Rays either. No, it doesn't love the Rays. It doesn't hate the Rays.
Speaker 1Part of the reason I have said call them fraud and stuff, their third-order stuff, it's fine. Yeah. It's fine.
Speaker 3It's a good team, not a great team. And they played like a great team. All right, why don't we take a break and come back with the rest of the show.
Speaker 4We'll be right back.
Speaker 3Welcome back to episode 590 of Five and Dive. We're on segment three, staffing up. We're getting front office moves. We're getting managerial decisions. Martin Maldonado is on the dock for the second straight week.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 3It's that time of year. Taylor Smith takes over in Sacramento, soon to be potentially Las Vegas.
Speaker 1Maybe.
Speaker 3Maybe.
Speaker 1Possible. Possible. Taylor Smith.
Speaker 3That's about as anonymous a name as you can get these days. And he's probably thankful.
Speaker 231 years old.
Speaker 1Yeah. Wow. Yeah. Okay. Sure. He's, uh, he went to Tampa Bay out of college and worked there for seven years and then went to Boston, ran the analytics department there for a couple of years. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, Sacramento. Yeah.
Speaker 1Like, I have to think that if you're a Sacramento fan, all four of you, and you get together on your weekends, this has to feel like a comforting hire, given the alternatives, right? This is at least a nod towards, hey, we used to have something and we lost it.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I assume he'll get.
Speaker 3At Tampa, he ran quantitative modeling or.
Speaker 2Something, right? He is a spreadsheet guy, as they say derisively nowadays. But, you know, it's– you know, I do wonder how much– that's still kind of an old-school-ish front office underneath him.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2I'm curious if he gets, like, the Paul Toboni license to really remake this organization in the way he wants.
Speaker 3Steve Fisher, yes, you have complete control as long as you don't spend any money.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think– I mean, look, he just– he came from Tampa, so.
Speaker 3You know, and, you know, they do spend on their front office a little bit.
Speaker 1They do. Yeah. As Jared has written, it takes time to overhaul a front office. Yeah. It will take less time to overhaul the athletics office because there's only eight guys. Yeah.
Speaker 2And also, look, they don't expect anything until they move into the stadium in Vegas, whenever that is. So I think he'll get he'll get time.
Speaker 1And the athletics, when he comes in and does his evaluation, he's not dealing with a club that is full of underwater contracts.
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 1If there are certain people on this roster he wants to move, he should have the ability to move them. Right? So I can imagine this being about as smooth as you.
Speaker 2Could hope for.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2And hey, that division looks pretty winnable right now.
Speaker 1Yeah, it does help.
Speaker 2They don't have to be that good that soon.
Speaker 1Yeah, it is.
Speaker 3The contracts are really Luis Severino.
Speaker 1Yeah. Which is one more year, right?
Speaker 2One more year.
Speaker 1And, you know, we'll see how Brent Rooker looks.
Speaker 2Yeah, you can probably still make that deal now, but it's not a lot of money.
Speaker 3It also tops out under $ 20 million in a year, so.
Speaker 1It's not that big an anchor or anything like that.
Speaker 3Jared Banner.
Speaker 1Goes from the Chicago Cubs to take the GM role in Baltimore.
Speaker 3I'll hand it to Jeff, who made a face.
Speaker 2This is on some level, like, on paper, saying that out loud is fine, right? But everything around this move and this GM job has been weird.
Speaker 3Um yeah what was he what was his role in.
Speaker 2He's a he's a play his background is player dev which is why he got this.
Speaker 3Because they wanted he wasn't a an agm.
Speaker 2I think he had an agm title yeah i mean he was director of player dev he left the cubs to go to the mets to be the cubs to go to the mets or the guardians to go to the mets to be a director of player dev and then went back to the cubs he was in charge of like special projects but i think he has an agm title now yeah.
Speaker 1Um he did have an agm title um he has been at that job since uh taylor smith was 13.
Speaker 2Yeah i mean it's just specifically like we're hiring a player dev guy to fix our player dev but also be the gm instead of just hiring a player dev guy to be the player dev guy is a little weird although like.
Speaker 1How much the gm does under elias's.
Speaker 2Yeah like i don't know like i don't know i really.
Speaker 1Don't know Boston to the Mets. Boston.
Speaker 2That's what it was. That's right. He was a, he's a Theo tree guy, which I think how he's ended up back in Chicago or in Chicago.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Like again, I just, we'll see. The Orioles are kind of a mess right now.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I don't remember if we talked about it, but Sigma doll is not overseeing the analytics department anymore.
Speaker 1And instead doing.
Speaker 3The research of, emerging technologies, and innovative practices across baseball operations.
Speaker 2We'll see how this goes.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I don't know what that means.
Speaker 3It feels like playing with AI.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2They're already all playing with AI, but probably more playing with AI. This is a little weird to take this job when Elias might be fired in a year or two, but maybe you think you can.
Speaker 1Maybe you're the next guy up. Or you have general manager on your resume. Sure. Right. he's been waiting a long time I think he had to feel like it was time to move up did.
Speaker 3The Taylor Smith move happen first? was he like Jesus Christ at 31?
Speaker 2I think the manner happened first though Smith was remembered for that job for a while.
Speaker 3In regular manager news Aaron Boone is back baby everyone is happy The Yankees will keep drinking more of that garbage.
Speaker 2He has not been given an option or a year or an extension. So he is technically.
Speaker 1So I did.
Speaker 3I mean, it's this is very much Aaron Boone is an above average manager with clear deficiencies.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2And he makes the playoffs every year.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Although any Yankees manager should make the playoffs every year is the view of the.
Speaker 1I understand.
Speaker 2The fact that he hasn't won a World Series and only gotten to... Well, one of them, I think. I made one World Series.
Speaker 1That's 2024, right? Yeah, the Dodgers won it. I think.
Speaker 3I understand. I understand the frustration.
Speaker 2His deficiencies are also very visible in a lot of cases.
Speaker 3And I think it's one of those things where you could at least feel like without denigrating it like you don't have to go the larry lucchino route on the way out of town right where it's like you have to put a knife in his back you can just say like different.
Speaker 2Feel like we needed a new voice for his service.
Speaker 3Yeah he is not incapable he is actually quite capable but let's see what a different voice does for us.
Speaker 2I mean the problem is their bench coach is brad awesomest so Well, I don't think the different voice has to be his guy.
Speaker 1Especially in the offseason.
Speaker 2What I did enjoy was within 30 minutes of each other, we got the Michael K. Hal Steinbrenner is very upset with how the season ended to Jack Curry. Aaron Boone will be.
Speaker 1Back in 2027. I think this is fine. We constantly talk about how the playoffs basically don't give time for the live average to kick in. I think Aaron Boone is not a great manager. I think Aaron Boone is a good enough manager to luck his way into one once in a while, just as many other managers have before him. This was Dave Roberts, right, for a long time.
Speaker 2The easiest, yeah, the best way to win a World Series is keep making the playoffs every year.
Speaker 3Yep.
Speaker 1And I think, I also don't have to watch it. Yeah. I don't have to deal with them every day. So it's very easy for me to say, sure.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1But there are, I think there are more worse managers out there than there are better ones. And I honestly, when it comes to managers, I would rather just play safe. I was also the guy who said they shouldn't have fired Ron Thompson. I will keep saying that forever.
Speaker 3Well, I was going to say, I think the thing the Yankees fans might want to do is realize the franchise that has been behaving the way that they want their franchise to behave is the Phillies. And they just said, sign me up for more years of Don Mattingly.
Speaker 2I mean, some of the Yankees fans definitely want Don Mattingly and also possibly Jorge Posada managing them.
Speaker 3I think, I think they can have Don Mattingly as soon as the middle of next year.
Speaker 1If the Philly would.
Speaker 3Allow that to happen if it came to pass. Martin Maldonado. We brought him up because he was in consideration for the Astros job. He is instead going to Detroit as a quality control coach.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3Get some coaching years.
Speaker 2He will be a manager maybe even in Houston in a couple of years.
Speaker 1That's right. And Jeffrey?
Speaker 2Yeah, Kevin Long is interviewing with the Mets. Maybe they let Jeff Albert go at the end of the season. Kevin Long has obviously been a hitting coach there before for a number of years. And look, I don't, it's going to come off as kind of a retread, but in terms of, he was like ahead of the curve in telling guys to pull and lift the ball. And he's also good at the instruct. side of getting guys to pull and lift the ball.
Speaker 3Is Kevin Long a good hitting coach?
Speaker 1Go ahead, Patrick. Is Kevin Long a good hitting coach?
Speaker 2I mean, so much as any of this.
Speaker 1He almost feels like the Aaron Boone of hitting coaches. I think he's above average.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2He's obviously close with Juan Soto, and they obviously have the... Not that Juan Soto really needs a hitting coach, but they have the analytics and evaluation apparatus underneath him, and he's the guy that's going to be like, okay, this is what you do to actually do this. He's the swing doctor here, probably.
Speaker 1I think the difference is that Kevin Long is... The hitting coach equivalent, right? But hitting coaches, that's not enough to keep you safe, is.
Speaker 2A hitting coach. No, it isn't. They'll be gone in three years because you fire the hitting coach the first time they have that season.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, but he's had success in New York, in Washington.
Speaker 2In both New Yorks, yeah.
Speaker 3Both New Yorks and in Philly. He's more like the manager that wears out his welcome than he is, you know, not good. Like, he's good.
Speaker 1He just.
Speaker 2you know, eventually the issue with him and with the Mets last time is he wanted to, I think at least be more considered for manager than he was when they hired Mickey Calloway and got cranky about it. Maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe he was right.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Um, I, I do like, you know, could Brett Beatty use his help?
Speaker 1Probably. Yeah.
Speaker 3You know, uh, maybe he can just tell, uh, Carson bench not to listen to, to his college coach or whatever the.
Speaker 1Hell it was.
Speaker 2Was that, Well, they're not going to tell Carson Bench anything in six weeks.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's right.
Speaker 2Good point.
Speaker 1Good point.
Speaker 3Let's go to our fourth segment. It's a brief one. We're going around the horn. We have Gold Glove finalists. I know you posted something about this on our chat. I cannot tell you how little I care about Gold Glove.
Speaker 2About Jared Triolo getting a Gold Glove nomination. Of course he did.
Speaker 1Didn't he win one?
Speaker 3He's won it before, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. The final, like, I understand why they do the multi-position ones, but it also, like, it doesn't work to me. It's like, who is qualifying for this? Why are they being separated? Like, yeah, sure, Ezekiel Duran played a lot of positions, right?
Speaker 2Ezekiel Duran, yeah.
Speaker 1But, like, you see, I see Zach McKinstry's name on here, and I'm like, Okay, did Zach McKinsey not qualify for anywhere else? Would he have been on the... Like, to me, if you're in the utility one, it means you should have won another one. The problem with all of these is the qualifications, right?
Speaker 3This was how, like, Joe Adele got nominated or whatever because he was one of, like, three people to play left field exclusively.
Speaker 1Or Juan Soto, right? Oh, right, Juan Soto, right?
Speaker 3It was just like, this guy has played left field. Every other left fielder also played some center and some right and whatever. but these guys like actually hit the threshold. They just need to lower the threshold a lot.
Speaker 1Like to the point of meaninglessness.
Speaker 2Jared Triolo for the record, 71 games at shortstop, 50 at third base, eight at first base, six in right field, one in center.
Speaker 1Imagine writing Jared Triolo's bat into, into the lineup at first base.
Speaker 2Well, he only started there twice, but you still had to do it two times then.
Speaker 1Yeah. You didn't. The second time has got to really feel bad.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1That's why there wasn't a third.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Um, We also have a posting. Excuse me if I mispronounce this.
Speaker 1I apologize. Teruaki Sato. Sato? I think it's Sato. I apologize. I've not done my research yet. The Hanshin Tigers.
Speaker 2He's going to get obviously comps to Murakami and Okamoto as a cornerback with power. It's very funny because I've seen some people be like, well, you know, Murakami is, you know, because of Murakami's success, he's going to get more money. And I'm just like, I don't like how success, like how good was Murakami actually this season in total.
Speaker 1But I, well, so he came back from injury. I can't reveal my rookie year balance.
Speaker 3The question is how much you think it had to do with injury versus a book being out.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3Versus just coming back to earth on some stuff.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2And the other, like, I have not, like Patrick I'm not dug particularly deep into Sato because I have 700 other things to do and will not be writing about Sato at any point uh but my impression from talking to people and seeing the data and video that I've seen limited as it is is in some ways he's you would rather he have more of a Murakami offensive skill set than he does because he has a common like his own contact is not good and he chases a lot yeah.
Speaker 1He he's he has basically he's hit uh 39 and 40 home runs in the past two seasons. He has struck out 164 and 163 times. He only has walked 115 times between the two years, right? The other disadvantage is he's 28 as opposed to Murakami being 25 at the time. He'll be 20 next year. Murakami was 26. So he's two years older, essentially. He's also going to rank higher. I'm just starting to look at the free
Speaker 1agent 50 this year. He's going to rank higher than Murakami did last year.
Speaker 2The bat free agent.
Speaker 1Murakami would also rank higher than he did last year. It's not a good class. Yeah. But it's going to be very interesting where he falls on this list. I do.
Speaker 2I was talking about this with Jarrett a little bit. And I do wonder, well, I think the market and look, Murakami had longer term offers that he got that he ended up signing with for the White Sox. I think the market read Murakami pretty well in general. From what I heard about the length and AAV of the other offers. But I do wonder if they're like, it only takes one team to be like, oh, well, Murakami did. Well, so let's get the next one that buys into Murakami more than the.
Speaker 3Well, and it's like you said about the other offers, like Murakami did have five and six year offers. They just weren't, you know, he bet on himself.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3And he might get rewarded.
Speaker 2Probably will. Like, I think he'll probably end up. Because he's going to hit free agency again after his age 27 season. I think he'll probably beat the six-year offer in total.
Speaker 1I will say he is better defensively. He's probably better.
Speaker 2He's better defensively than Murakami, yes.
Speaker 1And probably better than Okamoto, who was a slightly below average third baseman. He won the equivalent of the MPB Gold Glove, which we can treat with as much respect as we'd like to treat the Major League Old Glove.
Speaker 2I think you can sign him to play third base, though.
Speaker 1I think he'd probably get Okamoto-level defense.
Speaker 3I will note that MLB.com spoke to a scout. Take that for what it's worth.
Speaker 2Anonymous scout, let's go.
Speaker 3Probably not a third baseman, corner outfielder, first baseman.
Speaker 1So, apparently, you know.
Speaker 2Sure, I made a name.
Speaker 3Uh, he also, to, to Jeff's point, uh, and talking about his contact, uh, 66% contact rate.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's not good.
Speaker 1And again, the.
Speaker 3MLB average was 77. That's so that's not in zone to be clear, but it's, it's just contact rate overall.
Speaker 2And he does chase a lot, which is a problem. Yeah.
Speaker 1So.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2You will find guys. So the general, the hard and fast rule is that usually your zone contact rate is eight points higher than your contact percentage on average. But like, if you chase more like he does, it can be born 10 or 12. And I think his end zone was like high seventies, maybe even 80. And again, you'll see different data from different sources because even in Japan, they model the strike zone differently for some reason.
Speaker 1Right. Right.
Speaker 3So it'll, it'll be interesting.
Speaker 2It'll be interesting.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3That'll take us to our game.
Speaker 1All right. I'm just going to leave this one because I don't have the energy to try and play it as well. Basically this, This is just League Leaders. All you have to do is we're going to give you 1 through 10 points. Oh, but it's Game Started. It's not Game Started, unfortunately. I think we'll just do the hitting stats this time. There are four categories. And we'll just make this quick. Jeff, who led the league in batting average? It's okay. I don't know.
Speaker 4Wow.
Speaker 2Batting average. Yeah, this is something I should at least have feel I mean I know Chandler Simpson hit 300 but there's gotta be somebody better uh Jordan Alvarez.
Speaker 1Jordan Alvarez 10 points yeah okay there it is Greg oh I I mean oh god he was bad.
Speaker 3I just I don't know maybe I should just say you know what fine fine fine Chandler Simpson.
Speaker 27 points Jeff that's fine um uh let's go with Otto Lopez.
Speaker 16 points Greg.
Speaker 2I'm better at this than I thought I would.
Speaker 1I'm going to be bad here. I'm going to say Louisa Rice. Eight points. Oh, okay.
Speaker 3That's what I was going to say before Chandler Simpson. But then Jeff said Chandler Simpson and I felt like.
Speaker 1I had to.
Speaker 2He hit okay in Philly, I guess. Not enough to.
Speaker 1Yeah, he was hitting quite well before Philly.
Speaker 2Yeah. Now it gets... Now it gets tricky. Batting average. Anybody else that might have hit 300 this year?
Speaker 1Three other people.
Speaker 2Three other people, wow.
Speaker 1One of them exactly 300th.
Speaker 2I don't think McGonagall. McGonagall's like 280-something, I think. I don't think it's him. Let's try... CJ Abrams?
Speaker 1Nope. Craig, for the win. Or potentially tie if you get 10, because you're down by a point.
Speaker 2Oh, you know, I know what I should have done now.
Speaker 1I think he was up there. This is not You know what? I'm going to say Fernando Tatis Jr. For unfortunately not.
Speaker 2Okay. Um, was Xavier Edwards on it?
Speaker 1No. No. Okay. So going up from the bottom, Yanni Diaz, two 93 is 10th. Ty France, two 95, Michael Harris, two 94. So I'm not really sure. Yeah. I guess Ty France was eighth. Michael Harris was nine.
Speaker 2Did France not have enough at bats? So he had to get the penalty for not having enough at bats.
Speaker 1TJ Rumfeld hit exactly 300. Oh yeah.
Speaker 4Um, nick gonzalez hit 303 no absolutely not yes absolutely not and you watch not in a million years probably is it.
Speaker 3Then he had five ty france at 500 so if you if he went over two he probably drops.
Speaker 2Below yeah so it's yeah this one was 162 times.
Speaker 1Three all right sorry for that yeah all right and uh gabriel moreno was second place overall.
Speaker 3Wow yeah i don't know that bad i i Tatis, because my theory on Tatis was he hit for average while not hitting for power, and then he had a good second half, was basically where I was going with that.
Speaker 1All right, Colin, tapping into my energy. Craig, stolen bases.
Speaker 2Oh, damn it.
Speaker 1Boy, you know, I knew this, too, at some point. You know what? Fine, fine, fine.
Speaker 3Chandler Simpson.
Speaker 1Well done, Colin. You just lured him right in. Nine points for Greg on Chandler Simpson. Fine.
Speaker 2If I wasn't caught stealing, then you'd have gotten ten.
Speaker 1I would have known that, yeah. Sugar.
Speaker 2Let's do Bryce Trang.
Speaker 1Bryce Trang is not on the list.
Speaker 2Really?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Greg, you can jump out to a big lead. Yeah, thanks for saying that. Hmm.
Speaker 3No, he got hurt and then didn't... Ah, shit.
Speaker 2I had it.
Speaker 1Pete Krum Armstrong. Yeah, why not the guy who went 40-40? 7 points.
Speaker 2Elie de la Cruz?
Speaker 1Also not on the list.
Speaker 3He didn't run much this year. I kept thinking him and then I knew he didn't.
Speaker 2Run that much this year.
Speaker 1Oh, God.
Speaker 3There's another guy that caught a fair.
Speaker 1Why can't I remember? Um... I like how your way of thinking of stolen bases is just who got caught a lot.
Speaker 3No, no. I just remember there was a guy who... There was a non-Chandler Simpson guy who ran a lot and also got caught a lot.
Speaker 1Yeah. And I'm not... You know what?
Speaker 2I'm just.
Speaker 3You said his name before and it's sticking in my head and I feel like maybe he ran some this year.
Speaker 1I'm going to say Michael Harris. No. No? Okay.
Speaker 2Nico Horner?
Speaker 1No. Wow, Jeff, shut up. All right, well, you guys missed a lot of juniors on this list. I took a guy in the second.
Speaker 2What?
Speaker 3Michael Harris is a second.
Speaker 1He is a second. Well, that's enough. C.J. Abrams.
Speaker 4Oh, C.J.
Speaker 1Abrams, yeah. Tied for eighth, four players. Otto Lopez, Estuary Ruiz, Jose Caballero, C.J. Abrams.
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 1Seventh, Jose Ramirez at 37.
Speaker 3Hmm.
Speaker 1Sixth is Fernando Tatis Jr., 38.
Speaker 3He got caught a lot. That's who I was thinking of. The guy I said in the last friggin' answer.
Speaker 1Tied with PCA at 41 was Jazz Chisholm Jr. Had no idea. No idea.
Speaker 2He said he was going to go 50-50.
Speaker 1Third place, Bobby Witt Jr.
Speaker 3I thought about saying him and then I was just not sure of myself.
Speaker 1And then finally, the guy who actually led the league in stolen bases, Nassim Nunez, 49.
Speaker 2How does he get on base enough to do that?
Speaker 1All 49 times that he got on base, he stole second. All right. Jeff, we're now getting into the bullshit categories. Enjoy doubles.
Speaker 2Doubles.
Speaker 1Craig is currently up 31 to 16, by the way.
Speaker 2Doubles.
Speaker 1I might give it back.
Speaker 2Let's go with Kevin McGonigal.
Speaker 1Kevin McGonagall is not on the list. Are you serious? He didn't?
Speaker 2Oh my god, wow. Okay, not good.
Speaker 3I'm worried about this answer because I know a lot of his are triples, but I assume he also gets a lot of doubles. I'm going to say Corbin Carroll.
Speaker 1No, not on the list. Okay.
Speaker 2Doubles. I don't like him.
Speaker 1Bigger park, maybe?
Speaker 2Um.
Speaker 1Number one floors me. I cannot believe this guy.
Speaker 2He got a lot of hits, so I'm just going to say Jordan Alvarez.
Speaker 1Jordan Alvarez tied for 10th. One point.
Speaker 2Okay, well, I'm on the board at least.
Speaker 1I'm on the board.
Speaker 3I'm going to go with Randy or Rosarena.
Speaker 1Tied for 10th.
Speaker 2One point.
Speaker 1That's too bad.
Speaker 2Doubles.
Speaker 1Yeah. Hmm. It was a tough list, guys.
Speaker 2It's going to be like a weird list, isn't it?
Speaker 1They're all going to be like guys that you get kind of mad are on the list, but also we'll have to admit we're on the list. It's not crazy names, just kind of upsettingly familiar names. And some of them are a little crazy. Like, I cannot believe number one. Doubles.
Speaker 2Let's go with... let's go with peter armstrong just assume he intervals nope nope great all right home runs and triples apparently greg um.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah i had a name and i it just it just vacated my my.
Speaker 3Brain uh uh you know what i'm gonna say bobby wood.
Speaker 2Jr no no really.
Speaker 1Yeah okay starting from the bottom you know All right, Matt Olsen at 34 to tie with Jordan and Randy.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1Carter Jensen, 35. No, pick the Ronald Royal.
Speaker 2Ronald Royal, Wright Park, yeah.
Speaker 1All tied for fifth, we got Brandon Nimmo, Raphael Devers, Bryson Stott, and Michael Harris II. Yeah, okay. Yeah. Tied for third, we get Alec Burleson and Jeff Sancer from previous, Bryce Durang.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1Number two, a guy both of you love, William Abreu.
Speaker 2I almost said Willier, but I thought the wall, because he's left-handed, I thought he wouldn't.
Speaker 1And finally, the guy who led the league in doubles, Brian Reynolds.
Speaker 2Yeah, I was thinking, after you said Nick Gonzalez, I started to get pirates in my head, because that's a pretty big stadium.
Speaker 1I don't care for the number of pirates you're saying. Yeah, frankly upsetting. All right, last category. Craig, you get to go first. It is hit by pitches. Ooh, okay, okay. Okay. All right. Sam Antonacci. Nine points. Oh, I thought he was first.
Speaker 2I know. Most gets hit by a lot of pitches.
Speaker 1All right, Jeff.
Speaker 3Brandon Geyer.
Speaker 1What?
Speaker 3Brandon Geyer gets hit by a lot of pitches.
Speaker 2Yeah, thanks.
Speaker 1Ron Hunt.
Speaker 2I think that's something I should know. I remember seeing his OBP is like all getting hit by pitches. Caleb Durbin.
Speaker 1Caleb Durbin is tied for 10th, one point. Now that we're past Sam Antonacci, I don't know. I don't think I could have gotten any of these.
Speaker 3Even number one, Patrick?
Speaker 1No, I don't think I would have gotten number one. I did not hear him connected to this in any way throughout the season. Interesting. Okay. There's one other guy on this list that I went, okay, yeah, I think I remember hearing about him getting hit a bunch. This is just.
Speaker 3General play style? I'm going to say Brandon Nimmo.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1Okay. Fine.
Speaker 2I feel like Otuve gets hit a fair bit.
Speaker 1Nope. Craig, your last guess. You have one, by the way. Yes. Take your victory lap. Okay. I will say... I don't know.
Speaker 3He leans over the plate. I'll say Jordan Alvarez, since Jeff has taken him every other time.
Speaker 1No, that's fine. Jeff?
Speaker 2Um um let's go with I feel like it's hit a lot like really did he played a fair bit Jeff McNeil.
Speaker 1No so uh congratulations to Greg who wins 41 to 18 your uh 10th place Henry Bolte uh Tyler Freeman.
Speaker 2Dylan why are you hitting Tyler Freeman yeah I.
Speaker 1Know Seventh was Joe Adele. Sixth, Isak Paredes. Hit the wrong Astros middle infielder. Fifth, the only guy I thought of as being hit, just because I think it's, like, actually injured him several times, Luke Kieschel. Oh, yeah. Yeah, Kieschel, yeah.
Speaker 2You know, at no point in this entire game did I think of the Twins. Like, never. Running through teams, like, well, what team runs a lot? There's, like, no situation where.
Speaker 1I would have. 2027, Jeff, at no point. No. That's what I think about. Speaking of which, Guy, who I would have expected, he was one off from the leaderboard. Probably would have gotten there if he qualified. Ty France only had 14.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1So that's probably the guy I would have guessed. Wilson Contreras.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's true. He gets cranky every time you hear about it.
Speaker 1Just because you want to hit Wilson Contreras. Randy Orozarena was third with 26.
Speaker 2Huh.
Speaker 1And the number one hit by pitch guy over in Antonacci, who I definitely thought was number one, is Yvonne Herrera. Really?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2He does step right at the plate.
Speaker 1He's right on the plate. That is true.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1All right. How many did he have? He had 31. He's 29. Yeah. Impressive. Yeah. All right. All right.
Speaker 3Well, thank you to Colin for the game. Thank you to Patrick for running it. And thank you to everyone else for joining us on another episode of five and dive brought to you by the baseball prospectus podcast network. You can get in touch with the show at five and dive at baseball prospectus.com. We are wherever you get your podcasts. Search for Baseball Perspectives Podcast Network and we'll be in that feed. We are also on Patreon if you want an ad-free version of the podcast. Feel free to sign up there. If you want to chip in a little more, you can get in on the Discord. If you like what we're doing and are on one
Speaker 3of those services, please drop us a rating and review five-star only if you're willing. We appreciate that. Thank you again for joining us. And if you've been waiting for the pod to be over, your time is now.
In Episode 596, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about the weather and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: The first salvo of free agent...
In Episode 595, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about Nick Martinez and feral cats and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Skubal Dooby Doo, where are you?: The latest in the Skubal sweepstakes, with some pun...
In Episode 594, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig once again chat about bagels (and cream cheese) and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: Qualifying...
In Episode 593, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about beans both Rancho Gordo and coffee and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. It's nice to have options: Lot of players and teams making choices. 2. Go West:...
In Episode 592, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about bagel preparation and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Aaron Ashby's Day Off: The Brewers bats wake up in a big way in Game 3. 2. These go to twelve:...